International Refugee Assistance Project v. Trump

Filing 297

OPINION ATTACHMENT. [17-1351] (JSN)

Download PDF
Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 1 of 20 DHS Announces Further Travel Restrictions for the Visa Waiver Program | Homeland Security    Official website of the Department of Homeland Security Contact Us  Quick Links  Site Map  A­Z Index Archived Content In an effort to keep DHS.gov current, the archive contains content from a previous administration or is otherwise outdated. DHS Announces Further Travel Restrictions for the Visa Waiver Program Release Date:  February 18, 2016 For Immediate Release DHS Press Office Contact: 202-282-8010 WASHINGTON—The Department of Homeland Security today announced that it is continuing its implementation of the Visa Waiver Program Improvement and Terrorist Travel Prevention Act of 2015 with the addition of Libya, Somalia, and Yemen as three countries of concern, limiting Visa Waiver Program travel for certain individuals who have traveled to these countries.  Pursuant to the Act, the Secretary of Homeland Security had sixty days to determine whether additional countries or areas of concern should be subject to the travel or dual nationality restrictions under the Act. After careful consideration, and in https://www.dhs.gov/news/2016/02/18/dhs­announces­further­travel­restrictions­visa­waiver­program 1/3 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 2 of 20 DHS Announces Further Travel Restrictions for the Visa Waiver Program | Homeland Security consultation with the Director of National Intelligence and the Secretary of State, the Secretary of Homeland Security has determined that Libya, Somalia, and Yemen be included as countries of concern, specifically for individuals who have traveled to these countries since March 1, 2011. At this time, the restriction on Visa Waiver Program travel will not apply to dual nationals of these three countries. DHS continues to consult with the Department of State and the Office of the Director of National Intelligence to develop further criteria to determine whether other countries would be added to this list.  Last month (/news/2016/01/21/united-states-begins-implementation-changesvisa-waiver-program) , the United States began implementing changes under the Act. The three additional countries designated today join Iran, Iraq, Sudan and Syria as countries subject to restrictions for Visa Waiver Program travel for certain individuals. Under the new law, the Secretary of Homeland Security may waive these restrictions if he determines that such a waiver is in the law enforcement or national security interests of the United States. Such waivers will be granted only on a case-by-case basis. As a general matter, categories of travelers who may be eligible for a waiver include individuals who traveled to these countries on behalf of international organizations, regional organizations, and sub-national governments on official duty; on behalf of a humanitarian NGO on official duty; or as a journalist for reporting purposes. The addition of these three countries is indicative of the Department’s continued focus on the threat of foreign fighters. DHS continues to review the security of the Visa Waiver Program, the threat environment, and potential vulnerabilities. This is the latest step in a series of actions over the past 15 months to strengthen the security of the Visa Waiver Program and ensure the Program’s requirements are commensurate with the growing threat from foreign terrorist fighters, many of whom are nationals of Visa Waiver Program countries. An updated Electronic System for Travel Authorization (ESTA) application with additional questions on travel to Libya, Somalia, https://www.dhs.gov/news/2016/02/18/dhs­announces­further­travel­restrictions­visa­waiver­program 2/3 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 3 of 20 DHS Announces Further Travel Restrictions for the Visa Waiver Program | Homeland Security and Yemen will be released this spring 2016 to address exceptions for diplomatic- and military-related travel provided for in the Act.  Individuals impacted will still be able to apply for a visa using the regular immigration process at our embassies or consulates. For those who need a U.S. visa for urgent business, medical, or humanitarian travel to the United States, U.S. embassies and consulates stand ready to provide visa interview appointments on an expedited basis. The new law does not ban travel to the United States, or admission into the United States, and the great majority of Visa Waiver Program travelers will not be affected. Information on visa applications can be found at travel.state.gov (http://travel.state.gov/content/travel/en.html) . Current ESTA holders are encouraged to check their ESTA status prior to travel on U.S. Customs and Border Protection’s (CBP) website at esta.cbp.dhs.gov (https://esta.cbp.dhs.gov/esta/) .   ###   Topics:  Air (/topics/air) , International (/topics/international) , Preventing Terrorism (/topics/preventing-terrorism) , Transportation Security (/topics/transportation-security) , Verifying Identity (/topics/verifying-identity) Keywords:  countering terrorism (/keywords/countering-terrorism) , ESTA (/keywords/esta) , Libya (/keywords/libya) , travel security (/keywords/travel-security) , Visa (/keywords/visa) , Visa Waiver Program (/keywords/visa-waiver-program) Last Published Date: February 18, 2016 https://www.dhs.gov/news/2016/02/18/dhs­announces­further­travel­restrictions­visa­waiver­program 3/3 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 4 of 20 Visa Waiver Program | Homeland Security    Official website of the Department of Homeland Security Contact Us  Quick Links  Site Map  A­Z Index U.S. Visa Waiver Program The Visa Waiver Program (VWP), administered by the Department of Homeland Security (DHS) in consultation with the State Department, permits citizens of 38 countries[1] (#_ftn1) to travel to the United States for business or tourism for stays of up to 90 days without a visa.  In return, those 38 countries must permit U.S. citizens and nationals to travel to their countries for a similar length of time without a visa for business or tourism purposes.  Since its inception in 1986, the VWP has evolved into a comprehensive security partnership with many of America’s closest allies.  The VWP utilizes a risk-based, multi-layered approach to detect and prevent terrorists, serious criminals, and other mala fide actors from traveling to the United States. This approach incorporates regular, national-level risk assessments concerning the impact of each program country’s participation in the VWP on U.S. national security and law enforcement interests.  It also includes comprehensive vetting of individual VWP travelers prior to their departure for the United States, upon arrival at U.S. ports of entry, and during any subsequent air travel within the United States. Visa Waiver Program Requirements (/visa-waiver-programrequirements) Electronic System for Travel Authorization (ESTA) (/electronic-system-travel-authorization-esta) Expand All Sections (#) https://www.dhs.gov/visa­waiver­program 1/3 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 5 of 20 Visa Waiver Program | Homeland Security Economic Benefits (#) Initial and Continuing Designation Requirements (#) National-Level Risk Assessments (#) Comprehensive Traveler Vetting (#) Mutually-Reinforcing Security Criteria (#) Visa Waiver Program Enhancements (#) Conclusion (#) Last Published Date: April 6, 2016 Was this page helpful? Yes https://www.dhs.gov/visa­waiver­program No 2/3 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 https://www.dhs.gov/visa­waiver­program Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 6 of 20 Visa Waiver Program | Homeland Security 3/3 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 7 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com President Donald Trump speaks at a rally on March 15, 2017 in Nashville, Tennessee.  Andrea Morales/Getty Images WHITE HOUSE Read President Trump’s Response to the Travel Ban Ruling: It ‘Makes Us Look Weak’ Katie Reilly Mar 16, 2017 President Donald Trump on Wednesday spoke at a rally in Nashville, Tenn., where he responded to a new ruling by a federal judge in Hawaii placing a nationwide restraining order on his revised travel ban. Trump criticized the ruling as "an unprecedented judicial overreach." "You don't think this was done by a judge for political reasons, do you? No," he said to applause. "This ruling makes us look weak, which, by the way, we no longer are. Believe me." Read Trump's full remarks from the rally, where he also spoke about the Republican health care plan: TRUMP: Thank you very much, everybody. Thank you. http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 1/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 8 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com (APPLAUSE) So, we're just going to let the other folks come in, ll it up. This is some crowd. You have to see what's outside. You wouldn't even believe it. (APPLAUSE) Unbelievable. (APPLAUSE) So, I'm thrilled to be here in Nashville, Tennessee, the home... (APPLAUSE) ... of country music, southern hospitality, and the great President Andrew Jackson. (APPLAUSE) I just came from a tour of Andrew Jackson's home to mark the 250th anniversary of his birth. (APPLAUSE) Jackson's life was devoted to one -- a very crucial principle. He understood that real leadership means putting America rst. (APPLAUSE) Before becoming president, Andrew Jackson served your state in the House of Representatives and in the United States Senate. And he also served as commander of the Tennessee Militia. (APPLAUSE) Tough cookies. Tough cookies. So, let's begin tonight by thanking all of the incredible men and women of the United States military and all of our wonderful veterans. The veterans. (APPLAUSE) AUDIENCE: USA! USA! USA! TRUMP: Crazy. Amazing. There's no place I'd rather be than with all of you here tonight, with the wonderful, hardworking citizens of our country. (APPLAUSE) I would much rather spend time with you than any of the pundits, consultants or special interests, certainly or reporters from Washington D.C. (APPLAUSE) It's patriotic Americans like you who make this country run and run well. You pay your taxes, follow our laws, support your communities, raise your children, love your country, and send your bravest to ght in our wars. (APPLAUSE) All you want is a government that shows you the same loyalty in return. (APPLAUSE) It's time that Washington heard your voice and, believe me, on November 8th they heard your voice. (APPLAUSE) The forgotten men and women of our country will never be forgotten again. Believe me. (APPLAUSE) I want to thank so many of your state leaders; State Party Chairman Scott Golden, Congressman Scott DesJarlais... (APPLAUSE) ... Congresswoman Marsha Blackburn... (APPLAUSE) http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 2/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 9 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com ... Congresswoman Diane Black... (APPLAUSE) ... Congressman Jimmy Duncan, right from the beginning... (APPLAUSE) ... Governor Bill Haslam... (APPLAUSE) ... a great friend of mine, Senator Bob Corker... (APPLAUSE) ... an incredible guy, respected by all, Senator Lamar Alexander... (APPLAUSE) ... and so many more. Thank you all for being here. We're going to be working closely together -- thank you; to deliver for you, the citizens of Tennessee, like you've never been delivered for before. Thank you. Thank you. (APPLAUSE) Thank you. (APPLAUSE) We are going to reduce your taxes. (APPLAUSE) Big league. Big. Big. And I want to start that process so quickly. Got to get the health care got done. We got to start the tax reductions. (APPLAUSE) We are going to enforce our trade rules and bring back our jobs, which are scattered all over the world. They're coming back to our country. (APPLAUSE) We're going to support the amazing, absolutely amazing men and women of law enforcement. (APPLAUSE) Protect your freedoms and defend the Second Amendment. (APPLAUSE) And we are going to restore respect for our country and for its great and very beautiful ag. (APPLAUSE) It's been a little over 50 days since my inauguration and we've been putting our America First agenda very much into action. You see what's happened (ph). We're keeping our promises. In fact, they have signs, he's kept his promise. They're all over the place. I have. We have done far more, I think maybe more than anybody's done in this of ce in 50 days. That I can tell you. (APPLAUSE) And we have just gotten started. Wait till you see what's coming, folks. (APPLAUSE) We've appointed a Supreme Court Justice to replace the late, great Antonin Scalia. His name is Judge Neil Gorsuch. (APPLAUSE) He will uphold and defend the Constitution of the United States. We are proposing a budget that will shrink the bloated federal bureaucracy -- and I mean bloated; while protecting our national security. You see what we're doing with our military; bigger, better, stronger than ever before. You see what's happening. http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 3/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 10 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com (APPLAUSE) And you're already seeing the results. Our budget calls for one of the single largest increases in defense spending history in this country. (APPLAUSE) We believe, especially the people in Tennessee -- I know you people so well... (APPLAUSE) ... in peace through strength. It's what we're going to have. (APPLAUSE) And we are taking steps to make sure that our allies pay their fair share. They have to pay. (APPLAUSE) We've begun a dramatic effort to eliminate job-killing federal regulations like nobody has ever seen before. Slash, slash. We're going to protect the environment. We're going to protect people's safeties, but let me tell you, the regulation business has become a terrible business and we're going to bring it down to where it should be. (APPLAUSE) (BOOING) (APPLAUSE) OK, let's go. One person, and they'll be the story tomorrow. Did you hear there was a protester? (APPLAUSE) We're going to put our miners back to work. We're going to put our auto industry back to work. (APPLAUSE) Already, because of this new business climate, we are creating jobs that are starting to pour back into our country like we haven't seen in many, many decades. (APPLAUSE) In the rst two job reports since I took the oath of of ce, we've already added nearly half a million new jobs. And believe me, it's just beginning. (APPLAUSE) I've already authorized the construction of the long-stalled and delayed Keystone and Dakota access pipeline. (APPLAUSE) A lot of jobs. (APPLAUSE) I've also directed that new pipelines must be constructed with American steel. (APPLAUSE) They want to build them here, they use our steel. We believe in two simple rules. Buy American and hire American. (APPLAUSE) On trade, I've kept my promise to the American people and withdrawn from the Trans-Paci c Partnership disaster. (APPLAUSE) Tennessee has lost one-third of its manufacturing jobs since the institution of NAFTA, one of the worst trade deals ever in history. (BOOING) http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 4/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 11 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com Our nation has lost over 60,000 factories since China joined the World Trade Organization; 60,000. Think of that. More than that. We're not going to let it happen anymore. From now on, we are going to defend the American worker and our great American companies. (APPLAUSE) And if America does what it says and if your president does what I've been telling you, there is nobody anywhere in the world that can even come close to us, folks. Not even close. (APPLAUSE) If a company wants to leave America, re their works, and then ship their new products back into our country, there will be consequences. (APPLAUSE) That's what we have borders for. And by the way, aren't our borders getting extremely strong? (APPLAUSE) Very strong. (APPLAUSE) Don't even think about it. We will build the wall. Don't even think about it. (APPLAUSE) In fact, as you've probably read, we went out to bid. We had hundreds of bidders. Everybody wants to build our wall. (APPLAUSE) Usually, that means we're going to get a good price. We're going to get a good price; believe me. We're going to build a wall. Some of the fake news said, I don't think Donald Trump wants to build the wall. Can you imagine if I said we're not going to build a wall? Fake news. (BOOING) Fake, fake news. (BOOING) Fake news, folks. A lot of fake. (BOOING) No, the wall is way ahead of schedule in terms of where we are. It's under design and you're going to see some very good things happening. But the border by itself right now is doing very well. It's becoming very strong. (APPLAUSE) General Kelly has done a great job. General Kelly. (APPLAUSE) My administration is also following through on our promise to secure, protect, and defend that border within our United States. Our southern border will be protected always. It will have the wall. Drugs will stop pouring in and poisoning our youth. (APPLAUSE) And that will happen very, very soon. You're already seeing what's going on. The drugs are pouring in to our country folks. They are poisoning our youth and plenty of others and we're going to stop it. We're not going to be playing games. Not going to be playing games. (APPLAUSE) Following my executive action -- and don't forget, we've only been here for like, what, 50 days? We've already experienced an unprecedented 40 percent reduction in illegal immigration on our southern border, http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 5/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 12 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com 61 percent -- 61 percent since inauguration day. Sixty-one percent; think about it. (APPLAUSE) And now people are saying we're not going to go there anymore 'cause we can't get in, so it's going to get better and better. We got to stop those drugs, though. We got to stop those drugs. During the campaign, as I traveled all across this country, I met with many American families whose loved ones were viciously and violently killed by illegal immigrants because our government refused to enforce our already existing laws. These American victims were ignored by the media. They were ignored by Washington. But they were not ignored by me and they're not ignored by you and they never will be ignored, certainly any longer. Not going to happen. (APPLAUSE) As we speak, we are nding the drug dealers, the robbers, thieves, gang members, killers, and criminals preying on our citizens. One by one -- you're reading about it, right? (APPLAUSE) They're being thrown out of our country, they're being thrown into prisons, and we will not let them back in. (APPLAUSE) We're also working night and day to keep our nation safe from terrorism. (APPLAUSE) We have seen the devastation from 9/11 to Boston to San Bernardino; hundreds upon hundreds of people from outside our country have been convicted of terrorism-related offenses. In the United States courts, right now we have investigations going on all over. Hundreds of refugees are under federal investigation for terrorism and related reasons. We have entire regions of the world destabilized by terrorism and ISIS. For this reason, I issued an executive order to temporarily suspend immigration from places where it cannot safely occur. (APPLAUSE) AUDIENCE: USA! USA! USA! TRUMP: But let me give you the bad news. We don't like bad news, right? I don't want to hear an alternative to good. But let me give you the bad, the sad news. Moments ago, I learned that a district judge in Hawaii... (BOOING) ... part of the much overturned 9th Circuit Court... (BOOING) ... and I have to be nice. Otherwise I'll get criticized for... (APPLAUSE) ... for speaking poorly about our courts. I'll be -- I'll be criticized by these people, among the most dishonest people in the world. (APPLAUSE) I will be criticized... (BOOING) (APPLAUSE) I'll be criticized by them for speaking harshly about our courts. I would never want to do that. A judge has just blocked our executive order on travel and refugees coming into our country from certain countries. (BOOING) http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 6/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 13 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com The order he blocked was a watered down version of the rst order that was also blocked by another judge and should have never been blocked to start with. (APPLAUSE) This new order was tailored to the dictates of the 9th Circuit, in my opinion, awed ruling. (APPLAUSE) This is the opinion of many, an unprecedented judicial overreach. (APPLAUSE) The law and the Constitution give the President the power to suspend immigration when he deems -- or she -- or she -- fortunately it will not be Hillary-she. (APPLAUSE) When he or she deems it to be in the national interest of our country. AUDIENCE: Lock her up! Lock her up! Lock her up! TRUMP: So we have a lot of lawyers here. We also have a lot of smart people here. Let me read to you, directly from the federal statute, 212(f) of the immigration, and you know what I'm talking about, right? Can I read this to you? Listen to this. Now, we're all smart people, we're all good students, were all everything. Some are bad students, but even if you're a bad student, this is a real easy one, let me tell you. Ready? So here's the statute, when they don't even want to quote when they overrule it. And it was put here for the security of our country. And this goes beyond me, because there'll be other presidents and we need this. And sometimes we need it very badly for security -- security of our country. It says -- now listen to easy -- how easy this is. Whenever the president nds that the entry of any aliens or any class of aliens would be detrimental to the interests of the United States, he may, by proclamation and for such period as he -- see, it wasn't politically correct, 'cause they should have said he or she. You know, today they'd say that. (LAUGHTER) That's (inaudible) (LAUGHTER) Actually, that's the only mistake they made -- as he shall deem necessary, suspend the entry of all aliens or any class of aliens, as immigrants or non-immigrants, or impose on the entry of aliens any restrictions he may deem to be appropriate. In other words, if he thinks there's danger out there, he or she, whoever is president can say, I'm sorry, folks, not now, please. We got enough problems. (APPLAUSE) We're talking about the safety of our nation, the safety and security of our people. (APPLAUSE) Now, I know you people aren't skeptical people, 'cause nobody would be that way in Tennessee. Nope, nobody. Not Tennessee. You don't think this was done by a judge for political reasons, do you? No. (APPLAUSE) This ruling makes us look weak, which, by the way, we no longer are. Believe me. (APPLAUSE) Just look at our borders. (APPLAUSE) http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 7/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 14 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com We're going to ght this terrible ruling. We're going to take our case as far as it needs to go, including all the way up to the Supreme Court. (APPLAUSE) We're going to win. We're going to keep our citizens safe. And regardless, we're going to keep our citizens safe. Believe me. (APPLAUSE) Even liberal democratic lawyer, Alan Dershowitz -- good lawyer; just said that we would win this case before the Supreme Court of the United States. (APPLAUSE) Remember this. I wasn't thrilled, but the lawyers all said, oh, let's tailor it. This is a watered down version of the rst one. This is a watered down version. And let me tell you something. I think we ought to go back to the rst one and go all the way, which is what I wanted to do in the rst place. (APPLAUSE) The danger is clear. The law is clear. The need for my executive order is clear. I was elected to change our broken and dangerous system and thinking in government that has weakened and endangered our country and left our people defenseless. (APPLAUSE) And I will not stop ghting for the safety of you and your families. Believe me. Not today, not ever. We're going to win it. We're going to win it. (APPLAUSE) We're going to apply common sense. We're going to apply intelligence. And we're never quitting and we're never going away and we're never, ever giving up. The best way to keep foreign terrorists or, as some people would say in certain instances, radical Islamic terrorists from attacking our country is to stop them from entering our country in the rst place. (APPLAUSE) We'll take it, but these are the problems we have. People are screaming break up the 9th Circuit and I'll tell you what. That 9th Circuit -- you have to see. Take a look at how many times they have been overturned with their terrible decisions. Take a look. And this is what we have to live with. Finally, I want to get to taxes. I want to cut the hell out of taxes, but... (APPLAUSE) ... but... (APPLAUSE) ... before I can do that -- I would have loved to have put it rst. I'll be honest. There is one more very important thing that we have to do and we are going to repeal and replace horrible, disastrous Obamacare. (APPLAUSE) If we leave Obamacare in place, millions and millions of people will be forced off their plans and your senators just told me that in your state you're down to practically no insurers. You're going to have nobody. You're going to have nobody. And this is true all over. The insurers are eeing. The insurers are eeing. It's a catastrophic situation. And there's nothing to compare anything to because Obamacare won't be around for a year or two. It's -- it's gone. So it's not like, oh gee, they this -- Obamacare is gone. (APPLAUSE) http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 8/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 15 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com Premiums will continue to soar, double digits and even triple digits in many cases. It will drain our budget and destroy our jobs. Remember all of the broken promises? You can keep your doctor. You can keep your plan. Remember the wise guy? (BOOING) Remember the wise guy that essentially said the American people -- the so-called architect; the American people are stupid because they approved it? We're going to show them. Those in Congress who made these promises have no credibility whatsoever on health care. And remember this; remember this. If we took -- because there's such divisiveness. And I'm not just talking now, with me. There was Obama, there was with Bush, the level of hatred and divisiveness with the politicians. I remember years ago, I'd go to Washington. I was always very politically active. And Republicans and Democrats, they'd ght during the day and they'd go to dinner at night. Today, there's a level that nobody's seen before. Just remember this. If we submitted, the Democrats' plan, drawn everything perfect for the Democrats, we wouldn't get one vote from the Democrats. That's the way it is. That's how much divisiveness and other things there are, so it's a problem. But we're going to get it by. So I've met with so many victims of Obamacare, the people who've been so horribly hurt by this horrible legislation. At the very core of Obamacare was a fatal aw. The government forcing people to buy a government-approved product. (BOOING) There are very few people. Very few people. (BOOING) And by the way, watch what happens. Now you just booed Obamacare. They will say Trump got booed when he mentioned... (LAUGHTER) They're bad people, folks. They're bad people. (BOOING) (APPLAUSE) Tonight I'll go home. I'll turn on. I'll say, listen, I'll turn on that television. My wife will say, darling, it's too bad you got booed. I said I didn't be booed. This was (inaudible). I said no, no. They were booing Obamacare. Watch, a couple of them will actually do it, almost guaranteed. But when we call them out it makes it harder for them to do it, so we'll see. (APPLAUSE) It's the fake, fake media. We want Americans to be able to purchase the health insurance plans they want, not the plans forced on them by our government. (APPLAUSE) The House has put forward a plan to repeal and replace Obamacare, based on the principles I outlined in my joint address, but let me tell you. We're going to arbitrate. We're going to all get together. We're going to get something done. Remember this. If we didn't do it the way we're doing it, we need 60 votes, so we'd have to get the Democrats involved. They won't vote. No matter what we do they're not going to vote. So we're doing it a different way, a complex way, it's ne. The end result is when you're at phase one, phase two, phase three; it's going to be great. It's going to be great. (APPLAUSE) http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 9/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 16 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com And then, we get on to tax reductions, which I like. (APPLAUSE) The House legislation does so much for you. It gives the states Medicaid exibility and some of the states will take over their health care. Governor Rick Scott in Florida said, just send me the money. They run a great plan. We have states that are doing great. It gives great exibility. Thank you, folks. Thank you. (APPLAUSE) Thank you. (APPLAUSE) It repeals hundreds of billions of dollars in Obamacare taxes. It provides tax credits to people to purchase the care that is rightfully theirs. The bill that I will ultimately sign, and that will be a bill where everybody's going to get into the room and we're going to get it done. We'll get rid of Obamacare and make health care better for you and for your family. (APPLAUSE) And once this is done, and a step further, we are going to try and put it in phase three. I'm going to work on bringing down the cost of medicine by having a fair and competitive bidding process. (APPLAUSE) We welcome this health care debate and its negotiation and we're going to carry it out and have been carrying it out in the full light of day, unlike the way Obamacare was passed. (APPLAUSE) Remember, folks, if we don't do anything, Obamacare is gone. It's not like, oh gee, it's going to be wonderful in three years. It's gone. It's gone. It's gone. Not working. It's gone. (APPLAUSE) What we cannot do is to be intimidated by the dishonest attacks from Democratic leaders in Congress who broke the system in the rst place and who don't believe you should be able to make your own health care decisions. (APPLAUSE) I am very con dent that if we empower the American people, we'll accomplish incredible things for our country, not just on health care, but all across our government. We will unlock new frontiers in science and in medicine. We will give our children the right to attend the school of their choice, one where they will be taught to love this country and its values. (APPLAUSE) We will create millions and millions of new jobs by lowering taxes on our businesses and, very importantly, for our workers. We're going to lower taxes. (APPLAUSE) Big (ph). (APPLAUSE) And we will ght for the right of every American child to grow up in a safe neighborhood, attend a great school, and to graduate with access to a high-paying job that they love doing. (APPLAUSE) No matter background (ph), no matter our income, no matter our geography, we all share the same home. We all salute the same ag. And we all are made by the same God. (APPLAUSE) AUDIENCE: USA! USA! USA! http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 10/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 17 of 20 Donald Trump Responds to Travel Ban Ruling: Full Transcript | Time.com TRUMP: It's time to embrace our glorious American destiny. Anything we can dream for our country, we can achieve for our country. All we have to do is tap into that American pride that is swelling our hearts and stirring our souls and we found that out very recently in our last election. A lot of pride. (APPLAUSE) We are all Americans and the future truly belongs to us. The future belongs to all of you. This is your moment. This is your time. This is the hour when history is made. All we have to do is put our own citizens rst and, together, we will make America strong again. (APPLAUSE) We will make America wealthy again. (APPLAUSE) We will make America proud again. (APPLAUSE) We will make America safe again. (APPLAUSE) And we will make America great again. (APPLAUSE) Thank you. God bless you. Thank you. (APPLAUSE) God bless you, everybody. http://time.com/4703622/president­trump­speech­transcript­travel­ban­ruling/ 11/11 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Alert travel.state.gov Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 18 The Immigrant Visa Process of 20 Important Announcement Executive Order on Visas U.S. Passports & International Travel Students Abroad U.S. Visa Intercountry Adoption March 22, 2017 International Parental Child Abduction | Contact Us Find U.S. Embassies & Consulates travel.state.gov > Visas > Immigrate > The Immigrant Visa Process Print   Email The Immigrant Visa Process   . t n e di s e r t n e n a m r e p l uf w al a g ni m o c e b o t p e t s t s rif e h t si si h T . a si v t n a r gi m mi n a ni a t b o t s rif t s u m s e t a t S d e ti n U e h t ni yl t n e n a m r e p e vil o t t n a w o h w s n e zi ti c n gi e r o F Immigrating to the United States is an important and complex decision. In this section, you will learn about who may immigrate to the United States, the different types of immigrant visas, the required forms, and the steps in the immigrant visa process. Because most immigrants receive visas in the family or employment based visa categories, they are a key focus of this section. To be eligible to apply for an immigrant visa, a foreign citizen must be sponsored by a U.S. citizen relative, U.S. lawful permanent resident, or a prospective employer, with a few exceptions, explained below. The sponsor begins the immigration process by filing a petition on the foreign citizen’s behalf with U.S. Citizenship and Immigration Services (USCIS).  Expand All Immigrating Based on Family Employment­Based Immigration Number of Visas Each Year is Limited in Some Categories Other Immigrant Visa Categories Español   What does it mean to be a... Agent Attorney of Record Beneficiary Petitioner Sponsor https://travel.state.gov/content/visas/en/immigrate/immigrant­process.html 1/3 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017   1 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 19 The Immigrant Visa Process of 20 Petition   2 3 After Your Petition is Approved Collect and Submit Forms   and Documents to the NVC 4 About Us Visa Newsroom Reports and Statistics Law and Policy   Interview Find a U.S. Embassy or Consulate Contact Us Careers https://travel.state.gov/content/visas/en/immigrate/immigrant­process.html STAY CONNECTED Dipnote Blog @travelgov Facebook Youtube 2/3 Appeal: 17-1351 5/24/2017 Doc: 297-1 Filed: 05/25/2017 Pg: 20 The Immigrant Visa Process of 20 Consular Notification and Access RSS Flickr   U.S. Passports & International Travel travel.state.gov Privacy Copyright & Disclaimer Students Abroad FOIA No FEAR Act Data U.S. Visa Office of the Inspector General Intercountry Adoption USA.gov International Parental Child Abduction GobiernoUSA.gov This site is managed by the Bureau of Consular Affairs, U.S. Department of State. https://travel.state.gov/content/visas/en/immigrate/immigrant­process.html 3/3

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?