I TH E UN I N TED STA TES D I STR I CO U R TO O - OF O U s Dl m c0ur CT FI : FOR THE W ES TERN DI TRI OF VI NI S CT RGI A A O N ,A TR A X v FI LED H A RR ISO NB UR G DIV ISIO N J 1i 2 1 AN 23 J UL C. UDLP/CLERK , BY; E CL ERK M I H A EL J.NA SSER ,SR . C , Pl ntf , ai if C i lA cton N o. 5: vi i : 12cv097 V. W HI TEPA G ES, N C . I , By:H on.M i haelF.U r c bans ki U nied St es D i ri Judge t at st ct D ef endant . Thi m a t rw asr e r d t t Honor bl B . augh Crgl ,Unied St t M a sr t s te ef r e o he a e W i er t a es gi ta e J d e pzs a t o2 U. C. 6 6 b ( )B) f rp o sd tn igso fc a arc mme d d u g , l u n t 8 S. j 3 ( )1( , o rpo e i dn f a t nd e o n e r di pos ton. The M agi ta e J s ii s r t udge fl a r por a r c m e ton on Dec m ber20,201 ied e t nd e om nda i e 2 r c m e ng t tdef nt sm oton t di m i sf f iur t sa e a c a m be gr nt d. N o e om ndi ha enda ' i o s s or a l e o t t l i a e o j cinst t er p r a drc mme d to ha eb e fld a dtec u tso t eo i int a be to o h e o t n e o n ai n v e n i , n h o r i f h p no h t e t r por a r c m e ton s d be ado e i is e ie y. I i a or ngl O R DERED he e t nd e om nda i houl pt d n t ntr t t s cc di y a ADJUDGED t tt de e ntsM oton t Dimis( .No.9)i GRANTED, nd ha he f nda ' i o s s Dkt s plitf sM otonf Deaul Judgme ( .No.6 andM otonf EntyofDeaul ( . anif i or f t nt Dkt ) i or r f t Dkt No.1 a eDENI asmoot a t tt smat i STRI 5) r ED , nd ha hi ter s CKEN fom t a tvedoc toft r he ci ke he cour . t The Cl r i diec e t s a c tt e c oft s Or rt a 1c e k s r t d o end erii d opy hi de o 1 ouns lofr c d a e e or nd pl i if pr e ng pr s a ntf , oce di o e. Ent r d: J nua y 1 201 e e a r 4, 3 / *S J fWG Mi chaelF.Urbanski Unied St es Di t ctJ t at sri udge