Wi-LAN USA, Inc. et al v. Apple Inc.

Filing 54

ORDER GRANTING 39 Defendant's Motion to Transfer Venue. Signed by Judge K. Michael Moore on 4/2/2013. (rg1)

Download PDF
I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI CO URT CT FOR THE SOUTHERN DI STRI OF FLORI CT DA Cas No.1 c 2431 - M e 2- v8 KM W iLAN USA,I an W iLAN,I C. NC. d N Pli if , antfs VS . A PPLE l C . N , De e nt f nda . / ORDER GRANTI DEFENDANT' M O TION TO TRANSFER VENUE NG S THI CAUSE ca be or t Cour upon Def nda ' Re we M oton t Tr nser S me f e he t e nts ne d i o a f Ve u t t eUn td Sae DititCo r f rt S uhen Ditito Caio a( No. 9 . n e o h ie tts src u t o he o t r src f l mi ECF f 3) Pli t f fld aM e r n u i Op o iin ( No 4 )a d Dee d n fld a Re l ( ani s i f e mo a d m n p sto ECF . 9 n fn a t ie py ECF No 5 ) Th M oi n i n w rp f rrve UPON CONS DERATI o te M oin,te . 3 . e to s o ie o e iw. I ON f h to h Re po e a Re y,t pe tne pori nsoft Re or and beng ohe wie f ly a s d i s ns nd pl he ri nt to he c d, i t r s u l dvie n t pr m ies t sCou te e st f l ng Or r he e s ,hi r nt r he olowi de . 1. BA C K G R O U ND 1 I De mber201 W iLAN fl d s tagans Appl f pa e i rnge e c e ni n ce 2 ie ui i t e or t nt nfi m nt onc r ng U. Pa e Nos 8315, a 8, 0 S. t nt . , 640 nd 311,40. The pa e sr ae t o t m ehodsa s t m sf t nt elt ç he t t nd yse or ta m ison of muli e m odult d sg s ove wie e s newor ,a pa ng s zce da a r ns s i tpl a e i nal r r l s t ks nd cki olr t pac t i o ta pori pac t wih fa e a i ' M e .i Opp. a 2. W iLAN hast ke s nt r ns tng kes t r gm ntton. ' m n ,t wo r aed a tonspe ng i t sCou t one fl d agans HTC Co por ton a HTC Ame ia,a elt c i ndi n hi r, ie i t r ai nd rc nd 1Thef t heen aet nfom De e ntsRe we M oint TrnserVe ( No. ; acs ri r ake r f nda ' ne d to o a f nue ECF 39) Pli if'M e a l i Opposton( No.49) a Deenda ' Repl ( No.53) antfs morndtm n ii ECF ; nd f nts y ECF . t ot r fld agans Sira W iees Am e i a I he he ie i t er rl s rc , nc. Thes aci c e tons once n t s m e pae s r he a tnt wih smia a lga i ofi rnge e . t i lr le tons nfi m nt W iLAN ,I i a co por to i t i elecualpr ry de l e a lc i nc. s r ai n n he nt l t ope t veopm nt nd iensng i ty he dqua tr i Ota Ont i W iLAN USA ,a wholy owne i r c s i a y ndusr a re ed n twa, aro. l d ndie t ubsdi r o W iLAN,i a Fl i c por ton wih isU . hea f s orda or a i t t S. dqua tr i M i mi W iLAN USA wm re s n a . s i om or td i Fl i i De mber2011 Def nda Appl i ba e i Cupe tno,Ca ionza nc ae n orda n ce . e nt e s sd n ri lf i, i t Norhe n Dititof Caior a. Appl has r t i l tons i t Sou he n Dititof n he t r src lf ni e e a l ocai n he t r src Fl i Qualomm,a de lpe oftc ogy i iae i t e pae s i ba e i Sa orda. c veo r e hnol mplc td n hes tnt, s s d n n Digo,Ca ior a,n t Sout r DititofCaiom i e lf ni i he he n src lf a. I. l LEGAL STANDARD Tie 2 U.. j 1 0 ( ) p o i e ta çfo te c n e in e o te p ris a d t 8 SC. 4 4 a r v d s h t t j r h o v ne c f h a t n l l e win se ,i te i ee t ofj tc ,a dsrc c r ma ta se a y cvi a to t a y oh r t e s s n h ntr ss usie itit ou t y rn fr n i l cin o n te dititordi son whe e i mi ha be n br ug ort any dititordi son t whih al src vii r t ght ve e o ht o src vi i o c l pa te haveco e e ' 28U. C,j1 a. ris ns ntd.' S. 404() Thesa r f tanse unde j 1 a gi br dicei t t ti c qand a tndad or r fr r 404() ves oad s rton o he ral our til c ts de son wil be ov t ne onl f r a e of dicr ton. M a on v.Sm ihklne ra our' cii l erur d y o bus s ei s t i Be hn Clni lLabs 1 F.Supp.2d 1 ec m i ca es ho i 355,1 ( D.Fl 2001. Congr s aut rzed 358 S. a. ) ., 46 c t t ta f rt ve ofa c s i o de t avoi Innec s a y i ours o r nse he nue ae n r ro d l e s r nconve e e t t ltga s ni nc o he ii nt , winese ,a t publc, t c e v tme e r a mone Se t. a 1 t s s nd he i and o ons r e i , ne gy, nd y. e t t 359. k Theq si ofwhehe t ta frvenuei ve at pr edi r J Thefrt ueton t r o rnse nvol s wo- ong nquiy. . Z is pr hol t tt at nmtve ve ç tbe one i whi t aci coul orgi ly have ong ds ha he le i nue ç mus n ch he ton d i na l bee br n oughtby t pl néf ' I The s c pr i ve a eeme - e e he ai f ' d. e ond ong nvol s n l ntby- l mentana yss l i. I r quiesCourst ç l e prvae a publc f cor ... t de e m i whe he ta f r i te r t o i anc i t nd ba i a t s ' o t r ne ' t r r ns e s j tfe l usi d. d. i 11 1. DI SCUSSI ON The a bove-t e a ton c d ha be fl d i t Sout m Diti t of Ca ior a. syld c i oul ve en ie n he he src lf ni Ap ei s be tt p ro l mid ci n i S. Ca . c us tto f r frs l o s lsa c s d pl s u j c o e s na j s ito n D. l be a e t fe s o ae r el c u e i p o u t i ta d src,a d t rf r h s s f in c n a t t e tb ih j rs cin tee' r d cs n h t itit n heeo e a u t e t o tcs o sa ls u idito h r . k ' M o .t Trns,a 6. Theeo e ta se i pemisbl p o i e ta ta se i j siid a to a .t rf r , rn fr s r si e r v d d h t r n f r s u tfe s e nce by a a yssofpublc a prva ef ct s vi d n nal i i nd i t a or . I M a ue v.Co v r ysCo . 43 F.d 1 3 ( 1 Ci.2 05 ,t Elv nh Cic i n n l n ec m , 0 3 1 2 1 1 r 0 ) he e e t rut l td a n mb ro p b i a d p iaef co sr lv n t d tr n wheh rta f ri j tfe i e u e f u lc n rv t a tr ee a t o eemie te rnse s usiid s t rj 1 0 ( ) Th s f co sicu e mde 4 4 a. e e a tr n ld : ()t e c n e in e o te wi e ss ( )te lc to o r lva td cz ns 1 h o v ne c f h t se ; 2 h o ai n f ee n o l t n me a dt er ltv e s o a c s t s u c so pr o ;( )t ec n e e eo t e n h eaie a e f c e s o o re f o f 3 h o v ninc f h p ris () t e lc s o o eaie fcs () t a albit o p o e s t ate ; 4 h o u f p rtv a t; 5 he v i l y f r c s o a i c mp lte atn a c o u lng win se ;( )t r ltv me n o te o e h te d n e f nwil i t e s s 6 he eaie a s f h p ris ( ) a f r m' fmiirt wi t e g venn lw; () te weg t at ; 7 e o u s a laiy t h o r ig a 8 h h ih a c r e apanifsc oieo f r m; n ( )tilefce ya dteitrss c o d d li tf' h c f o u a d 9 ra fiinc n h ne e t o j tc , a e o t ett lyo t cru tn e . f usie b s d n h oai f he ic msa c s t l a 11 n. No sng ef t i dipostve, c t ha dif r d i t weghta f de t d. t 35 1. i l acor s s ii and ours ve fe e n he i for d o ea h i vi lf c or Compa eCelulr son Te h. Teec c ndi dua a t . r l a vii c & l omm s.L. v. le Cop . 508F. . P. Alt l , S p 2 1 8 1 8 ( D.Fl.2 0 ) (v laig sx fco s t NI SM Co .v.Ti u p. d 1 6, 1 9 S. a 0 7 e au tn i a t r)wih S p me W a n r l c, 0 - 2 6 4 2 0 W L 5 7 8 a * ( D. a Fe 2 ,2 0 )(v lai r e. n .No. 7 CV- 0 2 , 0 8 40 5 , t 2 S. Fl. b. 5 0 8 e au t ng s ve fco s. Ass ve a f t sose i y overa wih onea t r t sCour wilsrvet e n a tr) e r l acor tnsbl lp t nohe , hi t l ti o a yz ea h f c ori a mA nal e c a t n nnermos t l ed t t i t ntdiput t aior o he nsa s e. 1 TheConve e oft W ine s s . ni nce he t s e Ap l c ne d t a çh mao i o n n p dy win se a e lc td mu h moe pe o tn s h t t e j rt f o - a y t e s s r o ae c r c onve e l t SD Ca t n SD Fl ' M ot t Tr . a 8. Thi i l ni nty o 1 ha a.' . o ans, t s ncudeswines e c t s s onne e t ctd o çhid pat c pma r Quacomm . . .t s ir of t a cus d tc ogy t r ry hi ke t l he upple he c e e hnol I d. t ii l a l s t e of t sx i nt r of t pa e s i s t and t a tr y t t t tonaly, t ea t hr e Add he i nve o s he t nt-n- ui he to ne ha pr e e t paent i s thav r sde si SD Ca .... I os cutd he t s n ui e e i nce n l ' d. ' W iLAN poi soutt ta num be oft i nt s lve out i t S. Ca . i Te s nt ha r he nve or i sde he D. l, n xa , M a s c e t,I r e a Chi M e . n Opp. a 1 1 Fort e wines es W iLAN a gues s a hus ts sa l nd na. m i , t 3- 4. hes t s , r , Sa Digo i notmor conve e t M i mi I a 1 W iLAN alo diput st r e nc of n e s e nint han n . d. t 4. s s e he elva e t l ai ofQualomm' hea rest t sltgai I W iLAN poi so t tAppl he oc ton c s dqua tr o hi ii ton. d. nt ut ha e, notQuacomm,ma a ur t pr t,Appl ha noti iid ke Qualomm wine s l nufct es he oducs e s dentfe y c t ses l ae i S. Ca. ndt ti a ton Quac oc td n D. la ha n ddii lomm hasofiesa os t county.1 fc cr s he r d. Thi Cour ma consde t a nt ges of t ta f r e r gi a a whol a t s t y i r he dva a he r ns e e e on s e nd he a l i i no lmie t t ltr bo nayss s t i t d o he ie al unda i oft ta f r f r m . See I r TS Te h USA res he r nse ee o u n e c Co . 551F. 1 5 1 ( d.Ci.2008 (onsderng t a ia lt ofe de ne rt m, 3d 31 , 321 Fe r ) c i i he valbiiy vi nce a he ta see dsrc, o j s i t ed src isl Se as Co s-o co s S o e . n . W o c rn fre itit n t u t n h itit teg. e lo m tt - m t tr s l c v. ma kBo r. Ic,5 4 F. S p . 7 1 7 4 ( M in. 1 8 )(1 h Ar a s s v n e wo d b we s n . 9 u p 3 , 3 D. n 9 4 çT) e k n a e u ul e ( c n iea l s p ro t M in s t ...(sl h g e ts n mb ro win se i t i a to o sd r by u e ir o n e oa a lt e r ae t u e f t e s s n hs cin l r i i Ar ns s Furhe ,t e wine s swho do no lvei M i ot r i i sa e whi h esde n ka a . t r hos t s e t i n nnes a esde n tt s c ar c i r l cos rt Ar ns s...) e onsdeaby l e o ka a '. ' He e,s r ome potntalwine s i t sc s r i i Ca iom i et ri i o o sdeof e i t s es n hi a e esde n lf a, ihe nsde r ut i S. Cal A numbe of ot wines es a e dipe s d a r s t county a t word. D. . r her t s r s r e c os he r nd he l H o e r no po e i l w ines e a e l a ed i S. . F1 , t St t of Fl i , or t gr a e w ve , t nta t s s r oc t n D a. he a e or da he e t r 4 s her r on. Gi t s dipmiy,hol ng t sltg ton i Ca ior a ge r ly a i S. out n egi ven hi s t di hi ii a i n lf ni ne a l nd n D. Ca .mor s cik al woul be mor c l e pe t ly d e onve e f t wines est n hol ng t sltga i i nint or he t s ha di hi ii ton n Fl i The e or t sf c orf vor ta f ri t aci n. orda. r f e, hi a t a s r ns e rng he to 2. The Loc ton ofRel van D oc z en s ai e t tm t Appl a g t t S. Ca .t s cl e t t s m c of r e nt docz e s' M ot t e r ues ha D. l % os r o he o e i elva lm nt . ' .o Tr ns, at 7. W iLAN poi s out t t a . nt hat ç e wil pr 'ma y pr Appl l esl bl oduce is doc nt t ume s e e toni a l i t sca e, nd i wilbeno m o e bur ns l cr c ly n hi s a t l r de ome f i t do s i t c er mai i or t o o f he as e ns n Fl i ' M em.i Opp. 1 Appl c e t tû s r i t sca e wili t bl r r orda. ' n , 1. e ont nds ha i cove y n hi s l nevia y equie di t pr to ofs ce c ..and f r s trt r a ons ..s h e de mus be physcal he oduci n our ode . o ecliy e s . uc vi nce t i ly ta pore a vi we on s c a c putrt r i l . Re y,a 1 r ns td nd e d pe i l om e e m na s' pl t 0. ' l i lkey t tt bul oft doctme pr t s i l ha he k he l nt oducton wilbe elctoni . 4l a word wih i l e r c fn l t f x ma hi s c mac nes e l o m i s ppi and mobie phonest tca s a a a c ne , opy hi , mai, ve ght hi ng, l ha n c n nd s nd doc nt ,t physc l l to of doc e ume s he i a ocai n umen s i ir l va .' M ir phe i LLC v. t s re e nt' c os rx Bic mp t ls l c. s No 1 - 8 81 , 01 W L 24 7 4 a * ( D. a J n. 5 2 2 . o o ai e . n .Ca e . 1CV- 0 3 2 2 b 3 6 , t 3 S. Fl. a 2 , 01 ) ç n lghtoft bm de a pa t m ovi f ta f rbe r ,a e a s ç i l he n ry ng or r ns e a s bs nt howi by t m o ng pa t ng he vi ry t t conta y,t sCour c i r t l a i ofr l va docl t a t r ltve ea e of o he r r hi t onsde s he oc ton e e nt lmen s nd he ea i s a c s t s c ofpr a non-acon' 1 I t abs e ofmor s cii i c tons t c es o our es oof f t ' d. n he enc e pe fc ndia i hat c i r bl doc e pr ton wilt ke pl c on c putrt r na sa notelc r c l onsde a e um nt oduc i l a ae om e e mi l nd e tonialy, t l ton oft r l ntdocu e s doe not f vor et r ge a c l ton. Thi Cour he ocai he eeva m nt s a ihe ogr phi oca i s t t r f e de e m i st s f c ort be ne r . he e or t r ne hi a t o utal 3. Conve e e t t Pa tes ni nc o he r i Appl c t nds t t S. Ca .i t m or conv e f t f Appl,as Appl i e on e ha D. l s he e enint orz or m e e s he dqua tr d i Norhe n Calf ni a t e de and docz e s i t s ma tr wilbe a re e n t r ior a nd he vi nce lm nt n hi te l l aed i et rS. .Ca .orge r l i t St t ofCalf i M ot t Tr ns. a 6- Appl oc t n ihe D l ne aly n he a e iom a. . o a , t 7. e f t rco e t tt tno wine s ordoc nt ar pr s nti S. .Fl .and t tW iLAN ' urhe nt nds ha ha t s es ume s e e e n D a ha S ofie s a diecor a e l ae i Ca fc r nd r t s r oc td n nada and notFl i J. a 7. W iLAN diagee , orda. ., t 1 J s r s i ca i t t< ndi tng ha ç e' al d bur n ofltg tng i Fl i woul beequa l f tb W iLAN Appl s lege de ii a i n orda d ly el y i i we e f ce t ltga e i Ca ionza ..' M e .i Opp. a 1 Thi Cour ûndst twhie i f t r or d o ii t n lf i ..' m n , t 2. s t ha l t woul be s tntaly mor dit ul f Appl t ltgae i M i mia oppos d t Sa Digo,i d ubsa i l e fk t or e o ii t n n s e o n e t woul notbe s t ntal m or ditc tf W iLAN t ltgae i Sa Digo ms o d ubsa ily e fi ul or o ii t n n e ppos t ed o M imi W iLAN ha ve y f w r s i Fl i c pa e t Appl s sr ng r s i Caio ni a . s r e oot n orda om r d o e' to oot n lf r a. The ef e,hi f ct f vo sta f r r or t s a or a r r ns e . 4.The Loc ofOpe a i Fa t us r tve c s ç ( l ee t e o eaie fcsu d ryng t e c u e o a to dd n to cz wihn te $ W h r h p rtv a t n e li h a s f cin i o c l t i h t r f um c e by t Pli if t c ce off um i e ild t l s consde a i '' M ot ol or hos n he a ntf, he hoi or s ntte o e s i r ton.' or a M obiiv.I v.Mir of Co p. 804 F.Su 2d 1 , 1 ( D.F a 2 1 (uoig lt nc. cos t r , pp. 271 276 S. l . 0l ) q tn Wi ndme e Com .v.Remi t Pr . I . 61 F.Su 8,1 ( D. a 1 8 :. Hee Ap e r nz on odsm nc, 7 pp. 0 S. Fl. 9 5 r , pl c ends t t lhe c nt r of gr viy of t a us d a tviy i l a e i SD Ca ,whe e t ont ha t t e e a t he cc e c i t s oc t d n l r he r s a c desg m a ke i a s l sdec sonsr a e t t a cus pr t and tc ogy e e r h, i n, r tng, nd a e ii elt d o he c ed oduc s e hnol oc r e ' M ot t Tr . at9. W iLAN c e t tt r e z h,desg a de l pm e cu r d.' . o ans, ont nds ha he es a c i n nd ve o nt t pl c i Cu ri notSa Di go. M e .i Opp. a 1 W iLAN alo poi soutt tt ook a e n pe tno, n e m n , t 2. s nt ha he a c e i tu e a ii s i t s i t nce ar t Appl pr c us d nsr m nt lte n hi nsa e he e oducs nott c t, he omponen pr t , t oduc s a i i t rf eirlva t tQualomm i ba e i Sa Digo.l a 1 nd t s heeor ree nt ha c s s d n n e d. t 3. W hehe i Sa Di o orCupe tno,i i a e t tt ope ai f c sa i s i t s t r n n eg ri t s ppar nt ha he r tve a t t s ue n hi ltg i t plce ne l e ie y i Calf ni W iLAN c nnotpoi t any a tviy i t s iiaton ook a ary ntr l n ior a. a nt o c i t n hi c s t tt pl c i Fl i W hie t r i s e dit a e ha ook a e n orda. l he e s om sance bewe n N orhe n a Sout r t e t r nd he n Ca ior a, t e l ai a e muc c os r t ea h ot r t n Fl i i t a lf ni hes oc tons r h l e o c he ha orda s o nywher i e n Calf ni The e or t sf c orwe g i f vo ofta f r ior a. r f e, hi a t i hs n a r r ns e . 5.Ava l lt ofPr s iabiiy oces Appl c t ndst tt unde l ng t c ogy a is i t sma tri mmmf t r d by e on e ha he ryi e hnol t s ue n hi te s ac u e at r pa t Quac hid ry, lomm,a t tt st hnol y i i r aedi o Appl pr t. M ot t nd ha hi ec og s ncopor t nt e oducs .o Trns,a 9. f ac mm wi l l s p l t ep i r t c ia win se ta wiltsiy a a . t ç lo ou l i y u py h rma y e hnc l t e s s h t l etf t l ke til' J S. Calc n c ra. . D. . a ompelQuacomm winese t a a t t tf whieS. Fl.c no . 'Z l t s s o ppe r o esiy l D. a an t Se L- l a ton,S. Cal hass e da n ddii D. . ubpoenapowe o rt pr e i at ney a muli e r ve he oscutng tor nd tpl i ntr whieS F1 ha s nve o s l C SD a s ubpoe powe ove noneoft non- t wine s s' J .t9-0. na r r he pary t s e . #aa 1 ' W iLAN a g st tç r ue ha t e ha notpr e e a evi ncet tt wines e l atd i Appl s es nt d ny de ha he t s s oc e n Caior aa e a t ly unwilng t ta lt Fl i t t tf 'ort tt rt tmony c nnotbe lf ni r c ual li o r ve o orda o esiy' ha hei esi a o frd tr ug d po iin tsi n . Me .i Op ,a 1 - 2. E clu t g n r l ta se fee ho h e sto etmo y m n p. t 1 1 ç o rs e eal r n f r l y c s s whe i po tnt wine s c n no be compe ld t t tf i t f u ,but c d be ae n m ra t s es a t le o esiy n he or m oul s bpo e i t ta f r e c t' Comm e calSol nt Cor v. be t M u . ns. ,371F. u ena d n he r ns e e our. ' ri ve s p. Li ry t I Co. S p .2 7 2 0 ( D. Y.1 7 ) Hee S. Ca.i te prfr be v n f rt e e e cs o u p 4 , 5 S. N. 9 4 . r , D. l s h eea l e ue o h x r ie f s ubpoe powe ove t r pa t w ines e . The ef e t sf t rf vor ta f . na r r hid ry t s s r or , hi ac o a s r nser TheRe ai M e nsoft Pari l tve a he tes Bo h pa te i t si t nc a el r cor ae e ii .The e or t sf c o i ne ta . t ri s n hi nsa e r a ge por t nttes r f e,hi a t r s u r l 7.A For ' Fn la iy wih t Gove i La um s miirt t he m ng w Pa e c esa egove nedby f de allw andbo h ditit a ef m iirwih f de al t nt as r r e r a t src s r a la t e r pa e l . Thi f t i neu r . t nt aw s ac or s t al 7 8.TheW ei Ac or d Pl n if 'Choi eofFor m ght c de aitfs c u tç hepl i ifs c ce off u s d no be dit bed unl s i i cea l out g d tr antf hoi or m houl t sur e s t s l ry weihe b oh rc n ieains' Ro i o v. n mac & BilP. , 4F.d2 3 2 0( 1hCi.1 9 ) y te o sd rto .' bns n Gir r o ls C.7 3 5 , 6 1 t r 9 6 ' ( u tn Ho l v Ta n r 6 0 F.d 61 61 (t Ci.Uni B 1 81 Ho v r ls q oi g wel . n e , 5 2 0, 6 5h r t 9 :. we e , e s c i r ton i due whe t oper tve f c sdi no oc uri Pl ntf c c off u . Se onsde ai s n he ai a t d t c n ai ifs hoie or m e M as 1 F.Supp.2d a 1 on, 46 t 360. N o oft o r tve f c si t si t e oc ur e i S. ne he pe a i a t n hi nsnnc c r d n D. Fl Rahe ,t ope a i f c s occ r d i Ca io ni ,at a. t r he r tve a t ure n lf r a lhough notne es a iy i S. Ca . c s rl n D. l M ot.t Tr ,at 11. o ans. Appl as c e Fl i i no a t ly W iLAN USA' home f um . M ot t Tr ns, e lo ont nds orda s t c ua l S or .o a . a 1 11 W iLAN,t pa en c t 0- . he r t ompa of W iLAN USA,i bas d i Ca ny s e n nada a W iLAN nd - US Sç r sn ei Flrd a p ast b smpl a atfc o ltg to ' 1 .a 1 (iains A' ç e e c n o ia p e r o e i y n ria t f iiain. d t 1 ctto p ' omitd) W iLAN a t t tisde son- ki t bas is l i Fl i t i o ac ot te . dmis ha t cii ma ng o e tef n orda ook nt c mt ç e a dititc t t ta ekno e a econc r ngpa e m a tr ,pm ii t i t pae s der l src ours ha r f wl dge bl e ni t nt te s c pae n he tnt pltp o r m,a d man an a e p di d d c e c mpae t oh rjlid ci n . M e i i r ga n o iti n x e t o k t o rd o t e t s ito s' e r ' m. n Opp.a 7.W iLAN' onl Fl i e oye i apaen at ne J a 4,8.AsW iLAN USA ,t S y orda mpl e s t t tor y. Z t l ppe r t ha be c e e s ey f t pur e offlng c e i t Sout r Dititof t a s o ve en r atd ol l or he pos a ii as s n he he n src Fl rda't r i çl s t n pe s sve r s t de ta f r . o i ' he e s ses ha rua i ea on o ny r ns e W ila USA.l v. -- n , nc. Alae- c n US I .No.1 - 2 5 8 2 3W L 3 8 8 , t* ( D. a J n. 9.2 3 c tlLu e t A nc, 2 CV- 3 6 , 01 5 3 5 a 5 S. Fl. a 2 , 01 ) ( nyi t moton t ta f f l ng a c i rto of alt f t s . Gi n t s de ng he i o r nser olowi onsde ain l he acor) ve hee cic sanc s ltl wei s dbe gi n t t Pl i ifschoi off m . r um t e , ite ght houl ve o he antf ce onz 9.Tra Efi e a t I t r t ofJ tc il fcincy nd he n e ess usi e Appl c ends t t ta f r t S. Ca . i i t publc i e e t bec us of l a e ont ha r nse o D. l s n he i ntr s a e oc l con ci a l a it r s. M ot t Tr ns,a 11. M ea ne tons nd oc l n e e t .o a . t nwhie,C Fl ha ltl f cual l I SD a s ite a t 8 c onne ton t t ca ms a ns Appl o he t n t s l of a c ed pr t i t ditit' c i o he li gai t e t r ha he a e c us oduc s n he src . ' L ,a 1 W iLAN c n e d t a t u iile o o wilb b s s r e b d n i te 4 t 2. o tn s h t t d ca c n my l e e t e v d y e yng h jl M oton' be us t smia a tons a e as pe ng i t s diti t whi h çi ve t s i ' ca e wo i lr c i r lo ndi n hi src , c çnvol he nme paen sa s t nta l smia is sofi rnge nta i ldiy,a m a be c oldae t t nd ubsa ily i l r s ue nf i me nd nvai t nd y ons i td wih t s a ton. M ot i Opp. a 9. Appl poi s o i r s e t tmotons t ta f rt t hi c i ' ' .n ,t e nt ut n e pons ha i o r nse o S. Ca . D. l havebe fld i bot oft s ca esa wel. Re y,a 5.ç c us t e c e a e i en ie n h he e s s l pl t ç a e hes as s r n Be t i e ri s sag a m a a s be ta f red Fr m SD Fl t SD Cal i woul bepr maur t her a le t t es nd y l o r nse r o ao ,t d e t eo asumet tt c ess dbekep i SD Fl andc oldaed. J Bec us t ec e ha s ha he as houl tn a ons i t ' #= a e hes ass ve ' t pos i lt o beng c olda e i eiherditit t sf t i ne ta . he sbiiy f i ons i t d n t src , hi acor s u r l **+ l c n l in, e ii wh te t ta frac s iv l smo et nj t aligfco s n o cuso d cdng eh r o rnse a e n ove r ha us tlyn a tr. Thi Cour,howe r fndst tt t alt ofcr um sanc m a ta f rt mos a opra e s t ve , i ha he ot iy ic t es ke r ns e he t ppr it dee m i ton. W hie i i notpe f c l c e rt t Sa Di go i t pe f c f u t hos t s tr nai l ts re ty l a ha n e s he r e t or m o t hi ltgai i Calf ni ,i i a ii ton n ior a t s bunda l cla t ta Caiom i f u i f rm o e optm a t n a nty e r ha lf a or m s a r i l ha Fl i f u . Se Coa tt coas St es I v.W om a korda or m e s-o- t or s nc. c Bowe s l ,594 F. r . nc. supp.a 734 t ( nsdei t a t esoft tanse e r gi a awhol) l a ton,i tlsi fnc co i rng he dvanag he r fr e e on s e . n ddii n ii nsn e, ltl weght s d be gve t t Pli tf c c of f u . A ta f r t t Sout r ite i houl i n o he a n ips hoie or m r nse o he he n Ditit of Caior a woul be mor c src lf ni d e onve e f t pa te a wine s a i i t ni nt or he ri s nd t s es nd s n he itr sso j tc .Se 28U. C. 1 0 () nee t f usie e S. j 4 4 a . 11 1. Conc uson l i Bas on t f eg ng,i i ed he or oi t s i o a f r nue ORDERED AND ADJ UDGED t t De e nts Re wed M oton t Tr nse Ve ha f nda ' ne ( No 3 )i GRANTED. TheClr o Co r i drce t TRANS ECF . 9 s e k f u t s ie td o FER t i a to t te h s cin o h Un td Stt sDititCo tf t Sout r DititofCa iom i . I i f rhe ie ae src ur or he he n src lf a t s u t r ORDERED AND ADJ UDGED t tt Clr of Cour i die t d t CLOSE t sca e. ha he e k t s r ce o hi s A1 pe ng motonsa eDENI AS M OOT. 1 ndi i r ED DONEAND ORDE D i Chmb r aMimiFoiatiz d yo Api 2 1 . RE n a es t a , lrd,hs a f r,0 3 l K . I AEL M O ORE M CH UNI TED STATES DI STRI JUDGE CT c Al c ms ofr co d c: l ot el e r 1 0