USA v. State of Arizona, et al

Filing 143

Received original and 7 copies of Amicus Curiae Ray Elbert Parker brief in 9 pages. Major deficiencies: motion pending. Other deficiencies:. Served on 10/05/2010 [7505150] (FT)

C S NO. 0-1 6 5 A E 1 64

I THE N

F RTHENI TH CI CUI O N RT
UNIE SA E OFAME I ,LA T D T TS RG E L
Panif A p l e lit - p el , f e
V .

R E C E lV E D M.LoiTYAoôt O c D r -R L R: tsYtWfsN!K J.CRoE (Ep

0 1-??! : C) f
-

SAT OFARZ N a dJ NIE K TE IO A n A C . B E E , v ro o teSaeo R W R Go en r f h tt f Aro a i h r ocatp tt, i n .n e o ila ai z y

D fn at-A p l n. ee d ns p el t a

AM IUSCURI EBRIFI S PP R C A E N U OT OFT ES ATEOFARIONA RE E S L HT Z V RA

USA v. State of Arizona, et al

Doc. 143

R yEb a P re pos a le ak r r e

P sOfeBx 2 66 ot fi o 30 j c
(0 )2 - 36 73 38 26

Alx n r , i ii 2 3 0 e a d i Vr na 2 2 ag

Dockets.Justia.com

C SENO.1 -1 6 5 A 0 64

I THE N

UNI E S ATE COUR OFAP E L TD T S T PAS
F R THENI TH CI CUI O N RT
UNIE S AT SOFAME IAE .AL TD T E RC T .
A p ln, p el t a
V .

S ATEOFARIONAE . . T Z T AL
Ap ele pl . e

AM IUSCURI EBRIFI S P OR C A E N UP T OFT ES ATEOFARIONA F RRE E S L HT Z O V RA
P tin rR YEB R P R E , ee yflshs miu cr eBifns p ot f h eio e,A L E T A K R h rb i ia cs ui r i u p ro te t e ae

Sae f ro aaditei eet frt,uteadjdc lxe inystfr te ige tt o Ai n n n h n rso t hjsi n uiaepde c esot h s l z t u c i hn i u peetdt ticuts jdc lrcd n ite itntne Eeyhn e eite s e rsne o hso ra au iapee etn h fsisac. vrti l n h s i r gs
cs so lb c niee o lavr t no tite e T eisebfr ticutsa ae h ud e o s rd ny ai i n hs h m ! h su eoe hs o ri s d ao
flws ol : o

T BL OFCON EN S AE TT
P GE A 2 CERTIIAEOFCOMPLANCE. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 FC I .. .. ... ... .. ... 0 SECTINS O

TABL OFAUTHORI IS E TE
'

F DERALCASE E S

Mabr zMa lo, U. 1(rnh 17(8 3 .- . .... .. 6 ruy dàn5 S. Ca c) 3 10) .. ... .. .
* e

#

j

9 S C.004 8U. .8 (94 .. ... ... .. .. 69 4 . t39 , 1 S 63 17 ) ... ... .. ... ,
CONS IUTI NALPROVII NS TT O SO
4 6 5 7

ST TUTE A

ImlrtnaJ& #p# A /' A)8U. . .j10 esq m tai n a/a/ c(I ', S C j 11 te . o #N

5

-I -

THEP R M OUNTIS EBE ORETHI C UR I W HE HE AA SU F S O TS T R THEPRE I E TOFTHEUNIE S ATE HASBE NAND I SD N TD T S E S C M M I I GANI P AC ABL ACTPURS ANTTO T E O UN ME H E U H AR IL SI 1OFTHEUNIE S ATE C NS IUTI N TC E AND 1 T D T S O TT O
T eo u itics d e n trso teso leso p bio iilfrh Saeo h n sn hs ae o s o et n h h ud r f u l fcaso te tt f c
-

A zn y h -x ri - e tp biai / o a- oeecs t e y o l t w eh g>

, ep niit n moettlg tk d a' so s: D d ne ihs e/ i bB M

wi teivso a dcn urn o Amei b ie a ain.h o t f o to a acy t h nain n o q eig f r a y lg l l sT e u o c nrln rh h cle trae igo r ainsb res n ct e s i clafcT xsAro a N w Meioa d hetnn u nt ' od ra d izn dr t fet ea, i n , e xc n o i ey z
C lonatefu sae ta ma o lb lfwi acoc b t e na n x t nit Meio ai ri,h o rtts ht y ny e et t h i ew e n eai no xc f h e o o sceso fo teUntdSae 'h ns t Ob mas . r ucsin rm h i tts' a k' o a im e t'

T ewa o s uh r ages nta ica gn ted mo rp isc l r a dwel h r fo ten grsi h ts h n ig h e ga hc,ut e n l o u b igo ta io aAmeiah s eo ec na iu fr v rtwn cu t, i a dsaei en frdt n l r a b c m o tgo s o eey o ,o nyc y n tt n i c t

tint n T iitk gp c a adrcrslo te lw dIeai o al e Tosyts hs ai . hssai l e s i teu f% f e i rlm f lgd rtki o na et a bs e e
B rc Husi Mo a ma O a a H ueS e kr nyP lsa dS ntr ryR i, s aak sen h m d b m , o s p ae Na c eoi n e ao Har ed a

welsteIg l l aa c ehbtdb Atre Ge eaEiH le'D p rme t f' s la h ea maf sne x ii y ton y n rlr od r e at n o 'ut e e c s J

U,tebidD mbca IcPr Iylt n algdyteup toimeitaapi i s h l u orts) at oasad l e l h n ar t daht p lst 'n iyi e, ic es
P vo incn io iga dMa i nA e u sbi ia p re t ntos f ta et ter alva o dt nn n ds v n e u l n l ecpi o lo watg o h i i o m o a pidstrto p we t c ec tee tec i nyit afa eo rfrned sg e t p l auain o ro o re h ni iz r no rm feee c ein d o e r te

gat mnsyadre nie ett te1 miino moei glln arayiti rn a et n /e etl nso h 2 l r r l aai s l d n hs tm l o eee cutyT eraf wiA ei 'eet n it alwte daocniu ter non o nr.h ebl n m ras l i sso l h meit ot e hio g i a c co o n g f ac lrfer gadtepotuino o r ainll t n. i ni poi ei n h rsi t f u nt aee i s n a tn to o co
-2

T etligh a s fh me ia ueterttso slsrige omasg b h akn e d o te da b s h isau f ef evn g sae y cniun t p reu t ter pno ae I eaie si t rv reo rwreA eia o tn ig o ep tae h io iintd i rl d pn o e es re i m r n bz t c

hsoy n Sn a Sh otahn wi a acl e sl teorai tadf so ib i rad u dy co lecig t cl a d ee i junlm ht ei Igc y t h u t cv s e
sbtuigtikcnrlop ru d to ewh h a, u d ntltnt sp oth isl u si t hn o to t es a e h s o erb t o ' ie ,o u p rter ef tn s srighp teita eie csab ta a o A eiab stigfrhtepe i ta e ey evn y oh s ht vd ne erU l f m r y et ot h rm s h t v r s y c n e ma ,wo a a dc i wh ie ale trhs o nr b wi uvoaino o rmmirt n n m n n hl o lg l ne tic u ty y l lilt f u i gai d ly l f o o Iwsaen t r iasb tah rh udb tetda a ad e wi ct e si a dalfh a r o ci n l u rte so l e rae s w re s t iznhp n lo te m, hi lei ee tlme t a db n fso nt eb r A ei n a tere adfr ra igo r i t nie ns n e ei f ai on m ra s sh irw r o be kn u fm t t v c
- ---

I s A ei C nrl C oe imirt nad mei 'b ressn h C ntui o a . m ra o t ( ) vrm gai n A ras od riite osi t n f w c oA o c to
teU i dSae, o teD p rmeto Jsi Cvl ihsDvs no D. .o to! h nt ttsn th e at n fut e iiRg t iii f C c nrl e c o

T eo u frh a p a n w b fr t ih n rbec uts ntep p ee r rsd n, h n s o te p e l o eoe hs o oa l o rio h u p te Peie t

B rc H senMo a ma Ob mawh c nrltep p e sr g o hs tre Ge ea, aak usi h m d a , o o tos h u p tti s n iAton y n rl n

EiH le,odfn teralrt uh lteU idSae C ntuinmadt rq in r od rt eedhifi eo pod h nt tts o si t nae eur g c u e to i
tefd rlo en e t rtcino Amei 'b resa ds eicl, rs etB rc h e eag v rm n poet f r as od r; n p c i l Pei n aak o c f ay d

H senMoa ma O a as ineu u bhvo a te eryr fh o t oa i ain usi hm d b m 'ds gno s eair sh bt e ote ah f fr t i a fm o adhs lgdcnc nbe odrn fop ni edd t ao idrcvoaino hs ah n ial e osi alb rele n u n ne )r snn i til o f iot e o i t e et
o ofea dteC ntuino teU i dSae. f fi n h o si t fh nt tts c to e

Termeyo a pleo ap at tihn rbe orijdc lei f mte h e d frp el n p elo hs ooalcutsu iarlfr h e i eo
UntdSae D p rme t fut eMcatys syeo Iiainta's llfr oicl i tts e at n o Jsi c rhittl figt h t oey o p li e c to s ta p roe, sub tr c ir hsa dteq eto mo bs c mp rainb v ie sc a up ssmatraoy ili t n h u s fr b i o ugt y ocs u b s vg h o

teR vrn Alh rtn wh sbtuevlmefro i. h eee d S apo, o u si t ou o Igc t T ed cso o teIwe c utta c n o e ti da oi lsh meo maiiu h ei n f h o r o r h t o d n d hs ib la ce f l o s i c c

poe uinb o eso ng v rme t s b rvre .Ash meta vci ie tein cn rsct y n ' w oen n mut e ees d ce ht i mzs h n o e t o t whl a alg die imaePeie tB rc Husi Mo a ma Ob mawer teco no i n l e lgt t rsd n aak sen h m d a as h rw f e e li

di iteOaOset qoieceiiyt h ont reoitacmeot fh bc em n h vl fc o rvd rdbl o i rae htr hto s u ote ak s i is t c
o a Aa inc me. f n rba a l

Atl1j8oteC ntuino teUntdSae ra s rc , fh o sit fh i tts ed: ie to e
' ..Th Co ge ss al a etep we . .o ' . e n rs h lh v h o r .t

po iefrh 'o mo d fn e a d'e ea rvd o te c m n ee s' n g n rl wefr' fh UntdStts T po iefr l e o te i ae . o rvd o a e c ln o teMiit ee uetelwso te alg fh la o x c t h a fh i i t Naln sp rs ls re tna drpelvso s' t , upesh urcl n e lh a in . b b '

(mpaiad d E hss de )
Th fd rlg n isa dtefd rlfcass c a teUntdSttsAt re e e ea a e ce n h e eaof il u h s h i ae t n y i e o Ge ealEr Hole, mea dSe ui, e ie t a aa dViePe ie t o n r , i d rHo ln c ry Prsd n Ob m n c rsd n J e c t

Bie ae b lw rso sbefrmmirt ne fre e ân tt Igsainfr d n r,y a e p n il o i gai nocm n o i e ilt o o s o
p lia g i, iir hse p de c , roe lreap lia p r 's uc o v tst oic l an cvli t x e iny o t nag oic lats o re f oe o t g t y g aa teree t nt c ryo t Brv Ne Wol a e d o lvlnays càim a u rne e lci o ar u a a e w r g n a fh ou tr oll s o d s

-

4 -

as btuefr e o rc . u sit o d m ca y t

T esauoyImèrtna dN tnl A t ' A', U.. j h tttr m al n al ai c(I ' 8 S C.j b bt y N) 10 esq,mpwesvru fd rlgnis(cuiga p ln D p r etf 11 te .e o r ai se eaae ce i ldn peat e at no o n m

â# cA gmlleA de fW ,s ,, ' ' ' jw d hY rn -ny f ,
Co ge so teUntdSae . n rs fh i tts e

p0 ugtdb46= rm 1a6 .yh -

Aro insa daIfh oh r 9sae ,a en oh r lraieoh rh n i na ', n lo te te 4 tts h v o te at n t te ta z ev

b t y l f me b ivoaino tero t o Omc; n aS ektArD prsd n er a oA n a n ilt fh i ah f ea d h l p ay eie t a o f ta s e k wi afre tn u e h igf m teb l-it o ea daI t soc h t p as t ok d o g e c on r h ul pto n n Iwi ti h o y h arg netefd rlo en e t p lyonteimo o oyo Ameiasle a ro a c h e eag v rm n' oi h r n p l f r ' lg l sc cl

imirt npo lm'' ,wo t n y uctt m gai rbe . + t a d o a ' o ' '

AdceIj2oteCositnoteU idSae pae terso s lyîr il I fh ntui fh nt tts lcsh ep nlï o , to e bl l

tepoetnoAmeiasbressury o teso l ro tePelet fh h rtci f r ' od r qae nh h ud s fh rs n ote o c e d
&n e SttsteWc Prsd nto aIte cvlmc r o teUntdStts #J ae ,h e ele a d Ioh r iio es fh i ae e
-

5 -

( cuigtea plnDea met fute, ob ter n oh flrya-fr i ldn h pel t pd no Jsi )wh yhiog lg aï e er en a c u a
y a t p r r ad t te aergz/ tp r r ud r o sit n l n sauoy e r o ef m uy h y r e thl o ef m n e c n tui a a d tttr o z o to L w,r alg dyalwigPrsd n Baa kHus i Mo a ma ob rat arg nl a ae l e l l n e ie t rc sen h m d a o ro a t e o y
.

4u bhs c ea A e . En' tt-l' 'n ' h m -jm s=t m W i GGsaer'ta g 's g h

' n t n l e xl l'i d.E N ai a sc ' 'df' o - tn e= r

-E

voaino teo t o o c a dtewelb igo tep o lo Ameia ilt fh ah f m e n h l en fh e pe f r . o c

T ihnrbecuta tejndcbnpeee tn teIg luhnyfr hs o oa l o rh sh uàit , rcdna d h eaa toï o

alg dyg i o dleaeya dwiulvoai teOahoAmr ainstot i l el ul fei rtl n l l iltg h t f m t efr n e y b fy n o h Adc Ij1oteC ntuinoteU idSae,noth vwe thnrth il l fh osit fh ne ttsa ah e o do ooate e, to t

Jnay2,09iag rtnMabr MMa lo, U S 1Crnhl72 LE .0 a ur 020 nuuai . ruy dén5 . . acl3 ,1 . d6 o (83; ntdSae zRk adM N/ pPele tfh & #JSae,4S. t 10)U l tts h r a , rs n ote p / tts9 C. e p d

3 9 ,1 U S 6 3(9 4. 0 048 . .8 17)
Peion r u mi ta Prsd n B rc Hu si Mo a ma ob paso g ig ti e s b t h t e ie t aa k sen h m d a ' n on t s
wiu flr t e freten t nsi mirt nIwsia alg dIp a h beofn e l lal e o noc h ai ' m gai a s n l e à e ca l f s lu f o o e e
-

6 -

ivoainoAtlI54oteC ntuinoteUne Sae'ute,h figo n ilt f rce I fh osit fh id ttsfr rtei f o i, to t ,h l n
Iws i b teOb maa miitaina ais sae a dp bis ra t tkn a ut y h a d nsrt g nt tts n u l ev ns a ig s o c
rso sbeat nu d rsaer hsa dtefd rlmmirt nIwst poeti e p n il ci n e tt i t n h e ea i gai a o rtc t o g o s
-

dte lf mv kee d kox eAnd Tk&4oa emf N o G r n i n r n nr n r do e th lc % zo +
b sls rigpg pz to p r ns, ulw s ntayct s n npoiprfe r a d y ef evn ra //ï p ot ito t a cu r ie ,o -rf o tes n u a i t

mig ie rliu go p a doh r, opaeteio ns ls riga e d a o e s ud d eio s ru s n tes wh lc h r w ef evn g n a b v g -

Thsc u c nma eara o a llfrn eb s do teo g lgIws i b i o d a k e sn be hee c a e n h n oh a ut y s

Prsd n Ob masUntdSttsDe a me t f utea ant ttsa dp bi e ie t a ' i ae p d n o J si g issae n u l e c c

ofil(..AroaViii)opeet eefre et fh imirt nI so fcas eg, i n , rna t rvnb nocm notem gai a r i z g ow
atraiey t e c ua eie a ain a doh r t b ic riil,rsil, l n t l,o no rg lg l l s n tes o e nor be i cbe ev l e ga c na k ru , io e in a dt e g g te s le if uigIwe fre e t n a tn eo s ds b de t n o n a e h m ev s n l t a noc m n a d on

telwiefojsi arvraotelw ro rsjd me t h a t lt uty eeslfh o e cut u g n. s f '

T eat a dat n o tia miitaine ie c ap paf zcs o a h cs n ci s fhs d nsrt vd ne n z b a e f o o e Prsd nil n De a me t f utemlds tsmce t n u ht ie tyte a e ie t a d p d n o J si h -e u in e o g o d ni h m s a c f

wiigac soist teMe ia g vrme t s ls rigmirt nmo e e to ln c es r o h xcn o en ns ef evn gai v m n t l e o -' savxtoUW YY/ F O CXVWR WZ YQIXW S - fbs-h g WWW X W WF O X 'f ' Z Z -

'

Ameia p liin a ditrssgo p wh aeadig a etg a dc nr uigt r n oica s n nee t ru s o r in , b tn n o ti t o c t i bn
ci iaa ti , irse to lwa dod r n d p n e c o c lu la es ita r n lcit dse p c fra n re a d e e d n y n al se d rhp h t m vy o

Th rai o testainita iAmeiac nt rtc i b res ic nt e e ly fh i t s h tf r a 'poett od r,t a ' t uo c s poett n t nTh Aro acs s o lma eAmeiaa dtec ut waeo ' e rtc i ai ! e i n ae h ud k so z r n h o ra r f' c t h tra o texysb a dtecn u r goAmeiae27& th as o'swela te he t fh h a /n n h o q ei f r / /i g h ta l s h n c @n s lo t f rab o r lce p liin wh srt i stn d wni Str el u o Amei y u ee td oica s o tu whl iig o n a c t et S aw/Jate p / e ti . r

WHE EF RE,h p tin r v stih n rbec utor vreted cson R O te eio e mo e hs o oa l o rt ees h e ii t

o teIw rorii ete adtfdcntuinlilt n a anth fh o e cutnt nl @ n o i osit avoai s g i te sb n to o s
-

8 -

a p lnsfr liu po e uina da Jpe c a l ofn e & # #SttsM p el t o maio s rs c t n ns a h be f s . p / ae a c o e Rlh r M N/ q spa b ad m u r. Re p cfl s b ie , se t l u mt d uy t
--

XV

-è -i - -- -RAY E BERTP RKER pos A re PotOfieBo 3 0 3 s f x 266 c Alx n r , rii 2 3 0 e a di Vi na 2 2 ag

(0) 2 -26 7 3 38 36

-

9 -

CERTIIATEOFCOMPLANCEPURSUANTTO FC I

F R A. .2( )7 A DCICUTCOUR R L 3 -1 . . P 3 ( () N R I a T UE 2

Apelt Poeue3 ()7 () n teNnhCiut ue3 -1teatce Bi pl e rcdr 2 a ()C ad h it r iR l 2 ,h t hd rf a c a e
o a lu c n eipo ot n l s ae ,a atp fc o 1 p it, rmoea d f m b s u à s rp ri al p c d h s yeae f 2 ons o r n oy c nan 14 2wod o atraiey1 1Ie o tx. o tis ,3 rs r l n t l 2 i s fet ev n

// s

6
RAY EL BERTP RKERpos A re

-

10

CERTII ATE OFSERVI E FC C
1RhYEL ERTP RKER, ee yc rf u d r ahta atu c p o te , B A h rb ety n e o t h t re o y fh i

a lu cr eBr f a ti X ed yo Oco e, 0 0 b e mald,o tg pe ad, mb s ui i h s hs H ba f tb r2 1 , e n i p sa e rp i ae e
t teflwig J h J B u a E q.o b h lo Ro e A. n , q;o e hG. o h ol n :o n . o m , s , n e af f b d He l Es .J s p o

Ad ms E q, NE L'WIL E L L R, eAro aC ne,0 E sV nB rn a , s .S L L M R . . On i n e tr4 0 a t a ue , z
Ph e i, io a8 0 4-2 0 * n J s p A. n f l, q, feo teGo en r o nx Ar n 5 0 2 2, d o e h Ka eid Es .Ofc fh v ro z a e i J nc K. e e, 7 0We t s igo ,*Fo rPh e i, io a8 0 7 c u sl a ie Brw r10 s Wa hn tn 9 lo, o nxAr n 5 0 ,o ne z fr ee d nsa p lns o d fn a t/p el t. a An To yWetEs .Asitn UntdSttsAt re Ge eao b h lo d n s, q, ssa t i ae t n y n rln e af f e o

Den iR. re Es .Ad u R. lb r, q; r Chlk a , q, n J s u ns Buk , q; h r God eg Es .Van i m n Es .a d o h a a

Wie fl, q.UNIEDST TESDEPARTMEN OFJ SYIE, vl vso , 0 l ned Es , T k A T U C CiiDiiin 2
Mas c uetAvn e, Wa hn tn D. 2 5 0,o n efrpani-a p le. sa h st e u NW, s igo , C. 0 3 c u s lo litf p el s f e // s ' RAYE BERTPARKER P s Ofc Bo 3 0 3 ot fe x 2 6 6 i Alx n r , rii 2 3 0 e a di Vi na 2 2 ag

(0) 2 -2 36 73 3 8 26
-

11