Montoya v. 3PD Incorporated et al

Filing 40

ORDER: Scheduling Conference set for 9/4/2013 at 03:30 PM in Courtroom 605, 401 West Washington Street, Phoenix, AZ 85003 before Senior Judge Stephen M McNamee. Signed by Senior Judge Stephen M McNamee on 7/8/2013. (LMR)

1

WO

2
3
4
5
6

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

7

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA

8
9

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

Dennis Montoya,
Plaintiff,

10
11

vs.

12

3PD Incorporated, et al,

13

Defendants.

14

No. CV-13-8068-PCT-SMM
ORDER SETTING RULE 16
PRELIMINARY PRETRIAL
CONFERENCE

15
16

This matter now being ready for a pretrial conference,

17

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that pursuant to Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Civil

18

Procedure a Preliminary Pretrial Conference is set for September 4, 2013 at 3:30 p.m.

19

before the Honorable Stephen M. McNamee in Courtroom #605, sixth floor, Sandra Day

20

O’Connor U.S. Courthouse, 401 W. Washington Street, Phoenix, Arizona.

21

***NOTICE***

22
23

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED:

24

1.

COUNSEL WHO WILL BE RESPONSIBLE FOR TRIAL OF THE

25

LAWSUIT FOR EACH PARTY SHALL PERSONALLY APPEAR

26

AND PARTICIPATE IN THE PRELIMINARY PRETRIAL

27

CONFERENCE. Counsel for all parties are directed to Rule 16 of the

28

Federal Rules of Civil Procedure for the objectives of the conference. At

1

least one of the attorneys for each party attending the conference shall have

2

authority to enter into stipulations and make admissions regarding all

3

matters which may be discussed.

4

2.

IN ADDITION TO COUNSEL OF RECORD, EACH PARTY, OR A

5

REPRESENTATIVE OF EACH PARTY (WHO IS NOT COUNSEL

6

OF RECORD) WITH BINDING SETTLEMENT AUTHORITY IF

7

THE PARTY IS AN ENTITY, SHALL BE PRESENT AT THE

8

PRELIMINARY PRETRIAL CONFERENCE. NO PARTY OR

9

COUNSEL SHALL BE EXCUSED FROM PERSONALLY

10

APPEARING AT THE CONFERENCE WITHOUT PRIOR

11

PERMISSION OF THE COURT. See Fed. R. Civ. P. 16(f).

12

3.

Counsel must be prepared to discuss what the parties must prove in order to

13

prevail on their respective claims or defenses at the time of the Preliminary

14

Pretrial Conference.

15

4.

Counsel should be prepared to discuss logistical matters.

16

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all parties are directed to meet at least twenty-

17

one (21) days before the Preliminary Pretrial Conference, in accordance with Rule 26(f)

18

of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, to discuss the following matters:

19

1.

The possibility of consent to trial before a United States Magistrate Judge

20

pursuant to 28 U.S.C. § 636(c), the suitability for referral of this matter to this

21

District's court-annexed voluntary arbitration program or any other alternative

22

dispute resolution mechanism, or the reference of this matter to a special master;

23

2.

24

parties;

25

3.

26

prompt settlement or resolution of the case;

27

4.

Any matters relating to jurisdiction or venue or the joinder of additional

The nature and bases of their claims and defenses and the possibilities for a

A schedule of all pre-trial proceedings;

28
-2-

1

5.

2

the case;

3

6.

4

the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Unless otherwise stipulated in writing by the

5

parties or otherwise directed by a written Order of this Court, Initial Disclosures

6

shall be made at the initial Rule 26(f) case management meeting or within fourteen

7

(14) days after the meeting; and

8

7.

9

an efficient manner.

10

Modification of pre-trial procedures due to the simplicity or complexity of

Arrangements for Initial Disclosures in compliance with Rule 26(a)(1) of

Any other matters which counsel may feel will help dispose of the matter in

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that to satisfy the requirements of Federal Rule of

11

Civil Procedure 26(a) the parties shall file with the Clerk of the Court a Notice of Initial

12

Disclosure; copies of the actual disclosures shall therefore not be filed.

13

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that at the Rule 26(f) case management meeting,

14

the parties shall develop a Proposed Case Management Plan which shall include brief

15

statements or proposals concerning:

16

1.

The nature of the case, setting forth in brief statements the factual and legal

17

basis of plaintiff's claims and defendant's defenses;

18

2.

19

and each affirmative defense. Where the burden of proof shifts, each party shall

20

list the elements of the claim or defense that the party must prove in order to

21

prevail. The list of the elements of proof must contain citations to relevant legal

22

authority (i.e., United States statutory and/or administrative law, U.S. Supreme

23

Court case law, Ninth Circuit Court of Appeals case law, Arizona state case and

24

statutory law, or other authority as dictated by conflicts of law rules);

25

3.

26

narrowed by stipulation or motion;

27

4.

A list of the elements of proof necessary for each count of the complaint

The factual and legal issues genuinely in dispute, and whether they can be

The jurisdictional basis of the case, citing specific statutes;

28
-3-

1

5.

Parties, if any, which have not been served, as well as parties which have

2

not filed an answer or other appearance. Unless counsel can otherwise show

3

cause, a proposed form of order shall accompany the joint Case Management Plan

4

which dismisses any party which has not been served, or seeks default judgment

5

on any non-appearing party;

6

6.

The names of parties not subject to the Court’s jurisdiction;

7

7.

Whether there are further dispositive or partially dispositive issues to be

8

decided by pretrial motions, and the legal issues about which any pretrial motions

9

are contemplated;

10

8.

Whether the case is suitable for reference to arbitration, to a special master,

11

or to a United States Magistrate Judge for trial;

12

9.

13

before other courts;

14

10.

15

disclosures under Rule 26(a), Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, including a

16

statement of when Initial Disclosures were made or will be made;

17

11.

The status of related cases pending before other judges of this Court or

Suggested changes, if necessary, in the timing, form, or requirement for

Proposed specific dates for each of the following:

18

a.

A deadline for the completion of fact discovery;1

19

b.

Dates for full and complete expert disclosures under Federal Rule of
Civil Procedure 26(a)(2)(A)-(C);

20
21

c.

A deadline for completion of all expert depositions;

22

d.

A deadline for filing dispositive motions;

23
24
25
26
27
28

1

The discovery deadline is the date by which all discovery must be completed.
Discovery requests must be served and depositions noticed sufficiently in advance of this
date to ensure reasonable completion by this deadline, including time to resolve discovery
disputes. Absent extraordinary circumstances, the Court will not entertain discovery disputes
after this deadline.
-4-

1

e.

2

A date by which the parties shall have engaged in good faith
settlement talks;

3

12.

4

phases or should be limited to or focused upon particular issues. For example,

5

where dispositive motions will be filed (e.g., motions for summary judgment or a

6

defense relying on the statute of limitations) counsel should consider limiting

7

discovery to the issue at hand until the court has ruled on the motion;

8

13.

9

Federal Rules of Civil Procedure and LRCiv 16.2;

The scope of discovery and whether discovery should be conducted in

Suggested changes, if any, in the limitations on discovery imposed by the

10

14.

11

trial, and any suggestions for shortening the trial;

12

15.

13

trial is contested. If the request for a jury trial is contested, the Proposed Case

14

Management Plan shall set forth the reasons that a trial by jury is in dispute;

15

16.

16

conference before another United States District Court Judge or Magistrate Judge,

17

or other request of the court for assistance in settlement efforts; and

18

17.

19

dispute in a just, speedy, and inexpensive manner.

20

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all deadlines to which the parties stipulate in

Estimated date that the case will be ready for trial, the estimated length of

Whether a jury trial has been requested and whether the request for a jury

The prospects for settlement, including any request to have a settlement

Any other matters which counsel feel will aid the Court in resolving this

21

the Proposed Case Management Plan shall fall on a Friday barring extenuating

22

circumstances which make doing so impracticable.

23

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that counsel shall jointly file their Proposed Case

24

Management Plan with the Clerk of the Court not less than five (5) business days before

25

the Preliminary Pretrial Conference. Absent extraordinary circumstances, no extensions

26

of time will be granted.

27
28
-5-

1

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that it is the responsibility of counsel for the

2

Plaintiff(s) to initiate the communications necessary to prepare the joint Proposed Case

3

Management Plan. Once contacted by counsel for Plaintiff(s), counsel for Defendant(s)

4

shall act in an expeditious manner to effectuate the preparation of the Case Management

5

Plan.

6

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that counsel for all parties are expected to comply

7

with Rule 26 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, and to minimize the expense of

8

discovery.

9

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Court, after consultation with counsel and

10

the parties, will enter a Rule 16(b) Scheduling Order concerning, inter alia, discovery and

11

dispositive motions. (See Attached) To the extent that the Court’s Rule 16 Scheduling

12

Order differs from the parties’ Proposed Case Management Plan, the provisions of the

13

Court’s Order shall supersede the parties’ Proposed Case Management Plan and shall

14

control the course of this action unless modified by subsequent Order of this Court. The

15

parties and their counsel are all cautioned that the deadlines set in the Rule 16 Scheduling

16

Order shall be strictly enforced.

17

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that counsel review the requirements of LRCiv 7.1

18

and LRCiv 7.2, Rules of Practice of the United States District Court for the District of

19

Arizona, with their administrative/support personnel to ensure that all pleadings are in

20

compliance with the rules.

21

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that this Court views the Preliminary Pretrial

22

Conference as critical to its case management responsibilities and the responsibilities of

23

the parties under Rule 1 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. FAILURE TO

24

COMPLY WITH EVERY PROVISION OF THIS ORDER MAY LEAD TO

25

SANCTIONS PURSUANT TO FEDERAL RULE OF CIVIL PROCEDURE 16(f).

26

///

27

///

28
-6-

1

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Clerk of the Court send copies of this

2

Order to any party appearing in propria persona.

3

DATED this 8th day of July, 2013.

4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
-7-

1

WO

2
3
4
5
6

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

7

FOR THE DISTRICT OF ARIZONA

8
9

,

10

Plaintiff,

11
12

v.
,

13
Defendants.
14

)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)
)

No. CV-

-

-PHX-SMM

RULE 16 SCHEDULING ORDER

15
On _________, 20___, a Preliminary Pretrial Conference was held in open Court
16
pursuant to Rule 16(b) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure. Prior to the conference,
17
the parties filed a Rule 26(f) Case Management Plan. Pursuant to the terms of the Case
18
Management Plan, and the representations made by the parties at the Rule 16 Preliminary
19
Pretrial Conference, all parties were ordered to comply with the deadlines established in
20
this Order.
21
IT IS HEREBY ORDERED that the current provisions of the Federal Rules of
22
Civil Procedure shall apply to all proceedings concerning this case.
23
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all Initial Disclosures as defined in Federal
24
Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a), if not already exchanged prior to the time of this
25
Preliminary Pretrial Conference, shall be made no later than five (5) days after date of
26
27
28

-8-

1

entry of this Order or, in the alternative, no later than ___________________________________

2

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that to satisfy the requirements of Federal Rule of

3

Civil Procedure 26(a), the parties shall file with the Clerk of the Court a Notice of Initial

4

Disclosure, rather than copies of the actual disclosures.

5

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that any amendment to the Complaint shall be

6

filed no later than ____________________________________________. Any

7

amendment to the Answer shall be filed no later than

8

__________________________________________.

9

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all discovery, answers to interrogatories, and

10

supplements to interrogatories must be completed by ___________________________.

11

In no event, however, shall this provision alter the duties and obligations imposed upon

12

the parties by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(e). This Order contemplates that each

13

party will conduct discovery in such a manner as to complete, within the deadline, any

14

and all discovery. "Last minute" or "eleventh hour" discovery which results in

15

insufficient time to undertake additional discovery and which requires an extension of the

16

discovery deadline will be met with disfavor, and could result in denial of an extension,

17

exclusion of evidence, or the imposition of other sanctions.

18

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that discovery by interrogatory shall generally be

19

governed by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 33. However, notwithstanding Federal Rule

20

of Civil Procedure 33, there is a limit of _____________ interrogatories, including

21

discrete subparts, applicable to this case.

22

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that requests for admissions shall be governed by

23

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 36. The parties shall serve no more than

24

requests for admissions.

25

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED reminding counsel of their duty under Rule 26(e)

26

of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure to supplement all Rule 26(a) disclosures and

27

responses to discovery requests. Pursuant to Rule 26(e)(1), any additions or other

28

changes to information previously disclosed must be made prior to the time that Rule
-9-

1

26(a)(3) Pretrial Disclosures are due. Since this Court effectively requires all Rule

2

26(a)(3) Pretrial Disclosures to be contained in the Proposed Final Pretrial Order, this

3

Order contemplates that all exhibits and witnesses that may be offered at trial will have

4

been disclosed before the close of discovery as established by the provisions of this

5

Order. This Order therefore supersedes the “thirty-day before trial” disclosure deadline

6

contained in that Rule. Therefore (1) failure to have timely supplemented a Rule 26(a)

7

disclosure, including but not limited to witnesses and exhibits, or (2) a failure to have

8

timely supplemented responses to any valid discovery requests, or (3) attempting to

9

include any witnesses or exhibits in the Proposed Final Pretrial Order that were not

10

previously disclosed in a timely manner as to allow for meaningful discovery prior to the

11

discovery cutoff date as established by this Order, may result in the exclusion of such

12

evidence at trial or the imposition of other sanctions.

13

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, in the event of a discovery dispute, the

14

parties shall contact the Court to request a telephonic conference prior to filing any

15

discovery motions. The parties shall not contact the Court regarding a discovery dispute

16

unless they have been unable to resolve the dispute themselves, despite personal

17

consultation and sincere efforts to do so. The parties shall not file any written materials

18

related to a discovery dispute or discovery motion without express leave of Court. If the

19

Court does order written submissions, the movant shall include a statement certifying that

20

counsel could not satisfactorily resolve the matter despite personal consultation and

21

sincere efforts to do so, in accordance with LRCiv 7.2(j) of the Rules of Practice of the

22

United States District Court for the District of Arizona.

23

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Plaintiff(s) shall disclose the identity of

24

any person who may be used at trial to present evidence under Federal Rules of Evidence

25

701, 702, 703, 704, and 705 no later than

26
27
28
- 10 -

1

___________________________________________.2 The Defendant(s) shall disclose

2

the identity of any person who may be used at trial to present evidence under Federal

3

Rules of Evidence 701, 702, 703, 704, or 705 no later than

4

___________________________________. Rebuttal experts if any, shall be disclosed

5

no later than _____________________________. No deposition of any expert witnesses

6

shall occur before the disclosures concerning expert witnesses mandated by this Order are

7

made. Depositions of all expert witnesses must be concluded by ___________________.

8

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the disclosures of the identities of any persons

9

who may be used at trial to present evidence under Federal Rules of Evidence 701, 702,

10

703, 704, or 705 shall also include all of the disclosures required by Federal Rule of Civil

11

Procedure 26(a)(2)(B) if the witness is either (1) retained or specifically employed to

12

provide expert testimony in the case, or (2) is an agent or employee of the party offering

13

the testimony whose duties regularly involve giving expert testimony.

14

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that depositions shall be limited as provided by

15

Rules 30 and 31 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure unless the parties otherwise

16

stipulate in writing when permitted to do so pursuant to the Rules or when granted

17

permission to depart from the provisions of the Rules by Order of this Court.

18

Notwithstanding any provision in the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure or the Local

19

Rules, the parties shall conduct no more than _________________ depositions.

20

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil Procedure
hours3 to conduct a deposition of

21

30(d)(1) that there shall be a time limit of

22

any witness in this case. Additional time shall be allowed where the deponent or a party

23

impedes or delays the examination. This time limit may only be extended by Order of

24

this Court upon motion of any party that demonstrates good cause for doing so. Counsel

25
2

26
27
28

The parties are hereby given notice that this Order requires disclosure greater than that
required by Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 26(a)(2).
3

The Court finds that a presumptive limit of seven (7) hours is sufficient for
depositions in a standard track civil case.
- 11 -

1

shall conduct themselves courteously and professionally, especially during the taking of

2

depositions. Any objections made during the course of a deposition must be in

3

accordance with Rule 30(c)(2) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

4

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that notwithstanding any provisions of the Federal

5

Rules of Civil Procedure or any other provisions of this Order, non-party witnesses shall

6

not be permitted to attend, either physically, electronically, or otherwise, the deposition of

7

any other witness in this case without an Order of this Court to the contrary.

8
9

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all dispositive motions shall be filed no later
than __________________________________. Such motions must be, in all respects, in

10

full compliance with the Rules of Practice of the United States District Court for the

11

District of Arizona.

12
13
14

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that no submissions to the Court shall contain any
footnotes in excess of five (5) lines.
IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that all parties are hereby specifically admonished

15

that failure to respond to a motion by serving and filing an answering memorandum

16

within the time period expressly provided for in LRCiv 7.2 of the Rules of Practice of the

17

United States District Court for the District of Arizona may be deemed a consent to the

18

denial or granting of the motion and the Court may then dispose of the motion summarily.

19

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the parties shall not notice oral argument on

20

any motion. Instead, a party desiring oral argument on a motion shall request argument

21

by placing “Oral Argument Requested” immediately below the title of such motion,

22

pursuant to LRCiv 7.2(f) of the Rules of Practice of the United States District Court for

23

the District of Arizona. The Court will then issue a minute order scheduling the oral

24

argument.

25

Oral argument shall be scheduled at the request of a party on all motions to dismiss

26

and motions for summary judgment. On all other motions on which a party requests oral

27

argument, the Court will determine whether oral argument is necessary. FURTHER,

28

THE PARTIES ARE REMINDED THAT OBTAINING A HEARING DATE IS
- 12 -

1

PURELY ADMINISTERIAL. ACCORDINGLY, REGARDLESS OF A HEARING

2

DATE, THE COURT MAY, AT ANY TIME AFTER THE MOTION IS FULLY

3

BRIEFED, DETERMINE THAT A HEARING IS UNWARRANTED AND RULE ON

4

THE MOTION WITHOUT ORAL ARGUMENT.

5

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that any and all motions, requests, or stipulations

6

for extensions of time shall be made in accordance with the provisions of LRCiv 7.3 of

7

the Rules of Practice of the United States District Court for the District of Arizona.

8

Notwithstanding this directive, however, if such a motion, request, or stipulation seeks an

9

extension of time in which to file a memorandum in response or in reply to a motion

10

previously noticed for oral argument, under no circumstances shall such a motion,

11

request, or stipulation seek an extension that would preclude the Court from having at

12

least thirty (30) days from the due date for the filing of the reply memorandum to

13

consider the merits of the underlying motion unless the motion, request, or stipulation

14

also seeks to vacate and reschedule the oral argument. Any motion, request, or

15

stipulation that so seeks both an extension of time and rescheduling of a hearing shall

16

contain a memorandum of points and authorities which demonstrates good cause for the

17

Court to grant the requested extension.

18

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, if no dispositive motions are pending before

19

the Court after the dispositive motions deadline has passed, Plaintiff(s) shall file a Notice

20

of Readiness for Order Re: Final Pretrial Conference within ten (10) days of the

21

dispositive motions deadline.

22

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that, if dispositive motions are pending before the

23

Court following the dispositive motions deadline, the Court will issue an Order Re: Final

24

Pretrial Conference following its resolution of the dispositive motions, if necessary.

25

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the Order Re: Final Pretrial Conference shall:

26

1) set deadlines for the filing of and response to motions in limine; 2) instruct the parties

27

on their duties in preparing for the Final Pretrial Conference and for trial; and 3) include a

28

form for the completion of the parties’ Proposed Pretrial Form of Order.
- 13 -

1

IT IS ORDERED that the attorneys for each party who will be responsible for

2

trial of the lawsuit shall APPEAR and PARTICIPATE in a Final Pretrial Conference on

3

______________________________________________ at _________________, ___.m.

4

in courtroom # 605 on the sixth floor of the United States Courthouse, 401 West

5

Washington Street, Phoenix, Arizona. Because the Final Pretrial Conference is held for

6

the benefit of all parties, and further because the presence of all parties will facilitate

7

frank discussion of the pertinent issues in the lawsuit, each party, or a representative

8

with binding settlement authority if the party is an entity, shall attend the Final

9

Pretrial Conference. At the Final Pretrial Conference, the Court shall set a firm trial date.

10

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that the parties shall keep the Court informed

11

regarding the possibility of settlement and should settlement be reached, the parties shall

12

file a Notice of Settlement with the Clerk of the Court.

13

IT IS FURTHER ORDERED that this Court views compliance with the

14

provisions of this Order as critical to its case management responsibilities and the

15

responsibilities of the parties under Rule 16 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
- 14 -