Gary Black, et al v. Google, Inc.

Filing 22

Filed original and 7 copies of Appellants Holli Beam-Black and Gary Black (Informal: Yes) reply brief of 19 pages. Served on 05/10/2011. [7752222] (GLS)

Download PDF
1 2 NO. 0 1 9 2 1 -6 9 R OLYc E 1V E D Ec M L .D E CEK l J . C I7IAPAS s OIWYR EL R'F / LB I M t1221 A 21 UNTFORT T MCOUDIOFAP fny ... .111 IE STHE SNTHR S CT jyy .x . 4l D AE T TRI P E . ... lt s n. A / - GARY BL Ar HOL BE - BL ACK LI AM ACK Plit /p elns ano A p l t a , v. GOOGLE,NC. I Deed n/p ele fn at p l . A e 1 1 OnApelrm teUntdSae Dirt utote paf h i tts si Corfrh o e tc NotenDitit fCai ni r r src o lo l h f a CaeNo 41 -v0 3 1CW s . :0c -2 8' eHooalClu iWi e l nrbe ada l n ' h k 'NF ' ORMAI' I , ' M PELLANTSREBUTTALTO DEFENDANT- P AP ELLEEGOOGLEI ' NC. S ANS WERI BRI NG EF GARY B LACKAND HOL BE BL K LI AM- AC 1 1AudCo r 0 l ut Gre ValyFl , lona954 en l al Cai ri 43 e s f (0) 7-90 773326 Panisaeatn :' Po iP roa' litf r cig 'n rpra esn ' f I zneilsl1I aR l tl3if w.pl ' i-' 1 e7 t.1 e î al '.I 4u' r j t l. n . a f ) NO. 01 9 2 1 -6 9 UM TED S TATESCOURT OF AP PEALS FOR THE NI DI TRI NTH S CT GARY BLACK AND HOLLIBEAM - BLACK Plit Ap l ns anp/p el t a , v. GOOGL I E,NC. Deedn/p ele fnat p l . A e 1 1 OnAp elrm teUntdSae Dir t uto te p afo h i tts s i Co rfrh e tc NotenDir t f lona rhr s i o Cai ri tc f CmeNo41-v0 3 1CW s . :0c-2 8Th Ho oal Clu i Wi e e n rbe a da l n k 'NFORMAL' ' I ' APP ELLANT REBUTTAL TO S DEF ENDANT- P AP ELLEE GOOGLEI ' NC. S ANS NG BRI WERI EF GARYBL K AND HOL BE BL AC LI AM- ACK 1 1AudCo r 0 l ut Gre ValyF l, lo a9 5 4 en l al Cai mi 4 3 e s f (0)7-90 773326 Panifaeat g ' Prpr P ro a' litfs r ci '' o i esn ' n .f n a T EOFCONTENTS ABL 1 2 1Op nn R bta Sae n OfIs e . . e ig e utl ttmet s us 1 3 1. o l D e No Qu lyF r. IGo ge o s t ai o f 1 l nt U d r h CDA mmu i n e T e y 4 5 11A AMatr Sr t ibly 1. s te Of ti La it c i 4 Go geI I F c T eP ryDea n Pani Bu ie s s. o l s n a t h at fmig litf: sn s e f 6 l Go gesR s o s T Ap eln'Br f V. o l' e p n e o pl t i as e Ci sCo fso Ov rPanisTrd N me t nu in e litf a e a s e f 5 8 V.Go geCa s dT eDitit ut ros. o l u e h src Co rE rr 6 9 VIGo geAd ie T a Panis . o l vss ht litf f 1 H dOte Re de At a . 0 a h r me is L w .. .. 7 .. 1 V1.Pani sCa eI u i e c a l 1 1 litr s s nmp a h be f 9 j Ag is D fn a t OnTh Mei z an t ee d ns e rs t 1 3 Mirpee tt n. . . . se rs nai . . . o 1 4 Be c o Co t c . . ra h f nr t . a 1 5 Unar uiesPate /as Ade iig fiB sn s rci sF le v dsn c 1 6 Ne le c . gi n e . g 1 7 Vilt n o L w oai s f a o 1 8 Itnin lnlt nOf moin l irs . . ne t a Ifci E t ads e s . o io o t 1 9 VlID fn at Dee s l Ftl l. ee d ns fn es aal y 2 Fa dAn I Vilt Of a 0 lwe d n oai L w on . ... .. . . .. 2 l .con lsi 1 X cu on 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 1 7 1 8 2 2 2 3 2 4 1 0 1 1 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 T EOFCASESANDAUTHORI E ABL TIS N n aectdi rbt l la es eAp eln' Bi fr ae a da toie o e r i n e ut pe s e p l t rfo cs s n uh ris e a aé e t i i gp:I# '.,l . b!ali . li?sI:nfR li . e h a atj!-. e .- ? f ? è)-. tl r 1 ' l ) 1 1Op nn Re utlttmet fs us . e ig b ta Sae n o Is e 1 . 2 A taidsrto rp iisakdfrn rci djdc lei o tematr n tr l i i cut lnf se o ad ee e u iarv w fh t ad i n tc a tf v i e e 3 4 5 6 7 8 rq eto 'u g n o tePla ig ' ihflwe a' t nT Dimis b Go ge lc. i e u sfr' d met n h e dn s whc ol d Moi o s s' y o l,n .Whl J ' o o ' e Go gee g g dtec ue o at nwi itec mpan, o l n v r cu l a s rdte o l n a e h a s s f ci t n h o litGo ge ee a tal nwep h o h y idvd a alg t n a da s do s Smir , o l n v r i cl rs o d t Ap eln' Bif n niiu l l ai s n se in . i l l Go ge ee dr t e p n s o p l t r o e o ay ey as e fec nenn panislg l ru n ta Go gei ntmmu eu d rh Co nct n i o c rig litf e a ag me tht o l s o i n n e te mmu iai s l f o Dee c Ac a difc i ivoaino tea ta itn o teCD lgsain Go geise d c ny t n n a tsn ilt fh cu lne t fh A e ilt . o l nta o o a s r aIn u boe Ieo cs siv ligi nt rlg u d rh C mmu iain Dee c set o g n rk ni f a e novn mmu i ui s n e te o nct s c ny s n y n o g AtC A adi oe tecue oatni'rtibi'g isGogeb al igati p d. c(D ) n g rsh ass f ci ns i l iyaant o l y lgn hd a y n o tc a l t e r j o 1 1 1 2 1 3 Ths c s saent fiekn , n Go ged e nt rwsmirist tic s o cefcsfo o e a e r o o I id a d o l o s o da i l ie o hs a e r i at rm k at t toec s sismiryt tefcso tics .Thscs c nesu o ufib sn s pate , h s ae n i l i o h at fhs ae i a e e tr p n nar uies rci s at c i g lo d c b Go gei tes l o a v ds me t, o l i 'r tiblyd fmigpanis l a cn ut y o l n h ae f d e ie ns Go ge n s i l l 'ea n litf l e tc a i t f b sn se a dn th d fmaino panisb ti p re . litf c mpan fcs so uie ss n o te ea t f litf y hr ats Panis o litou e n o f d i f Go gessak g ag rh cd fmaindrce a panis a dGo ge d srcino panis o l' tli , loi mi ea t i td t litf, n o ls e t t f litf n t o e f uo f b sn se whl Go geie g g di ufib sn s pat e , se rs nain be c o u ie s s i o l s n a e n nar u ie s rci s mirpee tt , ra h f e c o c nrc, n voaino Iw. o l'c s a ay ia dag me t aea anof on a datmp t o t ta d ilt fa Go ges ae n lss n ru ns r g i fp it n t to a o e co dteis e a pani ddsaei dsrt o d Go gesag me to i nt e t p ltsa lu h su s s litf i tt n i i c u . o l' ru n frmmu i xr oae f tc y a ti p d d fmainc ueo at nfo afw Ie o txtk no t f o txfo tec mpan hr a y ea t a s f ci rm e i s fe ta e u o c ne trm h o li d o o n t whltec mpan hsn b ssfr d fmainc u eo at no c uea ant ti p d . h i h o lit a o a i o a ea t a s f ci r a s g isa hr a yT e e o o d dfn e Go geo lrp asb fr teNit Ci ut f cu l mildtedsrt o r. edsrt ee s s o l ny e e t eoe h nh r ief tal se h i i c utTh i i c e y tc tc 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 cu a arslerdids sigtecs rte ta gatgp iisug no tep ai s od s eu r n i s h ae ah rhn rni lnf jd met nh l dn t e mi n n a tf e g 2 1 2 (aes. 2 ppr) 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 l. o l D e No Qu lyF r 1Go ge o s t ai o f I nt Un e T eCD mmu i d r h A y 2 . Ap eln'Bif hwsted fn a t d nt u lyfrh i nt u d rh CDAb c ueiti p l t r s o h ee d ns o o q ai o te mmu i n e te as e f y e a s n hs isa c ,h g nu o Go gespo rmmiga Go geMa sa dPlc sb r tesauoyi nt ntne te e is f o l' rga n t o l p n ae as h tttr mmu i y a ta i nt iq aie a dmu d n i nt a dn t na s lt. o l'd fn e ifc, s h tmmu i s u lid n n a e mmu i n o a boue Go ges ee s ,n at y f y caln e tes p rblyo tei nt saueb cu ete'r t a ig'n teU. h l g s h e aa it fh mmu i ttt e a s h s i me nn a d h S. e i y tc 1 C n rse 'auoyitn' t peetrfcig(iot emi i )sak g(n atd ogesss ttr ne tso rvnt i n wt upr s o ,tln uw ne t i a k h sn i 2 aetn,n tehrsmet fteso le Goge ag met n tedsrt orod ra t ni )ad h aas noohr nn. ol' ru n adh i i cutres t t o i s tc 3 h n atmp t rwreU. Iwf m teb nh ad t to e i S.a r h e c . e t o 4 3 . Go ges l pani't d n me a s ac k ywod t panislc lo eio gvn toe o l el litf r e a s s e rh e rso litf oa c mp tin iig h s s fs a f t 5 c mp tose ps r a dac s t pani'h r d i pop cigefr wh npani'po pcs o ei r xo ue n ce so li fs ad al rset f t e litf rset t tf y n os fs 6 iqi oleflwigpanisdo- -o r rsetg (afkgbdfi nbcueiidn nur ni ol n litf o rodo popci .tfci y eit eas ts oe e n o f t n ri n ni o 7 wiotliispr sina dfe iA pln'Bil litfg do- -o r ahdyisac o t up nf emi o s ei dn pel t rfPanis o o rod o ec a n erh f h a tf s n as e f t 8 h me wi q et n beros Plitfert o t rs et wh pe e t aen thn iga ot o s t u si a l o f. anifres u po p cs o rs nl r o tikn b u a h o f y 9 ro, u p ra sn e e h lwh nd sg igter o sGe eals e kn paniss lmoe o fb t eh p e d d ep e e inn h ih me . n rl p aig litf el r y f 1 0 rosi o emot ta moto fr d ia e tey a. i lp tpanisaee ve , o o f n n nh h n s roes o n n ni e rSmpy u, lit r n id nt r i 1 1 u d rto , n n t lIe b tec mp tina i v r rr ta paniss laro t ap d neso d a d o weli d y h o ei st ey ae ht litf el o fo a y k t o ' s f 1 2 ta'a teye g g do itemakto aro. litf s lspo p csae' vlp db ht ci l n a e rn h re fr ofPani' ae rs et r d oo c 'y s v fs o 1 3 pani'h r woka de p n e c ld' lsla g n rtn'n a alg di c mpan, litf litf ad r n x e s ,al s e e d e eai ,a d s l e n o litpanis fs e a o e f 1 4 d n t orticmmecaa v rsn b tah reyu o o lwodo- uh Panisc u h o o d ealo rild etig u rte rl p n ny r-f t. litf a g t i mo f 1 5 Go gese lgpaniss lsIa g n rt nwh no led fmain weebo g topanis o l tai litf ae e d e eai e ni ea t s r ru h t litf n f o n o f 1 6 atninb c nu r a panispo p ce fr ae , h t t ninb cn u r c ue t t y o s mes s lit rs e td o s ls T a at t y o s mes a sd eo # eo 1 7 f e io a s 1 panist sf r u lt n e arsme ta dls s lsa Go geMa sa dPa e s l 8 litf o uf h miai , mb r s n, n o t ae s o l p n lc s el 1 panisn met oh r fr lc me t etopani i Go gesa v ds me t. o ltee f r 9 litf a o tes o pa e n n xt litfn o l' de ie ns Go ge h rat f f e 2 gvse p s r t panisc mp tost a c s panisd i d o- -o re dg n rt na 0 i x o ue o litf o eir o ce s litf al o rod o Ia e eai s e f t f y t o 2 panispo p csiq i o lea t teie tyo pani. o la c rigt po f eoete 1 litf rs et n ur ni s o h d ni f litfGo ge codn o ro bfr h f e n t f 2 c u ,h nd fme panisb sn se t ice s teraef m panisd o- -o r al 2 o d te ea s li f u ie ss o n rae h itk r litf o rod o d i tf o f t y 2 c na sn efd . o l'at aealg da n t nyu fib t l i g lnc mpan b c uei 3 a v sig f s Go ges cs r l e s o o l nar u as l a i o lit e a s t o e ol e 2 ijsa iG o lw r stgitep ii po ero tk ga a p iissl l d tsl n 4 sut sf oge ee ii n h lnf h n om ai w y lnf ae e so e o tn a tf s n a tf s a 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 tesre. o l rte ta a s r gtealg t n c niu sd cigu d r fleag me to h t tGo ge ah rh n nwei h l ai s ot e ukn n e a as ru nfr e n e o n i nt. h pani p itdo tnAp eln' Bifh th dsrt o rerdi nt hfn te mmu i T e litf one u i p l t r ta te i i cut r n o s iig h y f as e tc e t b re o pofo rsted fn a t e pani'c mpan a cs dGo geo b igte ud n f ro twad h ee d nwh n litf o li cu e o l f en h fs t a to/u lh r p no o to ed fmain a dGo gesih snte p n e t to ealg t n uh r bi e/ o s r fh s ea t s n o l tl a o rs o d d o h s l ai s p s s o l e o 2 z'eli I'rl R bt 1 t 'Ils1bla . ut tp at f r f e a p i etl lnf t ug no te l i s n eod s t o I l t h ri r c t a tf e an e w. i g 1 wh h ni sp iisojd met nh ped g adrcr a amatrfa Panis eenae 2 akn teNnhCru frhtug n. si h it i io tajd met g ct 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 l o 1 1 1 2 1 3 4 . Go gesd fn eo i ntwhlGo getkstepo e ya defr o pani'd i wok o l' ee s fmmu i i o l ae h rp d n f t f litf al r, y e os fs y voae F Crg lt n ,U. a v rsn Iwrh C mmu i t n De e c A ta dteB sn s ilts T e uai s S.d etig a te o nc i s c n y c, n h u ies o i ao a dPoe so sC d sp d iigt fita ea dwa alg da s c i c mpan. o ln w n rfsin o e e ann o arrd n s l e s u h n o li Go ge o e t atmpst mila teNit Ci u it tikn iin t o lb th at o oh r whc t t o s d h nh r ino hn igts o Go ge u te cs f tes i e e ct h ie aa ld ma epanis Go ge ag met a wel steretme t aesmpyn tre r p rby a g litf. o ls ru ns s la h itsa ns r i l o t . r f u 5 . Abidod dp bi, n c ut, n cn u r g n rl b lv Go geMa siv r c oa dta l fle u l ma y o r a d o s mes e eal ei e o l p s ey o l n h t n c s y e te smpyc nit f o eiv a v ds me t, i n t en a r o tetiv r tkn pae h y i l o s o c mp tie d e ie ns whl o b ig wae fh he ey a ig lc , s t e tefc ta Go geh ssoe toeb sn s ie tis o ta Go gecmmie at o prc t h a th t o l a tln h s u iesd nie , rh t o l o t d cs f i y o t t a bigtoeb sn s a v ds me t t tep bi. o la c mpih stiea oaec nprc , s r h s u ie s d e ie ns o h u l Go ge co l e hs lb rt o s i ya n c s a tec mpan alg s b ueo iiimaktoc itre t na dse ileainhp ta Go ge h o lit l e , y s fl t re fre nev ni n p ca rlt s is h t o l e l c o o 1 hsbiwi piav rsrads prtlwi tepbia Ire (e:16bl ols13ote 4 a ul t ad detes n eaaey t h ul tag .Se11 ew rr - fh t h i h c o 1 cmpa t 5 o li) n 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 6 . Mio so s lb sn se rlu o wodo- uhg o wia dfe cmmeca s e c i l n f malu ie s s ey p n r-fmo t o d l n re o rilp e hn l i l po p cigs ls Go gepe e t b fre wi o t emi in e g g spanisa dma yoh r rs et ae ; o l rs nl y oc , t u p r s o , n a e li f n n tes n y h s tf b tkn terd nie a db sn s ifr t nfr u laino le Go gete s l panis y a ig h iie tis n u ie snomai o p bi t ni . o l h n el litf t o co n s f v r c slIa g n rt nadh r wokt hsc mp tosfr e ne . oeslsla s ey ot e d e eai n ad r o i o ei r o p n isTh s ae e d y o t c mptosa t va v dsn ao g ieGo gesb sn s rve o pani'b sn se aesoe o ei r - b d e iig ln sd o l' u ie s e iw f litf u ie s s r tln t e ' fs f m panisb Go geMa sa dPa e .tsn df rnta iGo geweetkn te fo r lit y o l p n lc s Ii o iee th nf o l r a ig h m rm o l f panisp o ero b tp igpanistlp o e .ntiisa c panisg d o- -o r a h litf h n o m y a pn litf ee h n s l hsntne litf o o rod o e c f f f t 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 dyadaebigflwe (tl db uw ne atninadhrse) yGogeMasa dPlcs a n r en ol d s k y natd t t n aasdb ol p n ae; o ae eo Un o t v d dfcsalg ditic s icu ea s ro sta panisaeh r df a cala d c nr e e at l e n hs ae n ld setn h t litf r ame i n il n o e i f n y e tn l bcueo G o l'maktt nt ievnin(tln - n atdatnin io moi ay eas f oge re seghn ret s k g uw ne t t )n o s r t o ai eo t pani' b sn se a dbd igo c nrcs temak toc p p lryo Go gesitre t nwi litf uies s n idn f o tat,h re fre o uai f o l' nev ni t fs t o h drcoysyea v rsn , n ters ln c nu rn ur o leflwigac nat litf a i tr tl detig a d h e utg o s me iq i ni ol n otc pani h s e i i y n o f 3 i pInsnb-al bt i I n k t -p eattflll eua 1 2 3 4 5 ma ewi ac nu rTh mo u na efr panisma ee c d yaetee f rnevn db d t o s me. e n me tlf t litf k a h a r h rat itre e y h os f e Go geMa sa dPa e a dGo ges l of litf wokvac nu rn ur st panis o l p n lcs n o l el fpani' r i o s me iq ie o litf s fs i f c mp tos Go gea s o b po fma te d fmepanisf eya da o y u l, sma o eir. o l s h wn y ro, y h n ea litf r l n n nmo sy a y t f e ter reigp o lo c mmiso st ice s teetk o panisefr aIt litc h imak t e pe n o s in o nrae h r ae f litf f t la panis n f os f epne xes. 6 11A AMatr Stit ibly 1. s t Of r La it e c i Go geII F c T eP ryDea n Pani' Buiess o l s n at h at fmig litf sn se fs 7 7 8 T ec mpan whc ie c rtdwi iAp elnsBifalg sGo gea tea to a dp bih r h o lit ih s xepe t n p l t r , l e o l s h uh r n u l e h a e e s 9 o d fmain ta d v saepani'b sn se tee yd ma igpanisf a cala d f ea t s h t e att litf uies s h rb a gn litf i n il n o fs f n y 1 e tn l. hssifcacri t pofnt seuai o cnetr. i tWiite 0 moi ayT ii nat cod g o ro,oa pcl o rojcue Fr : tnh o n tn s h 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 .i 1s 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 c mpan a d'e lrt no G.Ba ktepani d c metdwi p ooa dc p Go geMa s o lit n D caai f lc'h litf o u ne t ht n o y o l p o f h i daeyflwigatrae igIt roGo gesIg l e t tepanisweedfme o mme itl ol n he tnn et t o l' e a d p. h litf r ea d n o e f , Go geMa sa dPae wi iafwd y o Go gerc in ten te Paniset tdte o l p n lcs t n e a s f o l e ev g h oi . litf si e h h i c f ma o d a 1 ,0 ,0 : ta iwa Go ged igted fmaina ted fmaoyc ne t sao g d s t 00 00 0 1 h tt s o l on h ea t s h ea tr o tn wa ln o teIeo ap lep we iv siaietp d fmainrte ta ta whc mih b catdb a l i f oi o rne t t y e ea t ah rh n h t ih g t e rf y n n c gv o e a e cn u rGo gehsnt d rse ta. c n : tiAp elnsBifpanispo ie te o s me. o l a o a de sd h tSe o d Wi n p l t r , litf rvd d h h f NihCiut t ac p o Go geMa suiga as ac tr tepaniswi,b sn s n me n r iwi o y f o l p sn s e rhem h lit , f s u ie s a t c h l e 'a t Ro f g,Th Nit Ci ut yf dtii o a t e rhatc e t pg 2o f p ln' , sl oi , e nh r ima i hsmp d n sac t h d o a e f, el t C e n. c n a Ap a s lfr l rf.t lctdb nahpg 2ote'fr l rf om,Iso apdo rp oa nomaBi'lsoae e et a e fh IomaBi Fr .thws htgah f e' ' n e b t nlb ld' ac Ma s't o l'we seu ig' sl Ro f g'sas ac tr T e ut a ee ' rh p'a Go ges b i sn ' t oi 'a e rh em. h o Se t Ca e n d fmain ,t o l Ma s aes o a dweeoiialp se ao g ieGo gesa v ds d ea t sa Go ge p , r hwn n r r n l o td ln sd o l' d e ie o g y Itgo C l a C nt cino ndb pa tfG. lc)Gogemaktge l eso Goge ii f aB y osr t w e y lii( Bak. o l rei mp ye r ol' sn uo nf n o s Ic le rhag rh , o ati p r ,h ratr u lh dto ed fmain o Ca B y o as ac loims nt hr at tee f p bi e h s ea t s f I a t d y e s o Co srcina anth b sn s rve o Ca t Ro f go Go geMa so e b a oh r litf nt t g is te u ie s e iw f sl oi n o l p wn d y n te pani uo e n f (. e m- lc)Whlpanis r hsadadwf te bsnse a dC L Ies gaent H B a Bak. i l tfae ub n n i hi ui ss n S B i ni r o e if e r e c n a scae a dGo ge n t ti p d , ea dCa t Ro f g Go geiiasrt n e te so itd n o l, o a hr a y d fme sl oi . o l sn ti ma n rh d e n c d fmigti p d tedsrt o rod r ga tmmu i t. h rfr tedsrt o rod r ae ea n hr a y h itc cut res rn i nt o T eeoe h itc c ut res r d i y i 4 zpeI t1flaï bla tplnsnb'aRettl a n t 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 j o 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 erdpoe uala dern o sfralgt s i teb re o po foted fn a t a ta a r rcd rl n ro e u o fi o hf h ud n f ro t h ee d ns tr l s e y i n t i sae iAp eln'Brf n fi gt a k o e g ta pani alg dta Go gewa te ttd n p l t i a d al o c nwld e h t litf l e ht o l s h as e i n f e a to/p no/u lh r fh c ne t r te s n gie tnrp biaino ted fmain a ant uh r o sr bi e o te o tn o a lat e l n i e u l t fh ea t s g is s p s g co o tewrn p d . id Go gea dt n l p bih sd fmain a ant ohpani'b sn se h o g a yThr: o l d io al u l e ea t s g is bt litf u ie ss i y s o fs b pg s' c e 'nGo geMa sa dPa e wi d fmaoyc ne trm Y h oswe sea y a e c h do o l p n lc s t ea tr o tn f a o ' b i s a h o t ce i cmpan a dwiiAp eln'bif n u a s rdb Go gesrs o s t tebifT i id n o lit n t n p l t r ad n nwee y o l' e p ne o h r . hs t h as e e d fmaoya tas b Go ge iatr o l wa ifr dta Ya o h drmo e te ea tr c, lo y o l,s f Go ge snome h t h o a e v d h e d fmain S e ic l sae wiitec mpan fr a g sa du a s rdb Go ge i ea t . p cfal ttd t n h o lito d ma e n n nwee y o l,s o iy h Ya o 'rso s a rmo ao ted fmaina dpanisIt roGo gesIg le ttrae ig h os e p n e te v lfh ea t n litf et t o l' e a d p.he tnn o f e tis iAp elnsBr f ealte eat b ec rt fo tedsrt o rpoe dn st i srt hs ut p l t i d ti h s cs y xeps rm h i i c ut rce ig o l t e . a e s tc l a u hw Go ged fme panisb sn se frh p roeo s l ga v dsn a de rh s o o l ea s litf uie ss o te up s f el d e iig n ni e f i n c te ev si si o tef a caa de t n l a g scu e t panis Pani sae i h ms l n pt fh i n il n moi a d ma e a s d o litf. li f ttd n e e n o f tf ' dsrt o rta tematr so eo ttcI blya dteei n me t no ati p r wi ite i i cuthth t wa n fsr ti i 'n h r s o ni f hr at t n h tc e i ai t o d y h c mpan' Ih alg t n a dc u e o at nweea ant o l,n .T edsrt o rerd o lital e l ai s n a s s f ci r g i Go ge Ic. h i i c ut r , t e o o s tc e wh nod r gta panisweese igt h lGo gel befrh c n ut fhr p re a e rei h t litf r e kn o od o l i l o te o d c o ti ats s n f a d i 1 p ii'cmp i olsesoh lGog Ib fr olsiui t pa tf.t i o atht 6 lnfs o ln ny e k t od o l i l o Gog ' jrso lii l mpd nta at f at e ae en e nf ' ss 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 panispoe uetic mpan a ant o l b c ueiin a n x t i o sbefr litf t litf rsc t hs o lit g isGo ge ea s ts e r e to mp sil o panis o f f s lh mei rv me t o roigwi Go gesie v bep lisa du win n s t elo mpoe ns ro f t o l' r mo a l oie n n l g es o n h r c l i h f c mmu iaewi panis Go ge at aesmpyu c nco a la dso ln t ec df do o nct t litf. o ls cs r i l no sin be n h ud o b o ie r i i c n b e b teNo h r Dsrt o do a yoh r o d o d n d y h d en itc C u r n te c u . 2 1 1 .Go gesR s o s T Ap eln' Br f V o l' e p n e o p l t i a s e 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 Ci sCo fso Ov r anisTa eNa s t nu in e Plitf rd me e f 8 . Pani'c mpan d e n t o tiacu eo at nfr ea t nb c uepanisb sn se litf o lit o s o c nan a s f ci o d fmai ea s lit u ies s fs o o f weeatce o len t nya Go gebt loYa o ,h B B, n o tego n a teCSL . r t kd ni o o l t o l u as h o te B a d n h ru d th B a n Pr roOc.0hwh nted fmainsa e a Go geMa s tepanishdt a s rote i t t2 t e h ea t td d t o l p ,h litf a o nwe t h o o f C l riSaeC nrcosL es B ad(S B.C nu e roi cmpansf m a frw y ai na tt ot tr i ne o r C L ) os m rofg o l t,r sa a a f o a c n i o a LsAn ee , .h db e Id e a ant l a Co srcina teCS B.Pani' s o g ls Ca, a e n o g d g is Ca B y nt t th L litf uo fs 5 'p Ils1b: l ett fp at - 4 4 ,a i 1 t as eEè 1f1 a1 bl l 2 3 4 5 6 7 a 9 l o 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 b sn se aeb t b sditeS. . a ae a dpanish dn v r e nt L sAn ee o e e u ie ss r oh ae n h F B y ra n li f a e e b e o o g ls r v r tf wok dtee P re oh rh npanisweeuigCa B yCo srcinsb sn s n me lct n re h r. at s te ta litf r sn I a n t t ' uie s a ,o ai , i f uo o a dIe s n mb r b t o Ca B ystlpo en mb r. h n mea dIe s n mb r h db e n i ne u es u nt l a ' ee h n u es T e a n i n e u es a e n c c soe b oh r t s lroigt cn u r. h CSL c mmu iae wi panisa dpe u by tln y tes o elo f o o s mes T e B o nctd t litf n rs ma l n h f a pe e d dteb dg y . litfweea s ltlatnse a hw q ikya de iinlte p rh n e h a u s Panis r b ouey so ih d t o ucl n lce t h f y CSL ce rdpani'n me . h panite ca g dten meo teIe s a teC Bf m B lae litf a s T e litfh n h n e h a n h i ne th SL r fs f c o Ca B yCo srcint Cat Rof ga dCo srcin S ot tee f rd fmain o Ie I a ntut o sl oi n ntut . h ry h rat , ea t s n i o e n o l e o n b g na ant I a Co srcinb t litf g is ce d dig tn tewe se t rmoe e a g is Ca B y ntut u pani a an u ce e n et g h b i s o e v o f i t toed fmain a Ya o a dteB .H we e,h panisweertlslbid ie a d h s ea t s t h o n h BB o v rte litf r uhesy l sd d n o f n a u h d a sae i c mpan, yGo ge u win n s t e e c mmu iaewi panis mb se , s ttd n o litb o ls n l g e so v n o nct t litf. l i h f Go gent ny po e d dt d v saepani'Ieio d b t ar dfd ted fmain t o l o o l rc e e o e att litf i l o s u c re o h h ea t s o fs v h i o paniswi 'b sn s a ' slRo f g'Pani teeoep iIrefe t iataehsb ies litf' f s u ie s tCat oi ' litfh rfr adag e s on ci t i ul r f e e n. f v d le s a teCS B a tele s b c meueesi cmmec a ant o lsc niu u i ne th L , s h i n e e a sls n o re g isGo ge o t o s c c n bo da t go d fmaino a2/ b ss cnrc c n elt n , u lt n , r fa dIs bd ra c si f ea t n 47 a i;o t t a c l i s h mi i sgi , n ot is n o a ao io e a e se a dc niu ie aa la o tn dwi i tepanis' caaino D ma e .Go ges n ud n o t e r p rby s ule t n h litf ' lrt f a g s' o l' n r i h f De o ' eecs o ic p lepwesa Go geMa sa dPa e wi iter e 4 1drcoyassa c x rie fl i oi o r t o l p n lc s t n h in w 1 i tr s i ne lt c i h e t a s h mea talrv k dMrBa k b iesle s u d r l a Co srcinb rn eigi d ce cu l e oe . lcs ul r i ne ne Ca B y nt t y e d r t y d c uo n io ea l o ad o- -o r r o mo t b ss Panisr hst f ecmmeca s e c wee n p rbe n o rod o wod f uh a i. li f i t o r o rilp e h r t tf g e i ig du o a dtk na yb Go ge Th ratrtePani h sp se a Go geh r i mpn e p n n ae wa y o l. ee f ,h litf a uh d t o l adn e f e uo o ag me t sGo gemia pidto eCa Ba Co srcind fmain t Mr.Ba k ' sl ru n a o l s p l h s I y nt t ea t s o s lc s Cat e Rofg,peu byirtltn( le.mmeitlatrin sia ant ol, ols oi ' rsmal neaii mai)I daey f fig utg isGo geGoge, n, ao c el cu sl a trae e t iv siaepaniso lewrig whc iwelo u ne ite o ne h d he tn d o ne t t litf ni ins ih s l c me td n h g f n t d poedns(elrtnoG.lc.F r nh paniblvdGogewa atcigpanisfr rce ig Dc ai f Bak) o mots litf ei e o l s t kn litf o a o . f e a f hswrig ,olwigac nes t nwi Go geslg le tatri gtecmpan. litfsa i in sfl n o v rai t o l' e a d p.f fi h o litPani i t o o h e l n f nw wre a dma h v oera tdi in rn e f srt n o tesrs o ta mo n i t . e ir n y ae v r ce ng oa c ,r t i , rh tes fht me tn i t e u ao me V. o lCas dTh Ditit ut ros Go ge u e e sr Co rErr c 9 . 6 , pln t- u l eua Zptat)tn a' bt ! 4 ' slè I t t ' l I l 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 g j o 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 T ec mpan a dp p r e tnieyd c me t o panistidfr nh a db n o e h o li n a es xe sv l o u n h w litf r o mo ts n et v r t f e . b cwad t igt c mmu iaewi Go get sv ter u ies s h me a dIeio d bt a k rs rn o o nct t o l o a e h ib sn se , o , n i l o ' u y h vh , Go gesmpyin rdpanisfrh s k o ter wnpoieig T efs d fmaina ant I o l i l g oe litf o te a e fh io rfe r . h it ea t g isCa f t n r o Ba Co srcinma b i p rt eb ac n u r u wrn fl p se a ant litf rte ta y nt t y e n atr y o s me b t ogul otd g is panis ah rh n uo u y f ie tytiv s Go getee f r otdwrn fl d fmain f m ' I yCo srcin' d ni he e . o l h rat p se o gul ea t s r ' Ba ntut ' t e ybe o o Ca o a ant' sl Ro f g' s p rt a ddsic p d t tia t n Ca t Ro fgis p rtl g is ' t oi ' e aae n i n t a y o hs ci ; sl oi s e aaey Ca e n a t o e n Ie s di Ca a dn t i lrnn mesy t Ca B yCo srcin Go gea anin rdpanis i n e n . n o smi i a tl o I a nt t . o l g i g oe litf c a e uo f iq i t c r c tia alg d Fo pani'e p r ne teCS B teB , n Ya o aI n ur o or ths s l e . rm litf x ei c ,h L ,h BB a d h o I y e e fs e cmmu iaewi b sn se a dpoeso asa amatr f b de c t Iw - b t o Go ge o nct t uie ss n rfsin l s t o o e in e o a h e u nt o l' , Go gea p rnlb lvsiib y n teIw, e a s o ter n r u p p lrya dsz . h o l p ae t ei e ts e o d h a b c ue fh ie omo s o uai n i T e y e t e pani ag e i dsrt o dta mu hlre U. e tiss c a b ns d awi blo so litf ru d n i i c u h t c ag r S. ni , u h s a k ,e l t i n f f tc t e h l i s niv d t ta scin d i b t r sih lrs o sbea da c u tbeiawrn fl c i e st e aa rna t s al u ae tled e p n il n co na l f o gu ats i o y l bo g toter t ninb ab sn s o p t n Panisb lv tedsrt o rern o sy ru h t h iat t y u ie s r ar . litf ei e h itcc ut ro v u l eo o f e i ds se paniscmpanwhc alg dn meo svoain o lw. eoetedsrt o r imisd lit o lit ih l e u ru ilt s fa B fr h i i c ut l e o tc , Go gep tot amila igc aln et teCo nct n Dee c Ac b tkn afwle o l u fr s dn h l g o h mmu iai s c ny t y a ig e i s h e e o n f m tec mpan o t feta c rigy d fn emi i ce tec ut atnint b lvn te r h o lit u o tx; codn l, ee s s r td h o r t t o ei ig h o de s eo e cmpan wa ati p r c ueo at na ant o l.T efc itec mpan d e n t aea o lit s hr at a s f ci g is Go ge h ats h o lit o s o h v d y o c u eo at nfr ea t na dnv r nin ati p d . T edsrt o dod r s o l a s f ci o d fmai n e e me t s hr a y h itc c u res h ud o o o d i 1 teeoeb ajdctda ern os r gisl .T ep iis eeetl tjdmet nh 9 hrfr e dui e s r e u o aanta h lnf w r ni doug no te a o w a tf t e 2 pe dn sa ant o l a ta, o ads sa o tematrT epanisaea kn teNit 0 la ig g is Go ge tr ln t imi l fh t . h litf r sig h nh e i s f 2 Ci utorvretadsrt oderr n gatug nfr lnis 1 r it ees ht i i cu r ad rnjd meto p itf. c tc o af 2 2 V1Go geAd ie T a Panis f . o l vs s h t lit f 2 3 H dOte R me e A L w a h r e dis t a 2 4 1. 0 Go gesg et litf c udc u trh n g t eb sn s rve wi p siecmme t, uta o l u g s panis o l o ne te e ai u ies e iws t oiv o ns bth t f y h t 2 5 v r smpyib da vc a dn tre Su g sigta b sn se p s psterv wst c u tr ey i l s a die n o tu . g et h t uie ss o t oiv ei o o ne n i e 2 6 n g terve wo l b ad c pieb sn s pat eid n b paniso e e oce t tdb e ai eiws ud e ee t uies rci f o e y litf r v n rh sr e y v v c f a panis Ad io alten g terve a i u aen t nwea l ia yme nn fl ne a litf. dt n l h e ai e iws ts e r o a s rbe n n a igu ma n r s f i y v s 2 8 7 ' p lnsn r al bt ! - peatfbn l eua l I fl' t t t 1 te as siaepanisb sn se a dcaa trPlitf lg dic mpan a drb t h y sasn t lit u ie ss n h rce. ani al e n o lit n e us l f e 2 hrtfrtawhte toes cldrv w aehoo cn,hyaesl deti cnet eeooe ht ehrhs o al ei s r r r o ' e r t avrs g otn e e t i in 3 slidf mtep bc tag b Gogeadsb ctteavrs gI s iiteU S oit r h ul a lre y o l n uj to h deti a wtn h . . ce o i e in w h 4 bcuete' ue icnuci wt piavdsmetht r uee adufitte ea s hye sdn ojntn i ad de i ntaae nvn n naro h r o h e 5 panisTh a v dsn s h mea Go geMa s a d mo srtdiAp eln'Bifnd tiae lit . e de iig c e t o l p , s e ntae n p l t r i eal r l as e , 6 wio t n ra o a l d utn t v no fic mp tin T a fc o tics iu c nrv d db t u a y e s n be o b, o ee rar o eio . h tat fhs ae s n o t e e y h t o 7 Go gea tefc ice r gn tmp a h bea dv r rlv nt tepaniscu e o a t n o l s h ats lai o i e ca l n ey eea to h litf a s s f ci . n f o 8 11 Go geh sd v lp ds e ileain hp wi tep bifr i coysyea v rsn t fclae o l a e eo e p ca rlt s is t h u l o dr tr tl d etig o a i t o h c e i i t 9 tesl(etopanis aysl add o- -or rsetgefr t ohr. oge sl h a t f fli f d i a s n orod o popci f t o tesG o ls el e h ) tf l e t. n os ' s j o panist d n met panisIc lo ei r whc e a lstoec mpto'a dp i litf r e a o litf oa c mp tos i n be h s o ei r n ad f a f t h ts 1 1 a v ds r a e p s r t panisd i iq ie f m c nu r vaGo gesh mep g . hsi de i s n x o ue o litf al n ur s r o s mes i o l' o a e T i n e f y i o 1 2 . paniso iinin th fnt no a ltre ifr t npo ie b tah rh t f po u t litf pno s o te u ci f n nen tnomai rvd r u rte ta o a rd c f o o 1 3 Go geis l ga dpo t ga apoie''n t na t yati p r . h s at b Go geae o l s el n rmoi s rfe ri o a cb hr at T o e cs y o l r i n n t ,s t d y 1 4 d n whl Go geites mema e v r a s sge t am t panisb wa o s li dpoo c n oe i o l nh a e n ue c ue ra h r o litf y y f oit r r o f ce 1 5 a v dsn c ne trm tep bia Iret ac mp n tea v rs me t ia u ee a dufi de i g o tn fo h u l tag o co a y h dete nsn n n v n n nar i c i 1 6 ma n ro rstepani'b sn se . h s at b Go gebane s itre eu o te n e twad h litf u ies s T ee cs y o l rilsl nev n p n h fs y 1 7 v g f f t ay 1 s btni r hso panisi c mmec . tepani g e d o- -o r eie s nil tak d 8 u sa te i t f litf n o re As h litf o s o rod o h s se t l rce 1 b Go geMa sa dPae vac n u rn ur a do ls ta Go gema s lpani'g o wi 9 y o l p n lc s i o s me iq i n ny o h t o l y el litf o d l y fs l 2 a dwodo mo t a v rsn efr t oh r ntob h lflnifr n c nu r a u q aie 0 n r f uh detig f t o tes o t e epu i nomig o smés s n u lid i os f 2 se c ma a talc u eh r a c n u r ma b rdrce fo A+rtdc mp ne twad 1 p eh y cu l a s am s o s mes y e e i td rm ae o a is o rs y e 2 to ewh b lv byn pani'ta en mefo Go geiehc lAd i n l, s aycne t 2 h s o ei e uig litf rd a rm o l s tia. dt al mot n o tn e fs i y o 2 ac mp nigtepanisbsn s ifr t nia itre t na dd fmainb c ueee a 3 co a yn h litf u ies nomai s nnev ni n ea t e a s v n n f o o o 2 itre ig p d sg e t gab y r e a oh r i a tes met pani i pyialwrigu 4 nevnn a y u g si ue g t nte bd th a i litfs hs l in p n me f cy t 2 ac nrc,sd fmaoyt as ls n F rhte s npanisb lv tec uth udod r 5 o t ti ea tr o ae ma . o ta ra o lit ei e h o rso l re a l e 2 Go geMa st b sln, r te s b s rialc r c a dipo e od r e a v dsn te 6 o l p o e i to a la t e ugc l or t n n rp r re wh n d e iig h e y e 2 b sn s e a dpoe so so oh r wio th ip r sin Isatalteie t no mot IIw 7 u ie s s n rfs in f tes t u ter emiso .t cu l h n ni f s aIa h ' y t o 2 i c mmec a dtepanisb lv tec u mute t i Go gei ta rs etSh do ta,h 8 n o re n h litf ei e h o d s rsr n o l n h te p c. o fh tte f e a 8 ?peJ !l9rt l?ta ApInsn.ta k1l I s a )l l t ' ' .t 7t 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 mae solb ajdctda a ufibs espatea do fl avrs ga al e i t r hu e dui e s n na ui s rcc n/ra e deti s lgdn t d a r n i s in e cmpan. o ma yma yy as i b e at dt ni teU. t alwf ec mmeca se c , o litF r n n e r,t e n r io n h S.o l r o rilp e h ' s ai o e wodo- uhmak t g a ds lspo p cigwi o t iub neo u fiitre t nb Ire r-f t rei , n ae rs et t u ds ra c r narnev ni y ag mo n n h t o c roaemaktocsa db sn s sc a Go ge Ic. op rt re fre n u ie s uh s o l,n . 1. 2 Go gesg etdpanisc udseti p de ipanisb lv terve aefl .ntic s o l u g se litf o l u hr a isf litf ei e h eiws r as I hs a e f d f e e ta int not nfr litf. sae iAp eln,Brf n ic mpan, o l Ma sc ue h ts o a pi o panis As ttd n p l t i a d n o litGo ge p a ss o f as e e omo sf a ca d ma e v r q ikyb c ueo Go gesmaktoc p n t t n srn t, n n r u i n il a g s ey ucl e a s f o l' re fre e er i , t gh a d n ao e p p lryo ter 1 drcoysyep biain a alg d Ap ro o c n u r t awe st o uai fh i4 1 i tr tl u l t , s l e . es n r o s me wi b i t e co e h e d fmigpani'b sn se wo l c ueIl,f n , a g a dmeeyg u n te . h ea n litf u ies s ud a s ie ia y d ma e n rl o n oi d T e fs t t c panisd ma e aec ue drclb Go ge Ic'p we a dternevnina alg di litf a g s r a s d i t y o l,n . o r n h iitre t s l e n f ey s o e c mpan. h d ma et panisiGo ne slnino naniss btnier hst c mmeca o litT e a q o litf s o ls i cn f litf u sat i t o o ril f e f v n se c . o lsitre t nn t nvitr pspanis lsne e tt nb t lotk sa v n e h Go ne nev ni o o l ner t litf ae rsnai u as a e wa o u f o nanish r efr o pop cina Go nes l hss lsla st oh r iit . o l' litf ad f t f rse t s o l el i ae e d o tesl iv Go ges f os n s ll c ag me tht litf ma s ec n u r Icsmeib c ueto ed ma e a de t n l ru n ta panis y u o s mesa k r ea s h s a g s n moi a f t o dsrs aente o ea lf m toep ro s Ia Go ges g eth pani se ac n u ro it s r o rcv rbe r h s es n .f s o l u g ste litf u d o s me fr e o f av dsn c mme tr ars etbec u o Iwwo l n v r o d n ga t gah me de i g o nay e p ca l o d fa ud ee c n o e rni o i n i rv me t o t co ac n u r Iesvn st p ys c sz a ld ma e ,nta te 'p it mpo e n c nr tr o s mesi a ig o a u h ie be a g s ise d h yd on a f 1 drclaG oladtoerkae e ipa tscmp i aFs1 . h d m g sa poel 9 i t t o g n hs i lg dn lni o ln t - T e a a e s rpr ey e s il at 3 y e l i c 2 alg daec u e b Go gesc n u t n ict cso pwe, o to eo tep bia Ire 0 l e r a s d y o l' o d c a d l ia t f o rn th s fh u l tag . 2 Go ged e ifc e t etep bifr dc ne th rb pa igto ep rosit h r wa 1 o l o s n at ni h u l o a otn tee y lcn h s es n no ams y c c 2 wh nbsn se a dpoe so saed ma e . 2 e uies s n rfs in r a g d 2 3 1. 3 F d emoe panish v n te ev diq i o a yrp r f m cn u r cn enn ad fcïe u h r r, litf a e o rc ie n ur r n e ot r o s mes o c rig eet f y so v 2 4 roi poet n a panis hwpofht oldfme pa tf bsnse teeso lb of g r cad s li f so rotaGo g ea d lii' ui ssh r h q e n j tf e nfs e d 2 5 n ne fr liisog sacigfr bcr ptnilhdpre irlfPa tfbtejy o ed o p nf t o e rhn o osue o t ti atsn ee. lnis oh no a tf e a r i i if 2 p r c rptt n wi A a dA+b sn s rt g a teBB a dIe sn a e ce . 6 ef te uai s t n e o h u ie s ai s th B n i n ig g n is n c 2 7 2 8 V1. litf Cael u i e c a l 1Pani' s s nmpa h be fs Ag is Dee d nsOnT eMei an t fn a t h rs t 9 zp'1l lfr aT bl I t r1rsnol 1t tt t eat - e t n a 1 . 14 Th cs b fr teNit Ciutsv r mei r u . s aIa sso at nwi itec mpan ae e a e eoe h nh r ii ey roi s Mot Ic ue f ci t n h o lit r c to o h 2 3 a mie t o u c nrvd db d fn a t wi tee c pino Vilt no Lw. eo ia d t d o r no toe e y ee d ns t h x e t f oai f a B lw s t h o o 4 s mmayo e c c ueo at nirb t lo' fn a t p leGo geIc'AnweigBif u r f a h a s f ci n e ut t ' e d n- el o l n . s r r . o a De Ap e s n e . 5 Mirpe e tt n se rs nai o 6 1. 5 7 T s ce di ac uefr se rs nainpanismut rv ted fn a t ma emaeil o u ce n a s o mirpee tt litf s po e h ee d ns d tr o f a 8 mi ttme t. i tGo geMa sp bih dd fmaoyav rsn c ne tne d dt d fmeCa s ae ns Fr : o l p u l e ea tr d etig o tn itn e o ea s s s i I 9 B yCo srcino Ca t Ro f gsb sns a v ds met ss o itepanisIfr l r f a nt t n sl oi ' u ie s de i n a hwn n h litf noma Bi , uo e n e f e j (tce tp2oteifr lrfom)Cat R oigiasprt addsicbsns etywi o at hdo . fh nomabi fr . sl of s eaae n it t uies ni t a e e n n t h 1 s p rt dsic o es i a dIe sn iteSaeo Ca. emirpe e tt niGo ges 1 e aae i n t wn rhp n i n ig n h tt f .Th se rs nai s o l' t c o 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 ' ' ' ' 4 o ' % ' o n =' % 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 rp biaino s id fmaina anth wrn p r . anisb lv ic ntue Ie i i' e u l t f ad ea t g is te o g at Plitf ei et o si tsi lnt co o y f e t b s srtsfr ac rigt po f n alg sia a u fib sn s pa tea dmirpe e tt n tcetom codn o ro a d l e t s n nar uies rci n se rs nai . i e c o Se o d Go ges li fralws po ts a de te f m tep biu q aie se c a c n ; o l oit o, l , rmoe , n ni s r h u l n u lid p e h s cs o c o c f a vdsn c ne to teb sn s a dpoe so sa Go geMa sa dPae . h s de iig o tn frh u ie s n rfsin t o l p n lcs T o e a vds me t d n wio t emiso aerfr dt wi itec mpan a ' uts de ie ns o e t u p r s in r eer o t n h o lit sc r y h e h o e dete ns. o l up d d t n h i' i o imis' a te rga up s s i a vrsme t'Go gep ro e wi iter' t nT Ds s'h th po rmsp ro ewa h Mo o t sae p bilt 'epc n u r ma emoeifr dc oc s' litf eiv sta sae n b ttd u l y o ' l o s mes k r nome h ie.' ani b l e ht ttme t y c h p f e Go geiap bimirpe e tt no ter rd c t c nu r b c ueu q aie se c ue o l s u l se rs nai fh ipo uto o s mes e a s n u lid p e h sd c o f ia v rsn teb sn s o poe so so oh r ih r ut c n u r a Go geMa s T ii n d etig h u ie s f rfs in f tess amflo o s mes t o l p . hss i b cuecnu rma b adaeitics s yd iue ,rnerpe f m by gpo ut ea s osmes y e n r nhs ae wae , jrd o i r tdr ui rd c n tu o n s fo welsa lh dc mp ne wi p r c rp tt n b u q aie a du mo i rds e c i rm letbi e o a is t ef te uai s y n u lid n n nt e p e h n s h e o f o fv r f o lsp i a v ds r wh b lv ta p rh sn teie tyo oh r iehc lTh s a o o Go ge ' ad d e ies o ei e h t uc a ig h d ni f tess tia. oe e t s mec nu r otnf dte ev spa e ih r wa , o o lb wrn cocsc ue b a o s mes f i h ms le lcd n ams y n t ny y o g h i a sd y e n e u q aie se c , u as b Go gesh vn e te ac n u rnoma igac mme t ih n u lid p e h b t lo y o l' a ig ni d o s me it k o n whc f c n Itr rv st b bane so ta c ue ge t am t absn s o poe so . o l i rpyt ae po e o e rils rh t a s s ra h r o uies r rfs in Go ge n e l o Apeln'Bif cu l s g et litf c uds eto ec nu r ise do Go ge Co s mes p l t r atal u g s panis o l u h s o s mes nta f o l. n u r as e y f 1 0 zpeIns(fr aI bi' - a -l' f t zpl t 1ti lt ttl ï k 1n e a ig n rlrnt waeo Go ge p re t no teCD a dtearyo ic b h vosb Go ge n e ea ae 'a r f o ls ec pi fh A n h r fl i e a ir y o l, o a lt i 1 p ia v ds r, n oh r a Go geMa s F rh s rao s panisb lv ter a s o at n ad d e ies a d tes t o l p . o tee e sn ,litf ei e h ic ue f ci f e o 2 fr se rs nainiv r s u d Mic if t o l Ma sas pe e t a c beds ue o mirpee tt s ey o n . s he a Go ge p lo rv ns mia l ip t o 3 rslt nb t e b sn se a dpoe so aswi c n u r't d io alitrut ad eoui ewe n u ie s s n rfsin l t o s mes ia dt n l nerps n o h , i y 4 5 dsry slsadteef ri jb. et s ae,n hrat kl os o e l s 6 7 8 9 $ o j j 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 Bra ho Co ta t e c f nrc 1. 6 Go geb itre t n be ce ac nrc b t e tepani'b sn se a dacnrc o l ynevni , ra h s o t t ewe n h litf uie ss n o t t o a fs a panish v wi tep o ec mp n c n enn tepani'Wht P g ltgo ter u ie ss litf a e t h h n o a y o c rig h litf i a e ii fh ib sn se . f h fs e sn Panissae id caainta te ween t bet f da yhn itea re n wi Wht litf ttd n e lrt h th y r o a l o i ntig n h ge me t t i f o n h e P g sta alwsGo get tk teWht P g It go panisb sn se a drp bihte ae ht l o o l o a e h i a e ii f litf u ie ss n e u l h m e sn f s o lefrh p ro e o s ln a v rsn t oh r. h at fe u lhn te ipo ii db ni o te up s s f elg det ig o tes T e co rp bi ig h m s rhbt y n i i s e teIg l oie p bih do leb Wht P g su ls Go geo sWht P g swhc inth h e a n t s u l e ni y i a e ne s o l wn i a e ihs o te c s n e e cs . h alg t n a wel s mot Ialg t n wi itecmpan, r u c nrv r db ae T e l ai , s la , s aI l ai s t n h o litwee n o t et v e o e o h o e Go nea Go gerldwh l u o i ntfrhr p de . h p biaino panisb sn s o l s o l ei ol p n mmu i o ti a is T e u l t f li f uies e y y d co tf p o eIt g id f e wi iAp eln'Brf sati n r itre icbe c o c nrc h n i i s s ei d t n p l t i a hr at nev nn rah f o t t sn n h as e d v a ie T n o sin be nrcs' h a is . w t p ru n t teU. C. tl 2- lsu d r'h L wOfU c nco a lCo tatbT eI ce us a to h C. Arc Sae n e ' e a a flws sol : o Ucc. tl2- ae ' eeti pr itretncue ucnc nbetr tacnrc .. Arce S ls Whr hr al nevni ass no si al emso ot t i d y o o a btenohrtectl yI th apiainoayucnc nbetr a taoday ew e tesh oz ma i te pl t fn nosi al em so vi n r mi co o u c nco a lrs l' n o sin be eut' . Go gea mie wii ter' t nt Di s'olt gmio so b sn se a dpoeso sa d o l d t d t n h i' i o s s' ii l n f uies s n rfsin n t h Mo o mi t s n l i aannvrepne t tealgtn tatoeItg weedn wiotemiso (afk gb gi ee rsodd oh l ai shths ii s r oe t u pr sintfci y e o sn h r in dfi na dtidiApeln'Bi)Plitf bsnse hv cnrcswi WheP g sfr eit s eal n pl t rf anis uiess ae otat t i ae o ni o e a s e. f h t c n u r o v ne c o l. o l be c e ta c nrc b tkn panisn me a des a d o s me c n e ine ny Go ge ra h s h t o t t y a ig litf a , d rs, n a f p o en mb rrm tep o eIt g o tieo ta c ne to u ea Go geMa sa dPa e . h n u e fo h h n ii s usd fht otx fr s t o l p n lc s sn Go gesp ro eit u iu lie typani' b sn se a dmio so oh r. o ltee f r o l' up s s o nq eyd ni litf uies s n l n f tes Go ge h rat f fs l i e cetsucncoaltr adrkfr litf a alg ditiIwsi('13bl )Pani rae no sinbeems n i o panis s l e nhsa ut$ - eo . litf s f e s w f 1 1 /pelnsIfl aReutl lpl t non l bt k a m a . 1 s tdid c rt nw i ic ddehbsta h'p cdteC L (0) hn nmb rnte te n elai , h hnl e xii,ht e l e h S B 80 poe u e i h a a o c u t da 2 Gog M p Itgo cuts a vrsmetf aB yC nt ci . ole i dta(0) ol asii r or y dete n oC I a osr tn Goge dt ht80 e sn e i uo e 3 4 5 6 7 8 : l o n mb r u a dc a g dib c t pani'oiialasg e p o en mb r t i Pa e . u e o t n h n e t a k o litf r n l sin d h n u e a Wht g s fs g y e Go geipe e t sibo d at gteCa B yCo srcinsp o en mb r niea e idb o l s rs nl tl ra c si h I a ntut ' h n u e o l s dt y y l n o n e Go ge Go gese st u iu lie tyb sn se b ter sin dpo en mb r' ssae i o l. o l e k o nq eyd ni u ie ss y hiasg e h n u es a ttd n f , Ap eln' Bifh r e i h n rd o ' sl R oig b sn se wi iteUntdSae a dte p l t r tee xs u de s fCat o f ' uie s s t n h i tts n h as e t e n h e tlp o en mb r aeteo lu iu c aatrt . litf alg da de hbe ta Go ge ee h n u es r h ny nq e h rceii Panis l e n x iid h t o l sc f e t be ce panisp o ec nrc a e c rtdf mtec mpan b lw a dtecmpan wa ra hd litf h n otat s xepe r h o lit eo n h o lit s f o ac mp ne b aWheP g sIg lico ueite' caaino G. lc 'olwigte co a id y i a e e a ds ls r n h ' lrt f Ba k' l n h t De o fo c mpan whc po ii terp biaino Wht P g spo ut b oh r. litfttdtifc o lit ih rhbt h e u l t f i a e rd cs y tes Pani sae hs a t s co e f 1 iidsi cutt 1, . wiite'E LR TONO G R BA Kwtehbs truhLa d 1 tn irtora:2 p 7 tn h D CA A I F A Y LC , i xii A ho g ' n tc h h t 1 tefc iu c nrv d db Go ge E c rtfo dsrt o rrc r aea flws 2 h ats n ot e e y o l. xeps rm i i cute od r s ol : o tc o 1 3 '2Sissio s fh D fnatmarg op bcItg,d b ohricmptina d ' .tlupc u o te eedns rae f ul ii sas y tesn o ei ,n 1 l i i i sn t o cnu reeae cnetdc e iJn 21 tcekte4 1drc ri.h Whe osme gnrtd otnIei dn ue 00 o hc h 1 i ty. te i d eo e t j 4 adY lwP gsIg li lsrsa i e me tmete w u nt nter rdc n el ae e ads oue st e do hy ol owathipo ut o c s d ue wi aypo utr ev eta inthi. ueeog I sr h.h ttl ote sd t n rdcosri ht oter S r nuh wa i tT eoai fh h c s s g t y 1 5 4 1 icoy o n ue id re drclf mo e pbi e poeItgite 1 dr trcmmo l sds ei d i t r ns ulhd hn ii nh e y v e yo s sn WheP gsTefleadsl ueocpr ha dt d despbi e b WhtP gs i ae. h ul gli o r foyi tn r e rs ulhd y i ae t I cs g a s e 1 6 iatce hrta (xiiK) s t hd eeo sEh t '' a b' . ' 1 pani a dt n l sae tecam a dalg ds e ileain hp wi tep bia Irewi ite 7 litf d io al ttd h li n l e p ca rlt s is t h u l tag t n h f i y e o h c h 1 c mpan whc weeic roae it aIa sso at nic mpan a flws 8 o lit ih r n op rtd no Ic ue f ci n o lit s ol : o o 1 9 2 0 'j)T eo fnatGogeIc'bsns rve pormmigIt nlefr ulve n ' h eedn, o l,n. uieseiw rga n i ö i o pbi iwig 2 s s n c 2 1 bsns nme,d rse,n poenmb r.'h Panicned teD fnatGogeIc, uies a sadessa d hn u es.' e li ; otnsh eed n, ol,n. .T t ib freabimaktoc,asn Pani'bs esocntnlmoirn Io oe U s yoc,l t refrecuig li fs ui s t osat no ado k vrt e tf n y t s soles a ntob a uhdb uko nItre sucsadtatepateofrigs l h u ro s ot e mbse y nnw nento re n hth rci focn mal d c ' In bsdbs esst bcmeItre swy ositsa ufibs espate ' ad ae ui se o eo nenta cntue n nar ui s rci n t n c 2 2 ,2)TedfnatGogeIc,a rfsdo muilocs n truhute ' . h eedn, ol,n.hseue n l e cai shogoth 2 t p o 2 3 2 4 .. . pss m nh trmoe meit, rvnako eg dma i avdé gdrce a ati o tso e v, dae oee cnwlde a gn de in i td t x g i e tePanisbs ess' h li f ui se. tf n '3).lsoth dfnat ol,n.a hlie oty a oi pormmiga adc i . .. n hrte eednGogeIchs edt l ubw y ft rga n s ein 2 . , sf ' s dg 2 5 fcoitep iisb dn poesadinrdpanisrqetfr fio raoal atrnh lnf i ig rcs n goe l tf eusso aar resnb a tf d ' if e dsuersltnpoes i ivoaino Fdrln SaeIw' ipt/ oui rcs whl n il o f eeaad tt a . e o e t ' 2 6 2 7 '1 .TePaniale tateDfnatGogeIc,hs tsosrosme-eeae '..h l tflgshth eedn, ol,n. oeo pnocnu r nrtd ). if e c g cnetnojntnwtpiavrsmetado Iebs esrvwsisc amatrhtta otnicnuci i ad dete ns n ni ui s ei n uh t tai s o h i n n e e h 2 8 '.TePanialgshth D fnatGog ,n. fcal s cld' uts 2) h lif l etate eedn, ol Ici atlws o al c r y tf e e n o e oe etbse a edresosreai siwi tepbiaIre salhd n nosrpno rl o hp t h ul tag . i tn h c avrs gotePanisbs essob p cdo i we sewioth Pani' deti 'fh li f ui se t e l e nt b i t ute li fs in tr n a ' t h s tf 1 2 ?I'llsIfqn'Rbt l :7ell nc'a l ut 'l at l l e a v ?: - % 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 j j 1 2 pr sinwhlea grtgtebnfsoaf epoutotepbia Ig adfi t emi o i xgeai h eei f r rdct h ul ta e n al o s e n t e c r s dsls tbsnse amaeileainhp eeoeeisbte ntepbialrea d i oeo uiess tr rl o siwhr n x t ew e h ul tag n c a t s c tePa tf bsns. lii hrial etateeatcmbn tcntueav linoI h lnis ui sPanf ee lg hths cs o i o o sit iao fa if e tf n e s e t ot w udr i 1 U C4 - e.5()))adTt 1 U C5 ()) neTt 5 S 5 Sc4 a(( .n i 5 S 3a( . l e 12 l e b '.B teDfnatGogel .e lygsimen omaktgte'uts avrsn'r ' )yh eedn, ol,n , mp i a as f rei h c r y deti f 3 c on d n oe i go tePanisbsnse tePanis r hr db asmi ark frdcadsri sbig h li f ui ssh li f ae ame y su n i o po ut n ev e en tf e ' tf g s c miersne adteptnilaiytaacmpne sirk' s peetd n h oet Ibi ht co ais ad i . r ai l t s' Go gen v r nwee tealg t n wi itec mpan fr a g sidvd al, ee a des d o l ee a s rd h l ai s t n h o lito d ma e n iiu l n v r d rse e o h y tealg dr ka dd ma e i o e u o panis a dd ce e eyiq i . litf eiv ste h l e i n a g s mp s d p n litf, n u kd v r n ur Pani b l e h e s f y f e ti -at itre igbe c o c nrcc u ea an t o l Ic i mei r u . hr p r nev nn ra h f otat a s g is Go ge n .s roi s d y to UnarBu ie sPa tc sF leAd et ig fi sn s rcie /as v ri n s 1. 7 Unar u iespat e weealg da cn prdb Go geis e ileain hp wi oh r. fib sn s rci s r l e s os i y o l n p ca rlt s is t tes c e e o h .ol n aes meo tek ywod et ce a de c rtdf mtec mpan,te ' i lie a F lwig r o fh e rs xr td n x epe r h o lit h yr t iz d s o a o e ac 1 flw : o g al e l'eatts(moinl adm ntr a al e ) lni'bs essb 3 oo sG ol lgdydvs e ' t al n o eai s lg d p i fs ui se y ee a e o y l e a tf n y 1 ' nprc' oa oain t ohr) n ' fimaktoc itre tn. oge' e (c n r 4 c si y( lbrt wi tesadu a refrenevni ' o l k w' i t o a c o h nr o G n se e 1 ko eg) n Goge' te 'nue n) tesocmmi oguadueh aat. lni' 5 nwl e ad o l e i d(dcmetohrt o t nfln nti lcsPa tf d nc i wr c i fs 1 alg dac nprc b Go gec nit go sv rl lme t b gn igwi s e ileain hp i 6 l e o s i y y o l o ssi f e eaee ns e inn t p ca rlt s isn e a n h o 1 etbihn a 'nosrp no rltnhpwi tep bia Ire'sctdaoe T e 7 sal ig n' dre- o sreai si t h ul tag.a i bv. h s e s o h c e 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 c nprc iv l dac u ls e ileain hp ,o ewi p i av ds r a da oh r t te o s i yn ov o pe p ca rlt s is n t ad de i s n n te wi h a e o h e h p bib s lin a v dsn c ne to ted v lp n o a 4 1drcoysyeav rin s ls u l y oit g d e iig o tn frh e eo me t f n 1 i tr tl d etig ae c ci e s c mp in Wi itec mp in d v lp db Go ge teav rs me t aeu ee a dice il a ag . t n h a ag , e eo e y o l,h dete ns r nv n n n rdby h i o e f i f u fia Go gealwsu atn e a du q aie a v rs me t o panisb sn se 'h d ti nar s o l l n t d d n n u lid dete ns f litf u ie s ste eal s , aedsus dfl wi iteAp eln'Brf eetea v ds me t aes o t b ttdt fv r r ic se ul t n h p l t i wh r h d e ie ns r h wn o e ie o ao y h as e l Go ge I ada v rs r rte ta te'o d s a v rs me to pani'b sn se wio t o l p i d etes ah rh n h c u e y d ete n,f litf uie s s t u s i i fs h p r sin B a v dsn panisb sn se wi o t emi inGo geia v dsn as rie emiso . y de iig litf uie ss t u p r s o o l s de i g evc f h s i panisc nntpo ie T iismpyb c uec n u r vst gteav rs me t udb lv lit a o rvd . hss i l e a s o s mes iin h dete nwo l ei e f i i e ta te c udc lpanisa dg t net t o an w ro whc ig n rl ntre-as hth y o l al litf n e a si e n e o f ihs e eal otu fle f ma y a v rsn . litf aed o-od o s lsp o lo eaigi ara n ma n r n trei d etig Panis r o r -o r ae e pe p rt n o mig n e a d ag tg i f t n n s e icn ih oh o ae si a o t lv ndf rn ct s Dia c sa dtaet swi iteb y p cf eg b ro d ra n b u ee e iee t ie . s ne n rvli t n h a i f i t me h l 3 Jpnl1t1tZ'l.btI t e(' 1nIa ? a 'j 1's.i'. 1 ut f 1 ' e l . L i pe e t litffo a v dsn c mmecala dpanisd nt d e ieb c ueters ln rv n panis rm d e iig o ril n litf o o a v ds ea s h e ut g f y f i 1 aln r o s mes r nerpi s l i lid emsh litfo r a o do ee - o o , f f o 2 clisf m c nu r aeitru t n 'nsmpie tr tepanitmorw c nn t rps v n 3 o e ha pimet peceue f mcnas giN vt tdi t Pesno o B rlyut r i t p o t ns rshd l r avsi n oaoo re o l atn r ek js g n do n v a e 4 5 6 7 8 9 l o a a e a l. t r smpypani tpc l d e a ot ee o eg t u s mei sa ma y s n x mpe Pu moe i l li f y ial o s b u s v n r ih bt o t s n tf y me a t l ro et tsp r a a dwin t rpfeo sxa p it nst di toedsa c sfr swev of si e e d y n l o do i r i p onme t o re h s i n e o e ma l v v t ac li g tn bd fo e eyc nrco te f do leta'wiig Panisb sn s i aln et g is rm v r o t trh yi ni h t ln . litf u iess - i a n n s l f cn utdwh l b wodo mo t a dd o-od o a aema yto s n so oh r mal o d ce ol y r f uh n o r -o r s r n h u a d f te s l y t b sn se a dpoeso sThsids u sdid ti titec mpan, rfa dd caaino uie s s n rfsin . i s ic se n eal hn h o litbi, n elrt f wi e o G. lc. e o es c a Go geIu ce a' uts a vrsn 'rga o panisb h l Ba k Wh n n uh s o l a n h s c r y detig po rm n litf e af o e i f , s c a i tic s , ia u fib sn s pate u c nco a l, lita drd t nt u h s n hs ae is n nar uie s rci , n o sin be ei , n u e o o t c t s 1 cmmu i twi tebs eso e (lii)Miersnai dsusda17aoecmbnd 1 o nc e t h ui s wnrp nf. s peettn i se t1 bv,o i a h n a tf r o c e 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 wi acam fr e le c dsu s db l a dted fmaino panisb sn s d n drclb t li o n gi ne icse eo n h ea t f li f u ie s o e i t y h g w o tf ey Go ge o at i n gie c ,o iet maepanisc u eo at nfr nar uies o ls wn csn e l n e cmbn o k li f a s f ci o u fib sn s g tf o pa te a dflea v rsn u i e ca l. dt n l, swel ic se iAp eln'Brfte rci s n as d etig nmp a h be Ad io al a l s us d n p l t i, h c i i y d as e meh do cmme tr ao g ieteGo geMa sltg o pani'b sn se aeo ldrce a to f o nay ln sd h o l p ii s f litf u ie ss r n i td t sn fs y e pani'b sn s a dn th p i av ds r o paniscmptosa v ds do tesmewe litf u ie s n o te ad de ies f litf o ei r d e ie n h a fs f t b a e iwe y o s mes hs ks h de i nsn rdby n v n n i o rs n P g ve db cn u r.T ima e tea v ds me t ice ilu e e a dttdtwad o e e l e o teoh r fh a v ds r a d tidiAp eln'BiflsIwls a i a ei tGo ge rh te o te de i s s eal n p l t r . t a es s n n li, o l, e e as e ' t s s o s r gad gf h b tn ta o d g isd n wi p o lsIeio d gvn ret tee s ne p n oi o i t u ise d f o st o e t e pe i l o s i g i o h se c n g ' h vh i s isa go d ge t o .Asalg d panisa das c n u r s etep g sa Go geMa sa n ln f o a d g l e , litf n lo o s mes e h a e t o l p s e f av rs grte bs esrv w adp itfblv toepgssolb sb cttesme deti ah r ui s ei s n lnis eee hs ae hud e uj to h a in n e af i e a v dsn I a a yoh r u lla v dsdpo utAntigs o o ta s o l cn tuea d e iig a s n te p biy d e i rd c. yhn h d fh t h ud o sit n ws c e t ufib sn s pat e nar u ie s rci . c Ne l e c gi n e g 2 6 1. 8 Th smpee ie c o ab sn s rve alwigfr n u lid u atn e , n banes e i l xs n e f u ie s e iw l n o u q aie , n t d d a d rils t o f e 2 7 c mme tr ao g iea v rs me t alwigfr t cso panisb sn se a doh r u ie s o nay ln sd d ete ns l n o at k n lit u ies s n te b sn s i o a g 2 8 a dpoe s n liu c n co a l. o Go get in r tema yb sn s i ursb panis n rfsi ass n o sin be F r o l og oe h n uies n ie y litf o q i f 1 4 gp)lns1f1 'ReuLI A $ k ' 'o7 . -(' . at 1 .I 7t e - n. t 1 1 a 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 o 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 pirotefigo tec mpan i ngie c b y n ta whc ira o a le p ce o mu h r t h i fh o lits e l n e e o d h t ih s e s n by x e td f c o l n g Ire b snse ta Go ge Aspe iu sae idsrt o d, vnIreb nsaeh l ag r u ie s s h n o l. rvo s ttd n i i c u e e ag a k r ed tc f h ac u tbewh na po c e a dn tido wrn fl csas cae wi terrlt nhpo co na l e p ra h d n oie f o gua t so itd t h i eai si r o d aig .Th s lreb n sh n lbl n o ta s cin d i, a igta iGo ge e l s oe ag a k a de io s frn at s al me nn h tf o l n l i o y weet c niu ,t yn e t e ly eto s n so a dt n le pet po ela miie te r o o t e ima e d o mpo e h ua d f d io a p o l o rp r d ns rh n i y t po rmste ,ece tda Go geMa sa dPae . e t gto epo rmste in r gte rga h y rae t o l p n lc s Crai h s rga h ng oi h v n n rso sblista c meao gwi ter rain d mo srtsa u c nco a l r ea d ep nii e h t o ln t h ice t s e nt e n n o sin be i n i t h o a s arg n ei c roaep we o e mio so s lb sn se a dpoe so asa Go gemae a r a c n op rt o r v r l n f malu ie s s n rfs in l s o l ks o l i mo k r o teU. J sieS se a dc mmec wi iteU. .Pani ia kn teNnhCi ut cey fh S. ut ytm n o re t n h S. litfs sig h it r i c h f c freifnta rg r a panisb lv Go geMa sa te' pe e t bo da t r sse c o rl i h te ad s litf ei e o l p s h yr rs nl ra cs ae ytmi e f e e y a da anth p biitrsa dsus diA p ln' Bif n ic mpan. n g is te u l neet s ic se n p el t r a d n o lit c as e Vilt n o Iw oai s fa o 1. 9 Ne r aIa p d iigt tuhi a v dsn , nfr c mmeca cd s bsn s a dpoë so s al lIw e ann o rt n de iig u i m o rilo e , uie s n rfsin y o cd s a dteCD ds u sda oeaevoae b Go geMa sa dPlcsa wes e k Go ge o e , n h A ic se bv r iltd y o l p n ae s p a . o l 1 iifcptn teiet fh C AtatsbfrteNnhCiu whete r ece i te 7 snatutg h n n ote D o et eoe h it r i i h/e xedn h i t ct l g 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 b u d rso c iod r n o e in et lw e p ce b b sn s a dpoe so aswi ite o n ai f il re a d b de c o a x etd y uie s n rfs in l t n h e v h c mmu i a da pa te b teCS B, B F Ca doh r s c a An isLs a d Go ge o nt n s rci d yh L BB , T n tes uh s ge it n . o l y c d e n t d rs teitn a dme nn o tei nt saueoh rh nt tk io t f o txt o s o a des h ne t n a ig fh mmu i ttt te ta o a et u o c neto y s iati p r d fn en t lg dwi i pani'c mpan. litf b lv i ce r d tid ut hr at ee s o al e t n litf o litPanis ei e t lal eal d y e h fs f e ' y e s wi iAp eln' Bifhth ' nu 'f o l'po rmmigb r Go ge i nt d fne t n p l t r ta teg iso Go ges rga n as o lsmmu i ee s h as e e y 2 pr ogessl g aewiitesaueie. o l dfneo i nyo e b ter 3 e C n rse' n ug t nh ttt t lGoge ee s fmmui ji d yhi a h sf s t n 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 c n ut lg d fe itefc o teCo nct n D cn yAc a Co ge sitn e i T e o d c al e ,ls n h ae fh mmu iai s e e c t s n rs ne d dt h e i o . dsrt o dod r aeteeoef we ita te aea anth Iw p ru n t te itc c u res r h rfr l d n hth y r g iste a us a to h i a Co nct n D c n yAc. mmu i i s e e c t ao 2. 0 Go gesfreu maktnevnina da v dsn o s o swio t b sn s o esp r sin o l' oc fl re itre t n de i g f h p t u a u ie s wn r emi o , o i h s 1 2 3 4 5 slne ta s oss e c a dv ltstes btni r hso tes o o e t fe cmmeca i cs h t h p p e h n iae h u sa te i t fh h p wn ro re o ril e o v g s e c a dpia ywh nsln , rs et g a dg n rtgs lspo p csa iti cs . p e h n r c e elg po p ci , n e eai ae rse t s n hs a e v i n n Panisaeu a r o a y1w poet gter hso o les e c wh rb ta s e c iue i litf r nwae f n a rtci h i t f ni p e h ee y h t p e hs s d n f n g n a vrsn s h me l t maie b poiess c a Go get e h nea v dsn rv n e fr detig c e s wi l , y rfe r u h s o l o n a c d e iig e e u s o i h c t tepoie. o lMa sa dPae a p a t b oewh l dwi fl , se dn ,lg la d h rfe rGo ge p n lc s p e ro e v r eme t as mila ig i a, n t h e l e 6 uq afdse c ta iue,amsadd sry bs essadpoesosT ehr ipri nule peh htn rsh r , n et s ui se n rfsin. h am n at i i j o n s 7 8 9 l o b cueo tea o y u a du q aie s e c Go gep r t t a c mp n a v ds me t a e a s fh n nmo s n n u lid p e h o l emi o c o a y d e ie ns s f s c ne t u tege tr am ita Go gein rsters o sblister rga ce t t o tn b th rae h r s h t o l g oe h e p n ii e h ipo rms rae o i t c mmu i t wi toea v rs dite' uts a v rs me t' h t k sGo gea a s lt o nc e t h s d ete n h c r y d et e ns. a mae o l n b oue a h i o e i T mo se b cu ete ' tkn a v na eo mio so u ss e tgpoe so sta smpywok ntr e a s hyr a ig d a tg f l n f n up ci rfsin h t i l r e l i n 1 adpouejb. ogee rhshmsl sateep neoohrb sadn o tesbtni 1 n rd c o sG o l ni e te ev th xes ftes y tni nh usptl c e g a 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 r hso oh r, rfs in l a welsc n u r.Th u fipat e alg da ant o l ,n i t f tes poe so as s la b s mes e nar rci s l e g isGo ge i g c e s otaetewh lsl tkn o mio so p o lsb sn s a dpoe so a ie tis s eic l h r r h oe ae a ig f l n f e pe u ie s n rfsin ld nie ,p cial , l i t f y tepaniswio t emiso .T eiv so o paniss btnier hst fe e pe so i h litf t u p r s in h n a in f litf u sa t i t o re x rsin n f h f v g s ls u lwflx lit na dtet f lii's lsIa g n rt no ad i b ss n giet ae , na u e pot i n hfo panfs ae e d e eai n al a i, e l n ao tf o y g d fmainb Go gea ant litf b sn se a dsu sda oec mbn t c ntuea ea t y o l g is pani' u ie s s s icse b v o ie o o sit n o fs t ufib sn s patea da ars lie aa lh r panisg o n me rp tt n a d nar u ie s rci n s e utr p rby am litf o d a , e uai , n c r f o od l l . 9 owi Itnin lnl t no E to a Dsrs ne t a Ifci f moin l ite s o io 2. 1 Panisc nnthn o amoematruwa o s b tgn teU. e o o ta wh t o l h s litf a otik f r sefl y f a oa ig h S c n my h n a Go ge a f 2 cnre . o l h so lafwto s n e ly e whlteU. . p.f a o rp r te 2 o tv d Go ge a ny e h ua d mpoe s i h S De to L b re ot h i e s 2 eie c o a o t 00 00 0 s lb sn se a dpoe s n l rcie . litf c nevtey 3 xs n e f b u 1 ,0 ,0 malu ies s n rfsi a pa t s Panis o s rai l t o c f v 2 4 et t ta2 0- O jb ado cres r peet l tvrfwdy wiite1,0 , 0 smae ht 0 30os n/raerae rs nl o eeye as t nh 0000 i ys h 0 2 5 ta e i d et tetp o po rm mima a e n a alg da ant o l. rcoysye ht xs u o h y e f rga s n g me t s l e g is Go ge Di tr tl t e e 2 6 a v rsn sh me , uha Go geMa s aes ra igit eeyct, o ny a dsae detig c e s s c s o l p, r pe dn no v r i c u t, n tt i y 2 7 tru h u teU. q ik a da wese k R g rls o tep ia ds f r gt to s n so ho g o th S. ucl n s p a . e ades fh an n uf i o h ua d f y en 2 8 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 j c 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 b sn se a dpoe so stepiaesd o teeo o ivr moiae b iit rfe r g u ie s s n rfsin h r t ie fh c n mys ey t td yl ipoiei , v v l c t n e p calite b lv te c ng t ywi iTh r e i h r r tr so b sn se ls aI v r s e il fhy ei e h y a e b t t ee xs or soi f uie s sot Io e y e h. t o e teItre a dee s iie rs ln f m te eo lepo rmsa dan w b sn s makt f h nen t n v n ucd s e uig r h s ni rga n e u ies re o t o n rp tt nd fn esico pn u a da v dsn d i a b sn se a dpoe so asae e uai ee d r s rp ig p n de iig al s uie ss n rfs in l r o y atce o le AsteIse t e ly n aerigq ik ,t o lamatr fi b fr tee t k d ni . h os s o mpo me t r in ucl is ny t o t eoe h s a n s y' e me po rmse po et acicltt tee ypugn teU.. c n myit c a so fd e d wnte rga x ld o ria sae h rb ln ig h S e o o no h o ru h r o h t e o o clt rT epo lm iv r ra ,nfc,n14 me wees n t teU. o ac mp int c n mi at . h rbe s ey e l i ati 9 3 n r e to h S. n a ag o q s b tg fcoisa wel s'mal cso tr r m' i da Jwiho e s o sA ta mo n a oa e atr s la ' la t fer i ' me t e s-wn d h p . th t met e s os a it ,h U. s ne c dtoep o lt d ahfr a oa igAmeia b snse . e n i te S.e tn e h s e pe o e t o s b tgn r n u ie ss Th me c e t n lt s o h vn o e leio dtknf m te wto t n rc us b Go gess l moi a sr s f a ig n s i l o a e r h m i u a v e o re y o l' ef o e vh o h po li dp lep wesie t n l d v saig Go gee s nil rv k dpanisSae rcame oi o r s moi al e att . o l s e t l e o e litf tt c o y n ay f c nrcosle s t b i a dd v sae tewi 'Cat R oigb in r gtere p n iiis o tatr i ne o ul n ea ttd h f s sl o f yg oi h irs o sble c d e e n n i t i c mmec t ma a etepo rmste ce td T ecmbn da t alg da ddsu sd n o re o n g h rga h y rae . h o ie cs l e n i se e c h rtfr ipaniso iinaeo ta e u,a b y n teb u d o a od r c mmec l eeooen litf pno r urg o s fr e o d h o n s f n rel o ri f y a s cey a dsse ct teU. . c n mya ds us diAp eln'Bif n e p biitrs. o it, n ytmi o h S e o o s ics e n p l t r u d r u l nee t as e c 1 6 VII D fn at D fnelF tl I ee d ns ee s s aal y 1 7 1 8 Fa dAn I Vilt nOf a lwe d n oai L w o 22 Plit sbsn s ia dawa sh sb é 10A bs du o f ec mmeca se c a dd o- ani uie ss n l y a e n 0 o ae p n r o rilpe h n o ro l e t d o s lsGo ged sry panisg o wiwi n giet ea t na ditre t nu o to e o r ae . o l etos litf o d l t e l n d fmai n nevni p n h s f l h g o o f e o o c mmecas e c . o l ag e ta teI it alw u ft rds e c o te r d ms f o rilp e h Go ge rus h th a s o l net e p e h n h e w o e Itre a dta Go ged e n t weteWola o laint e s r ta se c o teltre i nent n ht o l o s o o h r n bi t o n ue h t p e h n h nen ts d go a c rt.ntiisa c Go geiv rwrn a o th ta panisaen t waeo a yIwsite c uae I hsntne o l s ey o g b u ta,s litf r o a r f n a n h f U. ta poet p e hu e d r gtec mmis no a ie tytet n a v dsn sa Th S.h t rtc se c s d ui h o si f nd ni h fa d de iig cm. e n o t v r CD IgsainGo gectswa catdb teU. Co ge sa aIw,oalwwe se t ey A e ilt o l i s rf y h S. n rs ,s a t l b i s o o e e o t rmo eh r uc ne trm teItre wio te r figt nfr e s r gtese c o se e v amflo tn fo h nen t t u fa o Iiai o c n oi h pe h f i h t o n t u es T elwsitn ice r yd f io a dpe ieyitn e t pee t n p ns t fcig s r. h a ne ts la b eit n n rcs l ne d d o rv n a d u ih r fkn , ni ai sakn , n h rsigo teItre. o lipe e t e g g dito eat a dc n uth tlig a d aasn n h nen tGo ge s rs nl n a e n h s cs n o d c te y 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 1 7 r)èIl:ï':)I.tLtI :))ê; I1- p1ïiC -:(.'5 't6i1th' 5t l ù )-- 2!t; k! )' 39 ( t 1 C Aiatmpi t dtrIint cnetr adso lnt eam t ro dsrt no te D s t tgo ee.ts oa ojcue n hud o b at fr i ei frh e n e c o 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 c utwi rg r t tesauoyitn itiisa c . c s e itepo e Ih ib c me o r t e ad o h tttr ne tn hsn tn e On e e n n h rp ri tt e o s s h g meeya ee nayc s o whte Go ge 'csaewrn fl n n t matr f o l'alg d rl n lme tr ae f eh r o lsat r o gu a d o a t o Go ges l e e e i nt u d rh saue Ap eln'Bif raso th s e icyo teCD ds us ste mmu i ne te ttt. p l t r be k u te p cfi fh A, ic se h y as e it s p rblyo sauoyca s s a dd f e teat b Go geia c ra c t teE gih e aa i f tttr lue , n ei s h cs y o l n c od ne o h n l i t n s dcin r d f io a dlw. op tt i l,g oigpanista iq i wh nGo geiu igter it ay eit n n a T u ismpy in r litf htn ur e ' o l s sn h i o ni n f e b sn s ie tiswi o t emi int s lter ae Ia sa dpo p cigt oh r ia u ie sd ni t u p r s o o elh is lse d n rs e t o tess n t h e s n u c nco a l at fh fa dds b de c frh Iw. n o sin be c o tet n io e ine o te a 9 j co cu in x n lso 1 0 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 1 7 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2. 3 Unetrdse c o teItre is p o e b panis a ia o y t, n teCo nct n ft e p eh n h nen ts u p d d y li f , ss n n mi a d h mmu iai s e tf y o Dee c Ac.I tiisa c a dcru tn etepapisaen t waeo a yU. Iw c ny t n hsn tn e n i msa c h litf r o a r f n S.a c f o fs a n me tih ta poet tiv r,a kteig o teg nu o Go geMa sa dPae rit me d n r th t rtcs he ey rc ee r , rh e is f o l p n lcs r g n a o tn diAp eln'BrfGo ge ag me to i nt t al u ft rds e c o s ule n p l t i . o ls ru nfrmmu i o lw net e p e h n i as e y o e teItre a db lfhth yc nn t osbymo i rh iq ie f m bsn se a d h nen t n ei ta te a o p sil nt te n ur s r uie s s n e o i o poe so ast is r a crc wi iter rga idsn e u u . o l ismpya tgi rfsin l o n ue cua y t n h ipo rmss iig n o s Go ge s i l ci n h n od roaodad t o dt tebsn s o poe so a c mmu i,a itic s . re t v i uy we o h uie s r rfs in lo nt sn hs a e y 2. 4 Go geisln apo ut t o l Ma sa dPa e ,ntic s tepo utsc mmeca o l s elg rd c a Go ge p n lcs i hs ae h rd ci o ril i av rsn rte ta Go gep r r n tefnt no smpypo iigifr t ni ap bi detig ah rh n o l ef mig h u ci f i l rvdn nomai n u l i o o o c fr tPanisaeu a r b a ylw,ttt, re uains p o igtepo o i nta oma. litf r n wae f n a saue o rg lt u p dn h rp st h t f o i o i nt e tn st i nzn ac mp n ta isln apo utTh dsrt o dod r, ol mmu i xe d o mmu iig o a y h ts elg rd c. e itc c u reswh l y i i y lc meia daeb ldb tefrg iga p aa dag me t, ste in r tep biitrs. a k r n r ei y h oe on p e l n ru ns a h yg oe h u l nee t t e c T eeaea e t td1 mio s lb sn se a dpoe so asiteU. e lyn miin o h r r n si e 0 l n mal u ie ss n rfs in l n h S. mpoig l s f ma l i l o p o la crigt teU. D p. f a o. h ie lg o afwto s n Go gep o ltkn e pe codn o h S. e to L b rT e d oo y f e h u a d o l e pe a ig a v na eo mio so p o lsIeio d i apoieigs h mema e tedsrt o dod r d a tg f l n f e pe i l o sn rfe r ce l i vh t n ks h i i cu res tc 2 ujsadufit p iisadtebs escmmu i alre Pa tfaeak gteNnh 7 nut n naro lnf n h ui s o ny tag . lii r si h i a tf n t nf s n t 2 8 1 8 ApelnsIfr aReutl pI L nol l bt a m a 1 Cru t rv wtepoedn s n rvreteI e cu b gatgajd meto pa tfo i io ei h rce i ad ees h o ro d y rni ug nfr liis n ct e g w n nf 2 3 4 5 6 7 tepe dn sa drc rsi panisfv r h la ig n e od n li f ao. tf 2. 5 Go geh snt o d ce dso eyte'eo lrp ae ta pani'd ma e ma b c ue b o l a o c n utd icv r,h y ny e e td ht litf a g s y e a s d y v fs oh r, n ee sae ta paniss o ln t ealwe t se kbfr teNit Ci utF r tes a d v n ttd h t litf h ud o b l d o p a eoe h nh r i o f o c. to era o spanisb lv Go geso l nt ee tldt c s,e afe , r n oh rom h s e s n litf ei e o l h ud o b ni o otlg le so a y te fr f e t e o rlfitimatr fei n hs t . e e 2 6 8 F rh mo t at mal uies sa dpoeso asaeh lls wh nd sry db drcoysye o te s p rs l sn se n rfsin l r epe s e et e y i tr tl b o e 9 a vrsn po rms T e d n t aergsee t d mak ,aeIc lnntr, n n t aty det ig rga . h y o o h v e itrd r e rs r oa i aue a d o we l . i a h 1 Th 0 e r w ri fmi swt fmi o ndpate. o lspwewi rgrst Gog M p /e ok g a l i a l w e rccsGoge o r t ead o ol a s n i h y e i ' h e 1 a dPa e itee s n eo c roaeeis a Go gek o to emio so s lb sn se 1 n lcss h se c f op rt lim s o l nwsh s l n f mal u ies s t l i 1 2 a dpoe so asc nn te u a Go gebok of I o nc t nfo te .K o n wht n rfs in l a o rb t s o l lcs faI mmu iai rm h m nwig a c o 1 3 Go geid igt to s n so b sn se a dpoeso sa dted ma eic ue te weg s o l s on o h u a d f u ie s s n rfsin n h a g t a s s h m ih 1 4 h ayu o panish at swel s o l a yrao a lmid dp ro .I tiisa c e v p n litf e ra lî h ud n e s n by n e es n n hsntn e f t 1 5 Go gesafmaied fne aeala e a dalg da tec n u t f teswhl a tes me o l' fr t ee ss r Ib sd n l e s h o d c o oh r i th a i v e e 1 6 t algn a a s lt Igsaiei nt. tepani in t natre ,tec s rq i s i l ig n b oue e i t mmu i As h litfs o a t n y h a e e ur me e lv y f o e 1 7 c rfle iwb tec ut n so lteNit Ci ut ge wi panisc s o teIwtematr aeurve y h o ra d h ud h nh r ia re t litf ae n h a h t c h f e 1 8 c udb smpea dpo elco e b c u ewi o th i nt Go gelce a afmai o l e i l n rp r ls d e a s t u te mmu i o l a k d n fr te y h y i v 1 9 a f i e tc 2 d fn ea tilPanisp st no teIw rq i sarv ra o tedsrt o dod r a d 0 ee s tr . litf o io n h a e ur e es lfh i i cu res n 2 jdme totepa tfo tep ai sadrcrt smp adpoelc s tecs. 1 ug nfrh lii n h l d g n eod o i l n rpr l e h ae nf s e n y yo 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 Panisdc r ud rh pn l op rr udrh I s fh U idSae tatefrg i i li f ele ne te eat fej y ne tea o te ne ttshth oeon s tf a y u w t g t ea dc r c t teb s o ter n wld e E e ue a B nca Cai ri9 5 0o Ma 1 r n or to h e t fh ik o e g . x ctd t e ii, lona 4 1 n y 0 u e f , 2 1 a drs et l s b t db fr teNnhCi ut u Of p e l 0 1 n e p cf l u mie eoe h it r iCo d A p as uy t c , ' ' x . nvu w .z / G YB A K id i yC Ia C nt cinpani AR L C , id , aB y o sr t ,li f u o tf 2 7 7 ) 7 - /( 0. ' ,. , . 2 H LB AM-L C ,niiul, at R oi ,lii 8 OLI E B A K id dal C sl ofgpans v y e n t l 9 .. ef t('i1t eutf h p.nsfI'aR ht p 1 'ln . I: ' a '. jl ' n . : z ca vp v 2 CERTI CATE FOR FI NG I P FI LI N APER FO 4 5 T 9hCic iCaeNu e 1 -6 9 t rut s mb r 0 1 9 2 6 1GayBa ka dHolB a -Blc ,etyta tefrg ig l e m ak c rf h th oe on : i i , r lc n 8 9 ' ORMAL' ' N ' AP ELLM TSujssw xsvo P y DEF ENDANT- ELLEE GOOGLEI ' APP NC. S ANS WERI BRI NG EF 1 0 1 1 iieniat tev rins b t delcrnc l a drc ie b tec ut nMa 1 , 01 . sd t lo h eso u mie eto ial n e ev d y h o ro y 0 2 1 c t y 1 2 1 3 1 4 / . / u zz r GAR B A ,n i'u l, l a Co srcin pani Y L CK idv al Ca B y ntut , litf y o f Dae t 1 5 1 6 . $ . ôlx v HOL I E B ACK,n id al, sl R oig pani L B AM- L idv u l Cat o f , lit i y e n l 1 8 1 9 2 0 2 1 2 2 2 3 2 4 2 5 2 6 2 7 2 8 Jpelnslflcl. ttl3if -pl t n'naP bial e a k' e t r A .) Dt ae zw);, p p oue? , ' 1 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 1 0 CERTI C OFSE CEB USMAI FIATE RVI Y L 1J s G. or s d cae e , o e T r , e lr: I m e lydi S a oCo ny I m oerh a eo 1 y asa dn t p d t tewii a mpoe n oln u t. a v te g f 8 e r n o a a y o h t n h at n Myb sn s a de si:4 0MiarWe ts i #14B ii Cai ri 9 51 . ci . u ie s d rs s 14 l y s; ut 0 enca, lona 4 0 o i t e f Im ra i fmia wi d p st gmal t teUntdSae P saSevc Ontid t I a e dl a lr t e o in iwi h i tts o tl rie. hs ae, y i h i h e s re o e c p r Itdb lw, d c me t nie ev d n a h at ie eo a o u n e tld: ys t 'NFORMAL' ' I ' APP ELLANTSussurrxlro rj aj n , DEF ENDANT- ELLEEGOOGLE I ' APP NC. S ANS WERI BRI NG EF Ca en . 019 2 s o 1 -6 9 B fr eoe UNI DS A ESCOUR OFAP E S TE T T T P AL F T NIT DITRI OR HE N H S CT GAR B ACKANDH L B AM- A YL OL I E BL CK PanisA p lns V. litf/p el t, GOOGL ,N , fn a t p le f a E IC.Dee d n/ ee . Ap l 1 1 1 2 1 3 1 4 1 5 1 6 On paf mteU idSae Dirt o rfrh Apelr h ne tts s i C uto te o t tc 1 7 N d enDsrtf l ri o hr i i oCai n tc f a o C s N .:0c-28-W ae o41-v0 31C 1 8 T eH nrbeCl daWie h ooa l a i l n u k 1 b pa igiit a e v o ewi fl p i p sa etee n s ae tee v lp , n 9 y lcn tno n nelp t ul ad otg h ro ,e ld h neo e a d h y 2 d lee tee v lp fr in t teUntdSae P s OfieiBe ii Cai ri. 0 ei rd h nep e o malg o h i tts o t f n nca, lona v i e c f 2 1 Wio So sn Go dih&Ro ai l n n ii o r s c st 2 2 atre sa lw t n y ta o 6 0P g MiRo d 5 ae l a l 2 3 PaoAI yCai ri 9 3 41 5 l t lona 4 0 -0 0 o f 2 4 T lp oe(5) 9-3 0 eeh n 6 04 39 0 2 Ielr ud rh pn l o pr rud rh l oteUne Sae tatefrg igi 5 dcae ne te e at fej y ne tea fh id ttshth oe on s y u ws t 2 tu a dc retEx ctda B nca Cai ri 9 1 o Ma 1 , 0 1 6 re n orc. e ue t e ii, lona 45 0 n y 0 2 1 . f 2 ' 7 ' l G Wo'ttb ftsz f 2 J s G. re 8 o e Tors P . OFS RV;FU. ..b1 R QOF E C ( S 5li. , 1 t

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?