Johann v. Wyeth et al

Filing 43

ORDER directing Plaintiff to provide any additional evidentiary support for claims against generic manufacturers by 5 p.m., Monday, May 20, 2013. Signed by Judge Billy Roy Wilson on 05/06/2013. (jak)

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
FOR THE EASTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS
WESTERN DIVISION

IN RE:
PREMPRO PRODUCTS LIABILITY
LITIGATION

:
:
:
:

MDL DOCKET NO. 4:03-CV-1507-BRW

CASES EXHIBIT A

ORDER
Pending are the generic drug manufacturer defendants’ motions for judgment on the
pleadings under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(c). However, I intend to consider matters
outside the pleadings1 when addressing the motions, so the motions must be treated as motions for
summary judgment.2
Accordingly, by 5 p.m., Monday, May 20, 2013, Plaintiff must provide all additional
evidence that she claims support the causes of action in her amended complaint against the generic
drug manufacturers. I believe that two weeks is sufficient time since discovery has been ongoing for
ten years and my September 2012 Order directed that Plaintiff provide specific factual allegations -at this point, Plaintiff should have the evidentiary support for any allegations in her amended
complaint.
The supplement should provide supporting evidence for Plaintiff’s allegations rather than
prose. Generic allegations without evidentiary support are insufficient at this point.
IT IS SO ORDERED this 6th day of May, 2013.

/s/ Billy Roy Wilson
UNITED STATES DISTRICT JUDGE

1

For example, on April 1, I requested that Plaintiff provide me with the FDA’s letter from 2000
mentioned in the Amended Complaint. In response, Plaintiff provided several documents.
2

Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 12(d) reads: “If, on a motion under 12(b)(6) or 12(c) matters
outside the pleadings are presented to and not excluded by the court, the motion must be treated as one for
summary judgment under Rule 56. All parties must be given a reasonable opportunity to present all the
material that is pertinent to the motion.”

1

EXHIBIT A
4:04-cv-00717-BRW
4:04-cv-00723-BRW
4:04-cv-01223-BRW
4:04-cv-01294-BRW
4:04-cv-01308-BRW

Lund v. Wyeth, et al
Gallegos v. Wyeth
Alexander et al v. Wyeth LLC et al
Cheltra v. Wyeth, et al
Banard, et al v. Wyeth, et al

4:05-cv-00075-BRW
4:05-cv-00146-BRW
4:05-cv-00206-BRW
4:05-cv-00253-BRW
4:05-cv-00396-BRW

Clouser v. Wyeth, et al
Lee v. Wyeth, et al
Posey et al v. Wyeth et al
Palomo, et al v. Wyeth, et al
Daly v. Wyeth, et al

4:05-cv-00558-BRW
4:05-cv-00598-BRW
4:05-cv-00614-BRW
4:05-cv-00697-BRW
4:05-cv-00910-BRW

Andenoro, et al v. Wyeth, et al
Paquin, et al v. Wyeth, et al
Campbell v. Wyeth, et al
Spicer v. Wyeth, et al
Wilkerson v. Wyeth Inc, et al

4:05-cv-01366-BRW
4:05-cv-01433-BRW
4:05-cv-01573-BRW
4:05-cv-01575-BRW
4:05-cv-01793-BRW

Cain v. Pharmacia a Upjohn Company LLC et al
Bowling et al v. Wyeth et al
Beaver v. Wyeth et al
Miller v. Wyeth et al
Keener v. Pfizer Inc et al

4:05-cv-01896-BRW
4:06-cv-00079-BRW
4:06-cv-00160-BRW
4:06-cv-00294-BRW
4:06-cv-00430-BRW

Johnson v. Wyeth et al
Hinkle v. Wyeth et al
Giambrone v. Wyeth et al
Ridgeway et al v. Wyeth et al
Dudley v. Wyeth et al

4:06-cv-00443-BRW
4:06-cv-00493-BRW
4:06-cv-00722-BRW
4:06-cv-00800-BRW
4:06-cv-00821-BRW

Plowman et al v. Wyeth et al
Bolton et al v. Wyeth et al
Moffett v. Wyeth et al
Thomas v. Wyeth et al
Goldberg v. Wyeth et al

4:06-cv-00879-BRW
4:06-cv-00916-BRW
4:06-cv-00938-BRW
4:06-cv-01022-BRW
4:06-cv-01048-BRW

Russell et al v. Vivelle Ventures LLC et al
Lyons v. Wyeth et al
Wright v. Wyeth et al
Black v. Wyeth et al
Goodman v. Wyeth et al

2

4:06-cv-01120-BRW
4:06-cv-01127-BRW
4:06-cv-01165-BRW
4:06-cv-01224-BRW
4:06-cv-01339-BRW

White-Brown v. Wyeth et al
Wojcik v. Wyeth et al
Cavaliere v. Wyeth et al
Bradley v. Wyeth et al
Kinser v. Wyeth et al

4:06-cv-01345-BRW
4:06-cv-01398-BRW
4:06-cv-01438-BRW
4:06-cv-01443-BRW
4:06-cv-01455-BRW

Clement et al v. Wyeth et al
Puzzuole v. Wyeth et al
Zimmerman v. Wyeth et al
Johnson v. Wyeth et al
Neubarth v. Wyeth et al

4:06-cv-01488-BRW
4:06-cv-01502-BRW
4:06-cv-01506-BRW
4:06-cv-01516-BRW
4:06-cv-01564-BRW

Roseman v. Wyeth et al
Rosenbloom et al v. Wyeth et al
Balis et al v. Wyeth et al
Schultz v. Wyeth et al
Sayers v. Wyeth et al

4:06-cv-01617-BRW
4:06-cv-01650-BRW
4:06-cv-01679-BRW
4:07-cv-00095-BRW
4:07-cv-00419-BRW

Koch v. Wyeth et al
Chambers v. Wyeth et al
Rittenberry v. Wyeth et al
Williams et al v. Wyeth et al
Tangman et al v. Wyeth et al

4:07-cv-00478-BRW
4:07-cv-00558-BRW
4:07-cv-00731-BRW
4:08-cv-00402-BRW
4:08-cv-00462-BRW

Harding v. Wyeth et al
Dale v. Wyeth et al
Irwin et al v. Wyeth et al
Kielty v. Wyeth et al
Okon v. Wyeth et al

4:08-cv-00699-BRW
4:08-cv-00864-BRW
4:08-cv-01393-BRW
4:08-cv-01687-BRW
4:08-cv-01848-BRW

Draper et al v. Wyeth et al
Barnes v. Wyeth et al
Fisher v. Wyeth et al
Peterson v. Wyeth et al
Weaver v. Barr Pharmaceuticals Inc et al

4:08-cv-01999-BRW
4:08-cv-02116-BRW
4:08-cv-02313-BRW
4:08-cv-02314-BRW
4:08-cv-02388-BRW

Weaver v. Wyeth et al
Blaisdell v. Wyeth et al
Weaver v. Wyeth et al
Kropf v. Wyeth et al
McCarthy v. Wyeth Pharmaceuticals Inc et al

4:08-cv-02413-BRW
4:08-cv-03119-BRW
4:08-cv-03121-BRW
4:08-cv-03167-BRW
4:08-cv-03178-BRW

Cook v. Wyeth et al
Estell v. Wyeth et al
Reed v. Pfizer Inc et al
Bumpas v. Wyeth et al
Johann v. Wyeth et al
3

4:08-cv-03207-BRW
4:08-cv-03211-BRW
4:08-cv-03213-BRW
4:08-cv-03631-BRW
4:08-cv-03677-BRW

McLain v. Wyeth et al
Haupert v. Wyeth et al
Weinfurtner v. Wyeth et al
Alvarran et al v. Wyeth, et al
Burton et al v. Wyeth, et al

4:08-cv-03699-BRW
4:08-cv-03723-BRW
4:08-cv-03777-BRW
4:08-cv-03833-BRW
4:08-cv-03905-BRW

Hennin v. Wyeth Inc et al
Cornell v. Wyeth, et al
Goodman et al v. Wyeth, et al
Humphreys v. Wyeth, et al
Mayo et al v. Wyeth, et al

4:08-cv-03913-BRW
4:08-cv-03923-BRW
4:08-cv-03927-BRW
4:08-cv-03932-BRW
4:08-cv-03985-BRW

Roy et al v. Wyeth, et al
Saunders et al v. Wyeth, et al
Scarbro et al v. Wyeth, et al
Scott et al v. Wyeth, et al
Mitchelll v. Wyeth, et al

4:08-cv-04017-BRW
4:08-cv-04087-BRW
4:09-cv-00103-BRW
4:09-cv-00741-BRW
4:10-cv-00291-BRW

Utt et al v. Wyeth, et al
Poe et al v. Wyeth, et al
Huff v. Barr Laboratories Inc et al
Frambs v. Wyeth et al
Turk v. Wyeth et al

4:10-cv-00350-BRW
4:10-cv-00370-BRW
4:10-cv-00461-BRW
4:10-cv-00475-BRW
4:10-cv-00478-BRW

Banks v. Wyeth LLC et al
Steele et al v. Wyeth et al
Slaton v. Wyeth LLC et al
Hart et al v. Wyeth LLC et al
Evosevich et al v. Wyeth LLC et al

4:10-cv-00569-BRW
4:10-cv-00609-BRW
4:10-cv-00656-BRW
4:10-cv-00823-BRW
4:10-cv-00912-BRW

Williams v. Wyeth LLC et al
Walther v. Wyeth LLC et al
Wilson v. Wyeth LLC et al
Kirchhoff v. Wyeth LLC et al
Jacquemart v. Wyeth LLC et al

4:10-cv-00921-BRW
4:10-cv-00922-BRW
4:10-cv-00923-BRW
4:10-cv-00926-BRW
4:10-cv-00935-BRW

Bussart v. Wyeth LLC et al
Moore v. Wyeth LLC et al
Meranto v. Wyeth LLC et al
Fields v. Wyeth LLC et al
Wood v. Wyeth LLC et al

4:10-cv-00941-BRW
4:10-cv-00955-BRW
4:10-cv-00988-BRW
4:10-cv-00989-BRW
4:10-cv-01018-BRW

Mangan v. Wyeth LLC
Provasnik v. Wyeth Inc et al
Anglin v. Wyeth LLC et al
Dahlman v. Wyeth LLC et al
Raatz v. Wyeth LLC et al
4

4:10-cv-01029-BRW
4:10-cv-01030-BRW
4:10-cv-01034-BRW
4:10-cv-01035-BRW
4:10-cv-01039-BRW

Beylen v. Wyeth LLC et al
Contreras v. Wyeth LLC et al
Howard v. Wyeth LLC et al
Stanionis v. Wyeth LLC et al
Gilmore v. Wyeth LLC et al

4:10-cv-01040-BRW
4:10-cv-01046-BRW
4:10-cv-01060-BRW
4:10-cv-01061-BRW
4:10-cv-01080-BRW

Crane v. Wyeth LLC et al
Meiller v. Wyeth LLC
Sain v. Wyeth LLC et al
Struckmann v. Wyeth LLC et al
Dasen v. Wyeth LLC et al

4:10-cv-01267-BRW
4:10-cv-01272-BRW
4:11-cv-00203-BRW
4:11-cv-00787-BRW

Owens et al v. Wyeth LLC et al
Mosely v. Wyeth LLC et al
Whatley et al v. Wyeth LLC et al
Riegle et al v. Wyeth LLC et al

5