Ohio Valley Environmental Coal v. Fola Coal Company, LLC
Filing
OPINION ATTACHMENT. [16-1024]
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 1 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 2 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 3 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 4 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 5 of 75
No
6-1
.1
4,
02
ed
iew
v
2/
1
/16
19
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 6 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 7 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 8 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 9 of 75
d
e
N
.
o
6
1
2
0
1
w
ie
v
,
4
/1
2
1
6
/1
9
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 10 of 75
9
/1
2
6
/1
.
o
N
-1
6
1
4
2
0
ie
v
,
1
d
e
w
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 11 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 12 of 75
ed
w
o.
N
-1
16
ie
,v
24
0
/1
12
16
9/
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 13 of 75
No
6-1
.1
4,
02
ed
iew
v
2/
1
/16
19
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 14 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 15 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 16 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 17 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 18 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 19 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 20 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 21 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 22 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 23 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 24 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 25 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 26 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 27 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 28 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 29 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 30 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 31 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 32 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 33 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 34 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 35 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 36 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 37 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 38 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 39 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 40 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 41 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 42 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 43 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 44 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 45 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 46 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 47 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 48 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 49 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 50 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 51 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 52 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 53 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 54 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 55 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 56 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 57 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 58 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 59 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 60 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 61 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 62 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 63 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 64 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 65 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 66 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 67 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 68 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 69 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 70 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 71 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 72 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 73 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 74 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Appeal: 16-1024
Doc: 75-4
Filed: 01/04/2017
Pg: 75 of 75
o
N
6
1
.
2
0
-1
v
,
4
d
e
w
ie
6
/1
9
/1
2
1
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?