Adamson et al v. United States of America, Departmment of the Interior through its Bureau of Reclamation

Filing 121

ORDER GRANTING 97 Motion for Determination of Good Faith Settlement re: 119 Proposed Order Submission. Signed by Magistrate Judge Robert A. McQuaid, Jr on 8/4/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - MLC)

Download PDF
i ase 3: cv09- OO715LDG RAM Document119 Fi 08/ 11 Page 1 of5 l ed 03/ 1J OAN C W RI GHT,ESQ. Ne a aitt Ba xo 1 4 v d ae r . 0 2 2 CHRI MACKENZW1ES S 00 6Q. N 3 ALLlaStt Ba No e a ae r kœ vd sox , M a tEx cl pAvn ts, GHTâ FAGAN, xll wRI LTD. -- FIED L --- EFRD NEE - 4 40 N , i s on St e t 2 D vi i re ' h$ , ' P. Bo 6 6 O. x 4 Tee ? ( )687- 02 Iph(ne:775 02 gt j j g j . s gj j ' o 5 Ca s Ciy, V 8 02 ron t N 97 6 Fcl l:75 827 1 E sml (7) 8-98 a e 7 --- Rcjo ' 5:y ' jwa o s : custgè g aon oNEm yao a a - E alIlct)lsnsonnpni. lcon) m ! c a ez @alr kackenzl ma:wrhrqlolpcez cn 1 niknli ia e o g t. ' ie e. CE#la lj cuy tRt sjé na s l p *Y ' - . 8 At t ' DTl G''.j . lRr byi, s c 'Tr urT ey j.q y -.'yJ--. -u a ., pro ; : 2- o, '' !q , . or ys f Crs D eve opm e ,l ne or i p l nt nc. a Be l G .Cr s nd r e ip . . w r : . y'' r J! ' . 9 1 0 l1 I TH E U NI N TED STA TES D I STRI COU RT CT 1 2 FOR THE D I STRI O F N EV AD A CT 1 3 l 4 1 5 1 6 cas N o. 3: c 246e 08- v- LDG - AM R J DY KR osl s,e a . U du t I, Pl ntf s ai if , VS . O R OER G RA N TI G N M O TI N FO R D ETERM I A TI N O N O OF G O op FAI j SETTLEM ENT TI UNI TED STATES 0F AM ERI CA, 1 7 eta1) . 1 8 Dee f ndant . s / 1 9 A tl A U HO U SE,e al, t . - cl 20 Ca eN o.3: c 028 LD G s 08- v- 5RAM pl ntf s, ai i f 21 vs. 22 ORDER GM NTI NG M O TI N FO R D ETER M I A TI N O N O O F G O O D FAI SE TTLEM EN T TH UNI TED STATES DEPA RTM EN T 0 F THE I NTERI R,e a . O t l, 23 D ef da s en nt . 2 4 25 / . 26 27 28 :cwmlcls e .omwp u l tp so o 1 . ase 3: c O0715O9- vLDG RAM Document119 Fi 08/ 11 Page 2 of5 l ed 03/ . I BI ADAM SON,e a . LL t I, 2 3 VS . 4 Ca eNo.3: g- v (62juoos 0 c ) RAv . Pl ntfs ai if , ORDER G RANTI NG M O T I N FO R D ETER M I ATI N O N O O F G O O D FA I H SE TTLEM EN T T UNI TED STATES 0 F A M ERI CA , 5 6 7 Def (a , en j nt / LA RRY J. M O OR E,e a . t l, 8 9 1 0 . Ca e N o.3: c 0l LD G s 09- v- 67RAM pl ntf s ai i f , O R D ER G R A N TI G N M O TI N FO R D ETERM NA TI N O O O F G O O I FA I H SETTLEM EN T ) T vs. UNI TED STATES OF AM ERI , CA l1 Def endant . / l 2 J M ES A D G ETT,e aI, A t . Ca e N o.3: c 06 LD G s 09- v- 49RAM j3 . Pl ntf s, ai i f ' 1 4 URDER G RAN TI NG vs . M O TI N FO R D ETER M I ATI N O N O O F G O O D FA I H SE TTLEM EN T T 15 UNI TED STATES 0F A M ERI , CA l 6 D ef nda . e nt . l7 l 8 BI ADAM SON,e a . LL t l, 1 9 2 0 / Ca eN o.3: c 071 LDGs 09- v- SRAM Pl ntf s ai i f , ORDER GR ANTI NG M O TI N FO R D ETERM I TI N O NA O O F G O O D FA I SETTLEM EN T TH vs . 21 U N I TED STATES OF AM ERI , CA 22 D ef endant . / 23 ' J M ES A M ES e al, A , t . 24 Ca eN o.3: 0- vs 1 c 0463- G - v LD Rx Pl ntf s ai i f , 25 ORDER GR ANTI NG M OTI FO R DETERM I ON NATI ON OF G OOD FAI SETTLEM ENT TH vs . 26 27 28 UNI TED STATES O F AM ERI , CA D ef da . en nt ' JcwmlcRs a. twp u l psoolq o / 2 . ase 3: cvO9- 00715LDG RAM Document119 Fi 08/ 11 Page 3 of5 l ed 03/ . I ORDER G RANTI NG M OTI N FO R GOOD FAI SETTLEM ENT DETERM I O TH NATI ON 2 3 Bas o M oton m ade by Spe a l A ppe i Pa te ,CRI D EVELOPM EN T, ed n i ci ly arng r i s SP 4 I (t ' a BERLE G.CRI P,idvd l IBEl.E' (ol ciey Q I P' , a d NC. t ' nd CDl) S n iiual ' k ' c l tv l S S ' by n y Q L I e CR- I 5 tr h ougb t i a t ne ,ALLI he r tor ys SON , aC M KEN ZI PAV LAK I W RI HT & FA GAN , E, S, G LTD .upon , 6 t pape sa pl di on fl i t sm a tr a t he rng hed t e t Cour now e e s he r nd ea ngs ie n hi te , nd he a i l her on, he t nt r 7 isfndi offct,c l i oflw a dj t i ngs a s oncusons a n udgme a f l : nt s olows 8 1. Thi ca ea ie fom abr a h oft Tr ke Ca i Lyo Cou y, va s s rs s r ec he uc e naln n nt Ne da 9 on J nuar 5,2008. a y 1 0 2. A Com pl ntf D a a w a fl a i tn e ous de en s ai or m ges s ied ga ns um r f dant . 11 3. Pl i tf s a e ow ne s ofr s de i lpr ry s m a e i Fe nl y, eva a n if r r e i nta ope t i t d n r e N da. 1 2 4. A Com pl nt f D am a s was alo f l d a ns BERLE on ale eg ai or ge s ie gai t tr o 5. Pl ntfs cl i t tt s f r da a s r s tng f om t foo wat r ai if a m ha hey uf e ed m ge e uli r he l d es 1 gr 3 ounds . 1 ' 4 l t tca e f om t br a h oft Tr ck Ca on J 5 ha m r he e c he u ee nal anua y 5,2008. r l 6 6. Pl ntfs ale t t t J nuar 5,2008 tood i Fe l w a due t t ai if l ge ha he a y l n nley s d he 1 i de t m a nt na e a ope a i oft Ca ,a on ot rr as .n e f t ra s r t t 7 na qua e i e nc nd r ton he nal m g he e ons y urhe s e t ha 1 t food c e nc we et xa r t ' t CiyofFe nly a t Cou yofLyon be us 8 he l ons que es r t ce baed'by he t e r e nd he nt ca e 1 ofti e i i fer e'o r quii g t c r ct sa buide soft r si i s vii 9 tnt ntonal ndif enc 't e rn be onta or nd l r he e dental ubdi son 20 t c tucti r sr c ur t woul m i m i t da a c us d by toodi i t tve t o onsr nfa tu t e hat d ni ze he m ge a e l ng n he nt he 21 foodw at r e er t s vi i whe t Pl i if 'hom esw e e l a ed. l e s nt ed he ubdi s on r a ntf s r oc t 22 7. Pl ntf s alo a s r t t tood c e nce w e e e c r ed by t ai if s s e t hat he l ons que s r xa e bat he 23 S ror a om isons'i con tu i va i elment,i udi Roli M e dowss vii t r s nd e s i ' n sr ctng rous e s ncl ng lng a ubdi son 24 i pr vem en s h es J m o t ) ous , enny' La c os i a t S nuckl ' a W r ngl Road a W agon s ne r s ng nd he ' K e ' t a er nd 25 W he , om m itd byt Def nda s aswel a ale tonsofm ir pr en a i ma ont s e elc te he e nt, l s lga i s e es t tons de he al 26 ofRoli M e dow s pr ri s lng a ope te . 27 8. CRI ha s d TRUCKEESP s ue CARSON I GATI DI RRI ON STRI CT, t he 28 BOARD OF DI RECTORS OF TRUCKEECARSON I GATI RRI ON DI STRI CT, STEVE :cw lc s c.o o u m lR p s mwp o 3 , ase 3: cv09- O0715LDG RAM Docum ent119 Fi 08/ 11 Page 4 of5 l ed 03/ . 1 CAM POY,i vi l a dba STEVE CAM POY GENERAL CONTRACTI GREATER ndi dualy nd NG, 2 NEVADA BUI LDERS, t CI he TY 0F FERNLEY, t COUNTY OF LYON, KJ he NG 3 CUNS TRUCTI I , CARLS TECHNI ON, NC. ON CAL, mC. a d WI AM CARLSON, , n LLI 4 i vi ualy f r i m niy. ndi d l , o nde t 5 9. TheCI OFFERNLEY a COUNTY 0F LYON, TY nd STEVE CAM POY a nd 6 GREATER NEVADA BUI LDERS ha s CRI f i m niy. STEVE CAM POY a ve ued SP or nde t nd 7 GR EA TER N EV AD A BUI ERS ha nam ed varous t r pary de e LD ve i hi d- t f ndant on t t or e of s he he i s 8 ne i enc ,c rb i a i mniy. glg e ontï uton nd nde t 9 1 0. l i ale d t tCDlwa t de ope a gene a c r corofRoli t s lge ha s he vel r nd r l onta t lng 1 M e do s i ve i t J nny' La c os i a t d nuc e' a W r e Roa a W a 0 a w , nvol d n he e s ne r sng nd he ' K kl ' t angl r d nd gon l1 W heel ndt tBERLE i t a tre ofCDI l i as ale t t ir pr e a i we em a a ha s he le go . t s lo lged ha m s e es nt tons r de 1 whe t Roli M ea spr te w e e s d. 2 n he lng dow operi s r ol 1 3 11 . CD Icl i si ne rha a a tver ea t de l er g r lc r t a m t ve d ny c i ol s he ve op or ene a ontac or 1 ofRoli M ea 4 lng dows ort ot ri pr m e s a i t a w a sm pl t l nder l i a r e t t he he m ove nt nd ns e d s i y he e . t s g e d ha 1 CDItna e t prj c i ove nt,i udi home , s dnoho s.Howeve, ai if 5 i nc d he o e tmpr me s ncl ng s but ol me rPl ntfs 1 ale ,des t CD ls pos ton,t tC DIdi m or The e i a di put a t w he herCD I ha an 6 l ge pie ' ii ha d e. r s s e so t s y 1 labiiy f Pl i if da age . 7 i lt or a ntf s' m s 1 8 1 2 . fc r . hels BERLE w a t à l s r hol , r c orandofie ofCDI Nonet e s, ' s he o e ha e der die t 1 BERLE as e t t r i no pr t s 9 s rs he e s oof o uppor t ne es a y elmen sf acli ofale e The e t he c s r e t or am t r go. r 20 i adipu ea t whehe hec por t ve l CDIs oul lepir dt i s s t s o t rt or a e i of h d ) e ce o mpos la lt onBERLE. e i biiy 2l l 3. An a iabl gl ls tlm e oft sm a trha bee r c d a m c e oba e te nt hi te s n ea he mong t he 22 Pl i tf s a m os pa te t t sca e. a n if nd t r i s o hi s 1 23 1 4. TheSetl m ent e e es e i l ovi st t sp s l colec i l te Agr em nt s ntalypr de ha cRl ha l l tve y 24 pa t s of$558, 0. i exc ge f ra c y he um 00 00 n han o omplt r l a e fom t i tntac i a a l e e e e s r he nsa ton nd l 25 pe ng a tons a lsed i t M oton. ndi c i s i t n he i 26 1 5. N eiherCD1no BERLE ha i ur et tw o d pr decove a f a t r d ns anc ha ul ovi r ge or ny 27 oft pe ng a tons he ndi c i . 28 l 6. :cwu lcR p soop. p u ll sc. . o w C DIha ce e al bus nes a t hm no r gul s c ofi om e f om s as d l i s nd hus s e ar our e nc r 4 I . . ase 3: cv09- 0O715LDG RAM Docuï ent119 Fi 08/ 11 Page 5 of5 l ed 03/ . 1 whih t m a a f t epa nt .W iho as ceofi ome, ' de ens oft s p di c o ke ny u ur yme s t ut our nc CDIs f e he e en ng 2 a i di s pa e t lm ied pooloff ctons s i t s he i t undsava l bl f s t l en oft e l w s t . ia e or e tem t hes a uis 3 1 7. Theam ountpa d by CRI w ilbe aloc e t t Ro y cl spu s ntt i SP l l at d o he nd as r ua o 4 c c a i t whi h CRI w a noti prvy butt s s pa d i i c i r ton f t gl bal al ul tons o c SP s n i , he um i ! n ons de a i or he o 5 s tl m e ofaI cl m s e te nt l ai . 6 1 8. CRI Sac i sar a a I nde a a s h a e m or pa s ve t n m os ot r SP' ton e s e r nd s uc r e s i ha t he 7 D ef endant t under i ng any cl m s f i s, hus m ni ai or ndem niy, t 8 1 9. The e i no e denc or aleg i n t t t s s tl m e i f a e l r s vi e l ato ha hi e te nt s r udul nty, 9 c l i yo t tousyai datij i non-etlngDee nt. olusvel r ori l me nurng s ti fnda s 1 0 20. 1 1 21 TheCo r tn sta tes t e n a re n i ma ei g o fih W . u ti d h t h e t me t g e me t s d n o d atk l 1 2 T 1 DE 3 1 4 1 5 The Co tgr nt a ovaloft G l lSe tem e Agr em e ur a s ppr he oba tl nt e nt O M EN , ma nd i 'm is s s se RL . p ' di c a 's is P. RI SP , I I SO O RDERED . T S DATED: August4,2011. 1 6 1 7 UNI VTXYE; MAGI TX STRATE J UDGE 1 8 1 Res ct u l s it d by: 9 pe f ly ubm te . 2 J 0 OAN c. RI T.EsQ. w GH clm sM a u Nzl ESQ. l c t. 21 ALLI SON. a lfNàI . M cf E PAVLAKI S, w RI k F GHT AGAN. f L'D. 22 4O2NorhDi sonsie t vii r et p. .Box 6 o 46 23 caron ci Nv 89702 s t y 24 25 26 27 ' 28 . ' :cwm lcl e. wp u l up soox. o 5 .