J & J Sports Productions Incorporated v. Gonzalez Arvizu et al

Filing 19

ORDER granting in part and denying in part 18 Motion for Attorney Fees. Signed by Judge David G Campbell on 4/4/2018.(DGC, nvo)

1

WO

2
3
4
5
6

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

7

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA

8
9
10

No. CV-17-03130-PHX-DGC
J & J Sports Productions, Inc.,
ORDER

11

Plaintiff,

12

v.

13

Francisca Angelica Gonzalez Arvizu,
individually and d/b/a/ Taco Mich; and
Taco Mich & Bar #4, LLC, an unknown
business entity d/b/a Taco Mich

14
15

Defendants.

16
17
18
19

Plaintiff J & J Sports Productions has filed a motion for an award of attorneys’

20

fees and costs. Doc. 18. No response has been filed. The Court will grant the motion in

21

part.

22

Plaintiff obtains licenses to distribute pay-per-view programming to bars and

23

restaurants. Plaintiff claims that on September 17, 2016, Defendants intercepted a pay-

24

per-view boxing match and displayed it to the public at Taco Mich, a Mexican restaurant

25

and bar operated by Defendants. Plaintiff brought this civil action seeking statutory

26

damages for violations of the Communications Act of 1934 and the Cable and Television

27

Consumer Protection and Competition Act of 1992, 47 U.S.C. §§ 553 and 605 et seq.

28

Doc. 1.

Defendants failed to answer or otherwise respond to the complaint. Docs. 12.

1
2

Plaintiff was awarded default judgment in the amount of $30,000.00. Docs. 17.

3

Under the Communications Act, the Court “shall direct the recovery of full costs,

4

including awarding reasonable attorneys’ fees to an aggrieved party who prevails.”

5

47 U.S.C. § 605(e)(3)(B)(iii). Pursuant to Local Rule of Civil Procedure 54.2, a party

6

seeking to recover attorneys’ fees must file a motion that includes a discussion of the

7

eligibility and entitlement to fees and the reasonableness of the requested award.

8

LRCiv 54.2(c). The supporting memorandum should include a consultation statement,

9

the fee agreement, an itemized statement of fees, and an affidavit of moving counsel.

10

LRCiv 54.2(d).

11

With respect to costs, Local Rule 54.1 directs prevailing party to “include a

12

memorandum of the costs and necessary disbursements, so itemized that the nature of

13

each can be readily understood, and, where available, documentation of requested costs

14

in all categories must be attached.” LRCiv 54.1(a).

15

I.

Attorneys’ Fees.

16

Plaintiff seeks a fee award in the amount of $3,130 for 14.5 billable hours.

17

Docs. 18 at 3, 18-4 at 10. The request includes $805.00 in fees for the work of an

18

administrative assistant.

19

engaged in substantive legal work under a lawyer’s supervision, most of the work is

20

secretarial in nature. Secretarial or clerical work is not properly included in an award of

21

attorneys’ fees. See J & J Sports Prods., Inc. v. Mosqueda, CV-12-00523-PHX-DGC,

22

2013 WL 5336848, at *3 (D. Ariz. Sept. 24, 2013) (citing Schrum v. Burlington N. Santa

23

Fe Ry. Co., No. CIV 04-0619-RCB, 2008 WL 2278137, at *12 (D. Ariz. May 30, 2008)).

24

The Court is particularly reluctant to award fees for all of this work, as many of the

25

itemized time entries appear to be a lawyer’s review or duplication of the administrator’s

26

tasks. The Court has noted this same issue in ruling on Plaintiff’s motions for attorneys’

27

fees in other cases. See Mosqueda, 2013 WL 5336848, at *3; J & J Sports Prods, Inc. v.

28

Macia, No. CV-13-00921-PHX-DGC, 2014 WL 3747608, at *1 (D. Ariz. July 30, 2014).

Doc. 18-4 at 7-10.

-2-

Although this individual occasionally

1

The Court will reduce the requested fee award by the amount sought for time spent

2

by the administrative assistant on secretarial tasks. The Court, in its discretion, will

3

award attorneys’ fees of $2,900.00.1

4

II.

Costs.

5

A prevailing party is entitled to “the recovery of full costs” under the

6

Communications Act. 47 U.S.C. § 605(e)(3)(B)(iii). Plaintiff seeks an award of costs in

7

the amount of $1,330.71 for filing fees, service of process fees, courier charges, and

8

investigative costs. Docs. 18 at 3, 18-4 at 10-11.

9

The statute has been interpreted as including investigative costs. See Kingvision

10

Pay-Per-View Ltd. v. Autar, 426 F. Supp. 2d 59, 67 (E.D.N.Y. 2006). Although the

11

Court has the power to direct the recovery of such costs, it is not required to do so. Id.

12

(citing Int’l Cablevision, Inc. v. Noel, 982 F. Supp. 904, 918 (W.D.N.Y. 1997)). Rather,

13

“[i]n order to recover investigative costs a plaintiff must make a showing similar to that

14

required to recover attorneys’ fees,” and the movant “must document (1) the amount of

15

time necessary for the investigation; (2) how much the investigators charged per hour;

16

and (3) why the investigators are qualified to demand the requested rate.” Id. (internal

17

citations and quotation marks omitted).

18

Plaintiff has submitted a $650 invoice from the investigator, but provides

19

no explanation or supporting documentation for the reasonableness of this charge.

20

Doc. 18-4 at 15. Plaintiff fails to describe the investigator’s qualifications or identify her

21

hourly rate.

22

Defendants’ establishment on the night in question. Doc. 16-4 at 2. The Court will not

23

award costs for these investigative services.

24
25

It is worth noting that the investigator spent less than a half hour in

Nor will the Court award costs for the $151.71 in courier charges. Doc. 18-4
at 10-11. Plaintiff provides no supporting documentation for these charges.

26
27
28

1

Counsel for Plaintiff avows that he does not have a fee agreement with Plaintiff.
Doc. 18-4 at 4. Counsel further states that a consultation statement is unavailable given
that no Defendant has appeared in this action. Id. at 5.
-3-

1

IT IS ORDERED:

2

1.

3

Plaintiff’s motion for award of costs and attorneys’ fees (Doc. 18) is

granted in part and denied in part as set forth in this order.

4

2.

Plaintiff is awarded $2,900.00 in attorneys’ fees.

5

3.

Plaintiff is awarded $529.00 for costs.

6

Dated this 4th day of April, 2018.

7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-4-