Hamrick et al v. REO Properties Corporations et al

Filing 34

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that P's 3 Motion to Remand is DENIED. Signed by Judge Robert C. Jones on 7/15/2010. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - PM)

Download PDF
1 2 3 4 jjt 1j ky g j 5 6 UNI E D STATES D I T R I T CO U RT T S C 7 8 D I T R I T O F NEVA DA SC 9 LEW I L.HAMRI K andTONIM.DAVI , ) S C S ) plitf, an if ) REO PROPERTI S CORP,and FI ELIY) E DT ) 3:9- V- 071 - CJ-RAM) O C 0 4R ( 1V 0. 11 l 4 15 16 17 18 19 Hamrick et al v. REO Properties Corporations et al ) ) ) ) y ORDER 1 NTO A T L ISendNt.C . 2 AINL I ENUAaC O, T DefR nE 1 3 Thi i a di put i vol i g f r c osur . Pl i t f Lewi L.Ham rck and ToniM .Davi ss s e n vn o e l e a nis f s i s (plit f' s ed Deen ans Fi ei Nai n l t Is r n e Cor o a in (Fiei ' a d d a n is' u ' f) f d t d ly t a Til n u a c t o e p r t ' d ly' n o f t) REO Pr perisCor orton(' EO' (ol ctvel ' ef ndant' i stt cour andasked te o te p ai ' ' c l i y D e R)e s' n a e ) t h cour t cancelhetust e' deedandawar damagesi excessof$20,00. Subsequenty, to t r es d n 01 l Doc. 34 20 Def ndantFiely r moved t e cas t t i Cour. (/ ) Pr senty bef r t e Cour i e di e t h e o hs t /1 . e l o e h ts Plitf' Motont Remand(/ ) Bot Deendant oppos dt emotont r mand( 11./ 4) an i s i o f /3 . h f s eh i oe # ,1 / 22 andPlitfr pl d.(/ 5) TheCourhear or l gumentonJune11, a n i e i /1 . fe t d a ar 2010.I I HEREBY TS 2l 23 24 25 O RDERED t atPlitf' Motont Remand (/ )i DENI D. h a nif s io /3 s E 26 28 l ai tfsar r si ent ofand domiied i Ney da Def ndantFi elt i a Calf r i pl n if e e d s cl n a e d iy s i na o . 27 cor or ton. Def ndantREO i a Del w ar c r or ton. p ai e s a e o p al j Dockets.Justia.com 1 1 BACKGROUND . 2 Pl i t#s l ed i t ei hom e f rffeen year . W hen Pl i tfs'i com e decr ased, ani i v nh r oi t s a n if n e 3 Pl i tfs atem pt d t m odiy t ei hom e l ans butcoul notm ake m orgage paym ent on a n if t eo fhr o d t s 4 tm e. Pl i t f alege Def ndant m ade f l e and m i l adi g st t m ent wih r gar t t ei i an is l f e s as se n a e s t e doh r 5 m od gage and Pl i tfs wer t l ' ver t i g woul be wor ed out' Pl i t#s fl d t ei a n if e od ' y hn e d k . a n i ie h r 6 c mplitoquittteonJul 22, o a n t e il y 2009 and adef uljdgmentwasent r dagais Fiely a tu ee nt d i t 7 i t e Nevada st t c ur f rSt r yCount onAugust28, nh a e o to o e y 2009. Nonet elss, Sept m ber h e on e 8 15, 2009,Fi elt r cor ed a tust e' deed upon s l , d iy e d r es a e nami g REO ast e gr nt e. Fi al , n h ae nl y 9 on O ct ber22,2009,R EO m ai d a Notc t V acat Pr pery t Pl i t f . o l e ie o e o t o ani s f 1 0 Pl i tfs alege t atDef ndant il gal r cor ed a tust e' deed upon sal and t at a n if l h e sl e le d y r es e h 11 Def ndant i pr pery f r cl sed t ei r si enc .Pl i tfs' pl i ti cl dest r e c ai s, e sm o l oe o h r e d e a n if com a n n u he l m 1 i c udi g sl nderoftte,cancel ton ofa t us ee' deed,and ator ey 'f es. Addii nal , 2 nl n a il li a rt s tn se to l y 1 Pl i tfs ask d t e s at cour t awar gener ldamages i excess of$20, 00 as wel as 3 a n if e h te to d a n 0 l 1 punii e dam ages. 4 tv 1 5 Afer Pl i tfs fl d t ei com pl i t Def ndant Fi el y fl d a notce of r m ovalon t a n if ie h r an , e d i ie t i e 1 Decem ber 7,2009. Fi el y cl i ed t e U , .Di ti t C our f r t e Di ti tof Nevada has 6 d i am t h S s rc to h s rc 1 orgialursditonoverte casebecauset er i complt dier iyo ciienshi bet een 7 i n j i ci h h es ee v st f tz pw 1 t e pari s and t e pr pery i curen l val ed at $1 8, 00, whi h sats i s t e 8h te h o ts r ty u 20 c ife h 1 amounti - ontover y r quiem entf rr m oval l addii n,Fi elt ar ues t atPl i tfs' 9 -n c r s e r op .n to d iy g l n a n if 20 demandf rc m pens t r damages, tvedamages, a or ey 'eesexc eds$75,O0. oo ao y punii and Q n s f e O 21 Pl i tfs fl d a moton t r m and ar uig Fi el y di notmeetis bur en t pr ve t att e a n if i e i oe gn di d t t d oo hh 22 amounti c ntover y exceeds $75, 00. Def ndant Fi ely and REO bot opposed t e nor s 0 e s di t h h 23 m oton t r m and. i oe 24 I. LeoAu ST NDARD I A 2 5 Remov li an ide en en b ss f riv kn f d r lurs it n. Gen r l ,t e a s n p d t a i o n o ig e e a j idci o eal h y 2 def ndantcanivok f der lemovalursditonīt ecase c ul have beenfld orgialy 6 e n e e ar j i ci f h od i e in l 27 28 2 1 i f d r l ou t 28 U. . . 1 41 a . Th d f n a tc n r mo ea c s i 1 t e p dis n e e a c r. S C j 4 ( )2 e e e d n a e v a e f ) h a e : 2 ar ofdier eciienshi'and2)t eamounti contover y, usieofit r st andc st, e v s tz p, h n r s excl v ne e s os 3 exceeds$75,00. 28.U. . . 1332( ) 0 SC j a. 4 The def ndantseekng r m ovalal ays bear t e bur en ofes abl hig gr undsf r e ie w sh d t in o s o 5 f der lj rsditon. Calor i exr lLock erv.Dyner y,Ic. 375 F.d 831,838 ( t Ci. e a u i ci i na e. y f g n, 3 9h r 6 2004) Ther moval endantmayest blsht atheamountnc ntover yexc eds$75,00 . e def ai ht ior s e 0 7 byeiher1)demonstatngtatii 'acil appar nt'r m tecomplittattecli slk l t r i h ts ' al fy e 'o h f an h h am ie y 8 exceed$75,00* 2)setigf rhf csi t enotceofr movalhatsuppor afndig oft e 0, or tn o t a t n h i e t lin h 9 r quiieamount SigerB. af Far MutAut .ns.Co.116 F.d373, ( t Ci.1 97) e st .n Sl e m . ol , 3 377 9 h r 9 . , 1 Mccaa v Mas . .Lie Is.Co.330 F. 0 . s Mut f n , Supp. 1143,1145( .Nev, 2d D 2004) Mostc uds . o 1 hol t e r m oval endantm us pr ve by a pr ponder nc oft e evi enc t att e am ount 1 dh e def to e ae h d eh h 1 i contovery exc eds te j rs itonalr quiementatt e tme ofr mov l Sanchez k. 2n rs e h u id ci er hi e a. ' 1 Monum ent lLi I s.Co. 1O2 F.d 398,4O4 (t Ci.1996) McNut F,Gener /Motr 3 a fn e , 3 9h r , . t a os 1 Ac eptnce Cor .298 U. .178,189 ( 936) see alo Shaw l Dow Br nds,I c.994 F.d 4 ca pt S 1. , s ? , a n, 2 1 364, n. ( t Ci.1993)( oligt atter moval t ndar i metiadef ndant s ow 5 366 2 7 h r h dn h h e sa d s fe can h 1 ' r asonabl pr babiiy'hatheamountncontoveryexceedst ej rsditonal ni um ) 6 'e a e o l 't t t i rs h u i ci mi m . 17 11 ANALYSI 1. S 1 8 Her , tesdonotc nt s t edier iyof tzenshi.Thus,her lv ntursditonal e pari o e th v st cii p t e e a j i ci 1 queston i whet er t e am ount i - ontover y r quiem ent has been m et Pl i tfs ar 9 is hh -n c r s e r . a n if e 20 seeki g $20, 00 i com pens t r damages i addii n t punii e damages and ator eys' n 0n aoy n to o tv tn 21 f es. Sice i i notdacily appar nt t atte amounti c ntover y exceeds $75,00, e n ts ' al f e 'h h nor s 0 22 Def ndant bear t e bur en of sh w i g t at i i m or lkel t an not t e am ount i e s h d o n h ts eiyh h n 23 conr verysatsistej rs itonalmii um .Sanchez,102 F.d at404. to s ife h u id ci nm 3 24 W her t ecompl its eksdeclr t r orij nctve r le ,te valeoft e ' ateri eh an e a ao y nu i e if h u hmt n 25 c ntover y' texceed$75,00.28 U. . . 1 32( ) It epl itf seek declr t r or o r s 'mus 0 S C j 3 a . f h a nif s a ao y 26 27 ecton 1 41( )st t st at anyciiactonbr ughti a St t c ur ofwhiht e i 4 a ae h vl i o n ae o t ch 28 dititcoursofte Unied Stt shaveorgialursditon,mayber moved byte src th t ae i n j i ci e h def ndant .u! o t e di titc ur oft e Unied St t s f rany diti t... e t h s rc o t h t ae o s rc wher such e acton i pendi g. is n' ' 3 zS u l ij ncie r l f t e amounti c ntover y i meas r d by dhe vale ofte obec oft e nu tv ei , h e nor s s ue ' t u h jt h 2 Iia in. Hu tv Na h. at Ap l Adv riig Co m b, 2 U. . 33, 47 ( 97 ) s e ig t ' n . s St e p e e t n t o' s m 43 S 3 3 1 7 , e . 3 aloMcNut, U. . 181(idigt evaleoft eobj c wasmeasur dbyt e Is est at s t298 S at fn n h u h e t e h os h 4 woul f low it e satt i quesinwer enor ed) d o l f h t ue n to e fc . 5 Her ,t e obectoft e Itgaton i t e f r clsed pr pedy,and t e pr pedy' vale eh j h ii i s h o e o o ho su 6 exc edss7sj oo.Appar nty, ai tfst emselesadmi edt e pr pery i w orh$128, 00, e o e l Pl n if h v t h o ts t t 03 7 Bec use t evale ofPlitfs'homeexceededt ej rs itonalr quiementatt e tme of a h u an if h u id ci er hi 8 r movalte amounti conr veryf rdier i j rsditon i met e ,h n to s o v st u i ci s . y 9 Addiinal ,hej rsditonalmii um i dier i c sesi det r iedbyt eamount to l t u i ci y nm n v st a s e m n y h 1 atsak t eiherpary.BEM (LLC.v. hr polgi,I c.301F.d 5 8,553( t Ci.2002) 0 t eo t t Ant o o e n , 34 7h r 1 ( olig t at'hejrsditonalmii um i dier iycases i nott & amountsoughtbyt e 1 b d n h ' u i ci t nm n v st s h h 1 pl it; butt e amountatsaket eiherparyt te sui'. l ot erwor s,t e amounti 2 an i h t ot l oh t) n h ' dh n 13 cont over y i satsfed w hen eiher pl i tf ' gai or def ndants l ss exceeds t e r ss ii t a n ifs n e 'o h 1 j r dit n l mou t I r Fo dMotrCo.ciba k 2 4F.d9 2, 8( t Ci, 01 (idig 4 ui ci a a n. n e r so o / t n , 6 3 5 95 9h r20 ) f n i n 1 t at' he am ount i contover y r quiem enti s ts i d i eiherpary can gai or I se t e 5h' t n r ser s a i fe f t t n oh 1 jrsditonalamount) 6 u i ci '. 1 7 Her ,Pl i tfs ar aski g t e cour t canc l deed oftustand gr nt hem equiabl e a n if e nh to ea r at te 1 r l fagai s Def ndant .It etust e' deed wer canc l d, he pot ntal nf rPl i tfs 8 ei e nt e s fh r e s e ee t e i gai o a n if 1 woul bet eownerhi andenoymen oftepr pery, chi worh$128,00atmii um . 9 dh sp j t h o t whi s t 0 nm 20 Mor over REO cai ed ipai $130, 00t acquie i t r s i t ef r cl s dpr pedy.I REO e , lm t d 0o r n e e tn h o e o e o f 21 wer t f rei is i t r sti t e f r cl sed pr pery, REO w oul sufer a I ss of at I ast e o o f t t nee n h o e o ot d f o e 22 $130,00, ch i abov t ejrsditonalmi i um . 0 whi s e h u i ci nm 2 3 Pl i tfs r l on Gugl l i o $.M cl'e Foods Cor .and cl i t atDef ndant have a n if e y im n / e k e p am h e s 2 not m et t ei heavy bur en t oppose r m and, Pl i tfs asser t at t avoi r m and, 4 hr d o e a n if th o de 25 Def ndant m us pr ve t a I gal t i t t atoppos ng c unsel sf l el assessi g t e c se e s t o o e cera n y h io i as y nha 26 :7 3Event ough Fi ely' opposii n t Pl i tf s moton t r m and st t st atPl i tfs h d is t to o a n ir i oe ae h a n if' com ql i ti cl ded an exhi ishowi qt eval eofpr pery t be $128, 00, he Cour di not an n u bt nh u o to 0t td 28 r c le any exhi i showi g Pl i t s' aial t e pr pedy vql e. However Pl itfsdo e ev bt n a n i appr s of h o g u , a n if not sput t at he pr peryval eexc eds$75, 00.I st ad,Pl l t#sar ue t atDef ndant di e h t o t u ē 0 ne an i g h e s have notm et hei bur en t pr ve Pl l tfs ar f l el assessi g t e am ounti contover y. tr d oo a n if e a s y nh n rs 4 1 oric m pet ntydoig so.Gugl l io t.Mc/eeFoodsCor .506 F.d 696,699 ( t Ci, no el n imn / f e p, 3 9h r 2 2007) However Plitfs' gumentoverook t e Gugl l io cour' holig t ata Igal . , an if ar l sh imn e ts d n h e 3 cerai t t stappl s onl when a orgi al om pl i t i d i a s at coud sufi i nty st t s t e t ny e i e y in c a n fl n t e e fc e l a e h 4 j rsditonalmii um ,/ ,The Gugl l iocour hel t atwhen te amounti contovery u i ci nm d im n e t dh h nrs 5 i ambi uousfom t e compl i t t e def ndantm u tpr vi e evi ence est blshi g t ati i s g rh a n, h e s od d a i n h ts 6 ' or Ikel t an not'hatt e amounti contover y exceeds $75, 00. I . see alo Val ez ' ei yh m 't h n rs 0 d' , s d 7 y. ltt I s.Co.372 F.d 1115,1117 (t Ci.2004)( olig t att e pr ponder nce of 'Alsae n , 3 9h r h dn h h e a 8 t e evi enc st ndar appl s w hen t e am ounti contover y i notf ci l appar ntfom h d ea d i e h n r ss a al y er 9 t e c m plit;see a/o McNut, U. .at189. h o an l s t298 S 1 0 Her ,Def ndant have shown t att e val e of pr pery Ik l exceeds $75,00. e e s hh u o t ie y 0 ll Plitfsdo notdiput t i showig.Sic Def ndant hav esabl hed tej rsditonal a n if s e hs n ne e s eti s h u i ci 1 m i i um by a pr ponder nce oft e evi ence,Def ndant have m ett ei bur en t oppose 2 nm e a h d e s hr d o 13 r m and . e 1 4 I . CoNcuusl N V o 1 5 1 6 Accor igl,I I ORDERED tatPlitf' Motont Remand ( 3)i DENI D. dn y T S h an if s io #s E I I SO O R D ER ED . TS 1 7 18 l9 Dat d: hi 15t day ofJul ,201 . e ts h y 0 2 0 21 22 . O B ER T C.. ES U n t d St t u s rc J d e ie a t ti t u g 23 24 25 26 27 28 5

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets were retrieved from PACER, and should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.