Perfect 10 Inc v. Google Inc et al

Filing 724

DECLARATION of Kris Brewer in opposition to MOTION for Discovery regarding A DOCUMENT PRESERVATION ORDER TO PREVENT SPOLIATION OF EVIDENCE BY GOOGLE #670 Supplemental Declaration of Kris Brewer in Support of Google Inc.'s Opposition to Perfect 10, Inc.'s Motion for a Document Preservation Order to Prevent Spoliation of Evidence by Google, and Exhibit A Thereto filed by Counter Claimant Google Inc, Defendant Google Inc. (Kassabian, Rachel)

1 QUINN EMANUEL URQUHART OLIVER & HEDGES, LLP Michael T. Zeller (Bar No. 196417) 2 [e-mail] 865 South Figueroa Street, 10th Floor 3 Los Angeles, California 90017-2543 Telephone: ~13) 443-3000 4 FacsImile: 213) 443-3100 Charles K. erhoeven (Bar No. 170151) 5 [e-mail] 50 California Street, 22nd Floor 6 San Francisco~ California 94111 Rachel HerrIck Kassabian (Bar No. 191060) ·7 [e-mail] 555 Twin DolphinlJrive, Suite 560 8 Redwood Shores, California 94065 9 Attorneys for Defendant GOOGLE INC. 10 11 12 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA CASE NO. CV 04-9484 AHM (SHx) [Consolidated with Case No. CV 05~753 AHM (SHx)]

DISCOVERY MATTER
Hon. Stephen 1. Hillman

SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF KRIS BREWER IN SUPPORT OF GOOGLE INC.'S OPPOSITION TO PERFECT 10, INC.'S MOTION FOR A DOCUMENT PRESERVATION ORDER TO PREVENT SPOLIATION OF EVIDENCE BY GOOGLE
Date: · January 15,2010 Time: 10:00 a.m. Ctrm: 550 24 AMAZON.COM, INC., a corporation; A9.COM, INC., a corporation; and 25 DOES 1 through 100, inclusive,
26 Defendants.

Discovery Cut-off: None Set Pretrial Conference Date: None Set Trial Date: None Set

27 28
01980.51320/3271805.3

SUPPLEMENT AL DECLARATION OF KRIS BREWER

1 2

I, Kris Brewer, declare as follows: 1. I am an Associate Discovery Counsel at Google Inc. ("Google"). I make

3 this declaration of personal, firsthand knowledge and, if called and sworn as a 4 witness, I could and would testify competently thereto. . 5 2. I have worked full-time at Google since March 30, 2009. I have been

6 employed by Google on a full-time basis as Associate Discovery Counsel since 7 August 10, 2009. 8 3. Prior to my employment by Google, I was employed by Dewey &

9 LeBoeufLLP. My last day of full-time work at Dewey & LeBoeuf was March 27, 10 2009. From March 30 to July 31, 2009, I worked at Google as a legal secondee from 11 Dewey & LeBoeuf. My employment with Dewey & LeBoeuf formally ended 12 on July 31, 2009. 13 4. During the course of my employment with Google, I have become

14 familiar with the discovery aspects of the Perfect 10 v. Google litigation, including 15 assisting in managing Google's document preservation, collection and production 16 efforts, and reviewing historical files to familiarize myself with the materials, 17 correspondence and personnel involved, and the events which have transpired. I 18 relied on this lmowledge and experience in preparing my December 30, 2009 19 Declaration. 20 5. As a former employee, I lmow that Dewey & LeBoeuf has an official

21 firm website, which is located at www.deweyleboeuf.com. 22 6. Attached as Exhibit A is a true a correct copy of a printout from

23 www.deweyleboeuf.com showing that running a search for the query "kris brewer" as 24 of January 6,2010 (which I personally did) yielded no responsive hits. 25 26 27 28
01980.51320/3271805.3

-]SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF KRIS BREWER

1

I declare under penalty of perjury under the laws of the United States of

2 America that the foregoing is true and correct. 'Executed January 12, 2010 at 3 Mountain View, California.
4

5

Kris Brewer

6 7
8

9
10
11

12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25

26
27 28
01980.51320/3271805 .3

-2SUPPLEMENTAL DECLARATION OF KRIS BREWER '

EXHIBIT A

~') Dewey 11 LeBoeuf Se.orch Results Manila Flrefox

~~~

x
~ Most VISited .
Get1rog Started

1

0:l ;;",i.i/I-~~.;;-:;,","",;;;;;;;';~-;";'~'~" '~~~;;"~~~" ~-;;;;;.~-~~;-;-;;-;~;:::===================0('LJ1 ~t(·=-~;;::=========P81 JI : ; ; ~; ; ; ; ;; ;;; ;;; ; v

IiIU l a test fl<~ U ~

Coogle

I In; br.......

ott SeMen
[ -:-

-

+oj. - C' - ~ C) M - n

8oobn.wI<s -

l D ~l!o. l~ ~rdo R~1to

S".rell

~

DEWEY

& LEBoEUF

Search Results
Search
ReslJ~s

f()r: kris brewer

Sorry, we didn' find any ,.,ulto 10' y<>u, ,..,ch. rl e . , e t ry "9_in Here are some suggest ions th at may help \,00 find wh at yoo're looking f<>r · F<>r det ail s on our >"act ices , globa l indust ry sector groups , th e reqions in wh ic h we worX and locat ions 01 our offices , "; s it our SeMces sect ion · F<>r D<.wey 8; LeB""uf cl ient alert s , upcom ing event s or art icl e s " ; ew our Ideas sect ion · To find a lawyer, ";s it our P""rHe sect ioo and searc h our direct ory 01 lawyers and """sors · o..t ail s of t he fi rm ' s >,,0 bono and d",m it y comm itm ent s and actMt ies , D<.wey 8; LeB""uf s Med ia Center, rHu s lu ll det ail s of awards and oth er recog nit ion of th e fi rm ' s act Mt ies , ca n be found in our Firm sect ion · A count r y - b y < o unt ry guide t o careers opportun it ies and our appfOac h t o recru itm ent ca n be foo nd in our Car""rs sect ion · Med ia and Press cont ac t s ca n "; s it our Media Center · For more inform at ion about D<.wey 8; L.B""uf, quest ions or t o >"""de feedback rHease Contact Us

S ea , ch

Uarrow 10ur results or enter a new search

~

Contoc!Us

1

S.teMap

1

l_lfIobces

1

PW.cy

1

AHorneyAdve<tlSrI\I

1

C>2009Oewey& l e B o e u f l l P

Th.io we,sie iornonto....o tlyOewey&

l~B[>e<Jf

llP n flew Yo<'<, flY, USA

Exhibit A, Page 3

~') Dewey 11 LeBoeuf Lawyer Results Manila Flrefox

~~~

x
~ Most VISited .
Get1rog Started

rrI :),,;,"~/-;;;-;,;";,;"";;";-;" ' '~"";;;;;~;;';;;';" ';-;;;;;;;-;;~;;:==================0('LJ1 ~t(,~-;;;;:::========pl J l ;. ~;;; ;;, ;;; ~ ~ ;; ; ' ~ ; ~ ;;;; ~ ;;; : ;l'J
IiIU l . tes t fl<~ U ~
v

Coogle

I In; br.......

ott SeMen
[ -:-

-

+oj. - C' - ~ C) M - n

8oobn.wI<s -

.1 D ~l!o. l~ la~r R~ b

S".rell

~

DEWEY

& LEBoEUF

Lawyer Results
Sorry, we d id n 't
~nd

any resu lt s l o r y o ur sea rch Please try aga in
~ nd

He re are some suggestions that may he lp y ou

what y ou ' re k>oking lor

· For det. il s on our practices , glob. 1ir"(j ust ry sector groups , th e regions in wh ic h we wor!< . nd loc.tions of our offices , "; sit our s.,..,;ces section · For o..-y 8; LeBoeuf cl ient alert s, ur>Coming """nt s or . rt icl es "; ew our Ideas section · To find. lawyer, "; sit our P""ple secti on and sea rc h our directory of lawyers and m sors · Detail s of th e firm's pro bono . nd diversity comm it ment s . nd actMties , o..-y 8; LeBoouf s Med ia Cent " " plu s lu ll detail s of awards and oth er recognition of th e firm's actMties , ca n be found in our Firm sect io n · A count ry-{)y < o unt ry guide to ca rM " owort un it ies and our approac h to rec ru it ment c. n be found in our Careers sect ion · Med ia and Press cont ac t s ca n "; sit oo r Med ia Cent", · For more information .bout o..-y 8; LeBoouf, questions or to prcMd e fMdback please Contact Us

Exhibit A, Page 4