US v. Aaron Graham

Filing

OPINION ATTACHMENTS filed. Copies to all parties and the district court/agency. [12-4659, 12-4825]

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 1 of 60

NUMBERS, FACTS AND TRENDS SHAPING THE WORLD

FOR RELEASE APRIL 1, 2015

e

d
we

, vi
659

015
3/2
7/2

0

4

12.
No

FOR FURTHER INFORMATION
ON THIS REPORT:
Aaron Smith, Senior Researcher
Dana Page, Communications Manager
202.419.4372
www.pewresearch.org

RECOMMENDED CITATION: Pew Research Center, April, 2015, “The Smartphone Difference”
Available at: http://www.pewinternet.org/2015/04/01/us-smartphone-use-in-2015/

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 2 of 60

1
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

About This Report
This report examines the increasingly important role that smartphones play in helping Americans
access, share, and create information and communicate with others. It places a particular focus on
the sometimes-fragile financial and technical circumstances of those who rely heavily on their
smartphones for internet access. The report documents the continued growth in the number of
Americans with smartphones through data captured in two omnibus polls in November 2014.
These findings are supplemented by a survey of the role of smartphones in users’ lives that was
conducted among 2,188 smartphone owners in Pew Research Center’s American Trends Panel in
October 2014.
To complement this core data, the report utilizes a form of survey known as “experience sampling”
to gather data about how Americans use their smartphones on a day-to-day basis. Respondents
were asked to complete two surveys per day for one week (using either a mobile app they had
installed on their phone or by completing a web survey) and describe how they had used their
phone in the hour prior to taking the survey. This produces a unique and intimate portrait of
smartphone usage—the apps and features that are used most frequently, the locations where
smartphone use is most prevalent, and the benefits and emotions that smartphones inspire.

015
3/2
7/2

0
ed the public about the issues, attitudes
Pew Research Center is a nonpartisan fact tank iew
that informs
,Itv not take policy positions. It conducts public
and trends shaping America and the world. does
659
opinion polling, demographic research, media content analysis and other empirical social science
4
research. The center studies U.S. politics and policy views; media and journalism; internet and
12.
technology; religionNopublic life; Hispanic trends; global attitudes and U.S. social and demoand
graphic trends. All of the center’s reports are available at www.pewresearch.org.

Pew Research Center is a subsidiary of The Pew Charitable Trusts, its primary funder. This report
was made possible by The Pew Charitable Trusts, which received support for the project from the
John S. and James L. Knight Foundation.
This report is a collaborative effort based on the input and analysis of the following individuals.

Aaron Smith, Senior Researcher
Lee Rainie, Director, Internet, Science & Technology
Kyley McGeeney, Research Methodologist Scott Keeter, Director, Survey Research
Maeve Duggan, Research Analyst

© Pew Research Center 2015

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 3 of 60

2
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Summary of Findings
The traditional notion of “going online” often evokes
images of a desktop or laptop computer with a full
complement of features, such as a large screen,
mouse, keyboard, wires, and a dedicated high-speed
connection. But for many Americans, the reality of
the online experience is substantially different.
Today nearly two-thirds of Americans own a
smartphone, and 19% of Americans rely to some
degree on a smartphone for accessing online services
and information and for staying connected to the
world around them — either because they lack
broadband at home, or because they have few
options for online access other than their cell phone.
Indeed, 7% of Americans own a smartphone but
have neither traditional broadband service at home,
nor easily available alternatives for going online
other than their cell phone. This report documents
the unique circumstances of this “smartphonedependent” population, and also explores the ways
in which smartphone owners use their phones to
engage in a wide range of activities.

d
we

e

, vi
659

4
12o.
Ndetails about these major
Below are some more

findings on the state of smartphone ownership in
America today, based on a series of surveys
conducted by Pew Research Center in association
with the John S. and James L. Knight Foundation:

Nearly two-thirds of Americans are now
smartphone owners, and for many these devices
are a key entry point to the online world
64% of American adults now own a smartphone of
some kind, up from 35% in the spring of 2011.
Smartphone ownership is especially high among
younger Americans, as well as those with relatively
high income and education levels.

www.pewresearch.org

Key Themes of This Report
10% of Americans own a smartphone but
do not have broadband at home, and 15%
own a smartphone but say that they have
a limited number of options for going
online other than their cell phone. Those
with relatively low income and educational
attainment levels, younger adults, and
non-whites are especially likely to be
“smartphone-dependent.”
Smartphones are widely used for
navigating numerous important life
activities, from researching a health
condition to accessing educational
resources. Lower-income and
“smartphone-dependent” users are
especially likely to turn to their phones for
navigating job and employment resources.

015
3/2
7/2

0

A majority of smartphone owners use their
phone to follow along with breaking news,
and to share and be informed about
happenings in their local community.
Smartphones help users navigate the
world around them, from turn-by-turn
driving directions to assistance with public
transit. This is especially true for younger
users.
An “experience sampling” of smartphone
owners over the course of a week
illustrates how young adults have deeply
embedded mobile devices into the daily
contours of their lives.
The experience sampling survey illustrates
that smartphone usage often produces
feelings of productivity and happiness, but
that many users also feel distracted or
frustrated after mobile screen encounters.

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 4 of 60

3
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

And for a number of Americans, smartphones
serve as an essential connection to the broader
world of online information. The survey
measured reliance on smartphones for online
access in two different ways — first, by asking
smartphone owners whether or not they have
traditional broadband service at home, and
second, whether they have a reasonable number
of options for accessing the internet in general
from any location. It found that:




The “Smartphone-Dependent”
Population: 7% of Americans Rely
Heavily on a Smartphone for Online
Access
% of U.S. adults who have a smartphone, but lack other
broadband internet service at home, and/or have limited
options for going online other than their cell phone

10% of Americans own a smartphone but do
not have any other form of high-speed
internet access at home beyond their phone’s
data plan.
Using a broader measure of the access
options available to them, 15% of Americans
own a smartphone but say that they have a
limited number of ways to get online other
than their cell phone.

d
we

e

, vi
659

015
3/2
7/2

0

4

12.
No

In all, one-in-five American adults (19%)
indicate that at least one of those conditions
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27
apply to them, and 7% of the public says that
2014.
both of these conditions apply — that is, they do
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
not have broadband access at home, and also
have relatively few options for getting online
other than their cell phone. Throughout this report, we refer to this latter group as “smartphonedependent” users.
Certain groups of Americans rely on smartphones for online access at elevated levels, in particular:



Younger adults — 15% of Americans ages 18-29 are heavily dependent on a smartphone for
online access.
Those with low household incomes and levels of educational attainment — Some
13% of Americans with an annual household income of less than $30,000 per year are
smartphone-dependent. Just 1% of Americans from households earning more than $75,000
per year rely on their smartphones to a similar degree for online access.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 5 of 60

4
PEW RESEARCH CENTER



Non-whites — 12% of African Americans and 13% of Latinos are smartphone-dependent,
compared with 4% of whites.

Compared with smartphone owners who are less reliant on their mobile devices, these
smartphone-dependent users are less likely to own some other type of computing device, less
likely to have a bank account, less likely to be covered by health insurance, and more likely to rent
or to live with a friend or family member rather than own their own home.

The connections to online resources that smartphones facilitate are often most tenuous for
those users who rely on those connections the most
Even as a substantial minority
of Americans indicate that
their phone plays a central role
in their ability to access digital
services and online content,
for many users this access is
often intermittent due to a
combination of financial
stresses and technical
constraints.

Smartphone Ownership is Often Most Tenuous for
Those Who Rely on Their Devices the Most
% of smartphone owners in each group who have experienced the following

015
3/2
7/2

"Smartphone-dependent"

9, v
65

4
12-

d0

Have had to cancel or
suspend service due to
financial constraints

e
ew
i

Frequently/occasionally reach
maximum data allowed on
smartphone plan

Other smartphone owners
48

21

51
35

Nearly half (48%) of
smartphone-dependent
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014. “Smartphone
dependent” users lack broadband service at home, and/or have limited options for internet
Americans have had to cancel
access other than their cell phone.
or shut off their cell phone
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
service for a period of time
because the cost of maintaining that service was a financial hardship. In addition, 30% of
smartphone-dependent Americans say that they “frequently” reach the maximum amount of data
that they are allowed to consume as part of their cell phone plan, and 51% say that this happens to
them at least occasionally. Each of these figures is substantially higher than those reported by
smartphone owners with more access options at their disposal.

.
No

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 6 of 60

5
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Smartphone owners of all kinds use their phone to help navigate numerous important life
events; lower income and “smartphone-dependent” users are especially likely to use their
phone for job and employment resources
Smartphones are used for much more than
calling, texting, or basic internet browsing.
Users are turning to these mobile devices as
they navigate a wide range of life events:









62% of smartphone owners have used their
phone in the past year to look up
information about a health condition.
57% have used their phone to do online
banking.
44% have used their phone to look up real
estate listings or other information about a
place to live.
43% to look up information about a job.
40% to look up government services or
information.
30% to take a class or get educational
content.
18% to submit a job application.

465

12.
No owners are
Lower-income smartphone


9, v

More than Half of Smartphone Owners
Have Used Their Phone to get Health
Information, do Online Banking
% of smartphone owners who have used their phone to
do the following in the last year

Get info about a
health condition

62

Do online banking

57

Look up real estate
listings or info about a
place to live

44

Look up info about a job

43

015
3/2
7/2

Look up government
services or info

d0

e
ew
i

Take a class or get
educational content

Submit a job
application

40
30

18

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27
2014.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

especially likely to use their phone during a job
search. Compared with smartphone owners
from households earning $75,000 or more per year, those from households earning less than
$30,000 annually are nearly twice as likely to use a smartphone to look for information about a
job — and more than four times as likely to use their phone to actually submit a job application.
Similarly, “smartphone-dependent” users are much more likely to use their smartphones to access
career opportunities. 63% of these smartphone-dependent users have gotten job information on
their phone in the last year, and 39% have used their phone to submit a job application.
Young adults (85% of whom are smartphone owners) are also incorporating their mobile devices
into a host of information seeking and transactional behaviors. About three-quarters of 18-29 year
old smartphone owners have used their phone in the last year to get information about a health

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 7 of 60

6
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

condition; about seven-in-ten have used their phone to do online banking or to look up
information about job; 44% have consumed educational content on their phone; and 34% have
used their phone to apply for a job.

A majority of smartphone owners use their phone to follow along with breaking news, and
to share and be informed about happenings in their local community; smartphones also
help users navigate the world around them, from turn by turn driving directions to
assistance with public transit
A substantial majority of smartphone owners use their phone to follow along with news events
near and far, and to share details of local happenings with others:




68% of smartphone owners use their phone at least occasionally to follow along with breaking
news events, with 33% saying that they do this “frequently.”
67% use their phone to share pictures, videos, or commentary about events happening in
their community, with 35% doing so frequently.
56% use their phone at least occasionally to learn about community events or activities, with
18% doing this “frequently.”

015
3/2
7/2

0
ed of smartphone owners. Mobile news
Each of these behaviors is common across a diverse group
w
consumption is common even among older smartphone owners, who tend to use these devices for
vie
more basic activities. Four-in-ten smartphone owners ages 65 and older use their phone at least
59,
-46
occasionally to keep up with breaking news, half use it to share information about local
. 12
happenings, and one-third use it to stay abreast of events and activities in their community.
No
Smartphones also play an important role in helping their owners navigate their environment and
get where they need to go, especially as a mobile GPS for real-time driving directions:




67% of smartphone owners use their phone at least occasionally for turn-by-turn navigation
while driving, with 31% saying that they do this “frequently.”
25% use their phone at least occasionally to get public transit information, with 10% doing this
“frequently.”
11% use their phone at least occasionally to reserve a taxi or car service. Just 4% do so
frequently, and 72% of smartphone owners never use their phone for this purpose.

Each of these behaviors is especially prevalent among younger smartphone owners: for instance,
17% of smartphone owners ages 18-29 use their phone to reserve a taxi or car service at least
occasionally. Additionally, African American and Latino smartphone owners look up public transit

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 8 of 60

7
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

information on their phones at higher rates than whites (37% of black smartphone owners, 30% of
Latinos, and 21% of whites do this at least on occasion).

Users view smartphones as freeing, connecting, helpful, and usually worth the cost — but
not always essential
When asked to choose from a
series of statements
representing how they feel
about their phone, a substantial
majority of smartphone owners
feel that these devices are
“helpful” rather than
“annoying,” “connecting” rather
than “distracting,” and that
they represent “freedom” rather
than a “leash.”

Despite Clear Benefits, 54% of Smartphone Owners
Say Their Phone is “Not Always Needed”—but 46% Say
it is Something They “Couldn’t Live Without”
% of smartphone owners who say that the following items from each pair
best describe how they feel about their phone

d
we

015
3/2
7/2

0

At the same time, smartphone
owners are relatively divided on
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014.
the essential necessity of mobile
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
connectivity: 54% say that their
phone is “not always needed,”
while 46% say that it is something they “couldn’t live without.” And while a substantial 80%
majority of smartphone owners describe their phone as “worth the cost,” 19% — and 29% of those
who pay more than $200 per month for service — describe it as a “financial burden.”

e

, vi
659

4

12.
No

A special “experience sampling” survey of smartphone owners offers new insights into how
Americans use their mobile devices
In addition to the surveys of smartphone owners that form the main findings of this report, the
Pew Research Center also conducted an “experience sampling” survey of smartphone owners as
part of this project. In the experience sampling survey, smartphone owners were contacted twice a
day over a period of one week and asked how they had used their phone in the hour prior to taking
the survey. This analysis offers new insights into how smartphone owners interact with their
mobile devices on a day-to-day basis: the features and apps they use; the locations where that use
happens; the issues or problems they use their phones to solve; and the emotions they feel as a
result.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 9 of 60

8
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Text messaging is the most widely-used smartphone feature but voice/video calling remains
popular, even among young smartphone owners; email continues to retain a place of
prominence in the smartphone era
Fully 97% of smartphone owners used text
messaging at least once over the course of the
study period, making it the most widely-used
basic feature or app; it is also the feature that is
used most frequently, as the smartphone
owners in this study reported having used text
messaging in the past hour in an average of
seven surveys (out of a maximum total of 14
across the one-week study period). Younger
smartphone owners are especially avid users of
text messaging, but this group has by no means
abandoned voice calls—93% of smartphone
owners ages 18-29 used voice or video calling
on at least one occasion during the study
period, and reported doing so in an average of
3.9 surveys.

Some Features are Popular With a
Broad Spectrum of Smartphone Owners;
Social Networking, Watching Video, and
Music/Podcasts are Especially Popular
Among Young Users
% of smartphone owners in each age group who used the
following features on their phone at least once over the
course of 14 surveys spanning a one-week period

18-29

Three smartphone features in particular —
social networking, watching video, and listening

100
98
92

015
3/2
7/2

97
90

Internet use

0
ed

80
93
91
94

Voice/video calls

91
87
87

Email

91
SNS

to play a prominent role in the mobile era as
well. Some 88% of smartphone owners used
email on their phone at least once over the
course of the study period, making email a
more widely-used smartphone feature than
social networking, watching video, or using
maps and navigation, among others.

Social networking, video consumption, and
music/podcasts are especially popular with
younger smartphone owners

50+

Text messaging

w
vie

59,
Email has long ranked as one of -46
2 the most online
1
common activities that users take part in
o.era, and it continues
since the desktop/laptop
N

30-49

77
55
75

Video

46
31
64

Music

39
21

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling
survey, November 10-16 2014.
Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one
week (14 total surveys) and asked how they had used their phone in
the preceding hour (besides completing the survey). Only those
respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of
the study period are included in this analysis.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 10 of 60

9
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

to music or podcasts — are especially popular with younger users. Fully 91% of smartphone
owners ages 18-29 used social networking on their phone at least once over the course of the study
period, compared with 55% of those 50 and older (a 36-point difference). These young
smartphone owners reported using social networking in an average of 5.6 surveys, tied with
internet use as the second-most frequent smartphone behavior among young adults after text
messaging.
Features such as watching video and listening
to music or podcasts are even more the domain
of young smartphone owners. Three-quarters of
younger smartphone owners (75%) indicated
using their phone to watch videos at least once
over the study period, compared with 31% of
those 50 and older (a difference of 44
percentage points). And 64% of younger adults
used their phones at one time or another to
listen to music or podcasts — a 43-point
difference compared with the 21% of older users
who did so.

Younger Users More Likely to Use Their
Phone for Preventing Boredom, Avoiding
Others, Getting Somewhere
% of smartphone owners in each age group who used
their phone for the following reasons at least once over
the course of 14 surveys spanning a one-week period

18-29

30-49

015
3/2
7/2

50+
93

Avoid being bored

, vi
Young users are particularly likely to use a
59
smartphone to avoid boredom — 46 ignore
and
12other people
.
No

e

d
we

0

Avoid others
around you

Find a good way
to get somewhere

82
55
47

32
15
57
37
33

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling
Younger users stand out especially prominently
survey, November 10-16 2014.
when it comes to using their phone for two
Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one
week (14 total surveys) and asked how they had used their phone in
purposes in particular: avoiding boredom, and
the preceding hour (besides completing the survey). Only those
avoiding people around them. Fully 93% of 18respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of
the study period are included in this analysis.
29 year old smartphone owners in the
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
experience sampling study used their phone at
least once to avoid being bored, with
respondents in this age group reporting that they did so in average of 5.4 surveys over the oneweek study period. Similarly, 47% of young smartphone owners used their phone to avoid
interacting with the people around them at least once during the study period, roughly three times
the proportion of older smartphone owners who did so.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 11 of 60

10
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Smartphones frequently inspire their owners to feel “productive” and “happy” — but can also
lead to distraction and frustration
When it comes to the emotions that people experience as a result of having a smartphone,
“productive” and “happy” lead the way—79% and 77% of smartphone owners, respectively,
indicated that their phone made them feel this way at least once over the course of the study
period. But smartphones do not always inspire positive feelings, as 57% of smartphone owners
reported feeling “distracted” thanks to their phone, and 36% reported that their phone made them
feel “frustrated.”
Younger smartphone owners tend to experience a wider range of these emotions compared with
older users—they are more likely to report feeling positive emotions like “happy” or “grateful,” but
also more likely to report negative emotions like “distracted” and “angry.”

More details about the data sources used in this report

015
3/2
7/2

This report is based on data from three different sources, each of which is discussed in more detail
below.

0
ed within the U.S. adult population (the
Basic findings on smartphone ownership and demographics
w
first section of Chapter One) are based on telephone surveys conducted December 4-7 and 18-21,
vie
2014 among 2,002 adults. These figures 9 overall smartphone ownership/usage were collected
5for,
-46
via telephone survey to make them consistent with past Pew Research Center measurements of
12
smartphone adoption. o. margin of error for the total sample of 2,002 adults is plus or minus 2.5
The
N
percentage points. For more details about this survey, see Appendix A.
Findings about how smartphone owners use their phones (the remainder of Chapter One, and
Chapter Two) are drawn from the October wave of the American Trends Panel, conducted October
3-27, 2014 among 3,181 respondents (2,875 by Web and 306 by mail), including 2,188 smartphone
owners. The margin of sampling error for the total sample of 2,188 smartphone owners is plus or
minus 2.7 percentage points. For more details about this survey, see Appendix B.
Data about how smartphone owners use their phones over the course of one week (Chapter 3) is
taken from the American Trends Panel “experience sampling” survey, conducted November 10-16,
2014 among 1,635 respondents. Respondents were asked to complete two surveys per day for
seven days (14 in total), using either an app they had installed on their phone (n=697) or by
completing a web survey (n=938). All findings in this report are based on respondents who
completed 10 or more surveys over the course of the week-long study period (n=1,035). The

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 12 of 60

11
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

margin of sampling error for smartphone owners who completed 10 or more surveys is plus or
minus 4.0 percentage points. For more details about this survey, see Appendix C.

d
we

e

, vi
659

4

12.
No

www.pewresearch.org

0

015
3/2
7/2

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 13 of 60

12
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Introduction
When the Pew Research Center began studying the social impact of the internet in 2000, the act of
going online was typically a stationary activity. Users would sit down at a computer, log in to the
internet (often using a dial-up connection), look up whatever information or services they were
interested in, and then continue with their lives.
Today, people increasingly are accessing online services and information throughout the day,
whenever and wherever they happen to be — and smartphones are often the primary vehicle for
this “on the go” access. Previous Pew Research surveys have examined a number of different
aspects of mobile phone ownership, from the activities that users engage in with their phones to
their attitudes about the benefits and limitations of their devices. Other surveys have found that
around one in ten Americans own a smartphone but lack traditional home broadband service, and
that roughly one in five cell phone owners conduct most of their online browsing using their cell
phone, rather than a computer or similar device.

015 of the state
This report builds on this existing body of research by conducting a deep examination
3/2
2
of smartphone ownership in America today.
07/
d
we ownership, how much users pay for
Chapter One discusses the demographics of smartphone
e
, vi devices, and their attitudes towards their
service, the problems they encounter in using their
59
phones. This chapter also focuses46 extent to which many users depend on their smartphones
on the
for online access, and the sometimes-tenuous nature of these mobile connections.
12.
No
Chapter Two looks more deeply at the ways in which smartphone owners use their phones to
access services and information, with a particular focus on news, community information, and
smartphones as a vehicle for navigating important life events (such as finding a new job or getting
information about a health condition).
Chapter Three is based on a time-use survey in which smartphone owners were tracked over the
course of one week and surveyed about how, where, and to what effect they were using their
phones. This analysis allows for a more fine-grained look at how smartphone owners use their
devices on a day-to-day basis, with a specific focus on differences between different age groups.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 14 of 60

13
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Chapter One: A Portrait of Smartphone Ownership
As smartphones have grown increasingly common in recent years, these devices have taken on a
central role in the information lives of a substantial number of Americans. And yet, those
Americans who rely most heavily on their smartphones as a gateway to online services and
information are often the ones whose connections to their devices are most tenuous. This chapter
of the report examines the general state of smartphone ownership in America today, with a focus
on how these devices fit into the digital access options available to their owners.

64% of Americans now own a smartphone, up from 58% in
early 2014
Nearly two-thirds of American adults (64%) now own a
smartphone of some kind, up from 58% in early 2014.
Smartphone ownership has increased by 29 percentage points
since Pew Research conducted its first survey of smartphone
ownership in the spring of 2011, when 35% of Americans were
smartphone owners.

Smartphone Ownership
Highest Among Young
Adults, Those With High
Income/Education Levels
% of U.S. adults in each group who own
a smartphone

015
3/2
7/2
All adults

64%
63

18-29

85

30-49

79

50-64

54

65+

27

White, non-Hispanic

61

Black, non-Hispanic

70

Hispanic

71
52

Some college

69

College+

78

Less than $30,000/yr

50

$30,000-$49,999

71

$50,000-$74,999

72
84

Urban

The cost of smartphone ownership

Female

$75,000 or more

Ownership levels remain particularly low among seniors, as
just 27% of Americans 65 and older now own a smartphone.
However, this does represent an 8-point increase in ownership
among seniors compared with early 2014.

66

HS grad or less

0
ed
As in past surveys, smartphone ownership is highest among
w
younger Americans, as well as those with relatively high income
vie
and education levels. Some 85% of Americans ages 18-29 are
59,
6
smartphone owners, as are 78% -4
of college graduates and 84%
. 12
of those living in households with an annual income of $75,000
o
or more per year. N

Male

68

Suburban
66
The ongoing monthly cost of smartphone ownership depends
Rural
52
heavily on the type of plan one has. Some 29% of smartphone
Combined analysis of Pew Research Center
owners are on an individual plan (which includes pre-paid
surveys conducted December 4-7 and 18-21,
plans), and most of these users spend less than $100 per month 2014.
on their cell phone bill: 34% of individual plan holders say that PEW RESEARCH CENTER

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 15 of 60

14
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

their monthly bill is less than $50, and 43% say that their bill is
between $50 and $100. Just 2% of smartphone owners on
individual plans pay $150 or more per month for service.
An additional 68% of smartphone owners belong to some sort of
group or family plan, and these services tend to be more
expensive on a monthly basis compared with individual plans.
Among group or family plan holders who are wholly responsible
for the cost of their monthly bill, 57% pay between $100 and $200
per month, and one-in-five (21%) pay $200 or more to maintain
their smartphone service.1

23% of smartphone owners have had to cancel or suspend
their service in the past due to financial constraints

How Much Smartphone
Owners Pay for Service
% of smartphone owners who pay
the following each month for their
cell phone service
Individual
Plan
34%

Group
Plan*
2%

$50-<$100

43

13

$100-<$150

14

31

$150-<$200

2

26

$200 or more

<1

21

<$50

Pew Research Center American Trends
Panel survey, October 3-27 2014. *Group
plan category includes only respondents
who personally pay their entire monthly
service cost themselves

015
3/2
7/2

For many smartphone owners, the ongoing cost of ownership can PEW RESEARCH CENTER
be a financial hardship: 23% have had to cancel or shut off their
cell phone service for a period of time because it was too expensive to maintain. These financial
challenges are especially common among lower-income smartphone owners, as fully 44% of
smartphone owners with an annual household income of less than $30,000 have had to let their
service lapse at some point or another.

d
we

e

, vi
659

0

4

12.
No

Along with lower-income users, African Americans and Latinos are around twice as likely as
whites to have canceled or cut off their smartphone service, and younger smartphone owners are
substantially more likely to have done so compared with older adults.
Lower-income smartphone owners tend to subscribe to relatively low-cost plans covering only
themselves as individuals rather than higher-cost group or family plans. Accordingly, individual
plan subscribers are around twice as likely to have canceled or cut back service as those on group
or family plans (34% of individual plan members and 18% of family plan members have done so),
and those with relatively low-cost plans are actually more likely to have canceled or suspended
service than those with more expensive plans.

1 Calculating the true “cost” of a group or family plan is complicated by the fact that survey respondents may not be wholly or even partially
responsible for the cost of their service. Some 57% of group or family plan members indicate that they pay for their entire smartphone bill
themselves; however, 24% are responsible for only a portion of their total monthly bill, while 19% say that the entirety of their monthly bill is
paid for by someone else. For the sake of simplicity, the cost figures discussed in this paragraph and the chart that follows refer only to those
family plan members who are personally responsible for the full cost of their monthly cell phone service.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 16 of 60

15
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Smartphone owners
encounter a range of
problems with their devices,
from functional to financial

Lower-income and Minority Smartphone Owners are
Especially Likely to Have Canceled or Cut Off Service
% of smartphone owners who have canceled or cut off service for a period of
time because maintaining their service was a financial burden

Smartphone owners encounter
a range of issues and
challenges when trying to use
their phones, some of which
relate to the physical function
of the phone itself. This survey
asked smartphone owners
about three such issues and
found that:

Total

23

18-29

32

30-49

25

50-64
65+

17
5

White

17

015
3/2
7/2

Black



42

49% of smartphone
Hispanic
36
owners experience content
HH Income $75k+
10
that they are trying to
access not displaying
HH Income $30k-<75k
20
properly on their phone at
HH Income <$30k
44
least on occasion, with 10%
saying that this happens to
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014.
them “frequently.”
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
47% experience poor or
dropped signal quality
that prevents them from using their phone, with 11% saying that this happens to them
“frequently.”
46% experience apps that they have downloaded not working correctly, with 9% experiencing
this “frequently.”

d
we

e

, vi
659

0

4





12.
No

Each of these issues impacts a fairly wide spectrum of smartphone owners, although certain
groups do report problems with apps not working correctly at somewhat elevated rates. These
include African Americans (55% of whom experience at least occasional problems with their
smartphone’s apps), those with relatively low household incomes (52% of those earning less than
$30,000 per year experience this), and those younger than 50 (half of smartphone owners ages 1849 have at least occasional problems with apps, compared with 39% of those 50 and older).

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 17 of 60

16
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Along with these questions about functional problems smartphone owners might face, the survey
also asked about three potential challenges relating to the financial cost or contractual constraints
of smartphone ownership and found that:






37% of smartphone owners reach the
maximum amount of data that they are
allowed to use as part of their plan at least
on occasion. Fully 15% of smartphone
owners say that this happens to them
“frequently.”
27% at least occasionally encounter a
monthly bill that is substantially higher than
they expected it to be, with 7% saying that
this happens to them “frequently.”
9% experience unexpected charges from inapp purchases at least occasionally. Just 2%
of smartphone owners say that this happens
“frequently,” and 60% indicate that this
never happens to them.

Many Smartphone Owners Experience
Higher Than Expected Bills, Reaching of
Data Caps
% of smartphone owners who experience the following
“frequently” or “occasionally”

All smartphone owners

Reach max Monthly bill
amount of much higher
data allowed than expected
37%
27%

18-29

48

32

30-49

38

27

50-64

25

65+

/
/23
7

White, non-Hispanic

d0

Black, non-Hispanic

vie
,more
These financial and contractual limitations
59
consistently impact non-whites, -46 users,
younger
2
and those with relatively . 1
low household incomes.
Roughly one-third of African American and
No

we

Hispanic

015
2

22

19

21

31

22

43

36

49

34

HS grad or less

43

30

Some college

35

28

College+

32

22

Less than $30,000/yr

43

28

$30,000-$74,999

35

28

$75,000 or more

32

24

Latino smartphone owners experience much
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27
2014.
higher-than-expected monthly bills at least on
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
occasion, and about one-in-ten indicate that
surprisingly high bills happen to them
“frequently.” Similarly, 43% of black smartphone owners, 49% of Latinos, and 48% of those ages
18-29 say that they reach the maximum amount of data they are allowed to use on their plan at
least occasionally, with around one-in-five from each group indicating that this happens to them
frequently.

The “smartphone-dependent” population: 7% of Americans own a smartphone, but indicate
a shortage of other online access options — either at home or elsewhere
Many smartphone owners have ample options at their disposal when they need to go online: 85%
have a high-speed broadband connection at home, 87% own a desktop or laptop computer, and

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 18 of 60

17
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

53% own a tablet computer in addition to their smartphone. At the same time, smartphones serve
as a crucial connection point to the broader world of online information for many Americans.
The survey measured this reliance on smartphones for online access in two different ways — first,
by asking smartphone owners whether or not they have traditional broadband service at home,
and second, whether they have a reasonable number of options for accessing the internet in
general — and found that:



10% of Americans own a smartphone but do not have any other form of high-speed internet
access at home beyond their phone’s data plan.
Using a broader measure of the access options available to them, 15% of Americans own a
smartphone but say that they have a limited number of options for going online other than
their cell phone.2

015
3/2
7/2

In all, 19% of Americans fall into one or the other of these categories, and 7% of the public
indicates that both conditions apply to them — that is, they own a smartphone but lack any other
type of high-speed access at home, and have limited options for going online other than their cell
phone. Throughout this report, we will refer to this 7% of Americans as “smartphone-dependent”
users.

d
we

0

ie
, vrely especially heavily on smartphones for online
Demographically, several groups of Americans
659
access. These include:
4
12.
 Those with low household incomes and low levels of educational attainment —
No





Some 13% of Americans with an annual household income of less than $30,000 per year are
smartphone-dependent, and 9% of those with a high school diploma or less fall into this
category as well. By comparison, just 1% of Americans from households with an annual income
of $75,000 or more depend on their smartphone for internet access to a similar degree.
Younger adults — Fully 15% of Americans ages 18-29 are heavily dependent on a
smartphone for online access (20% of have a smartphone but not traditional broadband
service, and 25% have a smartphone but have relatively limited options for going online
otherwise).
Non-whites — 12% of African Americans and 13% of Latinos are smartphone-dependent,
compared with just 4% of whites.

2

These two questions were asked only of smartphone owners: 15% of smartphone owners indicate that they do not have broadband
service at home, and 21% indicate that they have limited options for online access other than their smartphone. The October 2014
wave of the American Trends Panel found that 68% of Americans are smartphone owners, and that 68% ownership figure was used to
derive the “general population” results cited in this section of the report.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 19 of 60

18
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

In addition to their
demographic differences, these
smartphone-dependent users
also differ substantially from
the rest of the smartphone
adopter population in terms of
the technology devices they
own and financial assets they
possess. Compared with other
smartphone owners, they are
less likely to own a traditional
computer (50% do so,
compared with 91% of other
smartphone owners) or tablet
(27% vs. 56%); less likely to
have a bank account (63% vs.
91%); and less likely to be
covered by health insurance
(71% vs. 87%). They are also
less likely to own their current
residence, and more likely to
rent or to live with a friend or
family member.

Young Adults, Non-Whites, Lower Income Americans
are Especially Dependent on Smartphones for Online
Access
% of American adults in each group who have a smartphone but lack
broadband at home, or have limited options for online access other than their
cell phone
% who have a smartphone and…
Do not have Have few access
Total
broadband at
options other
“Smartphonehome
than cell phone Dependent”*
10%
15%
7%

All adults
Male

10

12

Female

11

18

8

18-29

20

25

15

30-49

11

16

6

50-64

6

11

4

65+

4

7

2

12

4

/
/23
7

White, non-Hispanic

7

d0

Black, non-Hispanic

19

12

17

23

13

15

19

9

10

16

7

College+

4

7

2

Less than $30,000/yr

19

24

13

$30,000-$74,999

8

14

5

$75,000 or more

3

5

1

we

Hispanic

e
, vi
659

HS grad or less
Some college

4

12.
No

21

015
2

5

Urban
12
17
8
Perhaps unsurprisingly given
Suburban
9
14
6
their demographic profile,
Rural
11
14
7
many of these smartphonePew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014. *”Smartphone
dependent users gravitate
dependent” users are those who own a smartphone but have no broadband at home, and
towards relatively low-cost
have limited access options beyond their cell phone.
plans: among those who pay for PEW RESEARCH CENTER
at least some portion of their
plan, 27% say that their monthly bill is less than $50. But at the same time, many devote fairly
substantial resources towards maintaining their cell phone service: 29% spend between $100 and
$200 per month, and 5% say that their monthly bill is $200 or more.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 20 of 60

19
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Smartphone ownership is often most financially tenuous for the subset of users who
depend on their mobile devices most heavily
Even as a sizeable number of Americans indicate that their phone plays a central role in their
ability to access digital services and online content, for many of these users this access is tenuous
thanks to a combination of financial constraints and technical limitations.
In terms of financial
constraints, fully 48% of
smartphone-dependent
Americans have had to cancel
or shut off their cell phone
service for a period of time
because the cost of
maintaining that service was a
financial hardship. That is
double the rate among those
who have broadband at home
and/or ample alternate access
options (just 17% of these
smartphone owners have had
to cancel or suspend their
service).

Smartphone Ownership is Often Most Tenuous for
Those Who Rely on Their Devices the Most
% of smartphone owners in each group who have experienced the following
"Smartphone-dependent"
Have had to cancel or
suspend service due to
financial constraints
Frequently/occasionally reach
maximum data allowed on
smartphone plan

48
21

015
3/2
7/2

d0

e

w
vie

Other smartphone owners

51
35

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014. “Smartphone
dependent” users lack broadband service at home, and/or have limited options for internet
access other than their cell phone.

59,
46

12.
No
In addition, 30% of smartphone-dependent Americans “frequently” reach the maximum amount
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

of data that they are allowed to consume as part of their cell phone plan, and 51% say that this
happens to them at least occasionally. Each of these figures is significantly higher than those
reported by other smartphone owners.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 21 of 60

20
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Chapter Two: Usage and Attitudes Toward Smartphones
Smartphones often serve as a go-to source for staying informed about breaking news and
community happenings, getting from place to place, conducting transactions, and navigating life
events such as finding a new job or getting information about a health condition. This chapter of
the report looks in more detail at the specific activities that smartphone owners engage in, and the
types of information that they seek out on their mobile devices.

Smartphone owners use their phones to access a wide range of services and information
One key objective of this study was to determine the extent to which smartphone owners turn to
their phones to access services or information pertaining to important life events, such as applying
for a job, addressing a health issue, or finding a
new place to live. The survey asked whether or
More Than Half of Smartphone Owners
not they had accessed several different types of
Have Used Their Phone to Get Health
information or services within the past year
Information or Do Online Banking
using their cell phone, and found that:
% of smartphone owners who have used their phone to

015
3/2
7/2

do the following in the last year











62% of smartphone owners have used their
phone in the last year to look up
information about a health condition.
57% have used their phone to do online
banking.
44% have used their phone to look up real
estate listings or other information about a
place to live.
43% to look up information about a job.
40% to look up government services or
information.
30% to take a class or get educational
content.
18% to submit a job application.

.
No

4
12-

e
, vi
659

d
we

0

Get info about a
health condition

62

Do online banking

57

Look up real estate
listings or info about a
place to live

44

Look up info about a job

43

Look up government
services or info

40

Take a class or get
educational content
Submit a job
application

30
18

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27
2014.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 22 of 60

21
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Lower income and smartphone-dependent users rely especially heavily on their
smartphones for job and employment resources
Lower-income and higher-income smartphone owners obtain certain types of information (health,
education, or government content, for example) on their phone at similar rates, and higherincome users are a bit more likely to use their phone for real estate searches or to engage in online
banking. However, lower-income users are substantially more likely to utilize their phone when
seeking out and applying for jobs.
Compared with smartphone owners from households earning $75,000 or more per year,
smartphone owners from households earning less than $30,000 annually are nearly twice as likely
to use their phone to look for information about a job—and more than four times as likely to use
their phone to actually submit a job application. Just 7% of smartphone owners from higherincome households have
Lower-income Smartphone Owners Much More Likely
applied for a job using their
to Use Their Phone for Job Seeking
phone in the last year, but 32%
% of smartphone owners in each income category who have used their phone
of smartphone owners from
in the last year to…
lower-income households have
HH income <$30k
HH income $75k+
done so.
Similarly, “smartphonedependent” users (that is, the
9% of smartphone owners who
lack another form of highspeed access, and also have
limited internet access options
besides their smartphone) are
much more likely than other
smartphone owners to utilize
their phone as part of a job
search. Some 63% of these
smartphone-dependent users
have gotten job information on
their phone in the last year,
and 39% have used their
phone to submit a job
application.

d
we

e

, vi
659

4

12.
No

015
3/2
7/2

0

Get information about a
health condition

63
59
51

Do online banking

62
39

Look up real estate or info
about a place to live

46
58

Get information about a job

32

Look up government services
or information

38
41
33
30

Take a class or watch
educational content
Submit a job application

32
7

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 23 of 60

22
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Younger adults use their smartphones to access a wide range of services and content
Where lower-income and smartphonedependent users stand out primarily when it
comes to using their phone for job resources
and information, young adults incorporate
mobile devices into a host of information
seeking and transactional behaviors at a higher
level than older users.

Young Adults Rely Heavily on Their
Smartphones for Job Seeking,
Educational Content, and Health
Information
% of smartphone owners in each age group who have
used their phone in the last year to do the following

Three-quarters of 18-29 year old smartphone
owners have used their phone in the last year to
get information about a health condition;
seven-in-ten have used their phone to do online
banking or to look up information about job;
44% have consumed educational content on
their phone; and 34% have used their phone to
apply for a job. In each instance, these young
adults are significantly more likely than
smartphone owners in other age groups to use
their phone for these reasons.

9, v

5
-46
Nearly one-in-three smartphone owners
. 12
frequently use their phone for navigation or
No
turn-by-turn driving directions; one-in-ten
use it frequently for public transit
information

Smartphones play an important role in helping
their owners navigate their environment and
get where they need to go, especially as a
mobile GPS for real-time driving directions:




18-29

30-49

50+

Info about a
health condition

39

Online banking

015
3/2
7/2

Real estate info

d0

34

44

29

Educational
content

14

4

16

77

72

54
51

17

Gov't services or
information

Submit a job
application

65

26

Info about a job

e
ew
i

68

34

69

43
46
44

34

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27
2014.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

67% of smartphone owners use their phone at least occasionally for turn-by-turn navigation
while driving, with 31% saying that they do this “frequently.”
25% use their phone at least occasionally to get public transit information, with 10% doing this
“frequently.”
11% use their phone at least occasionally to reserve a taxi or car service. Just 4% do so
frequently, and 72% of smartphone owners never use their phone for this purpose.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 24 of 60

23
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Each of these behaviors is especially prevalent among younger smartphone owners. Fully 80% of
smartphone owners ages 18-29 use their phone at least occasionally for turn-by-turn driving
directions; 38% do so to get public transit information; and 17% do so to reserve a taxi or car
service. Each of these is substantially higher than among smartphone owners in other age groups,
although turn-by-turn driving assistance is relatively common across a range of ages.
Whites, blacks, and Latinos
are equally likely to use their
smartphones for turn-by-turn
driving directions and to
reserve a taxi or car service,
but African American and
Latino smartphone owners
look up public transit
information on their phone at
much higher rates than whites
do (37% of black smartphone
owners, 30% of Latinos, and
21% of whites do this at least
on occasion).

Young Adults are Especially Likely to Use Their Phone
for Navigation – Either by Car, Public Transit, or Taxi
% of smartphone owners in each age group who use their phone
frequently/occasionally for…

18-29

30-49

50-64

65+

80
72

015
3/2
7/2

52
37

4

59,
6

12.
No

d
we

vie

0

38

24
17

16
9

9

7

5

Residents of the transit-dense
Turn-by-turn navigation
Get public transit info
Reserve taxi or car svc
Northeast are also especially
likely to access public transit
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014.
information on a smartphone.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
Fully 41% of smartphone
owners who live in the
Northeast get public transit information on their phone at least occasionally, with 19% doing so
“frequently.” By contrast, just 23% of westerners—and 20% of Midwesterners and southerners—
use their phone for this purpose at least occasionally, and roughly six-in-ten Midwesterners and
Southerners say that they “never” use their phone to navigate public transit.

A majority of smartphone owners use their phone to follow along with breaking news, and
to share and be informed about happenings in their local community
A substantial majority of smartphone owners use their phone to follow along with news events
near and far, and to share details of local happenings with others:

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 25 of 60

24
PEW RESEARCH CENTER





68% of smartphone owners use their phone at least occasionally to follow along with breaking
news events, with 33% saying that they do this “frequently.”
67% use their phone to share pictures, videos, or commentary about events happening in
their community, with 35% doing so frequently.
56% use their phone at least occasionally to learn about community events or activities, with
18% doing this “frequently.”

Using smartphones to keep up
with breaking news, and to
share or learn about local
happenings, are each common
across a relatively wide range
of demographic groups.
Smartphone owners age 65
and older are among the
groups that are least likely to
engage in these behaviors;
even so, four in ten older
smartphone owners use their
phone at least occasionally to
keep up with breaking news,
while half use them to share
information about local
happenings, and one third use
them to stay abreast of events
and activities in their
community.

Using One’s Phone for News and Community Info is
Popular Across a Range of Ages
% of smartphone owners in each age group who use their phone
frequently/occasionally to…

18-29

72

30-49

75

9, v
65

0
ed

iew
42

65+

015
3/2
7/2

73
61

50-64

70

60

60

64

52

45
35

4

12.
No

Follow breaking news

Share info about local
events

Learn about community
events

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

In addition, some 8% of
smartphone owners use their phone at least occasionally to make a monetary donation to a
charitable or political cause. Just 2% do so frequently, and 77% of smartphone owners say that
they never use their phone for this purpose. Overall there are very few demographic differences
when it comes to using one’s smartphone to make a political or charitable contribution.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 26 of 60

25
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

17% of smartphone owners have used their phone to report a problem in their
neighborhood
Along with using their phone to share and keep up with neighborhood happenings, 17% of
smartphone owners have used their phone to report a problem in their neighborhood (such as a
pothole or missing street sign) to the local authorities.
Those with some college education or a college degree are more likely to have done this with their
phone than those who have not attended college (20% vs. 12%), and usage of smartphones for this
purpose is more common among 50-64 year olds (22% have done so) than among those ages 1829 (14%) or 65 and older (13%).

Half of smartphone owners have used their phone to get help in an emergency situation
Fully 53% of smartphone owners indicate that
they have been in an emergency situation where
having their phone available helped resolve the
situation.3 Smartphone owners in various
demographic groups have encountered this
situation at relatively high rates, although
younger owners are especially likely to have used
their phone in an emergency (59% of 18-29 year
old smartphone owners have experienced this).

How Smartphones Help in Emergencies

4
12.
When asked to describe a recent emergency in
No proved helpful,
which having a smartphone

0

50%

Report a possible crime

14

Medical emergency / call doctor

8

911 / emergency call (general)

5

Lost / stranded / need directions

3

Fire, gas leak, water leak

3

Locked out of house

2

d
we

e
, vi
659

015
3/2
7/2

53% of smartphone owners have used their phone to get
help in an emergency situation; here are some recent
situations they describe
Car accident / flat tire / roadside assistance

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27

2014.
scenarios involving cars or driving were by far
the most commonly-mentioned situation: 50% of PEW RESEARCH CENTER
those who have used their phone to resolve an
emergency said that their recent experience involved a car accident, flat tire, roadside assistance,
or other automotive emergency. These are a few representative quotes from their responses:




“A car accident happened right in front of me and both drivers involved in the accident did not
have their cell phones with them.”
“Car broke down on freeway. Used my cell to call AAA and to obtain rental car, where they
picked me up right there on the freeway. I also called a garage to arrange repairs to my
vehicle.”

3

A 2011 survey found that 43% of smartphone owners had used their phone for help in an emergency situation in the preceding 30
days. See http://www.pewinternet.org/2011/08/15/focus-on-smartphone-owners/ for more information

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 27 of 60

26
PEW RESEARCH CENTER




“Got a flat tire in the middle of the interstate, called AAA and looked up nearest store to
replace the tire.”
“I had a flat tire on the freeway at night, without my cell phone I would have been terrified.”

An additional 14% of those who have been helped by their smartphone in an emergency said that
they witnessed or experienced a potential crime and used their phone to get help or notify the
authorities, while 8% described a recent experience in which their phone was helpful in a medical
emergency.

44% of smartphone owners have had a problem doing something they needed to do
because they didn’t have their phone with them
Reliance on smartphones can also have an
unintended downside, as 44% of smartphone
owners have experienced a situation in which
they had a hard time accomplishing some sort of
task because they did not happen to have their
cell phone with them.4 When asked to describe a
recent time that this happened to them, the
largest group (representing 25% of those who
have experienced the situation) mentioned
having trouble getting somewhere because they
didn’t have their phone to look up an address or
get directions.

59,
46

12.

No

Here are some quotes from people in this
situation:






What People Have Trouble Doing
Without Their Smartphones

015
3/2
7/2

44% of smartphone owners have had trouble doing
something because their phone wasn’t with them; here
are some recent situations they describe

0
ed

Getting directions or finding an address

w
vie

25%

Trying to meet someone / let someone know
you’re running late
Call someone or get in touch with others
(general)
Look up online info or complete online
transaction

13

Access email, calendar, or address book

9

Get help in an emergency

8

Shopping (forgot list, needed advice, etc)

6

Online banking

2

Work-related tasks

2

10
9

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27

“I was going somewhere for the first time and 2014.
needed a GPS system, but I had left my
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
phone at home.”
“Finding the location of a business when staying in a new town.”
“I left my cell behind and ran into a detour in an unfamiliar area while low on gas. I had to find
my way without a map or my phone for the first time in many years.”
“I was trying to use the Chicago public transit system to travel from a restaurant back to a
friend's apartment. I would usually use my cell phone to get directions.”

4

A 2011 survey found that 34% of smartphone owners had trouble doing something without their phone in the preceding 30 days. See
http://www.pewinternet.org/2011/08/15/focus-on-smartphone-owners/ for more information

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 28 of 60

27
PEW RESEARCH CENTER




“I'm a chauffeur for a limousine business in a suburban county. If I don't have my cell phone
with me I cannot find a lot of the places that I need to go because I use it for my navigation.”
“Left to pick up take out, knew general location of restaurant but assumed I could use phone to
find exact spot when close. Drove around for a long time before finding it.”

Another 13% mentioned how they have had trouble coordinating with other people because they
didn’t have their cell phone handy:





“I couldn’t let someone know I would be late for an appointment.”
“I did not know where my son was and had no way to be in touch with him to see if he was
OK.”
“Needing to find my child in a crowded store.”
“Did not know when or where to meet my ride, because I was accustomed to having them call
me when it was time to pick me up.”
“I couldn’t tell my boss I was running late due to traffic.”

15
0information, and 9%
One in ten (9%) described being unable to look up a specific piece of3/2
online
/2 address book, or email but
mentioned a situation in which they needed to access their calendar,
7
d0
didn’t have their phone available:
e
ew
vi
 “Couldn’t find the answer to a group 9,
question.”
5 on Google
 “Needed to look up a medical 46
-conditionticket could but phone was not available.” from a
 “I couldn't enter a concert because my
only be scanned by the barcode
. 12
o
phone.”
N









“Couldn't look up severe weather conditions/forecast when in wilderness.”
“I rely on my phone for keeping track of the time of my appointments.”
“I was unable to see my calendar and couldn't tell if I already had an appointment for that time
when trying to make another.”
“Trying to check and return a work email on the road.”
“My phone truly is an extension of me and assists me in performing various tasks.”

Shopping-related issues are also relatively common, as 6% described having trouble shopping
without their phone — either because their shopping list was on the phone itself, because they
needed to call someone for assistance, or because they wanted to look up additional information
on a product while they were in the store:


“I wasn't able to make an informed decision on purchasing an item because I couldn't compare
prices.”

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 29 of 60

28
PEW RESEARCH CENTER





“I forgot my phone at home and when I got to the store I couldn't remember everything I was
supposed to be getting, so it took two trips to get what I needed.”
“Grocery shopping—did not have access to my grocery list and left my cell phone on the table
as I left the house. UGH!!!”
“I was at the store and wanted to check if my spouse needed anything, but had forgotten my
phone so could not contact him.”

How smartphone owners view their phones: freeing, connecting, helpful, and generally
worth the cost — but not always essential
When asked how they feel about their phones, smartphone owners paint a generally positive
picture — connecting rather than distracting, helpful rather than frustrating, and ultimately worth
the cost of ownership. But despite these benefits, users are fairly evenly divided on whether or not
their phone is an essential component of their lives that they could not possibly live without.

015
3/2
7/2

The survey presented smartphone owners with a series of phrases that might describe their phone,
and asked them to choose the
one that most closely matches
Despite Clear Benefits, 54% of Smartphone Owners
Say Their Phone is “Not Always Needed”—but 46% Say
how they themselves feel. The
choices presented to them, and it is Something They “Couldn’t Live Without”
% of smartphone owners who say that the following items from each pair
their responses to those
best describe how they feel about their phone
choices, are discussed in more
detail below.

d
we

e

, vi
659

0

4

12.
No vs.
“Not always needed”

“Couldn’t live without” —
Smartphone owners are nearly
evenly divided on this question;
54% say that their phone is “not
always needed,” while 46% say
that it is something they
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27 2014.
“couldn’t live without.” Women PEW RESEARCH CENTER
and African Americans have
higher than average levels of attachment: half of female smartphone owners (52%) say that their
phone is something that they couldn’t live without (compared with 39% of men), as do 57% of
African American smartphone owners (compared with 46% of whites).

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 30 of 60

29
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Interestingly, responses to this question are not correlated with whether or not someone has
plentiful access options beyond their cell phone. Some 49% of smartphone-dependent Americans
say that their phone is “something they couldn’t live without,” nearly identical to the 46% of users
with more plentiful access options who say the same. Indeed, there are a notable lack of
differences between smartphone-dependent users and other smartphone owners across all of
these choice pairs.
“Freedom” vs. “Leash” — A substantial majority of smartphone owners (70%) feel that their
phone represents “freedom,” while 30% feel that it represents a “leash.” Older adults are actually
more likely than younger users to find their smartphones freeing: 78% of smartphone owners over
the age of 50 say that their phone represents “freedom,” compared with 66% of those ages 18-49.
Similarly, 34% of 18-49 year olds say that their phone represents a “leash” (compared with 21% of
those 50 and older).
“Connecting” vs. “Distracting” – As with
the “freedom” vs. “leash” choice pair, a
substantial majority of smartphone owners (by
a 72% to 28% margin) feel that their phone is
“connecting” rather than “distracting.” This
question also exhibits a relatively pronounced
age split, with younger adults being more likely
to describe their phone as “distracting.” Some
37% of 18-29 year olds selected the “distracting”
option, compared with 29% of 30-49 year olds
and 18% of those 50 and older.

.
No

“Helpful” vs. “Annoying” – Fully 93% of
smartphone owners describe their phone as
“helpful,” while just 7% feel that “annoying” is a
better descriptor. There is very little variation in
the responses to this question, as every
demographic group chooses “helpful” by an
overwhelming margin.

% of smartphone owners who say their phone is “worth
the cost” vs. a “financial burden”, by cost of monthly
service plan

d
we

e

, vi
659

4
12-

015
3/2
7/2

Pricier Smartphone Plans More Likely to
be Seen as a Financial Burden

0

16

84

<$100

26

29

"Financial
burden"

74

71

"Worth the
cost"

$100-$199

$200+

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel survey, October 3-27
2014.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

“Worth the cost” vs. “Financial burden” – A substantial majority of smartphone owners
(80%) describe their phone as “worth the cost,” although one-in-five (19%) describe it as a
“financial burden.” There is relatively little variation across demographic groups on this question,
although users with expensive service plans are more likely to say that the cost of maintaining

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 31 of 60

30
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

their service is a financial burden. Fully 29% of those who pay more than $200 per month for their
cell phone service describe their plan as a financial burden, compared with 16% of users whose
plan costs less than $100 per month.

d
we

e

, vi
659

4

12.
No

www.pewresearch.org

0

015
3/2
7/2

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 32 of 60

31
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Chapter Three: A “Week in the Life” Analysis of Smartphone
Users
Pew Research Center technology surveys (such as those that form the basis of Chapters 1 and 2 of
this report) typically ask respondents whether they use various devices or online platforms, the
ways in which they incorporate those tools and platforms into their lives, and the impact of those
technologies on their attitudes and experiences. These traditional survey methodologies can help
provide a broad view of the use and impact of technology among the American public. But survey
respondents often have trouble remembering and providing precise details of their day-to-day
lives—such as the number of times they have taken a particular action in the course of a week.
In an effort to gain a more fine-grained view into the ways that smartphone owners use their
devices on a daily basis, Pew Research conducted a week-long survey of smartphone owners. In
this survey, respondents were contacted on multiple occasions (by email, text message, and/or via
an app installed on the respondent’s phone) and asked a short series of questions about how they
had used their phone in the hour prior to taking the survey. This type of survey, in which
respondents are asked about their experiences or behaviors at specific times over the course of the
study period, is known as an “experience sampling” survey.

d
we

e

, vi
659

015
3/2
7/2

0

These findings provide a unique glimpse into several different aspects of smartphone ownership,
such as:




4
12- are the most widespread within the smartphone owner
Which behaviors and.
experiences
No ones are used or experienced by the largest subset of users over the
population (that is, which
course of a typical week).
Which behaviors and experiences are the most frequently used among smartphone owners
(that is, which ones occur with the greatest regularity throughout the course of the week).

Details of the study, and the findings from this week-long survey of smartphone users, are
discussed in more detail below.

How Pew Research conducted this experience sampling survey of smartphone owners
Participants in the experience sampling study were recruited from the 2,188 smartphone owners
who responded to the American Trends Panel survey that forms the basis of Chapters 1 and 2 of
this report. Upon completion of the main survey, these respondents were asked if they would be
willing to take part in a follow-up study, in which they would complete a series of short surveys
about their smartphone use over a period of one week.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 33 of 60

32
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Respondents who agreed to take part in the follow-up study were contacted twice a day for a
period of seven days. Each time, they were asked a short series of questions about how they had
used their smartphone in the hour prior to taking the survey. Specifically, they were asked to
indicate the features or apps they had used on their phone; the locations where they had used
their phone; the issues or problems they had used their phone to solve; and the emotions they felt
as a result of having their phone with them.
The specific times on which the individual surveys were administered are listed below:








Day 1 (Monday, November 10 2014): 8am and 3pm
Day 2 (Tuesday): 9am and 4pm
Day 3 (Wednesday): 10am and 5pm
Day 4 (Thursday): 11am and 6pm
Day 5 (Friday): Noon and 7pm
Day 6 (Saturday): 1pm and 8pm
Day 7 (Sunday, November 16 2014): 2pm and 9pm

015
3/2
2
A total of 1,635 respondents completed at least one survey over the course of the week-long study
07/ who completed 10 or more
period. The analysis that follows is based on the 1,035ed
w participants
surveys over the study period.
e
, vi
659
For a more detailed description of the study methodology, please see the Study Methods section of
4
12this report.
.
No
5

The first question in the survey asked respondents to indicate which apps and features they had
used on their phone in the preceding hour, apart from answering the survey. These findings
indicate that certain features are used nearly universally and relatively frequently among a diverse
range of smartphone owners, including text messaging, voice and video calls, internet use, and
email. Other features are extremely popular among certain groups of users but less widely-used
among others. For example, social media, listening to music, and watching video are all extremely
common among younger smartphone owners but less common among older age groups. A third
category of features are less prevalent overall but appeal to a relatively wide cross-section of users,
such as gaming and news consumption.

The “ten or more completions” cutoff point was chosen to ensure that the reporting in this section was conducted on a reasonably
consistent group of respondents. Demographically, the group discussed in this report differs only marginally from the entire pool of 1,635
respondents.
5

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 34 of 60

33
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

The “Big Four” smartphone apps and features: text messaging, voice calls, internet use,
and email

Text Messaging, Voice/Video Calls, Internet, Email
Rank Among Most Popular Smartphone Features

Four smartphone features —
text messaging, voice and video
calling, using email, and using
the internet — stand out as the
most widely used out of the
eleven apps and features
evaluated in this study. Nearly
all of the smartphone owners
surveyed (97%) used text
messaging at least once over
the course of the study period.
Text messaging is followed
closely in popularity by voice
calling (engaged in by 92% of
smartphone owners), using the
internet (89%), and using
email (88%).

d
we

e

, vi
659

015
3/2
7/2

0

4

In addition to being the most
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling survey, November 10-16
widely-used smartphone
2014.
feature, text messaging is also
Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one week (14 total surveys)
and asked how they had used their phone in the preceding hour (besides completing the
the most frequently-used.
survey). Only those respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of the
These smartphone owners
study period are included in this analysis.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
reported using text messaging
in the past hour in an average
of 7 different surveys over the course of the study period (out of a maximum of 14). By comparison,
they reported using email in an average of 5.3 surveys, internet use in an average of 4.4 surveys,
and voice/video calling in an average of 4.1 surveys.

12.
No

These smartphone features are also popular with users from a wide range of age groups. For
example, 100% of 18-29 year old smartphone owners used text messaging at least once over the
course of the study,6 but so did 92% of those 50 and older. These age-related differences are even
more modest for email (91% of 18-29 year olds and 87% of those 50 and older used email at least
A total of n=202 smartphone owners ages 18-29 completed at least 10 surveys over the course of the week-long study period. Out of these
202 respondents, just one respondent did not use text messaging at least once over the course of the week.
6

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 35 of 60

34
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

once) and voice/video calling (93% of 18-29 year olds did this, as did 93% of those 50 and older).
Internet use, though quite common among older adults, is near-ubiquitous among younger users—
fully 97% of 18-29 year old smartphone owners used their phone to go online at least once during
the study period, compared to 80% of those 50 and older.
As with teens, text messaging supplements —
rather than replaces — voice calling among
adults
Pew Research surveys of teens and technology
have found that voice calling and text
messaging go hand in hand, and this correlation
also holds true for the adult population: Put
simply, adults who do more text messaging
tend to do more voice calling as well.
Smartphone owners who use text messaging
relatively infrequently (defined as reporting text
messaging use in 1-5 surveys over the course of
this study period) reported making voice calls
in an average of 2.6 surveys; those who use text
messaging moderately frequently (in 6-10
surveys) reported making voice calls in an
average of 4.3 surveys; and those who use text
messaging very frequently (in 11 or more
surveys) reported making voice calls in an
average of 6.4 surveys.

.
No

Text Messaging, Internet, Email, and
Voice/Video Calls are Widely-Used by
Smartphone Owners of Many Ages
% of smartphone owners in each age group who used the
following features on their phone at least once over the
course of 14 surveys spanning a one-week period

18-29

Text messaging

50+
100

015
2

98
92
97

Internet use

e

, vi
659

4
12-

d
we

/
/23
07

30-49

90
80
93

Voice/video calls

91
94
91

Email

87
87

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling
Similarly, young adults use text messaging
survey, November 10-16 2014.
more frequently than older adults—but do not
Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one
week (14 total surveys) and asked how they had used their phone in
exhibit corresponding lower rates of voice
the preceding hour (besides completing the survey). Only those
calling. Smartphones owners ages 18-29
respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of
the study period are included in this analysis.
reported using text messaging in nearly two
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
more surveys over the course of the study
period compared with those ages 50 and older—
young adults reported using text messaging in an average of 7.8 surveys, while those 50 and older
did so in an average of 6 surveys. But despite these fairly pronounced differences in text messaging
frequency, rates of voice calling for older and younger smartphone owners are nearly identical:

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 36 of 60

35
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

young adults reported using voice calling in an average of 3.9 surveys over the course of the study,
while those age 50 and older did so in an average of 4.2 surveys.

Disproportionately popular with young people: Social networking, watching videos,
listening to music/podcasts
Activities such as social networking, watching video, and listening to music or podcasts vary
substantially in terms of their overall popularity. At the high end, 75% of smartphone owners
indicated using social networking on their phone in the previous hour at least once during the
study period, while on the low end 41% used their phone at least once to listen to music or
podcasts. But although they differ in terms of their overall usage rates, they share the common
characteristic of having especially high rates of engagement among younger smartphone owners.
Young smartphone owners are particularly avid
participants in social media activities. Fully 91%
of smartphone owners ages 18-29 used social
networking on their phone at least once over
the course of the study period, compared with
55% of those 50 and older (a 36-point
difference). These young smartphone owners
reported using social networking on their
phone in the prior hour in an average of 5.6
surveys, which is tied with internet use as the
second-most frequent smartphone behavior
among young adults.

015
3/2
7/2

% of smartphone owners in each age group who used the
following features on their phone at least once over the
course of 14 surveys spanning a one-week period

d
we

e

, vi
659

4

12.
No

Use of Smartphones for Social Media,
Video Watching, and Music/Podcasts is
Especially Common Among Young Users

0

18-29

30-49

50+
91

Social
networking

77
55
75

These differences between older and younger
smartphone owners are even more pronounced
when it comes to watching videos and listening
to music or podcasts. Three-quarters of younger
smartphone owners (75%) used their phone to
watch a video at least once over the study
period, compared with 31% of those 50 and
older (a difference of 44 percentage points).
And 64% of younger adults used their phone at
one time or another to listen to music or
podcasts—a 43-point difference compared with
the 21% of older users who did so.

Watching video

46
31
64
39

Music or podcasts
21

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling
survey, November 10-16 2014.
Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one
week (14 total surveys) and asked how they had used their phone in
the preceding hour (besides completing the survey). Only those
respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of
the study period are included in this analysis.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 37 of 60

36
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Other activities and apps: News, games, maps/traffic, and taking pictures or video
The remaining apps and activities (news, games, maps and navigation, and taking pictures or
video) occupy a middle ground between the two groups discussed above. They are not as widely
used as activities like text messaging or voice calling—but they also exhibit more modest
differences across age groups compared with activities like social networking.
Of this group of activities, picture-taking and news consumption are the most common: 60% of
smartphone owners used their phones for taking pictures or video at least once over the course of
the study period, and 55% used their phone for news over the same time period. Games and
maps/traffic are slightly less common: 47% and 41% of smartphone owners, respectively, used
their phone for these purposes at least once in the course of the study period.
Each of these behaviors is more prevalent among younger smartphone owners than among older
users, although these differences are generally modest in comparison with activities like social
networking. There is a 16-point gap between those ages 18-29 and those 50 and older when it
comes to using one’s phone for games; a 13-point gap for taking pictures and video; an 11-point
gap for using maps and navigation; and an 8-point gap for getting news.

d
we

015
3/2
7/2

0

ve
,widei range of locations during the experience sampling
Smartphone owners used their phones in a
59
survey, but home was by far the -46common—99% of smartphone owners in this study used
most
their phone at home at least once during the previous hour over the course of the study period,
. 12
reporting that they did so in an average of 6.8 surveys over the week.
No
Many smartphone owners use their phones while in a car or on public transit (82% indicated
having done so at least once), and usage at work is also common (69% used their phone at work at
least once). Notably, not all the study participants are employed full-time—among those who are,
fully 91% used their smartphone at work over the study period, reporting doing so in an average of
4.3 separate surveys.
Usage of smartphones in locations other than home, work, or in a car or public transit is less
prevalent. Around half of respondents indicated that they used their phone at least once in the
previous hour over the course of the study period while waiting in line (53%), while at a
community location like a coffees shop or park (51%), or while walking from place to place (50%).

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 38 of 60

37
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Just one in five smartphone owners (17%) indicated that they had used their smartphone while
exercising in the previous hour over the course of the study.7
Home usage is ubiquitous
among smartphone owners
both young and old, and
smartphone owners ages 1829 and those 50 and older are
similarly prone to using their
phones while in a car or on
public transit (85% of younger
users and 79% of older users
did so), as well as in a
community place like a park or
coffee shop (49% of both
younger and older smartphone
owners used their phone in
this type of location over the
course of the study period).

Smartphones Used Frequently at Home and in Transit,
Less Often While Exercising

d
we

015
3/2
7/2

0

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling survey, November 10-16
2014.

e

, vi
659

Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one week (14 total surveys) and
asked how they had used their phone in the preceding hour (besides completing the survey).
Only those respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of the study
period are included in this analysis.

However, younger adults are
substantially more likely to use
their smartphone while
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
walking from place to place.
Almost two-thirds of 18-29
year olds (64%) did this at least once during the week-long study period, compared with 48% of
smartphone owners ages 30-49 and 37% of those 65 and older. Smartphone owners ages 18-29 are
also a bit more likely than those 50 and older to use their phone while waiting in line (55% vs.
43%) and while exercising (21% vs. 11%).

4

12.
No

7

Note that due to space limitations, the experience sampling study was not able to collect detailed information about the locations
respondents had visited or the activities they had engaged in during the hour prior to taking the survey. As such, locations that people
visit regularly (such as home or work, in particular) are likely to be heavily represented in this analysis.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 39 of 60

38
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Smartphone owners use their
phones to solve a range of social
and informational problems as
they go about their daily lives. The
experience sampling survey asked
smartphone owners about seven
different types of problems they
might use their phones to help
solve, the most prevalent of which
are:


Coordinating With Others, Avoiding Boredom, and
Reminders are Among the Most Common Problems
Smartphones Help Address

Coordinating with others —
80% of smartphone owners
reported using their phone to
help coordinate meeting with
someone at least once over the
course of the study period,
reporting that they did so in an
average of 2.6 surveys.
Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling survey, November 10-16
Avoiding boredom — 77% of
2014.
smartphone owners reported
Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one week (14 total surveys) and
asked how they had used their phone in the preceding hour (besides completing the survey).
that they turned to their phone
Only those respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of the study
period are included in this analysis.
to avoid being bored, reporting
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
that they did so in an average
of 3.5 surveys.
Reminders and life logistics — 74% of smartphone owners used their phone at least once to
help remember something they needed to do (in an average of 2.4 different surveys).

d
we

e





, vi
659

015
3/2
7/2

0

4

12.
No

Other problem-solving behaviors are somewhat less prevalent. Just over half of smartphone
owners in this study (55%) used their phone at least once to learn about an important news
development, and a similar number (53%) used their phone to resolve an issue or settle an
argument. Some 42% used their phone at least once to find a good way to get somewhere they
needed to go, and almost one-in-three (31%) used their phone to avoid having to deal with people
around them.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 40 of 60

39
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Younger users are much more likely to use their phones to avoid boredom — and also to
avoid other people
Younger users stand out especially prominently
when it comes to using their phones for two
purposes in particular: avoiding boredom, and
avoiding people around them. Fully 93% of 1829 year old smartphone owners used their
phone at least once to avoid being bored, with
respondents in this age group reporting doing
so during the previous hour in an average of 5.4
surveys over the one-week study period.
Similarly, 47% of young smartphone owners
used their phone to avoid interacting with the
people around them at least once during the
study period, roughly three times the
proportion of older smartphone owners who
did so. Younger users were also substantially
more likely than older users to say that they had
used their phone to help them find a good way
to get somewhere — 57% did so.

Younger Smartphone Owners More
Likely to Use Their Phone for Preventing
Boredom, Avoiding Others, Getting
Somewhere
% of smartphone owners in each age group who used
their phone for the following reasons at least once over
the course of 14 surveys spanning a one-week period

18-29

50+
93

Avoid being bored

Avoid others
around you

ed

/
/23
07

Find a good way
to get somewhere

w

e
, vi
9

5
-46
At the same time, certain types of information
. 12
are equally common among younger and older
No
users. There are few age-related differences

30-49

82

015
2

55
47

32

15

57
37
33

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling
survey, November 10-16 2014.
Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one
week (14 total surveys) and asked how they had used their phone in
the preceding hour (besides completing the survey). Only those
respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of
the study period are included in this analysis.

when it comes to using one’s phone to resolve
PEW RESEARCH CENTER
or settle an argument, learn about a news
development, coordinate with meeting
someone, or be reminded of a task or appointment.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 41 of 60

40
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

When it comes to the emotions
that people experience as a
result of their smartphones,
“productive” and “happy” lead
the way — 79% and 77% of
smartphone owners,
respectively, indicated that
their phone made them feel
this way at least once over the
course of the study period. On
average, users reported feeling
“productive” in 3.8 surveys and
“happy” in 3.4 surveys. At the
other end of the spectrum, just
15% of smartphone owners
indicated that their phone
made them feel “angry” at any
point during the course of the
study.

“Productive” and “Happy” are Common SmartphoneRelated Emotions — but Many Feel “Distracted” and
“Frustrated” as Well

d
we

015
3/2
7/2

0

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling survey, November 10-16
2014.

e

, vi
659

Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one week (14 total surveys)
and asked how they had used their phone in the preceding hour (besides completing the
survey). Only those respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of the
study period are included in this analysis.

4

12.
No

PEW RESEARCH CENTER
Younger users are especially
likely to say that their phone
makes them feel “distracted” and “frustrated,” but also more likely to feel “happy” and
“grateful”

Younger smartphone owners tend to experience a wider range of emotions vis-à-vis their phone
compared with older users—from positive ones like “happy” or “grateful,” to more negative
feelings like “distracted” and “angry.”
Feelings of smartphone-induced distraction are especially common among younger adults. Fully
73% of 18-29 year old smartphone owners indicated that their phone made them feel “distracted”
during the study period, 11 percentage points higher than among those ages 30-49 and 41
percentage points higher than among those 50 and older. Younger users were also around three
times as likely as those 50 and older to say that their phone made them angry at one point or
another during this study (22% vs. 7%). At the same time, younger users are significantly more
likely than those in other age groups to indicate that they experienced being happy or grateful as a
result of their phone.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 42 of 60

41
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Smartphone owners reported feeling
“productive” thanks to their phones at high
rates across a range of age groups — 78% of 1829 year olds, 79% of 30-49 year olds, and 80%
of those 50 and older reported that their
smartphone made them feel this way.

For Younger Adults, Smartphones
Inspire a Range of Emotions — from
Happy and Grateful, to Distracted and
Frustrated
% of smartphone owners in each age group who indicate
that their phone made them experience the following
emotions at least once over the course of 14 surveys
spanning a one-week period

18-29

30-49

50+
85

Happy

76
71
78
79
80

Productive

015
3/2
7/2

Grateful

.
No

4
12-

59,
6

d0

e

w
vie

Distracted

66
53
54
73
62

32
45
39

Frustrated

23
22
Angry

14
7

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling
survey, November 10-16 2014.
Respondents were contacted twice a day over the course of one
week (14 total surveys) and asked how they had used their phone in
the preceding hour (besides completing the survey). Only those
respondents who completed 10 or more surveys over the course of
the study period are included in this analysis.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 43 of 60

42
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Appendix A: About the December Week 1 and Week 3
Omnibus Survey
The PSRAI December 2014 Omnibus Weeks 1 & 3 obtained telephone interviews with a nationally
representative sample of 2,002 adults living in the continental United States. Telephone
interviews were conducted by landline (1,001) and cell phone (1,001, including 605 without a
landline phone). The survey was conducted by Princeton Survey Research Associates International
(PSRAI). Interviews were done in English and Spanish by Princeton Data Source from December
4-7, 2014 (1,001) and from December 18-21, 2014 (1,001). Statistical results are weighted to
correct known demographic discrepancies. The margin of sampling error for the complete set of
weighted data is ± 2.5 percentage points.
December Omnibus Week 1 and December Omnibus Week 3 were run as separate studies. The
sample for each survey was weighted independently, not as a combined sample, although both
studies used the same sample design, contact procedures, weighting procedures and weighting
parameters. Details on the design, execution and analysis of the surveys are discussed below.
Sample Design

d
we

e

, vi
659

015
3/2
7/2

0

For each survey, a combination of landline and cellular random digit dial (RDD) samples was used
to represent all adults in the continental United States who have access to either a landline or
cellular telephone. Both samples were provided by Survey Sampling International, LLC (SSI)
according to PSRAI specifications.

4

12.
No

Numbers for the landline sample were drawn with equal probabilities from active blocks (area
code + exchange + two-digit block number) that contained three or more residential directory
listings. The cellular sample was not list-assisted, but was drawn through a systematic sampling
from dedicated wireless 100-blocks and shared service 100-blocks with no directory-listed landline
numbers.
Contact Procedures
December Week 1 interviews were conducted December 4 to 7, 2014 and December Week 3
interviews were conducted December 18 to 21, 2014. As many as three attempts were made to
contact every sampled telephone number. For each study, sample was released for interviewing in
replicates, which are representative subsamples of the larger sample. Using replicates to control
the release of sample ensures that complete call procedures are followed for the entire sample.
Calls were staggered over times of day and days of the week to maximize the chance of making

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 44 of 60

43
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

contact with potential respondents. Each phone number received at least one daytime call when
necessary.
For the landline sample, interviewers asked to speak with the youngest adult male or female
currently at home based on a random rotation. If no male/female was available, interviewers
asked to speak with the youngest adult of the other gender. This systematic respondent selection
technique has been shown to produce samples that closely mirror the population in terms of age
and gender when combined with cell interviewing.
For the cellular sample, interviews were conducted with the person who answered the phone.
Interviewers verified that the person was an adult and in a safe place before administering the
survey.
Weighting and Analysis

015
3/2
7/2

Because the studies were run at separate periods, the sample for each wave was weighted
separately and not as one combined study. The weighting procedures detailed below were used for
both surveys.

d
we

e

, vi
659

0

Weighting is generally used in survey analysis to compensate for sample designs and patterns of
non-response that might bias results. The sample was weighted to match national adult general
population parameters. A two-stage weighting procedure was used to weight the dual-frame
sample.

4

12.
No

The first stage of weighting corrected for different probabilities of selection associated with the
number of adults in each household and each respondent’s telephone usage patterns. This
weighting also adjusts for the overlapping landline and cell sample frames and the relative sizes of
each frame and each sample.
The second stage of weighting balanced sample demographics to population parameters. The
sample is balanced to match national population parameters for sex, age, education, race,
Hispanic origin, region (U.S. Census definitions), population density, and telephone usage. The
basic weighting parameters came from the US Census Bureau’s 2012 American Community Survey
data. The population density parameter was derived from Census 2010 data. The telephone usage
parameter came from an analysis of the July-December 2013 National Health Interview Survey.
Weighting was accomplished using the SPSSINC RAKE, an SPSS extension module that
simultaneously balances the distributions of all variables using the GENLOG procedure. Weights

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 45 of 60

44
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

were trimmed to prevent individual interviews from having too much influence on the final
results. The use of these weights in statistical analysis ensures that the demographic
characteristics of the sample closely approximate the demographic characteristics of the national
population.
Post-data collection statistical adjustments require analysis procedures that reflect departures
from simple random sampling. PSRAI calculates the effects of these design features so that an
appropriate adjustment can be incorporated into tests of statistical significance when using these
data. The so-called "design effect" or deff represents the loss in statistical efficiency that results
from unequal weights. The combined total design effect for both surveys is 1.31.
The margins of error reported and statistical tests of significance are adjusted to account for the
survey’s design effect, a measure of how much efficiency is lost from the weighting procedures.

015 from the
/ ever
Tables 2 and 3 report the disposition of all sampled telephone numbers2 dialed
2 fraction of all eligible sample
/the3
original telephone number samples. The response rate estimates
7
d0
that was ultimately interviewed. Response rates are computed according to American Association
e
of Public Opinion Research standards. Thus for ew
December Week 1, the response rate for the
, vi
landline samples was 5 percent and the response rate for the cellular samples was 4 percent. For
59
December Week 3, the response-46 the landline samples was 6 percent and the response rate
rate for
for the cellular samples was1 percent.
. 82
No
Response Rate

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 46 of 60

45
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Table 2. December Week 1 Sample Disposition
Landline
Cell
1,138
77 OF = Out of Frame
1,134
77 Non-residential/Business
4
---- Cell in landline frame
20,211
19,248
963

3,078 NWC = Not working/computer
3,063 Not working
15 Computer/fax/modem

4,670

2,828 UHUONC = Non-contact, unknown if household/unknown other

4,555
4,517
38

9,543 UONC = Non-contact, unknown eligibility
9,496 Voice mail
47 Other non-contact

2,802
2,378
424

3,710 UOR = Refusal, unknown if eligible
2,583 Refusals
1,127 Callbacks

27
------84

d
we

e

, vi
659

015
3/2
7/2

0

4
12.
No= Screen out
108 SO
50 O = Other

108 Child's cell phone
101 R = Refusal, known eligible

501
500 I = Completed interviews
33,988 19,995 T = Total numbers dialed

27.2%
100.0%
37.0%
14.7%
5.4%

e1 = (I+R+SO+O+UOR+UONC)/(I+R+SO+O+UOR+UONC+OF+NWC) - Est. frame
81.6% eligibility of non-contacts
84.8% e2 = (I+R)/(I+R+SO) - Est. screening eligibility of unscreened contacts
27.4% CON = [I + R + (e2*[O + UOR])]/[I + R + (e2*[O + UOR + UONC]) + (e1*e2*UHUONC)]
13.2% COOP = I/[I + R + (e2*[O + UOR])]
3.6% AAPOR RR3=I/[I+R+[e2*(UOR+UONC+O)]+[e1*e2*UHUONC]] = CON*COOP

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 47 of 60

46
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Table 3. December Week 3 Sample Disposition
Landline
Cell
1,156
138 OF = Out of Frame
1,146
138 Non-residential/Business
10
---- Cell in landline frame
20,574
19,612
962
3,156

5,749 NWC = Not working/computer
5,716 Not working
33 Computer/fax/modem
672 UHUONC = Non-contact, unknown if household/unknown other

3,974
3,953
21

3,767 UONC = Non-contact, unknown eligibility
3,758 Voice mail
9 Other non-contact

3,479
3,265
214

4,583 UOR = Refusal, unknown if eligible
3,521 Refusals
1,062 Callbacks

19

d
we

e

, vi
659

42 O = Other

015
3/2
7/2

0

4

12.
No

-------

371 SO = Screen out
371 Child's cell phone

132

172 R = Refusal, known eligible

500
32,990

501 I = Completed interviews
15,995 T = Total numbers dialed

27.2%
100.0%

e1 = (I+R+SO+O+UOR+UONC)/(I+R+SO+O+UOR+UONC+OF+NWC) - Est. frame
61.6% eligibility of non-contacts
64.5% e2 = (I+R)/(I+R+SO) - Est. screening eligibility of unscreened contacts

46.1%
12.1%
5.6%

CON = [I + R + (e2*[O + UOR])]/[I + R + (e2*[O + UOR + UONC]) +
57.6% (e1*e2*UHUONC)]
13.7% COOP = I/[I + R + (e2*[O + UOR])]
7.9% AAPOR RR3=I/[I+R+[e2*(UOR+UONC+O)]+[e1*e2*UHUONC]] = CON*COOP

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 48 of 60

47
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

SMART1 Some

cell phones are called 'smartphones' because of certain features they have. Is your
cell phone a smartphone or not, or are you not sure?
Among cell phone owners [n=1,802]

%

CURRENT

Yes, is a smartphone
No, is not a smartphone
Not sure / Don’t know
Refused

66
27
7
*

SMART2 Which

of the following best describes the type of cell phone you have? Is it an iPhone, a
Blackberry, an Android phone, a Windows phone, or something else?
Among cell phone owners [n=1,802]

%

CURRENT

Android
iPhone
Windows
Blackberry
Basic cell phone - unspecified (VOL.)
Flip phone - unspecified (VOL.)
Samsung - unspecified (VOL.)
LG - unspecified (VOL.)
Tracfone (VOL.)
Nokia - unspecified (VOL.)
Motorola - unspecified (VOL.)
Pantech - unspecified (VOL.)
Something else
Don’t know
Refused

4

12.
No

d
we

e

, vi
659

33
30
3
1
10
6
5
2
1
1
*
*
3
4
1

www.pewresearch.org

0

015
3/2
7/2

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 49 of 60

48
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Appendix B: About the American Trends Panel October Wave
The American Trends Panel (ATP), created by the Pew Research Center, is a nationally
representative panel of randomly selected U.S. adults living in households. Respondents who selfidentify as internet users (representing 89% of U.S. adults) participate in the panel via monthly
self-administered Web surveys, and those who do not use the internet participate via telephone or
mail. The panel is being managed by Abt SRBI.
Data in this report are drawn from the October wave of the panel, conducted October 3-27, 2014
among 3,181 respondents (2,875 by Web and 306 by mail). The margin of sampling error for the
full sample of 3,181 respondents is plus or minus 2.3 percentage points, and the margin of
sampling error for the 2,188 smartphone owners is plus or minus 2.7 percentage points.
All current members of the American Trends Panel were originally recruited from the 2014
Political Polarization and Typology Survey, a large (n=10,013) national landline and cellphone
random digit dial (RDD) survey conducted January 23rd to March 16th, 2014, in English and
Spanish. At the end of that survey, respondents were invited to join the panel. The invitation was
extended to all respondents who use the internet (from any location) and a random subsample of
respondents who do not use the internet.

d
we

015
3/2
7/2

0

e
, vi to take part in the panel. A total of 5,338
Of the 10,013 adults interviewed, 9,809 were invited
659
agreed to participate and provided either a mailing address or an email address to which a
4
welcome packet, a monetary incentive and future survey invitations could be sent. Panelists also
12.
receive a small monetary incentive after participating in each wave of the survey.
No

The ATP data were weighted in a multi-step process that begins with a base weight incorporating
the respondents’ original survey selection probability and the fact that some panelists were
subsampled for invitation to the panel. Next, an adjustment was made for the fact that the
propensity to join the panel and remain an active panelist varied across different groups in the
sample. The final step in the weighting uses an iterative technique that matches gender, age,
education, race, Hispanic origin, telephone service, population density and region to parameters
from the U.S. Census Bureau's 2012 American Community Survey. It also adjusts for party
affiliation using an average of the three most recent Pew Research Center general public telephone
surveys, and for internet use using as a parameter a measure from the 2014 Survey of Political
Polarization. Sampling errors and statistical tests of significance take into account the effect of
weighting. The Hispanic sample in the American Trends Panel is predominantly native born and
English speaking.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 50 of 60

49
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

The following table shows the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable to sampling that
would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups of smartphone owners in the
survey:
Unweighted
sample size
2,188

Plus or minus …
2.7 percentage points

18-29

402

6.4 percentage points

30-49

763

4.7 percentage points

50-64

673

5.0 percentage points

65+

343

6.9 percentage points

White, non-Hispanic

1,668

3.1 percentage points

Black, non-Hispanic

170

9.9 percentage points

Hispanic

199

9.1 percentage points

HS grad or less

316

Some college

601

Group
Smartphone owners

College+

59,
6

$30,000-$74,999
$75,000 or more

4

12.
No

Smartphone-dependent
Non-dependent

5.2 percentage points

d0

1,269

Less than $30,000/yr

e

w
vie
401

015
3/2
7/2
7.2 percentage points
3.6 percentage points
6.4 percentage points

725

4.8 percentage points

961

4.1 percentage points

110

12.3 percentage points

2,078

2.8 percentage points

Sample sizes and sampling errors for other subgroups are available upon request.
In addition to sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and practical
difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion polls.
The Web component of the October wave had a response rate of 78% (2,875responses among
3,6738 Web-based individuals enrolled in the panel); the mail component had a response rate of
55% (306 responses among 555 non-Web individuals enrolled in the panel). Taking account of the
response rate for the 2014 Survey of Political Polarization (10.6%), the cumulative response rate
for the October ATP wave is 3.4%.
8

Prior to this wave, 962 web panelists who had never responded were removed from the panel. The response rate including these
panelists would have been 62%. Mail panelists who never responded were not yet removed.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 51 of 60

50
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

ASK ALL
SMARTPHONE.

Which type of cell phone do you have? [If you have multiple cell phones, select the one you
use most often]

Oct 3-27
2014
68
28
33
1
2
0
4
24
6
1

NET Smartphone
iPhone
Android
Blackberry
Windows
Symbian
Some other type of smartphone
I have a cell phone, but it’s not a smartphone
I do not have a cell phone [EXCLUSIVE PUNCH]
No answer

ASK CELL PHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-7) [N=3,019]:
COST1. Do you have an individual cell phone plan, or are you part of a group or family plan?
Oct 3-27
2014
35
61
34
14
13
4
1

015
3/2
7/2

Individual plan, including prepaid
NET Group or family plan
Group or family plan, and I pay for the entire bill
Group or family plan, and I pay for a portion of the bill
Group or family plan, and I don’t pay for any of the bill
Not sure
No answer

d
we

e

, vi
659

0

4

12.
No

ASK IF KNOW TYPE OF PLAN AND PAY SOME PORTION OF BILL (COST1=1-3) [N=2,568]:
COST2. How much do you PERSONALLY pay or contribute each month for your cell phone service (including
your voice, texting, and/or data plan)? [IF COST1=3, Group or family plan, and I pay for a
portion of the bill: “If you only pay for a portion of a group or family plan, please indicate that
amount.”]
Oct 3-27
2014
27
28
18
11
8
3
1
4
*

Less than $50
$50 to less than $100
$100 to less than $150
$150 to less than $200
$200 or more
I pay nothing because someone else pays my bill
Not sure
Prefer not to say
No answer

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 52 of 60

51
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

ASK CELL PHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-7) [N=3,019]:
COST3. Have you ever had to cancel or shut off your cell phone service for a period of time because the cost of
maintaining the service was too expensive?
Oct 3-27
2014
21
78
*

Yes, have done this
No, have not had to do this
No answer

ASK ALL:
COMP. Do you own a desktop or laptop computer?
Oct 3-27
2014
80
19
1

Yes
No
No answer

ASK ALL:
TAB.
Do own a tablet computer?
Oct 3-27
2014
43
56
1

Yes
No
No answer

d
we

015
3/2
7/2

0

ASK SMARTPHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-6) [N=2,188]:
SM1.
Other than the data plan on your cell phone, do you have high-speed internet service at home (such
as cable internet, DSL, FIOS, or satellite internet service)?

e

Oct 3-27
2014
85
15
*

, vi
659

4

12.
No

Yes, have high speed internet service at home
No, do not have high speed internet service at home
No answer

ASK SMARTPHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-6) [N=2,188]:
SM2.
Which of the following statements comes closest to describing how you use your cell phone to access
online services and information, even if neither is exactly right?
Oct 3-27
2014
22
78
1

Other than my cell phone, I have a limited number of ways to get online
I have a number of other options for getting online in addition to my cell phone
No answer

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 53 of 60

52
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

ASK SMARTPHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-6) [N=2,188]:
SM3.
How often… [RANDOMIZE ITEMS SM3a-SM3f]?

a.

b.

c.

d.

e.

f.

Frequently

Occasionally

Rarely

Never

No
answer

10

39

40

11

*

Do apps that you’ve downloaded
on your cell phone not work
correctly
Oct 3-27, 2014

9

37

41

12

*

Is your monthly cell phone bill
substantially higher than you
expected it to be
Oct 3-27, 2014

7

20

35

38

*

Does content that you are trying
to access on your cell phone not
display properly
Oct 3-27, 2014

Do you experience unexpected
cell phone charges from in-app
purchases
Oct 3-27, 2014
Do you reach the maximum
amount of data you are allowed
to use as part of your cell phone
plan
Oct 3-27, 2014

4
12.

No

7

11

30

60

1

21

25

38

1

36

d
we

15

e

, vi
659

Do poor or dropped signals
prevent you from using your cell
phone
Oct 3-27, 2014

015
3/2
7/2

2

43

10

*

0

ASK ALL:
EXPS. Which of the following have you done in the last year? [RANDOMIZE A-F] [Check all that apply]

a.

Look for information about a job
Oct 3-27, 2014

Yes

Not selected/
No answer

43

57

b.

Submit a job application
Oct 3-27, 2014

31

69

c.

Access government services or
information
Oct 3-27, 2014

41

59

Take a class or watch educational
content
Oct 3-27, 2014

40

60

Look up information about a health
condition
Oct 3-27, 2014

63

37

d.

e.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 54 of 60

53
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

f.

g.

Yes
43

I have not done any of these
[EXCLUSIVE PUNCH]
Oct 3-27, 2014

57

16

Look up real estate listings or
information about a place to live
Oct 3-27, 2014

Not selected/
No answer

84

ASK ALL:
BANK. Do you have an account with a bank?
Oct 3-27
2014
86
12
2

Yes
No
No answer

ASK SMARTPHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-6) [N=2,188]:
SM4.
In the last year, have you used your cell phone to… [RANDOMIZE SM4A-SM4G, MATCH SAME
ORDER OF RANDOMIZATION OF A-F FROM EXPS WITH G ALWAYS LAST]
No, have not
done using
cell phone

No answer

57

*

18

82

*

Look up government services or
information
Oct 3-27, 2014

40

60

*

Take a class or watch educational
content
Oct 3-27, 2014

30

69

*

Look up information about a health
condition
Oct 3-27, 2014

62

38

*

Look up real estate listings or
information about a place to live
Oct 3-27, 2014

44

56

*

Do online banking (for example, pay a
bill or transfer money)
Oct 3-27, 2014

57

42

*

a.

Look for information about a job
Oct 3-27, 2014

b.

Submit a job application
Oct 3-27, 2014

c.

d.

e.

f.

g.

015
3/2
7/2

Yes, have
done using
cell phone

.
No

e
, vi
9

5

-46
12

w

0
ed
43

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 55 of 60

54
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

ASK SMARTPHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-6) [RANDOMIZE SM5A-SM5C] [N=2,188]:
SM5.
How often, if ever, do you use your cell phone to…
Frequently

Occasionally

Rarely

Never

No answer

10

15

21

54

*

Reserve a taxi or car service
Oct 3-27, 2014

4

7

17

72

*

Get turn-by-turn navigation
while you are driving
Oct 3-27, 2014

31

36

17

16

*

a.

Get public transit information
Oct 3-27, 2014

b.
c.

RANDOMIZE ITEMS
ASK SMARTPHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-6) [RANDOMIZE SM6A-SM6D] [N=2,188]:
SM6.
How often, if ever, do you use your cell phone to…
a.

b.

c.

d.

Frequently

Occasionally

Rarely

Never

No answer

33

Follow along with breaking
news events
Oct 3-27, 2014

35

16

16

*

18

14

*

Share pictures, videos, or
commentary with others
about events happening in
your community
Oct 3-27, 2014
Make a monetary donation
to a political or charitable
cause
Oct 3-27, 2014

.
No

35

5

-46
12

Learn about events or
activities in your community
Oct 3-27, 2014

0
ed

w

e
, vi
9

015
3/2
7/2

32

2

6

15

77

*

18

38

23

21

*

ASK SMARTPHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-6) [N=2,188]:
SM7.
Have you ever used your cell phone to report a problem in your neighborhood (like a pothole or a
missing street sign) to the local authorities?
Oct 3-27
2014
17
9
74
*

Yes, have done this with my cell phone
Have done this, but not with my cell phone
No, have not done this
No answer

ASK CELL PHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-7) [N=3,019]:
EMER1. Have you ever been in an emergency situation where having your cell phone helped resolve the issue?
Oct 3-27
2014
52
48
1

Yes
No
No answer

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 56 of 60

55
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

ASK CELL PHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-7) [N=3,019]:
PROB1. Have you ever been in a situation where you had trouble doing something because you didn’t have
your cell phone with you?
Oct 3-27
2014
41
59
1

Yes
No
No answer

RANDOMIZE ITEMS SM8a-SM8e
ASK CELL PHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-7) [N=3,019]:
SM8a. Which of the following statements most closely matches how you feel about your cell phone, even if
neither one is exactly right? [RANDOMIZE ORDER OF RESPONSE OPTIONS]
Oct 3-27
2014
59
40
1

Not always needed
Couldn’t live without
No answer

015
3/2
7/2

RANDOMIZE ITEMS SM8a-SM8e
ASK CELL PHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-7) [N=3,019]:
SM8b. Which of the following statements most closely matches how you feel about your cell phone, even if
neither one is exactly right? [RANDOMIZE ORDER OF RESPONSE OPTIONS]
Oct 3-27
2014
72
27
1

Freedom
Leash
No answer

d
we

e

, vi
659

0

4

12.
No

RANDOMIZE ITEMS SM8a-SM8e
ASK CELL PHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-7) [N=3,019]:
SM8c. Which of the following statements most closely matches how you feel about your cell phone, even if
neither one is exactly right? [RANDOMIZE ORDER OF RESPONSE OPTIONS]
Oct 3-27
2014
73
27
1

Connecting
Distracting
No answer

RANDOMIZE ITEMS SM8a-SM8e
ASK CELL PHONE OWNERS (SMARTPHONE=1-7) [N=3,019]:
SM8d. Which of the following statements most closely matches how you feel about your cell phone, even if
neither one is exactly right? [RANDOMIZE ORDER OF RESPONSE OPTIONS]
Oct 3-27
2014
91
8
*

Helpful
Annoying
No answer

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 57 of 60

56
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Appendix C: About American Trends Panel Experience
Sampling Study
The American Trends Panel (ATP) is a national, probability-based panel of US adults fielded for
the Pew Research Center by Abt SRBI. A special Diary Study was fielded November 10 through 16,
2014, with smartphone users identified in the panel. This study consisted of 14 short surveys
administered twice a day for seven consecutive days. The study was conducted using two different
self-administered approaches or “treatments.” One treatment required the panelist to download a
special app to their phone, and then they used that app to complete the surveys. The other
treatment was a normal Web survey, which could be completed on a mobile device, tablet, laptop
or desktop computer. The app is only compatible with certain smartphones. Eligible panelists
with a compatible phone were randomly assigned to participate in the app treatment (60%) or the
normal Web survey treatment (40%). Eligible panelists with a non-compatible phone were
assigned to the normal Web survey treatment. In total, 1,635 ATP members completed at least one
of the 14 surveys, with 938 participating by Web and 697 participating with the app. The survey
was administered in English and Spanish. Survey weights are provided to account for differential
probabilities of selection into the panel, attrition, and differential nonresponse to the Diary Study.

d
we

015
3/2
7/2

0

Data in this report are drawn from the 1,035 respondents who completed at least ten of the 14
surveys over the course of the study period. The margin of sampling error for these 1,035
smartphone owners is plus or minus 4.0 percentage points.

e

Sample Design

, vi
659

4

12.
No

The target population for the Diary Study was non-institutionalized smartphone owners age 18
and over, living in the US, including Alaska and Hawaii. The sample consisted of smartphone
users identified and recruited in Wave 8 of the ATP, which was administered using the routine
panel protocol. The ATP is a probability-based panel of adults in the United States. Currently all
ATP panelists have been recruited from a large (n=10,013) national overlapping dual frame
landline and cell phone random digit dial (RDD) survey conducted for the Pew Research Center.
At the end of that RDD survey, respondents were invited to join the panel. The invitation was
extended to all respondents who use the internet (from any location) and a random subsample of
respondents who do not use the internet. The RDD survey was conducted from January 23rd to
March 16th, 2014, in English and Spanish. Sample for the RDD survey was obtained from SSI.
Please refer to the Pew Research Center Political Typology/Polarization Survey Methodology
Report for additional information on the sample design for the RDD survey.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 58 of 60

57
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

At the start of Wave 8, the ATP featured 4,228 active panel members, and 3,181 of them completed
Wave 8. The Diary Study sample consisted of ATP panelists who had internet access, reported
having a smartphone in Wave 8, and consented to participate in the smartphone follow-up (Diary)
study. In total 2,188 Wave 8 panelists reported having a smartphone. Of those, 42 belonged to the
non-internet arm of the panel and were ineligible for the Diary Study. Of the remaining 2,146
smartphone panelists, 1,945 consented to participate in the Diary Study. Among those consenting,
1,635 completed at least one of the 14 Diary Study surveys.
The Diary Study was conducted using two different self-administered approaches or “treatments.”
One treatment required the panelist to download a special app (SODA®) to their phone, and then
they used that app to complete the surveys. The other treatment was a normal Web survey, which
could be completed on a mobile device, tablet, laptop or desktop computer. SODA® is only
compatible with iPhones, Androids and Blackberry phones. Eligible panelists with one of these
three phone types were randomly assigned to participate in the app treatment (60%) or the normal
Web survey treatment (40%). All of the eligible panelists with a different type of smartphone (e.g.,
Windows) were assigned to the normal Web survey treatment. Among the 1,211 panelists assigned
to the app treatment, 292 declined the follow up survey invitation and were then asked if they
would complete the Diary Study via normal Web surveys. Some 195 agreed to that offer.

d
we

e

, vi
659

Data Collection Protocol

015
3/2
7/2

0

4

12.
No

ATP panelists who agreed to participate in the special week of surveys (Diary Study) were sent an
email notifying them of the upcoming week of surveys on November 7, 2014. Respondents for
whom we also had a residential address received a matching letter in the mail with $5 cash
enclosed, while respondents without an address were emailed a $5 Amazon gift code as a preincentive. The data collection for the surveys was conducted from November 10-16, 2014.
An identical survey measuring smartphone usage was dispatched to each respondent twice daily
for seven days, for a total of 14 surveys. All respondents were sent an email invitation. Those who
agreed to receive text message reminders were sent those, and the SODA® app had an alarm
feature that notified SODA respondents of the current survey’s availability. Each survey was
available for two hours, and the survey invitations were dispatched at the times specified in the
table below based on the respondents’ reported local time zone.

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 59 of 60

58
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

Survey Administration Contacts
Date
Monday, November 10

First Survey
8am

Second Survey
3pm

Tuesday, November 11

9am

4pm

Wednesday, November 12

10am

5pm

Thursday, November 13

11am

6pm

Friday, November 14

12pm

7pm

Saturday, November 15

1pm

8pm

Sunday, November 16

2pm

9pm

Pew Research Center American Trends Panel experience sampling survey,
November 10-16 2014.
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

015
3/2
7/2

Panelists received $1 for each survey they completed during the week and an additional $5 bonus
for completing 10 or more of the surveys during the week. Panelists who had previously selected a
method of payment received their incentive based on their check or electronic Amazon gift code
preference.

d
we

e

, vi
659

Weighting

0

4

12.
No

The ATP data were weighted in a multi-step process that begins with a base weight incorporating
the respondents’ original survey selection probability and the fact that some panelists were
subsampled for invitation to the panel. Next, an adjustment was made for the fact that the
propensity to join the panel and remain an active panelist varied across different groups in the
sample. The next step was a weighting cell adjustment for non-response to the experience
sampling study since the response rate differed somewhat across the treatment groups. The final
step in the weighting uses an iterative technique that matches gender, age, education, race,
Hispanic origin, region and smartphone type to parameters for US adults who have a smartphone
from the October 2014 wave of the ATP. Normally ATP samples are calibrated to benchmarks for
the US adult population. For this study, however, the target population was US adults who have a
smartphone. There are no official government statistics on the demographics of this population.
The best available data were from the October 2014 wave of the American Trends Panel, which
featured a national probability-based sample of 2,188 adult smartphone users.
The margins of error reported and statistical tests of significance are adjusted to account for the
survey’s design effect, a measure of how much efficiency is lost from the weighting procedures.
The Hispanic sample in the American Trends Panel is predominantly native born and English

www.pewresearch.org

Appeal: 12-4659

Doc: 170-5

Filed: 08/05/2015

Pg: 60 of 60

59
PEW RESEARCH CENTER

speaking. In addition to sampling error, one should bear in mind that question wording and
practical difficulties in conducting surveys can introduce error or bias into the findings of opinion
polls.
The following table shows the unweighted sample sizes and the error attributable to sampling that
would be expected at the 95% level of confidence for different groups in the survey:
Unweighted
sample size
1,035

Plus or minus …
4.0 percentage points

18-29

202

9.1 percentage points

30-49

403

6.4 percentage points

50+

426

6.2 percentage points

Group
Smartphone owners, 10+ surveys completed

015
3/2
7/2

Pew Research Center is a nonprofit, tax-exempt 501(c)3 organization and a subsidiary of The Pew
Charitable Trusts, its primary funder.

d
we

e

, vi
659

4

12.
No

www.pewresearch.org

0