Rabon et al v. Kimani et al
Filing
68
ORDER regarding designated deposition testimony. Signed by Honorable Susan O. Hickey on September 14, 2017. (mll)
<![CDATA[
IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
WESTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS
TEXARKANA DIVISION
TERRANCE RABON and
KATHLEEN RABON
v.
PLAINTIFFS
Case No. 4:16-cv-4007
JOHN K. KIMANI;
TOLYN EXPRESS, LLC; and
JOHN DOES 1-6
DEFENDANTS
SENRTY SELECT INSURANCE
CO.
INTERVENOR
ORDER
Plaintiffs have designated portions of depositions that they plan to present at trial for the
following witnesses: Alexa Rabon, Jane Hall, Robert Ancell, Andres Munk, and Habib Gennaoui.
The Court has reviewed the deposition transcripts and makes the following rulings regarding
objections to deposition testimony:
1. Alexa Rabon
•
page 14: line 24 through page 15: line 1 – Defendants’ objection sustained.
2. Jane Hall
•
page 8: line 9 through page 10: line 4 – Defendants’ objection sustained as to
page 8: line 9 through page 8: line 11, and as to page 8: line 15 through
page 8: line 19. Defendants’ objection overruled as to the remainder of this
section.
•
page 11: line 7 through page 11: line 21 – Defendants’ objection sustained as
to page 11: line 9 (beginning with “and in fact”) through page 11: line 12
(ending with “you know.”). Defendants’ objection overruled as to the
remainder of this section.
•
page 13: line 21 through page 14: line 5 – Defendants’ objection sustained as
to page 13: line 22 through page 14: line 5.
Defendants’ objection
overruled as to the remainder of this section.
•
page 14: line 22 through page 17: line 23 – Defendants’ objection sustained
as to page 15: line 12 (beginning with “And then Kathy”) through page 15:
line 17. Defendants’ objection overruled as to the remainder of this section.
•
page 18: line 2 through page 18: line 13 – Defendants’ objection sustained.
•
page 18: line 21 through page 19: line 1 – Defendants’ objection sustained.
•
page 20: line 13 through page 20: line 16 – Defendants’ objection sustained.
•
page 22: line 17 through page 23: line 17 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
•
page 24: line 10 through page 24: line 12 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
•
page 25: line 10 through page 25: line 16 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
•
page 26: line 14 through page 26: line 17 – Defendants’ objection sustained.
•
page 26: line 21 through page 26: line 24 – Defendants’ objection sustained.
•
page 36: line 5 through page 39: line 5 – Defendants’ objection sustained.
3. Robert Ancell
•
page 21: line 10 through page 22: line 13 – Defendants’ objection sustained
as to page 21: line 17 through page 21: line 24. Defendants’ objection
overruled as to the remainder of this section.
•
page 22: line 24 through page 23: line 19 – Defendants’ objection sustained
as to page 23: line 5 through page 23: line 13 and page 23: line 17 through
2
page 23: line 18. Defendants’ objection overruled as to the remainder of
this section.
•
page 25: line 25 through page 27: line 2 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
Page 26: line 3 and page 26: line 13 should be excluded.
•
page 33: line 12 through page 33: line 13 – Plaintiffs have withdrawn this
designation.
•
page 34: line 17 through page 34: line 18 – Plaintiffs have withdrawn this
designation.
4. Andres Munk
•
page 48: line 8 through page 50: line 24 – Defendants’ objection sustained as
to page 49: line 14 through page 50: line 12.
Defendants’ objection
overruled as to the remainder of this section.
5. Habib Gennaoui
•
page 15: line 2 through page 15: line 9 – Plaintiffs have withdrawn this
designation.
•
page 23: line 8 through page 24 line 13 – Defendants’ objection sustained as
to page 24: line 1 through page 24: line 9 (ending with “I would say it’s
conclusive.”). Defendants’ objection overruled as to the remainder of this
section.
•
page 24: line 21 through page 26: line 4 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
•
page 27: line 4 through page 27: line 15 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
•
page 28: line 10 through page 29: line 7 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
•
page 65: line 21 through page 67: line 8 – Defendants’ objection sustained.
3
•
page 70: line 15 through page 71: line 7 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
•
page 72: line 11 through page 72: line 13 – Defendants’ objection overruled.
IT IS SO ORDERED, this 14th day of September, 2017.
/s/ Susan O. Hickey
Susan O. Hickey
United States District Judge
4
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
