Hardy et al v. Malvern School District et al

Filing 99

ORDER denying as moot 95 Motion for Voluntary Non-Suit for Specific Plaintiffs; granting 96 Amended Motion for Voluntary Non-Suit for Specific Plaintiffs, dismissing without prejudice Violet Crabtrey, Alicia Dertow, Tim Dertow, Janice Fowler, Ran dy Fowler, Tamara Griffin, George Hathcock, Julie Hathcock, Chris Hilborn, Lana Hill, Ronnie Hill, Amanda Hogan, Don Hogan, Tabetha Johnson, Jenna Jordan, Amanda C Martin, Michael Martin, Penny McInroe, James Mears, Parents for School Choice, Jeff Ra y, Tonya Ray, Earnest Reynolds, Vianna Reynolds, Doug Stell, Jennifer Stell, Linda - Williams, Patricia Williams, Patricia Brown and Jody Chadwick. Parties terminated. Signed by Honorable Robert T. Dawson on December 15, 2009. (dmc) Modified on 12/16/2009 to edit text (cap).

IN THE UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT WESTERN DISTRICT OF ARKANSAS HOT SPRINGS DIVISION DARRIN HARDY; JULIE HARDY; BENJAMIN LYNCH, SR.; SUE WALLACE; JOHN WALLACE; RON TEAGUE; KATHY TEAGUE; KAREN MEARS; JAMES MEARS; DON HOGAN; AMANDA HOGAN; VIANNA REYNOLDS; JENNIFER STELL; DOUG STELL; JANICE FOWLER; RANDY FOWLER; TABETHA JOHNSON; JODY CHADWICK; MARK DRAPER; JENNIFER DRAPER; PENNY MCINROE; RHONDA RICHARDSON; TAMARA GRIFFIN; LANA HILL; RONNIE HILL; GEORGE HATHCOCK; JULIE HATHCOCK; KAREN WEST; PATRICIA BROWN; EARNEST REYNOLDS; JENNA JORDAN; VIOLET CRABTREY; JEFF RAY; TONYA RAY; TIM DERTOW; ALICIA DERTOW; LINDA WILLIAMS; CHRIS HILBORN; PATRICIA WILLIAMS; MICHAEL MARTIN; AMANDA MARTIN; c/k/a PARENTS FOR SCHOOL CHOICE v. Civ. No. 08-6094

PLAINTIFFS

MALVERN SCHOOL DISTRICT; DIANE TATUM, BRENDA GULLETT, ALICE WILLIAMS MAHONY, DR. BEN MAYS, SAMUEL LEDBETTER, JIM COOPER, and SHERRY BURROW, members of the Arkansas State Board of Education; DR. NACCAMAN WILLIAMS, Vice Chair of the Arkansas State Board of Education; and RANDY LAWSON, Chair of the Arkansas State Board of Education ORDER Currently before the Court are Plaintiffs'

DEFENDANTS

Motion

for

Voluntary Non-Suit for Specific Plaintiffs (doc. 95) and Amended Motion for Voluntary Non-Suit for Specific Plaintiffs. (Doc. 96). Because their amended motion renders the original motion moot, Plaintiffs' Motion for Voluntary Non-Suit for Specific Plaintiffs (doc. 95) is DENIED AS MOOT. For their amended motion, Plaintiffs

seek an order dismissing Don Hogan, Amanda Hogan, Vianna Reynolds,

Jennifer Stell, Doug Stell, Janice Fowler, Randy Fowler, Tabetha Johnson, Jody Chadwick, James Mears, Penny McInroe, Tamara Griffin, Lana Hill, Ronnie Hill, George Hathcock, Julie Hathcock, Patricia Brown, Earnest Reynolds, Jenna Jordan, Alicia Dertow, Tim Dertow, Chris Hilborn, Amanda Martin, Michael Martin, Jeff Ray, Tonya Ray, Linda Williams, Patricia Williams, Parents for School Choice, and Violet Crabtrey. The Court, being well and sufficiently advised,

finds that Plaintiffs' Amended Motion for Voluntary Non-Suit for Specific Plaintiffs (doc. 96) should be GRANTED, and these

Plaintiffs are dismissed without prejudice. IT IS SO ORDERED this 15th day of December, 2009. /s/ Robert T. Dawson Honorable Robert T. Dawson United States District Judge

Page 2 of

2