Kristin Perry, et al v. Arnold Schwarzenegger, et al

Filing 23

Filed original and 7 copies of Pacific Justice Institute amicus brief of 18 pages. Served on 09/24/2010. [7492905] (FT)

Download PDF
Do k tNo ce . I te nh 1 -6 51 01 7 Kntt *t ts G ur pf ppt t t; a t t ag pr, 'f o/ c nt %j l jo Mt s y W i fit t n rm lo:E )K L (j,u )j A R )q l %# . m w s P2821 E 22 RD W n r mn Y KRITI P RRY,t 1 SNE ea. , ad n MV l= . M PanisAple, litf-pels f 'e ! k CIYAMDC UNT OFS NF NCS O, T O Y A V IC Plit -ne eo-p ele anX ltx nrAp l , e ARNOL S HWARZE EGGAR, DC N i hsofca cp ct a Go en ro Caionae a. n i fiilaai s vro f l ri,t 1 y f , DENNI HOLLI GS ORTH,t 1 S NW ea. , ad n COUNT OFI PE I L ea. Y M R A ,t 1 , Deednsltreos fna t hevnr, A pelns p l t. a Apafo aDeio oteUidSaeDirt or o te oten srtfc lona pelrm cinfh nt tt si Cut rh N r rDi i o afri s e s tc f h tc , No 0- V022 'Ho oa l V uh R. le . 9C -2 9 n rbe ag n Wakr AM I USCURI E BRI FI S PPORT OFAPP LLANTS C A E NU E C UHE COUNTY RAM T RI OANDOASEL R IOR OF OT T OFI P OFI PEEB A DIFB P VARGAS N Y M E IV H AL R S U E V S S Kristin Perry, et al v. Arnold Schwarzenegger, et al Doc. 23 MA IE B. RE N L SES . TI W MC Y O D , Q I KE I T S DE , s . VN .N R E Q P CII J S I EI S IUT A FC U TC N TT E PO. x2 6 0 . Bo 7 6 Sca et, ai mi 9 87 arm no C lo a 52 f (1)5-90 eehn 968760 Tl oe p (1)5-92Fcii 968760 as l me Atnyfr mi s ui, tresoA c Cre o ua fciJscIsit 'fcutentu l/ i te * CISPE'03PEL ONLRS(0-PA JE S 8)A Dockets.Justia.com PPEORCCDAE Y RIDNE L PP T YE R Rue2 . CORPORATE DI CLOS RE S ATEM ENT l 61 S UT P ru n t F d rl l o Ap elt P o e te2 .,h u d rin d u sa to e ea Rue f p l e rcdl 61 te n esg e a r sae ta a iu c ra ,h P ct J sielsiue in t cpoainta ttsh t m c s u ie te a ic u t nt t,s o a o rt h t ict o ise soko h s ae t o oainta ise sok su s tc r a ap rn c m rt h tsu s tc . o S pe b r2 , 0 0 e tm e 4 2 1 l i . p ' By // Kei T.s ie : s vn nd r Ke i T. nd r Ba No 1 0 8 vn S ie CA r . 7 9 8 P CI I J S I E W S I UTE A FC U T C TT P. .o 2 6 0 O B x 760 S ca e t,CA 9 8 7 arm no 52 yy i 1 1 P oe (1) 5-90 hn: 96 8760 - - a; W V VVX -- x p W Emalkvnndr pcljsc.r - i eisie@ aicut e g : io At refr mi sPct Jsc Ist e t ny o A c , aicut entm o u iii TABLE OF CONTENTS CORP RAT DI CLOS RE S AT M E T O ES U TEN I E TI Y AND W TE ES OFTHE DN T RT 1l C CU E- SIPIE E T(FIIZ- zlElt (11 ;:- I N ; Vk -4pl3 O 2!2 - kM W MI :II kL l 6 h ll;IRY ........... iEEI ........... ET ..........2 W T ODUCT ON AND S MM ARY OFTHEARGUME T........... R I U N ..........3 .......... 1 Ov riw o Ho o eu lyi An in Gre ea dRo e...... . eve f m sx ai n ce t e c n m ......4 t ...... l. (ls1a (rc)?)nlV1ws(z a 1g .............1 l 2sc l3e (l(At - ) =- e............. 1 t-L1lz e l a ............. B. TABLE OFAUT ORI I S H TE CAS S E Per v S h azn g e ry . c w re e g r -- - Fsp .d--2 1 WL3726( .. AA g l,00....., .upz - ,00 108 ND C u .22 1)..... 4 ....3 ta s v O tn r us . ro 6 Y. t 3 1 9 ..........................@.. 1 6 ) ....................@.......1 1 ............................ 2 CONS I UTI NS TT O a1O 5 5 l( 1 (lt t)5 il 1' 8 i) - )si il ce 1 1 l tl t ................ ................ ................ ai) i (zt t)r il 17 1 ....................... l( 1 lsi il ce 1 ....................... t l tz ....................... l1) 1 tzt tl, il 11jS.....................2 t1 - lsi il ce 1, 5..................... lr J l tz -t t ...................... U.. n tm in Fo re nhAme d e t S Co si o , u te t n m n t OTHER AUTHORI I S TE Arsol, hc b . itt Etis k e ' tt 1o a e n tis 1 e ca c Arsol, lia b . itt Poic , k 1 et 1 eO, lc s tll, t ll&, .1 ....................15 - r t u l1s ? --t 11 .................... 5 c r lt ll s z) .................... ' c r5 ac s ul s e li 5 1 eo ru lu 5 i ci s 1 4 1e O, Jc sll1s z tis1 .:! ....................3 - r t u M lt , ; le ! t71 ...................1 c r n ll lt 3 $: ................... Do e, J Gre Ho o eu ly1 v rK. ek m sx ai 4 , t ( avr Unvri PesC mbig, u dtd18)......,, 1 H rad iesy rs, a r eMA p ae 99...... 6 1 t d .....5 Gln e Peu ia =C L 1 .7 1 a d s rsn e 1 16 2 Hu b r, h ma K. mo eu lyi Greea dRo e b ad T o s Ho sx ai n ec n m : t - dSucbo oB sc cmet1 (nvri o Cai riPes oreokf aiDou ns 5U iesy f lona rs, t f 1ek1 y2::)3.......................,16 1, 1 3ree (9 1()....................... t ) ( 1 y :,() ......................5 ,, ) ' Te m eo C ntnies rig Lgsain(9 5 h E prr os t 'Marae ei t 19) an lo J dt E a sGrb ,rw q dFa i i L t Aniut: u i v n u b f n m l n ae t i h y qy Mu o isRu u:h Ro a S cae 8 snu fs te m n orts 9 (oaE L te. t n.97 C r .uz d& r s14) a Puac , y ug s1 . ltrh L c r u 84 P bisOvdu Nac , tmoph sn97 07 0 u l iis so Mea r o e .0 -1 u P meo , aa , ce t e c . Poic lS ca a dCul r l soy o ry S rh An in Gree W lia, o il n t a Hitr t u (11!.(xodllAlir3 S,1(! ..................t 11 11 Xfr -lis)1eS1)7 ..................5 14 4, lit t r ()) .................. r R fsMuoisIMaraea n i pt te usiop isp y ....1 uu, snu,s rig Hadc oh P rutf hl oh ? ....5 a o .... Ru u, snu , h udEvr Chl T a iBonb Ras d fsMu o isS o l ey i h ts r e ie ? d R fsMuoisWhtsteC i E do Marae uu, snu, ai h he n f rig ? f S eo isNeo2 u tnu r 8 Tlltl; (r2 e ez11 n sla=1s!)-()................8 rtttns )( n =2(j e e - :6)1) ................ lfll l 1)e u .6 ( ................ T jl , fnoC riaLe P r ete o NauaMar g , n ioAl s adnl pz es ci s n trl ri e lo pv a T e auefmar g adi vr u ap cs4Av MaiL h n tr o ri e n t ai s set, e r . a so a Re.9 (06 (ut gCcr, nDuis 3 v2 7 20)qoi ieo O t 2 n e Grf n& E. . ln e s, ii M At s d . t d 1 3 WieJh ,r TeGod adG asfMar g, t,onJ. h os n olo ri e t , a :; t Ill l.e.(6(()).............../1, 515 7Nor TreJ v 11 :)1 ..............1,3 1,t t e l l R )) !( ..............: t Z n o Ciu , r2 8Soc r m V tr m Frg e t = e o f t m F .4 tio u eeu a m na i Ilg n sLe 1s21!-3)......................... Do e e l1d- 3 :)1 ( ........................6 t u .6 ........................) I ENTI Y AND I TERES OFTHE AMI ICURI E D T N T C A PACI I J S I E I S I UTE FC U T C N T T T i a iu c ra b ifsb igfe b P cfcJ sielsi t. hs m c s uie re i en i d y aii ut n tue l ct T eP cfcJ sielsi t i an npoic poainog nz du drscin h ai u t n tue s o -rf o rt ra ie n e e t ict t o o 5 1c() fh ltraReeu C d.Amiu iddctdt poiiglgl 0() o tenenl vne oe css eiae o rvdn ea 3 i l ' ' srie t tec mmu i wi o t h rei teae so Frt n me t ihs evc so h o nt t u c ag n h ra f isAme d n r t, yh g 1 t j l prclliteraorl iu letssec adascain lta atuaynh aes feiosi re,peh n soit .nht ir g bi o tePaicJ sieI si eruieyrpee t tefi c mmu i ,t a a h cf u t ntm o t l e rsns h at o nt ih s n ict n h y '.. J'.! E l J .. ltrsmteoto eo-ecs.Thslprclf#tu mtatel-ecut neet h ucm fh ae' i s atuil re hth b r or t l W ma ei d cso b sdu o wh tt eiv dt b rl iu b l f o tev tr d t eiin ae p n a ib l e o e ei o s ei s fh oes s e g e o Cai ri.T eb if u mie h ri d e n te et ru e t o tep r e f lona h re sb t d een o s o rp a ag m ns fh at s f t i o oh ra iib t lpo ieau iu p rp ciewi teg a o assigte r te m c, u wi rvd nq e eset t h o l f sit h l vh n Co ri i a ay i. u tn t n lss s T ib ifsfe p ru n t cn e t f 1Co n e o Reod hs re i i d u sa to o sn o a1 u sl f c r. l S ATEM ENT OFI S ES T SU F o a hsoia p rp cie d e stn tep rmeeso mar g a a rm n itrcl es et , o s et g h aa tr f ri e s n v i a o p s esxu inidct u c nt uin l ici iaino oh r ierfet p oi e no n iae n o si t a dsr n t r tew s elc t to mo maiea ansho oe uasa amatro lw? lc g i t m sx l s te fa 1 S ATEM ENT OFF CTSAND P OCEDURAI HI TORY T A R ,S T efcsnticsaeo pbiko ld e n cnob sbeto h ati hs ae r f ul nw eg ad ant eujct c rao e dsue OnNo e b r , 0 8 tep o l o teSaeo Caiona esn d ip t. v m e 4 2 0 ,h e pe fh tt f l ri f a e d dterCo si t nb p aeul c sigter alt.T ea e d e t m n e h i n tui y e cfl at h ib l s h m n m n to yn o a d dscin75t Aril l ihra si f1:G nyma ig b t enama d e eto . o t e whc ed n u1 i l n a e ew e c o n 1 :.( '. . I 1 : ; .. . ' .' g y adawo a ivl o rcg ie i Cai ri. T eatoi frh p o l t n m n s ai r eo nzd n lona' h uh rt o te epe o d f' y a edteCosiuinwa drvdfo Arill,j18 1 adArilXVl1 m n h nt t s eie rm t e Ij ,,0 n t e I, to c c j3o teCosi t n OnNo e br ,0 8a etariaywrt sfe i fh nt i . vm e520 ,n xrodnr iwa i dn mo l -- t--iY i StrmeCb- se 'ga i meit-tN fh a e met - - - h c l a t e Y e n n m ab te m n nef p --o c aln igwh te teCo si inwa lwfl a ed do wh te Aril 1 h l gn eh r h ntm o s a ul m n e r eh r t e , e t y c j75wa a ieal eatdrvso.DtigteliainteCaiona . s n lgl nce eiin ln h igt ,h l ri ly r to f At re Geeaage taAril1j75(l ko na trp sin8'n t ny nrlrudht t e, . as nw s ooio 'ad o c o pt tet ar g Amed ef) s na fl addtteC ntuinbcue h rae nm n 'wa ulw ul de oh o stt eas Mi y io ma ig i a n l n berg t'l a6 1d cso ,h CaionaS pe eCo r n a e s n E ai a l ih. n - e iin te l ri u rm u t ie ' f rjce taagmetn fudtate epeatdlwfl i a edn ter eetdhtru n ad on hth pol ce a ul n m nig hi y Co si t n1 nt ui . to OnMa 2 , 0 9 alwsiwa fldi fd rl o rc aln ig y 2 2 0 , a ut s i n e ea cu t h l gn e e teMar g Ame d e t ae u o teF u te t Ame d e tote h ri e n m n b sd p n h o renh n m n t h a 'tus . r n4 C l4h34(09. Sr svHot ,6 a.t 6 20) a o U.. o smt n T efdrl ir toretrdug etgis SC nt i . h eeadsi cutnee jdm n aant io tc Saed fn a t o Au ut1 ,201 . tt ee d ns n g s 2 02 I TRODUCTI N AND S M M ARY OFTHE V GUM ENT N O U Ciiz t n whc h v tlrtdo e e c lb ae h mo e u l vl ai s ih a e oeae r v n eertd o sx a io rlto sis a en n tees e uae ma ig s a t manania a eain hp h v o eh ls rg ltd n a e o s o iti t s n ' 1 1 . 1 o p st sxu in. hs re wi b cnie t po iiga o eve o p oi e no T i bif l e o fn d o rvdn n v riw f e l h moe u lyi a ce t ec a dRo ea dte dsu sh s sceis o sx ai n n in Gre e n m n h n ic s to e o it ' t e 3 mara elws rig a . ., a .. ; - '@ - p. p T ed-t -c- '-imis eas int--- inao ei n as fte ' h -itit'o ' s si se o h't o n s o u iih - -o j t v t te -t 1 e e ntae , o f 1 rao t d f ema ig i go s smpit . Aswi b d mo srtd smeo esn o ei n a e s rsl i lsi 4 n y c tegetsmid ta teW et a po u e cmet tesmec n lso a te h raet n sh th s h s rd cd a o h a o cu in s h v tr o Caio i rg rigtei p ra c o gvn seil lc t ma ig a oes f l m a e adn h m otn e f iig p ca pae o n a e s f amaea dfmaeu d ra n .Th Gre sa dRo a s i n t ce t rig l n e l n etl g e ek n m n dd o a cp mar e d a b t enama a dawo a wi o t o me t As lb dsu sdi ti bif ew e nn m n t u c m n. wi e ic se n hs re, h l teeweeitl cu l rb s cvl ain ta lf awrt nrc r o b t ter h s r nel tal o u t iiz t sh tet ie e od f oh h i ey io t p i sp yo timatro p bi p l ya wel stera s e uaigma ig hl o h n hs t f u l oi s la h ilw rg lt n a e o e cc n 2er vSh aznge--Fsp .d--2 1 WL372 6( .. AAu . Pry . cw reegr- .upz -,00 10 8 ND C g 1,00. 22 1) 3t udn t epat a i ti l i dsaet dsu s o oe u lya d lwo l o b rci ln hs i t p c o ic s h m sx ai n c me t maig fr vr mao cvlain l tateacet eoRo a nae o eey jr iizt .nhth nin Grc- m n io cvl ain aepi aysuc sfr oicllg lh u h a ds utr i te iizto s r rm r o re o p lia,e a to g t n t cue n h i t r UntdSae,h ywi b tee a pe u e i ti bif i ttste l e h x m ls sd n hs re. e l 3 ' ' SJ U OIXS D H 3J O I I WI P?fl!XNlg01u :JJ IOSEO Ot!3 JlP?JMulolooa JIJ u lgl T t !33D CISIJ IuZ t u 2 /st dld I O l o$ ;; u ; OI) t X IC JSWI P JPSO O 0 0U 3O ! Cd0IFI U UC Q Slt I 0I q I OIU I OO IU O q ) 12 3) J t I J IN ; !cI P) T I 3 )) M x l op to p =Aio 3J1 u no !pgq s t S lslp om=o!S OD ' cd lgu o u t d ! S p lu I fn op usop ? J J; P J s oW I . J COI I 0IS ;! 2d3lJ OmEl u $J= 0lJ 3u PA S lo to O JI d t ! 3; J t O l lP ? t ) t O 3 3 !3 ul dl o p)3) 1 $ ll Ac!t Elw ?gq ooldSOD sp Mo Jln oou tg gupAq I)!Iqo x d sl P J oc d p x stolo ogl: II q 33 . 3 31 9 * Y * 1 310 PHu@3 J )I!I I IMI 3OIO J M3A a O 11N 3 3D I3aW 1 I I SI H O !J A ! XI AVH ZDXV W 'Eq O I JSI I J < :;co MJlnuu o0tut! oolpv o ol t J <opqTt :q o v . q u tto t !) st lM ) cp u o pl lw l I ) IM ; J P I OJJ $tS ZU PO CI IJJIDJ SWO 0lS ZW I CIU SWO IJC 0 OJ IO C 0I JO O A ICUOJ 0 J A t C O J I 0 J IPCI O C ) JI I D WIO SVO O E$I SI EPU JIDIOOl 'XJIJCS JSIWSOU T A J S : P S EI !I J OS I t II UI II S !I O J )M X O Z IC s l pu als o v-uuo to m gc.q! oos lps .Jsol : pl q up l! t v : l t p t. ll ) J lo oq cI q oq u l ; u ll u M o n oO aIp topoo sll/ pt OETU I PIM JIq0lfdt u ! IJ J3 I gu o lM olI. l TJS OI I OJ t S!SOp o ) l1l s D! )l In :Ot qJ u l loo U A Pl 0u JI;!t =!SG 'lo d lo E X StO O oi q lo O O t 32o0 JoI ; 3 oq q ou q I / z ;d muXJJoOJ Stu k P tSIOD 0 ) BMOI IMJ I Sl 'IIJ1lPI I I JM t tol u S J q pt I I OJ li XIW t l 2 l O S! Q l I ) E f '- (0f'D;2MJHKOJEUOIDJ &!o!1) lS gmoG f0 V Xl O S J IJJI O S AuR ' u o S C J l u amg-poqon,p.to pu aa- utg?xm?t Klqn-'lcuttl / /y o' uo rauoe n aao ?f lla z? pcql 'stol t a ' ' / r kN ly . (g I a pnvw I:l tc**od&!g!nP/ / I 1'*1 66 pp d op qua s l s Au JM H : d. 0 a sJ p (8 1 o pnVW I PJIC I3J 66 Pp d O I ID S J S qI S llalnpv v ) 1-8'd<I 'dGl naoulyap 'A ('' s au JM H 1 11 d #-rd tl xst - au J oIf' l n ol g y I # f P l l0 ' 'lldVpl : f f f f 1f% lo ' d 1 Dl 0 -I'PI0 #T : P .1 1y g j ) .g6 1 g y -g sg 'I: p P l p u o ool dq lM JJ<o l oX vuJo ;uX t X t pq Jp o om s ! q s c ot o u m l u t / q o vu gl ;o l ml q ) u u to opl u l : .c c ; u <lp p u p o oul i o c glg a s ! ou M t o op g: s q p c oq o m p t o g u q t m o l ; m slsouol X /.p sA psqJAS C 0 ) u jIupl f l o u l ld d ang t sM u l olo c g IM I q p /l: l sl w o ow n o u o J sv t cs smoa ol: ou p : n o osM ap mdolwt p uos o o u ou v u z t u tu o m o u u o o t l c su u ; ;; 0'ICI IJU Ot l CS PNWSVJ I OOI I;t P SW I OITI 1JI OH OIO l q C O OS v IW SIOICI W O ' I S. C I; t Ol S V ' 6Js o c tsl-o d , m p d q'C-d n, spll J U P ZIJI 20 J u ! EJ3pJO DPJ OI20 P lqlp S Slt 'O J3J 0 O C I OI $ O O$ 0 ! 3 u O SJ ) on l ! l. P P O I CI 3 ) l sMglcdol osomuslgl u putp v ' cuoup?Apo o& u = o l tl u p oodlo on l pi u X to !u t d ! ! p J O! Cd0IJ O U PA OO.S OOI 8 ' 0 #I1 SSAU WOI U WC UNC O; J t 0 O O JO JI J JI ' S 9 Pm OC C IV 0 P I O) U ZD S go s cwnoouqil x IntvLsau oaco op s! pnoou t l- p xsto ll o ol & u m l q ; p sJl xstol od qo c t l c u pa c su.iz c -9 ;a u a -u c u 'o l -s d . u s u o c c lo p l s: qt . co !o v vl !u uw u o o . z s m o u u u / qX pn aou qa t .q q m s Xla - o sc tt p l ! c a p x sto p uo p M c so ow a ! . l t o- 9 '9 -9IC'Z N IJQPH s 1 f f I D Y S PC I : PI: , PI: 9 'Jn<efvto o s 9 l l/n a c : 7t PI1 : *I 1 P1s 6 I. l , 0 .. 1 f Ig Iucun yxqn r 9 ! ) nd g qu j ' i posq p : n ol Xi l x al : op g o I l u qX p p n m s u q lx d g m o s lol o tq n tp s q l m o q ou o : p p ld xu l l . . ' s pwo o sou s!o spro 'ns! t sap ut ll <aul pooduo c o o, !om u . J a s o s op slp l t u t o s t o T o- V ! . ! gol mguq-ots o dsldIaooc ggxxo'(jaus ! o oo l cl op pl oo/ . Asl? lt-'g1 ol co oH q lp l h lp ( t : X dsl dqaoupngololg=Jln go o o tu s /sl q ool ol !u o sM qlJ p xsp q pu o i lu q q . l 1xoq dw p oo sM dtsopl. aJnqo sopcq, 1y n u ) u l u l o q=j' q sllg, lu x v&lod sMJqut glc a; ; osu Js og ' o c u q p u cl& v gtgu as d Ipqqn s> m pd jm x p c n v v sI q u g o oohool u s lsopl.g x sg t m 0/1o ;O JI u X gw q l? o go ! dq u l g In o p u 11 q I:/ p = g l 1 l l I I i i #' o J I u o Eltos Io ld=sop ? 1- o o p n o xqu s? vp o s-p l m l J ;JO3ln X? II0; !I O01 0UIOI PS3C3) 3I O O 3J l d u P0I)# JW ItJ CUIV OnO tPAM P q ) T 1 POI O QSOJS C I ! ! OdJ U I S OCol. f' mo l u p p od S O n J SM I ) ) J 0 OW I O t l q x o o m sl W O Om S I Js o t p cXc l ol Nl n oou ql Jq tc p socIooau : ln p u u out go p x sto o gw p g on o gulg ! us u p vcu pa mol- p cJlmc oslq t c p q vw s o o d Iop fl u o o lo tl u oo q qo w p : go l w u d o glnod i Jlddmpgd oJpou ' suoJlo g s qut&! t! Og oMsl g un o dc ;ol ls sl ood o - tg JuJ JM q o-. o o u ?d m OIA O 0 IIIJ P S SICJA VZ'! n SI0IlI 0 3IOOO $olX 3I U 3 ) OPO On OJSOP I I = 0I tg/I $ C JJJ!! 3 ! V? I IU d S CI' ' f fOUS J 3J t JJP I I 1 ZJO t IO J I IOI M I D S J O JP O O 3I 0 OI I 1 S I O 1 Ip O I U IV I T S Q d II ! CI * I SJ O N SJq 0 =0 x= S Dq l d $1AO%N.q 6 = Tu =l 0 P OO A P O 0 q !@ ?T ru 1 tO ZP 3I W 1 V= P JA 3U JH 3SJ QJ NXI f= !S0 % u oo 0 ' O q/ t 0 T : OIOJ SUJ J. 3 PJq 0 0 'I 0 S 0 /: l q (0 1*a@ uouq l 16 0 slo gtu p o p ox g: l a Mo l Ju lqq /0 1swx p vg slt lv l l x o o oi lx p go u s xul l , o u q ll o o o o (ITf 'O I P;!)JI=T RJE=O A0Po J ZTI So S = 00 z; SI O!A SC J d0S J u= #=ET - TTn q TT olowla o og os l Aatq xyi llNu ls o qto 'lo ' o q/ q on s o o w a= ow . ' l. l zlg u q o / oo o s o /: l lq -p u q g Isl Jlolnop qza' v;qJloH'l sual pl : ( 6 sod s au : g uc s lu oqc x z npnu o d, r l u) ' (1f 00 g 'o u p;!)sJJ po?ooA/vMg g sat=owlxmugw zi s o o!A gp =@ d s u uf v r lpA ct sl cv lc t ' ! i .1 1 1 '. '1 1 . -, -t ? j <0)n0mIIMVU4V ' OI O **) fS DDs oOWO F9 ' lo u! PJ t! ' / ' W IAN uG # m .of Y t O dr o )S V I 4 l Xp .9j .gj : .p p y ) - - .o-u ouqasodazswal -a,.oio mupocJu-oo;- p o -ognvl s -vu-woc dJql dovu), av so w pwu o o c m -cs o -o u c d a o, lx . a p uq f a q q o w ' u v o m a s qoo p uo X t u t sl / ocup ?o to 0 )X p o old ga sod lf gI ol om u lt u p u. q q ou l x m u l )M o - I ! Ina glwt swt pcol: olinuoopt S l oos cgl cxs t l ! p u zu oo st u l ut u !-t ;; ;p T; Ggua !oioupgqsl;ap odvooJt t g sopval i tv u J sf! fn s stcld u gl l o sll:z s q pM ' I I 3 )qS OFIJII O I . I M o U I J CI S DU o X : lpqo gmscpu JJppoA?o swru Npu. lgqu opost up ll. l Io! ?o o op t t l ! !oog o l l ! l lk j a xd u t Jm qSM O O ou pl pt P TO I u l Jwl ;I Y A MO /l g E A I lo d l OSW I ol o OEd O O H ; ; S; I'Pl PSn S l P CS O JA CItO IIO Uu U M U 3 O 1 ) p l s c u q p v uplX p qo q Xu d s p c Ja lal ! ol ! q o - u t q o l sv lv ! u o o t u ; u &l:t Mo mslg'lo ,ouuso tcl olsolpt ! i lz u u:q'osq ptu nz uo; t pg l qI 'l s; ; S l soluq Eul ooJtou pvsos:p ptl Sloo ul t o;t os o gl o u v d um ut uqn; d; sv l l uA pu Xqa;cu:lms'tlgusmcsstJAlq Ju oo u) o I Jo ux ''u; to d cloo 0)o v I g ' Xq o cp ?u t uu a o a o post l wn ovu g C c u o t u <pl u uu ow q a l lxl o o o v A : s p nf !o d d na 0. $ a los o alS lu pp =q o o ; u d u o C p q g p : t ux g u m : q : p a o X ; JJRCP0 P T TP O K ' 6 fI I M SPJO 6'lt I! SJt AO t O I3 ) OT 3 U ; ' g 6 P S J O S 1t l IM U t3 IA1 H D C to ; ; 1! 8 '0 -6fSlm/ St S !I=JIJ DJ SJP O Iy 0 I6 ' nl q JD 0( I X O nO O q r 3 ' : #8Sl g N O J7 O N'OIIJ g z1 ' 't N.Y IJ W ZJ SW r C Dp J O -89 9s n gwl z f 6 t r o dz l hg alo IM u t ol a ; lu lloJals$,'q o oldS: m o pn ool t q I vu sM q pt oud lt !1 X d sl t n q lo t ;! ; ;, ql M s o Jpo oo o J Jpcv ou Xu p squ t : n xg o o p l l o -ls x q o lJ A lo o lq o lo oc ou u o o A l ol m ago o glp A ld g ' 0 fXlou p p n lIq o oldg Iopsomsol t o od ? ' g 0 l ! o u o x d sl o o t l tt ; a v q u #'SR OWU In O JJIJS S 0 f JOJ !C X S O WOX ! H O lal t q l-m o f ' s al ca ou I ona u t : n xJ x qI l v qulu lo p v ! ts v s !l s q cu u o o o l m a qpn - u u u pll z qS J SS JJO u IJ S g u to Ilmt q?Tu IO al m p ! q ? ? S !R 3n q /u M nl o :Pn M ll 'lm/qPt 3 33 XIJSW I l p OD P JM JI !I l g t TJ J so JtlJ wgu ou p po A vX d sl d oIo o ilo o ol o x q olo o tx fo o o p q o ol g o q s su p H tt l q u E' od osu l mqJq q v g s u l )uovX t ru l l p ol aw o o o p ol o J ol i g l ; n M J . ' o : u a ?o m ssc )u t su l a m ov oo mu a v o4 s o m u p q gc o ! ol p og q so : v p JJ su p cv ol oo . 'u lsg ssldqp gg 0l p v Jqo o p ou J t sqt : o sl ic lsu l t u o l M ) ogpv o Xp o gso gco cl t.sodu q Jt lo wvt? v lM ; lu H sl J w t o u l c ; cl A ? ;m p p J o u t x u X p zlpccp s dqu l pl oil Iol J ;g o : cp c c q o l lt ! ls op l g jt ! n a o ; 'OFTHRI OWOSI U I U I T TSI JXI CB TO d oqmpOO T? J$//IJ J O pI P ud JTTI <!A;I S0Iu l/ JU SM g3lt 0 A I I 3 lo I S V u: I t l o ; OJ W$ PIX q 0 0 S I S SIKU R M SIH J PI SII I! Sll I 0 q $ IK OZ I P O/ D I JCI CM pcI O I z II ; C I 6 ' ' f 0 ' ' 6 fu D g # ;a g 0 ! ( ln oouqqooupi lw!lqluuto )uon /a l u lnx J w xsto al ! gs o sol o cux susl t o os da c p l u l o;I J p iloo ul p ss oln o u to gl-'# -0 p G d s'lq n.z IOJ csx a tm p ! l d ; vu x t f fg g z n p c q l6 I q J ..Is? n z gomnds :g n a o r q a l r g 'LW TIz Z t . f6 Gj9 p . t sGxq n j f . g g - j n i p q jx un ' 'f -fI1 0 I6 ' sl o' su : l =nu ts u ln//a tn o ll 8 z' gmpaJ o o nu vl o o oq lau ng / - al u u oos # J t l o u z r zaz g Jt 1 l '1l / qSM gl! A I 3CIC3 0 0 3 ld -d u IJm 3 ? tJ O CS It A I ) p lod / ! l I l / 1 : p lps o musM Tp ?:/S?t! P o;/dp Pn oS3 I X SUO oo lu ; ? ! u A I IM o l l q lo ;/ O OO IH ; 3 : l l : usM s < : I CO svu x Io gl t! s vIn oou l up i g c v I :I JM u to u q gl IM p c x sto. o c! ; l 6ZIX ? I WO CIQ X I X Y * 9 'i l o;cs- all p o pao cg uu xw o cacpI-JA.I-xs - -pm x z - t - a woslp o vw qol , .(-Jp p s p lv m >jz. q . p - 8 O IM 0q UJ 1' UO 1O 0 U s oq o oog ; tco op sl:pt to ; u tvp to s o sM Mo ''v p fo p l q ou o q s l! l u q S ou ou m g s c q ' q ; p J p o Jq q < u l x qJo l ou l md .o ; ! ov ssc o , ' opld d o o : g p M s ol o lq l op g q u p lq JA q, s l n o pg z u ccugp cgcuc ; wq: ou p opcds> A slp dc c su Iltc o ltc u lt q q u tc o l l c q co g v d !adu x J u 'l mg c g/UJ oEslq u uu lsol ou ssggIf pq g u o4 Ai p d IIO J sga p o osn s to ! Jt s sl o s p )u : lo o p o o poa sqt nus mus calt n q v l' is / c oJ Jq t uq n ; l o. l l p t c ! .t l o q rz t n p u o o w u lm l ;: .l o ?p cp p cu<ln p o)usv o M ol 9s qo g old sp l ou to u ou t xs om o d v d s t Zo sq o t / ol /u M vM d / / 0Alo 0Iu PTJSM &! n oOt tJ/IJ 0P03 ;OI :Jl J t d t ! UI / I X StOl II J J3JSI/ tt o)O ? 1D Ju ji0t 1 O 3PC W P HTJ ''O1 I X JM O TO c O3 ' K I - omc vcmcv d vol gJ t X iqq gX.ooo M so ooll JA I l l u c .o d l p I q llx lcl q x q st o J O o l m; T i Or sib cu eiwa n t n eml o sa eu frh me o odt i t ea s t s o u se y r h m flo te n f l o lv maesa e wh weei tersao o y uhu b a t, ste o e l lv s o r n h i e sn f o tfl euy a h cme iss o e e td y b th ye p aial k p a a fo fe o de h w v n o a , u te m h t l e t w y rm re cy b y , n fe b y b r ti sg s me wo l n tb u cr i i o s a d re o s oe hs in o n ud o e n et n f a te e c u trdb y n k d 3 h y n o nee o s a e ? 1 l 2 0B..h Ro a Pa wrg t luu i hsc me is eerdt n 0 C te m n ly ih Pa ts n i o de rfre o hmoeulyivligs vs2L tr rlt txshnbgnrjcigte o sxai novn l e. aemoaii ette ea eet h t a3 sc n cm3 0 C, patc, se sbyb cu eo rsn d mo rt sni e tS By1 0B. . rcie otn il e a s f iig e cai e t n. c me iso P mp nu a dNo is a dtest e o L cl s d rfrn e t o de f o o is n vu ,n h ak s f u iu ma e eee c s o i C. Aue sa Ro e u tn m W i i tec ne t f layepot, g rsiemaeh mo eu ly t n h o tx o mitr x li a gesv l o sx ai h i s t fu depeso io sees gn o sq sobltite e ga bte(1 on xrsinn bcn l as n l ghtul snh Pm in at 4 o i e l BC) ewenOcai(tr a e AuutsadhsiaMakAnhn . At bt e tvalenm d gsu)n ir l r toy3 a v 5 tesmet e armat tp o p er e eg dpi ai b sdo h tr sx a h a i , o ni y e f o ty m re rm rl ae n eeoe u l m c y te e,u as ocsoaltuhdhmort sbet.F rxmpea om hm sbt l cainl oce o eoi ujcs o ea l, p e o y c o avc o h w t sc edwi b y b gn ,< h ts o rsce? Yo k o n d ie n o o u c e t o s e ist a'y u ert u n w h W h w t cthg o -o kn b y , u i'n t o rlo s ru h u c mb d b ad o o ac o dlo ig o sb tts o y u o k : o g , n o e , er ' d a3 8 I.t 0 . 3Hu b r,u r, t 0 . 2 b ad sp a a 3 9 31 . t 0 -0 3d a 3 9 1 . Ml . t 1 . d a3 0 3 ltrhR ma Qusin 28 . 1 uac, o n et s 8A P o 1 0 u crdfrn k dy ue d r tefe zn witra dtesoc igsmme d g n ae o ; a e o n ue h reig ne, n h c rhn u r o d y '6 a s, 3 Iwa twad tee do teAu utneata aRo a p e, u l s t s o rs h n fh g sa r h t m n o tP bi u O iis s,nwna Ovd(3B.-7C ) oe tmop oe,h fs vdu Naoko s i 4 C 1 E wrtMea rhssteit r Ro a txsmyhcltr st adese ae o oeuly l oe asg a m n et( tias i )o drsfm lhm sxai .n n psae oe t - l j I 1 , J grwatngnee b a E ytngdes i sr sedrd y n gpi ods. la a He br p n scmeu o h rte ,n h r ud nbo g ttefno r it a g a p n e h n a d e b re ru h i lit h s t rse tr e l hl, n n oh rfte He te asd h p ra : m i heo cel. afbaecddsakowntewoaho,'rmoharie e e n i To erie au b o..h e r brs coh s rdh d y as y. s e y lte n a tekn o fc ta wo l b c l db a t, suieo fmiie3 h id f ae h t ud e al euy mac l r e nn . e n 7 l. Clska Grc - o a Viwso Ma ra e l as l e oR m n e n rie A. (re e iec An in Gre wr ese p aie tep lia a dscar l o mara e ce t ek i r m h szd h oic l n o iloe f rig , t t fr o do tescey Ho e e, e c ddn tn ein rd v lpab l fh t o g o fh o it. w v rGre e i o ih rt o e eo ei ta a e dvn p we h drv ae t ma kn ac d o r> lto o sx a b h vo a d iie o r a e e ld o l id o e f e ain f eu l e a ir n h dn rl iu isi to soe fresx a po iio s 8 a o ei o snt uin t noc e u l rhbt n . g t i3 l te eu l (8 B..Paowrttaiwa ovo sht&js nh Rp bi 30 C) lt oehtt s biu taE ut c a Reu l .. sarn efr rig s sca e tl n temot ardmara e p bi .mut ra g o mara e,arm na a d h ssce rig s c 3 d a 3 4ct gGln e Peuia = CL 1 .7 1 5 .t 4 in a d s rsn e 1 16 2 . 1 i 3Tiuls14 6 b l .. u 3Ovd Mea oph sn97 07 0 7 i, tm r oe .0 - 1 . 3Do e, u r ,t 0 . 8 v rsp a a 2 3 be sleietoal jr iizt n.Ave taC lona oesat ga en efvdn t 1mao cvlai s iw ht ai rivtr,ci s io f n teut aelwma esweeirt n lnd cdn t mananteta io a h lm t a k r, r rai a i eiig o iti h rdt n l i o i fmi u ia teb i igbo ko ter o mu ie i n tsp otdb te a l nt sh ul n lc fh ic m nt s s o u p re y h y d i hsoia rc r.l ve o teGre a dRo a ve so b t h mo eu ly itrcle od n iw fh ek n m n iw n oh o sx ai t a dtei p ra c o mara ea teb ssfretbihn teh u e od i n h m otn e f rig sh ai o sa l ig h o sh l, t s s pyd e n tolw ta l in mara ea b t enama a dawo a i i l o s o fl h ti t g rig s ew e m o mi nn mns bg td h tfl roh r iemaiiu . Hitrcl ,t s i pyarao a l ioe , aeu o tew s l o s soial iwa sm l e sn be c y d tr iainma eb gethn esma yo wh m weeh mo eu la o t eem n t o d y ra tik r, n f o r o sx a, b u T eeaeav r t o l igarn e e t fr ihp o l f dte sle. h r r ai y fi n ra g m ns o whc e pe i h m ev s e v n S meo teeaeb sdo meep ro a o go pepoain Otesaeb r of o fh s r ae n r esn l r ru x lrt . h r r on o n c si .No eh ls,h s atraieu i aen tt ara e' eest n teestee l n t nt r o t rig s' y ev s m Re rt byteeiisfiin sa et dsu sget iizto s9o te get l h r snu f e t p c o ic s ra cvl ain m h a c i Eateaiet lwso mara ea dtefmi ,ao gwihviwso srlt o a n rig n h a l ln t e n v y h moe u ly T o esra so to g t udas b h lfloteCo r i o sx ai . h s tem fh u h wo l lo e epu t h u tn t frh r e o srt gta ted cso b tev tr f d rao e sp otn ute d m ntai h th e iin y h oes i s esn d u p r i n n oh r itrc l n p i sp ia ta io s No eh ls,tss fiin t s o te hsoia a d hl o hc lrdt n . n teesii ufce to h w o i ta tet osceiswhc ma etemot inf at o tiuin t ti h th w o it , ih d h ssg icn c nr t so hs e i bo Ote ta terw p we ta a e p rr o sse ,teewa n lg l ai fr h rh n h a o rh t n m eo p sesd h r s o e a b ss o 1 7 teG aig.( cesdSp.72 1) h E nae'A cse et1,0 0. m ' c u tyi p i sp y tep lia sse ,n telw, eme mara eb t en o nr n hl o h ,h oicl ytm a d h a d e d rig ew e o t o p st sx sa fu d to a t a od rdscey T ru htev t gpo es p oi e e s o n ain lo n ree o it. ho g h oi rc s, e n iwa tec l ciewid m o tect e so Caio i t manana t sh ol t so fh izn f l m a o iti n ev i f u d rtn igo ma ig whc i cn itn wi tewid m o tecvl ain n esa dn f n a e ih s o sset t h s o fh iizt s h io fr ihte aeh is T i i n t ioe a dii n t n esn be Th r i o whc h y r er. hs s o bg td n ts o u rao a l. ee s ' j h t .' .t ' 1 ' g ' j t ? rget lisfcetpc itee ae tpoie igahclkths f ertby nuf i saen hspgso rvd borpiasece o a in itlcul i ttaaeqoe ihri.T oesece wolrvatate nel taga shtr utdn een h s kths ud eelhthy e n hdclausfinsfmi me brwh weehmoeullde,o eo a ol ge,red,a l m es o r o sx a. nedsm f e y ' tk- me weeteh-v sg y l l sn ete aen t-lk tV tr 6 h-- n r l tj e a . h s e s y r o u- ' h -ej f s e t -e hik o Cai mi.Wh te d si ti o b cu eo ti,h s get ndtr ie lo a eh r ept hs r ea s fhstee ra me eem n d f e ta mar g so l b l i da a isiuinb t enama a dawo a . h t ri e h ud e i t s n nt t ew e a me to nn mn He c , eiigmara ea au ino ama a dawo a rf cs o o l te n e d t n rig s no f n n n m n el t n t ny h e - c l ce wid m o tect e sb t fh a e a wel ol td so fh izn , u o te g s s l. e i Rep cfl sb ie ti 2 t d yo S pe b r2 1 . s etul u m t d hs 4h a f etm e, 0 0 y t By // Ke i T.nd r : s vn s ie Ke i T. nd rCA Ba No 1 0 8 vn S ie r .798 P CI I J S I EI S I UT A FC U TC N TT E PO .o 2 6 0 . B x 76 0 S ca e t,CA 9 8 7 arm no 52 P oe (1) 5-90 hn: 96 8760 Fx (1) 5-92 a: 96 8760 Ema: eisie@pc/jsc. g - i kvnndr aicut eo l ir Atrefr miu, aicJsc Istt t ny o A csP ci ut entue o fii CERTI I ATE OFCOMPLI NCE FC A 1 T i bif c mpis wi te tp -ou e l i t n o F AP . hs re o l t h y ev lm i t i f R eh m ao 3( ) ) )i ta i cnan n moe ta 1,0 wod. Acodn t 2A ( ( n ht t otis o r hn 400 rs crig o 7B '' . 1 1 1 Mirs fWodsi tt t s'ti d c me t o tis41 0wod . co ot r ' ai i , hs o u n c nan ,3 rs s sc ' 2 T ibito pis ttetptc rqimeto-'-xp3()5 hsrecm l wi h yeaeeur ns t R 2a(0 - eh e s adtetp s erqi met o F A 3() )bcueti bifhsbe n h ye t eur ns f R P 2a( eas hs r a en g e 6 e pe ae i ap o o t n l sa e tp fc u ig Mirs f OfieWod 2 0 rp rd n rp ri al p cd y ea e s oy n co ot f c r 03 Ti e Ne Ro a 1 p ity e m s w m n 4 on tp . By - / Ke ir s ie: / -vt nd t 1 t : .* 7 .1 . . ( 1 l Kei T. ndrCABa No 10 8 vn S ie r .798 P CII J S I EI S I UT A FC U TC N TT E P. .o 2 6 0 O B x 760 S ca e t,CA 9 8 7 arm no 52 P oe (1) 5-90 hn: 96 8760 F x (1) 5-92 a: 96 8760 Emalkvnndr pc cuteog - i eisie@ ai jsc. : l ir Atrefr csP ct Jsc lstt t ny o Amiu, ai utentue o kii 1 9 CERTI I ATE OF S RVI E FC EC l eeycriyta o S pe b r2 , 0 0 Ieeto ial fldte h rb et h t n e tm e 4 2 1 , lcrncl ie h f y frg igwi teClr o teCo rfrteUntdSae Co ro Ap e l fr oe on t h ek fh u to h i tts u t f p as o h e teNit Cic ib u igteap l t CM/ CFs se . h nh rut y s h p el e E y tm n a P riia t i tec s wh aergsee CMJ C u eswi b sre b at p ns n h ae o r e itrd E F sr l e evd y c l i tea p l t CM/ CFs se . h p el e E y tm a L ' ( '( .j j i j 1utecrftasme fhprc atiteaernteiee fr retyhto ote ati nsnh csa orgsrd hi ip e t CW ECFues 1 aemaldtefrgigdcmetyFrtclsMal sr. hv i h oeon ou nb is- as i e , p sepea ,r aedsatdit Y p rycmmeca'rifff ot rp i o v iptl --- l at o rl i d - t - ;a d l eyt tefl wign nCM / CFp riiat: ei r o h ol n O - E at p ns v o c JfryMae r efe te Liet lsiue b r nt t yt 2 01W PlnoPakwa 0 a ry S i 10 ut 6 0 e Pa o T 7 0 5 ln , X 5 7 Lic l C. ih n n on Ol a t p Cou b sS h o o La lm u c o l f w T eCah l Unv ri o Ameia h toi iest f rc c y W ahn tn DC 2 0 4 sigo , 0 6 W c adJ Betn hr . t a BOI SS HI L R & F EXNER LLP E C LE L 7hFo r t lo 5 5Le igo Av . 7 xn tn e Ne Yok, 1 0 2 w r NY 0 2 T o a MoeS cey h m s r o it Si 40 ut 4 e 2 S LaS l Sre 9 . al t t ee Chc g ,L 6 6 3 ia o I 0 0 s / Se h nMo r tp e oe T o a Beca h m s rjh 2 0 CERTI I ATE OFS M ENES FC A S 1 , Kei T.ndr vn Sie ety h ths re s d ni lo i f c ,cr f tati b i i ie t a t Spe br 42 1 et e2,00 m p s at m un tev rinsb ie eeto ial o h eso u m t d lcrnc l n t y A1Nit Cic iCae . 1 nh rut ss t R l6c o te miirt eOreR grigEet ncFl gi o ue () fh Ad nsai dr eadn lcr i in n tv oi Dae t: Spe br 72 1 etm e2,00 Sg aue s KeiT S ie in tr : / vn .ndr

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?