Advanced CNC Technologies, Inc v. Composite Concepts Company

Filing 55

STIPULATED PROTECTIVE ORDER Signed by Honorable Paul K. Holmes, III and parties on July 15, 2011. (sh)

Case2:10-cv-02023-PKH
Document
54

Filed07112111
Page4 of 14

STATEIJ
I}ISTRICT
COURT
UNITED
DISTRIET ARK{iti$AS
OF
FORTHE WESTERN
PLAN{TTFFS

INC.
ADVANCED
CI{C TECI{NOLOGIE$,
and
JBM 1VIREGROUPCO,, LTD.

cAsENo, 10-20?3

VS,

COIVIPANY
COMPOSITE
CONCEPTS

DEFE}fDANT

$TIPTILATED
PROTECTIVE
ORDER
Protcctivt
Thepanies rhislitipulnted
to
Olderhavergreedto the tennsof rhisOrder.
Accordirrgll', Court
protective
the
the
entcrs lbllowing
order.
l.

Thc Courttiruls
thartheparties tlriscase
Findines:
to
nlayrequesr produce
or

inlbnttation
involvingtrildcstlcrets conlidential
or
reseErch developmenr connrercial
and
or
rrl'
intbmratiqn. disclrrstrlc 1vfiislr likell' Irr causcharnrto the partl' prcducing
the
is
such
intbrmarion.
?.

Defidtions:

a.

*Pany"lncans rtanted
a
panyin rhiscase. "Persorr"
mean$ individual arr
an
or

rntity. "Producer''
rnerlns petsotl
R
wlroproduces
inlbmtation lhe discovery
via
proce$s this
irr
t

rase. "Recipient"
rvhoreceives
metnss persoll
intbrmation the discoveq'
r,ia
process rhis
in
casd.
b'

"Confidcntial" irrlirnrtstion is
infonnadon coneenring a person'$ busirrcss

proces$Es. technicaland developnrent
opcrations.
nnd
intbnnation s.ithin the scopc ol Rule
l6tc)tl XG). the disclosure u'hichis likell' to hamrrhatperson's
of
cornperitive
posirion. the
or
disL'losure u'hicltrvouldi:orrtrnvene obligoriorr
of
an
ot'contjdenrinliry a rhird person to s
to
or

Coun.

8l7Jg5-|

Case2:10-cv-02023-PKH
Document
Page5 of 14
54 Filed07112111

$.

..Highll.Conficleutinl"
rvithin the scopeof Rule
is
inlbrmstion iutbnnution

and
or
fiadesesrets plarutnorcsetrsitive
or
l)rG) tlratis currrurt tututelrusirtess rcclutical
l6(,JX
harm
of
is
the
inlbnrration. disclosure rvhich likclf' to signilicantlv
thau
or srrtregic ConJirientinl
of
art
wouldconlavene obligatiort
of
positiou. thedisclosure rvhich
or
comperirive
rharpersou'$
or
to
contidentialil)' it thirdPer$on to a Coun.
d.

in
or
if
is
tntbnuuriun ntrt Contidentisl Higlrly Contideruial it is disclttsed n

tvitltout
obligatiort
ol
publicariou. krou'u to tlre public.u'asktto$nto the rccipient
is
prinred
by
disclosed or is or becorrrcs
it,
hruulr to tltt reuipient
corrJidenrialiry
betbrcthe producer
of
is
nor
or
a
nor
meilns constituring brcach thisOrder. Irubrnration likervise Confideutial Higttly
of
lur'4irlly
otrtnined indepndent thislitigstion.
it
Coutrdentisla persou
if
-1.

of
as
Deslqllariflr informorioll Co

a.

designntion
ot'inJbrmation Cuntidenrial Highil'Confidential
as
or
A person's

nfideilisl:

qualities
in
inquiry,
thattheintbrmation
means person
rhat
believes goodthitlr.uponrrasdudble
ussuch.
h,

designates
in
iulbnrtatiou a docuurent thingnsConfidentialor
or
A persort
Highly'

"CONFIDENTIAL'' *HICHL\'
nnd
rnarking its t'ace
on
Contidentinl
b1.'clear'ly pnrnrirreutly
OR
CONFIDE}ITIAL.- A producer
ruay nlrtkedocuments thingscontaining
or
Contidenrial
or
iut'onuutiort
available inspection copyingrvidrour
tbr
and
HightJ"
ConJidential
nrarliing
themss
n
suchrvithout
lbrfeiting claiurof corrlideutiolit.v". as rhe producer
so long
uauses
copies rhe
of
providing
as
or
docrutents things be ur$rked Confidentisl HiehlyCoufidential
or
to
thern
betbre
to therecipient.
panl'.all copies.
to
Priorto ptoduction another
imagesduplicares.
elecrronic
(hereinalter
ext$lcts.sununaries descriprions
or
rel'erred cullecrivelyas "copies")of
ro
do$uluents
d+signatcd Crontideutisl HighlyContidential
ns
or
under
this Ordershallbe urarked

I
8t7.t8$

Case2:10-cv-02023-PKH
Document
54 Ftled07112111
Page6 of 14

shnll
on
appesr the copi-' All suchcopies
11
rvitlrtlte designarion 15srvorddoesnot already
"ct1ries"
indices.
shullrrotinclude
of
ru
be
rherurtier eprirled tlreprntectiou rhisOrder,Tltctentr
or
electrottic
datsbnses listsdo
indices,
provided
these
ofldocunrerrrs
o;
dars
elecrrorric ba$Es lisrs
or
of
porrions inruges the rer{Iof Contidential HighlyContidential
or
substanrial
nor courain
of
discloserhe substance Contidenilalor Highly' Confiderrtiol
or
docunrenrs orhenvise
dtlc
contui itt tltttse unl€lrts.
ned
inlbrnrstion
c.

or
teslirlolryas Conlidential
int'onttation a depositiorl
in
clesignates
A pcrson

is
at
th$t
on
b1'
HighlyCorrtidenriul smring therecord thedeposition tlteitttbnnntion Coutideutisl
panl'andthestenographer videographer
artd
the
or Highll'Contidenrinl by advising opposiog
or
(lJt duys otier receipt
lrunscripl. tlte
tlut
ol'the depusitiort
rvirhintburreen
irr rvriting,
as
Suchdesignation
sltallbe specil'ic to
or
intbrurnrion Conlitlentiat Highl;*Conlidential.
is
oI
porious thetranscrilx rrnyexhibitto bedesignatedContidentiol HighlyConfidentinl.
as
of
or
d.

a
thing,or testintouy Corttidential
A person's
lhilureto designatedocuneut.
ns
or

us
tbrlbiture a clainrof contidentinlity to flnl' other
of
HighlyContidentiul
doe$nol c(rnstitute
docunrent.
thing. testinro:ly.
or
e.

rvlro
or
ifibrmatiort Corttidentill HighlyCuntidenriul
as
A persr.rn ltqsrlesignated

rvithdrarv desigrratiorr rvritteu
b}'
ma;itr
notilication all panics thccase.
to
the
t:

a
designation int'ormation Conlidential
of
If il pany disputes producer-s
as
or

shallnotil-r' producer tvritingof the basis rhedispure.
the
HighlyConfidcntial. pnrr;tlre
lbr
in
or
as
identitf rhc specitic
ing
dor'untent[s] thing[sJ to rvhichthc de.signutiorr
is disputcd
and
proposing thedesiguntion modit'ied u'ithdrau'n suchnrarerinls.
lhtt
\Virhintbuneerr
bc
or
tbr
( l4) duys. prurlucer respotrd rvriting,
pruposal:
the
shull
the
iu
either: I ) acceptirrg ub.iecror's
{3l
{
senirtg
rvhy
lbnh in rensonntrle thereasons theproducer
detsil
the
bclieves iutbnuation entitled
is

8l ?,r$t_
I

Case?:10-cv-02023-PKH
Document
54 Filed07/12/11 Page7 oI 14

detail
flnd
rhe
srarusl tl) nroditving designntion seningtbnh in reasormble
or
ro r6edesiglared
lf
designationto
is
the
belleves intbnnerion entitleql the nroditied
rvlryrlrepruducer
rtreresso*s
or
the
ma)'
thc
dispuring rlesignariorl nrove Countirr 8uordcrrvitldra$'ilrg
the
notsstisfi€d, trflny
is
of
bears burden provingthutthe itllirtTrtdtion
thc
The
tlte
mtrditi,ing designnriorr, ;rnrclucer
shall remain
0r
as
properll,
desigurrred Contidenlisl Highll' Coruidenrisl.The intbtrnntitrn
on
urttilthcCouttrules
dcsigration
Contidenrial
or
Corfidenrial Highhro
suhjecr rheprortucer's
or
as
of
a
lhilureto contest designation intbrnration Confidertial Highll'
A
rhedispure. parry"s
designated such.
ss
rvas
that
is
Confidenriul notanudrnission theinforuradon properly
d His

4.

of
Usennddiselurrrre Confident

il.

t'or
nraybe uscdcsclusivcly
inlbnrration
nnrl
Contirlcnrial Highly Conlidenrial

iflt:

of this
purPoses thislitigarion.
sutriect therestrir--tiorts Orcler'
to
of
h.

or
perrnission theproducer tlnlter ordcrby theCoun.thc
rvrirten
tlorn
Absenr

otlterthanthctbllottittg;tit a
intbmration ilnyperson
to
Corrtjdential
recipienr nordisclose
nlf,)'
purulcgal.
pcrstrnnel
nrtd
secreturial clericul
ussisting
patry's
counscl.
includirrg
neces$rry
our$ide
courtsel: a pan}''sofficers
directl.r'
andemplol'ees
suchcounsel: n psrrl"sin-house
{iii)
tii)
to
to
occe$s the inbrmationis rensonubly
rcquired supervise.
irtvolved this cu$es'lru$e
in
testitnon)'
in
recording
and
manoge. panicipate this casc;(iv) a stenoEapher videographer
or
.ltd)
(\,)
to
of
dre
conceming irrfor:nationi subject theprovisions peragruph of thisolder.e.xpefls
(vit
s
tbr
rvhont partrtmploys purposes thislitigation
of
onl)'iand
ud
sndconsulr$ts tlrir srnl'l
p+trr.ruelussistirtg Cuun.
the
theCounurrd
c.

rrdttenperrnissiou theproducer timherordcrhy the Coun.the
or
t'rpnr
.Absent

irttirrnutiorr rur) pclsr)n
trr
othertltan thosc
rucipient
lllrt) tlor disclussllighlS'Ctrntideutial
(iv),(\').and(r'i).
+(hlti),
idenriliecl poragrnph
in

8l?.rrt_l

Case2:10-cv-02023-PKH
Document
54 Filed07112111
PageB of 14

d.

to
intbnnotion an
or
ConJidential Highly Corrlidenrial
A portl-may nor disclose

until afier the expeflttr
4(b)
ro
expenor cogsulglt pursu4nt panrgraptr or 4(c) of tlris Order
shall
I
in
underrnking the tbrnrOf Apperrdix to rlrisOrder' Courtsel
lras
cousufiant siEreda11
of
tbr u period
by
of
or
rhe
nrainrnin originals copies rhelbrmssignerl thecxpenor consulta$t
or
dismissal entryof
b1'
nhether senlemettt,
of
aftcrl[naldisposirion this litigation.
onc( l) !.ear
("FiuatDisposition").
to
not
linuljurlgrnent subjecr tttflltersppeul
e.

or
Conlldtntial
4(nt
prrrngrnFlr and(bt. n pnfly ntal' disclose
Nohvirhstnnrling

(ii)
fltr
of
or
rrr:
int'ornrntiurr (i) unentployee auth(rf theproducen slly per$trll
Higlly Coptirjentinl
ond
in
0r
u'hoauthored inJbrnration rvhole in part; tiiit m1'
rhe
s.irhrheproflucrr
atlilinted
louger
rvas
betbre case lilcd.
the
p€rton
the
sltu rer:eived inlbrrnatirrn
t:

inlbrmation
or
Conlidentinl HighlyConfidential
to
A pafly\\ho rvishes disclose

to
ctnenlpt
I
paragraph or 4(c)nrusttinit ntake reasonable
4(bl
uuder
not
ro I person authorized
pemrission, ma."tttovetlte
it
to
lf
perurission. a panyis unable obtairt
the
obtqirt producer's
pcrmission.
Counto obtuirt
5.

b1'
protectcd the
of
disclosures ntaterial
lnadvenerrr
Disclosure: lnadtertenl

rvitlr
doctrine
pnrduct
in
privilege
shallbe ltnrrdled accordanuc Fedenrl
or,rr,rrrk
arrorney.clienr
guls0f fviderce50J.
6.

ttith the
that
nrolion. othcrdosuurent is lilerJ
or
Filiuqurder'scul:An.vplerrding.

int'ornrirtion be tiled urdtr scslirt
or
shall
Contidenri$l l{iglrll' Contidential
Counconrsining
b1'
Protective
requircd this Stipulated
n'irh
ruleundrviththedesignutions
conrplilrrce uny'coufl
on
which states the
tilccl undersealmustbe placcdin iur envelopc
Order. fui1' docunrenr
(i)
type.
the
and
including casc
trunrher'; (ii) in prontinenl the
ol'theuuse.
outside; thecaption
"FILED UNDER SEAL PURSUA.I{T STIPULATED
ORDER
PROTECTIVE
TO
rvorrls

817.t8f
r

Case2:10-cv-0?023-PKH
Document
54 Frled
07112111
PageI of 14

the
to
shnll
Thisparagraph notbeconstrued linrit or prohibit rightof a
ON
ENTERED [dareJ.
a
to
standillg challengc designation'
tlrc
petron
huving requisitc
pstq/or en)orher
7.

at
it*brurstiorr trial or ill coun
or
Use of Cont'idenrial Hiehlv Contidential

or
Contidctttial
uottr proceedings
et
ro
If a
EIgSggCi11gE: p*rty inrEnds preseur trial or Lt other
porty,suchpartl' shallprovideadvanced
produced nnother
b1'
intbrmation
Hig5l1'Contidential
of
the
flr
noticeto rhe producer lca$ltive (5) daysbet'ore conrntetlcetilent the trial of coufi
(i.e,'
as
at
f,s
or
the
by
proceedings irientifying clocuurellts infomtation issue specificfllly possible
or
divulging acnralCorrtrdentisl
the
lines.
prlge
deposition erc.)t,itlrout
bl,Bates
number. rnn{c.
lcl
8s
orc{ers srettecesga4'
nruke
such
maythereafter
The
irrlonrrnrion. Courr
Highll'Confidential
o[
govern useof sush
docuntettts inlbnttation'
the
I.

thinl' (301
and
Afier FinalDispositiorl rvithirt
bv
Docurnenr
disposal rhenanies:

all
tttust
eitherretumto theproducer
ar
by
a recipient. i$ electiun,
duysof u r€qucsr rrproclrrcer.
or
the producer'sCorrfidenrial Highll'
containing
and
docurnenrs copies of docuntertts
and
or
ru
inJbrnrarion the prr.rduucr'. desuoyall docunrents copiesof douuntents
Coglidenrial
int'ormatiou,
unless docuntent
tlte
or
Coruidenrial
rhe
Corilideurial Higlrlr.,
containing producer"s
The
as
resriction tcrdisclosure. partyrttunring
inro
or
lrusbeen
otl'ered evidence liled u'ithout
infornratlort Highly Coulidcntial
intbrmation
or
tlre
Conliderrtial
desrroying producer's
nud/or
rvith the rcquirenrenm this pnrrgraph.
of
mlrsrprcnrptll'cenit'vin rvririrrgits courpliance
ntal' relrin
rtocultrtttts,
counsel
to
rhc
)*lonvirhsrandirrgabovcrequireulents returnor destrol'
to
or
or
an
inctuding inderis'hichrel'ers relates Coulidentigl Highly
drrolleyrvorhproduct.
verbatint
substslltial
doesnot duplicate
so
inlbrnrarion. long Rsthe work product
Contidenrial
Tltis rt'ork
ponions rhc text or imuges Contidential Higlil)' CrrnJidetrtial
intbnnation.
or
of
of
this
(or
hrlbmration
under Ordtr.
product
ro
shallconriuue beClontiderrtial Hiehl)Contidcntinl)

t | 7tt5- I

#aSe2:10-cv-02o?e.F.K}'|.'--D€euFnent54Fi|ed07|1-?|11-*He4H14

f

does
provided itsuse
thut
litigation
in
nl.+ry his
An anomey u$e or lrr workproduct n sttbsequent
intbrntation.
()r
confidenrial l{ i glrlycorrJideutisl
nordisclosr
tlre
seal: Attcr Final Disposition. Clerlitttny
tiled
of
Rcrunr rlocunrrrrrs under

q.

at
tiled
docutttetrls or otlered
destruy
$r
tbr
to
t*
elest ...tunr courtsel tlreprnducer. atleruotice,
b1'
restricted rlteCorltasto disclosurs.
$ef,l
trinlugdcr or otlterwise
10.

or
Cuttlidential
regurding
Survivslof obtiuurious:T[is Order'sobligntiorts

on'
F
iott
ial
ll'
High Contident i nthnttnt survive inalDilpositi

IT IS $O ORDERED,

Dated:

t<fia^r*-- 4*t'*--* *,
K. l'lolnres.
lll

. l- l f - v t ]

Paul
Honorable
Judgc
District
Urrired
$tates

BY
ANI) AGIIEETO ABTDE TTIETERMSOF TIIIS OITDER'
}VESTIPTILATII

--l,t-

**

Octbndant
lounterclairu

lrrc'
Advflns;i CNC'l'r'-chnolosics.

,vm$,&?1$mffiffit*
r{t

JUL 5 20tl
|
CI{R.[SR. JOHNSON,fl*:
BJ

Deputycle*

*r,

Co.,
JBlvlWireGrouP, LTD.

fuA,zu^r*-

a
r\ ttoirr lbr Retl urt rrt/t\urtf tercInintnttt
e.v
CotrrPnsy
Cotrcepts
Corrrposite

EI t.ltf- I

l0

.,ii
.,t'i.

4

Case2:10-cv-02023-PKH
Document
54 Filed07112111
Page11 of 14

does
provided irstme
that
litigation
in
5is
5ily
fui anorney u,se or 5ers,orkproduct a subsequent
intbtntation.
conlidential
or
contidcnrial l-lighl1,
nurdisclrrse
q,

tlw
seah Atrcr Final Dispositiotr. Clerk tnal'
tiled
of
Rerurn rlocunrertrs under

at
rltrcttttlenls or ollbred
tilerl
or
electtg retunlto coulseltirr tlreprnduuer. afttr rutice,rlestruy
nS
by Court to disclosure'
restricted rlre
seal
trialr,{tder Orotltenvise
10.

or
Cuntidential
regarding
Suniv$l of oblipurions: This Order'solrlignriuns

ve
ion.
ott
dential
int'orrttati stuvi FinalDisposit
Hi shlv Confi

IT IS SOORTTERED.

Dated:

III
Paul
Honorable K. I'lolnrcs.
Judge
District
Unired
States

OF
OITDER.
BY
TERMS TTIIS
TO
ANI)
WESTIPI.ILATII AGREE ABIDE TTIE

lai
tbr nt ou
.tnonrey Plai it17C nterc nt Det'endant
CltjC'[cr,.hnologir;s.
I nc.
Advsncsd

tbr
Artorney PluintitVC
Co.,LTD.
JB\,tWireOroup.

ffi#J,,ffi
Co
Corttpurry
Contpositc n-'epts

tl?.rt$-1

l0