MDY Industries, LLC v. Blizzard Entertainment, Inc., et al

Filing 52

Filed Appellee Blizzard Entertainment, Inc. additional citations. Served on 10/06/2010. (panel) [7506668] [09-15932, 09-16044] (CW)

Download PDF
Z W ILLIN G E R G E N ETS K I LL? 1 0 N Sre N 75 t t W e Q QQ 63 8 O 9 55 z l nc m l g Wahn tnD 2 0 6 www.wi e .o sigo C 0 3 Oco e 6 2 1 tb r , 0 0 VaR a lr i i e ua Mal MsMolD y r . l we y Ceko C ut lr f o r U..o ro Ap e lfrh Nit Crut S C ut f p aso te nh i i c PO. o 1 3 3 . Bx 999 SnFa cso C 9 1 93 3 a rni , A 4 1 -9 9 c RMELcD YRCEK c E lV LRD Os OROEPEL LY TF /AS U, W A E .C 0 T1 21 2 3 92 FE ID L M KE GD . DT AE IIA N IL T R : MD Id sr sLCe a.. lzr E tran et t I e Fn u te L t IvBi ad netim n e a. i z C s N s0 -5 3 &0 -6 4 ae o .919 2 91 0 4 Ag e Jn 7 2 1 a dsb ie t Wiim CC n yC nu l M. ru d u e , 0 0 n u mt d o l . a b, o s eo t l a C lh n a dSn r S Iua al a , n a da .k t. a D a MsD y r e r . w e: Wewreo bhloA pleBiadEtrimetIc(Biad'prunt FRAP i n ea f pel lzr netn n,n.'lzr' usato .... t f ez a 'z ) 2(t ntyteCuthth FtCrutawida nioiiniMG USSse slcvG 8j o oi h ortate ih i ihs t rw t pno n E P ytm ,n..E )f fc h s Cnu e&Idsrln ,1 F3 70(tCr21)' G / adiudanwoiin MG US osm r nutalc 62 .d 6 5h i 00(M F' n s e e pno. E P i . ''s ) Sse sIcvG Cnu e&Idsrl c ea.N .8151 F3 ,00WL791 (t ytm.n..E osm r nutaI ,tI o0-02, .d 21 36205h in , CrSpe br921)' G ltatce)Iapeiu2(Itret nuy2,00 i etm e2,00(M El (t hd.n rv s8je esno Jl 221, . ' 'a ' o )t A plnslie taMG leetdBiadsru etadspotdrvraoteDsrt pel tc m dht E rjce lzr'agm ns n upre eeslfh i i aa z tc t ada et ee etocisne1 USC10())yrqin panisopoeht o d n xr lm nt lm udr7 ...21a( b eurg li f t rv taa a a 2 i tf MDY Industries, LLC v. Blizzard Entertainment, Inc., et al Doc. 52 C ut rlgwi rgrt Biads MC c is T d s, Yp itt teMG Io rseine o rsui t ead o lzr'D A lm . o o o MD onso h E cut rl c 'n h z a 'a o dcaiLx aklt,n..tt CnrlytmsadCa b riGopIcvSyikTcsIc n i n em r n'IcvSai ot Sse n hm eln ru,n..kl eh,n. t l co a n tcnlgcl auent nypeetacst, u a ocpigotepoetdwok 's lzr ehoo i mesr o o l rvns cesobt l oyn fh rtce r.' Biad a s Az hs rudii bifadrsos t MD'Itrtiaddee et a n baig ntics, a age nt r s n ep neo YSe e,hs d e lm n hs o e r o hs ae se t n wh rA plns ohcru v ne Biads ces otos n cpe Biadspoetdwok ee pel tbt i m etd lzr'acscnrlad o id lzr' rtce r. a c z z N nteesteriudo iiniMG 1dsad tevrp i o whc MD rlsni o eh l ,h es e pno n E1 i rsh ey on n i Y ei i t s s c t h es pir8jlte,bnoi ispotosc a adt nllmetyrmoigteprinote r 2( etraadnn t uprfruh n dioaee nb e vn h ot fh o) gs i o o iinta rldo Lx akadCa br i. E1h l o lta tep itfaldt peet pno htei n em r n hm eln MG 1od ny hth lnifi o rsn e a s af e ayeiec so igtata dfn at a atalatrdtesf aea iu t bpste n vdne hwn htht eedn hd cul l e h ot r ts e o yash ye w s acscnrl aue.nta,h pani hdo lpo ue eiec tatedfnat a ue cesotomesrs Isedte l tfa ny rdcd vdne hth ee dn hd sd if te otaeatrh acscnrl aue weeccmv ne . s e osrtdii bif g h sfw r f te ces otomesrs r iu etd A dm ntae nt r i , e r s en K OW L DGE J DGM E T VII N N E U N SO Dockets.Justia.com Biadpo ue a peeiec ta MD adMrD nelpr n l eggditeccmvnin lzr rd cd m l vd ne ht Y n . o nl es al nae n h iu et z y oy r o o Biads cesotosnt rlueotesf aeatriu vnin Seeg Apeln' f lzr'acscnrl o mee s fh ot r f cr m et . e,.. p l t z , y w ec o , as B.t 21.C ne unl MG 1de ntup rrvra. ra 1-4 o sqet, E1os o spoteesl y Sneey icrl , / C rt nSG ntk hii . e esi sa C* C LneCV nbe ac .e al E coue nlsr Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 1 t i : 92 /0 0 e I THE UNI ED STATES COURT OF APPEALS N T e ro FOR THE FI TH CI CUI UntdSttsCouutAppas F R T i aehCrtf el F il ic A R E C Y IV E D FIL E D V,c7rAl L%r l l' L '' s fp Y .7 2 T1 21 C 3 22 DT AE N KTD XD EE X No.08-05 1 12 Se tmb r 9 2 1 pe e 2 , 0 0 L l W. y e ye Ca c Clr ek ICA NI TL MGEUPSS STEMS1 C Y N Pli tf- p la t Cr s - p ele an if Ap eln - o sA p le GECONS M ERAND I DUSTRI LI C; I DUSTRI LS STEM SI C; U N A N GE N AY N GENERAL ELECTRI COMPANY; POWER MAI TENANCE C N I TERNATI NALI C N O N Dee d nt fn a s Ap eln s p la t App le s ele Cr sos Ap e l fo t eUntdSttsDititCo r p as rm h ie ae src u t frt eNo t enDitito Te a o h rh r src f x s Beo eBARKS ALE, fr D GARZ , ndPRADO, rutJ d e . Aa Cic i u g s EMI I M. L O GARZ , rutJ d e A Cic i u g : Theo ii a o iini t i c s wa is e b t ep ne o Juy2 , 01 . rgn l pno n h s a e s su d y h a l n l 0 2 0 Tr ai g t e p tto frr h a i g e b n a o e frpa e r he rn ,we e tn h eiin o e e rn n a c s n o n l e a i g GR NTtep tini pr, tda o rpeiu oiin(1 F3 7 0(t A h eio n atwih rw u rvo s pno 6 2 .d 6 5h t Cr2 1),n sbttt tefl wig i.0 0)a d u siue h ol n . o MGEUP S se sIc( GE'a p ash dsrccut FeeaRue S ytm ,n.R ' p elte ititor' drl l M) s o CvlP oe ue5 ()ds islo isDiia Mie nu Coyih Ac f ii rcd r 0a im sa f t gtl l n im p rg t t l ( MC 'camaant o e Manea c Itrain lIc(P I)Ge ea R A )li gisP w r itn nenen to a,n .RM '; nrl D ' Ca e 0 -0 21 D c me t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 2 t i 0 /92 1 e No 08 1 5 1 . -0 2 ElcrcC mp n (GE'; Co sme a dId sra,n .a dGEId sra eti o a y d )GE nu r n n utilIc;n n util < S se s Ic(olciey < E/MI) MGEas a p astedsrc cut ytm ,n .cl tvl,d P '. e G lo p el h itit o r' s dnaopeu g etneetnMGEs a ae a ad GEp lrs-p el e ilfrjd m n itrso 'd m gs w r . /M cosa pas o fu go n s()wh te tedsrc cuterdi ds isn GE/MI n o r ru d:1 ehr h itit o r re n im sig P ' S Rue5 () t nb cu e fie t pee tvdn e f a ae,rnte l 0a moi ea s MGE ald o rsn eie c od m gso i h o atraiewh te tedsrccut re i ds isn GEP I Rue5*) len tv, eh rh itit or erdn im sig /M ' l 0 S moinbcuete$ .miinjr a adwa nt rao a l cluaino to ea s h 46 lo uy w r s o a esn be aclto f l dma e;()wh te MGE i pr isby du l-eoee d ma e;() a gs 2 eh r m em sil o bercvrd a gs 3 wheh rt ep risha atli ga r e e ti pa et a pemit dMGE t t e h a te d oln g e m n n lc h t r te o rcvrd mae pirt Dee br1, 0 1a d() ehrtedsrc cu t eoe a gs ro o cm e 7 2 0;n 4 whte h itito r erdi ga tn MGEijntv rl f gis GEPMI re n rnig nu cie ei a ant / . e I Unnerpil pwe sp l (UPS'mahn saeue d rn pros itru t e o r u py < ' c ie r sd uig eid b <) o p we o tg s t po ie p we t ciia o eaig s se s MGE f o r u a e o rvd o r o rtcl p rtn ytm . ma ufcur ss v r li e o UPSma hi e , o eo whihr q iet eus o n a t e e ea ln s f c n s s m f c e ur h e f M GE' c p rg td s fwa ep o r msPa r ta dMug e d rngs r ii g S o y ih e ot r r g a ce n u t u i e vcn . Th ssfwa efx sc lb ainp o lmsmo eq ikyt a ta iin lma ua i ot r ie air to rb e r u c l h n r dto a n l s r ii g tc n q e . Wih utt e sfwa e a sr ie tc nca c n sil evcn eh iu s t o h ot r , e vc eh iin a tl p rilysriea MGE UPS ma hne b tan mb ro ciia p oe u e atal evc n c i , u u e f rtcl rc d r s ( cu ig eairt na dajsme t fotg lvl)a olb prome i ldn rcl ai n dut n ovla eeescn ny e efr d n bo trug u eo t esfwae whc wokso l o MGE- a uatr dd vcs h o h s f h ot r , ih r ny n m n fcu e e ie . Thes fwa er q ie cnn cin o a e tr a ha d a es c rt k y ot r e u r s o e to f n x en l r w r e u iy e (aldaRo ge)oteatpsrap r. c dn lh s neprt nd t, cl dn l't h lpo eil ot Eah o ge a a x iai ae e o a ma i um n mb ro us s a d auniuep swo d. Whe t es fwa ei xm u e f e, n q as r n h ot r s a tv td,i s a c e fra p o e l p o r mme d nge b fr i wilfly cia e t e rh s o r p ry r g a d o l eo e t l ul lu c .Onc lunhe ,h sfwa ewilg t rug ascndsre o prtcl a n h e a c d te ot r l o h o h eo eis f ooo e c a g swih t e d t lc td o t e UPS ma hies mir p o e sr t xh n e t h aa oae n h c n ' co r c so s o cnim ta MGE sfwaei cmmu iaigwih MGE had ae I te o fr h t ot r s o nctn t rw r. f h 2 Ca e 0 -0 2 D c me t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 3 t i : 92 /0 0 e No 081 5 1 . -0 2 poooe c a g is ce sulMGE'sfwaepoed t cletyse saus rtclxh n e s u csf , S ot r rce so olc s tm tt ifr a infrt etc niin. no m to o h eh ca Ye r atrMGEito u e issc rt tc noo y anumb ro sfwae a s fe n rd cd t eu iy eh lg , e f ot r hake sp bihe i fr aino t ei tr e dslsngg ne a i sr cin o c r u ls d n o m to n h n en t ico i e r ln tu to s n h w t d fa tee tr a sc rt fau e o aha d a ek y. Onc t e o o ee t h xen l eu iy e trs f rw r e eh s fwa e i ca k d a d t e s c rt ke i d fae ,t e sfwa e c n b ot r s r c e n h e u iy y s ee t d h ot r a e a c s e a dus dwih u lmia in. ce s d n e t o t i t to PM Ii aciia p we s r iec mp n sr ii gava it o b a d o s rtc l o r evc o a y e vcn rey f r n s f UPS mahn s icudngMGE UPS mahie . P 1iiilys b o tatd cie,n l i c n s M ntal u cn rce MGEt p rom sfwaesr ieo MGEUPSmahn sb tsmei eb fr o efr ot r evc n cie ,u o tm eoe J n 2 0 ,ago po PMIe po eso tie a la to ecp o MGE' u e 0 0 ru f m ly e ban d t e s n o y f S sfwa efo a un n wns u c .GE a q ie PMIi 2 01 ot r r m n k o o r e c ur d n0 . I De e b r 2 0 ,MGE fld s i a ans GE/ M I fr i tr ala n cm e 0 4 ie u t g i t P o , n e i, cp rg tifi g m e t mia p o ra ino ta es ces u fi c mpeiin, o y ih nrn e n , s p r p ito f r d er t, n ar o tto cn eso ,ndDMCAvoains GE/MI o sno ds ut la iiy,na mu h o v rin a ilto . P d e t ip eiblt i s c a i a mist r c v rngalptpfo afr e PMIe po e t a c nti e s t d t o e o ei a o r m o m r m ly e h t o an d h c e MGE sfwa e a da mist fv isa cso ti sfwa esus fo ak d ot r, n d t o ie n tn e fhs ot r' e rm J ne2 0 tr ug Ma 2 0 .MGE alg sta GE/MIusdt esfwaea u 0 0 ho h y 0 2 l e ht P e e h ot r tt lo 4 8 tme ,icudng us s atr t e dsrc c ur g a t d MGE a oa f 2 i s n l i e fe h itit o t r n e pei iayijnto a antGEP I ueo MGE' sfwaea dta e rl n r nu cin g is /M ' s f S ot r n rd m S s ces er t. Durngt epoe dng frt i ato ,GE/MImo e ,rne e ,a d i h rce i s o hs cin P vd e w d n r-re moin frs mmayjd me ta djdmeta amatro lw eugd to s o u r u g n n u g n s te f a p ru n t F drl lso CiiP oeue5() n ()ag ig itrai, us a to eea Rue f vl rcd r 0a a d b run ,ne l a t a MGE cul no s sanaDMCA cus o ato a ans GE/MI Afe ht o d t u ti a e f cin g i t P . tr iiil dn igGEP I pera moinfr u mayjd me t ndis l ntal eyn /M ' rtil to o s m r u g n a t Rue y S 5 ()moino MGE'DMC cam,h dsrc cutds isdteDMC 0a to n S A li te itit or im se h A cam d rn a ofrcr jr cag cnee c.T euyfu dta GEP I li uig n f-eoduy h re o frne h jr o n h t /M 3 Ca e 0 -0 21 Do u e t0 5 14 3 1 P g r DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 4 t i 0 /92 1 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 ha ifig dMGE' cp rg t,mia p o rae MGE' ta esces a d d nrn e S o yih s sp rp itd S r d ert, n cmmie u fi b sn s patcs Th jr a ad dMGE tefl wig o t d nar uies rcie. e uy w re t h ol n o d ma e : a gs A. Da a e frmia p o raino ta esces nMGE'd t m g so s p rp ito fr d erto S aa ds : ik Ne p oise r e b GE/MIfo J nuay1 2 0 t t rft an d y P rm a r , 0 1 o Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 6 ,0 cm e 7 2 0 : 4 00 0 Ne poise r e b GE/Mlfo Dee b r1 , 0 1 t rft an d y p rm cm e 8 2 0 t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ ,5 ,0 o g s 5 2 0 : 18 20 0 B. Da a e frc p rg tifig me t m g s o o y ih nrn e n : 1 Ne p oise r e b GE/MIrm Ja uay1 2 01t . t rft an d y P fo n r ,0 o Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 6 ,0 cm e 7 2 0 : 3 80 0 2 Ne pois ane b GE/MIrm Dee b r1 ,0 1 . t rft e r d y P fo c m e 82 0 t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ ,5 ,0 o g s 5 2 0 : 18 20 0 C. Da a e frmia p o raino MGEsfwa eta es ces m g s o s p r p ito f ot r r d e r t: Ne p oise r e b GE/ M Ifo Ja ua y1 2 01t t r ft a n d y P r m n r , 0 o Dee b r1 , 0 1 $ 20 0 cm e 7 2 0 : 9 ,0 2 Ne p oise r e b GE/M Ir m Dee be 1 , 0 1 . t r ft a n d y P fo c m r 8 2 0 t Au u t1 , 0 5 $ o g s 52 0 :0 TOT L: $ ,2 ,0 A 46 40 0 T edsrc cuta addMGE tettluyvrit ps- d me t h itit o r w re h oa jr edc, otj g n u itrs, p r a etijnto aantGEP Ii pu d e toifign neeta em n n nu cin g is /M ,m o n m n fnrn ig ma eil,a a l c ssa datr e 'fe . dsrc c u t e lne t a a d trast x be o t, n to n yse s The itit o r d ci d o w r peu g e tneet nted maea ad. rjd m n itrs o h a g w rs 1 1 MGEag e ta tedsrccut re i ga tn GEP I Rue5 () ru sh th itito rerdn rnig /M ' l 0a S moin ds isngMGE' DMCA voain cam.Werve deno oatil to im si S ilto li e iw v ra cut dcso o aRue5 () to fru g et samatrolw,iwig or' eiin n l 0a moin o jd m n a te fa ve n s 4 Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 Pa e 5 DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 g: t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 al fhee ie c fnt elg t n wihal e s n beifr n e mo t a o a l lo t v d n ed h ih a d t 1r a o a l n e e c s s fv r be i t tep ryo p sdt t emoin. ReouinTr s Cop.t Cr zc, F.d o h at p oe o h to ' slto u t r ) cn r 6 3 ' . 10 , 19(t Cr19)itr aq oain o ie)ARue5 () to i 12 10 5h i.9 3 ( en l u tto s m t d. l 0a moin s n t poel ga td Ri te fcs a d ifrne pit s srn l a d rpry rne lf h at n nee cs on o to gy n l oewhl igyi fvr fh moig at ..h tesn beu oso ln t vr em nl n ao ote vn p ry .ta rao aljrr cud o h v arvda acnrr vrit'I.ctto o itd. ae rie t otay edc. d (iain m te) ' GE/MIa g e t a MGE ha fie t s o t a t eDMC ' a tP ru s h t s ald o h w h t h A S ni crumve to p o iin a pid t t e a to s o t e GE/ M I e po e s ic n in rvso p le o h cin f h P m ly e , b cus i ctsnoeie c t a aGE/MIe po e o rp ee ttv wa ea e t ie vd n e h t P m ly e r e rsnaie s rs o sbefrcru v nig te sc rt faurso MGE' sfwae a ep n il o ic m e tn h eu iy e t e f S ot r- s o p s dt meeyusn t esfwa eatrs meohe p ryds be t ec d p o e o rl i g h ot r fe o t r a t ia ld h o e rq iigad nge Asars l, PMIa g e,t ato sddn tvoaet e e urn o l. e utGE/ ru s is cin i o ilt h DM CA a dwo l , tmo t ha ea o n e t c p rg tifi g me t n ud a s, v m u t d o o y ih nrn e n . Oneo Co gesp r oe b hide atngteDMCA wa treigt e f n rs' u p ss e n n ci h s ag tn h cru v nto o tc n lgc lp oe to s Davd o & Asos v J n , 2 ic m e in f eh oo ia r tcin . is n s c. . u g 4 2 F3 6 0 6 9 4 (t Cr 20 )Th DMC 'a t-ic mvninpoiin .d 3 , 3- 0 8h i. 0 5. e AS ni ru eto rvso c sa e ,R op r o s alcrumv n atc noo ia me s r t a efciey t ts N e s n h l ic e t e h lgc l a u e h t fe tv l cnrlacs t awokpoetdu drtitte'1 U... 10 ()1() otos ceso r rtce n e hs il. 7 SC j 2 1a() . A Todic mv n a tc n lgc lme s r 'me nst d e ca bea sr mbe d ru e t eh oo ia a u e' a o s sr m l ca ld c d wo k, od cy ta e cy t d wo k,o ohewiet a od, y a s r mo e r t erp n n rpe r r t r s o v i b p s, e v , d a tv t ,o i para t c noo ia me s r ,wiho tt ea t o iy o t e e ciae r m i eh lgc l a u e t u h u h rt f h cp rgto n r'I. 10 ()3() Rfetvl cnrl acs t awok oyih w e. d j 2 1a() . Efciey o tos ces o r' A me n t a Gheme s r ,nt eo dna yc ureo iso e ain, e uie t e a s h tt a u e i h r i r o s f t p r to r q r s h a pia ino ifr a in, rap o e so ate t e twiht ea t oiyo t e p lc to fn o m to o r c s r r a m n , t h u h rt fh cp rgto nrt gi acs t tewok'I . 10()3() oyih w e,o an ces o h r . d j 2 1a()B. Bea s j10 ()1itree a cru vnin ide nt p l t te cue 2 1a()sagtd ticm eto ,t os o a py oh ue foyihe wok cfrh tcn lgcl au e a be cru vne. s ocp rg td r s /cteeh ooiamesrh s en icm e td SeUnvra Ci Su is I ct C re, 7 F.d4 9 4 3(dCr 20) e iesl t tdo, n.) ol 2 3 3 2 , 4 2 i. 0 1. y .y 5 Ca e 0 -0 21 D c me t0 5 1 4 31 P g : DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 6 t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 - 0 21 . 81 5 (()eDMC trestecru vnino dgtl l g adn cp rg td dTh < A agt h ic m e t f iia wal u rig oyihe o s maeila dtaf kn i cru vnintos,u d e nto cr islwih tra(n rfcign icm eto ol)b t os ocnen tef t i teueo toemaeil atrcru vnin h socre .. T eise h s f h s tras fe icm e to a curdM h su , ) t eeo e i n twh t e t etc noo ia me s r st a efcieyc ntold h r fr ,s o eh r h eh lgc l a u e h t fe tv l o r le a c s t MGE' sfwa eweecrumv n e a s mep it b twhehe t e ce s o S ot r r ic e t d t o on , u t rh a to s o GE/ M ISo n r p e e ttv s a o n e t crumv nto . The cin f P ' w e r s n aie m u td o ic e in DMCA dfn scrumv nto b o dyt icu en to l dsbigp oeto s eie ic e in ra l o n ld o ny ia ln rtcin , b tas a odn o bp sigte . S e1 U...j10 ()3() We u lo viig r y asn h m e 7 SC 2 1a() . , A ho e e , ono c n tueR y a s o Rv i't e cm p s us o ac p rg td w v r d t o sr b p s' r a od'o n o a s e f o y ih e ' wok s b e u ntt acrumv n inme eyb c us t a us wo l ha eb e r u s q e o ic e to r l e a e h t e u d v e n sbeto tcn lgcl aueh t o lh v cnrl dacst te r, u jcta eh ooiamesr taw ud ae otol ceso h wok e b tfrt a crumv nto .S b o dacn tucinwo l e tndteDMCA u o h t ic e in o ra o sr to ud xe h b y ndisitnd dp r o e t r a he tnsv c n uc ar a ywelr g ltd e o t n e e u p s s o e c x e ie o d t le d l-e u a e b e itn cp rg tlws MGE ddn tp e e ta ye ie c s o i gt a a y xsig o y ih a . i o r s n n vd n e h w n h t GE/ M Ir p e e t tv atr d t e Pa r ta d Mu ue sfwa e s c t a a P e r s n a ie le e h ce n g t ot r u h h t d n l wa no r q ie t us t es fwa e r t e , mpo e ssmpyu e t e o ge s t e ur d o e h ot r ;a h re ly e i l s d h sfwa e atrt e atr to wa ma e As s c ,t e a to sby GE/ M I ot r fe h le ain s d . u h h cin P e po esddno a o n t crumv nto .Wiho tpo igGE/MIat al m ly e i t m u t o ic e in t u rvn P cu ly crumv ntdt etc n lg , ic e e h eh ooy MGE d e no p ee tav ldDMCA cam. os t r sn ai li Bea s MGEha no so nt a GE/MI ic mv ne MGE'sfwa e cu e s t h w h t P cru e td S ot r poeto si voaino t eDMCA,hedsrc cu tddno eri g a tng rtcin n ilto fh t itit o r i t r n rn i GE/MI Rue5() to ds isn MGE'DMC cam. P ' l 0a moin im sig S A li S II I GEP Iag e tedsrc cuterdi dn igisRue5 () to /M ru s h itit o r re n eyn t l 0a moin wihrg r t MGE'cam undrteCo yiht tb c u et etsi o yo t e ad o S li e h p rg Ac ea s h etm n f MGE'd ma e e p r ha b e src e ,ndMGEi po el rle o PMIs S a g s x et d e n tik n a m rp ry eid n ' tt lg o srv nuefg r r t e t a t epo to r a o a l r lt dt t e oa r s e e iu e ah r h n h rin e s n by eae o h cp rg tifig me t Fo t esmera o , PMIag e MGE fie t o yih nrn e n . r h a e sn GE/ r u s ald o 6 C s : 81 5 1 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 Pa e 7 DaeFld 0 /92 1 a e 0 -0 2 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 g: t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 p o ealt eee e t o issa elw mia p o rain o ta es ce sa d rv l h lm n s f t tt a s p r p ito f r d er t n u fi c mp tto camswiho tnto u ige i e c o PM1sp oisr ltd n ar o eiin li : t u i r d cn vd n e f ' r ft ea e t t eifi g me t MGE ha fie t p o ed ma e frt e ecams o h nrn e n , s ald o rv a g s o h s li . A GEP Iag e ta tedsrc cuterdi dn igisRue5 () /M ru s h t h itit o r re n eyn t l 0a moinb cus MGEfie t p ee ts fiin e ie c o d ma e . d r1 to ea e ald o rsn ufce t vd n e f a g s Un e 7 U...j54a() n ()acprg to nripr itdt rcv rhso n SC j 0 ()1 a d b, o yih w e s em te o eo e i w G cua d ma e yicu i gls p oisa dSe s na l r y lyr t s'o wha a t l a g s' n ldn o t r ft n < a o be o at ae , r t ' r ' awiln b y rwo l ha ebe nr a o a l r q ie t p yawilngs le a l g u e ud v e e s n by e u r d o a i l elr s i alc n igfefrt ea t a us o t ec p rg tdmae il t ei fi g r . ie sn e o h cu l e f h o y ih e tra by h nrn e s Da i&Ga ,n.26F.d1 21 7(dCr2 0)Acp rg t wnrma as vs . p Ic,4 3 5 ,6 2 i.0 1. oyih o e y lo s e Rnyp oiso t ei fi g rt a a eatiu a l t t eifi g me ta d e k a r ft f h n rn e h t r trb t be o h nrn e n n ae n ttke it acun i cmp tn t eat a d ma e. 1 U... r o a n no co t n o uig h cu l a g s' 7 SC ' j54 ) l tecprg to n rcosst cam ifigr pois dh 0* . f h oyih w e h oe o li nrn e' rf ,f e s tt c p rg t wn ri r q ie t p e e tp o f nyo t eifi g rsg o sr v n e o y ih o e s e ur d o r s n ro o l fh nrn e ' r s e e u , a dt eifig ri rq ie t p o ehso h rd d cil ep n e a dt e n h nrn e s e ur d o rv i r e e u t e x e ss n h b ee e t o p oi atiut bet fco soh rt a t ec p rg tdwok. I . lm n s f r ft trb a l o a tr t e h n h o y ih e r ' d ; ' seas Esaeo F z vF i Ic,4 F2 16 18(t Ci.9 8 (p lig e lo tt f cz . ar n.8 9 .d 8 , 8 5h r18)a pyn c , ti sa d r t cprg tifigme tato seigifigrspois. hs tn ad o oyih nrn e n cin ekn nrn e' rf ) t GE/MIa g e ta MGE fie t stsyt efrtse o p o igifig rs P ru s h t ald o aif h is tp f rvn nrn e' p oisb cus MGE' o l e ie c o gosrv nu swa Ex ii DX-7 a rft ea e S ny vd n e f rs e e e s hbt 3 , o ep g b rg a hs o i gPMIsGo a r v nue'r m ali e o b sn s fo n -a e a r p h w n ' tt l e e ' o lln s f u i e s r m f 2 01t rug 2 0 .GE/ M I o tnd t a t i c a tncud sundfe e tae 0 h o h 0 4 P c n e s h t h s h r i l e ifr n it d gosrv nu fo sriigav reyob a dso euime tn tmeeyMGE rs e e e rm evcn ait f r n f q p n , o rl e uime t a d t e eo e d e no rfet rv nue Rtrb tbl t t e q p n , n h rfr o s t elc e e s a tiu a e o h i fi g me t' n rn e n . ' Rolc l blyh sbe so n, 5 4b cetsa iiil rsmpin l n ei it a en h w j 0 ()rae n nta peu to ai t a t eifi g rsrft . . trb t bet t eifi g me ta ee ua t is h t h n rn e ' p ois . atiu a l o h n rn e n ' r q l o t 7 Ca e 0 -0 2 D c me t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 1 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 8 t i 0 /92 1 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 gos ee u .Bo nr . wsn 4 4F.d2 02 4(t Cr2 0)atrto rs rv n e' n e vDa o ,0 3 9 ,9 4h i.0 5 (leain ' ioiia)q oig1 U... 54 ).f metn isntab re ,o e e, n rgn l(u tn 7 SC j 01 )dn eigtii l udnh w v r l i acpy iht le mus s o mo et a t ei fi g rstt l r s rv nuefo o rg hod r t h w r h n h n rn e' oa g o s e e r m a lo isp oi sr a s l f t r ft te m . Ra h r Ir s r v n e r fr o l t r v nue t e ,g o s e e u ' ee s ny o e e rao a l rltdt teifigme t I.e p ae a dd;e as Da i, esn by eae o h nrn e n. d (m h ss d e)se lo vs ' 2 6F.d a 19 6 (n ig pofrd eie c o dfn a t ttlgos 4 3 t 5- 0 f dn rfee vdne f ee d n' oa rs i s rv nu s t o b o d t s p o t a c p rg t ifi g me t cam b s d o e e e o r a o u p r o y ih nrn e n li a e n dfn a t ueo pani scp rg tdeelse i a a cmp in; tt ee d n' s f litf oyihe ygassn n d a ag )Esae s f o F n ,8 9F.da 18 10(n igta < lmpsm fg r frpois f c c 4 2 t 8 , 9 f dn h td u -u iu e o rf i a t atiut bet t etlvso c mme cast a cnti e i fi g dma eila trb a l o h ee iin o ril h t o an d n rn e tra s awhoewih u a cun i gfrt ef c t a t eifi g dma eilcnsiu e l t o t co tn o h a t h t h nrn e tra o tt t d o l afa to o a y gv n c mme ca'wa t os eultv a cnneto t ny r cin f n ie o ril s o p c aie o cin o ' ssand ma e)T yo tMerc,1 F.d1 1,12(t Ci.9 3(n ig uti a gs; c lr) ii 72 2 1212 7h r18)f dn .k i isfiin frj5 4b p roe ta pani s o e dfn a t gos nuf et o 0 () up ss h t litf h w d ee dn' rs c f s rv nu sfo t es lso a l r d csi se do d mo sr tngg o sr v nue e e e r m h ae f lp o u t n t a f e n ta i r s e e s fo sl o teifign po ut) rm ae fh nrn ig rd cs. MGEsu h o e $ 0 miini d ma e b sdamotx lsv l o t e o g t v r 1 0 lo n a g s ae l s ecu iey n h l tsi o yo iso l d ma e e p r,Dr La r n ePr sot Dr Pr sots etm n f t ny a g s x e t . u a c e c t. . e c t' tsi oy rltd t t od mae moes ()MGESls pois a d () etm n eae o w a g d l: 1 ' ot rf ; n 2 t rc v rng a r a o a l r y ly Noa l,Dr Pr sot d d no tsiy t e o ei e s n be o at . t by . ec t i t e tf o GE/MI p oisatiu a l t t eifig me t Thedsrc cur c rid P ' rft trb tbe o h nrn e n . S itit o t a re GE/MI FeeaRue f iec 7 2a dDa brkbet n t DrP ect' P ' drl loEvdne 0 n u etojci so . rsot S o s t si o ya dp r it dhi t t siya til Afe he rn hi tsi o y,he e tm n n e m te m o etf t ra. tr a i g s e tm n t dsrc c ur c n l d dt a i s o l b src e i ise tr t ,d t r i i g itit o t o cu e h t t h u d e tik n n t n iey e e m n n t a Dr Pr sot cncu insr g r i g MGE' ls p oiswe eba e o h t . ec t' o l so e a dn s S o t r ft r s d n is fiin fcs n d t,nldn u s p otdas mpin rg r igMGE' n ufce tata d aaicu ig n u p re su to s e adn S ' uet. rel wP ams Ic,0 U..7,9 (93. Da bruMerlDo h r . n.59 S 5952 19) , 8 Ca e 0 -0 2 D c me t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 o u n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e g t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 ls ma k ts a ea dsr iep ii g Thedsrc c u tas fu dDrPr sot ot r e h r n evc rcn . itit o r lo o n . e c t ha n e p re c i a s si ghy oheia r a o a l r y lyr t sa dt a d o x e in e n s e sn p t tc l e s n b e o at ae n h t hspofrdh pteia rao a l rylyrt wa ntb sdo ojcie i rfee y oh tcl esn be oat ae s o ae n bet v a ay i. n lss Onc DrPrsotstsi o ywa src e , ofrdafna wines e . ect' etm n s tik n MGE fee i l t s, MGEg nea ma a e Miha l Bre , p ee tdtsi o yrltngo l e rl n g r c e O' in who rsn e etm n eai ny t MGE' ra o a l ry lyd ma e. O're wa n v rd sg ae a a o S e sn be o at a g s B in s e e ein td s n e p r o d m a ec lu ains Thedsrc c u t li a eyfu dhi tsi o y x e t n a g ac lto . itit o r utm tl o n s etm n isfcett p r i MGEt ofrajr isrcino rao al ry l nuf in o em t i o f uy n tuto n e sn be oat e y d ma e. a g sz M GE' o l r mannge ie c o d ma e wa DX-7 t eb rg a h S n y e ii vd n e f a g s s 3 , h a r p i dc tngPMIsttlr v nu fo 2 0 t r ug 2 0 .Tho g t i wasa n iai ' oa e e e r m 0 1 h o h 0 4 u h hs n e hbi p e a e b GE/M I t edsrc cur a mit dt ee hii d rngDr x i t rp r d y P ,h itit o t d te h x bt u i . P ect'r-iet x miain.MGEq eto e DrPrsoto l o telc rsot edrc e a n to s u sin d . ect ny n h ak o GE r v n er p e e t do DX- 7sg a h.Dr Pr sotwa n tq eto e f e e u e rsne n 3 ' rp . e c t s o u sin d a o twh t e t e tt lPMI rv n e i dc td o t e g a h r p e e td b u e h r h oa e e u n iae n h r p e r sn e rv nu rltdt PMlsifig me to MGE'cp rg t' e e e eae o ' nrn e n f S o yih . 2T pcl ,odmo srtrao alry l d mae, pani pee t eie c yial t e ntae esn be oat a gsa litf rsns vdne y y f a t d h th p ris udh v are t a afipiefrle sn tedfn a top t sod a te ate wo l ae ged o s ar rc o i n ig h ee d n t u w c teta esce t teuetedfn a titn e a t etmetemia porainto h rd ert o h s h eed n ne dd t h i h sp rpito ok pae'UnvCmpuigC.)L ksYugtwnC r.54F.d5859(t Cr17) lc. i. o t ot ye-onso op,0 2 1,3 5h i.94. ' n. Ho ee, B inwa ol a l t tsi a t terylya o nsta MGEwo l aka w vrO're s ny be o ety s o h oat m u t h t f ud s cmpttrop y o rvn ta cmpttrrm etrn te Ssrieid sr- ta i, o eio t a tp eeth t o ei fo neigh UP evc n uty h ts o sagrn l hg rylya o nsh t udpieo t o pttr.S c a o nsaent tg eigy ih oat m u t ta wol rc u cm eios uh m u t r o cg ia la aGe sn be oat' aclto a whc ab y r n sl r udaretb onzbe s rao alry ly cluain t ih u e a d el wo l ge o e ' e mak t au frap riua peeo sf ae Se c tlUS ,n. . soS:, 3 F r e v le o at lr ic f ot r. e Alae A Ic u Cic y .2 9 . c w S p.d 6,6 (..e.02 Crhs aueso e acltd ae o a esnbe u p2 6069ED Tx20) l imesritb cl ae bsd n raoal a u ry l t whc tepriswo l h v a re a tet eo tealg dmia porain oat o ih h ate ud a e ged t h i fh l e sp rpito . y m e Whl teC u trcgie ta smed ge o seuaini ih rn i cluaiga i h o r eonzs h t o ere f pclto s n ee t n acltn e sp oiiu le sn are e tb t en t o p ris ta h sn vr ocre,ti u p st s i nig gem n ew e w ate h t a ee curd hs oc h pteiacntut .mutcnansmedre ocriue'(mp aiadd) yoht losrc.. s oti o e e fet d. e hss del. c t' gah(X4, cmprsnoMGEUP eup etrsrvn e ess Ssr c p's rp D -2a o aio f S qim n goseeu vru UP ed e o s 3 h tilrn citn iae ta MGEma h v be tyn t rfr oadf rn T e rata srp idctsh t y a e en rig o ee t iee t f Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 Pa e l D t Fld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 g : o ae i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 GE/MIag e ta i wo l n th v icu e DX-7i ispo oe P r u s h t t ud o a e n ld d 3 n t r p sd e hiisha i k o nt a Dr Pr sot t si o ywo l b src e 4 e a s x bt d t n w h t . ec t' e tm n u d e tik n b c u e s iha n ie MGEwo l b se igGE/MISpoisrt e t a MGE'o n t d o da ud e e kn P ' rft ah r h n Sw ls p oisa dra o a l ry lis MGE cntnd t a s e igd fnd nts ot rf n e sn be o ate . t o e s h t e kn ee a ' p ois wa no a ne t e r o r c v r b c u e t e J i tPr tilOr e rft s t w h o y f e o ey e a s h on era d r idctsta isu h R oeayd mae p ru n t 1 U... 5 4'o n iae h tt og t m ntr a gs us a t o 7 SC j 0'fr cp rg tifi g me t Thi p o iin e c mp se altpe o da a e o y ih nrn e n . s r vso n o a s s l y s f m g s a albefrc p rg ti fi g me t i cu i g t ec p rg to n rsa t a v ia l o o y ih nrn e n ,n ldn h o y ih w e ' cu l d ma e ,hei fi g rsprft a tiu a l t t eifi g me ta dsautr a g s t n rn e' ois trb t be o h n rn e n , n t t oy d mae.Ho ee,nisFeea Rueo CiiP oeue2 ()dslsrs a gs w vri t drl l f vl rcd r 6a icoue, whe a k dt p o ied c mp t to o e c c tg r o d ma e came y n s e o rvd d o u a in f a h ae o y f a g s li d' a ' MGE idctd t a Dr Prsotstsi o y wo l cmp ie isd ma e n iae h t . ect' etm n ud o rs t a g s c lulto .Dr Pr soto l t siidt MGE' a t a d ma e : ac a in . e ct n y e tfe o S cu l a g s MGE' o n Sw ls p oisa dr a o a l r y lyr ts I ohe wo d , her c r i dc ts o t rft n e s n be o at ae . n t r r s t e o d n ia e t a MGEp a n dt r l e tr l o isa t a d ma e cam; PM Iha n ht ln e o ey n iey n t cu l a g s l i GE/ do rao t t ikt a MGE wa se igGE/MI poisatiua l t t e e sn o hn h t s e kn P ' rft trb tbe o h S i fi g me t no wa i p e a e t d fnda ans s c acam . n rn e n , r s t r p r d o ee g i t u h li RWle o eo teprmafceee et o acam i d mae a dte l h n n fh i ai lm ns f li s a gs n h cama t al t i to u ee ie c o t o ed ma e , o s ec mmisaft l li n fis o n r d c vd n e f h s a g s he r h o t a a err'P u ttAr. eg t asIc,6F.d6 96 2(t Cr19)MGES ro. r ny) kFrihw y,n.1 3 4 ,5 5h i.9 4. ' ' . d cso t se GE/ M ISp oiswa ce ryals- i ut atmp t s veis e iin o e k P ' r ft s la l a tm n e te t o a t cp rg tnfig me tli fo ds islo fiu et p o ed ma e.MGE o yih i rn e n cam rm im sa fr alr o rv a g s ha no s ce d d. pM l r s n e e i e c t a a p o i aey1 % o PMls s t u c e e GE/ p e e t d vd n e h t p r xm tl 0 f ' UPSsr ieb sn s cmefo MGE-rnd dmahie, ndMGE'sfwa e evc u ies a rm ba e c n sa S ot r rvn erm 19 truh20) hnirqetdt amiD -7 eeu f 97 hog 07w e t euse o d t X3. o 4 /MI l gst nyitn e tu e 3 t i p ahDrP ect'asrinta GEP al e iol ne dd o s DX-7om e c . rsot seto h t e s a MGESrvn e wetdwn GEP I rvn e wetu ;h ehbtso sP l ttl s ' eeu s n o , /M ' ee u s n p te x ii h w M ' oa S s rvn ermann rlt eycn tn fo 20 tru h2 0 . eeu e iig eai l o sa trm 0 1 ho g 0 4 v 1 0 Ca e 0 -0 21 Do u e t0 5 14 31 P g : 1 DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 1 t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 wa u a l o l wihMGEUPSmahie a dno wihcmp ttr'rd cs s sbe ny t c n s n t t o eiosp o u t. Thus PMls tt lr v nu fr e c e s t e a p o i a ey 1 % o r v nu , ' oa e e e a x e d h p r xm tl 0 f e e e r a o a l r ltdt t eifi g me to MGE' c p rg t MGE ne de t e s n by ea e o h nrn e n f S o y ih . e do p e e tamo ena r wl t io e c lulto o PMI p oisi o d rt c g ie rsn r ro y alr d ac ain f ' rft n r e o o n z s acam frc p rg td ma e f trb t bet t eifi g me t'Ac o dn l, li o o y ih a g s' tiu a l o h nrn e n . c r i gy a ' tedsrc cuterdi dn igGEP I Rue5()moino MGES h itit o r re n e yn /M ' l 0a to n ' S c p rg ti fi g me tcamsbe a s MGE ha no s o n d ma e und r o y ih n rn e n li c u e s t h w a gs e j5 4 ) 0* . B GEP Iag e tedsrc cuterdi dn igi Rue5 () to /M ru sh itit o r re n eyn t l 0a moin s rg r i g MGE' mia p o rain o ta e s c es a d un ar c mpeiin e a dn S s p r p ito f r d e r t n fi o tto camsb c us t ee ie c ddn ts p o td ma e frt e ecams Att e li e a e h vd n e i o u p r a g s o h s li . h co eo MGE'c s ,heo l e ie c i to uc dt s p o tt d ma e cams ls f S a e t ny vd n e n r d e o u p r is a g s li wa t eaoe e to e DX-7c a ts o i gPMI tt l e e ue e r e fo s h fr m n in d 3 h r h w n ' oarv n s an d rm s als ure o ic me GE/M Ic n e dst a wiho te ie c o PMI ne l o c s f n o . P o tn h t t u vd n e f ' t s p oise r e o t eMGE e uime ta is e MGE' saelw camss o l rft a n d n h q p n t su , S t t a li h u d h v b e ds isdo GE/MI Rue5() to . ae en im se n P ' l 0a moin S Th r i ltl p e e e tund r Te a lw t g ieusi d t r i i g e e s ite r c d n e x s a o ud n ee m nn whehe MGEha s sane t eb r e o p ofrq ie o apantfse ig tr s u ti d h u d n f ro e urd f li if ekn t r c v rad fnd n ' ne p ois I t eo l r potdTe a c s i v li g o e o e ee a ts t r ft. n h n y e re x s a e n ovn t er cv r o d fnd n 'p oisframia p o raino ta es cescam, h eo e y f ee a ts r ft o s p r p ito fr d er t li teDalsCo r oAp e lhedt a ato g dfnd n'p oisa eadrp r h la u t f p as l h t lh u h ee a ts rft r d o e p ee e t1 f a a e i acs ivligtewrn fl s o ataesce,a lm n l o d m gsn aen ovn h o gu ue f rd ert' ' pan ifc nn tr c v rd ma e wiho tofrnge ie c dos o t ea t a litf a o e o e a g s t u fe i vd n e< h w h cu l t poima eb (ee d nl'Elo C e . r.JAgi u,n .4 4SW.d rf d y dfn a t. cr h m Cop I r- lIc, 9 . 2 t ' .s 2 42 4(e . vAp . Dals17 , irf n...se loC roC rmis 0 ,1 T xCi. p- l 9 3wrte d re) eas a b ea c, a ; IcvKef, 6 F. px7 4 7 3(t Cr2 0)(n u l h d ( trrtn n. . ee 16 Ap ' 1, 2 5h i. 0 6 u p bi e)i epeig sn Te a lw t pemi apantf t de k d m a e me s r db t ed fnd n ' x s a o r t li if o f e a g s a u e y h ee a ts s Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : z DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e l t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 atapoisrsligfo teueo dslsr oteta esce'Ho so cu l rf eutn rm h s r icou e fh rd erf) u tn t ; Mecni Exh C r.tDal Perlu C r.90SW.d22 2 8(e. ra te c . op ) iy toe m op, 3 . 2 4, 4 T x l .e Ap . Ho so (4h Dit 19 ,n wrt (n ig ta,a a trsod p u tn 1t s. 9 6 o i) f dn h t s heh l ) i rq ie e tt rcv rngda a e frta esce a d u fi cmp tto eurm n o eo ei m g s o r d ert n nar o eiin cams< pani mut rd c eiec fo whc teuyma rao al li ,d litf spoue vdne rm ih h jr y e sn by a f ifr t a t e d ma e s e fr ha e r s le fo t e c n uc o t e ne h t h a g s u d o v e utd r m h o d t f h dfn a f . ee d n ) l t eisa tmatr MGE fcst es mepo lmss o igGcua n h n tn te, ae h a rbe h w n a t l p oisr s li gfo t eu eo d sls r o t eta es ce'a i ddo is r f e u tn r m h s r ico u e f h r d er t s t i n t t ' c p rg tcam .DX-7d mo sr t dPMIsttl ee u , td cua prft. o y ih li 3 e n tae ' oa rv n e no d t l ois' a ' MGE ha no pee tde ie c t a po ie a yme nso dsig ihig s t rsn e vd n e h t rvd s n a f itn us n rv n e PMI g ie fo oh r s ure fo r v n e g ie t r ug ee u an d r m t e o c s r m e e u an d h o h mia p o ra ino MGE'ta es ces ltao eac lu aino p oisfo s p rp ito f S r d er t,e ln ac lto f rft r m terlv n p rino rv nu .MGEatmpst dsig ihElo b ag i g h ee a t oto f e e e te t o itn us cr y r un t a DX-7 i Sr dbl e ie c o PMIsp ois'b tMGE n e e t t k h t 3 s ' e i e vd n e f ' r ft, u c ' edd o a e a dto a se st d d c u r ltdr v nuea dcssfo t e ett liur s d iin l t p o e u t n ea e e e n o t r m h s oa fg e i odrt d mo srt P I prftrltdt teifigme t MGEfie n re o e ntae M ' oi eae o h nrn e n. ss ald t d s. ooo Ho ee, ag e'h tcmme tft teRET TME T(HR ) F w vrMGE ru sta o n o h SA E N T ID O UN ARCO P TTO j4 (9 5 gv rsdma e u drTea lw,a d F I M EIIN 5 1 9) o en a gs n e x s a n c n e d t a i me isb r e u d rt i b r e -hitngfa e o k: o tn s h t t t t u d n n e h s u d n s fi r m w r Th ta iina fr o r siu ina y r le i a a to frt e e r dto l o m f e tt to r eif n n cin o h a p o raino ata es ce i a a c u tngo t ed fnd nts p r p ito f r d er t s n co n i f h ee a ' p oiso s lsatiut bet t eus o t eta es ce. . The rft n ae trb a l o h e f h r d er t . . pantf ha t eb r e o et bih n t ed fnd n ' s ls t e li if s h u d n f sa ls i g h ee a ts ae ; h d fnd n ha t eb r e o e tbls i ga yp rino t es ls ee a t s h u d n f sa ih n n oto f h ae n tatiut bet t eta es ce a da ye p ns st bed d ce o trb a l o h r d er t n n x e e o e u td i d tr i i gne p ois n ee m n n t r ft. M GE p it t PM1s ttlrv nue i DX-7 a d a g e t a ,un e t e on s o ' oa e e n 3 n r u s h t d r h Re tt me t t i e hii s tsisis'u d n o p o fwih r g r t PM1s sae n , h s x bt a ife t b r e f ro t e a d o ' 1 2 Ca e 0 -0 21 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : 3 DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e l t i 0 /92 1 e No 0 -05 1 . 81 2 Rae'o po iigsriet UPS mahie. MGE cntnd t a GE/MI sls f rvdn evc o ' c ns o e s ht P s b e ue tyha t eb r e o d mo sr tngwhc p rin o PMI r v n e u s q n l d h u d n f e n ta i ih oto s f ' e e u s we en tatiu a l t t esaelw cams whihi fie t d . r o trb t be o h tt a li , c t ald o o Tea cut h v n ta otdteRET T ME T(HR )O UNAR xs ors a e o dpe h SA E N T ID F F I CO PTTO i is nieya dwh te j 5s o me ticnrln iTea M EIIN n tetrt n eh r 4 'cm n fso tol gn x s i cursi sila o e q eto .Sc, ..I r Ba s 1 3S. .d7 5 7 9 4 o t s tl n p n u sin c eg,n e s, 1 W 3 3 , 3 - 0 (e . 0 3 ( l wigteoiia RET TME TO TO T' eiiino a d T x 2 0)f l n h rgn l SA E N F R Sdfnto f n oo fco sus d t ie tf ta es ce s d s ie t i scinssihtatr to a tr e o d n iy r d e rt , e pt h s e to ' lg le ain teefnte SA E E T(HR ) F N ARC MP TTO S;er ige,n. hroi h RETT M N T ID O U FI O EIIN)La SelrIc tPcc,1 SW.d4 04 17 (e.9 1 (dpiga Nntu t e prin 7 rz8 9 . 2 7 ,7- 2T x 19) a otn n srci ' ot . v o o teRETT ME T(E O D O T R Sb tn tn ta teTea S pe e f h SA E N S C N ) F O T u oig h t h x s u rm Co r h snta otdteRET T ME Ti ise trt) T eb re -hfig ut a o dpe h SA E N n t niey. h udnsi n t p o e u e n t di cmme tfa eno i cud di t efrtRE T T ME TOF r c d r s o e n o n r t n l e n h is S A E N TOR Swho ed fniino a dfco s e t ie tf ta esce sa esi us d T , s ei to f n a tr us d o d n iy r d e rt r tl e l b Te a c u t. Se I r Ba s 1 3S. .d a 7 9 4 . Net e t eTe a y x s o rs e n e s, 1 W 3 t 3 - 0 ih r h x s Su rmeCo r n ra yo t eTe a a p laecursha eseiial a pid pe u t o n f h x s p elt o t v p cfcly p le cmme t t d tr iead fnd n'p oisi ata esce ato . v nt a o n fo eem n ee a ts rft n r d ert cin Gie h t c mme t ssa d r st apan if bu d no p o f o ta es ce d ma e o n f tn a d es litfs r e f r o fr r d er t a g s lwe t a tesa d r a pidi Elo , cn ld ta t eTe a S pe e o r h n h tn ad p l n crwe o cu e h t h x s u rm e Co r wo l n ta o tt eb r e -hitn p o e ur so c mme tf u t ud o d p h u d n s fig r c d e f o n . Acodngy,hedsrc cu terdi d ciigt ga tGE/MI Rul cri l t itit o r re n elnn o r n P ' e S 5 () to o MGES sp rpito ota esces n u ficmptto 0a moin n 'mia po rain frd erta d naro ei n i cam s li . I V RETTME T F OT adwatnaieysae frnlso ite ETTMET(EO o SA E N O T RS n sett l ltdoicuinnh R SAE N S cN ) v O ToT,snwadesdi teR SAE E T(HR ) :UNARC MPTTO . F Rsi o drse n h ETTM N T IDon FI O EIIN 5T ecneto u fi cmptt n whc wa oiial icu e i tef s h ocp f nar o eii , ih s rgn l nld d n h i t o y r Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 14 3 1 Pa e 1 DaeFld 0 /92 1 s : 815 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 g :4 t i : 92 /0 0 e No 0 -0 2 . 81 5 1 GEP Io tn sh dsrccut re i dn igis l5 () to /M cne d te itit o rerd n eyn tRue 0b moin a tecoeo t ec s b cus t eewa lg lyis fiint vd nc t s p ot th ls fh ae ea e h r se al n ufce e ie e o u p r tejr' $ . miin d maea ad i dn igisrq ett apyte h uys 46 lo a g w r ;n e yn t eu s o p l h l OnesaifcinRul t MGE' rcv r und rTe a lw;a di cncudng - tsato e o S eo ey e x s a n n o l i t a d ma e fo at oc rigb fr Dee be 1 , 0 1weeno b re b h t a gs rm cs cu rn eoe cm r 72 0 r t ard y t etrey a saut o lmiainsund rb t t eCo yih Ac a dTe a h h e -e r tt e fi tto e oh h p rg t t n x s lw. Ad iinal,MGE c ntnd t edsrc cur a us d isdsr to b a dto ly o e s h itit o t b e t ic ein y dn igMGE'rq etfrpeu g e titrs o d mae.Bea s te eyn S eu s o rjd m n neet n a gs cu e h dsrc cuterdi ds isn GEP I Rue5()moina tecoeo itit or re n im sig /M ' l 0a to t h ls f S M GE' c s b c us MGE h s fie t p o e is d m a e cams t e e S a e ea e a ald o r v t a g s li , h s a g m e t a emo t ru ns r o. V GEP Ia p astedsrc cut ga to apr a etijnt n /M p el h itit or' rn f em n n nu ci s o a ans GE/MISus o MGE' sfwaea dta esces Werve te gi t P ' e f S ot r n r d ert. eiw h dna o ga to a pr a e tijnt n fr a a u e o dsrto . eil r rn f em n n nu ci o n b s f icein o Sc lts y' Lt .JStrigPu c asn & Nat Diti. .5 0F.d3 3 4 2 hoz k s d I e ln rh ig , . ' srb Co, 2 3 9 , 0 l (t Cr2 0) 5h i. 0 8. S cin 5 2o teCo yih Ac a toie t ecutt g a tGfna eto 0 f h p rg t t u h rzs h o r o rn d l i ijnto so sc tr sa i ma de rao al t peeto rsri nu cin n uh em s t y em esn be o rvn r etan ifig me to ac p rg t' AlatlUS , n .t DGIT c s, n . 1 6F.d nrn e n f o y ih .' c e A I c 7 ' . eh .I c, 6 3 7 27 0(t Cr19 )q oig1 U... 5 2a) GEP I otn sta i 7 ,9 5h i. 99 (u tn 7 SC j 0 (). /M cned h tn 2 0 it r e o e t eo l i fi gn a tce alp o t a ha no b e us d 0 5 t u n d v r h ny n rn i g ril, a tp h t d t e n e snc 2 0 ,a d t a t e o l d t ds fund wa i a fr e e p o e ' i e 0 2 n h t h ny a a ik o s n o m r m ly es p s e so whoa mitdt k e i gi frh so nr fr n eatrhelf t e o s sin d te o e pn t o i w ee e c fe et h cmp n . Ho e e,GE/MIa mitdt f eisa cso drc cpyiht o a y w v r P d te o i n tn e f iet o rg v ifig me ta dMGEp ee tdnu eo sisa cso GE/MISifigng nrn e n , n rsne m ru n tn e f P ' nrn i atvt a tilicu igsmeu e o MGE sfwaet a ocre atrt e ciiy t ra,n ldn o ss f ot r h t cu rd fe h dsrc cute trdispei iayijnto a di p u d e todri itit or nee t rl n r nu cin n m on m n re n m 1 4 Ca e 0 -0 2 Do u e t0 5 1 4 3 1 P g : 5 DaeFld: 92 /0 0 s : 81 5 1 c m n: 0 1 2 8 1 a e 1 t i 0 /92 1 e No 0 -0 21 . 81 5 Au us 2 05 Ad iinal,help o so t otil t e s swhoa mit dt g t 0 . dto l t a tp f w ra win se y d te o usngMGEsfwa ea dta escesrs etv l, r n ve rcv rd,nd i ot r n r d ert,ep ciey wee e r eo ee a GE/MIfie t ofrcncusv eie c t acu to teelpo sa snc. P ald o fe o l ie vd n e o co n fr h s a tp 'b e e Gie t a t eema b ifigngmaeilsilnGE/MISp seso , v n h th r y enrn i tras tli P ' ossin a dgve GE/MISfiur t cnom t tecnsrit o tepei iay n i n P ' al e o o fr o h o tans f h rlm n r ijnto ,h dsrccut in tb sis iceini ga tn apr a e t nu cinte ititordd oa uetdsrto n rnig em nn ijnto aantGE/MI ftr ueoMGE'sfwaea dta esces nu cin gis P ' uue s f S ot r n rd ert. S VI Acodngy,hep eiu o iini ti c s i WI HDRAWN.Fo t e cr i l t rvo s pno n hs a e s T rh frgigrao swe FRM tedsrccut ga tf P I Rue5 () oeon esn , AF I h itit or' rn oGE/M ' l 0a s S moinds isn MGE'DMCA cam.Weas AFFI M t edsrc cu ts to im sig S li lo R h itit o r' gato apr a e tijnto aantGEP I u eo MGESsfwaea d rn f em nn nu cin gis /M ' s f ' ot r n S ta esces WeRE E S tedsrccut dna o GE/MI Rue5() rd ert. V R E h itit or' e il f P ' l 0a s S moin o MGE' cp rg t ifig me t u fi cmp tto , a d to n S o yih nrn e n , nar o eiin n mia p o raino ta escescamsfrMGE' fiur t p o eda a e s p rpito f r d ert li o S al e o rv m g s u dr1 U... 5 4ba dT x sa ,n RENDE atk -ohn jd me t n e 7 SC j 0 () n ea lw a d R a entigu g n frMGE. o

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?