The Authors Guild, Inc. et al v. Hathitrust et al
DECLARATION of James Fruchterman in Opposition re: 81 MOTION for Summary Judgment.. Document filed by Georgina Kleege, Blair Seidlitz, The National Federation of the Blind, Courtney Wheeler. (Goldstein, Daniel)
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE SOUTHERN DISTRICT OF NEW YORK
THE AUTHORS GUILD, INC., et al.,
Case No. 11-cv-6351(HB)
HATHITRUST, et al.,
SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF JAMES FRUCHTERMAN
IN SUPPORT OF DEFENDANT INTERVENORS’ OPPOSITION TO PLAINTIFFS’
MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT
I, James Fruchterman, do hereby declare that:
1. Based upon my experience with the Bookshare® online library for people with print
disabilities, I believe that the risk of online piracy or unauthorized copying and distribution of
works made fully available to individuals with print disabilities through the HathiTrust is
Facts Relied Upon
2. One of Benetech’s primary programs is Bookshare, an online library that provides over
200,000 people with print disabilities in the United States access to more than 150,000 books and
150 periodicals that can be converted to braille, large print or synthetic speech. Originally
created by a community of volunteers, Bookshare is a subscription-based service operated by
Benetech. Bookshare has the capacity to create 2,000-3,000 accessible digital books per month.
3. Bookshare’s collection includes a large quantity of bestsellers, many of which become
available just hours after they are released to the public. Bookshare receives most new books in
digital formats directly from publishers under permission agreements.
4. With the knowledge and consent of these publishers, Bookshare employs a seven-point
digital rights management plan (“DRM”) to protect its digital copies from illegal copying. The
DRM is sometimes referred to as “social” DRM because its goal is to make online “piracy”
5. Under point 1 of the DRM, only blind and other persons with print disabilities (and
agencies, such as schools, serving such individuals) are permitted to download copyrighted
books. These users must register with Bookshare and supply proof of a qualifying disability
from an appropriate professional.
6. Point 2 of the DRM entails a contractual agreement between Bookshare and its users
forbidding violations of copyright law. The agreement warns users that any violation will result
in a loss of access to Bookshare and that other legal consequences may follow. Attorneys from
the publishing industry reviewed and were given the opportunity to suggest changes to the
Point 3 requires that all copyrighted materials bear a notice informing the user that the
copy is for that individual’s use only. The notice also identifies the copyright owner and the date
of the original publication.
8. Pursuant to point 4, Bookshare encrypts a requested book for a given user, and the files
are delivered through secure/encrypted channels.
9. Once a Bookshare reader has received a book and decrypted it, however, it is in a format
that permits copying. This is intended primarily to permit use by assistive technology devices,
such as Braille notetakers, but it is technically possible to redistribute copies to third parties.
10. Point 5 requires all copyrighted material downloaded to be fingerprinted as part of the
encryption process so that the identity of the authorized user is contained within the decrypted
material in a difficult-to-find fashion. This way, if a user illegally redistributes material
downloaded from Bookshare and we have access to a copy, it is possible to confirm both that the
materials came from Bookshare and which user was responsible.
11. Under point 6, all transactions, encryption codes, and fingerprints are stored in a database
enabling Bookshare to track any abuse to the source. Users are informed of the existence of this
database as part of Bookshare’s privacy program, and are informed of the limitations of the use
of this data (it will only be used to respond to abuse problems, and not for marketing or other
12. Finally, point 7 calls for a security watch program that monitors all transactions and
automatically limits any user whose account downloads more than a fixed number of titles in a
given month, typically 100 titles. In addition, Bookshare regularly searches the web for illegal
copies of content originating from Bookshare user downloads and suspends the account of users
found to have been the source of such content. In addition, Bookshare issues take-down notices
to the websites hosting such content.
13. Generally, Bookshare identifies fewer than ten instances of unauthorized distribution of
its digital books each year. This is a very low number considering the popularity of the
bestsellers in our collection and the more than one million downloads in a typical year.
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets were retrieved from PACER, and should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.