Direct Marketing Association, The v. Huber

Filing 65

DESIGNATION OF DEPOSITION TESTIMONY Joint Designation of Additional Deposition Testimony Regarding Plaintiff's Motion for Preliminary Injunction by Plaintiff Direct Marketing Association, The. (Schaefer, Matthew)

Download PDF
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF COLORADO Civil Action No. 10-CV-01546-REB-CBS The Direct Marketing Association, Plaintiff, v. Roxy Huber, in her capacity as Executive Director, Colorado Department of Revenue, Defendant. JOINT DESIGNATION OF ADDITIONAL DEPOSITION TESTIMONY REGARDING PLAINTIFF’S MOTION FOR PRELIMINARY INJUNCTION ______________________________________________________________________ Plaintiff, the Direct Marketing Association, and Defendant, Roxy Huber, Executive Director of the Colorado Department of Revenue, submit this Joint Designation of Additional Deposition Testimony in accordance with the stipulation set forth in the parties’ Joint Status Report Regarding Hearing on Motion for Preliminary Injunction [#58] and the Court’s Order dated December 6, 2010 [#59]. The deposition excerpts and exhibits listed herein, and filed concurrently herewith, are submitted by the parties in addition to the supporting declarations (including exhibits thereto) and other exhibits (including deposition excerpts and public documents) that have been filed in support of: (1) the Plaintiff’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction and Incorporated Memorandum of Law [#15]; (2) the Defendant’s Response in Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction [#50]; and (3) the Plaintiff’s Reply to the Defendant’s Response In Opposition to Plaintiff’s Motion for Preliminary Injunction [#56]. The designating party for each excerpt and exhibit is indicated in the following chart, and on the transcripts filed herewith by highlighting of the text (Plaintiff’s designations in yellow, Defendant’s in blue) consistent with REB Civ. Practice Standard III.F.6. Deponent F. Curtis Barry Excerpt (by page and line) 12:20 – 13:4 13:5 – 21:25 23:20 – 25:21 25:22 – 27:21 32:5-8 32:9 – 36:10 36:11-25 37:1-21 39:15 – 41:3 41:16 – 42:2 42:16 – 44:8 44:9 – 46:9 46:10 – 49:3 51:15 – 52:18 52:19 – 53:14 53:15-24 53:25 – 55:11 55:12-20 57:8 – 58:19 60:2 – 61:25 63:19 – 64:4 64:18-21 65:12-25 67:19 – 68:12 71:9-22 73:4-8 75:25 – 76:22 78:25 – 79:18 80:8 – 81:23 81:24 – 83:7 83:8-14 83:15 – 84:3 84:4-10 88:11 – 89:7 Corresponding Exhibit(s) [First Ref.] Dep. Ex. 1 Dep. Ex. 3 Dep. Ex. 4 Dep. Ex. 7 2 Designating Party Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Deponent (Barry, cont.) Excerpt (by page and line) 90:23 – 91:18 93:9 – 94:6 94:13-15 95:10-17 95:21 – 96:10 97:4-14 97:20 – 98:1 100:4-18 100:19 – 101:2 101:13-20 101:21 – 102:10 102:11 – 103:17 103:22 – 106:25 107:7 – 108:21 109:2-21 114:18 – 120:11 122:7-22 123:25 – 129:4 124:2 – 128:24 130:8-25 131:25 – 132:22 134:5 – 135:15 137:9 – 140:7 140:14 – 141:1 143:11 – 144:9 144:10 – 146:3 146:4-16 147:5-7 147:18 – 149:19 152:18-25 154:2 –157:7 158:14-16 158:17 – 160:25 161:1-14 161:15-21 162:1-6 162:15 – 163:4 163:5 – 164:2 164:3-23 164:24 – 165.23 165:24 – 167:13 167:14 – 168:12 168:13 – 170:15 170:16 – 172:4 172:5 – 173:21 176:12 – 177:18 Corresponding Exhibit(s) [First Ref.] Dep. Ex. 9 Dep. Ex. 5 Dep. Ex. 10 Dep. Ex. 11 Dep. Exs. 12, 13 3 Designating Party Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Deponent (Barry, cont.) Kevin L. Keller Excerpt (by page and line) 178:13-19 180:17 – 182:7 183:22 – 184:1 185:11 – 186:8 187:4-24 188:16 – 189:6 190:7 – 191:17 191:18-23 191:24 – 193:25 195:3 – 197:20 207:6-21 208:25 – 209:3 211:7-23 219:16 – 221:6 225:13-19 225:20-24 225:25 – 226:5 226:6-24 229:5 – 239:18 8:8-11 8:22 – 10:7 11:10 – 12:20 11:16 – 15:7 24:17 – 25:1 25:5 – 29:23 30:1 – 31:22 34:1 – 36:17 41:2 – 44:8 44:23 – 45:9 46:23 – 51:15 64:7-13 Corresponding Exhibit(s) [First Ref.] Dep. Ex. 15 Dep. Ex. 8 Dep. Ex. 17 Dep. Exs. 18, 19 Dep. Ex. 16 Dep. Ex. 20 Dep. Ex. 21 Dep. Ex. 22 67:4 – 72:23 73:2 – 80:8 81:8 – 83:17 83:23 – 86:20 94:6 – 95:5 95:6-14 96:16 – 104:20 107:12 – 109:17 118:3 – 119:17 120:2-8 121:10-23 129:5 – 130:5 Dep. Ex. 23 Dep. Exs. 24, 25, 26 Dep. Exs. 29, 30, 31, 32, 33, 34 Dep. Exs. 35, 36, 37 Dep. Exs. 37, 38 4 Designating Party Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Deponent Thomas J. Adler Excerpt (by page and line) 16:2 – 18:16 23:14 – 25:9 30:6 – 32:10 33:6 – 35:11 35:13 – 36:10 36:13 – 37:1 43:1 – 44:1 44:16-23 45:5-23 46:4-23 50:10 – 52:10 51:11 – 52:5 53:1 – 54:15 55:13 – 60:20 62:9 – 63:17 64:18 – 73:8 74:10 – 75:6 85:14 – 86:4 86:13-23 90:19 – 93:4 93:23 – 97:17 98:9-15 101:7 – 102:1 103:4 – 107:11 107:13-21 107:22 – 108:20 108:21 – 110:2 111:4-14 118:10 – 120:7 120:16 – 121:15 123:12 – 125:20 133:20 – 141:4 149:1 – 150:3 150:17 – 152:22 William F. Fox 12:13 – 15:11 20:22 – 21:13 29:10 – 33:9 38:10 – 39:17 40:20 – 46:15 46:18 – 48:6 Corresponding Exhibit(s) [First Ref.] Dep. Exs. 42, 44 Dep. Ex. 47 Dep. Exs. 48, 49 Dep. Ex. 52 Dep. Exs. 53, 54 Dep. Ex. 55 Dep. Exs. 56, 57 Dep. Ex. 58 Dep. Ex. 60 Dep. Ex. 61 Dep. Ex. 62 Dep. Ex. 63 Dep. Exs. 65, 66, 67 Dep. Ex. 68 Dep. Ex. 69 Dep. Ex. 70 Dep. Exs. 39, 72 Dep. Exs. 74, 76, 79, 80 Dep. Ex. 82 Dep. Ex. 86, 87 Dep. Ex. 88 Dep. Ex. 90 Dep. Ex. 92 Dep. Exs. 21, 39, 90, 93 Dep. Exs. 95, 96 Dep. Ex. 98 5 Designating Party Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Deponent (Fox, cont.) Dieter G. Gable Excerpt (by page and line) 48:14-16 48:17 – 51:10 51:11 – 54:11 51:11 – 58:14 59:13 – 59:23 59:24 – 61:14 61:19 – 64:15 64:16 – 65:10 65:11 – 66:7 67:18 – 68:10 75:8-23 85:8 – 89:15 85:8 – 90:10 89:25 – 90:6 96:6 – 98:17 Corresponding Exhibit(s) [First Ref.] Dep. Ex. 99 Dep. Ex. 100 Dep. Ex. 101 12:20 – 13:17 14:11-16 17:10-12 21:2-18 22:14 – 23:11 24:24 – 25:14 30:11-23 37:25 – 38:7 38:8 – 40:17 41:14 – 44:17 47:16 – 48:8 53:25 – 54:21 84:19 – 85:11 86:1-20 86:21 – 87:20 96:14 – 99:7 99:20 – 101:5 102:16 – 103:2 115:7 – 118:25 120:19 – 122:8 120:19 – 124:25 123:6 – 125:18 125:19-22 126:9 – 127:17 127:18 – 128:15 130:4 – 131:12 131:13 – 132:3 132:4 – 132:22 132:23 – 134:7 134:8-23 Designating Party Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff 6 Deponent (Gable, cont.) Excerpt (by page and line) 134:24 – 135:7 135:8-11 135:12-24 135:25 – 136:4 136:5-12 136:13 – 138:1 138:2-5 138:6-13 138:14 – 140:6 143:3 – 145:8 146:3-11 147:15-23 147:24 – 148:17 148:18 – 149:6 150:13-20 151:12-20 151:24 – 152:11 153:16 – 155:18 159:10-18 Corresponding Exhibit(s) [First Ref.] Designating Party Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Plaintiff Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Defendant Defendant Defendant Plaintiff Defendant Dated: December 17, 2010 . Respectfully submitted, s/ Matthew P. Schaefer George S. Isaacson Matthew P. Schaefer BRANN & ISAACSON 184 Main Street, P. O. Box 3070 Lewiston, ME 04243−3070 Tel.: (207) 786−3566 Fax: (207) 783-9325 E-mail: gisaacson@brannlaw.com mschaefer@brannlaw.com s/ Jack Wesoky Jack Wesoky, Jr. Senior Assistant Attorney General Stephanie Lindquist Scoville Senior Assistant Attorney General Melanie J. Snyder Assistant Attorney General State of Colorado 1525 Sherman Street, 7th Floor Denver, CO 80203 E-mail: Jack.Wesoky@state.co.us stephanie.scoville@state.co.us melanie.snyder@state.co.us Attorneys for Plaintiff Attorneys for Defendant 7 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on December 17, 2010, I electronically filed the foregoing Joint Designation of Additional Deposition Testimony, using the CM/ECF system, which will send notification of such filing to counsel of record: Jack Wesoky, Jr. Senior Assistant Attorney General Stephanie Lindquist Scoville Senior Assistant Attorney General Melanie J. Snyder Assistant Attorney General State of Colorado 1525 Sherman Street, 7th Floor Denver, CO 80203 Jack.Wesoky@state.co.us stephanie.scoville@state.co.us melanie.snyder@state.co.us Attorneys for Defendant s/ Matthew P. Schaefer Matthew P. Schaefer 8