Wolff v. NH Department of Corrections et al

Filing 23

RESPONSE re 20 Answer to Complaint filed by Charles Jay Wolff. (Attachments:, # 1 Exhibit 1 - Miscellaneous Papers)(mxm, )

Wolff v. NH Department of Corrections et al C e 1:06-cv-00321-PB i/L i Filed I - j/4(asSA&,STI4 APDocument 23 o904/09/2007 r CJ,L w J fi1t Doc. 23 Page 1 of 11 Y B \N(1 (-FI OF ^d.^P. S G %tTy OI vlfl H d, 01 I i dkl-4 xrATi J7A&r q P 12: 13 C O NC o ho) N& w 14AM Pd wAa a33of Coo A Uf F TI-k5 vfli rrb / ri-Tgj D1J rA/ ci C a vJcr CHHML J :^ AV W o `FP O . Q Wl144 - M1. ") AM QJ Y .S AIJt CLS/l IT /V w/v 1-f .^ ^^ OF C u p T 1(/ IC l\,0CTIo"J . c^ro, No. o -CV- 3i- O'?c-CT To ATTaAAI&Y AlVhn(^w 3eL/C'&/il1" ..,.^ i - . -^.. , ,, h 1 , 4 ph 1 C ;l a o o 9 WTo O 1 J M IJJ PLA LN 7PT1 CO M P WMyT /,Ni) 0 l-1tANT J'u (-1-f o T/t&/t AlY b T-UAX&A 7Li&p 4J 7) iST,CL A / 71 aQ&/A t Ire, C C oSWc[JN I e 11 P4R A fi i T JleV ue1r JLIP D I A PPcr 4, f17-r& ^ T^ 11 CC ^t^a j C &/& To T/)& , 7/ J) A 2AFAM,-9 ] 11 c a A ! (jtt^ W '4a T f CA& /Vor D M) M t 1R/L IA /(/Aj ^.IV C 11'4 v8 fi/ 1-19-A oO( lAO N We, b^,ri.4 71f-^ J 9T U C C P^ . ^^' /L c I,.r1^ E^,^ C ^1 (T^H ^ ^ / c4( Iq M-J v/f/ IA Ti, L r7 J Al'/1 Ly L O A L 77/-. // 1Z Nct11kc 7i A o i'/ / Tjw \/ vvA Ku J d}t-A P/ &T `"A L A 1 v o lE T h A )&N nT T/ h 1 FYAIu W y' Wrr *G r. c ^ / ^ y ( al A C inTU A Li r ,C1^re rG. Z I uq C , f^b r^^ ^ L ij. d 0 keA 6 AC(u (Jta. 6-x ,4 1(Q wtfl . ._., TT)H & O hry 7 7? ig II ^'^nr S1-f 0 c C 0 o1 v Gn ,'ty , 16 0 1c 4-T %/w f Alir1 A16 fyV-AIC4,77,..V,f P",-r4al 4/\& Aar fC6,rbt64 2 PACQ / Gr^ ^- Dockets.Justia.com Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 2 of 11 ERCLi i tb P C&AJI F/N4 /A 7LVI P A GO. A(AALefla g v eJ J L iI) , 1) V - )^3 -; o o( /n Two Q) ?A- J A* &k-E;,t D 7-ff* fr^ v A 1 p C n Nt ^ V7Y l T I ^T e Aly ^i^11 "^ 7b F^ 0IA p1 4" ' J'',-ML^ x^-Ctrl) ' )Tj 4 T7 /J A u TJti 1 T /^ h'Ac N.lvg; L GAl d ;r/H^ A /lfa'91 C v Ay o- rz AJII u"A LL ,i CLt1 e. it, \NA W A' A -2E-K . A C A,J e o 1Z JT9T C ^ .(,cL 14 / f tP I I A dA?`MDuf 7& .u . E o:AL,& AA"( AM M,i. ). ,zp Tu e 1 i r/4 8 3 /i A DAMN bA^/ ,AJ L,/& A/lfl 7 7 L 4 D c.,a( J( 3 6' c ?&ArIJ-44 AM.AJ 4/&- OW& Ar Z gr ii yvv C4m c - A4 A YP 7Nrei'oi f{a ^^ / i . o', v 1 L [r T1t1 'F fA - I A sLl at r d ^ -, t J - ., A - 'r ic - x /x u-, ' `-'rr^ A,13 U'LT V N LL I--G V h /^-xr n Pi PT^& I** WOLLA! . f& C oNb AMQ NDLb L^uht LAINT` T^ 7Zj f / 14 /f u f-ll wwANL&. P^,u o JL 7ht (vA)C tr& v A' D 1//J 1"' 7, A CL DW 'r4 `l4/I ,C -7 AlLlo , w -^ ri-j OW4 7-1 7 / p C 4 /2e c 4-t 6 /1 P7fC C& 7 VACPA/M rluD7 ;tO,'^T lso'^A)t /w^t Ake rw?I ^ 4 ii )7)(,LA J(/"4"j Utiy^4-U -^(f L( Alvt Z?lzjl 7'b'L"- p ils/ ACi pP b 7 I) U/^ p-!J CGc . 0 f ^ Q3 /fr M ? A fr/hf! I>i^ Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 3 of 11 vs M/JLn fl,I\ /NLC, &'` - G4 A-g / vAJ OJJ * T - [ 1 * , I/A-1/J `^J , A v-i'tl+ TA' ;^-' ^' Ctc 1 U - J /p '. ' ^ ^I r4C A ut Glo vj Lf Cc Ad- b ' /D141 7`Tc o tP.-r 10 1 (jIAGtlwJ /iA cAJL4k ff .f r^ To D, v6A7 ILLa k& L" o (-) (' D t-^ f/-,Osy/ x'^'y/ti'R /-^A / M__ P t i+T raol i 7` Ab e Cp 1.1y ^ M r11w d ^ 0 /-;r4< 7' IAUC-4-t ofj 3 L-Pp t,/A/ 77-1-411 R I !u r y 6 to // / V-M :^J( Q ) oci hj n P k7H1 h1rI //'r 74Cr 14M I v?T 1 1 7 C AIt 9 9o I I ?" 1 d 14 /c WA Ti46 At G/-f ^l ih-^ t Cii ''J a 14 c 0 9- tv kto X' WA0 cr 25 /"cz, Al o-vr{ri a ?r4 k/c b4 Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 4 of 11 J,IOA attT- G'tr. A -0 A f , C 1 .4L t tLt X kM 1 /YAi 7vvJ . / di-JJ1 7 iL d , ( d oc.B6i.'6y I Uc /M-'i1/J' e ", b c 1 1Tcb tP4 T UrP4a nwj /J., ut A-L T 'ff 7 c/1/onii //-Jv u`J "ui 12 A^ ,[ ' c j / L c e A( Cj /,Y. Av^IX ;r4AM r J (trc r/ M T b / ^,-7 a P 70 ' `-. 71/p L,- U pjA 3r 7-1 let I L I 7T ) pA 0 LK A-'^t b-e i (.^ /^to^ u j fa M Y /M ^/+T ,6 01 / ^^^^^i 4tr/4 ^ W{ /7 A") 47(4 Al) ) uc .L rri 3 t-,Pfl -WW /J /) At J-ffllt 03, AIo M A' ) ^1It^ ^ th i, 0 T ? tr 4 A 07 Yb to 1 o#sIij 1 b /h / 9 t+C bl 0 P Nf ^^/ c TI46 A( (4L }^ 7j Lq OZ U-MA Ld a l-j-c n-g- w k& I& GAG ^ 71*'-^ 71 7jU, cc ?A^& 3 oll Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 4TO Page 5 of 11 IP A 17 7 G C tv 13 A ^AV Ai1 jlxj 4-7z;^ , )j',j 0ci A4-( Tlfyc C6 C D 6&iT/1i/ ICC T/4 & At^ T3 o ,4 JAJ1 A M s 7 h A ci ^,lfe: Jwl ail Ld/v A C/4w- tr j 1 U 74zq ,/ v Al J N f v tl,,k (' /J v A T4&/L Cii,t &, p 4H 0 OAT E^ n J)PY Pg-ct T 7'' ,^S J- IX 7C wv& Lv LI$ 7^V 4&(^7 w a c 6# Ue Q L () ^ 0 lqu? 17-ail (/ n 9 LIV 0-7 7rC g ijt 72 .^ 4 D / 4J e72k A&Y e-rCohD /^'f/I/77,0-E C /rl-l (J, ^/ 'v f /, D4 C, // A , 4M Av 6 (1) CG 41' W fp&,-iy /V+t( W/TP O,e CUU^ ^q- C # 17. ifr V 3 J) u4ul . J Jr#/v&-i, -7 PA7#A re p4V&p A cj r CJl^ Ity A t;oKe r Y4 4 T96 A#t4J)1^ AA 0 0' S /-)Y Thi T, CSort W I-CA Vi/t` aj-2 a-q A,, l A144 ]z^ AA, p,Jfley ip` Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 6 of 11 fiLp- /"r s IL8-1L Cv C'1N1^ AA T7 fi c644'1l &,,rL AAW - Fw& u A)Cc / , ,,&n ? // Cu tJ U AA (d I y PL V^rf c f L 7lu jr f Lit c A t 1i. C LoIl# )V ' Z J-Co* 1J J JC-t C,9 7cc W. N wb ky 1,9 - "I o 0 97 WAIA'^ UAY Ci-T7W- I Ari Ywj, 7/Y / A' 4 W H Kh JT7/ c wvwv JQ O IL 7I jrkoG/r IT (3 -E/u t L coe D /1(, &J u e L c LF fz, 1eli p llI /r A AA tI O Q ^) 4 LC C 7 t Al M-u i4,4-T t f3- A*r) 7 J y-/f't 71 (Z -tk& V`J -, ) -I-"Flz P -" K14, 7 c I^^ 7 ^D A M 17 J aS Ok xr-(, L J-?jZ p C6r 7 v 7l L df/ .. ^^^4h r J(i'1/ 4 f^ hfc p L 1c 1t^ Ile Cc/1 $ 771 14..Q y&..g af f f/ 7 7 p3 4y 77P r T Jt +U c- ?vl-tow pMI )i. T,Tr^ va /AlCJj4LL ^ii (o LmAc J t /u A 4ffJ tfi 7- ,d17 sea- e6 7'Y e7l"' T z W^ ^7^ c k ttr Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 7 of 11 A/I 7" NA P t dfi A AU M^r ^ A^ A L'13E,kTo f7K No a ,(3 hi 0 / ii 711 11 F ei ^#A1 Cx J v frr G (-4-1 7^rf L /^ g U 77f ar- INN Xti5r frCJ Lv 741 L L A)SI Au 1 7~ C t,`r C xr/^ T Lh Ir f v o k ^^ A PJt IA, A-ICI)Lr 6p,4-&n 1 cd Tc( 1 /V\ 440 17 ( ?ei, 7lx ^ ^ ^i4^c/ 4/ 7W - r/ Ar C 1 z c7 tsfit 0 rn l , A* 1 hv^r^h l^- dn ^r7 tA Fdo'P ^h f v r^ ^i^r (lr^ v2! ` ! } A." ,1^Co N 4-^1 f `C e ^'ta C^ c. t^r9. - Th 714 6 F CLo W-c 7T-^+ry & tr41l'a(iA /VY b 6g O (aIf TI? vT1^ T h 8 a-p Orfz MLI 1 ^^r. Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 8 of 11 cO N30 rvrA F(hjfi p, r- o A rY ?/ cc Q IL To l/'((.vI C 4I /JA CvA - 3vla3 S T/ Tu r / V / G L 4-MI JA 1(5 A-) N fe^' %&;A 2 A M At Y .' j3 CT;A (^ jb V. U8 1 pL5 JT41. 0 0 kz'r;a ST1-TJ Co HJriT cT/ Q' 4AT1 c c & vii, c i V) c. A1iiin L^ u v)^ )J&J. ,A N D k l t b J f4 C cr b . T/TL L )Y17'Y T/IcM 1 - To hCLti b ep LL rPwer" I t i fLU "7)/U I J# ^l 7^^- -r^ / ,^ c7'^ OeB ^ IN 7Ae fi AD Mjlvi Thw" fL G D,&/ Ad AALe, A va(cA1C& A/i & ANh 1-] A ve 13t&,' &/^bjf 1/ A fi I VA)'JCL Pii CjI h AJI&O? D. I a* Dt-CT - VNNb^A (IH I1U /T-A-W C b&, 77cr. V, 41b th " Ct MAQ * ot 4LJ - p T bA,1zf /-!AvT No t7/4&1 /MA&u iv T o 1ZI L t3 1; p . 2 /A IrAt -.4h1 _Tq ^ ^1 6V1H )) J (1) .6'h T7 t UT P/ /4 11 Gle 1M STA11 TT (0 Tif & 0A IU1 \ TIJ & T/ t /KY (Pd . vA)Y Cf:S kAcr A& A) (( a d AU -A 1 (lA C s j'/, t 1Y L d HA ,4M TT o fS r4L ro A C Ct w T ASSt4Af / ^^tlri 6 Co04S 1 F ^ /Jc# v I A' oI tA Td^1L ) NT&'l aC b/t 71 4L,'r 71 114t- v.J, 1)L),7--i Icr Cv w-r AowrA 4c% . n.C( 6H ,+MeMA 4Y Tr Syp P&T1 c,A* ZG M e (//Yt l-\ /l A4 . ANu H40 1 o ,477lak/fi,> roj4eA 4a o71` ,%/ & P4."L ^ OfL^ , Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 9 of 11 p L( Afl P' 74 Y Tl-e1 47 T/C- ? - 0 )C/i c q A 0 LI-A^ 7 LCf, Ii,k+ ( ( I 1,1 e A ,&4 (I A, C / Mh' T 71 Yf%Ait j4 u A, 7 #c KI TCIJcr o AN PH cTe Ci/ 7 aJ7 i A &9'v lf IL/J rd tr - TIcua7l& ] 2c, 01 J &-/ei , t 0 A, C LuJ G D P(,8,VO, 71frO 4/Y AA ^-m 0 FA (f ^ , m 17 ea 4 ' c )t A Tlvf 9 k, cp A 1'^ "rCAc CC C) J / ), j ^} l L' / t y,^ ,^ Lf ^^' J` TAT/^^ 1^1 Z CLPrJI6N 0 CT Z& A 13ri 2c tr 3 &- w 11JJ /---tv L I DA C - Y-f 0 !V 1 11 1-1-1 p P u ll, C! r T14-li hA- 'r f ^ fr VVAf P1Q,, /A( 7`/L /1'jit1A k h e p t Ara rj)-i t ^ A r^ l^^ n -/C4J, , 1 7 f ) ^* /,Y 1 Tc - t sr T/41 > O ^ , O /MA'' L/1"/1 2'b ( A-f14(Y1 J1 MY - T1* 0 PAI CtA /* CU * / L 1 M M r(i L-o / `L^ ] ^crv LA V-^i ! u ti. r L n o - G 7? ^ AH b T i b Xlr AT G rg ApA/Lbt CLAJI / "/- /'r r/ f^J bia AT 0 6 1S ,4-o&1- T ruA^yCM pt' , 7/YMn71) y 14A, A / A/4 fA Ur /-Kk IrA 0 LL , ee JA/ A f b U i [A' 4CfCe:;Q Gv 7 4oft 1 r AT !41/ bG p&AtI.v Ajita 1*-AA U4 r/.&e ?`/Ler pi p /A/()$- f t IrAoLL t( cL C A LC /'\ 1 7* c /&A CA ti^ / tN 6 LIZP jk?nLy Pd lN t C c P.& 6z 9 7 Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 10 of 11 d /f ^Y' f ,A 47 Th P 711 oP / 4 b , 2- co9- r I//A )4-& A Cf4^,j A CY f2 Ifl Vf G)^ no-C y /4 8 h 7T- - '^SAP^^- / l^[u T "A P ^- A C,?,k o L/ /^ 8 A # A /& I) ! t z Lo /A & 2 Jt A 6 1 c^ (c "AFr ar I-Ac n, Irk Lc kta- C, iv^,c tr t 9-1- calr, tu^1J ^Yoc; l^ ^ CG 1-jt-4(rp v,( E. rrAf a4lA)r/"rj#A fi14 /^ pa C()VEA GA 774PAVI-io-cpe^;L A Q * ?# -4 cTrc^ 0A ^ CC ^TTo^^^r AxD^ew e13 , LIPff Ai^ o l f Q' S 'De-T,^z Te-okh-iNj G pv cY /\,c d ^a V41LC1AAo,, WA(2--H/Y h A c9 'Z 9 M (/ Aor i i Lc P iJ& rya- L, u ^ ^ h r MAc, NA1 . cl 19, 2GU' 9 L-ts A M CG14I fi/' oJ/f T#( ,C I7A ,1i y, PAO D A ?Ar- E I G F 9 Case 1:06-cv-00321-PB Document 23 Filed 04/09/2007 Page 11 of 11 T6 04A 11 C C.1 ^.^ y licl a LF11 U oT VPATA/w Ctv^^ /la . ^i^-cv-3zl-P13 f 14'AL ^ 7th 7'(.i 7 /A' C C v t A W SC'P P 6-0 G T/f , -M 0 1 T/ G' 7 7` 14 t // Pe- A J C i P 7t' NE Co y g Th J (LL TIJ& NFT 11L4 ly^ aU t- CJ7 M 6 W14 & ,, f {1^^ 7 g)(,/,J w hC^' 1 dJ y AT LA !l 'L .'^ b l o' sc. 7P l- A7/4 eC 7r O-j ^C(- CLTr'&C