MDY Industries, LLC v. Blizzard Entertainment, Inc., et al

Filing 50

Filed Appellants' MDY additional citations. Served on 07/22/2010. (panel) [7417518] [09-15932, 09-16044] (EL)

Download PDF
; LneCVeal ac . nbe Mi al . a p o c eF Cm z h A. vdL gnPI . Dai oa,ID . Jsp RMeny oeh . ae Cry . toy aeB Anhn . V E N A B LE C A M P ILLO L0 G A N A N D M EA N EY. PC WWW.C ML W.OM VL A C 13 E sOsonR . 98 at br d P onxAZ 806 h ei, 51 Jh CMacr+ on . sai ITL E T A P O E T AWO N Y N E L C U L R PR Y R E S V i : 0)3-10 o e( 261 0 c6 9 Fx( 261 59 a: 0)3- 2 64 . ineih , Y&C Lc s n zN T ed W ACERTI I D USMAT FE L MsMolDwyr .l e y Ceko teCo r lr fh ut U.. ut f p a frh Nit Ctut SCo to Ap el o te nh ici s PO. x133 . Bo 999 SnFacso C 9 1933 a rni , A 41-99 c l cv vll . m a e@ c a c n mwo Jl2,00 uy 221 R E c E lV E D M LYcD YRCE K OL .W E LR UsCUT FkEL ..O R O APAS J L2621 U 22 FE ID L DCWE OK D DT A E II NA IL T Re MDYld st sLLCe a. . ad ; n u te i t 1v BMz r Enetkme t : 1 tra. n e a. n C s No. 9192a d0-64 ae s0-53 n 9104 Ol'H No PHLV11-0 zF e : z 1001 Der . e: a MsDwyt Weetsnte plnsMDYIds e,L adMi al neyr DY'ite tpeeth Apent l , nut sL C n c eDonl < ',th d h l M )l aoeeeecdmat,bc wsrudbfrte nhCtutnte,00 Une bv-f ne trw i aage eoeh Nit i io l 721. dr rt eh cm FRA..8)1mndy gteCuthtnuy 021, e . oro peso e ..P2j,a ofn l ortao ll2,0 il . ut pa r Ff Cruts e a eio iMG U Sysm,n vG CnueadnutaIcef (ae ih i iiud dcinn E P t s c.E os rnIdsi n t? Cs tcs s e I. m rl . f No0-02)htsaly etetn sniatotics. oyt cne ec,hv .8151tailglprnnadi icnt hsaeFro ovi neI ae ii g u ecoe acp o tadcs n nlsd o y fht eio . i T e esnfrhsu pe etlid nifa teFf Crut a rldfa ac i u dz h rao o tisp lm nact o sh th if i ihsue h t bm n e a hc te iil lnmC pdhAtT MC 'dentpltccmsnewhra h Dgt Mi nl oygt c( A' osoap o il t cs ee ae <) D y rl a poed nmesr d e n t cul peet oyn o sf ae I prcl ,fh poed n ttco ale os o atay rvn cpig fot r. n adua ite rtc o z l w r mes ed e n t lc tetp o acs teDMC id s ndt peette tesfw r i at os o bok h ye fcesh u A s ei e o rvnyhn h otaes g 're acsilywi i temenn o teDMC . t i rl gteFf Ci utolwe te Tel ces e' t n h aig fh fy b' h A Wi t li ,h ih r ifl d h h s ln tc o t opi aycss w r t ae MDY tftne i i b esosp ottagmettateAp el ' m eeecd n t d ft u p ri ra n hth ples s s e Doc. 50 MDY Industries, LLC v. Blizzard Entertainment, Inc., et al (lzr' ci udrh DMC wamets-Dx a f/ IcvJ /Cn l t stm Bi a s bm nete A s dls mr r'n..%/ ot ysm f z d) e kl 2m eo te it Ctutn Ca briGrv,n..klkTcsIcf m teFdrl iciTh nlg h Sxh iciad hm ean y IcvSyi e ,n.t h eeaCrlt e an l/ nh o z. i isnfateaste ihCtuts o tehrapltccittjt lzr'agmet si icnbcueh Ff i iinw h ti peaeiutoecBiadsru ns g tc d lt ez tgrigtDMC ci.lte nhCtztjtteehestddcinadusn ea n i A bm fh Nit iltec hstreo eiosn rl i ds ci es ms e Bi adsao,t lcet asl wi i tecrut ors nteise F rteetao sweak lzr'fv riwi tae pi t n h i icuto b su. o hs esn, s z l th c tayupoie cp otilt adte UP Ssmsaeoteugsofl e hto rvd aoy fhsee n h MGE S yt cst l jdeftlt t tt e a b cnieabn o s rt . d Th rlvn p Go so MDY'bifta ag eteep itaeo pgs 53 o i Frt e eeat o n f S r sht tu hs ons r n ae 2 -8 ft i e ss B e o CrsAp eln o pgs1-4o i RelBt f T eep itweeas dsusd h f n os paad n ae 93 ft py i . h s ons r l icse s e o Dockets.Justia.com MsMoy we . lD yr Jl2,00 u 221 y Pg2 ae dtgoaagmetrm1: t 1: ad3: t3: ( idct iteeodn a ibe li tlta nf 10o 6 4n 7 4o 8 0a niadnh rcrigwl l zn o4 3 4 3s e l ate nhCrutwese. th Nit i is bi) . c' t Sn ee , icrl y VE A L , MPL O, G N& ME NE , C. N B E CA IL LO A A Y P. L neC. nbe ac Veal F th Ft o te im L v/o c rc c: hidnGe esiEs. Co nefr ple cC t a ntk, q- u slo Ap ees s l E cote nls u Ca e 0 -0 21 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e 1 t i : 72 /0 0 e I THE UNI ED STATES COURT OFAPPEALS N T FOR THE FI TH CI CUI uisxclfpa F R T ndv auAes t e : pl F IL E D No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 J l2 , 0 0 uy 0 2 1 L l W. y e ye Ca c clr ek M GE UPSS S EM SI C YT N Plitf- p la t Cr s - pp le an if Ap eln - o sA ele GECONSUMERANDI DUSTRI LI C; I DUSTRI LS STEMSI C; N A N GE N AY N GEN ERAL ELECTRI COMPANY; POWER MAI TENAN CE C N I TERNATI NAL 1 C N O N Dee d n s Ap ele Cr s fn a t pl s e os Ap elnt p la s App a fo t eUnie S a e DititCo r e lr m h td t ts src u t frt eNo t e nDitito Te a o h rh r src f x s BeoeBARKS ALE, fr D GARZ , n PRADO,Cic i J d e . A ad rut u g s EMI I M. L O GARZ , rutJ d e A Cic i u g : MGEUP S se sIc( GE)p eltedsrccut F drl l S ytm ,n .d 'a pash itito r' e eaRue M s o CvlP oeue5()ds islo isDiia Mienu Coyih Ac f ii rcd r 0a im sa f t gtl l n im p rg t t l (DMC Dcama an t o eMane a c Itrain lIcC MI)Geea C A li gisP w r itn nenen to a,n .P '; nrl ElcrcC mp n (GE)GEC n u e a dId sra,n .a dGEId sra eti o a y$ '; o s m r n n u tilIc;n n util $ S se s I c (olciey t E/MI) MGE as a p astedsrc cu t ytm ,n .cl t l,d P '. ev G lo p el h itit o r' s dnaopeu g etneetnMGE'd mae a ad GE/MIrs-p el eilfrjd m n itrso S a gs w r. P cosa p as o fu go n s () eh rt edsrc cu terdi ds isn GEP I n o r ru d :1 wh te h itit o r re n im sig /M ' S Rue5 () t nbcu e fi dt peet vdn eod mae,ri te l 0a moi ea s MGE al o rsn eie c f a gso n h o e Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e z DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g: t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 atraiewh te tedsrccut re i ds isn GE/MI Rue5 () len t , eh rh itit or erd n im sig P ' l 0b v S moinbcu ete$ .miinjr a adwa n t rao alcluaino to ea s h 46 lo uy w r s o a esn be aclto f l d mae;()wh te MGE i pr isby du l-eoee d mae;() a gs 2 ehr m em sil o bercvrd a gs 3 whehe t ep risha atligare e ti plc t a p r itdMGE t t r h ate d oln ge m n n ae h t em te o rcvrd mae pirt Dee b r1, 0 1a d() eh rtedsrccut eoe a gs ro o cm e 720 ;n 4 wh te h itito r erdi ga tn MGEijntv rl f gis GEP I re n rnig nu cie ei aan t /M . e I Unn er pil p we s p l ( P ' mahn saeu e d rn p ro s itru tbe o r u py t S' c ie r sd u ig eid d) U o p we o t g s t p o ie p we t ciia o e ai g s se s MGE f o r u a e o rvd o r o rtc l p r tn y tm . ma ufcur ssv r lie o UPSma hie , o eo whc r q iet eus o n a t e e e a ln s f c n s s m f ih e u r h e f M GE' c p rg td s fwa ep o r msPa rta dMu u td rngs r ii g S o y ih e ot r r g a ce n g e u i evcn . Thi sfwa efx sc l r to p o lm smo eq ikyt a ta iina ma ua s ot r ie ai a in r be b r u c l h n r dto l n l sr ii g tc niue . Wiho tt e s fwa e a s r ie tc nca c n si evcn e h q s t u h ot r , evc eh iin a tl l p ril s r iea MGE UPS ma hne b tanumb ro ciia p oe ur s a tal evc n y ci , u e f rtc l r c d e ( cu igrcl rto a dajsmet fotg lvl)a o lb p rome i ldn eai ain n du t n ovlaeeescn ny e efr d n b t r u hu eo t esfwa e whihwo k o l o MGE- a u a t r dd vcs h o g s f h ot r , c r s ny n m n fcu e e ie . Thesfwa er q ie cnneto o a e tr a ha d a es c rt ke ot r e u r s o cin f n xe n l r w r e u iy y (aldaRo ge)oteatpsrapr.E c dn lh s neprt nd t, cl dn l't h lpo eil ot ah o ge a a x iai ae e o ama i um numbe o u e,a dau iu p swod Whe t esfwaei xm r f ss n nq e a s r . n h ot r s a tv td,i s a c e fra p o el p o r mme d ngebeo e i wi fly cia e t e rh s o r p ry r g a d o l fr t l ul l lun h.Onc lun he ,hesfwa ewil ot r ug as cnds re o p oo o ac e a c d t ot r lg h o h eo eis f rtc l e c a g swih t e d t lc td o t e UPS mahi es mir p o e sr t x h n e t h a a o ae n h c n ' co r c so s o cnim t a MGE sfwaei cmmu iaigwih MGE had ae l t e o fr h t ot r s o nctn t r w r. f h p ooo ec a g is cesu, Ssfwaep oe d t clety tm saus rtclxh n es u csflMGE' ot r rce so olc sse tt ifr a infrt etc nca . no m to o h eh iin Ye r atrMGEi to uc diss c rt tc noo y, numb ro s fwa e a s fe n r d e t eu iy e h lg a e f ot r ha k r pu ls e i fr aino t eitr e dslsngg ne a isr cinso c e s bih d n o m to n h n en t icoi e r ln tu to n h w t d fa t e e tr a s c rt fa u e o a ha d a e ke . Onc t e o o ee t h xe n l eu iy e t r s f r w r y eh Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e 3 DaeFld: 72 /0 0 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g: t i 0 /02 1 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 sfwa e i c a k d a d t e sc rt ke i d fa e ,t e s fwa e c n be ot r s r c e n h e u iy y s ee td h ot r a a c s e a dus dwiho tlmiain. ce s d n e t u i tto P Ii aciia p we sr iec mp n s rii gav reyo b a dso M s rtc l o r e vc o a y evcn a it f r n f UPS mahie,icu igMGE UPS mahne. PMIiiil s b o tatd c n s n ldn ci s ntal u cnr ce y MGEt p rom sfwaesr ieo MGEUPSmahne, u smei eb fr o efr ot r evc n c i sb t o tm eoe J ne 2 0 ,a g o p o PMIe po e so t ie a la to e c p o MGE' u 0 0 ru f m ly e b an d t e s n o y f S sfwa efo a un n wnsu c.GEaq ie PMIi 2 01 ot r rm n k o o re c urd n0 . I Dee b r 2 0 ,MGE fld s i a ans GE/MI fr itrala, n cm e 0 4 ie ut g i t P o, ne i c p rg ti fi g me t mia p o ra ino ta esce s un arcmpeiin, o y ih n rn e n , s p r p ito f r d e rt , fi o tto c n e so , ndDMCAvoains GE/ M I o sno ds u ela iiy ia mu h o v r in a ilto . P d e t ip t ib l ,n s c t a i a mist rc v rngalptpfo afr e PMIe po e t a c n ane s t d t o e o ei a o r m o m r m ly e h t o t i d hake MGEsfwae a da mist f eisa cso ti sfwaesus fo cd ot r, n d t o i n tn e fhs ot r' e rm v J ne2 0 t r ug Ma 2 0 .MGE alg st a GE/ M Ius dt es fwa ea u 00ho h y 02 le e h t P e h ot r tt lo 4 8 tme ,icudng u e atr t e dsrc c u tg a t d MGE a oa f 2 i s n l i s s fe h itit o r r n e pei iayijnt na an tGEP I u eo MGESsfwaea dta e rl n r nu ci gis /M ' s f ' ot r n rd m o S s ces er t. Du igt ep oe dng frti ato ,GE/MImo e ,rne e ,a d rn h rce i s o hs cin P vd e w d n r-re moin frs mmayjd me ta djd meta amatro lw eugd to s o u r u g n n u g n s te f a p ru n t F drl lso CiiP oeu e5 ()a d()ag ig itrai, us a to e ea Rue f vl rcd r 0a n b run ,ne l a t a MGE cul no s san aDMCA c us o a to a ans GE/ M I Afe ht o d t u ti a e f cin g i t P . tr iiil d n igGEP I p era moinfrs mmayjd me t n is l ntal e yn /M ' rtil to o u r u g n a d t Rue y S 5 ()moino MGESDMC cam,h dsrc cu tds isdt eDMC 0a to n ' A li t e itit o r im se h A cam d rn a of eodjr c ag cnee c. euyfu dta GE/MI li uig n f- cr uy h re ofrne Th jr o n h t P r h d i fi g d MGE' c p rg t,mia p o rae MGE' ta e sces a d a n rn e S o y ih s s p r p it d S r d e rt, n cmmitdu fi b sn s patcs T ejr a ad dMGE tefl wig o te nar uies rcie. h u y w re h ol n o d ma e : a gs Ca e 0 -0 2 D c me t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e 4 DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 o u n: 0 1 1 9 6 g: t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 Da a e frmia p o raino ta es ceso MGE'd t m g s o s p r p ito fr d er t n S aa ds : ik 1 Ne p oise r e b GE/ M Ifo J nua y1 2 0 t . t r ft a n d y P r m a r , 0 1 o Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 6 ,0 cm e 7 2 0 : 4 00 0 Ne p oise r e b GE/M Ir m De e b r1 , 0 1 t rft a n d y P fo c m e 8 2 0 t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ ,5 ,0 o g s 5 2 0 : 18 20 0 B. Da a e frc p rg tifi g me t m g s o o y ih n rn e n : 1 Ne p oise r e b GE/ M Ir m J nua y1 2 0 t . t rft a n d y P fo a r , 0 1 o Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 6 ,0 cm e 7 2 0 : 3 80 0 2 Ne p oise r e b GE/M I rm De e b r1 , 0 1 . t r ft a n d y P fo c m e 8 2 0 t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ ,5 ,0 o g s 5 2 0 : 18 20 0 Da a e fr sp rpito oMGEsfwa eta esces m gso mia p orain f ot r rd ert: Ne poise r e b GE/MIfo J nuay12 0 t t rft an d y P rm a r , 0 1 o Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 20 0 cm e 7 2 0 : 9 ,0 2. Ne p oise r e b GE/ M Ifo De e b r1 , 0 1 t r ft a n d y P r m c m e 8 2 0 t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ o g s 52 0 : 0 T T L: $ ,2 ,0 OA 46 40 0 h-I rC Cur a a e - -S l o . r W e Oa J r V r 1t P S-I g e i l y e Cj O tJ m n l I itrs, pr a etijnto a antGEP Ii p u d eto ifign neeta em n n nu cin gis /M ,m o n m n fnrnig mae il,a a l c ssa datr e 'fe . dsrc c ur d cie t a a d trastx be ot, n to n ys e s The itit o t eln d o w r peu g e tneet nted ma ea ad. rjdm n itrs o h a g w rs 1 1 M GEag e t a t edsrc cu t re i ga tn GEP I Rue 0a ru s h th itit o r erd n rnig /M ' l 5 () S moin ds isngMGE' DMCA voain cam. Werve d n v a til to im si S ilto li e iw e o o ra cut dcso o aRue5() to fru g et samatr fa ,iwig or' eiin n l 0a moin o jd m n a te olw ve n s al fhee ie c Nnt elg ta dwihale s na l i fr nc s s fv r be lo t vd n e h ih n t lr a o be n e e e mo t a o a l t t ep ryo po e t t emoin. ReouinTr s Cop. .Cr me , F.d o h a t p s d o h to ' s lto u t r v a r 6 3 ' 10 , 19(t Ci.93 ( tra q oain o i e)ARue5 () to i 12 10 5h r19 )i en l utto s m t d. l 0a moin s n t p o el ga td di t e fcs a d ifrn e p it s srn l a d rp ry r ne dq h at n nee cs on o to gy n lf Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e s t i : 72 /0 0 e No 081 5 1 . -0 2 oewh l igyi fvr fh moig at ..h tesn beuoso l nt vr em n l n ao ote vn p ry .ta rao aljrr cud o h v arvda acnrr vrit'I.ctto o itd. a e rie t o tay edc. d (iain m te) GE/MIa g e t a MGE' dnged e n tat al p e e tcp igo P ru s h t S o l os o cu l rv n o yn f y MGE'sfwae b tmeeyp ee t a cs t tesfwae On et a a cs S ot r, u rl rv n s ces o h ot r. c h t ces i b e c e ,h r a en b rir t c p i gt es fwa e Aco dngy, PM I s r a h d t e e r o a re s o o yn h ot r . c r i l GE/ a g e t a MGE' s fwa ei dr ey a c sil'wihn t eme ni go t e ru s h t S ot r s t e l ce sbe' t i h a n f h f DM CA b c us t ed nged e n tbok tetp o fces'teDMCA i ea e h o l os o lc h y e fd cs' h a s d sg e t p e e t Furhemoe to g teMGE sfwa ei GE/ MI ein d o rv n . t r r , h u h h ot r n P ' S p s e so d a mo iid't ei ia et ene d fra d nge MGE ha no o s sin d s dfe ' o lm n t h e o o l, w st p e e tde ie c t a aPMIe po e iiil mo iidt es fwa e r sn e vd n e h t m ly e ntal dfe h ot r . y Oneo Co gesp r oe b hnde atngt eDMCA wa tr eigte f n rs' u p ss e i n ci h s agtn h crumv nto o t c n lgc l rtcins Se Davd o ( Aso s v Ju g, 2 ic e in f eh oo ia p oe to . e is n s c. . n 4 2 F3 60 6 94 (t Cr2 0 ) T eDMC 'a t-icmvninpoiin .d 3, 3- 0 8h i. 0 5. h AS ni ru eto rvso c sae ,d opes n s alcrumv ntatc noo ia me s r t a efciey t ts d ro h l ic e N e h lgc l a u e h t fe tv l cnrlacs t awokpoetdu drhsil. 1 U... 10 ()1() o tos ceso r rtce n e titte' 7 SC j 2 1a() . A To dic mv ntatc noo ia me s r 'me n t H e ca bl a sr mbe cru e e h lgc l a u e' a s o d sr m e ca ld wok,t d cy ta e cy t dwo k,o oh r iet a od b p s ,r mo e r o erp n n rpe r r tew s o v i, y a s e v , d a tv t ,o i par at c n lgc lme s r ,wiho tt ea t o iy o t e e ciae r m i eh oo ia a u e t u h u h rt f h cp rgto nr' I. 10()3() d f cieycnrl acs t awok o yih w e. d j 2 1a() . d f tvl otos ces o r' A Ee me nst a Rheme s r ,nt eo dna yc u s o iso e ain, e ur st e a h tt a u e i h r i r o r e f t p r to r q ie h a pia ino i fr ain, rap o e so ate t e twiht ea t oiyo t e p lc to fn o m to o rc s r r am n , t h u h rt f h cp rg t wn rt gi acs t tewok'I. 10 () ) ) GEP Ide oyih o e,o an ces o h r . d j 2 1a( ( . /M os 3B n tcnts t a MGE' s fwa ewa awok p oe td u d rTil 1 o t e o o et h t S ot r s r rt ce n e te 7 f h Co y ihtAc. p rg t TheDMCA d e no d srb t e y eo S ce s-o toln tc noo ia o s t e cie h t p fd c snc n r lig eh lgc l a me s r r q ie t i v k t eDMCA'p oe to s a dt i i a is eo frt au e eurd o n o e h S r tcin , n hs s n su f is i p e so i t i Cic i. MGE p o o e a d fniin fo a Fit Cic i m r sin n hs rut r p s s ei to r m fh rut nO - M CA c s t a d sus e c p rg tis e a d d tr i e R ce s t nD a e h t ic s d o y ih su s n ee m n d a c s' o ' Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e 6 t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 icu e$no p runt t ve t ec p rg tdwo k. Feg s n! Na 'Br a . n ld $ p ot iy o iw h o y ih e r ' r u o p t o d a ' .l Co,8 F.d1113(t Cr17 )ctn 3M. IME , PRG Tj1.2A) .5 4 2 1,1 5h i.9 8 (iig N M RCO Y IH 30 ( (9 8) Re dn ti d f io ao gied f io sfo Mera - e se' 1 7 ). a ig hs ei t n ln sd ei t n rm rim W b tr ni ni s dcin r a d Blc ' La Dito a y MGE c n l d st a d ce s me n ito a y n a ks w cin r , o cu e h t d c s' a s a' diwigma igu eo,rusngtep oetdwok.MGEag e ta d nge d e n , kn s fo i h rtce r ' v ' r u sh t o ls p e e t da c s t iss fwa ea dt a wiho tu i gb t t i ha d a eke r v n e ce s o t ot r n h t t u sn oh h s r w r y a discre p n i gp swo d ausrc nn t iw, ana c s t ,rma eus n t o r s o dn a s r , e a o ve g i ce s o o k e o t esfwa e f h ot r . Ho e e ,MGE a v c t s to b o d a d fniin o d ce s' t er w vr d oae o ra ei to f d c s i h i a ' itrrtto wolpr il bly n e j 2 1afr cesn awoksmpy nepeain ud em ti itu dr 1 0()o acsig r i l ai t ve i o t u ei wihn t epu ve o Sarus'pemitd un e t e o iw t r o s t t i h r iw f d i e' r te d r h f Co yiht t Meeyb p sigatc n lgc l rtcint a rsrcsausr p rg Ac. rl y asn eh oo ia p oeto h t etit e fo ve i g o usng a wok i i s fiin t tig r t e DMCA' rm iw n r i r s n ufce t o rg e h S a t-ic mv ninp oiin.TheDMCA p o iiso l fr so acs t a n icru e to rvso rhbt ny om f ces h t wo l voa eo i png o t ep oeto st a t eCo y ihtAc ohewie u d ilt r m i e n h r tcin h t h p rg t t r s afr scp rg to nes Sc Cha branGru ,n . . yikTeh .I c, fo d o yih w r. c m eli o p I c vSk ln c s,n . 3 1F.d1 7 , 2 2(e . i. 0 4.T eF drlCruti a ayigte 8 3 1 8 10 F d Cr 2 0) h e ea ici,n n lzn h DMC 'a t-icmvninpoiincnld dh ttcn elq oadto a AS ni ru e to rvso ,ocu e taido vysn d iin l c poet rg ti a dote sle;i)i pypoiespo et o n r wih rpry ihsn n fh m evs( sm l rvd g)rpry w es t t n w wa st s c r t erp o et . I .a 1 9 -9 .I d e ,dit al e e y e y o eu e h i r p ry' d t 1 3 4 n e d d ru l v r ' v y ca s o j10 ta meto sacs'ik dcestirtcin. I.t19 . lu e f 2 1h t nin dcesl sacs'opoeto ' d a 17 n ' W iho ts o i gal k b t e n dce s a d Rr tcin'o t ec p rg t d t u h w n i ew e d c s' n p oeto ' f h o y ih e n a' wo k, heDMCA' a t-ic mv nto p o iin d e no a py.Theo ne ' rt S n icru e in rvso o s t p l w rs tc n lgc l me s r mus p o et t e c p rg td mae il a ans a eh oo ia a u e t r tc h o y ih e tra g i t n ifi g me to arg tt a t eCo y ih Ac p oet, tfo meeus o nrn e n f ih h t h p rg t t r tcs no r m r e r ve ig I . t1 0 ;e as L x akI t I cv Stt C nrl o p n ns iw n . d a 2 4 se lo em r n k n . . ai o to C m o e t, c Ic, 8 F.d5 2 57(t Cr2 0)(n ign DMC a t-icmvnin n.3 7 3 2 , 4 6h i. 0 4 f dn o A ni ru e to i c l blt wh r a a t e tc to sq e c i ap itrmir c i bo k do e i iiy e e n u h n iain e u n e n rn e co hp lc e n a Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e 7 DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g: t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 fr o acs (rne fnto) u p r itdfe acs fo ohra eu s om f ces pitr u cin b t em te re cesrm te v n e ( r xmpea yn wh p rh sdta ba dopitro ldwnodacp f ea l,n o e o uc ae h t rn f rne cud o la o y o o tepo r ml. f h rga ) Hee MGE ha no s o n ta b p sigisd ngeifig sarg t r, s t h w h t y asn t o l nrn e ih p oetdb teCo yiht t MGE'd ngemeeyp e e t iiil cest rtce y h p rg Ac. S o l rl rv n snta ac s o t esfwa e I n d n l i d tce ,hesfwa ep o r m wi n tc mpee h ot r . f o o ge s eet d t ot r r g a l o o lt l t esa tupp oe s Ho e e , v ni ad ngei p e e t i d e n tp e e t h tr- r cs . w v r e e f o l s r s n ,t o s o r v n t eltr l o eo tx o MGE'c p rg t dc mp tr ot a efo b i gfe l h ie a c d r e t f S o y ih e o u e s fw r r m en r ey r a a dcpe o c t a a c s i o t i e ;he ei noe cy to o ohe fr e d n o id n e h t c e s s b an d t r s n r p in r t r o m o p oe to o t esfwa eislt p e e tc p rg t ilto s Bea s t e f r tcin n h ot r tef o r v n o y ih voain . c u e h d nged e no p o eta ans c p rg tvoain ,t eme efc t a t e o l o s t r tc g i t o y ih ilto s h r a t h t h dn l i efi cru vne de ntgv rs t acru vninvoain o ge t l s icm etd os o ie ie o icm eto ilto s wihi t eme nngo t eDMCA. t n h a i fh Moev rt eDMCA'a t-ic mv nto poiind e no a pyt t e ro e,h S nicru e in rvso os t p l o h ue foyihe wok cfrh tc nlgcl aue a be cru vne , socprg td rs / teeh ooiame sr h s en icm e td c treigise dtecru v nto isl.Unies l t StdisI cvCo ly ag tn n ta h ic m e in tef vra Ciy u o,n .. re, 2 3F.d4 9 4 3(dCr 2 0) MGE ctsn eiec ta aGEP I 7 3 2 , 4 2 i. 0 1. ie o vdne h t /M e po e o rp e e t tv wa r s o sbefratrngt ePa rta dMu ue m ly e r e r s n a ie s e p n il o lei h ce n g t sfwa es c t a a d ngewa n tr q ie t u et esfwa e Wiho t ot r u h h t o l s o e ur d o s h ot r . t u p o igGE/MIat al cru v n e t etc n lg (so p sdt u ig rvn P cu l ic m e td h eh ooy a p oe o sn y tc n lg ara ycru v ne )MGEd e n t rsn av l DMC cam. eh oo y le d ic m e td, o s o pee t ai d A li Sei.(()eDMC trestecru vnin o dgtlwal g adn ed$h < T A agt h icm e t f iia l u rig o s cp rg tdmaeil(n tafkn i cru vnintos,b tde n t oyihe tra a d rfi ig n icm eto ol) u os o c cn enislwiht e s otoemaeilatr ic mv ninh s cu r d'. o cr tef t h u e fh s tras fe cru e to a oc re . ' ) Be a s t eDMCA d e n ta pyt me eus o acp rg t dwok,a d cue h o s o p l o r e f o y ih e r n b cus MGE ha n ts o n t a GE/MIcrumv ne MGE' sfwae ea e s o h w h t P ic e td S ot r poeto si voaino teDMCA,hedsrc cu tddn teri ga tng rtcin n ilto fh t itit o r i o r n r ni GEP I Rue5() t nds isn MGE'DMC cam. /M ' l 0a moi im sig S A li S o Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e 8 t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 II I GE/MIag e tedsrc cut re i dn igisRue5() to P ru sh itit or erd n eyn t l 0a moin wihrg r t MGE'cam und rt eCo yih Ac b c u etetsi o yo t ea d o S li e h p rg t t ea s h etm n f MGE'd ma e e p rha bensrc e ,ndMGEi p o el rle o PMls S a g s x et d e tik n a m rp ry eid n ' ttlgosrv n efg r rt e t a tepoto ra o a l rltdt t e oa rs e e u iu e ah r h n h rin e sn by eae o h cp rg tifigme t Fo t es merao ,GE/MIag e MGE fie t o yih nrn e n . r h a e sn P r u s ald o p o ea1t eee e t o issa elw mia p o rain o ta es cesa d r v 1 h lm n s f t tt a s p r p ito f r d er t n un arc mp tto camswiho tito u ige ie c o PMIsp oisr ltd fi o eiin li : t u n r d cn vd n e f ' r ft ea e t t eifig me tMGEha fie t p o ed ma e frt eecams o h nrn e n , s ald o rv a g s o h s li . A GE/MIag e ta tedsrc cuterdi dn igisRue5 () P ru s h t h itit or re n eyn t l 0a moinb c u eMGEfie t p e e ts fiint vd nc o da a e .Un e 1 to e a s ald o r s n u fce e ie e f m g s d r 7 U...j5 4a()a d()acp rg to n ri pr itdt rcvrhso n SC j 0 ()1 n b, oyih w e s em te o eoe i w dcua d ma e ,icu i gls p oisa dSe sna l r y lyr t s'o wha t t l a g s' n ldn o t r ft n s a o be o at ae ,' r t a ' r awilngbu e wo l ha ebe nz a o a l r q ie t pa awii gsle a li y r ud v e e sn by e u r d o y l n elr s l alc n i gfefrt ea t a us o t ec p rg tdma eil yt ei fi g r . ie sn e o h cu l e f h o y ih e tra b h n rn e s Da ivGa ,n.2 6F.d1 21 7(dCr20 )Acp rg twn r yas vs . p Ic,4 3 5 ,6 2 i.0 1. oyih o e ma lo se d n p oiso t ei fig rt a a eatiutbet t eifi g me ta d e k s y r ft f h nrn e h t r trb a l o h n rn e n n a a e no t k n it a c u ti c mpu i g t e a t a d m a e .' 1 U... r t a e n o co n n o tn h cu l a g s' 7 SC j54b. I tecprg to n rcosst cam ifigr pois Gh 0 () f h oyih w e h oe o li nrn e' rft, te s cp rg t wne i r q ie t p e e t r o o l o t eifi g rsg o srv nue o y ih o rs e ur d o r s n p o f n y fh n rn e' r s e e , a d t ei fi g ri r q ie t p o ehi o he d d cil e p ns sa dt e n h n rn e s e u r d o r v s r r e u tbe x e e n h ee e t o p oi atiutbet fco soh rt a t ec p rg tdwo k.'I . lm n s f rft trb a l o a tr t e h n h o y ih e r ' d; seas Esaeo V n vFarIc,4 F.d16 18(t Cr18 )apyn e lo tt f ' e . i,n .89 2 8 ,8 5h i.9 8 (p lig c ti sa dr t cp rg tifigmetato se igifigr pois. hs tn ad o oyih nrn e n cin ekn nrn e' rf ) st GE/ MIa g e t a MGE fie t s tsyt ef s se o p o i gi fig rs P ru s h t ald o a if h i t tp f rvn nrn e ' r p oisb c u eMGE'o l e ie c o gosrvnu swa Ex ii DX-7 a rft ea s S ny vd n e f rs ee e s hbt 3 , o epa eb rg a hs o i gPMI Roa r v n e'r m ali e o b sne sfo n - g a rp h w n ' ttl e e u ' o lln s f u i s r m s f Cae0 -0 2 Dou et0 5 17 9 9 Pa eg DaeFld 0 /02 1 s :815 1 c m n 0 1 196 g: t i : 72/0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 2 01trug 2 0 .GE/MIcne d t a tic aticud su dfee tae 0 h o h 0 4 P o tn s h ths h r n l e n ifrnitd gosrv n efo sriigav reyob a dso euime tno meeyMGE rs e e u rm evcn ait f rn f q p n , t zl e uime t a d t e eo e d e n t r fe t rv nu s Strbu a l t t e q p n , n h r fr o s o elc e e e f ti tb e o h a ifig me t' nrn e n . ' 'olc l blyh s enso n j5 4b cetsa iia peu pin d n ei it a b e h w , 0 () rae n nt l rsm t l ai i o t a t eifi g rsTr ft . . trb t bet t eifi g me ta ee ua t is h t h n rn e' p ois . a tiu a l o h nrn e n ' r q l o t gosrv n e'Bo n r . w o , 0 F.d2 0 2 4(t Ci. 0 5 (leain rs e e u . n e vDa sn 4 4 3 9 , 9 4h r2 0 )atrto i oiia)q oig1 U... 5 4b)tnmet gtiiilu dnh wee, n rgn l(u t 7 SC b 0 ().d ei isntab re ,o vr n l n acp rg th le mus s o moet a t eifi g rstt l r s rv n efo o y ih od r t h w r h n h nrn e ' oa g o s e e u r m alo isp oi sra s l f t rft te m . Rah r (rs rv n e rfr o l t rv n e te ,gos e e u ' ees ny o e e u raoa l rltdt teifigme t f .e p ae a dd;e as Da i, esn by eae o h nrn e n. d (m h ss d e)se lo vs ' 2 6 F3 a 19 6 (n igpofrd eie c o dfn a t ttlgos 4 .d t 5- 0 f dn rf e vdne f ee dn' oa rs i e s rv nu s to b o d t s p ot a c p rg t ifi g me t cam b s d o e e e o r a o u p r o y ih nrn e n li a e n dfn a t u eopani scprg tdeelse i a a cmpin; tt ee dn' s f litf oyihe y gassn n d a ag)Esae s f o V n,89F.da 1 8 1 0(n igta G lmpsm fgr frpois f c e 4 2 t 8 , 9 f dn h t a u -u iue o rf i t atiu a l t t etlvso c mmecast a cnti e ifi g dma eila trb t be o h ee iin o ril h t o an d n rn e tra s awhoewiho ta c u tngfrt efc t a t ei fi g dma e ilcnsiutd l t u co n i o h a t h t h n rn e tra o tt e o l afa to o a ygv n c mme ca'wa tos e ultv a cnne to t ny r cin f n ie o ril s o p c aie o cin o ' ssand ma e)T yo !Merc,1 F2 1 1,12(t Cr1 8)fn ig uti a gs; c rJ iik7 2 .d 1212 7h i.9 3( dn . i isfce tfrj 54b p roe ta pani so e dfn a t gos nufin o 0 () up ss h t litf h w d eed n' rs i f s rv nu sfo t es lso alp o u t ise do d mo sr tngg o srv nu s e e e r m h ae f l r d cs n ta f e n tai r s e e e fo sl o t eifign p o u t) rm ae fh nrn ig rd cs. MGEsu h o e $ 0 miini d ma e b sdamot x ls eyo t e o g t v r 1 0 lo n a g s ae l se cu i l n h l v tsi o y o iso l d ma e e p r,Dr La r n ePr sot Dr Pr sot e tm n f t ny a g s x et . u a c ec t. . e c t' s tsi oy rltd t t o d maemoes ()MGE' ls poi ;a d () etm n eae o w a g dl: 1 S ot rfs n 2 t r cvei g a r a o a l r y ly. Noa l,Dr P e c t dd n t tsi t e o rn e s n b e o at tby . r s ot i o e tf o y GE/MISpoisatiutbet t eifig me t Thedsrc cur c rid P ' rf trb a l o h nrn e n . t itit o t are Cae 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e l DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g : o t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 GE/MI F drl loEvdne 0 a dDa brkbetoso .rsot P ' eeaRue f iec 72 n uetojcin tDrP ect' S s tsi o ya dp r itdh m t tsiya til Afe he rnghi tsi o y t e e tm n n e m te i o e tf t ra. tr a i s e tm n ,h d src c u tc n l d dt a i s o l b src e i ise tr t , ee mii g itit o r o cu e h t t h u d e tik n n t n iey d tr nn ta Dr Prsot cncuso sr gr igMGE' ls poisweeb sdo h t . ect' o l in e adn s S ot rft r a e n is fiin fcsa dd t,ncu igu s p ot da s mpin r g r igMGE' n ufce ta t n a ai ldn n u p re su to s e a dn S ls ma ke s a ea ds r iep ii g Thed src c u tas fu dDr Pr sot ot r t h r n evc rcn . itit o r lo o n . e c t ha n e p re c i a s sigh p t eia r a o a l ry lyr t sa dt a d o x ein e n se sn y oh tc l e s n be o at ae n h t hspofrdh pteia rao al rylyrt wa ntb sdo ojcie i rf e y oh tcl esn be oat ae s o ae n betv e a ay i. n lss Onc Dr P e c t' tsi o ywa src e , e . r sots etm n s tik n MGE ofr dafna wine s fe e i l t s , M GEg nea ma a e Miha l Bre , op e e t dtsi o yrltngo l e r l n g r c e O' in wh r s n e e tm n eai ny t MGE' r a o a l r y ly d ma e . O're wa ne e d sg a e a a o S e s n be o at a g s B in s v r e in td s n e p r o d ma ec lulto s Thedsrc cur uli aeyfun hi tsi o y x et n a g ac a in . itit o t tm tl o d s e tm n isfcett pr iMGE t ofrajr isrcino rao al ryly n uf in o em t i o f uy n tut n esn be oat e o d ma e . a g sz M GE' o l r manige ie c o d m a e wa DX-7 t eb rg a h S ny e i n vd n e f a g s s 3 , h a r p i dc tngPMIstt lrv nu fo 2 01t r ug 2 0 .Th u ht i wa a n ia i ' oa e e e r m 0 h o h 0 4 o g h s s n e hbtp e a e b GE/ M It edsrc c u ta mit dt ee hii d rn Dr x ii r p r d y P ,h itit o r d te h x b t u ig . ' uetJMerlDo P ams fc,0 U..7,9 (93. Da brI rel w h r . n.59 S 595219) . , 2T pcl ,odmo srt rao alry l dmae,apani peet eie c yial t e ntae esn be oat a gs litf rsns vdn e y y f a t R h th p riswo l h v are t a afipi frle sn tedfn a top t so w a te ate ud a e ged o s ar rc o i nig h ee d n t u ec tetaesce t teu etedfn a titn e a tet etemiaporainto h rd ert o h s h ee dn ne dd t h i h sp rpito ok m pae'U i. o puigC..ye-onso nC r.54F2 5859(t Cr17) lc. nvC m t ovLksYugtw op,0 .d 1,3 5h i.94. ' n Ho ee, Bre wa o l al t tsi a t tery lya onsta MGEwo l aka w vrO' in s ny be o ety s o h oat m u t h t f ud s cmpt o tp ytpeeth to pttrrm etrn teUP srien uty -h ts o ei ro a o rvn ta cm ei fo neig h S evc id sr- ta i, t o sagrn l hg ry l a onsta wol pieotcmpttr.S c a o nsaent tgeigy ih oat m u t h t ud rc u o eios uh m u t r o y cgi be s tesnbeoat'a uain t hc a u eadslr olareo e onz la ad aoalryl cl lt a w i b yr n ee w ud ge tb a r /co h l mak t au frap riua peeo sfwae S e ctlUS ,n. . ic Ss, 3 F re v le o at lr ic f ot r. e Alae A Ic u Cso y .2 9 . c S p.d6069(..e.02Cl hs auesob cluae bsdo araoal u p2 6,6 ED Tx20) r imesrit eacltd ae n esnbe a ry l t whc tep risw udh v a re a tet eotealgdmiaporain oat o ih h at o l ae ged th i fh l e sp rpito . y e m e Whl teC utrcg ie ta smedge o seuaini ihrn i cluaiga i h or eonzs h t o ere f p clt s n ee t n acltn e o sp oio sl e sn are e tbt en t o p rista h s nvr ocre ,ti u pst u i nig gem n ew e w at h t a ee curd hs ic e hpteiacntut.. scnansmedge ocriu e'e p aiadd) yohtclosrc .mutoti o ere fet d.(m h ss del. t' 1 0 Cae 0-0 2 Dou e t0 5 179 9 P g :l DaeFld 0 /02 1 s :815 1 c m n:0 1 19 6 a e l t i :72/0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 Pr sotsr -iete a i a in.MGEq eto e Dr Pr soto l o t elc e c t' edr c x m n to u sin d . e ct ny n h a k o GE r v nuer p e e tdo DX-7sg a h.Dr P e ct wa no q e to e f ee e rsne n 3 ' r p . r sot s t u sin d a o twhehe t e t tlPMIr v nue i dc td o t e g a h r p e e td bu t r h oa e e n iae n h r p e r s n e r v nuer ltdt PMI i fi g me to MGE'c p rg t' e e ea e o ' n rn e n f s S o y ih . GE/MIag e t a i wo l no ha eicud dDX-7i ispo oe P ru s h t t ud t v n l e 3 n t rp sd e hiish dikn wnt a Dr Pr sot tsi o ywo l b src e 4 e a s x bt a t o h t . ec t' e tm n ud e tik n b c u e s ih dnoie MGEwo l bese igGE/MISpoisrt e ta MGE'o n t a da ud ekn P ' rft ah r h n Sw ls p oisa dr a o a l r y lis MGE c n e d t a se i gd fnda ts o t r ft n e s n be o ate . o t n s h t e kn ee n ' poiswa n tan w t er o rcv r b c us teJ itPrtilOr e rft s o e h oy f eo ey ea e h on era d r idctsta isu h ( oeayd mae p ru n t 1 U... 54'o n iae h tt o g tt ntr a gs u sa t o 7 SC b 0 'fr m cp rg t ifi g me t Thi prvso e c mp se alt p s o d ma e o y ih nrn e n . s o iin n o a ss 1 y e f a g s a albe frcp rg tifig me t icudng t ec p rg to ne' a t a v ia l o o y ih n rn e n , n l i h o y ih w rs cu l d ma e ,heifig rsp oisa tiu a l t t eifi g me ta dsa utr a g s t nrn e ' rft trb t be o h nrn e n , n t t oy d ma e. Ho e e,nisFe ea Rueo Cii P oe u e2 ()dsls rs a gs w v r i t d rl l f vl rcd r 6a icou e, whe a k dt p o i e$ c mpu a in o e c c tg r o d ma e came , n s e o r vd ( o t to f a h a e o y f a g s li d' a ' MGE i dc td t a Dr Pr sots tsi o y wo l c mp ie is d ma e n ia e h t . ec t' e tm n u d o rs t a g s c lua in.Dr Pr soto l tsi e t MGE' a t a d m a e : ac lto . ec t ny e tf d o i S cu l a g s MGE' o n Sw ls p oisa dr a o a l ry lyr ts I ohe wo d , her c r i dc ts ot r ft n e s n be o at ae . n t r r s t e o d n ia e t a MGEp a n dt rl e trl o isa t a d ma e cam; PMIhadno ht ln e o ey n iey n t cu l a g s li GE/ r a o t t ik t a MGE wa s e i g GE/ M ISp oisa tiutbet t e e s n o hn h t s ekn P ' rft trb a l o h ifig me t n rwa i p e a e t d fnda ans s c acam. nrn e n , o s t r p r d o ee g i t u h li dWle o eo teprmafceee e t o acam i d mae a dte d h n n f h i ai lm ns f li s a gs n h E cama tfist ito u ee i e c o t o ed ma e , o s ecmmisaft l li n al o n r d c vd n e f h s a g s he r h o t aa 3 h tilrncitn iae ta MGEma h v be tyn t rfroadf rn T e ra ta srp idcts h t y ae en rig o ee t ieet f gah(X-2acmprsnoMGEUP eup et rsrvn evru UP sriegos rp D 4 , o aio f S qim n goseeu ess S evc rs rvn erm 19 truh20) e irqetdtamiD -7 eeu fo 97 hog 07whn teu se o d t X3. 4 /MI l gst nyitn e t ue 3 ti pahDrP ect'asrinta GEP al e iol ne d d o s DX-7 om ec . rsot set h t e s o a MGESrvn e wetdwn GEP I rv n e we t p teehbtso sP I ttl s ' eeu s n o , /M ' eeu s n u ;h xii h w M ' oa S s rvn ermann rlt eycntn fo 2 0 tru h20 . eeu e iig eai l o sa trm 0 1 ho g 0 4 v Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : z DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e l t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -05 1 . 81 2 err'PrnyvAr. eg tasIc,6F.d6 96 2(t Cr19)MGE' ro. u t . kFrihw y,n.1 3 4,5 5h i.9 4. S d cso t se GE/MISpoiswa ceryals- iut atmp t sv is eiin o ek P ' rft s lal atm n e te t o a e t cp rg tnrng me tli fo ds is lo fiu et po ed ma e . o yih ifi e n cam rm im sa fralr o rv a g s MGE ha no s ce d d GE/ M l r s n e e ie c t a a p o i a ey1 % o PMI s t u c e e . p p ee t d vd n e h t p rxm tl 0 f ' s UPSs r ieb sn s c mefo MGE-r n e ma h n s a dMGE'sfwae evc u ie s a r m b a d d c ie, n S ot r wa usbeo l wihMGEUPSmahie a dn t t cmpeiosp o ucs s a l ny t c n s n o wih o ttr'r d t. Th s PMI tt lrv nu fr e c e s t e a p o i aey 1 % o rve ue u , ' o a e e e a x e d h p rx m tl 0 f e n s rao a l rltdt t eifig me to MGE'cp rg t MGE nede t e sn by eae o h nrn e n f S o yih . e do p e e tamo ena rwl t io e c lu aino PMI p oisi o de t c g ie r sn r ro y alr d ac lto f ' r ft n r r o o nz s acam frcp rg td m a e dtrb tbet t ei fi g me t'Aco dn l, li o o y ih a g sd tiu a l o h n rn e n .' cr i gy a tedsrc cuterdi dn igGEP I Rue5()moin o MGE' h itit or re n eyn /M ' l 0a to n S S c p rg ti fi g me tcamsbe a s MGE ha no s o n d ma e un e o y ih nrn e n li c u e s t h w a gs dr j54b. 0 () B GE/MIag e tedsrc cu t re i d n igisRue5 () t n P r u s h itit o r erd n e yn t l 0a moi o r g r i g MGE' mia p o rain o ta e s ces a d un ar c mp tto e a dn S s p rp ito f r d e rt n f i o eiin camsb cus t eeie c ddno s p otd ma e frteecams Att e li ea e h vd n e i t u p r a gs o h s li . h co eo MGE'c s ,heo l e ie c i to uc dt s p o tt d ma e cams ls f S a e t ny vd n e n r d e o u p r is a g s li wa t eao e e to e DX- 7c a ts o i gPMIs o a rv nu se r e fo s h fr m n in d 3 h r h w n 'tt l e e e a n d r m als u c so i cme GE/ M Ic n e d t a wiho te ie c o P Isne l o r e f n o . P o t n s h t t u vd n e f M ' t p oise r e o t eMGE e upme ta is e MGE' sa elw camss o l r ft a n d n h q i n t s u , S t t a li h u d h v be ds isdo GEP I Rue5 () to . ae en im se n /M ' l 0a moin S Th r i ltl p e e e tund rTe a lw t g ie u i d tr ii g e e s ite r cd n e x s a o u d s n eem nn whehe MGE ha s sane t eb r e o p o f e uie o apli tfs e i g tr s u t i d h u d n f ro r q r d f an if e kn t r cv rad fnd n 'ne p ois I t eo l r p re Te a c s iv li g o eo e ee a ts t r ft. n h n y e o t d x s a e n ovn t er cv r o d fn a tsp oisframia p o raino ta es cescam, h e o ey f ee d n ' r ft o s p r p ito f r d er t li teDalsCo r o Ap e lhedt a at o g dfn a ts oisaeadrp r h la u t f p as l h t lh u h ee d n 'prft r d o e p ee et)f a ae i acs iv ligtewrn fl s o ata esce,a lm nl o d m gsn aen ovn h o gu ue f rd ert ' 1 2 Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 17 9 9 P g : 3 DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e l t i : 72 /0 0 e No 081 5 1 . -0 2 pan if a no rc v rd ma e wiho tofrnge ie c os o t ea t a litfc n t e o e a g s t u fei vd n e h w h cu l t poima eb (ee dnl Elo C e . r. . r-u, n.4 4SW.d rf d y dfn a t. cr h m Cop vAgi lIc, 9 . 2 t ' s 2 42 4(e .i.p . Dals 9 3wrtednre)gc lo roC rmis 0 ,1 T xCvA p l 17 , irf ... cas Cab ea c, a ; IcvKef, 6 F Ap '74 73(t Ci.0 6 (n u l h d ( trrt g n.. ee16 . px 1 ,2 5h r2 0)u p bi e)i epei sn n Te a 1w t p r i apan ift de k d ma e me s r db t edee d nts x s a o e m t litf o t e a g s a u e y h fn a ' s atapoisrsligfo teu eo dslsr oteta escen; utn cu l rf eutn rm h s r icou e fh rd ert)Ho so t M e c ntl Ex h Cop.t DalyPer lu Cop.9 0S. .d2 2 2 8(e . ra ie c . r J ie toe m r , 3 W 2 4 , 4 T x . Ap . Ho so (4h Dit 19 ,n wrt (n ig ta,a a trsod p utn 1t s. 9 6 o i f dn h t s h eh l ) )i r q ie e tt r cvei g d ma e frta es ce a d u fi cmpeiin e ur m n o e o rn a g s o r d er t n n ar o tto camsd panif spoueeie c fo whc tejr ma rao al li ,a lit mut rd c vdn erm ih h uy y esn by t f i fr t a t e d ma e s e fr ha e r s le fo t e cnd c o t e n e h t h a g s u d o v e utd r m h o u t f h dfn a f) eed n ' . I t ei sa tmatr MGE f c st es mep o lmss o i gd cua n h n tn te , a e h a r be h w n d t l a p oisr s li gfo t eus o dsls r o t eta es ce'a i ddo is r ft e utn r m h e r ico u e f h r d e rt s t i n t ' cp rg tcam.DX-7d mo sr tdPMIsttl e e u ,no S cua p ois' o y ih li 3 e n ta e ' oa rv n e ts t l r ft . a ' MGE ha no pee tdeie c ta po ie a yme nso dsig ihig s t rsn e vd n e h t rvd s n a f itn us n r v n e PMI g ie fo ohe sure fo rv n e g i e t rug eeu an d r m t r o c s r m e e u an d h o h mia po raino MGE'ta esces1tao eaclulto o p oisfo s p rpito f S rd ert,e ln ac ain f rft rm t erlv n p rino rv n e MGEatmpst dsig ihElo b a g ig h ee a t oto f ee u . te t o itn us cr y run t a DX-7i drdbeeie c o PMIsprft, b tMGE ned dt tke h t 3 s d e il vd n e f ' ois' u c ' ee o a a dto a se st d d c u rltdr v nu a dc ssfo t e ettlfg r s d iin l tp o e u t n ea e e e e n ot r m h s oa iu e i odrodmo srt P I poi rltdt teifigmet MGEfi d n re t e ntae M ' rft eae o h nrn e n. ss al e t d s. ooo Ho ee, ag e t a cmme tft t eRE T T ME T(HID O w v r MGE r u s h t o n o h S A E N T R ) F UNF R C MPTTO j4 (9 5 gvr sd mae u drT x slw,a d M O EIIN 5 19 ) oen a gs n e ea a n cntn st a i me isb r e u d rt i b r e -hfi gfa e o k: o e d h t t t t u d n n e hs u d ns itn r m w r Th ta iin lfr o r siu ina y r le i a a to frt e e r dto a om f e tt to r eif n n cin o h a po raino ata esce i a acunigo ted fnd n' p rpito f r d ert s n co tn fh ee a ts 1 3 Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g :4 DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e l t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 p oiso s lsatiutbet t eu eo t eta es ce. . The r ft n ae trb a l o h s f h r d er t . . pan ifha t ebu d no e tbihngt ed fn a t s ls t e litf s h r e f sa ls i h ee d n ' ae ;h s d fnd n ha t eb r e o et bihi ga ypoto o t es ls ee a t s h u d n f sa ls n n rin f h ae n tatiutbet t eta es ce a da ye pe sst b d d ce o trb a l o h r d er t n n x n e o e e u td i d tr i i gne p ois n eem nn t rft. M GE p it t PMIstt lr v nue i DX-7 a d a g e t a , un e t e on s o ' oa e e n 3 n r u s h t d r h Ret tme t t i e hbts tsisisb r e o p o fwih r g r t PMIs sa e n , h s x ii a ife t u d n f r o t e a d o ' Gae'o p o i i g sr iet UPS ma hi e . MGE cntn st a GE/ M I s ls f r vdn evc o ' c ns o ed h t P s bsq e tyha t eb r e o d mo sr tngwhc p rinso PMIsr v nue u e u n l d h u d n f e n tai ih oto f ' e e ween tatiutbet t esae1w cams wh c i fie t d . r o trb a l o h tt a li , ih t ald o o Tea cut h v n ta otdteRET TME T(HR )O UN AR x s o rs ae o dpe h SA E N T ID F F I C MPTTO i is nieya dwh tej4 'cmmet icnrln i Tea O EIINI te t t n eh r 5s o n fso tol gn x s I r i cursi sila o e q eto .Sc,cg.I r Bas 1 3S. .d7 5 7 9 4 o t s tl n p n u sin c . ,n e s, 1 W 3 3 , 3 - 0 (e. 0 3 ( l wigteoiia RET TME TO TO T' eiio o a d T x 2 0)f l n h rgn l SA E N F R Sdf t n f n oo ni fcosusdt ie tf ta esces d s ieti scin' sih atr to atr e o d n iy rd ert, ept hs eto s lg t leain teefnte SA E E T(HR )F NF RCO PTTO SZcr elrIc hroi h RET TM N T ID O U M M E IIN) c Si e,n. ; g ( ee , ) rz . . . 4 0 4 1 7 e . 9 1 a o tnga dnsr cie' o to 7 , 7 - 2 x 1 9 d p i n d tu tv 'p rin i o teRET TME T(E O D 0 T R Sb tn t gta teTea S pe e f h SA E N S C N ) F O T u oi h t h xs u rm n C u th sn t d pe t eRET T ME Ti ise trt) T eb r e -hfig o r a o a o td h SA E N n t niey. h u d ns i n t p o e u e n t di c mme tfa eno icud di t efrtRESAT ME TO r c d r s oe n o n r t n l e n h is T E N F TOR Swho ed fniino a dfco s e t ie tf ta esce s r sil e T , s ei to f n a tr us d o d n iy r d e rt a e tlus d b Te a cu t. Se I r Bas 1 3S. .da 7 9 4 . Net e t eTe a y x s o rs e n e s, 1 W 3 t 3 - 0 ih r h x s S p e eCo r no a yo t eTe a a pelt cursh v s e iial a pl d u r m u t r n f h x s p lae o t a e p cfc ly p i e c mme t t d tr iead fnd n 'prft i ata es ce a to . v nt a o n fo ee m n ee a ts ois n r d er t cin Gie h t c mme t ssa d r st apantfsb r e o p o fo ta esce d m a e o n f t n a d es li if u d n f r o fr r d e rt a g s R SAE ET F OT adwatnaieysae frnlso ite ETTME TSc N ) ETTM N O T RS n sett l ltdoicuinnh R SA E N (Eo D v O T RsinwadesditeRETTMET(HR ) FUNARC MPTTO . F oT,s o drse n h SAE N T ID O FI O EIIN 1 4 T ecneto u fi cmptin whc wa oiial icu e i te f s h ocp f nar o eio , ih s rgn l n ldd n h i t t y r Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g :s DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e l t i : 72 /0 0 e No 081 5 1 . -0 2 lwe t a t esa d r a pidi Elo , c n ld t a t eTe a Sup e e o r h n h t n a d p le n c rwe o cu e h t h x s r m Co r wo l n ta o tteb r e -hitngpoe u e o cmme tf u t ud o d p h u d ns fi rcd rs f o n . Aco dngy,hedsrc c u ter di d cii gt g a tGE/ M ISRul c r i l t itit o r re n eln n o r n P ' e 5() to o MGE'mia po rainota e erta du ficmptto 0amoin n S sp rpito frd sces n naro eiin cams li . II S GEP Io tn sh dsrccu tre i dn igis l 5() to /M cne d te itito rerdn eyn tRue 0b moin a t eco eo t ec s b c us t eewa lg l i s fiin e ie c t s pp r t h ls fh a e e a e h r s e al n ufce t vd n e o u ot y tejr' $ . miin d ma ea ad i dn igisrq ett a pyte h uys 46 lo a g w r ;n e yn t e u s o p l h l OnesaifcinRul t MGE'rcv r un e Te a lw;a di cncudng - tsato e o S eo ey d r x s a n n o l i t a d ma e fo a t oc ri gb fr De e be 1 ,2 0 ween tb re b h t a g s r m cs cu rn eo e c m r 7 0 1 r o ar d y t et r ey a saut o lmia insund rb t t eCo y ih Ac a dTe a h h e -e r tt e f i t to e oh h p rg t t n x s lw. Ad iinal,MGE c n e d t edsrc cur a us disdsr to b a dto ly o tn s h itit o t b e t icein y dn igMGE'rq etfrpeu g e titrs o d mae.Bea s te eyn S eu s o rjdm n neet n a gs cu e h dsrc cuterdi ds isn GE/MI Rue5 ()moina tecoeo itit or re n im sig P ' l 0a to t h ls f S M GE' c s bea s MGE ha fie t p o e is d m a e cams t e e S ae cu e s ald o r v t a g s li , h s a g me t a emo t r u n s r o. V GEP Ia p astedsrc cut ga to ap r a e tijnt n /M p el h itit o r' rn f em n n nu ci s o a ans GE/MISu eo MGE' sfwa ea dta esces Werve t e gi t P ' s f S ot r n rd ert. e iw h d na o ga t o a p r a e t ijn to fr a a u e o dsr t n e il r r n f em n n nu cin o n b s f icei . o Sc lts y' Lt .JStrigPurha igd Nat Diti.Co, 2 F.d3 3 4 2 h oz k s d I e ln c sn s 1 srb .5 0 3 9 , 0 ,. (t Cr2 0) 5h i.0 8. S cin 5 2o t eCo yihtAc a t oie t ecu tt ga tSia eto 0 f h p rg t uh rzs h o r o rn s n l f f ijnt n o sc tr sa i ma de raoal t pee to rsri nu ci s n uh em s t y em esnbe o rvn r etan o i fi g me to acp rg t' Ala e US ,I c u DGITeh .I c,1 6F.d nrn e n f o y ih . c tl A n . . ' ' c s, n . 6 3 72 70(t Cr19 )q oig1 U... 52a) GEP I otn sta i 7,9 5h i. 99 (u t 7 SC j 0() /M cned h tn n . 2 0 i t r e o e t eo l i fi gnga tce alp o t a ha n tbe nus d 0 5 t u n d v r h ny nrn i ril, a tp h t d o e e 1 5 Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e l DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g :6 t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 snc 2 0 ,a d t a t e o l da a ds fund wa i a fr e e po e ' i e 0 2 n h t h ny t ik o s n o m r m ly es p se so whoa mitdt k e i gi frhso n r fr nc atrhelf t e o s sin d te o e pn t o i w ee e e fe et h cmpa y. Ho e e ,GE/M Ia mitd t fv i sa c s o dr c c p rg t on w v r P d te o ie n t n e f iet o y ih i fi g me t a dMGE p e e t dn meo si sa c so GE/ M ISifi gng n rn e n , n r s n e u r u n t n e f P ' n rn i a tvt a tili cudngsm eu e o MGE s fwa et a o c re atrt e ciiy t ra,n l i o s s f ot r h t cu r d fe h dsrc cute trdispei iayijnto a di pu d e todri itit o r nee t rl n r nu cin n m o n m n re n m Aug s 2 0 .Ad iinal,hel p o so t otil t e s swhoa mitdt u t 0 5 dto ly t a tp f w ra win s e d te o usngMGE s fwa ea dta esc es rs e tv l, r ne e rc v r d a d i ot r n r d e r t,e p ciey wee v r e o ee , n GE/ M I aldt ofrcncusv e ie c t a cun frt e elp o sa s nc . P f ie o fe o l ie vd n e o co t o h s a tp ' b e e Gie t a t e ema b ifi gn ma eil silnGE/ M IS se so , v n h th r y e n rn ig tras tli P 'po s sin a dgv n GE/ M ISfi r t c nfr t t ec n tan so t ep ei i a y n ie P ' al e o o o m o h o sr it f h rlm n r u ijnt n tedsrccut in tb s is iceini ga tn apr a e t nu ci ,h ititordd oa uetdsrt n rnig em n n o o ijnt naantGE/MI ftr u eo MGE'sfwaea dta esces nu ci gis P ' uue s f S ot r n rd ert. o S VI Fo t e fr g i g r a o s we AFFI M t e dsrc cur' g a to r h oe on e s n , R h itit o ts r n f GEP I Rue5 () to ds isn MGES Acam. as AFF RM /M ' l 0a moin im sig 'DMC li We lo I S tedsrc cut ga to apr a e tijnto a an tGE/MI u eo h itit o r' rn f em nn nu cin gis P ' s f s S M GE' s fwa ea dta es ces WeREVERS t edsrc c u t d nil f S ot r n r d er t. E h itit o r' e a o s GEP I Rue 5 () moin o MGE' cprg t ifigme t u fi /M ' l 0a t n S o S oyih nrn e n, nar c mpeiin, ndmia p o ra ino ta esc escamsfrMGE'fiur t o tto a s p r p ito f r d e rt li o S al e o poed ma e u dr1 U... 5 4b a dT x slw,n RENDE atk rv a gs n e 7 SC j 0 () n ea a a d R ae ntigjd meto MGE. ohn u g n fr 1 6

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?