Leps v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al

Filing 29

ORDER finding this case is designated to proceed with case-specific discovery under PPO 9, and directing Plaintiff to provide Defendants with an updated medical authorization within 3 weeks of the date of this Order. Signed by Judge William R. Wilson, Jr on 11/5/2010. (jct)

Leps v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al

Doc. 29

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS WESTERN DIVISION IN RE: PREMPRO PRODUCTS LIABILITY LITIGATION : : : : MDL DOCKET NO. 4:03-CV-1507-WRW ALL CASES in EXHIBIT A

ORDER Exhibit A lists cases designated to proceed with case-specific discovery under Practice and Procedure Order 9. Specifically, the parties may take case-specific discovery depositions of the plaintiff(s), spouse(s), treating physician(s),1 and sales representative(s).2 In each case listed in Exhibit A, Plaintiffs are directed to provide Defendants with updated medical authorization3 within three weeks of the date of this order. Failure to do so may result in dismissal for failure to prosecute. As was mentioned in the March 19, 2010, Order,4 cases designated under PPO-9 are no longer limited to cases with Wyeth and Pfizer as the only defendants and claims for only breast cancer injuries. Additionally, I expect all parties to cooperate in expeditiously scheduling and taking these PPO-9 depositions. It seems to me that, generally, the PPO-9 discovery should be completed within six months of the date of this Order. However, when scheduling the depositions, the parties should be careful not to load one firm's wagon with more poles than a mule can pull, i.e., I expect all parties to be reasonable in this regard. IT IS SO ORDERED this 5th day of November, 2010. /s/ Wm. R. Wilson, Jr.________________ UNITED STATE DISTRICT COURT

This applies to treating physicians who are identified as trial witnesses by any party under the transferor court procedures. Treating physicians include prescribers. With regard to depositions of sales representatives or district sales managers, Plaintiffs may take only one general deposition of each such person.
3 2

1

The Medical Authorization Form can be found at Doc. No. 2007-3 in In re Prempro, 4:03-CVDoc. No. 2235.

001507.
4

1
Dockets.Justia.com

EXHIBIT A Arkansas Cases Fowler et al v. Wyeth Inc et al Adkisson, et al v. Wyeth, et al Musgrove v. Wyeth Inc, et al Hamby v. Wyeth Inc, et al Mooney v. Wyeth Inc et al Eustace et al v. Wyeth et al Miles et al v. Wyeth et al McCarthy et al v. Wyeth et al Knudsen v. Wyeth et al Massenburge v. Wyeth et al Littlefield v. Wyeth et al Knight et al v. Wyeth et al Posey v. Wyeth et al Rankin et al v. Wyeth et al Rachal v. Wyeth et al Ring v. Wyeth et al Stogsdill et al v. Wyeth et al Mitchell v. Wyeth Vernon v. Wyeth Inc et al Kibat v. Wyeth et al Wynn, et al. v. Pfizer Inc, et al. Scarbrough v. Wyeth et al 3:06-cv-00149-WRW 4:05-cv-00636-WRW 4:05-cv-00881-WRW 4:05-cv-00882-WRW 4:05-cv-00958-WRW 4:05-cv-01006-WRW 4:05-cv-01044-WRW 4:05-cv-01045-WRW 4:05-cv-01046-WRW 4:05-cv-01047-WRW 4:05-cv-01048-WRW 4:05-cv-01050-WRW 4:05-cv-01053-WRW 4:05-cv-01055-WRW 4:05-cv-01056-WRW 4:05-cv-01058-WRW 4:05-cv-01068-WRW 4:05-cv-01295-WRW 4:05-cv-01858-WRW 4:06-cv-00766-WRW 4:07-cv-01230-WRW 4:08-CV-03594-WRW E/D AR W/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/DAR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR E/D AR W/D AR W/D AR W/D AR W/D AR E/D AR

Non-Arkansas Cases Smith v. Wyeth Inc, et al Linscomb, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Gordon, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Barrios, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Spalding v. Wyeth Inc, et al Francis v. Wyeth Inc et al Coppick, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Glenn, et al v. Wyeth Inc Hardy, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Lo v. Wyeth Inc, et al 4:04-cv-00330-WRW 4:04-cv-00344-WRW 4:04-cv-00347-WRW 4:04-cv-00348-WRW 4:04-cv-00352-WRW 4:04-cv-00353-WRW 4:04-cv-00399-WRW 4:04-cv-00446-WRW 4:04-cv-00455-WRW 4:04-cv-00457-WRW USDC SD TX USDC ED TX USDC ED TX USDC ED TX USDC ND TX USDC ND TX USDC ED TX USDC SD NY USDC SD TX USDC SD TX

2

Klein v. Wyeth, et al Kohls v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Kim v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Prigge v. Wyeth Inc, et al Maclam, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Norman, et al v. Wyeth, et al Merk, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Dodeja v. Wyeth Inc, et al Slitor, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Damron, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Flannary, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Taulbee, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Minnear, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Braden v. Wyeth Inc, et al Wilson v. Wyeth Inc, et al Livingston, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Kutz v. Wyeth Inc, et al Obradovich, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Brinkley v. Wyeth Inc, et al Bosworth, et al v. Wyeth, et al Strauss v. Wyeth Inc, et al Filer, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Stevens v. Wyeth Inc, et al Grisso v. Pharmacia & Upjohn, et al Harvill v. Wyeth Inc, et al Floyd v. Wyeth Inc, et al Faro, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Lee v. Wyeth Inc, et al Ryan, et al v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al McCormick, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al DuFour v. Wyeth, et al Close v. Wyeth, et al Davenport, et al v. Wyeth, et al Canavan v. Wyeth, et al Ashbaugh, et al v. Wyeth, et al Ross, et al v. Wyeth, et al Schweikl, et al v. Wyeth, et al Gloria, et al v. Wyeth, et al Delonga, et al v. Wyeth, et al Safar, et al v. Wyeth, et al

4:04-cv-00614-WRW 4:04-cv-00649-WRW 4:04-cv-00650-WRW 4:04-cv-00756-WRW 4:04-cv-00830-WRW 4:04-cv-00852-WRW 4:04-cv-00857-WRW 4:04-cv-00858-WRW 4:04-cv-00861-WRW 4:04-cv-00863-WRW 4:04-cv-00864-WRW 4:04-cv-00865-WRW 4:04-cv-00866-WRW 4:04-cv-00867-WRW 4:04-cv-00873-WRW 4:04-cv-00879-WRW 4:04-cv-00882-WRW 4:04-cv-00884-WRW 4:04-cv-00925-WRW 4:04-cv-00939-WRW 4:04-cv-00956-WRW 4:04-cv-00981-WRW 4:04-cv-00997-WRW 4:04-cv-01002-WRW 4:04-cv-01054-WRW 4:04-cv-01060-WRW 4:04-cv-01067-WRW 4:04-cv-01069-WRW 4:04-cv-01072-WRW 4:04-cv-01075-WRW 4:04-cv-01078-WRW 4:04-cv-01087-WRW 4:04-cv-01150-WRW 4:04-cv-01155-WRW 4:04-cv-01190-WRW 4:04-cv-01192-WRW 4:04-cv-01194-WRW 4:04-cv-01200-WRW 4:04-cv-01204-WRW 4:04-cv-01231-WRW

USDC CD CA USDC CD CA USDC CD CA USDC MN USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC SD OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC MN USDC ND OK USDC ND OH USDC SD TX USDC SD OH USDC ND CA USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC WD TX USDC ED TX

3

Mulcahy v. Wyeth, et al Corso v. Wyeth, et al Skeens v. Wyeth, et al Baker v. Wyeth, et al McLean v. Wyeth, et al Ocraman, et al v. Wyeth, et al McBride, et al v. Wyeth, et al Kelley, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Brumley v. Wyeth, et al Boucher v. Wyeth, et al Allen v. Wyeth, et al McComas v. Wyeth, et al Powell v. Wyeth, et al Trammell, et al v. Wyeth, et al Robbins, et al v. Wyeth, et al McMahon, et al v. Wyeth, et al Duran v. Wyeth, et al Adams, et al v. Wyeth, et al Gibson v. Wyeth, et al Franczak v. Wyeth, et al Gamble v. Wyeth, et al Buccini, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Coleman v. Wyeth, et al Tubb, et al v. Wyeth, et al Kenney, et al v. Wyeth, et al Johnson, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Kingsley v. Wyeth, et al Malik v. Wyeth, et al Eural v. Wyeth, et al Swaggerty v. Wyeth Stedman v. Wyeth, et al Cocker v. Wyeth, et al Howard, et al v. Wyeth, et al Carey v. Wyeth, et al Main, et al v. Wyeth, et al Tappan, et al v. Wyeth, et al Barath v. Wyeth Inc, et al Holifield, et al v. Wyeth, et al Davis v. Wyeth Inc, et al Alexander v. Wyeth, et al

4:04-cv-01279-WRW 4:04-cv-01282-WRW 4:04-cv-01283-WRW 4:04-cv-01293-WRW 4:04-cv-01296-WRW 4:04-cv-01302-WRW 4:04-cv-01304-WRW 4:04-cv-01314-WRW 4:04-cv-01332-WRW 4:04-cv-01333-WRW 4:04-cv-01334-WRW 4:04-cv-01336-WRW 4:04-cv-01339-WRW 4:04-cv-01342-WRW 4:04-cv-01343-WRW 4:04-cv-01344-WRW 4:04-cv-01352-WRW 4:04-cv-01353-WRW 4:04-cv-01354-WRW 4:04-cv-01356-WRW 4:04-cv-01360-WRW 4:04-cv-01370-WRW 4:04-cv-01373-WRW 4:04-cv-01374-WRW 4:04-cv-01376-WRW 4:04-cv-01378-WRW 4:04-cv-01380-WRW 4:04-cv-01383-WRW 4:04-cv-01384-WRW 4:04-cv-01386-WRW 4:04-cv-01388-WRW 4:04-cv-01389-WRW 4:04-cv-01395-WRW 4:04-cv-01396-WRW 4:04-cv-01403-WRW 4:04-cv-01404-WRW 4:04-cv-01407-WRW 4:04-cv-01409-WRW 4:04-cv-01410-WRW 4:04-cv-01411-WRW

USDC ED TX USDC CT USDC SD WV USDC MN USDC MN USDC ED TX USDC ED TX USDC SD MS USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC WD TX USDC CT USDC ED TX USDC ED TX USDC ND TX USDC NE USDC ED VA USDC ED VA USDC ED VA USDC ED VA USDC SD MS USDC ND OK USDC ED TX USDC ED TX USDC MD USDC MD USDC ND OH USDC SD MS USDC ND TX USDC SD MS

4

Hennington v. Wyeth, et al French v. Wyeth, et al Linton v. Wyeth, et al Whitehead v. Wyeth, et al Weber v. Wyeth, et al Steely, et al v. Wyeth, et al Goldrich v. Wyeth, et al Bennett, et al v. Wyeth, et al Perona v. Wyeth, et al Contreras v. Abbott Labs Inc, et al Stefanik, et al v. Wyeth, et al Taja, et al v. Wyeth, et al Foster v. Wyeth Inc, et al Welch v. Wyeth Inc, et al Duke, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Barlow, et al v. Wyeth, et al Bowman, et al v. Wyeth, et al Bishop v. Wyeth, et al Pashalidis, et al v. Wyeth, et al Hamilton v. Wyeth, et al Struve v. Wyeth, et al Gillaspy v. Wyeth, et al Cook v. Wyeth, et al Blake, et al v. Wyeth, et al Wright, et al v. Wyeth, et al Garcia v. Wyeth, et al Griffice v. Wyeth, et al Colucci v. Wyeth, et al Dillon v. Wyeth, et al Granier v. Wyeth, et al Egan, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Jackson v. Wyeth Inc, et al Gray, et al v. Barr Pharm, et al Wingfield v. Wyeth Inc, et al Ellis, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Summersett, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Taylor, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Strops et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Howell, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Hyatt v. Wyeth Inc, et al

4:04-cv-01412-WRW 4:04-cv-01413-WRW 4:04-cv-01414-WRW 4:04-cv-01415-WRW 4:04-cv-01420-WRW 4:04-cv-01422-WRW 4:04-cv-01427-WRW 4:04-cv-01432-WRW 4:04-cv-01433-WRW 4:04-cv-01434-WRW 4:04-cv-01436-WRW 4:04-cv-01439-WRW 4:04-cv-01440-WRW 4:04-cv-01441-WRW 4:04-cv-01446-WRW 4:04-cv-01448-WRW 4:04-cv-01467-WRW 4:04-cv-01472-WRW 4:04-cv-01490-WRW 4:04-cv-01492-WRW 4:04-cv-01494-WRW 4:04-cv-01497-WRW 4:04-cv-01505-WRW 4:04-cv-01507-WRW 4:04-cv-01511-WRW 4:04-cv-01512-WRW 4:04-cv-01516-WRW 4:04-cv-01518-WRW 4:04-cv-01521-WRW 4:04-cv-01523-WRW 4:04-cv-01524-WRW 4:04-cv-01530-WRW 4:04-cv-01534-WRW 4:04-cv-01547-WRW 4:04-cv-01548-WRW 4:04-cv-01554-WRW 4:04-cv-01555-WRW 4:04-cv-01560-WRW 4:04-cv-01561-WRW 4:04-cv-01562-WRW

USDC SD MS USDC SD MS USDC SD MS USDC SD MS USDC ED TX USDC ED TX USDC ND IL USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MD FL USDC ED NY USDC ED TN USDC WD TX USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC ED NY USDC SD TX USDC SD TX USDC CT USDC MD LA USDC SD TX USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND A USDC ND AL USDC ND AL

5

Schwartz v. Wyeth Inc, et al Tobin, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Craven, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Nichols, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Coday, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Campis, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Blunk, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Baker, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Breyfogle, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Richardson, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Gary, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Parker v. Wyeth Inc, et al Hamilton v. Wyeth Inc, et al Shearin, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Nodine, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Dutt, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Battle, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Pendergrass, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Spiers, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Kincaid, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Magner, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Anderson, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Freeney, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Stewart, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Hargis, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Giordano, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Trommer, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Buchanan, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Henning, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Barco, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Wilson, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Pahlman et al v. Wyeth Inc et al Chester, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Doan, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Baker v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Ball v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Bell v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Bentley v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Blankenship v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Boyles v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al

4:04-cv-01563-WRW 4:04-cv-01566-WRW 4:04-cv-01571-WRW 4:04-cv-01572-WRW 4:04-cv-01574-WRW 4:04-cv-01576-WRW 4:04-cv-01577-WRW 4:04-cv-01578-WRW 4:04-cv-01579-WRW 4:04-cv-01581-WRW 4:04-cv-01586-WRW 4:04-cv-01591-WRW 4:04-cv-01593-WRW 4:04-cv-01594-WRW 4:04-cv-01596-WRW 4:04-cv-01597-WRW 4:04-cv-01600-WRW 4:04-cv-01603-WRW 4:04-cv-01609-WRW 4:04-cv-01610-WRW 4:04-cv-01611-WRW 4:04-cv-01614-WRW 4:04-cv-01615-WRW 4:04-cv-01617-WRW 4:04-cv-01618-WRW 4:04-cv-01619-WRW 4:04-cv-01620-WRW 4:04-cv-01621-WRW 4:04-cv-01624-WRW 4:04-cv-01625-WRW 4:04-cv-01632-WRW 4:04-cv-01635-WRW 4:04-cv-01637-WRW 4:04-cv-01638-WRW 4:04-cv-01980-WRW 4:04-cv-01981-WRW 4:04-cv-01983-WRW 4:04-cv-01984-WRW 4:04-cv-01987-WRW 4:04-cv-01989-WRW

USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND A USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL

6

Young v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Bright v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Brindley v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Brooks v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Burrell v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Clayton v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Cook-Sabree v. Wyeth, et al Corker v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Cawford v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Davis v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Derwin v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Dew v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Dinkins v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Driver v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Dubin v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Edge v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Ezell v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Faggard v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical Ford v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Fore v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Gilbert, et al v. Wyeth, et al Godwin, et al v. Wyeth, et al Goss v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Greenough v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Griffin, et al v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Griffin v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Hamm, et al v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Hammond, et al v. Wyeth, et al Hollingsworth, et al v. Wyeth, et al Huckans v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Hudson, et al v. Wyeth, et al Hughey, et al v. Wyeth, et al Hunt v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Johnson v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Jones v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Kelly v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al King v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Knight v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical Inc et al Langford v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Langston v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al

4:04-cv-01990-WRW 4:04-cv-01992-WRW 4:04-cv-01993-WRW 4:04-cv-01995-WRW 4:04-cv-01998-WRW 4:04-cv-02006-WRW 4:04-cv-02011-WRW 4:04-cv-02012-WRW 4:04-cv-02014-WRW 4:04-cv-02020-WRW 4:04-cv-02022-WRW 4:04-cv-02023-WRW 4:04-cv-02024-WRW 4:04-cv-02026-WRW 4:04-cv-02028-WRW 4:04-cv-02032-WRW 4:04-cv-02033-WRW 4:04-cv-02034-WRW 4:04-cv-02038-WRW 4:04-cv-02040-WRW 4:04-cv-02048-WRW 4:04-cv-02049-WRW 4:04-cv-02053-WRW 4:04-cv-02056-WRW 4:04-cv-02057-WRW 4:04-cv-02058-WRW 4:04-cv-02061-WRW 4:04-cv-02062-WRW 4:04-cv-02074-WRW 4:04-cv-02078-WRW 4:04-cv-02080-WRW 4:04-cv-02081-WRW 4:04-cv-02083-WRW 4:04-cv-02090-WRW 4:04-cv-02093-WRW 4:04-cv-02096-WRW 4:04-cv-02099-WRW 4:04-cv-02100-WRW 4:04-cv-02102-WRW 4:04-cv-02103-WRW

USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL

7

Leps v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Lindsey v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Long v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Lott v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Love, et al v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Mann v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Martin, et al v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Martin v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al McClinton, et al v. Wyeth, et al McDowell, et al v. Wyeth, et al McLin v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al McMahon, et al v. Wyeth, et al McNeil v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Meier, et al v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Mindrebo v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Flowers, et al v. Wyeth, et al Sharma, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Golay, et al v. Wyeth Pharm, et al Williams v. Wyeth Inc, et al Jordan, et al v. Wyeth Pharm, et al Sauls v. Wyeth, et al Gibbons, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Ostenso, et al v. Wyeth, et al Armstrong, et al v. Wyeth, et al Pauly, et al v. Wyeth, et al Weinstein, et al v. Wyeth, et al Swingle v. Wyeth Inc, et al Case, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Decker v. Bristol-Myers Squibb, et al Lemmon, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Kuball, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Peters, et al v. Wyeth, et al Biernacka, et al v. Wyeth, et al Giberson, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Howell v. Wyeth Inc Walters, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al McKenzie v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical House v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical Swanson, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Silva, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al

4:04-cv-02105-WRW 4:04-cv-02106-WRW 4:04-cv-02110-WRW 4:04-cv-02111-WRW 4:04-cv-02112-WRW 4:04-cv-02117-WRW 4:04-cv-02119-WRW 4:04-cv-02120-WRW 4:04-cv-02121-WRW 4:04-cv-02122-WRW 4:04-cv-02123-WRW 4:04-cv-02124-WRW 4:04-cv-02125-WRW 4:04-cv-02126-WRW 4:04-cv-02128-WRW 4:04-cv-02257-WRW 4:04-cv-02260-WRW 4:04-cv-02261-WRW 4:04-cv-02263-WRW 4:04-cv-02286-WRW 4:04-cv-02295-WRW 4:04-cv-02314-WRW 4:04-cv-02317-WRW 4:04-cv-02321-WRW 4:04-cv-02322-WRW 4:04-cv-02325-WRW 4:05-cv-00001-WRW 4:05-cv-00002-WRW 4:05-cv-00003-WRW 4:05-cv-00007-WRW 4:05-cv-00008-WRW 4:05-cv-00010-WRW 4:05-cv-00016-WRW 4:05-cv-00027-WRW 4:05-cv-00028-WRW 4:05-cv-00042-WRW 4:05-cv-00050-WRW 4:05-cv-00051-WRW 4:05-cv-00052-WRW 4:05-cv-00053-WRW

USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ND AL USDC ED TX USDC MD LA USDC WD OK USDC ND FL USDC ED TX USDC SC USDC CT USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC MN USDC WD MO USDC WD MO USDC NV USDC ED MO USDC MN USDC MN USDC ND IL USDC WD MO USDC WD PA USDC CD IL USDC WD OK USDC WD OK USDC NE USDC CT

8

Clark v. Solvay Inc Carlson v. Wyeth, et al Knox v. Wyeth, et al Devoe v. Wyeth, et al Hanrahan, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Land v. Wyeth Inc, et al Shepherd v. Wyeth Pharm, et al Jimenez v. Wyeth Inc, et al Noyes, et al v. Wyeth, et al Yeauger v. Wyeth Inc, et al Albright, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Lee v. Wyeth, et al Wankier v. Wyeth, et al Fullmer v. Wyeth, et al Nina Schilling v. Wyeth Brown v. Wyeth Inc, et al Bush v. Wyeth Inc, et al Waites, et al v. Wyeth, et al McClure, et al v. Wyeth, et al Sheffield v. Wyeth Inc, et al Barnes, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Hilkens v. Wyeth, et al Toitch, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Gornor, et al v. Wyeth Inc, et al Bonnett v. Wyeth Inc, et al Dye v. Wyeth Inc, et al Danitz v. Wyeth Inc, et al Gutchman v. Wyeth Inc, et al Turonis v. Wyeth Inc, et al Baldy v. Wyeth Inc, et al Fowle v. Wyeth Inc, et al Costa v. Wyeth Inc, et al O'Shea, et al v. Wyeth, et al Shah, et al v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Lynn v. Wyeth, et al Consorti v. Wyeth et al Zarra-Redden v. Wyeth, et al Krol, et al v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Epstein, et al v. Wyeth, et al Broumandi, et al v. Wyeth, et al

4:05-cv-00063-WRW 4:05-cv-00064-WRW 4:05-cv-00065-WRW 4:05-cv-00066-WRW 4:05-cv-00071-WRW 4:05-cv-00074-WRW 4:05-cv-00092-WRW 4:05-cv-00121-WRW 4:05-cv-00125-WRW 4:05-cv-00132-WRW 4:05-cv-00133-WRW 4:05-cv-00146-WRW 4:05-cv-00152-WRW 4:05-cv-00159-WRW 4:05-cv-00164-WRW 4:05-cv-00166-WRW 4:05-cv-00169-WRW 4:05-cv-00174-WRW 4:05-cv-00182-WRW 4:05-cv-00185-WRW 4:05-cv-00189-WRW 4:05-cv-00190-WRW 4:05-cv-00191-WRW 4:05-cv-00193-WRW 4:05-cv-00194-WRW 4:05-cv-00195-WRW 4:05-cv-00196-WRW 4:05-cv-00197-WRW 4:05-cv-00198-WRW 4:05-cv-00199-WRW 4:05-cv-00201-WRW 4:05-cv-00203-WRW 4:05-cv-00213-WRW 4:05-cv-00359-WRW 4:05-cv-00366-WRW 4:05-cv-00367-WRW 4:05-cv-00368-WRW 4:05-cv-00369-WRW 4:05-cv-00370-WRW 4:05-cv-00372-WRW

USDC ED MO USDC OR USDC OR USDC ED NY USDC ED MO USDC/MD USDC WD TX USDC MD FL USDC OR USDC SD OH USDC SD OH USDC ID USDC UT USDC UT USDC ND NY USDC SD GA USDC ND TX USDC MD AL USDC SC USDC ND MS USDC WD KY USDC ND OH USDC ND OH USDC MD LA USDC MD FL USDC MD FL USDC MD FL USDC MD FL USDC MD FL USDC MD FL USDC MD FL USDC MD FL USDC SD TX USDC CD CA USDC ND AL USDC CT USDC VT USDC CD CA USDC CD CA USDC CD CA

9

Hawthorne, et al v. Wyeth, et al Heller, et al v. Wyeth, et al Spears, et al v. Wyeth, et al Kriss v. Wyeth Pharmaceutical, et al Mills, et al v. Wyeth Inc Leader, et al v. Wyeth, et al De Moss v. Wyeth, et al McCadden v. Wyeth Inc, et al Pipkin v. Wyeth Inc, et al Shuster, et al v. Wyeth, et al Denison v. Wyeth, et al Galyen v. Wyeth Inc, et al Danos, et al v. Wyeth, et al Keller v. Wyeth, et al Campbell v. Pfizer Inc, et al Christiansen v. Wyeth, et al Dees v. Wyeth Inc, et al Lewallen v. Wyeth, et al Youngwerth, et al v. Wyeth, et al Gilmore v. Wyeth Inc, et al Galinsky v. Wyeth, et al Narehood, et al v. Wyeth, et al Nina Reilly v. Wyeth Kramer v. Wyeth Inc, et al Spravzoff v. Wyeth, et al Strickland, et al v. Barr Pharm et al Harris v. Wyeth Inc, et al Arcuri v. Solvay Inc, et al Bierfass, et al v. Wyeth, et al McCoy v. Wyeth, et al

4:05-cv-00373-WRW 4:05-cv-00374-WRW 4:05-cv-00377-WRW 4:05-cv-00422-WRW 4:05-cv-00416-WRW 4:05-cv-00436-WRW 4:05-cv-00437-WRW 4:05-cv-00439-WRW 4:05-cv-00440-WRW 4:05-cv-00445-WRW 4:05-cv-00450-WRW 4:05-cv-00454-WRW 4:05-cv-00455-WRW 4:05-cv-00459-WRW 4:05-cv-00461-WRW 4:05-cv-00462-WRW 4:05-cv-00464-WRW 4:05-cv-00485-WRW 4:05-cv-00502-WRW 4:05-cv-00503-WRW 4:05-cv-00504-WRW 4:05-cv-00511-WRW 4:05-cv-00520-WRW 4:05-cv-00521-WRW 4:05-cv-00528-WRW 4:05-cv-00530-WRW 4:05-cv-00533-WRW 4:05-cv-00534-WRW 4:05-cv-00548-WRW 4:05-cv-00553-WRW

USDC CD CA USDC CD CA USDC SD OH USDC CD CA USDC ND TX USDC ND IL USDC MT USDC MD USDC MD USDC SD FL USDC MT USDC ND TX USDC MN USDC MT USDC ED TN USDC MD AL USDC SC USDC ND GA USDC MD USDC MN USDC MN USDC WD NC USDC SD NY USDC SD NY USDC ND USDC ND MS USDC MT USDC ED LA USDC MN USDC MN

10