Gary Black, et al v. Google, Inc.

Filing 23

Filed Appellants Holli Beam-Black and Gary Black objection. Served on 07/27/2011. [7836397] (MT)

R C(9 (
E F E)
f
O.ICrFTEPLA s
FCU% 0H OEP
FC 0 FA PE K
IS 0 '
J
.
T
t

NO.1 -6 9
019 2

2IJL2 F 2 k
gl(- 7 H : 8
J
UM TED S
TATESCOURT OFAP A S
M I,
l
'
F THENI DI TRI KTDDTE lll I
OR
NTH S G EE A sTzu J
î
. ..
,

GARY BL AND HOLLI AM - BL
ACK
BE
ACK

Panp /p elns
lit Ap l t
a ,
GOOGL I
E,NC.

Deed n/p ele
fna t p l .
A e

1
4
1
5
1
6
1
7
1
8
1
9
2
0
2
1
2
2
2
3
2
4
2
5
2
6
2
7
2
8

OnAp elrm teUntdSae Ditit uto te
p afo h i tts s c Corfrh
e
r
NotenDitit f lona
r r s c o Cai ri
h
r
f
CmeNo 41-v0 3 1CW
s . :0c-2 8 T eHo oal Clu i Wi e
h n rbe ada l n
k

OBJ ON
ECTI
(rcdrl
Poeua)

G YB AC ANDHOL I E B AC
AR L K
L B AM-L K
1 1 l Cor
0 Aud ut
Gre ValyF l , aiona9 5 4
en l al C l ri 4 3
e s f

(0)7-90
773326
Panisratg ' Por Proa
li f aect :I rpi esn '
tf
n n a

l'
f5
'

1

2

1
.
OnDee e 2 t, 01 tepanisfe abif t teNit Ci utic s #1cmb r 0h 2 0 h litf id r wi h nh r in a e 0
f l
e h
c

a 19 2T ecekojce t tefi otebif ae uo pg cut n cuslote
69 . h lr betdo h i g fh r bsd p n ae on ad o nefrh
l
n
e
4 dfneojce ttefigoa ybifytepanisAtr ru nsb tepre o
ees betdo h i f n r b h litf. f agmet yh ats n
l
n
e
f e
i
5
6
7
8
:
1
0
1
1
1
2
1
3
1
4
1
5

Mac 2 ,2 1tec u od rda flws
rh 1 01 h o d ree s ol :
o
'h Clk hli teoes e oei bi rci do D cmbr 02 1.'h Clrsal
' e e sall h vri d p n g rfee e n ee e 2 , 00'T e ek hl
T r fe
z
n e v
'
dsadteoeigbifrci do Jnay32 1 adJnay 02 1.
i r h pnn r seev n a ur ,0 1 n aur1,01'
c
e
e
'

F lwiga a dt fh p birc r tepaitf dso ee teceknv r o ld
ol n n u io te u l e od h lnis ic v rd h lr ee c mpi
o
c
f
e
wi tec u 'od rOnMac 21tia p aso rc r ta tecekfe abif ae
t h o ds re.
h
rh s,t p e r n e od h th lr id r d td
l
e
J n ay3whc wa od rdt b dsad d Th cekn v ridpanisoiia bif
a u r ih s ree o e ic re . e lr e e fe litf r n lr ,
l
f g
e
d tdDe e e 20ha od rd.Th d fn a t hv snerpidt tebif n te
ae c mb r t s ree e ee d ns ae ic e l o h r a d h
e
e
panisfe a o t n le lbif
lit id n pi a rpy r .
l l
o
e
2
.
S v np p r o iso teoiia De e er 0hbif r s re a dfe wi te
e e a e c pe fh r n l c mb 2 t r wee ev d n id t h
g
e
l h
cek u o tecek rq e to Mac z s;h yaec retbif, nytecersp bi
lr, p n h lrs e u s, n rh ltte r orc r s o l h l k u l
e
c

1 figierno sa divoainotecut're (o.# 4.
6 i s r e u n n ilt fh or odrD c 1)
l
n o
o
s
1
7

1
8
3
.
Plitf b lv tec rs o lc reth cek er r eoepo e dn wi a
anis ei e h out h ud orcte lrs r b fr rc e ig t
f e
o
h
1
9
.
v rit sa yv rit yb u d r n db s ivoain o tec utod r tite
edca n edc ma e n emie y ad ilt s fh o r re wi n h
o
s
h
2
0
2 rc r
1 e od.
2
2
4
.
Plitf aeteeoeakn tec u t drc n csaypo e ue t c ret
anis r h rfr s ig h o d o i t e es r rc d rs o orc
f
e
2
3
terc r a Do . 5-a ic ret fe oin l ihwa od e dsad da dpanis
h e od t c #1 n norcl id r awhc s rerd ic re n litf
y l gi
f
2
4
e
2 fd e a ktec u freif
5 u h r s h o d o rl .
2
6
5
.
2
7
Apo e rlfis e t paniswo l b a e p dt no tematr p nte
rp rei ,t e mso litf ud e n x e io fh t u o h
e
f
i
e

2 zu so moina teojcin b dfnat admifigb tecekhv u d l
8 o d wn t sh bet s y eed ns n si yh lr ae n u
o
o
l
n
y
2

1 c ue u wad o sxmo tsid ly
a s d p rs f i nh n ea .
2
3
Re pcfl s b t db fr teNit Ci ut o dOf p as
se t l u mie eoe h nh r iC u Ape l,
uy
t
c
4
z
5
D tdJl2,01
ae:u 72 1
y
GayBak idvd alpani
r lc,n i u l litf
i y f
6
'
. . - - /2.,
' - - 1,s.
,
e
.,
.t
.ot:l7201
adu2, 1
eJy
7
H lB a Blc ,n iiu l pani
ol e m a k idvd al litf
i
y f
8
9
1
0
1
1
1
2
1
3
1
4
1
5
1
6
1
7
1
8
1
9
2
0
2
1
2
2
2
3
2
4
2
5
2
6
2
7
2 3
8
3

1
2
3
4
5
6

7
8
9
1
0
1
1
1
2
l
g
1
4

CERTII OFSERVI B USMAI
FCATE
CE Y
L
1J s G. ors d car:
e
, oe T r ,ele
l m e lydiSoa oCo ny l m o e tea eo 1 y asa dn t p d t tewi i
a mpoe n ln u t. a v rh g f 8 e r n o a a yo h t n
h
at n Myb sn s a desi:4 MiayWe ts i #14B ii Cai ri 9 5 0.
ci . u ies d rs s 140 l r s; ut 0 enca, lona 4 1
o
i
t
e
f
Im ra i fmi r t d p st gmal t teUntdSae P saSevc . tid t,
a e dl a l wi e o in iwi h i tts o tl rie On hs ae l
y i h
a
i
h
e
s re o e c p r Itdb o ad c me t nie
evd n a h at ie elw, o u n e tld:
ys
t
OBJ ON
ECTI
(rcdrl
Poeua
)
Ca en . 01 9 2
s o 1-6 9
B fr
eoe
UNI DS ATE COUR OFAPP AL
TE T S
T
E S
F THENIT DIT CT
OR
N H S RI
GAR B A ANDH L B AM- ACK
Y L CK
OL I E BL
Pani p elnsV.
litWA p l t, GOOGL ,NC.Dee d n/p ele
f
a
E I , fn a t p l .
A e

1
5
1
6
1
7

OnA paf mteU idSae Dsrt orfrh
pelr h ne tts i i C utote
o
t
tc
N renDsrtf airi
ot r i i oC l n
h tc
f a
o
C s N .:0c-28-W
ae o41-v03 1C
T eH n rbeCl d Wie
h o oal a i l n
ua k

1 b paigiit a e v lp wi fl p ip sa etee n s ae tee v o e, n
8 y lcn tno n n eo e t ul ad otg h ro ,e ld h nelp a d
h y
1 d lee teeneo efr in t teUntdSttsPot feiBe ii, lona
9 ei rd h v lp o malg o h i ae s Ofi n nca Cai ri.
v
i
e
c
f
2
0
Wio S sn Go dih&Roai
l n on ii o r
s
c
st
21
atre sa Iw
ton y ta
6 0P g MiRo d
5 ae l a
l
2
2
P lAl , lona9 3 41 5
ao t Cai ri 4 0 -0 0
o f

2
3
T lpo e(5) 9-3 0
ee h n 60 4 390
2 Ielr ud rh pn l o prr ud rh IwsoteUne Sae tatefrg igi
4 dcae ne te e at f ej y ne tea fh id ttshth oe on s
y u
t
2 tu a dc r c. e ue a Be ii, lona9 5 0o J l2 , 0 1
5 re n or tExc td t nca Cairi 4 1 n uy 7 2 1 .
e
f
2 .-'
6 w faeut
.l tt ' x t
- ob o ' t o
2 Js G. re
7 oe Tors
2
8

,

l
P OOFOFS R IEU. . L
R
E V C S MAI