Delanney v. Aldi Inc.

Filing 12

AGREED PROTECTIVE ORDER. Signed by Honorable Robert T. Dawson on August 13, 2009. (lw)

I N 1'tlti, s t1NtTtrI) r'At'ttsDISTtil(r't(.r(]ult'l' WIISTEITIT I}ISTIIICI' fNTA RH.ANSAS l " ( ) t { I ' SMITH t)IVlritON M I I I A I I I}I]I,,\NNEY PI,AIN'I'IFF

v.
A I , D I IN(].

r i 0 , 08-r\.-0245 r
DIII'IiNI)ANT . { C R I l l { l l ) PltOTECr'l Vtit (}R-DBll I 'l irc prLrlies this aolion,hv thcir ruspectivc to of iltt{tffrcys lecord,hclcLry stipliat64s

f ollrrrrs: l, lhc pulpo$e this Pfotective of Oldcl is to ltrot+c1 aEirinst urrnocdssilry [he1

t l i s c l u s u l e t'onficlcn[ial of ()nlcr sha.. inlbrntLition. ivlirt+rials inl'ornrirtion and protectt:tl tJLis by i n c l u d tall <lrlcurltcnts iulirt'rttalion Itlnintitl'ry.)$$es$ion in ol proi{rrc.ul I,laintifT rrmJ./or ro hy [ ) e f l r t t ] i t : ritr resportsc PIainlilTs t to I:rtcnog.atorics, Request Production lJorurrren ol any l'or o1'' Li; o l l t c t tiiscttvtt,v rtqucslsby Plailtill, regflIdirrg pelrornt:lrutolrlsatrtltolirted lirc irrl'r.lmrtion of i r t r l i v i t j r r a enrlrlolttlrvith Atdi Kiursas. ls Irtc. Suchtlocrrrlcuts he rlcsig,rtrrtcrl will spcciljrrnll),as " t o t t l i d e niirl" uport t ploduition 'i b]' the[).'fetrdarlt. he nrnr+rials infornrirtitrrr ard pruLecteil h;,

i' ale t h i sOrulcr helcirraller rritercn00d collectively "prntected as rr)irtr.:rials. il, As ust<l lrr:rcil,"tlisclosrrr't:" "kr disclose" or shullrlearrto ciivLrlco. rcve;.rl.

w dcscribe'sutrlttttLizc.para1llrtast:,c1uote't'rttnsttti1,tlr.other.wisei0IIllLlLlIliL:1le h e t h e fpursuitlllto rcqucst,inlerr(Jgtory, process otlrcrwisr., and rvhctltrr in lccoLdartctlvith or t h c l ' r c l e l a ll i r t l t s o l ( l i v i l l ) r l c r d L r r e t ,o t l t r x i : i c . w o .J, llrtltr:clcdlllnl.crii $ sltall not hc <listhrstcl auy rrrirrLr'Lcr, irr tlilecll;- t.rlintlir'cctl.v, lo

a t l y fcrs{)ll otlttr thitu Fersculs assisljngl'laintjlf s c unscl jn thc insLant litigation. As usccl h e L e i n rhc terlr "persorts , assistirrg Plaintill's counscl in Lhcinstruttlirigrtion" is linritrcl to:

(:r{tt7il485.t I

(il)

Plairlilfi i { l t o leys in prrrtnership rtssociated with I)l4intift'scoLulsul; or c l c r l t s , palalegtls ar)dsccrLjtitrids the enrplov rrfPlaintifl-s coLrnscl: iu L r - \ I : r c riurd profissirrrrll(L1lr:Julli who have bgcn rctainctl by I)laintil'l's [s rts c u u n s c ltrrd r'vhohavc a rtoutiLohnow slid lrrotcctcdrnitt+riuls orldl'to rn l s s i s t .counscl jn tlttir prqrarationf'ortlrc'trjaJol tltis rnLLttrr. iurv . l n thc cvr.:rrt prolectedlr]aterials disciusedto [tlaintil]'s cxportsirnri arc

(b) {c) (d)

rl s, lt c l ) t u l c s s i u l r ao r r s r L l t a n ts u c i tt l i s r k r s L u m u s l { ) cn t a ( i tr v i t ht l r c u n d r r s t a n { : l i nlgi i l a l l I c s t r i c : t i o n colrlLrinod lhis (.)r'dtluPply r'r,itJr {irrceiur(l$i}i}dt16 5h'inr. At:coldinp.lv. s it' in lirll p l . ( ) t d { t d r l r tel'ills .r'ctiisclosctl L(]I'laintil-f's exPerts,thc party or pr]r$oll to wltoni th$ rilt uiitls irr l f q l disclosedshall stutelris or hcl conser)t wliting (in thc f'ornrof arr Acknou4ed;,,nrerrt jve f l t l chLr(l hL:rel() l,.xh ilrit AJ to lrt hnr.rnd lhc tcrnls of this Protecl ()nler. as lry 5, 'lhe fe$tijctionsconLairre(l JrelcinregucljlLg clisclusurc ol'|r'olccted nri.llcfitlsdlso

a p l t l y with t(lLrll fi)rce to any L'xtL:ryls, iLrulyl;es, suntrtrulics such ilcms ()f lhe ilrlbrnlaliorl ol or c o r l l i r i r l t dtltr,rtin as \r'cillas fit tnv lrrjrli;, pleiidings,crhiLtits,lLtrrr$L]ril)Lrulher rlocirrrtentt ur w l t i c hr i r y b c p l c P i r | r : t r l L r o r ] r r c c l i o,rv r t hh i s l i t i g a l i o r w h i c h c o n t t i i no f r r h : f t o t l r r u r a t c t i l t l s r 'i t il r o r inlirrrnatiotr an;rlvscs, contairrctltlrcrein,Lotllc 0xt(xrtthtlt such exLrcrpts, ttr:, irltrtlity or' i n c l L r t i t i t l t : r r t i [ . 1 , i r r 5 1 i n t . . t r l t t t i r t i o r r I C ! " l ' i t r d i luF l ls ke rn d i iv i h L } t t . l v t . e l l l L e ' r a h .i wh c O x i + r lvill prtciudc tiisciosr.rtc illiorrnlti()n wherrridentifying infirlnratitxthas br:crrredacLrd of in l l o u r tlto dtlclurrcnlor rvherrc refcrcrrcus or tliscussionof inforrrtatiorr conluinocl prr.rlectcrJ Lo t l l a l c r i i r l scontaitrsno inl'orrrtittion ir.lentifying subjcctrrl'suchrurLterials. the 0, In llrc gvg111 t a pirft-y's lh $(:aiosilctirrgas ttLrnsul ilr lLris lrrescnlLrounslil

l i L i t r , a t i oall plotcttcdnralcriirls riciirwllhereirr, n, or cxccrpts, i.rnalysts ds nny t'.o1rirs. including s r r n r n r a l ithcrcol'shall rctrrmed cs be k; wjlh rhr exccplron forthwitlr tlrerryposirrg 0oullsrl Furlyrs r : i unl such nr'tl.etittls c rrtairr lLtornfv which:l:Lt, h,.'dr-'.;ltttlr:'1, tltirt work-Ftodrlct,
a
|l ) 7 l , i r i 5I

7.

rtl' lighi ]'his Order docs rrot limit 1111r rri arrvJriilrl) {lbicct to tlre sc{)pe tllstrovely 1o

i r thc rbLrvc-c4lic,ned action,
It. r o W i t h i n i i r u l t e e r ( 1 4 ) c i r l c r r c l id t L y s i l i r r a ld c l e l n r i r r i r t i r urlrtrh i s a c L i o ni.n r l u ( i i n i l u .

scttlellcrrtor othurwisLr, Fartiet sirall {urn ovrr all thc d l l irpptal:i,v,,he1hiir jrrrigrrrcnt, b5, d o c u r r r s t \ ( sru:civr:ti l:r,tsnant to thiij r'\rdcr (u {}pposing coun$eJ. Irr thtr rvrnt a paLty'stotur$sl or rrrirlerii{]$ dcl'lncdltcrcrrr. contuirring refererrcing as Ffotectu(l [ ) o s s e s s cirltorrcy wr)rk-prrrcluct s o u c l ' ] i ] t t o | n c y r ' v t t : . k - 1 r r i x l t t i : 1 s h a l l r c l t r i r i r r s t l l r . j e c l l ' t t l hre S s tt.J : i l(rrl|'il r i n ) IfS tl $ r in thc irltcrnttive nray Lre destroycd. 9. p N l r t h i n gc o n t a i r r t tiln t h i s ( . ) r ' i l e th f i l la l l c c t o r r c s t l i c l t h r :t i g h t so J L r n y a l t v r v i t h s :

Iosl]ec|l0atlyd,'rtlttnrtltrtorin1i]|lr1i'l1]ioI1clcvclopct11jrlntlsr]ttrt:crr1jtcrtIratr}]Iotct]tL. {|tr'tillelill|s

(lr Sur:h witiloutrugirrtt o b t a i r r r (throuulr l discovrrr'),ircrtirr. irrl'onnirtiorr docLLnlcnts hr rrscd lnlrv t o Lhi$ Ol(lLx, cvcrriJ sirrrilar idcrlticttl inftrnrratjon docLrllcnts haveheendesignuted as or or prfitLrcled c o n l ' i d t r r l i i tlr'nrf othcllvise Ll hcrcrrndcr, 10. Ihr lbrcgoing without prcjudict thc ghtol'anl par{y tppl}'lfilltt (loLrrt is to to

I altrr or ar'nend tcflrrs()l lhis t)r'r1er thc upona silowirlg l goddcirut$.

t]I1

l ;','l4li5

l l.

,i\ny rvilllirl violittion ol thc lcrfnrs this Or:dcrnray. in thc disc:r'ctioLr Lhe r.rl of

L l o u r t ,Lre lounrl to constitLrtc rrot]lunrltt a ofCourt. wllich urly lcsLlll in sanction:; llc tixcr_l to bv t i r u( l o r r r 'i1 i t s t i i s c r e l i l r r , n

s,uru /ESTERN uuuHl' DFilUBAHIfiNSAE
r\ AUG320ffi |
CHRR.JffNsffi, CLERK IS

u.

rfilul

r I ls s(] ()RtjLlllllr).

//\t\ \ t/__ >l \_,e'----_ l( [J.onorahl.: KoLrelt I , Dirr,r:,rrn
W u s t f fn L)i$tlict ol Arkarrsas

( I {- \\

/1

sY ^

L ) l r r d : _ j l r : - * l-}_ l, I

H.*K DEP'IY

1

t 0 []v tht urrdcrsigflud Par-lies:

v/{ o t
t : Attotrrr:vlilrc.lPininlifi

s liur I)eJr:tttiarrl