USA v. State of Arizona, et al

Filing 143

Received original and 7 copies of Amicus Curiae Ray Elbert Parker brief in 9 pages. Major deficiencies: motion pending. Other deficiencies:. Served on 10/05/2010 [7505150] (FT)

Download PDF
C S NO. 0-1 6 5 A E 1 64 I THE N F RTHENI TH CI CUI O N RT UNIE SA E OFAME I ,LA T D T TS RG E L Panif A p l e lit - p el , f e V . R E C E lV E D M.LoiTYAot O c D r -R L R: tsYtWfsN!K J.CRoE (Ep 0 1-??! : C) f - SAT OFARZ N a dJ NIE K TE IO A n A C . B E E , v ro o teSaeo R W R Go en r f h tt f Aro a i h r ocatp tt, i n .n e o ila ai z y D fn at-A p l n. ee d ns p el t a AM IUSCURI EBRIFI S PP R C A E N U OT OFT ES ATEOFARIONA RE E S L HT Z V RA USA v. State of Arizona, et al Doc. 143 R yEb a P re pos a le ak r r e P sOfeBx 2 66 ot fi o 30 j c (0 )2 - 36 73 38 26 Alx n r , i ii 2 3 0 e a d i Vr na 2 2 ag Dockets.Justia.com C SENO.1 -1 6 5 A 0 64 I THE N UNI E S ATE COUR OFAP E L TD T S T PAS F R THENI TH CI CUI O N RT UNIE S AT SOFAME IAE .AL TD T E RC T . A p ln, p el t a V . S ATEOFARIONAE . . T Z T AL Ap ele pl . e AM IUSCURI EBRIFI S P OR C A E N UP T OFT ES ATEOFARIONA F RRE E S L HT Z O V RA P tin rR YEB R P R E , ee yflshs miu cr eBifns p ot f h eio e,A L E T A K R h rb i ia cs ui r i u p ro te t e ae Sae f ro aaditei eet frt,uteadjdc lxe inystfr te ige tt o Ai n n n h n rso t hjsi n uiaepde c esot h s l z t u c i hn i u peetdt ticuts jdc lrcd n ite itntne Eeyhn e eite s e rsne o hso ra au iapee etn h fsisac. vrti l n h s i r gs cs so lb c niee o lavr t no tite e T eisebfr ticutsa ae h ud e o s rd ny ai i n hs h m ! h su eoe hs o ri s d ao flws ol : o T BL OFCON EN S AE TT P GE A 2 CERTIIAEOFCOMPLANCE. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 1 FC I .. .. ... ... .. ... 0 SECTINS O TABL OFAUTHORI IS E TE ' F DERALCASE E S Mabr zMa lo, U. 1(rnh 17(8 3 .- . .... .. 6 ruy dn5 S. Ca c) 3 10) .. ... .. . * e # j 9 S C.004 8U. .8 (94 .. ... ... .. .. 69 4 . t39 , 1 S 63 17 ) ... ... .. ... , CONS IUTI NALPROVII NS TT O SO 4 6 5 7 ST TUTE A ImlrtnaJ& #p# A /' A)8U. . .j10 esq m tai n a/a/ c(I ', S C j 11 te . o #N 5 -I - THEP R M OUNTIS EBE ORETHI C UR I W HE HE AA SU F S O TS T R THEPRE I E TOFTHEUNIE S ATE HASBE NAND I SD N TD T S E S C M M I I GANI P AC ABL ACTPURS ANTTO T E O UN ME H E U H AR IL SI 1OFTHEUNIE S ATE C NS IUTI N TC E AND 1 T D T S O TT O T eo u itics d e n trso teso leso p bio iilfrh Saeo h n sn hs ae o s o et n h h ud r f u l fcaso te tt f c - A zn y h -x ri - e tp biai / o a- oeecs t e y o l t w eh g> , ep niit n moettlg tk d a' so s: D d ne ihs e/ i bB M wi teivso a dcn urn o Amei b ie a ain.h o t f o to a acy t h nain n o q eig f r a y lg l l sT e u o c nrln rh h cle trae igo r ainsb res n ct e s i clafcT xsAro a N w Meioa d hetnn u nt ' od ra d izn dr t fet ea, i n , e xc n o i ey z C lonatefu sae ta ma o lb lfwi acoc b t e na n x t nit Meio ai ri,h o rtts ht y ny e et t h i ew e n eai no xc f h e o o sceso fo teUntdSae 'h ns t Ob mas . r ucsin rm h i tts' a k' o a im e t' T ewa o s uh r ages nta ica gn ted mo rp isc l r a dwel h r fo ten grsi h ts h n ig h e ga hc,ut e n l o u b igo ta io aAmeiah s eo ec na iu fr v rtwn cu t, i a dsaei en frdt n l r a b c m o tgo s o eey o ,o nyc y n tt n i c t tint n T iitk gp c a adrcrslo te lw dIeai o al e Tosyts hs ai . hssai l e s i teu f% f e i rlm f lgd rtki o na et a bs e e B rc Husi Mo a ma O a a H ueS e kr nyP lsa dS ntr ryR i, s aak sen h m d b m , o s p ae Na c eoi n e ao Har ed a welsteIg l l aa c ehbtdb Atre Ge eaEiH le'D p rme t f' s la h ea maf sne x ii y ton y n rlr od r e at n o 'ut e e c s J U,tebidD mbca IcPr Iylt n algdyteup toimeitaapi i s h l u orts) at oasad l e l h n ar t daht p lst 'n iyi e, ic es P vo incn io iga dMa i nA e u sbi ia p re t ntos f ta et ter alva o dt nn n ds v n e u l n l ecpi o lo watg o h i i o m o a pidstrto p we t c ec tee tec i nyit afa eo rfrned sg e t p l auain o ro o re h ni iz r no rm feee c ein d o e r te gat mnsyadre nie ett te1 miino moei glln arayiti rn a et n /e etl nso h 2 l r r l aai s l d n hs tm l o eee cutyT eraf wiA ei 'eet n it alwte daocniu ter non o nr.h ebl n m ras l i sso l h meit ot e hio g i a c co o n g f ac lrfer gadtepotuino o r ainll t n. i ni poi ei n h rsi t f u nt aee i s n a tn to o co -2 T etligh a s fh me ia ueterttso slsrige omasg b h akn e d o te da b s h isau f ef evn g sae y cniun t p reu t ter pno ae I eaie si t rv reo rwreA eia o tn ig o ep tae h io iintd i rl d pn o e es re i m r n bz t c hsoy n Sn a Sh otahn wi a acl e sl teorai tadf so ib i rad u dy co lecig t cl a d ee i junlm ht ei Igc y t h u t cv s e sbtuigtikcnrlop ru d to ewh h a, u d ntltnt sp oth isl u si t hn o to t es a e h s o erb t o ' ie ,o u p rter ef tn s srighp teita eie csab ta a o A eiab stigfrhtepe i ta e ey evn y oh s ht vd ne erU l f m r y et ot h rm s h t v r s y c n e ma ,wo a a dc i wh ie ale trhs o nr b wi uvoaino o rmmirt n n m n n hl o lg l ne tic u ty y l lilt f u i gai d ly l f o o Iwsaen t r iasb tah rh udb tetda a ad e wi ct e si a dalfh a r o ci n l u rte so l e rae s w re s t iznhp n lo te m, hi lei ee tlme t a db n fso nt eb r A ei n a tere adfr ra igo r i t nie ns n e ei f ai on m ra s sh irw r o be kn u fm t t v c - --- I s A ei C nrl C oe imirt nad mei 'b ressn h C ntui o a . m ra o t ( ) vrm gai n A ras od riite osi t n f w c oA o c to teU i dSae, o teD p rmeto Jsi Cvl ihsDvs no D. .o to! h nt ttsn th e at n fut e iiRg t iii f C c nrl e c o T eo u frh a p a n w b fr t ih n rbec uts ntep p ee r rsd n, h n s o te p e l o eoe hs o oa l o rio h u p te Peie t B rc H senMo a ma Ob mawh c nrltep p e sr g o hs tre Ge ea, aak usi h m d a , o o tos h u p tti s n iAton y n rl n EiH le,odfn teralrt uh lteU idSae C ntuinmadt rq in r od rt eedhifi eo pod h nt tts o si t nae eur g c u e to i tefd rlo en e t rtcino Amei 'b resa ds eicl, rs etB rc h e eag v rm n poet f r as od r; n p c i l Pei n aak o c f ay d H senMoa ma O a as ineu u bhvo a te eryr fh o t oa i ain usi hm d b m 'ds gno s eair sh bt e ote ah f fr t i a fm o adhs lgdcnc nbe odrn fop ni edd t ao idrcvoaino hs ah n ial e osi alb rele n u n ne )r snn i til o f iot e o i t e et o ofea dteC ntuino teU i dSae. f fi n h o si t fh nt tts c to e Termeyo a pleo ap at tihn rbe orijdc lei f mte h e d frp el n p elo hs ooalcutsu iarlfr h e i eo UntdSae D p rme t fut eMcatys syeo Iiainta's llfr oicl i tts e at n o Jsi c rhittl figt h t oey o p li e c to s ta p roe, sub tr c ir hsa dteq eto mo bs c mp rainb v ie sc a up ssmatraoy ili t n h u s fr b i o ugt y ocs u b s vg h o teR vrn Alh rtn wh sbtuevlmefro i. h eee d S apo, o u si t ou o Igc t T ed cso o teIwe c utta c n o e ti da oi lsh meo maiiu h ei n f h o r o r h t o d n d hs ib la ce f l o s i c c poe uinb o eso ng v rme t s b rvre .Ash meta vci ie tein cn rsct y n ' w oen n mut e ees d ce ht i mzs h n o e t o t whl a alg die imaePeie tB rc Husi Mo a ma Ob mawer teco no i n l e lgt t rsd n aak sen h m d a as h rw f e e li di iteOaOset qoieceiiyt h ont reoitacmeot fh bc em n h vl fc o rvd rdbl o i rae htr hto s u ote ak s i is t c o a Aa inc me. f n rba a l Atl1j8oteC ntuino teUntdSae ra s rc , fh o sit fh i tts ed: ie to e ' ..Th Co ge ss al a etep we . .o ' . e n rs h lh v h o r .t po iefrh 'o mo d fn e a d'e ea rvd o te c m n ee s' n g n rl wefr' fh UntdStts T po iefr l e o te i ae . o rvd o a e c ln o teMiit ee uetelwso te alg fh la o x c t h a fh i i t Naln sp rs ls re tna drpelvso s' t , upesh urcl n e lh a in . b b ' (mpaiad d E hss de ) Th fd rlg n isa dtefd rlfcass c a teUntdSttsAt re e e ea a e ce n h e eaof il u h s h i ae t n y i e o Ge ealEr Hole, mea dSe ui, e ie t a aa dViePe ie t o n r , i d rHo ln c ry Prsd n Ob m n c rsd n J e c t Bie ae b lw rso sbefrmmirt ne fre e n tt Igsainfr d n r,y a e p n il o i gai nocm n o i e ilt o o s o p lia g i, iir hse p de c , roe lreap lia p r 's uc o v tst oic l an cvli t x e iny o t nag oic lats o re f oe o t g t y g aa teree t nt c ryo t Brv Ne Wol a e d o lvlnays cim a u rne e lci o ar u a a e w r g n a fh ou tr oll s o d s - 4 - as btuefr e o rc . u sit o d m ca y t T esauoyImrtna dN tnl A t ' A', U.. j h tttr m al n al ai c(I ' 8 S C.j b bt y N) 10 esq,mpwesvru fd rlgnis(cuiga p ln D p r etf 11 te .e o r ai se eaae ce i ldn peat e at no o n m # cA gmlleA de fW ,s ,, ' ' ' jw d hY rn -ny f , Co ge so teUntdSae . n rs fh i tts e p0 ugtdb46= rm 1a6 .yh - Aro insa daIfh oh r 9sae ,a en oh r lraieoh rh n i na ', n lo te te 4 tts h v o te at n t te ta z ev b t y l f me b ivoaino tero t o Omc; n aS ektArD prsd n er a oA n a n ilt fh i ah f ea d h l p ay eie t a o f ta s e k wi afre tn u e h igf m teb l-it o ea daI t soc h t p as t ok d o g e c on r h ul pto n n Iwi ti h o y h arg netefd rlo en e t p lyonteimo o oyo Ameiasle a ro a c h e eag v rm n' oi h r n p l f r ' lg l sc cl imirt npo lm'' ,wo t n y uctt m gai rbe . + t a d o a ' o ' ' AdceIj2oteCositnoteU idSae pae terso s lyr il I fh ntui fh nt tts lcsh ep nl o , to e bl l tepoetnoAmeiasbressury o teso l ro tePelet fh h rtci f r ' od r qae nh h ud s fh rs n ote o c e d &n e SttsteWc Prsd nto aIte cvlmc r o teUntdStts #J ae ,h e ele a d Ioh r iio es fh i ae e - 5 - ( cuigtea plnDea met fute, ob ter n oh flrya-fr i ldn h pel t pd no Jsi )wh yhiog lg a e er en a c u a y a t p r r ad t te aergz/ tp r r ud r o sit n l n sauoy e r o ef m uy h y r e thl o ef m n e c n tui a a d tttr o z o to L w,r alg dyalwigPrsd n Baa kHus i Mo a ma ob rat arg nl a ae l e l l n e ie t rc sen h m d a o ro a t e o y . 4u bhs c ea A e . En' tt-l' 'n ' h m -jm s=t m W i GGsaer'ta g 's g h ' n t n l e xl l'i d.E N ai a sc ' 'df' o - tn e= r -E voaino teo t o o c a dtewelb igo tep o lo Ameia ilt fh ah f m e n h l en fh e pe f r . o c T ihnrbecuta tejndcbnpeee tn teIg luhnyfr hs o oa l o rh sh uit , rcdna d h eaa to o alg dyg i o dleaeya dwiulvoai teOahoAmr ainstot i l el ul fei rtl n l l iltg h t f m t efr n e y b fy n o h Adc Ij1oteC ntuinoteU idSae,noth vwe thnrth il l fh osit fh ne ttsa ah e o do ooate e, to t Jnay2,09iag rtnMabr MMa lo, U S 1Crnhl72 LE .0 a ur 020 nuuai . ruy dn5 . . acl3 ,1 . d6 o (83; ntdSae zRk adM N/ pPele tfh & #JSae,4S. t 10)U l tts h r a , rs n ote p / tts9 C. e p d 3 9 ,1 U S 6 3(9 4. 0 048 . .8 17) Peion r u mi ta Prsd n B rc Hu si Mo a ma ob paso g ig ti e s b t h t e ie t aa k sen h m d a ' n on t s wiu flr t e freten t nsi mirt nIwsia alg dIp a h beofn e l lal e o noc h ai ' m gai a s n l e e ca l f s lu f o o e e - 6 - ivoainoAtlI54oteC ntuinoteUne Sae'ute,h figo n ilt f rce I fh osit fh id ttsfr rtei f o i, to t ,h l n Iws i b teOb maa miitaina ais sae a dp bis ra t tkn a ut y h a d nsrt g nt tts n u l ev ns a ig s o c rso sbeat nu d rsaer hsa dtefd rlmmirt nIwst poeti e p n il ci n e tt i t n h e ea i gai a o rtc t o g o s - dte lf mv kee d kox eAnd Tk&4oa emf N o G r n i n r n nr n r do e th lc % zo + b sls rigpg pz to p r ns, ulw s ntayct s n npoiprfe r a d y ef evn ra // p ot ito t a cu r ie ,o -rf o tes n u a i t mig ie rliu go p a doh r, opaeteio ns ls riga e d a o e s ud d eio s ru s n tes wh lc h r w ef evn g n a b v g - Thsc u c nma eara o a llfrn eb s do teo g lgIws i b i o d a k e sn be hee c a e n h n oh a ut y s Prsd n Ob masUntdSttsDe a me t f utea ant ttsa dp bi e ie t a ' i ae p d n o J si g issae n u l e c c ofil(..AroaViii)opeet eefre et fh imirt nI so fcas eg, i n , rna t rvnb nocm notem gai a r i z g ow atraiey t e c ua eie a ain a doh r t b ic riil,rsil, l n t l,o no rg lg l l s n tes o e nor be i cbe ev l e ga c na k ru , io e in a dt e g g te s le if uigIwe fre e t n a tn eo s ds b de t n o n a e h m ev s n l t a noc m n a d on telwiefojsi arvraotelw ro rsjd me t h a t lt uty eeslfh o e cut u g n. s f ' T eat a dat n o tia miitaine ie c ap paf zcs o a h cs n ci s fhs d nsrt vd ne n z b a e f o o e Prsd nil n De a me t f utemlds tsmce t n u ht ie tyte a e ie t a d p d n o J si h -e u in e o g o d ni h m s a c f wiigac soist teMe ia g vrme t s ls rigmirt nmo e e to ln c es r o h xcn o en ns ef evn gai v m n t l e o -' savxtoUW YY/ F O CXVWR WZ YQIXW S - fbs-h g WWW X W WF O X 'f ' Z Z - ' Ameia p liin a ditrssgo p wh aeadig a etg a dc nr uigt r n oica s n nee t ru s o r in , b tn n o ti t o c t i bn ci iaa ti , irse to lwa dod r n d p n e c o c lu la es ita r n lcit dse p c fra n re a d e e d n y n al se d rhp h t m vy o Th rai o testainita iAmeiac nt rtc i b res ic nt e e ly fh i t s h tf r a 'poett od r,t a ' t uo c s poett n t nTh Aro acs s o lma eAmeiaa dtec ut waeo ' e rtc i ai ! e i n ae h ud k so z r n h o ra r f' c t h tra o texysb a dtecn u r goAmeiae27& th as o'swela te he t fh h a /n n h o q ei f r / /i g h ta l s h n c @n s lo t f rab o r lce p liin wh srt i stn d wni Str el u o Amei y u ee td oica s o tu whl iig o n a c t et S aw/Jate p / e ti . r WHE EF RE,h p tin r v stih n rbec utor vreted cson R O te eio e mo e hs o oa l o rt ees h e ii t o teIw rorii ete adtfdcntuinlilt n a anth fh o e cutnt nl @ n o i osit avoai s g i te sb n to o s - 8 - a p lnsfr liu po e uina da Jpe c a l ofn e & # #SttsM p el t o maio s rs c t n ns a h be f s . p / ae a c o e Rlh r M N/ q spa b ad m u r. Re p cfl s b ie , se t l u mt d uy t -- XV - -i - -- -RAY E BERTP RKER pos A re PotOfieBo 3 0 3 s f x 266 c Alx n r , rii 2 3 0 e a di Vi na 2 2 ag (0) 2 -26 7 3 38 36 - 9 - CERTIIATEOFCOMPLANCEPURSUANTTO FC I F R A. .2( )7 A DCICUTCOUR R L 3 -1 . . P 3 ( () N R I a T UE 2 Apelt Poeue3 ()7 () n teNnhCiut ue3 -1teatce Bi pl e rcdr 2 a ()C ad h it r iR l 2 ,h t hd rf a c a e o a lu c n eipo ot n l s ae ,a atp fc o 1 p it, rmoea d f m b s u s rp ri al p c d h s yeae f 2 ons o r n oy c nan 14 2wod o atraiey1 1Ie o tx. o tis ,3 rs r l n t l 2 i s fet ev n // s 6 RAY EL BERTP RKERpos A re - 10 CERTII ATE OFSERVI E FC C 1RhYEL ERTP RKER, ee yc rf u d r ahta atu c p o te , B A h rb ety n e o t h t re o y fh i a lu cr eBr f a ti X ed yo Oco e, 0 0 b e mald,o tg pe ad, mb s ui i h s hs H ba f tb r2 1 , e n i p sa e rp i ae e t teflwig J h J B u a E q.o b h lo Ro e A. n , q;o e hG. o h ol n :o n . o m , s , n e af f b d He l Es .J s p o Ad ms E q, NE L'WIL E L L R, eAro aC ne,0 E sV nB rn a , s .S L L M R . . On i n e tr4 0 a t a ue , z Ph e i, io a8 0 4-2 0 * n J s p A. n f l, q, feo teGo en r o nx Ar n 5 0 2 2, d o e h Ka eid Es .Ofc fh v ro z a e i J nc K. e e, 7 0We t s igo ,*Fo rPh e i, io a8 0 7 c u sl a ie Brw r10 s Wa hn tn 9 lo, o nxAr n 5 0 ,o ne z fr ee d nsa p lns o d fn a t/p el t. a An To yWetEs .Asitn UntdSttsAt re Ge eao b h lo d n s, q, ssa t i ae t n y n rln e af f e o Den iR. re Es .Ad u R. lb r, q; r Chlk a , q, n J s u ns Buk , q; h r God eg Es .Van i m n Es .a d o h a a Wie fl, q.UNIEDST TESDEPARTMEN OFJ SYIE, vl vso , 0 l ned Es , T k A T U C CiiDiiin 2 Mas c uetAvn e, Wa hn tn D. 2 5 0,o n efrpani-a p le. sa h st e u NW, s igo , C. 0 3 c u s lo litf p el s f e // s ' RAYE BERTPARKER P s Ofc Bo 3 0 3 ot fe x 2 6 6 i Alx n r , rii 2 3 0 e a di Vi na 2 2 ag (0) 2 -2 36 73 3 8 26 - 11

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?