PBM Capital Investments, LLC v. Lalonde

Filing 23

MEMORANDUM OPINION. Signed by District Judge Glen E. Conrad on 7/9/13. (hnw) [Transferred from Virginia Western on 7/10/2013.]

Download PDF
CL ERK' OFFP U. . ST. S CE S DI COURT AT ROANOG A . FL IED T TH E UN ITED STA TES D I I COU RT N STR CT FO R TH E W ESTERN D I I OF V I N I STR CT RGI A CH ARLOTTESV I LLE DI I ON V SI g J 2SA 1 UL 3 J A . l ubt DtDuR , ) RK c BY: D p- . r Y $ PBM CA PI TAL I V ESTM EN TS,LLC, N Ci lAc i N o. 1 vi ton 3: 3CV 00008 Pl i if a ntf , M EM O R AND U M O PI IO N N M I A EL G .LA LON DE, CH By:Ho Gln E.Conr d n. e a Chi fU nied St t sD i t i tJ e t a e sr c udge Def nda . e nt PBM Ca tll sme s LLC (i 'fldt saci a i tMiha G. l pia nvet nt, t PBM' ie hi ton gans c el Laonde ) (1 l ' ,a s tngcli frfaud e i e nta s c ii fa PBM alge t t i onde' seri ams o r ulnt nduc me nd e urtes rud. La ) le s ha La onde m a f s r pr e a i nsa l de al e e es nt to bouta m e c de c t the cl i e t ha c e t d t t e t di al vi e ha a m d o ve r a e o r a se p a a whih c us d PBM t i s ove $3, 000. i oa lm ied la lt c l e pne , c a e o nve t r 000, 00 nt i t ibiiy ompa ny (i 't ti fr dwihLaonde. Reyi o pr sonsi t LLC Ag e me ,Lal has û LLC' ha t ome t l ) l ng n ovii n he r e nt onde move t dimist c d o s s he ompl ntf i pr perve a f f iur t sae ac am or i t ai or m o nue nd or a l e o t t l i , n he a t r tve, o t a f rven t t U nie St t D it i tCo tf t D i ti tofD e awa e For le na i t r ns e ue o he t d a es s rc ur or he sr c l r. t r as ns t f l t co twilgr ntt m oton t tans e ve he e o hat olow, he ur l a he i o r f r nue. The m o i n t d s i s to o im s f ri pr rve wilbe de e asm oot a t c tw il e r i f om r i on t m oto t o m ope nue l ni d , nd he our l r f a n r ulng he in o dim i f faiur t s at a cl m . s ss or l e o t e ai Backeround PBM i aD el w a e LLC bas d i Cha l t vil ,V ig ni The com pa w a f s a r e n rotes le r i a. ny s onne f r d o t pur e ofa quii s c ii s a i tng i i he pos c rng e urte nd nves i n nnova i t c tve e hnol e . PBM ' f under ogi s So , pr i nt a c efe cutve ofi e i Pa M a ng. es de , nd hi xe i tc r s ul nni I Sept berof2010,Lal n em onde,ar dentofGeor a,ûs i t M anni s i t entf esi gi solcied ng' nves m or t pur he pose ofcom m er alzi Lal ci i ng onde' pr ot ofw hathe cl m ed w ast s ales , f l s ot ype ai he m l t uly f to lando rtonal( ii ar yprsur (1 '1me c lde ce'orte tng uncina, peai postve iwa e s e $PAP' dia vi 'f r ai ) i vi l wih o tuci se pa . ( ndi duas t bsr tve le pnea Compl! 1 ) Baedo Laonde' rprs ntto . 2. s n l s e e e ains r ga di t spur t br a hr h i see a a t c e r ng hi pored e kt oug n l p pne e hnol ogy,PBM a ee t bec e a gr d o om me rofDehu M e ca, mbe s m di lLLC,fkaZe La ,LLC to es l. PBM e erdi oa ll phyr bs l hum' nt e nt n LLC Agee ntf t opeai ofDehum (he' Agre nf'a uli tl i se ove r me or he rton s t I LLC e me ) nd tmaey nvetd r $3, 000. i o t c me cilz ton ofLa o ' see a a s tm . 000, 00 nt he om r a ia i l nde s l p pne yse l t i t ntac i PBM a l ge t ta t ren e i i t t LLC A gr e e a m a ng n he ns a ton, le s ha fe t rng n o he e m nt nd ki isi s m e ,PBM di c t nve t nt s over d t tLa onde' r pr s n a i r r ng t pe f e ha l s e e e t tons ega di he r onna e and nc f tona iy oft s e p a a s t m w e e f l e PBM f t ra l gest tt unc i lt he l e pne ys e r as . urhe le ha he m i r pr e a i w e e kno i y a i e i naly m adeby La onde, nd t tPBM r le upon s e es nt tons r w ngl nd nt nto l l a ha e id t m i r pr e a i nsi f r i D e hum ,pur ha i D e hum s lrte ,a i s i m ilons he s e es nt to n o m ng s c s ng s ecz ii s nd nve tng li ofdola si o t s e p a l r nt he l e pnea s t m . PBM a s t c a m s f r c m o 1 w f a e ys e s ers l i o om n a r udul nt i e e a s a ut r s urte f a ndue m nt nd t t o y ec ii s r ud. La onde hasm oved t di m i s t co pl i tor i t a t m a i ,t t a f rve t t l o s s he m a n , n he le tve o r ns e nue o he Unie St t s D i ti tCour f t D i ti tofD e a r . Them oton i pr m i e on c r a n t d a e s rc t or he sr c l wa e i s e sd e ti pr sonsoft LLC Agr eme ,whi h wass ovii he e nt c ubmil d asa e bi t Lal te n xhi t o onde' moton. s i Sec i n 1 03 oft LLC A gr e e co a nsbo h a c c of1 w c a e a a f m t o 4. he e m nt nt i t hoi e a l us nd onz s l ton cl e. The s ton pr de ,i pe tne pa t a f l s e ec i aus ec i ovi s n r i nt r , s olow : G o r nc Law sSubm i s on t J r s i to .W a ve s Thi A gr e e a t ve ni ' s i o u i d c i n' i r . s e m nt nd he rght oft pa te he e i s he ri s r unde s l be i e pr t i a co da e wih t l w s of r ha l nt r e ed n c r nc t he a t St t ofD e a a e, ihoutgi ng e f c t a c lc of1 w pr nc pl s Ea h he a e lw r w t vi f e t o ny onfi t a i i e . c oft M e r a e t i a diput i no r ol by t pa te ,i s lbe he mbe s gr es hat f ny s e s t es ved he ris t hal r ol d onl i t f der lors a e c ' oft St e ofD e a a e s ti i N e es ve y n he e a t t oul s he at t l w r itng n w CateCount a t a laec ursha ngj iditonofappe si s hc t sl y nd he ppelt o t vi urs ci al n uc ours (ole tvel t t o rCours'. l t tco e ,a wihoutlmii t c lci y,he t pe pr t' n ha ntxt nd t l i tng he ge r lt oft f e ng,e h oft M e be sir ne a iy he or goi ac he m r r evoc bl a unc tonaly a y nd ondii l ()s t f is fa ispr ryi a a tonrltngt t doc nt a ubmis or tel nd t ope t n ny ci eai o he ume delve edpurua t t sAgr e e orf r cog ton a e or eme ofa i r s nt o hi e m nt or e nii nd nf c nt ny j g n i rs c hee f t t ee cu iej rs ito o ud me t n epe t ro ,o h x lsv u idcin f t Pr pe Co t a a e t ta1 c a m si r pe tofa s h ac i n s lbe he o r urs nd gr es ha 1 l i n es c ny uc to hal hea d a de e m i d i s h c ti t St t ofDe a a e t t e ent nnit r nd t r ne n uc our n he a e l w r , o he xt pe ted byl i s hf erlco t gnd)( c e st ta s hacinma a s l aw,n uc ed a ur;a b) ons nt ha ny uc to y nd hal bebr oughti s hc t a wave anyo j ci t tima now o t r fe n uc ours nd i s b e ton ha t y r heeatr ha t t v orj iditonofa s h a toni a s hc 'o t ts h ve o he enue urs ci ny uc ci n ny uc oul r ha uc t ac i n w asbr to oughti a i nve e c r a ag ee nott pl d orc a m t n n nco ni nt ou t nd r s o ea l i he Sarne .... ( Agr me j1 03. LLC ee nt 4. ) The LLC A gr e e a s c ai a m e ge cl us a a no r i e cl us Se ton e m nt l o ont ns r r a e nd n-elanc a e. c i 1 06pr dest tdgl sAg e me ,ogehe wihalExhi t heeo,a a ResrcedUni 4. ovi ha ithi r e ntt t r t l bis rt nd ny tit t A g e m e s c a nst e i e unde s a ng a ong t pa tesa s pe s desa pr o a r e nt , ont i he ntr r t ndi m he r i nd u r e ny i r nd c n e o a e usu d rtn i sa da r e n sb t e t e rs e tn tes b e t te o tmp rn o n e sa dng n g e me t ewe n h m e p cig h u j c matr hee ' (d.j1 06. Se ton 1 02( pr dest te chme rr e e sa warnt t t rof' l 4. ) ci 3. 9 ovi ha a mbe eprs nt nd ra s ha d tha r le onl o t i o m a i n s tf r h he e n i de e m i ng t a qui e Unis....' i s e i d y n he nf r to e o t r i n t r ni o c r i t ' (d.j1 02( ) TheAgre ntdefne d t' ûa ownerhi i e eti t Compa l 3. 9, e me i s t 'as dn uni s p ntr s n he ny, i udi a 1oft r ght a oblga i i c ncl ng 1 he i s nd i tons n onne ton t r w ih unde t sAgr em e . .. (4 c i he e t r hi e nt . ' 1. ' j 101) . . Bas o t f egoi s ci nsoft LLC Ag e m e t Lal ed n he or ng e to he r e n , ondea g st tve uei t s r ue ha n n hi dit i i i pr s rd s m opera t tt eo pl i tf ist s a e a d a m upon whi h r lefo n be g a e nd ha he m a n a l o t t i c ei a r nt d. Thecou t l ahea i on Lal r he d rng onde' m otonsc M a 2, 3. The m a t rha be f l br e e s i m y 201 te s en uly i f d and i ri f r ew . s pe or evi pic so s us i n The t z hol i s r i e by Lal h es d s ue a s d onde i w h he t W eser D it i tofVi gi a i a s et r he t n s rc r ni s pr opervenue f t s acton. Rel ng on t f um sel i cl or hi i yi he or ecton ause cont ned i t LLC ai n he Agr ent Lal eem , onde arguest t cas s d be di m i ed ort fer t t D it i of hat he e houl s ss rans red o he s rct 3 Dea r PBM oppos st m o i a gui t iscli sf l outi t s ope oft f um lwa e. e he ton, r ng hat t am al sde he c he or sel i cl e. ecton aus The e or ea lt ofa f r m s e ton c a e i f de alc ti a m a t rgove ne by nf c biiy o u el c i l us n e r our s te r d fde a lw. Stwa tOr ,nc v.RiohCom.487U. 22,32( 988 ;Al ma l Cor v. e rla e r g.l . c , S. 1 ) be re p. Asrze c UK Lt ,6 F. 643,650(t Ci. 0) Unde fdea lw,af m s lci ta ne a d. 28 3d 4h r 201 . r e rl a onz ee ton cl us i t i a f i va i a s d be e or ed unl s e or m e i s w n by t r s s i a e s t m ac e ld nd houl pr nf c e s nf ce nt s ho he e itng pa t t be û ea o bl unde t cic sa ry o unr s na e' r he r um t nces' The Br l n v.Za a Of - r Co. 407 .' ehe pat f sho e , U. 1,9(972) A f um s l tonclus ma bec i rdunr s na ei: S. 1 . or eeci a e y onsdee ea o bl f ( )kt)f mai wasi 1 is or ton nduce byfa o overac ng;( t c ai ngpa t d rud r re hi 2) he ompl ni ry d ilf a 1 a tc pur e be de i d ofhi d y i c t bec us oft g a t l or 1 pr c i al pos s w pr ve s a n our ' a e he r ve ' i on ninc orunf r s oft s e tdf um;()t f me alt ar s nc ve e e aine s he elce or 3 he unda nt mfines oft chos nlw mayde i t plitf ofar dy; ( (tle oreme he e a prve he anif eme or 4) is nf c nt w oul cont avene a s r publc polcy oft f um s at d r t ong i i he or t e. Ale v.Ll sofLondon,94F. 9 9 ( h Ci.1 )( i TheBrme 408U. at ln oyd' 3d 23, 28 4t r 996 quotng e n, S. 1 . 8) l t sca e,PBM doesnotco e t tt a f r i t c e t Del w a e woul n hi s nt nd ha r ns e rng he as o a r d c r ne publc polc o d prve t c pa ofis d y i c t an a opra e r m e ontave i i y, r e i he om ny t a n our or ppr i t e dy. Li w i e, he e i no a l ga i off a i t i e e oft f r m s l to c a e is l . ke s t r s le ton r ud n he nduc m nt he o u e ec i n l us t e f W hie PBM cl i st tt LLC A g e m e a a whol wast pr l a m ha he r e nt s e he oduc of La onde' f s t l s al e r pr s nt tons ge r lcl m s offa s h a t e co a ned i t c pl i ,t nots fc e e e a i , ne a ai r ud, uc s hos nt i n he om a nt û do uf i e t i ldaeavai fr s e tonca e. W oncv. ryGa ngLt ,589F. 821 828( h o nvai t ld oum elci lus ' ' Pat mi d. 3d , 6t Ci.2009 ;s eas Sc k v. bet cul rCo.41 U. 5 51 n.4( 974)( fa r ) e lo hgr Al ro- ve , 7 S. 06, 9 1 1 The r ud e e i i The Br m e ç s notm e t ta tm e a di put a i i outofa ta a ton i xc pton n e n t doe an ha ny i s e rs ng r ns c i s ba e upona alegain o fa ...heca ei unenf c abl Rahe ,ime nst tgj... sd n l to f rud t lus s ore e. t r t a ha a f r - el ton c a e i a c r c i une or e bl i t i l i o t tcl us i t co r c o um s ec i l us n ont a t s nf c a e f he nc uson f ha a e n he nt a t 4 wa tep o u to fa do c eco ' (mp a i i o ii a) l t ea e c o a y ohe s h r d c f ru r o rin.) e h ss n rgn l. n h bs n e f n t r ' a g e ast t valdiy oft f um s e ton c a e, he c tc l st tt c a e i r um nt o he i t he or el c i l us t our onc ude ha he l us s r s ea onabl a e or ea e e nd nf c bl . H a ng r c t s de s on,t cou tm us now de e m i whe he t c a e a i s t vi ea hed hi ci i he r t t r ne t r he l us pple o t c ai sas e td i t i t ntc s Se e :. Robi o v.La Fu niur LLC,995 F. he l m s re n he ns a a e. e, . , ns n dd r t e. 2d 1 1 U. App. 064, 993 S. LEXI 1 2, t*1 (t Ci.1 (iti note S 425 a 2 4h r 993) $1 s noughsmpl t de i t t i y o cde ha t scl us i e o c a e i t a t a t w e m us a s de e m i whe he i i e or ea e aga ns hi a e s nf r e bl n he bs r c ' , t l o t r ne t r t s nf c bl i t t epatc a cai .'. I ma ngt sd e nai t co tl ûot lng geoft hes riulr l ms' n ki hi etnui ton,he ur ooks s he a ua ) t he pa te c rcg)t deemi whihc us ofa tonaeg r dbyt fnz s lcton ris' onta t o tr ne c a es ci r ove ne he o m ee i ca eg15 M ai c nc Shipi Lt v.Se ta 1 F. 21 222( t Ci.1 . lgl lus . ' rne ha e p ng, d. basiq, 43 3d 6, 5h r 998) dlf t s t eofghepl ntf s cli ,srppe o t i lbes doesno f lwihi t sopeof he ubsanc t ai if ) ams ti d f her a l, t al t n he c t clus Jt ca e 1c he a eg ,he lus l annota y. Robyv. )p ofLl s 996F. 1 1 ( Ci, ppl ' ' C(r . oyd', 2d 353, 361 2d r 1 . 993) H er t pori oft LLC A gr enti diput pr desasf l s: e, he ton he eem n s e ovi olow Thi A gr e e a t r g soft pa te her unde s l be i e pr t d i s e m nt nd he i ht he ri s e r ha l nt r e e n a or nce w ih t l w s oft St t ofDel w a e w ihou gi ng ef e tt a cc da t he a he a e a z , t t vi f c o ny c l c s ofl w prnc pl s Eac oft M e be sa e st ti a di put i not onti t a i i e. h he m r gr e ha f ny s e s r s ve by t pa te ,i s l be r s ve onl i t f er lor s a e cou t oft e ol d he r i s t ha l e ol d y n he ed a tt r s he St t ofDel w a e sti i N e Casl Co t a t a la e c t ha ng ae a r itng n w te un y nd he ppe l t our s vi j rs ito o a pe l i s c c u t (o lciey teI o e Cou s'. u idcin f p as n u h o rs c le tv l ,h t p r t1 ' pr l ( Ag e men j1 03. Forhi pa tLao eague t tt f um slci ca ea is LLC r e t 4. ) s r, lnd r s ha he or ee ton lus pple br dl t a di put bet e n t pari . l r s ns ,PBM a guest tt cl us i lm ie by oa y o ny s e w e he tes n e po e r ha he a e s i t d t c c of1w pr so c ane i t frtlneofj1 03a t ,ha ii onl ti rd he hoie a oviin onti d n he is i 4. nd,hus t t t s y rggee when ac tmus i e r tt LLC Agr e e o t pa te 'rght t emde . our t nt p e he e m nt r he ris i s her l r U li a e y,t c tfndsi un c s r t r ol t s di p e. Eve as um i t t tm t l he our i t ne es a y o es ve hi s ut n s ng ha PBM ' na r r a ng oft f m s l to c a e i co r t t c tc l st tis c a m s S r ow e di he onz e ec i n l us s r ec , he our onc ude ha t l i off a r udul n i e t nduce en a s c ii f a f l w ihi t s ope oft e a e. m t nd e urtes r ud a l t n he c he l us By sg ng t LLC Agr e e ,PBM ex es l si aed t ti ha C e id onl on t i ni he e m nt pr sy tpult ha t d k le r y he i or to stf t (nt Ag e menl'n a quii a o rhi i ees i t LLC, ndt t nf main e orh i he r e t'i c rng n wne s p ntr t n he a ha t Agre ntc ai d khee ieunde sa nga he e me ont ne % ntr t rtndi mongt pate . ( Agre ntjj he ris' LLC e me ' 1 02()& 1 06 . Nowihsa ngt s pr viins PBM now cams i ea hofiscou s t t 3. i 4. ) t t tndi he e o so , li ,n c t nt,ha i r le on f l e r pr s nt t o ,whi h w e enotco a ned i t LLC A g e m e ,i m a ng is t ei d a s e e e a i ns c r nt i n he r e nt n ki t de i i n t e eri t t LLC A gr e e a pur ha e D e h s c ii s A se de e by t r c s o o nt n o he e m nt nd c s s um e urt e . vi nc d hei bre son t m oto t di m i sf f iu e t s a e a c a m , he pa te s p l di ag e ast if he i n o s s or a l r o t t l i t r i s ha y s r e o whe he t m e ge a non- ela pr vi i oft LLC A gr e e pr c ud PBM f om t r he r r nd r i nce o s ons he e m nt e l e r e t bls ng t e s ntale e e sofisf a cl i s Com pa e RA A M gm t.LLC v. vaz s a i hi he s e i l m nt t r ud a m . r . Sa e SporsHol ngs l ,45A.d 1 11 ( . 2)( di unde Dea r lw,ha a t di .nc. 3 07, 9 Del201 hol ng, r lwae a t t pli ifsfa camsweebardbyano rla edicame ca ei t pa te 'a r e nt, antf rud li r re n-einc sli r lus n he ris g e me ) wih FS Phot I v. pis e sonl , F. t o. n vs curvii nc.61 Supp. 473, ( D. 1 2d 48l E. Va. 999)( di t r hol ng,mde - Vigi alw,ha ac r t ldicli rofrla edi notpr l acam offa i seas r ni a t t ontacua s ame einc d ecude li rudl* e lo AESCor v.Dv uvPowe Cor ,325F. 1 4,1 ( Ci. 03 ( lni t hol t ta p. ne r p. 3d 7 81 3d r 20 ) deci ng o d ha non-e i nce cl us w ila w a pr vi i m uniy fom f de a s urte f a la lt but r la a e l l ys o de m t r e r l ec ii s r ud i biiy, e pha i i t tc s s i vi a no r la e cl us i a ne i e conta be wee m s z ng ha a e nvol ng n- e i nc a e n gotat d r ct t n s p itc tdp rist l o tnbea p o raec n i ae f rr s lto a t s mmayj dg n o h siae a t i l fe e wi p rp it a d d ts o e ou in the u r u me t sage). Eve i i i uli tl deemi dt tt s pr sonsdonotopeaet barPBM ' t ' n f t s tmaey tr ne ha he e ovii rt o S cl m s off audul i ai r ent nducem entand seclrtesf aud,t r uton oft zii r he esol i hese cl m sw il ai l *The pari alo diput t s tes s s e he cope oft LLC Agr m e ' choi ofl pr son and t efec t ti he ee nts ce aw ovii he f t ha t hason t mert oft pl ntf ' cl msunde sat Iw . he is he ai ifs ai rtea 6 ne s a iy i plc t t i e pr a in oft LLC Agr me a t pari s rg st r unde . ce s rl m i ae he ntr etto he ee nt nd he te ' iht he e r Cons que l t c tco l e nty, he our nc udest t e n t de t na r r a ng a nc by PBM ,t ha , ve m r he r ow e di dva ed he c a m sa i s f l w ihi t s ope oft f um s l c i cl us . See Soi Bl Sys v.CM l l i t s ue a l t n he c he or e e ton a e l dz. . Terex C orz No. 04- 0210, 4U. DitLEXI 1 p, 3: CV200 S. s. S 0663,a *1 ( D.Te J 9 2004) t 8 N. x. une , - ( di t tt pli ifscamsoffa a mirprs ntto we egovene byafr m hol ng ha he antf' li rud nd se e e ain r r d ou s l to c a e,snce s h cl i sr quie i e pr t ton oft pa a e e sofa a r e e ' e ec i n l us i uc a m e r d nt r e a i he r m t r n g e m nt s pr sondicli nga1orlrprs nttonsa prora e nt) ovii s ami l a e e e ai nd i greme s. Be aus t f um s l c i c a e r qui e ltga i i D e a a e,i f l st tve i c e he or e e ton l us e r s ii ton n l w r t olow ha nue s no pr ri t sditit Rahe t ndimisngt c eunde Rul 1 b)3)oft Fe rl t ope n hi src. t r ha s si he as r e 2( ( he dea Rue o Ci iPr c d r ,h c u' i t eitrs o j sie wi ta se t ec s t t Ditit f ls f vl o e u e t e o r,n h n eet f u tc , l r n fr h a e o he src o t l Delwae,whe ei c dha be nbr a r r t oul ve e oughti tal See28U. C.j1 a)Ct- ditit niily. S. 406( -he src l c tofa dit i ti w hi h i fl a c e l yi ve i t w r di s o ordi t i ts l our s rc n c s ied as a ng nue n he ong vi i n sr c ha l d s s, ri ibei t eitrs o j sie ta frs hc s t a yd src o dv so i wh c i imis o f t n h n eet f u tc ,rnse uc a e o n itit r iii n n ih t c dha bee brug .) oul ve n o ht' . ' Concl i us on Fort r ons s at t courtwilgr Lal he eas t ed, he l ant onde' m oton t t ansf t s acton t t s i o r er hi i o he D i t i tofDe a a e, nd de a m oothi m o i t di m i sf i pr pe ve sr c lw r a ny s s ton o s s or m o r nue. The c t our dec i st r e on La o ' m oto t dim i sf f iur t sa e a c a m and l a t tm o i t lne o ul l nde s i n o s s or a l e o t t l i e ves ha ton o be de i ed by t t a f r e c t cd he r ns e e our . The Cl r i di e t t s nd o r ii d c pi oft sm e or ndum opi on a t e k s r c ed o e e tfe o es hi m a ni nd he accom panyi ordert a1 couns ofrecor ng o 1 el d. ENTER: i Q Ths d yo J l, 01 . a f uy 2 3 / i M W . Chi Unied St esD i rctJudge ef t at sti

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.