Kristin Perry, et al v. Arnold Schwarzenegger, et al

Filing 252

Received notice regarding service of letter of joinder to amicus brief on the interested parties in said action. [7536093] (MT)

Download PDF
#4yt $/>' . j z 3 4 5 x .0166 o1-69 O-Ilf .' F C'i E Ftzk p rt c F tjjj-.tsp,s l cykj )ga sy)y.y#psj (F - cgt j py yyrkyjyl y z!yyjj k yjyy , yy 2jjy. gj:g 2 g - jjj g: FL.) -E lt I THEUNI ED S AT SCOURTOFAP EALS ?O EEN T TE P O: T:jF-pjjt -g N. zr i A F R THENI TH CI CUI NORTHERN DITRI TOFCALI ORM A O N RT SC F CiiCaeNo vl s 6 KRITN P R Y,t 1 S I E R e a. , PanisAp ele, litf- p l s f e 7 8 DE NI HE RE A,e a. N S R R t1 9 1 0 V. (.v29 k w )c .22 R q Pani-ne eosAp ele, litflt> n r- pl s f e 1 1 AR OL S HWARZ NE GER,t l N DC E G e a. , 1 2 1 3 ad n 1 4 DE NI HOLLNGS ORTH,t l NS IW ea. , l 5 l 6 Dee dns fn at, Deed n- t>e osAp el t. fn atne n r- p l s l r Ap el rm teUntdSae Ditit uto te rhl pa Fo h i tts s c Co rfrh Note' e r n Dirt f lona si o Cai ri tc f Ho oal JdeVagnR. le n rbe u g u h Wakr 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 Kristin Perry, et al v. Arnold Schwarzenegger, et al P OOFOFS R IEP OVI I GNOTI ETOAL RE LP RTESI R E V C R DN C LAAIN WT RES ; SL TT ROFJ I DER DAT D 1/21 I S P ORTOFBAY E T CAA' E E ON E 02/0N U P AREALAWYERSF RI DI I UALF EE OM, T. SFLI G OFAMI I O N VD R D E AL' I N C CURI EBRIFI S P ORTOFP AI TF - P E L ES A E N UP L N IFA P L E Doc. 252 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 Vicn Pn E euieDi co n et a , x ct r tr ve Chns fr fmaieAcin iee o Afr t t iv o 1 Watr Ll Pae 7 l U. t lc em SnFacso CA9 1 8 a rnic , 4 0 Tl# (1)7-70 e.:452465 fx(1)9-70 a 453787 -3 s . J. ' .z . ), . ' . f Dockets.Justia.com 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 PROOF OF SERVICE BY M I L I, SI ART AR M de l r t a : DHO cae ht I a o e t e a e o ei ht e ye r , a d n t a p r y to t e m v r h g f g en a s n o at h wi h n e ti l d a ti n; m b s n s a d es i 1 2 Mi s o ti n t e c o y u ie s d r s s 11 sin S r e , S n F a c s o, C 9 10 . tet a rn ic A 4 3 O O t be 2 , 20 0, I s r ed: n co r 5 1 ev LETTER OF JOI DER TO M I US BRI F N C E On t e i t r s e pa ti s i s i a t o , b pl ci g a tr e c py h n ee td r e n a d c in y a n uo t e e f e c os d i a s a e e ve o e wi h pps a e t er on f l y hro n l e n e ld n lp t >g h e u l pr pa d, i a Uni e S at s p s of i e ma l b x i S n ei n t d t e o t fc i o n a F a c s o, C l f r i a d es e as f ll ws: r n i c a i o n a d r sd oo S e At ac me t A e thn 1 6 I d c a e u d r p n l y o p ru y t a t e f r g i g i e l r n e e a t f e j r h t h o e on s 1 7 ' t ue a d c rr c . E ec t d o O t be 2 , 2 1 , a 1 2 Mi s o r n o et x u e n c o r 5 00 t 11 sin 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 S r e , S n F a c s o, C li o n a. t et a rn ic a fri Sg : in P i t: rn t. ! c /l j /'. rL/ .i . . 4tk At Axoei. o*? . -1 ATT C ME TA AH N 1 2 3 4 At o n y f r P a n i f- p e l e tr e s o l i t f A p l e s T E D R J.B U R U , J . HOOE OTOS R C RI T P E D.D S E U T H SOHR USAL T E N E A G LI K P R HAE VNE S AU S R H E.PI P EI R AA EM E E RI U A.M N G S N QE OAA GI S N, D NN & C U C E L P BO U RTHR L 3 3S u h G a d A e u 3 ot rn vne L s A g l s,C 9 0 1 o nee A 07 (1 )2 9 7 0 2 3 2 - 84 T E D R B.O S N HOOE LO C u s l o Re o d on e f c r M T H W D.MC I L TE GL A I C.T Y A I MR ARN GI S N,D N & C U C E L P BO UN RTHR L 1 5 C n e t c t A e ue, N. . 0 0 o n c iu v n W Wa hi gt n,D. .2 0 6 sno C 03 (0 ) 9 5 8 0 22 5-50 At o ne s f r Mo a t-p e l nt tr y o vn Ap la s A VO A E F R F I H A D F E D M D CT S O A T N R EO R be t H.T l r, C Ba No.1 9 7 or ye A r 752 J n i e L.M n ,C B rN .2 5 1 enr ok A a o 452 2 9 0 L s B i a R a ,S i e 1 0 41 a rss od u t 1 Mrit , C 952 urea A 26 T lp o e: (5 )3 4 7 8 e eh n 9 1 0 -5 3 F c i i e: (5 )6 0 4 9 a sm l 9 1 0 -9 6 r yl r f i h- r e o .o t e @ a t f e dm cm 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 j o k f i h f e d m.o 4 m n @ a t -r e o cm 1 A t r e s f r P a n if - n e e vo -p e l e 5 t o ny o l i t f l t rn rA p l e D NJ JH R E A,te a#369 CTA o e E A S . E R R Sa 8r 196 - i dm y t T EI S NM.S E A T, S a e B r # 0 9 0 - C i f D pu y C t At o ne H R T E vA W R t t a 1 4 3 h e e t i y t r y EE x AE T KN 1 CRSI 6H tt a 215 , saeBr#475 M L I M.L E,S a e B r # 51 0 OLE E tt a 2 44 1 Dpt Ct Atre s 7 e uy i y t o n y Ci y H l , R o 2 4 t al om 3 1 O e D .C rl o B.G o l t P a e 8 n r a tn odet lc S n F a c s o,C l f r i 9 1 2- 6 2 a r n i c a io n a 4 0 4 8 1 T lp o e: (1 ) 54 4 0 9 eehn 4 5 5-78 2 0 2 1 2 2 at o n y z r De e d nt z t r e o - p e l nt tr e s o fn a - n e v n r A p l a s A d e p.p g o nrw un L W O FI E OF A D E P.P G O A F CS NRW UN 1 1 P r s o e Dr v , S i e 1 0 0 a k h r ie u t 0 F lo ,C l f r i 9 6 0 o sm a io n a 5 3 (1 ) 6 8 3 6 ; (1 ) 6 8 3 6 F x 96 0-05 96 0-06 a 2 Br a W.R u 3 in am Ja es A.C m be l U D mI N E D F NS F N 2 ALAC ap E 4L EE l 1 1 0N r h 9 t S r e 5 0 o t 0h t e t 2 s ot s al , Ar z na 8 2 0 5 c td e i o 5 6 (8 )4 4 0 2 ; (8 ) 4 4 0 2 Fx 40 4 -00 40 4-08 a AT AC ME TA THN 1 2 3 C a l s J.C o e hre op r D vi H.T o ps n ad hm o H w r C.N e s n, J . oad ilo r P t r A.P t e s n ee atro C O E A D K R ,P L OPR N IK LC 1 2 Ne H m s i e A e. N. . 5 3 w ap h r v , W W s i g o , D. . 2 0 6 ahntn C 03 4 (0 ) 2 0 9 0 ; (0 )2 0 9 0 Fx 2 2 2 -6 0 2 2 2 -6 1 a 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 -2 1/22 1 02/00 W AE ECT OM C FLI G LR IN Mol C. e l Dwyr y CekoteCor lr fh ut UntdSae Coro Ap elfrh Nit Crut i tts utf p aso te nh i i e c 9 SvnhSre 5 eet t t e SnFm ic, lona9 1312 a rw so Cai ri 40 -56 f RE: Per nS h azng e, .902 2 ry c w re eg rNo0-2 9 Toh Hooal C if u g adCiutu gs te n rbe he Jd e n r iJd e: c OnOcoe 2t, 0 0Ba AraL wyrfrn iiul reo pa t fea n iu tbr 5h 2 1, y e a eso Idvd aFedm ln o i n m cs l b e isp ot f pl e wi tecnet f 1o te ats P run t te nhCrut d fn up ro Ap el s t h o sn o a1 fh pri . usato h Nit ici eh e A vsrCmmieNoeo nh iutue 91C ieeoA r av A tnCC A di y o te ttNitCr iR l2-,hnsfr m te ci A D o t c io hr yoniterl etadfculte etmae y a Ara a yrfrniiul ee jisnh agl nsn atast ns d b B y eLw esoldvda b m am Fedm i teao erfrn e at n reo n h b v-eeecd ci . o C Awa ft ddi 16 t poeth cvln p lia r hs f iee rc l A som e n 9 9 o rtcte iiad oicli to Chns Ameims tg adt avn e lrca dmorc i teUntdSae. oa , iaporsiev iei n o d ac mut ail e cay n h i ttsT dy CAA s rges oc n i e v ado bhlo tebo dr inadP cfc rcncmmu i . av ctfrytmi n n eaf fh ra eAsa n ai Ameia o nt We d oae o sse c y cagtapoetimirnrhspo oel gae iesyade eisai iute hnehtrt sm gati t,rm t a ugdvri,n rm derc n sc. c g sn t iji Asrudb Ba Ara wyr frniiul reo ,rp sin8ecu e acas age y y e La eso ldvd aFedm po oio xlds ls t opol-gyme adlsin -f mtevnrbentuinomarg ivoaino fepe a n n ebas r h eealistt f ri en il o f o io a t fut nhJ ed etseul rtcincas.' ivoainii n wa migtdb acs or et i n m n' q apoet lue l s ilto sn o y t ae y ces tm o h i tcpspcetnohdrtlifrrrghme aflmet pmerhggn rot,t oh in aes isrnl neio cai odsin whtesv. evrte teemtadneeb am meyns do scnl ei Moeim h yo m in e e lso rae cniea ehr f a n n ebas i srm olg i ae x gvrmetlup s.CAAug shs utoasmtapooio 8iu cntuinl oen naproe re tiCort fr ht rp sin s no sit a. t to Repdfl sb ie , se ul um t d y t Vicn P n net a Chns fr fmaie iee o Afr t iv Acin t o c; 1omsl cA1cl e No1-69 .0166 3 4 I THEUNI EDS ATESCOURTOFAP E LS N TT PA F RTHENI T CI CUI NORTHERNDITRI TOFCAL F RNI O NH R T SC IO A CiiC s No vl ae PanisAp ele, litf- p l s f e SN e1 , 6 KRITI PERRY,ta. 7 g.v2qk w 9y. 2 R (z mz / c 1 -. :: pr Q4 . k , ( T ;T rt -% . 8 DE NI HE RE A,ea N S R R t1 9 $y 1' -j l )i ; - .Z 1 ' l 0 M . Patfne eos oels lii-t> nr-x le, nfl Ao e * Deed ns fn a t, . 1 A N L SH A ZN G E,t1 2 R OD C W RE E G Rea, 1 3 ad n 1 4 DE NI HOL I GS ORTH,t 1 N S LN W e a. , l 5 1 6 Deedn- treosAp elns fn atl evn r- pl t. n a . 1 7 1 8 1 9 Ap el rm teUntdSae Dir t o rfrh Note. p aFo h i tts s i C uto te r l e tc hn DitcoCai mi srtf lo a i f Ho oalJd eVag nR. le n rbe u g uh Wakr P OOFOFS RVI EP OVI I GNOTCETOAL RE LP R ISI R E C R DN I L A A TE N IT R S ; I QU LT -C'L T E OFJWD RDA E 1/21I N E E T APE A IYN S E T R O E T D 0 /0N 2 S P ORTOFBAYARE L WYE SF RI DI I UALF E DO , T. S UP A A R O N VD R E M E AL' FLNGOFAMI I AEBRIFI S P ORTOFP Am TF - P EL E S II C CURI E N UP L IFA P L E T waP n aoi Di co a l aycst r tr ,e AP Eqai oNotenCairi I uly f r r lona t h f 1 Watr L m Pae 7 l U. u jc e SnFacsoC 9 18 a rnic, A 40 T l# 4 52 46 6 e. : 1-7-7 0 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 fX(1)9-70 a 453787 1 POFO SRIEB MI RO F EVC Y AL 2 3 I S D RT AR R d c ar t a : IA H O A e l e h t I a o e t e a e o e g t e y a s, a d no a p r y t t e m v r h g f ih e n e r n t a t o h 4 wi hi e ti l d ac i n;m b s n s ad r s i 1 2 Mi s o t n n t e to y u i e s d e s s 1 1 s i n 5 S r e , S n F a ci c , C 9 10 . te t a rn so A 4 3 6 O O t b r 2 , 2O O I s r e : n co e 5 1, ev d 7 8 L T E OF J I D R T AMI U B I F ETR O N E O CS R E 9 : . 1 0 On t e i t r s e pa t e i s i a t o ,b pl c n a t u c p h n e e t d r i s n a d c i n y a ig re oy 1 1 t e eo e cl s d i a s a e e ve o e wi h po t g t e e n f l y h r f n o e n e l d n lp t s ae h ro u l 1 2 pr pa d, i a Uni e S a e pos of i e m i bo i S n ei n td t t s t f c a l 'x n a 1 3 F a c s o, Ca i or i a d es e a f ll w : rn ic l f n a d r sd s o o s 1 4 S e At a h e t A e tcmn 1 5 1 6 Id c a e u d r p n ly o p r u y ta i e f rg ig i elr ne eat f e jr ht h oeon s 1 7 t-'' '' ' t ue a d c r e t. E e ut d o Oc o e 2 , 20 0, a 1 21 Mi s o r n o rc x c e n tb r 5 1 t 1 sin 1 8 S r e ,S n F a c s o C l fr i . te t a rn ic , aion a . ./ . y 1 9 ./ , 2 0 2 1 2 2 Sn i: g P i t: rn I C t J+fT#Ag c . oO Q ' / m f 2 3 2 4 2 5 t t: f )': ', ' : ' :' , ! I -1 ' AT AC ME TA THN 1 g 3 At o ne s f r Pl i t f -p e l e t r y o a n i fAp le s T E D R J.B U R U : J . HOOE OTOS R C R S O H R D.D S E U T H I T PE U SA L T E N E A G LI K P R H A E V N E S AU S R H E. P E M I R AA I PE E E RI U A.M N G S N QE OAA GB O ,D N & C U CE L P IS N U N R TH R L 3 3S u h G ad A eu 3 o t rn v n e L s M g l s, C 9 0 1 o ee A 07 (l )2 9 7 0 2 3 2 -8 4 T E D R B.O S N HO O E LO C u s lo R c r on e f e o d M T H W D.M G L ATE CIL A I C.T Y AN MR AE I G BS N,D N & C U C E L P I O U N R TH R L 1 5 C n e t c t A e u ,N. . 00 on ci u v n e W W s i gt n,D. .20 3 ah n o C 06 4 5 6 7 8 9 (0 )9 5 8 0 2 2 5 -5 0 1 At o n ys f r Mo a t A pe l nt 0 t r e o v n -p la s A V C T S FR F IH A D FE D M D OA E O A T N RE O 1 R b r H.T l r, C B r No. 1 9 7 1 oet y e A a 75 2 J n i e L.M nk, C B r No. 2 5 1 en f r o Aa 452 2 90 L s B i a R a ?S i e 10 4 1 a r s s od u t 1 1 M r i t , C 9 56 2 u re a A 2 2 T lp o e: (5 )3 4 7 8 ee h n 9 1 0 -5 3 1 P c i ie: (5 ) 604 9 3 a sm l 9 1 0 -96 r yl r f l h- r e o .o t eg a t f e d m cm 1 jo k f ih f e d m.o 4 m n @ a t -r e o cm 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 At oIe HEoEPl i t f - n e e v r- p e l e t rSy Rr Aa i f l t n o p l DE NnAs fR R ,Sne a#36r-i AAme e N t 8r 196 C1 t y a t 9 o T E E EM.SE A T S a eB r # 0 9 0 -C fD p t Ct A tr e HR S T W R , t t a 1 4 3 h e euy iy ton y C R S I E v u AK N, s a eB r # 4 7 5 H IT N A E t t a 2 1 5 M L I M.L E S a eB r # 54 4 OLE E , tt a 210 D p t C t At o n ys e uy iy t r e C t H l ,R o 2 4 iy a l om 3 O e D .C r t n B.G o l t P a e n r alo o d e t lc s n F a ci c , C l f r i 9 1 2 4 8 a r n so a i on a 4 0 -6 2 T lp o e (1 ) 54 4 0 e eh n : 4 5 5 -7 8 (1 )6 83 6 : (1 )6 8 3 6 Fx 96 0 - 05 9 6 Q -0 6 a 2 B i n W.R u 3 ra am 2 4 2 5 JL es A.C m b l F N a A E aF N E A mI NC DE p e l U D L ES 1 1 0 N r h 9 t St e t 5 0 o t 0h r e s o t d l ,Ar z na 8 2 0 c t s a e io 5 6 At o ne s f r De e d nt l t r e o - p e l n s t r y o fn a -n ev n r A p l a t A d e P.P g o n rw un L W O F C S O A D E P.P G O A F I E F N RW U N 1 1 P r s o e Dr ve,S i e 1 0 0 akhr i ut 0 P ls m,C l f r i 9 6 0 o o a i o n a 53 (8 ) 4 4 0 2 ; (8 )44 02 Fx 4 0 4 -0 0 4 0 4 - 0 8 a -1 AT AC ME TA THN 1 2 3 C a l s J.C o e hre opr D vi H.T o p o a d hmsn H w r C.Ni l o , J . oad es n r P t r A.P t e s n ee a tr o C O E A D KR ,P L O P R N IK L C 1 2 Ne Ha ps i e A e. N. . 53 w m h r v , W W s i g o ,D. .20 3 a h n t n C 06 4 (0 )2 0 9 0 ; (0 )2 09 0 Fx 2 2 2 -6 0 22 2 -6 1 a 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 21 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 ' .. 2 1/22 1 02/00 W AE EC ROM CFLI G LT IN MolC. e l Dwyr y Clr o teCor ek fh ut UntdSae Coro Ap elfrh Nit Ci ut i tts ut f paso te nh r i e c 9 SvnhSre 5 eet t t e SnFacsoCai ri91312 a rnic, lona 40-56 f Per vS h azng e, .9022 ry . c w reeg rNo 0-2 9 RE: Tote nrbeCheJdeadCiutugs h Hooal ifug n r iJde: c tbl5h2 1, a e a esoIdvdaFedm lnoi a s cs l OnOcoe2t,00B yAraLwyrfrniiul reo pa tfe nmiu bifnsp ot f pl e wi tecnet f 1o tepre.P run t te nhCrut r i . p ro Ap el s t h o sn o a1 fh ats usatoh Nit i i eu eh i c AdioyCo mit Noet Nit Ci ut l2 -, inPct lln e E ulyoNot vsr m te t o nh r iRue 91Asa aic s dr qai f r e c la t h Ba AraL wyrfrn iiul reo i teao erfrne at n y e a eso Idvd aFed m n h bv-eeecd ci . o ClonaG PE ulpNcleeyoniteru etadfc ast etmae y afri(A 1 qat 'hr jisnh agm nsn am lte ns db it i b am A I qat-cicmmietwokn ite i ad ai IadrA l PEulyl so tdo ri nh Asnn Pck sne(P) ii t g a fl cmmt i i Cai mi adnt nl frq amar g r hsfik ametadoeal o m t n lo a n ai al o eul ri e i t,ar et n:n vrl yf oy ag acpacolba,a,ixa adr sedrL B )epeWokn mclbrtn cet efe i gybs ul n tngne(O Tpol rig oloao n sn e, a . ai wi oroapr esAP E ulyt adAP Eqai -Fweegg i pbieuain t u lcl at r, I q ai -, n I ulys , n aen u l d ct , h n tA t co cmmui ognzn ,n lgl n lgs t eav cc t aheeoug as o nt raiig ad ea ad eili doay o civ t-ol. y av As rudb Ba Ara wyrfrniiul reo ,rp sin8ecue acas age y y e La eso Idvda Fedm po oio xlds ls t op ol-gyme adlsin -fo te eealisi tno maraei voaino f epe a n n ebas rm h vnrbe ntui f r g n ilt f to i o fut nhs ed et eul rtcincas. hs iltniin wa migtdb acs ore t m n m n' q apoet l e T ivoai sn o y t ae y ces e s ou o i t tesprtadihrnl ifro mehns o dmet p nrhp Moevrt oh eaae n n eet neir caim f o si m esi. roe,l y o w ec s ncetscniealhr fr a me adlsin whlsrign lgt ae xl i rae o s rbe nm o gy n n ebas i evn o eim t uo d e i gvrmetl u oe AP Eqai - ctgshs utoalm +apooio 2i o en napp s, I u lyN t e tiCort fr trp sin s tr i t u cnt t nl nosi i a. mo Repcfl sb ie, setul um td y t . < / wy : q /va ' I . Ta aP vaoi w l m cs t AP Eqai oNoten 1 u ly f r r t h C lona ai ri f c: lone cAlcu sl 1/22 1 01/00 21) - llIk 2fJ? tI: 2 l( VI ELECTRONI F LI G A CIN Mol C. e l Dwyr y lE- t ' ; -. - Ft. .. Clr o teCo r ek fh ut , C EE . K '0 4f : UntdSae Co ro Ap elfrh Nit Ci ut i tts ut f pas o te nh r i e c D I lllL AE t1A k 9 S vnhSre 5 eet t t e S nFa cso Caio i 9 131 2 a rn ic, l m a 4 0 -5 6 f RE: Per vSc wazng en .902 2 r. . h re eg rNo 0 -2 9 v T teHo oal Che Jd eadCi utu g s o h n rbe if u g n r iJd e: c OnOco e 2 t, 0 0 Ba AraL wyr frIdvd aFed m pa t fl a n iu tb r 5h 2 1 , y e a es o n iiul reo ln o i n m c s e bifnsp ot f p l e wi tecnet f lo tep re.P ru n t teNit Ci ut r i u p ro Ap el s t h o sn o al fh at s usato h nh r i e eh i c 0 'it'lE) Fi)L?9. t t!T#( L- E( J) -- 2P A s ; r USFc'TfiA2E K . . 0i ' ! L (I.-,,(.ElI )I:.F$Pnt ' Jri..-, R r P g l tr.'-,. N U Lc J;tj j ,. ! a , - A vsrC mmieNoetNitCrut ue2-, hnsfr fmaie tnCC A' di y o te t o nh i iR l 91C ieeoAfr t Aco A ' o t c ivi ) hrb jisnteagmetadfcultt etmae yByAra a yrfrniiul eeyoni h ru nsn atas e ns d b a e Lw esoldvda am Fed m i tea o erfrne at n reo n h b v-eeecd ci . o CAAwa fu ddi 16 t poeth cvl n p lia rgt o Chns Ameias s on e n 9 9 o rtcte iiad oiclihs f iee r n t c adt avn emutail e orc i teUntdSae. o a , iapo rsiev iei n o d ac lrca dm cay n h i ttsT dy CAA s rgesv oc n i e ado bhlotebodr inadP cf Ameia cmmu i . av ctfrytmi n n eaf fh rae Asa n aic rcn o nt We doaeo sse c i y Asag e b Ba AraLa yr frldvd a Fedm, rp st n8e cu e acas rud y y e w es o n iiu l re o po oio x ld s ls i o p o l-gyme adlsin -fo tevn rbeisi t no maraei voaino f e pe a n n eba s rm h e ea l ntui f rig n ilto f to futet n e d etse ul rtcincas.Thsvoainii n wa migtdb acs orenh m n m n' q apoet lue i ilt sn o y t ae y ces o o i t tesprt a dih rnl ifro meh ns o d met prnrhp Moevrte o h eaae n n eet neir ca i f o si atesi. ro e,h y m c e cuincets o sd rbeh r frgyme adlsin whl srign lgt ae x lso rae c nieal am o a n n eba s i evn o eim t e i g vrmetl up s.CAA ugsti Co rt afm ta po oio 8it cntuin l o en nap roe re hs uto fi ht rp st n sm o stt a. r i io ep c y b ie , set mtd t f cag tapoetimirnr hspo oelnug dvri,n rmeisailnute hnehtrtcsm gati t rm tsagae iesyade derc i sc. g, t aji Vicn P n n et a Chn s fr fmaie iee o Afr t iv Acin t o c : 1 one cA1cu sl 1/22 1 01/0 0 VI ELECTRONI F LI G A CIN Mol C. e l Dwyr y Clr o teCo r ek fh ut UntdSae Co ro Ap el frh Nit Crut i tts ut f p as o te nh ici e 9 SvnhSre 5 eet tet SnFacso Cai ri 9 1312 a rn ic, lona 4 0 -5 6 f RE: Per nS h azng e, . 90 2 2 ry c w re eg rNo 0 -2 9 T teHo oa lChe Jd eadCi utu g s o h n rbe if u g n r iJd e: c USC I'CH TO ANT !: P..CtC-FAIEUC UL o)-(- PN LI BI HTR A P F) !.-9J tFtEC ttl OFC,t-1tLR FIE1;rE) CK 2l?)- 1I$v 1( C21! ' lI: 1 ? w. , fL t 7E I) !C EE 0h TD OT IIIL AE NTA OnOco e 2 t, 0 0 Ba AraLa yr frn iiu l reo pa t fea n iu tb r 5h 2 1 , y e w eso Idvd a Fed m ln o i n m cs l bifnsp ot f p l e wi tecnet f 1o tepris P ru n t teNit Ci ut r i u p ro Ap el s t h o sn o al fh at . usa to h nh r i e eh e c AdiyCmmieNoeoNihCrut ue91AsnPcf llneEulyoNot vs o te tt n i iRl2-, i aics dr qai f r o t tc a a t h Clou ( P EulpNc'hrb jisnteagmetadfculttmetmae y afn aC I qai leeyoni h ru nsn atas e ns d b iW t a Ba AraL wyr frn iiul re o i teao erfrn e ato . y e a es o Idvd a Fed m n h b v-eee cd cin cmmu i i Cai ri a dnt n l freu l raer hsfitet etado eal o nt n lona n ai al o q a mar g i t,arram n,n vrl y f oy ig acpac olsi ,a,ixa adtngne(GB ) epeWokn iclbrtn cet e feba gybs ul n r sedrL T pol. rign ol oai n n e, a ao wi o ro ap r esAP Eq ai -v adAP E u lys , eg g i p bi eu ain t u lcl at r, I u lyl n l q ai -F we n a en u l d ct , h n tA t c o cmmt i og nzn ,n lg ln lgsaieav cc t ahe eo r ol. o m t ra iig a d ea ad eilt d oay o c iv u g as y v AP EulyNcicmmie twokn ite i adPcillne(P) 1 qai- so tdo rignh Asn n aics drA 1 t t a fa As ru db Ba AraL wyr frn iiu l reo , rp st n8e cu e acas ag e y y e a es o Idvd aFed m po oio x lds ls i o po l-gyme a dlsin -fo tevnrbeisi t no mar g i voaino f epe a n n eba s rm h eeal ntui f ri en ilt f to a o futet a ed etseu l rtcinca s.T ivoainii n wa migtdb acs o r nh m n m n' q a poet lue hs ilt sn o y t ae y ces e o o i t tesp rt adihrnl ifro mehns o d met prnrhp Moevrte o h e aae n n eet neir caim f o si atesi. ro e,h y c ecuincets o sdrbehr fr a me a dlsin whl srign lgt ae xlso rae cnieal am o gy n n ebas i evn o e im t e i g vrmetl up s.AP Eq ai - clg shsCo rt afr ta po oio 8i o en nap roe 1 ulyN z e ti uto fim ht rp st n s tr i t cntuin l m o si t a. to Rep cfl sb ie, setul u m t d y t Z p T waP n aoi a l ay c s t AP Eq ai o Noten I u ly f rhr t Cai ri lona f c: 1o ne c Alcu sl Vicn P n net a E euieDietr x ct rco v Chn s fr fmaieAcin iee o Afi t to rv 1 Watr L m Pae 7 l U. u lc e SnFacso CA 9 1 8 a rn ic , 4 0 UFIF rTf L:L 0FC! .Fh PRS :' H C A . . ( : S PS SC) % I : EK t. pl 1I;i/I LI tLcit':c IT B --HJ . N ' t. N .t r t1N.?- l (:i '(. c9 l) 4 '. 1 It $? . . , 't ( tt. ) :. V ',) ig . T usa, tbr2 , 0 0 h rdy Ooo e 8 2 1 THEJ ME R. A S BROWNI G COURT OUS N HE 9 - TH S RE T 57 T E S N F NCICO, 9 13 A M S CA 4 0 AT : eksOfie T Clr' f c FL' 'L lI J 0K2E rE D ;1 nt IIA AE N IL t UntdSae Co l O Ap e l frteNit Cic i ie tts u' f p as o h nh rut t RE:P ry e a. . cwazn g e,t l-Ap el f DCn .0 -2 9 VRW er,t lv Sh re eg rea. p ao US o 90 2 2 Der ek a Clr : E coe pes f da oiia a dt ocpe o tefl wigd cmet t b te ad n lsd lae i n rgnl n w o is fh ol n ou nso ei d n n o l ld e wi teCeksOfieo T eU.. ut f p aso teNit Ci ut o gd t h lr' fc f h S Co ro Ap elfrh nh r i h c: 1 C ieefr fm te tns et oJidr ae 1/21 ispotf a Ae ) hns oAfrai Aci 'Ltrfonedtd 02/0n uproB y ra iv o e L wyr frn iiu l reo ,t l'Fl go a Amii ra Bre i S p ot f a es o ldvd a Fed m ea. in f n c Cuie ifn u p ro si PanisAp ele; litf- p l s& f e OriaPoff ev e rvdn NoieoAl aPreiltrs(ymal inlroo Sri Poiig t t 1Rel atsnneetb i g c c i ) Pes po ieolognzt nwi ed re cpe o teed c me ti tesladesd lae rvd t ra iai t n osd o is fh s ou nsn h ef d rse , r oh s mpdev lp whc wehv icu e . t e n eo e ih ae n ld d a Iy uh v ayq et n , laefe fe t gv meacla: 1-7 -7 0 Thn y u f o ae n u so spes elreo ie i al t4 52 46 5 . nk o . Yori eadatnindrce twadtimatrs sapeitd u t n t t ietd o r hs t imot p rcae . m eo e Snee , icrl Vicn P n net a E euieDi co xct r tr ve C ieefr fmaieAcin hns o Afr t t iv o T waP n aoi a l ay cst Di co r tr e AP E uly-NotenCaio i 1 q ai t r r l ma h f 1 Watr Ll Pae 7 l U. t lc e m SnFacso CA 9 1 8 a rnic, 4 0 Thrdy Oco e 2 , 0 0 usa , tbr 8 2 1 t -jEti9.( EK F' 'u-) ' .1iEC i '' -i :F pEt Ulfc''I( pR s - .on ( tLA sI tg?-1 HUI c1t(i' NT qH PJLC krl,1 t ,-- to B lt1 q tIh' $-It4 t2lh 'I:l ) f/ t 1 .s l 1 . it. o-i il )c EE. - -.--.K 10 . DT IIIL AE . IA, N -- THEJ MESR. A BROWNI G COURTHOUS N E UntdSae Co r O Ap e l frt eNit Cic i ie tts u t f p as o h nh rut 9 - T S RE T 5 7H T E S N F NCICO, A 9 13 A M S C 40 AT : eksOfc T Clr' f e i lE:P ny e a. . cwazn g e,t l-Ap el f DCn .0 -2 9 VRW k e',t 1v S h ree gre a. pa o US o 90 2 2 Der ek a Clr: E coe pes f da oiiaadtocpe otefl wigd cmett b fldad nlsd laei n r nln w ois fh ol n ou nso ei n n g o e ld e wi teClr'Ofc o T eU.. ut f pasfrh Nit Ci ut o gd t h eks f e f h S Co ro Ap el o te nh r i: h i c 1 APE uly-otenClonas et oJidr a d1/21 ispotf a ) l qai . r r airi'Ltr fonedt 02/0n uproBy tN h f e e OiiaPoff evc Poiig tetAlRaPreiItrs(ymal r nlroo Srie rvdn Noi o l elatsn neetb i g . c i ) Pes po ieo r raiainwi e d re cpe o teed cmeti tesladesd lae rvd u ognzt t n osd o is fhs o u nsn h ef d rse , oh sn p devlp whc weh v icu e . tm e n eo e ih ae n ldd Iy uh v a yq et n, laefe fe t gv meacla: 1-7 -7 0 T nky u f o ae n usi spe s el'e o ie al t4 52 46 5 . h n o . o r Yozt ea datnindrce twadtimatrsmot p rcae . l i n t t ietd o r hs te i s apeitd rm eo Sn eey icrl, .' AraLa yr frIdvd aFed m,t lsFl go a Amii ra Bre i S p ot e w es o n iiu l reo ea. in f n c Cuie ifn u p r 'i o Panif- p ele; f lit sA p l s& f e z . Z . Ta a P n aoi Di co w l ayc st r tr ,e AP Eq ai - r e'Caiona I u ly Not l l ri t hn f

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets were retrieved from PACER, and should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.