Ward v. Cisco Systems, Inc. et al

Filing 76

SUPPLEMENT by Plaintiff John Ward, Jr to 75 MOTION for an Order Directing Cisco to Provide Identified Documents to the Court for In Camera Review Redacted Version of Plaintiff's Privilege Log - Ex. 1 to DE #75. (Patton, Nicholas)

Ward v. Cisco Systems, Inc. et al

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 1 of 18

WARD V. CISCO PLAINTIFF'S PROPOSED SUBMISSION LOG

Documents produced in the Albritton v. Cisco litigation in the Eastern District of Texas:1
Begin Bates No.2 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000001 End Bates No. CISCO PRIVILEGED.000001 People - To Bart Showalter John Corcoran Kurt Pankratz Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Bart Showalter Kurt Pankratz Mark Michels Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Bart Showalter Kurt Pankratz Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Bart Showalter Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Bart Showalter Kurt Pankratz Mallun Yen Mark Michels People - From Rick Frenkel People - CC Dan Lang Main Date 17-Oct-2007 Type E-Mail Title Amended ESN Complaint Description Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000002

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000003

Marta Beckwith

Dan Lang

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

RE: Amended ESN Complaint

Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000004

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000004

Rick Frenkel

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000005

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000005

Kurt Pankratz

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

RE: ESN

Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000006

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000006

Kurt Pankratz Rick Frenkel

Dan Lang

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

RE: ESN

Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation.

Plaintiff believes that these documents should be produced pursuant to this Court's March 30, 2009 Order and the holding in In re Chrysler Motors Corp. Overnight Evaluation Program Litigation, 860 F.2d 844, 847 (8th Cir. 1988). 2 Cisco's privilege log entries do not include the electronic header information for each document that was later produced in the Albritton case. If the Court orders these documents produced, Ward requests that Cisco's production also include the electronic header information for each email.

1

Dockets.Justia.com

Doc. 76

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 2 of 18

Begin Bates No.2

End Bates No.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000007 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000009 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000010 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000011 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000014 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000015

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000008 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000009 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000010 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000013 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000014 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000016

People - To Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel Bart Showalter Jillian Powell Kurt Pankratz Kurt Pankratz Jillian Powell Steve Schortgen Mark Chandler John Noh, Cisco Public Relations Mallun Yen, Cisco Mark Chandler Matthew Tanielian Neal Rubin John Noh Bart Showalter Kurt Pankratz Mallun Yen Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Mallun Yen Mark Michels Marta Beckwith Michael Ritter Rick Frenkel

People - From

People - CC

Main Date

Type

Title

Description

Kurt Pankratz Rick Frenkel Jillian Powell Kurt Pankratz Mallun Yen Rick Frenkel, Cisco Rick Frenkel

22-Oct-2007

E-Mail

FW: Urgent - please read - ESN

Email with attorney regarding litigation. Email with attorney's staff regarding litigation. Email with attorney's staff regarding litigation. Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation. Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation.

22-Oct-2007 22-Oct-2007 25-Feb-2008 18-Oct-2007

E-Mail E-Mail E-Mail E-Mail

RE: ESN Re: ESN FW: ESN - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL CISCO HAS AGREED TO PRODUCE THIS DOCUMENT RE: ESN

Mallun Yen

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000019

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000026

Rick Frenkel

Dan Lang

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Urgent - please read - ESN

Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000027

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000027

Rick Frenkel

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

We were just sued by ESN, LLC

Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000028 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000037

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000028 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000041

Mark R. Weinstein Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) BCC: Edward Reines, Weil Gotshal; Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts; Bart Showalter, Baker Botts, Charles Verhoeven, Quinn Emanuel; Doug Kubehl, Baker Botts, Matthew Powers, Weil Gotshal, Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Emanuel Charles K Verhoeven

25-Oct-2007 22-Oct-2007

E-Mail E-Mail

ESN Filing Date - From the Blogs - A/C Privileged In case you haven't seen this about your DJ case in ESN

Email with attorney regarding ESN litigation. Email forwarding Michael Smith's article about the ESN litigation.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000043

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000043

Victoria Maroulis

Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi)

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

Troll Tracker

Email with attorney informing them that Rick Frenkel was the Patent Troll Tracker.

2

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 3 of 18

Begin Bates No.2 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000044

End Bates No. CISCO PRIVILEGED.000048

People - To Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi)

People - From People - CC bart.showalter@bakerb otts.com

Main Date 22-Oct-2007

Type E-Mail

Title In case you haven't seen this about your DJ case in ESN

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000087

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000087

Samir.Bhavsar@ba kerbotts.com

Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi)

bart.showalter@bakerb otts.com

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

Troll Tracker

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000089

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000089

'bart.showalter@ba kerbotts.com'

Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi)

bryant.c.boren@bakerb otts.com chad.walters@bakerbot ts.com doug.kubehl@bakerbot ts.com Samir.Bhavsar@bakerb otts.com

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

Troll Tracker

Description Email attaching Michael Smith's blog about the ESN litigation and discussing his impression of the article as it relates to the ESN litigation. Email with attorney informing them that Rick Frenkel was the Patent Troll Tracker Email with attorney informing them that Rick Frenkel was the Patent Troll Tracker.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000094

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000094

gchambers@McKool Smith.com

Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi)

25-Nov-2007

E-Mail

New local rules

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000103

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000105

Mallun Yen (myen) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) Mallun Yen (myen)

Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi)

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000109

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000111

Mark Chandler (machandl)

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

ESN - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000112

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000115

Mallun Yen (myen)

Mark Chandler (machandl)

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

ESN - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000116

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000118

Mark Chandler (machandl)

Mallun Yen (myen)

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

ESN - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000122

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000125

Mark Chandler (machandl)

Mallun Yen (myen)

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

ESN - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

Email regarding plans to discuss amendments to local rules in Eastern District of Texas Email regarding the legal effect of the filing of the ESN lawsuit before the patent issued and regarding hiring local counsel. Email regarding timing of events with respect to the October 17, 2008 Patent Troll Tracker article. Email regarding timing of events with respect to the October 17, 2008 Patent Troll Tracker article. Email regarding timing of events with respect to the October 17, 2008 Patent Troll Tracker article. Email regarding timing of events with respect to

3

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 4 of 18

Begin Bates No.2

End Bates No.

People - To

People - From

People - CC

Main Date

Type

Title

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000126

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000126

Matthew Tanielian (mtanieli)

Mark Chandler (machandl)

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000134

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000135

Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel)

John Corcoran (jocorcor)

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Amended ESN Complaint

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000136

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000137

John Corcoran (jocorcor)

Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel)

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Amended ESN Complaint

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000138 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000141

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000140 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000144

Matthew Tanielian (mtanieli) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel)

Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel)

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Mallun Yen (myen)

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

Fair Comparison of Patent Litigation Statistics, 1990 v. 2006 v. 2007 ESN - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

Description the October 17, 2008 Patent Troll Tracker article. Email regarding potential conversation with local counsel regarding filing of ESN lawsuit. Comment in response to legal strategy regarding the timing of the filing of the ESN litigation. Comment in response to legal strategy regarding the timing of the filing of the ESN litigation. Email regarding patent statistics. Email regarding timing of events with respect to the October 17, 2008 Patent Troll Tracker article. Email regarding timing of events with respect to the October 17, 2008 Patent Troll Tracker article. Email regarding patent litigation statistics.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000146

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000149

Mallun Yen (myen)

Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel)

25-Feb-2008

E-Mail

ESN - PRIVILEGED AND CONFIDENTIAL

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000154

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000156

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000167

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000168

CISCO

CISCO

Mark Chandler (machandl) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) 'bart.showalter@ba kerbotts.com' 'kurt.pankratz@bak erbotts.com' Mark Michels (mmichels) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) bart.showalter@bak

Matthew Tanielian (mtanieli)

Dan Lang (dlang) Mallun Yen (myen)

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Fair Comparison of Patent Litigation Statistics, 1990 v. 2006 v. 2007 ESN

Mallun Yen (myen)

Dan Lang (dlang)

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket.

kurt.pankratz@bakerbo

Dan Lang (dlang)

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

Email attaching both

4

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 5 of 18

Begin Bates No.2 PRIVILEGED.000169

End Bates No. PRIVILEGED.000169

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000192

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000194

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000204

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000204

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000212

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000212

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000227

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000228

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000231

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000233

People - To People - From People - CC Main Date tts.com erbotts.com Mallun Yen (myen) Mark Michels (mmichels) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) Mallun Yen (myen) Michael Ritter (micritte) 18-Oct-2007 Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) kurt.pankratz@bak Zahner, Gail Bucci, Michael A. 17-Oct-2007 erbotts.com Sicilian, James Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) 18-Oct-2007 'kurt.pankratz@bak Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen (myen) erbotts.com' (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) bart.showalter@bak erbotts.com 19-Oct-2007 'bart.showalter@ba Rich Renfree (rrenfree) kerbotts.com' 'doug.kubehl@bake rbotts.com' 'kurt.pankratz@bak erbotts.com' Mallun Yen (myen) Mark Michels (mmichels) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) 'Victoria Maroulis' Michael Ritter (micritte) 1-Nov-2007

Type

Title

Description online version of the complaint in the ESN litigation.

E-Mail

ESN

Email regarding similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket. Email attaching papers served on ESN and notices from court.

E-Mail

Complaint for Declaratory Judgment - Cisco v ESN LLC

E-Mail

Re: Hertz/TSD Motion to Correct Docket

E-Mail

ESN Files Motion to Enjoin Cisco's CT Case

Email attaching filings in similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket. . Email attaching ESN's amended complaint.

E-Mail

ESN v. Cisco -- Conference Call

CISCO

CISCO

Mallun Yen (myen)

Marta Beckwith

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

Email regarding trying to get in touch by phone to discuss response to ESN motion. Email regarding status of

5

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 6 of 18

Begin Bates No.2 PRIVILEGED.000234

End Bates No. PRIVILEGED.000237

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000250

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000251

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000254

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000254

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000255

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000255

People - To Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) ip-disputesteam(mailer list)

People - From (mabeckwi)

People - CC

Main Date

Type

Title

Description similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket. Email regarding status of similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket.

Mallun Yen (myen)

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

Mallun Yen (myen)

Mark Michels (mmichels)

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Go ahead and contact Quinn and Weil as the short list.

Email regarding selection of counsel.

Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi)

25-Nov-2007

E-Mail

New EDTx rules

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000256 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000257

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000256 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000260

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000261

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000261

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000264

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000265

John Noh (jnoh) Mark Chandler (machandl) Mallun Yen (myen) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) bart.showalter@bak erbotts.com John Corcoran (jocorcor) Mallun Yen (myen) Mark Michels (mmichels) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) John Noh (jnoh) Mark Chandler (machandl) Matthew Tanielian

Mallun Yen (myen)

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

Email regarding proposed amendments to the local rules of the Eastern District of Texas. Email regarding calling potential counsel. Email regarding status of similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket. Email attaching exhibits to complaint in ESN litigation.

Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel)

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

kurt.pankratz@bakerbo tts.com

Dan Lang (dlang)

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Amended ESN Complaint

Mallun Yen (myen)

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

Email regarding rumors about the ESN filing.

6

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 7 of 18

Begin Bates No.2

End Bates No.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000269

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000272

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000276

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000277

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000278

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000281

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000287

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000287

People - To People - From People - CC (mtanieli) Neal Rubin (nrubin) Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen (myen) (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) kurt.pankratz@bak bart.showalter@bakerb Dan Lang (dlang) erbotts.com otts.com Mallun Yen (myen) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) Marta Beckwith Mallun Yen (myen) (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel) John Noh (jnoh) Mallun Yen (myen)

Main Date

Type

Title

Description

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

Email regarding status of similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket.

16-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Urgent - please read - ESN

Email concerning contents of complaint and subject-matter jurisdiction.

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

Email regarding status of similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket.

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

ESN

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000324 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000327

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000324 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000331

John Noh (jnoh) Mallun Yen (myen) Marta Beckwith (mabeckwi) Michael Ritter (micritte) Kurt Pankratz, Bart Showalter, Baker Botts, Marta Beckwith, Mallun Yen, and Michael Ritter, Cisco Jillian Powell, paralegal at Baker Botts

Mallun Yen (myen) Rick Frenkel (rfrenkel)

17-Oct-2007 18-Oct-2007

E-Mail E-Mail

Amended ESN Complaint ESN

Email forwarding both versions of complaint showing different filing dates. Email attaching amended complaint. Email regarding transfer of ESN case to Texas.

BB_0001-Privileged

BB_0006-Privileged

Rick Frenkel

Dan Lang, Cisco

22-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Kurt Pankratz

E-Mail

7

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 8 of 18

Begin Bates No.2 BB_0007-Privileged

End Bates No. BB_0009-Privileged

People - To People - From People - CC Jillian Powell, Baker Steve Schortgen, Baker Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts paralegal Botts Botts

Main Date 22-Oct-2007

Type E-Mail

Title

Description

BB_0010-Privileged

BB_0012-Privileged

Steve Baker Steve Baker

Schortgen, Botts Schortgen, Botts

Jillian Powell, Baker Botts paralegal Jillian Powell, Baker Botts paralegal

Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts

22-Oct-2007 22-Oct-2007

E-Mail E-Mail

BB_0013-Privileged

BB_0016-Privileged

BB_0017-Privileged

BB_0017-Privileged

Jillian Powell and Steve Schortgen, Baker Botts Kurt Pankratz and Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Michael Ritter, and John Corcoran, Cisco Bart Showalter and Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels, and Michael Ritter, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels and Michael Ritter, Cisco Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Rick Frenkel, Bart Showalter, Marta Beckwith, Mallun Yen and

Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Rick Frenkel, Cisco Dan Lang, Cisco

22-Oct-2007

E-Mail

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

Dan Lang, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Kurt Pankratz, Cisco

Dan Lang, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

BB_0018-Privileged

BB_0018-Privileged

Kurt Pankratz

Dan Lang

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

.

8

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 9 of 18

Begin Bates No.2 BB_0019-Privileged

End Bates No. BB_0023-Privileged

BB_0024-Privileged

BB_0026-Privileged

People - To Michael Ritter Kurt Pankratz, Bart Showalter, Marta Beckwith, Michael Ritter and Mallun Yen Kurt Pankratz and Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith and Michael Ritter, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith and Michael Ritter, Cisco Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Bart Showalter and Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels, and Michael Ritter, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels and Michael Ritter, Cisco Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Bart Showalter and Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels, and Michael Ritter, Cisco

People - From Rick Frenkel

People - CC Dan Lang

Main Date 16-Oct-2007

Type E-Mail

Title

Description

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

Dan Lang, Cisco

16-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Bart Showalter, Baker Botts

Dan Lang, Cisco

16-Oct-2007

E-Mail

BB_0027-Privileged

BB_0028-Privileged

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

Dan Lang, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts

Dan Lang, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

BB_0029-Privileged

BB_0033-Privileged

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

Dan Lang, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

9

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 10 of 18

Begin Bates No.2

End Bates No.

People - To Rick Frenkel, Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels, Michael Ritter, Cisco Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Bart Showalter and Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels, and Michael Ritter, Cisco Bart Showalter and Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels, and Michael Ritter, Cisco

People - From Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts

People - CC Dan Lang, Cisco

Main Date 18-Oct-2007

Type E-Mail

Title

Description

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

Dan Lang, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Mallun Yen, Cisco

Dan Lang, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Documents not produced in the Albritton v. Cisco litigation in the Eastern District of Texas but that Plaintiff believes are likely to contain information that falls within the subject-matter waiver of this Court's March 30, 2007 Order:3
Begin Bates No. CISCO PRIVILEGED.000030 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000031
3

End Bates No. CISCO PRIVILEGED.000030 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000031

People - To Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Rick Frenkel, Michael Ritter,

People - From Marta Beckwith, Cisco

People - CC

Date 24-Oct-2007

Type E-Mail

Title

Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts

Doug Kubehl, Bryant C. Boren, Bart Showalter,

25-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Description Email with attorney regarding representation in ESN litigation. Email with attorney regarding legal strategy

Plaintiff selected these documents because they were written on dates corresponding to the publication of the accused articles, October 17, 18, and 19, 2007, were written or received by Richard Frenkel and/or the Cisco employees (Yen and Noh) who encouraged Frenkel to write the accused articles, are correspondence with counsel upon whom Frenkel relied for information concerning events written about in his posts, contain document descriptions that include the same subject matter as Frenkel's posts, likely include facts concerning Cisco and Frenkel's motives for defaming Ward, and/or because they are communications with persons who are not attorneys (Noh, Tanielian and Willhoft) for which Plaintiff believes Defendant's claim of privilege is unwarranted.

10

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 11 of 18

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000034

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000034

Marta Beckwith, Mark Michels, Cisco Attorneys Michael Bucci and James Sicilian, Day Pitney Charles Verhoeven, Quinn Emanuel Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Emanuel Edward Reines and Matthew Powers, Weil Gotshal Charles K. Verhoeven, Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Emanuel Charles K. Verhoeven, Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Emanuel Charles K. Verhoeven, Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Emanuel Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Bart Showalter, Baker Botts John Corcoran, Cisco Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco John Noh, Cisco

Baker Botts

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

with respect to motion to stay filed in ESN litigation in Connecticut. Email regarding service of amended complaint in ESN litigation. Email regarding research of ESN for purposes of ESN litigation. Email with attorneys discussing filing of amended petition in ESN litigation. Email among attorneys discussing ESN filing and declaratory judgment action in Connecticut Email regarding subjectmatter jurisdiction in ESN litigation Email regarding amended complaint in ESN litigation Email discussing claims made by ESN Email with attorney discussing amended complaint in the ESN litigation and the significance of the file date of the ESN litigation on strategy in the case.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000035

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000036

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000042

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000042

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000088

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000088

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000091

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000092

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000093

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000093

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000095 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000098

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000097 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000098

Paul Devinsky, McDermott Will & Emery Rick Frenkel, Cisco

16-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Dan Lang, Cisco

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000099

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000100

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

John Corcoran, Cisco

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding ESN's claims in ESN litigation

CISCO

CISCO

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding

11

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 12 of 18

PRIVILEGED.000101

PRIVILEGED.000101

Public Relations

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000106

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000107

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000108 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000119

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000108 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000121

Rick Frenkel, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Matthew Tanielian, Cisco Director of Governmental Affairs Rick Frenkel, Cisco

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

potentially filing declaratory judgment action in Connecticut. Email regarding hiring of local counsel

Mark Chandler, Cisco Mark Chandler, Cisco

17-Oct-2007 19-Oct-2007

E-Mail E-Mail

Email regarding hiring local counsel Email regarding patent statistics

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000145

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000145

Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000150 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000157

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000151 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000158

Marnie Willhoft, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Rich Renfree, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Doug Kubehl, Baker Botts Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Marta Beckwith, Cisco Charles Verhoeven, Quinn Emanuel Mallun Yen, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco John Noh, Cisco Public Relations

Rick Frenkel

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Mark Michels, Cisco

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding similar case where filing party filed a motion to correct the docket Email regarding informing Cisco employee of ESN lawsuit. Email regarding service of ESN lawsuit

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000159

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000160

Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Rick Frenkel, Cisco Emanuel Michael Ritter, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Mark Michels, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000170

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000170

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding legal strategy with respect to declaratory judgment action. Email regarding ESN's motion to enjoin proceeding in Connecticut. Email regarding potential motion to dismiss and cooling off period.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000171

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000171

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

2-Nov-2007

E-Mail

12

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 13 of 18

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000175

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000175

Rick Frenkel, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco

Mallun Yen, Cisco

Mark Michels, Cisco

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000178

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000180

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding selection of local counsel and strategy for filing declaratory judgment action. Email regarding selection of local counsel for ESN litigation. Email regarding selection of local counsel

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000183

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000185

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000186

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000187

Mark, Michels, Cisco

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding selection of local counsel

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000188

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000188

Marta Beckwith, Cisco

John Noh, Cisco

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000189 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000190

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000189 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000191

Marta Beckwith, Cisco John Noh, Cisco public relations John Noh, Cisco Neal Rubin, Cisco Public Relations Mallun Yen, Cisco Mark Chandler, Cisco Matthew Tanielian, Cisco Governmental Affairs Mallun Yen, Cisco Kurt Pankratz, Baker Marta Beckwith, Cisco Botts

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding mechanics of filing declaratory judgment action. Email regarding filing declaratory judgment action Email regarding local counsel

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000195

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000197

Rick Frenkel, Cisco Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Michael Ritter, Cisco

16-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000198

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000199

Rick Frenkel, Cisco Doug Kubehl, Baker Michael Ritter, Cisco Botts Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Doug Kubehl, Baker Botts Bart Showalter, Baker

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding status of filings in the ESN case and filing of the declaratory judgment action. Email regarding service of complaint and motion to enjoin in Connecticut.

13

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 14 of 18

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000200

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000201

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000202

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000203

Botts Bart Showalter, Baker Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Botts Mallun Yen, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco William Rick Frenkel, Cisco O'Shaughnessy, McCarter & English

Dan Lang, Cisco

16-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding legal analysis of complaint and filing of declaratory judgment action.

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000205

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000207

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000208

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000211

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000213 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000215

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000214 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000217

William Bright and Mark 15-Oct-2007 Giarratana, McCarter & English Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Katherine Bennett, Quinn 27-Oct-2007 Emanuel Marta Beckwith, Cisco Emanuel Kevin Smith, Quinn Emanuel Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Sayuri Sharper, Quinn Emanuel Rick Frenkel, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Katherine Bennett, Quinn 27-Oct-2007 Victoria Maroulis, Emanuel Quinn Emanuel Kevin Smith, Quinn Emanuel Sayuri Sharper, Quinn Emanuel Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco 18-Oct-2007 Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco 15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding possible representation in Connecticut.

E-Mail

Email regarding legal strategy in dealing with subject-matter jurisdiction

E-Mail

Email regarding legal strategy in dealing with subject matter jurisdiction

E-Mail

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000225

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000226

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000229

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000230

Rick Frenkel, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Bart Showalter, Baker Rick Frenkel, Cisco Botts Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Mallun Yen, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco

Dan Lang, Cisco

16-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding legal analysis subject-matter jurisdiction argument Email regarding selection of counsel and filing of declaratory judgment action. Email regarding facts about ESN

Dan Lang, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding legal strategy for dealing with the filing of the ESN lawsuit

14

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 15 of 18

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000238

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000238

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000242

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000243

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000244 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000252 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000253 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000262

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000244 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000252 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000253 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000263

Michael Ritter, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Kurt Pankratz, Baker Botts Bart Showalter, Baker Botts Rick Frenkel, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco

Doug Kubehl, Baker Botts

19-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding plans to discuss ESN's motion to enjoin proceedings in Connecticut.

Mallun Yen, Cisco

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding selection of counsel

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

Mark Michels, Cisco

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Mallun Yen, Cisco

John Noh, Cisco Public Relations Mark Chandler, Cisco

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Mallun Yen, Cisco

Mark Chandler, Cisco

18-Oct-2007 18-Oct-2007

E-Mail E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000266 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000273 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000275 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000282 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000284 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000285

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000268 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000274 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000275 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000283 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000284 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000286

John Noh, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Public Relations Mark Chandler, Cisco Matthew Tanielian, Cisco Governmental Affairs Rick Frenkel, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mark Chandler, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco John Noh, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Public Relations Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mark Chandler, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco

Email regarding timing of filing declaratory judgment action Email regarding procedure for filing in Connecticut Email asking response from potential counsel Update on claims made by ESN concerning the filing of the ESN litigation.

18-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Email regarding selection of local counsel Email regarding selection of local counsel Update about status of filings in ESN litigation Email regarding summary of claims in ESN litigation Email regarding filing of amended complaint by ESN Email regarding topics for meeting

18-Oct-2007 17-Oct-2007

E-Mail E-Mail

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Mark Chandler, Cisco

Mallun Yen, Cisco

17-Oct-2007

E-Mail

Mallun Yen, Cisco

Mark Chandler, Cisco

15-Oct-2007

E-Mail

15

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 16 of 18

CISCO PRIVILEGED.0002884 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000325

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000323 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000326

Chart of patent lawsuits Rick Frenkel, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Dan Lang, Cisco 15-Oct-2007 E-Mail Email discussing facts about ESN

Documents not produced in the Albritton v. Cisco litigation in the Eastern District of Texas but that Plaintiff believes may contain information that falls within the subject-matter waiver of this Court's March 30, 2007 Order.5
Begin Bates No CISCO PRIVILEGED.000029 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000032 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000033 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000049 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000050 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000064 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000073 End Bates No. CISCO PRIVILEGED.000029 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000032 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000033 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000049 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000063 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000072 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000086 People - To People - From Marta Beckwith, Cisco S. Baxter, McKool Smith Marta Beckwith, Cisco S. Baxter, McKool Smith Marta Beckwith, Cisco S. Baxter, McKool Smith Rick Frenkel, Cisco Not included on Cisco's privilege log Not included on Cisco's privilege log Not included on Cisco's privilege log Bart Showalter, Baker Marta Beckwith, Cisco Botts Not included on Cisco's Not included on Cisco's privilege log privilege log Not included on Cisco's Not included on Cisco's privilege log privilege log Not included on Cisco's Not included on Cisco's privilege log privilege log People - CC Date 31-Oct-2007 Type E-Mail Title Description Email with attorney regarding representation in ESN litigation. Email with attorney regarding representation in ESN litigation. Email with attorney regarding representation in ESN litigation. Email attaching analysis of ESN patent claims Analysis of ENS patent claims Analysis of ENS patent claims Analysis of ENS patent claims

31-Oct-2007

E-Mail

31-Oct-2007

E-Mail

30-Nov-2007 30-Nov-2007

E-Mail Not included on Cisco's privilege log Not included on Cisco's privilege log Not included on Cisco's privilege log

30-Nov-2007

30-Nov-2007

4 5

This document is included because Cisco's privilege log does not include sufficient information for Plaintiff to evaluate the document. To the extent that these documents include information concerning the filing of the ESN Complaint, the Amended Complaint, subject-matter jurisdiction in the ESN v. Cisco litigation, the truth or falsity of any of the statements contained in the accused Troll Tracker posts, Cisco and Frenkel's negligence, knowledge of falsity, or recklessness in libeling Ward, or motive for libeling Ward they should be produced. Many of the issues in the ESN case, including subject-matter jurisdiction and venue, have long been resolved and there is little to no harm to Cisco if documents regarding those topics are produced. However, some of these documents may contain legal analysis concerning the patent infringement issues in the underlying ESN v. Cisco litigation; an ongoing issue in that case. The Court should permit Cisco to redact theses documents to ensure that its infringement analysis in the ESN v. Cisco litigation is not disclosed.

16
5536654v.2

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 17 of 18

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000090 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000102

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000090 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000102

Marta Beckwith, Cisco S. Baxter, McKool Smith Rick Frenkel, Cisco Mallun Yen, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco

31-Oct-2007

E-Mail

26-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000127

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000130

Victoria Maroulis, Rick Frenkel, Cisco Quinn Emanuel Marta Beckwith, Cisco

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000131 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000152

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000133 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000153

Rick Frenkel, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco

Rick Frenkel, Cisco John Corcoran, Cisco

Katherine Bennett, Kevin 27-Oct-2007 Smith, and Sayuri Sharper, Quinn Emanuel Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco 12-Nov-2007 2-Nov-2007

Email

Email with attorney regarding representation in ESN litigation. Email regarding case strategy and determination of representation for ESN lawsuit. Email regarding strategy with respect to subject matter jurisdiction arguments IP team monthly report with case summaries. Legal evaluation of potential agreement to dismiss declaratory judgment action and potential stay agreement Email regarding case status of various Cisco lawsuits Email regarding case status and case strategy in the ESN litigation Email regarding new venue case and how it relates to case strategy

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000161 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000164 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000172

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000163 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000166 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000174

Mark Michels, Cisco

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

12-Nov-2007

E-Mail

Mark Michels, Cisco

Rick Frenkel, Cisco

28-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000176 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000177

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000176 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000177

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000181

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000182

Rick Frenkel, Cisco Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Katherine Bennett, Kevin Marta Beckwith, Cisco Emanuel Smith, and Sayuri Sharper, Quinn Emanuel Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Rick Frenkel, Cisco Marta Beckwith, Cisco Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Emanuel Victoria Maroulis, Rick Frenkel, Cisco Mark Michels, Cisco Quinn Emanuel Marta Beckwith, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Victoria Maroulis, Rick Frenkel, Cisco Quinn Emanuel Marta Beckwith, Cisco

27-Oct-2007

E-Mail

29-Oct-2007 28-Nov-2007

E-Mail E-Mail

Email regarding selection of local counsel Email regarding discussing revenue numbers with ESN. Email regarding requirements to file declaratory judgment action in Connecticut. Email regarding status of declaratory judgment action and local counsel

25-Oct-2007

E-Mail

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000218

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000220

Katherine Bennett, Kevin 27-Oct-2007 Smith, and Sayuri Sharper, Quinn Emanuel Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco

E-Mail

17

Case 4:08-cv-04022-JLH Document 76

Filed 06/29/09 Page 18 of 18

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000221

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000224

Victoria Maroulis, Rick Frenkel, Cisco Quinn Emanuel Marta Beckwith, Cisco

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000239 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000245

CISCO PRIVILEGED.000241 CISCO PRIVILEGED.000249

Katherine Bennett, Kevin 27-Oct-2007 Smith, and Sayuri Sharper, Quinn Emanuel Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco Victoria Maroulis, Quinn 31-Oct-2007 Emanuel Rick Frenkel, Cisco Victoria Maroulis, Quinn Katherine Bennett, Kevin 27-Oct-2007 Marta Beckwith, Cisco Emanuel Smith, and Sayuri Sharper, Quinn Emanuel Mark Michels, Cisco Michael Ritter, Cisco

E-Mail

Email regarding case law on venue.

E-Mail E-Mail

Email regarding status of motion to transfer venue Email regarding conference call and evaluation of ESN's connections with Texas.

Exhibits: Plaintiff believes the following Exhibits will be helpful to the Court in examining the documents contained on this submission log: Exhibit 1--October 17, 2007 Troll Tracker Blog Post Exhibit 2--October 18, 2007 Troll Tracker Blog Post Exhibit 3--October 18, 2007 Troll Tracker Blog Post after it was edited by Rick Frenkel on October 19, 2007 Exhibit 4--The internal correspondence among Cisco employees and agents that Cisco has produced in this case, totaling 22 pages.

18