Roberts v. Hobbs et al

Filing 142

ORDER. The Court attaches recently received letters and materials from counsel to this Order. To make a complete record, the Court prefers that counsel communicate about such matters with the Court only by filing matters in the docket. Signed by Judge D. P. Marshall Jr. on 3/5/13. (kpr)

Download PDF
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT EASTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS PINE BLUFF DIVISION BRUNSON ROBERTS, ADC #127841 v. PLAINTIFF No. 5:10-cv-174-DPM DEFENDANTS RODERICK JOHNSON and RICKY WEBB ORDER The Court attaches recently received letters and materials from counsel to this Order. To make a complete record, the Court prefers that counsel communicate about such matters with the Court only by filing matters in the docket. e. D.P. Marshall Jr. United States District Judge 5 March2013 Page 1 of 1 Roberts v. Hobbs, et al5:10CV00174 Christine Cryer to: grather@wlj .com, Courtney C. McLarty 03/04/2013 05:42PM Cc: "dpmchambers@ared.uscourts.gov" Hide Details From: Christine Cryer <christine.cryer@arkansasag.gov> To: "grather@wlj.com" <grather@wlj.com>, "Courtney C. McLarty" <CMcLarty@wlj.com>, Cc: "dpmchambers@ared.uscourts.gov" <dpmchambers@ared. uscourts.gov> History: This message has been forwarded. 1 Attachment ,:1 _, 20130304174142.pdf Letter attached. Christine A. Cryer Assistant Attorney General 323 Center, Suite 200 Little Rock, Arkansas 72201 (501) 683-0958 christine.cryer@arkansasag.gov file://C: \Users\rkculp\AppData\Local\Temp\notesAB3C21 \-web5066.htm 3/5/2013 STATE OF ARKANSAS OFFICE OF THE ATTORNEY GENERAL DUSTIN McDANIEL Direct dial: (501) 683-0958 Facsimile: (501) 682-2591 E-mail: christine.cryer@arkansasag.gov Christine A. Cryer Assistant Attorney General March 4, 2013 Courtney C. McLarty Gordon S. Rather, Jr. Wright, Lindsey & Jennings 200 West Capitol Ave., Suite 2300 Little Rock, AR 72201-3699 Re: Via email and Regular U.S. Mail Roberts v. Hobbs, et al., USDC 5:10cv174 Dear Courtney and Gordon: In preparation for next week's trial, I visited the Varner Unit today to obtain cleaner copies of the sanitation documents already in the record. As I was going through the sanitation and security records, I found a number of VSM Sanitation Rosters dated September 2009 which had not previously been produced to me. Attached is a copy of the sanitation rosters I found. I think you will agree they are relevant to the lawsuit, and as such, I intend to offer then as exhibits at trial. Although they are relevant, I anticipate you will object to the introduction of these records due to their late discovery. If the Court does not allow me to introduce them as exhibits, I will ask that I be allowed to use them for impeachment purposes. By copy of this letter to the Court, I am notifying his Honor of the document discovery, so that the issue can be addressed prior to trial. ~~ CHRISTINE A. CRYER Assistant Attorney General CAC cc: Honorable D.P. Marshall via email w/ attachments 323 Center Street • Suite 200 • Little Rock, Arkansas 72201 (501) 682-2007 • FAX (501) 682-2591 Internet Website • http://www.ag.state.ar.us/ VARNER SUPERMAX SANITATION ROSTER , Cellfilock6 DATE~ Cell Name CB6-601 [~ex'{.\ CB6-602 ADC# 1~.n,. Rt~\J f1 ~Wr\IJ CB6-603 ,I,.)}~ CB6-606 1 \~]~ __Lil l~J "1)J J{_\ '/\~. ( 1\{,J. Dlr'\Q \, I CB6-609 CB6-610 CB6-611 ~ '"·(\!"I i '-!) . ~-~~.Ciin-~11) .\-\li\~\(~\ ltJ~~\~ . I 'G l C'k1h C\ I l') m.'J\~l· I~ ,,.S,_r~),. CB6-612 ,__G~~c:a'\ CB6-613 Is. t>~rJ.\\\ CB6-614 B. f!Jr)bf'"~ CB6-616 CB6-617 CB6-618 CB6-619 CB6-620 CB6-621 CB6-622 I .. C--rt~.;."\ f>WJ~ ll) ~<"b~\lJ\ r-·~ 'e ~ bO\~riJ l·t 0' G'-'.\·hli [E.lwnb ., rs.bv£~.u- CB6-625 ;'fL\'\11l\ I v. P?..£\ti-'L Supervisor's Signature v ~ \} \/\!.. \.)~hru1m C'fl6..624 v: v \~~li l.t l~t'&l~ollh \1b6~ I~ ., CB6-623 CB6-626 I Grooming " vi '\d\\)n 1{1\ ~\\t'l-l •• I I IV', irJ J \~h~ 1r~ ~~1k~ rvtb~~J.~ p· 'r\d\\'\A\~ CB6-615 Shower llr'\r\[-,\ ir/''1\.)l..ll CB6-608 1 v I I \..!.\ './ Cl IeM obs I p, J ItroiD_~ I ~i v. lant-dl J-n \/, llfl~l . Ll~ V< . n~ ~&CQ-. CB6-607 IJru . ~ 1~, Cleaning Lo'tt k,A(..JX..,-v,y· Wlw J. ~'\ •. 190\U!b CB6-605 In l\11 8"tl I~'1 ll!Ibn~\ CB6-604 I Race OFFICER: 1 0~'-1~~ I~ \\~ hYLt I L L ...... / ~ ,tY ,tY v v/ J '11' \/. IG 1\/ I 1\-t\.\1!.\~ I~ ~k ~----- )// w h/ (\G~\1·1 ~ ~\~1 v ,; v Cell Bloc I Other Co~e_nts ' VARNER SUPERMAX SANITATION ROSTER - Celllilock 6 DATE Cell CB6-627 CB6-628 CB6-629 CB6-630 6 631 CB CB6-632 CB i\:!-{J l\. OFFICER: I Name '::\6\1\\t:} Shower It:l\~~ 1·-B II ~ ---lfu~t~\\IE Tf\' K\1~~\'\ 1a:'\~\ 11, 'P.~tP\\- rJZ tt , 1 n~ L,\ 1 \rJ 1 1\~\0l-\2 I~ 'l:\ttt'ilnr._ ·-··-·l E~~~f' · · · ·- ~-- A P: (;.~( ~ 11'3t1lDt~ II\) In. JLv Tl\7 f&~i~,~--Tt3 1\'Q~f57D 1-G Ih/ .\5~\;, L 1\~\{~\ D ~~-ll\7; CB6-634 I (. CB6-635 rt"'~,l~h n~,,~~~ '~. lrJ.~)~{~} 1\qroo J·~ 11v, lnllb1t ,. ~. 1rv ID~YI IXh 1 ~ Lv 1\Tl i\i 1 11 .\J t\ l\lLb11a.l ~ Ih/ I\3E.rlnY I t1 IJJ/J CB6-636 6 637 CB - p. 1 wh~. ----- 1\~i\6 'Gt£J CB 6-638 t\~ 6 639 CB - 6 641 cs - R'.~rn~ _ I P. ~~~~r--r1/Y\~~~\~r·Y~l\ cs6-642 lr • htrJNh.V\1'\ 6 643 CB - lf\l.~f\'hA\1~ CB6-644 I~.G~~\~:i CB6-645 k\. ft-iG~l\. 6 640 CB - 6 646 CB 6 647 CB CB6-648 CB6-649 cs6-6so CB6-651 CB6-652 -~ . 1\~t)\(Jll'l n--~1\7 -- . -------l\\~~\ llv li\- -1 Kl ---- - rrt~ I"K~ l~'\c.Cr~ f\~I~K~&~CJ p /t fN'i I l\'-':l~~t\ I # ~ .-7- £ ~ _· ~ ~ 1117I rt, 1 hi. 1\\ ~'t \o~' I Q 11\]J 1\\~~~& 1 '[\-lTv; 1\~\,~tl\J Jl VL t\. \\ru\::\\0 Supervisor's Signature ,.-1 ~ II \j 1\\~~~~ ~ 16frii\~ L'S. :rs~\~ta- lrJJc\d\M\~1\ 1\S.ow._~ · u0 I£_ Jtv' ·~ ~ 1r1H"''' 1 ~ 11v Cell Bloc C,cu i-1\Vtfvy l Grooming T Other Comments Cell BLock t I Cell r- Name G-. fC!'-N\t.!' I CB6-656 ,t CB6-657 I • -- l~kc\~81 ~ I\C~DC\~1 ~ ....... ~~ Pt. t\\~- Cliti-&l;t-TCJ '~~~(~t\r\:\ --~--··· -I R~W't.Cl\\J'L{' csG-6tD lfj. \\!~\'\\'\ CB6-ul•~ I fU\~ \\c~\.\. ca6-665 Cll6·bl•l• - --- -- - 173_.~\\~b~u~ I C~\i.Jh~\\d. IJ'v\. t\~\\{.{'. l'B6·b"~ t ~~b-{• 70 C'Bo-6 71 CBu-~n CB6-613 6 674 cs 675 CBC.- __ j ~. r\\1W~-N'o~Wocd rc 1\(, ~C\Qrt... ; . ~\\_\\A.L\~)f\_1t ~·t'r\~ \~. Cb\~'tY\rA,(\ p' GFJdi L'l3b·b7(l I ~.·ul•-l•7l II v, 1\~t;,'d-C\L\L\lv ''~~~C\\o I\N. S\Si'~l \1\J ~t)\i~t~ ~l\tXX\1. t1 tt 11-V: II v II \/; ][\7, / ~<YbGIIJ.I ~ '"~'""" Si'"""" ~~-- - ~ ~ II V, l\'n1\il~ . . ll V rrv . \ r'f6 IV l\~\i1vt C\1 n II v 1 \\~~~)ltr ~ -- ~···'·" iffi,'lt~. Comments {S ·-~~~ 1\\q~f~ __ j\\'llilaS31 ~ 1 1\, ~v t~i t\e- f I tl V, ''~1s1 \_J ~ ~u iL .n\.{)L\.K'l. 1.~ II \1/ lt<l3"R~I61 ·~ IJ \!J - 1 R'('(;~\t1 '<~ 1[, rx;[~'. 1 t:) ~~~i~qL\J dlt>·(•u7 ('Bo-Oll'l ~ '- U V; II \h Itt\L-G~ r~ 1 1 l\7 I\~~)~ I ~ .ll v l\~l~SQ .I \tJ JJ~ I\1lY16C\ I :r~ I 1\7 Ig4\l\q I \r-J II \ \\(ii;)[\.'\ ~- Jly L_ 1\o!Dl.S ll) IT\7 1\\n~c\ 1 '(>, II.J, 1~\'\.t~\ (ll6-65~ ~~- ~c~('r\;J 4 CBb-bS ~~ I C..f.,~'f( CB6-6oll ~. C::~~~ 'CSir6~1 Cell Block 6 ---~--- csc,-~ 53 t\,~B~~m cau-654 IM..~'\-Lr,.~e~ CB6-o55 VARNER SUPERMAX ...,ANITATION ROSTER DATE --~~-t)C\ OFFICER: L...e:u: ~J\vt..1'" ..... I ADC# I Race I Cleanipg Shower I Grooming I Other ... ~ ~ I IIV .. ...,.. ~ " ·- - r- .. ·- .,.if~ T~·t ., ·~-- 't 400-5 DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS SECURITY CHECK LOG DATE: C/-(/-(J ~ C/uzrf c~(~ OFFICER SIGNATURE 400-5 400-5 DEPARTMENT OF CORRECTIONS SECURITY CHECK LOG DATE: Cc 1( C I t:q;(}- L1 C0l~ OFFICER SIGNATURE 400-5 VARNER SUPERMAX vANITATION ROSTER Cell Blod\ f> DATE ___ I cG6-Citll T 1 \J'On<......c; _11· cBc.-c.o2 I 1\nJ)tM.-K cuu-bU3 1 4tn~re.J~7 Cell j Name . CBlH>IJS I M.Wirl.-t. ~h;~~~J. CBo-b09 I U~s~·l")_ ~- csti-(l!O 1 - -J \41 7 ' a~n.l r~. i"'J' MoDl<-.- A - CB6-(,14 I cal•·() I; 1 f;r~. cs6-616 1 C:Bu-ul7 I .a.LtJ~ cBt•-(lls I <:f6hnsQh. lr/ ctv•-t-19 1 hr.e,<./Y'l, 1 Cl~tH• 211 M -Uoll6wev.A. p V ILvl IJ(', fJ\ ' 't_.a_,;~ulrtlJ, ('JS(H•, l ~-~~- cBc•-!122 In 'bu._;,./n" CBt,·i123 1,~j,A1h.P~ U CG¢·-b14 \ - ('B(\·U:1 5 Cl>tHi~CI • "J ../.. ~~.I' \I'\ "(_,S'_ ,...... O~uk£.,#. I \1 t>~Ol . K j 1 S""'NoW; p J cr I.J/ V ,I.,{JJI'{.JR- . :/"\ s;,.,,,.,., ~ u~~ j tJ>iX ~ {Llf vh·~ Grooming I .ell Block 6 iJ Othi;:--T · Comments Y""" ~ V' .,. v II ,.... ~II II ~ I I V . v .......... .......- \q?~1J3 j8~~ ~ 'V""' ...,/ v- v I I II II - ~ .......,.. ..,.... v IJ6b'JJ3 llb.-c:;B7'1 lt~k.ins. T I Ji IJ,:S Lj66,~ I J< I C\36-613 I!31J.;)B8 IJ~ 78'1 I I Cleaning ......... ~37Y..:3j ~~<153} CBu-607 C\3~>-bll I s~++J~~ Cl'lll-61~ 1 b45'Jo~. L \ Race TiJq'1s~ 1 f 1u;~. ADC# ~~:!wH: IL~7al<; A- Mi llt:>n,bl<..s. A lcso.oo; I ~no~ .I? : ~-s ~ cso-6o6 cs(l-bO~ q~.J~-o9 ~',, v l131~tpf> ~ .......... 17 ..,..,- v IF-ld5~LJ IJifl ~8 !8JtD '/&; Ihla/"1 IJL"i~~L/] ho~&D 1J}'7 ~<.l::S I \'J6g bt,:) I' J.;)!i~;o;q .. !JaB 1{5~ ~ I ~ ·a ....... Y' Y"""' ~i ~ v ......... ~ v v v .,. ~y ~t v ,/ jqLjqf41 a.-- v ln3'194 ~ ./ I/()?, BYl 14.,"'IJn-"10.... 1, Q""' C> ,... !/ v/ v/ 1,, I VARNER SUPERMAX .vANITATION ROSTER Ct:il Blm:k (. CJ_:-:J~::..a!_____ ~!i!i~: &>• J<. DATE _____ j Cell l'Bi>-6.:!7 . J N:1me -ro..l ' • VI I cl3l>-629 1 ~~ Cl3i•-6.3U I~~ \iy-. ("l3(i-6j:! 1 ~wJ.. CBG-tiJJ I ovv ., 1 CBti-634 ~ v v t./ v 13 A ()»i{,, ( .J \NtJ.l81li'n. P I Grooming v v ........- IJdtif::J.. L Jfl j 6'f'i/io Ia -:-TI ff 0\Q(.,(.. n - Cleaning v i~l370 I c5<.:tJ<L.l:~ l't;~>-u31 j Race I - 01 N\,,1')~. l ) l"l3<t-(J2ll AOC# J66Bll c_j t~ j 1-ale'lal:f 1'1315~ rr?B670 iJ3~3tO ~l&Jg_ v v -7 wa Jtwms j Other Comments J .,... . l'f .,/' ........ v ., v v ;:en Block 6 v Wa,vdJow, 0 63346 vi /l 14tJi"J(>.~ ./ .,/ J llli~B v"' ,../' ~ ~. v L'Bn-ti35 1 CBC.-u36 I W~if'. l·n...".n 1 L"i)lH!}li I l'B•i·<•~9 1 'Ao\1 B Ae.a....i 3 , .......... I Ll~··-6~H J. 'T I f(f....." k~J . D IB:J.IJJ/ cuti-6-11 t Si -~rn. 6 -rJ t IY\ 1/®'}':(..:J v (1311·114:! I Ni>Yth.WV"' . J/, ....,.. l'l3u-t.-B I I -rht>rn ~6l'1 , 1\f IJ35Du4 /' I v CG<.i-o-1-1 I /f 1 # c. -"( \ /-:»( ~ • J 'I {JT>We,.lY! tJ };;l1803 lboi.Jlt.f tb.'1a' v v v L'13u-b4~ I ~ lt'fllt-b-l(l l Ar.Jr ~. s CBt,.M7 I fn({ol.# (/<.hab;r, 1,.. le7z~<o ('1311-(14~ llllo~~l CBu-ll-1'1 I ... , II u · - )I lcvn fl. a .IAlt'LtA-. t I ~(.N'(v\- t ~ Oll . ('1311-t>Sll I C'\31•·651 1 u ul Vukl ~-·-O~i 1 ~u~s Superviso1·~. Atl..JJ ; I 41 ~. Sign<1ll•re -, ~ • 1-l~ P>&./1 l1.2at:t<IJ.IU:>. Stt..e li(l'1'l.8 }3/3d.O /3'1888 v v' 17 7 ,/ ..7 ,/ .......... ,/ v 7 v v v v v i7 ..... ,.•. Cell Block(, \. f · c~~~-r Name 7J't A.l.f C86·o5J l cau-65~ I MPh C'B6·6~:i I J;r)r..Jl~v ~ J ~S 'All ~··-----, VARNER SUPERMAX ...,ANITATION ROSTER DATE ......_ q-llf_.,oCf ~FFlCER: fie-.tiJ .ltl~l}l~ __ L_ .. _.._L_ .o....,I{P~~········\ ADC# Race I Cleaning l ~·fGrooming I -6th~ T 13135 i/3L/6tu; /~e~a::t L ~ .L. t\ v / ........ a/ ........ / v IIJBA.CJt:t v v IJ3,z:-.,c;,CI ll~B09(n ~ L'B6·6~~ I p~;;Js t ~ CS6-65'l I ~I(_' IJ:JJCjSD llarJOffB ..JtPl.II~J.jq 1 WDodl [) cf:J6·oo~ 1 W~s.f<. csti-66; I Wvtln, f). Jo8itli l/68cr76· 110'1B'1 CB6·6\J~ I Jg,~l7"M ('El6-6C•5 I CBll·(•t•ll I ?i'Jlsb~ ~~h;}{ £.t1. 0 r..TH,·lil•7 1 ~-LL+k/V~·M. L'B6·Ut•~ I ~.·Bl•·6ll'' I A.fnvW~Dd cau-o 1u I · CBo-671 I Q..=~ ('8(H172 1 CB6·673 I .,--J:r t" 04.-dc.sct{. ,) CB6·6H I 5rnJ.l.-h. I ('L%·675 I Ul.~~ ('l)(l-(17(• l ClltH• 77 I IT.. L'(~(>o(>7:; i_. t::£1!\~~ l./ r... s P.,rn A.lt.wJ,. )( ~~ .r 1/ 6{~. I ,;) Bba:\ . tJ . ~ I » tr!A.JJ \ h.Ol . n (I L· -v-r ; IIL/bOSI ll3l57 J )t.fo'l9i). li3Y>i6 fl'td~ &St,SS a~(,.3tf ~ 1\A \" ,. ~~ v & v v ../ v ~ ./ .'A. A v ! ../" ._.,.. ., v / P1 b" ·' ,/ / v jti14~ I l n.!IV&OSbY'l, 'v" if ~{)0~6:: ·3S6le'J . (' ,/" v 1 ·~n;s,"A.. cs(i-6t•l V'" A ca6-o57 i916Bl il6lo'1CJ5 I Dxlvvd, ;-r. v A I ~}; ~h J ir Comments ..,..... v v CB6·656 .. lcsG-libll ........ ........ Cell Block 6 v" .,/ /3lPiif1 (i v / v' IJJq7~ .,....., . ...._ .... ~- - -~ P'-·-·• .. """ ;~·· ~.,:~'et'v,sof'~• Si£1n:~1l•r:: VARNER SUPERMAX SANITATION ROSTER oATE 9TIT{l]lJll oFFICER: Jj) t G._jbJr\(L,iS Cel1Block6 Cell· CB6-601 CB6-602 CB6-603 6 CB -6° 4 CB6-605 CB6-606 Name ADC# ifZnh:J~,® A ''Y\; \ Lhroo~\A ll"l )(J.V;-<)~JV'C~-,-!Tjrt ~-t<~rz. ~::: ~;~ CB6-609 ~r ,-'Mfu')D~T CB6-610 lrn.wJGY\...S:I CB6-611 ~)k'1S?t uJr~ -- 2 CB6-6!3 CB6-6! CB6- 4 615 CB6-6l 6 cs6-6 cs 6 17 -6IB CB6-619 6 620 CB - CB6-621 CB6-622 rr:J~~N\_ '';=tnl \0\NtL'/,,..P ~b 1J,jd~N\ r:Jn~C)o~'\N' ~r~rn d·~KJ ·-- CB6-626 1 1 J 11 Comments Other 11 vJ L7 17 7 IO~f(tfttlJ3 jrzL)~(oOI511 1 TID\Ara ,~ r~~-~ S~oot"<e ~~ J7 linG531J3 r~J7 -1102blo'VIf3 II 7 ll'113'27>91lt5 ·1 r ~ em 1 21e -rr~t7 rva.=r\, (/ It 0(N t\JkD E, __, 11 rt~ A1 r\fC,--r_ S"P'N'"'' 1 Grooming II ~ ·-··- ·-··-lf2JV1~ IJ3 -lr7. ll391mJ3 II V 1=5tM~ CB6-625 vr 1(5_ II ,7 11Dffiir5 11 [{Blq_IB II IIZfl'ZkaX IB II li lK9<JK 14311 'l~~D"-<U II ~1~ Ls\t) rN\on r11 Ir3 -~- · 11 1 u--~-~-·•••••••1~1"17 7 CB6-6l Shower llJ12.88fJ3l r L7 ~ ~2QE2R 1J3 11 ~/ IITffi'n\AI IIV/ ll31Ll51J3 II v lr31~1J311 . 7v ~rJ~(tr3'fiJ311 17 v [Jn~. N l"l-\J~ l lZ/. I Race I Cleaning_::.,J Cell Blo( n m;~l~ I r;-llm:ii.J:311 ~ _j131l1lZR5 II m7/ /J AA 5,J7PtP-- VARNER SUPERMAX SANITATION ROSTER CellBiock6 Cell cs6-627 Name DATE~ G/f 0q 1 ADC# rr 0--1. \ tL\1, {"" J cs6-629 CB6-630 r·tfL\1 \ h~ CB6-632 1 \ CB6-633 CB6-634 CB6-635 CB6-636 CB6-637 .cs6-63s t1CJ.52J,p) 1V,QCltL-zf' Vi~Cj 1\NJLl 5+1) ~ p ~~10 JB ~IOIB CB6-640 J CB6-641 _ JV\.. INn~ t!:l ~!){(h_..l\{ 'CB6-644 CB6-645 CB6-646 1 ICB6-647 CB6-648 CB6-649 CB6-650 I(~;r- \ ~~ \J rR)\.Jtl (f 17 H~Y·l·······-·IPS- p iWflfJTB 131LJR IJY\ct{}\J I1GLJ 1\I(LrJ<'O!O\}/(L\}\"J ,1 l~l o~R l I.B 3?Slts4'1 PJ \'2FG21B I __, l'fqq-x J I~ 'l}(1/J~:q:>f{~._ CB6-651 I'V(G\J:\:.\ \VJ '\ l CB6-652 'T'Xl.Vt s\~ s'""""""'' s;g,•.,., v 1W4i2fiE> Jl~ha:rl ~ rn jry·\f' 1) 3\6201\N j ~/~ - -J / ~lo-1IV3 J 'Si~ <sh1L'&ii'd/, 'D ICB6-643 .// // R01Q3113 ,/_ lrt52f15 7/ ?21rl1 lrs 7 ,// 112A~EL~[R rl013ID3 "i7/ , ... CB6-642 7 ~ ~ "'l.:Tr)l (f) t ( 1~--p· 1 ~vcv.., // ffiki~IJ3 l\JJh.t:..t\< p_j' 1\ 1\(ar-f'J JmA[ 'PA CiJl CB6-639 7/ ,7/ '~to921t13 hl--o\.Jlk=.~J I 7 7/ Y¥flto_ lW ~ I Cleaning [31~ \1 )illfRf) CB6-631 I Race f2l31oi\B ~~tR·IJ IB 1 rvi:t\._so ~0 'f'il'W\o r.D CB6-628 OFFICER: ~KR' ~- KB 7 / v 17 ,/ ,/ V' 7 vir v Shower I CellBio( CJJ' Cl:lo ~ Grooming I Other Comments VARNER SUPERMAX SANITATION ROSTER Cell Block 6 DATE Cell J CfJUJJt1 _f. til£l\ , CB6-6:53 I .:; {I CB6-654 1 /~O\N.-.5)!{\_ CB6-655 I 'C.b~ CB6-656 I "'l.iXJ}h,'L \« (~ / t:, CB6-658 c l J. ~)\.A IFa.i-F ~-<)J -~ CB6-659 If' Dl'!.l<.£ CB6-657 CB6-660 CB6-661 CB6-662 CB6-663 CB6-664 CB6-665 CB6-666 CB6-667 I 11))6-(J{) trl'1J "JVJ)f)chs'l.D I\Na Cui« J1 'fZ,; Jrt{\f nn.J) !diU I , JY\. rr.. .nLsb'll\t\/,_f5_ l \N'h.+' t\f, f'1 I ~lkYl«~~'M., cs6-668 '1=-ltnJar~ 0 CB6-669 I 6 70 cs -6 v ~- 5ftJpU a)J, 10 CB6-671 f43o~ CB6-672 11 CB6-673 C86-674 l_0 JLJ!.-1 nJcL. tG \_flQ.Q.,I ~Dh..0 .l_)Yl\f}· ~ -r CB6-675 ~~ ..Oia~.lf CB6-676 l1~nd.\L.-r)/ CB6-677 I CB6-678 l'lf .(1\~- /I.A \ .11#-r-..rl'l_ _.l_ __ K\LW IJ .. 'I.Il_!l-\.. I p;i){) /bCh ~ ~ • ~il\1!\f=D,:S .f.., J ? I~ Supervisor's Signature I Race I Cleaning IGL'35} IR t3t0Gf{o IJ.3 ·tfa~lh I l// ·v--/ v/ L~'1~_5 lffin~IW v/ ,/L v/ ,// t/ [R~Ktl?-; 13J9oo IW l'llJqoGJ ll3 to8'at<f[n l3:YD15JB rrJgq lB fJ7K29'Cfll-') lt352SICJHAI t~Wit~IW 17/ c/L v_v V' z .1/~ jL__Li 11u'S'Jtll'11J3 ~ 11316_1/l B ltcrtf2JB z J/ f~~Q3 r J'1222.JJ~ 1// :L tastmB , / 1 1El6'il13 l / :Dm.J II-3 v t1a1t9JB .,....,_ J1~ t~\.A..ra-------~ '"-A}t t - Cl)_~_.,. .~0 ~<') OFFICER: ADC# Name -1 (.....) ~ LLt Shower Cell Bloc I Grooming I Other Comments Cell Block.(; J Cell ('06·(1\ll I:LIC.-M2 CUo-<103 CS6-t>O~ CB6-C,05 Cl3b-606 CBu-607 CBtH1Ug Cl3t>-o09 I Name \ I Cleaning I Shower , I Grooming f Other {( l 11-t~ J.7hl/,e.< AA_J .-1.-L /) 71/Z,J ./1, 'if 1 I / 11 t(()O ~ \ / mvtlh~>- · 1!1tt s~ 11 7t/J /, fl...i §A I ).-.. j / ~ ~~~1)) b& 1-i ).1 /1.{-z..ft--f ),.CL-. . -~ q / ~. // ~ (o 'f <r ' ' I o) '1.1f CGt1·6l ~ be.+-:L CBb-6!3 {.;} u~ li 4-.iJio.c-/~ 171], 6'1 j( t t~!Jt--A_d,._ .IIJPYtLiP.tv-~ 1'1 Sf l'tf~ /~1~17 ./ ~ ./, vj v/ .. CBt,-bl7 ;1v71/Z .// 1.·· (i3(1·bll) ~~~~ Vi4- lzot{;tJ ~ ... lt7tJff /Of ll/JZ ltJ ~}1 11 S l/fz [fl{1iP1 ,// r/ ' Ct3tH•2ll Cl.l6·t•21 (13lH•22 C6t,-i,~.3 Cl'lli·h2~ Cl:l<1-u2~ Cl~<Hi26 l Comments / (~~ Cl3t•·o19 .ell Block 6 / ;z.? a lfi /Af4NJ.,I-~ CBt>-616 Race );A./L,rJ, CBt,·(ltt (8t,·ul5 ADC# 1~ !Cff J if]..(IJO:J--.., ' CB6-biU CB6-6t ~ i~ VARNER SUPERMAX uANITATION ROSTER oATE I 7..-- ZJ -o 1 oFFiceR~_..-:-;; J d - ~ - (s,/"2-<f'i'-" J/e--~ t; . ._..~A I C, ~,.~.cl"'.n ,_ - )/--~. IJ~A-.5 l '£//tJ " _,#~.;1"'_..,/ / v-1 •« /: /OJ g'{? ?g liS 'i J Vfl1V~<vDy Superv,sor-s Signatur"' -Pc- 111t.t4'1 p""~'~h '. ;/ v ~ ----------- .. ~ ... Cdl Bloot:k t r VARNER SUPERMAX .-.~ANITATION ROSTER (;, 2.-_,;;: .Jd/. cz~ z.; -(; " .... - ·I ADCII I Race Cleaning :! Shower I Grooming I Other I /?.., /"'J t~ / .C:ell Block~ ,... Cell Name CB6-o:!7 f.J/~ ('Gt•·(Jls lit VIA~ Cl3l•·<i2\l r:~ ~ ,r (!3i>-6.3U .~~ tog..:; 11 : /D 1'II' /1f f:)t{J, (131•-()}1 (;,_flji'J/ j}{pt)Z,'( / (l3C)-6:l:! ft b 9J7ft f2_ / CB6-633 IA;4,..vt:. /)~f>70 / CBti-63~ ;j:.VI'; /JtfJ(0 / i /J?ltl? / , /'/0 Jd J Comments ,/"' f'D WLf L'Bt!-635 CB6-o36 L·n, •• (,J7 <./' Vluif tvL-"/lnAI' 4 ~ $ • // 1- l'iJ,;.,,:;~ t.'H•;·I1N ~ t1• ., - /11/~ZT v f) 'lf7 lho ud / / 1 l'Bu-6-w (L-t»~ /2,1/6} / Cllri-o-'1 -i.G,......... ,~~.....,.( ~ ./ l'l3o-M2 lliJI"tnA-- 11/() 7Jz, r;., Ofcl/ CBII·h~J f7tu,_./fo._ IZO~?Y ('l3•.•·ll-l-l I.'BtH>-16 li)ArJv CBu-<•·17 /Y1 £-f.h.JIJ g7 '{l {p V6 ~ g f{ C'l3h-()5ll C'O•o-<>51 lt~,-h,,t,,_..,_.., 'f:.//ul 1 il-.r~? v~~.~Jtft'IV ('13t1-652 IJ~NVl) SlJpervisoJ·~. Sign<)\ure l-- , /"_/,. //1 j((/7 C6u-('H~l / .. /_; .fiJWdl l'13h·C•-lli ./ . //'l/1 rI lib u• l.eu L'Bu-<>~:i • ' IJ ttiSif / J -z, 8 (. 1 lttt'l'tl ,. ~ / : l- / ., / ,.. / "' /1/JZ,O -/ ~~-. / 11'1'881 l:t .• L-_._.J...!C:..:..........:..!.-----------.I.!...!-~:....:_....~--_~...~-_---J.---1..--....1-----L--....L-....1------L..I..---------- Cdl Block t VARNER SUPERMAX ...,.ANITATION ROSTER DATE .... .._1:._._&___ - --- ~ Ci'-z ]'0 OFFICER: ('r; '2 /? .J;fl,......,..,........--I ADC# I Racej_c:lea_~ingl[ Shower \ Grooming I Other [ Cell Block t t q Name 171.; ' ' 11 '(t:><j' e/'%1 .,/" ...,.. IZ. r;,zz, /~ tj'IJ!/ /v IJ~ /y 771 IJ/zfo r-_;r (' lzo7t>CJ : /. '~ :•, /Cftf~(/t( / /D6 >tV I] Z 61) /_A trg7'2Cf I' / .. 1'1 )..~~ JJ5 J,fq ; J ZtJr~ l(oo ).Jo /'))0(,7 / / 7_)t r / ,.,- ~---' / ~- /'A" , v JJ/111 /k': 1+/o lt$Z /jj i l(~ / v 1/?J;..t- ~ t)f {p}J /1--D "b ~g, (lll•·b77 l.•.'Bt, . t,7:C ..... S.:;)'?fViSO(S Si9n:lturi! \~· / \ 'ljz!,J/ 1..:8t1·(l7b Comments ! jo 7 '1.(2.( JJ{p 7'{~ i11ottt~ ~ A" ./' / . . . . . . -+. V' ... •' VARNER SUPERMAX uA:NITATION ROSTER . . L) /_A_ DATE ~ OFFICER: CQ 2- I. ...J E Pi ""-'<:1 ..,_.. - q...,. - t,..... O_C( ....... Cell Block {} ~ I j Cell Cl36-hlll I Name ADCII ~ .JA......o<.<-._ I Race j Sl t.fS (13(•-()02 i"(J/~((f~ t't?Btfr ('13()-hl)J JJ~~l Jf~'i.ft.. tnJJ btrt~ CB6-1:1~ (136-605 (13(>-606 CBo-607 CBlH'!l)~ -.Oewn (? 1 J..ttf ' It'!~ Jt 1 j £/flO) h.1kr ~~~ JffJI.kr v CBti·<•IU hJ...f~o·.l CBt•·61~ CB6-ld3 I(~ l;ionhr/ I CS6-616 a'""'"· /l.-v CB!>-t>IS ~n/ . ! _, I v~ \ tJ !( ),~,.L,.... CtlM•2~ 1/L,Z~-1:6 Cl~!H;11• A ... Sutlervisor·s Signalw·e ./ ~ .. ~ '- ·t I I I11 l/'jl( /0' 'J 1(7 1 iiPsg I v~~A/ !{.-l( ~~ I /.~~II< ... I? '6 tf}i <frtlt~ 1 :...A"' CBtH1~3 Cl::lb-o25 ~/I I {,. /'! p-..,-..rv /JpAq ~~ CJC /_. I I lf / 11110)5 rotblPt 1.:..-A """· C'I3!•·C.~2 ·- ·£JJJ·17M . }~{] 'lbO ('H6·t•21 I Comments : """' lr:¥1 7'fz, CBn·t•~ll T I ~I f.plf& !~I )11 ?iJlwW4J. i ll~oA4,AVfA/J 19 Other 11$1S Z ca<.>-o17 ("13t.1~{) r t~o17 /'1, 1 ?,~</ lfl1oA/I/j Ctll•·()l; Grooming lvt/trJ 1iu.wik CBli-61~ . 1~C~I 11~ 1 1?) I ( ii1C11Z3 l-Gfw'i9 . . . Shower . ii. /I /11 'IZJ CBo-o09 CBt>·l•ll Cleaning , . .ell Block 6 :r. • o/~ .. ... ., . -· . ~ \ / / ' • Cdl Blo~k VARNER SUPERMAX ..JANITATION ROSTER <t DATE Cell ~S6-u:n :'l3M!l8 :su-629 :·l3ii-63U .'Bh·Cl31 ::'l~b-63:.! C'Bci-6.13 C'Bti-634 2.r- 2-? -0 t{ ·-·~---·- j N:1me i~tf.tl1 ihll~~~ I ADCII ·- tb /! u~--"l,. OFFICER: ! j Race 1 Cleaning !]..... Shower 2ell Block 6 1 Grooming I Other I Comments J,/J7u [J;D ?J 17/ lt:>r~l.' ~~~ l~r.~lov fe- J I 17167() /Jt(J(O . !/J~/Ullt' z.t: l i11f{z 1~. . &.~{. CB6-1>36 .. (Jfp]J,f 11. f'f)Vdr l'Bti·ti35 1 ( lrt()L/z 1uttlt)/ / wWf .,L,~f {~ \ flfZ,)Zl( /J7qf/5 Ll)h-b.n Wwl--~ 11/d ?t>) L'Uti-n;::; l?ttvl ftJffz£ l'l;ti·(•.N l'Bu-6-111 CBti·u~ I l'Ho·h-12 t:"Stt'-{t-!3 t'l3t>-o-l-l t.'13u-b<l:' orJ¥11 ~ez;f~ fJ.'I'~w/ (; l'k,'A4,~J>t..f /'2.7 i'6 J /'({) 7Jz. f3$'0{,.tf 1/Jo//JJ'. ~l'fc;lhll' 1~11' if4-Wd! l'f3o-b-lb ~~~-l'iJer CBu-!•·17 /11b {A/-'&f lti,.r£~o.-tJ..p~J C'Uu-bJ S CSu·t>~'l F ('[3{1-ll~\J L_ .e-1'/'ll H""wJf ta.~-()51 Cl3ti-65 2 u. F .~fvp{l~ ' / )JIC.; rl'"'5 Superviso!'s SignC\lure {2641'/ ,, lct'il /f3fl.{? lDf) (1(;, Joft:.'t81 17 1- f{'l ttt~~z II '1 titt6 \ \ J L ·~ I \ \ j ~:. l ., ; _( /317,Z,o "> lrPIItl ./ v Cell Block VARNER SUPERMAX ..;ANITATION ROSTER t DATE r Cell T CB6-o5) CBt>-65~ CB6-o:i5 CB6·656 c:s6-b57 ('1:16-65~ CB6·65t.J CB6-titn1 Name lt-t~l ~z,g.-q~(-··· .. I ADCII I Race 1 Cleaning / 11/1)/ f/1(~t!I1V,; 11'10'1~ £u...l~r i/ll -: ....... v· Shower U1,~Y~· 1 Grooming l Other f IZi'J-2-1.. OFFICER: Cell Block t \ t:>91./1/( IJJ; 717 £/L,-s h.AA -.. . \ J I J3ft?56 ~ ()-.nhu-t~- !to9of J lo·f51t{ CS6+6"1 tv;,.,_,_ CB6-6<•2 /i/t!6t;'! fv!~.t-.r t,:S6-66J Wy(VIII-' lt/.,Jt 't. \ \ jJ j·~! \ 13161} ltJ /lf CB6-6LlJ J JgJ,t:r'f CB6-6(•~ Aii'J/1.~""- Cllb-bt•t• '~;.,?t,~.. l'l\(!-(j() i h~J11 11 zb1(, " /)V/..-1-kr' 1.-'L~<,·I.illS •.:13tl·6~t•l 1.:86-67LI CBo-671 CBb-~71 CB6·67J ('86-674 ('136·67~ I (00)1o f151b1 I 1 ' I!Jtl/tY \ £/.}.N:Af~ //t-Ie/¥ J,~{~t; -g;;Jj;' /11~1( · /l(otr~z iAhor-t-· J ~(/t-.1-t?lv' {m,r:H.. '· "' (;f~{J j'z,Oi ],1 u..JJ.A-.~ (lq 1-t-~ }jlf)-;k /61 VIZ./ CUtH•77 1 {/f,(Jvt~ n~ ttf't 1/JC!ij/~ '-• : /7J 91.(5 \.'t~IJ•b7(1 l.Bh·t•7~ I ~~M- ~·\=~~~rvisoi''S Si£1n:~lur~ '-,,, 1 __... . L' ...... _ .. -~·. . --..-,. · - _........., t.::~ ·t•- "~" Comments Page 1 of2 RE: Roberts v. Hobbs, et al5:10CV00174 Gordon S. Rather, Jr. to: 'Christine Cryer', Courtney C. McLarty 03/04/2013 06:17PM Cc: "dpmchambers@ared. uscourts.gov" Hide Details From: "Gordon S. Rather, Jr." <GRather@wlj .com> To: 'Christine Cryer' <christine.cryer@arkansasag.gov>, "Courtney C. McLarty" <CMcLarty@wlj .com>, Cc: "dpmchambers@ared. uscourts.gov" <dpmchambers@ared. uscourts.gov> History: This message has been forwarded. Christine The plaintiff understandably objects to any use of documents that should have been produced in discovery, that should have been produced in response to requests contained in deposition notices, and that have not been listed in pretrial disclosures. Fairness and the Federal Rules required their production. The problems with the medical records caused a considerable amount of additional work for appointed counsel as you are well aware. To now come up with sanitation records when that has been the focus of this case from the beginning is a real concern to say the least. We are preparing for trial with the understanding that the witnesses and exhibits are those that have previously been disclosed. We ask that these sanitation records not be mentioned or used for any purpose until Judge Marshall has ruled on them after a hearing on why the defendants should be allowed to rely on evidence that has never been disclosed throughout an exhaustive discovery process. We trust you appreciate the position of the plaintiff and his Court appointed counsel. I am only copying the Court with this correspondence because you included the Court in yours. Gordon Gordon S. Rather, Jr. Wright, Lindsey & Jennings LLP 200 West Capitol Avenue, Suite 2300 Little Rock, Arkansas 72201-3699 Main: (501) 371-0808 Direct: (501) 212-1267 FAX: (501) 376-9442 www.wlj.com WLJ WIUGHT. LINDSEY & JBNNlNGS LLP From: Christine Cryer [mailto:christine.cryer@arkansasag.gov] Sent: Monday, March 04, 2013 5:43 PM To: Gordon S. Rather, Jr.; Courtney C. Mclarty file://C:\Users\rkculp\AppData\Local\Temp\notesAB3C21\~web1262.htm 3/5/2013

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?