Speed Technologies, LLC v. Bully Dog Sale & Distribution LLC et al

Filing 28

ORDER. IT IS ORDERED that Ds' 7 Motion to Dismiss for Lack of Personal Jurisdiction is DENIED. FURTH ORD that Ds' 16 Motion to Strike Exhibits is DENIED. Signed by Judge Larry R. Hicks on 8/4/2011. (Copies have been distributed pursuant to the NEF - PM)

Download PDF
' $ : p FL IED ENTERED . REcEl gEn SERVEDON COUNS A I OFRE EUP RTES CORD l . . Aj g5 2g j g j . cu qxrs nj j couqr sm cy DITRI OFNE S CT VADA 3 B Y: 4 DEp ly t' r , 5 6 UN I TED STATES DI STRI COU RT CT 7 DI STRI 0 F N EVA D A CT 8 *** 9 SPEED TEC> OLOGI LLC,aDelwae ) ES, a r lmie la lt c i td ibiiy ompa ny, ) 1 0 ) Pl ntf, ai if ) 11 ) v. ) 1 2 ) BULLY DOG SM ES& DI BUTI STRI ON, ) 1 LLC, I lmiedlabiiyc ny; 3 an daho i t i lt ompa ) BULLY DOG TECHNOLOGI S,LLC,a ) E n 1 I ho lmie la lt compa DOES 1 1 ) 4 da i td ibiiy ny; - 0; a ROE CORPORATI A- i usve ) nd ONS Z,ncl i , 1 5 ) Dee ans fnd t. ) 1 6 ) 1 7 , t ' ' 03: 1CV- 8O- -RAM 1 - 001 LRII . .. ORDER Be or t co ti Def nda sBulyDog Sal & Diti i LLC a Buly Dog f e he ur s e nt l es srbuton, nd l 1 Te l o e ,LLC' ( l tveyt l Dog' M otont Dimisf La kofPes 8 cmolgis S coleci l t y Bul ' i o s s or c ) ronal 1 J idi ton. D oc. 7' 9 urs c i # . Plitf S edTel lge, Csp e Te h olge )flda anif p e cmoo is tLC e d c n o if' i n e 20 opposton( # 1 t whih BulyDogrple ( # 17 . ii Doc. 3) o c l e id Doc. ) 21 Alo be or t c ti Buly Dog' M o i t Sti Exhi t 1 l a 1 30 t Spe d s f e he our s l s ton o lke bis - 7 nd 9- o e 22 Te l o e 'Opposton M e and cmol gis ii mor um. Do # 1 Spee Tec ogisGl d a opposton c. 6. d hnol e e n ii 2 ( c #2 )t wh c Bul Do rpid( c #27 . 3 Do . 4 o ih l g e le Do . ) y 24 // / 25 26 l f r t t c r ' do tnum be . Re e s o he ou ts cke r l 1 . . . r ' j . 7 ' l 1 . Fact and ProceduralH i ory s st 2 ' sa tonaie outoftee c i a peroma c ofac r trf e t mst I ci rss hi h xe uton nd fr h e ' r ontac,een'd o he ' s p c e , we ' ' m ogi l 3 'sponsor hi and sew i es Agr em ent' bet en speed Tecl ol es and Buly D og. Spe d e ! 4 Te hnol e i a D e awa e c or ton w ih ishe c ogi s s l r om a i t t adqua t r an pl nc pl pl ce ofbus nes i re s d i i e a i sn 5 Re Ne da. Spe d Te hnol gi sm a a t e ,s l,r pais and r sof-oa m o orpo t no, va e c o e nuf c ur s els r r , ent fr d t s r 6 rcn tuk a dmoocce i Reoadh s poeso a moors rcn ta tac mpts aig rcs n try lsn n n a a rfsiil tcosaig em ht o ee 7 i a num b ofhi pr i e r c a r ci s r e . n er gh- otl a es nd a ng e i s 8 Buly Dog i an l ho c or ton w 11 isprnci e pl ce ofbus ne s i Aber e l ho. l s da om a i t: t i pl a i s n de n, da 9 Buly D og m a a t r s a s lspe f m a e enh i pr l nuf c u e nd e l r or nc - anc ng oduct f r di s lpi kups a gas i s o ee c nd olne 1 po er ve cl s a s 0 w ed hi e nd pons r a s o s nd uppors ofl oa r c ng t a sand s res i cl ng t Luca t fr d a i e m e i , n udi he s 11 OiOf dRa ngSe is(1 l fRoa ci re 1 LOORRS' . ' ) 1 2 l lt 2008,Mi De d(t For 'zt makei a pu i r ltonsman rf n ae ke For E De d' hen r tng nd blc eai ) age or 13 BulyDog, st Ke nSi eon(t nglt ',ge r ma ge ofSpe dTe hnol e ,t l viied vi nglt t eon' neal na r si ) e c ogis o 1 pr s ntBuly Dog' pr pos f aSpons s p a Se viesAgr e e f t 2009 LOORRS 4 ee l s o al or or hi nd r c e m nt or he l5 rcngsu o Se Doc # l Exh.1 Si eonDe a !5.0nJ nuay 1 2009,a J nuay a i e n. e . 3, 8, nglt po. t a r 6, nd a r 16 1 2009,r s c i y Spe Te l ogisa BulyDog e c edt Spons s i a Se v c 8, e pe tvel, ed cmol e nd l xe ut he or h p nd r i es 17 A g ee ent Se D oc. 1 Exh.26. r m . e # 3, l8 0n Fe u y 1,2 1,Spe d Te l ogisfl d ac br ar 01 e cmol e ie ompl ntagans Buly Dog alegi ai i t l l ng 1 eg tcamsf rrle : 1 fa di teid c me t ( )âa d e t se r sn ain ( )b e c o 9 ih li o eif () ru n h n u e n ' 2 u uln mirp e e tto ' 3 r a h f , , 20 c n rc) 4 c nr c'a b e c o tei le c v na t fg o f i a fi d aig ( )tfiu o ta t ( ) o ta t l ra h f h mp id o e n o o d at nd ar e ln ; 5 o o s u h 21 bra oft i idc ena o goodfiha f rde i ()bra offducir duy; e ch he mple ov nt f at nd ai alng; 6 e ch i ay t 22 ( )c nsrciefa d a d()c n rin Doc # 12 ! I 8 8 .l r s n e Bul Do fldte 7 o tu t r u ; n 8 o veso . . - , !3 - 4 n e po s , l g i h v y e 23 pr s ntM oton t Di m i sf La ofPer onalJ r s cton ptr uan t Fe r lRul ofCi l ee i o s s or ck s u i di i t s t o de a e vi 2 Pr c d t 1 ()2 ,Do . 7 4 o e t e 2 b () c # . r . . 25 // / 26 2 1 I. 1 Le St gal andar d 2 W heeadee tc le st e r s ofpes lurs ci t pli ifbe r t r fndan halnge he xecie rona j iditon,he antf a s he 3 bt de ofde kai t tt cour hm urs ci overt deenda .Sc r e gge v Fr d l n r mons tng ha he t sj iditon he f nt hwa z ne r . e 4 Mari Mot Co.374F. 797,8 ( hCi.200 ,W hee,a he e t cour rcevesonl tn or , 3d 00 9t r 4) r s r ,he t e i y 5 wrte maeil,h p an ifn e o yma eaprmaf ces o n tr u hispla n sa d itn tras te litf e d nl k i a i h wig h o g t e dig n 6 a d vt t th e ecs o pes n lu id ci o e ted fn a ti po r I Al o g a o a is ha te x r ie f ro a j rs it v r h ee d n s r pe. d. t u h on h 7 pl i ifc nnots m pl r s on t bar a l ga i ofis c pl i , he u a ntf a i y e t he e le tons t om a nt t ncontove t d ale tons r r e l ga i 8 i t e pli tY sc n h ani ompl ntar t en a tue an con lct be we t f t c ai d i t ai e ak s r , d fi s t en he acs ont ne n he 9 pa tes af i visa e r s ve i t pl ntf ' f or 1 r i ' f da t r e ol d n he ai if s av . d. 10 111. Di scuss on i 1 1 Toe tbihp ro a j rs ito o e n n e i n Bul Do , lyDo mu t a e sa ls es n l u idcin v r o r sde t ly g Bul g s h v 1 s fcen t i m t c ac swih Ne da tuc t tt m ant na e oft s tdoe notofend 2 ufi i t i ni z ont t t va s h ha he i e nc m m he ui s f l ta iin l o in o fi p a a d s b tn ilu tc .'I .(u tn 1 t Sh Co v Wa hn t n 3 rdto a n to s f ar ly n u sa ta j sie' d q o ig n 1 oe . . s ig o , ' 1 3 U. 31 ,31 ( 9 :.Pes n l t idcino e an n e ie td fn a tma b et r 4 26 S. 0 6 1 45 ro a jz s ito v r o rsd n e e d n y e i r he 1 ge r ors c fc.He io e osNato e de Col 5 ne al pe ii lc ptr i nals umbi S. v Hal, U . 408,41 nn.8a A. . l 466 S. 4 9 1 (98 . 6 1 4) 1 7 I isM oton t D i m i s B uly D og cont ndst ati i nota r i ntofN eva and doe . t n i o s s, l e h ts es de da s 1 no h v s fi in mii m c n a t wi Ne a af rtec u tte ecs p ro a j rs cin 8 t a e u lce t n mu o tcs t v d o h o r t x rie e s n lu idito . h l 1 Se Do . 7.I o p sto , p e Te l lge a g e t a Bul Do i s b e t ob t ge ea 9 e c # n p o i n S e d cmoo is r u s h t l g s u j c t o. n rl i y h 20 a s cfcpes jziditon.Thec 's la r se his bel nd pe ii ronaltrs ci ou! hal ddes ac sue ow. t 21 A. G ene Jur s c i ral i di t on' 22 Forac toe cs ge a j iditonove adee t t tdee ntsa tvii i our t xerie nerlurs ci r fndan,ha fnda ' ci tes n 23 t f um mus beeihert ubsa i l'o çc i he or t t t t nta' r tontnuousa s t ma i ' s h t tt de e s nd yse tc, uc ha he f ndan ' ' ts 2 a t te a p oa haI y ia p e e c 'i t ef r m.Ba c o d M a tr, nc v Au saNa ' 4 ci is p r c ç sc l r sn e'n h o u vi ph n rh : se s I . . gu t t( 25 I .223F.d 1 2,1 (t Ci.2000) TheNit Cic tdifrntae bewee doi busne s nc, 3 08 086 9h r . nh rui fee its t n ng i s 26 . 3 1 i asaea dd igb sn s wi asae t lte g neal n tgvn rs t g n r lu idito . n tt n on u ie s t tt ,he atr e rl o iig ie o e ea j rs ci n h y 2 I (mpha i a ) Todeemi i adee ti doi busne si t f u sae,t r b d e ss dded . tr ne f fndan s ng i s n he orm tt he e y ' 3 warn i t e ecs o g n r lu idcino e ad fn a tt ec u t x mie t efe u n y ra t he x r ie f e ea j rs ito v r ee d n ,h o r e a n s h rq e c ng 4 an vol m eoft d e ntstans cto wih t f um ' r sde s Se Gor d u he ef nda ' r a i ns t he or s e i nt . e man v Ame ir . r tade 5 Hol ngCor ,293F. 5 51 ( C.Ci. di p. 3d 06: 3 D. r 2002)(ppl ngt si n sal ts us di Zèpo a yi he ldig-c e et e n 6 MJ Co v ZlpoDo Co I c,9 2F. p 1 1 ( . Pa l 7) Fa t r c u t c n ie k .. p t m, n . 5 Su p. 1 9 W D. . 99 ). co s o rs o sd r 7 i l dewhehe t de e ntma ss l si t f u ,s iisore age i r gu a busne si nc u t r he f nda ke a e n he or m olct ng s n e l r i s n 8 t f u ,s r e t e f r m ' ma ke s desgn esa ag tf s r ie ofpr es i t f um , he or m e v s h o u s r t, i at n en or e vc oc s n he or 9 hol alc nc i t f u , i i om o a e i t f u .Se His h v Bl Cr s Bl Shi d ds ie e n he or m or s nc r t d n he or m e r c . ue os , ue el 1 o n a C/ 8 F2 1 7 ,1 7 (t Ci.1 8 ) 0 fKa s s / 00 .d 4 4 4 8 9h r 9 6 . % 11 H e e, h c t i dst tBuly Dog' c a s wih N e da f l s to e t rt r t e our f n ha l s ont ct t va a l hor f ihe he 1 ts tntal ort ontnuousa s tm ai 'c t c st tha pr vi l b n hel t co tt t 2 tubsa i ' ç i ' c nd yse tc' on a t ha ve e ousy ee d o nsiu e 1 s fiintprs nc i af um.Se eg.GatsLe je Cor v Je e 743F. l 1 ( . 3 ufce e e e n or e . , e ar t p. . ns n, 2d 325, 330 9t h 1 Ci.1 (i ngtats i t inofac ta t physc pr s ei t fr m onoc son, 4 r 984) fndi h olciato onrc, ial eenc n he o u ca i 1 c 5. onune ci lt a ac i w ih r s de soft f u , d t l phone and wrte c r s r a r ns tons t e i nt he or m an e e it n or e ponde nce 1 wi i iiu l i tef r m weeis E ce t ci te t s p o t e e a j idcin .Fis,h 6 t ndvd as n h o u r n u in a t is o u p r g n r lurs ito ) rtt e h vi 1 c r not t tBulyDog' we ie on wh c i ma k sa s lsispr t a gui us r t 7 ou t es ha l s bst , i h t r et nd e l t oduc s nd des e s o 1 p o u td ae si tef r m,sis f ce tt s p o t e ea j rs it .Se Co e tis I c v 8 r d c e lr n h o u i n u t in o u p r g n rl u id ci i on e r merc, n . . 1 At cPa kc LLC,37 F.Su 2d 1 3,1 9( D.Ca. 9 omi r om, 0 pp. 01 01 N. l2005)(i ngtatt mai ena e tndi h he nt nc 20 ofa i e aci we ie,whih i a e sbl t c t e si t f um i nots cintby is ft n ntr tve bst c s cc s i e o usom r n he or s um e tel o 21 etbls ge r j iditon) Se sa ih nealurs ci . cond,BulyDog' occ sonalmerha s s est Ne da l s ai c ndie al o va 22 r i nt vi iswe ie c nnotbec a t ied a doi s t nta busne son ac i esde s a t bst a har cerz s ng ubsa il i s ontnuousa nd 2 s tmai b ss S eBa c o a dM a tr , 2 F.d a 1 8 (ng gn i c mme c wi 3 yse tc a i. e n rs n se s 2 3 3 t 0 6 e a ig n o re t h 24 rsdensoft f um saei no aon t tpeofa tviyt tappr maesphy i lpr enc ) e i t he or tt s t l e he y ci t ha oxi t sca es e . 25 Thid,Buiy Dog' a r l s nnua a tnda e a t Spe at Equi e and M a ke i As ociton l te nc t he cily pm nt r tng s ai 26 . 4 I ! : . l (T J SEMA' ta s i LasVe doe notgï rs t t lvelofs tnta orc tnuous ' rde how n ) gas s ve ie o he e ubsa il oni 2 c na t e e sr t s p o t e ea jlidcin S eCo g lu Cop. . W Akin s ls h f o tc n c say o u p r g n r l t s ito . e n oe m r v Df r te ge elc a ' 3 7 F. 1 1 42(t Ci.1 (te ngtades wsa s e meei i t f m saei 29 2d 240, 2 9h r 984) atndi r ho nd als tngs n he onz tt s 4 n ts fiin c na tt a s r g n r l u idcin .Fn l ,h c u t oe t a Bul Do do s o u fce t o tc o set e e a j rs ito ) ial te o r n ts h t l g e y y 5 n ha a d i nat a ntf s r i e ofp o s i N e ot ve es g ed ge or e v c r ce s n vada doe nothol a bus ne s lc ns i t , s d i s i e e n he 6 sa e a i noti om or t d t r The ef e, hec t tt , nd s nc a e he e. r or t our concudest tt e r ie o gen a l ha he xe c s f er l 7 j iditonove BulyDogi notwarnt urs ci r l s ra ed. 8 B. Spe ii Juridi ton c lc s ci 9 Alh u ht ec u t d t a Bul Do i n ts be t og n r lu id ci ,h c u t y t o g h o r Gn s h t l g s o u j c t e ea j rs it t e o r ma y on 1 sile r s s ci cperona j idi i ove Bul Dogi t c eaie outofBulyDog' 0 tl xecie pe t s l urs cton r ly i f he ms rs s l s 11 fr m-eae c tcs Banco , F. a 1 6.A t e po ts a i t deemi whehe o u rltd ona t. rjt223 3d t 08 hre- et pples o tr ne t r 1 tee ecs o s ctcj rs ito stsi sc n ttto a d ep o e s ( )ten nr sd n 2 h x r ie f pe i u id ci n aite o si i n l u r c s : 1 h o -e ie t i u 1 de e ntm us pup os f ly di e thi a tvii s orc um m a e s e t a a i w ih t f r m or 3 f nda t e u l r c s c i te ons t om r ns cton t he o u 1 pe f m s 4 ror ome a tbywhi h pu pos f l a l hi s l oft prviegeofc c ch e r e uly vais m e f he i l onduc i aci te tng tviis 1 i t f u ( t cl m mu tbeonewhihars sou ot orrltst t deenda ' f u 5 n he or m; 2) he ai s c ie t l eae o he f nts or m- 1 r ltda tvte ; nd( ) h e rieo j rs ito mu t omp r wi fi plya ds b tn il 6 eae ciiis a 3 t e xecs f u idcin s c o t t ar a n u sa ta h 1 j tce Br yt Pur lLLP v.Rec don ( Re or 606F.d 11 1128(t Ci.201 ) The 7 usi . a on cel or t c don, 3 24, 9. r 0 . h 1 pli ifbe r t btr n ofesabls ng t fr tt pr ,a i s ce s u ,%he bur n t 8 antf a s he lde t ihi he is wo ongs nd f uc s f l ç t de hen 1 s fst t d fn a tt Er s n ac mp ligc s ' h t h e e cs o j rs ito wo dno b 9 hit o he ee d n o p e e t o el a e t a t e x rie f u idcin ul t e n ' 20 r s bl ' Sc z ne rv Fr#M ari Mot Co.374F. 797,802( hCi. ea ona e, hwar e gge . c ' tn or , 3d 9t r 2004) 21 ( tngBu ge Kig Cop. Rudz wiz, U. 462, 78( 985). quoi r r n r v. e c 471 S. 476- 1 ) 22 Alhough t t m I os f la ime 'i ofe us t i ntf t fr tpr t he er t pum e u va l nt' s tn ed o de iy he is ong,i t 23 e ompm s bot pur e ula l e andpur e uldie i whi h a e t ditnc conc pt . nc s es h pos f vaim nt pos f r cton, c r wo s i t e s 24 l Pur e ula l e a i i c ess d. pos f vaim nt pples n as oundi i conta ta i e tbls d by e de e oft ng n r c nd s sa ihe vi nc he 25 de enda ' a tonsi t f u , uc mse c i orpe f mi ac ta t f By c r t f nts c i n he or m s h xe utng ror ng on r c . #. ontas, 26 . 5 l pu pos f die ton a isi ca ess ndi i t r a i e t ihedby e de e oft r e ul r c i pple n s ou ng n o t nd s sabls vi nc he . 2 de enda t s a tvii s out i t f um s a e t ta e diec ed a t f um . I a 8 W he e, f n ' c i te s de he or t t ha r r t t he or d. t 03. r as 3 he e,a a ton i vest tc a m st ta i e outo t pa tes c r c u r a i hi t N i h r n c i nvol or l i ha r s f he r i ' ont a t al el tons p, he nt 4 Cic ta i t pu pos f la l ntts f bot con r c a t r cl m s She v Johns 911 r ui pples he r e u vaime e t or h ta t nd o t ai . r . on, 5 F. 1 1 62( hCi.19 , 2d 357, 3 9t r 90) 6 7 1 . Pur e ulAva l e pos f im nt ' l i wel- e ted i t N i h Cic tt ta c r c a one does n a om a i aly es a i h t s ls tl n he nt r ui ha ont a t l ot ut tc l t bls 8 t erq iiemii c na t f rs e ii jlidcin Gr yd Co v Fise begMa h Co, h e u st nmum o tcs o p cfc t s ito - a : . . r tn r c . . r 9 9l F.d 7 76 ( hCi.1 ,Pro n i i ,c e aedft ec eque s t tnns 3 2 58, 0 9t r 990) ir egotatons ontmplt uur ons nce ,he e 1 oft c r c , t pari 'ac ua cotr e ofde i a e r e tc i a i . Bur rK i 0 he ont a t and he tes t l zs alng r el van ons der tons ge ng, 11 471U. a 479.Fu t r e, hee S. t rhe mor t cono i i c oft c r t lr l tons p on t f um m c mpa t he ontac ua e a i hi he or 1 saei ofpatc arr ev e.R0t v Gar aM ar e 9 F. 617 622( bCi.1 )(ii 2 tt s riul el anc 1 . ci 1 qu z, 42 2d , 9' r 99l ctng 1 Bu ge Kig,471U. a 475 . 3 r r n S. t ) 1 4 H e e t e c t i t tBuly Dog' c t ct w ih N e da a e s ci ntt s r , h our f nds ha l s on a s t va r um e o uppor t 1 s ci cj iditon.BulyDog' a tviisceal de taet tipur e ulya l is fof 5 pe t urs ci i l s ci te l ry monsrt ha t posf l vaied tel 1 t prv lgeofdoi busne si Nev . Fis,BulyDog s i t busne si Ne a by 6 he i ie ng i s n ada r t l olcied i s n vad 1 a oa hi Spe Te 7 ppr c ng ed chnol esr ga di t pr ogi e r ng he opos d Spons s p a Se v c A gr e e . e or hi nd r i es e m nt 1 S eDo . 1 , h 1 , n lt nDe . t 5 I d n s Bul Do a tv l p o td i 8 e c # 3 Ex . 8 Sigeo po a ! , n oig o, l g ci ey r moe t y s 1 pa tcpa i i t Ne dama k t 9 ri i ton n he va r e. 20 Se ond, heSpons r hi a Ser c Agr e e contm plt d s tntalpe f m a e i c t o s p nd vies e m nt e a e ubsa i ror nc n 21 N e da.Ptr ua t t a e m e t BulyDog wm o i t d t peronn varouss r i s va zs nt o he gr e n , l s blga e o f i e vce , 22 i l ng gi a a pr otons m e c ndi e pr nc udi ve w y om i , r ha s oduc i and s e ,t e s on a r o s s a ton al s el vi i nd adi pot , nd 23 va i ot rmar etng a a rii s r i s i c rous he k i nd dve tsng e vce , n onneci wih s ve alr e t oug ton t e r ac s hr hout 24 Ne da Se Doc. 1 Exh.18, ngl onDe a ! 11.l M orover BulyDogatndedt va . e # 3, Si et po. t d. e , l te he 25 an lSEM A ta s nua r de how i La Veg t ma ke t rpr t i a cor nc wih t n s as o r t hei oduc s n c da e t he 26 ' 6 1 Spons rhi andSe iesAgr me .f a !1 os p rvc ee nt #. t 2, 2 F . Thid,Buly Dog wm pr en i N e daf s ve alsa usme tngswih Spe d r l s es t n va or e r tt ei t e 3 Te hnol e .l a ton t t i talmeei r a di f ma i oft Spons s p a c ogis n ddii o he nii tng eg r ng or ton he orhi nd 4 Ser c Ag ee t DeFor viie LasVegm ont addii lo asonst dicus pe f m a e vies r men , d st d s wo tona cc i o s s ror nc 5 o t Spons s pa Se vi sAgreme .Se Doc # 1 Exh.1 Si eonDe a ! 11. f he orhi nd r ce e nt e . 3, 8, nglt po. t 6 M oeove,i e ry201 DaylKl s ntt m s n'snow ma erofBulyDog, twih r r n a l 0, r mse tols e ' l l nag l me t 7 r pr s nt tv sfom Spee Te nolgisi lasVe t dicus Buly Do sr pr s nttonsa e e e ai e r d ch o e n w gms o s s l g' e e e a i nd 8 pef nceunde t c rc .1 a ! l Fora1oft aorme i dra ons t cour Gnds ronna r he onta t d. t 3. I he f e ntone e s ,he t 9 t BulyDog pu pos uly a ld is l oft plvie ofc hat l r ef l vaie t ef he i l ge onduc i busnes i Ne da tng i s n va . 1 0 11 2. Arsng OutofFor Re at d Ac i te ii um- l e tvii s Ha ng f vi ound pur ef a l ,t e c rt us e m i whe he Spee Tec ogis pos ul vaiment h ou m t xa ne t r d hnol e ' elt o l s or m r lt d tvii . nt r ui pples 1 cl m sa i e outof orr a et Buly Dog' f u -ea e aci tes TheNi h Cic ta i a 2 ai - r s , 1 l f 't tt deer ne whet rapa tc a cli a iesouto f u -ea e aci te . Balar 3 t or'es o t mi but he riulr am rs f or m r lt d tvii s l d 1 v Sava ,65F. 1 1 (t Ci.1 .Her,butf rt Spons s pa Se vce 4 . ge 3d 495, 500 9h r 995) e o he orhi nd r i s 1 Agr em e e er d i o a pe f m ed i N eva Spe Te hnol e w oul notha s f r t 5 e nt nt e nt nd r or n da, ed c ogi s d ve uf e ed he 1 ha msa lge i t c 6 r le d n he ompl nt Acc di y, hec tfndst tSpee Tec o e 'c am sai e ai . or ngl t our i ha d hnol gi s l i ls 1 ou of an r a et BulyDog' f m -ea e aci ii s 7 t , d elt o l s ont r lt d tvte . 18 1 9 3. R e onabl nes as e s Fi ngt tSpe dTec oge 'stsi t frtt elme sf s ctcj iditon, ndi ha e hnol is aifes he is wo e nt or pe ii urs ci 2 t ec u t r s me ta t ee r ieo s e i cj rs cin i ra o a l, n t eb r e s it t 0 h o r p e u s l t h xecs f p ct u idito s e s n b e a d h u d n h fs o l i 2 l t de e he f ndantt t es a com peli c e t tt pr enc o s e ot r c i r t o woul o t ent pr lng as ha he es e f om he ons de a i n d 22 rn e j rs ito t e na l. Bu ge Kig, 1U. a 47 .l e au tn u ra on be e s e d r u idcin mr uo be' r r n 47 S. t 7 n v laig n e s a ln s, ' 23 ac t nsdest f l ngs ve fct s ( )t e entofad e ntspuposf a l nt our co i r he olowi e n a or: 1 he xt efnda ' r e ul vaime ; 24 ( t bu de ondef ntofa ai i t f u ( co lcsbewe t f u saea 2) he r n enda ppe rng n he or m; 3) nfit t en he or m tt nd 2 d f n a tsh mesae;4 t f r m saesitrs i a j diaigt d s ue ( )temo t 5 ee d n ' o tt ( ) he o u tt ' ne et n du c tn he ip t; 5 h s 26 7 1 efiintudii rs uto oft c r ve sy;()t pli i si e eti t f um;a ()t fce j cal e ol in he onto re 6 he antY ntr s n he or nd 7 he 2 exitnc ofa at r t f um. Se Har i Rut y & Co.I . c v.v Bel(. e nt LI ,328 se e n le nae or e rs sk ns s'r â . l f Cl me s d. . 3 F. 11 11 (t Ci.2003) ' 3d 22, 32 9h r . 4 Hee tec u t id ta e ecsn s e ii j rs ci no e Bu l Do i rm on be r,h o r fn s h t x r iig p cfc u idito v r ly g s e s a l. 5 Fis ,Buly D og h f l t e t i h t td e ng is l i N eva w oul i pos an rt l as aied o s abls ha ef ndi t e f n da d m e 6 unr ms bl bur n on isabiiyt de e is l.Buly Dog a ist tr e e atvesha e ona e de t lt o f nd te f l dm t ha epr s nt i ve 7 t a l d t N e da o num e ousocc i f r as bot r a e a unr a e t t s di put r ve e o va n r u ons or e ons h el t d nd el t d o hi s e 8 i c tng t ati woul nots f rfna a ha ds p ta lng t Ne da Furhe , hef c t ta ndia i h t d ufe i ncil r hi r veli o va . t r t a t ha 9 gr a e num be ofBuly D o e pl esm a be r r d t t tf a t i ldoe noti a of is l e tr r l g m oye y equie o es iy t r a s n nd t e f 10 de ons r t t tde e ng is fi t s l w s tw oul be ove l bur ns e. m t a e ha f ndi t el n hi a ui d ry de om 11 Se ond, vad ha a obvi i er s i pr e tng t i er ssofc or i t t c Ne a s n ous nt e t n ot c i he nt e t om atons ha 1 r i a c 2 es de nd onduc bus ne st r n, a ng N e da a a opra e f um f r ol i oft s t i s he ei m ki va n ppr i t or or es uton hi 1 di put M or ove ,co i a i nsofe f c enc a c 3 s e. e r ns der to f i i y nd onve e f vorr s uton o t sc e i ni nce a e ol i f hi ms n 1 Ne 4 vada msa nu b ofe nt t a ga rs t t s l w s to ur e t r n. , m er ve s h t ve ie o hi a ui cc r d he ei 1 5 Thid, l Dog f ist e tbls t ta aler a i f u i m or c r Buly a l o sa ih ha n t n tve or m s e onve e or nint 1 ap o it . The e i no i cai n t tSpee Tec ogi eve tavee t I o i c ec i 6 pr pra e r s ndi to ha d hnol es r r ld o dah n onn ton 1 wih t Spons s p a Se vc Agr eme , ri t r a i ca i t tSpe d Te hnol es 7 t he orhi nd r ies e nt no s he e ny ndi ton ha e c ogi 1 pu pos f l a ie is l oft p i lgeofdoi busne si l ho. n us on balnc t c t 8 r e uly va ld t ef he rvie ng i s n da , a e he our l fn st a Bul Do h sf i dt p ee t c mp ligc s ta t ee e cs of u idci ni t s 9 id h t l g a al o rs n a o eln a e h t h x r ie j rs ito n hi y e 20 dsrc wo l b t e s n be n ec u th r f r c n ld sta Bu l Do i prp rys be to itit ud e mr a o a l. o r tee o e o cu e h t ly g s o e l u j c t 21 s e ii p ro a j rs it i t i d src. p cfc es n l u id ci n h s itit on 22 The cou tfnds unpe s s ve B u l D og' a gum entt atSpe Te r i r ua i ly s r h ed chnol es ha t bur en ogi s he d 23 ofe tbls ngpes l ui ditonwihr pe tt e hofiscli .Sc Doc. 1 p. Unde sa ihi rona j ls ci t es c o ac t ams e # 7s 8. r . 2 ted ti o pe d n pes n l u idito , c u t ya s r pes n l u idcin o ra 4 h ocrne f n a t ro a j rs cin a o r ma se t ro a j rs ito ve 25 d fn a tt t rs e t oacam frwh c teei n id p n e tb sso p ro a j rs ito ee d n t h e p c t li o ih h r s o n e e d n a i f e s n l u idcin wi 26 8 1 s l asi a ie ou ofaco nmon nuceusofoper tvef cswih acai i t s m es tove o ong t rs s t r l ai a t t l m n he a ui r 2 whiht c tdoe ha peronaltrs ci ' Aci Embr deyCor v AtantcEmbr dey c he our s ve s jliditon. ton ' oi r p. . l i oi r 3 I c, 68F.d 1 7 1 8 (t Ci. 0 4 .Be a s Bul Do i s be top ro a jzidito f r n .3 3 1 4, l 0 9h r 2 0 ) c u e l g s u j c t e s n lt s cin o y r 4 S e dTe h olge 'b e c of o ta tcams tec u t h l e ecs p ro a j rs ito ov r p e c n o is ra h c n rc li ,h o r s al x r ie es n l u idcin e 5 Buly Dog f a Ic ai s l or l l m . 6 I V. M oton t St i i o rke 7 Pts a t oF d R. v P.1 ( ac u t ysrk a ype dn f rrd md n,mmaeil t u n t e . Ci. 29, o r ma ti e n la ig o e t a t i tra, r 8 i pe tne t ors a l m a era . The c t r vi w e t doc en s a pl di s on f l m ri n , c nda ous t i l our has e e d he um t nd ea ng ie 9 an fnd t Buly Dog' M oton t Sti e i wihoutm e i. On ywhe e t ale tonsi t d i s hat l s i o rk s t rt l r he lgai n he 1 pl di ha nopo sbl rltont t c r ryandma c us prj c t oneoft pates 0 ea ng ve s i e eai o he ontoves y a e eudie o he ri 1 wil c u t rn amo i t srk .T a eesCa . r u .Co o 1 l a o r g a t t o tie r v lr s d S r . fAm. . n e 2 0W L on v Du mor , 01 1 5 0 9 0 * ( D. l 2 0 .Hee Bul Dogh sma en s c s o n .Fu temo e wh r, 2 2 0 4 , 3 E. Ca. 01 ) r , l y a d o u h h wig rh r r , ee l3 a he e t cha l nge m a era r s s a i s off c ,t m o i n t s zke s l bede e tl a ng s r , he le d t i l ai e n s ue a t he t o o ti ha l ni d, te vi 1 a a s sme t ftes fiin yo t ealg to sf a j dc to o teme i . l ( i n 4 n se s n o h u fce c f h l ain or d u iai n n h rt ' d ct g e s' i 15 White t ,I .v.Handicr .f Co.61 F. 970( hCi. 0).Ac r ngl t c t hal tls one nc - a t , 8 3d 9t r201 ) co di y,he our s l 1 de Buly Dog' M oton t Sti Exhi t 1 1 a 1 30. 6 ny l s i o rke bis - 7 nd 917 I 8 I I THEREFORE ORDERED t tDe enda s'M o i n t Dimisf La ofPer on T S ha f nt to o s s or ck s al 1 J rs ito Pt s a t oF 9 u idcin l u n t RCP 1 ( )2 ( c # 7 i DENI r 2 b ( ) Do . ) s ED. 20 I I FURTHER ORDERED t tDe e nt 'M oton t Sti Exhi t 1 1 a l 30 t ' T S ha f nda s i o rke bis - 7 nd 9- o 21 Pl ntT sOpposto ( .# 1 i DENI ai i iip Doc 6) s ED. 22 I I SO O RD ERED . T S 23 hs a f gs DATEb ti V d yo Au ut2011. , < . 24 25 26 LA RRY R . CK S HI UNI TED STATES DI STRI J DGE CT U 9