Kristin Perry, et al v. Arnold Schwarzenegger, et al
Filing
382
Received copy of Supreme Court Of California opinion dated 11/17/2011. [7975582] (RR)
R E c E IV E D
M LYcD E ,LR
O L .WYRCEK
U .OROAPAS
.COT FkEL
s
SPE C R
U R ME OU T
I THE S
N
UPREM E COURT OF CALI Fe eikK OhrhClr
FORNG . lc ek
rdr
c
i
D pN
eu
KRITI M. ERRY ea.
SN P
t1
,
PanifadRep n et,
litfs n so dns
519 7
84 6
G.
BROWN,R.a Go ro,t.e a. 9hCi. .016 6
J , s ven rec,t 1 t rNo 1-6 9
,
Deedns
fn at;
N. Ca. .
D. lNo
CI AND COUNTY OFS F NCICO,
TY
AN M
S
30 -v0 2 2W1
:9c-2 9 - W
Itree a dRep n et
nevnr n so dn;
ED
DE SHOLLI WORT ea.
NNI
NGS
H t1
,
ItreesadAp elns
nevn r n p l t.
a
Ath rq et fh UntdSae Co ro Ap elfrteNit Cici
te eu so te i tts ut f p as o h nh rut
e
,
weare t d cd aq et no Caionalw tairlvn t teu dryn
ged o eie u si f l ri a hts ee ato h n elig
o
f
l utntimatr o pnigitafdrlpeltcut(cr vBo
a ii hs t nw edn nhteeaapl e or.P ry . rwn
ws
e
a
(t CrNo 1-69)seCa. ue o C uirl85 8)As oe b te
9h i- .0166;e lR ls f or,ue .4 . psd yh
Nit Crutteqet nt b dcddiSwlehr n eatlI,etn8o
nh i i h usi o e eie ss hteudr rce Isci f
c,
o
l
i
o
teCaionaCo si to ,rohr s u drCaionalw,heofca
h lfri ntuin o tewie n e l ri a t f il
t
f
po o eto a iiaiemesr p sesete apriuaie itrsi te
rp nns f n nt t aue oss i r at lrzd neetn h
iv
h
c
iiitv 'v l i o teatoi t asrteSaesitrsi teiiaies
nt ies ai t rh uh rt o seth tt' neetn h nt t '
a
dy
y
iv
v l i , ihwo l e alte t dfn tecnttto ai o teiiaie
ai t whc ud nbehm o eed h o si in ly fh nt t
dy
u t
iv
uo i aotnoapaaug nivlaigteiiaiewhnte ul
pnt dpi rpeljdmetnai t h ntt , e h pbi
s o
dn
iv
c
ofcascag dwi ta d t rfs t d s '
fiil hre t ht uy eueo o o.
h
'
I adesn tiisewee h sz ateo teta ato g iti
n d rsig hs su , mp aie th ustht l u h n hs
h
cs teq eto poe b teNit Cicihp est aiei liain
aeh u sin sd y h nh rut apn o rs n igto
t
S E CONCURI OP NI
E
UNG I ON
caln igtev ldt,ndrh UntdSae Co si to , fteiiaie
h l gn h aii u e te i tts ntuin o h nt tv
e
y
e
t
i
mesr (rp sin8taaddascint teC lo aCosttn
auePooio )htde et o h ai mi ntui
t
o
f
io
poiigtaûonymar g bt e ama ada ma ivl o
rvdn htç ll ri e ewen n n wo n s ai r
l
a
d
rcg ie i C lo a'C lCos.a ., 75,h sae1wisetahs
eonzdn ai mi'(a. nt l 1j .)te tt a su hta
f
,4
be sb te t ticutsttl u rltdt tesbtnieq et no te
en u mi d o hs ori oal neae o h u sat u si fh
t
y
v
o
cntuinl aii o Po oio 8 lsed teq eto b fr u ivov sa
o si to a v l t f rp st n . nta,h usin eoe sn le
t
dy
i
fn a na po eua isetama aiewi rsetoayiiaiemesr,
' dmetl rcd rlsu ht y rs t ep ct n nt t aue
u
h
iv
wioteadt i sbet tr T esme rcdrlsu rgriga
t u rgr ot ujcmat . h a poeuaise eadn n
h
s
e
of ilntt e rpnn's nigt apaa a atiauiilrceig
fiaiiai pooet t dn o per s pr n jdcapoedn
c iv
sa
y
t dfn tevl i o avtrapoe iiaieot apaaug n
o eedh ai t f oe-p rydntt ro p el jdmet
dy
iv
iv l aigiwhnt p biofcaswh odnrl po iesc ad fneo
n ai t t e he u lc fiil o riai rvd uh ees r
d n
y
flsc a apel el et d s,o l aiewi rgr t a iiaie
i u h n p a d ci o o o cud rs t ead o n nt t
e
n
h
iv
mesr ta,o ea l,1l tdcmpincnr uin tama b
auehtfr xmpe()i e a ag oti t sht y e
mi
bo
clce b eetdlgsaieo eeuieof il,r2 i oe tr l t
ol td y lce eilt rxct fi aso ()mpsdem i s
e
v
v c
mi
freilieadeeuieof e,r3 poiidgvmmet fcasrm
o lgst n xct fcso ()rhbt oe n of ilfo
av
v i
e
i
acpige ly n atrlaigofc wi cmpne o idvd asht ae
cet mpo met fe evn fie t o ais rn iiu ltahv
n
h
bn ftdfo teofcas dsrto aygv mmetl eiin whl i ofc.
eeie rm h fiil' iceinr o e na dcso s i n fie
e
( .eg,rp 7 (r r Ee.Jn 7 18),naiae ipriKopv
Cf ..Po .3Pi y lc(ue ,98)ivl td n atn p .
,
ma
d
FarP lPate Co (9 5 1 Ca.t 67(a ag cnr uinl t)
i o. rci s m.19) 1 1 h 0 cmpin oti t i s;
c
4
b o mi
Po .4 ( nEe.No .,90)uhliLgs tr vE (9 15
rp 10 Ge. lc( v 619),p ed n eiaue . u 19) 4
l
C l d42(r l tjCi o SnaMoias alt aue rpL
a. 9 t m i s; t f at nc'bl mesrPo .L
3
e mi y
o
( noiae Ge. n Ee.No .,00)uhli Ci o a tMoiav
Cosl td nMu . lc( v 72 0),p edn t fsna nc .
d
y
Se at20)16Ca.p .t4 (otoen n e ly n l tq T e
tw r(05 2 1 p4h 3p s vrmetmpometi s. h
A
g
mi )
rslto o tipoeuaq et nd e n tuno t sbtn eo te
eouin fhs rcd rl usi os o tr nhe u sac fh
o
priua iiitv mesr a iseb tahro tep roeaditgi o te
at lrntaie aue tsu ,u rte n h up s n nert fh
c
y
iiai poesief
nt t rcs t l.
i ve
s
Aswedsusmoefl b lw,ntep sofca po o eto iiaie
ic s r ul eo i h at fiil rp nns fnt tv
y
i
mesrsi Caionah v u ioml be pr t dt pat iaea pat s
aue n l ri a e nfr y en emit o ri p t s ri f
e
c
e
ete a itre eso a rap risi itrs i n meo slwsi i
i r snevnr r s el at n neet n u ru a ut n
h
e
s
Caionacutcaln igtevl i o teiiaiepesr tepo o et
l ri o rs h l gn h ai t fh nt t aueh rp nns
f
e
dy
iv
sosrd Sc prcpt nhsot eybe pr t d() totn
pnoe. uh atiai a rui l en emie 1wi u ay
i o
n
t
h
iq i it o so n tatepo o et' wnpo et,iet, rohr
n ur no r h wig h th rp nnso rpry l ry o te
y
b
pro a lg l poetditrsswo l b seil afce b iv l aino
esn le al rtce neet ud e p cal fetd y n ai to f
y
y
d
temesr,n () ehr r otegvrmetfiilwh odnry
h auead 2 whteo nth oen n of as o riai
c
l
dfn ac aln e eat n weeas d fn igtemesr i tepo edn .
ee d hleg d n cmet r lo eedn h auen h rceig
Thscuth we e, a n t rvo syh do cso fl t epli tebss
i o r, o vrh s o peiul a cain ul o x an h ai
y
uo whc a of ilntt epooetsait tpriiaea apr i
pn ih n fiaiiai rpnnr bly o at pt s at n
c iv
i
c
y
sc liainrss
uh igt et.
t o
Aswesal x li, eas teiiaiepo esiseiial itn e
hlepan b cueh nt t rcs s p cfcl ne dd
iv
y
t ea ltep o l t a n tesaeCo si to o t eatsaue whn
o n beh epeo me d h tt ntuin ro n c ttts e
t
creto e n of ilhv dcie t aotadotnhv p bil
urn gvmmet fcas ae el do dp (n f ae ul y
i
n
e
c
op sdtemesri qet nte oeswh hv scesul aotda
poe)h auen uso,h vtr o ae ucsfl dpe n
i
y
iiai mesr ma rao al hro algt t cn entatep bi
nt t aue y esnby ab r e imae o cr hth u l
i ve
i
c
ofcaswh odnrl d fn acaln e sae1w i cut yn ti tecs
fiil o riai ee d hl g d tt a n o rma o,n h ae
y
e
o a iiaiemesr,l y u draesc adfnewi vg ro wi te
f n nt t aueawa s n etk u h ees t io r t h
iv
h
h
ojcie aditrssotoe oes aa utnmid As cneune
bet s n neet fh svtrprmon i n . a osqec,
v
Caionacuthv ruieyp r t dteofcapo o et o a iiaie
l ri ors ae o t l emit h fiilrp nns f n nt t
f
n
e
iv
t itre eo ap a a ra prisi itrst d fn acaln e vtr
o nevn r p er s el at n neeto eed h legd oee
apo e iiai mesr i odrtog adtep ol'rgtoe ecs
p rv d nt t auen re ç u r h epes ih t xrie
i ve
t
iiaie o r(uligIdsrAsnvCi o a rl (964 C1d
ntt pwe'B i n nut s.. t fcmaio 18) 1 a.
iv
' d
y
y
l
3
80 82( i igldsrAsnlo,nohr rst ealsc pooet
1,2 Bul n nut s. ri tewod,o nbe uh rp nns
d
y )
t asrte o e' adhn etesae' itrsi d fn igtev l i o
o seth pepl s n ec h tt s neetn ee dn h ai t f
,
,
dy
teiiaiemesr.Alo n ofcapo o ett asrtesaesitrsi
h nt tv aue lwig fiil rpn nso seth tt' neetn
i
tevl i oteiiaie auei sc liain(ln wi ayp bi
h ai t fh nt t mesr n uh igt aog t n u l
dy
iv
t o
h
c
of ilwh ma as b dfnigtemesr)1asrs oes o
fias o y l e eedn h aue() suevtrwh
c
o
sp otdtemesr a de atdiit lwta ayrsd a h sit o
u p re h aue n nce tno a ht n eiu l otly r
i
idfeec o cret g l ofcast tesbtn eo teiiaiemesr
n ifrn e f urn p bi f il o h u sa c fh nt tv aue
c
i
wi n t rv n afla drb sdfneo temesr t b mo ne i cut n
l o peet ul n out ees fh aue o e u td n o ro
l
tepol'bhl ad() nue acutae wi teep niit o
h epes eaf n 2 esrs orfcd t h rsos ly f
,
h
bi
rve n adrsligalg lh ln et a iiitv mesr ta iia r
e iwig n eovn ea cal g o n ntaie aue htts wae
e
o a dadessteflrn eo lg lru nstarao a l ma b
f n drse h ulag fea ag met htesnby y e
pofrdi temesr'dfne I timanrteofcapo nns
rfee n h aues ee s. n hs n e,h fiil rpo et'
gn rl blyt aperaddfn tesaesitrsi tev l i o te
eea aii o p a n ee d h tt' neetn h ai t fh
t
dy
iiaiemesr adt apaalwe cutug nivlaigtemesr
ntt aue n o pel o r orjdmetn ai t h aue
iv
dn
sre t ehnebt tefi s o teuiilrcsadteapaac o
evso nac ohh ames fh jdcapoes n h perne f
fin s o ta poes
ares fht rcs.
Wehv cuin dta i motisacsima wel ea aueo
ae ato e htn s ntn e t y lb n b s f
dsrto frac u't fit pr th ofcapo o eto a iiit et
icein o o l o alo emite fiil rp nns f n nt i o
t
av
itreeiau iilrceigtpoeth pol'r h teecs ter
nevn n jdcapoedn o rtcte epesi to xriehi
g
iiaiepo ree wh no eo moeg vrme t ee dnsaed fn igte
nt t we vn e n r r o en n dfn at r eedn h
iv
iiaies aii ite rceig (e BuligIdsyAsn,u a4
nt t 'vl t n h poedn . Se i n n ut s.spr, 1
i v dy
d
r
Ca.dap 82)T u,na is ne l etaiet e iteqet n
1 t .2 . h si nnt c i htdni dn h usi
3
a
k
f
o
sb te b teNit Cici- i whc tep bi ofcashv ttl
u mitd y h nh rut n ih h u lc fiil ae oal
y
d cie t dfn teiiaiesvldt a a1wecn ld ta,nl h o te
el d o ee d h nt t ' aii t 1 o cu e hti i t fh
n
iv
y ,
g
ntr adp roeo teiiaiepoese o idi at lI,eto 8o te
aue n up s fh nt t rcs mb de n ri e 1scin fh
iv
c
C lonaCosit n(eefr rceI,et n8 adteuiu rlo
ai ri ntui hrat atl Isci )n h nqeoe f
f
to
e i
o
iiai po nnsi tecnttto aiiaiepoesa rcg ie b
nt t rpo et n h o si in lnt t rcs s eo nzd y
i ve
u
iv
n meo spo iin o teElcin Co e iwo l cerycnttt a aueo
u ru rvso s fh eto s d,t ud lal o si e n b s f
u
dsrto fracutodn teofcapo o et o a iiaiete
icein o ort ey h fiil rp nns f n nt t h
iv
o p ru i t p riiaea fr l at si tepoedn ,i e a itrees
p otnt o at p t s oma pri n h rceig et r snevnr
y
c
e
h
4
o a rap risi itrs,nodroasrtep o l'a dh n etesaes
r sel at n neeti re t seth epes n e c h tt'
e
itrsi tevli o temesr adt apaaug n ivlaigte
neetnh ai t fh aue n o p el jdmetn ai t h
dy
dn
mesr.I oh r rsb cueiiesniloteitgiyo teiiai
aue n te wod, ea s ts setat h ner fh nt t
t
i ve
poese o idi atl I,eto 8tateebesmen t asrtesaes
rcs mb de n ri e lscin hthr o o e o seth tt'
c
itrsi a iiaiesv l iyo bh lo tep o lwhntep bi ofcas
neetn n nt t ' ai t n e af fh epe e h u l fiil
iv
d
c
wh n r l asrta itrsd ciet d s,n bcueteofca
o omal sethtneet el o o o ad eas h fiil
y
n
pooeto a iiaie( l h oter nqerlinhptteiiaie
rpnns fnntt i i t fhiu iu eaosi oh ntt
iv n g
t
iv
mesrudrr.Ij8adterlvnpoiin o teElcC d)rte
aue n e atI, n h eeat rvsos fh e. oeaeh
motovo sadlgcl esn t asrtesaesitrsi teiiai '
s b iu n o iap ro so seth tt' neetn h ntt s
i ve
v l i o b hlo tevtr whoeatdtemesr, cnld ta
ai t n eaf fh oes n ce h auewe o cu e ht
dy
Caionalw atoie teofcapo o et, n e sc cru tn e,o
l ri a uh rzsh fiil rp nnsu dr uh ic msacst
f
ap a i tepoedn t asrtesaesitrsiteiiit esv l i a d
p ern h rce ig o seth tt' neetn h nt i ' ai t n
av
dy
t apaaug n ivl aigtemesr. ieteGo enrte
o p el jdmetnai t h aue Net rh vro,h
dn
h
AtonyGe ea,o ayohe eeuieo lgsaieofca h sh atoi
tre nrlnr n t r x ct reilt fiil a te uh rt
v
v
y
t vt o iv l aea iiaiemesr tah sb e apo e b t v tr.l
o eo rn ai t n nt t aueht a en p rv d y he oes t
d
iv
wo l eatom o e sbtn et itrrt lona1wi amanrht ud
ud x lfr vr u sa c onepeCai ri a n n e tawo l
f
pr th s p biofcast idrcl aheesc arslb dn igte
emitee u l fiil o n iet civ uh eut y eyn h
c
y
ofca iiai poo etteatoi t se i t asrtesaesitrsi
fiilnt t rp nnsh uh rt o tp n o seth tt' neetn
i ve
y
tevl i o temesr o tapaalwe cutug nivl aigte
h ait fh aue ro pel o rorjdmetnai t h
dy
dn
mesr whntoep bi ofcasdciet asrta itrso t ap a a
aue e h s u lc fiil el o sethtneet ro p eln
n
avreug n.
desjdmet
Acodn l werso t teq eto poe b teNit Cicii te
crigy, ep nd o h usin sd y h nh rutn h
atnntv .I ap seeto c aln et av trapoe iiit emesr,h
f aie n otlcin h l g o oe-p rvd nt i auete
s
e
av
otcapo o eto teiiaieaeat rzdu drCaio a1wt ap a
f il rp n ns fh nt tv r uhoie n e l mi a o p er
s
i
f
adasrtest'itrsiteiiaies aii adtapaaug n
n seth tesneetnh ntt 'vl t n o pel jdmet
a
i v dy
iv l aigtemesr whntep bi ofcas oodnrl dfn te
n ai t h aue e h u l fiilwh riai eed h
dn
c
y
mesr o apasc aug n dciet d s.
aue rpeluh jdmet el o o o
n
5
1Fata a dPr cdu a Ba k run
. cu l n oe rl c g o d
Webgnwi abifu r o tefculn poeua bc gon
ei t re smmay fh ata ad rcdrl ak ru d
h
o tecret rce ig
fh urn poedn .
I Ma 20, maoi o ticutocue tateC lonasaue
n y 0 8a jry fhs orcnlddhth ai ri ttts
t
f
l t gtedsg aino ma aet o p st-e cu ls iltdterg to
i i h einto f nig o p oi sx ope voae h ih f
min
e
smesxcu lsoteeul rtcino t lwsa g aate b tete a -e ope t h q apoeto fhea s urned y h h n
gvmigpoiin o teC lo aC ntuin ( r Mar g C ss2 0)
o e n rvsos fh ai mi osit .f e ri e ae (0 8
f
to n
a
4 Ca.t 77)T eef ritegnrllcinhli C lonai
3 1 h 5. hrat ,nh eeaeet ed n ai ri n
4
e
o
f
Noe e2 0, maoi o vtrapoe Pooio 8a iiaie
vmbr 0 8a jry f oes prvd rpst n ,n ntt
t
i
iv
mesr ta a n e teCaionaCo si t nb adn anw scinaue ht me dd h lfri ntt i y d ig e et
uo
o
scin75 t at l I fh Caio aCo si to S cin75o atl 1o
eto . o ri e o te l mi ntuin. eto . f ri e f
c
f
t
c
teCaionaCo si to po ie i 11:C l maraebt e ama ada
h lfri ntuin rvdsn 1 ç y rig ewen n n
t
on
d
f '
wo niv l o rcg zdi Caio a'
ma s ai r eo nie n l mi.
.
Prp sto 8wa sb te t teAt re Geea,ic ltdfr
o oi n s u mi d o h t n y nrlcruae o
i
t
o
sg aueadfr lyfldwi teSceayo Saefrsb sint te
in tr,n omal ie t h ertr f tt o u miso o h
h
v trb fv Caionaeetr- DensHol gwot Gal . ih, ri
oes y ie lfri lcos n i ln s rh, iJKngtMat
i
n
F. terzHa-hn Wiim Ta adMakA.aso - wh aete
Guire, ks ig la m,n r Jnsn
l
orh
of ilrpnnsoteiiaiemesr udr lo alw.(lcC d,
fiapooet fh ntt aue neCai mi a Ee. oe
c
iv
f
j 32 90. S ot atro nigteiiaie eio poeste
j 4,0 1 hry f cmmecn h ntt ptin rcs,h
) l e
iv t
pooetetbihdPoet rig.o - Yeo 8a rjcoCairi
rpnns s l e rtcMar ecm s n , Poetf lona
as
a
f
Ree lhratr rtcMarg.o a aSalt auecmmie'(e
nwa(eefePoet ri ecm) s ç l mesr o t e se
a
bo
t'
Go . d, 8 17 t spri a1seto tecmpint qai te
vCoej 4 0)o uevs lapcs fh a ag o ulyh
e
f
mesr frh b lo a dt se t o ti isao to a teesigeet n.
aue o te alt n o ek o ban t dpin th nun lci
o
On dyatrteNo e e 2 0 eet nawhc Po oio 8wa
e a f h vmb r 0 8 lci t ih rp st n s
e
o
i
apoe b amaoi ovtr,p oeto temesr fe treptin
prvd y jry f oesopnns fh aueidhe eios
t
l
t
frnoiiawr o madtiticutcalnigte aii o
o a r nt i f naenhsor,hl gn h vl t f
g
t
e
dy
Pooio 2udrh Cai riCostt n T etre eios r
rpsin n ete lona ntui .(h he ptin wee
t
f
i o
t
6
ut tl cnoiae addcddtgteiSrusvHotn(09 4
lmaey osl td n eie oehrn t s . ro 20) 6
i
d
a
C lt 34(tas )T e eios otn e pi rytaPooio 8
a.h 6 Sruh. h ptin cnedd r i ht rp sin
4
t
mal
t
cntue acntuin leiin whc u drh CaionaCo siuincud
o si td o si to a rvso , ih n e te l ri nt to ol
t
t
f
t
n t rpel b ao tdtru hteiiaiepoesrte ta acntuinl
o po ry e dpe ho g h nt t rcs,ah rhn o si to a
iv
t
a n me twhc cudb ao tdb iiitv ; n ptinas cned dta
med n, ih o l e dpe y ntaieo e eio lo otn e ht
t
Prpoio 2voae tesp rt no p wesd crn e oidi te
o st n iltd h eaai f o r otie mb de n h
i
o
CaionaCo si t n.
lfri ntui
to
Whi toepeio sweepn ig a db fr ticut eie whte
l h s tin r edn ,n eoehs ordcdd ehr
e
t
t acp tematr frd cso ,h ofcapo o et o Po st n8fld
o ceth t s o eiin te fiil rp nns f rpoio i
e
i
e
moin t itre ei ec o tepoedn st dfn tev l i o
to so nevn n ah fh rceig,o eed h ai t f
dy
Prp sto 8 S ot teehe,hscutgedt ha addcd teptt n
o oi n . h rl hra rti o rare o er n eieh eio s
i
y
i
ad i tesmeodrgatdteofcapo nnsmoin t itreeite
n ,n h a re, rne h fiil rpoet' to so nevn n h
poedn sl
rce ig.
Afe bifn adoa ag me ttic uto Ma 2 , 0 9 hn e
tr reig n rlru n,hs o r, n y 6 2 0 , ad d
dwni dcs niSrusspa4 Ca.t 34cnldn ()htudrh
o t eii n t s,ur,6 l h 6,ocu ig 1ta,n ete
s o a
4
CaionaCo si t n Prp sto 8wa acntuin l med n,ahrta
lfri ntui , ooi n s o si t a a n metrte hn
to
i
to
acntuinarvso ,n tu cudb a otdtru hteiiaiepoes
o si to le iin ad h s o l e dpe ho g h nt t rcs,
t
iv
ad()hth mesrddnt iltte eaaino pwes otn
n 2 tate aue i ovoaeh sprt f o rdcr e
o
i
e o idi teCai mi Co si to
mb de n h lo a ntuin.
f
t
OnMa 2,09jsafwdy bfrtedcso iSrusspa4
y 220,ut e as eoeh eiinn t s,ur,6
a
Ca.t 3 4 wa fldplitfKrsi M. ry S n r B.te, al Kaa ,
1 h 6 , s i , anis itn Per, ada SirP u T. tmi
4
e
f
adJfryJZarl - t smesxcu lswh ,fe teao t no
n efe . rio wo a -e o pe o atrh d pi f
l
o
Th odri Srusspr, 6Ca.t 3 4 whlgat gtemoint
e re n ta s,u a 4 1 h 6 , i rni h to o
4
e n
itreefldb teofcapo o eto Po oio 8 smutno sydne a
nevn i y h fiil rp nns f rp st n ,i l eul eid
e
i
a
moint itre etah db e fldb asp rt popo oiin8av cc
t o nevn ht a en i y eaae r-rp st d o ay
o
e
o
ognzto Ca infrCaionaFa l stawa n tnofcapo o et
raiain, mpag o lfri mii ,ht s o a fiil rp nn
e
o tecaln e iiitv mesr.
fh h l gd ntaie aue
e
Prp sto 8h dsu h b t a b e dne ma ael e ssi Alme a
o oi n , a o gt u h d en eid nig i ne n a d
i
c
Co nyadLo An ee Conyrset ey- fldteu dr igat ni te
u t n s gls ut ep ci l ie h n el n ci n h
v
y
o
cret trnfdrlitccutnSnFacso ( ryv
urnmat i eeadsitori a rni .Per .
e
r
c
Sh reegr( D.a. . :9c-29- . . Paniscmpani
cwazng e N. C INo30-v022W1 ) litf'o litn
W2
f
Per nme a dfn ati terofcacp cte teGo e ro Caiona
ry a d s eednsn h i fiil aai sh vmo f l ri,
i
f
teAton yGeea o CaionateDietradteDeuyDietro te
h tre n rl f l ri,h rco n h p t rco fh
f
SaeDe rmet f u l He1 teAlme aCo nyClr- cre,n te
tt pat n o P bi at h a d u t ekReodrad h
c h,
Lo An ee Co nyReita- cre/ u t Clr.T ecmpan algd
s g ls u t gsrrReodrco ny ek h o lit l e
e
taPo oio 8voae ted epoesadeu l rtcinca sso te
ht rp st n iltsh u rcs n q apoeto lue fh
i
fdrl o stt nadsuh ij t eaddcaaoyrlf
eeaC ntui n ogtnt i n elrtr ei .
i o
mcv
e3
OnMa 2 , 0 9 tepo o et o Po oio 8ad
y 8 2 0 ,h rp nns f rp st n n
i
Poet naecm (eef r rp nnsfe amoint itreeite
rtcMaig.o hrat Pooet id t onevn n h
e
)l
o
Per po edn , itiigta tee it gp risi teat nwo l nt
ry rceig manann h th xsi at n h ci ud o
n
e
o
aeutl rpeeth itrsso toewh wihdt dfn temesr.
dq aey ersn teneet fh s o se o eed h aue
2
Th d cso rn ee b tefdrl ititcutfe til s u lh d
e eiin edrd y h e eadsrc oratrrawa p bi e
s
aPryvSh reegr( D. I21)0 Fsp .d91n,o
s er .cwaznge N. Ca.0074 .upz 2 adfr
c n ein ewi hratrb rfre t i tio iina Per 1 T eNit
o vnec, l eefe e eerd o n hs pno s ry . h nh
l
Ciciodrsb tn teqeto o sadn t ticut s u lhda
rut re u mit g h usin ftn ig o hs o rwa p bi e s
i
s
Pfre.ohtrepne(tCr2.Afe8F3 n1Cicdfldeefr, nw
e yvS wazny r9h i 016 hed19,ni lhrat b
r c
eg
r 1) 2 . h1a wi t re e
.
l e
r èrdt i hso lina Pe y1 trt Nit ruti isodra e
er n i o s r 1
e
Go en ro Caionato ofc a dtematrwa sbeunl rtldPer
v ro f lfri o k fie n h te s u sq et eie ry
y t
vBrwn tecretil o tepoedn i ticut
. o ,h urn tt fh rceig n hs o r.
e
Heefe,x et e seicl rfnn t ete tedsrc cut
ratrecp whn p cf al ee ig o i rh itit or'
i y
h
s
d cso o t Nit Cici'odrtio iinwilee t tefdrla ut
eiin rhe nh ruts re,hs pno lrfroh eea lwsi
smpya tePer ato
i l sh ry cin.
l teSrusliainfldi ticuttepeio esc aln e te
n h ta s igt i n hs o r,h tinr h l g dh
t o e
t
e
vl i o Po oio 8o l o saecntmin l ru d,n ddn tas t
ai t f rp st n ny n tt osi o a go n sad i oriehe
dy
i
t
q eto o tecntmto av l iyo temesr u drtefdrl
u sin fh o si in l ai t fh aue n e h e ea
d
Costt n (e Srusspa4 C 1t ap41, 1. Ou oiini
ntui . Se t s,ur,6 a.h t . 21. 1) r pno n
io
a
4
Srusddn t d rs tefdrlo si o a ise
ta s i o a desh eea cntmin lsu .
t
8
OnJn 1, 0 9 a1 a ddfn at fldas r t tecmpan.l
u e 2 2 0 ,lnme eedns i nweso h o lit n
e
tera s r,h nme d fn at ohrhnteAt me Geea rfsdt
h i nweste a d eedns te ta h t y nrleue o
o
tk ap sto o temei o panif' o si inl hleg addcie t
ae oiin n h rt f lit scnt o a c aln e n el d o
s
f
mt
n
dfn tevldt o Prp sto 8 Th as rfldb teAt re Geea
eed h aii f o oi n . e nwe ie y h t ny nrl
y
i
o
as dcie t dfn teiiaieb t n frhradafmaieyto te
lo el d o ee d h nt tv, u wetute n fi tvl o k h
n
i
r
poiintaPo oio 8iu cntuin l
st ht rp st n s n o si t a.
o
i
to
OnJl 2 2 0 ,h dsrccut edahaigo an mbro matr,
uy , 0 9te itit o rh l ern n u e f tes
icu igtemoint itreesldb Po o et.Atht ern ,h dsrc
nldn h to o nevn e y rp n ns tahaig te itit
cut bev dtadndr lonalw,sIu drtn i po o eto
o ro sre htc e Cai ri a a n esad t rp n ns f
u
f
,
iiitv mesrsh v sadn t rpeet rp nnsadt dfn a
ntaie aue a e tn ig o ersn po o et n o eed n
eat n ta ibo g tno1w b teiiaiepo es'n sg etdta
n cmethts ru h it a y h nt tv rcs'ad u g se ht
i
sc itret nb teofca iiaiepo o etwa p riual aporae
u h nevni y h fiilnt t rp nns s at lr p rpit
o
iv
c y
S eetea toie,h dfn atwh odnrl wo l d fn te
ç r h uh rt ste eedns o riai ud eed h
wh
i
y
po oio o tee at n ta ibigcaln e h r,r tkn tep sto
rp st n rh ncmeth ts en h l gd ee aeaig h oiin
i
e
ta,nfc,ts osit nl ifng. Netepanisnrn o tenme
hti atiicntui al ninl i r litf o ay fh a d
to y l ' h
f
dfn atojce t Pooet' t nt itreeadtedsr tor
eedns betdo rpnnsmoi onevn n h i i cut
o
tc
gatdtemoin4
rne h to .
4
Th rlv n p rino tetasrp o teJl 2 2 0 h aigras
e eeat ot fh rncit fh uy , 0 9 ern ed:
o
çWlhrsetotemointitreetabscl iuopsdadid e
ç i epct h t onevn,ht aial s np oe n,t os
g t
o
y
se t mesbtnil jsf ditics, atualwhrteatoie,
em o ,u sat l uti nhs aeprclr eeh uhris
ay ie
i y
t
tedfn atwh odnrlwo l dfn tepooio o teeat n ta
h eedns o riai ud ee d h rp st n rh n cmetht
y
i
ib igcaln e hr,r tkn tep st nta,nfc,tscntuinl
s en h l gd eeaeaig h oio hti atii o si to al
e
i
t
y
ifmg.An s,temsomebt fr rciaraosadraoso
ni j d oise t ,oh opat lesn n esn f
r
c
poedn iticsia odr adjdcafsintaitretni
rceignhsaen n rel n uiilaho htnevni s
y
o
apor t.gjCetil,neCai milw,s u drtn ipooeto
p rpie ! ranyudr lo aa a I nes dt rpnns f
a J
f
a ,
iiaiemesrshv tesadn t rpeet rp n nsadt d fn a
nt tv aue ae h tn ig o ersn po o et n o eed n
i
eat n taibog tno1wb teiiaie rcs.( ..Aqehr ay
n c thts ruh it a y h ntt poes % .( rtee n
me
iv
ojcin t gat gtemoint itree ( rsos.Her gnn,ht
bet so rni h t onevn? No ep ne) ai oeta
o
n
o
n
moinwil egatd'
to lb rne .
'
9
T eefe, rp nnsp rcp tda itre esi tedsrc cutra
h ratrPoo e t atiae snevnr n h itit ortil
i
iPer Id e, rp nnsweeteo l p ryi tedsrc cutopeet
n ry. n ed Po o e t r h ny at n h itit ort rsn
wi essadlgl ru n i dfneo tec aln e iiaiemesr.
t se n ea ag metn ees fh h l gd nt t aues
n
e
iv
Ath cn lso o tetiltedsrc cutsudaln tyo iin
te o cuin fh ra,h itit o rise egh pno ,
stigfrhn meo sf dn so fca cn lso so 1w addtr nn
et ot u ru i ig fatnd o cuin fa n eemiig
n
n
ta Po oio 8voae bt ted epoesadeu l rtcincasso te
ht rp st n ilts oh h u rcs n q apoeto lue fh
i
fdrl ntuiù (erLspa74Fsp .d91)T edsr tor
eeaCosit .P ry ur, 0 .upz 2. h i i cut
to
tc
iuda odr nonn dfn atiter fcacpct sadalesn
s e n reejiig eednsnhiot ilaaie,n 1pros
s
i
i
5 Th dsrc cutnPer as gatdamoinfldb teCi a d
e itit o ri ry lo rne
to i y h t n
e
y
Conyo SnFacso(a Facso t itreeiteatno bhlo
ut f a rni Sn rni )onevn n h ci n eaf f
c
c
o
panif.Asa itre e, a Facsoh sp riiae a ap r i tee
lit s n nevnrS n rnic a at ptd s at n h s
f
c
y
poedn si tedsrc cuti teNit Cici adi ticutAl o g
rceig n h itit or,n h nh rut n n hs o r. t u h
d
h
panif adSnFacsohv fldsp rt bif iticuttelg l
lit s n a rn ic ae i eaae resn hs o r,h ea
f
e
ag metrie b teeprislreyo elpa dfrcn ein ewesal
ru ns asd y h s at ag l v ra n o o vnec h l
e
rfrt teag metpeetdb ete o teep risa panif'agmet.
ee o h ru ns rsne y i r fh s at s lit s ru ns
h
e
f
At ltrsaeo tedsrccut rceig,h Conyo l eilt
a ae tg fh itit o rpo edn ste u t fmpra,he
l eil u t Bor o S priosadteI eil u t DeuyCo ny
mp ra Cony ad f u evsr, n h mpraCo ny p t u t
Clrceodrmo e t itreei teato t d fn tev l i o
ek cre v d o nevn n h cin o eed h ai t f
dy
Po oio 8 Thedsrc cut i n tueo teI eil u t moint
rp st n . itit ordd o rl n h mpra Co ny to o
i
itreeu tl fe tetil scmpee a dtecut a hn e d wni
nevn niatrh rawa o ltd n h o rh d ad d o t
s
rl go temeis Atht on,h dsrc c ut eidteitreto
ui n h rt. tap itte itit o rdne h nevnin
n
moin Th ratrI eil u t,tb ado spriosadi dp t
to . eefe,mpraCony i or fu evsr n t euy
s
s
cu t cekrcre ap ae tedna o termoint itreet teNit
o ny lr/eodr p eld h e il fhi to o nevn o h nh
Cici.OntesmedyteNit Cic ifldi odrsb tn teq et n
rut h a a h nh ruti t re u miig h usi
e s
t
o
o Po o et'tn igt ticutteNit Cic iise a o iinafmig
f rp nns sadn o hs or,h nh rutsud n pno fi n
r
tedsrcc utsdna o itret nb I raCo ny i b ado
h itit o r' eil fnevni y mpeil u t,t or f
o
s
spriosadi dp t cut cekrcre.l afr n tednao
u evsr n t euy o ny lr/eodr n fimig h eil f
s
itreto ,h Nit Cic io iinrl di p ro tefctaitreto
nevnin te nh rut pno ei n at n h athtnevnin
e
hdbe su h b tedpuycu t cekrcre rte ta tecu t
a en o g t y h e t ony lr/eodrahrhn h o ny
cekrcre h refteo iinlfo e teq eto whte acu t
lr/eodr esl;h pno etp n h u sin ehr o ny
cekrcre wo l hv sadn t itre e OnF b ay2 , 01,h nwl
lr/eodr ud ae tn ig o nevn . enlr 5 2 1te e y
eetdCo nyClrceodro I eil u t fldamoiniteNit
lce u t ek cre fmp ra Co ny ie to n h nh
Ciciseigt itreei teato .T a moinicretyp n igi te
rut ekn o nevn n h cin h t t s urnl e dn n h
o
Nit Cic i
nh rut
.
udrhispriino cnrlfo apyn o efrigPooio 8 (0
neteruevso r ot ,rm plig r nocn rp sin .74
o
t
Fsp .dap 10 . T eNit Ciutusqet ise a odrtyn te
.upz t .03) h nh r isbeunl sud n resaigh
c
y
dsitor'jdmet edn apa,n a aeut rpstn8rman i
ir cut u g npnig p elad s rslPooio e isn
tc s
i
efc atepeeti .
fet th rsn tme
Prp nnsa itreesi tedsrc cuqfldi teNit Cicia
o o et,snevnr n h itit or i n h nh rut
e
t lapao tedsitorjdmetnaiaigPooio 86Noeo
i y pel fh itccutu g n ivl t rp sin . n f
me
r
dn
t
tenme dfnatawhmt:dsr tor'ijnt nwa drce
h a d eedns t o h i i cut nuci s i td
tc s
o
e
ap ae fo tedsitorjdmethwee,n,na er odr
p eld rm h ir cutu g n,o vrad i n al re
tc
y
etbihn ash d l frcnieigteap a,h Nit Ciciseiial
salsig ceue o o sdrn h p elte nh rut pcfcl
y
rqetdteprist bifteq et nwhte Prp nnshv sadn t
euse h at o re h u si ehr o o et ae tn ig o
e
o
ap a tedsrc cutsrl gi
p elh itit o r' ui .
n
6 Iiil ,1fv o teidvd apo o et o Prp sto 8mo e t
nt l alie fh n iiul rp n ns f o oi n v d o
ay
i
itre ei tePer liain l tecus o tedsrc cutiiain oe
nevn n h ry igto . n h o re fh itit o rl gt , n
t
t o
o teidvdapoo et- Ha-hn Wiim Tm (a - moe t
fh n iiul rpnns ksig la a Tm) vdo
l
wi da a ad fn atitree.Th dsrccut i n t zeo Ta s
t rw s eedn nevn r e itit o rdd o nl n m'
h
moint wi da u tl fe iise isdcso o temei,n atap it
to o t rw niatrtsu dt eiin n h rt ad tht on
h
s
tedsrc cut eidtemoint wi da a mo t
h itit ordne h to o t rw s o.
h
T mddntoniteapafo tedsrt orjdmetht s
a i oji nh p elrm h itccutu g ntawa
i
fldi teNit Cic ib teoh rfu idvd apo o eta d
i n h nh rut y h te o rn iiul rp nns n
e
PrtcMara ecm.Fo cn einefrhrrfrn e t G o o et'rfr
oet rig .o r ovnec,ute eeecso ç p nns'ee
pr
cl cieyt tefu idvd apo o etadPoet rig .o wh fld
ol t l o h o rn iiu l rp nns n rtcMara ecm o i
ev
e
teapelnteNit Cic iadhv p riiae i tepeet rceigi
h p a i h nh rutn a e at ptd n h rsn poedn n
c
ticut
hs o r.
7 Un e fdrla aprywh h s e p r te t itre ei alwe
dre ea lw, at o a ben emi d o nevn n o r
t
cutrceigietldt apaaug n iteasneo tepr o
orpoedn s nie o pel jdmetnh bec fh at n
t
y
whoesd itreto wa p r te o l u o aso n t th itree
s ienevnin s emitd ny p n h wighatenevnr
idpn et flistecs o cnrvryrq ie nso atl II fh
n e ednl ufl h ae r o to es eurmet f ri e Io te
y l
c
fdrl ntmin (e,.. a n vC als(96 4 6U..46 .
eeaCost o. Seeg, mod . hre 18) 7 S 5,8)
i
Di
lwecutrceigt dfn a atnma apafo a avreug n
o r orpoedn o eed n ci y pelrm n desjdmet
o
dsi tefir o teoiiadfnatofea apa.(e,..P olv
ept h al e fh r nleednt i n p el Seeg, epe .
e
u
g
l
P riIr ainDirc(9 1 12Ca.8,9-9.
ersri t s it10) 3 l29202 1)
go t
Un e Caio alw, ycnrs, pat wh h sb e pr te t itreei a
dr l mi a b otata ry o a en emitd o nevn n
f
I tebif fldi teNit Cicio ta isepanif ag e ta
n h resi n h nh rut n h tsu, litfs rud ht
e
Po o et lce sadn t apa adta, sacneu neteap a i
rp n nsakd tn ig o p el n hta o sq e c,h p eln
Per so l b ds se .Po o etvg rul cnetdplitfs
ry h ud e imisd rp nns ioo sy otse anif'
cneto , onigo th thyh db e pr te t itreea dpriiae
o tnin p itn u ta te a en emitd o nevn n at pt
c
a prisi d fn eo Po oio 8b t b ticutnSrusspr, 6
s at n ees f rp st n oh y hs o ri ta s,u a 4
e
i
Ca.t 3 4 a db tedsrccutnPer,n asrigtate p sesd
l h 6 ,n y h itit o ri ry ad set hthy osse
4
n
terq ii sadn u drbt Caionaa dfdrla 8
h eust tn ig n e oh l ri n eealw.
e
f
Afrodcigoaagmettehe- depnlfh NitCrut
t cnut rlru n,h treug aeote nh i i
e
n
j
c
asg e t tics ise a odro Jn ay4 2 1,eu sigticuto
sind o hs aesu d n re n aur , 0 1rq et hs o rt
n
as rteq eto o Caio alw stot ao en meywhte, n e
nwe h usin f l mi a e frh b v ; a l, ehru dr
f
Caio alw,h ofca po o eto a iiaiemesr tah sb e
lfmi a te fiilrp n ns f n nt tv aueht a en
i
apo e b tev tr p sesete ç patuaie itrsi teiiaies
p rv d y h oes oss i r1 ri lrzd neetn h nt t '
h a c
iv
vldt'o çh atoi t asrteSaesitrsi teiiaiesvldt'
aii 'rç e uhrt o seth tt' neetn h nt t ' aii '
y t
y
iv
y
s a t afr tepo o et sa dn t d fn tecntuinlyo te
o so fod h rp n ns tn ig o eed h o si to ai fh
t
t
iiaieo t apaaug n ivl aigteiiaiewhntepbi
ntt ro p el jdmetnai t h ntt e h ul
iv
dn
iv
c
ofcaswh odn rl wo l po iesc adfneo fl sc a apa
fiil o riai ud rvd uh ee s rie uh n p el
y
dcieod s.(er I sp a68F3 ap 19 . I i odrte nh
el t o o P ry L ur,2 .d t . 13) nt re,h Nit
n
s
8 l a dto t dsgeiga t whte Po o ethv sadn t
n d i n o iaren so eh r rp nns ae tn ig o
i
ap a,nterbifa doa ag met eoeteNit Cic ipanif ad
p eli h i res n rlru n b fr h nh rut litfs n
Po nnsdsgedo tecneun e ta wo l fo fo adtr nto
rpo et ia re n h o sq ecsh t ud lw rm eemiain
b teNit Cic it t rp n nslc sadn t ap aa dteds sa o
y h nh ruthaPo o et ak tn ig o p eln h imisl f
terap a.Plitfscne ddtaads sao teap awo l laete
h i p el anif otn e ht imisl fh p el ud ev h
dsitorjdmetnefcadtatedsr torrl gwolb bnig
itccutu g n i fetn hth itccutui ud e idn
r
i
n
o ten me saeofcr ado tet nme cu t cek .Po o et
n h a d tt fies n n h wo a d o ny lrs rp nns
cned db cnrs,htfh Nit Cicidtr nste lc sa dn t
o tn e, y o tattaite nh rut eemie h y ak tn ig o
ap a,h t orwo l b rq ie n tol t ds s teap ab tas t
p elta cut ud e eurd o ny o imish p el u lo o
vcttedsitorjdmet (e PerI spa 68F3 ap 19 &
aaeh irccutug n. Se ry L ur,2 .d t . 15
t
f.. B cueisb tdteqetnoPoo et'tnigudrttlw
n2) eas tumie h usi f rp nnssadn n esaea
t
o
t ticutte nhCi ut i n tn iaei ve a t teefc o te
o hj o r h Nit r idd o idct t iw so h fet n h
,
c
s
dsitorjdmet f dtr nt ntaPooetlc s nigt apa.
irccutug n o a eemiai ht rpnnsak t dn o pel
t
o
a
1
2
Ci utn iae ta teas rt tiq eto o Caiona1wma wel e
r iidctd h th nwe o hs usin f l ri a y lb
c
f
dtr nt eo teiseo sn igfreealwproe.(dap 19 .
eemiai fh su ft dn o fdrla upss 1.t .16)
v
a
I epann isesnfru miigtiq eto t ticutteNit
n x liig trao o sb tn hs usin o hs or,h nh
t
Cicisae i pat ç tog teGo en rh scoe n todfn
rutttd n r: s h u h h v ro a h sn o t eed
Al
Po oio 8i teepoedn siin t la whte h ma, o sset t
rp st n n hs rceig,ts o cer ehr e y cnitn wi
i
h
teCaionaCo si to ,civ tru harfsloliaewht ema nt
h lfri ntuin aheeho g euat igt ah y o
t
t
d drcl efcieyvt teiiaieb rfsn t dfn io ap aa
o iet fet l eo h nt t y euig o eed t r p el
y:
v
iv
jdmetn aiaigi in oees- icuigteiiaies rpnns
ug nivl t t f o n le nldn h ntt 'pooetdn ,
iv
iq ai dt d s .Prp nnsag eta sc ahrhrsliaod dite
s u l o o o o o et ru htu h as euts v ie fh
Ge
b lneo p we po ie iteCaionaCo si to etbihsta
aa c f o r rvdd n h l ri ntt in salse ht
f
u
po o et o a iiaieaeatoie t dfn ta iiaie a aeto te
rp nns f n nt t r uh rzd o ee d htnt t ,s gns fh
iv
iv
Pepe i l uo p bi ofcas orfs t d s Smiry u drCaiona
o l,n i f u l fiilwh eueo o o. i l l, n e l ri
e
c
a
f
lw,h poo et o a iiaiema p sesapriuaie itrsi
a te rp nns f n nt t y oss at lrzd neetn
iv
c
dfn igtecntuin lyo teriiaieu o i e at n;h
eedn h o si to ai fhi nt t p n t ncmette
t
t
iv
s
Co si to sp roei rsrigteiiit epo rotePepewo l
ntt in' up s n eevn h ntai wet h o l ud
u
v
ap a t b i-evdb alwigeetdofcast n lf ete po oet'
p ero e lsre y l n lce fiil o uly ihr rp nns
l
o
i
efrst çrp s saue ada n mett teCo si to 'o teP o l'
fot o po oe ttts n med nso h ntuin rh epes
t
r h G aot reetsc pooio s Ca. ntat1, 8a.R teta
i tt dp o rjc'uh rp sin. lCos. r.Ij () ahrhn
g o
t
,
rl o o ro u drtn igo tibln eo p we u drteCaiona
ey n u wn n esa dn fhs aac f o r n e h lfri
Costt nhwee, cri teqet ns tate( lonaSpe )
ntui ,o vrwe etyh usi ohth Cai ri urme
io
f
o
f
Co rma po iea atoit ea s ra t tergt,neet,n atoi
ut y rvd n uh rt i nwe so h ihsitrssad uh rt
av
y
u drCaio alw o teofcapo nnso a iiai mesr t dfn
n e l mi a fh fiil rpo et f n nt t aueo ee d
f
i ve
i v l i u o iseat n i tecs o ac leg t i cnttt n ly,
t ai t p n t n cmetn h ae f haln eo t o si i ai
s dy
s
uo t
whr tesaeof ilcagdwi tadt rfst eeuei'(elI
eeh tt fias hre t ht uy eueo xct t'P ry L
c
h
. .
spr,2 F3 ap 19.
u a68 .d t .17)
OnF bur 1, 0 1weare t dcd teq eto o Caiona1w
e ray 6 2 1, ged o eieh usin f l ri a
f
a rq etdb teNit Ciciadetbih da epdtdbifn shd l
seu se y h nh rut n salse n x ei reig ceue
e
1
3
tawo l p r thscutocn ut rlru n i timatra erya
ht ud emiti o rt o d coa ag metn hs te s al s
Spe e 2 1 .A1pat sadn meo a c cra t l fldbif i ti
etmbr 0 1 l ri n u rus miiuie i y i resn hs
e
me e
matradoa ag met sh l o Spe e 62 1.
te,n rlru n wa ed n etmb r , 0 1
I.Reea c o SaeLa t Sa digUn rFe rl w
I lv n e f tt w o tn n de dea La
Deiin o teUntdSae S pe Coretbihta te
cso s fh i tts u rme ut sal hth
e
s
dtr n t nwhte a idvd a o etyseigt p riiaea apryi a
eemiai ehr n n iiu l r ni ekn o at pt s at n
o
t
c
fdrlorpoedn o t apafo a avreu g n etrdisc a
eeacutrceig ro pelrm n desjdmetnee n uh
poedn p sessterq ii sadn t stsytelaeo c nrv ry'
rceig osse h eust tn ig o aif h ç s r o to es'
e
c
po iin o atl 11o teUntdSae Co si to iutmaeyaq eto
rvso s f ri e 1 fh i tts ntuin s l tl u sin
c
e
t
i
o#drla uo whc tefdrlor hv tef asy (e,..Phlp
f ealw pn ihh eeacut aeh i la. See , iis
s
n
g l
Perlu C ..ht (95 42U..9,0 .As cneunemay
t em ovS ut 18) 7 S77 84) a osqec, n
o
s
raeso tio iinma rao a l b u cranwh teNit Cicih s
edr fhs pno y esnby e n eti y h nh rut a
ak dticutoavs iwhte iiaiepo o etp sesatoi u d r
se hs o rt d iet ehrnt t rp n ns oss uh ry n e
iv
t
C lonalwtdfn tevli o a iiaiemesr iacutrceig
afri a o eedh ai t fnnt t auen orpoedn
dy
iv
i whc temesr icaln e ad is,heb sso sc atoi .l l h
n ih h aues h l g d n ,fo t ai fuh uh rt n i t
e
y g
o tip tnilo fso , b lv ta iiue'ln apo raebityt
fhs oeta cnuin we ei eh tts sf ad p rpit rel o
e
u
stfrh ateote, u u drtn igo tefdrl eiin tadsuste
e ot,th ustor n esadn fh e ea dcso sht ics h
rlta saelw pa si dtr nn whte,n e fdrla a idvd a
oehttt a ly n eemiig ehru dr eea lw,n n iiul
o etyp sesssadn t priiaea ap ryi afdrl rceig We
r ni osse tn ig o at pt s at n eeapoedn .
t
c
e h sz tao rdsuso o fdrl eiin in titn e t,n d e n t
mp aieht u ic sin feea dcso ss o ne dd o ad o s o
p roto dcd ayiseo fdrla a dwefl rcg ietateefc
up rt, eie n su feea lw,n ul eo nz h th fet
y
ta tio iin'caiiaino teatoi ofcapo nns sesu e
h ths pno s lrfct fh uh rt ' iil rpo etposs ndr
o
yf
Cai ri 1w ma hv o teq et no sadn u drfdrla iamatr
lonaa y a e n h usi f tn ig n e eealw s te
f
o
taut tl wil ed cddb tefdrl o rs
ht lmaey lb eie y h eea cut.
i
Asteq et np sdb teNit Ciciidctsi tepeet ae
h u si oe y h nh rutn iae,n h rsn cs
o
t ptnilae frtnigaei lae:() h ot il rpnns f
wo oet bsso sadn r mpi td 1T e fcapooeto a
a
c
s
scesu iiaiemesr ma hv atoi t ap a i cutoasrte
ucsflnt tv aue y ae uh rt o p ern o rt seth
i
y
1
4
saesitrsi dfnigtevli o adleatdsae1w,o ()h
tt' neetn eedn h ait f uy nce tt a 9 r2 te
dy
of ilrp nns yhv te o proa Iatuai d'itrsite
fiapoo etma aehi wn esnlà ri lr e 'neetn h
c
r
c z
iiaiesv l i .Webitydsustefdrl eiin ta a ay ete
nt t ' ai t
iv
dy
rel ics h e ead cso sh t n lz h
efc o sae1w o ec o teep tnil ae frsadn i fdrl or.
fet f tt a n ah fh s oeta bss o tn ig n e ea cut
A. tn igt Asett SaesItrs i a I tai 'Vai t
Sa dn o sr he tt' neetn n ni t s l y
i ve
di
Wi rsetoteq et no wh p sesssadn t asrtesaes
t ep ct h u si f 0 osse tn ig o seth tt'
h
o
itrsi dfn igtev l i o asaecnttt nl rvso o sauewhn
neetn eedn h ai t f tt o siui a po iin r ttt e
dy
o
tesaemesr icaln e i afdrl rceig web l v teUntd
h tt aues h l gd n eeapoedn , ei eh i
e
e
e
Sae Spe Cor'dcso iKace vMa (97 44U..2( rhr
tts urme ut eiinn rhr . y 18) 8 S 7 Kace)
s
srn l idctsta afdrl o rwilo kt saelwt dtr n wh m te
to gy n iae ht eeacut llo o tt a o eemie o h
saeh satoie t asrtesae'itrsi tev ldt o tecaln e
tt a uh rzd o seth tt s neetn h aii fh h legd
y
ne s r .
Aa u e
I Kac e, lwsiwa fldi fdrl ititcuto tn igtaa
n rhra a ut sie n e ea dsrc o rcne dn ht
rcnl e atdNe Jre sauetarq ie pi r adscn ayp bi
eet n ce w esy ttt hteurd rmay n eo dr u l
y
c
sh osi ta saet o sreamiueo sln eatesat fec sh o dy
co l n h ttt o bev n t fiec th trO ah c ol a
wa u cnsi t nl savoaino teetbih n cas o teFis
s no tui a a ilto fh salsmet lue fh rt
to
Amed n o tefdrl ntuin Whnib cmeapaet th o te o
n met fh e eaCo si t . e t ea p rn a te ust f
to
teliainta ni e tecret w Jre At re Geea n rayo te
h igto h t et rh urn Ne esy t ny n rl o n fh
t
h
o
nme g v rmetdfn at- teNe Jre Deat n o Ed cto ,h
a d o en n ee dns h w esy p rmet f u ainte
dprmetscmmiso e, n t lcl orso euain- wo l d fn
e at n' o sin rad wo oab ad f d ct
o
ud eed
tev l i o tec aln e sa etete S ek r fh Ne Jre Ge ea
h ai t fh h l gd tmt,h hn p ae o te w esy nrl
dy
e
Ase l ( rhradtehnPeiet fh Ne Jre Snt( eho
smby Kace) n h te rsdno te w esy eaeOrci)
9 Deiosfh Une SaeSje C utlaletbi taC Sa
cin ote id tts urme orcer s lhht( te
s
t
y as a t
hstnigt dfn tecntuinlyo i saue'( a n vC als
a sadn o eedh osit al ft ttt. Dimod . hre,
to t s
'
sp a4 6U..4 6;e as Man vTyo (96 47U..3,3-3 ra
ur, 7 S 5,2se lo ie . alr 18) 7 S 111617 d
l
Saeceryh salgtmaeitrsitecniu defreblyo iso
tt lal a e i t neetn h otn e nocaii ft wn
i
t
s ttsq
t ue'.
a ')
1
5
su h a dweegatdtergtoitre ea dfn att dfn te
o g t n r rne h ih t nevn s eednso eed h
c aln e saueo bh lo tesaelgsaue I tepoedn si dsrc
hlegd ttt n eaf fh tt eiltr. n h rceig n itit
cuttelgsauetru hi peiigofcr,a idteeteb re o
o r,h eiltr,ho g t rsdn fiescn e h ni udn f
s
r
d fn igtesaue Th dsrc cutli tl cn lddta tesauewa
eedn h ttt. e itit orut ey o cu e h th ttt s
ma
ucntuinln etrdjdmetnaiaigtesa e
nosit aad nee ug n ivl t h tmt.
to
dn
Kac e a dOrci,cigi terofca cp ct sa S ek ro te
rhr n eho at n hi fiila aii s p ae fh
n
e
Ne Jre Geea Ase l adPrsdn o teNe Jre Sn t,p eld
w esy n rl smby n eiet fh w esy eaeap ae
tedsitorjdmetoteC utf pasfrh T i Crut T e
h ir cutug nt h oro Apel o te hr i i h
tc
d c.
Thr Cic ih adteap ao temei a dutmaeyafr dtedsrc
id rut er h p el n h rt n l tl fi h itit
s
i
me
cut eiiniv ldt gtesaue
ordcso n aiai h ttt.
n
Afe teThr Cic t a dddwni d cso , rhradOrci ls
trh id ruihn e o t eiin Kace n eho ot
s
terp ssa peiiglgsaieofcr adweerpae b ohrlgsaos
h i ot s rsdn e ilt fies n r e lcd y te eiltr
v
i toelgsaiep ss Dept ticag i sau, rhradOrci fld
n h s e ilt ot. si hs h n en ttsKace n eho i
v
e
e
a ap a o teThr Cicidcso i teUntdSae S pe Co r.Th
n p el fh id rut eiin n h ie tts u rme ut e
nw saelgsaiepeiigofcr wh hdrpae Kace adOrci
e tt eilt rsdn fies o a elcd rhr n eho
v
n tidteUntdSae S pe Cortate weewi da n te
oie h i tts u rme uth thy r t rwig h
f
e
h
lgsauesap a, u a tesmet ifr dtecutht rh r ne
eiltr' p elb t th a i nome h o rta Kace watd
me
t cniu hsap a o teT idCicidcso i teS pe Co r.Kac r
o o t e i p el fh hr rut eiin n h u rme ut rhe
n
cnfme tap sto .
o i d ht oiin
r
T eUntdSae S pe Co rp sp ndcnieaino te
h i tts u rme ut oto e o sdrto fh
e
jrsit nlsu pn igi haigotecs,n ,feoaagmette
uidci ai e edn t er fh aead atr rlru n,h
o s
s n
hg cutsudisd cso ,o cu igta bcueKace adOrci wee
ih o rise t eiin cn ldn ht ea s rh r n eho r
n ln e telgsaielaeso tersetv h ue o teNe Jre
o o grh e ilt edr fh ep cie o ss fh w esy
v
Leiltr,hylc e sadn t ap a.Th cutx lie:Go rhrad
gsauete ak d tn ig o p el e orepand Gac e n
l
Orci itree i tilwsii terofca cp cte a peiigofcr
eho nevn d n hsa utn h i fiil aai s s rsdn fies
i
o bhlo te wJre L gs tr.T e d ntp elh jd metn
n eaf fh Ne esy eilue hy o o apateu g n i
a
toecp cte.Ide ,h ycudntfrte n ln e h ltoeofcs
h s aai s n ed te ol o,o hy o o g r od h s fie.
i
Th atoi t p ruetelwsio b h lo telgsa eb ln sotoe
e uh rt o us h a ut n e af fh eilmr eo g t h s
y
wh sceddKaceadOrcii of e'( rhrspa44U..t
o ucee rhr n ehon fi . Kace,ur, 8 Sa
c'
p7 .
.7)
Kace adOrc i frhragzdta i,stehg cuto cu e ,
rh r n eho ute rt htfa h ih o rcn ldd
e
terp el sob ds se fr n ojrdcin tecuth udas
hiapawa t e imi d o wat fui it ,h orsol lo
s
s o
vctteu g nsotedsitoradteT i Crutht a ivl ae
aaeh jdmet fh irccutn h hr icitahdnai td
t
d
d
tesaueaise I rjcigticam,h Spe C uteidepiiyo
h ttt tsu.n eet hs li te urme orrl x l t n
n
e cl
tefcta Ne Jre lw pr t dtecret rsdn lgsai ofcr,
h ath t w esy a emit h urn peiig eilt fies
e
ve
atn o b h lo tesaelgsauet rpeeth saesitrsi
cig n e af fh tt eiltr,o ersn te tt' neetn
dfn igacaln e saelw.Th cut bevd tf eNe Jre S pe
eedn h legd tt a e oro sre :c' w esy u rme
-h
Co rhsgatdapiain o teS ae o teGeeaAse l adte
uta rne p lct s fh pekr fh n rl smby n h
o
Prsdn o teSnt t itreea p risrso dn o bhlo te
eiet fh eae o nevn s at -ep n et n eaf fh
e
lgsauei d fneo algsaiee at n.I r Fos h , N..41 14
e iltr n ees f e ilt n cmet n e ryte91 J 1 ,4 ,
v
40A.d49 50(92. ic teNe Jre Lgsauehdatoi udr
5 2 9,0 18)Sneh w esy eiltr a uhrt ne
y
saelw t rprsn teSae'itrssi b t teDitit ut n teCor
tt a o e eeth tt sneet n 0h h src Cor a d h ut
oApaswcne ntaaeteug nsblwfrako poe
f p el ed ovct hjdmet eo o lc fa rpr
,
dfnatp eln '( rhrspa44U..t .2 ils de.o
eedn- p l t'Kace,ur, 8 Sap8,ti addl
a a
ac
l
1 I I r F ryh ( J18) 5 A.d49- tedcso o te w
0 n n e osteN. 92 40 2 9 h eiin fh Ne
.
Jre Spe Co rtawa ctdadrle u niKac e frte
esy u rme utht s ie n eid po n rhr o h
pooio tauhr wJre lwteeiauetruhteSekr fh
rp sin ht neNe esy a h lgs tr,hog h paeo te
t
l
Geea Ase l adtePrsdn o teS nt, a atoi t rpeeth
n rl smby n h eiet fh eaehd uh ry o ersn te
t
st'itbsfndfnnn tcalcpdstfteStero tesySpe
tut nyei i eed gae aej to ea - ekN wJrenurme
aesee t y x li d hlne t 1 h e e rl
rs
i
a w
Co rvr rel epa e h prilaino h p ae fh Ge ea
t
Ase l a dtePrsdn o teS nt i ta liain,tt g:(feiia
smby n h eiet fh e aen htigto sai ç' nt l
t
n -h i
avrayp risi tecs weeteptt nr adteAton yGe ea.I
d esr at n h ae r h eio es n h tre nrl n
e
i
adt n teCo rga tdteapiain o teS ekro teGe ea
d ii ,h ut rne h p l t s fh pa e fh nrl
o
co
Ase l a dteGe eaAse l,n tePrsdn o teS nt a dte
smby n h nrl smby a d h eiet fh e ae n h
Snt t itreea p risrs n eta1 f o wi teAton yGeea,
eaeo nevn s at -epo dn, 1o wh m, t h tre nrl
e
h
dfn tevl i oteeat n. (5 A.dap50)
eedh ait fh ncmet'4 0 2 t .0.
dy
'
Iontcniudonxpg)
otoeot e netae
n
1
7
Astefrg ige hszdp saedmo srtsiKace te
h oeon mp aie asg e ntae,n rhrh
S pe Co rlo e t sae1w t dtr n whte apop cieliat a
u rme uto kd o tt a o eemie ehr rset ign h d
v t
atoi t asrtesaesitrsi dfn igacaln e saemesr i
uh rt o seth tt' neetn eedn h l gd tt auen
y
e
fdrl or.Up nrfeto tirslin tupiig iamuha lgc
e ea cut o elcin hs euts o srrsn ,n s c so i
sg etta asaeso l hv tep we t dtr n wh iatoie t
u g ssh t tt h ud ae h o ro eemie o s uh rzd o
asrtesae'& itrs i dfn igacaln e saelw.
seth tt s wn neetn eedn h l gd tt a
e
Aspanifacrtl p it u, rhrspr, 8 U. 7 , i n t
lit s cuaey on o tKac e, u a 4 4 S.2 dd o
f
iv leacaln et a iiaiemesr adddn t drs teq eto
n ov h leg o n nt t aue n i o adesh usin
iv
wh te teofcapo o eto a iiit ecudpo el asrtesaes
ehrh fiil rp n ns f n nt i o l rp r seth tt'
av
y
itrs i d fn igtev l i o sc a iiaie Panif as n t tai
neetn ee dn h ai t f uh n nt tv . lit s lo oe htn
dy
i
f
i sbeundcs niAroaso 04En.. i n (9750U..3
t usqeteii n i nnfr .. gvAroa 19)2 S4
s
o z
/
'
z
( ioaso OhcaEgi )whc ddivleh qetnoofca
Ar nnfr f ilnlh, ih i nov te uso ff il
z
s
i
iiaie rpnnss nigudreeal t apaaug n ivlaig
ntt pooet't dn ne fdrla o p el jdmetnai t
iv
a
w
dn
a iiaiemesr,h UntdSae S pe Co repesdçrv d u t'
n nt tv auete i tts u rme utx rse ç a e o bs'
i
e
g
( .t .6 whteteiiaiepooetitacs p sesdterqit
i ap 6) ehrh ntt rpnnsnht ae osse h euse
d
iv
i
sa dn addsig ihdi erird cso i Kace.A coerve o te
tn ig n itnuse t al eiin n rh r ls eiw fh
s e
rlvnp ro o teoiiniAr oaso O il gi ,o vr
eeat otn fh pno n i nnfr ycaEnlhhwee,
i
z
s
idctsta tedu t epesdb tehg c utnta cs ap rnl aoe
n iae h th o bs x rse y h ih o ri ht ae p ae t rs
y
ot fh cutsu cranycnenn teatoi o ofca iiaie
u o te o r' n etit o crig h uh rt f fiilnt tv
y
i
po nnst dfn tev l i o acaln e iiaieud r io aDw.
rpo et o eed h ai t f hl gd nt tv n e Arz n
dy
e
i
Th rlvn p saed e n tu g sta iasaeslw d e atoiete
e ee at asg os o sg ethtf tt' a os uh rz h
Oontcniud mrcf,ae
btoeot eko rvpg g)
n
tp
x
Th si Fostetep riswh teUntdSae Spe Cori
u,n ryh,h at o h i tts u rme utn
e
e
Kac e sbeunl cn lddh datoi u drsae1wt rpeeth
rhr u sq et o cu e a uh rt n e tt a o ersn te
y
y
saesitrsi d fn igacaln e saueweep r t dt itreei a
tt' neetn eedn h l g d ttt r emie o nevn n
e
t
Ne Jre S pe Co rcs t d fn tev l i o acaln e sa
w esy u rme utaeo ee d h ai t f h l g d tt
dy
e
me
ao gieteNe Jre AtonyGeeawh wa as d fn igtesaue
ln sd h w esy tre nrl o s lo eedn h ttt.
ofcapo o et o a iiaiet asrtesaesitrsi teiiaie
fiil rp n ns f n nt t o seth tt' neetn h nt t
iv
iv
mesr'v l i whnp biofcashv d cie t d fn temesr,h
aues ai t e u lc fiil ae el d o eed h auete
dy
n
po o etwo l lc sadn t asrta itrsi afdrl rceig
rp n ns ud ak tn ig o sethtneetn eea poedn .
l adesn tes nigiu iAr oaso OfcaE gi ,ur,
n drsigh t dn s en i n nfr flil nlhspa
a
s
z
s
5 0U. 4 ,h hihc utttdi rlv n p r:S eio esag epi rl
2 S. 3te g o rsae n eeat at ç tt nr ru rmai
p i
y
ta, siiaiepo o et,hyhv aq ailgsaieitrsi dfn igte
hta nt tv rp n nste a e u s-e ilt neetn eedn h
i
v
cntuinlyo temesrte scesul sosrd (h iiaie
o stt ai fh auehy ucsfl pnoe.T entt
io t
y
iv
pooet)tesh f d adefrte epne t aheeaot no ( e
rp nnssrs te t s n fothy xeddo ci dpi ft
m
v
o h
iiaie.Wehv rcgie tas tlgsaoshv sadn t cnet
ntt q ae eonzdhtt eei tr aetnigo otsa
iv
a l
dcso h ligasaesaueu cntuin lfsaelw at rzslgsaos
eiin odn tt ttt n o si t a i tt a uhoie e iltr
to
trpeeth Saesneet.SeKace vMa,8 U..28 (97.
o ersn te tt'itrss e rhr . y 44 S7,2 18)
(h iiaiepooetqhwee,rntlce rpeette,n weae
T entt rpnns,o vrae o eetd ersnai sad r
iv
v
a aeo oAroalwap itgiiaiesosra aeto hpeplo
w r fn i n a p oni ntt p noss gnsfte o ef
z
n iv
Aroatdfn iluopul o il tecntuinlyo ntte
i n o ee4 ni f bi ycas h osit ai fiiais
z
e
c
,
to t iv
maelwo h Sae No hshsC utvrietidiiaie rpnnss
d a fte tt. r ati oree dnie ntt pooeta
f iv
Aril-l-u lidd fn eso temesrste av ctd CfDo '
t ellq aie eedr fh aue h y d oae . . nt
c
f
Bakut sigo Co tevCotetl1Na. n tTut .f
nrp Wahntn mmie . ni na11 tBak: rsCoo
t
n
.
t
'
Chcg ,6 U..0 7(93 (u ryds sigfrako sadn apa
iao40 S 17 18)smmai imis o lc ftnig p el
l
n
b a iiaie rpnn fo adcso hligteiiaieu cntminl'
y n nt t poo etrm eiin odn h ntt nosi oal'
iv
iv
t .
(2 U..t .5ilsaddf.mie.
50 Sap 6 ,ti d e,n o t d)
ac
t
Al o g frtefrg igrao stecutx rse çrv d u t'
t u h o h oe on esn h o repesd t ae o bs'
h
g
whte teiiaiepo o eti q eto h dsadn u dratl Ilo
ehrh nt tv rp nnsn u sin a tn ig n e ri e It
i
c
pru apltrve ( innfrO il gi,ur,2 U..t .6,
usepeleeiw Aroaso scaEnlhspa50 Sap6)
a
z
s
tecut n o cn ld taç n e n t eiieyrsleteise' fh
h o rwet n o cu ehtç ed o d f tl eov h su 'o te
we
n
iiaie rpnnssadn ( i.bcueicnlddta,nayeeta
ntt pooet'tnig idj eas tocue hti n vn,
iv
b
c ag i tesau o t panifi ta cs rn ee teliainmo t n
hn en h tts fhe litf n h t ae ed rd h igt o a d
t o
1
9
jsie vct gtelwefdrlorrl g tahdivl ae teiiaie
utid aai h o reeacutui sht a n ai tdh ntt
f
n
n
d
iv
mesr.(e i.tp 6-0)
aue Sedap .78.
Ash e hse prinotepsaefo Aroaso O il
te mpai d ot fh asg rm i nnfr sca
z o
z
En ihq oe ao eidctstehg cutsd u ta t teofca iiaie
gl u td b v n iae,h ih o r' obs so h fiilnt t
s
iv
po o et'tn igi ta cs weebsd a latnsbtnil aqo te
rp nns sadn n ht ae r ae ,tesi u satap r n h
fctatecut sn t waeo ay( io alw ap it giiit e
athth o rwa o a r f n l zn a p oni nt i
Ar
n av
so sr a aet o tep o eo Arzn t dfn . .h cntuin lyo
p nos s gns fh epl f io a o eed .te o si t ai f
to t
iiaie mae1 o teSae'(r oaso O il nlhspa50
ntt s d a fh tt. A i nnfr scaE gi ,ur,2
iv
w
' z
s
U..t .5)I or iw,ohn itadcso idctshtf saes1w
Sap6 . n u ve ntig nht ei n niaetaia tt' a
i
d e atoieteofcapo o eto a iiaiet asrtesaesitrs
os uh rz h fiil rp nns f n nt t o seth tt' neet
iv
i tev l i o acaln e saeiiaiewhntep biofcaswh
n h ai t f h l gd tt nt t e h u lc f il o
dy
e
iv
odnrl asrtaitrshv d cie t d s,h po o etwo l n t
riai sethtneet ae el d o o o te rp n ns ud o
y
n
hv sa dn t asrtesaesitrsi teiiaiesvl i i afdrl
ae tn ig o seth tt' neetn h nt tv ' ai t n eea
i
dy
lwsii whc saeofcash v d cie t po iesc adfnel
a utn ih tt fiil ae el d o rvd uh ee svl
n
1 WenttauleiKace,ur,8 U..2iAroaso
1
oehtni n rhrspa44 S7,n i nnfr
k
z
O il gi tegvrmetfcas a da dfnatitefdrl
scaEnlhh oen nofilnme s eednsnh eea
s
i
lwsidddfn tecntuin l aii o tec aln e saepo iini
a ut i eed h o si to av l t fh hlegd tt rvso n
t
dy
tedsitorpoedns ( innfrO/f/nlhspa50U..t
h ir cutrceig.Aroaso .2tEgi ,ur,2 Sa
tc
z
Jcz s
p.15.An,giuleiKace,nAi nnfrO il gihte
p5-3) daan ni n rhri rz aso scaEnl h
k
o
s
ofca iiaiepo o etddn tse t itreei teliainu tlfe
fiilnt t rp nns i o ek o nevn n h igto niatr
iv
t
tedsitoraed hdise i jdmettkn dwnteiiaie
h ir cutl ay a sudt ug n sr ig o h ntt
tc
r
s
i
iv
mesro cntuinl rud.(2 U..t .6)
aue n ostt agons 50 S ap 5.
i o
Ash psaefo Ar oaso O#ccEn lhqoe aoe(nea
te asg rm ï nnfr .3i/ gi utd bv at,t
t
' s
p 1)niae,h hg cutntacs as ctdDo ' nrp Wahntn
.9 idctste ih ori htae lo i nt kut sigo
e
Ba
C mmie vCotetl1Na.ak&Tut oo iaospa40U..
o te . ni na11 tB n rsC .fchcg,ur,6 S
t
n
.
17 , smmayodrht imisda ap a fo aNit Cicid cso fr
0 7 a u r re tads se n p elrm nh rut eiin o
lc osadn.AsnAroaso OhcaLnug,nDo 'B nrp
ak ftnig i i nnfr f ilagaei ntakut
z
Wahn o Co t etenme gv rmetdfn at dfn e te
sigtn mmie h a d o en n ee dns eed d h
t
calne iiaieo bhlo tes titelwe cut(e Cotetl1
hl gdnt t n eaf fh t enh o r orsse ni na1.
e
iv
a
n 1
Na. akecvSaeo s.9hCi 18) 9 F.d626772,n tee
tB nit..tt fWah(t r 9 3 66 2 9,9-0)adhr
.
in idcto tateofca iiaiepo o et i ta matretbih d
s o n iain hth fiilnt t rp nnsn h t te sal e
iv
s
ta,neteapialsae1w( eete1wo teSaeo Wahn tn,n
htu drh p l be tt a t r,h a fh tt f sigo)a
c
h
(o o cniudMnxpg)
f t t ot et etae
bn e n
2
0
Wen t i tirgr tai i odrsb tn tepeet usint
oen hs ead htn t re u mit g h rsn q eto o
s
i
ticutteNit Cicisae epiiyta,ni ve iteof il
hs o r,h nh rutttd x l t hti t iw,fh fi a
cl
s
c
po o et o a iiaiehv atoi u drCaiona1w t asrtesaes
rp n ns f n nt tv ae uh rt n e l ri a o seth tt'
i
y
f
itrsi teiiit emesr'v l i i sc acs,hn u drfdrla
neetn h ntai aues ai t n uh aete, n e eea lw,
v
dy
tepo nnswo l hv sadn i afdrl rce igt asrtesaes
h rpo et ud ae tn ig n eeapo e, n o seth tt'
d
itrsi dfn igtecalne iiaieadt ap aaug n
neetn eedn h hl gdntt n o p el jdmet
e
iv
ivl aigteiiaie (erI sp a68F3 ap 19 .F r emoe
nai t h ntt .P ry L ur,2 .d t . 16) ut r r,
dn
iv
h
ato g teprisb fr u e htcl dsge a t whte Caionalw
l u h h at eoe s mp aial iare so ehr l ri a
h
e
y
f
atoie teofcapoo et o a iiit et asrtesaesitrsi te
uh rzsh fiil rp nns f n ntai o seth tt' neetn h
v
vldt o av trapo e iiaiemesr,ntebiffldb t i teNit
aii f oe-p rvd nt tv aue i h res i oh n h nh
y
i
e
Ci utadi ticutlprisarewi teNit Cici' sae n ta i
r i n n hs ora1 at ge t h nh ruts ttme thtf
c
e
h
teofca po o et d hv atoi u drCaiona1w t asrtesaes
h fiil rp n ns o ae uh rt n e lfri a o seth tt'
y
itrsi sc acs,hnu drfdrla tepo o etwo l hv sadn
neetn uh ae te n e eea 1w h rp n ns ud ae tn ig
iafdrlrceigt dfn teiiaieadt apaaug n
n eeapoedn o eedh ntt n o p el jdmet
iv
iv l aigi.
n ai t t
d n
B. tn ngBae o ç a tc lrzdltrs'
Sa di sd n d riua ie neet
p
'
Un e tecnrln fdrluh rt sterltasae1wpasi
drh otol g eeaatoii ,h oehttt a ly n
i
e
dtr nn wh te a ofcapo o et fascesu iiaiemesr hsa
eemiig ehr n fiilrp n n o u csflnt t aue a
iv
sfiin p ro a Satuaie itrs'i tev l i o temesr t
ufcet esn ls ri lrzd neet n h ai t fh aue o
p c
'
dy
sp othepo o etssadn u drfdrla apasob moecmpe
u p rt rp nn' tn ig n e eea lw p ert e r o lx
ta terlplydb sae1wwhnteof il rp nn iatoie b sae
hn h oe a e y tt a e h fi apo o e ts uh rzd y tt
c
lw t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o teiiitv .
a o seth tt' neetn h ai t fh ntaie
dy
Iontcniud mpcfzpg)
otoeot e#o rvt-ae
n
pç
f
iiit emesr'ofcapo o ethv sadn t dfn temesr whn
ntai aues fiil rp n ns ae tn ig o ee d h aue e
v
tenme saed fn ati teliainhv u dra e sc ad fne
h a d tt eednsn h igto ae n etkn uh ee s.
t
21
Un e tepriuaie itrssadr,e ea dcso setbihtaa
drh at lrzd neettn ad fdrl eiin sa l ht
c
s
fdrl orcnieswhte apopet ep ryial t dmo srt çn
eea cuto sdr eh r rs ci at s be o e ntaeç
v
a
ivso o algl poetditrswhc i()o ceeadprclr e, .
nain f eal rtce neet ihsa cnrt n atuai d..
y
i z
ad()atao i nn,oGojcua'o çy oht a.''(ua v
n b çculrmmietntç netrl rç p tei l' ' Ljn .
c
' h
c'
Deedro Wile(92 54U..5,6.ILua,h hg cutute
fnesf lf 19) 0 S5550) n jnte ih orfr r
d
h
epandtaçbypriuaie, mentateijr mut feth
xlie htç j at lr dwe a hth nuy safcte
l
c z
pani iaproaadidvdawa. (#ap 50f.. Alog te
litfn esnln niiul y' f.t .6 ,n 1) t u hh
f
'
h
UntdSae S pe Co rh srcg ie taasaeSa tep we t cet
ie tts u rme ut a eo nzd ht tt t sh o ro rae
h
nw itrssteiv so o whc ma cne sadn 'u d re ealw
e neet,h n ain f ih y o fr tn ig' n e fdrla
( a n vC alsspa46U..46,n 1)ntvr itrstasae
Dimod . hre,ur,7 S 5,5f.7,oeey neethttt
1w rcg ie a cne n sadn o a idvd a o etyt isi t o t
a eo nzs s o fnig tn ig n n n iiu l r ni o ntue ro
t
t
d fn apriua kn o lwsii saec ut lb s fcetoetbihta
eed at lr id fa utn tt o rwi e ufiin t sal ht
c
l
s
teidvd a o etyhsap riuaie itrst bigo d fn a
h n iiu l r ni a at lrzd neeto rn r eed n
t
c
aaooslwsiifdrlor.(o aeC d Ci.rc, 56 (ttlw
nlg u a utn eeacut C mpr oe vPo.j 2a s ea
a
rcg iigsadn o tx ae t caln eiea ep n i r o p bif s
eonzn tn ig fapy ro hl g l gl x edt e f u l t
e l
u
c md
isaecutwi DamlrhylrC r.. uo(06 57U..3,4-4
n tt or t i ec rse op vC n 20) 4 S 323236
q h
(tttxae lcstn igt cal g tecntuinlyo saetxcei
saeapyrak sadn o hln eh osit ai ftt a rdt
e
to t
i fdrlor.Unetegvrigfdrlae, ehr r h cetdb
n eeacut) drh oenn eeacsswhte ai trae y
q
g
saelw i sfiin t sp oteeasadn u drtepriuaie itrs
tt a s ufceto u p rfdrltn ig n e h at lrzd neet
c
tsn csai dpn su o ten tr o terg tcnerdb tesaeadte
et eesrl eed p n h aue fh ih o fre y h tt n h
y
ntro teiuytama b sfee b te udb liat ( . r v
aue fh n r ht y eufrd yh wol-eign. CfWat .
j
t
h
Sli (9 5 42U..9,0.
edn 17) 2 S4 050)
I tepeet aetep risdsge a t whte a ofcaiiitv
n h rsn cs,h at iare so ehr n fiilntaie
e
po o et osse as ca o dsic itrsi tev l iyo a iiaie
rp nn p sess peil r it tneetn h ai t f n nt t
n
d
iv
mesr tepo o et a so srdO c teiiit eh sbe apo e b te
aueh rp nn h s p noe n eh nt i a en p rv d y h
av
v tr adao tda saelw,n ,vnis, ehrtentleo ta itrs
oes n dpe s tt a ad ee f owhte h at fhtneet
r
adoteijr te rpnn wol sfeiteiiaiemesr iivlae
n fh nuy h pooet ud ufrfh ntt auesnai td
iv
d
2
2
aesfiin t acr tepoo ettn igfrfdrla p roe u drh
r ufceto cod h rp n n sa dn o eea lw up ss n e te
priuaie itrs sadr.
at lrzd neettn ad
c
Po o et manantab cuete p sesafn a narg t ndr
rp n ns iti ht eas hy oss udme tlih u e
teCaionaCo si int po oesauoyo cntuinl hn e tru h
h l ri nt o o rp s tttr r o si t a c agslo g
f
mt
to
l
teiiaiepoesseeg, otvSp ro C ut20) 7Ca.t96
h ntt rcs(e,..C sa .ueir or(06 3 1 h 8,
iv
4
10)te pses proa,atuaie itrsitevl i o a iiaie
07,hy ossa esnlprclr dneetnh ait fn ntt
i z
dy
iv
mesr tate h v po sda dta hsbe apo e b tev tr,n
auehthy a e rpoe n ht a en p rv d y h oesa
itrstawo l g u d fn e ite aen t emitdt po iesc a
neetht ud o n eedd fhy r o pr te o rvd uh
dfnewh ntep bioicaswh odnrl d fn ac aln e saelw
ees e h u lc f il o riai eed hleg d tt a
y
dciet d s.Poo et ag etater esn lf a na rg t
el o o o rp nns ru hthip ro a,t metlih
n
md
g aate b teiiaiepo iinwo l b n lfe iav trapo e
u rned y h nt tv rvso ud e ulid f oe-p rv d
i
i
mesr te hv so srdii rp ryadicretyiv ldtdb cue
aue hy ae p noe smpo el n n orcl n aiae ea s
p bi ofcaswh aeh si t temesr hv fi dt mo n adfneO t
u l fiil o r otl o h aue ae al o u t ee s ro
c
e
e
apaalwe cutu g nsr igdwnteiiaie
p el o r orjdmettin o h ntt .
k
iv
Plitfsb cnrs,setht l o g teofcapo o et o a
anif,y otatasrta at u h h fiilrp n ns f n
h
iiitv ma p sesapro a, at uaie itrsu drteCaiona
nt ie y oss esnlpri lrzd neet n e h l ri
a
c
f
Co si to a dteapia lsauoypo iin i hvn a iiaiemesr
ntuin n h p lcbe tttr rvso sn a ig n nt t aue
t
iv
te hv po oe sb te t tev tr, n ea iiaiemesr hsb e
hy ae rp sd u mitd o h oeso c n nt t aue a en
iv
apo e b tevoesteofcapo o ethv n getrpro a lgly
p rv d y h tr h fiil rp nns ae o rae esn le al
poetditrsi temesr'vl i ta ayohrme e o tep bi.
rtce neetn h aues ai t h n n te mbr fh u l
dy
c
Acodn l, litfsag eta o c a iiit emesr hsb e eatdit
crigy panif ru ht n e n nt i aue a en n ce no
av
lw,tofcapo o et d n t oss adsic, at uaie itrsi te
a i fiil rp n ns o o p ses it tp ri lrzd neetn h
s
n
c
iiaiesvl i
nt t ' ai t
iv
d y.
Aswe x li, n e n t eie e e teof il rp n nso a
epan we ed o dcd wh t rh fcapo o et f n
h
i
iiit emesr p sesapatuaie itrsi teiiitv 'v l i o c
ntai aue oss ri lrzd neetn h nt ies ai t ne
v
c
a
dy
temesr h sb e apo e b tev tr.F rh rao sdsuse b lw,
h aue a en p rv d y h oes o te esn ic sd eo we
cn ld ta wh np bi ofcasdciet d fndav trapo e iiaieo
o cu eh t e u l fiil el o ee oe-p rv d nt t r
c
n
iv
2
3
asrtesaesitrsi teiiaiesv l i u drCaiona1w te
seth tt' neetn h nt t ' ai t n e l ri a h
iv
d y,
f
ofcapo o et o a iiaiemesr aeatoie t asrtesaes
fiil rp n ns f n nt t aue r uh rzd o seth tt'
iv
itrsitevl i oteiiaieadt apaau g n ivl aigte
neetn h ai t fh ntt n o pel jdmetnai t h
dy
iv
dn
mesr.Beas tacn lso isf in t sp otnafmaierso s
aue cue ht o cuin s ufceto u p ra fi t ep ne
r v
t teq eto p sdb teNit Cici, n e n t eiewhte, n e
o h u sin oe y h nh rutwe ed o d cd ehru dr
Caionalw,h of il rp nnsas p sesap riuaie itrsi a
lfri a te fi apo o et lo oss at lrzd neetn
c
c
v trapo e iiaiesvl i .
oe-p rv d nt tv ' ai t
i
dy
11 Anaysso l iit ePrpo e t'Sa dn Und rCaio naLa
1. l i f ntai o n ns tn ig e lfr i w
v
A.Baio I taiePrp n ns Sa i
ss fniit o o e t' tndng
v
Aril I,et n1o teCaionaCo si to po li 'ç l oiia
t e Isci fh l ri ntuin rcams Wlp l cl
c
o
f
t
.
t
pwe i ihrn i tepo l.Go e n i isi tdfrterpoet n
o rsn eetn h epe vmmetsntue o hi rtci ,
t
o
scrt,n bn fta dte h v tergtoatro rfr iwh ntep bi
eui ad eei n hy a eh ih t l reom t e h u l
y
,
e
c
g o ma rq ie'Asticutoe i Srussp a 4 Ca.t 3 4 42
o d y eur. hs orntd n ta s,ur , 6 1 h 6 , 1'
4
S- spo iinoiiae i o eo teiiileto so teDelrt no
khi rvso rgntd n n fh nt scin fh caai f
l
a
o
RgtcnandiCai ni'fsC ntuin(a. nto 14,r 1j2,
ihs otie n loa sit osit C 1Cos.f 89at , )
f a r
to
.
adrt cs bsc rcp o or oen nasse tatepolhv te
n el ta aipeet fu gvrmetlytm:hth epe aeh
e
cntuinlih tatr reomter oef n. (no t d)
ostt ar to l orfr higvrmet'F .mie.
i o g
e
l '
t
Al og C lonas rgnl89Costt ndcae ta.lq
t uh ai ri'oiia 14 ntui elrd hts l
h
f
i o
tal
p lia p we iihrn i tep o e'iwa n t ni6 yasltr i
oicl o rsn eetn h epl, t s o u tl 0 er ae n
t
'
1 1 tateCaionaCosi t nwa a n e t afr tev tr o
9 1 hth l ri ntt i s me dd o fod h oes f
f
uo
Caionateatoi t drclpo oeada otsaecnttt n l
lfri h uhrt o iet rp s n dp tt o siui a
y
y
o
a n meta dsauoypoiin tru hteiiit ep we.I Asoitd
med ns n tttr rvso shog h nt i o r n scae
av
Ho B iest.IcvCi oLiemoe(96 1 Cld5251
me ul rec,n.. t f vr r 17) 8 a. 8,9
d
y
3
(soitdHo Budrjwebif dsr e tehs r,inf ac,n
Ascae me l es, r l eci d h ioysgicnead
ey b
t
cnietuiilnepeainotecntuinl bsdiiaiepwei
oss njdcaitrrtt fh osi t al ae ntt o rn
t
o
to y
iv
Caiona çl ea n met fteCaio aCo si to i 1 1 t poiefr
lfri:ç- me d n o h l mi ntuin n 9 1o rvd o
-h
f
t
teiiai a drfrn u sg iiso eo teo ttn igahee nso te
h nt t n eeed m infe n fh usadn civ met fh
i ve
2
4
po rsiemo e n o teery10 '.Drf di lgto tete r ta a1
rgesv v met fh al 9 0s at n ih fh h oy ht l
e
p we o gv rmet lmaeyrsdsi tep ol,hea n metsek o
o r f o en n ut tl eie n h epet med n p as f
i
teiiaieadrfrn u n t sarg t rne tep o l, u a ap we
h nt t n eeed m, o a ih gatd h epe b t s o r
iv
rsre b te Delr giç edto tecuttjaos g adtir h
eevd y hm. cai tt uy fh or o elul ur hsi t
n h
s
y
g
o tep ol' . ,h cuthv dsrbdteiiitv adrfrn u a
fh epe . .te ors a e ecie h nt ie n eeed m s
a
atuaigçn otemot rcosihs fu dmort poes.. Gj
rclt oe fh speiu r to or e cai rcs..' g/
i n
g
c
.
J
hsln be oruiil lyt apyaleacntutnt tip we
a og en ujdcapoi o p l i rlosrci ohs o r
c
b
o
whrvriicalne iodrtater h b ntm rpela nld J
eee ts hl gdn re hth i te oip o r n ul .f
e
g
y e
dutcnraoalb rsle lfvro h ueo h'rsre o rcut
obs a esnby eeovd' ao fte s ftl eevpwe,or
n
s
s
wip eev i''(aisaddctt n & fso td)
l rsret ' I l de,i i s n.mie.
l
. tc
ao
t
Asan mbro orp sdcso shv epand tepo rsie
u e f u at eiin ae x lie ,h rgesv
mo metnCaionata ito ue teiiaiep we it o rsae
ve n i l ri htnrd cd h nt t o rno u tt
f
iv
Co si to ge oto dsaifcinwi tete-o e n p bi ofcas
ntuin rw u f istsato t h hng vmig u lc f il
t
h
a dawiepedb l fta tep o ehdlscnrl fh p lia poes
n d sra ei h th epl a ot oto o te oicl rcs.
e
t
(e,..ne net nryPrd crAs.. p esn(0 6 3 C lt
Seeg, dpednf eg oues snvMchro 20) 8 a.h
I
4
12,0 114 ;t usspa4 C lt 34404 1)l tistn,ûqe
00 14 -03Sr s,ur,6 a.h 6 ,2-2 . nhs et gçt
a
4
i gh
iiaiewa ve da o emen o rsoigtep o esihfl oto oe
nt t s iwe s n as fetrn h epl'rgtu cnrl vr
iv
terg vmmetb po dn ameh dta wo lp r th p o l t po oe
h i o e n,y rviig to ht ud emite epe o rp s
adaottttr poiosadcntuinlmed ns'(t usspa
n dp s uoy rvs n n osi t aa nmet. Sr s,ur,
a
i
to
' a
ap4 1 T e r r proeo teiiaie soafr te epete
t .2. h pi y ups fh ntt wat fod h pol h
)
ma
iv
a it t po oea dt ao t o tuin lme d nso sauoypo iin
bly o rp s n o d p cnsi to aa n met r tttr rvso s
i
t
tatereetdp bi ofcash drfsdo dcie t ao t Th 1 1 bl t
hthi lce u l fiil a eue r el d o dp. e 9 l al
c
n
o
pa he ag meti fv ro temesr d srb dteiiaiea çht
mp lt ru n n ao fh aue ecie h nt t sç a
iv t
sfg adwhc tep o l so l rti frte ev st sp lmeth wok
aeu r ih h epe h ud ean o hmsle,o u pe n te r
o telgsaueb iiaigtoemesrswh' telgiltr c/e vco sy
fh e iltr y nt tn h s aue lh h e saue ïgr iiul
i
c
/
o ngietfi orfssteat.. (eto SaePooe Amed.o
r el nl al reue o nc..' Sc.ftt,rpsd nst
g y s
'
2
5
Cos. tLei. aosGe.lc( t1,9 1Resn wh Sn Cos
ntwi gsResn, nEe.Oc.0 11) aos y e. nt
h
.
AmedNo2 solb aotd ils de.
n . .2 hud e dpe,ti add)
ac
Th Caionacntuin l rvsosstigfrhteiiai p we
e l ri o si to apo iin et ot h nt t o r
f
t
n
i ve
d n t x lct rfrt o fl pecieteatoi o rso sbliso te
o o epiiy ee o r ul rsrb h uh rt r ep niite fh
l
y
y
i
ofca po o et o a iiaiemesr, b th Leiltr,nao t g
fiil rp n ns f n nt t auel u te gsauei d pi
iv
z
n
1 Th cntuin l rvso srltn t teiiaiep we aec ret
2
e o si to apo iin eaig o h nt t o r r urnl
t
iv
y
stfrhi atl 1,eto s8ad1,ril l scin1adat lXVI1
e ot n ri e Iscin n 0 at e V,eto ,n ri e 1,
c
c
c
scin 3a d4o teCaionaCo si t n.
eto s n fh l ri ntt i
f
uo
ArceI,et n8poie irlvnpr:çaT eiiaieite
tl lsci ,rvdsn eeat at $) h ntt sh
i
o
(
iv
p we o teeetrt po oesaue ada n mett teCo si t nad
o r fh lcoso rp s ttts n med nso h ntt i n
uo
taotreethm.
o dp o rjcte
tb Aniiaiemesr ma b pooe b peet gtteSceay
û) ntt aue y e rpsd y rsni oh ertr
(
iv
h
o Saeaptintastfrhtetx o tepo oe saueo a n meto
f tt eio htes ot h et fh rp sd ttt r me d n t
t
teCo si t nadicrie t hv b e sg e b eetr eu lnn mbrt
h ntui n s etid o ae en ind y lcos q a i u e o
to
f
5p retntecs o asauea d8preti tecs o a a nmetote
ecn i h ae f ttt,n ecn n h ae f n med n t h
Co si to , ftev tsfral addtsfrGo en ratelsg braoil
ntuin o h oe o 1cn iae o vro th at u entra
t
eet n
lci .
o
dcT eSceayo Saesalhnsb th mesr atenx gnrl
$) h ertr f tt hlte umite aue th et eea
(
eeto h l a lat1 1dy atriq aiiso a ays ca sae d eet n
lcin ed tes 3 as fe t u l e r tn peilttwie lci
f
o
h l pirt tag nrl lcin Th Go en rma claseilttwie
ed ro o ht e ea eeto . e vro y al p ca sae d
eeto frh mesr.
lcin o te aue'
'
ArceI,et n1 poie i rlvn pr:çaAniiaiesaue..
tl Isci 0 rvdsn eeat at ç) ntt ttt .
i
o
(
iv
apoe b amaoi o vtshro tksefctedyatrh eetn
prvd y jry f oeteen ae feth a f te lci
t
e
o
ulstemesrpoie ohr s.E ..!
nesh aue rvds tewie N . ()
$c T eLeiltr .. ya n o rpaa iiaiesa tb
t) h gs ue .ma med reelnnt t tt e y
(
a
iv u
aohrsaueta bcmeefcieo l whnapo e b teeetr u ls
n te ttt ht eo fet ny e p rvd y h lcos nes
v
teiiaiesauepr ta n met reel to thiapo a.
h nttv ttt emis med n o rp a wi u ter p rv l
i
h
$d Pirocruaino a iiaie. .eio frintrsacp
ç) ro t i lt fn ntt .ptin o s aue, oy
(
c o
iv
t
g
sal esb te t teAtonyGeeawh sal rp r atl adsmmay
h lb u mi d o h tre n rl o hlpeae ie n u r
t
t
o temesr a po ie b lw.
fh aue s rvd d y a
(s f v 1, 0 1.
g2 2hml a o No.72 12
)
4
9
Geea o ohrp bi ofcashv dcie t d s, anif hv ctdn
nrl r te u l fiil ae el d o o oplit s ae i o
c
n
f
e
cs ta sp rstecam ta iwol vilt tesp rto o p wesd crn
aehtu pot h li htt ud oaeh eaain f o r otie
e o idi teCaio aCo siuinfrt Leilmr t po iesc a
mb de n h l mi nttto o he gsa e o rvd uh
f
d fnewh nohrp bi ofcasdciet d s.I an mbro Caiona
ees e te u l fiil el o o o n u e f lfri
c
n
cssteLeiltr o o eo i cnttet o sshsapae a ap ryi
ae,h gsaue r n ft o si n h ue a p erd s at n
s
u
liaincaln igtev l i o apo oe o ao tdiiit eo
igt h l gn h ai t f rp sd r dpe ntai r
t o
e
dy
v
rfrnu mesr (e,..Snto h Saeo a..oe,ur,1
eeedm aueseeg,eaefte tt fc lvJnsspa2
Ca.t 14 ,15 ,n. ; giltr v Euspr, 4Ca.t 4 2 Le sauev
l h 12 16 f 9Le saue . ,u a 5 1 h 9 ; giltr .
4
4
Dek ja,ur,4Ca.d68Ase lvDek ja,ur,0C ld
umeinsp a3 1 5; smb . umeinspa3 a.
3
y
3
68- ot i isacsnwhc te tre Geeao ohr xct e
3) fn nntne i ihh At ny nrlr teeeui
e
o
v
ofcasokap sto cnrr t teLe iltr'rgrigtev l i o te
f ilto oi n o t y o h gsaues eadn h ai t fh
i
a
dy
mesr(e,.. eiauevEuspa5 C 1t 42Lgsauev
aueseeg, gs tr . ,ur,4 a.h 9 ;eiltr .
f l
4
Dek ja,ur,4C ld68Ase lvDek ja ,ur,0Ca.d
umeinsp a3 a. 5; smby . umeinspa3 1
3
3
6 8.T eecss eiaysget ntasc at nb teL gsa eiay
3) hs aebl n ugso htuh ci yh eilmr n n
e
i
o
wa uup do itree wi teeeuieofcasp romac o ter
y sre rnefrd t h x ct fiil' efr n e fhi
h
v
eeuiefntn (e as Cafrinfra O e Pr rvMc esn
xct uci .Se l lonaso n pn i y . phro
v
o
o
ma
(06 3 C 1t 75( gsauerpeetdb sprtcuslapae a
2 0) 8 a.h 3 Leiltr,ersne y eaae one,p erd s
4
rapryi itrst dfn v l iyo v trapo e cnttto a
el at n neeto ee d ai t f oe-p rv d o si in l
d
u
a nmetsb tdt eetrtb LeilmrjKopvF iP lPrcie
med nsumie o lcoae y gsa e; p . ar o. at s
t
c
C m.spa 1 Ca.t6764Leiltrpr tdtitreetdfn te
o ,ur, 1 1 h 0, 1 L gs ue emie onevn o eedh
4
a
t
v l i o ted fn atcmmiso 'ato swhntecmmiso iefo ka
ai t fh eed n o sins cin e h o sin t lto
dy
s
nurl oio wi msetotecaln eti at nq
et p sin t pct h hl g ot ci s.
a t h
e
s o )
Acodn l, f dn meii panif' li ta ap aigi cuto
crigy we i o rtn litfs cam ht p ern n o rt
n
asrtesaesitrsi tevl i o ac aln e 1w ie cuieya
seth tt' neetn h ai t f hlegd a s xlsv l n
dy
eeuiefnto o ta iwo l voaetesprt no p wesd crn t
x ct u cin rhtt ud ilt h eaai f o r otieo
v
o
pnnth ofcapo o et o a iiaiet asrtesaesitrsite
e ite fiil rp n ns f n nt t o seth tt' neetn h
iv
vl i o teiiaieiau iilrceigiwhc te aii o te
ait fh ntt n jdcapoedn n ih h vl t fh
dy
iv
dy
5
0
mesr ic aln e .F rhr r, ea s teein rao t du thth
aue s hleg d utemoebcuehr s o esn o o b ta te
Caio aLeilmr,ieteUntdSae Co gesi Ch d a spr, 6 U..
l mi gsa e l h ie tts n rs n a h ,u a 4 2 S
f
k
99 o teNe Jre Leiltr i Kace, u a 4 4U.. 2 wol hv
1, rh w esy gsauen rh rspr, 8 S 7 , ud ae
atoi t se i t asrtesaesitrsi tev l iyo asaueeatd
uh rt o tp n o seth tt' neetn h ai t f ttt n ce
y
d
b teLeiltr itesaeseeuieofcashv d cie t d fn te
y h gsaue fh tt' x ct fiil ae el d o eed h
v
n
saues aii i acutrceig wecnld tatep o l aen ls
ttt'v ldt n o rpoedn , o cu e hth epe r o es
y
etldt hv tesaesitrsi tevldt o avoe-p rv diiaie
nie o ae h tt' neetn h aiiy f trapo e nt t
t
iv
asre o terb hlwhnp bi ofcasdciet d fn temesr.
setd n h i e af e u lc fiil el o eed h aue
n
3
.
Plitfsas rieaohrsme arltd sp rt no p wescam,
anif lo as n te,o whteae ,eaai f o r li
o
cnedn ta pr tiga iiaiepo o etoasrtesaesitrsi
o tn ig h t emi n n nt t rp nn t seth tt' neetn
t
iv
tevldt o ac aln e iiaiemesr wi itreewi teAton y
h aii f h l gd nt tv aue l nefr t h tre
y
e
i
l
h
Ge ea'e ecs o tep weso hso h rofc i rpeet gtesaes
nrls xrie fh o r f i r e fien ersni h tt'
n
itrs.Ou rcg io taofcaiiit po o etaeatoie t asr
neet r eo nt n ht f ilnt i rp nns r uh rzd o set
i
ave
tesaesitrsi a iiaiesv l i whnp bios ilhved cie t
h tt' neetn n nt t ' ai t e u l fcas a el d o
iv
dy
c
n
d fn temesrs o v rd e nt a, s litf sg ettate
ee d h aueh wee, o s omen a panis u gs,hth
f
po nnsaeatoie t Cvrie'h Ato ayGeea'o ohrp bi
rpo et r uh rzd o ç erd'te tne n rls r te u l
o
c
ofcas at rt t ma etero dcso srgrigted fneo te
fiil'uhoiy o k h i wn eiin eadn h ees fh
mesr.Asweh v dsusd i mayp scssiiaiepo o eth v
aue
a e icse ,n n at ae nt t rp nns a e
iv
be pr te t p riiaea fr l at sd fn iga iiaiemesr
en emi d o at pt s omapri eedn n nt t aue
t
c
e
iv
ao gwi tep biofcasnme a dfn at,n i toeisacsec
ln t h u l fiil a d s eednsad n h s ntn e ah
h
c
pryh sb e p r te t pofri o agmet adcnrlt o ato s
at a en emitd o rfe t wn ru ns n oto i wn cin
s
s
i d fneo teiiaie
n ees fh nt tv .
i
Smial,h ait o ofcaiiaiepo o ett dfn acaln e
i lry te bly f fiilnttv rp nnso eed hleg d
i
i
iiit emesr o bh lo tesaein tno sset t tedsrt nte
ntai aue n eaf fh tt s o icnitn wi h icei h
v
h
o
AtonyGeeama p sest dciet d fn acaln e mesr o t
tre n rl y oss o el o ee d h l gd aue ro
n
e
dcieoapafo a avreug n whnteAt re Geeaio te
el t pelrm n desjdmet e h t ny nrls fh
n
o
ve taacalne iiaiemesr iucntuinl(fSaeo
iw ht hl gdntt aues nosit a. C.tt f
e
iv
to
C lonavSpr rC ut18)14C1 p3 34)Aslaydsusd
afri .uei or(96 8 a. .d 9. ar d icse,
o
Ap
e
ee whnteAtonyGe eahsdsrto t d ciet dfn asae
vn e h tre nrl a icein o el o ee d tt
n
cnttt n l rvso o sauei acut rceigcaln igtemesr,
o siui a po iin r ttt n o rpoedn h l gn h ape
o
e
teAtonyGeead e n t aeatoi t peet tesfo moniga
h tre nrl os o hv uh ry o rv n ohr rm u t
t
n
dfneo bh lo tesaesitrsi tev l i o temesr.Fo
ee s n eaf fh tt' neetn h ai t fh aue r
dy
ea l,nteu dr n poedn si tePer liainh dayo teoh r
x mpe i h n el g rceig n h ry ig t , a n fh te
yi
t o
p bi ofcaswh ween me a dfn at coe t peetasbtni
u l fiil o r a d s ee dns h sn o rsn u sat
c
ve
dfneo tecalne mesro tap ateavreug netrdb
ees fh hl gd aue ro p elh desjdmetnee y
e
tetil o r,h At re Geea cudno hv peetdtap bi ofca
h ra cutte t ny nrlo l t ae rvne ht u lc fiil
o
fo peet gad fneo fl ga ap a adcudn t esaieymanan
rm rsni ees rin n p eln o l o prusvl iti
n
i
ta tepeetto o sc ad fneo tefl go sc a ap a b a oh r
hth rsnain fu h ees rh ii fu h n p el y nte
n
dfn at udcnsi t a i rpritreec wi teAt re Geea'
ee dn wo l o tue n mpo e nefrn e t h t ny nrls
t
h
o
eecs o hso hrofca atoi .Bytesmetk n teatoi o
xrie f i r e fiiluhrt
y h a o e ,h uh rt f
y
ofcaiiit epo o ett priiaea afr l att dfn acaln e
fiilntai rp n nso at pt s omapry o eed h l gd
v
c
e
iiaieadt apaaug n ivl aigtemesr,os oi rpr
nt t ,n o p el jdmetnai t h auede ntmpo el
iv
dn
y
itreewi teAton yGeea'atoi add e n t ilt tesprto
nefr t h tre n rls uh rt n o s o voaeh eaain
h
y
o p wesd crn ,
f o r otie
4
.
Plitf as cnedtab cueteofcapo o eto a iiaie
anis lo otn h t eas h f il rp nns f n nt tv
f
i
mesr aepiaeidvd aswh hv n tbe eetdt p bi ofc,aen
aue r rv t n iiul o ae o en lce o u l fietk o
c
ot t u h l teCaionaCo si to o lwscn o b rcle o
ah o p od h l ri ntt in ra ,an t e eald r
f
u
i ece,n ae o sbetotecnlt fneetue o ohrtia
mpahdad rntujct h ofco itrsrls r te ehcl
i
sad rsta apyt p bi ofcaste cn opo el asrtesaes
tn ad htp l o u l fiil,h y an t rpry seth tt'
c
itrsi tev ldt o acaln e iiaiemesr.
neetn h aii f hlegd nt tv aue
y
i
Ou dtr nto ta teofcapo o et o a iiaieaeatoie
r eemiain hth fiil rp nns f n nt t r uh rzd
iv
t asrt saesitrsi tev l i o teiiaiemesr wh np bi
o sethe tt' neetn h ai t fh nt t aue e u lc
dy
iv
5
2
ofcashv dcie t dfn temesr, o vrd e n t a tate
fiil ae el d o eed h aueh wee, os o men hth
n
po o et bc med fcop bi ofcaso p sesayofca atoi t
rp nns eo e at u l fiil r oss n fiil uh ry o
c
t
eatlwso rg ain o ee t drcl efreteiiaiemesr i
n c a reult s r vn o iety noc h nt t auen
o
iv
q eto .Rahrteatoi tepo o etp sesi ticnetismpyte
usin te,h uh rt h rp n ns oss n hs o tx s i l h
y
atoi t p riiaea apryi acut cinadt asrlg lru nsi
uh rt o at pt s at n orato n o sete a ag met n
y
c
d fneo tesaesitrsi tev l i o teiiaiemesr whnte
ee s fh tt' neetn h ai t fh nt tv aue e h
dy
i
p bi ofcaswh odnrl wo l asrtesaesitrsi tevldt o
u l fiil o riai ud seth tt' neetn h aii f
c
y
y
temesr h v n t o es.Thsatoi iete l nro adl tdad
h aue a e o d n o i uh rt s xrmey arw n i e n
y
mi
d e n tmpyayatoi t at nb hlo tesaei oh rep cs
os o i l n uh rt o c o eaf fh tt n te rset.
y
Beas o tel tdn tr o tepo o et'uh rt,h yaepo el
cue fh i e aue fh rp nnsatoi te r rp ry
mi
y
sbetotesmeehclosanshtp lt altepre i algl
ujct h a tiacnt ittaapy o 1ohr atsn ea
r
i
po edn .
rce ig
Asdsusda o ewercg ie i BuligId sr Asn,u a41
icse b v , eonzd n i n n ut s.spr,
d
y
Ca.dapae82 tab cueo tefn a nap roeadu iu ntr o
1 t g 2 ,ht eas fh u dmetlup s n nq e aue f
3
teiiaiepoes- apoesd sg e t gv tep o l o Caionate
h nt t rcs
iv
rcs eind o ieh epe f l ri h
f
atoi t drcl a o t o si t nl med nso saue ta tereetd
uh rt o iet d p cntui aa n met rtttsh thi lce
y
y
to
ofcashv rfsdo d cie t a ot n ma otnop s teeia
fiil a e eue r el d o dp a d y fe p oe hr s n
n
icesdrs,v nwhnp bi ofcasaedfn igac aln e iiaie
nrae ik ee e u l fiil r ee dn hleg d nt t
c
iv
mesr,hth p bi ofcasma fit d fn t mesr wi vg r Asa
auetate u l fiil y alo eed he aue t io.
c
h
cneun eweidctdiBul n Id sr Asn ta e ni s h
o sq ec, n iae n i g n uty s.htve n uc
di
cru tn e acut eeal so l pr th ofcapo o eto a
ic msacs orgnrl h ud emite fiil rp nns f n
y
iiaiet itre ei tepo edn çog adtepepeseecs o
nt tv o nevn n h rce ig ç ur h o l' xrie f
i
t
iiaie o r'(bd)Whnp biofilttl dciet dfn a
ntt p we. li. e ul fiasoal el o eed
iv
'
c c
y n
caln e iiaiemesr,h saesitrsi teiiaiesv l i wol
h l gd nt t auete tt' neetn h nt t ' ai t ud
e
iv
iv
dy
g c mpeeyu dfn e,n tev trwh eatdteiiaiemesr it
o o ltl n eedd a d h oes o n ce h nt tv aueno
i
lw wo l b etrl dpie o hvn tesaesitrsi teiiaies
a ud e niey erv d f aig h tt' neetn h nt t '
iv
vldt asre o terbh l, nessmepiaeidvd a o etyi
aiiy setd n h i eafu ls o rv t n iiul r ni s
t
p r t dt asrta itrso tev tr'ta it sy tep o l', eaf
emie o sethtneet n h oes,hts o a,h epesbh l.
t
Beas o terseileainhpt teiiaiemesr,h ofca
cue fh i p ca rlt si o h nt t àuete fiil
o
iv
po o eto temesr aetemot b iu adlgcl rv t idvd ast
rp nns fh aue r h so vo s n o ia piaen iiu l o
al advg rul d fn tev l i o tec aln e mesr o b hlo te
by n ioo sy ee d h ai t fh h l g d aue n e af fh
dy
e
itrsso tev tr wh aotdteiiaieit lw,n tu t asrte
neet fh oes o d pe h nt t no a ad h so seth
iv
saesitrsi teiiaiesv l i wh np bi ofcashv dcie t d
tt' neetn h nt t ' ai t e u lc fiil ae el d o o
iv
dy
n
S.
O
Moe vree otieteiiaiecnetiin i e u pee etdn r
ro e,vn usd h nt t otx ts et r n rcdne o
iv
h
priual u uu l n e Caiona1w frp ro sohrta p bi ofcast
at lry n sa u dr l ri a o esn te hn u l f il o
c
f
c
b p r t dt p riiaea fr l at si acut cint asrtep bi'
e emie o at pt s oma pri n o rato o seth u l s
t
c
e
c
o tesaesitrsi u h ligo efrigad l e atdlw.F rea l,
rh tt' neetn p odn r nocn uy n ce a o xmpe
u drtes-aldku l itrs'e cpini madt ato spiaect es
n e h ocle ç bi neet xeto n n ae cin,rv t ii n
p c
'
z
hv ln benatoie t bigamadt ato t e freap bi dt
ae o g e uh rzd o rn n ae cin o noc u lc uy
iv ligtepoet no ap birgti odroe sr tan g vrmet
n ovn h rtci f u l ih n re t nueh t o oen n
o
c
bd i aro dfasteproeo lgsainetbi igsc ar h.(e,
oy mpi r eet h ups feilt salhn uh i t Se
s
o
s
g
eg, cnvObeo(9 12 Ca.d16 1415Co nC ue . ado
..Grc . ld 18) 9 1 2,4-4 ; mmo as vBor f
3
Sp rios(99 4 Ca.d4249 segnrl 8Wi i, lPoeue
uevsr 18) 9 l 3,3;e eeal t nCa.rcdr
3
y k
(t e.08 E t odnr Wrsj8,p 9093)Smir ,nete l
5h d20) xr riay i, 4p.7-7 . i ll udrh wel
a
t
ay
etbihdpi t atre gn rl otiepiaeidvd asaep r t dt
sal e r e t n y eea d crn ,rv t n iiu l r el t o
s
va o
hie
ati sp ro tep bi itrsb bign lwsi t efresae
c n upot fh u l neet y rn ig a ut o noc tt
c
s
cntuin l rsauoypo iin i cru tn e i whc efre n b
o si to a o tttr rvso sn icmsa csn ih nocmet y
t
pbiof ilma n tesfiin.(e,..SraovP i t17) 0
u l fcas y o b uf et Seeg,ern .ye (97 2
c i
c
s
C 1 d2, 24 ; o ln His eietAs.IcvCi Coni(99 2
a. 44-7 Wodad l R sdns sn,n.. t ucl17) 3
3
l
y
C 1d97 939 192)5Ide,h atoi o teof ilrpnns f n
a. 1,3, 4*4. nedte uhry fh fcapooeto a
3
- 2
t
i
2 Wen t ta i b t tep biitrsadpiaeatre gnrl
5
oe htn oh h u l neetn rvt t ny eea
c
o
cnet,h atoi o piaeidvd ast at nb hlo tep bi itrs
otxste uh rt f rvt n iiu l o c o eaf fh u lcneet
y
(ontcnieo nxpg)
t toeotud netae
b
n
5
4
iiaiet asrtesaesitrsi tepeet o tx iamoemo et
nt tv o seth tt' neetn h rsn cnets r d s
i
atoiyta teatoi e ecsdb piaeidvd asu dretete
uh rt hn h uh rt xrie y rvt n iiu l n e i rh
y
h
p bi- trsma dt ecpino tepiaeatre gn rl otieb cue
u l i eet n ae x et rh rvt tony eea d crn , eas
cn
o
u drtoed cr e piaeidvd asaeatoie t atafr t eyo
n e h s oti s r t n iiu l r uh rzd o c fimai l n
n v
v
b h lo tep bia disi tpoedn st efreap bi rg twhra te
e af fh u lc n ntue rceig o noc u l ih, eesh
t
c
atoi p sesdb teofcaiiaiepoo et' tepeetcnets
uh rt osse y h fiilnt tv rp nnsi h rsn otx i
y
i
n
smpyap sied fnieatoi t se i t asrtesaesitrsi te
i l asv , eesv uh rt o tp n o seth tt' neetn h
y
v ldt o acaln e mesr whnteiiaieh sb e c aln e b oh r
aii f h l gd aue e h nt tv a en h l g d y tes
y
e
i
e
iauiilrceig adp biofilhv dcie t dfn temesr.
n jdcapoedns n u l fias ae el d o eedh aue
c c
n
I sm,v nto g teofcapo oet o a iiai mesr aen t
n u ee h u h h fiil rp nns f n nt t aue r o
i ve
p bi ofcasterlte plyi asrigtesaesitrsi tev l i o
u l fiil h oe hy a n set h tt' neetn h ai t f
c
n
dy
a iiaiemesri tijdcastn de nthetntedmort
n ntt auenhsu iilet g os otrae h e cai
iv
i
c
po eso tepo e gv mac o tesaeb to tecnrr sre t
rcs rh rpr o e n e fh tt, u,n h o tay,evso
sfg adteu iu ee nsaditgi o teiiaiepo es
aeu r h nq e lmet n nert fh nt t rcs.
y
iv
5
.
Fial, litfssg etht dtr n to tateofca po o et
n l panif u g sta a eemiain hth fiil rp n ns
y
o a iiit eaeatoie t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o a
f n nt i r uh rzd o seth tt' neetn h ai t f
av
dy
caln e iiaiei acutrceigwi rsli u twadcneu ne i
hlegd nt t n o rpoedn l eutn no r o sq e csn
iv
l
ohrcnet.
te o txs
Fo e a l, litfscnedtaiofca iiaiepo o et ae
r xmpepanif otn htf fiilnt t rp nns r
iv
pemitdt asrtesaesitrsi a iiit esv l i adt ap a a
r te o seth tt' neetn n nt i ' ai t n o p eln
av
dy
Iontcniud mpeisae
otoeot eko rvupg)
n
o
udr lo a1wwa iialrcgie b jdcadcso nt tsadn
n eCai mi a sntl eonzd yu iil ei n owi tnig
f
iy
i
h
teasn eo aysei cntuin l rsauo'po iineprslgat g
h be c f n p cfc o si to a o tttl rvso x esy rni
t
y
n
sc atoi .(e,..Grc vObeospa2 Ca.dap .4-4,n
uh uhry See , cn . ld ,ur,9 1 tp 1415ad
t
g
3
cssctdSraovP is,ur,0Ca.dap .54 .
ae i ;ern . retspa2 1 tp 4-7)
e
3
5
5
avreug n whnte tre Geeaadohr u l of ilhv
desjdmet e h At ny nrln tepbi fcas ae
o
c i
dcie t d s,h pooet'cini figa apama sbeth s t
el do o ote rpnnsat n in n p el y ujctet e
n
o l
a
t sbtnil n tr l blyfratre fe so l tepo o e t' foti
o u sat mo eay i it o ton y es h ud h rp nns efrsn
a
ai
sp ot ftecaln e mesr po eu scesu.Th q eto o wh
u p ro h h l gd aue rv nu csfl e u sin f o
e
so l b a rso iit frayatre fea r i sc cru tne,
h ud er ep nsbly o n t ny e wad n uh icmsa cs
i
o
h we e,seteydsicfo teq et nwh te teofcapo o et o
o vri ni l it trm h u si eh rh fiil rp n ns f
r
n
o
a iiitv aeatoie t asrtesaesitrsi tev l i o a
n ntaie r uh rzd o seth tt' neetn h ai t f
dy
caln e iiaiemesr adin t eoeu i tipo edn .Ou
h l g d nt tv aue n s o b fr sn hs rce ig r
e
i
cn lso ta ofca iiaiepo o etaeatoie t asltesaes
o cuin ht fiilnt t rp n ns r uh rzd o se'h tt'
iv
t
itrsi tev l i o acaln e iiaiemesr whnp biofcas
neetn h ai t f hl g d nt t aue e u lc fiil
dy
e
iv
dciet d s d e n t a taaymo eayl blyicre a arslo
el o o o os o men ht n ntr i it nurd s eut f
n
a i
tepo o et' cin so l o mut ebreb tesae Th atre fe
h rp nns ato s h ud r sb on y h tt. e ton y e
iu cnpoelb adesdiadwhnteqet naie itef r.( .
s e a rpr e drse fn e h usi r sn h mue Cf
s
y
o s
Co nryvSaePesn eBd,u a 3 Ca.t a p 17 -19
n el . tt ro n l .spr, 7 1 h t p. 1817
4
(it gihn sau o itreeiiaie rp nnsrmtao a csuie
dsi usig tts fnevnrntt pooetfo ht fmiu cr
n
iv
a
i cn ldn ta a c scra cudn t rpryb h l l befr rv tn o cu ig ht miu uie o l o po el e ed i l o piae
a
atre-eeaatre fea rj
t nygnrlt ny e wad.
o
o
)
Smial, hv n o cso i tics t adeyoh rlgl usin
i lry we ae o cain n hs ae o d rs te ea q etos
tama aiei itr cssiteeiacnlt ewente oiosae b
ht y rs n l e ae fhr s o fcbt e h p sin tkn y
u
i
t
iiit epo o et adb ohrdfn atwh aeap aigo bh lo te
ntai rp n ns n y te eedns o r p ern n eaf fh
v
sae Th iseb fr u il tdt teq eto whte ofca iiaie
tt. e su eoe ssi e o h u sin eh r fiilnt tv
mi
i
po nnsaeatoie t ap a a p rist asrtesaesitrsi te
rpo et r uh rzd o p er s at o seth tt' neetn h
e
v l i o a iiaiemesr wh ntep bi ofcaswh odnrl po ie
ai t f n nt tv aue e h u l fiil o riai rvd
dy
i
c
y
sc adfneh v dcie t d s.Th n meo scssdsusdao ei
uh ees a e el d o o o e u ru ae icse b v n
n
whc iiit epo nnsCo geso saelgsaielaesh v b e
ih nt i rpoet, n rs,r tt eilt edr ae en
av
v
pr te t itreet peetea ag metrgrigtev l i adpo e
emitd o nevn o rsn lglru ns e adn h ai t n rpr
dy
itmrtto o acaln e 1wrft tecam tap n tiga iiit es
ne eain f h l gd a eue h li ht e ni n n ntai '
e
t
v
ofcapo o et t prii t o tib ssiu wokbeo wi ie iby
fiilrp n nso at pae n hs ai s n ral r l nvt l
c
l a
rsli dti na cneu ne.
eutn ermetl o sq e cs
C.Ou-fsaeDeiin
to-tt cso s
Astefrg igdsuso idctsi rahn tecn lso ta te
h oeon ic sin n iae,n ecig h o cuin hth
ofcapo o et o a iiaieaeatoie u drCaionalw t dfn a
fiil rp n ns f n nt t r uh rzd n e l ri a o ee d
iv
f
calne iiaiemesr adt apaf maug n ivl aigte
hl gd ntt aue n o pelr jdmetn ai t h
e
iv
o
dn
mesr wh np bi ofcasdciet d fn teiiaiewehv rl duo
aue e u l fiil el o eed h nt tv , ae ei p n
c
n
i
e
tehsoyadp roeo teiiaiepo iin o teCaionaCo si to
h itr n up s fh nt t rvso s fh l ri ntuin
iv
f
t
adu o ten meo sCaionadcso stahv u iomlp r te te
n p n h u ru lfri eiin ht ae nfr y emitd h
ofcapo nnso iiaiemesrst ap a a prisa ddfn te
f il rpo et fnt t aue o p er s at n eed h
iv
e
v l i o temesrshyhv so srd
ai t fh aue te ae p noe .
dy
I a dto , n t tai rcn y asec o tet ohrsaespe
n d i n we oe htn eet er ah fh wo te tt u rme
i
cutta hsadesdteq eto whehrteofcapo o et o a
o rsht a d rse h usin te h fiil rp n ns f n
iiit emesr h v sadn u drsae1wt itreei a ato
nt i aue a e tn ig n e tt a o nevn n n cin
av
c aln igtevldt o teiiaiemesr hsc nld dta,n e ec
h l gn h aii fh nt tv aue a o cu e h tu dr ah
e
y
i
saesrset elw,ntaiepo oe tgnrl aeatoie t itree
tt' ep ci a ii t rp nns e eal r uh rzd o nevn
v
iv
y
ao ihisc a atnisaecut
sfr tn uh n ci ntt or.
g
o
1
.
IAlsaso aCo nLnug vKrt( ak 20) P3 96
n aknfr mmo agae. i Alsa 003 .d 0
z
( aknfraCo nL nug)teiseo s nigaoei a at n
Alsaso mmo agae,h su ft dn rs n n ci
a
o
caln igtev l i o av trapo diiaiemesr ta- l ete
h l gn h ai t f oe-p rve nt t aue ht i h
e
dy
iv
k
Aroaiiaieivle iAroaso O il nlhspa50U..3
i n ntt novdn i nnfr ycaEgi ,ur,2 S4
z iv
z
s
(e at,tp 1-0 - poie taE gihsaleue b alul
se neap .82) rvddht nl hlb sd y 1pbi
s
c
a ece i a1 o en n f to sadato sa di tepe rto o a1
gn isn 1g vrmett in n cin n n h rpaain f 1
mc
ofcap bi d cmet adrcrs Twoognzto s t frtteofca
fiil u l ou ns n eod.
c
ra iain heis,h fiil
po o et o tei taiemesr i Alsaadtescn , n t nl
rp n ns fh ni t auen ak ,n h eo d a ai a
iv
o
ognzt n( SE gih tasp otdte ak mesr - suht
raiai U.. n l )htupr h Alsa aue ogto
o
s
e
5
7
itreea fr l at si tetilo rpo edn sb th til ordne
nevn s oma pri n h ra cutrce ig,u te ra cute id
e
b t rq eto tegon tateitrsso tewol-eitrees r
oh eu ss n h ru d hth neet fh udb nevn rwee
a eutl rpeetdb teg v mme t ee dnswh weed fn igte
dq aey ersne y h o e n dfn at o r eedn h
iiaiemesr i tepoedn .Bohognzto sapae tetil o r'
nt t aue n h rceig t raiain p eld h ra cut
iv
s
rl gdn igitreto .Onapa,h AlsaS pe Co rrv re te
ui eyn nevnin
n
p elte ak u rme uteesd h
tilo r'nl gisfra idne itreto b teofcapo o eto
ra cuts zi noa st eid nevnin y h fiil rp n ns f
n
temesr b t fime telwe cutuigisfra idne itreto b
h aue u afr d h o r o rrl noa st eid nevnin y
n
teohrognzto .
h te raiain
l aay igteqeto o teofca po o et'ih t itreete
n nlzn h usin fh fiil rp n nsrgto nevn ,h
AlsaS pe Co rn tdtapirotev t o teiiaiemesr a
ak u rme ut oe ht ro t h oe n h nt t aue t
iv
isei ta cs,h AtonyGe ea' Ofiehdrie p tnil u sin
su n ht aete tre nrls f a asd oeta q eto s
c
rgrigtecnsi to ai o temesr adteGoen rh dp ro al
eadn h o tt inly fh aue n h vro a esnl
u t
y
op sdtemesr dr gteeet ncmpin ( aknfraCo n
poe h aue ui h lci a ag.Alsaso mmo
n
o
L n ug,ur, P3 ap .0-1.Noehls,bevn tacut
ag aespa3 .d tp9990) nteesosrightor
s
gnrl çeo nz apeu t no aeut rpeett nwhng vrmet
e eal ç cg ie rsmpi f d q ae ersnai e o en n
yr
o
o
etisaep rist alwsib cuetoeetisaecag db lw wi
nie r at o a ut eas h s nie r hre y a t
t
e
t
h
rpeet gteitrs ote epe ( .t . 1)teAlsaSpe Cor
ersni h neet fh pol' l ap93,h ak urme ut
n
s
'd
sae taçbae o tepeu t no aeutgvrmetersnainwe
ttdhtç jsd n h rsmpi fdqae oen nrpeett ,
l
o
o
peu teAtonyGeea'Ofiewo l ntfit dfn te
rsmeh tre nrls fc ud o alo eed h
cntuin lyo teiiaieeegtcl adcpby.Bae o ta sme
o si to ai fh nt t n reial n a al sd n hta
t
t
iv
y
peu t nweas peu tategvro wolntnefr. (da
rsmpi , lo rsmehth oenr ud o itree' 1.t
o
'
p 94)
. 1.
T ecutnAlsaso aC mmo L nug ,ur, P3 96wet n
h ori aknfr o n aga espa3 .d 0, n O
t epan h wee,hadsi tecut peu to tategv rmet
o x li, o v rt t ept h o r' rsmpin hth o en n
e
s
dfn atwo l e egtcl adcp bydfn tecaln e mesr,
eedns ud nreial n aal eed h hl gd aue
y
e
iamuha teiiit epo o ethdçsdtepo eso drc lgsaint
n s c sh ntai rp nns a ç e h rcs f ieteilt o
v
u
o
eat lwtateeeuiebac qet ndadopsd,(hycr te
ncaa hth xct rnh usoe n p oel t e amob
v
i
ql
5
8
futdfr nigt g aatetateiiitv idfn e zao syo fr
al o wat o urne hth ntaies eedd elul r o
e
n
tyn t e sr tateceiit o isi inl ru nsi fv ro te
rig o nueh th rdbly fnt o aagmet n ao fh
i
mt
iiai in t i nse b tepeiu cmmetfo teeeuieba c.
nt t s o dmiih d y h rvo s o nsrm h x ct rnh
i ve
v
Tote a dt tep bi i smp tywi teiiaieteg vro'
hm,n o h u l n y ah t h nt t ,h oen rs
c
h
iv
op sto a dteAton yGeea Ofiesq et n . .uigtecmp in
p oiin n h tre nrl fc' u si s .d rn h a ag ,
o
cudcet a apaac o avri .Evr srtgcd cso ma eb te
o l rae n p ern e f d est ey tae i eiin d y h
y
Aton yGe ea'Ofiei dfn igtelgsainmih b p bil
tre nrls fc n eedn h e ilto g t e u lcy
q eto e a dscn -use b teiiaiessmp ties Th ths
u sind n eo dg esd y h nt t ' y ahzr. a ti
iv
ssiinma b ufu ddden t k ils ieibe'(P3 ap 94)
upco y e none os o maetesnvt l. 3 .d t .1.
a
Th AlsaS pe Corweto t cn ld :slr, ea s o te
e ak u rme ut n n o o cu eç- ebcue fh
le
ntr o drc lgsaintru hteiiaiepo estep silap aa c
aue f i teilto ho g h nt t rcs,h osbe p erne
e
iv
o av riyo itrs isfiin t o ec metepeu t no aeu t
f d est fneets ufceto v ro h rsmpi f dq ae
o
rpeettn Ide w:blv taa fnt te s no'drcitrsi
ersnai .ne4 ei ehtn iiailposrs i tneetn
o
e
iv
e
lgilto ea tdtru hteiiaieprcs a dtecno tn n e t
e sain n ce ho g h nt t o es n h o cmi t ed o
iv
a
aodteaperneo destwi odnrlp eld cutko dnig
vi h p aac favri l riai rcue ors m eyn
y l
y
itretna o lhtasosrn gow. ( aknfr C mmo
nevni sfr to pnoig rz ' Alsasoa o n
o
k
'
L n ug,u a3P3 ap 94 ils de.6Acodn l,h cut ed
ag aespr, .d t .1,ti add) crigyte orhl
ac
2
ta tetil orerdi dn igitreto b teofcapo nnso te
h th ra cutre n eyn nevnin y h f il rpo et fh
iiit emesr a drv re tap rino tetilo r'rl g.
nt i aue n eesd ht ot fh racuts ui
av
o
n
2 T ecut d e anro q aiiaint isbodh ligta iiaie
6 h o radd arw ulfcto o t ra odn htnt tv
i
po o etaeetldt itreei sc liaina amatro rg t
rp n ns r nie o nevn n uh igt s te fih,
t
t o
epliigta û ak cutso lrti dsrt nt dn itreto i
x ann htWlsa ors h ud ean icei o ey nevnin n
o
ecpinlae,eas ( erlvnAlsasauerligt iiaie
xet acssbcuet eeat ak ttt ean ontt
o
h
t
iv
so srq lcs ol tntenmbr fntt esosradteeoe
p nospae n i o h u eo iiai pnos n hrfr
mi
iv
poetal o n ted o t a u l tdn mb ro moin frnevnin As
tnil pesh oro n ni e u e f to so itreto .
y
mi
a atraiet l t gitreto i toecsscutma i ta co s t
n lent o i i nevnin n h s ae,o rs y nsed h oe o
v min
rd c dpiainb rq iigtoeso sr wi sbtnil smi ritrss
eu e u lcto y eurn h s p nos t u satal i l neet
h
y a
t cnoiaehibif gadt priiaetruhla cusl'( akn
o o sl tter rei n o at pt hog ed one. Alsas
d
n
c
'
fraCo nLnug,u a3P.dap94)
o mmo agaespr, 3 t .1.
5
9
Th AlsaSpe Co rrahdacnrr cn lso , o vrwi
e ak u rme utece o tay o cuin h wee, t
h
rsetoteohrognzt ntah dsu h itret ni tetil or.
ep ct h te ra iai ht a o g tnevni n h ra cut
o
o
P it gOthtçlercr fi t so adU.. nlhhs o asr d
oni utait eod al o hw,n SE gi a ntset ,
n
gh
s
s
e
ta i drcosofcr,ricroaosweeso sr o teiiaiei
htt ietr, f eso n op rtr r p nos fh nt t n
s
iv
Alsaoweeme esoteiiaiecmmie'Alsaso aCo n
ak r r mbr fh ntt o te( aknfr mmo
iv
t
L n ug,ur, P3 ap96,h cuton taS .. gi hs o
agaespa3 .d t . 1)te orfu dhtC SEnlh a nt
U
s
etbih dta i itrsiaygetrh nagnrl e itrso ap lia
sal e h tt neets n raeta e eai d neet f oicl
s
s
z
t
ntr'( i. Ihltateognztnddntulyfrnevnina a
aue'i dj t edhth raiai i oq ai o itret s
b .
o
f
o
matro rg tn ta tetilo rddn t b s i dsrto i d n ig
te fih ad h th r cut i o auet icein n eyn
a
s
pr sieitret n (bd)
emis nevni .Ii.
v
o
2
.
lS rmefr-4 vF#enhJdCor( n.024 P3 40
npot no113 . et u. utMot20) 0 .d 0
s
(p r mefr-44teMotn Spe C uti lr adesdte
Sot n o 113,h naa urme ors al drse h
s
mi y
gnrlsu t ehrtepi r po o et f b l tntaiehsalgl
e eaisel te h rmay rp nn o a al ii t a eal
wh
o iv
y
poetbeitrssfiin t alwit itreei acs c aln igte
rtcal neetufceto l to nevn n ae hlegn h
o
rsln stt. ( .t.0.AsnAlsasoaC mmo L nug,ur,
eutgtue' 1 ap42) i aknfr o n agaespa
i a 'd
3P3 96iSotmefr-4 tetacuta dne amoint itree
.d 0 ,n p r no 113h r lorhd eid t onevn
s
i
o
b teso sr o tecaln e iiaiemesr o tegon tate
y h p nos fh h legd nt tv aue n h ru d hth
i
g vrmetdfn at a di tepo edn - teeteMotn De at n
o en n eedn n me n h rce ig h r,h na a prmet
o Fih, lle adP rs- cudaeutl dfn temesr.Al og i
f s Wi i ,n ak o l dq aey ee d h aue t uh n
df
h
taisac teewa lterao t sseth th nme g vrmet
htntn e hr sil esn o upc ta te a d o en n
t
dfn at udn t ioo sydfn teiiaiemesr adters t g
eedn wo l o vg rul eed h nt t aue n h euln
iv
i
lgsaint iiaieh degn ee ,h Mo tn S pe Co rn ntees
e ilto hent t a n e drd te naa u rme ut o ehls
iv
o sre ta teiiaiepo o et û oatvl datdadsp otd113
bevd hth nt t rp n nsl ciey rfe n u p re -4
iv
wh
ma b i tebsp st nt d fn teritprtto o tersln
y en h et oii o eed h i ne eain fh eut g
o
i
lgsain (0P3 ap 43 adhlta,sagnrl triiaie
eilt '4 .d t .0)n ed hta eeamat ,ntt
o
e iv
6
0
pooetçr etldtitreea amatro ih'ia atncaln ig
rp nnsse nie onevn s t fr t n n ci hl gn
a t
e g'
o e
tev l i o temesr te hv sosrd. ( i ils de.7
h ai t fh auehy a e' noe I d,ti add)
dy
p
b ac
2
I co cuin
v. n lso
I rso s t teq et nsb te b teNit Cic i wecn ld,o
n ep ne o h u si u mi d y h nh rut ocu e fr
o
t
,
terao sdsusda o etawh ntep biofcaswh odnai d fn a
h esn icse b v,ht e h u l fiil o ri rl ee d
c
y
calne sae1w o apaaug n ivl aigte1wdciet d s,
hl gd tt a rp el jdmetnai t h a el o o o
e
dn
n
u drat l I,eto 8o teCaionaCo si inadterlvn po iin
n e ri e Iscin fh lfri nt o n h eeat rvso s
c
mt
o teEldin Co eteofcapo net o av trapo e iiit e
fh e o s d,h fiil rpo ns f oe-p rvd nt i
av
mesr aeatoie t asrtesaesitrsi teiiaiesv l i s
aue r uh rzd o seth tt' neetn h nt t ' ai t
iv
dy
ea l gtepo o ett dfn tecntuinlyo teiiitv adt
n bi h rp n nso eed h o si to ai fh ntaie n o
n
t
t
apaau g n ivlaigteiiaie
p el jdmetn ai t h ntt .
dn
iv
CANTI S
L-AKAUYE, J
C..
WECONCUR:
IENNARD,.
Q
J
BAXTER, .
J
WERDEGAR, .
J
CHI J
N,.
CORRI J
GAN,.
LI J
U,.
2 WenttabtAlsasoaCmmo L nug,ur, P3 96
7
oehtoh aknfr o n agaespa3 .d 0,
adS rs n o 113sp a4 P3 4 0weedcddatrh UntdSae
n pot fr-4,ur,0 .d 0 , r eie f te i tts
me
e
e
Spe C ut dcso iAi nnfrO ilnlhspa50U..3
urme or' ei nn rz aso ycaEgi ,ur,2 S4.
s i
o
s
T oedcsoscnimtatefdrlihcut dcso iAr oaso
h s eiin of hth eeahg or' eiinn i nnfr
r
s
z
O il gihi oen i ei ntattcut dtr ntnta,
ycaEnl mpss ompdmeto sae or' eemiai ht
s
s
o
u drsaelw,niiaiepoo et a teatoi t itreea o rgti
n e tt a a nt t rp nn h sh uh rt o nevn s fih n
iv
y
a ato i saecuth l n igtevl i o a iiaiemesr.
n cin n tt o rcal gn h ai t f n nt tv aue
e
dy
i
6
1
CO PY
PERRYv.
BROWN
5 846
19 7
CONCURRI OPI ON BY KENNARD, .
NG NI
J
Whljiigfl itecut uai u oiinatoe b teC if
i onn 'l n h or' nnmo s pno uhrd yh he
e
uy
s
Jsie 1 i sprtlt hg lgth hsoia adlgl vnstahv ld
utc, wrt e aaey o ihih te itrcln e ae et ht aee
e
t tdy'dcso adt epanwh I o cri tad cso .
o o a s eiin n o x li y cnu n ht eiin
Thscs mak tefuttmei rcn yertaticut a adesd
i ae rsh o rh i n eet ashths orh s drse
ise rltdt teo g igp lia adlgltu gea ot ehrsmesx
su s eae o h n on oicl n ea srg l b u whte a -e
t
mara e so l b rcg ie a v l i Caio a I 2 0 ,hscutedta
rigs hud e eonzd s ai n l mi. n 0 4 ti o rhl h t
d
f
SnFrn ic p bi ofcasecee teratoi whnte ise ma ig
a a cso u l fiil x edd h i uh rt e h y sud nae
c
y
l essosmesxcu ls tot piru iileemiaino te
i ne t a -e ope wi u a r jdcadtr nt fh
c
h
o
o
c nttt n lyo aCaionasamersrcigmaig t htrsx a
o si i ai f lfri tt etitn n ae o eeoe ul
uo t
culs (okevCi adC ufo a Frnic (043 Ca.t 15
ope.f cyr. t n ony fsn acso20)3 1 h 05
y
4
(o#e) Ageigwi te jryta, tiorttgvrmet
L c r. ren t h maoi htwi n u s e oen n,
4
h
t
h
a
dtr nn tecntuin l aii o saesaue iats rsre t te
eemiig h osi t a vldt ftt tttss ak eevd o h
to
y
jdcabac,jie itadcso,xetnoa a idcae v isme
u iil rnhIondnht ei n ecp isfrst elrd od o
i
40 0smesxmara e p rome i rl neo le ssise i S n
,0 a -e rigs efr dn ei c n i ne su d n a
a
c
Facso ( .t . 15(oc& dson oKemadJ. Mysprt
rni .1 ap 12 cn. i.p .f r r,.) eaae
c d
)
o no i Lok repandta bcuetep ro swh s mara e weea
piin n cye x lie h t ea s h esn oe rig s r t
iseweent eoehs or adbcueuiilrceig t dtr n te
su r obfrticut n easjdcapoedn so eemieh
,
c ntuin lyo Caio alwsbrigsmesxmaraeweete pn ig
o si to ai f lfmi a arn a -e rig r h n edn
t
t
i oh r lonacut, wo l hv rfan df m dtr nn te aii o
n te Cai ri o r I ud ae erie r eemiig h v l t f
f
s
o
dy
toemar gs (bd)
h s ri e.Ii.
a
Thratri Ma 2 0 ,hscutedta Caio assauoy1w
eefe,n y 0 8ti orhl ht lfmi' tttr a
dn igsmesxcu lsterg tomar voae tepiay d epoesad
eyn a -e ope h ih t ry iltd h rv c,u rcs,n
eulrtcinpoiin o orttCostt na ite ra.( r
qapoet rvsos fu s e ntui sthn ed f c
o
a
io
n
MaraeC ss(0 84 Ca.h77( rig C ss.I adt nt s nn
rig ae 2 0) 3 1t 5 Marae aej n d io o i ig
4
)
i g
temaoi oiinteeI oesprtltepanimyo wodwh I
h jry pno hr,wrt eaaeyo xli n wn rs y
t
rjce teagmetht ehra -e cu lshudb alwe t mar
eetdh ru ntawhtesmesx ope sol e l do r
o
y
peetdesnil < scaopliaiseiaporaefruiil
rsne set l t oilroiclsu nprpit ojdca
ay a
t
cnieain'(dap 89(ocono KemadJ. 1 oehtç ut
o s rt . 1.t .5 cn.p .f r r,.) wrtta(or
d o'
)
c s
ao emutdcd wh te ecu igidvd asfo ma ig bcueo sx a
ln s eie eh r x ldn n iiul rm n ae eas f eul
oinaincnb rcn idwi o rsaeCo si to seu l rtcin
rett a e eo cl t u tt ntuin' q apoet
o
e h
t
o
gaate'( .t .6.
urne. f ap 80)
'#
Sxmo tsltri No e e 2 0 , lonasv tr apo e
i nh ae,n vmbr 0 8Cai ri' oes p rvd
f
Po sto 8 a iiaietaa n e CaionasCo siuinb adn a
rpoi n , n nt tv ht med d lfri' nt to y d ig
i
i
t
nwpoiinepesyl t gmaig thtrsxacu ls ( 1C nt
e rvs xrsl i i naeo eeoeulope.Ca. o s,
o
min
.
at1j75)I Ma 2 0,hs orrjce saecntuinlhlne t
r., .. n y 09ticuteetd tt osit acal gso
to
e
Prpoio 8 dtr nn ta ihdbe vldyeatdb tepo eue
o st n , eemiig htt a en ail n ce y h rcdrs
i
pecie frcnttto a a n met,ahrta temoerg ru
rsrb d o o si in lme d nsrte hn h' r ioo s
u
poeue pecie frcntuin le so saddtr nn as ta
rcd rs rsrb d o o si to arviin,n eemiig lo ht
t
Po oio 8ddnt ilttesprt nop wes otn.(t usvHotn
rp sin i ovoaeh eaai f o rdcr e Sr s . r
t
o
i a
o
(09 4 C lt 34(tasl T icutntacs as dcddta
20) 6 a.h 6 Srus. hs ori ht ae lo eie ht
4
)
Prpoio 8ddn tn aiaeaymarae p rome b fr isefciedt.
o st n i o iv l t n rigs efr d eoe t fetv ae
i
d
(t usap44)Iindtecut oiinadwrtacnu igoiini
Sr s,t .7 . sge h or' pno n oe ocnn pno n
a
s
whc Iepan dta ato g itrrtn eitn saecntminl rvso s
ih x lie ht l u h nepeig xsig tt o si oapo iin
h
t
iauiilepniit,h vtrrtilgsaieatoi t atrh
s jdcarsos lyte oesean eilt uhry o l te
bi
v
t e
CaionaCo si to 'ln ug adteeyt lnag o rd c tep ro a
lfri ntt insa gae n hrb o ç lre reu eh esnl
u
e
rg tta tesaeCo si to a s a n e wilhratrg aatead
ihsh th tt ntuin s o medd lteefe u rne n
t
poet'(dap46(ocon oKe adJ)
rtc. 1.t .7 cn.p.f mlr,.)
'
.
I Ma 2 0,hrybfrticutsudi oiinrjcigtesae
n y 09sot eoehs orise t pno eet h ttl
s
n
lwcaln e tPooio 8(t usspa4 Ca.t 34,orniiul
a hl gso rp sin Sr s,ur,6 1 h 6)fu idvdas
e
t
a
4
bo g t nato i fdrl itit orcaln igPo oio 8o fdrl
ru h a cin n e ea dsrc cuth l gn rp st n n eea
e
i
cnt in l ru d.Na da d fn atweeteGo en rCaionas
o si o a go n s me s eedns r h v ro, l ri'
mt
f
Aton yGeea,n Caio asDietro P biHe1 .No eo toesae
tre nrlad l mi' rco f u l at n fh s tt
f
c h
p bi ofcash wee,iiae i dfneo Po oio 8 Th Go en rad
u l fiil, o v rl gtd n ees f rp st n . e v ro n
c
t
i
teDietro P bi Hel dcie t tk ayp sto o temei, i te
h rco f u l at el d o ae n oi n n h rt whl h
c h n
i
s e
Aton yGeea to tep sto ta Po sto 8voae teUntdSae
tre nrlo k h oi n h t rpoi n iltsh i tts
i
i
e
Co si to Th fdrl itit orp r te Po oio 8soGca
ntuin. e eea dsrc cut emi d rp st n ' f il
t
t
i
po o ett itre eadiwa te ,n te ao ewh dfn e te
rp n nso nevn ,n t sh y ad hy ln, o eedd h
mesr dr gteesignnuyta.(e ma.p .at,t p71.
aue ui h nun ojr r l Se jon,neap .-0)
n
i
Afe tetiltefdrl itit orise a o iincn ldn ta
trh ra,h eea dsrccutsu d n pno o cu ig ht
Po oio 8voae b t ted epoesadteeu l rtcinca sso te
rp st n ilts oh h u rcs n h q apoeto lue fh
i
fdrl ntuin Onyteiiaiepo o et apae,oteUntdSae
eea Co si to . l h nt t rp n ns p eldt h ie tts
t
iv
Coro Ap elfrh Nit Cici whc ise a odrakn ticuto
ut f p as o te nh rut ih su d n re sig hs ort
,
dcd, samatro saelw, eh r rp nnso a iiaietatev tr
eie a te ftt a whte po o et f n nt tv hth oes
i
apo e hv ete a(atuaie itrs'i teiiit esv l i o te
p rv d ae i r d ri lrzd neet n h ntai ' ai t rh
h p c
'
v
dy
atoi tçseth saesneetidfnigteiiaie (e ma.p.
uhryotsrtett'itrs'n eedn h ntt .Se jon,
t a
'
iv
a t,tp 1-3)Wi ot eiigwhte iiaie rpnns aea
neap .01. t udcdn ehrntt pooethv
h
iv
S riulrzditrs'i teiiaiesv l i ,hscuts n nmo so no
d t aie neet n h nt t ' ai t ti o r'u ai u piin
pa c
'
iv
dy
h lsta u drCaio a1w teoûcapo o et o av trapo e
od ht n e l mi a h f il rp n ns f oe-p rvd
f
iiit ehv at rt t (seth saesitrs'i tevaii o ta
nt i ae uhoiy o ç srte tt' neet n h ldt fht
av
a
'
y
iiaieadt apaaug n ivlaigteiiaiewhns tof il
ntt ,n o p el jdmetn ai t h ntt , e t e fias
iv
dn
iv
a c
hv dcie t d s.( jon,neap., 1)
ae el do o o Ma.p .a t,tp 56.
n
1
1
Iarewi tdy'h ligadwi terao igo tecut
ge t o a s odn n t h esnn fh o r'
h
h
s
u ai u o iin lbif epanwh .
nnmo s pno . rel x li y
y
Astemaoi oiiniSrus one otticut dcsosnte
h jry pno n t sp itd u,hs or' eiin i h
t
a
s
treerirsmesxma ig cssiutaetepo e rlso,n te
he ale a -e na e ae l srt h rp roe fad h
l
l tt n i oe u o ,ahba c o Caio asg vrmet te
i ai smp sd p n ec rnh f l mi' o en n - h
mi o
f
eeuietelgs t eadteuiil udr u saeCosit n
xct ,h eili ,n h jdca- n eortt ntui .
v
av
to
(tas,ur,6Ca.t 343 5)L cyrso taterlo Caio as
Srussp a4 1 h 6,8 . oke hwshth oe f l mi'
4
f
e euieba c ofcasit efresauoylwswhc te mutra a
x ctv rnh f il so noc tttr a , ih hy stet s
vl ,eades fhiproave ,nesadut teuiir hs
ai rgrls o ter esnl i u ls n ni h jdcay a
d
ws
l
dtr ndohmie (oke,ur,3Ca.t 15,08)MaraeCae
eemie te s.f cyrspa3 1 h 05 16 . ri ss
4
g
so ta terl o Caio aslgsaiebac it eatsaue ta ae
h wshth oe f l mi' e ilt rnh so n c tttsh tr
f
v
c nitn wi CaionasCo si o , iha n ohrtig g aate te
o sset t l ri' ntmin whc mo g te hn s urnesh
h f
t
r hsopiayd e rcs,n eulrtcino telws ( rig Cae,
i tt r c,u poesad qapoet fh a .Marae ss
g
v
o
sp a4 C 1t 77 79758586)Srusso taterlo
ur, 3 a.h 5,7-8,5-5. t s hwshth oe f
4
a
Cai mi'jdcabac it itrrtxsigs tsauoyadcntuinl
lo asu iilrnh sonepeei n t e tttr n osit a
f
t a
to
po iosapweadrsosblytaisbetotel tt ntate
rvs n, o r n ep niit htsujct h i ai hth
i
i
mi o
eetrt,ho g tep we o teiiai , a a n tesaeCo siuint
lcoaetru h h o r fh nt t cn med h tt nt to o
i ve
t
oer efo tat fr r,h cut rl g (t ussp aap .8,
vri ,rm hti owadte or' ui .Sr s,ur,tp 3 5
d
me
s n a
3 132)
9-9 .
Thscs rie a iseo smiri otnet apo e u drtn igo
i ae ass n su f i l mp ra c o rpr n esadn f
a
o rsaeg vmmetltutr u drCaionasCo si to :Whnte
u tt o e nasrcue n e l ri' ntuin e h
f
t
v tr,ho g teeecs o tercntuin l g aate iiaiep we,
oestru h h xrie fhi o si to al urned nt t o r
t
y
iv
hveeatdanw saueo hv a n e tesaeCo si t n a dtev l i
a n ce e ttt r ae medd h tt ntui ,n h ai t
to
dy
otaiiaieicaln e iauiilrceigwh ma apaicuto
fhtnt t shl gdn jdcapoedn, o y p ern ort
iv
e
dfn teiiit e
ee d h nt i ?
av
Caionassaetil n ap lt cuthveruieypr te
lfri' tt raa d p el e o rs a otn l emitd
a
iiaiepo o ett d fn a iiaiesv l iy adt ap a fo a
nt t rp n nso eed n nt t ' ai t,n o p elrm
iv
iv
d
jdmetodn a iiaieivl,atualwhnsaeofilhv
ug nhlig nntt nai pri lr e tt fias ae
iv d c y
c
dcie t d s.(e ma.p .at,tp 2-1)T et manraoso
el do o o Se jon,neap .83. h wo i esn fr
n
t ssadr patc aeesl sae .
hi tn ad rcie r ai ttd
y
Frttevli o adleatdsaeiiaiemesr (atual oe
is h ait f uy nce tt ntt auepri lr n
, dy
iv
c y
taa n sh s tCosit na Pooio 8de)samatr f ra
htmed te t e ntui ,s rpst n osi t o get
a
to
i
e
pbiiprac tacnb dtn ie oltruhjdcapoedns S c
u l m ot ehta e eeund ny hog uiilrceig. uh
c
n
poedn saemotieyt po uearsltawi b rlal,n tate
rceig r sl l o rd c eutht l e eibea d hth
k
l
p biwi fn acpa l,fh ise aetoo g l advg ru l liae .
u lc l id cetbe ite sus r h ru hy n ioo sy igtd
l
t
Ash cut o iinntsma.p .at,tp4 -3,nt t epooet
te or' pno oe ( jon,neap .04)iiai rpnns
s
iv
gnrl h v temoiaina dtersucst liaetoo g l ad
e eal a eh t to n h eore o igt h ru hy n
y
v
t
vgrul idfneo iiaiemesrshyhv sosrd(atual
ioosyn ees fntt aue te ae pnoe pri l y
iv
cr
whnsaeofcas aedcie t d s)adteeyt asstecuti a
e tt f ilhv el do o o,n hrb o sith or n
i
n
s
wa ta ivtloteitgi o teetepoes
y hts i t h nert fh ni rcs.
a
y
r
S cn ,h iiai p we wa addt tesaeCo si to i 1 1
eo d te nt t o r s de o h tt ntt in n 9 1
i ve
u
( lC nt atI j 8 1) eas oteve wieyhla n C lonas
Ca. os. r.I j ,0 bcue fh iw, dl ed mog ai ri'
, ,
f
v tr,h th Le iltr adsaeoscashdbcmes dpedn o seil
oestate gsaue n tt f il a eo o e n et n pca
itrssta te weeu a lo u wiigt tk ato sta t p bi itrs
neet h th y r n be r n ln o ae cin hthe u lcneet
l
rq i d Togvetoesmesaeofcasslatoiyt dcd whte o nt
eur . i h s a tt f il oe uh rt o eie ehr r o
e
ad l eatdiiaiewi b dfn e i cut udb icnitn wi te
uy n ce nt t l e eedd n o rwo l e n o sset t h
iv l
h
p roeadrto aeo teiiit ep we, eas iwo l alw p bi
up s n ain l fh ntai o rb cuet ud l u l
v
o
c
of il,hog iat n efcieyt an lntt etate dsiel(e
fcastru hnci ,f t l o nu iiai shthy il . Se
o ev
iv
k
BuligIdsr A s.. i o maio(964 Ca.d80 82)
i n nut snvCt fca rl 18) 1 1 1,2.
d
y
y
l
3
1 Aths on an t o cuinii odr Whnten me dfn atna
tip it oe f ato sn re. e h a d eedn i
lwsibo g tnaCaionasaecut el e t peet d fneadn
a ut ru h i l ri tt ordci so rsn a ee s,n o
f
n
(ontcniudonxpg)
t toeot e n etae
b
n
Itiepaainsfkin t as rteq eto ta teNit Cici
shs x lnto uf eto nwe h u sin hth nh rut
p sdt ticuqwhc iwhtepo o eto a iiaiehth vtr
oe o hs o r ih s ehr rp nns f n nt t tate oes
iv
apo e hveete aû riuaie itrs'i teiiaiesvl i o te
p rv d a ihr t t lrzd neet n h nt tv ' ai t rh
pa c
'
i
dy
atoi t Gseth saesitrs'i d fn igteiiitv ?Moe
uh rt o ç srte tt' neet n eedn h ntaie r
y a
'
seiial, osiso a ticut o iinh lsta iiit epo o et
p cfcl d e th w,shs or' pno od,h tntai rp nns
y
s
v
hveatoi t çseth saesitrs'i teiiaiesv l i ?Th
a uh rt o ç srte tt' neet'n h nt t ' ai t e
y a
iv
dy
as riç s'
nwe s( .
Ye '
T ewodçuh rt'i ista iiit epo o eth v argh t
h r d toi 'mpl htnt i rp n ns ae i to
a y
e
av
dfn a iiit ei cutAl o g Caionassaecutgnrl hv
ee d n ntai n o r. t u h lfri' tt ors eeal ae
v
h
y
dsrto t gat r eyitret n iwo l b a a ueo dsrt nfra
icein o rn o d n nevni ,t ud e n b s f icei o
o
o
cutodn a iiaiepo o etsmoint itre ewh ntev l i o te
o rt ey n nt tv rp nn' to o nevn e h ai t fh
i
dy
iiaiemesr ibigc aln e adCaionasaeof ilaen tciey
nt t aue s en h l gd n lfri tt fi as r o at l
iv
e
c
v
dfnigi (e ma.p.J/,t .9)Itasutnalatiiacrt
eedn t Se jon,ncap3. nhtiai tes,tscuae
.
t o
t saeta iiit epo o ethv atoi t itrees ta teitgi o
o tt h tntai rp nns a e uh rt o nevn o hth nert f
v
y
y
teiiaiepo esma b peevdadtev l i o teiiaiemesr
h nttv rcs y e rsre n h ai t fh nt t aue
i
dy
iv
(ontcniud mpeiupg)
f toeot eko rv sae
o
n
o
pryitree t asradfnet tepanifscam,wodfeetad
at nevn so set ee s o h lit li t ifrn n
f
o p st rslsaep sil, eedn o tepriua cru tn e.T e
p oi eut r osbedp n ig n h at lr icmsacs h
e
c
pani ma wib dfutrsln iet o adfutug n o siuae
litf y n y eal eut gn nr f ealjdmet rt ltd
f
, i
y
p
jdmetrnijh rqetdee.See .C d CvPo.j 55te.
ug ngat teeus rlf(e,., oe i.rc j 8 esq,
n
e i
g
,
646)Butetacut ydcd isedtawiot gniedsue
6.. th r lorma eienta ht t u a eun i t
l
h
p
bt e tepre,u iilciniuncsayadiaporaersln ia
ewenh atsjdcaat s neesr n np rpit,eut gn
i
o
i
ds sao te cinwi otnr o ayjdmet(e i.â16 ; o n
i sl fh at t u ety fn ug n. Sed, 0 1C mmo
mi
o h
CuevB ado u rios18)9Ca.d4249Pa6cLgl
as .or fspev r(994 l 3,3; c ea
s
3
F udtnvC lonaC atl o (92 3 Ca.d18 1011 Beas
onai . afri os C m.18) 3 l 5,7-7 . cue
o
a
3
)
tepeet te cn en o l tenro yfa dq sinp sdb teNit
h rsn matr o crs ny h arwl rme ueto oe y h nh
Cici, iho teet apoc e so l apyi a ypatua cs ia
rutwhc fh s wo p rah s hud p l n n ri lr ae s n
c
isen t eoeticut ee
su o b fr hs o rhr.
ma b rl bydtr ndtru hvg ru liainab t tetil n
y e ei l eemie hog ioo s igto t oh h ra ad
a
t
apltlvlo Cai ri'jdcasse
p eleees f lonasuiilytm.
a
f
II
I
Th atoi p sesdb teofcapo o et o a iiaiemesr
e uh rt osse y h f il rp nns f n nt t aue
y
iv
t asrtesaesitrsitaiiaies aii cmpe nsh jdcays
o seth tt' neetnhtntt 'vl t o lmetteu iir'
i v dy
atoi t ma etef a dcso o whte teiiaieivld AsI ae
uh rt o k h i l eiin n ehrh nttv s ai. hv
y
n
i
srse i mysprt o iin i teerirsmesxmaig scss
tesdn e aae pno sn h al a -e n ae ae,
e
itrrt gsaesaue adsaecntuin l rvso sa ddtr nn ter
nepei tt ttts n tt o si to apo iin,n eemiig h i
n
t
vl i ,r tersos it o tegvrmet jdcabac.(tas,
ai t aeh epni ly fh oen n' uiilrnh Srus
dy
bi
s
spa 4 Ca.h3446(ocon oKenr,.MaraeCae,ur,3
ur,6 1t 6,7 cn.p .f n adJ; ri ssspa4
4
)
g
C 1 t 77 80(ocono Kenr,.L cyrspr,3Ca.t 15,
a.h 5,6 cn.p .f nadJ) oke,u a 3 1 h 0 5
4
;
4
12 (oc& dsono Kenr,.)
15 cn . i.p .f n adJ.
)
T eu iilytm idsge t oeaetruhpbipoedn sn
h jdcass s eindo prt hog u l rceig i
e
c
whc avesre liaefcu ln lglsustoo g l advg rul
ih d raisigt ataa d ea ise h ru hy n ioo sy.
t
Whna iiai mesr icaln e i c utteitgi a defciees
e n nt t aue s hlegd n o r,h nert n fetvn s
i ve
y
o teuiilrcsrqieht cmptn adsitddfne epeetd
fh jdcapoeseurtaa o eetn pre eesb rsne.
i
Ip bioscasrfs t po ieta dfneteaii o teiiaie
f u l f il eue o rvd ht ees,h bly fh nt t
c
t
iv
po o et t itreeitepedn liain adt apelnaves
rp n ns o nevn n h n ig igto ,n o p a a d re
t
jdmetiihrn i,n esniloteefcieeecs o,h
ug n,sneetnad set t h f t xri fte
a
ev
e
cnttto a iiit ep we.Toh l oh m ien t nywo l u dr n ta
o si in lnt i o r od te s o o l ud n emieh t
u
av
cnttto a p we,tas wo l alw saeeeuieba c ofcast
o si in l o ri lo ud l tt x ct rnh fiil o
u
o
v
efcieya n l oe-p rv diiitvssmpyb dciigt d fn te
fet l n u v trapo e ntaie i l y el n o eed h m,
v
n
teeyp r tigtoeofcasoe ce terpo e rl i orsae
h rb emit h s fiilt xed h i rproe n u tt
n
g v mmetscntuin ltutr.
o e n' o si to a srcue
t
F rteerao sIareta, e saeofcasrfs t dfn avoeo hs esn, ge htwhn tt fiil eue o eed tr
apoe iiaiemesr i cuqo t apaaug nivl aigta
p rvdntt auen or ro pel jdmetnai t ht
iv
dn
iiit e i ofcapo nnshv atoi ,samatro saelw,oasr
nt i ,t f il rpoet ae uh rt a te ftt a t set
av s
y
tesaesitrsi teiiaies l i .
h tt' neetn h nt tv 'vai t
i
dy
KENNARD,.
J
8
Seataeoadessn tehnnmbrfronewoJgffnSpeeCut
el pgfrdrseadepoeu esocuslh rzti urm or
s
l
c
.
Na o Opno Pryea.. o
me f iin er tlvBrwn
Un u lhdOpno
p bi e iin
s
Orgnl pa
iiaAp el
Or iaP oedn XXX-o rqet usatorl858Ca.ue o Cor
in l rce ig
g
n eusprunt ue .4, l ls f ut
R
ReiwGrne
ve a td
Reern Grne
haig a td
Opno No584 6
iin . 197
DaeFld Noe e 1,0 l
t i : vmbr 72 1
e
Co r:
ut
Cony
u t:
J de
u g:
Co ne:
usl
LwOfie oAnrwP PgoAnrwP PgoAl ne f s Fn , r nW. am,a s .
a f s f de .un, de . un ; l c Dee e ud Bi R u Jme A
c
i
a
n
a
Ca bl C o eadKi , hr s . oe, vdH. hmpo,Ho r C. io,r NioeJ
mp el opr n r C al JCoprDai T o sn wad Nel nJ. cl .
,
'
k e
s ,
Mosn Ptr Pt ro frnevnradAp elns
sad eeA.atsn o Itrees n pl t.
e
a
E wiMes 11Jh C. at nadKae JL g fr neo Costt nlui rdneaAmiu
d n ee1,on E s n rn . uo oCetr f ntui aJrs uec s cs
.
ma
io
p
C r eo bhlo ltrees n Apelns
ui n eaf fnevnrad pl t.
a
a
Sao L Bo eH rlE.omsnadDa e M,Shffr aicLgl onainWadC nel
hrn . rwn, aod Jl o n min ci o Pcf eaF udt , r onr
f
i
o
y
Gl n utdRnU z n T e o adJriTxaes soii aAmi C re n eaff ,
y C se,o n ad h H w r a s apyrAsctn s c ui o bhlo
n r
v
ao
i a
ItreesadApelns
nevnr n pl t.
a
Pcf JsieIsit, vnT.ndrMate B. Renlsn KelA.Wa fr .oha
aicut ntueKei S ie, t w Mc yod ad l
i c t
h
y y o DrJsu
Beke a Amiu Cuieo bhlo ltrees n Ap el t.
cl s cs r n eaf fnevnrad plns
y
a
a
Jme Jsp L nhJ.fr riR iya Amiu Clieo bhlo ItreesadApel t.
a s oeh y c,r,o Mage el s cs za n eaf fnevnr n plns
l
r
a
Jl B. erdfru iil th Ic,aAmi s r e nbhlo Ievnrad plns
ui Axl o JdcaWac,n. s c Cui o eaffn reesn Apel t.
e
o
u a
t
a
Bos,cir&FenrDaiBoe,ee M.God nT edrH. o Gisn Dun&Crthr
i Shl lxe, vd isJrmy lma, hooe Un; bo, n uce
e e
T edr B. sn Mate D. Gi, r T yaiT edrJBot u,r, hiohr
ho oe Olo, t w Mc lAmiC.arn, hooe . ur sJ.C rtpeD. ,
h
l
o
s
D seladE r u A. ngsfr litfadRep net.
usatn ni e Moaa o Panisn sodns
q
f
KedlBi &KlgrLuaW. i, coa FDam, iodS DaisnadAsl R.y f
nal rl i e, ar BrlNihls . u Clfr . vdo n he Ll 0
l e
l
f
e m r
JnB. sn egadPoesr ar L.eesna Amii uieo bhlo Panisad
o Ei br n rfso L ui Lvno s cC ra n eaf f litf n
e
e
f
Repnet.
sodns
P g 2-5 84 6- o necniud
ae 197 cu slot e
n
Co ne:
u sl
Miul ruzCutCuslsn Ca)LrEPg,siatony oneJnpr.
geMéqe,ony onetat la,oi.egAstnCutCuslui L
a r
s
, e
Do sAcigLa DeuyC utCone,JnySYei,mpcLt ainF lw' ci n
wn, t ed pt ony usl en . l I at igt el , hs ,
n
n
i o o At o
BroeC not&Koaei ,on BroeCtAtre (atC l;onA R s ,i
ain, odt vcvc Jh G.ain, i t ny Sna nz Jh . us Ct
s
i
h
s y o
l
o y
Atre ( kad, abrJPre,heAst t i Atre;o CB isC utCusl
t nyOal )B raa .akrCi sia Ct t nyJl . er, on one
o
n
f sn y o m e
y
(rne, enM.eyDptCutCuslEiDn ;aaMca,ony one(at
Oag)Gl Lv,euy ony one;r al Dn ReCutCuslSna
n
c y
CuladBl D.odtiCutCuslSnma,oCutoSna laCutoSna
rz;n nc G l e on one(oo )frony fatCa,on fat
e sn y
f y
CrzCi o Oaln, to ClvraeConyo SnMae, t oSnaCu adC uto S nma
u, t f kad Ci f oedl, ut f a toCi f at rz n ony f oo
y
y
y
a Amii ra o bhlo Panisn Repnet.
s cCuie n eaf f litfad sodns
f
DensJHerr, t At re, hrs M.Se r C if ptCi At re, nyChuC iff
n i . reaCi tny T eee twat he Deuy t t ny Dan o heo
y o
,
y o
C mpe adS eil igt nVic C hbi, leM.L eadChiieVa Akn Deu,Ci
o lx n pcaLt ai , ne haraMol e n rt n e, pt t
io
i
sn
y y
AtresfrItree adR sodn.
t ny,o nevnrn epnet
o
C lwelLsi&PotrDaiC. dlAlet agAls iAgai; hrnP. ne'n Jn
ad l el rco, vd Coel brGi , atr col Sao Mitrad o
, e
,
n a
i
,
W. vdo frE ulyCai ri, t nl etro LsinRihsn LmbaL gl fnead
Daisn o qai lonaNai aC nefr eba g tad a d eaDees n
t f
o
EuainF n,n .a Amii ui o bhlo ltree adRepnet
dct ud Ic,s cC re n eaffnevnrn sodn.
o
a
GensMat,ti& RihadRoiMedwadC nhaE.To i nfr eg eoCai ri
rie, rnSen cln, bn ao n yti bs o Lau f lona
i
ma
f
Wo nVoeso C lonaa Amiu Cuieo bhlo ItreeadRepnet
me tr f ai ri s cs r n eaffnevnr n sodn.
f
a
EiAlnIaco ;ua Ka WevrSae M.Kal ;n R vSl Nadnfr airiFi fr
r a sasn Ssn y ae;tcy pa ad e. io roio C lona aho
c
n
v
f
t
E ulyC lonaConio C uce, nrl yo o teUntdC uc o C rtUnvra
qai , ai ri uclf hrhsGeeaSnd fh i hrh f hi, iesl
t f
e
s
Flwsi o Merp la C rmui ChrhsT e psoaBi os f lona n L s gl ,
el hp f tooin on nt uce, h E i pl s p o Caf iad o Anee
o
t
y
c
h
ir
s
PorsieJwihAlac, aicAsoiino R fr RabsUntra Unvrai Asoiinad
rges e s lnePct scao f eom bi, i in ieslt scao n
v
i
i
t
a
s
t
UntrnUnvrait gs t eMiir Cai ria Amii ra o bh loItreead
i i iesl Leiai nsy lona s cCuie n eaf fnevnrn
aa
s lv t f
R sodn.
epn et
Ka lD. nsAt re Geea, neM.MeersSaeS lir nrlDaiC ae,C if
maa Hai, t ny nrlMaul di ,tt oit Geea, vd hny he
o
o
co
AsitnAt re Geea, u ls. osAcigAsiat tre Geea, cal rnoo
ssat t ny nrlDoga JWo d, t ssn At ny nrlMiheTocs,
o
n t o
Sno Cone, ntneL L L usadTmaPctrDeuyAt res nrla Amii r e
eir uslCosac . e oi n a r ahe, pt t ny Geea,s cCui .
o
a
C usl oage iSpe C utntneddfr u lainwi oiin:
onewh rudn urme or(oitne o pbi t t pno)
co h
C alsJCopr
hr . oe
e
C oe adKi
opr n r
k
l2 Ne Ha si AvneN. .
53 w mphr eu, W
e
WahntnD. 206
sigo, C. 03
(0)2-60
222090
T edrB. sn
hooe Ol
o
Gisn Dun&Cuce
bo, n rthr
15 ConciuAvneN. .
00 net t eu, W
c
WahntnD. 2 06
sigo, C. 03
(0)5-50
229580
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?