MDY Industries, LLC v. Blizzard Entertainment, Inc., et al

Filing 52

Filed Appellee Blizzard Entertainment, Inc. additional citations. Served on 10/06/2010. (panel) [7506668] [09-15932, 09-16044] (CW)

Z W ILLIN G E R G E N ETS K I LL?

1 0 N Sre N 75 t t W e Q QQ 63 8 O 9 55 z l nc m l g Wahn tnD 2 0 6 www.wi e .o sigo C 0 3

Oco e 6 2 1 tb r , 0 0
VaR a lr i i e ua Mal MsMolD y r . l we y Ceko C ut lr f o r U..o ro Ap e lfrh Nit Crut S C ut f p aso te nh i i c PO. o 1 3 3 . Bx 999 SnFa cso C 9 1 93 3 a rni , A 4 1 -9 9 c

RMELcD YRCEK c E lV LRD Os OROEPEL LY ùTF /AS U, W A E .C

0 T1 21 2 3 92
FE ID L M KE GD
.

DT AE

IIA N IL T

R : MD Id sr sLCe a.. lzr E tran et t I e Fn u te L t IvBi ad netim n e a. i z C s N s0 -5 3 &0 -6 4 ae o .919 2 91 0 4 Ag e Jn 7 2 1 a dsb ie t Wiim CC n yC nu l M. ru d u e , 0 0 n u mt d o l . a b, o s eo t l a C lh n a dSn r S Iua al a , n a da .k t. a
D a MsD y r e r . w e:

Wewreo bhloA pleBiadEtrimetIc(Biad'prunt FRAP i n ea f pel lzr netn n,n.'lzr' usato .... t f ez a 'z ) 2(t ntyteCuthth FtCrutawida nioiiniMG USSse slcvG 8j o oi h ortate ih i ihs t rw t pno n E P ytm ,n..E )f fc h s Cnu e&Idsrln ,1 F3 70(tCr21)' G / adiudanwoiin MG US osm r nutalc 62 .d 6 5h i 00(M F' n s e e pno. E P i . ''s ) Sse sIcvG Cnu e&Idsrl c ea.N .8151 F3 ,00WL791 (t ytm.n..E osm r nutaI ,tI o0-02, .d 21 36205h in , CrSpe br921)' G ltatce)Iapeiu2(Itret nuy2,00 i etm e2,00(M El (t hd.n rv s8je esno Jl 221, . ' 'a ' o )t A plnslie taMG leetdBiadsru etadspotdrvraoteDsrt pel tc m dht E rjce lzr'agm ns n upre eeslfh i i aa z tc t ada et ee etocisne1 USC10())yrqin panisopoeht o d n xr lm nt lm udr7 ...21a( b eurg li f t rv taa a a 2 i tf
MDY Industries, LLC v. Blizzard Entertainment, Inc., et al Doc. 52

C ut rlgwi rgrt Biads MC c is T d s, Yp itt teMG Io rseine o rsui t ead o lzr'D A lm . o o o MD onso h E cut rl c 'n h z a 'a o dcaiLx aklt,n..tt CnrlytmsadCa b riGopIcvSyikTcsIc n i n em r n'IcvSai ot Sse n hm eln ru,n..kl eh,n. t l co a n

tcnlgcl auent nypeetacst, u a ocpigotepoetdwok 's lzr ehoo i mesr o o l rvns cesobt l oyn fh rtce r.' Biad a s Az hs rudii bifadrsos t MD'Itrtiaddee et a n baig ntics, a age nt r s n ep neo YSe e,hs d e lm n hs o e r o hs ae se t n wh rA plns ohcru v ne Biads ces otos n cpe Biadspoetdwok ee pel tbt i m etd lzr'acscnrlad o id lzr' rtce r. a c z z N nteesteriudo iiniMG 1dsad tevrp i o whc MD rlsni o eh l ,h es e pno n E1 i rsh ey on n i Y ei i t s s c t h es

pir8jlte,bnoi ispotosc a adt nllmetyrmoigteprinote r 2( etraadnn t uprfruh n dioaee nb e vn h ot fh o) gs i o

o iinta rldo Lx akadCa br i. E1h l o lta tep itfaldt peet pno htei n em r n hm eln MG 1od ny hth lnifi o rsn e a s af e ayeiec so igtata dfn at a atalatrdtesf aea iu t bpste n vdne hwn htht eedn hd cul l e h ot r ts e o yash ye w s acscnrl aue.nta,h pani hdo lpo ue eiec tatedfnat a ue cesotomesrs Isedte l tfa ny rdcd vdne hth ee dn hd sd if te otaeatrh acscnrl aue weeccmv ne . s e osrtdii bif g h sfw r f te ces otomesrs r iu etd A dm ntae nt r i , e r s en

K OW L DGE J DGM E T VII N N E U N SO
Dockets.Justia.com

Biadpo ue a peeiec ta MD adMrD nelpr n l eggditeccmvnin lzr rd cd m l vd ne ht Y n . o nl es al nae n h iu et z y oy r o o Biads cesotosnt rlueotesf aeatriu vnin Seeg Apeln' f lzr'acscnrl o mee s fh ot r f cr m et . e,.. p l t z , y w ec o , as B.t 21.C ne unl MG 1de ntup rrvra. ra 1-4 o sqet, E1os o spoteesl y Sneey icrl ,

/
C rt nSG ntk hii . e esi sa
C* C

LneCV nbe ac .e al

E coue nlsr

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 1 t i : 92 /0 0 e

I THE UNI ED STATES COURT OF APPEALS N T e ro FOR THE FI TH CI CUI UntdSttsCouutAppas F R T i aehCrtf el F il ic A R E C Y IV E D FIL E D

V,c7rAùl îL%r l l' L '' s fp Y .7
2 T1 21 C 3 22
DT AE

N KTD XD EE X

No.08-05 1 12

Se tmb r 9 2 1 pe e 2 , 0 0 L l W. y e ye Ca c Clr ek

ICA NI TL

MGEUPSS STEMS1 C Y N
Pli tf- p la t Cr s - p ele an if Ap eln - o sA p le

GECONS M ERAND I DUSTRI LI C; I DUSTRI LS STEM SI C; U N A N GE N AY N GENERAL ELECTRI COMPANY; POWER MAI TENANCE C N I TERNATI NALI C N O N
Dee d nt fn a s Ap eln s p la t App le s ele Cr sos

Ap e l fo t eUntdSttsDititCo r p as rm h ie ae src u t frt eNo t enDitito Te a o h rh r src f x s
Beo eBARKS ALE, fr D GARZ , ndPRADO, rutJ d e . Aa Cic i u g s EMI I M. L O GARZ , rutJ d e A Cic i u g : Theo ii a o iini t i c s wa is e b t ep ne o Juy2 , 01 . rgn l pno n h s a e s su d y h a l n l 0 2 0 Tr ai g t e p tto frr h a i g e b n a o e frpa e r he rn ,we e tn h eiin o e e rn n a c s n o n l e a i g

GR NTtep tini pr, tda o rpeiu oiin(1 F3 7 0(t A h eio n atwih rw u rvo s pno 6 2 .d 6 5h t Cr2 1),n sbttt tefl wig i.0 0)a d u siue h ol n . o MGEUP S se sIc( GE'a p ash dsrccut FeeaRue S ytm ,n.R ' p elte ititor' drl l M) s o CvlP oe ue5 ()ds islo isDiia Mie nu Coyih Ac f ii rcd r 0a im sa f t gtl l n im p rg t t l ( MC 'camaant o e Manea c Itrain lIc(P I)Ge ea R A )li gisP w r itn nenen to a,n .RM '; nrl D '

Ca e 0 -0 21 D c me t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 2 t i 0 /92 1 e No 08 1 5 1 . -0 2

ElcrcC mp n (GE'; Co sme a dId sra,n .a dGEId sra eti o a y d )GE nu r n n utilIc;n n util < S se s Ic(olciey < E/MI) MGEas a p astedsrc cut ytm ,n .cl tvl,d P '. e G lo p el h itit o r' s dnaopeu g etneetnMGEs a ae a ad GEp lrs-p el e ilfrjd m n itrso 'd m gs w r . /M cosa pas o fu go n s()wh te tedsrc cuterdi ds isn GE/MI n o r ru d:1 ehr h itit o r re n im sig P ' S Rue5 () t nb cu e fie t pee tvdn e f a ae,rnte l 0a moi ea s MGE ald o rsn eie c od m gso i h o atraiewh te tedsrccut re i ds isn GEP I Rue5*) len tv, eh rh itit or erdn im sig /M ' l 0 S moinbcuete$ .miinjr a adwa nt rao a l cluaino to ea s h 46 lo uy w r s o a esn be aclto f l dma e;()wh te MGE i pr isby du l-eoee d ma e;() a gs 2 eh r m em sil o bercvrd a gs 3
wheh rt ep risha atli ga r e e ti pa et a pemit dMGE t t e h a te d oln g e m n n lc h t r te o

rcvrd mae pirt Dee br1, 0 1a d() ehrtedsrc cu t eoe a gs ro o cm e 7 2 0;n 4 whte h itito r erdi ga tn MGEijntv rl f gis GEPMI re n rnig nu cie ei a ant / . e
I

Unnerpil pwe sp l (UPS'mahn saeue d rn pros itru t e o r u py < ' c ie r sd uig eid b <)
o p we o tg s t po ie p we t ciia o eaig s se s MGE f o r u a e o rvd o r o rtcl p rtn ytm . ma ufcur ss v r li e o UPSma hi e , o eo whihr q iet eus o n a t e e ea ln s f c n s s m f c e ur h e f M GE' c p rg td s fwa ep o r msPa r ta dMug e d rngs r ii g S o y ih e ot r r g a ce n u t u i e vcn . Th ssfwa efx sc lb ainp o lmsmo eq ikyt a ta iin lma ua i ot r ie air to rb e r u c l h n r dto a n l s r ii g tc n q e . Wih utt e sfwa e a sr ie tc nca c n sil evcn eh iu s t o h ot r , e vc eh iin a tl p rilysriea MGE UPS ma hne b tan mb ro ciia p oe u e atal evc n c i , u u e f rtcl rc d r s

( cu ig eairt na dajsme t fotg lvl)a olb prome i ldn rcl ai n dut n ovla eeescn ny e efr d n bo
trug u eo t esfwae whc wokso l o MGE- a uatr dd vcs h o h s f h ot r , ih r ny n m n fcu e e ie . Thes fwa er q ie cnn cin o a e tr a ha d a es c rt k y ot r e u r s o e to f n x en l r w r e u iy e

(aldaRo ge)oteatpsrap r. c dn lh s neprt nd t, cl dn l't h lpo eil ot Eah o ge a a x iai ae e o
a ma i um n mb ro us s a d auniuep swo d. Whe t es fwa ei xm u e f e, n q as r n h ot r s a tv td,i s a c e fra p o e l p o r mme d nge b fr i wilfly cia e t e rh s o r p ry r g a d o l eo e t l ul lu c .Onc lunhe ,h sfwa ewilg t rug ascndsre o prtcl a n h e a c d te ot r l o h o h eo eis f ooo e c a g swih t e d t lc td o t e UPS ma hies mir p o e sr t xh n e t h aa oae n h c n ' co r c so s o cnim ta MGE sfwaei cmmu iaigwih MGE had ae I te o fr h t ot r s o nctn t rw r. f h
2

Ca e 0 -0 2 D c me t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 3 t i : 92 /0 0 e
No 081 5 1 . -0 2 poooe c a g is ce sulMGE'sfwaepoed t cletyse saus rtclxh n e s u csf , S ot r rce so olc s tm tt ifr a infrt etc niin. no m to o h eh ca Ye r atrMGEito u e issc rt tc noo y anumb ro sfwae a s fe n rd cd t eu iy eh lg , e f ot r hake sp bihe i fr aino t ei tr e dslsngg ne a i sr cin o c r u ls d n o m to n h n en t ico i e r ln tu to s n h w t d fa tee tr a sc rt fau e o aha d a ek y. Onc t e o o ee t h xen l eu iy e trs f rw r e eh s fwa e i ca k d a d t e s c rt ke i d fae ,t e sfwa e c n b ot r s r c e n h e u iy y s ee t d h ot r a e a c s e a dus dwih u lmia in. ce s d n e t o t i t to PM Ii aciia p we s r iec mp n sr ii gava it o b a d o s rtc l o r evc o a y e vcn rey f r n s f UPS mahn s icudngMGE UPS mahie . P 1iiilys b o tatd cie,n l i c n s M ntal u cn rce MGEt p rom sfwaesr ieo MGEUPSmahn sb tsmei eb fr o efr ot r evc n cie ,u o tm eoe J n 2 0 ,ago po PMIe po eso tie a la to ecp o MGE' u e 0 0 ru f m ly e ban d t e s n o y f S sfwa efo a un n wns u c .GE a q ie PMIi 2 01 ot r r m n k o o r e c ur d n0 . I De e b r 2 0 ,MGE fld s i a ans GE/ M I fr i tr ala n cm e 0 4 ie u t g i t P o , n e i, cp rg tifi g m e t mia p o ra ino ta es ces u fi c mpeiin, o y ih nrn e n , s p r p ito f r d er t, n ar o tto cn eso ,ndDMCAvoains GE/MI o sno ds ut la iiy,na mu h o v rin a ilto . P d e t ip eiblt i s c a i a mist r c v rngalptpfo afr e PMIe po e t a c nti e s t d t o e o ei a o r m o m r m ly e h t o an d h c e MGE sfwa e a da mist fv isa cso ti sfwa esus fo ak d ot r, n d t o ie n tn e fhs ot r' e rm J ne2 0 tr ug Ma 2 0 .MGE alg sta GE/MIusdt esfwaea u 0 0 ho h y 0 2 l e ht P e e h ot r tt lo 4 8 tme ,icudng us s atr t e dsrc c ur g a t d MGE a oa f 2 i s n l i e fe h itit o t r n e

pei iayijnto a antGEP I ueo MGE' sfwaea dta e rl n r nu cin g is /M ' s f S ot r n rd m S
s ces er t.

Durngt epoe dng frt i ato ,GE/MImo e ,rne e ,a d i h rce i s o hs cin P vd e w d n

r-re moin frs mmayjd me ta djdmeta amatro lw eugd to s o u r u g n n u g n s te f a p ru n t F drl lso CiiP oeue5() n ()ag ig itrai, us a to eea Rue f vl rcd r 0a a d b run ,ne l a
t a MGE cul no s sanaDMCA cus o ato a ans GE/MI Afe ht o d t u ti a e f cin g i t P . tr

iiil dn igGEP I pera moinfr u mayjd me t ndis l ntal eyn /M ' rtil to o s m r u g n a t Rue y S 5 ()moino MGE'DMC cam,h dsrc cutds isdteDMC 0a to n S A li te itit or im se h A cam d rn a ofrcr jr cag cnee c.T euyfu dta GEP I li uig n f-eoduy h re o frne h jr o n h t /M
3

Ca e 0 -0 21 Do u e t0 5 14 3 1 P g r DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 4 t i 0 /92 1 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 ha ifig dMGE' cp rg t,mia p o rae MGE' ta esces a d d nrn e S o yih s sp rp itd S r d ert, n

cmmie u fi b sn s patcs Th jr a ad dMGE tefl wig o t d nar uies rcie. e uy w re t h ol n o
d ma e : a gs

A. Da a e frmia p o raino ta esces nMGE'd t m g so s p rp ito fr d erto S aa ds : ik Ne p oise r e b GE/MIfo J nuay1 2 0 t t rft an d y P rm a r , 0 1 o

Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 6 ,0 cm e 7 2 0 : 4 00 0
Ne poise r e b GE/Mlfo Dee b r1 , 0 1 t rft an d y p rm cm e 8 2 0

t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ ,5 ,0 o g s 5 2 0 : 18 20 0
B. Da a e frc p rg tifig me t m g s o o y ih nrn e n : 1 Ne p oise r e b GE/MIrm Ja uay1 2 01t . t rft an d y P fo n r ,0 o

Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 6 ,0 cm e 7 2 0 : 3 80 0
2 Ne pois ane b GE/MIrm Dee b r1 ,0 1 . t rft e r d y P fo c m e 82 0

t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ ,5 ,0 o g s 5 2 0 : 18 20 0
C. Da a e frmia p o raino MGEsfwa eta es ces m g s o s p r p ito f ot r r d e r t: Ne p oise r e b GE/ M Ifo Ja ua y1 2 01t t r ft a n d y P r m n r , 0 o

Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 20 0 cm e 7 2 0 : 9 ,0
2 Ne p oise r e b GE/M Ir m Dee be 1 , 0 1 . t r ft a n d y P fo c m r 8 2 0

t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ o g s 52 0 :0 TOT L: $ ,2 ,0 A 46 40 0 T edsrc cuta addMGE tettluyvrit ps- d me t h itit o r w re h oa jr edc, otj g n u itrs, p r a etijnto aantGEP Ii pu d e toifign neeta em n n nu cin g is /M ,m o n m n fnrn ig
ma eil,a a l c ssa datr e 'fe . dsrc c u t e lne t a a d trast x be o t, n to n yse s The itit o r d ci d o w r

peu g e tneet nted maea ad. rjd m n itrs o h a g w rs
1 1

MGEag e ta tedsrccut re i ga tn GEP I Rue5 () ru sh th itito rerdn rnig /M ' l 0a S
moin ds isngMGE' DMCA voain cam.Werve deno oatil to im si S ilto li e iw v ra

cut dcso o aRue5 () to fru g et samatrolw,iwig or' eiin n l 0a moin o jd m n a te fa ve n s
4

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 Pa e 5 DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 g: t i : 92 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 al fhee ie c fnt elg t n wihal e s n beifr n e mo t a o a l lo t v d n ed h ih a d t 1r a o a l n e e c s s fv r be i t tep ryo p sdt t emoin. ReouinTr s Cop.t Cr zc, F.d o h at p oe o h to ' slto u t r ) cn r 6 3 ' .

10 , 19(t Cr19)itr aq oain o ie)ARue5 () to i 12 10 5h i.9 3 ( en l u tto s m t d. l 0a moin s n t poel ga td Ri te fcs a d ifrne pit s srn l a d rpry rne lf h at n nee cs on o to gy n l oewhl igyi fvr fh moig at ..h tesn beu oso ln t vr em nl n ao ote vn p ry .ta rao aljrr cud o h v arvda acnrr vrit'I.ctto o itd. ae rie t otay edc. d (iain m te) '
GE/MIa g e t a MGE ha fie t s o t a t eDMC ' a tP ru s h t s ald o h w h t h A S ni crumve to p o iin a pid t t e a to s o t e GE/ M I e po e s ic n in rvso p le o h cin f h P m ly e , b cus i ctsnoeie c t a aGE/MIe po e o rp ee ttv wa ea e t ie vd n e h t P m ly e r e rsnaie s rs o sbefrcru v nig te sc rt faurso MGE' sfwae a ep n il o ic m e tn h eu iy e t e f S ot r- s o p s dt meeyusn t esfwa eatrs meohe p ryds be t ec d p o e o rl i g h ot r fe o t r a t ia ld h o e rq iigad nge Asars l, PMIa g e,t ato sddn tvoaet e e urn o l. e utGE/ ru s is cin i o ilt h DM CA a dwo l , tmo t ha ea o n e t c p rg tifi g me t n ud a s, v m u t d o o y ih nrn e n . Oneo Co gesp r oe b hide atngteDMCA wa treigt e f n rs' u p ss e n n ci h s ag tn h cru v nto o tc n lgc lp oe to s Davd o & Asos v J n , 2 ic m e in f eh oo ia r tcin . is n s c. . u g 4 2

F3 6 0 6 9 4 (t Cr 20 )Th DMC 'a t-ic mvninpoiin .d 3 , 3- 0 8h i. 0 5. e AS ni ru eto rvso c
sa e ,R op r o s alcrumv n atc noo ia me s r t a efciey t ts N e s n h l ic e t e h lgc l a u e h t fe tv l

cnrlacs t awokpoetdu drtitte'1 U... 10 ()1() otos ceso r rtce n e hs il. 7 SC j 2 1a() . A
Todic mv n a tc n lgc lme s r 'me nst d e ca bea sr mbe d ru e t eh oo ia a u e' a o s sr m l ca ld c d wo k, od cy ta e cy t d wo k,o ohewiet a od, y a s r mo e r t erp n n rpe r r t r s o v i b p s, e v , d a tv t ,o i para t c noo ia me s r ,wiho tt ea t o iy o t e e ciae r m i eh lgc l a u e t u h u h rt f h

cp rgto n r'I. 10 ()3() Rfetvl cnrl acs t awok oyih w e. d j 2 1a() . Efciey o tos ces o r' A
me n t a Gheme s r ,nt eo dna yc ureo iso e ain, e uie t e a s h tt a u e i h r i r o s f t p r to r q r s h a pia ino ifr a in, rap o e so ate t e twiht ea t oiyo t e p lc to fn o m to o r c s r r a m n , t h u h rt fh

cp rgto nrt gi acs t tewok'I . 10()3() oyih w e,o an ces o h r . d j 2 1a()B. Bea s j10 ()1itree a cru vnin ide nt p l t te cue 2 1a()sagtd ticm eto ,t os o a py oh ue foyihe wok cfrh tcn lgcl au e a be cru vne. s ocp rg td r s /cteeh ooiamesrh s en icm e td SeUnvra Ci Su is I ct C re, 7 F.d4 9 4 3(dCr 20) e iesl t tdo, n.) ol 2 3 3 2 , 4 2 i. 0 1. y .y
5

Ca e 0 -0 21 D c me t0 5 1 4 31 P g : DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 6 t i : 92 /0 0 e
No 0 - 0 21 . 81 5

(()eDMC trestecru vnino dgtl l g adn cp rg td dTh < A agt h ic m e t f iia wal u rig oyihe o s maeila dtaf kn i cru vnintos,u d e nto cr islwih tra(n rfcign icm eto ol)b t os ocnen tef t i teueo toemaeil atrcru vnin h socre .. T eise h s f h s tras fe icm e to a curdM h su , )
t eeo e i n twh t e t etc noo ia me s r st a efcieyc ntold h r fr ,s o eh r h eh lgc l a u e h t fe tv l o r le a c s t MGE' sfwa eweecrumv n e a s mep it b twhehe t e ce s o S ot r r ic e t d t o on , u t rh a to s o GE/ M ISo n r p e e ttv s a o n e t crumv nto . The cin f P ' w e r s n aie m u td o ic e in DMCA dfn scrumv nto b o dyt icu en to l dsbigp oeto s eie ic e in ra l o n ld o ny ia ln rtcin ,

b tas a odn o bp sigte . S e1 U...j10 ()3() We u lo viig r y asn h m e 7 SC 2 1a() . , A
ho e e , ono c n tueR y a s o Rv i't e cm p s us o ac p rg td w v r d t o sr b p s' r a od'o n o a s e f o y ih e ' wok s b e u ntt acrumv n inme eyb c us t a us wo l ha eb e r u s q e o ic e to r l e a e h t e u d v e n

sbeto tcn lgcl aueh t o lh v cnrl dacst te r, u jcta eh ooiamesr taw ud ae otol ceso h wok e
b tfrt a crumv nto .S b o dacn tucinwo l e tndteDMCA u o h t ic e in o ra o sr to ud xe h b y ndisitnd dp r o e t r a he tnsv c n uc ar a ywelr g ltd e o t n e e u p s s o e c x e ie o d t le d l-e u a e b e itn cp rg tlws MGE ddn tp e e ta ye ie c s o i gt a a y xsig o y ih a . i o r s n n vd n e h w n h t GE/ M Ir p e e t tv atr d t e Pa r ta d Mu ue sfwa e s c t a a P e r s n a ie le e h ce n g t ot r u h h t d n l wa no r q ie t us t es fwa e r t e , mpo e ssmpyu e t e o ge s t e ur d o e h ot r ;a h re ly e i l s d h sfwa e atrt e atr to wa ma e As s c ,t e a to sby GE/ M I ot r fe h le ain s d . u h h cin P e po esddno a o n t crumv nto .Wiho tpo igGE/MIat al m ly e i t m u t o ic e in t u rvn P cu ly crumv ntdt etc n lg , ic e e h eh ooy MGE d e no p ee tav ldDMCA cam. os t r sn ai li Bea s MGEha no so nt a GE/MI ic mv ne MGE'sfwa e cu e s t h w h t P cru e td S ot r poeto si voaino t eDMCA,hedsrc cu tddno eri g a tng rtcin n ilto fh t itit o r i t r n rn i

GE/MI Rue5() to ds isn MGE'DMC cam. P ' l 0a moin im sig S A li S
II I

GEP Iag e tedsrc cuterdi dn igisRue5 () to /M ru s h itit o r re n eyn t l 0a moin
wihrg r t MGE'cam undrteCo yiht tb c u et etsi o yo t e ad o S li e h p rg Ac ea s h etm n f MGE'd ma e e p r ha b e src e ,ndMGEi po el rle o PMIs S a g s x et d e n tik n a m rp ry eid n ' tt lg o srv nuefg r r t e t a t epo to r a o a l r lt dt t e oa r s e e iu e ah r h n h rin e s n by eae o h cp rg tifig me t Fo t esmera o , PMIag e MGE fie t o yih nrn e n . r h a e sn GE/ r u s ald o
6

C s : 81 5 1 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 Pa e 7 DaeFld 0 /92 1 a e 0 -0 2 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 g: t i : 92 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 p o ealt eee e t o issa elw mia p o rain o ta es ce sa d rv l h lm n s f t tt a s p r p ito f r d er t n u fi c mp tto camswiho tnto u ige i e c o PM1sp oisr ltd n ar o eiin li : t u i r d cn vd n e f ' r ft ea e t t eifi g me t MGE ha fie t p o ed ma e frt e ecams o h nrn e n , s ald o rv a g s o h s li . A

GEP Iag e ta tedsrc cuterdi dn igisRue5 () /M ru s h t h itit o r re n eyn t l 0a
moinb cus MGEfie t p ee ts fiin e ie c o d ma e . d r1 to ea e ald o rsn ufce t vd n e f a g s Un e 7

U...j54a() n ()acprg to nripr itdt rcv rhso n SC j 0 ()1 a d b, o yih w e s em te o eo e i w
G cua d ma e yicu i gls p oisa dSe s na l r y lyr t s'o wha a t l a g s' n ldn o t r ft n < a o be o at ae , r t ' r ' awiln b y rwo l ha ebe nr a o a l r q ie t p yawilngs le a l g u e ud v e e s n by e u r d o a i l elr s i alc n igfefrt ea t a us o t ec p rg tdmae il t ei fi g r . ie sn e o h cu l e f h o y ih e tra by h nrn e s

Da i&Ga ,n.26F.d1 21 7(dCr2 0)Acp rg t wnrma as vs . p Ic,4 3 5 ,6 2 i.0 1. oyih o e y lo
s e Rnyp oiso t ei fi g rt a a eatiu a l t t eifi g me ta d e k a r ft f h n rn e h t r trb t be o h nrn e n n ae n ttke it acun i cmp tn t eat a d ma e. 1 U... r o a n no co t n o uig h cu l a g s' 7 SC '

j54 ) l tecprg to n rcosst cam ifigr pois dh 0* . f h oyih w e h oe o li nrn e' rf ,f e s tt
c p rg t wn ri r q ie t p e e tp o f nyo t eifi g rsg o sr v n e o y ih o e s e ur d o r s n ro o l fh nrn e ' r s e e u ,

a dt eifig ri rq ie t p o ehso h rd d cil ep n e a dt e n h nrn e s e ur d o rv i r e e u t e x e ss n h b
ee e t o p oi atiut bet fco soh rt a t ec p rg tdwok. I . lm n s f r ft trb a l o a tr t e h n h o y ih e r ' d ; '

seas Esaeo F z vF i Ic,4 F2 16 18(t Ci.9 8 (p lig e lo tt f cz . ar n.8 9 .d 8 , 8 5h r18)a pyn c , ti sa d r t cprg tifigme tato seigifigrspois. hs tn ad o oyih nrn e n cin ekn nrn e' rf ) t
GE/MIa g e ta MGE fie t stsyt efrtse o p o igifig rs P ru s h t ald o aif h is tp f rvn nrn e' p oisb cus MGE' o l e ie c o gosrv nu swa Ex ii DX-7 a rft ea e S ny vd n e f rs e e e s hbt 3 , o ep g b rg a hs o i gPMIsGo a r v nue'r m ali e o b sn s fo n -a e a r p h w n ' tt l e e ' o lln s f u i e s r m f 2 01t rug 2 0 .GE/ M I o tnd t a t i c a tncud sundfe e tae 0 h o h 0 4 P c n e s h t h s h r i l e ifr n it d gosrv nu fo sriigav reyob a dso euime tn tmeeyMGE rs e e e rm evcn ait f r n f q p n , o rl e uime t a d t e eo e d e no rfet rv nue Rtrb tbl t t e q p n , n h rfr o s t elc e e s a tiu a e o h i fi g me t' n rn e n . '

Rolc l blyh sbe so n, 5 4b cetsa iiil rsmpin l n ei it a en h w j 0 ()rae n nta peu to ai
t a t eifi g rsërft . . trb t bet t eifi g me ta ee ua t is h t h n rn e ' p ois . atiu a l o h n rn e n ' r q l o t
7

Ca e 0 -0 2 D c me t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 1 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 8 t i 0 /92 1 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5

gos ee u .Bo nr . wsn 4 4F.d2 02 4(t Cr2 0)atrto rs rv n e' n e vDa o ,0 3 9 ,9 4h i.0 5 (leain ' ioiia)q oig1 U... 54 ).f metn isntab re ,o e e, n rgn l(u tn 7 SC j 01 )dn eigtii l udnh w v r l i
acpy iht le mus s o mo et a t ei fi g rstt l r s rv nuefo o rg hod r t h w r h n h n rn e' oa g o s e e r m a lo isp oi sr a s l f t r ft te m . Ra h r Ir s r v n e r fr o l t r v nue t e ,g o s e e u ' ee s ny o e e

rao a l rltdt teifigme t I.e p ae a dd;e as Da i, esn by eae o h nrn e n. d (m h ss d e)se lo vs ' 2 6F.d a 19 6 (n ig pofrd eie c o dfn a t ttlgos 4 3 t 5- 0 f dn rfee vdne f ee d n' oa rs i s
rv nu s t o b o d t s p o t a c p rg t ifi g me t cam b s d o e e e o r a o u p r o y ih nrn e n li a e n

dfn a t ueo pani scp rg tdeelse i a a cmp in; tt ee d n' s f litf oyihe ygassn n d a ag )Esae s f o F n ,8 9F.da 18 10(n igta < lmpsm fg r frpois f c c 4 2 t 8 , 9 f dn h td u -u iu e o rf i a t
atiut bet t etlvso c mme cast a cnti e i fi g dma eila trb a l o h ee iin o ril h t o an d n rn e tra s awhoewih u a cun i gfrt ef c t a t eifi g dma eilcnsiu e l t o t co tn o h a t h t h nrn e tra o tt t d o l afa to o a y gv n c mme ca'wa t os eultv a cnneto t ny r cin f n ie o ril s o p c aie o cin o '

ssand ma e)T yo tMerc,1 F.d1 1,12(t Ci.9 3(n ig uti a gs; c lr) ii 72 2 1212 7h r18)f dn .k i isfiin frj5 4b p roe ta pani s o e dfn a t gos nuf et o 0 () up ss h t litf h w d ee dn' rs c f s
rv nu sfo t es lso a l r d csi se do d mo sr tngg o sr v nue e e e r m h ae f lp o u t n t a f e n ta i r s e e s

fo sl o teifign po ut) rm ae fh nrn ig rd cs. MGEsu h o e $ 0 miini d ma e b sdamotx lsv l o t e o g t v r 1 0 lo n a g s ae l s ecu iey n h l
tsi o yo iso l d ma e e p r,Dr La r n ePr sot Dr Pr sots etm n f t ny a g s x e t . u a c e c t. . e c t'

tsi oy rltd t t od mae moes ()MGESls pois a d () etm n eae o w a g d l: 1 ' ot rf ; n 2 t
rc v rng a r a o a l r y ly Noa l,Dr Pr sot d d no tsiy t e o ei e s n be o at . t by . ec t i t e tf o GE/MI p oisatiu a l t t eifig me t Thedsrc cur c rid P ' rft trb tbe o h nrn e n . S itit o t a re

GE/MI FeeaRue f iec 7 2a dDa brkbet n t DrP ect' P ' drl loEvdne 0 n u etojci so . rsot S o s
t si o ya dp r it dhi t t siya til Afe he rn hi tsi o y,he e tm n n e m te m o etf t ra. tr a i g s e tm n t dsrc c ur c n l d dt a i s o l b src e i ise tr t ,d t r i i g itit o t o cu e h t t h u d e tik n n t n iey e e m n n t a Dr Pr sot cncu insr g r i g MGE' ls p oiswe eba e o h t . ec t' o l so e a dn s S o t r ft r s d n is fiin fcs n d t,nldn u s p otdas mpin rg r igMGE' n ufce tata d aaicu ig n u p re su to s e adn S

' uet. rel wP ams Ic,0 U..7,9 (93. Da bruMerlDo h r . n.59 S 5952 19) ,
8

Ca e 0 -0 2 D c me t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e g t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 ls ma k ts a ea dsr iep ii g Thedsrc c u tas fu dDrPr sot ot r e h r n evc rcn . itit o r lo o n . e c t ha n e p re c i a s si ghy oheia r a o a l r y lyr t sa dt a d o x e in e n s e sn p t tc l e s n b e o at ae n h t

hspofrdh pteia rao a l rylyrt wa ntb sdo ojcie i rfee y oh tcl esn be oat ae s o ae n bet v
a ay i. n lss Onc DrPrsotstsi o ywa src e , ofrdafna wines e . ect' etm n s tik n MGE fee i l t s, MGEg nea ma a e Miha l Bre , p ee tdtsi o yrltngo l e rl n g r c e O' in who rsn e etm n eai ny t MGE' ra o a l ry lyd ma e. O're wa n v rd sg ae a a o S e sn be o at a g s B in s e e ein td s n e p r o d m a ec lu ains Thedsrc c u t li a eyfu dhi tsi o y x e t n a g ac lto . itit o r utm tl o n s etm n

isfcett p r i MGEt ofrajr isrcino rao al ry l nuf in o em t i o f uy n tuto n e sn be oat e y
d ma e. a g sz M GE' o l r mannge ie c o d ma e wa DX-7 t eb rg a h S n y e ii vd n e f a g s s 3 , h a r p i dc tngPMIsttlr v nu fo 2 0 t r ug 2 0 .Tho g t i wasa n iai ' oa e e e r m 0 1 h o h 0 4 u h hs n e hbi p e a e b GE/M I t edsrc cur a mit dt ee hii d rngDr x i t rp r d y P ,h itit o t d te h x bt u i . P ect'r-iet x miain.MGEq eto e DrPrsoto l o telc rsot edrc e a n to s u sin d . ect ny n h ak o GE r v n er p e e t do DX- 7sg a h.Dr Pr sotwa n tq eto e f e e u e rsne n 3 ' rp . e c t s o u sin d a o twh t e t e tt lPMI rv n e i dc td o t e g a h r p e e td b u e h r h oa e e u n iae n h r p e r sn e rv nu rltdt PMlsifig me to MGE'cp rg t' e e e eae o ' nrn e n f S o yih .
2T pcl ,odmo srtrao alry l d mae, pani pee t eie c yial t e ntae esn be oat a gsa litf rsns vdne y y f a t d h th p ris udh v are t a afipiefrle sn tedfn a top t sod a te ate wo l ae ged o s ar rc o i n ig h ee d n t u w c teta esce t teuetedfn a titn e a t etmetemia porainto h rd ert o h s h eed n ne dd t h i h sp rpito ok pae'UnvCmpuigC.)L ksYugtwnC r.54F.d5859(t Cr17) lc. i. o t ot ye-onso op,0 2 1,3 5h i.94. ' n. Ho ee, B inwa ol a l t tsi a t terylya o nsta MGEwo l aka w vrO're s ny be o ety s o h oat m u t h t f ud s cmpttrop y o rvn ta cmpttrrm etrn te Ssrieid sr- ta i, o eio t a tp eeth t o ei fo neigh UP evc n uty h ts o sagrn l hg rylya o nsh t udpieo t o pttr.S c a o nsaent tg eigy ih oat m u t ta wol rc u cm eios uh m u t r o cg ia la aGe sn be oat' aclto a whc ab y r n sl r udaretb onzbe s rao alry ly cluain t ih u e a d el wo l ge o e ' e mak t au frap riua peeo sf ae Se c tlUS ,n. . soS:, 3 F r e v le o at lr ic f ot r. e Alae A Ic u Cic y .2 9 . c w S p.d 6,6 (..e.02 Crhs aueso e acltd ae o a esnbe u p2 6069ED Tx20) l imesritb cl ae bsd n raoal a u ry l t whc tepriswo l h v a re a tet eo tealg dmia porain oat o ih h ate ud a e ged t h i fh l e sp rpito . y m e Whl teC u trcgie ta smed ge o seuaini ih rn i cluaiga i h o r eonzs h t o ere f pclto s n ee t n acltn e sp oiiu le sn are e tb t en t o p ris ta h sn vr ocre,ti u p st s i nig gem n ew e w ate h t a ee curd hs oc

h pteiacntut .mutcnansmedre ocriue'(mp aiadd) yoht losrc.. s oti o e e fet d. e hss del. c t'

gah(X4, cmprsnoMGEUP eup etrsrvn e ess Ssr c p's rp D -2a o aio f S qim n goseeu vru UP ed e o s

3 h tilrn citn iae ta MGEma h v be tyn t rfr oadf rn T e rata srp idctsh t y a e en rig o ee t iee t f

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 Pa e l D t Fld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 g : o ae i : 92 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 GE/MIag e ta i wo l n th v icu e DX-7i ispo oe P r u s h t t ud o a e n ld d 3 n t r p sd e hiisha i k o nt a Dr Pr sot t si o ywo l b src e 4 e a s x bt d t n w h t . ec t' e tm n u d e tik n b c u e s iha n ie MGEwo l b se igGE/MISpoisrt e t a MGE'o n t d o da ud e e kn P ' rft ah r h n Sw ls p oisa dra o a l ry lis MGE cntnd t a s e igd fnd nts ot rf n e sn be o ate . t o e s h t e kn ee a ' p ois wa no a ne t e r o r c v r b c u e t e J i tPr tilOr e rft s t w h o y f e o ey e a s h on era d r

idctsta isu h R oeayd mae p ru n t 1 U... 5 4'o n iae h tt og t m ntr a gs us a t o 7 SC j 0'fr
cp rg tifi g me t Thi p o iin e c mp se altpe o da a e o y ih nrn e n . s r vso n o a s s l y s f m g s a albefrc p rg ti fi g me t i cu i g t ec p rg to n rsa t a v ia l o o y ih nrn e n ,n ldn h o y ih w e ' cu l d ma e ,hei fi g rsprft a tiu a l t t eifi g me ta dsautr a g s t n rn e' ois trb t be o h n rn e n , n t t oy

d mae.Ho ee,nisFeea Rueo CiiP oeue2 ()dslsrs a gs w vri t drl l f vl rcd r 6a icoue,
whe a k dt p o ied c mp t to o e c c tg r o d ma e came y n s e o rvd d o u a in f a h ae o y f a g s li d' a ' MGE idctd t a Dr Prsotstsi o y wo l cmp ie isd ma e n iae h t . ect' etm n ud o rs t a g s c lulto .Dr Pr soto l t siidt MGE' a t a d ma e : ac a in . e ct n y e tfe o S cu l a g s MGE' o n Sw ls p oisa dr a o a l r y lyr ts I ohe wo d , her c r i dc ts o t rft n e s n be o at ae . n t r r s t e o d n ia e t a MGEp a n dt r l e tr l o isa t a d ma e cam; PM Iha n ht ln e o ey n iey n t cu l a g s l i GE/ do rao t t ikt a MGE wa se igGE/MI poisatiua l t t e e sn o hn h t s e kn P ' rft trb tbe o h S i fi g me t no wa i p e a e t d fnda ans s c acam . n rn e n , r s t r p r d o ee g i t u h li

RWle o eo teprmafceee et o acam i d mae a dte l h n n fh i ai lm ns f li s a gs n h
cama t al t i to u ee ie c o t o ed ma e , o s ec mmisaft l li n fis o n r d c vd n e f h s a g s he r h o t a a

err'P u ttAr. eg t asIc,6F.d6 96 2(t Cr19)MGES ro. r ny) kFrihw y,n.1 3 4 ,5 5h i.9 4. ' ' .
d cso t se GE/ M ISp oiswa ce ryals- i ut atmp t s veis e iin o e k P ' r ft s la l a tm n e te t o a t cp rg tnfig me tli fo ds islo fiu et p o ed ma e.MGE o yih i rn e n cam rm im sa fr alr o rv a g s ha no s ce d d. pM l r s n e e i e c t a a p o i aey1 % o PMls s t u c e e GE/ p e e t d vd n e h t p r xm tl 0 f ' UPSsr ieb sn s cmefo MGE-rnd dmahie, ndMGE'sfwa e evc u ies a rm ba e c n sa S ot r

rvn erm 19 truh20) hnirqetdt amiD -7 eeu f 97 hog 07w e t euse o d t X3. o
4 /MI l gst nyitn e tu e 3 t i p ahDrP ect'asrinta GEP al e iol ne dd o s DX-7om e c . rsot seto h t e s a MGESrvn e wetdwn GEP I rvn e wetu ;h ehbtso sP l ttl s ' eeu s n o , /M ' ee u s n p te x ii h w M ' oa S s rvn ermann rlt eycn tn fo 20 tru h2 0 . eeu e iig eai l o sa trm 0 1 ho g 0 4 v 1 0

Ca e 0 -0 21 Do u e t0 5 14 31 P g : 1 DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 1 t i : 92 /0 0 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 wa u a l o l wihMGEUPSmahie a dno wihcmp ttr'rd cs s sbe ny t c n s n t t o eiosp o u t. Thus PMls tt lr v nu fr e c e s t e a p o i a ey 1 % o r v nu , ' oa e e e a x e d h p r xm tl 0 f e e e r a o a l r ltdt t eifi g me to MGE' c p rg t MGE ne de t e s n by ea e o h nrn e n f S o y ih . e do p e e tamo ena r wl t io e c lulto o PMI p oisi o d rt c g ie rsn r ro y alr d ac ain f ' rft n r e o o n z s acam frc p rg td ma e f trb t bet t eifi g me t'Ac o dn l, li o o y ih a g s' tiu a l o h nrn e n . c r i gy a '

tedsrc cuterdi dn igGEP I Rue5()moino MGES h itit o r re n e yn /M ' l 0a to n ' S
c p rg ti fi g me tcamsbe a s MGE ha no s o n d ma e und r o y ih n rn e n li c u e s t h w a gs e

j5 4 ) 0* .
B

GEP Iag e tedsrc cuterdi dn igi Rue5 () to /M ru sh itit o r re n eyn t l 0a moin s
rg r i g MGE' mia p o rain o ta e s c es a d un ar c mpeiin e a dn S s p r p ito f r d e r t n fi o tto camsb c us t ee ie c ddn ts p o td ma e frt e ecams Att e li e a e h vd n e i o u p r a g s o h s li . h co eo MGE'c s ,heo l e ie c i to uc dt s p o tt d ma e cams ls f S a e t ny vd n e n r d e o u p r is a g s li wa t eaoe e to e DX-7c a ts o i gPMI tt l e e ue e r e fo s h fr m n in d 3 h r h w n ' oarv n s an d rm s als ure o ic me GE/M Ic n e dst a wiho te ie c o PMI ne l o c s f n o . P o tn h t t u vd n e f ' t s p oise r e o t eMGE e uime ta is e MGE' saelw camss o l rft a n d n h q p n t su , S t t a li h u d

h v b e ds isdo GE/MI Rue5() to . ae en im se n P ' l 0a moin S
Th r i ltl p e e e tund r Te a lw t g ieusi d t r i i g e e s ite r c d n e x s a o ud n ee m nn whehe MGEha s sane t eb r e o p ofrq ie o apantfse ig tr s u ti d h u d n f ro e urd f li if ekn t r c v rad fnd n ' ne p ois I t eo l r potdTe a c s i v li g o e o e ee a ts t r ft. n h n y e re x s a e n ovn t er cv r o d fnd n 'p oisframia p o raino ta es cescam, h eo e y f ee a ts r ft o s p r p ito fr d er t li teDalsCo r oAp e lhedt a ato g dfnd n'p oisa eadrp r h la u t f p as l h t lh u h ee a ts rft r d o e p

ee e t1 f a a e i acs ivligtewrn fl s o ataesce,a lm n l o d m gsn aen ovn h o gu ue f rd ert' '
pan ifc nn tr c v rd ma e wiho tofrnge ie c dos o t ea t a litf a o e o e a g s t u fe i vd n e< h w h cu l t

poima eb (ee d nl'Elo C e . r.JAgi u,n .4 4SW.d rf d y dfn a t. cr h m Cop I r- lIc, 9 . 2 t ' .s 2 42 4(e . vAp . Dals17 , irf n...se loC roC rmis 0 ,1 T xCi. p- l 9 3wrte d re) eas a b ea c, a ; IcvKef, 6 F. px7 4 7 3(t Cr2 0)(n u l h d ( trrtn n. . ee 16 Ap ' 1, 2 5h i. 0 6 u p bi e)i epeig sn
Te a lw t pemi apantf t de k d m a e me s r db t ed fnd n ' x s a o r t li if o f e a g s a u e y h ee a ts s

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : z DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e l t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5

atapoisrsligfo teueo dslsr oteta esce'Ho so cu l rf eutn rm h s r icou e fh rd erf) u tn t ; Mecni Exh C r.tDal Perlu C r.90SW.d22 2 8(e. ra te c . op ) iy toe m op, 3 . 2 4, 4 T x l .e Ap . Ho so (4h Dit 19 ,n wrt (n ig ta,a a trsod p u tn 1t s. 9 6 o i) f dn h t s heh l ) i
rq ie e tt rcv rngda a e frta esce a d u fi cmp tto eurm n o eo ei m g s o r d ert n nar o eiin

cams< pani mut rd c eiec fo whc teuyma rao al li ,d litf spoue vdne rm ih h jr y e sn by a f
ifr t a t e d ma e s e fr ha e r s le fo t e c n uc o t e ne h t h a g s u d o v e utd r m h o d t f h

dfn a f . ee d n )
l t eisa tmatr MGE fcst es mepo lmss o igGcua n h n tn te, ae h a rbe h w n a t l p oisr s li gfo t eu eo d sls r o t eta es ce'a i ddo is r f e u tn r m h s r ico u e f h r d er t s t i n t t ' c p rg tcam .DX-7d mo sr t dPMIsttl ee u , td cua prft. o y ih li 3 e n tae ' oa rv n e no d t l ois' a ' MGE ha no pee tde ie c t a po ie a yme nso dsig ihig s t rsn e vd n e h t rvd s n a f itn us n rv n e PMI g ie fo oh r s ure fo r v n e g ie t r ug ee u an d r m t e o c s r m e e u an d h o h mia p o ra ino MGE'ta es ces ltao eac lu aino p oisfo s p rp ito f S r d er t,e ln ac lto f rft r m terlv n p rino rv nu .MGEatmpst dsig ihElo b ag i g h ee a t oto f e e e te t o itn us cr y r un t a DX-7 i Sr dbl e ie c o PMIsp ois'b tMGE n e e t t k h t 3 s ' e i e vd n e f ' r ft, u c ' edd o a e a dto a se st d d c u r ltdr v nuea dcssfo t e ett liur s d iin l t p o e u t n ea e e e n o t r m h s oa fg e

i odrt d mo srt P I prftrltdt teifigme t MGEfie n re o e ntae M ' oi eae o h nrn e n. ss ald
t d s. ooo

Ho ee, ag e'h tcmme tft teRET TME T(HR ) F w vrMGE ru sta o n o h SA E N T ID O UN ARCO P TTO j4 (9 5 gv rsdma e u drTea lw,a d F I M EIIN 5 1 9) o en a gs n e x s a n
c n e d t a i me isb r e u d rt i b r e -hitngfa e o k: o tn s h t t t t u d n n e h s u d n s fi r m w r Th ta iina fr o r siu ina y r le i a a to frt e e r dto l o m f e tt to r eif n n cin o h a p o raino ata es ce i a a c u tngo t ed fnd nts p r p ito f r d er t s n co n i f h ee a ' p oiso s lsatiut bet t eus o t eta es ce. . The rft n ae trb a l o h e f h r d er t . . pantf ha t eb r e o et bih n t ed fnd n ' s ls t e li if s h u d n f sa ls i g h ee a ts ae ; h d fnd n ha t eb r e o e tbls i ga yp rino t es ls ee a t s h u d n f sa ih n n oto f h ae n tatiut bet t eta es ce a da ye p ns st bed d ce o trb a l o h r d er t n n x e e o e u td i d tr i i gne p ois n ee m n n t r ft. M GE p it t PM1s ttlrv nue i DX-7 a d a g e t a ,un e t e on s o ' oa e e n 3 n r u s h t d r h Re tt me t t i e hii s tsisis'u d n o p o fwih r g r t PM1s sae n , h s x bt a ife t b r e f ro t e a d o '
1 2

Ca e 0 -0 21 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : 3 DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e l t i 0 /92 1 e
No 0 -05 1 . 81 2 Rae'o po iigsriet UPS mahie. MGE cntnd t a GE/MI sls f rvdn evc o ' c ns o e s ht P s b e ue tyha t eb r e o d mo sr tngwhc p rin o PMI r v n e u s q n l d h u d n f e n ta i ih oto s f ' e e u s we en tatiu a l t t esaelw cams whihi fie t d . r o trb t be o h tt a li , c t ald o o

Tea cut h v n ta otdteRET T ME T(HR )O UNAR xs ors a e o dpe h SA E N T ID F F I CO PTTO i is nieya dwh te j 5s o me ticnrln iTea M EIIN n tetrt n eh r 4 'cm n fso tol gn x s i
cursi sila o e q eto .Sc, ..I r Ba s 1 3S. .d7 5 7 9 4 o t s tl n p n u sin c eg,n e s, 1 W 3 3 , 3 - 0

(e . 0 3 ( l wigteoiia RET TME TO TO T' eiiino a d T x 2 0)f l n h rgn l SA E N F R Sdfnto f n oo
fco sus d t ie tf ta es ce s d s ie t i scinssihtatr to a tr e o d n iy r d e rt , e pt h s e to ' lg le ain

teefnte SA E E T(HR ) F N ARC MP TTO S;er ige,n. hroi h RETT M N T ID O U FI O EIIN)La SelrIc tPcc,1 SW.d4 04 17 (e.9 1 (dpiga Nntu t e prin 7 rz8 9 . 2 7 ,7- 2T x 19) a otn n srci ' ot . v o o teRETT ME T(E O D O T R Sb tn tn ta teTea S pe e f h SA E N S C N ) F O T u oig h t h x s u rm Co r h snta otdteRET T ME Ti ise trt) T eb re -hfig ut a o dpe h SA E N n t niey. h udnsi n t
p o e u e n t di cmme tfa eno i cud di t efrtRE T T ME TOF r c d r s o e n o n r t n l e n h is S A E N TOR Swho ed fniino a dfco s e t ie tf ta esce sa esi us d T , s ei to f n a tr us d o d n iy r d e rt r tl e l b Te a c u t. Se I r Ba s 1 3S. .d a 7 9 4 . Net e t eTe a y x s o rs e n e s, 1 W 3 t 3 - 0 ih r h x s Su rmeCo r n ra yo t eTe a a p laecursha eseiial a pid pe u t o n f h x s p elt o t v p cfcly p le cmme t t d tr iead fnd n'p oisi ata esce ato . v nt a o n fo eem n ee a ts rft n r d ert cin Gie h t c mme t ssa d r st apan if bu d no p o f o ta es ce d ma e o n f tn a d es litfs r e f r o fr r d er t a g s lwe t a tesa d r a pidi Elo , cn ld ta t eTe a S pe e o r h n h tn ad p l n crwe o cu e h t h x s u rm e Co r wo l n ta o tt eb r e -hitn p o e ur so c mme tf u t ud o d p h u d n s fig r c d e f o n . Acodngy,hedsrc cu terdi d ciigt ga tGE/MI Rul cri l t itit o r re n elnn o r n P ' e S

5 () to o MGES sp rpito ota esces n u ficmptto 0a moin n 'mia po rain frd erta d naro ei n i
cam s li . I V

RETTME T F OT adwatnaieysae frnlso ite ETTMET(EO o SA E N O T RS n sett l ltdoicuinnh R SAE N S cN ) v O ToT,snwadesdi teR SAE E T(HR ) :UNARC MPTTO . F Rsi o drse n h ETTM N T IDon FI O EIIN

5T ecneto u fi cmptt n whc wa oiial icu e i tef s h ocp f nar o eii , ih s rgn l nld d n h i t o y r

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 14 3 1 Pa e 1 DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 815 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 g :4 t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1

GEP Io tn sh dsrccut re i dn igis l5 () to /M cne d te itit o rerd n eyn tRue 0b moin
a tecoeo t ec s b cus t eewa lg lyis fiint vd nc t s p ot th ls fh ae ea e h r se al n ufce e ie e o u p r

tejr' $ . miin d maea ad i dn igisrq ett apyte h uys 46 lo a g w r ;n e yn t eu s o p l h l
OnesaifcinRul t MGE' rcv r und rTe a lw;a di cncudng - tsato e o S eo ey e x s a n n o l i t a d ma e fo at oc rigb fr Dee be 1 , 0 1weeno b re b h t a gs rm cs cu rn eoe cm r 72 0 r t ard y t etrey a saut o lmiainsund rb t t eCo yih Ac a dTe a h h e -e r tt e fi tto e oh h p rg t t n x s lw. Ad iinal,MGE c ntnd t edsrc cur a us d isdsr to b a dto ly o e s h itit o t b e t ic ein y

dn igMGE'rq etfrpeu g e titrs o d mae.Bea s te eyn S eu s o rjd m n neet n a gs cu e h dsrc cuterdi ds isn GEP I Rue5()moina tecoeo itit or re n im sig /M ' l 0a to t h ls f S
M GE' c s b c us MGE h s fie t p o e is d m a e cams t e e S a e ea e a ald o r v t a g s li , h s a g m e t a emo t ru ns r o. V

GEP Ia p astedsrc cut ga to apr a etijnt n /M p el h itit or' rn f em n n nu ci s o
a ans GE/MISus o MGE' sfwaea dta esces Werve te gi t P ' e f S ot r n r d ert. eiw h

dna o ga to a pr a e tijnt n fr a a u e o dsrto . eil r rn f em n n nu ci o n b s f icein o
Sc lts y' Lt .JStrigPu c asn & Nat Diti. .5 0F.d3 3 4 2 hoz k s d I e ln rh ig , . ' srb Co, 2 3 9 , 0 l

(t Cr2 0) 5h i. 0 8.
S cin 5 2o teCo yih Ac a toie t ecutt g a tGfna eto 0 f h p rg t t u h rzs h o r o rn d l i

ijnto so sc tr sa i ma de rao al t peeto rsri nu cin n uh em s t y em esn be o rvn r etan
ifig me to ac p rg t' AlatlUS , n .t DGIT c s, n . 1 6F.d nrn e n f o y ih .' c e A I c 7 ' . eh .I c, 6 3

7 27 0(t Cr19 )q oig1 U... 5 2a) GEP I otn sta i 7 ,9 5h i. 99 (u tn 7 SC j 0 (). /M cned h tn
2 0 it r e o e t eo l i fi gn a tce alp o t a ha no b e us d 0 5 t u n d v r h ny n rn i g ril, a tp h t d t e n e snc 2 0 ,a d t a t e o l d t ds fund wa i a fr e e p o e ' i e 0 2 n h t h ny a a ik o s n o m r m ly es p s e so whoa mitdt k e i gi frh so nr fr n eatrhelf t e o s sin d te o e pn t o i w ee e c fe et h cmp n . Ho e e,GE/MIa mitdt f eisa cso drc cpyiht o a y w v r P d te o i n tn e f iet o rg v ifig me ta dMGEp ee tdnu eo sisa cso GE/MISifigng nrn e n , n rsne m ru n tn e f P ' nrn i atvt a tilicu igsmeu e o MGE sfwaet a ocre atrt e ciiy t ra,n ldn o ss f ot r h t cu rd fe h

dsrc cute trdispei iayijnto a di p u d e todri itit or nee t rl n r nu cin n m on m n re n m
1 4

Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : 5 DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 1 t i 0 /92 1 e
No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 Au us 2 05 Ad iinal,help o so t otil t e s swhoa mit dt g t 0 . dto l t a tp f w ra win se y d te o usngMGEsfwa ea dta escesrs etv l, r n ve rcv rd,nd i ot r n r d ert,ep ciey wee e r eo ee a GE/MIfie t ofrcncusv eie c t acu to teelpo sa snc. P ald o fe o l ie vd n e o co n fr h s a tp 'b e e Gie t a t eema b ifigngmaeilsilnGE/MISp seso , v n h th r y enrn i tras tli P ' ossin a dgve GE/MISfiur t cnom t tecnsrit o tepei iay n i n P ' al e o o fr o h o tans f h rlm n r

ijnto ,h dsrccut in tb sis iceini ga tn apr a e t nu cinte ititordd oa uetdsrto n rnig em nn ijnto aantGE/MI ftr ueoMGE'sfwaea dta esces nu cin gis P ' uue s f S ot r n rd ert. S
VI Acodngy,hep eiu o iini ti c s i WI HDRAWN.Fo t e cr i l t rvo s pno n hs a e s T rh

frgigrao swe FRM tedsrccut ga tf P I Rue5 () oeon esn , AF I h itit or' rn oGE/M ' l 0a s S
moinds isn MGE'DMCA cam.Weas AFFI M t edsrc cu ts to im sig S li lo R h itit o r'

gato apr a e tijnto aantGEP I u eo MGESsfwaea d rn f em nn nu cin gis /M ' s f ' ot r n S ta esces WeRE E S tedsrccut dna o GE/MI Rue5() rd ert. V R E h itit or' e il f P ' l 0a s S
moin o MGE' cp rg t ifig me t u fi cmp tto , a d to n S o yih nrn e n , nar o eiin n mia p o raino ta escescamsfrMGE' fiur t p o eda a e s p rpito f r d ert li o S al e o rv m g s

u dr1 U... 5 4ba dT x sa ,n RENDE atk -ohn jd me t n e 7 SC j 0 () n ea lw a d R a entigu g n
frMGE. o