USA v. State of Arizona, et al

Filing 29

Filed Amicus Curiae - Pending Ray Elbert Parker motion for leave to file amicus curiae memorandum in support of defendants opposition to motion to dismiss file by appellant after docketing the notice of appeal with amicus curiae memorandum in support of the State of Arizona's opposition to motion to dismiss. Served on 08/25/2010. [7457850] (JFF)

Download PDF
R E c E lV E D M LYcD YRCEK OL .W E LR UsC UT F PEL ..O R O APAS I THE N As3 21 U 02 2 suo jn -UNI ED S ATE COURT OFAPP AL TTS EY o . ,!. x, F R THENI TH CI CUI O N RT T EU IE SA E OF MEIA H NTD T TS A RC ) ) Apln, ) pel t a ) T ESAT OF ION a dJ NIEK H T E ARZ A n A C . B E E , OVE NOROFT ES A E RW R G R H TT ARZ N ,nh r siila ai IO A i e o cacp cy t C No 1 - 6 4 A .0 1 6 5 (AN .:00c 11 S B C o 22 1 v 4 3 R ) A p le ) pel . e ) ) M OTI N F RL AVETO FL AMIUSCURI EME ORANDUM I OOE IE C A M N S PP R OFDE E DANT OP OSTONTO MOTI N T DIM IS U OT FN S P II O OSS FL D B APP L NTAF C DQCK TI GTHENOTIEOFAP E L IE Y E G TR CN C PA P tin rR yEb rP re,na iu cr ep riiatitics i teIwe eio e, a let uk ra m cs ui at p n n hs ae n h o r t ac c uth rb fls i utn o smoin wi tih n rbec ut n teU i dSae o r, ee y i sm l eu t s t hs o oa l o ra d h nt tts e a oh e Dsr C uto teDir o A i n , h e iDiio ,nsp ot fh Saeo Aio ai i i o rfrh s i f r o a P o nx vs n i u p ro te tt f r n n td td z i z ticueo a in Pt in r ry ta tih n rbecut rn hs t na dta te hs a s f d o . eio e pas h ths o oa l o rga ' imoi n ht h t o cutcetigo fi Me oadmaarn oteoz iteieetfute oracphsodat m rnu s fi dfh ctlnh n rsojsi . h e r t c USA v. State of Arizona, et al T eag me ta dcs Iwc nan diteac mp n igMe oa d m ae h ru ns n aea o tie n h co a yn m rn u r Doc. 29 i oprtdhrip runt R l1 ()fh Fd rlue o Cv Poe uea iul n roae een usato ue 0cote e eaR ls f ii rcd r,sf l c l fy sae aan ttd g i. Dockets.Justia.com R s etuls b ie , ep cfl u m t d y t // S R YEB R P R E pos A L T A KR r e P s O feB x3 0 3 ot fi o 2 6 6 c Alx n r , rii2 3 0 ea di Vi na 2 2 ag (0 ) 2 -26 7 33 8 3 6 -2 I THE N UNI ED S ATE COURT OFAPPE L TTS AS F RTHENI TH CI CUI O N RT T EU IE SA E OFA E IA H NT D T T S M RC Ap eln, pl t a V . C No 1 - 6 4 A .0 165 (AN .:00c 11 S B C o 22 1 v 4 3 R ) T ESA EOF ION a dJ NIE K H T T ARZ A n A C . B E E , R OROF HESA EOF R W R GOVE N T TT ARZ NA ih r fiila ai IO ,n e o ca cpct y A ple p el , e ) AM IUSCURI EM E OR NDUM I S P OR OFTHE C A MA N UP T S AT OFARIONA' OP OSTI NT MOTI N T DIM IS TE Z S P IO O O OSS P tin rR YEB RTP R E , ee ys b i tea o ecpin dMe oa d m a eio e, A LE A K R h rb u m t h b v ato e m rn u s t s ar n o te oz, i stfrhte ru d a d h I t b dsoiv o a t nt fi d fh ctlwhc esot h go n s n tea o e i si f Moi o e rh w p te o Di i ta wa atoi dt b fe b te2 td yo A g s,2 1, yteH n rbeS sn s s ht s uh re o e i d y h 6h a f u ut 0 0 b h o oa l ua ms z l R B l n Dsrtu g ,o teUntdSae Dir t o rfrh Saeo Aio a a d . ot , i i Jd e frh i tts s i C uto te tt f r n , n o tc e tc z Pt in rtts h flwig eio e sae te ol n : t o T eU id tts eat et futeatrh t e fig fh N teoA p a h nt Sae D pr n oJsi ,f tei l in o te oi f p el e m c e m yl c b teSaeo Ai n fo teIwe cut d r fh 2td yo Jl,2 1 ,a datrh y h tt f ro a rm h o r o rOre o te 8h a fuy 0 0 n fe te z a p lt c ut d na o Aro asmoint ep dt tecs a dtega t go a p el e o r' e il f i n ' t o x e i h ae n h rni f n a s z o e n elre etft efrh D prmet futet febis iiae tiflw u nagm n o i o te eat n oJsi o i rf,nt td hsoo -p m c le i srtgm iteIwe c ut i tecs io a p a wi wiflne topeld a y taae n h o r o rwhl h aes n p e l t lu itn t rcu e n e hl jdc leiw whto vr fh cntuinlsuso te' ei' tics. uii rve asee o te o sitoai e n h ' rt' hs ae a t s m so T eD p rme t fut eCvl ihsDiio iefntae tiIiaina anth h e at n o Jsi iiRg t vs n t lii td hsig t g iste c is i to p o lo Aro a adalgdyten t na dtee yd n igtevci so teo pesv e pe f i n, n l e l h ai ;n h rb, e yn h it fh p rsie z e o m ' a o N rh r Cvl ihs g rsinfo Wahn tn D. .a yrmeywh to v r y ' r f o ten iiRg tA geso rm sigo , C' n e d ase e b W ' te s opoeuasbe u ewhlo teohr adpo oi telw dplis n h ue f rcd rlu tr g, i n h te hn rm t g h f e oie ad f e na c b n rp c ntuin lyo Peie t aakH senMo a ma Ob maslne c twad a ku to si t ai f rs n B rc usi h m d a ' e iny o r to t d a n sylwlsn s,a acyflct e sifra -raesa dasc n tr a bt nt m et,a eses n rh ,uliznhp o lw be kr n eo d em m io o i i b Peie t f'h U i dSae o Me i 'n2 1 . e rsd n o ' e nt tts f xc i 0 2 T e o S ATE E TOFTHEF C S T MN AT T eU i dSae Dsr C uto teSaeo A i n e trda Ore o te2td y h nt tts i i o rfrh tt f r o a nee n d r n h 8ha e td z o Jl 2 1,rnigipra d eyn ip r teMoinfr PeiiayIucinfe fuy 00ga t n lln dnign ll h t o a rl nr n nt id , n , o m j ol b teUntdSae D p rme t fut e Peie tB rc Husi Mo a ma Ob ma a d y h i tts e at n o Jsi . rs n aak sen h m d a , n e c d hs p one Atre G n rlEi H le,nt tdtiliaino ter wnaanth ia p itd ton y e ea, r od riiae hsigt n h io g is te c i to Saeo Aro ap biofilwh weeat gwi iteso eo ter fiil uya d tt f i n u l fias o r ci t n h c p fh iof ad t n z cc nh c o l aint e frepo ugtdIw S B1 7 t c r 'u o c nrlr ia a acy' bi t o noc rm lae a . .0 0 o ub' t f o to ci n l n rh ' go o m voaigteb res f o o lA i n , u T xsN w Meioa dC lonaa welatra ilt h od ro n t ny ro a b t ea, e x n ai ri s l het n z c f t b t teriznya dten t n leui . o oh h icte r n h ai ascry i o t T eSae f roa idat ev oi o ap at teU i dSae C utf pel h tt o Ai n fe i ln te f p elo h nt tts o ro A pa zlm c e s frh Nit Crut t amoint ep dt tecs, moinwhc wa d ne b cue o te nh i iwi c h t o xe i h ae a t i s e id ea s o e oh -2 teUntdSae D p rme t fut ealgdte dd 'hv e o g t et pe aea h i tts e at n o Jsi l e h y int ae n u h i o rp r e ce m pe dn wi ter otm- s pt fi e p ro n l n txp y r ny la ig t h ib to l s io tm , esn e a d a-ae mo e. h e I gatn tefd rlo en e t rq eto e lre e t fi e tea p lt n rnig h e eag v rm n' e u sfr nag m n o t ,h p el e s m a cute fr a ie alfrh p re wi apoetdhaigdtfrh 1ta o o rstot t tbe o te ats t rjce er aeo te Sdy f hm ih n N vmbr21,ut n dy eoeh nt nllcin. oe e,00jso e a bfrte ai aeet s o o Atrh t e fig fh N teoA pa teD pr et futefe aMoin f te i l i o te oi f pel h eat n oJsi id t e myl n c , m cl o t Ds i iteU i dSae Dir t o rfr i n , h e iDiio , i tecs i o i s n h nt tts s i C uto Aro a P o nx vs n whl h aes ms e tc z i e p n igo a p a.rs e tB rc HusiMo a ma Ob maa dhsc n l rn g d e dn n p e lPei n aak sen h m d a n i l al e e a e d oy D pr et fT s U'IcCv RgtDv ino I alsn indrc sn i rae eat n o ut s s) ii ihs is fe l adoe ae aiz s r m il io g y te cryn o th io np ro a maa r v n et a dMc atyt d srcino te arig u ter w esn l cbe e d ta n c rh i etut fh e o c aatr n itgi o sae a ant meia ct e salg dyfrhe rao s h rce a d nery ftts g is A r n izn l e l o tre esn : t ci e FrttiIiainwa iiae a ant r o afr oicles n, o iteitrs i ,hsigto snt td g is Ai n o p lia rao sn tn h neet s t i z t ojsi .h Wht H ue tai a d olt li e rlvn it cmma de te fut eT e i o s moi t n n gaaaIm se atso o n erh c e vo t e Lt ov t b paigteo u o dsr iaino Aro aa di p biofilb alwig ai oe y lcn h n s f i i n t n i n n t u l fias y l n n cm o z s cc o teD mo rt at t cam ce ifr p rhcIglitr fr n ris n i g l ln ta h e ca Pry o li rdto a yri ea vcoyo mioie a d l aai s h t t le e eie cs naee b t ylf mei iv l inote osi t noteU idSae, v ne a lgd er aoA ra n ia o fh C ntui fh nt ttsa d a c ot to e b taata'b e o g igfrh p s eg te y asu d rhe Peie t, u cridt ery lh t e n n on o te at ihe n e r n e tre rs nsb t ar o s d e tee te eb tecre tnu b n. h xrm y h urn icm e t Scn , h fd rloen e tlws i ta p n letein cn a dta a on eo dT e e eag vrm n a ut h t e ai h n o e t n h t n it s z - 3 - teg iyu d rh b n e o Aa d i sretePeie t lb s iigteba ea a h ul n e te a n r f rb es ev h rsd n wely hfn h lm w y t m t fo PeietB rc Husi Mo a ma Ob maa dhsAtre Ge ea'rso sbly o rm rs n aak sen h m d a n i ton y n rl ep niit, r d s i teIkhro,oefre mei's ttrimirt nIwAtll 8C ntU S h a teeft noc A rast uoym gai a .rie j , os. . . c ca o t ra s e d: '...T eC n rs sal ae h p we ' h o ges h lh v te o r t po iefrh 'o mo d fne o rvd o te c m n ee s' a d'e ea wefr' fh U i dSae. n g n rl l eo te nt tts a e T po iefr algfrhtemit t o rvd o cln ot h li o i ia eeueh Iw ote no,upes xcttea sfh uinsp rs Isret nadrp/nain. nurci n eeivsos' o ' (mp aiadd E hs d e) s Ti,h Cntui oteUidSae (dc 1j2paetersos iyo hr te ositn fh nt ttsA ie1 )l sh epnil fr d to e l c bi t te rtcinoA ei 'bres q aey nteso les fh Peiet fh U i d h poet f m ras odrsurlo h h udrote rs n ote n e o c d t Sae (aak usiMoa ma O a a,h Vc Peiet Je ietn alte c i ttsB rc H se hm d bm tte i rs n (o Bdn ad l hril n ed ov ofesfh U idSae(c dn EiH l r D pr etfuteadHmead fcrote ne ttsi l i r od ' eat noJsi n o ln i t nu g c es m c Scry, ob ter non firya-f r eropd r adtte aerq i d o eui)wh y hio gigal e er t - a t e om uy hy r e ur t t u aey e p rom, yIw, r c lci la darg nltu bn ter o ea A ei ivoaino efr b a ae ol t ey n ro at h m ig h in s t m ra n il o f ev y c t tero si t nd t. h ic ntui uy to Iisb ie ta PeietB rc HusiMo a ma Ob maso g igwi u ts u m t d ht rs n aak sen h m d a ' n on l l t d l f firt efreteimiainlw otint nia al e ipah be fes i al eo noc h m g t a s fh ai s n lgdm ecalo nen u ro so e f voainoAtl1j4 C ntU. . il o f rie1 , os. S t c T efd rlg n isa dtefd rl/iilsc a teU i dSae Atre h e eaae ce n h e eao cas u h sh nt tts ton y e -4 G nrlEiH le,r b lwrsos lfrmmirt nefre e tn ttl iai . eea r odrae ya ep nieo i gai nocm n,o i e s t n ,c b o s gl o TetttrImirtnJ#N tnly rfN ' #UsCj10 esq e pwes h sauoym gui p ui ni A' A) ... 11 teo m o r o ot ', I vru aec si ldn teofcoitrsDpr etfutet amiiead ai sgni (cuigh cnltfneet eat noJsi )o d n trn o en i m c s efreh sauoyimiainI s rmu ae b teCnrsoteUidSae. noc tetttr m g t a po l td yh oges fh nt tts ro w g e T eC mmo we I o Vriiiatmpigt i pe e tIws i iroAro ao l h o n at f i nas te tn o m lm n a sm l t i n ny hg a z t dso e tetra o Iw si fo Peie t aa k senMo a ma Ob maa dhs o i v rh het fa ut rm rs n B rc Husi h m d a n i c s d D p rme t fut eie aaind fn eswh awassebaka wht a dwht a ba k e at n o Jsi lg ll ee d r, o l y e lc s i n i s lc cl e e e a welsalg dyb igi voaino Ig lti a dter a ot b avsn teie a s la l e l en n ilt fea ehc n h ib r ah y d iig h lg l e o s l ain t e gg icvli b de c a dt in r teIwsIAr o a teU.. e at e t f l so na en iids e in e n og oe h a .n i n ,h S D p rm n o e o z Jsi itraei t seteIclh rtntu pri yu lclhrfadiVrii uteshetnn o u h oasei o sp otg o roasei;n n i na c g f n f g te mei Cvliets no (CUanucdiw udseec adeey fcr h A ra ii breU inA L)none t ol u ah n vrofe c Li i e friga yVriii mirt nIwafcigie aain. r aice r ia'al nocn n i na m gai a f t lg ll sAmei s lal n ' i g o en l e c yt wagn ted g'i ainwh nic me t e frigtent n i mirt nlws g ig h o 'su t e t o so nocn h ai sm gai a . to o o Iy ucnt rtc y u b reste y ucntpoet o 'etent n Aro aa d f o a 'poet o r od r,h n o a ' rtc y ur h ai ! i n n oz Vrii aetahn ten t n b ea pe a o th tra o teivs na dc n u r go i na r e c ig h ai , y x m l, b u te he t fh nai n o q ei f g o o n Ameiawi o tin aso. r t u fig h t chr ltelh otiotf o t ln Iwesnaino A ei b i glln,n n h i t fh u ocnr ada l ivs f m ra yl aaesad g s o so cei Peie t aakHusiMo a ma Ob masa tcaimesg t Ai n a dten t n rs n B rc sen h m d a ' uo rt sa e o ro a n h ai d c z o c n o iga acyo e Iwa dod rneca g fr Lt ov t gcntu nyteft o o d nn n rh v ra n re i xh n e o a ai oi o si e c,h ae f nn t - 5 - tes uh etr sae, n p ra sh nt n rss oeywi tec nce c o tecut h o tw sen ttsa d eh p te ai ,ets ll t h o sine fh o rs o h o ticrutod awi a ie t n p ryrldslyn af u t atu efrh fhs i it e l t nn p o e at ue ipaig l ny ti d o te c h a t cntuinadteu iasse ta cmmu i tsoeeyl aA ei nci nta o si t n h jdc lytm hto nc e t vr e lm ra iz ht to i a g c te 'h fd rlo en et nta dy uc nt' ' e e eag v rm n wo ' n o a 'l t ' Un e tecntuin lu rne s ee ae t tesae a welsu d rh io n d rh o si t ag aa te d lg td o h tts s l n e ter w to a saec ntuin adafi r b tecutt po iearme y ad c inifv r fh tt o si t , n al e y h o rso rvd e d, eio n ao o te to u s D p rme t fut ewiIaeteGo en r f r o aa dtep biof ilwi o t e at n o Jsi le v h v ro o A i n n h u l fias t u a cl z cc h stfcoyatraiet rsoecl rla i t rpaea acy poeti c i n a d aiatr l nt o etr ut a snt o e lc n rh ; rtc t iz s n s ev u y s te tui fo ci ea dci elrsa dt rsstetci ,taae a dp lialmoi td o rtrm r n r od; n o ei h at ssrtg m n oicl t ae s m m t c ty v b yot gb og nzdo p ru i , ulw sntayct ss lsrign npoipoi es o c ti y ra i p otns o ta a cu r ie,ef evn o -rf rfe r n e t itt a dmi ud ds ntayrliu go p a doh r, opaeteref evn a e d n s ie a cu r eio s ru s n teswh lc h islsrig g n a g g a o ep titm ta'hvn teefc o dvdn Ameiawi terail n eh i b v ar i ht aig h fet f iiig r t h irca a d tnc os s ch rdclm dsusda 'h n e' yteS eko Arb ihs2 0 Peie t la p inT e a i i i i s' a g 'b h h i f a yn i 0 8 rsd ni cm ag . h as g e c a jdc lytm ma hv be b r a n h, u h pfl,o Isngt u iasse y ae en on t i tb t o eul ntat i ! i g y h C nie t t tea o e p tin r v s ohcutt dn teMoint Ds is o s tn wi h b v , eio e mo e b t o rso ey h t o im s s h t o pofrdb teU i dSae D p rme t fut eCvl ihsat isfrh fr e rf e y h nt tts e at n o Jsi iiRg t cis o te om r e e c vt rao s n terao s eo . es n a d h es n b lw - 6 - I THEFLNG OFTHENOTIEOFAP E LDI E T II C PA VS THEUNIE S ATE DITRI COUR OFJ RIDITI N TD T S S W T USCO T ein o a ie ad aiN teoA p aia eet fui iin li icne h fig f t l n vl oi f p el n vn ojrdco as nfac l my dc s st gi ta dvss ti cutfui itnoe matrrle t teapaa d o fr ht i ta rlo rojrdci v r tese td o h peln cnes ea so a jrdcino a a plt cutGgs . rv et osme Ds.o 49U S5,8 ui i o n n p ele o r i vPoi n Cnu r i C. 5 ..65 st a .g d c, (92;0a eWm. osMor'Fdrl rci j333 ()3dd 19)Pc/v 18)2 Jm s Mor oeseea Pate 0 .2 1(re.97,epe . , c . Medz1 cl t18 (9 9. ne, 9 a. h 04 19) 4 Onean t eo a p aife , lwe tilo rma n t aaeo a e di o n c oi f p e l id a o rr c ut y o vct r m n t w c sl a s jdmet r re n r oay te atht u afcter hs fh pre o ipcte u g n o odr o d n ohrctawo l f th i to te ats rm ath de g i i u s na p a; n mot etil, o t atr h i u s r imi tecs,n tee y s e o p e la d scranyn to l tes e o ds s h aea d h rb , s e s s d n a a p l ea yo p ru i wh to v ropee t d fneiacut fa i rso s e y n p el n p otnt ase e t rsn a ee s n o ro Iw n ep ne e y t aoiltoen et dmado cnomi adcnomi isec frhswh si o sc i gvrm n' e n frofr t n ofr t nineotoe o tl as s y yl l b lv isaer hsa dteC ntuino teUntdSae g aa te r h t d epoes ei en tt i t n h o si t fh i tts u rne d i to u rcs e g to e g o I . ne Vl vU i ri o suhr Clona6 C l p .d8 7(97. fa Medz av . nv st f oten al ri,7 a A p3 8 17 ) w o ey f . Lgca da'esn be'nepeaino teIw as tdb c mmo sneso l o i n ' ao a l'itrrtt fh a sie y o n e s h ud r o s dcaetajrd t noe a ae a o lb ioecutt t eTeeso lb n i t b ui ii vr cs cn n en n o ra ai .h r h ud e o t s co y m frh r rce ig i teIwe c ut uigtep n e c o a a p afe i at ey ute poe dn sn h o r o rd r h e d ny f n p e li d n i l n l m ma n r ea s o as i ifcs otehg e c ut n teaod neo d ashzp rnc n e b cue f hf n ou t h ih r o ra d h v ia c f u lci he i t o - 7 - liainta'n t ot n t eefin t ete tep riso tec uts o lb v i. igt ht o csa d i fiet o i rh aie rh o rs h ud e od to s mc h t Adsrto rlssui iin vrnat nw e () p r pr cs na pata i i cutoe jrdco oe a ci h n 1a at ef ta pelht tc st o ye ife iat e manr ()h apaifo a apa beodr fh Iwecutad sidn i l n e;2te pel rm n pel l re oteo ro r n l my s a ; ()h ius r nvr eie o te rsb teIwe cut 3tes e wee ee dc d n h mei y h o ro r s d t . T etmeies fh figo ten t eo a p a, sidctd h s o et b o h i l s o te in f h oi f p e la n iae , a c m o e f n l c cicl p r neijrdcinlemste u rme o ro teU idSae ie saig ri i ot c nui i o atr ,h S pe C utfh nt ttst l tt ta m a st e sf n wt c ryadseicyhtt eyi go anteo apaia ilaeiaui iinl i l i n pcitta 'i lfi f oi fp el c i s s jrdco a h at fi ml n c n vc st rq i methtofrjrddino ahge cut B we vRsel17SC.36 eur nta cnesui i o n ihro r- o l .usl 2 .t26, e s 's , 26 (07. h ciclaefr eemii whte jrdcinpse t tecut f 36 20)T e ri dt o dtr nn eh rui i o asso h o ro ta g st a p asited t o tefigo ten t eo a p a.e Gib,u r, 5 U..8 p e l s h ae fh i fh oi f p e lS e b ss pa4 9 S5 , l n c Whna oi o apait eyid ar lo ridvse ojrdcinate ie e n te f pel i lfe , tacuts i td fui i o th t c sm l i e st m ten t eife , o wh ntea p a isbe u nld cee b tea p lt c ut h oi sid n t e h p e ls u sq e t o ktd y h p el e o r. cl y a Teeoet al te rlo rt eec eui iinoeteD prmet futeMoin h rfr,o lw h ti cuto xri jrdco vrh eat n oJsi t o a s st co t Ds i w udnt n hv teutwadefco al igwocutt hv jrddin o i s o l o o l ae h no r f t f lwn t o r o aeui i o ms y eo s s oetesmecs atesme iebtt o lpeui aple r hsntics. vrh a ae th a t ,u iw ud rjdc pel si ti hs ae m e eg Tert nlbhn terltatein o anteo apat nfrjrdcin h ai ae e i h ue hth fig f oi fp elr sesui i o o d l c a st f mtedsrtort te p elecuts' po oeuiaeo o yadaodte r h i i cuto h ap lt o ri t rm tjdc lcnm n vi h o tc a o i cnui adieiectamihf wfo ptn tesmeiut bfrtoor a ofsn n nyc nyht gtl rm utgh a s es eoew cut t o i o i s) s tesmet e'2 Mor,spa j332 ()Gbsspa49U. .t8 Adsrt h a i 0 oe ur. 0.3 1, 'b,ur,5 Sa 5. i i m * tc cutn a aplt cutf pelsolntt mptasrjrdci oe acs orad n pele oroapas hu oat to setui i o vr ae a de s tn - 8 - Si utn o sy m l e u l, a T ep roeotejrdcin la it poeth rloterv wigc ut h up s fh ui i o abrso rtcte oe fh ei n or st e b prsrigtesau q ou ttea p a c nb d cd d Ote ie atilo r y e ev h tts u nih p e la e e ie . h - s , r c ut n l a c uditr r wi a a p a b ca gn ters lo terc r u d re iw, n o l nef e t n p e ly h n ig h e ut rh e od n e rve a d eh tee y p silmo t gtee tea p lt po e so sg ic nlatr go h rb , o sby oi h ni p ele rc s r infa t l i r n r a i y en maeil afcigtepe e tt no teise t b rve e .T wn e M Su eir tr l f t h rs nai fh s u s o e e iw d o s l p r ay e n o o C ut2 C l4h18 (9 9;nr Marg o Vre 6 Ca. p .t92(98 or 0 a.t 04 19 )I e rae f ann 8 lA p4h 3 19) i (T etacut ynt k a yod r i wiIse teefcieeso te 'h r lorma o mae n re whc lesn h f t ns fh i h ev a plt cut o iin) p ele ors pnov. a ' T erleist peet dsrto rf mzae// mo iigi d c in h ue x t o rvna i i cutr p/r # dfn t eio s tc o a yss p n iga p lt rve b c uea a p lt cutse tldt rve aqe rte e dn p ele e iw e a s n p eae o ri ni o eiw x 4 ah r a t e ta amo l rc r. r 0/&Re nh Co p n z Tn e s e0/Co pay 8 0F h n bl e od Ken 7 lg m a y e n se 7 m n 4 . e 2 70(A9 Ci-18) d 3 C * r 98. . Iis b ie ta alwigtelwe c utoe tr iApeln' Molnt ts u mt d h t l n h o r o rt net n p l t t o t o a as b - 9 - Di lsatrh apapoesiimoinwipeu i Apele r hsT ei us s f te pe lrcs sn t l rjdc pl s i t. h s e me o e eg s pe e tditic s s o l b tse i cuti ama n rh r cn itn wi te rs ne n hs a e h ud e etd n o r n ne ta s o sse t t h h r h t ' d yi c u 'g aa te b teCo si t no teUntdSae a dte i to ' a n o d' u rne d y h n tui fh i tts n h ga to e F d rl lsoAp elt Prc d r. l dSttsMEsaePrs ralnS/e e , e ea Rue f p l e o e ue Unt ae a e tt e evt r s b 22F3 19 ,0 7I , 1C 9 Cr-2 0) 0 .d 03 19 12 (A 1 i 00. . Th fd rlo en e t la speest h v ac s d cd db u ig e e eag v rm n aw y rfr o ae a e e ie y sn poe ua tcist d lycs sfr e r, a ku th o p st na dn v r a igt rc d rla t o ea ae o y as b nrpte p o io n e e h vn o c i a s e ac mpan o atraiey n v rh vn t a de steise o teme . nw r o lit r l n t l,e e a ig o d rs h su s n h ns ev Th s po e uag mn sisaetesa d r toso teDe at e t f utelg l ee rcd rly at r h tn ad o l fh p r n o J si e a c m c c mp n im frh pa tigo Iw iama n r n lg u t ta o p is p eswh o e du o te rcin fa n n e a ao o s o h t f hl o h r o c o agudfr e tr so e ' owma yAn escnd n eo teh a o apl7 r e o c nui v r' e H n g l a a c nh e d f h ' Th b re itic s i nt nteStt o Aron a tedrc rs lo te e ud n n hs a e s o o h ae f i a s h i te ut fh z e s lo to Ameiat teMe ia g v rme tie a ain a dtroit b Prsd n el u f r o h xc n o en n,lg l l s n err s y eie t c l e s Baa kHus i Mo a ma Ob ma teU. De a me t o J sie, aea d rc sen h m d a ;h S. p d ns f ut Stt n c - 10 H mea dS cryada'ontif Cogeswi e pysi srtn whlstn o ln eui;n d ohn nrs t m t-ut t tg i iig t h s ui e t d wndes di Strsan ldate. o rse n a-p ge tr i T eb re o tea pln prun a' ccaln e (yohtaijr)s h udn nh p el t usig f llh l g 'hptei lnuyi a a e c mu hh a irh nteb re o teStt o Ar o ap run a 'sa#/#' c e ve ta h ud n n h ae f i n us ig n ' # / z a # caeg (culnuy. naaMC o rz / ,1 F3 15 ,0 0I -4)CA h ln e ataijr)Getl # f tsn 23 .d 05 16 1 ( c 9 Ci-0 0.fh NnhCiut l tt in rtecne o imirt nta wi * r 20 )lte it r iee sog oe h acr fm gai ht l . cc o ie i byJel tin t nte Aro aa dAmeiaaewi o t n rme yu d r n vt l //a hs ai ,h n i n n a o z r r t u a y e d ne c h Iwwi teatraiee c ua iga acyi rv re. e KCo te tl s at a t h l n t n o rgn n rh n e es Dls r nl na Ca u l h ev h y C . 4 F 3 9 093( -4)C 8 Cr-20 ) o, 0 .d 2 ,2 2 (A t i 0 6. 4 h. Th Aro ac s iaciac s iv ligie aain be kn teIwo te e i n ae s n n la e novn lg ll s ra ig h a fh z le In ,n al e l,oi aciiascmmii b rele(opnitne)rao ada d lg dyp lc lr nl o tn odrh n u nedd t sn e tm i tg l e b fin t p d r tere p n iiisdcae b teCo sit no teUntd y alg o e om h irso sble ittd y h ntui fh i i i t to e SttsA'e sn be' es nc n o d n tefc ta e eyma , ma a dc i ae . z a o a l'p ro a n t e y h a tht v r n wo n n hl r d e tr gtic u t ie alaecslasb Ig l eiio ,fh yr be kn o r nei hs o nr lg l r n h l ye a d f t n ite ' raig u n yl y ni e - 11 Ivs av. Th fd rlo en e t symoet h v tedsrt o rga th iMoint e e eag v rm ns I v o ae h iti c ut rn ter t o c o Ds i t atrh apajrdciniafe lefro ter atoaodte ims o l te pelui i o s e b f tnh iprt v i h se st eo p siit o teDe at e t f utete s le h vn t a p awh tsb sc l a o sbly fh p r n o J si h m ev s a ig o p e l a i a ial i m c y cia ratrli weletdlwba teUntdSttscn o a p a iaciia nnn l t .ts ls te a th i ae a n t p e ln r n l e l e m c s wio th e pesc n rsin l uh rain UntdSae zMat l e a e t u te x rs o ge so a a toi t . l tts rn i n h zo e in &, 8 4 0U. 545 89 S, t14 .8U. C. j33 ; ndSae B &, 3 S.6 ,6 ,7 C.3 91 S. A. 71 U l tts . , e SYo,9 U. 2 7 2 1-12n 2 ,0S. . 17 lsn3 9 S.6 ,9 9 .0 9 Ct2 1. Th F d rl t peswan do o ep r c nrlv r Ihe ba c e o o r e e eal Pa r re f n a? o t o e al re rn h s f u yo t g v rme tT iIiain iiae b o r o en e t g is teStt o Ar o aa di o en n. hs ig t ,nt td y u g v rm n a an th ae f i n n t to i z s ct e s ialg dyac ecv atmp t h v tefd rlo rsse c n o e wh t iz n ,s l e l o rie t to a e h e ea c uty tm o d n a i e e c no lb d s r e a ab t y l f me b , n s p otgara o a l h p te i, a ny e e ci d s er a o A n a a d u p rn e s n be y oh ss b a i ta u d r rsd n Baa kHu s i Mo a ma ob wad morc k Ameiai h t n e Pe ie t rc s en h m d a e ca y n r s c dsedn whl fsit ollm ibgn igi acnin ecn ig i acs sci s e inn t seso . e s s - 12 WHE EF RE p tin r v stih n rbec utods isteg v rme t R O , ei e mo e hs o oa l o rt im s h o en ns t o ot f/emoinfe atrh SaeoAro afe i Noieo Ap a, to t rl u o /p t id f te tt f i n idt t f e lwi u oa ? ol e z ls c h ag me t n wi o t p o igbif b igrq i d, n ta tea p a b alwe t ru n a d t u o p sn r s en e ur a d h th p e l e l d o h e e o c niu o tep t a dt etbes to hb Ore o tea p lt c ut o t e n h ah n i a l e fd y d r fh p el e o r. n m a P ITS:Assae a oe ON ttd bv . AU HORIIS:Assae a o e T TE ttd b v . Re p cfl s b ie , set l u mtd uy t // s RA BE TP RK Rpos Y R A E re P s Olc B x3 0 3 ot e o 266 Alx n r , rii2 3 0 ea di Vi na 2 2 ag (0) 2 -26 7338 36 - 13 I THE N UNIED S ATE COURTOFAPPE L TTS AS F RTHE NI TH CI CUI O N RT T EUNIE 5A E OFAME IA H T D T T5 RC ) ) A p ln, ) p el t a ) ) ) C N . 0- 6 4 A o 1 16 5 (AN .:00c 1 1 S B C o221 v 43 R ) T ES A EOFARZ N ANDJ NIEK H TT IO A AC . B E E , R OROFA IONA i R W R GOVE N RZ ,n h r fiila ai e of a cp cy c t A p le p el . e ) ) C R IIATEOFS RVIE E TFC EC Pt in rR YEE E TP R E , ee ysae u d r ahta atu c p o te eio e, A LB R A K R h rb tts n e o t h t re o y fh t a o epe dn h s e nmald p saepe ad ti 2 td yo Au ut2 1 ,ote b v la ig a b e i , otg rp i,hs 5h a f g s, 0 0 t j e ) fl wig T eH n rbeJnc K Be e, v ro o teSaeo Aro a Ap ele ol n : h o oa l a ie . rw rGo en r f h tt f i n , p l , o z e EeuieT we o SaeC ptl1 0 Wet s igo Sre, h e i, r o a8 0 7 T e xct o r f tt a i , 7 0 sWahn tn tetP o nxAi n 5 0 9 h v o z H n rbeT ryG d ad Eq, ton yG n rlo teSaeo Ar o a C u slo o oa l er o d r, s -At re e eafrh tt f i n , o nefr z Ap ele Of eo teAtre Ge eafrh Saeo A i n , 2 5Wet s igo p l , fi fh ton y n rlo te tt f r o a1 7 s Wahn tn ec z Sre, h e i,Ai n 8 0 7 a dt c u slo teD p rme t fut eA p ln: ry tetP o nx ro a 5 0 ; n o o nefr h e at n o Jsi p el tTo z c a wetEq, si a t i dSae Atre o b h lo aIf p eln'ta , a ey s, s -A ss n Unt tts to ny n e af f Io a p l t e m n m l t e as , D vsK B re Eq, i d Sae Aton y Arh r . od egAsia tDrco, e ea a i . uk, s.Unt tts tre; tu R G lb r, s tn ietrFd rl e s - 14 Po rmsBa t ; h r hlk mar Eq; n lsp Wie fl. s .U i dSae rga rn h V u E i a ri s -a d oe h l ned Eq, nt tts a , k e D p rme t fut e Cvl iio , 0Masc uetAv n e N , sigo , . .0 3 . e at n o Jsi , iiDvs n 2 sah sts e u , W Wahn tn D C 2 5 0 c i R s e fl s b ie , ep d ul u m t d y t // s R YEB TP R E, r s AL A K R po e P s Ofi B x3 0 3 ot fe o 2 6 6 c Alx n r , rii2 3 0 e a di Vi na 2 2 ag (0) 2 - 36 73 38 26 - 15 I THE N UNI E S ATE COURT OFAPPE L TD T S AS F R THENI TH CI CUI O N RT T EU IE SA E OF MEIA H NTD T TS A RC A p ln, p el t a ) ) C N .0- 6 4 A o 1 16 5 (AN .:00c 11 S B C o221 v 4 3 R ) T ESAT OF ION ANDJ NIEK H T E ARZ A AC. B E E , VE N ROFARZ N ,n R W R GO R O IO A i H r /iila ai e o cacp cy t A p le p el . e ) ) ORDE R P tin rR YEB R P R E Sa iu c r emoina dMe oa d m hvn c me eio e,A L E T A K W m c s ui t n m rn u a ig o t ao b fr tih n rbecut tec nr uint ticut d cso maigpo esh vn eoe hs o oa l o r, h o ti to o hs o r' ei n kn rcs a ig b si b e cniee ,n tee tr pednso o p s gp rishvn b e rve e a d e n o s rd ad h ni la ig f p o i at aig e n e iw d n d e ne cniee ,tshs o s rd iiti d d yo af ,00 2 1, OR E E ,ht eio e'moinb , n tesmeih rb, rne ; n ii D R D ta p t in r t e a d h a s ee yga td a d ts tso , F R H ROR E E ,htpt in r pe dn b ma ep ro tecut of il U T E D R D ta eio e' la ig e d at fh o rs fia ts 'c rcrfr upss f f ajdmeted rdb ticut n a a t e rlvn a p r eodo proe oai lug n rn ee y hso rad t Ii seeat s at n lm o terc r o a p a. fh eod n p e l // S // S UNIE SA E AP EGT I D E TD TTS PL EU G UNIE S A E AP EG T J D E TD T TS PL EU G UNIE SA E AP EGT J D E TD TTS PL EU G -- // S -2

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?