Chaffin v. Eichert et al

Filing 179

JUDGMENT, pursuant to Jury Verdict, in favor of Stephen J. Eichert & Medical Assurance Company Inc. against Cristina Renee Chaffin. The complaint of Cristina Renee Chaffin is dismissed with prejudice. Signed by Chief Judge J. Leon Holmes on 7/21/2011. (jct)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

EASTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS

JONESBORO DIVISION

CRISTINA RENEE CHAFFIN

v.

PLAINTIFF
No. 3:09CV00002 JLH

STEPHEN J. EICHERT, D.O.; THE MEDICAL
ASSURANCE COMPANY, INC.; and JOHN DOE

DEFENDANTS

JUDGMENT
On the 18th day of July, 2011, this action came before the court for a trial by jury. Cristina
Renee Chaffin appeared in person and through her attorneys, Michael Noel Watts and Jonathan S.
Masters. Stephen J. Eichert appeared in person and through his attorney, Rick T. Beard, III. The
Medical Assurance Company, Inc., insurer for Mid-South Neurosurgery, Inc., appeared through its
attorney, Paul D. Waddell. All parties announced ready for trial. Ajury oftwelve was duly selected
and sworn. After receiving all ofthe evidence and being instructed on the law, on July 20,2011, the
jury returned a verdict as follows:
(1)

On PlaintiffCristina Chaffin's claim against Defendants Stephen Eichert and
Mid-South Neurosurgery, Inc., we find in favor of: (circle one)

Cristina Chaffin

OR

Stephen Eichert / Mid-South Neurosurgery

Note: If you circled "Stephen Eichert/Mid-South Neurosurgery" on Question
(1), then do not answer Question (2), but sign and date the form at the bottom.
If you circled "Cristina Chaffin" on Question (1), then answer Question (2).

* * *

lsi James L. Nowlin
Foreperson
7-20-2011

Date

Judgment is therefore entered in favor of Stephen J. Eichert and the Medical Assurance
Company, Inc., on the claims of Cristina Renee Chaffin. The complaint of Cristina Renee Chaffin
is dismissed with prejudice.
IT IS SO ORDERED this 21st day of July, 2011.

2