Cambridge University Press et al v. Patton et al

Filing 339

NOTICE by Cambridge University Press, Oxford University Press, Inc., Sage Publications, Inc. Plaintiffs' Objections To Defendants' Deposition Designations And Counter-Designations (Rains, John)

Download PDF
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE NORTHERN DISTRICT OF GEORGIA ATLANTA DIVISION CAMBRIDGE UNIVERSITY PRESS, OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS, INC., and SAGE PUBLICATIONS, INC., Plaintiffs, Civil Action No. 1:08-CV-1425-ODE v. MARK P. BECKER, in his official capacity as Georgia State University President, et al., Defendants. PLAINTIFFS’ OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS’ DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AND COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS 879245.1 Deposition of John S. Duffield April 14, 2011 PLAINTIFFS’ DESIGNATIONS (PAGE: LINE) 4:16-22 8:19-9:3 14:20-15:14 21:12-22:1 22:11-23:11 23:14-24:18 25:5-15 28:22-29:4 29:14-19 31:10-20 32:1-9 34:18-35:2 35:16-36:6 36:16-37:11 38:14-41:3 41:7-42:20 43:4-8 44:12-19 45:1-17 46:2-48:13 50:17-52:9 54:15-24 55:8-14 55:23-57:7 58:9-21 59:12-60:18 61:6-25 62:3-64:11 64:25-66:22 67:10-69:1 69:4-23 GSU COUNTERDESIGNATIONS (PAGE: LINE) 9:4-11; 10:8-13 15:15-21; 15:24-16:2 & 17:22-18:4 25:17-21 & 26:4-19 29:5-13 32:18-20; 33:4-7 & 33:1323 35:3-10 48:15-19 (if objection overruled); 49:3-17 & 50:216 52:21-54:14 59:1-4 66:23-67:9 879245.1 2 PLAINTIFFS’ OBJECTIONS PLAINTIFFS’ DESIGNATIONS (PAGE: LINE) 70:8-72:17 72:22-73:24 75:20-23 76:2-6 81:1-8 GSU COUNTERDESIGNATIONS (PAGE: LINE) 76:8-77:7 & 78:9-80:17 879245.1 3 PLAINTIFFS’ OBJECTIONS Leading Questions 30(b)(6) Deposition of Copyright Clearance Center (Debra Mariniello) June 30, 2009 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Objection Page 4, lines 5-8 Page 8, line 22 – Page 9, line 4 Relevance Page 9, lines 20-22 Relevance Page 10, line 8-10; lines 1316 Relevance Page 11, line 7 – Page 12, line 5 Relevance Page 13, lines 19-24 Page 14, lines 1-3 Page 14, lines 10-15 Page 15, lines 2-19 Page 15, line 20 – Page 16, line 5 Page 16, lines 9-18 Page 16, line 19 – Page 17, line 14 Page 17, lines 15-22 Page 18, lines 3-11 Page 20, line 23 – Page 21, line 16 Page 21, line 17 – Page 22, line 16 879245.1 4 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Objection Page 22, line 17 – Page 23, line 1-8 Page 23, line 18 – Page 24, line 13 Page 24, line 18 – Page 25, line 4 Page 25, lines 14-23 Page 25, line 25 – Page 26, line 14 Page 26, lines 15-17 Page 26, line 18 – Page 27, line 3 Page 28, line 2-12 Page 28, line 24 – Page 29, line 4 Page 29, lines 8-9 Page 31, lines 4-15 Page 31, line 19 – 32, line 11 Page 32, line 14-21 Page 33, lines 1-5 Page 35, lines 3-10 Relevance Page 35, line 18 – Page 36, line 5 Relevance Page 37, lines 10-24 Page 38, lines 1-17 879245.1 5 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Objection Page 39, lines 1-4 Page 39, lines 15-21 Page 40, line 3 – Page 41, line 1 Page 41, lines 2 - 18 Page 41, lines 19-21 Page 44, lines 6-23 Page 44, line 24 – Page 45, line 11 Page 45, line 16 – Page 46, line 2 Page 47, lines 16-24 Relevance Page 48, lines 8-24 – Pages 49 – 50, lines 1-13 Page 49, line 12 – Page 50, line 13 Page 51, lines 21-22 Page 52, lines 1-6 Page 52, line 22 – Page 53, line 7 Page 53, line 8-10 Page 53, line 11 – Page 54, line 9 Page 55, lines 20-24 Page 56, lines 1-8 879245.1 6 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Page 60, lines 13-24 Objection Hearsay Page 61, lines 1-11 Page 63, line 1 – Page 66, line 15 Page 66, lines 16-24 Page 67, line 5 – Page 70, line 13 Page 67, lines 1-4 Page 70, line 14 – Page 71, line 7 Page 71, line 8 – Page 74, line 2 Page 74, lines 3-16 Page 76, lines 16-20 Page 76, line 21 – Page 77, line 18 Page 78, lines 14-15 Page 78, line 23 – Page 79, line 24 Page 84, lines 12-24 – Page 85, lines 1-24 – Page 86, line 1-7 Page 86, lines 8-14 Page 87, lines 14-21 Page 88, lines 5-23 Page 89, line 18 – Page 90, line 3 879245.1 7 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Page 90, line 14 – Page 91, line 14 Page 91, lines 15-24 Page 92, lines 5-6 Page 92, lines 13-19 Page 92, line 20 – Page 93, line 11 Page 93, line 12 – Page 94, line 16 Page 94, line 17 – Page 96, line 7 Page 96, line 15 – Page 97, line 8 Page 97, line 9-12 Page 97, line 24 – Page 98, line 7 Page 99, line 6 – 106, line 18 Page 107, line 14 – Page 108, line 7 Page 108, line 24 – Page 109, line 16 Page 109, line 17-21 Page 112, line 19 – Page 113, line 14 Page 114, line 2 – Page 118, line 3 Page 118, lines 4-6 879245.1 8 Objection Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Page 119, lines 2-3 Page 119, line 4 – Page 121, line 14 Page 121, line 15 – Page 122, line 5 Page 112, lines 6-23 Page 122, line 24 – Page 123, line 7 Page 123, line 8 – Page 125, line 10 Page 125, lines 11-24 – Page 126, lines 1-24 – Page 127, line 1-5 Page 127, line 8 – Page 129, line 11 Page 129, lines 12-21 Page 129, line 222 – Page 132, line 24 Page 133, lines 1-18 Page 133, line 19 – Page 135, line 20 Page 135, line 21 – Page 136, line 5 Page 136, line 6 – Page 138, line 17 Page 138, lines 18-19 Page 138, line 23 – Page 879245.1 9 Objection Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation 139, line 13 Page 139, line 14 – Page 141, line 1 Page 141, lines 2-18 Page 141, line 23 – Page 143, line 4 Page 143, lines 5-14 Page 153, line 11 – Page 154, line 10 Page 153, lines 5-10 Page 154, lines 11-22 Page 154, line 23 – Page 155, line 11 Page 155, line 12 – Page 156, line 2 Page 159, line 11-21 Page 159:22 – Page 161, line 12 Page 162, line 1 – Page 163, line 7 Page 163, lines 8-9 Page 163, line 13 – Page 167, line 11 Page 167, line 12 – Page 168, line 8 Page 168, line 9 – Page 169, line 14 879245.1 10 Objection Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Objection Page 169, lines 15-17 Page 169, lines 18-24 Page 170, lines 1-15 Page 172 – Page 173 – Page 174, lines 1-12 Page 174, lines 23-24 – Page 175, lines 1-11 Page 175, line 12 – Page 177, line 2 Page 177, line 3 – Page 178, line 5 Page 178, lines 6-12 Page 178, line 13 – Page 179, line 9 Page 183, line 22-24 – Pages 184 - 187 Hearsay (Exhibit 14A) Page 188, lines 1-7 Page 188, lines 8-16 Page 188, lines 17-21 Page 188, lines 22-24 – Pages 189-203 – Page 204, lines 1-2 Page 204, lines 6-13 Page 204, line 17 – Page 205, line 4 Page 205, line 13 – Page 206, line 879245.1 11 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation 15 Page 206, line 16 – Page 207, line 6 Page 207, lines 10-24 – Pages 208, 209 – 210, lines 1-13 Page 210, line 14 – Page 211, line 5 Page 211, line 6 – Page 213 Page 214, lines 1-5 Page 214, line 13 – Page 215, line 21 Page 215, lines 22 – Page 216, line 9 Page 216, line 10 – Page 217, line 3 Page 217, line 4 879245.1 12 Objection 30(b)(6) Deposition of SAGE Publications (Sara Van Valkenburg) June 29, 2009 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Objection Page 4, lines 12-13 Page 4, line 14 Page 6, line 24 – Page 7, line 15 Relevance Page 7, lines 16-24 Page 8, line 1 Page 8, lines 7-17 Page 8, line 24 – Page 11, line 2 Page 11, lines 19-21 Page 12, line 9 – Page 13, line 2 Page 15, line 13 – Page, line 19 Page 15, line 24 – Page 16, line 11 Page 17, lines 2-13 Page 18, lines 4-16 Page 18, line 22 – Page 19, line 1 Page 19, line 5 – Page 20, line 19 Page 30, line 12 – Page 31, line 21 Page 34, line 16 – Page 35, line 16 Page 42, line 3 – Page 43, line 2 879245.1 13 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Page 44, lines 4-17 Page 46, line 9 – Page 47, line 12 Page 47, line 13 – Page 48, line 9 Page 48, line 16 – Page 49, line 5 Page 49, lines 6–9 Page 49, lines 10-19 Page 49, lines 20-24 Page 50, lines 1-2 Page 50, lines3-12 Page 51, line 5 – Page 53, line 5 Page 55, line 17 – Page 56, line 14 Page 57, lines 4-10 Page 57, lines 11-19 Page 58, line 17 – Page 59, line 15 Page 59, lines 10-23 Page 59, line 24 – Page 60, line 17 Page 60, line 18 – Page 61, line 11 879245.1 14 Objection Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Page 61, line 19 – Page 63, line 4 Page 63, lines 5-8 Page 63, line 18 – Page 64, line 19 Page 64, lines 20-24 Page 65, line 1 – Page 66, line 1 Page 68, lines 2-5 Page 68, lines 6-16 Page 68, line 17 – Page 70, line 4 Page 77, lines 3-21 Page 79, lines 1-17 Page 91, line 17-Page 92, line 15 Page 92, lines 16-20 Page 92, line 21 – Page 93, line 21 Page 96, line 12 – Page 98, line 7 Page 100, line 12 – Page 101, line 7 Page 122, lines 12 - 23 Page 127, lines 9-15 Page 131, line 8 – Page 132, line 6 879245.1 15 Objection Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Page 134, lines 1-13 Page 135, lines 11-18 Page 146, lines 3-14 Page 147, lines 1-8 Page 148, lines 6-24 Page 149, lines 1-4 Page 165, lines 5-22 879245.1 16 Objection 30(b)(6) Deposition of Oxford University Press, Inc. (John Challice) June 12, 2009 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Objection Page 4, lines 10-12 Page 6, lines 3-23 Relevance Page 17, line 25 – Page 18, line 12 Page 20, line 23 – Page 21, line 16 Page 21, line 25 – Page 23, line 4 Page 23, lines 5-18 Page 23, lines 21-23 Page 31, line 20 – Page 33, line 13 Page 34, line 21 – Page 36, line 20 Page 41, line 5 – Page 42, line 9 Page 44, lines 10-22 Page 45, lines 7-23 Page 51, lines 2-21 Page 57, line 13 – Page 58, line 3 Page 72, line 18 – Page 73, line 11 Page 84, line 7 – Page 86, line 6 Page 113, line 20 – Page 115, line 15 879245.1 17 Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Page 115, line 22 – Page 116, line 17 Page 141, line 5 – Page 142, line 14 Page 142, line 23 – Page 144, line 9 Page 147, lines 4-21 Page 163, line 12 – Page 164, line 16 Page 164, line 17 – Page 168, line 18 Page 195, line 2 – Page 196, line 7 Page 198, lines 7-10 Page 198, line 18 – Page 199, line 14 Page 199, line 22 – Page 200, line 8 Page 211, line 20 – Page 212, line 10 Page 212, lines 17-22 Page 252, line 22 – Page 254, line 16 Page 255, line 10 – Page 256, line 10 Page 276, line 19 – Page 277, line 25 879245.1 18 Objection Defendants’ Designation Plaintiffs’ Counter-Designation Objection Page 285 line 3 – Page 287, line 14 Page 288, line 4 – Page 289, line 21 Respectfully submitted this 17th day of May, 2011. /s/ John H. Rains IV Edward B. Krugman krugman@bmelaw.com Georgia Bar No. 429927 John H. Rains IV rains@bmelaw.com Georgia Bar No. 556052 BONDURANT, MIXSON & ELMORE, LLP 1201 West Peachtree Street NW Suite 3900 Atlanta, Georgia 30309 Telephone: (404) 881-4100 Facsimile: (404) 881-4111 879245.1 19 R. Bruce Rich (pro hac vice) Randi Singer (pro hac vice) Jonathan Bloom (pro hac vice) Todd D. Larson (pro hac vice) WEIL, GOTSHAL & MANGES LLP 767 Fifth Avenue New York, New York 10153 Telephone: (212) 310-8000 Facsimile: (212) 310-8007 Attorneys for Plaintiffs 879245.1 20 CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have this day filed the foregoing PLAINTIFFS’ OBJECTIONS TO DEFENDANTS’ DEPOSITION DESIGNATIONS AND COUNTER-DESIGNATIONS with the Clerk of Court using the CM/ECF filing system which will send e-mail notification of such filing to opposing counsel as follows: Stephen M. Schaetzel, Esq. Natasha H. Moffitt, Esq. John W. Harbin, Esq. Kristen A. Swift, Esq. C. Suzanne Johnson, Esq. Mary Katherine Bates, Esq. KING & SPALDING 1180 Peachtree Street Atlanta, Georgia 30309 Katrina M. Quicker, Esq. Richard W. Miller, Esq. BALLARD SPAHR, LLP 999 Peachtree Street, Suite 1000 Atlanta, Georgia 30309 Anthony B. Askew, Esq. McKeon, Meunier, Carlin & Curfman, LLC 817 W. Peachtree Street, Suite 900 Atlanta, Georgia 30308 Mary Jo Volkert, Esq. Assistant S. Attorney General 40 Capitol Square Atlanta, Georgia 30334 879245.1 21 This 17th day of May, 2011. /s/ John H. Rains IV John H. Rains IV Georgia Bar No. 556052 879245.1 22