MobileMedia Ideas LLC v. Apple Inc.

Filing 507

REDACTED VERSION of 506 Jury Verdict. (fms)

Download PDF
0J r--...~]~''{M ~_sl0c~©Ut~@ I - ~~. IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE DISTRICT OF DELAWARE MOBILEMEDIA IDEAS, LLC ) Plaintiff, ) ) Defendant. ) Civ. No. 10-258-SLR ) ) ) ) ) v. APPLE INC. VERDICT SHEET Dated: December 11, 2012 We, the jury, unanimously find as follows: I. U.S. Patent No. 6,070,068 ("The '068 Patent") A. Direct Infringement 1. Do you find that MobileMedia has proven, by a preponderance of the evidence, that each and every limitation of claim 23 and/or claim 24 of the '068 patent is found in the accused Apple iPhones (hereinafter, "Apple's iPhones")? Checking 'yes" below indicates a finding for MobileMedia. Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the Apple. Claim Verdict on direct infringement 23 ~ifyes 0 no 24 ~yes 0 no B. Indirect Infringement - Inducing Infringement 2. Do you find that MobileMedia has proven, by a preponderance of the evidence, that Apple has induced the infringement of claim 23 and/or claim 24 of the '068 patent? Checking "yes" below indicates a finding for MobileMedia. Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the Apple. Claim Verdict on inducement of infringement 23 0 yes ~no 24 0 yes [1f no C. Validity 3. Do you find that Apple has proven, by clear and convincing evidence, that the asserted claims of the '068 patent are invalid as being anticipated? Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the MobileMedia. Checking "yes" below indicates a finding for Apple. Claim No {VaHd) Yes (Invalid, anticipated) 23 ~ D 24 g' D 4. Do you find that Apple has proven, by clear and convincing evidence, that the asserted claims of the '068 patent are invalid as being obvious? Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the MobileMedia. Checking "yes" below indicates a finding for Apple. Claim No {Valid) Yes {Invalid due to obviousness) 23 ~ D 24 rt( D 2 11. U.S. Patent No. 6,253,075 ("The '075 Patent") A. Direct Infringement 1. Do you find that MobileMedia has proven, by a preponderance of the evidence, that each and every limitation of claim 5, claim 6, and/or claim 10 of the '075 patent is found in Apple's iPhones? Checking "yes" below indicates a finding for MobileMedia. Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the Apple. If you answer "no" with respect to claim 5, you must answer "no" with respect to dependent claim 6 for purposes of this question. Claim Verdict on direct infringement 5 0 no 6 0 no 10 0 no 3 B. Indirect Infringement - Inducing Infringement 2. Do you find that MobileMedia has proven, by a preponderance of the evidence, that Apple has induced the infringement of claim 5 and/or claim 6 of the '075 patent? Checking 'yes" below indicates a finding for MobileMedia. Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the Apple. If you answer "no" with respect to claim 5, you must answer "no" with respect to dependent claim 6 for purposes of this question. Claim Verdict on inducement of infringement 5 0 yes 6 0 yes 4 C. Validity 3. Do you find that Apple has proven, by clear and convincing evidence, that the asserted claims of the '075 patent are invalid as being obvious? Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the MobileMedia. Checking "yes" below indicates a finding for Apple. If you find that claim 5 is valid and not obvious, you must find that dependent claim 6 is also valid and not obvious for purposes of this question. Claim No (Valid) Yes (Invalid due to obviousness) 5 ~ 0 6 g-' 0 10 [{(' 0 5 - ...... Ill. U.S. Patent No. 6,427,078 ("The '078 Patent") A. Direct Infringement 1. Do you find that MobileMedia has proven, by a preponderance of the evidence, that each and every limitation of claim 73 of the '078 patent is found in Apple's iPhones? Checking "yes" below indicates a finding for MobileMedia. Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the Apple. Claim Verdict on direct infringement 73 Vyes D no B. Validity 2. Do you find that Apple has proven, by clear and convincing evidence, that claim 73 of the '078 patent is invalid as being anticipated? Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the MobileMedia. Checking "yes" below indicates a finding for Apple. Claim 73 No (Valid) ~ Yes (Invalid, anticipated) D 6 3. Do you find that Apple has proven, by clear and convincing evidence, that claim 73 of the '078 patent is invalid as being obvious? Checking "no" below indicates a finding for the MobileMedia. Checking "yes" below indicates a finding for Apple. Claim 73 No (Valid) ~ Yes (Invalid due to obviousness) D 7