MDY Industries, LLC v. Blizzard Entertainment, Inc., et al

Filing 50

Filed Appellants' MDY additional citations. Served on 07/22/2010. (panel) [7417518] [09-15932, 09-16044] (EL)

;

LneCVeal ac . nbe Mi al . a p o c eF Cm z h A. vdL gnPI . Dai oa,ID . Jsp RMeny oeh . ae Cry . toy aeB Anhn

.

V E N A B LE C A M P ILLO L0 G A N A N D M EA N EY. PC
WWW.C ML W.OM VL A C

13 E sOsonR . 98 at br d P onxAZ 806 h ei, 51

Jh CMacr+ on . sai

ITL E T A P O E T AWO N Y N E L C U L R PR Y R E S

V i : 0)3-10 o e( 261 0 c6 9 Fx( 261 59 a: 0)3- 2 64

. ineih , Y&C Lc s n zN T ed

W ACERTI I D USMAT FE L
MsMolDwyr .l e y Ceko teCo r lr fh ut U.. ut f p a frh Nit Ctut SCo to Ap el o te nh ici s PO. x133 . Bo 999 SnFacso C 9 1933 a rni , A 41-99 c

l cv vll . m a e@ c a c n mwo Jl2,00 uy 221 R E c E lV E D
M LYcD YRCE K OL .W E LR

UsCUT FkEL ..O R O APAS

J L2621 U 22
FE ID L DCWE OK D
DT A E II NA IL T

Re MDYld st sLLCe a. . ad ; n u te i t 1v BMz r Enetkme t : 1 tra. n e a. n C s No. 9192a d0-64 ae s0-53 n 9104 Ol'H No PHLV11-0 zF e : z 1001
Der . e: a MsDwyt

Weetsnte plnsMDYIds e,L adMi al neyr DY'ite tpeeth Apent l , nut sL C n c eDonl < ',th d h l M )l aoeeeecdmat,bc wsrudbfrte nhCtutnte,00 Une bv-f ne trw i aage eoeh Nit i io l 721. dr rt eh cm FRA..8)1mndy gteCuthtnuy 021, e . oro peso e ..P2j,a ofn l ortao ll2,0 il . ut pa r Ff Cruts e a eio iMG U Sysm,n vG CnueadnutaIcef (ae ih i iiud dcinn E P t s c.E os rnIdsi n t? Cs tcs s e I. m rl . f No0-02)htsaly etetn sniatotics. oyt cne ec,hv .8151tailglprnnadi icnt hsaeFro ovi neI ae ii g u

ecoe acp o tadcs n nlsd o y fht eio . i T e esnfrhsu pe etlid nifa teFf Crut a rldfa ac i u dz h rao o tisp lm nact o sh th if i ihsue h t bm n e a hc te iil lnùmC pdhAtT MC 'dentpltccmsnewhra h Dgt Mi nl oygt c( A' osoap o il t cs ee ae <) D y rl a poed nmesr d e n t cul peet oyn o sf ae I prcl ,fh poed n ttco ale os o atay rvn cpig fot r. n adua ite rtc o z l w r mes ed e n t lc tetp o acs teDMC id s ndt peette tesfw r i at os o bok h ye fcesh u A s ei e o rvnyhn h otaes g 're acsilywi i temenn o teDMC . t i rl gteFf Ci utolwe te Tel ces e' t n h aig fh fy b' h A Wi t li ,h ih r ifl d h h s ln tc o t opi aycss w r t ae MDY tftne i i b esosp ottagmettateAp el ' m eeecd n t d ft u p ri ra n hth ples s s e
Doc. 50

MDY Industries, LLC v. Blizzard Entertainment, Inc., et al

(lzr' ci udrh DMC wamets-Dx a f/ IcvJ /Cn l t stm Bi a s bm nete A s dls mr r'n..%/ ot ysm f z d) e kl 2m eo te it Ctutn Ca briGrv,n..klkTcsIcf m teFdrl iciTh nlg h Sxh iciad hm ean y IcvSyi e ,n.t h eeaCrlt e an l/ nh o z. i isnfateaste ihCtuts o tehrapltccittjt lzr'agmet si icnbcueh Ff i iinw h ti peaeiutoecBiadsru ns g tc d lt ez tgrigtDMC ci.lte nhCtztjtteehestddcinadusn ea n i A bm fh Nit iltec hstreo eiosn rl i ds ci es ms e Bi adsao,t lcet asl wi i tecrut ors nteise F rteetao sweak lzr'fv riwi tae pi t n h i icuto b su. o hs esn, s z l th c tayupoie cp otilt adte UP Ssmsaeoteugsofl e hto rvd aoy fhsee n h MGE S yt cst l jdeftlt t tt e a b
cnieabn o s rt . d Th rlvn p Go so MDY'bifta ag eteep itaeo pgs 53 o i Frt e eeat o n f S r sht tu hs ons r n ae 2 -8 ft i e ss B e o CrsAp eln o pgs1-4o i RelBt f T eep itweeas dsusd h f n os paad n ae 93 ft py i . h s ons r l icse s e o

Dockets.Justia.com

MsMoy we . lD yr

Jl2,00 u 221 y

Pg2 ae

dtgoaagmetrm1: t 1: ad3: t3: ( idct iteeodn a ibe li tlta nf 10o 6 4n 7 4o 8 0a niadnh rcrigwl l zn o4 3 4 3s e l ate nhCrutwese. th Nit i is bi) . c' t
Sn ee , icrl y VE A L , MPL O, G N& ME NE , C. N B E CA IL LO A A Y P.

L neC. nbe ac Veal F th Ft o te im

L v/o c rc
c: hidnGe esiEs. Co nefr ple cC t a ntk, q- u slo Ap ees s l
E cote nls u

Ca e 0 -0 21 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e 1 t i : 72 /0 0 e

I THE UNI ED STATES COURT OFAPPEALS N T

FOR THE FI TH CI CUI uisxclfpa F R T ndv auAes t e : pl
F IL E D
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 J l2 , 0 0 uy 0 2 1 L l W. y e ye Ca c clr ek

M GE UPSS S EM SI C YT N Plitf- p la t Cr s - pp le an if Ap eln - o sA ele

GECONSUMERANDI DUSTRI LI C; I DUSTRI LS STEMSI C; N A N GE N AY N GEN ERAL ELECTRI COMPANY; POWER MAI TENAN CE C N I TERNATI NAL 1 C N O N
Dee d n s Ap ele Cr s fn a t pl s e os Ap elnt p la s App a fo t eUnie S a e DititCo r e lr m h td t ts src u t frt eNo t e nDitito Te a o h rh r src f x s BeoeBARKS ALE, fr D GARZ , n PRADO,Cic i J d e . A ad rut u g s EMI I M. L O GARZ , rutJ d e A Cic i u g :

MGEUP S se sIc( GE)p eltedsrccut F drl l S ytm ,n .d 'a pash itito r' e eaRue M s o CvlP oeue5()ds islo isDiia Mienu Coyih Ac f ii rcd r 0a im sa f t gtl l n im p rg t t l (DMC Dcama an t o eMane a c Itrain lIcC MI)Geea C A li gisP w r itn nenen to a,n .P '; nrl ElcrcC mp n (GE)GEC n u e a dId sra,n .a dGEId sra eti o a y$ '; o s m r n n u tilIc;n n util $ S se s I c (olciey t E/MI) MGE as a p astedsrc cu t ytm ,n .cl t l,d P '. ev G lo p el h itit o r' s dnaopeu g etneetnMGE'd mae a ad GE/MIrs-p el eilfrjd m n itrso S a gs w r. P cosa p as o fu go n s () eh rt edsrc cu terdi ds isn GEP I n o r ru d :1 wh te h itit o r re n im sig /M ' S Rue5 () t nbcu e fi dt peet vdn eod mae,ri te l 0a moi ea s MGE al o rsn eie c f a gso n h o e

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e z DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g: t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5

atraiewh te tedsrccut re i ds isn GE/MI Rue5 () len t , eh rh itit or erd n im sig P ' l 0b v S moinbcu ete$ .miinjr a adwa n t rao alcluaino to ea s h 46 lo uy w r s o a esn be aclto f l d mae;()wh te MGE i pr isby du l-eoee d mae;() a gs 2 ehr m em sil o bercvrd a gs 3
whehe t ep risha atligare e ti plc t a p r itdMGE t t r h ate d oln ge m n n ae h t em te o

rcvrd mae pirt Dee b r1, 0 1a d() eh rtedsrccut eoe a gs ro o cm e 720 ;n 4 wh te h itito r erdi ga tn MGEijntv rl f gis GEP I re n rnig nu cie ei aan t /M . e
I

Unn er pil p we s p l ( P ' mahn saeu e d rn p ro s itru tbe o r u py t S' c ie r sd u ig eid d) U
o p we o t g s t p o ie p we t ciia o e ai g s se s MGE f o r u a e o rvd o r o rtc l p r tn y tm . ma ufcur ssv r lie o UPSma hie , o eo whc r q iet eus o n a t e e e a ln s f c n s s m f ih e u r h e f M GE' c p rg td s fwa ep o r msPa rta dMu u td rngs r ii g S o y ih e ot r r g a ce n g e u i evcn . Thi sfwa efx sc l r to p o lm smo eq ikyt a ta iina ma ua s ot r ie ai a in r be b r u c l h n r dto l n l sr ii g tc niue . Wiho tt e s fwa e a s r ie tc nca c n si evcn e h q s t u h ot r , evc eh iin a tl l p ril s r iea MGE UPS ma hne b tanumb ro ciia p oe ur s a tal evc n y ci , u e f rtc l r c d e

( cu igrcl rto a dajsmet fotg lvl)a o lb p rome i ldn eai ain n du t n ovlaeeescn ny e efr d n b
t r u hu eo t esfwa e whihwo k o l o MGE- a u a t r dd vcs h o g s f h ot r , c r s ny n m n fcu e e ie . Thesfwa er q ie cnneto o a e tr a ha d a es c rt ke ot r e u r s o cin f n xe n l r w r e u iy y

(aldaRo ge)oteatpsrapr.E c dn lh s neprt nd t, cl dn l't h lpo eil ot ah o ge a a x iai ae e o
ama i um numbe o u e,a dau iu p swod Whe t esfwaei xm r f ss n nq e a s r . n h ot r s a tv td,i s a c e fra p o el p o r mme d ngebeo e i wi fly cia e t e rh s o r p ry r g a d o l fr t l ul l lun h.Onc lun he ,hesfwa ewil ot r ug as cnds re o p oo o ac e a c d t ot r lg h o h eo eis f rtc l e c a g swih t e d t lc td o t e UPS mahi es mir p o e sr t x h n e t h a a o ae n h c n ' co r c so s o cnim t a MGE sfwaei cmmu iaigwih MGE had ae l t e o fr h t ot r s o nctn t r w r. f h p ooo ec a g is cesu, Ssfwaep oe d t clety tm saus rtclxh n es u csflMGE' ot r rce so olc sse tt ifr a infrt etc nca . no m to o h eh iin Ye r atrMGEi to uc diss c rt tc noo y, numb ro s fwa e a s fe n r d e t eu iy e h lg a e f ot r ha k r pu ls e i fr aino t eitr e dslsngg ne a isr cinso c e s bih d n o m to n h n en t icoi e r ln tu to n h w t d fa t e e tr a s c rt fa u e o a ha d a e ke . Onc t e o o ee t h xe n l eu iy e t r s f r w r y eh

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e 3 DaeFld: 72 /0 0 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g: t i 0 /02 1 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 sfwa e i c a k d a d t e sc rt ke i d fa e ,t e s fwa e c n be ot r s r c e n h e u iy y s ee td h ot r a a c s e a dus dwiho tlmiain. ce s d n e t u i tto P Ii aciia p we sr iec mp n s rii gav reyo b a dso M s rtc l o r e vc o a y evcn a it f r n f UPS mahie,icu igMGE UPS mahne. PMIiiil s b o tatd c n s n ldn ci s ntal u cnr ce y MGEt p rom sfwaesr ieo MGEUPSmahne, u smei eb fr o efr ot r evc n c i sb t o tm eoe J ne 2 0 ,a g o p o PMIe po e so t ie a la to e c p o MGE' u 0 0 ru f m ly e b an d t e s n o y f S sfwa efo a un n wnsu c.GEaq ie PMIi 2 01 ot r rm n k o o re c urd n0 . I Dee b r 2 0 ,MGE fld s i a ans GE/MI fr itrala, n cm e 0 4 ie ut g i t P o, ne i c p rg ti fi g me t mia p o ra ino ta esce s un arcmpeiin, o y ih n rn e n , s p r p ito f r d e rt , fi o tto c n e so , ndDMCAvoains GE/ M I o sno ds u ela iiy ia mu h o v r in a ilto . P d e t ip t ib l ,n s c t a i a mist rc v rngalptpfo afr e PMIe po e t a c n ane s t d t o e o ei a o r m o m r m ly e h t o t i d hake MGEsfwae a da mist f eisa cso ti sfwaesus fo cd ot r, n d t o i n tn e fhs ot r' e rm v J ne2 0 t r ug Ma 2 0 .MGE alg st a GE/ M Ius dt es fwa ea u 00ho h y 02 le e h t P e h ot r tt lo 4 8 tme ,icudng u e atr t e dsrc c u tg a t d MGE a oa f 2 i s n l i s s fe h itit o r r n e

pei iayijnt na an tGEP I u eo MGESsfwaea dta e rl n r nu ci gis /M ' s f ' ot r n rd m o S
s ces er t.

Du igt ep oe dng frti ato ,GE/MImo e ,rne e ,a d rn h rce i s o hs cin P vd e w d n

r-re moin frs mmayjd me ta djd meta amatro lw eugd to s o u r u g n n u g n s te f a p ru n t F drl lso CiiP oeu e5 ()a d()ag ig itrai, us a to e ea Rue f vl rcd r 0a n b run ,ne l a
t a MGE cul no s san aDMCA c us o a to a ans GE/ M I Afe ht o d t u ti a e f cin g i t P . tr

iiil d n igGEP I p era moinfrs mmayjd me t n is l ntal e yn /M ' rtil to o u r u g n a d t Rue y S 5 ()moino MGESDMC cam,h dsrc cu tds isdt eDMC 0a to n ' A li t e itit o r im se h A cam d rn a of eodjr c ag cnee c. euyfu dta GE/MI li uig n f- cr uy h re ofrne Th jr o n h t P r
h d i fi g d MGE' c p rg t,mia p o rae MGE' ta e sces a d a n rn e S o y ih s s p r p it d S r d e rt, n

cmmitdu fi b sn s patcs T ejr a ad dMGE tefl wig o te nar uies rcie. h u y w re h ol n o
d ma e : a gs

Ca e 0 -0 2 D c me t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e 4 DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 o u n: 0 1 1 9 6 g: t i : 72 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 Da a e frmia p o raino ta es ceso MGE'd t m g s o s p r p ito fr d er t n S aa ds : ik 1 Ne p oise r e b GE/ M Ifo J nua y1 2 0 t . t r ft a n d y P r m a r , 0 1 o

Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 6 ,0 cm e 7 2 0 : 4 00 0
Ne p oise r e b GE/M Ir m De e b r1 , 0 1 t rft a n d y P fo c m e 8 2 0

t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ ,5 ,0 o g s 5 2 0 : 18 20 0
B. Da a e frc p rg tifi g me t m g s o o y ih n rn e n : 1 Ne p oise r e b GE/ M Ir m J nua y1 2 0 t . t rft a n d y P fo a r , 0 1 o

Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 6 ,0 cm e 7 2 0 : 3 80 0
2 Ne p oise r e b GE/M I rm De e b r1 , 0 1 . t r ft a n d y P fo c m e 8 2 0

t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ ,5 ,0 o g s 5 2 0 : 18 20 0
Da a e fr sp rpito oMGEsfwa eta esces m gso mia p orain f ot r rd ert: Ne poise r e b GE/MIfo J nuay12 0 t t rft an d y P rm a r , 0 1 o

Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 20 0 cm e 7 2 0 : 9 ,0
2. Ne p oise r e b GE/ M Ifo De e b r1 , 0 1 t r ft a n d y P r m c m e 8 2 0

t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ o g s 52 0 : 0 T T L: $ ,2 ,0 OA 46 40 0
hè-I rC Cur a a e - -S l o . r W e Oa J r V r 1t P S-I g e i l y e Cj O tJ m n l I

itrs, pr a etijnto a antGEP Ii p u d eto ifign neeta em n n nu cin gis /M ,m o n m n fnrnig
mae il,a a l c ssa datr e 'fe . dsrc c ur d cie t a a d trastx be ot, n to n ys e s The itit o t eln d o w r

peu g e tneet nted ma ea ad. rjdm n itrs o h a g w rs
1 1

M GEag e t a t edsrc cu t re i ga tn GEP I Rue 0a ru s h th itit o r erd n rnig /M ' l 5 () S
moin ds isngMGE' DMCA voain cam. Werve d n v a til to im si S ilto li e iw e o o ra

cut dcso o aRue5() to fru g et samatr fa ,iwig or' eiin n l 0a moin o jd m n a te olw ve n s
al fhee ie c Nnt elg ta dwihale s na l i fr nc s s fv r be lo t vd n e h ih n t lr a o be n e e e mo t a o a l t t ep ryo po e t t emoin. ReouinTr s Cop. .Cr me , F.d o h a t p s d o h to ' s lto u t r v a r 6 3 '

10 , 19(t Ci.93 ( tra q oain o i e)ARue5 () to i 12 10 5h r19 )i en l utto s m t d. l 0a moin s n t p o el ga td di t e fcs a d ifrn e p it s srn l a d rp ry r ne dq h at n nee cs on o to gy n lf

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e s t i : 72 /0 0 e No 081 5 1 . -0 2

oewh l igyi fvr fh moig at ..h tesn beuoso l nt vr em n l n ao ote vn p ry .ta rao aljrr cud o h v arvda acnrr vrit'I.ctto o itd. a e rie t o tay edc. d (iain m te)
GE/MIa g e t a MGE' dnged e n tat al p e e tcp igo P ru s h t S o l os o cu l rv n o yn f y MGE'sfwae b tmeeyp ee t a cs t tesfwae On et a a cs S ot r, u rl rv n s ces o h ot r. c h t ces i b e c e ,h r a en b rir t c p i gt es fwa e Aco dngy, PM I s r a h d t e e r o a re s o o yn h ot r . c r i l GE/ a g e t a MGE' s fwa ei dr ey a c sil'wihn t eme ni go t e ru s h t S ot r s t e l ce sbe' t i h a n f h f DM CA b c us t ed nged e n tbok tetp o fces'teDMCA i ea e h o l os o lc h y e fd cs' h a s d sg e t p e e t Furhemoe to g teMGE sfwa ei GE/ MI ein d o rv n . t r r , h u h h ot r n P ' S p s e so d a mo iid't ei ia et ene d fra d nge MGE ha no o s sin d s dfe ' o lm n t h e o o l, w st p e e tde ie c t a aPMIe po e iiil mo iidt es fwa e r sn e vd n e h t m ly e ntal dfe h ot r . y Oneo Co gesp r oe b hnde atngt eDMCA wa tr eigte f n rs' u p ss e i n ci h s agtn h crumv nto o t c n lgc l rtcins Se Davd o ( Aso s v Ju g, 2 ic e in f eh oo ia p oe to . e is n î s c. . n 4 2

F3 60 6 94 (t Cr2 0 ) T eDMC 'a t-icmvninpoiin .d 3, 3- 0 8h i. 0 5. h AS ni ru eto rvso c
sae ,d opes n s alcrumv ntatc noo ia me s r t a efciey t ts d ro h l ic e N e h lgc l a u e h t fe tv l

cnrlacs t awokpoetdu drhsil. 1 U... 10 ()1() o tos ceso r rtce n e titte' 7 SC j 2 1a() . A
To dic mv ntatc noo ia me s r 'me n t H e ca bl a sr mbe cru e e h lgc l a u e' a s o d sr m e ca ld wok,t d cy ta e cy t dwo k,o oh r iet a od b p s ,r mo e r o erp n n rpe r r tew s o v i, y a s e v , d a tv t ,o i par at c n lgc lme s r ,wiho tt ea t o iy o t e e ciae r m i eh oo ia a u e t u h u h rt f h

cp rgto nr' I. 10()3() d f cieycnrl acs t awok o yih w e. d j 2 1a() . d f tvl otos ces o r' A Ee
me nst a Rheme s r ,nt eo dna yc u s o iso e ain, e ur st e a h tt a u e i h r i r o r e f t p r to r q ie h a pia ino i fr ain, rap o e so ate t e twiht ea t oiyo t e p lc to fn o m to o rc s r r am n , t h u h rt f h

cp rg t wn rt gi acs t tewok'I. 10 () ) ) GEP Ide oyih o e,o an ces o h r . d j 2 1a( ( . /M os 3B
n tcnts t a MGE' s fwa ewa awok p oe td u d rTil 1 o t e o o et h t S ot r s r rt ce n e te 7 f h Co y ihtAc. p rg t TheDMCA d e no d srb t e y eo S ce s-o toln tc noo ia o s t e cie h t p fd c snc n r lig eh lgc l a me s r r q ie t i v k t eDMCA'p oe to s a dt i i a is eo frt au e eurd o n o e h S r tcin , n hs s n su f is i p e so i t i Cic i. MGE p o o e a d fniin fo a Fit Cic i m r sin n hs rut r p s s ei to r m fh rut nO - M CA c s t a d sus e c p rg tis e a d d tr i e R ce s t nD a e h t ic s d o y ih su s n ee m n d a c s' o '

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e 6 t i : 72 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 icu e$no p runt t ve t ec p rg tdwo k. Feg s n! Na 'Br a . n ld $ p ot iy o iw h o y ih e r ' r u o p t o d a ' .l

Co,8 F.d1113(t Cr17 )ctn 3M. IME , PRG Tj1.2A) .5 4 2 1,1 5h i.9 8 (iig N M RCO Y IH 30 ( (9 8) Re dn ti d f io ao gied f io sfo Mera - e se' 1 7 ). a ig hs ei t n ln sd ei t n rm rim W b tr ni ni s
dcin r a d Blc ' La Dito a y MGE c n l d st a d ce s me n ito a y n a ks w cin r , o cu e h t d c s' a s a' diwigma igu eo,rusngtep oetdwok.MGEag e ta d nge d e n , kn s fo i h rtce r ' v ' r u sh t o ls p e e t da c s t iss fwa ea dt a wiho tu i gb t t i ha d a eke r v n e ce s o t ot r n h t t u sn oh h s r w r y a discre p n i gp swo d ausrc nn t iw, ana c s t ,rma eus n t o r s o dn a s r , e a o ve g i ce s o o k e o t esfwa e f h ot r . Ho e e ,MGE a v c t s to b o d a d fniin o d ce s' t er w vr d oae o ra ei to f d c s i h i a '

itrrtto wolpr il bly n e j 2 1afr cesn awoksmpy nepeain ud em ti itu dr 1 0()o acsig r i l ai
t ve i o t u ei wihn t epu ve o Sarus'pemitd un e t e o iw t r o s t t i h r iw f d i e' r te d r h f Co yiht t Meeyb p sigatc n lgc l rtcint a rsrcsausr p rg Ac. rl y asn eh oo ia p oeto h t etit e fo ve i g o usng a wok i i s fiin t tig r t e DMCA' rm iw n r i r s n ufce t o rg e h S a t-ic mv ninp oiin.TheDMCA p o iiso l fr so acs t a n icru e to rvso rhbt ny om f ces h t wo l voa eo i png o t ep oeto st a t eCo y ihtAc ohewie u d ilt r m i e n h r tcin h t h p rg t t r s afr scp rg to nes Sc Cha branGru ,n . . yikTeh .I c, fo d o yih w r. c m eli o p I c vSk ln c s,n .

3 1F.d1 7 , 2 2(e . i. 0 4.T eF drlCruti a ayigte 8 3 1 8 10 F d Cr 2 0) h e ea ici,n n lzn h DMC 'a t-icmvninpoiincnld dh ttcn elq oadto a AS ni ru e to rvso ,ocu e taido vysn d iin l c poet rg ti a dote sle;i)i pypoiespo et o n r wih rpry ihsn n fh m evs( sm l rvd g)rpry w es t t
n w wa st s c r t erp o et . I .a 1 9 -9 .I d e ,dit al e e y e y o eu e h i r p ry' d t 1 3 4 n e d d ru l v r ' v y

ca s o j10 ta meto sacs'ik dcestirtcin. I.t19 . lu e f 2 1h t nin dcesl sacs'opoeto ' d a 17 n '
W iho ts o i gal k b t e n dce s a d Rr tcin'o t ec p rg t d t u h w n i ew e d c s' n p oeto ' f h o y ih e n a' wo k, heDMCA' a t-ic mv nto p o iin d e no a py.Theo ne ' rt S n icru e in rvso o s t p l w rs tc n lgc l me s r mus p o et t e c p rg td mae il a ans a eh oo ia a u e t r tc h o y ih e tra g i t n ifi g me to arg tt a t eCo y ih Ac p oet, tfo meeus o nrn e n f ih h t h p rg t t r tcs no r m r e r

ve ig I . t1 0 ;e as L x akI t I cv Stt C nrl o p n ns iw n . d a 2 4 se lo em r n k n . . ai o to C m o e t, c Ic, 8 F.d5 2 57(t Cr2 0)(n ign DMC a t-icmvnin n.3 7 3 2 , 4 6h i. 0 4 f dn o A ni ru e to i c
l blt wh r a a t e tc to sq e c i ap itrmir c i bo k do e i iiy e e n u h n iain e u n e n rn e co hp lc e n a

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e 7 DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g: t i : 72 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5

fr o acs (rne fnto) u p r itdfe acs fo ohra eu s om f ces pitr u cin b t em te re cesrm te v n e ( r xmpea yn wh p rh sdta ba dopitro ldwnodacp f ea l,n o e o uc ae h t rn f rne cud o la o y o o tepo r ml. f h rga )
Hee MGE ha no s o n ta b p sigisd ngeifig sarg t r, s t h w h t y asn t o l nrn e ih p oetdb teCo yiht t MGE'd ngemeeyp e e t iiil cest rtce y h p rg Ac. S o l rl rv n snta ac s o t esfwa e I n d n l i d tce ,hesfwa ep o r m wi n tc mpee h ot r . f o o ge s eet d t ot r r g a l o o lt l t esa tupp oe s Ho e e , v ni ad ngei p e e t i d e n tp e e t h tr- r cs . w v r e e f o l s r s n ,t o s o r v n t eltr l o eo tx o MGE'c p rg t dc mp tr ot a efo b i gfe l h ie a c d r e t f S o y ih e o u e s fw r r m en r ey r a a dcpe o c t a a c s i o t i e ;he ei noe cy to o ohe fr e d n o id n e h t c e s s b an d t r s n r p in r t r o m o p oe to o t esfwa eislt p e e tc p rg t ilto s Bea s t e f r tcin n h ot r tef o r v n o y ih voain . c u e h d nged e no p o eta ans c p rg tvoain ,t eme efc t a t e o l o s t r tc g i t o y ih ilto s h r a t h t h

dn l i efi cru vne de ntgv rs t acru vninvoain o ge t l s icm etd os o ie ie o icm eto ilto s
wihi t eme nngo t eDMCA. t n h a i fh Moev rt eDMCA'a t-ic mv nto poiind e no a pyt t e ro e,h S nicru e in rvso os t p l o h

ue foyihe wok cfrh tc nlgcl aue a be cru vne , socprg td rs / teeh ooiame sr h s en icm e td c
treigise dtecru v nto isl.Unies l t StdisI cvCo ly ag tn n ta h ic m e in tef vra Ciy u o,n .. re,

2 3F.d4 9 4 3(dCr 2 0) MGE ctsn eiec ta aGEP I 7 3 2 , 4 2 i. 0 1. ie o vdne h t /M
e po e o rp e e t tv wa r s o sbefratrngt ePa rta dMu ue m ly e r e r s n a ie s e p n il o lei h ce n g t sfwa es c t a a d ngewa n tr q ie t u et esfwa e Wiho t ot r u h h t o l s o e ur d o s h ot r . t u

p o igGE/MIat al cru v n e t etc n lg (so p sdt u ig rvn P cu l ic m e td h eh ooy a p oe o sn y tc n lg ara ycru v ne )MGEd e n t rsn av l DMC cam. eh oo y le d ic m e td, o s o pee t ai d A li Sei.(()eDMC trestecru vnin o dgtlwal g adn ed$h < T A agt h icm e t f iia l u rig o s cp rg tdmaeil(n tafkn i cru vnintos,b tde n t oyihe tra a d rfi ig n icm eto ol) u os o c cn enislwiht e s otoemaeilatr ic mv ninh s cu r d'. o cr tef t h u e fh s tras fe cru e to a oc re . ' )
Be a s t eDMCA d e n ta pyt me eus o acp rg t dwok,a d cue h o s o p l o r e f o y ih e r n b cus MGE ha n ts o n t a GE/MIcrumv ne MGE' sfwae ea e s o h w h t P ic e td S ot r poeto si voaino teDMCA,hedsrc cu tddn teri ga tng rtcin n ilto fh t itit o r i o r n r ni

GEP I Rue5() t nds isn MGE'DMC cam. /M ' l 0a moi im sig S A li S o

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e 8 t i : 72 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 II I

GE/MIag e tedsrc cut re i dn igisRue5() to P ru sh itit or erd n eyn t l 0a moin
wihrg r t MGE'cam und rt eCo yih Ac b c u etetsi o yo t ea d o S li e h p rg t t ea s h etm n f MGE'd ma e e p rha bensrc e ,ndMGEi p o el rle o PMls S a g s x et d e tik n a m rp ry eid n ' ttlgosrv n efg r rt e t a tepoto ra o a l rltdt t e oa rs e e u iu e ah r h n h rin e sn by eae o h cp rg tifigme t Fo t es merao ,GE/MIag e MGE fie t o yih nrn e n . r h a e sn P r u s ald o p o ea1t eee e t o issa elw mia p o rain o ta es cesa d r v 1 h lm n s f t tt a s p r p ito f r d er t n un arc mp tto camswiho tito u ige ie c o PMIsp oisr ltd fi o eiin li : t u n r d cn vd n e f ' r ft ea e t t eifig me tMGEha fie t p o ed ma e frt eecams o h nrn e n , s ald o rv a g s o h s li . A

GE/MIag e ta tedsrc cuterdi dn igisRue5 () P ru s h t h itit or re n eyn t l 0a
moinb c u eMGEfie t p e e ts fiint vd nc o da a e .Un e 1 to e a s ald o r s n u fce e ie e f m g s d r 7

U...j5 4a()a d()acp rg to n ri pr itdt rcvrhso n SC j 0 ()1 n b, oyih w e s em te o eoe i w
dcua d ma e ,icu i gls p oisa dSe sna l r y lyr t s'o wha t t l a g s' n ldn o t r ft n s a o be o at ae ,' r t a ' r awilngbu e wo l ha ebe nz a o a l r q ie t pa awii gsle a li y r ud v e e sn by e u r d o y l n elr s l alc n i gfefrt ea t a us o t ec p rg tdma eil yt ei fi g r . ie sn e o h cu l e f h o y ih e tra b h n rn e s

Da ivGa ,n.2 6F.d1 21 7(dCr20 )Acp rg twn r yas vs . p Ic,4 3 5 ,6 2 i.0 1. oyih o e ma lo
se d n p oiso t ei fig rt a a eatiutbet t eifi g me ta d e k s y r ft f h nrn e h t r trb a l o h n rn e n n a a e no t k n it a c u ti c mpu i g t e a t a d m a e .' 1 U... r t a e n o co n n o tn h cu l a g s' 7 SC

j54b. I tecprg to n rcosst cam ifigr pois Gh 0 () f h oyih w e h oe o li nrn e' rft, te s
cp rg t wne i r q ie t p e e t r o o l o t eifi g rsg o srv nue o y ih o rs e ur d o r s n p o f n y fh n rn e' r s e e , a d t ei fi g ri r q ie t p o ehi o he d d cil e p ns sa dt e n h n rn e s e u r d o r v s r r e u tbe x e e n h ee e t o p oi atiutbet fco soh rt a t ec p rg tdwo k.'I . lm n s f rft trb a l o a tr t e h n h o y ih e r ' d;

seas Esaeo V n vFarIc,4 F.d16 18(t Cr18 )apyn e lo tt f ' e . i,n .89 2 8 ,8 5h i.9 8 (p lig c ti sa dr t cp rg tifigmetato se igifigr pois. hs tn ad o oyih nrn e n cin ekn nrn e' rf ) st
GE/ MIa g e t a MGE fie t s tsyt ef s se o p o i gi fig rs P ru s h t ald o a if h i t tp f rvn nrn e ' r p oisb c u eMGE'o l e ie c o gosrvnu swa Ex ii DX-7 a rft ea s S ny vd n e f rs ee e s hbt 3 , o epa eb rg a hs o i gPMI Roa r v n e'r m ali e o b sne sfo n - g a rp h w n ' ttl e e u ' o lln s f u i s r m s f

Cae0 -0 2 Dou et0 5 17 9 9 Pa eg DaeFld 0 /02 1 s :815 1 c m n 0 1 196 g: t i : 72/0 0 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 2 01trug 2 0 .GE/MIcne d t a tic aticud su dfee tae 0 h o h 0 4 P o tn s h ths h r n l e n ifrnitd gosrv n efo sriigav reyob a dso euime tno meeyMGE rs e e u rm evcn ait f rn f q p n , t zl e uime t a d t e eo e d e n t r fe t rv nu s Strbu a l t t e q p n , n h r fr o s o elc e e e f ti tb e o h a ifig me t' nrn e n . '

'olc l blyh s enso n j5 4b cetsa iia peu pin d n ei it a b e h w , 0 () rae n nt l rsm t l ai i o
t a t eifi g rsTr ft . . trb t bet t eifi g me ta ee ua t is h t h n rn e' p ois . a tiu a l o h nrn e n ' r q l o t

gosrv n e'Bo n r . w o , 0 F.d2 0 2 4(t Ci. 0 5 (leain rs e e u . n e vDa sn 4 4 3 9 , 9 4h r2 0 )atrto i oiia)q oig1 U... 5 4b)tnmet gtiiilu dnh wee, n rgn l(u t 7 SC b 0 ().d ei isntab re ,o vr n l n
acp rg th le mus s o moet a t eifi g rstt l r s rv n efo o y ih od r t h w r h n h nrn e ' oa g o s e e u r m alo isp oi sra s l f t rft te m . Rah r (rs rv n e rfr o l t rv n e te ,gos e e u ' ees ny o e e u

raoa l rltdt teifigme t f .e p ae a dd;e as Da i, esn by eae o h nrn e n. d (m h ss d e)se lo vs ' 2 6 F3 a 19 6 (n igpofrd eie c o dfn a t ttlgos 4 .d t 5- 0 f dn rf e vdne f ee dn' oa rs i e s
rv nu s to b o d t s p ot a c p rg t ifi g me t cam b s d o e e e o r a o u p r o y ih nrn e n li a e n

dfn a t u eopani scprg tdeelse i a a cmpin; tt ee dn' s f litf oyihe y gassn n d a ag)Esae s f o V n,89F.da 1 8 1 0(n igta G lmpsm fgr frpois f c e 4 2 t 8 , 9 f dn h t a u -u iue o rf i t
atiu a l t t etlvso c mmecast a cnti e ifi g dma eila trb t be o h ee iin o ril h t o an d n rn e tra s awhoewiho ta c u tngfrt efc t a t ei fi g dma e ilcnsiutd l t u co n i o h a t h t h n rn e tra o tt e o l afa to o a ygv n c mme ca'wa tos e ultv a cnne to t ny r cin f n ie o ril s o p c aie o cin o '

ssand ma e)T yo !Merc,1 F2 1 1,12(t Cr1 8)fn ig uti a gs; c îrJ iik7 2 .d 1212 7h i.9 3( dn . i isfce tfrj 54b p roe ta pani so e dfn a t gos nufin o 0 () up ss h t litf h w d eed n' rs i f s
rv nu sfo t es lso alp o u t ise do d mo sr tngg o srv nu s e e e r m h ae f l r d cs n ta f e n tai r s e e e

fo sl o t eifign p o u t) rm ae fh nrn ig rd cs. MGEsu h o e $ 0 miini d ma e b sdamot x ls eyo t e o g t v r 1 0 lo n a g s ae l se cu i l n h l v
tsi o y o iso l d ma e e p r,Dr La r n ePr sot Dr Pr sot e tm n f t ny a g s x et . u a c ec t. . e c t' s

tsi oy rltd t t o d maemoes ()MGE' ls poi ;a d () etm n eae o w a g dl: 1 S ot rfs n 2 t
r cvei g a r a o a l r y ly. Noa l,Dr P e c t dd n t tsi t e o rn e s n b e o at tby . r s ot i o e tf o y GE/MISpoisatiutbet t eifig me t Thedsrc cur c rid P ' rf trb a l o h nrn e n . t itit o t are

Cae 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e l DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g : o t i : 72 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5

GE/MI F drl loEvdne 0 a dDa brkbetoso .rsot P ' eeaRue f iec 72 n uetojcin tDrP ect' S s
tsi o ya dp r itdh m t tsiya til Afe he rnghi tsi o y t e e tm n n e m te i o e tf t ra. tr a i s e tm n ,h d src c u tc n l d dt a i s o l b src e i ise tr t , ee mii g itit o r o cu e h t t h u d e tik n n t n iey d tr nn ta Dr Prsot cncuso sr gr igMGE' ls poisweeb sdo h t . ect' o l in e adn s S ot rft r a e n is fiin fcsa dd t,ncu igu s p ot da s mpin r g r igMGE' n ufce ta t n a ai ldn n u p re su to s e a dn S ls ma ke s a ea ds r iep ii g Thed src c u tas fu dDr Pr sot ot r t h r n evc rcn . itit o r lo o n . e c t ha n e p re c i a s sigh p t eia r a o a l ry lyr t sa dt a d o x ein e n se sn y oh tc l e s n be o at ae n h t

hspofrdh pteia rao al rylyrt wa ntb sdo ojcie i rf e y oh tcl esn be oat ae s o ae n betv e
a ay i. n lss Onc Dr P e c t' tsi o ywa src e , e . r sots etm n s tik n MGE ofr dafna wine s fe e i l t s , M GEg nea ma a e Miha l Bre , op e e t dtsi o yrltngo l e r l n g r c e O' in wh r s n e e tm n eai ny t MGE' r a o a l r y ly d ma e . O're wa ne e d sg a e a a o S e s n be o at a g s B in s v r e in td s n e p r o d ma ec lulto s Thedsrc cur uli aeyfun hi tsi o y x et n a g ac a in . itit o t tm tl o d s e tm n

isfcett pr iMGE t ofrajr isrcino rao al ryly n uf in o em t i o f uy n tut n esn be oat e o
d ma e . a g sz M GE' o l r manige ie c o d m a e wa DX-7 t eb rg a h S ny e i n vd n e f a g s s 3 , h a r p i dc tngPMIstt lrv nu fo 2 01t r ug 2 0 .Th u ht i wa a n ia i ' oa e e e r m 0 h o h 0 4 o g h s s n e hbtp e a e b GE/ M It edsrc c u ta mit dt ee hii d rn Dr x ii r p r d y P ,h itit o r d te h x b t u ig .

' uetJMerlDo P ams fc,0 U..7,9 (93. Da brI rel w h r . n.59 S 595219) . ,
2T pcl ,odmo srt rao alry l dmae,apani peet eie c yial t e ntae esn be oat a gs litf rsns vdn e y y f a t R h th p riswo l h v are t a afipi frle sn tedfn a top t so w a te ate ud a e ged o s ar rc o i nig h ee d n t u ec tetaesce t teu etedfn a titn e a tet etemiaporainto h rd ert o h s h ee dn ne dd t h i h sp rpito ok m pae'U i. o puigC..ye-onso nC r.54F2 5859(t Cr17) lc. nvC m t ovLksYugtw op,0 .d 1,3 5h i.94. ' n Ho ee, Bre wa o l al t tsi a t tery lya onsta MGEwo l aka w vrO' in s ny be o ety s o h oat m u t h t f ud s cmpt o tp ytpeeth to pttrrm etrn teUP srien uty -h ts o ei ro a o rvn ta cm ei fo neig h S evc id sr- ta i, t o sagrn l hg ry l a onsta wol pieotcmpttr.S c a o nsaent tgeigy ih oat m u t h t ud rc u o eios uh m u t r o y cgi be s tesnbeoat'a uain t hc a u eadslr olareo e onz la ad aoalryl cl lt a w i b yr n ee w ud ge tb a r /co h l mak t au frap riua peeo sfwae S e ctlUS ,n. . ic Ss, 3 F re v le o at lr ic f ot r. e Alae A Ic u Cso y .2 9 . c S p.d6069(..e.02Cl hs auesob cluae bsdo araoal u p2 6,6 ED Tx20) r imesrit eacltd ae n esnbe a ry l t whc tep risw udh v a re a tet eotealgdmiaporain oat o ih h at o l ae ged th i fh l e sp rpito . y e m e Whl teC utrcg ie ta smedge o seuaini ihrn i cluaiga i h or eonzs h t o ere f p clt s n ee t n acltn e o sp oio sl e sn are e tbt en t o p rista h s nvr ocre ,ti u pst u i nig gem n ew e w at h t a ee curd hs ic e

hpteiacntut.. scnansmedge ocriu e'e p aiadd) yohtclosrc .mutoti o ere fet d.(m h ss del. t'
1 0

Cae 0-0 2 Dou e t0 5 179 9 P g :l DaeFld 0 /02 1 s :815 1 c m n:0 1 19 6 a e l t i :72/0 0 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 Pr sotsr -iete a i a in.MGEq eto e Dr Pr soto l o t elc e c t' edr c x m n to u sin d . e ct ny n h a k o GE r v nuer p e e tdo DX-7sg a h.Dr P e ct wa no q e to e f ee e rsne n 3 ' r p . r sot s t u sin d a o twhehe t e t tlPMIr v nue i dc td o t e g a h r p e e td bu t r h oa e e n iae n h r p e r s n e r v nuer ltdt PMI i fi g me to MGE'c p rg t' e e ea e o ' n rn e n f s S o y ih . GE/MIag e t a i wo l no ha eicud dDX-7i ispo oe P ru s h t t ud t v n l e 3 n t rp sd e hiish dikn wnt a Dr Pr sot tsi o ywo l b src e 4 e a s x bt a t o h t . ec t' e tm n ud e tik n b c u e s ih dnoie MGEwo l bese igGE/MISpoisrt e ta MGE'o n t a da ud ekn P ' rft ah r h n Sw ls p oisa dr a o a l r y lis MGE c n e d t a se i gd fnda ts o t r ft n e s n be o ate . o t n s h t e kn ee n ' poiswa n tan w t er o rcv r b c us teJ itPrtilOr e rft s o e h oy f eo ey ea e h on era d r

idctsta isu h ( oeayd mae p ru n t 1 U... 54'o n iae h tt o g tt ntr a gs u sa t o 7 SC b 0 'fr m
cp rg t ifi g me t Thi prvso e c mp se alt p s o d ma e o y ih nrn e n . s o iin n o a ss 1 y e f a g s a albe frcp rg tifig me t icudng t ec p rg to ne' a t a v ia l o o y ih n rn e n , n l i h o y ih w rs cu l d ma e ,heifig rsp oisa tiu a l t t eifi g me ta dsa utr a g s t nrn e ' rft trb t be o h nrn e n , n t t oy

d ma e. Ho e e,nisFe ea Rueo Cii P oe u e2 ()dsls rs a gs w v r i t d rl l f vl rcd r 6a icou e,
whe a k dt p o i e$ c mpu a in o e c c tg r o d ma e came , n s e o r vd ( o t to f a h a e o y f a g s li d' a ' MGE i dc td t a Dr Pr sots tsi o y wo l c mp ie is d ma e n ia e h t . ec t' e tm n u d o rs t a g s c lua in.Dr Pr soto l tsi e t MGE' a t a d m a e : ac lto . ec t ny e tf d o i S cu l a g s MGE' o n Sw ls p oisa dr a o a l ry lyr ts I ohe wo d , her c r i dc ts ot r ft n e s n be o at ae . n t r r s t e o d n ia e t a MGEp a n dt rl e trl o isa t a d ma e cam; PMIhadno ht ln e o ey n iey n t cu l a g s li GE/ r a o t t ik t a MGE wa s e i g GE/ M ISp oisa tiutbet t e e s n o hn h t s ekn P ' rft trb a l o h ifig me t n rwa i p e a e t d fnda ans s c acam. nrn e n , o s t r p r d o ee g i t u h li

dWle o eo teprmafceee e t o acam i d mae a dte d h n n f h i ai lm ns f li s a gs n h E
cama tfist ito u ee i e c o t o ed ma e , o s ecmmisaft l li n al o n r d c vd n e f h s a g s he r h o t aa
3 h tilrncitn iae ta MGEma h v be tyn t rfroadf rn T e ra ta srp idcts h t y ae en rig o ee t ieet f

gah(X-2acmprsnoMGEUP eup et rsrvn evru UP sriegos rp D 4 , o aio f S qim n goseeu ess S evc rs rvn erm 19 truh20) e irqetdtamiD -7 eeu fo 97 hog 07whn teu se o d t X3.
4 /MI l gst nyitn e t ue 3 ti pahDrP ect'asrinta GEP al e iol ne d d o s DX-7 om ec . rsot set h t e s o a MGESrvn e wetdwn GEP I rv n e we t p teehbtso sP I ttl s ' eeu s n o , /M ' eeu s n u ;h xii h w M ' oa S s rvn ermann rlt eycntn fo 2 0 tru h20 . eeu e iig eai l o sa trm 0 1 ho g 0 4 v

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g : z DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e l t i : 72 /0 0 e
No 0 -05 1 . 81 2

err'PrnyvAr. eg tasIc,6F.d6 96 2(t Cr19)MGE' ro. u t . kFrihw y,n.1 3 4,5 5h i.9 4. S
d cso t se GE/MISpoiswa ceryals- iut atmp t sv is eiin o ek P ' rft s lal atm n e te t o a e t cp rg tnrng me tli fo ds is lo fiu et po ed ma e . o yih ifi e n cam rm im sa fralr o rv a g s MGE ha no s ce d d GE/ M l r s n e e ie c t a a p o i a ey1 % o PMI s t u c e e . p p ee t d vd n e h t p rxm tl 0 f ' s UPSs r ieb sn s c mefo MGE-r n e ma h n s a dMGE'sfwae evc u ie s a r m b a d d c ie, n S ot r wa usbeo l wihMGEUPSmahie a dn t t cmpeiosp o ucs s a l ny t c n s n o wih o ttr'r d t. Th s PMI tt lrv nu fr e c e s t e a p o i aey 1 % o rve ue u , ' o a e e e a x e d h p rx m tl 0 f e n s rao a l rltdt t eifig me to MGE'cp rg t MGE nede t e sn by eae o h nrn e n f S o yih . e do p e e tamo ena rwl t io e c lu aino PMI p oisi o de t c g ie r sn r ro y alr d ac lto f ' r ft n r r o o nz s acam frcp rg td m a e dtrb tbet t ei fi g me t'Aco dn l, li o o y ih a g sd tiu a l o h n rn e n .' cr i gy a

tedsrc cuterdi dn igGEP I Rue5()moin o MGE' h itit or re n eyn /M ' l 0a to n S S
c p rg ti fi g me tcamsbe a s MGE ha no s o n d ma e un e o y ih nrn e n li c u e s t h w a gs dr

j54b. 0 ()
B

GE/MIag e tedsrc cu t re i d n igisRue5 () t n P r u s h itit o r erd n e yn t l 0a moi o
r g r i g MGE' mia p o rain o ta e s ces a d un ar c mp tto e a dn S s p rp ito f r d e rt n f i o eiin camsb cus t eeie c ddno s p otd ma e frteecams Att e li ea e h vd n e i t u p r a gs o h s li . h co eo MGE'c s ,heo l e ie c i to uc dt s p o tt d ma e cams ls f S a e t ny vd n e n r d e o u p r is a g s li wa t eao e e to e DX- 7c a ts o i gPMIs o a rv nu se r e fo s h fr m n in d 3 h r h w n 'tt l e e e a n d r m als u c so i cme GE/ M Ic n e d t a wiho te ie c o P Isne l o r e f n o . P o t n s h t t u vd n e f M ' t p oise r e o t eMGE e upme ta is e MGE' sa elw camss o l r ft a n d n h q i n t s u , S t t a li h u d

h v be ds isdo GEP I Rue5 () to . ae en im se n /M ' l 0a moin S
Th r i ltl p e e e tund rTe a lw t g ie u i d tr ii g e e s ite r cd n e x s a o u d s n eem nn whehe MGE ha s sane t eb r e o p o f e uie o apli tfs e i g tr s u t i d h u d n f ro r q r d f an if e kn t r cv rad fnd n 'ne p ois I t eo l r p re Te a c s iv li g o eo e ee a ts t r ft. n h n y e o t d x s a e n ovn t er cv r o d fn a tsp oisframia p o raino ta es cescam, h e o ey f ee d n ' r ft o s p r p ito f r d er t li teDalsCo r o Ap e lhedt a at o g dfn a ts oisaeadrp r h la u t f p as l h t lh u h ee d n 'prft r d o e p

ee et)f a ae i acs iv ligtewrn fl s o ata esce,a lm nl o d m gsn aen ovn h o gu ue f rd ert '
1 2

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 17 9 9 P g : 3 DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e l t i : 72 /0 0 e No 081 5 1 . -0 2 pan if a no rc v rd ma e wiho tofrnge ie c ços o t ea t a litfc n t e o e a g s t u fei vd n eç h w h cu l t

poima eb (ee dnl Elo C e . r. . r-u, n.4 4SW.d rf d y dfn a t. cr h m Cop vAgi lIc, 9 . 2 t ' s 2 42 4(e .i.p . Dals 9 3wrtednre)gc lo roC rmis 0 ,1 T xCvA p l 17 , irf ... cas Cab ea c, a ; IcvKef, 6 F Ap '74 73(t Ci.0 6 (n u l h d ( trrt g n.. ee16 . px 1 ,2 5h r2 0)u p bi e)i epei sn n
Te a 1w t p r i apan ift de k d ma e me s r db t edee d nts x s a o e m t litf o t e a g s a u e y h fn a ' s

atapoisrsligfo teu eo dslsr oteta escen; utn cu l rf eutn rm h s r icou e fh rd ert)Ho so t M e c ntl Ex h Cop.t DalyPer lu Cop.9 0S. .d2 2 2 8(e . ra ie c . r J ie toe m r , 3 W 2 4 , 4 T x . Ap . Ho so (4h Dit 19 ,n wrt (n ig ta,a a trsod p utn 1t s. 9 6 o i f dn h t s h eh l ) )i
r q ie e tt r cvei g d ma e frta es ce a d u fi cmpeiin e ur m n o e o rn a g s o r d er t n n ar o tto

camsd panif spoueeie c fo whc tejr ma rao al li ,a lit mut rd c vdn erm ih h uy y esn by t f
i fr t a t e d ma e s e fr ha e r s le fo t e cnd c o t e n e h t h a g s u d o v e utd r m h o u t f h

dfn a f) eed n ' .
I t ei sa tmatr MGE f c st es mep o lmss o i gd cua n h n tn te , a e h a r be h w n d t l a p oisr s li gfo t eus o dsls r o t eta es ce'a i ddo is r ft e utn r m h e r ico u e f h r d e rt s t i n t ' cp rg tcam.DX-7d mo sr tdPMIsttl e e u ,no S cua p ois' o y ih li 3 e n ta e ' oa rv n e ts t l r ft . a ' MGE ha no pee tdeie c ta po ie a yme nso dsig ihig s t rsn e vd n e h t rvd s n a f itn us n r v n e PMI g ie fo ohe sure fo rv n e g i e t rug eeu an d r m t r o c s r m e e u an d h o h mia po raino MGE'ta esces1tao eaclulto o p oisfo s p rpito f S rd ert,e ln ac ain f rft rm t erlv n p rino rv n e MGEatmpst dsig ihElo b a g ig h ee a t oto f ee u . te t o itn us cr y run t a DX-7i drdbeeie c o PMIsprft, b tMGE ned dt tke h t 3 s d e il vd n e f ' ois' u c ' ee o a a dto a se st d d c u rltdr v nu a dc ssfo t e ettlfg r s d iin l tp o e u t n ea e e e e n ot r m h s oa iu e

i odrodmo srt P I poi rltdt teifigmet MGEfi d n re t e ntae M ' rft eae o h nrn e n. ss al e
t d s. ooo

Ho ee, ag e t a cmme tft t eRE T T ME T(HID O w v r MGE r u s h t o n o h S A E N T R ) F UNF R C MPTTO j4 (9 5 gvr sd mae u drT x slw,a d M O EIIN 5 19 ) oen a gs n e ea a n
cntn st a i me isb r e u d rt i b r e -hfi gfa e o k: o e d h t t t t u d n n e hs u d ns itn r m w r Th ta iin lfr o r siu ina y r le i a a to frt e e r dto a om f e tt to r eif n n cin o h a po raino ata esce i a acunigo ted fnd n' p rpito f r d ert s n co tn fh ee a ts
1 3

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g :4 DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e l t i : 72 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 p oiso s lsatiutbet t eu eo t eta es ce. . The r ft n ae trb a l o h s f h r d er t . . pan ifha t ebu d no e tbihngt ed fn a t s ls t e litf s h r e f sa ls i h ee d n ' ae ;h s d fnd n ha t eb r e o et bihi ga ypoto o t es ls ee a t s h u d n f sa ls n n rin f h ae n tatiutbet t eta es ce a da ye pe sst b d d ce o trb a l o h r d er t n n x n e o e e u td i d tr i i gne p ois n eem nn t rft. M GE p it t PMIstt lr v nue i DX-7 a d a g e t a , un e t e on s o ' oa e e n 3 n r u s h t d r h Ret tme t t i e hbts tsisisb r e o p o fwih r g r t PMIs sa e n , h s x ii a ife t u d n f r o t e a d o ' Gae'o p o i i g sr iet UPS ma hi e . MGE cntn st a GE/ M I s ls f r vdn evc o ' c ns o ed h t P s bsq e tyha t eb r e o d mo sr tngwhc p rinso PMIsr v nue u e u n l d h u d n f e n tai ih oto f ' e e ween tatiutbet t esae1w cams wh c i fie t d . r o trb a l o h tt a li , ih t ald o o

Tea cut h v n ta otdteRET TME T(HR )O UN AR x s o rs ae o dpe h SA E N T ID F F I C MPTTO i is nieya dwh tej4 'cmmet icnrln i Tea O EIINI te t t n eh r 5s o n fso tol gn x s I r i
cursi sila o e q eto .Sc,cg.I r Bas 1 3S. .d7 5 7 9 4 o t s tl n p n u sin c . ,n e s, 1 W 3 3 , 3 - 0

(e. 0 3 ( l wigteoiia RET TME TO TO T' eiio o a d T x 2 0)f l n h rgn l SA E N F R Sdf t n f n oo ni
fcosusdt ie tf ta esces d s ieti scin' sih atr to atr e o d n iy rd ert, ept hs eto s lg t leain

teefnte SA E E T(HR )F NF RCO PTTO SZcr elrIc hroi h RET TM N T ID O U M M E IIN) c Si e,n. ; g
( ee , ) rz . . . 4 0 4 1 7 e . 9 1 a o tnga dnsr cie' o to 7 , 7 - 2 x 1 9 d p i n d tu tv 'p rin i

o teRET TME T(E O D 0 T R Sb tn t gta teTea S pe e f h SA E N S C N ) F O T u oi h t h xs u rm n C u th sn t d pe t eRET T ME Ti ise trt) T eb r e -hfig o r a o a o td h SA E N n t niey. h u d ns i n t
p o e u e n t di c mme tfa eno icud di t efrtRESAT ME TO r c d r s oe n o n r t n l e n h is T E N F TOR Swho ed fniino a dfco s e t ie tf ta esce s r sil e T , s ei to f n a tr us d o d n iy r d e rt a e tlus d b Te a cu t. Se I r Bas 1 3S. .da 7 9 4 . Net e t eTe a y x s o rs e n e s, 1 W 3 t 3 - 0 ih r h x s S p e eCo r no a yo t eTe a a pelt cursh v s e iial a pl d u r m u t r n f h x s p lae o t a e p cfc ly p i e c mme t t d tr iead fnd n 'prft i ata es ce a to . v nt a o n fo ee m n ee a ts ois n r d er t cin Gie h t c mme t ssa d r st apantfsb r e o p o fo ta esce d m a e o n f t n a d es li if u d n f r o fr r d e rt a g s

R SAE ET F OT adwatnaieysae frnlso ite ETTME TSc N ) ETTM N O T RS n sett l ltdoicuinnh R SA E N (Eo D v O T RsinwadesditeRETTMET(HR ) FUNARC MPTTO . F oT,s o drse n h SAE N T ID O FI O EIIN
1 4

T ecneto u fi cmptin whc wa oiial icu e i te f s h ocp f nar o eio , ih s rgn l n ldd n h i t t y r

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 P g :s DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 a e l t i : 72 /0 0 e
No 081 5 1 . -0 2 lwe t a t esa d r a pidi Elo , c n ld t a t eTe a Sup e e o r h n h t n a d p le n c rwe o cu e h t h x s r m Co r wo l n ta o tteb r e -hitngpoe u e o cmme tf u t ud o d p h u d ns fi rcd rs f o n . Aco dngy,hedsrc c u ter di d cii gt g a tGE/ M ISRul c r i l t itit o r re n eln n o r n P ' e

5() to o MGE'mia po rainota e erta du ficmptto 0amoin n S sp rpito frd sces n naro eiin
cams li . II S

GEP Io tn sh dsrccu tre i dn igis l 5() to /M cne d te itito rerdn eyn tRue 0b moin
a t eco eo t ec s b c us t eewa lg l i s fiin e ie c t s pp r t h ls fh a e e a e h r s e al n ufce t vd n e o u ot y

tejr' $ . miin d ma ea ad i dn igisrq ett a pyte h uys 46 lo a g w r ;n e yn t e u s o p l h l
OnesaifcinRul t MGE'rcv r un e Te a lw;a di cncudng - tsato e o S eo ey d r x s a n n o l i t a d ma e fo a t oc ri gb fr De e be 1 ,2 0 ween tb re b h t a g s r m cs cu rn eo e c m r 7 0 1 r o ar d y t et r ey a saut o lmia insund rb t t eCo y ih Ac a dTe a h h e -e r tt e f i t to e oh h p rg t t n x s lw. Ad iinal,MGE c n e d t edsrc cur a us disdsr to b a dto ly o tn s h itit o t b e t icein y

dn igMGE'rq etfrpeu g e titrs o d mae.Bea s te eyn S eu s o rjdm n neet n a gs cu e h dsrc cuterdi ds isn GE/MI Rue5 ()moina tecoeo itit or re n im sig P ' l 0a to t h ls f S
M GE' c s bea s MGE ha fie t p o e is d m a e cams t e e S ae cu e s ald o r v t a g s li , h s a g me t a emo t r u n s r o. V

GEP Ia p astedsrc cut ga to ap r a e tijnt n /M p el h itit o r' rn f em n n nu ci s o
a ans GE/MISu eo MGE' sfwa ea dta esces Werve t e gi t P ' s f S ot r n rd ert. e iw h

d na o ga t o a p r a e t ijn to fr a a u e o dsr t n e il r r n f em n n nu cin o n b s f icei . o
Sc lts y' Lt .JStrigPurha igd Nat Diti.Co, 2 F.d3 3 4 2 h oz k s d I e ln c sn s 1 srb .5 0 3 9 , 0 ,.

(t Cr2 0) 5h i.0 8.
S cin 5 2o t eCo yihtAc a t oie t ecu tt ga tSia eto 0 f h p rg t uh rzs h o r o rn s n l f f

ijnt n o sc tr sa i ma de raoal t pee to rsri nu ci s n uh em s t y em esnbe o rvn r etan o
i fi g me to acp rg t' Ala e US ,I c u DGITeh .I c,1 6F.d nrn e n f o y ih . c tl A n . . ' ' c s, n . 6 3

72 70(t Cr19 )q oig1 U... 52a) GEP I otn sta i 7,9 5h i. 99 (u t 7 SC j 0() /M cned h tn n .
2 0 i t r e o e t eo l i fi gnga tce alp o t a ha n tbe nus d 0 5 t u n d v r h ny nrn i ril, a tp h t d o e e
1 5

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 7 9 9 Pa e l DaeFld 0 /02 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 1 9 6 g :6 t i : 72 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 snc 2 0 ,a d t a t e o l da a ds fund wa i a fr e e po e ' i e 0 2 n h t h ny t ik o s n o m r m ly es p se so whoa mitdt k e i gi frhso n r fr nc atrhelf t e o s sin d te o e pn t o i w ee e e fe et h cmpa y. Ho e e ,GE/M Ia mitd t fv i sa c s o dr c c p rg t on w v r P d te o ie n t n e f iet o y ih i fi g me t a dMGE p e e t dn meo si sa c so GE/ M ISifi gng n rn e n , n r s n e u r u n t n e f P ' n rn i a tvt a tili cudngsm eu e o MGE s fwa et a o c re atrt e ciiy t ra,n l i o s s f ot r h t cu r d fe h

dsrc cute trdispei iayijnto a di pu d e todri itit o r nee t rl n r nu cin n m o n m n re n m
Aug s 2 0 .Ad iinal,hel p o so t otil t e s swhoa mitdt u t 0 5 dto ly t a tp f w ra win s e d te o usngMGE s fwa ea dta esc es rs e tv l, r ne e rc v r d a d i ot r n r d e r t,e p ciey wee v r e o ee , n GE/ M I aldt ofrcncusv e ie c t a cun frt e elp o sa s nc . P f ie o fe o l ie vd n e o co t o h s a tp ' b e e Gie t a t e ema b ifi gn ma eil silnGE/ M IS se so , v n h th r y e n rn ig tras tli P 'po s sin a dgv n GE/ M ISfi r t c nfr t t ec n tan so t ep ei i a y n ie P ' al e o o o m o h o sr it f h rlm n r u

ijnt n tedsrccut in tb s is iceini ga tn apr a e t nu ci ,h ititordd oa uetdsrt n rnig em n n o o ijnt naantGE/MI ftr u eo MGE'sfwaea dta esces nu ci gis P ' uue s f S ot r n rd ert. o S
VI Fo t e fr g i g r a o s we AFFI M t e dsrc cur' g a to r h oe on e s n , R h itit o ts r n f

GEP I Rue5 () to ds isn MGES Acam. as AFF RM /M ' l 0a moin im sig 'DMC li We lo I S tedsrc cut ga to apr a e tijnto a an tGE/MI u eo h itit o r' rn f em nn nu cin gis P ' s f s S
M GE' s fwa ea dta es ces WeREVERS t edsrc c u t d nil f S ot r n r d er t. E h itit o r' e a o s

GEP I Rue 5 () moin o MGE' cprg t ifigme t u fi /M ' l 0a t n S o S oyih nrn e n, nar
c mpeiin, ndmia p o ra ino ta esc escamsfrMGE'fiur t o tto a s p r p ito f r d e rt li o S al e o

poed ma e u dr1 U... 5 4b a dT x slw,n RENDE atk rv a gs n e 7 SC j 0 () n ea a a d R ae ntigjd meto MGE. ohn u g n fr

1 6