Kristin Perry, et al v. Arnold Schwarzenegger, et al

Filing 23

Filed original and 7 copies of Pacific Justice Institute amicus brief of 18 pages. Served on 09/24/2010. [7492905] (FT)

Do k tNo ce . I te nh 1 -6 51 01 7 Kntt *t ts G ur pf ppt t t; a t t ag pr, 'f o/ c nt %j l jo Mt s y W i fit t n rm lo:E )K L (j,u )j A R )q l %# . m w s P2821 E 22 RD W n r mn Y KRITI P RRY,t 1 SNE ea. , ad n MV l= . M PanisAple, litf-pels f 'e ! k CIYAMDC UNT OFS NF NCS O, T O Y A V IC Plit -ne eo-p ele anX ltx nrAp l , e ARNOL S HWARZE EGGAR, DC N i hsofca cp ct a Go en ro Caionae a. n i fiilaai s vro f l ri,t 1 y f , DENNI HOLLI GS ORTH,t 1 S NW ea. , ad n COUNT OFI PE I L ea. Y M R A ,t 1 , Deednsltreos fna t hevnr, A pelns p l t. a Apafo aDeio oteUidSaeDirt or o te oten srtfc lona pelrm cinfh nt tt si Cut rh N r rDi i o afri s e s tc f h tc , No 0- V022 'Ho oa l V uh R. le . 9C -2 9 n rbe ag n Wakr AM I USCURI E BRI FI S PPORT OFAPP LLANTS C A E NU E C UHE COUNTY RAM T RI OANDOASEL R IOR OF OT T OFI P OFI PEEB A DIFB P VARGAS N Y M E IV H AL R S U E V S S Kristin Perry, et al v. Arnold Schwarzenegger, et al Doc. 23 MA IE B. RE N L SES . TI W MC Y O D , Q I KE I T S DE , s . VN .N R E Q P CII J S I EI S IUT A FC U TC N TT E PO. x2 6 0 . Bo 7 6 Sca et, ai mi 9 87 arm no C lo a 52 f (1)5-90 eehn 968760 Tl oe p (1)5-92Fcii 968760 as l me Atnyfr mi s ui, tresoA c Cre o ua fciJscIsit 'fcutentu l/ i te * CISPE'03PEL ONLRS(0-PA JE S 8)A Dockets.Justia.com PPEORCCDAE Y RIDNE L PP T YE R Rue2 . CORPORATE DI CLOS RE S ATEM ENT l 61 S UT P ru n t F d rl l o Ap elt P o e te2 .,h u d rin d u sa to e ea Rue f p l e rcdl 61 te n esg e a r sae ta a iu c ra ,h P ct J sielsiue in t cpoainta ttsh t m c s u ie te a ic u t nt t,s o a o rt h t ict o ise soko h s ae t o oainta ise sok su s tc r a ap rn c m rt h tsu s tc . o S pe b r2 , 0 0 e tm e 4 2 1 l i . p ' By // Kei T.s ie : s vn nd r Ke i T. nd r Ba No 1 0 8 vn S ie CA r . 7 9 8 P CI I J S I E W S I UTE A FC U T C TT P. .o 2 6 0 O B x 760 S ca e t,CA 9 8 7 arm no 52 yy i 1 1 P oe (1) 5-90 hn: 96 8760 - - a; W V VVX -- x p W Emalkvnndr pcljsc.r - i eisie@ aicut e g : io At refr mi sPct Jsc Ist e t ny o A c , aicut entm o u iii TABLE OF CONTENTS CORP RAT DI CLOS RE S AT M E T O ES U TEN I E TI Y AND W TE ES OFTHE DN T RT 1l C CU E- SIPIE E T(FIIZ- zlElt (11 ;:- I N ; Vk -4pl3 O 2!2 - kM W MI :II kL l 6 h ll;IRY ........... iEEI ........... ET ..........2 W T ODUCT ON AND S MM ARY OFTHEARGUME T........... R I U N ..........3 .......... 1 Ov riw o Ho o eu lyi An in Gre ea dRo e...... . eve f m sx ai n ce t e c n m ......4 t ...... l. (ls1a (rc)?)nlV1ws(z a 1g .............1 l 2sc l3e (l(At - ) =- e............. 1 t-L1lz e l a ............. B. TABLE OFAUT ORI I S H TE CAS S E Per v S h azn g e ry . c w re e g r -- - Fsp .d--2 1 WL3726( .. AA g l,00....., .upz - ,00 108 ND C u .22 1)..... 4 ....3 ta s v O tn r us . ro 6 Y. t 3 1 9 ..........................@.. 1 6 ) ....................@.......1 1 ............................ 2 CONS I UTI NS TT O a1O 5 5 l( 1 (lt t)5 il 1' 8 i) - )si il ce 1 1 l tl t ................ ................ ................ ai) i (zt t)r il 17 1 ....................... l( 1 lsi il ce 1 ....................... t l tz ....................... l1) 1 tzt tl, il 11jS.....................2 t1 - lsi il ce 1, 5..................... lr J l tz -t t ...................... U.. n tm in Fo re nhAme d e t S Co si o , u te t n m n t OTHER AUTHORI I S TE Arsol, hc b . itt Etis k e ' tt 1o a e n tis 1 e ca c Arsol, lia b . itt Poic , k 1 et 1 eO, lc s tll, t ll&, .1 ....................15 - r t u l1s ? --t 11 .................... 5 c r lt ll s z) .................... ' c r5 ac s ul s e li 5 1 eo ru lu 5 i ci s 1 4 1e O, Jc sll1s z tis1 .:! ....................3 - r t u M lt , ; le ! t71 ...................1 c r n ll lt 3 $: ................... Do e, J Gre Ho o eu ly1 v rK. ek m sx ai 4 , t ( avr Unvri PesC mbig, u dtd18)......,, 1 H rad iesy rs, a r eMA p ae 99...... 6 1 t d .....5 Gln e Peu ia =C L 1 .7 1 a d s rsn e 1 16 2 Hu b r, h ma K. mo eu lyi Greea dRo e b ad T o s Ho sx ai n ec n m : t - dSucbo oB sc cmet1 (nvri o Cai riPes oreokf aiDou ns 5U iesy f lona rs, t f 1ek1 y2::)3.......................,16 1, 1 3ree (9 1()....................... t ) ( 1 y :,() ......................5 ,, ) ' Te m eo C ntnies rig Lgsain(9 5 h E prr os t 'Marae ei t 19) an lo J dt E a sGrb ,rw q dFa i i L t Aniut: u i v n u b f n m l n ae t i h y qy Mu o isRu u:h Ro a S cae 8 snu fs te m n orts 9 (oaE L te. t n.97 C r .uz d& r s14) a Puac , y ug s1 . ltrh L c r u 84 P bisOvdu Nac , tmoph sn97 07 0 u l iis so Mea r o e .0 -1 u P meo , aa , ce t e c . Poic lS ca a dCul r l soy o ry S rh An in Gree W lia, o il n t a Hitr t u (11!.(xodllAlir3 S,1(! ..................t 11 11 Xfr -lis)1eS1)7 ..................5 14 4, lit t r ()) .................. r R fsMuoisIMaraea n i pt te usiop isp y ....1 uu, snu,s rig Hadc oh P rutf hl oh ? ....5 a o .... Ru u, snu , h udEvr Chl T a iBonb Ras d fsMu o isS o l ey i h ts r e ie ? d R fsMuoisWhtsteC i E do Marae uu, snu, ai h he n f rig ? f S eo isNeo2 u tnu r 8 Tlltl; (r2 e ez11 n sla=1s!)-()................8 rtttns )( n =2(j e e - :6)1) ................ lfll l 1)e u .6 ( ................ T jl , fnoC riaLe P r ete o NauaMar g , n ioAl s adnl pz es ci s n trl ri e lo pv a T e auefmar g adi vr u ap cs4Av MaiL h n tr o ri e n t ai s set, e r . a so a Re.9 (06 (ut gCcr, nDuis 3 v2 7 20)qoi ieo O t 2 n e Grf n& E. . ln e s, ii M At s d . t d 1 3 WieJh ,r TeGod adG asfMar g, t,onJ. h os n olo ri e t , a :; t Ill l.e.(6(()).............../1, 515 7Nor TreJ v 11 :)1 ..............1,3 1,t t e l l R )) !( ..............: t Z n o Ciu , r2 8Soc r m V tr m Frg e t = e o f t m F .4 tio u eeu a m na i Ilg n sLe 1s21!-3)......................... Do e e l1d- 3 :)1 ( ........................6 t u .6 ........................) I ENTI Y AND I TERES OFTHE AMI ICURI E D T N T C A PACI I J S I E I S I UTE FC U T C N T T T i a iu c ra b ifsb igfe b P cfcJ sielsi t. hs m c s uie re i en i d y aii ut n tue l ct T eP cfcJ sielsi t i an npoic poainog nz du drscin h ai u t n tue s o -rf o rt ra ie n e e t ict t o o 5 1c() fh ltraReeu C d.Amiu iddctdt poiiglgl 0() o tenenl vne oe css eiae o rvdn ea 3 i l ' ' srie t tec mmu i wi o t h rei teae so Frt n me t ihs evc so h o nt t u c ag n h ra f isAme d n r t, yh g 1 t j l prclliteraorl iu letssec adascain lta atuaynh aes feiosi re,peh n soit .nht ir g bi o tePaicJ sieI si eruieyrpee t tefi c mmu i ,t a a h cf u t ntm o t l e rsns h at o nt ih s n ict n h y '.. J'.! E l J .. ltrsmteoto eo-ecs.Thslprclf#tu mtatel-ecut neet h ucm fh ae' i s atuil re hth b r or t l W ma ei d cso b sdu o wh tt eiv dt b rl iu b l f o tev tr d t eiin ae p n a ib l e o e ei o s ei s fh oes s e g e o Cai ri.T eb if u mie h ri d e n te et ru e t o tep r e f lona h re sb t d een o s o rp a ag m ns fh at s f t i o oh ra iib t lpo ieau iu p rp ciewi teg a o assigte r te m c, u wi rvd nq e eset t h o l f sit h l vh n Co ri i a ay i. u tn t n lss s T ib ifsfe p ru n t cn e t f 1Co n e o Reod hs re i i d u sa to o sn o a1 u sl f c r. l S ATEM ENT OFI S ES T SU F o a hsoia p rp cie d e stn tep rmeeso mar g a a rm n itrcl es et , o s et g h aa tr f ri e s n v i a o p s esxu inidct u c nt uin l ici iaino oh r ierfet p oi e no n iae n o si t a dsr n t r tew s elc t to mo maiea ansho oe uasa amatro lw? lc g i t m sx l s te fa 1 S ATEM ENT OFF CTSAND P OCEDURAI HI TORY T A R ,S T efcsnticsaeo pbiko ld e n cnob sbeto h ati hs ae r f ul nw eg ad ant eujct c rao e dsue OnNo e b r , 0 8 tep o l o teSaeo Caiona esn d ip t. v m e 4 2 0 ,h e pe fh tt f l ri f a e d dterCo si t nb p aeul c sigter alt.T ea e d e t m n e h i n tui y e cfl at h ib l s h m n m n to yn o a d dscin75t Aril l ihra si f1:G nyma ig b t enama d e eto . o t e whc ed n u1 i l n a e ew e c o n 1 :.( '. . I 1 : ; .. . ' .' g y adawo a ivl o rcg ie i Cai ri. T eatoi frh p o l t n m n s ai r eo nzd n lona' h uh rt o te epe o d f' y a edteCosiuinwa drvdfo Arill,j18 1 adArilXVl1 m n h nt t s eie rm t e Ij ,,0 n t e I, to c c j3o teCosi t n OnNo e br ,0 8a etariaywrt sfe i fh nt i . vm e520 ,n xrodnr iwa i dn mo l -- t--iY i StrmeCb- se 'ga i meit-tN fh a e met - - - h c l a t e Y e n n m ab te m n nef p --o c aln igwh te teCo si inwa lwfl a ed do wh te Aril 1 h l gn eh r h ntm o s a ul m n e r eh r t e , e t y c j75wa a ieal eatdrvso.DtigteliainteCaiona . s n lgl nce eiin ln h igt ,h l ri ly r to f At re Geeaage taAril1j75(l ko na trp sin8'n t ny nrlrudht t e, . as nw s ooio 'ad o c o pt tet ar g Amed ef) s na fl addtteC ntuinbcue h rae nm n 'wa ulw ul de oh o stt eas Mi y io ma ig i a n l n berg t'l a6 1d cso ,h CaionaS pe eCo r n a e s n E ai a l ih. n - e iin te l ri u rm u t ie ' f rjce taagmetn fudtate epeatdlwfl i a edn ter eetdhtru n ad on hth pol ce a ul n m nig hi y Co si t n1 nt ui . to OnMa 2 , 0 9 alwsiwa fldi fd rl o rc aln ig y 2 2 0 , a ut s i n e ea cu t h l gn e e teMar g Ame d e t ae u o teF u te t Ame d e tote h ri e n m n b sd p n h o renh n m n t h a 'tus . r n4 C l4h34(09. Sr svHot ,6 a.t 6 20) a o U.. o smt n T efdrl ir toretrdug etgis SC nt i . h eeadsi cutnee jdm n aant io tc Saed fn a t o Au ut1 ,201 . tt ee d ns n g s 2 02 I TRODUCTI N AND S M M ARY OFTHE V GUM ENT N O U Ciiz t n whc h v tlrtdo e e c lb ae h mo e u l vl ai s ih a e oeae r v n eertd o sx a io rlto sis a en n tees e uae ma ig s a t manania a eain hp h v o eh ls rg ltd n a e o s o iti t s n ' 1 1 . 1 o p st sxu in. hs re wi b cnie t po iiga o eve o p oi e no T i bif l e o fn d o rvdn n v riw f e l h moe u lyi a ce t ec a dRo ea dte dsu sh s sceis o sx ai n n in Gre e n m n h n ic s to e o it ' t e 3 mara elws rig a . ., a .. ; - '@ - p. p T ed-t -c- '-imis eas int--- inao ei n as fte ' h -itit'o ' s si se o h't o n s o u iih - -o j t v t te -t 1 e e ntae , o f 1 rao t d f ema ig i go s smpit . Aswi b d mo srtd smeo esn o ei n a e s rsl i lsi 4 n y c tegetsmid ta teW et a po u e cmet tesmec n lso a te h raet n sh th s h s rd cd a o h a o cu in s h v tr o Caio i rg rigtei p ra c o gvn seil lc t ma ig a oes f l m a e adn h m otn e f iig p ca pae o n a e s f amaea dfmaeu d ra n .Th Gre sa dRo a s i n t ce t rig l n e l n etl g e ek n m n dd o a cp mar e d a b t enama a dawo a wi o t o me t As lb dsu sdi ti bif ew e nn m n t u c m n. wi e ic se n hs re, h l teeweeitl cu l rb s cvl ain ta lf awrt nrc r o b t ter h s r nel tal o u t iiz t sh tet ie e od f oh h i ey io t p i sp yo timatro p bi p l ya wel stera s e uaigma ig hl o h n hs t f u l oi s la h ilw rg lt n a e o e cc n 2er vSh aznge--Fsp .d--2 1 WL372 6( .. AAu . Pry . cw reegr- .upz -,00 10 8 ND C g 1,00. 22 1) 3t udn t epat a i ti l i dsaet dsu s o oe u lya d lwo l o b rci ln hs i t p c o ic s h m sx ai n c me t maig fr vr mao cvlain l tateacet eoRo a nae o eey jr iizt .nhth nin Grc- m n io cvl ain aepi aysuc sfr oicllg lh u h a ds utr i te iizto s r rm r o re o p lia,e a to g t n t cue n h i t r UntdSae,h ywi b tee a pe u e i ti bif i ttste l e h x m ls sd n hs re. e l 3 ' ' SJ U OIXS D H 3J O I I WI P?fl!XNlg01u :JJ IOSEO Ot!3 JlP?JMulolooa JIJ u lgl T t !33D CISIJ IuZ t u 2 /st dld I O l o$ ;; u ; OI) t X IC JSWI P JPSO O 0 0U 3O ! Cd0IFI U UC Q Slt I 0I q I OIU I OO IU O q ) 12 3) J t I J IN ; !cI P) T I 3 )) M x l op to p =Aio 3J1 u no !pgq s t S lslp om=o!S OD ' cd lgu o u t d ! S p lu I fn op usop ? J J; P J s oW I . J COI I 0IS ;! 2d3lJ OmEl u $J= 0lJ 3u PA S lo to O JI d t ! 3; J t O l lP ? t ) t O 3 3 !3 ul dl o p)3) 1 $ ll Ac!t Elw ?gq ooldSOD sp Mo Jln oou tg gupAq I)!Iqo x d sl P J oc d p x stolo ogl: II q 33 . 3 31 9 * Y * 1 310 PHu@3 J )I!I I IMI 3OIO J M3A a O 11N 3 3D I3aW 1 I I SI H O !J A ! XI AVH ZDXV W 'Eq O I JSI I J < :;co MJlnuu o0tut! oolpv o ol t J m pd jm x p c n v v sI q u g o oohool u s lsopl.g x sg t m 0/1o ;O JI u X gw q l? o go ! dq u l g In o p u 11 q I:/ p = g l 1 l l I I i i #' o J I u o Eltos Io ld=sop ? 1- o o p n o xqu s? vp o s-p l m l J ;JO3ln X? II0; !I O01 0UIOI PS3C3) 3I O O 3J l d u P0I)# JW ItJ CUIV OnO tPAM P q ) T 1 POI O QSOJS C I ! ! OdJ U I S OCol. f' mo l u p p od S O n J SM I ) ) J 0 OW I O t l q x o o m sl W O Om S I Js o t p cXc l ol Nl n oou ql Jq tc p socIooau : ln p u u out go p x sto o gw p g on o gulg ! us u p vcu pa mol- p cJlmc oslq t c p q vw s o o d Iop fl u o o lo tl u oo q qo w p : go l w u d o glnod i Jlddmpgd oJpou ' suoJlo g s qut&! t! Og oMsl g un o dc ;ol ls sl ood o - tg JuJ JM q o-. o o u ?d m OIA O 0 IIIJ P S SICJA VZ'! n SI0IlI 0 3IOOO $olX 3I U 3 ) OPO On OJSOP I I = 0I tg/I $ C JJJ!! 3 ! V? I IU d S CI' ' f fOUS J 3J t JJP I I 1 ZJO t IO J I IOI M I D S J O JP O O 3I 0 OI I 1 S I O 1 Ip O I U IV I T S Q d II ! CI * I SJ O N SJq 0 =0 x= S Dq l d $1AO%N.q 6 = Tu =l 0 P OO A P O 0 q !@ ?T ru 1 tO ZP 3I W 1 V= P JA 3U JH 3SJ QJ NXI f= !S0 % u oo 0 ' O q/ t 0 T : OIOJ SUJ J. 3 PJq 0 0 'I 0 S 0 /: l q (0 1*a@ uouq l 16 0 slo gtu p o p ox g: l a Mo l Ju lqq /0 1swx p vg slt lv l l x o o oi lx p go u s xul l , o u q ll o o o o (ITf 'O I P;!)JI=T RJE=O A0Po J ZTI So S = 00 z; SI O!A SC J d0S J u= #=ET - TTn q TT olowla o og os l Aatq xyi llNu ls o qto 'lo ' o q/ q on s o o w a= ow . ' l. l zlg u q o / oo o s o /: l lq -p u q g Isl Jlolnop qza' v;qJloH'l sual pl : ( 6 sod s au : g uc s lu oqc x z npnu o d, r l u) ' (1f 00 g 'o u p;!)sJJ po?ooA/vMg g sat=owlxmugw zi s o o!A gp =@ d s u uf v r lpA ct sl cv lc t ' ! i .1 1 1 '. '1 1 . -, -t ? j <0)n0mIIMVU4V ' OI O **) fS DDs oOWO F9 ' lo u! PJ t! ' / ' W IAN uG # m .of Y t O dr o )S V I 4 l Xp .9j .gj : .p p y ) - - .o-u ouqasodazswal -a,.oio mupocJu-oo;- p o -ognvl s -vu-woc dJql dovu), av so w pwu o o c m -cs o -o u c d a o, lx . a p uq f a q q o w ' u v o m a s qoo p uo X t u t sl / ocup ?o to 0 )X p o old ga sod lf gI ol om u lt u p u. q q ou l x m u l )M o - I ! Ina glwt swt pcol: olinuoopt S l oos cgl cxs t l ! p u zu oo st u l ut u !-t ;; ;p T; Ggua !oioupgqsl;ap odvooJt t g sopval i tv u J sf! fn s stcld u gl l o sll:z s q pM ' I I 3 )qS OFIJII O I . I M o U I J CI S DU o X : lpqo gmscpu JJppoA?o swru Npu. lgqu opost up ll. l Io! ?o o op t t l ! !oog o l l ! l lk j a xd u t Jm qSM O O ou pl pt P TO I u l Jwl ;I Y A MO /l g E A I lo d l OSW I ol o OEd O O H ; ; S; I'Pl PSn S l P CS O JA CItO IIO Uu U M U 3 O 1 ) p l s c u q p v uplX p qo q Xu d s p c Ja lal ! ol ! q o - u t q o l sv lv ! u o o t u ; u &l:t Mo mslg'lo ,ouuso tcl olsolpt ! i lz u u:q'osq ptu nz uo; t pg l qI 'l s; ; S l soluq Eul ooJtou pvsos:p ptl Sloo ul t o;t os o gl o u v d um ut uqn; d; sv l l uA pu Xqa;cu:lms'tlgusmcsstJAlq Ju oo u) o I Jo ux ''u; to d cloo 0)o v I g ' Xq o cp ?u t uu a o a o post l wn ovu g C c u o t u jz. q . p - 8 O IM 0q UJ 1' UO 1O 0 U s oq o oog ; tco op sl:pt to ; u tvp to s o sM Mo ''v p fo p l q ou o q s l! l u q S ou ou m g s c q ' q ; p J p o Jq q < u l x qJo l ou l md .o ; ! ov ssc o , ' opld d o o : g p M s ol o lq l op g q u p lq JA q, s l n o pg z u ccugp cgcuc ; wq: ou p opcds> A slp dc c su Iltc o ltc u lt q q u tc o l l c q co g v d !adu x J u 'l mg c g/UJ oEslq u uu lsol ou ssggIf pq g u o4 Ai p d IIO J sga p o osn s to ! Jt s sl o s p )u : lo o p o o poa sqt nus mus calt n q v l' is / c oJ Jq t uq n ; l o. l l p t c ! .t l o q rz t n p u o o w u lm l ;: .l o ?p cp p cu lto o sx a b h vo a d iie o r a e e ld o l id o e f e ain f eu l e a ir n h dn rl iu isi to soe fresx a po iio s 8 a o ei o snt uin t noc e u l rhbt n . g t i3 l te eu l (8 B..Paowrttaiwa ovo sht&js nh Rp bi 30 C) lt oehtt s biu taE ut c a Reu l .. sarn efr rig s sca e tl n temot ardmara e p bi .mut ra g o mara e,arm na a d h ssce rig s c 3 d a 3 4ct gGln e Peuia = CL 1 .7 1 5 .t 4 in a d s rsn e 1 16 2 . 1 i 3Tiuls14 6 b l .. u 3Ovd Mea oph sn97 07 0 7 i, tm r oe .0 - 1 . 3Do e, u r ,t 0 . 8 v rsp a a 2 3 be sleietoal jr iizt n.Ave taC lona oesat ga en efvdn t 1mao cvlai s iw ht ai rivtr,ci s io f n teut aelwma esweeirt n lnd cdn t mananteta io a h lm t a k r, r rai a i eiig o iti h rdt n l i o i fmi u ia teb i igbo ko ter o mu ie i n tsp otdb te a l nt sh ul n lc fh ic m nt s s o u p re y h y d i hsoia rc r.l ve o teGre a dRo a ve so b t h mo eu ly itrcle od n iw fh ek n m n iw n oh o sx ai t a dtei p ra c o mara ea teb ssfretbihn teh u e od i n h m otn e f rig sh ai o sa l ig h o sh l, t s s pyd e n tolw ta l in mara ea b t enama a dawo a i i l o s o fl h ti t g rig s ew e m o mi nn mns bg td h tfl roh r iemaiiu . Hitrcl ,t s i pyarao a l ioe , aeu o tew s l o s soial iwa sm l e sn be c y d tr iainma eb gethn esma yo wh m weeh mo eu la o t eem n t o d y ra tik r, n f o r o sx a, b u T eeaeav r t o l igarn e e t fr ihp o l f dte sle. h r r ai y fi n ra g m ns o whc e pe i h m ev s e v n S meo teeaeb sdo meep ro a o go pepoain Otesaeb r of o fh s r ae n r esn l r ru x lrt . h r r on o n c si .No eh ls,h s atraieu i aen tt ara e' eest n teestee l n t nt r o t rig s' y ev s m Re rt byteeiisfiin sa et dsu sget iizto s9o te get l h r snu f e t p c o ic s ra cvl ain m h a c i Eateaiet lwso mara ea dtefmi ,ao gwihviwso srlt o a n rig n h a l ln t e n v y h moe u ly T o esra so to g t udas b h lfloteCo r i o sx ai . h s tem fh u h wo l lo e epu t h u tn t frh r e o srt gta ted cso b tev tr f d rao e sp otn ute d m ntai h th e iin y h oes i s esn d u p r i n n oh r itrc l n p i sp ia ta io s No eh ls,tss fiin t s o te hsoia a d hl o hc lrdt n . n teesii ufce to h w o i ta tet osceiswhc ma etemot inf at o tiuin t ti h th w o it , ih d h ssg icn c nr t so hs e i bo Ote ta terw p we ta a e p rr o sse ,teewa n lg l ai fr h rh n h a o rh t n m eo p sesd h r s o e a b ss o 1 7 teG aig.( cesdSp.72 1) h E nae'A cse et1,0 0. m ' c u tyi p i sp y tep lia sse ,n telw, eme mara eb t en o nr n hl o h ,h oicl ytm a d h a d e d rig ew e o t o p st sx sa fu d to a t a od rdscey T ru htev t gpo es p oi e e s o n ain lo n ree o it. ho g h oi rc s, e n iwa tec l ciewid m o tect e so Caio i t manana t sh ol t so fh izn f l m a o iti n ev i f u d rtn igo ma ig whc i cn itn wi tewid m o tecvl ain n esa dn f n a e ih s o sset t h s o fh iizt s h io fr ihte aeh is T i i n t ioe a dii n t n esn be Th r i o whc h y r er. hs s o bg td n ts o u rao a l. ee s ' j h t .' .t ' 1 ' g ' j t ? rget lisfcetpc itee ae tpoie igahclkths f ertby nuf i saen hspgso rvd borpiasece o a in itlcul i ttaaeqoe ihri.T oesece wolrvatate nel taga shtr utdn een h s kths ud eelhthy e n hdclausfinsfmi me brwh weehmoeullde,o eo a ol ge,red,a l m es o r o sx a. nedsm f e y ' tk- me weeteh-v sg y l l sn ete aen t-lk tV tr 6 h-- n r l tj e a . h s e s y r o u- ' h -ej f s e t -e hik o Cai mi.Wh te d si ti o b cu eo ti,h s get ndtr ie lo a eh r ept hs r ea s fhstee ra me eem n d f e ta mar g so l b l i da a isiuinb t enama a dawo a . h t ri e h ud e i t s n nt t ew e a me to nn mn He c , eiigmara ea au ino ama a dawo a rf cs o o l te n e d t n rig s no f n n n m n el t n t ny h e - c l ce wid m o tect e sb t fh a e a wel ol td so fh izn , u o te g s s l. e i Rep cfl sb ie ti 2 t d yo S pe b r2 1 . s etul u m t d hs 4h a f etm e, 0 0 y t By // Ke i T.nd r : s vn s ie Ke i T. nd rCA Ba No 1 0 8 vn S ie r .798 P CI I J S I EI S I UT A FC U TC N TT E PO .o 2 6 0 . B x 76 0 S ca e t,CA 9 8 7 arm no 52 P oe (1) 5-90 hn: 96 8760 Fx (1) 5-92 a: 96 8760 Ema: eisie@pc/jsc. g - i kvnndr aicut eo l ir Atrefr miu, aicJsc Istt t ny o A csP ci ut entue o fii CERTI I ATE OFCOMPLI NCE FC A 1 T i bif c mpis wi te tp -ou e l i t n o F AP . hs re o l t h y ev lm i t i f R eh m ao 3( ) ) )i ta i cnan n moe ta 1,0 wod. Acodn t 2A ( ( n ht t otis o r hn 400 rs crig o 7B '' . 1 1 1 Mirs fWodsi tt t s'ti d c me t o tis41 0wod . co ot r ' ai i , hs o u n c nan ,3 rs s sc ' 2 T ibito pis ttetptc rqimeto-'-xp3()5 hsrecm l wi h yeaeeur ns t R 2a(0 - eh e s adtetp s erqi met o F A 3() )bcueti bifhsbe n h ye t eur ns f R P 2a( eas hs r a en g e 6 e pe ae i ap o o t n l sa e tp fc u ig Mirs f OfieWod 2 0 rp rd n rp ri al p cd y ea e s oy n co ot f c r 03 Ti e Ne Ro a 1 p ity e m s w m n 4 on tp . By - / Ke ir s ie: / -vt nd t 1 t : .* 7 .1 . . ( 1 l Kei T. ndrCABa No 10 8 vn S ie r .798 P CII J S I EI S I UT A FC U TC N TT E P. .o 2 6 0 O B x 760 S ca e t,CA 9 8 7 arm no 52 P oe (1) 5-90 hn: 96 8760 F x (1) 5-92 a: 96 8760 Emalkvnndr pc cuteog - i eisie@ ai jsc. : l ir Atrefr csP ct Jsc lstt t ny o Amiu, ai utentue o kii 1 9 CERTI I ATE OF S RVI E FC EC l eeycriyta o S pe b r2 , 0 0 Ieeto ial fldte h rb et h t n e tm e 4 2 1 , lcrncl ie h f y frg igwi teClr o teCo rfrteUntdSae Co ro Ap e l fr oe on t h ek fh u to h i tts u t f p as o h e teNit Cic ib u igteap l t CM/ CFs se . h nh rut y s h p el e E y tm n a P riia t i tec s wh aergsee CMJ C u eswi b sre b at p ns n h ae o r e itrd E F sr l e evd y c l i tea p l t CM/ CFs se . h p el e E y tm a L ' ( '( .j j i j 1utecrftasme fhprc atiteaernteiee fr retyhto ote ati nsnh csa orgsrd hi ip e t CW ECFues 1 aemaldtefrgigdcmetyFrtclsMal sr. hv i h oeon ou nb is- as i e , p sepea ,r aedsatdit Y p rycmmeca'rifff ot rp i o v iptl --- l at o rl i d - t - ;a d l eyt tefl wign nCM / CFp riiat: ei r o h ol n O - E at p ns v o c JfryMae r efe te Liet lsiue b r nt t yt 2 01W PlnoPakwa 0 a ry S i 10 ut 6 0 e Pa o T 7 0 5 ln , X 5 7 Lic l C. ih n n on Ol a t p Cou b sS h o o La lm u c o l f w T eCah l Unv ri o Ameia h toi iest f rc c y W ahn tn DC 2 0 4 sigo , 0 6 W c adJ Betn hr . t a BOI SS HI L R & F EXNER LLP E C LE L 7hFo r t lo 5 5Le igo Av . 7 xn tn e Ne Yok, 1 0 2 w r NY 0 2 T o a MoeS cey h m s r o it Si 40 ut 4 e 2 S LaS l Sre 9 . al t t ee Chc g ,L 6 6 3 ia o I 0 0 s / Se h nMo r tp e oe T o a Beca h m s rjh 2 0 CERTI I ATE OFS M ENES FC A S 1 , Kei T.ndr vn Sie ety h ths re s d ni lo i f c ,cr f tati b i i ie t a t Spe br 42 1 et e2,00 m p s at m un tev rinsb ie eeto ial o h eso u m t d lcrnc l n t y A1Nit Cic iCae . 1 nh rut ss t R l6c o te miirt eOreR grigEet ncFl gi o ue () fh Ad nsai dr eadn lcr i in n tv oi Dae t: Spe br 72 1 etm e2,00 Sg aue s KeiT S ie in tr : / vn .ndr