Dennis Hollingsworth, et al v. USDCSF, et al

Filing 11

Received a copy of Supreme Court of the United States Office of the Clerk Washington, DC notice re: the enclosed per curiam was issued. [7203616] (RL)

Download PDF
Supr m e Cour oft eUnied St t s e th t ae Ofi eoft e Cl r fc h ek W as i gt n, 205 30001 h n o DC 4Wiim KS tr la .ue l Cekote or l fh Cut r J n a y1 , 0 0 a u r 32 1 (0)7-01 224931 1 5 Co netc t e ue N. . 0 0 n ciu Av n , W W ahigo , C.2 0 6 s n tn D. 0 3 Re De ni Holng wo t , ta. : n s li s rh e l v. itnM. ry,ta. Krsi Pe r e l No. 9 6 8 0A 4 DerMrOlo : a . sn TsonoB&sutcherLLP hde.o ernOn ol Gi Du n Cr b to- - Lz -: 7/ * > Y+ # *r Ya Wz e /04 *4 * &O p *p 4 t co : t 4o o e ouy4je o lMpep ap :i e ee z < do #, t y Th e doe p rc ra i tea oee tte cs is e td y. e n sd e u im n h bv -nild ae su d o a Veytuyy us r rl o r, Wila K. trClr lim Sue, ek B( z ' y; r Da n Bikel ny c l Saf tr e tfAton y Dennis Hollingsworth, et al v. USDCSF, et al Doc. 11 Dockets.Justia.com R OLc D YRC4K E E IV E D M LYc W E kR u .oi oApAs .ctTFuu sR Cta: 5 U S ( 1) i s58 .. 2 0 e 0 Pr uim e C ra F' l * J.1 21 A 9C : nT ki Ic g m S PREM E COURT OFTHEUNI ED S ATES U TT No0A68 .9 4 DE NI HO LNGS OR H E A .. S I M. N S L I W T T L pKRITN PE RYE A . R TL O AP LC TO F RSAY N P IA IN O T ( nay1,00 J ur 321) a PE C RA . R U IM Weaeak dt sa tebo dat f fdrlra. We r se o ty h ra cs o a eea til rsle ta q et n wi ot epesn a y ve o eov h t u si t u xrsig n iw n oh wh te sc til so l b bodat We ised ehr uh ras hud e racs. n ta dtr ieta tebo datntics so l b sa e eem n h th ra cs i hs ae hud e tyd bcuei a pastecut blw ddn tfl w te ea s t p er h ors eo i o ol h o apo rae poeue stfrh i fdrl1w bfr p rpit rcd rs e ot n eea a eoe c a gn terr lst alw sc bo datn . Cors h n ig h i ue o l uh racsig ut o efreterq ie eto poeua rg lrt o oh noc h eurm n f rcd rl euaiy n tesa dmutolwtoerqie e tte sle. r, n sfl h s eurm nsh m evs o T i lws i si i ap ei iaysae iv le a hs a ut tl n rl n r tg n ovs n ,l m ato caln igwh ttep risrfrt a P ooio cin h l gn a h at ee o , rp st n e e s i 8 aCai ri b l t rpst nao tdb teeetrt. , lona al pooio dpe y h lcoae f o i Po oio 8a ed dteSaeC ntuinb a dn a rp sin m n e h tt o si t y d ig t to nw scin poiigta tonymaraebt en a e et rvdn ht sll rig ew e ' o E ma a dawo a i v l o rcg ie i C lona' nn m n s ai r eonzd n ai ri. d f C lCntA t1j..T e litfcnedta Poo a. os. r.,75 h panis otn ht rpf st n8voae teUntdSae C n tuin A bnh ii ilts h ie tts o si to . e c o t tili tecs bgn o Mo dy J n ay1,2 1 ,n ra n h ae ea n n a, a u r 1 0 0 i teUntdSae DititCor frteNotenDitit h i tts src u to h rh r src e o C lona f ai ri. f T eDititC uth sis e a odrpr it gte h src or a su d n re em ti h n tilob bo datl evasra iga doa dvdot ra t e racs i i tem n u i n ie o v an mbro fdrl orh u e aon tecu ty T e u e feea cutoss ru d h o nr. h HOL I GS OR HpP RR LN W T . E Y Pr uim e C ra odrwa ise p ru n t ap rotda e d ett a re ssu d us a to up re m n m n o lcl l o teDititC ut T a R l h dp eiul oa Rue fh src o r. h t ue a rvo sy fridntebodatn o tilo tietecu to s obd e h ra csig fras usd h o rh ue i whc atila e pae T eDititC ut fetdis n ih ra tk s lc. h src or efce t a e d etva sv rlpsig o teDititCor' m n m n i eea ot s n h src ut n s We st i tedy i meitl bfr tetilnti b i n h as m daey eoe h ra i hs e cs wa t bgn ae s o ei. Ap l a t h r aedfn a titre osi telwpi ns ee r eed n- evnr n h a c n si. T e ojc t teDititCut odr agig ut hy bet o h src or' re, run s ta teDititC ut iltdafd rl ttt b po h th src o r voae eea saue y rm ugtn tea e d e tt i lclR l wi otsflaig h m n m n o t oa ue t u uf s h i ce topru i frn t ea d cmmeta d ta te in p otnt o oi n o n n h t h y c p bibo dat udvoaeterd epoesrg t t a u l ra cs wol ilt h i u rcs ihs o c fi a di p riltil Ap la t se a sa o te ar n m ata ra. pi ns ek ty f h c odrpn igtefigo ptt n frwrt o crirr re e dn h in f eio s o is f et ai l i o a dma d mu .Wega tdatmprr sa t cn ie n na s rne e oay ty o o sdr teisefrh r Potp .C nldn ta tea pi h su ute. s, . ocu ig h t h p l cnsh v ma ea sfcetso ig o ette e tt a t a e d ufin hw n f nilm n o i rl fwenw ga tasa . ei , o rn ty e P o oio 8 wa p se b C lonavtr i No rp st n s asd y ai ri oes n i f vmb r20 . I wa ab l tpooio d sg e t e e 0 8 t s al rp st n ein d o o i oetr arl gb teCai ri S pe eC utta vrun ui y h lona u rm o r h t n f pl n 2- 9 i Cizn U id v F drlElcin el t 8 2 n t es nt . eec et a i e o C mm', . > 2 5 n w pn igb fr ti C ut F r o n No 0 0 , o e dn eoe hs o r. o ea pe dnr t gop sp otn P ooio 8da e x m l, oos o ru s u prig rp st n s v ih rcie dah trasa de vlp scnann apweevd et het n n eoe o tiig o dr wht sbtne' Soe P o 8Do o We St ey ie u sa c. tn , rp nr b ie ' S o sDicou ei azEde S od N. Tme, e. , h w slsr s - gd w r , Y. i sF b 8 20 . S me avcts cam ta te h v rcie 0 9 o doae li h t h y a e eevd hd'vnsmesxculs r h t mar.Pooio a e a - ope a i to ry rpsin e g t 8wa adi tesbeto pbidbt truhu te s n s h ujc f ul eae hogoth c Saea d id e,n t n ie Isa vctscam ta tt n ,n ed ai w d. t d oae li h t o tslsv be erjcthreme.a arslffrAphyh r ensbeto. as .t spy ut f ul e ae f h u u pr a s, g n ere p bi oc d cou eo t i sp ot Se e ,Rel B i o i Cta: 8U.. ( 1) i s58 S 2 0 e 0 PrC ra e uim cnrnain lp oe cl a d emalmesgsfo o fo tt a h n al n - i sae rm o s o pn nso P o oio 8 ii. a doh r h v b e p o et f rp sin , bd, n tes ae en t fre t rs nterosatrt ea epbita te ocd o ei hijb f ibcm ul hthy g e c h d dn td t gop sp otn tea e d et se a o ae o ru s u p rig h m n m n, e B ifo C ne frC mptt eP lisa Amiu Cuie re fr e tr o o eii oic s cs ra vt 1- 4 i Ct esUntdv Feea El t nC mm', . 3 1,n izn i . d rl e i o n No i e co 0 -0 ,n w pn ig bfr ti C ut Op o et o 82 5 o e dn eoe hs or. p nns f P o oio 8as aealgdt h v cmpldGnent rpst n lo r l e o a e o i ltre i e e bakit' o popooiin 8 b sn se a d u gd lcl s f r-rp st s' o uiess n re oh r t byottoeb sn se i rtl to frsp tes o oct h s uiess n eai in o u a p rigteb l t au e Cal n Ga Aciit B yot ot h al mesr. rt , y tvss oct n o o Bakr o Po 8 Wal tetJun lDe. 7 20 , . ces f rp , lSre ora, c2 , 0 8 A3 An n meo sisa cso v n aim a dp yia vo d u ru ntn e f a dl n h scl is lneh v b e rpre a anttoewh h v be e c a e en eotd gis h s o ae en ie tida P o oio 8sp otr.S eE h . 1a d dnie s rpst n u pres e x sB,, n f i Lt Dee d n- treosMoinfrPoetv Ore i o fn a tl evn r' to o rtcie drn n Pryv Sh aznge,No 30-v022 (D C l er . cw reegr . :9 -29 N a. ) (eenfe Deedn- treosMoin. hriatr fn atl evnr' t ) n o Repn et fe si i teUntd Sae Ditit so dns i d ut n h ie tts src l C utfrteNotenDitito C lona se igt o r o h rh r src f ai ri, ekn o f iv l aePo oio 8 T e cne dta tea e d n ai t rpst n . hy o tn h t h m n d i me toteSaesC nttto voae teEq a P oen t h tt' o siuin ilts h u l rtc to a dDu P oesCa sso teF ute t Ame d in n e rcs lue fh orenh n me to teUntdSae C ntuin T eSaeo n f h ie tts osi t . h tt f to C lonadcie t dfn P ooio 8 a dtedfn ai ri el d o ee d rpst n ,n h ee f n i dn- treos(h aeteapiathr)nee te a tnevnr w o r h pl ns eeetrd h i c sit dfn is o si toaiy Abnhtil ea o ut o ee d t cntuin l . e c ra b gn n t t Mo d y J n ay1, 0 0 b fr teChe J deo te n a , a u r 1 2 1, eoe h if u g fh Ditit o r,h Hooal V u h R. le. src C utte n rbe a g n Wak r OnS pe b r2 , 09 teDititC u tnome te etm e 5 20 ,h src o r ifr d h p risa ah aigta teewa itrs i tepsii at t ern h th r sneetn h osbl e iyta tetil udb bodat Repn et idt h t h ra wol e ra cs. so dns n i ctdters p otfrteie, i a pia t opsd ae h i u pr o h da whl p l ns p oe ec f x'E h 9 p 7 , p t P tfrMa d mu i No 1l . x . , . 2Ap .o e.o n a sn . 0 u' i.T ecutntdta 'leeae o cus, u iil t h or oe h ts hr r,f oreJ dca l t Cofrnepst n o ti,b t lota Sliia1n neec oios n hs' u as ht' hss li i ' l t HOL I G WO T uP R Y LN S R H . E R Pr uim e C ra On mot ltr C ifJ deKoisio teUntd e nh ae, he u g zn k f h ie Sae C tto Ap el frteNit Cruta p itda tts oz f p as o h nh ici p one r trejdecmmitet eaut tepsiit o aot he- g o te o vlae h osbly f dpu i ig a Nit CrutR l rgrig tercrig a d n nh ici ue eadn h eodn n ta s iso o dsrc cu t rceig.T ecmmi e rn m sin f itit o r poedn s h o t e t (fwhc C ifJ deWakrwa a me br rcmo ih he u g le s m e) eo me ddt teNit CrutJ dca C u clh tdsrc n e o h nh ici u iil o nita itit cut b pr ie t ep rme t t bodatn cu t ors e em t d o x ei n wi ra csig o r t h poedn so atilb ss Che J d eWakrltr rceig n ra ai. if u g le ae ak o ld e ta whl tecmmitewa cn ieig cnw egd h t i h o te s o sd rn e tepltporm,f i cs wa vr muhi mida h i rga s s ae s ey c n n t o t h ta tmebcueih dcmet po ie c te a dwa h ti ea s t a o o rm nne hn n s to g tt b a iel a dd t frcnieain' I. h u h o e n da cn iae o o sdrto . d, ' E h 2 a 4 .T ecmmiteddntp bil dsls is x . , t 2 h o te i o u l y icoe t c cnieaino tepooa, o ddi sli o rcie osdrt f h rp sln r i t oit r eev c p bicmme t o tepooa. u l o ns n h rpsl c On Dee br 1,te Nit CrutJ dca C u cl cm e 7 h nh ici u iil o ni is e an wsrlaeidct gta i h da po e a su d e ees n iai h t t a p rvd n pltporm frdh l i du eo cmea i fdrl i rga o ' e i t s f a rs n e ea o t me dsrc cu t wihntecrut'I.E h 1, t1 T e itit o rs ti h ici. d, x . 3 a . h ' 703(A9(een fr ptPt. 06 C )hriat Ap.o e. e ) rlaeepandta teCu cl dcso dmede) ees xlie hth onis eiind n ld a ' a 19 Nit Crutpl/'ta h dbn e tep oo 96 nh ici oi ht a a nd h htc ga hn , swel srdoa dtlvso cvrg, fo r rp ig a la ai n eeiin oea eo cut poedn s Ii. T e rlaefrhridctd ta rceig. bd h ees u te n iae h t csswo l b slce frpriiaini teporm ae ud e eetd o atcp t n h rga o frp riiain i te pltporm h v sne be o at p to n h i rga ae ic en c o ise . su d On Dee br2 ,acaio o mei cmp ne rcm e 1 olin f da o a is e t q etdpr iso fo teDititCor t tlvs te u se em sin rm h src uto eeie h tilcaln igPo oio 8 T od y ltrtecu t ra h l gn rpst n . w a s ae,h o r e i idctdo isWe s eta i h da e ddCvl cl n iae n t b i h tt a m n e iiLoa t Rue7- , ihh dpe iul b n e tercrigo l 7 3 whc a rvo s a n d h eodn r y bodato cutpoedn s T ervsd vrin o ra cs f o r rceig. h eie eso f sytecifjdeo tedsrc cuti cnutto Y h he u g f h itit or n o slain wt tecifiutu g. Ii.Nofrhrgiens i h hec cijde bd ute udl e h r ' i Cta: 8 U S ( 1) i s58 .. 2 0 e 0 Pr uim e C ra 5 Rue7- cetda ecpint ti gnrl rhbt n l 7 3 rae n xet o hs eea po iii o o t alw Wrpriiaini aplto ohrpoetao l f atcpt n i r te rjc u oo o o toie b teJ dca Conio teNit Crut'1. h rzd y h u iil u c fh nh ici. d, l ' Eh 1.Aplat ojce t tervso,run ta x. 4 pi ns betd oh eiin agig ht c ayca g t Nit Cruto lclue wo l rq iea n h n e o nh ici roa rls ud eur sfce t oiea dcmme t eid uf in ntc n o n pro. i OnDee br3,h Diti Cor rvsdisWe st cm e 1te src ut eie t b i t e t rmoetepeiu a n u cmet bu teca g t o e v h rvo s n one n a ot h h n e o Rue7- .An w a n u cme twa pse idctn a l 7 3 e n o ne n s otd n iaig drp sdrvso o CvlL clR l 7- , whc h d t ooe eiin f ii oa ue 73' ih a p ' be dp rvdfrp bi cmmet' I.Ex .1. T e en ' poe o u l o n. d, h 7 h a c ' pooe rvs n wa te sme a tepeiul a rp sd eii s h a s h rvo sy n o n u cda e d et C mmet o tepooe rvso on e m n m n. o ns n h rpsd eiin weet b sb ie b F ia ,a u r 82 1. r o e u m t d y rd yJ n ay ,0 0 t OnJ n ay4 2 1,h DititC utaanrvsdis a u r , 0 0 te src or gi eie t We st. Th a n u cme trgrig te pooe b ie e n o ne n eadn h rpsd rvso o R l 7- wa rmoe a drpae wi a eiin f ue 7 3 s e vd n elcd t h tidvrin o tea n u cmet T i tid vrin hr es f h n one n. hs hr eso o sae ta tervsdR l wa ff cieDee b r2 , ttd h t h eie ue sif t cm e 2 ee v 20,adta 't ervsdrl wa aotdpru n 09' n h tsl eie ue s dpe usat ' lh t te d meit n e 'poiin o Tt 2 S cin o h i dae ed rvso f ie 8 et m l o 27()'I.E h 1,t . 01e. d, x .9a 3 ' OnJ n ay6 2 1,h DititC uth l ah aig a u r , 00 te src o r ed ern rgrigtercriga dbodat go teu cmig eadn h eodn n ra csi fh po n n til T ecu t n o ne ta a a doa dvdofe o ra. h o r a n u cd h t n u i n ie ed f til rceig wo l b sra e l et crancut ra poedn s ud e tem d i o eti o rv hu e i ohrcte. I as a n u cdta,pn ig o ss n te i s t lo n one h t e dn i a poa o teC if u g o teNit Cici tetil p rv l fh he J d e fh nh rut h ra , wo l b rcre a dte bodato teItr e.A ud e eodd n h n ra cs n h nen t cuttcnca epan dta tepoedn swo l b or eh iin x lie h t h rceig ud e rcre b trecmea, n te tersln bod eodd y he a rs a d h n h eut g ra i cs wo l b u la e frp sigo teltre, t a at ud e po dd o otn n h nentwi h dlyd et poesn rq ie et. ea u o rcsig eurm ns O J n ay 7 2 1,h DititC t tfe a odr n a u r , 0 0 te src ot i d n re rl fr al rq et gta Cl fJ de Koisia poe om l eu si h t le u g znk p rv y n i N cuinotetilntepltpoeto tetr sad nlso fh ra i h i rjc n h em n o HO LNGS O T uP R Y L I W R H .E R PrC ra e uim cn iin dsusda teJn ay6 2 1, ern a d o dt s icse t h a u r , 0 0 h aig n o sbeto eoui ocra tcnclsus I.E h ujc trslt n feti eh i ise. d, x. o n a ' 1 a 2 Ap l a t fe ap tinfrawrt f n a u ,t . pi nsl d eio o io ma d m s cl t i teCor o Ap el,seigt po ii o sa te n h ut f pas ekn o rhbt r ty h DititC utrm efrigis re.T efl wigd y src o r fo nocn t odr h ol n a , o atreu g pnl fh Cuto A pasdne te he- de a e o te or f pel eid h j ptt n eii . o On J n ay 8 2 1,C ifJ deKoisiise a a u r , 0 0 he u g znk su d n odrapoigteDitit ut dcso t alw rare p rvn h src Cor' eiin o l el s o tmesra igo tetilocranfdrlcuto ss i tem n fh ra t eti eea orh ue ltd i a smutn osy is e pesrlae Fv i e n i la eul su d rs ees. ie s lct n h d be slce:fdrlcu to ssi S n oai s a en eetd eea o rhu e n a o Fa cso P sdn ,S ate P rln ,a d Broln rnic, aa e a etl, ota d n oky . T epesrlaeas idctdta dadioa sts h rs ees lo niae htdjdt nl ie li ma b a nu cd'F drl o rh ue t Of rRe oe y e n o ne . eea C utosso f m t ' e Viwig o P ooio 8 T il o l e a e n f rpst n i ra, ni nt ht:ww . gu cu t.o/aatr/e ea z l/lo/ tp/ c .so rs vdtsoegn rp o oo/8 /a g Po 8Re oeviwigLct n.d (svse Jn 1, rp - m t- e n- oai s fa itd a . 3 op i 2 1,n aalbei teCekoC ut cs fe. 00ad vi l n h lr f or' aeil a sl C ifJ d eKoisi Jn ay8odrn tdta te he u g znk' a u r re oe h t h s rq ett bo dattetilo teItr e wa 'tl eu s o racs h ra n h nen t s si sl pn ig b fr hm. I a ltrlte t C ifJ de e dn ' eoe i n ae etr o he u g ' Wakrh epan dta terq et snt e Siefr le, e x lie h th eus wa o yt'p o r a poa'b cu eSh tcnclsafe cu trdsme p rv l ea s d e eh ia tf nonee o ' t u epce dfcle peaig a stsatr vdo n x etd iiut s rp rn fi aifcoy ie t pr io l ep biainwo l b ma ewh ntcno em t ni u l t ud e d e eh i n co cl iiut s r rsle . a dfcli wee eovd fe On J n ay9 2 1,apia t fe i ti C uta a u r , 00 pl ns i d n hs o r n cl a piainfrasa o teDititC ut od r T er p l t o ty f h src or' re. h i co s p tin sesa sa pn igrslt n o frho ig eio ek ty edn eoui f otcm n t o ptto so tewrt ocrirr a dma d mu . ei n fr h is fetoai n n a s i 1 1 T eq eto whte cu tom poedn ss ol b h u sin eh r o rro rce ig h ud e sialfro -n psig'Lte oJn 92 1 (vi utbeo nl e otn. etr f a .,00 aal i ' ali Clr o Cut cs le.Af a dcso whte ben ek f or' ae' l i l eiin ehr si ln Cta:58 S (00 i s 8 U.. 21) e PrC ra e uim bodat h s po pe cnieal n t n ldb t. ra cs a rm td osd rbe ai a eae o Resn bemid df ro tepo e rslto o ta ao al n s ie n h rpr eouin f h t f db t a do tersrcin ,ic msa cs a dpoe e ae n n h etito s c u tne, n rcr d rsu drwhc sc bodat so l ocr Wed u e n e ih u h ra css h ud cu . o n th r epesa yve so tepo reyo bodat o ee x rs n iw n h rpit f ra csigcut rceig gnrl . ' n o r poedn s e eal y lsed o rrve i cnie t an ro lglise nta , u eiw s of d o arw ea su : n wh te teDititCor'a e d eto i lclrls eh r h src ut m n m n ft oa ue s s t b odatti tilcmpid wih fdrllw. We o ra cs hs ra o l t eea a e cnld ta i l eydd nta dta a pia t h v o cu e h t t i l i o n h t p l ns ae k c dmo srtdta irp rbeh r wol l ey rsl e ntae h t reaal am ud i l eut k fo teDiti C ut at n . Weteeoesa te rm h src o r' ci s t so h rfr ty h cut Jn ay7 2 1,re t teetn ta ip r is o r' a u r , 00 odr o h xeth tt em t s tel esra igo cutpoedn st oh rfdrl h i te m n f or rceig o te eea v cuto ss Wed nta desohrapcso ta orhu e. o o drs t e set f h t odr s c a toerltdt tebodato cutpo re,uh s h s eae o h ra cs f o r rceig o teItr e, shs yb pe aue edn s n h nen ta tima e rm tr. A T o ti asa pn igtefiga ddsoio o a o ban ty e dn h in n ipst n f l i p tinfrawrto crirr, n a pia tmu tso eio o t i f et aia p l n s h w o c () raoalpoait ta fu J siewi cnie 1a esnbe rbbly htor ut s l osdr i cl teisesfcetymeirost gatcrirr;2 a h su ufinl rt iu o rn etoai() i o fi popc ta amaoi o teCutwi vt t ar rset ht jrt f h or l oe o y l rvretejdmetblw;ad ()al eiodta ees h u g n eo n 3 i l o ht kh irp rbeh r wi rslfo tedna o asa .I re aa l am l eut rm h eil f ty n l coecssteCrutJ sieo teC utwi b lne ls ae h ici utc r h or l aa c l teeute a dweg terltv h r st tea pia t h q iis n ih h eaie am o h p l n c a d t terso dn. L csv T wned 4 6U. . n o h epn et ua . o sn , 8 S 10,10 (98 (E N D , .i ca br)Rote v 31 34 18)K N E Y J,n h m es; skr . Godeg 48U. .10,10 (90 (rn a ,J,i lbr, 4 S 36 38 18) Ben n . n ca br) T oti asa pn igtefiga ddso h m es. o ban ty edn h in n ipl st no aptinfrawrto ma d mu, na pia t ii f eio o i f n a s a p l n o t c mutso afipopcta amaoi oteCorwi s hw ar rsetht jrt fh ut l y l vt t ga tma dmu a dal eiodta irp rbe oe o rn n a s n i l o h tre aa l kh h r wi rslfo tedna o asa .B fr awrto am l eutrm h e ilf ty eoe i f l HO LNGS O T uP R Y L I W R H .E R PrC ra e uim ma dmu ma iseaprymutetbihta ()n n a s y su, at s sal h t1Go s ohraeu t men (xs)t ati terlfh dte dqae as eit o tan h ei e e e srs'()h prys'ih tisac otewrtsder ie, 2 te at''gtosu ne fh ii c a ' r l a didsualy'n ()tewrtiaporaeu dr n nip tbe' a d 3 Rh i s prpit ne ' tecru sa cs' Chnyv UntdSae Dit C ut h ic m tne. ee . i tts s. o r ' e frD C,52U. . 6, 8-8 (04 ( meitra o . . 4 S 37 3031 20) s nenl o qoainmak o itd. T iCut lisetewrt ptto rs m te) hs orwi su h i l o ma d mu drcl t a fdrldsrc cu tdny f n a s iet o eea itit o r d l y o wh r a q eto o p bi i pra c i ivle ,o ee u sin f u l m otne s n ov d r c wh r teq eto i o sc an tr ta ii pcl ry ee h u sin s f uh aue h tts eui l a a porae ta sc ato b ti cuts ol b p rpit h t uh cin y hs or h ud e tkn. Exp reU i dStts 2 7U. .2 1 2 8 2 9 a e ' at nt ae, 8 S 4 , 4 -4 ' e (92.T eefmia sadrsaeflwe hr, ee 13) h s a lr tn ad r ol d eewhr i o a pia t cam ta teDititC u t odrwa b sd p l ns li h t h src or' re s ae c s o alcluea otdi voainofdrla . n oa r l dpe n ilto feea lw B Gie tei pra c o teise a sa e a do r vn h m otn e f h su s t tk , n u cnlso ta teDititC u tieyvoae afdrl ocuin h t h src o r l l iltd eea k sauei rvsn islcl ue, p la t h v so na ttt n ei g t oa rlsa pi ns a e h w i c fipopcta amaoi otiCut lete gat ar rseth t jrt fhs orwi i r rn y lh ap tin frawrto crirr a drvreteodr eio o t i f et ai n ees h re o blwo wi ga tap tinfrawrt f n a u . eo r l rn eio o io ma dm s l t A dsrc cuth s dsrt n t a otlclrls itit or a icei o dp oa ue. o Frzc v Heb,42U. .61 65 (97 (iig2 cfr . ee 8 S 4, 4 18) c n 8 t U. . .27; e. ueCvPo.3.T oe ue hv : C j01Fd R l i. rc8) hs rls ae d efreo lw. Gfv Ney,28U..10 19 oc fa ' e! . a 7 S 6, 6 t h (99.F drllw, o ee,eursadsrc cuto 12) eea a hw vrrqle itit or t fl w cranpoeue t a oto a edalclrl. ol eti rcd rs o dp r m n oa ue o L clrlstpcl ma n tb a e dd u ls te oa ue y ial y o e m n e nes h y dsrc cutRils aporaepbi ntead a itit or gve) prpit ul oi n n cc opaui f cmmet 2 U.. .270 ;e as po nt o o n. 8 S C 5019 se l yr ' o F d RueCv Po.8() A l ie ecpinpr is e. l i. rc 3a. i td xet em t m o dse sn wi ti ntc-n -o met rq ie e t ip nig t hs oiea dcm n eurm n h o l whr dh r i a i meit n e fr a rl. ny ee f ee s n m dae ed o ue' t ' j01e.E e w eearli a eddbsdo i me 27() vn hr ue s m ne ae n m - Cta: 8 US ( 1) i s58 .. 2 0 e 0 Pr uim e C ra 9 daen e ,h we'r teisig cutmutRrmpl it ed o v , h sun o r s po ty e teefe afr .. oiea dopru iyfrcmmet' h ratr f d . ntc n p otnt o o n. o ' Ii. bd Beoelt Dee br tecut L clR l 7- e fr ae cm e, h or' oa ue 7 3 x s piilb n e tebodat for poedn s l ty a n d h ra cs ocut rceig: c R nesalwe b aJ deo aMa itaeJ d e u ls l d y u g r gsrt u g o wi rsett hso h ro nca b r o asg e t ep c o i r e w h m es r sin d h cu tom frcrmo il upsstetkn o p o orro o ee na p roe,h a ig f h tgah ,p bi bodat g o tlvsn ,o rorp s u l racsi r eeiig r e c n crigfrtoep roe i tecutom o i e odn o h s upss n h orro r t n s vrn,ncn etnwt ayjdc l rceig i i si onco i n uia poedn ,s o ih i poiie . Eeto i ta s itlo cutom po rhbtd lcrnc rnm ta f o rro rceig a dpeetto o eiec wi i tecn edn s n rsnain f vdne t n h o h f e o tecuto s i pr itd ia toie b i s f h orhu e s em te,f uhrzd y n teJ deo MaitaeJ d e T etr S vrn , h u g r gsrt u g. h em e io s' n a u e i ti rl, a salloso whc ca s sd n hs ue men lf r n ih h m o br,o rro so o whc Ofcso teCekae es cu tom r n ih fe f h lr r i lctd wi teecpin o a ysaeseicl oae , t h xeto f n p c pcf al h iy dsg ae a aP esRom.Nohn i ti rl i ein td s rs o tig n hs ue s itn e t rsrc teueo eeto i men t rne dd o eti h s f lcrnc a s o e t cieo pee t ddned rn Cor poedn s' ev r rsn e ec uig u t rceig. ' Noal,h R l ecpe fo i gnrl a teta s tby te ue xetd rm t eea b n h rn s mi a ocranpoedn s b tti ie ta ecpin t l feti rceig- u il td h t xet t m o t ta s is n d i i tecnie o tecuto s. o rn m si sf t n h of s f h o rh u e' o wh n ' T en gtv ifrneo ti ecpin o cu s,sta h eaie neec fhs xeto, f o rei h t teR l wo l h v po ii dtesra igo ta s h ue ud ae rhbt h tem n f rn e miso s o ohrbo dat go tlvsn , eo dRh sin, r te racsi r eeiig byn te n cnie o tecuto s. o f s fh orhu e' n ' Repn e t d ntdsueta tivrinoRue7so dns o o ip t h ths eso f l 7 3 wol h v po ii d sra ig vdo o te til ud ae rhbt tem n ie f h ra e ao n tecu ty B tte asr ta ti i n tte ru d h o nr. u hy set h t hs s o h o eaievrino R l 7- .I asre o psig o prt eso f ue 7 3 n eis f ot s n v n isWe st,teDititC u tp rotd t rvs o t b ie h src o r upre o eie r po oervso st L clR l 7- . Thsa e d et rps eiin o oa ue 7 3 i m n m n wol h v cetda a dtoa ecpint Rue7- ' ud a e rae n d i n l xeto o l 73s i 1 0 HO LNGS O T =P R Y L I W R H .E R PrC za e uim gn rlb no tebo dat go cu tpoedn sd r e ea a n h ra csi f o r rceig ' n f o phiiaini aplto ohrpoetatoie b te a c to n i r te rjc uhrzd y h p o J dca C u clo teNit Crut' E h 1, p t u iil o ni f h nh ici. x . 4 Ap .o ' P t R so dnsrl o ti a e dd vrin o te e. ep n e t ey n hs m n e eso f h Rue l. T ea e ddvrino Rue7- a p ast b iv l . h m n e eso f l 7 3 p er o e n ai d I a e dn ti rl,ta pasta teDiti Cor n m n ig hs ue i p er h t h src ut t fi dt 'il) prpit pbintc ada opru al o'veaporae ul oie n n poteg c nt frcmmet' srq ie b fdrla .2 U. . . i o o n,a eurd y e ea lw 8 S C y ' 50 19 T efs t eh Ds i Cut se fr u 270 . h i ti te ir t or akd o p b rm tc l cmmet wa o teatron o Ne Y a' E e i o ns s n h fen o f w er v . c s T ecutsae ta i wol la etecmmetpro h o r ttd h t t ud ev h o n eid o e u tl a u r 8 AtmotteDititCor tee p n niJ n ay . s,h src ut h rfr alwe a cmme tpro sa nn f e b sn s oe l d o n eid p n ig i uies o v d y.T eei sbtnil rtoteag meth tti a s h r s u sata meit h ru n ta hs wa n tdp rpit'n tc a da opru i frcms o s porae oie n n p otnt o o a ' y met Ad iitaieaece,frisac,'sal' n. mnsrt gnis o ntne s u l v u/ poieacmme t eido Hhrydy o moe'Riervd o n pro ftit as r r. vr ' bn FamsIcv Ma ia , 5 F 2 17, 44(A9 ed r ,n. . dgn 98 .d 49 18 C 19) seP t v Bok 11F 2 19,10 (A C 92; e er . l , 3 .d 13 21 C D yc 18)CTh sots pr di w i priscnmen 94 ()e hret ei n hc at a a o he igul rve a po oe rl a d Ie ifr e rn fl eiw rp sd ue n ' nom d e y i l sossitit dy'. pne shry as ) T b sr,h p siit ta smeap cso tetil o e ue te os ly h t o set fh ra bi mih b bodatwa fs rie t tep risb te g t e ra cs s i t asd o h ate y h r DititC uta a i-or h aigo Spe br2 , src or t n ncut ern n etm e 5 smetremotsbfr teRuewa ca gd T e o he nh eoe h l s h n e . h bodatn , o ee, spo iie u drbt Crut ra csig hw vrwa rhbtd n e oh ici a dlclrlsa ta tme T ef s p bi idcto n oa ue t h t i . h i t u l n iain r c ta teDititC utitn e t a otarl o gn rl h th src or ned d o dp ue f e ea a-la it cmei i We st p sigo Dee b r2 . p i bly a n t b i otn n cm e 3 pc i s e A dee iC if u g Wak r i-or also t te n vn f he J d e le' ncut l in o h s u p siit ta teP ooiin8til g tb bo dat osbly h t h rp s o ra mih e ra cs i t cudb cniee a poiign t et teprisi o l e o sdrd s rvdn oi o h ate n c tics-hssae eth t'liialnf x'owi hs ae i ttm n ta ft ss li l 'nt t lh u h sa dn -tedslsr fl frsot fh (p rpit tn ig h icou e al a h r o ted porae s a Cta: 8 U S (00 i s58 .. 21) e Pr uim eC ra p bin tc a da opnu i frcmmetrq ie b u l oie n n p o nt o o n' eurd y c y ' j01b.lde,hr wa n pooe plyo whc 27() ned tee s o rpsd oi n ih c poedd wih a porae cuin i a desn ti rcee t p rpit a t n drsig hs o q eto .I 1 9,h J dca Cofrneo teUntd u sin n 9 6 te u iil neec f h i e Sae ao tdaplyop s gtep bi bo dato tts dpe oi p oi h u l racs f c n c cu tpoedn s T i pl ywa ao tdatramuto r rceig. hs oi s dpe fe c l i ya su y o teis eb teF drlJ dca C ne er td f h su y h eea u iil e tr whc de o dt fo s dsrc a dt oap l t ih rw n aa rm i itit n w p el e x a cut, swel ssaecutd t.I l h o tesu ys o rs a la tt-o r aa n i t f h td' g f dn s te J dca C neec cnld d ta dh i ig, h u iil ofrne ocu e h t d e n t itmiaig efc o cmea o smewin se a d ni dtn f t f a rs n o tess n e t cmme t o o n. T en e framenn flo metpro wa p riu h ed o a igu cm n eid s atclryauei ti cs.Bohcut a dlgsau e h v al ct n hs ae t o rs n eiltrs ae jrr ()a s frcnen'Reot fh Poedn so uosi cueo ocr. prote rceig f s ' teJ dca C neec oteUntdSae 4 (et2, h uiil ofrne fh i tts 7 Sp.0 e 19) 94. l moeta adcd s c isa ot nteJ dca n r h n ea e i e t dpi h u iil n o C nee c h scniu dt ah r t ispsto o te o frne a otn e o d ee o t oi n n h i bodato cu tpoedn s Whl teplycnlra cs f or rceig. i h oi ocu e c so s fh J dca C nee c ma nt ebn igo te in o te u iil o frne y o b idn n h lwe cut,h yae$th vr lat nie t rset o r orste r $ te ey es e tld o epca t fl o sdrt n'I r S n B GMui E tran e t u cn ieai . n e oy M sc netim n, o' 54F.d 1 6(AI20) Beoeaa dnn i o n 6 3 , C 09. fr bnoig t w s p ly- n cnitn wi te J dca C neec' oi -o e osset t h u iil o frne c h s ln sa dn ve s i wa icmbn o te Ditit o gtn ig iw - t s nu et n h src C utt a otapo oe rl ol atrntc a da o r o dp rpsd ue ny f oie n n e aeu t pro frp bicmme t dq ae eid o u l o n. c l dse sn wihp bi ntc a dcmmetteDin ipn ig t u l oie n o n h s c titC u'ivk dteGmme it ne 'ecpin 2 rc oz n o e h i dae ed'xeto . 8 t U. . .27() Idds truhaWe st psigo S C j01e. t i ohog b i otn n e J n ay z pirt teeprt n o tecmmetp a u r l ro o h x iai f h o n e o ro-idct gta Rue7- h dbe rvsdt pr id n iai h t l 7 3 a en eie o en mi priiain i teNit Crut pltporm. t atcp t n h nh icis i rga o 'o T eepsig gv n epa ain frivkn teeh s otn s ae o x ln t o n oig h x o cpin AttilteDiti C utepan d ta te eto . ra h src or xlie h t h t 1 2 HOL I GS OR HuP R Y LN W T .E R Pr uim eC ra i meit n e hr wa t alw ti cs t b bo d m dae ed ee s o l hs ae o e ra o cs p ru n t teNit Crut nw pltporm. at usa t o h nh icis e i rga ' o S eEx . , . 1S p . p t RepnefrP rye a. e h 1p 1, u pAp .o so s o er t l T i de ntqai a aci meit ne ta jshs os o u ly s n m dae ed h tut f i f sdse sn wihtent ea dcmmetpoe ue i ip nig t h oi n o n rcd rs e rqie b fdrla .Whlrsodns( epanis eurd y eealw i epn et t litf e h f i teDititCuthdidctdterapoa o te n h src or) a niae hi prvl fh pa , op ryalgdta iwol b i miet h r e ln n at l e h tt ud em nnl am d e y i tetilween tbo dat Ha a a miitaie f h ra r o racs. d n d nsrt v a ec atda teDititC ut i hr,h i meit gny ce s h src or dd eete m dae n e ecpinwo l l eynth v be aalbe Se ed xet ud i l o ae en v i l. e o k a 5 U.. .j5() ) (d iitaie aece cn o S C 53b( amnsrt gnis a nt B v iv k a ecpin t afrig n t ea dcmmet n o e n xet o f dn oi -n -o n o o c bfr rlma igu ls tentc-n -o metpoe eoe ue kn nes h oiea dcm n rcd rs udb Smpat al, n eesr,rcnrr t ue wo l es rci beu ncsay o otay o i c tepbiitrs) I isig is odr te Ditit h ul neef.n sun t re h src c C utrl do teNit CrutJ dca C u cl plt o r ei n h nh ici u iil o nis i e 'o porm. Y tn tigi ta porm-whc wa nt rga e ohn n h t rga ih s o a otd atr ntc a d cmme t poeu e,c.2 dpe fe oie n o n rcd rs f 8 U.. j3tll-rqie ayN meit'rvso i SC.3zdtl eurd n m dae eiin n ' lclrls T eNit CrutJ dca C u cldd nt oa ue. h nh ici u iil oni i o p rott moi o argt teDititC u t lcl upr o df r boae h src o r' oa y s R l. No cudi, steJ dca C u clo l h ste ue r o l t a h u i l o ni ny a h i pwe t mo i o arg t lcl ue ta cnl twih o r o df r boae oa rls h t o fc t y i fdrllw. Sej3()4 (emiigacrutcut eea a e 32d() pr tn ici or t cu cl omo i alclrl ta i S u dicn itn' onit df oa ue h t s' n no sset y f o ' wi rlspo ugtdb teS pe eCut.Nofd t ue rm lae y h u rm or) eh ea lwrq ie ta teDititC ut ra cs smeo rla eursh th src or bodat o f i css T eDititC ut lcl l,nadto , s t ae. h src o r' oa Ruei d iin wa s s nt a cnomig a e d e tt Nit Crutpl y o o fr n m n m n o nh ici oi , c bcu e ta ply de n trq ie dsrc cut t ea s h t oi os o eur itit ors o c bo dat rceig. ra cs poedn s Ap l a t as h v so nta irp rbeh r wi pi ns lo a e h w h t reaal am l c l l eyrsl fo tedna o tesa .Wi o tasa , i l eut rm h eil fh ty t u ty k h teDititC utwi bo dattetil I wo l b h src o r l racs h ra. t ud e l dfc l i n ti p sil-t rvre te h r fo iiut f o m os e o ees h am rm fb Cta:58 S (00 i s 8 U.. 21) e PrC ra e uim toebo dat.T etil livlevro swin se, h s ra css h ra wi n ov aiu tess l icu ig me br o smesxcu ls aa e is wh nldn m es f a -e o pe; cdm c, o a p rnl wi dsu sgn e ise a dgn e eu ly p aety l ics e drsus n e dr q ai , l t a wel sa i sr cte; n toewh p riiae i s la fm l tutrsa d h s o at p td n y z c t cmp in la igt tea oto o P ooiin 8 h a ag edn o h d pin f rp st . o T i C uth srcgie ta win s tsi o yma b hs o r a eonzd h t tes et n y e m cie ibodat S eEse v Tx s3 1U. . 3 , 4 hl d f ra cs. e ts . ea, 8 S 5 2 5 7 l (95;d,t51(aln J,ocrig.Smeoapi 16)i.a 9 H ra ,.cnurn) o f pl cn swi essh v araysi ta te wi ntts a t' t se ae le d ad h t h y l o en l tyitetili bodat a dte h v sbtnitd i f h ra s ra cs, n h y a e u sa t e f a tercnen b ct gicdns f at aas e t S e h i o crs y in niet o p s h rsm n. e, i c .E h K t Deedn- treosMoin(1nws ., x . o fnatl evnr' t 7 e g n o atce dtin icdnso h rsme t eae t p ol rils eal g niet f aas n rltd o epe i wh sp otdPooio 8. T eecnen aent o upre rpst n ) h s ocrs r o i dmiih db tefc ta smeo a pia t' tess i ns e y h at h t o f p l nswin se c aecmpn ae epr wi ess T eeaeq ai t e r o e std x et t se. h r r u lai n tv df rne bt enma igp bi a paa csrgrig ieecs ew e kn u l p ern e eadn f c a is ea dh vn oestsi oybo dath o g ot n su n aig n' etm n racs tru h u tecu ty Ap la t ma n tb a l t oti a e h onr. pi ns y o e be o ban dc q aerl fho g a a p a.T etil lh v aray u t ei truh n p el h ra wi a e led e l be bo dat I i dfcl t dmo srt o a aye en racs. t s iiut o e n tae r n lz f wh te awin s wo l h v tsie dfee t ihso eh r tes ud a e etf d i rnl f i r ify hrtsi oy h d ntbe bodat A d win se e et n a o en racs. n tess m sbett h rsmeta arsl o bodato ter ujc o aas n s eut f racs f hi tsi o ymih b ls l eyt co eaei a yftr etm n g t e es i l o op rt n n uue k poedn s rceig. T eb ln eo eute fvr apia t.Whl a pi h aa c f q i s a os p l ns i p l i c ecnsh v dmo srtdtetra o h r te fc i a t a e e n tae h het f am h y ae f tetili bodat rso dnsh v n talgda y h ra s racs, epn et ae o l e n e h r i tetilsn tbodat T eis e moevr am f h ra i o ra cs. h su , roe, mut ersle a tisaefrh ijr l e cn o sb eo d ths tg,o tenuy i l ant v ky b u dn o c tebodat a e pae e n o e n e h ra cstk s lc. T i C utas h sasg icn itrs i spriig hs o r lo a inf a tneetn u evsn i teamiitainotejdcasse .SetiC ut h d nsrto fh u iilytm e hs or' s Rue1()( eCutwi cnie whte tecut l 0a t or l osdr ehr h ors h l b lw h v $ofrdpre fo teacpe a duu l eo ae d a eatd rm h cetd n sa s 1 4 HOL I G WOR HvP R Y LN S T .E R PrC ra e uim cus ojdcapoedn s. .soclfra eecs ore fuiil rceig . a t alo n xrie otiCut sprioypwen.T eCut yueis fhs or' uevsr o r) h orma s t s ze,42U. .a 6566 i.a 62 64(enus, ir 8 S, t 4-4;d, t 5, 5 R h qit C..dsetn) T eC ut itrs i esrn cmJ, isnig. h or' neetn nuig o s pinewih poe rlso jdca amiitain i l c t rpr ue f uiil d nsrt s a o priual auewhntoerlsrlt t teitgi atclry ct e h s ue eae o h nert y ojdc l rcse.T e sr t orhr atmpe t fuiapoess h Di i Cut ee t td o i tc e sprioya toiyt iv l aelclrlsta wee u evsr uh rt o n ai t oa ue h t r d po ugtdi voaino a A to C nrs.S eFrrm lae n ilt f n c f o ges e c o rvs ismz si h se cnrr t fdrlsaue a d eie t l n at,o tay o eea ttts n e tepl yo teJ dca C nee c o teUntdSae. h oi f h u iil ofrne fh ie tts c I dd s t alw bodatn o ti hg -rfetil t i o o l racsig f hs ihpoi ra o l wi o ta ycniee sa drso g ieie i pae t u n o sdrd tn ad r ud l s n lc. h n T ea> met i fvrodvlpn poeue a drls h r nsn ao f eeoig rcd rs n ue t alw bo dato cran cssh v cnieal o l ra cs f eti ae ae osdrbe o mei,a drao al mid cn srl df ro e te rt n esn be n s a u ey ie v r h f gnrl n seictr so rlsa dsa d rsa otd eea a d pcf em f ue n tn ad dpe i frta p roe Hee hwee,h odri q et n o h t up s. r, o vr te re n u si o cmpid nih rwi eitn rlso plisn rte o l ete t xsig ue r oi e o h e h c rq ie poeu e fra e dn te . eurd rcd rso m n ig h m Byissigta cut cmpywi telw,p ris n it h t ors o l t h a ate n h vn iaen t nyterg t te asr b tas telw' idct o o l h ihs hy set u lo h a s o n isse c o n urly a d f ei t pic l. w nitne n etai n i ly o rni e t dt p T oesse ai itrssaealtemoeeie th r, h s ytm t neet r l h r vdn ee c whr telc o arg lrrl wi poe sa d rst ee h ak f eua ue t rpr tn ad o h dtr iet eg ieie frbodat gcudcmpo eem n h udl s o ra csi o l o rn n mieteodry dcru ,ain lrdt n ta cut s h rel, eoo srt a taii s h t ors o o rl uo t esr teitgi ote o njdmet. e pn o nue h nery fhi w u g ns y t r T eecnieain ,o, r pr o terao sla ig h s o sdrto sto ae at f h e sn e dn t tedcso t ga t xrodn r rl f o h eiin o rn etariay ei . e I a desn adsrt isa c a toiigacoen drsig icee ntne uh rzn lsd c c i bodato atil C n rs h siutae te i ut ra cs f ra, o ges a l srtd h r l n e fr aeu g ieie a dsa drs T etil fh ed o crfl udl s n tn ad. h ra o te n t odfn a t i teOka o aCt bmbn cs h d w ee dns n h lh m iy o ig ae a be ta serdt teUntdSae DititC l tfr en rn fre o h ie tts src oz o r teDi rc o C lrd,s i wa stt tk paei h s i f ooa o o t s e o a e lc n tt Cta: 8U.. (00 i s 58 S 21) e PrC ra e uim Devr T a men tefmie o dcae a dsrin e. h t a t h a l s f eesd n u vv i igvci si a dao n Oka o aCt wo l n t ae n it n n ru d lh m i ud o h v m y teo pru iyt osretetil C n esp se a h p otnt o bev h ra. o r s asd saueta alwe vci sfmie t wac tetil n ttt h t l d it 'a l s o th h ra o o m i coe-icitlvso.4 U. . . 168 T esaue lsdc uteeiin 2 S C j00. h ttt r wa da nwi cr t poiepeiea ddti dgz s rw t ae o rvd rcs n eal ad h ei a c wi rsetotewiern eoise i piae b ne t epc t h d a g fsu sm l td y h c tebodat Sej00()tesaueol apisI h racs. e 168a (h ttt ny pl s ei n csswh r tev n eo tetili c a gd t act ae ee h e u f h ra s h n e' o i ' y ta i du o teSae a dS oeta 30mi sfo h t ss t f h tt' n s r h n 5 l rm o 'm e telcto i whc toepoedn soiial wol h oain n ih h s rceig rgn l ud y hv tknpae)j168a-b (adrsfrwh cn ae ae lcn;j00()()s n ad o o a t ve sc tis;168c( s iin o tas is n. iw uh r l)500( r tcos n rnm si ) a ) e rt o An tesauegv teJ dca C nee c oteUntd d h ttt ae h u iil o frne fh ie Sae rlmaig a toiy o efcu t te ply tts ue kn uh rt d f tae h oi te c adesdb tiscin'j00() l tepeetae drse y hs eto. 168g.n h rsn cs, ' b cnrs,vrasa o trewek teDititC ut y o tatoe p n fhe e s h src o r a dNit CrutJ dca C u clise, erce , n n nh ici u iil o ni su d rtatd a d rise asre o We st p sig a dn wsrlae. esu d eis f b i otn s n e eess e T eep rott a e drlsa dplisa teh ato h s u pr o m n ue n oi e t h er f c a o gigcnieain o bodatn fdrltil. n n on o sdrto f ra csig eea ras An te h v dn s t ma esr ta o ep riua d h y ae o e o o k ue h t n atclr til yb bodat C n rs'eurme to antc ra ma e ra cs. o gesrq ie n f oie ad cmmetpoeue peet js sc abtay n o n rcdr rvns ut uh rirr ca gso cutrls Ised cut mu tuetepo h n e f or ue. nta ,ors s s h rcd rspecie b sauet a e d terrls 2 eu e rsrbd y ttt o m n hi ue, 8 U. . .27. S C j01 l L clRue7- h db e vl l rvsd q eto s f oa l 73 a en ai y eie, u sin d wo l si rmana o tteDititColt dcso t ud tl e i bu h sr t ' eiin o l c rs alwbodatn otip riua tili whc svrl l ra csig fhs at lr ra,n ih eea o c o tewin se h v sae cnen frtero nscf h tess a e ttd ocr s o h i w eu rt. E e dsrcsta alw til t b bo dat se i vn itit h t l ras o e rac s,e y o Cv Rue18(DNY20)Cv R l 18(DNY20) i. l . S 09; i. ue . E 09, rilnzlma d dsr tu g'dsrt nAcboecs a eo i etie,iti .. Hamitn i tcra ,9 2 cgi i ta secg, e ioev. ouTdat h t e,ejd s l o - k 4 c ta s r F.u p 16 18 (DNY 19)(racs fridn S p . 3, 3 E 96 bodat obde HOL I GS OR HuP R Y LN W T . E R Pr uim eC r a u ls 'h r i n itreec wihted epoes te ness ee s o nefrne t h u rcs,h t dgi o liat,uosa dwinse,o wihohr int fignsjrr n tess r t te yt aporae apcso teamiitain o jsie) prpit set f h d nsrt f ut n. o c DetceBa kWG,52 F Sp .2 58 55 (DNY ush n 8 .up d 2, 3 S 20)o ddntivlewi essMaio... uin, 08,r i o nov t se, rsl vGil i n A a 99F S p .6,6 (DIY19)Kaz a v Vcoi% 2 .u p 6061 S N 96; tm n . itr a SceC tlg e93F.up505657(DNY19) ert aaou,2 S p.8,8-8 S 96. ld e, n DititCor ddn talw tebodatn n ed o e src ut i o l h ra csig o oispoednsbcuetecs <nove)vr sni ft rceig eas h aefvlld ey esi t eise. Shesv Muem o MoenAr,59 i su s' cop . su f dr t 9 v ' F S p .2 52 54(DNY20) T i cs,to i.u p d 3, 3 S 09. hs ae o,n vle ise sbettitnedbt i orscey T e ovssus ujc ones eaen u oit. h DititCor itn sntol t bodath atres src utne d o ny o ra cs te tony' ag me t b tas wins tsi oy S eS n BMG, ru ns u lo tes etm n . e oy 54F.d a 1 (ie,J,cnurn)(itn usig 6 3, t 1 Lpz . ocrig dsigihn bo dato atr es ag me t fo ohrp rso te ra cs f ton y' ru ns rm te at fh til T i cs i teeoentago oefraplt ra) hs ae s hrfr o od n o i . o porm.E e tesu ista h v be cn utdtu rga vn h tde h t a e en o d ce h s frh v n ta aye teefc o bodatn i hg a a e o n lzd h f t f ra csig n ih e poi ,iiiecss SeAplainfrSa 1 (an rfe dvsv ae. e pi to o ty 7 w rl c igb J d eE wadR. ek rta i ftuyhg -rfe n y u g d r B ce h tnfrl ihpoi d l C neu nl,cut i toedsrcsh v alwe te o sq e t ors n hs itit ae l d h y o bo dato terpoedn so teb ssta toe racs f h i rceig n h ai h t h s cssween thg poi ,E' rd Fn nilC r.v ae r o ih rfe k a e ia ca op . lT css'oecnEjuti aiewhttef dnswol ae,'n a sls m gn a h i ig ud ' d n b'(utn E h 2,t , ptPt) e'qoig x .1a 2Ap.o e.. ' ) II I T eDititCor atmpe t c a g i rlsa te h src ut te td o h n e t ue t h s eee t hu t tetti cs df rnl ta oh r lvnh o r o ra hs ae ieet h n te fy til i tedsrc. No o l ddi in r tefdrl ras n h itit t ny i t g oe h e ea saueta etbih stepoeue b whc isrls ttt h t salse h rcd rs y ih t ue ma b a e dd i epesp roewa t bodata y e m n e ,t xrs up s s o ra cs s hg -rfe tilta wol icu e wi estsi oy ihpoi ra h t ud nld t s etm n l n ao tacne t u ise l cu' aet rq ieta bu o tni s su . f ozs r o e ur h t o t ohr fl w rg lrpoeue,cut mutd s a tes ol e ua rcd rs o rs s o o s o Cta:58 .. ( 1) i s 8US 2 0 e 0 PrC r m e ui a 1 7 wel T eCoztga t tea piainfrasa o te l h t rns h pl t o ty f h . r co DititCor' odro J n ay 7 2 1,p n igte src ut re f a u r , 00 e dn h s tmeyfig a d dsoio o a pt in frawrto i l in n ipst n f eio o l i t if crirr o tefiga ddsoio o aptt nfra etoai r h in n ipst n f eii o l i o wrt f n a u . io ma d m s Iis odrd ts o ree . Cta: 5U.. (00 i s58 S 21) e B EE,.dset g RYRJ,i ni sn S P EM E COURTOFTHE UNI ED S ATES UR TT No0A68 .9 4 DE NI HOL I GS OR H E A .. IT NM. N S LN W T T L uM S I P R YE M, ER T . O AP LC TONF RS A N P IA I 0 T Y GISU Ga dJ SIES TMAO ji,isnig N B R n UTC O O Y Ron dsetn. T eC u ttd yise a odrta wi peette h o r oa su s n re h t l rvn h l tas i inopoednsnannuy iicsoget rnms o frceig i ojr c laef ra s v p bi itrs t f eohrfdrl orh ue lctdi u l neet o i te e ea cuto ssoae n c v S atePaa e a P rln , a Fa csoa dB oky . etl, sd n , ota d S n rnic, n ro ln T eC u t gesta icnisetietariaylg l h o r a re h tt a su hs xrodn r ea ( nay1,00 J ur 3214 a J SIEB E E , t wh m J SIES E E SJ SIE U TC R Y R wih o U TC T V N ,U TC rlfol i()teei aficac teDititC ut ei ny f 1 hr s ar hne h src or e wa wrn aotteu dryn lglqet n ()ta s og bu h nelig ea usi ,2 ht o lgl usinmet ti C ut crirr sadrs () ea q et es hs or' et aitn ad,3 o so rfslfh rlf udwokRrprbehr ,()h euaote ei wol r i eaal am'4te e r ' blneo teeute ( cuig teCutsol sy aac f h qi s i ldn,h or hud a, in psil hr t tepbiitrs)fvr isac,() osbe am o h ul neet aos sune 5 c tep rysrg tt terl fi Sla a du dsual, h at' ih o h ei sker n n ip tbe' e ' ad()h dusiniopbii prac'(rohr ie n 6ted et s f ul m otne o tews qo c ' Reuiryaporaefrsc ato) Sea t,t6. pcl l prpit'o uh cin. e nea -; a ' 7 Rote v Godeg 48U. .10,10 (90 (rn skr . lbr, 4 S, 36 38 18)Benn J,nca br)(a sadr)C ee v Untd a , .i h m es s y tn ad; hny . i t e Sae Di.C uto D.C,52U. . 6,30(04 tt s or fr . 4 S 37 8 20) st (oigta madmu i aRrsi adetariay nt ht na s s datc n xrodn r n rmeyrsre frraletariaycue'(tra e d eevdo el xrodnr ass i enl y 'n qoainmak o iel. hscs,nmyve ,osnt utto rs mt d)T i aei iw de o t stsy asn l o eo teesa drs ltao ealo aif ige n f h s tn ad, e ln l f te .C neu nl, mutdse t h m o sq etyl s isn. Fi tcnie temeiso telg lsu :Th Untd r ,o sdr h rt fh ea ise e ie s Sae C d,nac atret ld' ue o Cors'tts tts o ei h pe nie t ls f ut,sae tR ' 2 HO LNG WO T uP R Y L I S R H .E R B ER,.dset g RYRJ,isni n ta Ran rl . .hlb pecie ol atrgvn ht lly ue . sal e rsrbd ny fe iig a po rae p bi ntc a d a opru iy fr cmp rpit u l oi n n p otnt o o ce met'2 U.. .27()T eqet nhr iwhte n. 8 S C 50 1b. h usi ees ehr ' o Pt frMa dmu i No 1-06 (A9 (eenfe e.o n a s n . 0703 C ) hriatr Ap .oPt.C oojcin Noea al,n bt sds pt e. N beto. n t 1'ad oh ie ) ' ) te DititC u tacmpne te moicto o is h src o r co a id h dfain f t i a t ie r l wih dp rpit p bi ntc a d a ni do ue t d porae u l oie n n v a c opru iyfrcmmet' p otnt o o n. ' C rany tep riste sle h dmoeta ae etil h ate h m evs a r h n d q aentc a dopru i t cmmetbfr teRue u t oie n p otnt o o n eoe h l y wa cagd OnSpe br2,20,tetiljde s h ne. etm e 5 09 h ra u g, C ifJ deVa g nWakr dsusdtep siit o he u g u h le, icse h os ly f bi bo datn til rceig bt wihntecuto s ra csig ra poedns oh ti h orh u e a dbyn ,a dak dfrteprisve s Nop ry n eo d n se o h ate' iw . at ojce t tepeec o cmea i tecutom fr betd o h rsne f a rs n h orro o ta s iso swi i tecut o s, x ., . 0Ap .o rnm sin t n h ozh ue E h 9 p 7 , p t h ma e wrte sb is n t tecutrgrig ter d i n u m si s o h or eadn h i t o ve so oh rta s iso s T ecuta anrie te iw n te rnm sin. h o r gi asd h is ea ah aigo Dee br1. su t ern n cm e 6 No,npatc, i oh rme br o te u iir lc ri rciedd te m es fh J dcay ak ifr ain a otteise I Ma 19 teCrut nom t b u h su . n y 96 h ici o Coni a otdapl ypr iigvdoi cn et n u cl dpe oi em tn ie n on ci c t o wi ap l t poedn s b tpoiin isu ei te t p el e rceig, u rhbt g t s n h h a i dsrc cu t S beu nl, p elt cutp n l h v itit o r. u sq ety a pl e or a es a e a feu nl pr ie eetoi cvrg. J d e,te rq ety em t d lcrnc oeae u gs h t pes lwyr, n ohr h v dsu sdtematr I rs,a es a d tes a e icse h te. n 20 telwyr a djde peeta teNnhCrut 07 h a es n ugs rsn th it i i c J dca C nee c cniee arslt n ta fvrd u iil ofrn e osdrd eoui h t a oe o An o Dee br1,20 ,h CrutC u clvtdt d n cm e 7 09 te ic i o ni oe o teueo cmea i dsrc cutcvl ojr poed h s fa rsn iti or iinnuy rcet ig. An ,vtn sprtl,bt lwyr adjde ns d oig eaaey oh a es n u gs Sp rvdterslt nb rsu dn magn . Letr d poe h eoui y eo n ig ris' te a o ' fo C if u g KoisioJ deAnhn Siia(a . rm heJ de znk t u g toy crc Jn 1, 00,E h 8 p4 S p. p t R sos frPly 0 2 1) x . , ., u p Ap.o epne o e' r ea.hriatrS p. ptRepne.Sbeunl, t l(eenf u pAp.o sos) u sqet e y acmmie o jde wa cetdt suytematr o t e fugs s rae o td h te. t Cta:58 .. (00 i s 5 U S 21) e B EE,.dset g RYRJ,isni n 3 a toieapltporm pr iigteu eo vdoi uhrz i rga em t n h s f ie n o t nnuycvlcssa pr o a txei etwihte ojr ii ae s at f n s prm n t h e dse iainovdo eodnsnc innuymatr' ism nt fie rcrig i i l ojr t s o v e (pcfal toeslce b teC if u g o teCr seicl hs eetd y h heJ de fh iiy ci a dteC ifJdeo teDititCut.An i ut n h he ug f h src or) d t ise apesrlae Ne sRees, nhCrutJ dsu d rs ees. w lae Nit ici u i ca C u clAp rvsE prmetlUs o C mea i il o ni poe x ei na e f a rs n Ditit ors(e.720)E h 1. ptPt srcCut D c1,09,x ,3Ap .o e. l ti cnetteUntdSae DititC utfrte n hs o tx h ie tts src o r o h NotenDitito C lonaa e ddi lcl ue o rh r src f ai ri m n e t oa rls n f s Dee br2 ,20 t bigte it cnomiywi cm e 2 0 9 o rn h m no ofr t t h Nit Crutply l p riua,teC uta e dd nh ici oi . n at lr h o r m n e c c telclRuefridn tep bi bodatn o tlh oa l obdig h u l ra csig r ee c vsn o cutpoedn sb cetn a ecpin S r iig f o r rceig y raig n xeto ' f o priiaini aplto ohrpoeta toie b te at pto n i r te rjc uhrzd y h c o J dca C u clo te Nit Crut' P bi Noie u iil o ni f h nh ici. u l t ' cc C n enn Reiin o CiiL clRue7- ,i.E h o crig vso s f vl oa l 7 3 d, x . 1 .T eC utiiil rl do apoiini teUntd 4 h or nt l ei n rvso n h ie ay e Sae C d ta pr isDitit ut t pecie ue tts o e h t em t src Cors o rsrb rls R wi otpbintea dopru iyfrcmmetdi t u ul oi n potnt o o n''l h cc 'lf tepeciigcutdtr ie ta teei a i mei h rsrbn o r eem n s h t h r s n m daene frarl,a ditecutdrmpl teefe t ed o ue' n f h or d o t h ratr ' py so s. T e,o Dee br3 ,te C utrvsd is pn e h n n cm e 1 h or eie t p bi ntc t akfrcmmet drcl.ByJ n ay8 u l oie o s o o ns iet c y aur , 2 1,h C ut a rcie 185 4cmmet,lb t3 0 0 te o r h d eevd 3 ,7 o nsa1 u 2 o whc fv rdta s it gtepoedn s I.a 1. f ih aoe rnm ti h rceig. d, t 2 n Viwe i l h o ti hsoy teCor stsidte e d n i t f hs itr,h ut aif h g e sauesisse c ta 'oie b p rpit. C. 8 ttt' nitn e h ts tc' e ' porae' f2 n'a ' U. . . 501b,e.T epristejde, n te S C j27()( h at ,h u gsa d h ) e itrse p bi weea aeo tepooast ca g neetd u l r w r f h rp sl o h n e c Nit Crutply ta cl iae i te di tpo nh ici oi h t um n td n h dl rc po ga 'welbfr tec a g i telclrlsta e rm' l eoe h h n e n h oa ue h t n ase ppiiaiaeitepeet eTxliihisnet be at s tn i hdD jc. h Nn gCru ld repeo n m e ce e it i i c i u da rs rl s nmi- cmbrepann t w s afrl)sc ntc adopru iyfrcmmet'2 f ds uh oie n potnt o o n, 8 o ' U. . . 27( . e E h 1 a 1, u p A p t R S C 5 0 1e Se x. , t 1 S p. p .o e ) HOL I GS O T wP R Y LN W R H . E R B EE,.dset g RYRJ,isni n di tporm. T e , neteDiti C uta ed d 'l rga ' h n o c h src o r m n e po ' t islcl ue i is e iso nntc n al trewek t oa rl,tsu d t w oie ery he e s bfr teta s is n ta terl ca g a toie eoe h rnm si s h t h ue h n e uh rzd o weet bgn An terl ca g isl i smpy a r o ei. d h ue h n e tef s i l ca g ta cnomslclrl t Crutply acn h n e h t o fr oa ue o ici oi - o c fr i ta telw ma welrqie (h J dca omt ht h a y l eur. T e uiil y Coni h d ln bfr vtdt maeisvdop ly u c a o g eoe oe o k t ie oi l c didn o alcu' wi i teNit Crut' etr n ig n 1 o zs t n h nh ici'L te b th , nu cdisn w di tporm'plyi Dee br20 , o ne t e sl rga ' oi n cm e 0 9 po c Ap .t Ap l ain Ex .1 ,Ap .t P t;a d fdrl p o pi to , h 3 p o e. n e ea c saue rn e dsrc cutrlsv i isfra te ttts e dr itit o r ue od n oa s h y h v be d oie o arg td'b te C u cl se a e en d df d r boae' y h on i e mi , j0 1c() C mpr a t,a 1 Ccu clol h ste 27( 1. o ae ne t 1 oni ny a h ) pwe t mo i o arg t lcl ue ta cnltwi o r o df r boae oa r ls h t o fc t y ih fdrllw', t 2 U. . .32d()Cl onisal eea a ' wih 8 S C j3()1 o u clhl ) ma eal eesr a da poraeodr frh efcie k ln csay n p rpit reso te fetv fo C if u g Hu t AlNit CrutJde (u e rm heJ de g o l nh ici u gsJ n 2,19)(vibei Ceko Cut cs fe;ta 1 96 aal l n lr f or' ae i)i n a s l adepdtosamiitaino jsiewi i i cr n xei u d nsrt fut t n t ii o chs ci') T eapiat pitt n itrse pro u ut) h pl ns on o o neetd esn n '. c a aeo tecag. H w cnteMaoi raoal w r fh hn e o a h jry esnby t dma dytmoen t ei rset oalcluemoice n e r oi n ep ct oa rl df a c i t nta asauel eyrq ie rgrls? i h t ttt i l eurs eades o k T eewa as sfcetp otnt frcmme t' h r s lo ufin ' pru i o o n. i o y ' T epristenevnr,te jde,h pbi al h at ,h itreosohrugste ul- l e c h da o pru iyt cmme t T ep risweeseia n p otnt o o n. h at r p cf e i cl ivtdb C ifJ d eWak rt cmme to te al n ie y he u g le o o n n h y psiit o bodata erya Spe br An te osbly f ra cs s al s etm e. d h i etr p bi wa ivtdb teDititC utt sb i nie u l s n i y h src o r o u m t c e cmmet atrterl c a g wa a nu cd rg tu o n s fe h ue h n e s n o ne,ih p t teeeo til AsIsi,h cutrcie 1854 o h v f ra. ad te or eevd 3 ,7 cmmet d rn ta tme Ho muhmoeSp otnt o n s uig h ti . w c r f pru i o y frcmme t de teC utbl v ncsay p riu o o n' os h o r ei e eesr, atc ' e lry wh n tesaue te sle a toietelcl al e h ttts h m evs uhrz h oa cu t op tanw rl it efc d i ot rciiga y o r t u e ue no f td t u' eevn n e wh ' do met'bfr digs wh nta lcl' utdtr ' m ns eoe on o e h t oa 'or eec ' c Cta: 5U.. (00 i s58 S 21) e B KE,.dset g RYRJ,isni n mie ta teei a i meit ne't d s (n t ns h thr s n m dae ed'o o o a d o rciecmmet ltr?An moeiprat , a i eev o nsae) d r m otnl whts y te lg lsuc o te C ut dma d fr a dt n l h ea ore f h o r' e n o d ii a s o cmmettmei rsett arl c a g t cnom t o n i n epc o ue h n e o ofr o J dca C u cl oiy u iil o nipl ? c S cn ,hslg l u sini nttekn o lg l u s eod ti ea q eto s o h id fea q eto ta ti C utwol nr al ga tcrirr t in h t hs or ud om l 'n etoai o yr cnie.T eei n cnl ta o gtesaeo fdrl o sdr h r s o o fc m n h tt r eea i cu t rg rigtepoeue b whc adsrc cu t o rs eadn h rcd rs y ih itit or cagsislclrls C.hsCut R ls1()() h ne t oa ue. fti or' ue 0a-b. s T etcnclv l i o tepoeu e fl we blw h eh ia ai t f h rcd rs ol d eo dy o de nti piaea oe (mpra tq et no fdrl os o m l t n pn s otn u si f eea c i o lw. C. ue1() No d tepoeue blwcery a ' fR l 0c. r o h rcdrs eo lal ' cnl t t a ypeee trm tiC ut C.bd o fc wih n rcdn fo hs o r. fii. i l i p riual iavsbefrti C u tt cn ie t s at lry n dial o hs o r o o sdr c ti kn o q eto bcuei ivle lclrlsa d hs id f u sin ea s t n ov s oa ue n lclrls i awod ti C u tmirma ae dsrc oa ue;n r, hs o r co n gs itit cuta miitaiepoeu e i temotdti dwa . or d nsrt rcd rsn h s eal y v e An , totbif g teC uti pssl iain o d wi u rei , h o r m oe i tto s n h n m teJ dca C u cs ait t i pe etpl y dch u iil o ni ' bly o m lm n oi ei li c dc. T e DititC u cl,te Crut C u cl,te it h src o ni h ici o ni h s s J dca C neec o teUntdSae,a dteC if u iil o frne f h i tts n h he e lcluiild iitain Heefrea peteCut oajdcaam nsrt . r,o xm l,h or o dcdsjs hw adsrc cutyol moi iso n eie ut o itit or hud df t w y sos at,a 1-1 (ugsigCu clplyde nt in, ne t 1 2 sget oni oi os o n c argt lclrls, t cneune wecn o pe boae oa ue)wi osq ecs a nt rh J si ba rsos it fruia amiirt n nt ut e er epnily o jdc l d ns ai , o c bi i to ti C ut Se2 U.. .53-3.A dtoebde hs or. e 8 S C 53132 n hs ois h v a eu t a toi t rsledsgeme t a o t ae dq ae uh ry o eov iare ns bu t h wt po ugt a da pylclue, n ,a iual, o o rm lae n p l oa rlsa d p a c lry ao th u eocmea i tecu tom. bu te s fa rsn h o rro Frtep s 8 yaslcluia amiirt nh s o h at 0 er,oajdc l d ns ai a i to be lf t teecuiepoic o teCiciJ dca en et o h xls rvne f h rut u iil v C u cl, n ti C utlcsterisiuin lep ro ni a d hs or ak h i nttto a x ei s ec.S egn rl P Fs , h Poic o F d rl u i ne e e eal . ih T e lis f e ea J dy t c lAd iitain1213(93 (rm terceto, i m nsrt 5-5 17)Fo hi rain a o HO LNGS O T uP R Y L I W R H .E R B EE,.dset g RYRJ,isni n Gt ecuclcntue .. meh ns truhwhc lh oni osi td .a caim hog ih l st tee cud b a cne tain o rso s it i te h r o l e o cnrt f epni ly n h o bi v ro sCrut-i me it rso sblyfrtewoko aiu ici m dae ep niit o h r f s i tecut, t pwe a da toi . .oisr cmph orswi o r n uhrt . t n ue o e h y tnei tli) r . ..Frta rao iiiapo ec n herwok .' o ht esn tsnpr' ) pit a wel s n eesr frti C utoitre en rae s la u n csay o hs or t nevn i tepoeua apcso lcljdca amiitain h rcdrl set f oa u iil d nsrt . o P ra sta iwh lh v n t ena l t f da yohr eh p h ts y ae o b e be o i n te n cs i whc ti C uth speiul dn s,ho g ae n ih hs o r a rvo s o e o tru h y e egnyrlfrohrie C. n oNoaSoi v m rec ei o tews. fBa k f v ct . e a U idSae, 8 U. .5, 6 (98 (C LAJ,ont tt 47 S 20 24 18)SAI,.cn es crig C d ntsetebssfraydrcatoi t urn) I o o e h ai o n iet uhrt o y spzielwe cut'(t gFcfrv Heb,8 U.. u evs o r ors ci rzc . ee42 S ' in 61 6162(97 menus, ..dset gl.No 4, 5-5 18) h qitC J, isni l r n) a Ia aeo a yisa c i whc ti C uth spe m w r f n n tne n ih hs o r a re pieysu h t mirma aedsrc cutpoed m tvl o gt o co n g itit or rceig a ide td y n s st os oa . Ircgieta teC utma seti matrnta eonz h t h or y e hs te o s o eo po ugtn a da pyn alclueb trte, n f rm laig n p lig oa rl u,ahr a peetn telre q et no tepaeo cmea s rsnig h agr u si f h lc f a rs o i tecutom. u tewidm o acmeap lyi n h o rro B t h so f a r oi s c pi ai amatrfrtepo e a miitaieb de t rm rl te o h rpr d nsrt o is o y v dtr ie Se2 U.. j3.ThsC ut a n lgl eemn. e 8 SC.32 i orh s oea a toi t a desta lre pl y q et n ecp uh rt o d rs h t agr oi u si xet y c o isfra iipi tsaqetno lw T erlvn noa s tm lae usi f a . h eeat c o q eto o lwh r cn en tepoeuefra e dn u sin fa ee o crs h rcd r o m n ig lclnls An teo l rlv n lg lpicpe ta oa z . d h ny eea t ea rn ils h t e alw u hr t tk acu to tei meit sbet l s ee o ae con f h m dae ujc o matro ta lcl uen meycmea, r toelgl te f h toa rl, a l a rsae h s ea picpe ta pr i u-ide rq ieu-t lo t rnils h t em t s n ed eur s o ok o ten tr o teh r a isea dt blneeut s h aue f h am t su n o aa c q ii , e ic dn tep bi itrs. cn eunl tr t toe nl ig h u l neetI o sq e t un o h s u c y t omatr. w tes T id cnie teh r : cn f d n b ssfrte hr, o sdr h am l a i o ai o h n C ut cnlso ta,weeteta s isost ohr o r' o cuin h t r h rnm sin o te s cutoms t tk pae te a pia t wol sf r o rro o a e lc, h p l ns ud uf c e Cta:58 S ( 1) i s 5 U.. 2 0 e 0 B EE,.dset g RYRJ,isni n 1 irp rbeh r . C ranyteei n eie c ta reaal am etil h r s o vdne h t sc hr cudaiei tinnuycvlaefo te uh am ol rs n hs ojr iics rm h smpefc o ta s iso isl.Bymycu t4 Sae i l at frnm sin tef on, 2 tts a dt oFdrl src Cut cretygv jde te n w eea Ditit ors urnl ieu gsh dsrto t bodatcvlnnuytil. SeMei icein o racs ii ojr ras e da Piaya dReae Lw 20-1 (09 (lcigsae rvc n ltd a 09 0 20)c l tn tt oe saue adrls; i. l 18(DNY20)Cv R l ttts n ue)Cv Rue . S 09; i. ue 18(DNY20) Nete teapiat nrayn es .E 09. i rh pl ns o noe le h c Oa b e al t peete prcld t s fce tt s en be o rsn m iia aa uf in o i etbihta temeepeec o tebodatmei sa l h t h r rsne f h ra cs da s ihrnl hsa avreeet n( eu ia) rcs, n eet a n des fc o t jdc lpoes y f hi ' C a devFlrd,4 U..6,7-7 (9 1.C. hn lr . oia49 S 505859 18) fM. C h & D.Do ,C mea i teCorro : lvso on w a rs n h utom Teeiin a dteP rutoJ sie6-4(98 (avsigsu n h usi f utc 26 19)cnasn td is n n o whc fu dh r ,a doeo whc fu d e, o e f ih o n am n n f ih o n ta wi essS h fcd a ovoscmea poie h t t se d o ae n b iu a r, rvd d n w a s esta weemoecretln tira dmoednw r h t r r orc,e ghe n r e tir) An ,nayeetayhr t teprisial . d i n vn, n am o h ate,n e cu igteapia t,i rprbetru ha p a. C. ldn h p l ns s eaa l ho g p el f c C a de,u r,t5 1 h n lrsp a a 8 . Th a pia t as cam ta te ta s iso wi e p l ns lo li h t h rnm sin l c l irp rby h r tewin se te sle,peu al reaal am h tess h m evs rs m by b icesn tep bi' a ae eso w otoewiy nraig h u l s w rn s f h h s t c n se ae A dte cam ta smeme br o te ess r. n h y li h t o m es f h p bi mih h rs toewinse. B ttewin se, u l g t aas h s tess u h tess c ato g cpbeo digs, aentak dti C utt l u h a al f on oh v o s e hs o r o h staieteDititC ut odr C. l r . bih, e sd h src o r' re. fMie v Alr t s l g o tewin se sp ot gte apia t ae ara y f h tess u pri h p l ns r led n c p bil ietidwi tercu e T e aealeprs u l y d nie t h i a s. hy r l x et c f h o a vctswh h v ete araya pae o tlvr d oae o ae i r le d p erd n eei h so o ltre bodat,aray tu e te Sae in r nen t ra css led o rd h tt a vct gaSe'vt o P ooiin 8 o araye d oai s s oe n rp s o , r le d n n y' t g gdi etniep bi cmme tr frmoel eyt ae n xesv u l o nay a r i l o c k 53 U..40 45 (98 ('onr J,jie b 2 S 2, 4 19) Ocn o, . ond y K N EY J,ocrigi jdmet P wr v O i, E N D , .cnur n u g n) o es . ho n ; 49U. .0,1 (9 1.A dta intsrrsn .Al 9 S 4041 19) n hts o upiig l 8 HO LNG WO T uP R Y L I S R H .E R B EE,.dset g RYRJ,isni n ma ete welk o nta acoe -rutbodatt k h m l n w h n lsdc ci ra cs o i a ohrfdrlorh u e n te eea cuto s. Th l eiod o a y G rprbe h r i frh r e i l o f n i eaa l' am s u te kh r ' dmiih d b tefc ta tecutodrbfr u i nse y h at h t h or re eoe s wo l smpyices tetil ve iga de c fo ud i l nrae h ra' iwn u ine rm s teoc p nso o ecutom i o ecuto s t te h cu a t f n orro n n orh u e o h ocp nso f e oh rcutomsi f eoh rcu t cu a t f i te orro n i te o rv v hue ( alowhc tkn pcue o rta s isos o ssi l f ih aig itrs r ernm sin n hv be fridn. Bywa o cmprsn leal ae en obde) y f o aio i rl ty h n rd o n to a a d itrain ln wsa esae u de s f ain l n nen to a e p pr r ara y cvrn ti tila drp rig i dti te led oeig hs ra n e ot n eal h n n me a dtsi o yo alo tewi ess S e e . a s n etm n f l f h t se. e, ., n g L f, ma R cl E oin lOrelo Ga Marae efWo n eal m t a da f y rig s o Ba , scae PesJn. 12 1 .1 e n rao wh n Asoitd rs, a 1, 00 se o esn y teice etlices i epsr cu e b ta s ih nrm na nrae n x oue a sd y rn m t t gteepoedn st l ea dt n lo rro swo l i h s rce ig o' d io a cutom ud n i v i ce t a yfrh rrs o h r , steC uta p rnl rae n ute ik f am a h or p aety bl vs S ea t, t1.Moevr ii rsett a y ei e. e ne a 3 roe,fn epc o n e p riua wi esti ta s iso trae sh r , h at lr t s hs rn m sin hetn am te c n Ditit Cor cn peet ta h r . C ifJ de sr ut a rvn h t am he u g c Wak rh sara ysi ta h wo l k e tebo dat le a led ad h t e ud ep h rac s Ro peeyu drteC ut cnrlt pr iteCor cm ltl n e h o r' oto,o em th ut s t so ii(lpoe t b apolm,fipoe t b a o tp tfi rvs o e rbe i t rvso e t dsrcin (r iipoe t cet polmswi wiitato,o)ft rvs o rae rbe t t h n se. S eE h 2 a 4 , p t P t T eCrutCon ess' e x . , t 5Ap .o e. h ici u ' c1cnzme i apesrlaeta teDititC ut i o f d n rs ee s h t h src o r r d i fl cnrlh poes a dta Yu g Wak rh s s l ul oto te rcs' n h t de le a wl y ' rsre tergtt tr iaea y p r o te a do eevd h ih o em n t n at f h u i o vdo o bt,o a yd rt n' rt tr iaep r r ie, r oh fr n uai 'o o em n t ao t iain i te plt porm dta y tme' Ne s ip to n h i rga s n i . w c o a ' Rees,F drlC uto sst Of rRe oeViwig lae eea o rh ue o f m t e n e o Popstn 8 Til (a .8 2 1) ht:www. f r-oii o ra Jn , 00, tp/ / cgu cu t.o/aatr/e eaz l/lo&rpa .so rsgvdtsoegn rv o oo/8 o8 Re oeviwigL ct n.d (svse Jn 1, 00 m t- e n - oai s fa itd a . 3 21, op i adaalbei Ceko Cor'cs Ie.S rl sc n vi l n lr f ut ae' ) uey uh a si l fm cnrleec e b a al dsrt orjdewt i oto xri d y n be itccutu g i r ,s i h Cta:58 S ( 1) i s 5 U.. 2 0 e 0 B EE,.dset g RYRJ,isni n 2 y as fra- a ae e t x ein ewi b sfiet 0 er o til n gm n epre c, l e ufin m l c t a desa yp sil h r ,i e t tewi esso t o d rs n os e am et r o h t se r o b h n teitgiyo tetil h nert fh ra. F ut, ofiblnigoteeute ( cu igh r orhn ar aacn fh qi si ldn am in t tep bi itrs)cudspotisac otesa. o h u l neet ol upr su ne fh ty c S e Tme-iau ePu l hn C r.v S h l g a p e i spcy n bi ig op . cui k m , s n 49 U. .10,10 (94 (o el J i C a br) 1 S 31 35 17) Pw l .n h m es , (eonzn dinfat pbi a d piae itrss rcgiig dgicn ul n rvt neet si c blne o bt sds whnGrsnldwih afn a aacd n oh ie' e peete tl u d ' me tlo fo tto bt entecmpt gv le o fe na cnrnain ew e h o ei au s fre n pesadfitir.A 1 aeutepandteapi rs n a r ) s hv js xlie,h pl ra cns eute cn ito ptnilh r t win sea t' q iis o ss f oeta am o tess h r ta i ete n nxse to ta cn b crd am h t s i r o eitn r h t a e u e h tru hpoetv mesrsb teDititC uta te h o g rtcie au e y h src o r s h cru sa cswarn.T ecmpt geut scnito ic m tne ra t h o ei q ii oss f n e ntol rso dnsitrs i otiigtecuto so ny epn et'neetn bann h orh ue t-o rh ueta s iso ta te dsr, u as te ocu to s rnm sin h t hy eie b t lo h p bi' itrs i osrig tilpoedn st lan u l s neet n bevn ra rceig o er c ao tti cs a da oth w cut wok S eNersa bu hs ae n bu o ors r. e bak PrsAsn v Sur,2 U. .3, 8 (96 (rn a, es s.. tat47 S 59 57 17)B en n J,ocrigi jdmet;e as E h 2a 4, p t .cnurn nu g n)se lo x .,t 2Ap .o Pe.(ttmeto C ifJ deWakr C(ftep bi t sae n f he ug le) 1 h ul J c cudsehwtejdc l rcs w rste wol tk ol e o h u ia poes ok,hy ud ae i asme h tdf rn ve o i.R tikteo l t e o w a iee t iw ft'l hn h ny i f ' m ta yur gigt da sfcetitrs i telgl h t o ' on o rw ufin neet n h ea e i poesi whnyuh v a is esc a teise h r, rcs s e o a e n su u h s h su s ee ta pol tik ao t tl ao t db t a ota d h t epe hn bu, ak bu, eae b u n cnie'.Wi teecnieai si teblnete osdr t hs os rtn n h aac,h )h do sae t h a i a antn tnfvroisigtesa . cls i evl gis, o i ao,fsun h ty p y T emaoi 'at ntdyiu uuo Igat asa h jry co oa s n sa.t rns ty ts i l i odrt cnie ama d mu ptt n wihave t n re o o sdr n a s eii , t iw o itre igi amatro lcl or a miitainta nevnn n te foa cut d nsrto h t iwol nt(n sol ntcnie.lctsn pee t ud o ad hud o) osdr t ie o rcdn frdigs. I ie tisn ra h r ,ltao e et o on o t dnie o el am e ln f Srprbeh r y t jsi isisac o ti sa. d eaal am' o uty t sune f hs ty i r ' f An tep biitrs weg si fvro poiigacs d h u l neet ih n a o f rvdn ces c HOL I GS O T uP R Y LN W R H .E R B EE,.dset g RYRJ,isni n t tecut.T jsi tietariayitreto, o h ors o utf hs xrodnr nevnin y temaoi isssta cut mutRnoc terh jrt nit ht ors s efre h e y q ie eto poeua rgz rt o oh r,a dmu t urm n f rcd rl etai n tes n s ly flw toerq ie e t te sle.Anea 1 A ds ol h s eurm ns h m evs' t, t . n o o ' Ib lv ti C utso l ah r t isisiuin l ei e hs or hud d ee o t nttto a e cmptne i hsoia pat e a d is gvrig o ee c, t itrcl rci , n t oenn s c peee t al f ihcu sl to gya antteisrcdn- lo whc on e srn l g is h su a c otisa. ne fhs ty I epcfl dse t rsetul isn. y

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets were retrieved from PACER, and should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.