USA v. State of Arizona, et al

Filing 136

Filed Amici Curiae - Pending Fight for Equality By Any Means Necessary and The Coalition to Defend Affirmative Action, Integration and Immigrant Rights motion to become amicus curiae. Served on 09/30/2010. [7500735] (FT)

Download PDF
R otyc.wyRCLR6 E c E Iv e M z D E. E K tsCUT F/EL J.ORO APAS . 0 T2121 C 1 22 No1-64 .0165 F R THE M NTH CI CUI O RT ,. ,- - -- jjo ju jy DT AE - IIA NI TL I I T EI TE S AT:SCOU TOFXP E L NH N DT R PA S =.... , ,= -s- , tx. S =T-TEFOFX M .R1 Aa=- =s-,,== = -- = - s =, - - y - S A S C E U --o . ,- .- = . TF )D . A. u= - . Plit f Ap ele ani - p l , f e V. .a , u- Dee d kAp elns fn a t- p t t. a .' S ATE.OF ARI ONA T Z ' DI TRI T COURT FOR DI TRI T OFARI ONA SC SC Z ONXP E UROM T EUMT DS ATE PM F H ET S THECOALI I NTO DEFEND AF I MATI EACTI N TO FR V O G TEGM TI N,MMI RANTRI HTSANDFGHTFOREQUALI Y OI G G, I T BYA YME NSNEC S MW (AMNINS P ORTOFXF I MANCE NA ES B I UP FR RONALD CRUZ GEORGEWAS I GTON HN USA v. State of Arizona, et al Doc. 136 MOTI NF RLE VET FLEAB IFAMIUSC TI EB O O A O I R E C IR A Y Aton v frAmiu tr es o c s S T D WE G AR R S TE FWASHNG ON &DRIE ,.. CTF , I T V R PC 65Grs od S i 11 4 iw l,ut 87 e Der i Mi 82 tot 4 2 6 , (1) 6-91 339312 Dockets.Justia.com P run t Rue2 o teF d rl lso CiiP o e ue teCo l int us a to l 9 fh e ea Rue f vl r cd r,h ai o o t Dee dAfi aieAcin ltgain a dl mirn Rihsa dFih fr fn fr t t ,ne rt , n m ga t g t n g t o my o o E ulyByAn Men Neesr IAMNI vso laetfeh atce q ai t y as csayB moe frev o i te t hd la Amiu CuieBre i sp o t fh Ap eleUntdSae a dafr igte c s ra ifn u p ro te p l i tts n fi n h ee m dsi cuthtst ce a E bt B . .itrse itic.trtortaiat hd s kiiX. -t neetdnhs a. tc a s. . s' e b cu eiian t n l ra iainfr e i 1 9 t fg t g is atc s nte e a s ts ai a og nz t om d n 9 5 o ih a an t t k o h o o a i mirn cmmu ie o tiNain m ga t o nt s fhs t . i o BAM N wa iial fr e t o p s ted cso b teUnv ri o snt l om d o p oe h eiin y h iest f iy y cai riReet'eiintbnafmaieato iteUCsse . tona gnsdcso o a fi t cin nh ytm B f rv sc rdterv ra o teRe et' a i 2 0 ,e tepoaf maieat n eue h e esl fh g ns b n n 0 1 1d h r-fi t -ci rv o itnr t nb su e t i Gr t rvBol g ra dog nzdten t n l ne e i y tdnsn ut . ln e ,n ra ie h ai a no e i o mo e e th t umiae i a5 ,0 -esnMac o Wahn tno ted y v m n ta c l n td n 00 0p ro rh n sigo n h a Gr t rwa ag e i teS pe eCo r. ut s ru d n h u rm u t e BAM N h sfldlg l h l n e t Mihg nsPo oa 2p n igi te a i e a c al g so c ia ' rp sl e dn n h e e SxhCi ut n t Caionas rp st n2 9p n igi teUntdSae it r ia d o l ri'P o oio 0 e dn n h i tts c f i e Ditit u to teNo tenDirc o Caio i.I1dtef h t k e Wad sr Co r frh r r s it f l m a te h i to ep r c h t f g Co n rysa t afr aieato p tinofh Arz n b l tn2 0 . n el' ni fim t cin eio fte io a al i 0 8 v t o BAM N h ssc esul ldtesu e t lo t tru h u teSaeo a u csfl e h td n wak us ho g o th tt f y Cai mi ta 1dt teata o sra c o Cea Ch v zdya ah l a i te lo a h te o h cu l b evn e f sr a e a s oi y n h f d p bi sh os1dasae iecmp int sc r apo a o teCai mi u l c o l,e ttw d a ag o e ue p rv l fh lo a c f Dra Ac,e acmp int ma eUnv ri o Caionaa Bek lya dLo e m t1d a ag o k iest f l ri t ree n s y f M g lssn taycmp ssb e p r o mac e a dcmp in frdie' ee a cu r a u e, e n at f rh s n a ag s o rv rs l e ssfr n o u etdrsd nsa dmac e a dcmp in a ant oie i n e o u d c m ne eiet,n rh s n a ag s g isp l c c b uai a an t t oa baka doh rct e sa drsd ns rtly g isLai /, lc n te iz n n eie t. t n i BAMXiantnlraiatniptgrcs atteatc o s at aognzt thi at nth t k n o o gn m a i mirn rg t Ise sla et fetiAmiu b ifnsp ot fh Ap ele m ga t ihs t ek ev o i hs c s re i u p r o te p l l e UntdSae a di sp ot fh u d c me tda doh rL t oarsd nsa d i tts n n u p r o te n o u ne n te ai / eie t n e n ct e so Ar o awh wi b vci ie b S n t Bi 1 4 i ii e e alwe izn f i n o l e it zd y e ae l 0 0 fts v r l d i z l m l o t g it efc. o o no fet BAMN asrsta ih s d ag me t i tepo o e a iu bifh t set h tt a ma e ru nsn h rp sd m c s re ta tea p l eh sn t d . h p el a o ma e e ByteAmiu BAMN' atme s h cs s t y, o S I F , II GTON & DI VER, C V F WAS-N I U PC B : RoadCu (af iSaeB o y nl rzC l a tt i . Ge reB. sigo l ia Ba No og Wahn tn c g n r . S atDr e ( i ia BaNo hna i rM c gn r . v h 6 5Grs od-ut 1 1 4 i l-s i 8 7 w e Deri, 4 2 6 totM1 8 2 31 -6 -9 1 39 3 1 2 Dae : e tmb r3 , 01 td S pe e 0 2 0 No 1 -6 4 . 01 6 5 I I THE UNI ED S ATESCOURTOFAPP ALS N TT E FOR THENI TH CI CUI N RT UM TEPSTATVSOFAMYFWA, Plitf-Ap ele an if p le , V. S ATE OFARI ONA T Z Dee da t- pp la t. fn nsA elns ON APPEAL FROM THE UNI ED S ATES TT DI TRI T COURTFOR DI TRI T OFARI ONA SC SC Z BRI FFOR THE AMI US E C COALI I N TO DEF ND AF I M ATI E ACTI N,NTEGM TI N, TO E FR V OI O I MI M NTRI HTSANDFI HTFOREQUALI YBYANYMEANS MG G, G T NE E S RY(AMN)NS P ORTOFAF I MANCE C SA B I UP FR RONALD CRUZ GEORGEWAS I GTON HN S ANTADRI ER H V Ato nv fr c s tr e s o Amiu S HEF , HI GTON, DRI ER, C. C F WAS N & V P. 6 5Grs od S i 1 1 4 iw l, ut 8 7 e Deri, 42 6 totMi 82 (1)6-91 339312 TABLE OFCONTENTS 6 1 1 ( 1 4 ) l @*@*****@@@*@@@**@**@****@*2 j *@@@@@*@@@@@*@*@*@@@*@**** i @@@@*@*@**** *@@@@@*****@@@1 i ; l L 1 1 6@***@@@@@@*********@*@@@****1 1******@*********@***********j @***@@*@@@@****@**@* * *@*** * ((ILI VI 1lI?LTS) FrJVIIIIhI.................... TEi!E II 2(I(I r ;TkT SIIr ........... ....... /I / T p hI IIIII IM. ...... . ......... S ATEM ENT OFF CTS T A 1 Bai fcsa o th u d c metdi mirnsag tdb S 1 7 .... . sc at b u te n o u ne m gat tree y B 0 0 ...3 ... l.l1 e e t lEll t teElllr( FB1)(................ 1 - e v nsetl t l ttn- l) ; (r ................ l trj l l tlt) f I C)...............6 t ARGUM ENT SB 1 7 I AN UNLAWFILASS RTI N OFC TATES' 00 S J EO G S RI HTS'N AN AREA Ar FOR A P RPOS TIAT G 'I U EJ VI LATESTl CONS I UTI N OFTlEUM TED S ATES.....1 O W TT O l T .... 1 .... A. 1 7 a awh l i a u lwfl seto o an ne itn SB 0 0 s oe s n na u asrin f o -xset ' (tt,rg,,opo ug t 1 o n1 1rt nP l y & aes 'j,t rm jae t w * - ai O1 s 1j t s mm g 0 C b cu esaeofcasaedsaif dwi fd rlmmirt n e a s tt flil r ist l t e ea l gai se h ' o B. B 1 7 ' d cae p l yo dtio tru he fre e t i S 0 0s elrd oi ft t n ho g noc m n' s c ari ' utryic n itn wi teg v rigfd rl oiy........l t l n o sse t t h o enn e ea p l ........ 6 e h c ....... C Th dsrc cu t o el fu dta fv o S 1 7 ' seii e itit o rprp ry o n ht le f B 0 0s p cfc p o ''n aeu'rylcn itn wi teg v rigfd rl rvso s r t l ' o sset t h o enn e ea ll tn e h PO 1. B 1 7 VI L TEST I F URT E T AME DMENTBY 1S 0 0 O A FE O E N H N LEGALI I G RACI LDI CRI I ATI N Ar CREATI G ZN A S MN O N CONDI I NSF R LATI A/ SI ARI ONA SM I AR TO TO O NON Z IL CONDI I NSF R BLACK P OP EI T- OL JM CROW TO O E L N IE D 1 1 S ATEM ENT OFI TERES T N T Th Co lint Dee dAfr aieAcin ltgain a dl mirn e aio o fn f m t t ,ne rto ,n m ga t t iv o Rihsn Fgto E ulyB An Men Neesr IAMNIsneetdi gtad ih fr qai y y as csay B t iitrse n ti cs b c ueii an t n l ra iainfr e i 1 9 t fg t g is hs ae e a s ts ai a og nzt om d n 9 5 o ih a an t o o rjfiu i:atc so t:imitt cmmt ie o tiNain ir fld t k n h m gl o m t s fhs t . ll a t i o BAM N wa iial fr e t o p s ted cso b teUnvri o snt l om d o p o e h e iin y h iest f iy y CaionaRe e t' e iint b naf n t eat ni teUC sse . l ri g nsd cso o a fi ai ci n h f nv o ytm B sc rdterv ra o teRe e t' a i 2 0 ,e tep oat maiea t n e ue h e esl fh g ns b n n 0 1 1d h r-fr t -ci ivo itre to b su e t i Grte v Bol ge,n ognie ten to a nevnin y td nsn utr . li ra d ra z n aln mo e e th t umiae i a5 ,0 -esnMac o Wahn tno ted y v m n ta c l n td n 00 0p ro rh n s igo n h a Gr t rwa ag e i teS pe eCo r. ut s ru d n h u rm u t e BAMN h s i dlg l h l n e t Mihg ns rp sl p n igi te a fl e a c al g s o c ia 'P o o a 2 e dn n h e e SxhCic ia dt Caio i' Po o io 2 9p n igi teUntdSae it rut n o l m as rp st n 0 e dn n h i tts f i e Ditit uto teNote Ditit f lo i.I 1dtet h t k e Wad src Co rfrh rh m src o Cai m a te h i to ep r f g Co n r ' a t afmaieato p tinofh Ar o ab l tn2 0 . n el s ni fi t cin eio f te i n al i 0 8 y -r v t z o BAMN h s u c sfl 1dtesu e t lo tt o g o th Saeo a s cesul e h td n wak usl u h u te tt f y u Caio i ta ldt teata o sra c o Cea Ch v zd ya ah l a i te l m a h te o h cu l b ev n e f sr a e a s oi y n h f d p bi sh os ldasae iecmp int sc r a po a o teCai ri u l c o l,e ttw d a ag o eue p rv l fh lona c f Dra Ac,e acmp int ma eUnv ri o Caionaa Bek lya dL s e m t1d a ag o k iest f l ri t ree n o y f An ee sn taycmp ssb e p ro mac e a dcmp in fr rv rs g ls a cu r a u e, en at f rh s n a ag s o die' l e ssfru d c me tdrsd nsa dmac e a dcmp in a ant oie i n e o n o u ne eie t, n rh s n a ag s g isp l c c b l lya an t t oa baka doh r iz n a drsd ns nt i g isLai /, lc n te ct e s n eie t. at n i BAMN i an t n l ra iainf higrcs a dteatc o s ai a og nzto g t a im n h t k n o n a i mirn rg t.Ise sla et fetiAmiu bifnsp ot fh Ap ele m ga tihs t e k ev o i hs c s re i u p ro te p l l e Untdjaeadi spotfl ud cmetbadohr aloaeietai ttsn n upro te nou ne n iett /rsdns n e t n 2 ct e so Ar o awh wi b vci ie b S n t Bi 1 7 iii e e alwe izn f i n o l e it z d y e ae l 0 0 fts v r l d i z l m l o t g it efc. o o no fet BAMN asrsta ih sma eag me t i tepo o e a iu bifh t set h tt a d ru ns n h rp sd m c s re ta teap l eh sn t d . h p el a o ma e e I DEX OFAUTHOW TI S N E Cae ss C iaop raC ua 58F3 .5 (tcr2 0)cr gat4 hcns o l as,5 .d86 9 i 09,c/ rne h. . 10SC.48(00 3 . t39 2 1) DeC ns . ia44U..5 (96 aa vBc,2 S3 1 17) 1 5 I r r L ej F 4 idrut uqD. ai rt 18) n e / e,6 .7 (t iCor C lbna 86 o c t 12,3 ,2 Pye vDo,5 U..0 (92 llr . e47 S22 18) 1 ,3 52 Yc FbvHokn, 1 U..5 (86 i k . p is18 S 36 18) Ote a torte h r u h iis Co s, r 1 sc8 c 34 ntat , e , l Co s, r2,e 2 ntat sc 1 -2 11 1 2 8 SC. 15() U.. j 37g S. . 0 0 B 17 71 ,2 pasm si CORP RATE DI CLOS RE S ATEM ENT O S UT P ru n t teF d rl ls f p l t P o e ue c u slo tea iu usa to h e ea Rue o Ap el e rcd r,o n e frh m c s a Co lint Dee dAfimaieAcin ltgaina dl mirn Rihsa dt aio o fn f tv t ,ne rt n m gat g t n o t r o o FgtoE ulyb An Men Neesr (AMN)etisht opr t ti ih fr qai y y as csayB t crf tan at ohs ie y apaiasbii' Git o agbiluwndcpoainadn pbiy /lj udy r fl e f u l yo e o rto n o u l t a c d o n dc roainta in t p r t ti a p a h s t a ca itrsi te w e op rto h ts o a at o hs p e l a a i n ilneetn h y n o to e Th a iu i aMihg nn n oic roain uc m . e m c s s c ia o - f op rto . t Ro a r n u Aton yfr c s tre o Amiu BAMN Dae S pe b r 0 2 1 . t: etm e 3 , 0 0 I TRODUCTI N N O l Pllrv Do ,h Untd Sae S pe eCo r h l ta teF ute t n ye . e te i tts u rm u t ed h t h o renh e Ame d e tpo ii d Te a fo e cu ig te c i rn o u d c mtd n m n rhbt x s rm x ldn h hl e f n o u ne e d i mirnsfo isp bi sh os T eCo r wan da an t raigalh d w m ga t rm t u l c o l. h u t re g is cet a o c ns P P lt n'atemaetcseo u d cmetdrsdn ain..dne te o uai , t r nn at f n ou ne eiet l s. e id o' P e h b n f sh to rsceyma e a albet ct e sa dlwfl eie t. Pllrv e ei ta u o it k s v i l o izn n a t rsd ns' ye . t a i l ' Do,47US22 281 (92.tdcae ta, dn igteecirna e5 0, 1-9 18)I elrd hty eyn hs hl e b d b sce u ain wed n te tea it t l ewi i tes utr o o rcvc ai d cto , e y h m h bly o i t n h t cue f u ii ivh r isi to s a dfrco ea yrait p siit ta te wi cnrb t i e e ntuin , n oels n e l i osbly h th y l o tiue n v n t sc i l tes alswa t tepo rs o o r to .1 . t 2 . h m l t y o h rges f u Nain' d a 2 3 e ' I te 2 y as sn e te ln mak d cso i Pllr te miin o n h 8 er ic h a d r eiin n ye, h lo s f l c i rn wh mih h v b e e cu e fo sh osi Te a h d n tb e hl e o g t a e en x ld d rm c o l f x s a o en d rsrie h v ma ee omo sc nrb t n t tepo rs o teNain l ter etan d a e d n r u o tiui s o h rges fh t .n h i o o oewhl igmaoi ,hy te cirn adtercirnscirnhv vr emn jry te,hi hl e n hi hl e' hl e ae t rd d d b cmep o u t ect e s e o rd ci iz n . vi T e aep l o temiin wh b g nteGra Mirto fo Me io h y r a f h lo s o e a h et gain rm xc 4 l a dCe ta Ameiaah n rdy asa o wh cmet a dtru hTe a, w n nrl rc u de er g , o a o n lo g x s Ne t M e io Arz n a d Caio i.T ee i mirnslc e tep p r gv n t xc , io a n l m a h s p ga t ak d h a es ie o f toe pe o ia t - uo en i mirnswh cmetru h pa e l e Els h s rd m n nl E rp a m gat o a ho g lc s i l y ki lln . to mu ho ta cnuy p p r ween t e d db c uetesuh r sa d Bu fr c fh t e tr, a es r o n e e e a s h o ten b re wa n t c moeta al eo ama . odr s o mu h r h n i n p n Eseil i p ro so eo o i dsrs,l eto ei Pllra d to e p cal n eid f c n m c ites i h s n ye n h s y k td y te a sn e o p p r cetd sv r h rsis frmay Me ia a d o a , h b e c f a es rae e ee adhp o n xcn n c nrl r a imtrnsB tt i nttpte io cmig f m rtn et Xmei n m gat. u idd o s im m o n ,r as g a c ot oi terc i rnh r, n fo e etal b c migp r o teAmeia n t n o h i hl e ee a d rm v nu l eo n at fh d y rcn ai , f o whc mayb cmelg l izn . ih n e a e a ct e s i Arzn ' S 17 po li sardcl dfee t oiy Aset gab rl io as B 0 0 rcam a ial ifrn p l . sri aey y c n c n eldsp o e saerg t opo li i o ni mirt np l y S cin 1 o c ae u p sd tt ih t rcam t w m gai oi , eto s oc o S 1 7 d cae ta Arz n wi fl w a p lc o lt io tru h f B 0 0 elrs h t io a l ol lo oiy f l tt n h o g a ri e fre e t' B 1 7 h scetdargmeo itno ain , tp , ret, n nocm n. S 0 0 a rae e i f ne -g t s so s arss a d ' o i pio me t h tamsn tsmpya rifrigap r a e tc sewi sc n m rsn n ta i o i l t enocn em n n at t e o d h cas rg t,b tta e piiy ams a frig a h l miin u d c me td ls ihs u h t x l t i t ocn cl af lo n o u ne l M e ia i mirnsa dterc i rnt la eArz n rte ta fc tewrt xcn m ga t n h i hl e o ev io a ah rh n ae h ah d o islws ft a . l S 1 7 wee e atd i o e sae ao e i wo l b o e omo s f B 0 0 r n ce n n tt ln , t ud e f n r u i p ra c. t n sae aetrae igt fl w Ar a T ei p ra c o m otn e Bu ma y tts r hetnn o ol i n . h m o tn e f oz ti cs h sh rfr go ne p n nil . hs ae a teeoe rw x o e tal y T edsrc c u t n teUntdSae h v d mo srtdta f es ei c h itit o r a d h i tts a e e ntae h ti p cf e v i po iin o S 1 7 aeu lwfl e a s tesaeh sn a toi t d ce i rvso s f B 0 0 r na u b cu e h tt a o uh rt o ere t y s 2 o n i mirt n p l is Bu S 1 7 i atal fr wos a d fr moe w m gai oi e . t B 0 0 s cu l a re n a r o c y u lwflh nteUntdSae h salg d BAMN st fr b lw wh ti 1w na u ta h i tts a l e . e e es ot eo y hs a h i e e wos ta teg v rmetsy i i. hsCo r so l b s isd cso s v n re h n h o en n a s t s T i ut h ud ae t eiin uhligadepn igteijnt no tesudsp sil lgl rud s podn n xadn h nuci n h onet os e eagon s o o b tan pro o Ameta stwi eeaa hv tfc tedaoinrgme hto esn n r n ol l vr gt aeo aeh rcna ei c l n a du lwfl u o eta aee b de i Arz n ' n w lw. n na u p m s h t r m o id n io as e a S ATEM ENTOFF CTS T A 1 Bai fcs b u teu d cmetdi mirnsag tdb S 1 7 . . sc at a o th n ou ne m ga t tree y B 0 0 W eb gnwi asae e t o o tefcsrg rigteapiaino ti e i t ttm n n t f h at e adn h p l t fhs h co lw, e a s to eh v n ty th p e e , u o tec mmo l-ce td fcs a b cu e h s a e o e ap n d b t f h o nyacpe at a o t u d c me td i mirns a o t Arz n , a d a o tte hsoy a d b u n o u ne m ga t, b u io a n b u h itr n epesdp ro eofS 1 7 . x rse up s B 0 0 By te b s et ae a albe tee ae a o t ee e miin h et si ts v i l, h r r b u lv n lo m a l u d cmetdrsd nsi teUntdSae,n ldn 15miinc i rnu d r n o u ne eie t n h i tts icu ig . lo hl e n e e l d 1 . tin mb rmu t ea d da oh rfu mil nc i rnwh aeAmeia 8 To hs u e sb d e n te o r lo hl e o r rc n id ct e sb cu e te weeb r t teeu d c me td i mirnswhl te izn e a s h y r on o h s n o u ne m ga t i h y i e rsd d i teUntd Sae.Ap rxmaey 5 p re to teeu d c me td eie n h i tts po i tl 0 ecn f h s n o u ne e wokr h v b e i teUntd Sae frtny as a po i aey 1 p re t res a e en n h i tts o e er; p rxm tl 0 ecn e h v b e h r frmoeta 2 y as Nieyp reto tet d c me tdme a e en ee o r h n 0 e r. n t ecn fh m o u ne n 3 a d7 p reto u d c me tdwo e at eyp riiaei teUSlb rfre n 0 ecn f n ou ne m n ci l at p t n h v c a o oc . l ten to a awh l, b u 6 p re t f n o u e tdi mirnsc mefo n h ain s oe a o t 0 ecn o u d c m ne m ga t o rm M e io. xc 1 Arz n ' p p lt n whc i et ae t b a o tah l miin dfes io as o uai , ih s si td o e b u af lo , ifr o m l sme h tfo ten t n la ea e Ab u nn t p re tc mefo Me io a o w a rm h ai a v rg . o t iey ecn o rm xc ; o lr e b tu k o n sae o te rmann tn p ret cme fo Ce ta ag , u n n w , h r f h e iig e ecn o s rm nrl Ameia T ep retg o c i rn a o gteu d c me tdrs e t i as rc . h ecna e f hl e m n h n o u ne ei ns s lo d d hg e ta ten t n l v rg ,h teeaepo ot n tl moemio c i rn ih rh n h ai a a ea e a d h r r rp ri aey r n r hl e o o d ta i ten to a awh l wh aeAmeia ct e sb vru o b igb r i h n n h ain s oe o r rcn izn y ite f en on n i ti c u ty.2 hs o nr l rcn d c d s A io ah sb e o e o te n to ' fsetgo ig n ee t ea e, lz n a en n f h ain s ats-rw n sae,b t dmo rp ial a d e o o ial.Bewen 1 8 a d 2 0 ,i tts oh e ga hc l n c n m cl t e 9 0 n 0 8 t y y s p p lt nmoeta d u ldfo 27miint 65miin go ig fo te o uai r h n o be rm . lo o . lo , rw n rm h o l l 2 t1rett tel tlretsaei teUno . l ti sa , io asLaiao 9h ag s o h 4h ag s tt n h in n hs p n Arz n ' t / n pp linmoeta qarpe f m nal 4 1 0 (6prett amot2 ouao r hn uduld r er 4 , 0 1 ecn) o l s t o y0 1JfryS.Pasl n D' eaCo n t P rrio Un uh rz dl mirnsi efe se a d V r h ,t otat f a toie m g a t n A teUntdSae,Pe Hip ncCe trApi1 , 0 9 a i, , v i bea h i tts' w s a i ne, rl 4 2 0 ,ti4 a al l t e ' a h p/ e hsai.grpl/ pdppRep l=l7(eef rtoti' l :pw i nco / o seo .h ? pdD o hrat ,t raf) / p re r epr ; h p/ e hsai.r/ pd/ pdppR plD=l6(eef r&S :pw i ncogr o seo .h ? eo l z hrat C /p er eU Unlsarcdn mirt nFo s) irto La atoie l gai s lw '. uh z m io o w m ' 2G- p n sa dArz n ' Ne l m g ain w,' w Hipa i Ce trApi Gi i l a 'Pe s nc ne, rl 2,00a52 ,vibeaht:pwrsac. Vpb/sga zn92 1,t , 1aal l t t / e eerho u sl7/d oa a p/ r i mirto -a -ats ethsa i-o uaino iindsrmiain m gainlw fc-h e-ip ncp p lto -pno -ici n t o 4 J fryPasl n D' eaCom, S Un uh rz dl mirt nFo saeDo n efe se a d V r l U.. a toie m gai lw r w o S apySn eMi- ea e'Pe Hip ncCetr S p. , 0 0 a i, v i bea h rl ic dD cd , w sa i ne, e t 12 1 , tv a al l t ' a miin(0 ecn) l 20,bu 3 pret f ioas aia rs ethd lo 3 pret. n 06aot 7 ecn o Ar n'Lt / ei ns a l 3 z no d b e b r i a oh rc u ty4Ofto e 7 .7p re tween tct e sa do l en on n n te o nr. h s, 9 ecn r o iz n n ny i 234p re te o tdta te s o eEn l h eywej, , . ecn rp r h th y p k e gi r j.5 sv As i te e t e S uh et erir g n rto s o Me ia a d oh r n h ni o tw s, al e eain f xcn n te r e Laiao i mirnsb i terio d ,d gtemie, n tn e teco sta t / m ga t ul h al a s u h n s a d e d d h rp h t n t r li tefu d t n frteArz n o td y I moercn y as teArz n ad h o n ai s o h io a f o a . n r e et er,h io a o Ch mb ro Co mec h satb tdtesaesrmak bego t t i Me ia a e f m re a tr ue h tt' e ra l rw h o t xcn i s i mirns m ga t' . jb fr rcn adimirns le, osoAmeias n m gatai . k, 6 I' n acd n ta Ar o a a d Grae P o nx h v b e a o g te ts o cie t h t i n n etr h e i a e e n m n h z fsetgo ig eo o isi ten to frn al t od cd s A rpdy ats-rw n c n m e n h ain o ery w ea e. a il g o ig i mirn p p lto fee tern wa c ntut n b o ,a rw n m ga t o uain uld h u a y o srci o m s o Ar o awa se a api es o fred ryp o l t rt e ab o ta i n s en s r p t o lel e pe o ei , o m h t z m r do etesaes ra -ae e o o i ep n in a ep ninta cetd rv h tt'bo db sd c n m c x a so , n x a so h t rae 3San , g lo ' aio, i sa dteS it gDe o rp yo Arz n ' e z Ro ei, L t sWht , n h hfi m ga h f io a . n e n Po uainReee c Bueu Th d t u e i tirp rc mefo tefl wig p lt frn e ra . e aa sd n hs e o t o rm h ol n o o suc sF a kHo b a dNioeSo p , mo rphcTe d i te2 t o re : rn b s n c l to sDe g a i rn s n h 0h C nuy C nu 2 0 Seil eot Sre C N R- ( ahntnDC: S etr ess 00 p caRp r, ei E S 4W sigo , U.. ss Cess ueu 20)adte18 5 P biUs Mi oaaSmpeIIMS, nu B ra,02;n h 9 0 % ul e c dt a l PJ I c r 1 9 5 P J S 2 0 5 P J S a d2 0 ACSS mpe d wno d dfo 9 0 % LM , 0 0 % IM ,n 0 8 a l, o la e rm Se e Ru ge e a.I tg ae Pu l Us Mir d t S re.V rin tv n g ls t 1 ner td bi e co aa eis eso , c 50( i ep l: iesyo Minst,00,cesd . M r aoi Unvri f neoa2 1)acse ms t a ht:us. unsogu iid x.hmlo J l 21201 . t tp/ ai l .r/s n e st , n uy , 0 /p 4 e: Hip ncCe tr' rz n : o uaina dLa o F reCh rceitc, P v s a i ne A io a P p lt n b r oc aatrsis o 2 0 -0 6.p. . 0 02 0 ' 3 , 5 bd li 6' rz n n e sasa l,lg l rfre'T eArz n Re u l , rl , 0 8 A io a e d tbe e a wok oc , h io a p bi Api1 2 0 . c 5 l 2 0 , mis ti te e d u p p lt ngo t, io asu e po me trt n 0 6 a d ths rm n o s o uai rw h Ar n ' n m ly n ae o z 7 so da o l 33p re t to t ny . ecn. T eu d cmetdi mirnsh v g n rl fldteh retlw-a ig h n o u ne m ga t a e e eal ie h ad s,o p yn yl jb i Aro a I i ntr ul htsmmes whr tmprtrsrglr os n i n. n t ooi s o u r, ee e eaue eual z s oy y ci bt 10d ge s teewee 1 60 0frinb m Laiao d c me tda d l o 1 e re,h r r 0 ,0 oeg -o t /, o u ne n m n u d c me td cn t cinwok r i 2 0 -whc wa o e 4 p re to te n o u ne , o sm t o res n 0 6- ih s v r 3 ecn f h saes ttlo 2 50 0 c ntuto wok r. l 2 0 ,i i et ae ta tt' oa f 4 ,0 o s cin res8 n 0 9 t s si td h t r m u d c me tdi mirnsc ntue 75p re to Ar o aslb rfre wi n o u ne m ga t o si td . ecn f i n ' a o oc, t t z h ma y scos o te e o o y h vn fr lre sae o u d c metd n etr f h c n m a ig a ag r h rs f n ou ne i mirns m gat. 9 l. Th e e t la igt tea o to o S 1 7 . l e v nse dn o h d pin f B 0 0 AsArz n ' Laiaoa du d c me tdp p lt nge - a dep cal io as t / n n ou ne o uai rw n s e il n o y atr e o o i c n io s b g n t wosn te mo t c n ev t e p lia fe cn m c o dt n e a o re - h s o srai oic l i v t la esi Ar o ab g nwinn eet n b so sr glwsta i p sdn w ed r n i n e a n ig lci s y p n oi a h t m o e e z o n h rs iso Arz n 'u d c me tdwok r. adhp n io as n o u ne res ThsCo r i fmia wi ma yo to elws l 2 0 , io ad ne al i uts a l r t n f h s a .n 0 4 Ar n e id 1 ih z p bi ass: c t u d c metd wok r a d rq i d alp bi ot il t u l sitn e o n o u ne res n eur 1 u l f cas o c e ci 7' rz n su eeo i mirt na g r b sn s,'Wal rc J un l A io a q ez n m gai n es uies' lNfc/ o r a, o Dee b r1 , 0 7 cm e 4 2 0 . S evHip ncCe tr ' rz n : p lt na dLa o F reCh rceit s P s sa i ne, A io a Po uai n b r oc aatrsi , o c 2 0 -0 6'p. 7. 0 02 0 ' 2 , 9 e Hip ncCe tr ' .. a toie l mitt nF o s eDo nS apy P w sa i ne, U S Un uh rzd m gai lw Ar w h rl o Sn eMi- ea e' . . ic dD c d ,p 9 6 rp r t i mirt na toie a yu d c me tdrsdn wh a pidfrs c e oto m gai uh ris n n o u ne eie t o p l o u h o t e assa c.n2 0 ,t v tr p se arfrn u rq iiga1e po est u e sitn e I 0 7 i oes asd eee d m e ur 1 m ly r o s s n te E-eiy sse b fr hrn wok r- a s se ta Co ges h d n t h v rf ytm eoe iig res y tm h t n rs a o ma d td Th t1w i n w b igc aln e i teS p e eCo r. ia o Po n ae . a a s o en h l g d n h u rm u tChc n s r e L C ua Ic vNaoi n, 5 F3 86(t Cr 09,..ga. ,3 -Z .. a as,n. . p la o 5 8 .d 5 9h i. 0)cr. rne l0S. . t 2 ef t . .. -. C.48(00. t39 2 1) I Maio aCo ny b frh lret o nyi Arz n , t ap p lt n n rc p u t- y a te ag s c u t n io a wi o uai h o e ce igta o 2 sae- s eifJsp Araoh slu c e wa e o s ep , x e dn h t f 4 tts h r o eh p i a an h d v s f w e s f a v t,ad icreain o u d c metd i mirns I Jn ay 2 0 ,te n ss n n acrt s f n o u ne m gat. n a u r 0 7 h o Untd Sae De at eto J siesg e a a re e twi Maio aCo ny i tts p r n f utc in d n gem n t rcp u t e m h udrSco 27g o tel mirt nadNainlyAc. U.... 37g. ne et n 8() fh m gai n t ai t8 SC s15() i o ot T e a re e ta toie alwe te S ei sdp t st e fre u d rte h gem n uh r d l d h h r f e ui o noc, n e h zo f e sp riin o te JsieDe at e t te fd rli mirto lws Maio a u evso f h utc p rm n, h e ea m gain a . rcp Co nyb cmetef s lcl g n ywi tep we t ma ei mirt narss u t ea h i t o a a e c t h o r o k m gai ret r h o o te sre a d t tl to e arse o e t l mirt n a d Cu tms n h tet n o u' h s retd v r o m gai n so n o E fre etlE. nocm n (C ) Af rc mpansa an ta il rfl ga darss f t ao frh mot t o lit g isrca poii n ret o Lai /s o te s e n n mio ofne i n meos dpr et oeaig udr Scin 2 7g nr f s n u ru eat ns prt n e et 8() e m n o are et,C ise anw s n adzdme oadm o are et( OA) gep ns lE sud e t drie m rnu f gem n M a ta ste fre e t roie a rmo igi mirnswh h db e c n itdo h t e noc m n p irt s s e vn m ga t o a en o vce f i 7 sr u ofn e, op sdatra t p bi sft,o h dwh h dara yb e ei s fe ss wh o e heto u l aey r a o a l d en o c e odrdrmo e b tei mirt nc ut.1l Se tmb r2 0 , fe wieped r ee e v d y h m gai o rs 0 n p e 0 9 atr d sra o cn e n to o Ar ao a d hs s ep a d masarsso Laiao ,1l E o d m ain f p i n i w e s n s ret f t /s1 C n cn eld te Maio a Co ny S ei s a toi t ma e sre arssu d r a cl h rc p u t h rf ' uh ry o k tet ret n e e f t scinj tg. piwa dl n: et ()Arao s e at o 1d n' n e tefd t d my ci esp rsin t o tt ars o t ed h e s o o rm u p eso o p o ret ie as lcn d i wi o ttefd rla toi , a d 1m g ig t l g l. a o t t u h e ea uh ry n ' on o l h t c niu t d i l ma e n dfee c. l h lsu . c ueld n' o t e o o t t k s o ifrn e t ep s Be a s o t n . h v t d altep p m okfrtefd ,n mb ro e An n mb r ae o o l h a e r o h es u e n . d u e t o 1 n'b u drteru bel,h ig ia c .S l lo eae w , wo t e n e h i m rl ter udn e o wi p rt a l tl S l . c ** ' * ap t ,fte d n' 11big tm my ef oteb r ek.The ce th m i h y o t ' r e slt h od r. y ,1n wat ou emet g t i o ti 2 7a re etars tec u ty...l n t s o e rd fhs 8 gem n cos h o nr wi d a oh rci esp rsinv r so t s o Wahn tna d l o n te r u peso ey o n o h w s igo n l m Co ges b alg d rca po l g iv siain b te J sie n rs, y l e a il rf m p etgto s y h utc e De at e tb alh s d mo s aos teep liin ,a1rigt p r n, y 1tee e nt tr,h s oica s 1tyn o m r t sprsingwepqwearsay oyta voae telw.fwe upes s es r t nb d ht il sh a I o e t f dd r gtearssta teeaeie as wears te . w te i ui h ret h th r r l g l, ret h m No h nn l ol df rne(q ' g igt tk dw t IE 1 oete ny ieec i wer on o ae e o n o C . hp hy f se m eeyoy es 1 ntcagn,lwi ntb it iae b vrbd l ' o hnij l o e ni dtd y em l m ke mef m digmyjb s ntigwi cag.tytnd1 ep r on o,o ohn l hneSa ue. o l 2 1Ln soteMOAso a1cie 8() rga s a b fu daIE 0 ik t h fr 1at 2 7g porm cn eon tC > v Deeainol mirtnAuh ry l t f m gai toi go o t h p/ . eg vp/e sfcset/et n 8 ghm. l :- i .o /i w /ath essci z 7 . t /c n o jSn eJn 2 0 ,teU.. p r et f ut eh s eniv siaig l ic u e 0 8 h S De at n o J si- a b e n et t m c gn alg t n o cvlr hsvoain fr ail rsigb teMaio aCo ny l ai s f ii i t ilt s o rcap o l y h rcp u t eo -g o n S eif Ofie OnS pe b r2 2 1 ,h U.S.utc De at e tse Arao h rfs f . e tm e , 0 0 te J sie p rm n u d p i c fr euigt c mpywi rq et fr o u e t,jitusaditriwsht o rfsn o o l t e u ss o d c m ns alor,n neve ta h teJsieDe at e t a b e rq et gfr1 mo tsArz n Re u lc h utc p rm n h d en e u si o 7 nh . io a p bi, n ' h rfJ eAr aose b J sieDe at e tncvlr hs rb ' S p. S eif o p i u d y u t p rm n i ii i t po e' e t3, c -g , 2 1. 00 1Ph e iNe Ti e,Je piDein o 27g,Vo s' ohigWil 2 o nx w m s 'o Arao t tn 8() w N t n l a Ch n e' h etn t De ot xcn Hi sl' t5, 0 . a g ,T rae s o p rMe ia s m ef Oc. 20 9 8 S ot atrArao amo n e hsd f n eo Co gesa d teJ sie h rl fe p i l u c d i e a c f n rs n h u t y c De at e t Arz n Sae S n trRu sl P ac , a fr e Maio a Co ny p rm n, io a tt e ao sel ere om r rc p u t dp t a d a ln -i eArao al,it d cd S n t Bi 1 7 . On amota e uy n o gt m p i l nr u e e ae l 0 0 yo l ls srih p yl v p,h Ltilmr pse ia d o Api2 ,2 1 ,Go e o tag t m i o tq gsa e asd t n , n rl 3 0 0 v m r n Jnc Brwe sg e i it lw.S ei Ar ao te nn u cd ta h wa a ie e r in d t no a h rf p i h n n o n e h t e s f o e ig tn cte t h u e te pio es ep ce u d r S 1 7 ,po dy p nn e t i s o o s h rsnr x etd n e B 0 0 ru l i po li igta tetmp rtr isd tetnswo l rah 1 5d gesi te rcam n h t h e eaue n ie h et ud ec 3 e re n h p siit o amig ou te p se't e freS 1 7 .1 osbly f r n d lner o ss o noc B 0 0 3 i v ' Nain la dAr o acvlihsog nz t n fldato sc aln igS t a n i n iirg t ra iai s ie cin h l gn B o z o e 1 7 wel eoeJ l 2 , 0 0 wh niwa t g it efc. Afe smed ly 0 0 lb fr uy 9 2 1 , e t s o o no fet tr o ea , teUntdSae fe a a t n algn ta S 1 7 wa iv l i i ttly h i tts i d n ci l ig h t B 0 0 s n ai n t oai e l oe dst b cuetesaeh dn rg top o ug t i o ni mirt np l is e a s h tt a o ih t rm lae t w m gai oi e. s oc OnJ l 2 , 0 0 tedsrc c ut rne teUntdSae ' to fra uy 8 2 1 ,h itit o r ga td h i tts moin o e peiiyiu cin Irfsdt siedwntewh l l , u iddrsa rl nr n nt .teue o tk o h oe a btt i et i m jo r w rn i pe et gtef emot rc na p o iin . m lm ni h i s dao in rvso s n v . h p/ lg .h e i e i e .o atr/o gl / e ap i- d fa tr - z8 g.. d : o s o nu M m s e sadz o /ol rao ein- e 7 a +p c ' o n .h dp p 1< et tCee rts1tAn iesr,'rsrlaeMai p C ut 3G nci lb ae 7h nv ray Pese s, roa ony Ty ' e c Vou te P sellg lmmirt nEnocmet l'Prs rlae S pe b r lner os l a l gai fre n Unt' es ee s, e tm e e o , 1 , 0 0 b t a albea www. coog 5 2 1 , oh v i l t m s .r . a 9 Seiluy2,00adthrf pliPamijSae fr r e hrtJl 021,n I ei Araon lr n tgso Am d f sf * S cin 2srq ie e tta saeo lclp l ema ig a y lwflso eto ' e urm n h t tt r o a oi kn n a u tp c mutiv siaetep ro ' i mirt n sau i te h v Ees n be s n et t h esn s m gai tts f h y a e t ao a l g o r s siin'h th idvd a i i teUntdSae u lwfl upco 'ta te n iiu ls n h i tts na ul e y * S cin 2s fr e rq i me tta i a idvd a i arse fra y et ' ut r e ur n h t f n n iiu l s retd o n o h e voain icu ig u p i p rig t k t,tesaeo lclp l emut ilt , n ldn n ad akn i es h tt r o a oi s o c c d ti teidvd a u tlt a b v rfe ta h o s ei a toie t b ean h n iiu l niicn e ei d h t e r h s uh r d o e i z i teUntdSae. n h i tts e * S cin3scet no asaemid men rfra yn nct e wh h sn t et ' rai f tt s e a o o n o -izn o a o o o i rgs rdwi teDeatet f meadScry(HS o wh de eiee t h pr n o Ho ln eui D ) r o os t h m t n t a eo hsp ro tea po r t fd rl e itaind c me t. o h v n i esn h p rp i e e ea rgsrt o u ns a o * S cin5sceto o asaemid men rfra u d c me tdi mirn eto ' rain f tt se a o o n n o u ne m g at wh a pisfrsl i , r efr s r . o p l o,oi t o p rom wok e cs * S cin6srq ie e tta saeo lc l oieof esars sme n i et ' e urm n h t tt r o a p l fi r ret o o e f o cc te h v po a l cu et b l v ta teidvd a cmmie ap bi h y a e rb be a s o ei e h t h n iiu l o t d u l e t c ofn ema ighm o h re o a l'fo teUntdSae. fe s kn i r e m v be'rm h i tts r e T edsi cut i nteji Scin5sa ed ett apexsn h irt or dd o non et ' m nm n o reiig tc o t saueb n n teh roigo cn el go a u d c me tdi mirn a dte ttt a i g h ab r r o cai f n n o u ne m ga t n h n n UntdSae h dn tse ic l c aln e po iin ma igiaci et bo k i tts a o p cf al h l g d rvso s kn t rm o lc e iy e o i p d tat b a u d c me tdi mirn e trn aso p dmoo v hce r m e e rf y n n o u ne m ga t neig tp e tr e il k crfrta so towoko fradie o a yct e si sau t bo ktafci a o rnp r t r r o r r f n izn hp tts o lc rfi n v i od roo ti wok r. re t ban res Asstfrhb lw, e ot eo BAMN fl sp o ttedsrc c uts pno srdh ul u p rs h itit o r'o iin ti g y l d wnf eo temotda o inpo iin o S 1 7 .F rterao sstfr o i f h s rcna rvso s f B 0 0 o h e sn e ot v h b lw, o e e, eo h w v r BAMN asrsta ti Co r s o l rsri e fre e to te set h ths ut h ud etan nocm n fh s eicpo iin a dtee t esaueb cu ei i b sd o a asrin o p cf rvso s n h ni ttt ea s t s ae n n set f i r o 1 0 tt' rg t'ta i ie t a t tecamsta sge ainssma eag n rt n laes ihs h ts d ni lo h li h t e rg t it d e eai s ' c o o a o b cu ei i a e pii atmp t u e saep we t freah l miin g , e a s t s n x l t t t o s tt o r o oc af lo ce l M e ia a dCeta A>eia i mirnst f etesae a db cu ei k y xcn n nrl rcn m gat o l h tt, n ea s t e e s P O iin aee e moedao in a d u lwflta teds itc uto te rVSO S r v n r rc na n na u h n h it c o r r h r UntdSae h v sae . i tts a e ttd e T i Cor sol ss i teiu cin o tebods ad su ds hs ut hud utn h n nt n h raet n on et a jo go n s p sil b cu e ru d osbe ea s h l miin Me ia a d Ce ta Ameia af lo l xcn n nrl rcn i mirnsso l n t efcdwi tec oc o f en tesaerte ta fc m ga t h ud o b a e t h h ie f l ig h tt ah rh n ae h e tewrt o teu lwfl rsd ta h sb e lt c e a anth m. h ah fh na u cua e h t a en am h d g is te ARGUM ENT SB 1 7 I AN UNLAW FUL ASS RTI N OF R TATES'RI HTS' 00 S EO S G ' I AN AREA AND FOR A P RPOS THAT VI LATES THE N U E O CONS I UTI N OFTHE UNI ED S ATES TT O TT . A. S 1 7 a awh l i a u lwfl set no an ne itn ttt rg t B 0 0 s oe s n na u asri f o -xse tt ae ih' o s ' t po ug t i o n i mirto p l y b cu e sae ofcas ae o rm lae t w m gain oi ea s tt f il r s c i dsaif dwi fd rlmmirt np l is ist i t e ea i gai oi e. se h oc Th Untd Sae Co si t n s ei cl ga t Co gestep we t e i tts ntui p ct al rns n rs h o r o e to iy etbiha nfr r l o n trl ain' n t le uaec mmec wi frin sa l iom ue f au ai to 'a d o g lt o re t oeg su z r h nains'a d i ga t tePrsd n tepo e t c nd c teNain' frin to , n t rns h eie t h w r o o u t h to s oeg ' rlto s icu igto eap cso frin rlt n rltdt tetet e to eain , n ldn h s set f oeg eai s eae o h ram n f o n nct e si ti c u tya do Ameia ct e sa ra . ntat1 sc8 c o -iz n n hs o nr n f r n izn bo d Co s, r , e , l i ci 34 at , e 2 Fo o e t ocnuis teS p e eCo r h sh l ta toe -; r 2 sc . r v r w e tre,h u rm u t a ed h t h s po iin gattefdrlg v rmete cu ie atoi t d tr ie t h rvso s rn h e ea o en n x lsv uh rt o eem n l o y w s o l a dso l n t ea mitdit tec u t a dtec n io su d r ih h ud n h ud o b d t no h o nr n h o dt n n e whc e y i alg l nrn ma rman'DeC n sv Bi ,2 U..5,5 (96. e a e ta t y e i. a a . c 44 S 3 134 17) ' a S cin 1o S 17 p y l sriet teUntdSae Co si inb eto f B 0 0 a s i evc o h i tts n tm o y p e t asrn taAr oahs lo pln itrsitecoeaieefre etf setg ht i n a at m elg neetn h op rt nocm n o i z ci v fdrlimirtn /w . SB.17,5 1(mpai add.Ar oasBr f eea m gai tw' . 00 o z' e hss de) i n ' i z e e p n so ti te eb asdigta tesaei atmpigt ti'tefd rl x a d n hs h m y se n h t h tt s t t o d'h e ea en a gvrmetadta i ass nesol b ecme'rte ta r etd o en n n ht t siac hud e lo d' ahr hn e ce st w j (r . ra1. A i B ,t) z Bu teeasrin aerdc lu . h UntdSae h sma ecerta i th s set s r iiuo s T e i tts a d la h tt o e d e n twatte i o p rt n'ta S 1 7 sp oe l ofr. Un e te o s o n h E o eai ' h t B 0 0 u p sdy fes d r h c o S pe ayClu e Arz n h sn rg t ofretefdrl o en e t oac p u rm c a s, io a a o ih t oc h e ea g v rm n t c e t Goprt n'hth fdrlo e met a rjce. oeai ' ate eeagvm nhseetd c ot ld e ,tewh l cam o c o eain in rsrai atg te. Asst n ed h oe li f o p rt g oe ely lo eh r o t e fr i teSae eto Fat, n rs h sa toie teAton yGe ea t ot n h ttm n f cs Co ges a uh rz d h tre n rl o h s n27g are et wi lcl oieaece t efreapcso fdrl i 8() gem ns t oa p l gnis o noc set f eea g h c i mirt nlw. tCo gesisse ta tefd rl o e n e tsp riete m gai a Bu n rs n itd h t h e ea g v nm n u evs h o saeotcr t as eta te crido tfd rln tsaep ir is 8US j tt f es o sm h t h y are u e ea, o tt r ie. i ot C 15() 37g. l 2 0,mmirt nadC so s nocmetlE s ndaco eain n 07l gai n utm E fre n ( )i e oprt o Cg o are e t t Arz n 'mot rmie ta e fre e t g n y teMaio a gem n wi io as spo n n 1w nocm n a e c - h rc p h Co nyS eifsOfie Bu i Oco e 2 0 ,1Etep ro o Scin2 7g u t h rf fc . t n tb r 0 9 C h otn f et 8() i o a toiigsre arssb cu eteS eifsOfieh dfi dt fl w fdrl uh rzn tet ret ea s h h rf fc a al o ol e ea e o p l is S eifArao te d f nl amo n e ta h wo l so c n u t oi e . h rf p i h n ei t r u cd h t e ud o n o d c c ay a oh ri mirto s epa dpo li e ta h wo l o b it iae b n te m gain w e n rcam d h t e ud d t e ni d td y n m C n rs,oj yalgdpoin ivsgt n b teJsc Deatet'S e oges(rb l e rfig n et ai s y h ut e pr n.' e e l io i m spa a 6 u r, t . Arz n SaeS n trRu slP ac po o e a dteArz n Le iltr io a tt e ao sel ere rp sd n h io a gsaue eatd S 17 t gv S ei Arao adohr as t sa t t jsf nce B 00 o ie hrf pi n tes te tt e o uty f au i cniu t n o tesmepl ista tefdrlgvrmethdrjce a o t ai f h a oi e ht h eea oen n a eetd s no c ic n itn wi fd rllw. S eifArao l eBulComo i Bi ig a , n o sse t t e ea a h rf p i, i l l r n r n h m h k m c uda and cd wh th i mirto p lce wo l b i Maio aCo ny o l g i eie a te m gain oiis ud e n rc p u t. Go e o Brwe si a mu h wh n se sg e te lw. S 1 7 ,se v m r e r ad s c e h in d h a B 0 0 h d cae , sao l ta Arz n c udu et Cov acii weddn tcet elrd wa l ' h t io a o l s o le rss i o rae t' s a d te fd rlg v rme th s rfsd t f ... te cii cu e b ilg l n h e ea o en n a eue o i h rss a sd y le a x i mirt na dAr o as oo s od r'l m gai n i n 'p ru b re.'4 o z 1Go e o Jnc Brwe,ttme t yGo en r e e o S 1 7 ' c nb 4 v m r a ie e r ae n b v ro Brw r n B 0 0' a e s ft da: om t , h p/ag v mo.o /ms po A R 0 2 1 Sae e t y o en r n B1 7 . l : z o e r vd / la / g u 4 3 0 ttm nB G v roo s 0 0p 1 3 Th s ae fec a d d f n asrin o ttt' rg t.' l Arz nas ee r ire n ei t set s f t aes ihs' f io ' a o s ofcasb l v te fd rlg v mme tsp l y i n tSo g ' e o g , te fiil ei e h e ea o e n' oi s o u h' n u h h n e c t Arz n wi s'tepo lm. fMe io a dten to so Lai Ameiaf e io a l x'h rbe l xc n h ain f t lt n rc l dpo ai p oet o e r e v lnerp se' h nig i mirns i te ilm t rtss v r m d ou te o ss u t m ga t n h c a 'n d sr, io asS ceayo Saewi h n l to epoet. l Caionaa d eetArz n ' ertr f tt l a de h s rtss f l ri n l f Ne Meioojc ta S 17 i afcigtereoo yadtercies w xc betht B 00 s fet hi cnm n hi izn n t whnte t vlhog Ar oatoe bet n cnas b inrdbcueh e hy r etruh i n,hs ojci s a l egoe easte a z o o sv rinsaeo Arzn h sso e . o eeg tt f io a a p k n I a atmp t d fn ti lw, io actsioae p rssfo fd rl n n t to ee d hs a Arz n i s ltd hae rm e ea e e saue a toiig c o eain i tes aig o ifr ain a d assa c o ttts uh rzn o p rt n h h rn f n om t n sitn e n o o prclrars (r o aBr f a 2) B tte ra peeetspotg atua ret A i n i , t 7. u h el rcdn uprn i sz e i Ar o asasro o p we i n tsauoypl sstm 9o terc ne tb t i n ' set n f o r s o tttr lae o m h i o tx, u z i r tuh r is l e te 1 5 o ten Ma iet' o S uh r c n rsme i toie' i h 9 6 uh l nfso' f o ten o ges n n a t 'k s' rsos tB o nvB adoE uain eppeo rw . o r f d ct . o Th suh m cn rsme d cae tero e d f n eo fdrlatmps e o te o ges n elrd h i p n ei c f e ea te t a t e fre teBr wn d cso .T e d n u cd fd rl e des' v we t o noc h o eiin h y e o n e e ea d lr,' o d o m u h l terl a i ,rdt n ,adwa o le'a dd cae ta te ,no te p od h i bt ta io s n y f i , n e lrd h t h y t h hs i f' c ut,wee te f a abtr o wh tte Fo renh Ame d e trq ie .1 o rs r h i l ri s f a h u tet n e n m n e urd 5 1 'eS uh r Ma iet.'Fo Co g eso a Reo d 8 t Co gesS c n 5h o ten nfso ' rm n rsin l c r , 4h n rs e o d f P it gOf e 1 5 . 4 94 6 . r i t , 9 6 4 5 -4 0 nn k SsihVo.0,at ( ac 1,96. sigo, C.Goen etl es . l12pr4M rh 2 15)WahntnD. : vrm na o 1 4 Go en rBrwe,u p re b S n tr ere S eif p i a doh r, a li v r o e r sp otd y e ao P ac, h rf Arao n tesh s ad cam t Arz n ' rg tt st io asi mirto p l yi tesmewa ta li o io as ih o e Arz n ' m gain oi n h a c y ht Go e o Ge reWalc o c li cam t Alb masih't stp l isfr v m r og l e n e ad li o a a ' g t o e oi e o a r' c i sh os t c o l. s Go e o Brwe,ieGo n rWalc b fr h r isssta seh sn v m r e r l v r o l e eoe e,nit h t h a o k a h sit t ayp riua rc .n e d S 1 7 rp ae l d cae ta tees al oti o n at lr ae ld e , B 0 0 e etdy elrsh th r h l ly c b n rca dsr iaini tee fre eto telw. teey n k o ,ta e o ail ici n t n h n ocm n fh a Bu v ro e n wsh t mo ti ls i drce a ah l miin u d c me td i mirnswh aeamot hs av s ietd t af lo n ou ne m gat o r l s l e t eyo Me ia o Ceta Ameia d se tEv ro ek o sta teo l ni l f xcn r nrl rcn ecn. ey n n w h t h ny r p o l so p d q et n d a d d tie u d ri po iin wi b Laiao . epe tp e , u si e n ean d n e t rvso s l e t /s o s l n I de ,ac n ce t u p l e ofcr at g i teb s o g o fi , wi s n e d o sini s oi f e, ci n h et f o d at l o o ci n hl e frete lw b c ue h ,to k o sta amotte o l p o l wh ae n o h a e a s e o , n w h t l s h ny epe o r u d c metdi mirnsnArz n aeLaiao . n ou ne m ga t i io a r t /s n Th dsrc c uta d faky teUntd Sae h v atmpe t in r e i it o r n ,rl l,h i tts a e te td p g oe t e teiseo rc b cu etesaueh sn t e b e apid Bu o e ah n rd h su f ae e a s h ttt a o y t en p l . t v r u de e y as a o te S pe e Co r snc d wn a saue wa fcal-e ta b t er g , h u rm u t tzk o ttt s ail n url u y dsr iae a an t ieen to as Yc lrv Hokn, 1 U.. 5 (86. ici n td g is Chn s ain l. ik rp . p is 18 S3 6 18) m t l ac s ta wa c n oiae ltrit Yc Fb afd rlcrutc u t setd n ae h t s o sl td ae no ik , e ea ic i o r asre : d t a a cu tb bid t wh tmutb n csai k o n t e ey itlg n n o r e l o a s e e esrl n w o v r nel e t c n y i pro i tesae'I r FbL e2 F 4 1(i ut utD. lona18) esn n h tt? n e e, 6 . 7 Cr iCor, Cai ri 86. ' c f 1 5 I l h o teraie o Arz n ' p p lt n ti Co rc mltin r terai n i t fh e lis f io as o uai , hs ut a o g oe h e ly g t o t ta tedrc a dc l trl it so S 1 7 wi amot ni l b Laiao . h th iet n ol ea vci f B 0 0 l l s et ey e t /s a m l r n T edsit orwa asltl cretnejiigtei pe ett no h ir cut s boue rci nonn h m l nai f tc y mo temotdao in po iin o S 1 7 frterao sta i gv . Aste h s rc na rvso s f B 0 0 o h esn h t t a e h UntdSae age i tedsrc cuthwee, teetr saues o l be i tts rud n h itit or, o vr h nie ttt h ud e src d wnb cu eii ifsdwi teu lwflasrino saesrg t.As tuk o e a s t s n ue t h na u set f tt' ihs h o teUntd Sae h sn tag e , o e e, h lw s o l as b s uk d wn h i tts a o ru d h w v r te a h ud lo e t c o e r b cu eih sa o vo sa do e rca tre ta teCo r cr o in r. S e a s t a n b iu n p n ail agt h t h u t am t g oe B 1 7 d cae ta Arz n h s lu c e a cua e t fre a h l miin 0 0 elrs h t io a a a n h d r sd o oc af lo l u d c me tdme , me a dc i rn amot lo wh m aeo Me ia a d n o u ne n wo n n hl e- l s al f o r f xcn n d Ce ta Ameia d se t t fe teSae Ev ro e e e tec i rnwh ae nrl rcn ecn- o le h tt. ey n , v n h hl e o r d ctzn mu tev . i e s s la e i o r hsoy tah s u a yhn , ti Co r so l q iky a d u itr ec e s n tig hs u t h ud uc l n e p aial s ied wnccy ap c o S 17 b c ueM z n h sn p we m h tcl t k o vr se t f B 0 0 e a s o a a o o r yr t a o ti a d b cu en i e ti Nain n ra y Nain so l e e a an o d p t n ea s et r hs t , o n to , h ud v r g i h o tlrt rcal-agtdmase p lin . oeae ail tree s x uso s y K S 17 ' dcae p l y o tio tru h efre et i utry B 0 0s elrd oi f tt n ho R nocm n' s t l c ari 'e ic n itn wi teg v rigfd rl oiy n o sse t t h o enn e ea p l . h c S cin1o S 1 7 d cae ta teAc itn s ot a eatt nto g et o f B 0 0 elrs hth tne d t t k t io h u h m ri e fre e th p bi p l yo alsaea dlcl o en e ta e ce'i od r nocm n te u l oi f 1 tt n o a g v rm n g n is'n re cc 1 6 t i ic ua ea dd trteu lFfle t a dpee c o ain a deo o i o so rg n ee h na u nr n rsn e f l s n c n m c d y e at i b p ro su lwfl pee ti teUntdSae.'SB. 00j1Evn ci t y esn na ul rsn n h i tts' . 17 . e vy y e wh r tese icpo iin o S 1 7 p rl lo ic roaefd rlp l y ee h p cf rvso s f B 0 0 aal r n op rt e ea oi , i e c te aepempe b cu ei Arz n ' h n s teep o iin aed sg e t h y r re td ea s n io as a d , h s rvso s r ein d o flhrap lyta i drcl cnrr t tepoiye atdb Co gesa d tte oi ht s iet o tay o h l n ce y n rs n r c y c i pe e tdb n meo samii rt n ,n ldn teOb maAd iitain m lm ne y u ru d ns ai sicu ig h a to m nsrt . o l d srbn fd rl p l y te ds it c ut b g n i o iin b n eciig e ea oi , h it c o r e a t pno y c r s smmaiig te rlv n fdrlsaue.Bre y fdrl lw,wi may u rzn h ee at eea ttts iv , eea a t n h e cpin ,ma e i a ci e fr a n nct e t e tr te cu ty wi o t x et s k s t rm o o -izn o ne h o nr t u o i h a toiain T efd rlsaue frh rpo ie a an wih ma y e cpto s uh r t . h e ea ttts ute rvd , g i t n x e in , zo ta p ro swh aeu lwfl p ee ti tecu ty o wh fi t o ti o h t esn o r na ul rsn n h o nr r o al o ban r y Cry te n c say P p r ma b d p re . Fial, a an wih i potn af h eesl a es y e e o td n ly g i t m rat e cpin ,h fd rlsaue po ieta i i aci efrcrane po est x eto s te e ea ttts rvd h t t s r o eti m ly r o m k o igye po pro s oaeu l fl peetntecut ( i C O , nwnl m ly esn wh r na ul rsn i h onr D s t p wy yt a56. t -) Th Bre o teUntdSae r hl asrsta S 1 7 ma e ci e o e if fh i tts i t set h t B 0 0 k s rm s f e gy a sta aen tci e u d rfd rllw,icu ig fin t o ti o cry d h t r o r s n e e ea a n ldn al g o ban r ar m i i mirto p p r a dapyn fro p romigwok T eUntdSae as m gain a es n p lig o r efr n r . h i tts lo e rg t p it o tta u d ritmain l o v nin ,sc at aeno nomal ihl ons u,h t n e ne t a c n e to s u h cs r t r l y o y 1 7 ci e b tr efre,fta,hog cvl eotinpoedn s( SBr f r s u ae nocd ia l truh iidp rt rceig U i , m l ao e a3-43-8. t 23 ,73) W i rg r t d p rainp o edn steUntdSae p o li si vg r t e ad o e ott rce ig ,h i tts r cam t io h o e s i efrigteelws( SBifa 67. h s wh hv be dpr dd nt n nocn hs a U r ,t -)T oe o ae en eot o o e e dsue ti asr o -ato g ma y wo l a d te wod cu l b ua a d i t hs set n-l u h n ud d h rs re, rtl n p ih ih ma e Bu la igaiep oeso so i io,'h UntdSae tc sa a n u n . t e vn sd r fsin fi g r te i tts u k w y v' e i tec reso i Bre sae e t ta rv a ta ih sn ta dcr o, noc n h on r ft if ttm ns h t e e lh tt a o, n am te fre s tefd rl tttsa antte1 miinp o l wh aed i l igi voain h e ea saue g is h 1 lo e pe o r al i n n ilt l yv o o toe saue.P tsmpy u d c ie td wok r aevtlt teAmeia f h s ttts u i l, n o u ne r es r i o h a rcn eo o y De ott n o 1 miinp o l wo l n to l d srytee o o y c n m . p rai s f 1 lo e pe ud o ny eto h c n m o l drcl b two l cu emasv p lia tr olb t i teUntd Sae a d i t u ud a s sie oicl um i oh n h i tts n ey t e a ra .ld e ,teo l g v rme t ta h v b e a l t lu c sc mas bo d n ed h ny o en ns h t a e en be o a n h u h s e p lin aeto eta h dara y ei iae d mo rtcrg t frtee t e x uso s r h s h t a le d l n td e cai ihs o h ni m r po ulto . p ain F rb t e o o i a dp lia rao s c c. a miitain icu igte o oh c n m c n oicl e sn , v r d nsrt ,n ldn h t y o Ob maAd iitain h setbih dp irt sta tre rmias a doh r a m ns t , a sa l e roie h t ag tt i n l' n te ro s i c ' i ihpirt'tresa dta ga ti pii o e pii wav r t tep rnso g roi 'ag t n h t rn m l t r x l t ies o h ae t f h y c c s alc i rn ln -i ersd ns p ro swh n w h v , o ma s o ha e m l hl e , o gt eie t, esn o o a e r y o n v , d m go n sfrlg lsau ,a d ah s o go p wh r tee ae t u a iain' ru d o e a tts n ot f ru s ee h r r t m ntra ' h raosoaodarss r eottn(e USBifa4-0. esn t vi reto dpr i Se r ,t 85) ao e 1 8 Fo p rsnrao s smepaerso sbly sll o P eietOb ma r at a e sn , o lc ep n iit oey n rsdn a i i frteep l is Bu teep l isae n tdfeetfo to e o teBuh o h s oi e. t h s oi e r o ifrn rm h s f h s c c Ad iitaino i pe eesr.n fc, Co gesh sa po e teep l is m nsrt r t rd c sos l at n rs a p rv d h s oi e o s c fr e a e i telwsh tih se atda dteb d eayd cso sih sma e o d c d s n h a ta t a n ce n h u g tr eiin t a d . F ro e t od cd sp liin i b t p rish v lc e ete tewi o te o v r w ea e, oica s n oh at a e ak d i r h l r h t e h l dset gat iznhpo t lu c Gao dp rt n,u hv isedste ei o rn ctesi ro anh jr eoti sbt aenta eld r i ao t fr rsrigaEhdwpplt n'dpie o eulyadsbetoa1oms o peevn t ao ouai , er d fqai n ujct 1fr s o' v t o au e b t e eteesl iga p ro teUntdSae. f b s- u n v rh ls i n s at fh i tts v e W i S 1 7 ,Arz n i c dfig a d i pe et gtefn a e tl t B 0 0 io a s o iyn n m lm ni h u d m nal h n y dfee t oiyo t io tru he fre e t' ifrn p l ft t n ho g noc m n.' c ari Thsp rs t io tru h e fre e t i tk n drcl fo Mak i hae d tt n ho g nocm n' s a e i t rm r a ri ' ey Kr oin e te eyc n ev t ee euiedrco o teCe tr o l mirt n i ra , xrm l o srai x c t ietr fh ne fr m gai k v v o Su is l 2 0 at l,Krk ra po o e En ice s i c n eto a tde. n 0 5 ri e ioin rp sd n rae n o v nin l c a e fre e t arss p oeuin , d p rain , ast siue, ec- wi nocm n- ret, r sc t s e o t o s se ez rs t. t o t h e p n e u eo v rfct n o lg lsau a av rey o i p ra tp it, t x a d d s f eiiai f e a tts t ait f m o tn ons o o paeia d cladupesn a p silt lehr jcJy.1(mp ai k t s @ ut n nlaat s osbe o i ee /g / '6e hss v /' add B digti teeWi b a ices i ten mbro llgl' o de) y on hs hr l e n nrae n h u e f eas wh , l i' l 1MakKrk ra ,' o n iigllg lmmirt n A Srtg o At io 6 r ioin ' w szn l a l gai : taey f tt n D e o ri tru hE fre e t'Cetr o l mirt nSu is,Ma 2 0 . albea ho g n ocm n ' ne fr m gai tde' y 0 5 Av i l t o a h p/ .i. Wa ilszo+ako .ml d :- cs r lce/os c6 s t . / o h 1 9 ieu a dd p r te sle's ta tern mb rcn b srr d wn t a v p n e oth m ev s o h t h i u e a e hul o o g ' k i aaebeniac rij' t ngal usne sc.1 m '7 Cal gmiin o h ma b ig at a a eben ia c'ma e cer o ln lo s f u n en s t n g a l usn e' k s la h w il m rcsMrKrk ra a dhsp l yatal ae Bu ii ta p lc- tepoiyo a it . ioin n i oi cul r. tts h t oiy h lc f c y ltlo tru h e tre e t' ta te Go en r S eif Arao a d te iit n ho g nocm n' ht h v ro, h rf p i, n h a ri - maoi o teAr oa eilue ae o aotd jry fh i n L gsa r hv nw dpe. t z t Ad igt tee rira t i mirn p l isd srb da o e S 1 7 h w dn o h al ni m g at oi e ecie b v , B 0 0 o ec rq ie e eyp l eof e t so , q et n a etaddti udcmet e urs v r oi fi r o tp uso, r s n e n nou ne cc i r, a i mirnsu d ramote eyc n ev bestain I te rq i spoe uos m ga t n e l s v r o c ia l iut . th n e ur rsctr o e ' t fe hre adugsosnec ofn eswi S ei Araos n igray oi cags n jde t etne fedr, t hrf pi t dn ed l hf a wi hstn cte,oma ee eyicreaina ih ma ea i lg l p sil. t i e t i s t k v r n acrt s n u n s s e al osbe h i o y T e S eife e po oe amig t ou te p se' t ma e sr ta n h h rf v n rp ss r n t lner o ss' o k ue h t o v u d c me tdwok r sa e hs rs . n o u ne re ecp s igap Arz n amst fretefd rl o en e tod p r a ma yrsd nsa io a i o oc h e ea g v rm n t e o t s n eie t s psil adt jitoewhm tefdrl oen et a dcddiwi nt os e n o alhs o h eea gvrm n hs eie t l o bl dp r fru a i ra 'o oh r e sn .T eso sr o S 1 7 ,o teoh r e oto i m nt in' r te rao s h p n os f B 0 0 n h te h a h n ,eo nz n h ma i ra e cpin .Bytero nwod ,h yaee g g d a d rc g ie o u nt in x e t s h i w rs te r n a e a o i acua et freah lmiinMe ia a dCeta Ameia p ro st la e n rsd o oc af lo xcn n nrl rcn es n o ev l Arzn - a dt tk terc i rnwi te . io a n o a e h i hl e t h m d h 1lk. 7 jt lj 20 F d rli mirto p l ismu tb e atdb fd rlofcas Arz n e ea m gain oi e s e n ce y e ea fiil. io a c h sn rg t ou lahsmeofcr a dma dt oh r t c ryo tacu la d a o ih t ne s o fies n n ae tes o ar u r e n d n eo sp l y ta fn a e tl c nrdcstefd rl oiyta Co ges a g ru oi h t u d m nal o ta it h e ea p l h t n rs c y c a dteP eie th v po ug tdu drteatoi o teCo si t n o te n h rsd n a e rm lae n e h uh ry f h n tui fh t to Unle Sae. td tts fs Th dsrccutrpryfu dtafv o S 17 'seicpoiin - e ititorpoel on htie f B 00s pcf rvsos i aeutr ic nitn wi teg v r igfd rl oiy r tel n o sset t h o enn e ea p l . y h c T edsrc c u tihl fu dta teUntdSae h dahg p o a it h itit o r rg t o n h th i tts a ih rb bly y e i ivsgt no toetupce'o u lwfl rsnei teUS,h scn n et ai fhs t setd' f na u peec n h )te eod io s snec o Scin2 (a o rlaeo aypro ars dfr n ofneut etne f et 8 bn n ees fn esn ret o ay fes ni o e l lwfl rsnevrid, et n3( aigias t ci et b wi oteea a u peec eie)Sci m kn t te r o e t u fdrl t o am h ppr) Scin5( aigiaci efrtd cmetdprost woko t aes, et m kn t r o m ou ne esn o r r o o m apy frwok,ad Scin 6 (emiig ars o idvdasfrwhm p l o r) n et o pr tn r t f n iiul o o t es poalcueeishycmmie a r etamae te rmoal) rbbe as x' te o t d ci ht kshm e vbe. s t tm BAM N a d trec mme t t tedsrc c utsa dteUntd Sae' d s l e o ns o h itit o r' n h i tts t e ag ie t d mo srt gh w u lwflh s scin ae run ns e ntai o na u tee et s r. n o Frt S cin 2 ' ma d tr itro ain o a1 up ce ' is, et o B s n aoy nerg t o f 1 d s etd' s u d c me tdrsdnsi a e ta riai bo d a du d f e sa dr ta n o u ne eiet s n xrodn rl ra n n ei d tn ad h t y n wi ete alw o freofcr t itro aeal esn o Laiaod se t o l i r l r oc fies o nerg t lp ro s f t / ecn wh lh o n d n tsekEn l h h v a a cn, p eru e po e ,o whooh r ieber o o p a gi , a e n ce ta p a n m ly d r s tew s a 21 wh tv ratiue a u d cmetdp ro i asme t h v .Ev nGo e o ae e t b ts n n ou ne esn s su d o a e e v m r r Brwe cudn tsaewh t r ei a ofcrso l u et etbihterq ii e r o l o tt a ci ra n fie h ud s o sa l h e ust t s e e sn be ss iin' o u lwfl sau. Gie S cin 2 ' po iin t ao a l upco ' f na u tts v n et B s rvso r o a toiigapiaerg to a int freof esa dd p r e t t a pyti uh r n r t ih f d o o oc fi r n e at ns o p l hs z v c m saue c mbn d wi n nct e s ia it t k e o t ie al-ban d ttt- o ie t o -iz n ' n bly o ep u l g l o tie h i i ly e ie c i d p rainp o edn sa dterpatcliait t d s i sae vdn e n e ott r ce ig n h i rcia n bly o o o n tt o i poeuin u d rS l 7 - s cin 2 i esnil adrciet itro ae rscto s n B o o et B s se tal iet o nerg t o y v wi da oia fro a1Laiao so p d fr ay rao . Asti po iin t ib l l ev r 1 t /s tp e o n esn h c n hs rvso c a g se eyruietaf so it ap tnil l eatrn e etted n es h n e v r o t rfi tp no oet l i -l ig v n, h a g r n c ay f e t rsd ns a dof es i o vo s o eiet- n fi r- s b iu . c S cin 3s a toiain o sae arss frfi r t manan fd rl et ' uh rzt f tt ret o al e o iti e ea o o u p p r i,i a yhn ,moe dao in Wi amot n e cpin , i b n a es s f n tig r rc na . t l s o x et s t a s h o sse d dsne cs po ain p ro s c mmuain , n eryrlae . S. . up n e etn e, rb t , ad n , o tto s a d al eess B o 1 7 , e . D. t at et-a sne c fraf s ofn e tiyd y fre c 0 0 sc 3 Wi w nydy etn e o i t fe s, hr a s o ah h r t sbe u n ofn e SB.1 7 , e . H,a dd t b n so to ewh h v b e u sq et fe s, . 0 0 sc 3 n aa a k n h s o a e en arse , retd a toie rp ae arss a d icreain o p riua uh r s e etd ret n n acrt s f at lr z o c u d c me tdrsd nsu t te la e n o u ne eiet ni h y ev . l Fn l ,S cin 5s i p s in o ci ia sn t n o u d c me td ial eto ' m oio f rm n l a ci s n n o u ne y t o p ro swh a pyfro p rom woki culntee te ei a dt nt b ig esn o p l o r efr r s re i h xrm n d io o en i ic nitn wi teCo geso a rfsloma elo igfrwoko wokn a n o sset t h n rsin leua t k o kn o r r rig h 2 2 ci e li,nefc,natmp t sav u d c metdwok r a dterc i rn rm .ts i feta t to tr e n o u ne res n h i hl e e d s ta te wi la e o h th y l e v . l l. B 17 W OLATESTHEFOURTEENTH AMENDMENTBY 1S 00 LEGALW NGRACI LDICRI I ATI NANDCREATI G A S MN O N CONDI I NSFOR LATI A/ SI ARI ONA S M I AR TO TO NON Z IL CONDI I NSFOR BLACK PEOPLE I THE OLD JM CROW TO N I SOUTH. T epee igscin d c me t o dt n ta mayo tieArz n wi h rc dn eto s o u n c n io s h t n usd io a l i l f du i a ia l: oies ep , n aoyq eto igo a y n ssetdo i nm gn be p l w e sma d tr u sinn f n o e up ce f n c b igu d c me td poeuin frfin t c n p p r,icreainfr en n ou ne , rscto s o al g o a y a es n acrt o i o ' atmpigt f dwok tn ct snted sr ame p se o ou tes' te t o i r ,e t ie i h eeq r d o ss f lner, nn i v s te poesocdt b ifr atfrC ,pndcaain o a ttnt te m lye fre o enom nso IE oe elrt s fnneto a o freah lmiinp o l a dterc i rnt f etesae fbiain a o t oc af lo e pe n h i hl e o l h tt, a rct s b u l d e o h a ls b de sp o e l fu di ted sr,a dGo e osa dS ei s o e des o is u p sdy o n n h eet n v m r n h rf wh f d caeta teP eiet n teCo gescn o tlte h w t e fretelw e lr hth rsd n a d h n rs an telh m o o noc h a i th i'sae n t er'tt. t Bu weh v u fA n tl se ial eoe i teJm Crw rgme t a e no aey en t 1b fr :n h i o e i c n e n db Brwn tee cu ino c i rnfo tep bi sh os o d m e y o ,h x lso f hl e rm h u l c o l d c cn e n di Pllr a dteatmp t dieChn s i mirnso t f a o d m e n ye,n h t to r iee m ga t u o S n e v F a csoc n e n di Yc mo rn ic o d m e n ik . 2 3 S 1 7 frt it saeteu d c metdrsd nso Arz n a dter B 0 0 isvci r h n o u ne eie t f io a n h i m c i rn 1s et it saeteLaiaorsd nso Arzn a dta ees rm hl e .t n x vci r h t / eiet f io a n rv lr fo d m n oh rsae,rm Lai Ameia a dfo oh r o nre wh o kl e'h y te ttsfo t n rc ,n rm te c u tis o o i 'te lk aeu d c me tdi mirns r n o u ne m gat. Bu iteemeh d c nb u e a anth u d cmetda da ant tfh s to s a e sd g iste n ou ne n g is Laiao ,h ycnb u e a ant lc a dNaieAmeia rsd nsa dte t /ste a e sd g isbak n t n v rcn eie t n h n a ant te mioie, i s orfs t g ao g a da y n es wh i o t g isoh r n rt swht wh eu e o o ln , n n o e le o s u i e o fv r t toewh n w rl.n ed S eif p i' c lb ae atmps o f a o wi h s o o ue Id e , h rf Ar aos ee rtd te t t h ivsiaeadpoeue onyof il jde,dtradrpr rae atn net t n rsctcut fcas ugsei sn eots rprad g i, o e p re wh dsge wi te h v awa sb e ap ro sc argme acl o ia re t h m a e l y en at f u h e i . h Miss p wa a lsdsceyfrvroentuttbakctes si i i s coe oit o eeyn,ojsi fc izn. sp s i l te1 5 sa d1 6 stiNainwa rc e b teatmp t e dteJm n h 9 0 n 9 0 ,hs to s ok d y h te to n h i Crw s se a di c n e u n e.n2 0 ,h Nainwa rc e b telr et o y tm n t o sq e c sl 0 6 te to s o k d y h ag s s d mo srto si i hsoy drce a ant blta wa n t s e rsiea e ntain n t itr, ietd g is a i h t s o a rpesv s s l ti o e Th Nainso l n t ep th o g teee et a an hs n . e t h ud o b u tru h h s v ns g i. o T i Co r so l srk d wnS 1 7 i is nieyb cu eivoae te hs uth ud tie o B 0 0 n t e t t ea s t ilts h r F utet Ame d e tat ls1 n 1 o teCo si t no 1 8 ,n e ey o r nh n m n, ri e a d 1 fh nt ui f 7 7 a d v r e c to d mo rt picpei teNainshsoy e cai r il n h to ' itr . cn 2 4 CONCLUS ON I F rh rao ssae ,h a iu Co lint Dee dAfimaieAcin o te e sn ttd te m c s aio o fn f t t , t rv o ltgain,mmirn Rihsa dt Fg to Eq ai b An Men Ne esr ne rt I ga t g t n o ih fr u ly y y a s c say o t (AMN) re tiC utoafmdsi cutn tbodni hligb B ugshs ort fr irtorado rae t odn y i tc s ejiigteefre et f lapcs f B17 . nonn h nocm n o alseto S 00 ByteAmiu BAMN' atre s h cs s ton y , S C FF WASINGTON & Dll C II t PC : . Gere Wahn og B. sig ihgnB r .22 1 cia a NoP 60) S atDl e( ihgnBaNoP 5 0) hna i rM cia r .607 v 6 5Grs od-ut 1 1 4 iw l-s i 8 7 e Deri, 48 2 totMI 2 6 31 -6 -9 1 39 3 1 2 Dae : e tmb r 0 2 1 td S pe e 3 , 0 0 CERTI I ATE OF COMPLI NCE FC A T e n es ndcrf s neR l3 () )C ote eeaRue o h u dri e eti udr ue 2a( () fh Fdrl ls f g ie 7 Ap elt Po e uea dNit Ci ut 2 1ta teatc e Amiu Bre o p l e rc d r n nh r i3 -,h th tah d c s if n a c Be af f h lo BAMN i p o o t n l sae , a atp fc o 1 p it o moe s rp ri al p cd h s y e ae f 4 ons r r oy a d p ru n t tewodc u t etr o tewodpo esn po rm u e t n , usa to h r -o n faue fh r rcsig rga sd o p e aeti bifc nan 56 9wod , x lsv o tematr ta ma b rp r hs re, o tis ,8 rs e cu ie fh tesh t y e o ie udr ue 2a() )i. m t d n eR l3()7( (i t B i) SCX FF, M NGTON, DRI ER, C. WAS & V P. ? .. . By: Ro adCrz nl u At re fr c s t n y o Amiu B o Dae : e tmb r3 , 01 td S pe e 0 2 0 CERTI I ATE OFSERVI E FC C lh rb cri ta o S pe b r3 , 0 0 Isre t oc pe o aMoin eey ety h t n e tm e 0 2 1 , ev d w o is f t f o fr a et Fl aBre Amiu Cuiei S p o t fh Ap elea dapo o e o Lev o i if c s ra n u p ro te p l n rp sd e e Br f c sCuiei S p ot fh Ap eleo b h lo teCo lint i Amiu ra n u p r o te p l n e af fh aio o e e t Dee dAf n aieAcin Itgain I mirn Rihsa dFg to Eq ai fn t u t t ,ne rto ,m ga t g t, n ih fr u ly iv o t B An Men Neesr (AMN) nteflwigpre b UntdSae mal y y as csay B o h ol n ats y i tts i o i e p sa epe ad otg rp i: To yWet ns De nsK. re n i Buk Arh rR. lb r tu God eg VauChlk mar r i a ri a J su Wi e fl oh a l ned k U.. prmet futc, vl vso S Deat n o JsieCiiDiiin 2 Masc u etAv n e N. . 0 sah st e u , W s W ahn tn D. . 0 3 sigo , C 2 5 0 J l J Bo ma om . u Ro et He r b rA. ny J sp G.Ad ms o eh a S el Wi e L.L.. n l& l r P m On Arz n Ce tr e io a ne 40 E. nBue 0 Va rn P o nx AZ8 0 42 0 h e i, 5 0 -2 2 Ro adCrz nl u S h f, sigo & Drv rPC. c efWahn tn ie, . Aton y frteAmiusBAMN tre s o h c Dae : e tmb r3 , 0 0 td S pe e 0 2 1

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?