May v. F/V Lorena Marie, O.N. 939683 et al

Filing 73

JDR ORDER regarding Costs and Fees for Discovery Violations. Signed by Judge John D. Roberts on 11/17/11. (JAM, Chambers Staff)

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE DISTRICT OF ALASKA

RAYMOND MAY,
Plaintiff,
Case No. 3:09-cv-00114-JWS-JDR

vs.
F/V LORENA MARIE, Official No.
939683, her Tackle, Apparel, Boats,
Appurtenances, In Rem; JAMES
SKONBERG and JANE DOE
SKONBERG, husband and wife, In
Personam,

ORDER REGARDING COSTS AND
FEES FOR DISCOVERY
VIOLATIONS
Dockets 67, 70 & 71

Defendants.

In the Court’s Order Regarding Motion to Compel Production of Photos
and Film or for Application of Spoliation of Evidence Rule at Docket 67, the Plaintiff
was awarded Costs and Fees associated with the depositions of Devon Skonberg
and Darren Muller on June 7 and June 9, 2011 and the relevant costs for the filing
of Plaintiff’s Motion at Docket 41.

At Docket 70, James Brennan filed his Declaration regarding his
relevant costs and fees, totaling $2,887.28. At Docket 71, Steven Gibbons filed the
same, with relevant costs and fees totaling $21,708.73.1
When the final costs and fees are calculated in this matter, the
Defendant shall pay the Plaintiff $24,596.46 in accordance with the Court’s Order at
Docket 67.
IT IS SO ORDERED.
DATED this 17th

day of November, 2011, at Anchorage, Alaska.

/s/ John D. Roberts
JOHN D. ROBERTS
United States Magistrate Judge

1

Mr. Gibbons calculation for his total fees appears to be off by $10.00. The
Court’s calculation is that the fees should total $19,019.50. Additionally, Mr.
Gibbons did not actually provide the Court with a final calculation of relevant
costs and fees. But, based on the information in his filing, the Court believes the
relevant costs and fees total $21,708.73.

09-cv-114-JWS-JDR Order @ Dockets 67, 70 & 71 Re Costs and Fees.wpd

2