USA v. State of Arizona, et al

Filing 136

Filed Amici Curiae - Pending Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary and The Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights motion to become amicus curiae. Served on 09/30/2010. [7500735] (FT)

R otyc.wyRCLR6 E c E Iv e M z D E. E K
tsCUT F/EL J.ORO APAS .

0 T2121 C 1 22

No1-64 .0165
F R THE M NTH CI CUI O RT
,. ,- - --

jjo ju jy

DT AE

- IIA NI TL
I

I T EI TE S AT:SCOU TOFXP E L NH N DT R PA S
=.... , ,= -s- , tx. S =T-TEFOFX M .R1 Aa=- =s-,,== = -- = - s =, - - y - S A S C E U --o . ,- .- = . TF )D . A. u= - . Plit f Ap ele ani - p l , f e
V.

.a , u-

Dee d ùkAp elns fn a t- p t t. a
.'

S ATE.OF ARI ONA T Z '

DI TRI T COURT FOR DI TRI T OFARI ONA SC SC Z

ONXP E UROM T EUMT DS ATE PM F H ET S

THECOALI I NTO DEFEND AF I MATI EACTI N TO FR V O G TEGM TI N,MMI RANTRI HTSANDFGHTFOREQUALI Y OI G G, I T BYA YME NSNEC S MW (AMNINS P ORTOFXF I MANCE NA ES B I UP FR
RONALD CRUZ GEORGEWAS I GTON HN
USA v. State of Arizona, et al Doc. 136

MOTI NF RLE VET FLEAB IFAMIUSC TI EB O O A O I R E C IR A Y

Aton v frAmiu tr es o c s

S T D WE G AR R

S TE FWASHNG ON &DRIE ,.. CTF , I T V R PC 65Grs od S i 11 4 iw l,ut 87 e
Der i Mi 82 tot 4 2 6 ,

(1) 6-91 339312

Dockets.Justia.com

P run t Rue2 o teF d rl lso CiiP o e ue teCo l int us a to l 9 fh e ea Rue f vl r cd r,h ai o o t Dee dAfi aieAcin ltgain a dl mirn Rihsa dFih fr fn fr t t ,ne rt , n m ga t g t n g t o my o o

E ulyByAn Men Neesr IAMNI vso laetfeh atce q ai t y as csayB moe frev o i te t hd la
Amiu CuieBre i sp o t fh Ap eleUntdSae a dafr igte c s ra ifn u p ro te p l i tts n fi n h ee m

dsi cuthtst ce a E ùbt B . .itrse itic.trtortaiat hd s kiiX. -t neetdnhs a. tc a s. . s' e
b cu eiian t n l ra iainfr e i 1 9 t fg t g is atc s nte e a s ts ai a og nz t om d n 9 5 o ih a an t t k o h o o a
i mirn cmmu ie o tiNain m ga t o nt s fhs t . i o BAM N wa iial fr e t o p s ted cso b teUnv ri o snt l om d o p oe h eiin y h iest f iy y

cai riReet'eiintbnafmaieato iteUCsse . tona gnsdcso o a fi t cin nh ytm B f rv
sc rdterv ra o teRe et' a i 2 0 ,e tepoaf maieat n eue h e esl fh g ns b n n 0 1 1d h r-fi t -ci rv o itnr t nb su e t i Gr t rvBol g ra dog nzdten t n l ne e i y tdnsn ut . ln e ,n ra ie h ai a no e i o mo e e th t umiae i a5 ,0 -esnMac o Wahn tno ted y v m n ta c l n td n 00 0p ro rh n sigo n h a Gr t rwa ag e i teS pe eCo r. ut s ru d n h u rm u t e BAM N h sfldlg l h l n e t Mihg nsPo oa 2p n igi te a i e a c al g so c ia ' rp sl e dn n h e e

SxhCi ut n t Caionas rp st n2 9p n igi teUntdSae it r ia d o l ri'P o oio 0 e dn n h i tts c f i e
Ditit u to teNo tenDirc o Caio i.I1dtef h t k e Wad sr Co r frh r r s it f l m a te h i to ep r c h t f g

Co n rysa t afr aieato p tinofh Arz n b l tn2 0 . n el' ni fim t cin eio fte io a al i 0 8 v t o BAM N h ssc esul ldtesu e t lo t tru h u teSaeo a u csfl e h td n wak us ho g o th tt f y
Cai mi ta 1dt teata o sra c o Cea Ch v zdya ah l a i te lo a h te o h cu l b evn e f sr a e a s oi y n h f d

p bi sh os1dasae iecmp int sc r apo a o teCai mi u l c o l,e ttw d a ag o e ue p rv l fh lo a c f

Dra Ac,e acmp int ma eUnv ri o Caionaa Bek lya dLo e m t1d a ag o k iest f l ri t ree n s y f M g lssn taycmp ssb e p r o mac e a dcmp in frdie' ee a cu r a u e, e n at f rh s n a ag s o rv rs l e ssfr n o u etdrsd nsa dmac e a dcmp in a ant oie i n e o u d c m ne eiet,n rh s n a ag s g isp l c c b uai a an t t oa baka doh rct e sa drsd ns rtly g isLai /, lc n te iz n n eie t. t n i

BAMXiantnlraiatniptgrcs atteatc o s at aognzt thi at nth t k n o o gn m a
i mirn rg t Ise sla et fetiAmiu b ifnsp ot fh Ap ele m ga t ihs t ek ev o i hs c s re i u p r o te p l l e
UntdSae a di sp ot fh u d c me tda doh rL t oarsd nsa d i tts n n u p r o te n o u ne n te ai / eie t n e n

ct e so Ar o awh wi b vci ie b S n t Bi 1 4 i ii e e alwe izn f i n o l e it zd y e ae l 0 0 fts v r l d i z l m l o
t g it efc. o o no fet BAMN asrsta ih s d ag me t i tepo o e a iu bifh t set h tt a ma e ru nsn h rp sd m c s re ta

tea p l eh sn t d . h p el a o ma e e
ByteAmiu BAMN' atme s h cs s t y, o S I F , II GTON & DI VER, C V F WAS-N I U PC

B : RoadCu (af iSaeB o y nl rzC l a tt i . Ge reB. sigo l ia Ba No og Wahn tn c g n r . S atDr e ( i ia BaNo hna i rM c gn r . v h
6 5Grs od-ut 1 1 4 i l-s i 8 7 w e Deri, 4 2 6 totM1 8 2 31 -6 -9 1 39 3 1 2

Dae : e tmb r3 , 01 td S pe e 0 2 0

No 1 -6 4 . 01 6 5
I

I THE UNI ED S ATESCOURTOFAPP ALS N TT E FOR THENI TH CI CUI N RT

UM TEPSTATVSOFAMYFWA,
Plitf-Ap ele an if p le ,
V.

S ATE OFARI ONA T Z Dee da t- pp la t. fn nsA elns ON APPEAL FROM THE UNI ED S ATES TT DI TRI T COURTFOR DI TRI T OFARI ONA SC SC Z

BRI FFOR THE AMI US E C COALI I N TO DEF ND AF I M ATI E ACTI N,NTEGM TI N, TO E FR V OI O

I MI M NTRI HTSANDFI HTFOREQUALI YBYANYMEANS MG G, G T NE E S RY(AMN)NS P ORTOFAF I MANCE C SA B I UP FR
RONALD CRUZ GEORGEWAS I GTON HN S ANTADRI ER H V Ato nv fr c s tr e s o Amiu

S HEF , HI GTON, DRI ER, C. C F WAS N & V P. 6 5Grs od S i 1 1 4 iw l, ut 8 7 e Deri, 42 6 totMi 82

(1)6-91 339312

TABLE OFCONTENTS 6 1 1 ( 1 4 ) l @*@*****@@@*@@@**@**@****@*2 j *@@@@@*@@@@@*@*@*@@@*@**** i @@@@*@*@**** *@@@@@*****@@@1 i ; l L 1 1 6@***@@@@@@*********@*@@@****1 1******@*********@***********j @***@@*@@@@****@**@* * *@*** *

((ILI VI 1lI?LTS) FrJVIIIIhI.................... TEi!E II 2é(I(I r ;TkT SIIr ........... ....... /I / T p hI IIIII IM. ...... . .........

S ATEM ENT OFF CTS T A 1 Bai fcsa o th u d c metdi mirnsag tdb S 1 7 .... . sc at b u te n o u ne m gat tree y B 0 0 ...3 ... l.l1 e e t lEll t teElllr( FB1)(................ 1 - e v nsetlé t l ttn- l) ; (r ................ l trj l l tlt) f I C)...............6 t
ARGUM ENT SB 1 7 I AN UNLAWFILASS RTI N OFC TATES' 00 S J EO G S RI HTS'N AN AREA Ar FOR A P RPOS TIAT G 'I U EJ VI LATESTl CONS I UTI N OFTlEUM TED S ATES.....1 O W TT O l T .... 1 .... A. 1 7 a awh l i a u lwfl seto o an ne itn SB 0 0 s oe s n na u asrin f o -xset ' (tt,rg,,opo ug t 1 o n1 1rt nP l y & aes 'j,t rm jae t w * - ai O1 s 1j t s mm g 0 C b cu esaeofcasaedsaif dwi fd rlmmirt n e a s tt flil r ist l t e ea l gai se h ' o

B. B 1 7 ' d cae p l yo dtio tru he fre e t i S 0 0s elrd oi fût t n ho g noc m n' s c ari ' utryic n itn wi teg v rigfd rl oiy........l t l n o sse t t h o enn e ea p l ........ 6 e h c .......
C Th dsrc cu t o el fu dta fv o S 1 7 ' seii e itit o rprp ry o n ht le f B 0 0s p cfc p o ''n aeu'rylcn itn wi teg v rigfd rl rvso s r t l ' o sset t h o enn e ea ll tn e h PO 1. B 1 7 VI L TEST I F URT E T AME DMENTBY 1S 0 0 O A FE O E N H N LEGALI I G RACI LDI CRI I ATI N Ar CREATI G ZN A S MN O N CONDI I NSF R LATI A/ SI ARI ONA SM I AR TO TO O NON Z IL CONDI I NSF R BLACK P OP EI T- OL JM CROW TO O E L N IE D 1 1

S ATEM ENT OFI TERES T N T Th Co lint Dee dAfr aieAcin ltgain a dl mirn e aio o fn f m t t ,ne rto ,n m ga t t iv o

Rihsn Fgto E ulyB An Men Neesr IAMNIsneetdi gtad ih fr qai y y as csay B t iitrse n
ti cs b c ueii an t n l ra iainfr e i 1 9 t fg t g is hs ae e a s ts ai a og nzt om d n 9 5 o ih a an t o o

rèjfièu i:atc so t:imitt cmmt ie o tiNain àir fldù t k n h m gàl o m t s fhs t . ll a t i o
BAM N wa iial fr e t o p s ted cso b teUnvri o snt l om d o p o e h e iin y h iest f iy y CaionaRe e t' e iint b naf n t eat ni teUC sse . l ri g nsd cso o a fi ai ci n h f nv o ytm B

sc rdterv ra o teRe e t' a i 2 0 ,e tep oat maiea t n e ue h e esl fh g ns b n n 0 1 1d h r-fr t -ci ivo
itre to b su e t i Grte v Bol ge,n ognie ten to a nevnin y td nsn utr . li ra d ra z n aln

mo e e th t umiae i a5 ,0 -esnMac o Wahn tno ted y v m n ta c l n td n 00 0p ro rh n s igo n h a Gr t rwa ag e i teS pe eCo r. ut s ru d n h u rm u t e BAMN h s i dlg l h l n e t Mihg ns rp sl p n igi te a fl e a c al g s o c ia 'P o o a 2 e dn n h e e SxhCic ia dt Caio i' Po o io 2 9p n igi teUntdSae it rut n o l m as rp st n 0 e dn n h i tts f i e Ditit uto teNote Ditit f lo i.I 1dtet h t k e Wad src Co rfrh rh m src o Cai m a te h i to ep r f g Co n r ' a t afmaieato p tinofh Ar o ab l tn2 0 . n el s ni fi t cin eio f te i n al i 0 8 y -r v t z o BAMN h s u c sfl 1dtesu e t lo tt o g o th Saeo a s cesul e h td n wak usl u h u te tt f y u Caio i ta ldt teata o sra c o Cea Ch v zd ya ah l a i te l m a h te o h cu l b ev n e f sr a e a s oi y n h f d

p bi sh os ldasae iecmp int sc r a po a o teCai ri u l c o l,e ttw d a ag o eue p rv l fh lona c f Dra Ac,e acmp int ma eUnv ri o Caionaa Bek lya dL s e m t1d a ag o k iest f l ri t ree n o y f An ee sn taycmp ssb e p ro mac e a dcmp in fr rv rs g ls a cu r a u e, en at f rh s n a ag s o die'

l e ssfru d c me tdrsd nsa dmac e a dcmp in a ant oie i n e o n o u ne eie t, n rh s n a ag s g isp l c c b l lya an t t oa baka doh r iz n a drsd ns nt i g isLai /, lc n te ct e s n eie t. at n i BAMN i an t n l ra iainf higrcs a dteatc o s ai a og nzto g t a im n h t k n o n a
i mirn rg t.Ise sla et fetiAmiu bifnsp ot fh Ap ele m ga tihs t e k ev o i hs c s re i u p ro te p l l e

Untdjaeadi spotfl ud cmetbadohr aloaeietai ttsn n upro te nou ne n iett /rsdns n e t n 2
ct e so Ar o awh wi b vci ie b S n t Bi 1 7 iii e e alwe izn f i n o l e it z d y e ae l 0 0 fts v r l d i z l m l o
t g it efc. o o no fet

BAMN asrsta ih sma eag me t i tepo o e a iu bifh t set h tt a d ru ns n h rp sd m c s re ta teap l eh sn t d . h p el a o ma e e

I DEX OFAUTHOW TI S N E
Cae ss

C iaop raC ua 58F3 .5 (tcr2 0)cr gat4 hcns o l as,5 .d86 9 i 09,c/ rne h. . 10SC.48(00 3 . t39 2 1) DeC ns . ia44U..5 (96 aa vBc,2 S3 1 17) 1 5 I r r L ej F 4 idrut uqD. ai rt 18) n e / e,6 .7 (t iCor C lbna 86 o c t 12,3 ,2 Pye vDo,5 U..0 (92 llr . e47 S22 18) 1 ,3 52 Yc FbvHokn, 1 U..5 (86 i k . p is18 S 36 18)
Ote a torte h r u h iis Co s, r 1 sc8 c 34 ntat , e , l Co s, r2,e 2 ntat sc 1 -2 11
1 2

8 SC. 15() U.. j 37g
S. . 0 0 B 17

71 ,2
pasm si

CORP RATE DI CLOS RE S ATEM ENT O S UT P ru n t teF d rl ls f p l t P o e ue c u slo tea iu usa to h e ea Rue o Ap el e rcd r,o n e frh m c s a

Co lint Dee dAfimaieAcin ltgaina dl mirn Rihsa dt aio o fn f tv t ,ne rt n m gat g t n o t r o o

FgtoE ulyb An Men Neesr (AMN)etisht opr t ti ih fr qai y y as csayB t crf tan at ohs ie y apaiasbii' ö éGit o agbiluwndcpoainadn pbiy /élj uédày r fl e f u l yo e o rto n o u l t a c d
o n dc roainta in t p r t ti a p a h s t a ca itrsi te w e op rto h ts o a at o hs p e l a a i n ilneetn h y n o to e Th a iu i aMihg nn n oic roain uc m . e m c s s c ia o - f op rto . t
Ro a r n u Aton yfr c s tre o Amiu BAMN

Dae S pe b r 0 2 1 . t: etm e 3 , 0 0

I TRODUCTI N N O

l Pllrv Do ,h Untd Sae S pe eCo r h l ta teF ute t n ye . e te i tts u rm u t ed h t h o renh e Ame d e tpo ii d Te a fo e cu ig te c i rn o u d c mètd n m n rhbt x s rm x ldn h hl e f n o u ne e d

i mirnsfo isp bi sh os T eCo r wan da an t raigalh d w m ga t rm t u l c o l. h u t re g is cet û a o c ns

P P lt n'atemaetcseo u d cmetdrsdn ain..dne te o uai , t r nn at f n ou ne eiet l s. e id o' P e h
b n f sh to rsceyma e a albet ct e sa dlwfl eie t. Pllrv e ei ta u o it k s v i l o izn n a t rsd ns' ye . t a i l '

Do,47US22 281 (92.tdcae ta,ç dn igteecirna e5 0, 1-9 18)I elrd htçy eyn hs hl e b d
b sce u ain wed n te tea it t l ewi i tes utr o o rcvc ai d cto , e y h m h bly o i t n h t cue f u ii ivh r isi to s a dfrco ea yrait p siit ta te wi cnrb t i e e ntuin , n oels n e l i osbly h th y l o tiue n v n t sc i l tes alswa t tepo rs o o r to .1 . t 2 . h m l t y o h rges f u Nain' d a 2 3 e ' I te 2 y as sn e te ln mak d cso i Pllr te miin o n h 8 er ic h a d r eiin n ye, h lo s f l c i rn wh mih h v b e e cu e fo sh osi Te a h d n tb e hl e o g t a e en x ld d rm c o l f x s a o en d rsrie h v ma ee omo sc nrb t n t tepo rs o teNain l ter etan d a e d n r u o tiui s o h rges fh t .n h i o o

oewhl igmaoi ,hy te cirn adtercirnscirnhv vr emn jry te,hi hl e n hi hl e' hl e ae t rd d d
b cmep o u t ect e s e o rd ci iz n . vi T e aep l o temiin wh b g nteGra Mirto fo Me io h y r a f h lo s o e a h et gain rm xc 4 l a dCe ta Ameiaah n rdy asa o wh cmet a dtru hTe a, w n nrl rc u de er g , o a o n lo g x s Ne t M e io Arz n a d Caio i.T ee i mirnslc e tep p r gv n t xc , io a n l m a h s p ga t ak d h a es ie o f toe pe o ia t - uo en i mirnswh cmetru h pa e l e Els h s rd m n nl E rp a m gat o a ho g lc s i l y ki

lln . to mu ho ta cnuy p p r ween t e d db c uetesuh r sa d Bu fr c fh t e tr, a es r o n e e e a s h o ten b re wa n t c moeta al eo ama . odr s o mu h r h n i n p n Eseil i p ro so eo o i dsrs,l eto ei Pllra d to e p cal n eid f c n m c ites i h s n ye n h s y k td y te a sn e o p p r cetd sv r h rsis frmay Me ia a d o a , h b e c f a es rae e ee adhp o n xcn n

c nrl r a imtrnsB tt i nttpte io cmig f m rtn et Xmei n m gat. u idd o s im m o n ,r as g a c ot oi
terc i rnh r, n fo e etal b c migp r o teAmeia n t n o h i hl e ee a d rm v nu l eo n at fh d y rcn ai , f o whc mayb cmelg l izn . ih n e a e a ct e s i Arzn ' S 17 po li sardcl dfee t oiy Aset gab rl io as B 0 0 rcam a ial ifrn p l . sri aey y c n c n eldsp o e saerg t opo li i o ni mirt np l y S cin 1 o c ae u p sd tt ih t rcam t w m gai oi , eto s oc o S 1 7 d cae ta Arz n wi fl w a p lc o lt io tru h f B 0 0 elrs h t io a l ol lo oiy f l tt n h o g a ri e fre e t' B 1 7 h scetdargmeo itno ain , tp , ret, n nocm n. S 0 0 a rae e i f ne -g t s so s arss a d ' o i pio me t h tamsn tsmpya rifrigap r a e tc sewi sc n m rsn n ta i o i l t enocn em n n at t e o d h cas rg t,b tta e piiy ams a frig a h l miin u d c me td ls ihs u h t x l t i t ocn cl af lo n o u ne l M e ia i mirnsa dterc i rnt la eArz n rte ta fc tewrt xcn m ga t n h i hl e o ev io a ah rh n ae h ah d
o islws ft a .

l S 1 7 wee e atd i o e sae ao e i wo l b o e omo s f B 0 0 r n ce n n tt ln , t ud e f n r u i p ra c. t n sae aetrae igt fl w Ar ö a T ei p ra c o m otn e Bu ma y tts r hetnn o ol i n . h m o tn e f oz ti cs h sh rfr go ne p n nil . hs ae a teeoe rw x o e tal y T edsrc c u t n teUntdSae h v d mo srtdta f es ei c h itit o r a d h i tts a e e ntae h ti p cf e v i po iin o S 1 7 aeu lwfl e a s tesaeh sn a toi t d ce i rvso s f B 0 0 r na u b cu e h tt a o uh rt o ere t y s
2

o n i mirt n p l is Bu S 1 7 i atal fr wos a d fr moe w m gai oi e . t B 0 0 s cu l a re n a r o c y u lwflh nteUntdSae h salg d BAMN st fr b lw wh ti 1w na u ta h i tts a l e . e e es ot eo y hs a h i e e wos ta teg v rmetsy i i. hsCo r so l b s isd cso s v n re h n h o en n a s t s T i ut h ud ae t eiin

uhligadepn igteijnt no tesudsp sil lgl rud s podn n xadn h nuci n h onet os e eagon s o o b

tan pro o Ameta stwi eeaa hv tfc tedaoinrgme hto esn n r n ol l vr gt aeo aeh rcna ei c l n
a du lwfl u o eta aee b de i Arz n ' n w lw. n na u p m s h t r m o id n io as e a

S ATEM ENTOFF CTS T A
1 Bai fcs b u teu d cmetdi mirnsag tdb S 1 7 . . sc at a o th n ou ne m ga t tree y B 0 0 W eb gnwi asae e t o o tefcsrg rigteapiaino ti e i t ttm n n t f h at e adn h p l t fhs h co lw, e a s to eh v n ty th p e e , u o tec mmo l-ce td fcs a b cu e h s a e o e ap n d b t f h o nyacpe at a o t u d c me td i mirns a o t Arz n , a d a o tte hsoy a d b u n o u ne m ga t, b u io a n b u h itr n
epesdp ro eofS 1 7 . x rse up s B 0 0

By te b s et ae a albe tee ae a o t ee e miin h et si ts v i l, h r r b u lv n lo m a l u d cmetdrsd nsi teUntdSae,n ldn 15miinc i rnu d r n o u ne eie t n h i tts icu ig . lo hl e n e e l d 1 . tin mb rmu t ea d da oh rfu mil nc i rnwh aeAmeia 8 To hs u e sb d e n te o r lo hl e o r rc n id ct e sb cu e te weeb r t teeu d c me td i mirnswhl te izn e a s h y r on o h s n o u ne m ga t i h y i e rsd d i teUntd Sae.Ap rxmaey 5 p re to teeu d c me td eie n h i tts po i tl 0 ecn f h s n o u ne e wokr h v b e i teUntd Sae frtny as a po i aey 1 p re t res a e en n h i tts o e er; p rxm tl 0 ecn e h v b e h r frmoeta 2 y as Nieyp reto tet d c me tdme a e en ee o r h n 0 e r. n t ecn fh m o u ne n
3

a d7 p reto u d c me tdwo e at eyp riiaei teUSlb rfre n 0 ecn f n ou ne m n ci l at p t n h v c a o oc .
l ten to a awh l, b u 6 p re t f n o u e tdi mirnsc mefo n h ain s oe a o t 0 ecn o u d c m ne m ga t o rm M e io. xc 1

Arz n ' p p lt n whc i et ae t b a o tah l miin dfes io as o uai , ih s si td o e b u af lo , ifr o m l
sme h tfo ten t n la ea e Ab u nn t p re tc mefo Me io a o w a rm h ai a v rg . o t iey ecn o rm xc ; o lr e b tu k o n sae o te rmann tn p ret cme fo Ce ta ag , u n n w , h r f h e iig e ecn o s rm nrl Ameia T ep retg o c i rn a o gteu d c me tdrs e t i as rc . h ecna e f hl e m n h n o u ne ei ns s lo d d hg e ta ten t n l v rg ,h teeaepo ot n tl moemio c i rn ih rh n h ai a a ea e a d h r r rp ri aey r n r hl e o o d ta i ten to a awh l wh aeAmeia ct e sb vru o b igb r i h n n h ain s oe o r rcn izn y ite f en on n i ti c u ty.2 hs o nr l rcn d c d s A io ah sb e o e o te n to ' fsetgo ig n ee t ea e, lz n a en n f h ain s ats-rw n sae,b t dmo rp ial a d e o o ial.Bewen 1 8 a d 2 0 ,i tts oh e ga hc l n c n m cl t e 9 0 n 0 8 t y y s p p lt nmoeta d u ldfo 27miint 65miin go ig fo te o uai r h n o be rm . lo o . lo , rw n rm h o l l 2 t1rett tel tlretsaei teUno . l ti sa , io asLaiao 9h ag s o h 4h ag s tt n h in n hs p n Arz n ' t / n

pp linmoeta qarpe f m nal 4 1 0 (6prett amot2 ouao r hn uduld r er 4 , 0 1 ecn) o l s t o y0
1JfryS.Pasl n D' eaCo n t P rrio Un uh rz dl mirnsi efe se a d V r h ,t otat f a toie m g a t n A teUntdSae,Pe Hip ncCe trApi1 , 0 9 a i, , v i bea h i tts' w s a i ne, rl 4 2 0 ,ti4 a al l t e ' a

h p/ e hsai.grpl/ pdppRep l=l7(eef rtoti' l :pw i nco / o seo .h ? pdD o hrat ,t raf) / p re r epr ; h p/ e hsai.r/ pd/ pdppR plD=l6(eef r&S û :pw i ncogr o seo .h ? eo l z hrat C /p er eU Unlsarcdn mirt nFo s) irto La atoie l gai s lw '. uh z m io o w m ' 2G- p n sa dArz n ' Ne l m g ain w,' w Hipa i Ce trApi Gi i l a 'Pe s nc ne, rl 2,00a52 ,vibeaht:pwrsac. Vpb/sga zn92 1,t , 1aal l t t / e eerho u sl7/d oa a p/ r
i mirto -a -ats ethsa i-o uaino iindsrmiain m gainlw fc-h e-ip ncp p lto -pno -ici n t o 4

J fryPasl n D' eaCom, S Un uh rz dl mirt nFo saeDo n efe se a d V r l U.. a toie m gai lw r w o S apySn eMi- ea e'Pe Hip ncCetr S p. , 0 0 a i, v i bea h rl ic dD cd , w sa i ne, e t 12 1 , tv a al l t ' a

miin(0 ecn) l 20,bu 3 pret f ioas aia rs ethd lo 3 pret. n 06aot 7 ecn o Ar n'Lt / ei ns a l 3 z no d
b e b r i a oh rc u ty4Ofto e 7 .7p re tween tct e sa do l en on n n te o nr. h s, 9 ecn r o iz n n ny i 234p re te o tdta te s o eEn l hç eywej, , . ecn rp r h th y p k e gi ç r j.5 sv As i te e t e S uh et erir g n rto s o Me ia a d oh r n h ni o tw s, al e eain f xcn n te r e Laiao i mirnsb i terio d ,d gtemie, n tn e teco sta t / m ga t ul h al a s u h n s a d e d d h rp h t n t r li tefu d t n frteArz n o td y I moercn y as teArz n ad h o n ai s o h io a f o a . n r e et er,h io a o Ch mb ro Co mec h satb tdtesaesrmak bego t t i Me ia a e f m re a tr ue h tt' e ra l rw h o t xcn i s
i mirns m ga t' .

jb fr rcn adimirns le, osoAmeias n m gatai . k, 6

I' n acd n ta Ar o a a d Grae P o nx h v b e a o g te ts o cie t h t i n n etr h e i a e e n m n h z fsetgo ig eo o isi ten to frn al t od cd s A rpdy ats-rw n c n m e n h ain o ery w ea e. a il g o ig i mirn p p lto fee tern wa c ntut n b o ,a rw n m ga t o uain uld h u a y o srci o m s o Ar o awa se a api es o fred ryp o l t rt e ab o ta i n s en s r p t o lel e pe o ei , o m h t z m r do etesaes ra -ae e o o i ep n in a ep ninta cetd rv h tt'bo db sd c n m c x a so , n x a so h t rae

3San , g lo ' aio, i sa dteS it gDe o rp yo Arz n ' e z Ro ei, L t sWht , n h hfi m ga h f io a . n e n Po uainReee c Bueu Th d t u e i tirp rc mefo tefl wig p lt frn e ra . e aa sd n hs e o t o rm h ol n o o suc sF a kHo b a dNioeSo p , mo rphcTe d i te2 t o re : rn b s n c l to sDe g a i rn s n h 0h

C nuy C nu 2 0 Seil eot Sre C N R- ( ahntnDC: S etr ess 00 p caRp r, ei E S 4W sigo , U.. ss Cess ueu 20)adte18 5 P biUs Mi oaaSmpeIIMS, nu B ra,02;n h 9 0 % ul e c dt a l PJ I c r
1 9 5 P J S 2 0 5 P J S a d2 0 ACSS mpe d wno d dfo 9 0 % LM , 0 0 % IM ,n 0 8 a l, o la e rm Se e Ru ge e a.I tg ae Pu l Us Mir d t S re.V rin tv n g ls t 1 ner td bi e co aa eis eso , c

50( i ep l: iesyo Minst,00,cesd . M r aoi Unvri f neoa2 1)acse ms t

a ht:us. unsogu iid x.hmlo J l 21201 . t tp/ ai l .r/s n e st , n uy , 0 /p 4 e: Hip ncCe tr' rz n : o uaina dLa o F reCh rceitc, P v s a i ne A io a P p lt n b r oc aatrsis o 2 0 -0 6.p. . 0 02 0 ' 3 , 5 bd li 6' rz n n e sasa l,lg l rfre'T eArz n Re u l , rl , 0 8 A io a e d tbe e a wok oc , h io a p bi Api1 2 0 . c 5

l 2 0 , mis ti te e d u p p lt ngo t, io asu e po me trt n 0 6 a d ths rm n o s o uai rw h Ar n ' n m ly n ae o z
7 so da o l 33p re t to t ny . ecn.

T eu d cmetdi mirnsh v g n rl fldteh retlw-a ig h n o u ne m ga t a e e eal ie h ad s,o p yn yl

jb i Aro a I i ntr ul htsmmes whr tmprtrsrglr os n i n. n t ooi s o u r, ee e eaue eual z s oy y
ci bt 10d ge s teewee 1 60 0frinb m Laiao d c me tda d l o 1 e re,h r r 0 ,0 oeg -o t /, o u ne n m n u d c me td cn t cinwok r i 2 0 -whc wa o e 4 p re to te n o u ne , o sm t o res n 0 6- ih s v r 3 ecn f h saes ttlo 2 50 0 c ntuto wok r. l 2 0 ,i i et ae ta tt' oa f 4 ,0 o s cin res8 n 0 9 t s si td h t r m u d c me tdi mirnsc ntue 75p re to Ar o aslb rfre wi n o u ne m ga t o si td . ecn f i n ' a o oc, t t z h ma y scos o te e o o y h vn fr lre sae o u d c metd n etr f h c n m a ig a ag r h rs f n ou ne i mirns m gat. 9 l. Th e e t la igt tea o to o S 1 7 . l e v nse dn o h d pin f B 0 0 AsArz n ' Laiaoa du d c me tdp p lt nge - a dep cal io as t / n n ou ne o uai rw n s e il n o y atr e o o i c n io s b g n t wosn te mo t c n ev t e p lia fe cn m c o dt n e a o re - h s o srai oic l i v t la esi Ar o ab g nwinn eet n b so sr glwsta i p sdn w ed r n i n e a n ig lci s y p n oi a h t m o e e z o n h rs iso Arz n 'u d c me tdwok r. adhp n io as n o u ne res ThsCo r i fmia wi ma yo to elws l 2 0 , io ad ne al i uts a l r t n f h s a .n 0 4 Ar n e id 1 ih z p bi ass: c t u d c metd wok r a d rq i d alp bi ot il t u l sitn e o n o u ne res n eur 1 u l f cas o c e ci 7' rz n su eeo i mirt na g r b sn s,'Wal rc J un l A io a q ez n m gai n es uies' lNfc/ o r a, o Dee b r1 , 0 7 cm e 4 2 0 . S evHip ncCe tr ' rz n : p lt na dLa o F reCh rceit s P s sa i ne, A io a Po uai n b r oc aatrsi , o c 2 0 -0 6'p. 7. 0 02 0 ' 2 , 9 e Hip ncCe tr ' .. a toie l mitt nF o s eDo nS apy P w sa i ne, U S Un uh rzd m gai lw Ar w h rl o Sn eMi- ea e' . . ic dD c d ,p 9 6

rp r t i mirt na toie a yu d c me tdrsdn wh a pidfrs c e oto m gai uh ris n n o u ne eie t o p l o u h o t e assa c.n2 0 ,t v tr p se arfrn u rq iiga1e po est u e sitn e I 0 7 i oes asd eee d m e ur 1 m ly r o s s n

te E-eiy sse b fr hrn wok r- a s se ta Co ges h d n t h v rf ytm eoe iig res y tm h t n rs a o
ma d td Th t1w i n w b igc aln e i teS p e eCo r. ia o Po n ae . a a s o en h l g d n h u rm u tChc n s r e

L C ua Ic vNaoi n, 5 F3 86(t Cr 09,..ga. ,3 -Z .. a as,n. . p la o 5 8 .d 5 9h i. 0)cr. rne l0S. . t 2 ef t . .. à -. C.48(00. t39 2 1)
I Maio aCo ny b frh lret o nyi Arz n , t ap p lt n n rc p u t- y a te ag s c u t n io a wi o uai h o e ce igta o 2 sae- s eifJsp Araoh slu c e wa e o s ep , x e dn h t f 4 tts h r o eh p i a an h d v s f w e s f a v t,ad icreain o u d c metd i mirns I Jn ay 2 0 ,te n ss n n acrt s f n o u ne m gat. n a u r 0 7 h o Untd Sae De at eto J siesg e a a re e twi Maio aCo ny i tts p r n f utc in d n gem n t rcp u t e m h

udrSco 27g o tel mirt nadNainlyAc. U.... 37g. ne et n 8() fh m gai n t ai t8 SC s15() i o ot
T e a re e ta toie alwe te S ei sdp t st e fre u d rte h gem n uh r d l d h h r f e ui o noc, n e h zo f e
sp riin o te JsieDe at e t te fd rli mirto lws Maio a u evso f h utc p rm n, h e ea m gain a . rcp Co nyb cmetef s lcl g n ywi tep we t ma ei mirt narss u t ea h i t o a a e c t h o r o k m gai ret r h o o te sre a d t tl to e arse o e t l mirt n a d Cu tms n h tet n o u' h s retd v r o m gai n so n o

E fre etlE. nocm n (C )
Af rc mpansa an ta il rfl ga darss f t ao frh mot t o lit g isrca poii n ret o Lai /s o te s e n n

mio ofne i n meos dpr et oeaig udr Scin 2 7g nr f s n u ru eat ns prt n e et 8() e m n o are et,C ise anw s n adzdme oadm o are et( OA) gep ns lE sud e t drie m rnu f gem n M a
ta ste fre e t roie a rmo igi mirnswh h db e c n itdo h t e noc m n p irt s s e vn m ga t o a en o vce f i
7

sr u ofn e, op sdatra t p bi sft,o h dwh h dara yb e ei s fe ss wh o e heto u l aey r a o a l d en o c e odrdrmo e b tei mirt nc ut.1l Se tmb r2 0 , fe wieped r ee e v d y h m gai o rs 0 n pé e 0 9 atr d sra o cn e n to o Ar ao a d hs s ep a d masarsso Laiao ,1l E o d m ain f p i n i w e s n s ret f t /s1 C n cn eld te Maio a Co ny S ei s a toi t ma e sre arssu d r a cl h rc p u t h rf ' uh ry o k tet ret n e e f t

scinj tg. piwa dl n: et à()Arao s e at o
1d n' n e tefd t d my ci esp rsin t o tt ars o t ed h e s o o rm u p eso o p o ret ie as lcn d i wi o ttefd rla toi , a d 1m g ig t l g l. a o t t u h e ea uh ry n ' on o l h t c niu t d i l ma e n dfee c. l h lsu . c ueld n' o t e o o t t k s o ifrn e t ep s Be a s o t n . h v t d altep p m okfrtefd ,n mb ro e An n mb r ae o o l h a e r o h es u e n . d u e t o 1 n'b u drteru bel,h ig ia c .S l lo eae w , wo t e n e h i m rl ter udn e o wi p rt a l tl S l . c ** ' * aèp tè ,fte d n' 11big tm my ef oteb r ek.The ce th m i h y o t ' r e slt h od r. y ,1n wat ou emet g t i o ti 2 7a re etars tec u ty...l n t s o e rd fhs 8 gem n cos h o nr wi d a oh rci esp rsinv r so t s o Wahn tna d l o n te r u peso ey o n o h w s igo n l m
Co ges b alg d rca po l g iv siain b te J sie n rs, y l e a il rf m p etgto s y h utc e De at e tb alh s d mo s aos teep liin ,a1rigt p r n, y 1tee e nt tr,h s oica s 1tyn o m r t

sprsingwepqwearsay oyta voae telw.fwe upes s es r t nb d ht il sh a I o e t f dd r gtearssta teeaeie as wears te . w te i ui h ret h th r r l g l, ret h m No h nn l ol df rne(q ' g igt tk ç dw t IE 1 oete ny ieec i wer on o ae e o n o C . hp hy f se m

eeyoy es 1 ntcagn,lwi ntb it iae b vrbd l ' o hnij l o e ni dtd y em l m

ke mef m digmyjb s ntigwi cag.tytnd1 ep r on o,o ohn l hneSa ue. o l 2

1Ln soteMOAso a1cie 8() rga s a b fu daIE 0 ik t h fr 1at 2 7g porm cn eon tC > v Deeainol mirtnAuh ry l t f m gai toi go o t

h p/ . eg vp/e sfcset/et n 8 ghm. l :- i .o /i w /ath essci z 7 . t /c n o jSn eJn 2 0 ,teU.. p r et f ut eh s eniv siaig l ic u e 0 8 h S De at n o J si- a b e n et t m c gn alg t n o cvlr hsvoain fr ail rsigb teMaio aCo ny l ai s f ii i t ilt s o rcap o l y h rcp u t eo -g o n S eif Ofie OnS pe b r2 2 1 ,h U.S.utc De at e tse Arao h rfs f . e tm e , 0 0 te J sie p rm n u d p i c fr euigt c mpywi rq et fr o u e t,jitusaditriwsht o rfsn o o l t e u ss o d c m ns alor,n neve ta h teJsieDe at e t a b e rq et gfr1 mo tsArz n Re u lc h utc p rm n h d en e u si o 7 nh . io a p bi, n ' h rfJ eAr aose b J sieDe at e tncvlr hs rb ' S p. S eif o p i u d y u t p rm n i ii i t po e' e t3, c -g , 2 1. 00 1Ph e iNe Ti e,Je piDein o 27g,Vo s' ohigWil 2 o nx w m s 'o Arao t tn 8() w N t n l a Ch n e' h etn t De ot xcn Hi sl' t5, 0 . a g ,T rae s o p rMe ia s m ef Oc. 20 9 8

S ot atrArao amo n e hsd f n eo Co gesa d teJ sie h rl fe p i l u c d i e a c f n rs n h u t y c
De at e t Arz n Sae S n trRu sl P ac , a fr e Maio a Co ny p rm n, io a tt e ao sel ere om r rc p u t

dp t a d a ln -i eArao al,it d cd S n t Bi 1 7 . On amota e uy n o gt m p i l nr u e e ae l 0 0 yo l ls

srih p yl çv p,h Ltilmr pse ia d o Api2 ,2 1 ,Go e o tag t m i o tq gsa e asd t n , n rl 3 0 0 v m r n Jnc Brwe sg e i it lw.S ei Ar ao te nn u cd ta h wa a ie e r in d t no a h rf p i h n n o n e h t e s f
o e ig tn cte t h u e te pio es ep ce u d r S 1 7 ,po dy p nn e t i s o o s h rsnr x etd n e B 0 0 ru l i
po li igta tetmp rtr isd tetnswo l rah 1 5d gesi te rcam n h t h e eaue n ie h et ud ec 3 e re n h p siit o amigç ou te p se't e freS 1 7 .1 osbly f r n d lner o ss o noc B 0 0 3 i v '

Nain la dAr o acvlihsog nz t n fldato sc aln igS t a n i n iirg t ra iai s ie cin h l gn B o z o e 1 7 wel eoeJ l 2 , 0 0 wh niwa t g it efc. Afe smed ly 0 0 lb fr uy 9 2 1 , e t s o o no fet tr o ea , teUntdSae fe a a t n algn ta S 1 7 wa iv l i i ttly h i tts i d n ci l ig h t B 0 0 s n ai n t oai e l oe dst b cuetesaeh dn rg top o ug t i o ni mirt np l is e a s h tt a o ih t rm lae t w m gai oi e. s oc OnJ l 2 , 0 0 tedsrc c ut rne teUntdSae ' to fra uy 8 2 1 ,h itit o r ga td h i tts moin o e

peiiàyiu cin Irfsdt siedwntewh l l , u iddrsa rl nr n nt .teue o tk o h oe a btt i et i m jo r w rn
i pe et gtef emot rc na p o iin . m lm ni h i s dao in rvso s n v . h p/ lg .h e i e i e .o atr/o gl / e ap i- d fa tr - z8 g.. d : o s o nu M m s e sadz o /ol rao ein- e 7 a +p c ' o n .h dp p 1< et tCee rts1tAn iesr,'rsrlaeMai p C ut 3G nci lb ae 7h nv ray Pese s, roa ony Ty ' e c Vou te P sellg lmmirt nEnocmet l'Prs rlae S pe b r lner os l a l gai fre n Unt' es ee s, e tm e e o , 1 , 0 0 b t a albea www. coog 5 2 1 , oh v i l t m s .r . a 9

Seiluy2,00adthrf pliPamijSae fr r e hrtJl 021,n I ei Araon lr n tgso Am d f sf

* S cin 2srq ie e tta saeo lclp l ema ig a y lwflso eto ' e urm n h t tt r o a oi kn n a u tp c mutiv siaetep ro ' i mirt n sau i te h v Ees n be s n et t h esn s m gai tts f h y a e t ao a l g o r s siin'h th idvd a i i teUntdSae u lwfl upco 'ta te n iiu ls n h i tts na ul e y

* S cin 2s fr e rq i me tta i a idvd a i arse fra y et ' ut r e ur n h t f n n iiu l s retd o n o h e voain icu ig u p i p rig t k t,tesaeo lclp l emut ilt , n ldn n ad akn i es h tt r o a oi s o c c d ti teidvd a u tlt a b v rfe ta h o s ei a toie t b ean h n iiu l niicn e ei d h t e r h s uh r d o e i z i teUntdSae. n h i tts e * S cin3scet no asaemid men rfra yn nct e wh h sn t et ' rai f tt s e a o o n o -izn o a o o o i

rgs rdwi teDeatet f meadScry(HS o wh de eiee t h pr n o Ho ln eui D ) r o os t h m t
n t a eo hsp ro tea po r t fd rl e itaind c me t. o h v n i esn h p rp i e e ea rgsrt o u ns a o * S cin5sceto o asaemid men rfra u d c me tdi mirn eto ' rain f tt se a o o n n o u ne m g at wh a pisfrsl i , r efr s r . o p l o,oi t o p rom wok e cs
* S cin6srq ie e tta saeo lc l oieof esars sme n i et ' e urm n h t tt r o a p l fi r ret o o e f o cc te h v po a l cu et b l v ta teidvd a cmmie ap bi h y a e rb be a s o ei e h t h n iiu l o t d u l e t c ofn ema ighm o h rçe o a l'fo teUntdSae. fe s kn i r e ç m v be'rm h i tts r e

T edsi cut i nteji Scin5sa ed ett apexsn h irt or dd o non et ' m nm n o reiig tc o t
saueb n n teh roigo cn el go a u d c me tdi mirn a dte ttt a i g h ab r r o cai f n n o u ne m ga t n h n n
UntdSae h dn tse ic l c aln e po iin ma igiaci et bo k i tts a o p cf al h l g d rvso s kn t rm o lc e iy e

o i p d tat b a u d c me tdi mirn e trn aso p dmoo v hce r m e e rf y n n o u ne m ga t neig tp e tr e il k crfrta so towoko fradie o a yct e si sau t bo ktafci a o rnp r t r r o r r f n izn hp tts o lc rfi n v i
od roo ti wok r. re t ban res Asstfrhb lw, e ot eo BAMN fl sp o ttedsrc c uts pno srdh ul u p rs h itit o r'o iin ti g y l d wnf eo temotda o inpo iin o S 1 7 .F rterao sstfr o i f h s rcna rvso s f B 0 0 o h e sn e ot v h b lw, o e e, eo h w v r BAMN asrsta ti Co r s o l rsri e fre e to te set h ths ut h ud etan nocm n fh s eicpo iin a dtee t esaueb cu ei i b sd o a asrin o p cf rvso s n h ni ttt ea s t s ae n n set f i r o
1 0

çtt' rg t'ta i ie t a t tecamsta sge ainssma eag n rt n laes ihs h ts d ni lo h li h t e rg t it d e eai s ' c o o a o b cu ei i a e pii atmp t u e saep we t freah l miin g , e a s t s n x l t t t o s tt o r o oc af lo ce l M e ia a dCeta A>eia i mirnst f etesae a db cu ei k y xcn n nrl rcn m gat o l h tt, n ea s t e e s P O iin aee e moedao in a d u lwflta teds itc uto te rVSO S r v n r rc na n na u h n h it c o r r h r UntdSae h v sae . i tts a e ttd e

T i Cor sol ss i teiu cin o tebods ad su ds hs ut hud utn h n nt n h raet n on et a jo
go n s p sil b cu e ru d osbe ea s h l miin Me ia a d Ce ta Ameia af lo l xcn n nrl rcn i mirnsso l n t efcdwi tec oc o f en tesaerte ta fc m ga t h ud o b a e t h h ie f l ig h tt ah rh n ae h e tewrt o teu lwfl rsd ta h sb e lt c e a anth m. h ah fh na u cua e h t a en am h d g is te
ARGUM ENT SB 1 7 I AN UNLAW FUL ASS RTI N OF R TATES'RI HTS' 00 S EO S G ' I AN AREA AND FOR A P RPOS THAT VI LATES THE N U E O CONS I UTI N OFTHE UNI ED S ATES TT O TT .

A. S 1 7 a awh l i a u lwfl set no an ne itn ttt rg t B 0 0 s oe s n na u asri f o -xse tt ae ih' o s ' t po ug t i o n i mirto p l y b cu e sae ofcas ae o rm lae t w m gain oi ea s tt f il r s c i dsaif dwi fd rlmmirt np l is ist i t e ea i gai oi e. se h oc Th Untd Sae Co si t n s ei cl ga t Co gestep we t e i tts ntui p ct al rns n rs h o r o e to iy etbihaç nfr r l o n trl ain' n t le uaec mmec wi frin sa l ç iom ue f au ai to 'a d o û g lt o re t oeg su z r h
nains'a d i ga t tePrsd n tepo e t c nd c teNain' frin to , n t rns h eie t h w r o o u t h to s oeg '

rlto s icu igto eap cso frin rlt n rltdt tetet e to eain , n ldn h s set f oeg eai s eae o h ram n f o n nct e si ti c u tya do Ameia ct e sa ra . ntat1 sc8 c o -iz n n hs o nr n f r n izn bo d Co s, r , e , l i ci

34 at , e 2 Fo o e t ocnuis teS p e eCo r h sh l ta toe -; r 2 sc . r v r w e tre,h u rm u t a ed h t h s

po iin gattefdrlg v rmete cu ie atoi t d tr ie t h rvso s rn h e ea o en n x lsv uh rt o eem n l o y w s o l a dso l n t ea mitdit tec u t a dtec n io su d r ih h ud n h ud o b d t no h o nr n h o dt n n e whc e y i
alg l nrn ma rman'DeC n sv Bi ,2 U..5,5 (96. e a e ta t y e i. a a . c 44 S 3 134 17) ' a

S cin 1o S 17 p y l sriet teUntdSae Co si inb eto f B 0 0 a s i evc o h i tts n tm o y p e t

asrn taAr oahs lo pln itrsitecoeaieefre etf setg ht i n a at m elg neetn h op rt nocm n o i z ci v fdrlimirtn /w . SB.17,5 1(mpai add.Ar oasBr f eea m gai tw' . 00 o z' e hss de) i n ' i z e
e p n so ti te eb asdigta tesaei atmpigt ti'tefd rl x a d n hs h m y se n h t h tt s t t o ç d'h e ea en a

gvrmetadta i ass nesol b ç ecme'rte ta r etd o en n n ht t siac hud e ç lo d' ahr hn e ce st w j (r . ra1. A i B ,t) z
Bu teeasrin aerdc lu . h UntdSae h sma ecerta i th s set s r iiuo s T e i tts a d la h tt o e d e n twatte i o p rt n'ta S 1 7 sp oe l ofr. Un e te o s o n h E o eai ' h t B 0 0 u p sdy fes d r h c o

S pe ayClu e Arz n h sn rg t ofretefdrl o en e t oac p u rm c a s, io a a o ih t oc h e ea g v rm n t c e t

Goprt n'hth fdrlo e met a rjce. ç oeai ' ate eeagvm nhseetd c ot
ld e ,tewh l cam o c o eain in rsrai atg te. Asst n ed h oe li f o p rt g oe ely lo eh r o t e

fr i teSae eto Fat, n rs h sa toie teAton yGe ea t ot n h ttm n f cs Co ges a uh rz d h tre n rl o h

s n27g are et wi lcl oieaece t efreapcso fdrl i 8() gem ns t oa p l gnis o noc set f eea g h c
i mirt nlw. tCo gesisse ta tefd rl o e n e tsp riete m gai a Bu n rs n itd h t h e ea g v nm n u evs h o saeotcr t as eta te crido tfd rln tsaep ir is 8US j tt f es o sm h t h y are u e ea, o tt r ie. i ot C

15() 37g.

l 2 0,mmirt nadC so s nocmetlE s ndaco eain n 07l gai n utm E fre n ( )i e oprt o Cg o
are e t t Arz n 'mot rmie ta e fre e t g n y teMaio a gem n wi io as spo n n 1w nocm n a e c - h rc p h

Co nyS eifsOfie Bu i Oco e 2 0 ,1Etep ro o Scin2 7g u t h rf fc . t n tb r 0 9 C h otn f et 8() i o
a toiigsre arssb cu eteS eifsOfieh dfi dt fl w fdrl uh rzn tet ret ea s h h rf fc a al o ol e ea e o

p l is S eifArao te d f nl amo n e ta h wo l so c n u t oi e . h rf p i h n ei t r u cd h t e ud o n o d c c ay a oh ri mirto s epa dpo li e ta h wo l ç o b it iae b n te m gain w e n rcam d h t e ud d t e ni d td y n m

C n rs,oj yalgdpoin ivsgt n b teJsc Deatet'S e oges(rb l e rfig n et ai s y h ut e pr n.' e e l io i m
spa a 6 u r, t .

Arz n SaeS n trRu slP ac po o e a dteArz n Le iltr io a tt e ao sel ere rp sd n h io a gsaue

eatd S 17 t gv S ei Arao adohr as t sa t t jsf nce B 00 o ie hrf pi n tes te tt e o uty f au i cniu t n o tesmepl ista tefdrlgvrmethdrjce a o t ai f h a oi e ht h eea oen n a eetd s no c
ic n itn wi fd rllw. S eifArao l eBulComo i Bi ig a , n o sse t t e ea a h rf p i, i l l r n r n h m h k m

c uda and cd wh th i mirto p lce wo l b i Maio aCo ny o l g i eie a te m gain oiis ud e n rc p u t.
Go e o Brwe si a mu h wh n se sg e te lw. S 1 7 ,se v m r e r ad s c e h in d h a B 0 0 h

d cae , saéo l ta Arz n c udu et Cov acii weddn tcet elrd wa l ö' h t io a o l s o ç le rss i o rae t' s a d te fd rlg v rme th s rfsd t f ... te cii cu e b ilg l n h e ea o en n a eue o i h rss a sd y le a x
i mirt na dAr o as oo s od r'l m gai n i n 'p ru b re.'4 o z

1Go e o Jnc Brwe,çttme t yGo en r e e o S 1 7 ' c nb 4 v m r a ie e rç ae n b v ro Brw r n B 0 0' a e s ft da: om t , h p/ag v mo.o /ms po A R 0 2 1 Sae e t y o en r n B1 7 . l : z o e r vd / la / g u 4 3 0 ttm nB G v roo s 0 0p
1 3

Th s ae fec a d d f n asrin o ttt' rg t.' l Arz nas ee r ire n ei t set s f t aes ihs' f io ' a o s ofcasb l v te fd rlg v mme tsp l y i n tSo g ' e o g , te fiil ei e h e ea o e n' oi s o ç u h' n u h h n e c t
Arz n wi çs'tepo lm. fMe io a dten to so Lai Ameiaf e io a l çx'h rbe l xc n h ain f t lt n rc l

dpo ai p oet o e çr e v lnerp se' h nig i mirns i te ilm t rtss v r ç m d ou te o ss u t m ga t n h c a 'n
d sr, io asS ceayo Saewi h n l to epoet. l Caionaa d eetArz n ' ertr f tt l a de h s rtss f l ri n l f

Ne Meioojc ta S 17 i afcigtereoo yadtercies w xc betht B 00 s fet hi cnm n hi izn n t whnte t vlhog Ar oatoe bet n cnas b inrdbcueh e hy r etruh i n,hs ojci s a l egoe easte a z o o
sv rinsaeo Arzn h sso e . o eeg tt f io a a p k n I a atmp t d fn ti lw, io actsioae p rssfo fd rl n n t to ee d hs a Arz n i s ltd hae rm e ea e e saue a toiig c o eain i tes aig o ifr ain a d assa c o ttts uh rzn o p rt n h h rn f n om t n sitn e n o o

prclrars (r o aBr f a 2) B tte ra peeetspotg atua ret A i n i , t 7. u h el rcdn uprn i sz e i
Ar o asasro o p we i n tsauoypl sstm 9o terc ne tb t i n ' set n f o r s o tttr lae o m h i o tx, u z i r
tuh r is l e te 1 5 ç o ten Ma iet' o S uh r c n rsme i ç toie' i h 9 6 ç uh l nfso' f o ten o ges n n a t 'k s'

rsos tB o nvB adoE uain eppeo rw . o r f d ct . o
Th suh m cn rsme d cae tero e d f n eo fdrlatmps e o te o ges n elrd h i p n ei c f e ea te t a
t e fre teBr wn d cso .T e d n u cd fd rlç e des' v we t o noc h o eiin h y e o n e e ea ç d lr,' o d o m u h l terl a i ,rdt n ,adwa o le'a dd cae ta te ,no te p od h i ç bt ta io s n y f i , n e lrd h t h y t h hs i f' c ut,wee te f a abtr o wh tte Fo renh Ame d e trq ie .1 o rs r h i l ri s f a h u tet n e n m n e urd 5

1ç 'eS uh r Ma iet.'Fo Co g eso a Reo d 8 t Co gesS c n 5çh o ten nfso ' rm n rsin l c r , 4h n rs e o d f P it gOf e 1 5 . 4 94 6 . r i t , 9 6 4 5 -4 0 nn k

SsihVo.0,at ( ac 1,96. sigo, C.Goen etl es . l12pr4M rh 2 15)WahntnD. : vrm na o
1 4

Go en rBrwe,u p re b S n tr ere S eif p i a doh r, a li v r o e r sp otd y e ao P ac, h rf Arao n tesh s ad cam t Arz n ' rg tt st io asi mirto p l yi tesmewa ta li o io as ih o e Arz n ' m gain oi n h a c y ht
Go e o Ge reWalc o c li cam t Alb masçih't stp l isfr v m r og l e n e ad li o a a ' çg t o e oi e o a r' c i sh os t c o l. s

Go e o Brwe,ieGo èn rWalc b fr h r isssta seh sn v m r e r l v r o l e eoe e,nit h t h a o k a
h sit t ayp riua rc .n e d S 1 7 rp ae l d cae ta tees al oti o n at lr ae ld e , B 0 0 e etdy elrsh th r h l ly c

b n rca dsr iaini tee fre eto telw. teey n k o ,ta e o ail ici n t n h n ocm n fh a Bu v ro e n wsh t mo ti ls i drce a ah l miin u d c me td i mirnswh aeamot hs av s ietd t af lo n ou ne m gat o r l s l
e t eyo Me ia o Ceta Ameia d se tEv ro ek o sta teo l ni l f xcn r nrl rcn ecn. ey n n w h t h ny r

p o l so p d q et n d a d d tie u d ri po iin wi b Laiao . epe tp e , u si e n ean d n e t rvso s l e t /s o s l n
I de ,ac n ce t u p l e ofcr at g i teb s o g o fi , wi s n e d o sini s oi f e, ci n h et f o d at l o o ci n hl e frete lw b c ue h ,to k o sta amotte o l p o l wh ae n oè h a e a s e o , n w h t l s h ny epe o r u d c metdi mirnsnArz n aeLaiao . n ou ne m ga t i io a r t /s n Th dsrc c uta d faky teUntd Sae h v atmpe t in r e i it o r n ,rl l,h i tts a e te td p g oe t e teiseo rc b cu etesaueh sn t e b e apid Bu o e ah n rd h su f ae e a s h ttt a o y t en p l . t v r u de e y as a o te S pe e Co r snc d wn a saue wa fcal-e ta b t er g , h u rm u t tzk o ttt s ail n url u y dsr iae a an t ieen to as Yc lrv Hokn, 1 U.. 5 (86. ici n td g is Chn s ain l. ik rp . p is 18 S3 6 18) m t

l ac s ta wa c n oiae ltrit Yc Fb afd rlcrutc u t setd n ae h t s o sl td ae no ik , e ea ic i o r asre : d t a a cu tb bid t wh tmutb n csai k o n t e ey itlg n ç n o r e l o a s e e esrl n w o v r nel e t c n y i

pro i tesae'I r FbL e2 F 4 1(i ut utD. lona18) esn n h tt? n e e, 6 . 7 Cr iCor, Cai ri 86. ' c f
1 5

I l h o teraie o Arz n ' p p lt n ti Co rc mltin r terai n i t fh e lis f io as o uai , hs ut a o g oe h e ly g t o t

ta tedrc a dc l trl it so S 1 7 wi amot ni l b Laiao . h th iet n ol ea vci f B 0 0 l l s et ey e t /s a m l r n

T edsit orwa asltl cretnejiigtei pe ett no h ir cut s boue èrci nonn h m l nai f tc y mo
temotdao in po iin o S 1 7 frterao sta i gv . Aste h s rc na rvso s f B 0 0 o h esn h t t a e h

UntdSae age i tedsrc cuthwee, teetr saues o l be i tts rud n h itit or, o vr h nie ttt h ud e
src d wnb cu eii ifsdwi teu lwflasrino saesrg t.As tuk o e a s t s n ue t h na u set f tt' ihs h o
teUntd Sae h sn tag e , o e e, h lw s o l as b s uk d wn h i tts a o ru d h w v r te a h ud lo e t c o e r b cu eih sa o vo sa do e rca tre ta teCo r cr o in r. S e a s t a n b iu n p n ail agt h t h u t am t g oe B 1 7 d cae ta Arz n h s lu c e a cua e t fre a h l miin 0 0 elrs h t io a a a n h d r sd o oc af lo l u d c me tdme , me a dc i rn amot lo wh m aeo Me ia a d n o u ne n wo n n hl e- l s al f o r f xcn n d Ce ta Ameia d se t t fe teSae Ev ro e e e tec i rnwh ae nrl rcn ecn- o le h tt. ey n , v n h hl e o r d

ctzn mu tev . i e s s la e i
o r hsoy tah s u a yhn , ti Co r so l q iky a d u itr ec e s n tig hs u t h ud uc l n

e p aial s ied wnccy ap c o S 17 b c ueM z n h sn p we m h tcl t k o vr se t f B 0 0 e a s o a a o o r yr t a o ti a d b cu en i e ti Nain n ra y Nain so l e e a an o d p t n ea s et r hs t , o n to , h ud v r g i h o
tlrt rcal-agtdmase p lin . oeae ail tree s x uso s y

K S 17 ' dcae p l y o çtio tru h efre et i utry B 0 0s elrd oi f ç tt n ho R nocm n' s t l c ari 'e
ic n itn wi teg v rigfd rl oiy n o sse t t h o enn e ea p l . h c S cin1o S 1 7 d cae ta teAc itn s ot a eatt nto g et o f B 0 0 elrs hth tne d t t k t io h u h m ri
e fre e th p bi p l yo alsaea dlcl o en e ta e ce'i od r nocm n te u l oi f 1 tt n o a g v rm n g n is'n re cc
1 6

t i ic ua ea dd trteu lFfle t a dpee c o ain a deo o i o ç so rg n ee h na u nr n rsn e f l s n c n m c d y e at i b p ro su lwfl pee ti teUntdSae.'SB. 00j1Evn ci t y esn na ul rsn n h i tts' . 17 . e vy y e

wh r tese icpo iin o S 1 7 p rl lo ic roaefd rlp l y ee h p cf rvso s f B 0 0 aal r n op rt e ea oi , i e c
te aepempe b cu ei Arz n ' h n s teep o iin aed sg e t h y r re td ea s n io as a d , h s rvso s r ein d o

flhrap lyta i drcl cnrr t tepoiye atdb Co gesa d tte oi ht s iet o tay o h l n ce y n rs n r c y c
i pe e tdb n meo samii rt n ,n ldn teOb maAd iitain m lm ne y u ru d ns ai sicu ig h a to m nsrt . o l d srbn fd rl p l y te ds it c ut b g n i o iin b n eciig e ea oi , h it c o r e a t pno y c r s

smmaiig te rlv n fdrlsaue.Bre y fdrl lw,wi may u rzn h ee at eea ttts iv , eea a t n h
e cpin ,ma e i a ci e fr a n nct e t e tr te cu ty wi o t x et s k s t rm o o -izn o ne h o nr t u o i h

a toiain T efd rlsaue frh rpo ie a an wih ma y e cpto s uh r t . h e ea ttts ute rvd , g i t n x e in , zo ta p ro swh aeu lwfl p ee ti tecu ty o wh fi t o ti o h t esn o r na ul rsn n h o nr r o al o ban r y Cry te n c say P p r ma b d p re . Fial, a an wih i potn af h eesl a es y e e o td n ly g i t m rat e cpin ,h fd rlsaue po ieta i i aci efrcrane po est x eto s te e ea ttts rvd h t t s r o eti m ly r o m

k o igye po pro s oaeu l fl peetntecut ( i C O , nwnl m ly esn wh r na ul rsn i h onr D s t p wy yt a56. t -)
Th Bre o teUntdSae r hl asrsta S 1 7 ma e ci e o e if fh i tts i t set h t B 0 0 k s rm s f e gy a sta aen tci e u d rfd rllw,icu ig fin t o ti o cry d h t r o r s n e e ea a n ldn al g o ban r ar m i
i mirto p p r a dapyn fro p romigwok T eUntdSae as m gain a es n p lig o r efr n r . h i tts lo e

rg t p it o tta u d ritmain l o v nin ,sc at aeno nomal ihl ons u,h t n e ne t a c n e to s u h cs r t r l y o y

1 7

ci e b tr efre,fta,hog cvl eotinpoedn s( SBr f r s u ae nocd ia l truh iidp rt rceig U i , m l ao e a3-43-8. t 23 ,73)
W i rg r t d p rainp o edn steUntdSae p o li si vg r t e ad o e ott rce ig ,h i tts r cam t io h o e s

i efrigteelws( SBifa 67. h s wh hv be dpr dd nt n nocn hs a U r ,t -)T oe o ae en eot o o e e
dsue ti asr o -ato g ma y wo l a d te wod cu l b ua a d i t hs set n-l u h n ud d h rs re, rtl n p ih
ih ma e Bu la igaiep oeso so i io,'h UntdSae tc sa a n u n . t e vn sd r fsin fi g r te i tts u k w y v' e i tec reso i Bre sae e t ta rv a ta ih sn ta dcr o, noc n h on r ft if ttm ns h t e e lh tt a o, n am te fre s

tefd rl tttsa antte1 miinp o l wh aed i l igi voain h e ea saue g is h 1 lo e pe o r al i n n ilt l yv o
o toe saue.P tsmpy u d c ie td wok r aevtlt teAmeia f h s ttts u i l, n o u ne r es r i o h a rcn eo o y De ott n o 1 miinp o l wo l n to l d srytee o o y c n m . p rai s f 1 lo e pe ud o ny eto h c n m o l drcl b two l cu emasv p lia tr olb t i teUntd Sae a d i t u ud a s sie oicl um i oh n h i tts n ey t e

a ra .ld e ,teo l g v rme t ta h v b e a l t lu c sc mas bo d n ed h ny o en ns h t a e en be o a n h u h s e p lin aeto eta h dara y ei iae d mo rtcrg t frtee t e x uso s r h s h t a le d l n td e cai ihs o h ni m r
po ulto . p ain

F rb t e o o i a dp lia rao s c c. a miitain icu igte o oh c n m c n oicl e sn , v r d nsrt ,n ldn h t y o

Ob maAd iitain h setbih dp irt sta tre çrmias a doh r a m ns t , a sa l e roie h t ag tt i n l' n te ro s i c '
i ihpirt'tresa dta ga ti pii o e pii wav r t tep rnso ç g roi 'ag t n h t rn m l t r x l t ies o h ae t f h y c c s alc i rn ln -i ersd ns p ro swh n w h v , o ma s o ha e m l hl e , o gt eie t, esn o o a e r y o n v , d m

go n sfrlg lsau ,a d ah s o go p wh r tee ae t u a iain' ru d o e a tts n ot f ru s ee h r r t m ntra ' h

raosoaodarss r eottn(e USBifa4-0. esn t vi reto dpr i Se r ,t 85) ao e
1 8

Fo p rsnrao s smepaerso sbly sll o P eietOb ma r at a e sn , o lc ep n iit oey n rsdn a i i

frteep l is Bu teep l isae n tdfeetfo to e o teBuh o h s oi e. t h s oi e r o ifrn rm h s f h s c c
Ad iitaino i pe eesr.n fc, Co gesh sa po e teep l is m nsrt r t rd c sos l at n rs a p rv d h s oi e o s c

fr e a e i telwsh tih se atda dteb d eayd cso sih sma e o d c d s n h a ta t a n ce n h u g tr eiin t a d .
F ro e t od cd sp liin i b t p rish v lc e ete tewi o te o v r w ea e, oica s n oh at a e ak d i r h l r h t e h l

dset gat iznhpo t lu c Gao dp rt n,u hv isedste ei o rn ctesi ro anh jr eoti sbt aenta eld r i ao t fr rsrigaEhdwpplt n'dpie o eulyadsbetoa1oms o peevn t ao ouai , er d fqai n ujct 1fr s o' v t
o au e b t e eteesl iga p ro teUntdSae. f b s- u n v rh ls i n s at fh i tts v e W i S 1 7 ,Arz n i c dfig a d i pe et gtefn a e tl t B 0 0 io a s o iyn n m lm ni h u d m nal h n y

dfee t oiyo çt io tru he fre e t' ifrn p l fçt t n ho g noc m n.' c ari
Thsp rs çt io tru h e fre e t i tk n drcl fo Mak i hae d tt n ho g nocm n' s a e i t rm r a ri ' ey Kr oin e te eyc n ev t ee euiedrco o teCe tr o l mirt n i ra , xrm l o srai x c t ietr fh ne fr m gai k v v o Su is l 2 0 at l,Krk ra po o e En ice s i c n eto a tde. n 0 5 ri e ioin rp sd ç n rae n o v nin l c a

e fre e t arss p oeuin , d p rain , ast siue, ec- wi nocm n- ret, r sc t s e o t o s se ez rs t. t o t h e p n e u eo v rfct n o lg lsau a av rey o i p ra tp it, t x a d d s f eiiai f e a tts t ait f m o tn ons o o

paeia d cladupesn a p silt lehr jcJy.1(mp ai k t s @ ut n nlaat s osbe o i ee /g / '6e hss v /' add B digti teeWi b a ices i ten mbro llgl' o de) y on hs hr l e n nrae n h u e fç eas wh , l i' l

1MakKrk ra ,' o n iigllg lmmirt n A Srtg o At io 6 r ioin ' w szn l a l gai : taey f tt n D e o ri tru hE fre e t'Cetr o l mirt nSu is,Ma 2 0 . albea ho g n ocm n ' ne fr m gai tde' y 0 5 Av i l t o a

h p/ .i. Wa ilszo+ako .ml d :- cs r lce/os c6 s t . / o h
1 9

ç ieu a dd p r te sle's ta tern mb rcn b srr d wn t a ç v p n e oth m ev s o h t h i u e a e hul o o g ' k

i aaebeniac rij' t ngal usne sc.1 m '7
Cal gmiin o h ma b ig at a a eben ia c'ma e cer o ln lo s f u n en s t n g a l usn e' k s la h w il m rcsMrKrk ra a dhsp l yatal ae Bu ii ta p lc- tepoiyo a it . ioin n i oi cul r. tts h t oiy h lc f c y

ltlo tru h e tre e t' ta te Go en r S eif Arao a d te iit n ho g nocm n' ht h v ro, h rf p i, n h a ri -

maoi o teAr oa eilue ae o aotd jry fh i n L gsa r hv nw dpe. t z t
Ad igt tee rira t i mirn p l isd srb da o e S 1 7 h w dn o h al ni m g at oi e ecie b v , B 0 0 o ec
rq ie e eyp l eof e t so , q et n a etaddti udcmet e urs v r oi fi r o tp uso, r s n e n nou ne cc i r, a à i mirnsu d ramote eyc n ev bestain I te rq i spoe uos m ga t n e l s v r o c ia l iut . th n e ur rsctr o e
'

t fe hre adugsosnec ofn eswi S ei Araos n igray oi cags n jde t etne fedr, t hrf pi t dn ed l hf a
wi hstn cte,oma ee eyicreaina ih ma ea i lg l p sil. t i e t i s t k v r n acrt s n u n s s e al osbe h i o y T e S eife e po oe amig t ou te p se' t ma e sr ta n h h rf v n rp ss r n t lner o ss' o k ue h t o v

u d c me tdwok r sa e hs rs . n o u ne re ecp s igap

Arz n amst fretefd rl o en e tod p r a ma yrsd nsa io a i o oc h e ea g v rm n t e o t s n eie t s

psil adt jitoewhm tefdrl oen et a dcddiwi nt os e n o alhs o h eea gvrm n hs eie t l o bl
dp r frûu a i ra 'o oh r e sn .T eso sr o S 1 7 ,o teoh r e oto i m nt in' r te rao s h p n os f B 0 0 n h te h a

h n ,eo nz n h ma i ra e cpin .Bytero nwod ,h yaee g g d a d rc g ie o u nt in x e t s h i w rs te r n a e a o
i acua et freah lmiinMe ia a dCeta Ameia p ro st la e n rsd o oc af lo xcn n nrl rcn es n o ev l

Arzn - a dt tk terc i rnwi te . io a n o a e h i hl e t h m d h
1lk. 7 jt lj
20

F d rli mirto p l ismu tb e atdb fd rlofcas Arz n e ea m gain oi e s e n ce y e ea fiil. io a c

h sn rg t ou lahsmeofcr a dma dt oh r t c ryo tacu la d a o ih t ne s o fies n n ae tes o ar u r e n d n eo sp l y ta fn a e tl c nrdcstefd rl oiyta Co ges a g ru oi h t u d m nal o ta it h e ea p l h t n rs c y c a dteP eie th v po ug tdu drteatoi o teCo si t n o te n h rsd n a e rm lae n e h uh ry f h n tui fh t to
Unle Sae. td tts

fs Th dsrccutrpryfu dtafv o S 17 'seicpoiin - e ititorpoel on htie f B 00s pcf rvsos i
aeutr ic nitn wi teg v r igfd rl oiy r tel n o sset t h o enn e ea p l . y h c T edsrc c u tihl fu dta teUntdSae h dahg p o a it h itit o r rg t o n h th i tts a ih rb bly y e i

ivsgt no toetupce'o u lwfl rsnei teUS,h scn n et ai fhs t setd' f na u peec n h )te eod io s snec o Scin2 (a o rlaeo aypro ars dfr n ofneut etne f et 8 bn n ees fn esn ret o ay fes ni o e l lwfl rsnevrid, et n3( aigias t ci et b wi oteea a u peec eie)Sci m kn t te r o e t u fdrl t o am h ppr) Scin5( aigiaci efrtd cmetdprost woko t aes, et m kn t r o m ou ne esn o r r o o m apy frwok,ad Scin 6 (emiig ars o idvdasfrwhm p l o r) n et o pr tn r t f n iiul o o t es poalcueeishycmmie a r etamae te rmoal) rbbe as x' te o t d ci ht kshm e vbe. s t tm
BAM N a d trec mme t t tedsrc c utsa dteUntd Sae' d s l e o ns o h itit o r' n h i tts t e
ag ie t d mo srt gh w u lwflh s scin ae run ns e ntai o na u tee et s r. n o Frt S cin 2 ' ma d tr itro ain o a1 çup ce ' is, et o B s n aoy nerg t o f 1 d s etd' s

u d c me tdrsdnsi a e ta riai bo d a du d f e sa dr ta n o u ne eiet s n xrodn rl ra n n ei d tn ad h t y n wi ete alw o freofcr t itro aeal esn o Laiaod se t o l i r l r oc fies o nerg t lp ro s f t / ecn wh lh o n d n tsekEn l h h v a a cn, p eru e po e ,o whooh r ieber o o p a gi , a e n ce ta p a n m ly d r s tew s a 21

wh tv ratiue a u d cmetdp ro i asme t h v .Ev nGo e o ae e t b ts n n ou ne esn s su d o a e e v m r r
Brwe cudn tsaewh t r ei a ofcrso l u et etbihterq ii e r o l o tt a ci ra n fie h ud s o sa l h e ust t s e çe sn be ss iin' o u lwfl sau. Gie S cin 2 ' po iin t ao a l upco ' f na u tts v n et B s rvso r o

a toiigapiaerg to a int freof esa dd p r e t t a pyti uh r n r t ih f d o o oc fi r n e at ns o p l hs z v c m
saue c mbn d wi n nct e s ia it t k e o t ie al-ban d ttt- o ie t o -iz n ' n bly o ep u l g l o tie h i i ly e ie c i d p rainp o edn sa dterpatcliait t d s i sae vdn e n e ott r ce ig n h i rcia n bly o o o n tt o i poeuin u d rS l 7 - s cin 2 i esnil adrciet itro ae rscto s n ç B o o et B s se tal iet o nerg t o y v

wi da oia fro a1Laiao so p d fr ay rao . Asti po iin t ib l l ev r 1 t /s tp e o n esn h c n hs rvso
c a g se eyruietaf so it ap tnil l eatrn e etted n es h n e v r o t rfi tp no oet l i -l ig v n, h a g r n c ay f e t rsd ns a dof es i o vo s o eiet- n fi r- s b iu . c S cin 3s a toiain o sae arss frfi r t manan fd rl et ' uh rzt f tt ret o al e o iti e ea o o u p p r i,i a yhn ,moe dao in Wi amot n e cpin , i b n a es s f n tig r rc na . t l s o x et s t a s h o

sse d dsne cs po ain p ro s c mmuain , n eryrlae . S. . up n e etn e, rb t , ad n , o tto s a d al eess B o 1 7 , e . D. t at et-a sne c fraf s ofn e tiyd y fre c 0 0 sc 3 Wi w nydy etn e o i t fe s, hr a s o ah h r t
sbe u n ofn e SB.1 7 , e . H,a dd t b n so to ewh h v b e u sq et fe s, . 0 0 sc 3 n aa a k n h s o a e en arse , retd a toie rp ae arss a d icreain o p riua uh r s e etd ret n n acrt s f at lr z o c u d c me tdrsd nsu t te la e n o u ne eiet ni h y ev . l Fn l ,S cin 5s i p s in o ci ia sn t n o u d c me td ial eto ' m oio f rm n l a ci s n n o u ne y t o

p ro swh a pyfro p rom woki culntee te ei a dt nt b ig esn o p l o r efr r s re i h xrm n d io o en i
ic nitn wi teCo geso a rfsloma elo igfrwoko wokn a n o sset t h n rsin leua t k o kn o r r rig h
2 2

ci e li,nefc,natmp t sav u d c metdwok r a dterc i rn rm .ts i feta t to tr e n o u ne res n h i hl e e d s ta te wi la e o h th y l e v . l

l. B 17 W OLATESTHEFOURTEENTH AMENDMENTBY 1S 00 LEGALW NGRACI LDICRI I ATI NANDCREATI G A S MN O N

CONDI I NSFOR LATI A/ SI ARI ONA S M I AR TO TO NON Z IL CONDI I NSFOR BLACK PEOPLE I THE OLD JM CROW TO N I SOUTH.

T epee igscin d c me t o dt n ta mayo tieArz n wi h rc dn eto s o u n c n io s h t n usd io a l i l
f du i a ia l: oies ep , n aoyq eto igo a y n ssetdo i nm gn be p l w e sma d tr u sinn f n o e up ce f n c b igu d c me td poeuin frfin t c n p p r,icreainfr en n ou ne , rscto s o al g o a y a es n acrt o i o
' atmpigt f dwok tn ct snted sr ame p se o ç ou tes' te t o i r ,e t ie i h eeq r d o ss fç lner, nn i v

s te poesocdt b ifr atfrC ,pndcaain o a ttnt te m lye fre o enom nso IE oe elrt s fnneto a o
freah lmiinp o l a dterc i rnt f etesae fbiain a o t oc af lo e pe n h i hl e o l h tt, a rct s b u l d e o
h a ls b de sp o e l fu di ted sr,a dGo e osa dS ei s o e des o is u p sdy o n n h eet n v m r n h rf wh f

d caeta teP eiet n teCo gescn o tlte h w t e fretelw e lr hth rsd n a d h n rs an telh m o o noc h a
i th i'sae n t er'tt. t

Bu weh v u fA n tl se ial eoe i teJm Crw rgme t a e no aey en t 1b fr :n h i o e i c n e n db Brwn tee cu ino c i rnfo tep bi sh os o d m e y o ,h x lso f hl e rm h u l c o l d c
cn e n di Pllr a dteatmp t dieChn s i mirnso t f a o d m e n ye,n h t to r iee m ga t u o S n e v

F a csoc n e n di Yc mo rn ic o d m e n ik .

2 3

S 1 7 frt it saeteu d c metdrsd nso Arz n a dter B 0 0 isvci r h n o u ne eie t f io a n h i m

c i rn 1s et it saeteLaiaorsd nso Arzn a dta ees rm hl e .t n x vci r h t / eiet f io a n rv lr fo d m n
oh rsae,rm Lai Ameia a dfo oh r o nre wh ço kl e'h y te ttsfo t n rc ,n rm te c u tis o ç o i 'te lk
aeu d c me tdi mirns r n o u ne m gat.

Bu iteemeh d c nb u e a anth u d cmetda da ant tfh s to s a e sd g iste n ou ne n g is Laiao ,h ycnb u e a ant lc a dNaieAmeia rsd nsa dte t /ste a e sd g isbak n t n v rcn eie t n h n a ant te mioie, i s orfs t g ao g a da y n es wh i o t g isoh r n rt swht wh eu e o o ln , n n o e le o s u i e

o fv r t toewh n w rl.n ed S eif p i' c lb ae atmps o f a o wi h s o o ue Id e , h rf Ar aos ee rtd te t t h

ivsiaeadpoeue onyof il jde,dtradrpr rae atn net t n rsctcut fcas ugsei sn eots rprad g i, o e
p re wh dsge wi te h v awa sb e ap ro sc argme acl o ia re t h m a e l y en at f u h e i . h

Miss p wa a lsdsceyfrvroentuttbakctes si i i s coe oit o eeyn,ojsi fc izn. sp s i
l te1 5 sa d1 6 stiNainwa rc e b teatmp t e dteJm n h 9 0 n 9 0 ,hs to s ok d y h te to n h i
Crw s se a di c n e u n e.n2 0 ,h Nainwa rc e b telr et o y tm n t o sq e c sl 0 6 te to s o k d y h ag s s

d mo srto si i hsoy drce a ant blta wa n t s e rsiea e ntain n t itr, ietd g is a i h t s o a rpesv s s l
ti o e Th Nainso l n t ep th o g teee et a an hs n . e t h ud o b u tru h h s v ns g i. o T i Co r so l srk d wnS 1 7 i is nieyb cu eivoae te hs uth ud tie o B 0 0 n t e t t ea s t ilts h r F utet Ame d e tat ls1 n 1 o teCo si t no 1 8 ,n e ey o r nh n m n, ri e a d 1 fh nt ui f 7 7 a d v r e c to d mo rt picpei teNainshsoy e cai r il n h to ' itr . cn

2 4

CONCLUS ON I F rh rao ssae ,h a iu Co lint Dee dAfimaieAcin o te e sn ttd te m c s aio o fn f t t , t rv o ltgain,mmirn Rihsa dt Fg to Eq ai b An Men Ne esr ne rt I ga t g t n o ih fr u ly y y a s c say o t

(AMN) re tiC utoafmdsi cutn tbodni hligb B ugshs ort fr irtorado rae t odn y i tc s ejiigteefre et f lapcs f B17 . nonn h nocm n o alseto S 00
ByteAmiu BAMN' atre s h cs s ton y , S C FF WASINGTON & Dll C II t
PC

:

.

Gere Wahn og B. sig ihgnB r .22 1 cia a NoP 60) S atDl e( ihgnBaNoP 5 0) hna i rM cia r .607 v
6 5Grs od-ut 1 1 4 iw l-s i 8 7 e Deri, 48 2 totMI 2 6 31 -6 -9 1 39 3 1 2 Dae : e tmb r 0 2 1 td S pe e 3 , 0 0

CERTI I ATE OF COMPLI NCE FC A

T e n es ndcrf s neR l3 () )C ote eeaRue o h u dri e eti udr ue 2a( () fh Fdrl ls f g ie 7
Ap elt Po e uea dNit Ci ut 2 1ta teatc e Amiu Bre o p l e rc d r n nh r i3 -,h th tah d c s if n a c Be af f h lo BAMN i p o o t n l sae , a atp fc o 1 p it o moe s rp ri al p cd h s y e ae f 4 ons r r oy
a d p ru n t tewodc u t etr o tewodpo esn po rm u e t n , usa to h r -o n faue fh r rcsig rga sd o

p e aeti bifc nan 56 9wod , x lsv o tematr ta ma b rp r hs re, o tis ,8 rs e cu ie fh tesh t y e

o ie udr ue 2a() )i. m t d n eR l3()7( (i t B i)
SCX FF, M NGTON, DRI ER, C. WAS & V P.
? ..
.

By:

Ro adCrz nl u At re fr c s t n y o Amiu B o Dae : e tmb r3 , 01 td S pe e 0 2 0

CERTI I ATE OFSERVI E FC C lh rb cri ta o S pe b r3 , 0 0 Isre t oc pe o aMoin eey ety h t n e tm e 0 2 1 , ev d w o is f t f o fr a et Fl aBre Amiu Cuiei S p o t fh Ap elea dapo o e o Lev o i if c s ra n u p ro te p l n rp sd e e Br f c sCuiei S p ot fh Ap eleo b h lo teCo lint i Amiu ra n u p r o te p l n e af fh aio o e e t Dee dAf n aieAcin Itgain I mirn Rihsa dFg to Eq ai fn t u t t ,ne rto ,m ga t g t, n ih fr u ly iv o t

B An Men Neesr (AMN) nteflwigpre b UntdSae mal y y as csay B o h ol n ats y i tts i o i e
p sa epe ad otg rp i:
To yWet ns De nsK. re n i Buk Arh rR. lb r tu God eg VauChlk mar r i a ri a J su Wi e fl oh a l ned k U.. prmet futc, vl vso S Deat n o JsieCiiDiiin 2 Masc u etAv n e N. . 0 sah st e u , W s W ahn tn D. . 0 3 sigo , C 2 5 0 J l J Bo ma om . u Ro et He r b rA. ny J sp G.Ad ms o eh a S el Wi e L.L.. n l& l r P m On Arz n Ce tr e io a ne 40 E. nBue 0 Va rn P o nx AZ8 0 42 0 h e i, 5 0 -2 2

Ro adCrz nl u S h f, sigo & Drv rPC. c efWahn tn ie, . Aton y frteAmiusBAMN tre s o h c

Dae : e tmb r3 , 0 0 td S pe e 0 2 1