Peter Voggenthaler, et al v. Maryland Square LLC, et al

Filing

Filed order (MARY M. SCHROEDER, SIDNEY R. THOMAS and BARRY G. SILVERMAN) The petition for panel rehearing by Appellees Maryland Square Shopping Center, LLC, et al is GRANTED. The slip opinion is amended as follows: At slip op. 41, the fourth paragraph, should read: The judgment for indemnity against SBIC is AFFIRMED, and the judgment for indemnity against Melvin Shapiro is REVERSED and REMANDED (11-15176). [8809335] [10-17520, 11-15174, 11-15176, 12-16409, 12-16412]

Case: 10-17520

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

FOR PUBLICATION

UNITED STATES COURT OF APPEALS
FOR THE NINTH CIRCUIT
PETER J. VOGGENTHALER; WILLIAM
MONTERO; BARBARA MONTERO;
CLIFFORD ROGERS; SHARON
ROGERS; HERMANN ROSNER;
MARCUS ROTHKRANZ; DANIEL
SOLDINI; CHARLES WALKER; VERNA
WALKER; JACK YENCHECK; OFELIA
YENCHECK; RICHARD MALM; ROGER
ELLSWORTH; JO ANN ELLSWORTH;
MARGARET RUDELICH-HOPPE;
PATRICIA MAHONEY; RICHARD
FALEN; PETER LEARNED; KRISTIAN
MEIER; ELIZA ACOSTA; MIRHA
ELIAS; AIKO BERGE; VICTOR
BECERRA; ARTHUR BODENDORFER;
BRENDA C. CHAFFIN; MICHAEL J.
SOLMI; JASON COWLES; JANE
GAUTHIER; HONORE GAUTHIER;
NIKOLAS KONSTANTINOU; DRAGAN
KURAJICA; KENNETH LOWTHER;
JAMES LUEHMANN; JACQUELINE
LUEHMANN; RUTH MANNHEIMER;
STATE OF NEVADA, on behalf of
Department of Conservation &
Natural Resources, Division of
Environmental Protection,
Plaintiffs-Appellees,
v.

No. 10-17520
D.C. No.
2:08-cv-01618RCJ-GWF

Page: 1 of 9

Case: 10-17520

2

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

VOGGENTHALER V. MARYLAND SQUARE

Maryland Square LLC,
Defendant-Appellant,
and
MARYLAND SQUARE SHOPPING
CENTER LLC; HERMAN KISHNER
TRUST, DBA Maryland Square
Shopping Center; IRWIN KISHNER;
JERRY ENGEL; BANK OF AMERICA,
NA, Trustee on behalf of Herman
Kishner Trust; CLARK COUNTY
SCHOOL DISTRICT; MELVIN
SHAPIRO; SHAPIRO BROTHERS
INVESTMENT COMPANY,
Defendants.

PETER J. VOGGENTHALER; WILLIAM
MONTERO; BARBARA MONTERO;
CLIFFORD ROGERS; SHARON
ROGERS; HERMANN ROSNER;
MARCUS ROTHKRANZ; DANIEL
SOLDINI; CHARLES WALKER; VERNA
WALKER; JACK YENCHECK; OFELIA
YENCHECK; RICHARD MALM; ROGER
ELLSWORTH; JO ANN ELLSWORTH;
MARGARET RUDELICH-HOPPE;
PATRICIA MAHONEY; RICHARD
FALEN; PETER LEARNED; KRISTIAN
MEIER; ELIZA ACOSTA; MIRHA
ELIAS; AIKO BERGE; VICTOR
BECERRA; ARTHUR BODENDORFER;

No. 11-15174
D.C. Nos.
2:08-cv-01618RCJ-GWF
3:09-cv-00231RCJ-GWF

Page: 2 of 9

Case: 10-17520

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

VOGGENTHALER V. MARYLAND SQUARE
BRENDA C. CHAFFIN; MICHAEL J.
SOLMI; JASON COWLES; JANE
GAUTHIER; HONORE GAUTHIER;
NIKOLAS KONSTANTINOU; DRAGAN
KURAJICA; KENNETH LOWTHER;
JAMES LUEHMANN; JACQUELINE
LUEHMANN; RUTH MANNHEIMER,
Plaintiffs-Appellees,
MARYLAND SQUARE SHOPPING
CENTER LLC, Trustee on behalf of
Herman Kishner Trust,
Defendant-Intervenor,
STATE OF NEVADA, on behalf of
Department of Conservation &
Natural Resources, Division of
Environmental Protection,
Plaintiff-Intervenor,
BANK OF AMERICA, NA, Trustee on
behalf of Herman Kishner Trust;
JERRY ENGEL, Trustee on behalf of
Herman Kishner Trust; HERMAN
KISHNER TRUST, Trustee on behalf
of Herman Kishner Trust, DBA
Maryland Square Shopping Center;
IRWIN KISHNER, Trustee on behalf of
Herman Kishner Trust,
Defendants-Intervenors,
v.

Page: 3 of 9

3

Case: 10-17520

4

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

VOGGENTHALER V. MARYLAND SQUARE

SHAPIRO BROTHERS INVESTMENT
COMPANY,
Defendant-Appellant,
and
CLARK COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT;
MELVIN SHAPIRO; MARYLAND
SQUARE LLC, Trustee on behalf of
Herman Kishner Trust,
Defendants.

PETER J. VOGGENTHALER; WILLIAM
MONTERO; BARBARA MONTERO;
CLIFFORD ROGERS; SHARON
ROGERS; HERMANN ROSNER;
MARCUS ROTHKRANZ; DANIEL
SOLDINI; CHARLES WALKER; VERNA
WALKER; JACK YENCHECK; OFELIA
YENCHECK; RICHARD MALM; ROGER
ELLSWORTH; JO ANN ELLSWORTH;
MARGARET RUDELICH-HOPPE;
PATRICIA MAHONEY; RICHARD
FALEN; PETER LEARNED; KRISTIAN
MEIER; ELIZA ACOSTA; MIRHA
ELIAS; AIKO BERGE; VICTOR
BECERRA; ARTHUR BODENDORFER;
BRENDA C. CHAFFIN; MICHAEL J.
SOLMI; JASON COWLES; JANE
GAUTHIER; HONORE GAUTHIER;
NIKOLAS KONSTANTINOU; DRAGAN
KURAJICA; KENNETH LOWTHER;

No. 11-15176
D.C. Nos.
2:08-cv-01618RCJ-GWF
3:09-cv-00231RCJ-GWF

Page: 4 of 9

Case: 10-17520

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

VOGGENTHALER V. MARYLAND SQUARE
JAMES LUEHMANN; JACQUELINE
LUEHMANN; RUTH MANNHEIMER;
STATE OF NEVADA, on behalf of
Department of Conservation &
Natural Resources, Division of
Environmental Protection,
Plaintiffs,
v.
MARYLAND SQUARE SHOPPING
CENTER LLC; HERMAN KISHNER
TRUST, DBA Maryland Square
Shopping Center; IRWIN KISHNER;
JERRY ENGEL; BANK OF AMERICA,
Trustee on behalf of Herman
Kishner Trust,
Defendants-Appellees,
v.
MELVIN SHAPIRO; SHAPIRO
BROTHERS INVESTMENT COMPANY,
Defendants-Appellants,
and
MARYLAND SQUARE LLC; CLARK
COUNTY SCHOOL DISTRICT,
Defendants.

Page: 5 of 9

5

Case: 10-17520

6

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

VOGGENTHALER V. MARYLAND SQUARE

PETER J. VOGGENTHALER; WILLIAM
MONTERO; BARBARA MONTERO;
CLIFFORD ROGERS; SHARON
ROGERS; HERMANN ROSNER;
MARCUS ROTHKRANZ; DANIEL
SOLDINI; CHARLES WALKER; VERNA
WALKER; JACK YENCHECK; OFELIA
YENCHECK; RICHARD MALM; ROGER
ELLSWORTH; JO ANN ELLSWORTH;
MARGARET RUDELICH-HOPPE;
PATRICIA MAHONEY; RICHARD
FALEN; PETER LEARNED; KRISTIAN
MEIER; ELIZA ACOSTA; MIRHA
ELIAS; AIKO BERGE; VICTOR
BECERRA; ARTHUR BODENDORFER;
BRENDA C. CHAFFIN; MICHAEL J.
SOLMI; JASON COWLES; JANE
GAUTHIER; HONORE GAUTHIER;
NIKOLAS KONSTANTINOU; DRAGAN
KURAJICA; KENNETH LOWTHER;
JAMES LUEHMANN; JACQUELINE
LUEHMANN; RUTH MANNHEIMER,
Plaintiffs,
and
STATE OF NEVADA, on behalf of
Department of Conservation &
Natural Resources, Division of
Environmental Protection,
Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.

No. 12-16409
D.C. Nos.
2:08-cv-01618RCJ-GWF
3:09-cv-00231RCJ-GWF

Page: 6 of 9

Case: 10-17520

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

VOGGENTHALER V. MARYLAND SQUARE
MARYLAND SQUARE LLC;
MARYLAND SQUARE SHOPPING
CENTER LLC; HERMAN KISHNER
TRUST, DBA Maryland Square
Shopping Center; IRWIN KISHNER;
JERRY ENGEL; BANK OF AMERICA,
NA, Trustee on behalf of Herman
Kishner Trust; CLARK COUNTY
SCHOOL DISTRICT; MELVIN
SHAPIRO,
Defendants,
and
SHAPIRO BROTHERS INVESTMENT
COMPANY,
Defendant-Appellant.

PETER J. VOGGENTHALER; WILLIAM
MONTERO; BARBARA MONTERO;
CLIFFORD ROGERS; SHARON
ROGERS; HERMANN ROSNER;
MARCUS ROTHKRANZ; DANIEL
SOLDINI; CHARLES WALKER; VERNA
WALKER; JACK YENCHECK; OFELIA
YENCHECK; RICHARD MALM; ROGER
ELLSWORTH; JO ANN ELLSWORTH;
MARGARET RUDELICH-HOPPE;
PATRICIA MAHONEY; RICHARD
FALEN; PETER LEARNED; KRISTIAN
MEIER; ELIZA ACOSTA; MIRHA
ELIAS; AIKO BERGE; VICTOR

No. 12-16412
D.C. No.
2:08-cv-01618RCJ-GWF

ORDER
AMENDING
OPINION

Page: 7 of 9

7

Case: 10-17520

8

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

VOGGENTHALER V. MARYLAND SQUARE

BECERRA; ARTHUR BODENDORFER;
BRENDA C. CHAFFIN; MICHAEL J.
SOLMI; JASON COWLES; JANE
GAUTHIER; HONORE GAUTHIER;
NIKOLAS KONSTANTINOU; DRAGAN
KURAJICA; KENNETH LOWTHER;
JAMES LUEHMANN; JACQUELINE
LUEHMANN; RUTH MANNHEIMER,
Plaintiffs,
and
STATE OF NEVADA, on behalf of
Department of Conservation &
Natural Resources, Division of
Environmental Protection,
Plaintiff-Appellee,
v.
MARYLAND SQUARE LLC,
Defendant-Appellant,
and
MARYLAND SQUARE SHOPPING
CENTER LLC; HERMAN KISHNER
TRUST, DBA Maryland Square
Shopping Center; IRWIN KISHNER;
JERRY ENGEL; BANK OF AMERICA,
NA, Trustee on behalf of Herman
Kishner Trust; CLARK COUNTY
SCHOOL DISTRICT; MELVIN

Page: 8 of 9

Case: 10-17520

10/04/2013

ID: 8809335

DktEntry: 87

VOGGENTHALER V. MARYLAND SQUARE

Page: 9 of 9

9

SHAPIRO; SHAPIRO BROTHERS
INVESTMENT COMPANY,
Defendants.

Filed October 4, 2013
Before: Mary M. Schroeder, Sidney R. Thomas,
and Barry G. Silverman, Circuit Judges.

ORDER
The petition for panel rehearing by Appellees’ Maryland
Square Shopping Center, LLC, et al is GRANTED.
The slip opinion is amended as follows:
At slip op. 41, the fourth paragraph, should read:
The judgment for indemnity against SBIC
is AFFIRMED, and the judgment for
indemnity against Melvin Shapiro is
REVERSED and REMANDED (11-15176).