Asia Economic Institute et al v. Xcentric Ventures LLC et al

Filing 159

REQUEST FOR JUDICIAL NOTICE re MOTION for Summary Judgment as to Entire Case 145 in Opposition to Motion for Summary Judgment filed by Plaintiffs Asia Economic Institute, Iliana Llaneras, Raymond Mobrez. (Attachments: # 1 Exhibit 1 to Request for Jusicial Notice (November 10, 2009 Transcript of Proceedings in Blockowicz v. Williams), # 2 Exhibit 2 to Request for Judicial Notice (Dismissal of Ninth Circuit Appeal in Xcentric v. Bird), # 3 Exhibit 3 to Request for Judicial Notice (Transcript of Sept. 21, 2010 oral argument in Xcentric v. Richeson), # 4 Exhibit 4 to Request for Judicial Notice (Dec of Justin Crossman in Russo v. Xcentric))(Borodkin, Lisa)

Download PDF
Asia Economic Institute et al v. Xcentric Ventures LLC et al Doc. 159 Att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ockets.Justia.com W V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ 0>>J0E0H-JBM K2' &C$ >3/(%&(@@+M 90INEQ ; <O,a. >?-? I7M MA?<A *?<D< 'B:C8> %NOI I7M (PAD 'I LQ;@> %NOI UWYY H? -$%&'/3 0A$%*$ B*(&$ WYYY >C2$%(Z. 0b [\YVW K2' &C$ F$@$%5/%&M OH >EL>EO0 >JEBLH0 I7M '8AR; )<S8:N9; V`Y^ PD(3(:C& F'(A$ a(33$$%. P" _^\XU NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP U V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ >EL-JJFOHQB PcJ -LNEPELLS FJ>NPdM -(A(3 -/+$ WYVY]V`UV. "#$%&'(# PC(+ (+ &C$ &(4$ +$& @2' / ,,-. $& /3?. A$'+*+ BC/D% E(#C$+2%? 8'$3(4(%/'7 (%e*%#&(2% C$/'(%:? -2*%+$3. 83$/+$ /%%2*%#$ @2' &C$ '$#2'5? SE? aNHbM PC/%= 72*. d2*' c2%2'? OT4 05/4 a*%1 @2' VUMXYMU\ "#$%&'(# )$%&*'$+ /%5 9/6*': ; <(3=? SB? B>JPcM 9/6*': ; <(3=? SE? EO-cJBLHM PcJ -LNEPM BC/D% E(#C$+2% &C$ 5$@$%5/%&? VUMXYMX^ S/'(/ B8$&C @2' "#$%&'(# )$%&*'$+ /%5 B8$/= (%&2 4(#'28C2%$. 83$/+$? OT4 BC/D% E(#C$+2%. &C$ 5$@$%5/%&? Q225 /@&$'%22%? SE? EO-cJBLHM PcJ -LNEPM 033 '(:C&? 033 '(:C&? S'? a*%1. C2D 52 72* D/%& &2 8'2#$$5 (% VUMXVMYW &$'4+ 2@ 8*&&(%: (% &C$ $A(5$%#$ 72* D/%& &2 8*& (%f SE? aNHbM <$33. d2*' c2%2'. (@ O 4/7 C/A$ 72*' (%5*3:$%#$. DC/& OT5 3(=$ &2 52 @('+& (+ 322= /& 5$@$%5/%& E(#C$+2%T+ /%+D$' /%5 42&(2%. >/:$ VY 2@ VU? PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM F(5%T& O /3'$/57 '*3$ 2% &C(+f H2& /62*& DC/& OT4 :2(%: &2 5'/D 72*' c$ #$'&/(%37 5(5 /8837 @2' / VUMXVMW[ /&&$%&(2% &2. d2*' c2%2'? 8'$3(4(%/'7 (%e*%#&(2% &C/& D2*35 /8837 @2' *+. /%5 O 6$3($A$ 72* 5('$#&$5 C(4 &C/& (@ C$ 5(5 (& (% &C$ 8'28$' D/7 (& D2*35 6$ #2%+(5$'$5? I*& &C$ A$'7 @('+& 8/'/:'/8C (% B$#&(2% W +/7+. VUMXVMXV gF$@$%5/%& 52$+ C$'$67 +&(8*3/&$ &2 &C$ 83/(%&(@@+T 8$%5(%: NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP X V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ /883(#/&(2% /%5 42&(2% @2' &$482'/'7 (%e*%#&(2% 5*'(%: &C$ /5A/%#$4$%& 2@ &C(+ #/*+$ 2@ /#&(2%?g PcJ -LNEPM S'? E(#C$+2%. (+ &C/& #2''$#&f d$+. d2*' c2%2'. /%5 %2? <C$% O @('+& VUMXVM\\ SE? EO-cJBLHM /883($5 @2' /% $Z8/%+(2% 2% &C/& &$482'/'7 (%e*%#&(2%. O D/+ ]] O /883($5 &C$ 3/D D'2%:? B2 72* C/5 '*3$5 2% (& 7$+&$'5/7. /%5 /& &C(+ &(4$ OT5 3(=$ &2 :2 /C$/5 /%5 C235 / C$/'(%:? PcJ -LNEPM <$33. :2 /C$/5 /%5 DC/&f 0%5 C/A$ 72* 52 72*' C$/'(%: 2% &C(+. VUMXWMVW SE? EO-cJBLHM d2*' c2%2'? O 52%T& D/%& &2 /'6(&'/'(37 +&(8*3/&$? O 52%T& *%5$'+&/%5 DC/& 72* /'$ +/7(%:? PcJ -LNEPM d2* /'$ /:'$$(%: &2 &C$ (%e*%#&(A$ '$3($@ &C/& &C$ 83/(%&(@@ (+ +$$=(%:. #2''$#&f SE? EO-cJBLHM &C/&? PcJ -LNEPM (% 72*' /%+D$'f SE? EO-cJBLHM PcJ -LNEPM d$+. d2*' c2%2'? B2 /'$ 72* '$&'/#&(%: DC/& 72* D'2&$ C$'$ H2. d2*' c2%2'? OT4 %2& /:'$$(%: &2 VUMXWMW^ <$33. S'? a*%1. OT4 %2& +*'$ C$ #/% VUMXWMU[ '$&'/#& (& 6*& /'$ 72* 8'$8/'$5 &2 8'2#$$5f SE? aNHbM O D2*35 6$ 8'$8/'$5 &2 8'2#$$5. d2*' c2%2'. 6*& O 52%T& &C(%= C$ #/% '$&'/#& (&? PcJ -LNEPM <$33. S'? E(#C$+2%. #2*35 72* $Z83/(% &2 4$ ]] /#&*/337. (& D2*35 6$ 6$&&$' (@ 72* D2*35 #24$ *8 &2 &C$ 825(*4 6$#/*+$ &C$ 4(#'28C2%$ (+ 6$&&$' &C$'$? VUMXWM\^ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP \ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ SE? EO-cJBLHM PcJ -LNEPM L=/7. d2*' c2%2'? <2*35 72* $Z83/(% &2 4$ DC/& 72*' 6/+(+ (+ @2' +$$=(%: 3$/A$ &2 '$&'/#& DC/& 72* D'2&$ C$'$. DC(#C 322=+ 3(=$ +24$&C(%: &C/& %2'4/337 / 3/D7$' D2*35 '$37 2% DC$% &C$7 '$/5 (&f <C/&T+ 72*' 6/+(+ @2' '$&'/#&(%: (& /%5 /+=(%: &2 VUMXUMVV 8'2#$$5 D(&C $A(5$%#$ &25/7f SE? EO-cJBLHM /883(#/&(2%? d2*' c2%2'. O (48'28$'37 4/5$ &C/& O 5(5%T& C/A$ / :'$/& 5$/3 2@ &(4$ &2 '$+82%5 /%5 0%5 /+ O '$/5 2A$' &C$ '*3$+ 2@ ]] VUMXUMUY $%&$' 47 #2*%&$'#3/(4+? K$5$'/3 E*3$+ 2@ -(A(3 >'2#$5*'$. O +$$ &C/& O 5(5 &C(%:+ h*(&$ D'2%:? B2 DC$% O 5'/@&$5 47 /%+D$'. O &'($5 &2 4(Z &2:$&C$' 47 /883(#/&(2% @2' / &$482'/'7 (%e*%#&(2% &2 $Z8/%5 &C$ +#28$ 2@ S'+? B8$&CT+ &$482'/'7 (%e*%#&(2%? 0%5 /@&$' '$#$(A(%: d2*' c2%2'T+ '*3(%: 7$+&$'5/7. (& 6$#/4$ #3$/' &C/& O 5(5 &C(+ (48'28$'37? B2 /& &C(+ &(4$. O D2*35 3(=$ &2 ]] <$33. O C$/'5 DC/& 72* +/(5? I*& (&T+ VUMXUM\Y PcJ -LNEPM '$/337 %2& 4/=(%: +$%+$ &2 4$. 6$#/*+$ DC/& 47 '*3(%: D/+ (+ &C/& 72*. 3(=$ /%7 3(&(:/%&. 72* /'$ @'$$ &2 /+= @2' (%e*%#&(A$ '$3($@ (@ 72* #/% 5$42%+&'/&$ &C$ @/#&+ /%5 &C$ 3$:/3 8'(%#(83$+ &C/& D2*35 D/''/%& :'/%&(%: &C/& '$3($@? /'$ 8'2#$5*'$+ @2' @2332D(%: &C/&? I*& &C$'$ VUMXXMY[ 0%5 &C/&T+ /33 O '*3$5. d2* #/% 4/=$ +*#C / &C/& &C(+ (+ %2& &C$ #2''$#& 8'2#$5*'$? '$h*$+& /%5 D$ D2*35 +#C$5*3$ (& (% 5*$ #2*'+$? S7 h*$+&(2% &2 72* (+ 5(@@$'$%&? O& +/7+ C$'$. /+ S'? VUMXXMW_ a*%1 82(%&$5 2*&. &C/& (% 72*' /%+D$' 72* #2%+$%&$5 &2 &C$ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP ^ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ &$482'/'7 (%e*%#&(2% 5*'(%: &C$ /5A/%#$4$%& 2@ &C(+ #/*+$? 0%5 +2 OT4 /+=(%: 72* DC/& 72*' 6/+(+ (+ @2' +$$=(%: &2 6$ '$3($A$5 @'24 &C/&. DC(#C (+ 5(@@$'$%& @'24 72*' @/(3*'$ &2 8'28$'37 8'$+$%& 72*' '$h*$+& @2' 72*' 2D% (%e*%#&(2%. DC(#C D$ D(33. (@ (&T+ 52%$ '(:C&. D$ D(33 #2%+(5$' (& (% 5*$ #2*'+$? I*& DC/& (+ 72*' 6/+(+ @2' +$$=(%: &2 6$ '$3($A$5 2@ &C(+ +&(8*3/&(2% @2' &C$ $%&'7 2@ / &$482'/'7 (%e*%#&(2% 5*'(%: &C$ 8$%5$%#7 2@ &C(+ #/+$f SE? EO-cJBLHM H2D &C/& &C$ h*$+&(2%T+ 6$$% 82+$5 3(=$ VUMX\MVY VUMXXM\W &C/&. d2*' c2%2'. &C$'$ '$/337 (+ %2 6/+(+ @2' 47 '$&'/#&(2% 2@ &C/&? PcJ -LNEPM )$'7 D$33 &C$%? O D(33 /##$8& &C$ 0%5 O &C(%= &C/& +&(8*3/&(2% /%5 C235 &C$ 5$@$%5/%& &2 (&? $3(4(%/&$+ &C$ %$$5 @2' &C$ 83/(%&(@@+ &2 :2 @2'D/'5 D(&C &C$ $A(5$%#$ &2 8'2A$ *8 &C$ @/#&*/3 6/+(+ @2' &C$(' (%e*%#&(2%? 0%5 &C/&T+ 72*' ]] &C/&T+ DC/& 72* /'$ +$$=(%:. S'? a*%1. #2''$#&f SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM d$+. d2*' c2%2'? PC/&T+ $Z/#&37 '(:C&? VUMX\MW\ H2D. S'? E(#C$+2%. 3$& 4$ e*+& +/7 /:/(%. VUMX\MXW (@ 72* D/%& &2 +$$= /% (%e*%#&(2%. 72* C/A$ &2 @(3$ / #2*%&$'#3/(4? O& C/+ &2 ]] +&/&(%: / #3/(4 (+ / &$#C%(#/3 <C/& (& 4$/%+ (+ &C/& (& 5$+#'(6$+ +24$&C(%: 3$:/3 $Z8'$++(2%? @2' DC(#C &C$ 3/D 8'2A(5$+ / '$4$57 &C/& (+ +24$&C(%: &C/&T+ #2%&'/'7 &2 &C$ 3/D /%5 @2' DC(#C / '$4$57 D(33 6$ 8'2A(5$5. /%5 &C$% 72* C/A$ &2 4$$& 2&C$' '$+82%+(6(3(&($+ /+ D$33 &2 :$& VUMX^MYW NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP _ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ /% (%e*%#&(2%? 0% (%e*%#&(2%. (% &C$ 6$:(%%(%: 2@ &C$ #/+$. (+ /% $Z&'/2'5(%/'7 '$4$57? O&T+ %2& :'/%&$5 /+ / 4/&&$' 2@ #2*'+$. /%5 (&T+ 52%$ &2 8'$A$%& (''$8/'/63$ C/'4 /%5 42+& 2@ &C$ &(4$ +24$DC/& +(4(3/'37. (& #/% 6$ 52%$ &2 8'$A$%& / #C/%:$ (% &C$ +&/&*+ h*2 &C/& D2*35 8'$#3*5$ &C$ -2*'& @'24 :'/%&(%: $@@$#&(A$ '$3($@ /& / 3/&$' &(4$? 0%5 &C$'$ /'$ 2&C$' VUMX^MV[ e*+&(@(#/&(2%+ /+ D$33. 6*& &C2+$ /'$ &C$ 4/(% 2%$+? B2 72* #/% @(3$ +*#C / 42&(2%? +(5$ '$+82%5+ &2 (&. O 322= /& (&? /33 (%? d2* @(3$ (&. &C$ 2&C$' VUMX^MUX O &78(#/337 D(33 #/33 72* d2* /'$ @'24 2*& 2@ &2D%. '(:C&f SE? EO-cJBLHM PcJ -LNEPM d$+. d2*' c2%2'? K2' %2%]$A(5$%&(/'7 4/&&$'+. %2%]&'(/3+. O <$ *+*/337 VUMX^M\Y /332D 8$283$ 2*& 2@ +&/&$ &2 /88$/' 67 &$3$8C2%$? :$& 2% &C$ 8C2%$ +#C$5*3$ / &(4$ &2 C/A$ &C/& C$/'(%: /%5 &C$% D$ C/A$ &C/& C$/'(%:? I*& D$T'$ %2& &2 &C/& 8C/+$ 7$& 2% /%7 '$3($@ '$h*$+&$5 67 72*? B2 O &C(%= 72* #/% &/=$ 72*' +$/&. 6$#/*+$ &C/& /%+D$'+ 47 h*$+&(2%+? 8*& &2 62&C +(5$+? S'? a*%1. 9*5:$ P$(362': '/(+$5 &C$ h*$+&(2% 2@ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%& (% &C(+ #/+$? SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM d$+? O 5(5 D/%& &2 $Z832'$ &C/&? <C/& (+ &C$ VUMX_MWW O 52 C/A$ +24$ 2&C$' &C(%:+ O %$$5 &2 VUMX_MY[ 6/+(+ @2' e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%& (% &C(+ #/+$f 0%5 9*5:$ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP [ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ P$(362': &235 4$ ]] /%5 &C$'$T+ /3D/7+ / '(+= O 4(:C& %2& :$& &C(+ $%&('$37 #2''$#&. +2 72* #/% C$38 4$ 2*&? I*& C$ &235 4$ &C/& 72* $Z83(#(&37 5(+#3/(4$5 /%7 '$3($@ 2' 5/4/:$+ 6/+$5 2% /#&*/3 5/4/:$+ &2 $(&C$' 2@ &C$ 83/(%&(@@+? H2D. (+ &C/& #2''$#&f SE? aNHbM O& (+ #2''$#& &C/& %$(&C$' 83/(%&(@@ (+ <$ #$'&/(%37 5(5%T& #3/(4 &C/& (& VUMX_MX` +$$=(%: /#&*/3 5/4/:$? 5(5%T& C/88$%. 6*& D$ /'$ %2& +$$=(%: (& /+ / '$4$57 C$'$? PcJ -LNEPM /42*%&? 0%5 +2 D/3= 4$ &C'2*:C &C$ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 VUMX[MY[ 0%5 S'? E(#C$+2%. 3$& 4$ $Z83/(% DC/& &C(+ (+ /62*&? PC$ +&/&$ K2' ]] &C$ @$5$'/3 #2*'&+ 52%T& C$/' /33 #/+$+? #2*'&+ #/% C$/' $++$%&(/337 /%7 #/+$. 6*& @2' / #/+$ &2 6$ 6'2*:C& (% @$5$'/3 #2*'&. (& C/+ &2 6$ 6'2*:C& *%5$' / +8$#(@(# +&/&*&$ &C/& :(A$+ &C(+ #2*'& e*'(+5(#&(2%? 0%5 2%$ +*#C VUMX[MW^ +2*'#$ 2@ e*'(+5(#&(2% (+ 3/D+*(&+ 6$&D$$% #(&(1$%+ 2@ 5(@@$'$%& +&/&$+ DC$'$ &C$'$ (+ 42'$ &C/% i_\.YYY (% #2%&'2A$'+7? PC/& (+. &C$ 3/D+*(& (+ 2A$' 42'$ &C/% i_\.YYY? H2D. 72* /'$ / #(&(1$% 2@ P$Z/+. '(:C&f SE? EO-cJBLHM PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM d$+. d2*' c2%2'? VUMX[MX^ 0%5 S'? a*%1? d2* D(+C 4$ &2 /55'$++ 72*' h*$+&(2%f d2* #/% #24$ *8 &2 &C$ 825(*4? 0%5 O D2*35 3(=$ &2 C$/' 72*' 8'$+$%&/&(2% /+ &2 C2D (& (+ &C/& 72* :$& e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%& (% &C(+ #/+$? SE? aNHbM K('+&. d2*' c2%2'. D$T'$ +$$=(%: %24(%/3 VUMX`MYX NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP ` V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ 5/4/:$+. DC(#C O '$/3(1$ 52$+%T& /55 4*#C &2 &C$ +*4? B$#2%537 D2*35 6$ 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+ *%5$' &C$ #/*+$ 2@ /#&(2%+ D$ C/A$ 6'2*:C& DC(#C $Z#$$5+ i_\.YYY /32%$? PcJ -LNEPM c2D (+ &C/&f 0%5 42+& ]] O C/A$ 322=$5 /& &C/&. /%5 O -$'&/(%37 VUMX`MWU 52%T& @(%5 /%7&C(%: &C/& /%+D$'+ &C/& h*$+&(2%? 52$+%T& /%+D$' (& (% 72*' @/A2'? B2 D/3= 4$ &C'2*:C &C/& (% 42'$ 5$&/(3 /+ &2 C2D &C$ 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+ 2@ &C$+$ #/*+$+ 2@ /#&(2% #/% :$& &2 &C$ i_\.YYY 6$#/*+$ (& +$$4+ &2 4$ (@ (& 52$+. $A$'7 +(%:3$ 3/D+*(& @2' &C$+$ #3/(4+ D(33 4$$& &C$ @$5$'/3 e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%&? Q2 /C$/5? SB? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM S/7 O #2%@$' D(&C S+? B8$&Cf -$'&/(%37? VUMX`MX_ RF(+#*++(2% 2@@ &C$ '$#2'5 6$&D$$% 83/(%&(@@+T #2*%+$3?G SE? aNHbM d2*' c2%2'. 2*' 82+(&(2% (+ &C/& &C$ VUM\YMU[ 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+ (+ :2A$'%$5 67 &C$ /42*%& #3/(4$5 67 &C$ 83/(%&(@@+ (% &C(+ #/+$. %2& 67 /%7 8/'&(#*3/' +&/&*&2'7 /42*%&? 0%5 &C/& D$ D2*35 +$$= 42'$ &C/% i_\.YYY D(&C2*& VUM\YM\\ 8'2A(%: &C$ /#&*/3 5/4/:$+? PcJ -LNEPM <$33. @2' ]] &2 4$$& &C$ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%& @2' /% 2'(:(%/3 e*'(+5(#&(2% #/+$. (& 4*+& 6$ %2& #3$/' &2 / 3$:/3 #$'&/(%&7 &C/& 72* 52%T& :$& &2 &C/& /42*%&? 0%5 OT4 322=(%: @2' /%7 6/+(+ &2 +$$ C2D 72* D2*35 :$& i_\.YYY 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+ DC$% 72* 5(+#3/(4 /%7 /#&*/3 5/4/:$+ DC/&$A$'? VUM\VMV\ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP VY V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ d2* #/% :$& / 5233/' 2' iVYY @2' %24(%/3 5/4/:$+? I*& DC$% &C$ 6/+$3(%$ 2@ 72*' #3/(4 (+ %24(%/3 5/4/:$+ /%5 @'24 &C/& 72* 6*(35 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+. /%5 /:/(%. O '$8$/& 47+$3@. 6*& &C$ *%*+*/3 #('#*4+&/%#$ C$'$ (+ &C/& ]] /%5 O C/A$ %$A$' +$$% / #/+$ 3(=$ &C(+? O 4$/%. O *%5$'+&/%5 DC7 72* 5(5 VUM\VMU` (&. 6*& O C/A$ %$A$' +$$% / #/+$ 3(=$ &C(+. DC$'$ 72* C/A$ 5(+#3/(4$5 /%7 /#&*/3 5/4/:$+? B2 2%#$ D$ 4$%&/337 @/#&2' 2*& /33 /#&*/3 5/4/:$+ /%5 72*' 6/+$3(%$ (+ %24(%/3 5/4/:$+. C2D (+ (& /%7&C(%: 2&C$' &C/% / 3$:/3 #$'&/(%&7 &C/& 72* #/%%2& :$& i_\.YYY 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+ DC$% 72* C/A$ %2 /#&*/3 5/4/:$+f SE? aNHbM <$33. 3$& 4$ /%+D$' &C/& &C$ 6$+& O #/%? I*& D$ C/A$ %2& 5(+#3/(4$5 0%5 O &C(%= &C$'$T+ /% VUM\VM\` 0%5 O 52%T& 4$/% &2 8/'+$ D2'5+? $Z8'$++37. D$T'$ +(4837 %2& +$$=(%:? (482'&/%& 5(@@$'$%#$ &C$'$. 6$#/*+$ (@ D$ %$$5$5 &2 &'7 &2 8'2A$ /#&*/3 5/4/:$+ D$ D2*35 D/%& &C$ 522' 28$% @2' *+ &2 52 &C/&? PcJ -LNEPM O *%5$'+&/%5 @'24 DC/& 9*5:$ P$(362': &235 VUM\WMV` 4$ &C/& &C$ '$/+2% 72* 52%T& D/%& &2 (483(#/&$ /#&*/3 5/4/:$+ (+ &C/& %$(&C$' &C$ 83/(%&(@@+ D/%& &2 C/A$ &C$(' 6*+(%$++ /@@/('+ /%5 8'2@(&+ 28$%$5 *8 &2 5(+#2A$'7. #2''$#&f SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM d$+? O 52%T& +$$ C2D 72* /##2483(+C &C/&? JA$% VUM\WMUW (@ 72* 52%T& +$$= 42%$&/'7 5/4/:$+. (@ 72* /'$ :2(%: &2 6$ /+=(%: @2' :$%$'/3 5/4/:$+ /%5 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+. O 52%T& +$$ C2D 72* #/% 8'$A$%& &C$ 5$@$%5/%& @'24 (%h*('(%: (%&2 &C2+$ VUM\WMX[ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP VV V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ +*6e$#&+ 6$#/*+$ +*'$37 &C2+$ +*6e$#&+. $A$% (@ 72* 52%T& D/%& 72*' #248$%+/&(2% 72* /'$ $%&(&3$5 &2 /'$ :2(%: &2 6$ '$3$A/%& &2 DC/& 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+ D2*35 6$? I$#/*+$ (@ 72* +&/%5 *8 /%5 /+= @2' i_\.YYY 2' _\ 4(33(2%. (&T+ 2=/7 @2' &C$ 5$@$%5/%& &2 #24$ 6/#= /%5 +$$ DC/& 72*' 3(=$37 5/4/:$+ /'$. DC/& 72*' 8'2@(&+ /'$ @'24 &C(+ /#&(A(&7? O& +$$4+ &2 4$ &C/& 72* /'$ VUM\UMY` %2& :2(%: &2 +C*& 2@@ &C$ 5(+#2A$'7 &C/& 72* 52%T& D/%& &2 C/A$ :2%$ (%&2 67 C/A(%: (& 62&C D/7+. +/7(%: O 52%T& D/%& &2 6$ 8/(5 @2' 47 /#&*/3 5/4/:$+ 6*& O D/%& &C$ 6$%$@(& 2@ (& /%7D/7 @2' 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+? O e*+& 52%T& +$$ C2D 72* /'$ :2(%: &2 VUM\UMW^ +&28 &C$ 5(+#2A$'7 &C/& 72* 52%T& D/%& &2 :2 @2'D/'5? SE? aNHbM </=$? P'*37 O 52? O *%5$'+&/%5 DC/& 72* /'$ +/7(%:. 9*5:$ ,$& 4$ &$33 72* C2D D$ D2*35 3(=$ &2 52 (&. DC(#C O &C(%= (+ 3$:(&(4/&$? PC$ /42*%& 2@ i_\.YYY. @('+& 2@ /33. (+ %2& i_\ 4(33(2%? 0%5 (@ D$ #3/(4 &C/& &C$'$ +C2*35 6$ i_\ 4(33(2% 2@ VUM\UMU` 8'$+*4$5 5/4/:$+ O +*882+$ &C/& D$ D2*35 C/A$ &2 6'(%: 2*' $h*(&7 8/'&%$'+ 2' @('4 /##2*%&/%& &2 &C$ +&/%5 /%5 &$33 72* &C/& D$ C/A$ 4/%7 #3($%&+ DC2 8/7 *+ 42'$ &C/% &C/&? c2D$A$'. VUM\UM\[ &C$ @(:*'$ i_\.YYY (+ D$33 D(&C(% &C$ '$/#C 2@ &C$ /42*%& / &78(#/3 #3($%& D2*35 8/7 *+ @2' / &78(#/3 +(%:3$ 8($#$ 2@ 3(&(:/&(2%? H2D. O 6$3($A$ &C$'$ (+ %2 '$/3 5(+8*&$ &C/& S'? E(#C$+2%T+ 8'(4$ 26e$#&(A$ (% +8'$/5(%: 3($+ /62*& 9/6*': ; <(3= D/+ &2 4/=$ +*'$. O &C(%= 2%$ 2@ &C$ h*2&$+ (+. D$ D2*35 VUM\XMV_ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP VW V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ C/A$ &2 +&/%5 2% / +&'$$& #2'%$' 2@@$'(%: &2 +*$ @2' @225? (@ S'? E(#C$+2% D/+ +*##$++@*3 (% 5$&$''(%: $A$% / +(%:3$ 0%5 &78(#/3 3(&(:/&(2% #3($%&. &C$ 5/4/:$+ D2*35 A$'7 3(=$37 $Z#$$5 i_\.YYY? H2D. O 52%T& &C(%= (& &/=$+ +8$#(@(# 5(+#2A$'7 (%&2 2*' 8'(A(3$:$5 @(3$+ ]] PcJ -LNEPM <$33. /#&*/337. 72* =%2D. (@ &C(+ #/+$ VUM\XMU\ D$'$ &2 :2 &2 &'(/3 72* C/A$ &2 8'2A$ &C/& *8 /+ / e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 4/&&$'? PC$'$T+ / H(%&C -('#*(& #/+$ D$T'$ /33 VUM\XM\U @/4(3(/' D(&C DC$'$ / e*5:$ 2@ &C(+ #2*'& :2& '$A$'+$5 (% / 5(A$'+(&7 #/+$ 6$#/*+$ /& &'(/3. C$ 5(5%T& '$h*('$ /%7 8'22@ 2@ &C$ /42*%&? /88$/3? B2 72* /'$ :2(%: &2 C/A$ &2 #24$ (% /%5 8'2A$ DC/& 72* e*+& &235 4$ /& &'(/3 2' 6$@2'$ 72* #/% :$& /%7 e*5:4$%& (% &C$ #/+$? O&T+ %2& 8'$+*4$5? Q2 /C$/5? SE? aNHbM O /8232:(1$? O 5(5%T& 4$/% &2 (%&$''*8&? 0%5 &C$ -2*'& +/(5 %2 #/+$ /%5 &C'$D (& 2*& 2% VUM\\MY[ O@ DC/& 72* /'$ &$33(%: 4$ (+ &C/& O C/A$ &2 52 $Z/#&37 DC/& O 8'24(+$5 72* &2 52. O #/% #$'&/(%37 52 &C/&? DC/& 72* /'$ &$33(%: 4$ (+ &C/& O C/A$ &2 C/*3 &C$ @('4T+ #3($%&+ (%&2 &C$ D(&%$++ 62Z ]] PcJ -LNEPM C2D &2 &'7 &C$ #/+$? ,$& 4$ (%&$''*8& 72*? OT4 %2& &$33(%: 72* O@ VUM\\MWU OT4 e*+& +/7(%: &C/& 72* #/%T& :2 &2 VUM\\MU[ &'(/3 /%5 :$& / e*5:4$%& (% 72*' @/A2' D(&C2*& 8'2A(%: NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP VU V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%&? d2* #/%%2& (:%2'$ (&? OT4 %2& &$33(%: B2 72* 72* C2D 72* C/A$ &2 8'2A$ (&. 6*& 72* #/%T& (:%2'$ (&? #/% @(:*'$ 2*& C2D &2 8'2A$ (&. 6*& (@ 72* 52%T& C/A$ /%7 $A(5$%#$ 2@ (&. 5(+4(++/3 @2' 3/#= 2@ e*'(+5(#&(2% (+ &C$ 2%37 8$'4(++(63$ 2*&#24$? OT4 %2& &'7(%: &2 h*/''$3 D(&C 72*? OT4 &'7(%: &2 VUM\\M\^ *%5$'+&/%5 &C(+. 6$#/*+$ O #/% *%5$'+&/%5 DC7 72* /%5 "#$%&'(#. @2' / A/'($&7 2@ '$/+2%+. D2*35 3(=$ 72*' 6*+(%$++ /@@/('+ %2& &2 6$ (%h*('$5 (%&2? O *%5$'+&/%5 &C/& 8$'@$#&37? VUM\^MV[ I*& ]] /%5 72* #/% #$'&/(%37 :2 &2 &C$ +*8$'(2' #2*'&. 6*& 72* C/A$ /% $Z&'/ 6*'5$% &2 #24$ C$'$? SE? aNHbM c2%2'? O *%5$'+&/%5 DC/& 72* /'$ +/7(%:. d2*' 0%5 O #/% '$8'$+$%& &C/& D$ D(33 A$'7 #/'$@*337 83/% 2*' +&'/&$:($+ &2 8'2A$ &C$ $3$4$%&+ D$ %$$5 &2 *%5$'+&/%5(%: &C/& D$ 4/7 6$ +*6e$#& &2 %2& 2%37 / 42&(2% (% 3(4(%$ 6*& / 42&(2% &2 5(+4(++? O@ O 4/7. d2*' c2%2'? PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM Q2 /C$/5? O 5(5%T& ]] OT4 3(+&$%(%:? VUM\^MU_ O% &C(+ 8/'&(#*3/' (%+&/%#$. 8*%(&(A$ VUM\^M\_ 5/4/:$+ /'$ /3+2 (482'&/%&. /%5 &C$ 42+& (482'&/%& #2482%$%& 2@ &C$ 5/4/:$+? 0%5 &C$ #2%5*#& #$'&/(%37 D/''/%&+ &C$4. /%5 &C$ /42*%& '$h*('$5 &2 5$&$' %2& 2%37 S'? E(#C$+2%. DC2 (+ $++$%&(/337 e*5:4$%& 8'22@. 6*& 2&C$'+ DC2 D2*35 $%:/:$ (% &C$ +/4$ #2%5*#& (+ #$'&/(%37 (% $Z#$++ 2@ i_\.YYY? PcJ -LNEPM 0:/(%. *%5$' &C$ N?B? B*8'$4$ -2*'& #/+$+ VUM\_MV[ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP VX V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ +$&&(%: A$'7 '2*:C 5*$ 8'2#$++ 3(4(&/&(2%+ 2% 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+. 72* #/%%2& 82++(637 :$& @'24 %24(%/3 5/4/:$+ &2 i_\.YYY (% 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+? SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM &C/&? O *%5$' ]] Q2 /C$/5? O *%5$'+&/%5 72* /'$ 6$(%: +=$8&(#/3 /62*& VUM\_MU^ I*& O 6$3($A$ D$ C/A$ /*&C2'(&7 &2 (%5(#/&$ &C/& (% /88'28'(/&$ #/+$+. %24(%/3 5/4/:$+ 2' 2&C$' $3$4$%&+ /'$ 8'2A$5 &C/& 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+ /+ / 5$&$''$%& /'$ /88'28'(/&$? PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM Q2 /C$/5? OT4 @(%(+C$5? PC/%= 72*? VUM\_M\V H2D. 72*' -2*%& V. (%&$'@$'$%#$ D(&C #2%&'/#&. &C/&T+ @2' 62&C 83/(%&(@@+f SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM -2''$#&? 0%5 O &/=$ (& &C$'$ (+ :2(%: &2 6$ %2 VUM\[MYW (%&$'@$'$%#$ D(&C &C$ #2%&'/#&*/3 /&&2'%$7j#3($%& '$3/&(2%+C(8 6$&D$$% "#$%&'(# /%5 &C$ 3/D @('4. (+ &C$'$f SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM 6$$% &C'(A(%:? L% &C$ #2%&'/'7? PC$'$ C/+ 6$$%? O D2*35 &C(%= &C/& &C$ '$3/&(2%+C(8 C/+ VUM\[MV^ 0'$ 72* &$33(%: *+ &C/& 72* /'$ (% ]] &C/& 72*' #3($%& 2' 72*' 3/D @('4 (+ #2%+(5$'(%: 5(4(%(+C(%: &C/& '$3/&(2%+C(8 6$#/*+$ 2@ S'? E(#C$+2%T+ /#&(2%+f SE? aNHbM ,$& 4$ :(A$ 72* 2%$ $Z/483$ &C/& OT4 #24@2'&/63$ :(A(%: 72*. DC(#C (+ /88/'$%& @'24 *%#2%&$+&$5 @/#&+ (% &C(+ #/+$? VUM\[MU^ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP V\ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ S'? E(#C$+2%T+ $Z&2'&(2% @2'#$5 "#$%&'(# )$%&*'$+ &2 52 +24$&C(%: &C/& (& 52$+%T& 52. &C/&T+ /:/(%+& (&+ 823(#7 &2 4/=$ '$5/#&(2%+ *%5$' &C'$/&? PcJ -LNEPM OT4 /+=(%: /62*& &C$ /&&2'%$7j#3($%& VUM\[M\W '$3/&(2%+C(8. 9/6*': ; <(3=T+ #2%&'/#& D(&C "#$%&'(# /%5 6/#= /%5 @2'&C? PC/&T+ DC/& OT4 /+=(%: /62*&? OT4 /+=(%: DC$&C$' 72* /'$ /33$:(%: &C/& &C/& '$3/&(2%+C(8 (+ (% &C'$/& 2@ 6$(%: C/'4$5 @'24 &C$ 8$'+8$#&(A$ 2@ $(&C$' &C$ /&&2'%$7 2' &C$ #3($%&? 0%5 72*' #244$%& /62*& '$5/#&(2% +&'(=$+ 4$ /+ %2& VUM\`MVW '$+82%5(%: &2 &C/&? SE? aNHbM O %$$5 &2 @(%5 / D/7 &2 $Z8'$++ &C(+ +2 72* OT4 %2& #3/(4(%: &C/& &C$ *%5$'+&/%5 &C/& (& (+ '$+82%+(A$? '$3/&(2%+C(8 (+ 5$+&'27$5? I*& O /4 #3/(4(%: &C/& &C$ PC$ VUM\`MW` '$3/&(2%+C(8 (+ 5/4/:$5 /%5 C/+ 6$$% (%&$'@$'$5 D(&C? $Z&2'&(2%/&$ &C'$/&+ &2 5$+&'27 &C$ '$8*&/&(2% 2@ 9/6*': ; <(3= @2'#$5 "#$%&'(# )$%&*'$+ &2 4/=$ #2%#$++(2%+? PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM B2 DC/&? O&T+ /% (%&$'@$'$%#$ 2@ &C$ #2%&'/#&*/3 '$3/&(2%+C(8 6$&D$$% /&&2'%$7 /%5 #3($%&+? PcJ -LNEPM O #2483$&$37 52 %2& +$$ &C/& &C$ @('4 PC$'$ (+ / #2483$&$ :/8 O e*+& VUM\`MX\ '$%5$'+ 3$:/3 +$'A(#$+ /%5 :$&+ 8/(5? 6$&D$$% DC/& 72* /'$ +/7(%: /%5 &C$ @('4T+ (%&$'$+&+? 52%T& *%5$'+&/%5 &C/&? /%5 /'$ 8/(5? &C$ #2%%$#&(2%? PC$ @('4 '$%5$'+ +$'A(#$+. +$%5+ / 6(33 O 52%T& +$$ VXMYYMY_ B2 DC/& (@ &C$7 '$5/#&$5 +24$&C(%:f NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP V^ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ &2 72*? SE? aNHbM 9*5:$ </=$. OT4 C/887 &2 &'7 /%5 $Z83/(% (& I*& O #$'&/(%37 D/%& &2 /A2(5 5$6/&(%: D(&C 72*? <2*35 72* 3(=$ 4$ &2 &'7 /%5 $3/62'/&$f PcJ -LNEPM H2? >3$/+$? I$#/*+$ O 52 %2& +$$ /%7 VXMYYMV[ #2%%$#&(2% &C$'$ /& /33 &C/& D2*35 #2%+&(&*&$ (%&$'@$'$%#$ D(&C &C$ 3/D @('4T+ #2%&'/#& D(&C "#$%&'(# 2' (%&$'@$'$%#$ D(&C "#$%&'(#T+ #2%&'/#& D(&C &C$ 3/D @('4 &C/& 4(:C& 6$ +24$ 2&C$' 6*+(%$++ (%e*'7 &2 "#$%&'(#? &C$ /&&2'%$7j#3($%& #2%&'/#&f SE? aNHbM >*&&(%: /+(5$ 2&C$' D/7+ &C/& &C$'$ D/+ I*& C2D 52$+ (& (%&$'@$'$ D(&C VXMYYMU[ (%&$'@$'$%#$ 6$&D$$% "#$%&'(#T+ 2&C$' #3($%&+ A$'+*+ &C$ '$3/&(2%+C(8 6$&D$$% "#$%&'(# /%5 9/6*': ; <(3=. 8*&&(%: &C/& /+(5$. &C$ '$3/&(2%+C(8 6$&D$$% /&&2'%$7 /%5 #3($%& (+ @/' 42'$ &C/% &C$ 4$'#$%/'7 '$3/&(2%+C(8 @2' +(4837 :$&&(%: 8/(5 &2 52 +24$ +$'A(#$ D2'=? PcJ -LNEPM $#2%24(# A/3*$? SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM d$+? B2 D/3= 4$ &C'2*:C C2D 72* :$& &C$'$? PC$ ]] d2*' c2%2'. /'$ 72* &$33(%: 4$ &C/& VXMYVMY` VXMYVMYV I*& &C(+ &2'& #248$%+/&$+ @2' 32++ 2@ *%3$++ D$ #/% +C2D / '$5*#&(2% (% &C$ $#2%24(# A/3*$ 2@ &C$ #2%&'/#& &C/& D$ #/%T& #3/(4 /% (%&$'@$'$%#$f /'$ &$33(%: 4$ ]] PcJ -LNEPM <C/& $3+$ /'$ 72* #3/(4(%:f <C/& VXMYVMW` I$#/*+$ (@ 72* %2%]$#2%24(# (%&$'@$'$%#$ /'$ 72* #3/(4(%:f B$$4+ &2 6$ /% NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP V_ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ 2Z742'2% @2' &C(+ &2'&? SE? aNHb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cJ -LNEPM PC$% 72* %$$5 &2 D(&C5'/D. 2' S+? B8$&C I*& 72* C/A$ %2& %$$5+ &2 D(&C5'/D /%5 72* C/A$ / #3/(4? D(&C5'/D%. C/A$ 72*f SE? aNHbM <$ C/A$ %2& D(&C5'/D%? VXMYWMVU 0%5 @2' &C$ '$#2'5. /%5 42+& '$+8$#&@*337. O 52%T& &C(%= &C$ C/'4 C/+ &2 '(+$ &2 &C$ 3$A$3 2@ &C$ 3/D @('4 D(&C5'/D(%:. (% 2&C$' D2'5+. &C$ '$3/&(2%+C(8 6$(%: 5$+&'27$5 2' (%28$'/63$ (% 2'5$' @2' (& &2 6$ 5/4/:$5? PcJ -LNEPM O 52 6$3($A$ (& C/+ &2 6$ /% $#2%24(#/337 VXMYWMUV 4$/+*'/63$ (%e*'7. /%5 O C/A$%T& C$/'5 /%7&C(%: @'24 72* 7$& &C/& :$&+ (%&2 &C/& '$/34 2% &C(+ -2*%& V? H2D. &C$'$ 4/7 6$ '$3/&(2%+C(8+ D(&C 2&C$' #3($%&+? SE? aNHbM 0%5 O #$'&/(%37 /:'$$. /%5 O &C(%= (& VXMYWM\V /342+& :2$+ D(&C2*& +/7(%: C2D '$3/&(2%+C(8+ D(&C 2&C$' #3($%&+ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP V[ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ /'$ 5/4/:$5? I*& OT4 %2& +*'$ (@ 72* /'$ /+=(%: ]] <$33. OT4 /+=(%: 72*. 322=(%: /& &C(+ PcJ -LNEPM /+8$#& 2@ &C$ '$3/&(2%+ D(&C 2&C$' #3($%&+ 2' 2&C$' #*+&24$'+. C2D ]] e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%& /3D/7+ C/+ &2 6$ h*/%&(@($5? PC$'$T+ %2&C(%: 322+$7]:22+$7 /62*& (&? O@ 72* #/%T& :$& VXMYUMV` &C'2*:C 2%$ 2@ &C$ /##$8&$5 4$/+*'$+ 2@ &C$ h*/%&(@(#/&(2% &2 i_\.YYY 72* /'$ 2*& 2@ #2*'&? d2* C/A$ &2 :2 &2 +&/&$ #2*'&? B2 OT4 /+=(%: C2D 72* 4$/+*'$ &C$ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%& /+8$#& 2@ &C(+ @2' '$3/&(2%+C(8+ D(&C 2&C$' #3($%&+? SE? aNHbM c2D 52 D$ 4$/+*'$ (&f -/%5(537 D$ C/A$%T& VXMYUMX^ 4/'+C/3$5 &C$ 8'22@ 7$&? PcJ -LNEPM J%&('$37 +8$#*3/&(A$? O @$/' &C/& (& (+ $%&('$37 +8$#*3/&(A$? I$#/*+$ @('+& 2@ /33. 72*' @('4 F2 &C$7 VXMYXMVV '$8'$+$%&+ h*/3(&7 6*+(%$++ #3($%&+ /%5 2&C$' 8$283$? '$/5 S'? E(#C$+2%T+ D$6 8/:$+. /%5 52 &C$7 8/7 /%7 /&&$%&(2%f 0%5 52%T& 72* C/A$ &2 8'2A$ / 8'26/6(3(&7 &C/& 8$283$ DC2 /'$ 72*' #3($%&+ 2' /'$ 3(=$37 &2 6$ 72*' #3($%&+ +$$ &C/& /%5 6$ 5$&$''$5 67 (& DC(#C +$$4+ ]] O +*882+$ /%7&C(%: #2*35 C/88$% (% &C$ D2'35. 6*& &C$'$ C/+ &2 6$ / '$/3(+&(# 8'2+8$#& 2@ (& C/88$%(%:? <C/& (+ &C/& '$/3(+&(# 8'2+8$#& 2@ &C/&f <$33. 3$& 4$ :(A$ 72* 2%$ $Z/483$? ,$&T+ VXMYXMXY SE? aNHbM +/7 / 82&$%&(/3 #3($%&. 2%$ DC2 (+ +$$=(%:. +/7. $+&/&$ 83/%%(%: +$'A(#$+ @'24 &C$ 6'/%#C 2@ 2*' @('4 &C/& 52$+ &C/&. 5$#(5$+ &2 52 / Q22:3$ +$/'#C 2% &C$ %/4$ 2@ 2*' @('4 /%5 &C/& 8'24(%$%&37 @$/&*'$5 (% &C$ +$/'#C $%:(%$ '$+*3&+. DC$&C$' (&T+ VXMY\MYY NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP V` V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ Q22:3$ 2' d/C22 2' I(%: 2' /%7 2@ &C$ 2&C$' +$/'#C $%:(%$+ (+ / 8'24(%$%& 82+&(%: +/7(%:. g9/6*': ; <(3= C('$+ #C(35 423$+&$'+ &2 6$ 8/'&%$'+ /%5 #2A$'+ (& *8?g PC/& (+ $%2*:C (% &C(+ 3$:/3 4/'=$& &2 5$&$' / 82&$%&(/3 #3($%& @2' &C$4 +(4837 &2 42A$ 2% /%5 #2%+(5$' / 5(@@$'$%& @('4 &C/& #/% 2@@$' &C$ +/4$ +$'A(#$+? PcJ -LNEPM S7 #2%#$'% D(&C &C/& (+ &C/& $A$'7 +&$8 2@ VXMY\MWX (& (+ +C$$' +8$#*3/&(2%? SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM <$33 ]] <$33. 26A(2*+37 OT4 C/A(%: &C(+ 5(/32:*$ VXMY\MXU D(&C 72* 6$#/*+$ O /4 #2%#$'%$5 /62*& &C$ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%& C$'$? 0%5 D$T33 :(A$ 72* /483$ 2882'&*%(&7 &2 /55'$++ $A$'7&C(%: &C/& 4/7 4/&&$'? ,$& 4$ /+= /62*& -2*%& W? '/#=$&$$'(%: #2*%& ]] SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM #2*%&f SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM /++$'&(%: &C$ #2*%&? PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM <C/&T+ 6$(%: +&23$% @'24 $/#C 2@ &C$4f "#$%&'(# (+ @2'#$5 67 &C$ $Z&2'&(2% &2 B2 &C$'$T+ /% VXMY^MUU PC(+ (+ &C$ 0'(12%/ d$+? ]] @2' &C$@&? <C2 (+ /++$'&(%: &C(+ VXMY\M\_ 9/6*': ; <(3=? 0%5 %2& "#$%&'(#f O 6$3($A$ "#$%&'(# )$%&*'$+ (+ /3+2 VXMY^MY` /3&$' &C$ 82+&(%:+ 2% '(8]2@@ '$82'& D$6 8/:$? /#&(A$ $Z&2'&(2% &C/& @2'#$+ "#$%&'(# )$%&*'$+ &2 :(A$ *8. (@ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP WY V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ 72* D(33. (&+ A/3*/63$ 8'28$'&7 (% &C$ 82+&(%:+ 2% &C$ (%&$'%$&? PcJ -LNEPM I*& &C$ +&/&*&$ '$h*('$+ &C$@& 67 $Z&2'&(2% &2 26&/(% 8'28$'&7 2' +$'A(#$ 67 4$/%+ 2@ / &C'$/&? <C/& 8'28$'&7 2' +$'A(#$ (+ $/#C 83/(%&(@@ ]] SE? aNHbM <$33. &C$ 8'28$'&7 &C/& "#$%&'(# (+ :(A(%: VXMY^M\X *8 (+ &C$ '(:C& &2 4/(%&/(% (&+ 82+&(%:+? PcJ -LNEPM I*& (&T+ %2& (&+ 82+&(%:+? PC$ '$/+2% (& #3/(4+ &2 $+#/8$ 5$@/4/&(2% 3(/6(3(&7 (+ &C/& &C$7 /'$ %2& &C$ 82+&(%:+ 2@ "#$%&'(#? B2 OT4 #C/33$%:$5 /+ &2 C2D /% (44*%(&7 VXMY_MVV @'24 5$@/4/&(2% &C/& $Z(+&+ +23$37 67 A('&*$ 2@ &C$ 5(+#3/(4$' 2@ &C2+$ 5$@/4/&2'7 82+&(%:+. /33$:$537 5$@/4/&2'7 82+&(%:+. #/% 6$#24$ &C$ 8'28$'&7 2@ "#$%&'(# &2 +*882'& DC7 ]] &C(+ (+ / #'(4(%/3 +&/&*&$ /+ D$33? / #'(4(%/3 +&/&*&$? O&T+ %2& e*+& / #(A(3 '$4$57? O&T+ VXMY_MU\ B2 &C(+ (+ / 6(& 2@ / #C/33$%:$. &22. /+ &2 DC/& 8'28$'&7 "#$%&'(# C/+ (% &C$+$ 82+&(%:+ +*882+$537 4/5$ 67 &C('5 8$'+2%+ D(&C %2 (%A23A$4$%& D(&C "#$%&'(#? SE? aNHb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` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ '(:C& /D/7 @'24 "#$%&'(#? PcJ -LNEPM <$33. D$T'$ e*+& C/A(%: / C(:C37 8'$3(4(%/'7 5(+#*++(2% C$'$. /%5 O 52%T& D/%& 72* &2 &/=$ /%7&C(%: OT4 +/7(%:. /%7 h*$+&(2%+ OT4 /+=(%: /+ '$@3$#&(%: /%7 @(%/3 '$+23*&(2% 2@ /%7&C(%:? I*& O /4 C(:C37 +=$8&(#/3 2@ &C/& /+ D$33? 0%5 DC/& /62*& 9/6*': ; <(3=f c2D /'$ &C$7 6$(%: ]] VXMY[MXV DC/& (+ &C$(' #/*+$ 2@ /#&(2% *%5$' &C$ 0'(12%/ '/#=$&$$'(%: +&/&*&$ @2' &C$ &C$@&f SE? aNHbM PC$7 /'$ &C$ A(#&(4 2@ &C$ $Z&2'&(2%? 0%5 VXMY`MYV &C$ 8'28$'&7 &C$7 32+$ (+ &C$ (%&$'$+& (% &C$(' /&&2'%$7j#3($%& '$3/&(2%+C(8 62&C D(&C "#$%&'(# /%5 2&C$' #3($%&+? PcJ -LNEPM d2* =%2D. / 32%: &(4$ /:2. O &'($5 / +(Z]D$$= e*'7 &'(/3 2% &C$ 0'(12%/ '/#=$&$$'(%: +&/&*&$. /%5 &C/& D/+ 3(=$ W\ 7$/'+ /:2. 6/#= &C$% O &C2*:C& O D/+ &C$ D2'35T+ 3$/5(%: /*&C2'(&7 2% &C/& +&/&*&$? &C(%= &C/& %2D? I*& /42%: &C$ :$%$'/3 &C(%:+ O '$#/33. &C$+$ /'$ #'(4(%/3 +&/&*&$+. /%5 &C$'$ 4/7 6$ +$'(2*+ h*$+&(2% C$'$ /+ &2 DC$&C$' 72* C/A$ $A$% +&/&$5 / #3/(4 @2' '/#=$&$$'(%:? H2D. 72* C/A$ 26A(2*+37 +&/&$5 / #3/(4 @2' 5$@/4/&(2%? d2* 4/7 D$33 C/A$ +&/&$5 / #3/(4 ]] D$33. O +*+8$#& 72* #3/(4 72* C/A$ +&/&$5 / #3/(4 @2' &2'&(2*+ (%&$'@$'$%#$ D(&C #2%&'/#&? (&? S7 #2%#$'% (+ &C$ 5233/' /42*%&+ 2@ &C$ A/3*$+ 2@ VXMVYMY^ VXMY`MXU VXMY`MWY 0%5 O 52%T& $A$% NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP WW V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ 0%5 DC$% D$ :$& &2 -2*%& U. &C$ +&/&*&2'7 C/'/++4$%& #3/(4. &C(+ (+ / +&/&$ +&/&*&$ &C/& C/+ A('&*/337 %2 /88$33/&$ #/+$ 3/D? 0%5 (&T+ /#&*/337 / '$3/&(A$37 %$D +&/&*&$? 0%5 (&T+ +24$DC/& +D$$8(%: (% (&+ 3/%:*/:$? @2' 8$/#$=$$8(%: (% &'2*63$5 +(&*/&(2%+? O&T+ 4$/%& :$%$'/337 I*& /:/(%. *%5$' &C$ VXMVYMXV 0'(12%/ C/'/++4$%& +&/&*&$. &C$ 3(%#C8(% &C$'$ (+ 6/+(#/337 #2%5*#& /#&(A(&7 &C/& 5(+&*'6+ 2&C$' 8$283$? :$& &2 i_\.YYY 2% &C/& +&/&*&$f SE? aNHbM O 52%T& =%2D &C/& D$ #/% :$& &2 i_\.YYY VXMVVMV_ 0:/(%. C2D 52 72* 6/+$5 2% &C$ C/'/++4$%&? PcJ -LNEPM JA$'7 3(&&3$ 6(& C$38+? B2 &C$% &C$ 5$@/4/&(2%. O 4$/%. &C(+ (+. /:/(%. D(&C2*& $Z8'$++(%: /%7 @(%/3 e*5:4$%& 2' 28(%(2%. /& 3$/+& e*+& 2% &C$ @/#$ 2@ (&. /88$/'+ &2 6$ $:'$:(2*+ 5$@/4/&(2%? SE? aNHbM PcJ -LNEPM SE? aNHbM d2*' c2%2'. 4/7 O h*/3(@7 47 3/+& /%+D$'f d$/C? I$#/*+$ O D/%& (& &2 6$ #3$/'? 0#&*/3 VXMVVMXX 5/4/:$+ @2' C/'/++4$%& 4/7 6$ 5(@@(#*3& &2 8'2A$ (% &C$ /42*%& 2@ _\.YYY? 0%5 O *%5$'+&/%5 72*' #2%#$'%+ /62*& &C$ I*& /:/(%. D$ VXMVVM\` #2%+&(&*&(2%/3 62*%5/'($+ 2@ 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+? '$37 2% &C$ 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+ $3$4$%&? PcJ -LNEPM <$33. /%5 /:/(%. :2(%: 6/#= &2 &C$ +&/&*&2'7 C/'/++4$%&. &C/&T+ ]] &C$ +23$ '$4$57 *%5$' &C/& +&/&*&$ (+ &C$ (%e*%#&(2%? L@ #2*'+$ @2' (%e*%#&(2% #/+$+ VXMVWMVX &C$'$T+ A/'(2*+ &$+&+ /+ &2 C2D 72* 4$/+*'$ &C$ /42*%& (% NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP WU V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ #2%&'2A$'+7? <$33. O C/A$ 52%$ ]] O C/A$ 6$$% /+=(%: / 32& 2@ h*$+&(2%+? O+ &C$'$ /%7&C(%: $3+$ 72* D2*35 3(=$ &2 8'$+$%& &2 4$ 2% $(&C$' &C$ 4$'(&+ 2' ]] D$33. 3$& 4$ 6/#= *8 6$@2'$ O 8*& &C/& 28$%]$%5$5 h*$+&(2% &2 72*? O 52 D/%& &2 :$& &2 / 3$A$3 2@ #24@2'& &C/& O 52 %2& 7$& C/A$ /62*& &C$ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%&? A$'7 h*(#=37. 6$#/*+$ &C(+ (+ &(4$ *':$%&? O /3+2 C/A$ +24$ #2%#$'% /62*& &C$ +#28$ 2@ &C$ (%e*%#&(2%? ,$& 4$ :2 6/#= &2 &C$ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%&? <(&C VXMVUMWV VXMVWM\W 0%5 D$ #/% 52 &C(+ 72* 5(+#3/(4(%: /%7 /#&*/3 5/4/:$+. /%5 DC$'$ &C$ 2%37 '$3($@ 72* /'$ +$$=(%: (+. /:/(%. &C$ %24(%/3 5/4/:$+. &C$ :$%$'/3 5/4/:$+. &C$ 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+. /%5 &C$ (%e*%#&(2%. D$ #/% 322= &2 &C$ (%e*%#&(2% /+ / 4$/+*'$ 2@ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%&? 0%5 VXMVUM\Y &C$'$ /'$ 5(@@$'$%& #/+$+ &C/& /'&(#*3/&$ 5(@@$'$%& 4$/+*'$+ 2@ &C/&? I*& ]] +2 O &C(%= O D2*35 6$%$@(& @'24 +24$ 6'($@(%: @'24 72* 2% &D2 /+8$#&+ 2@ &C(+M 2@ 5/4/:$+? L%$ (+ &C$ (%e*%#&(2% 4$/+*'$ B24$ #/+$+ 322= /& (& /+ &C$ $h*(A/3$%& 2@ &C$ VXMVXMWV $#2%24(# 6$%$@(& &2 &C$ 83/(%&(@@ /%5 +24$ 322= /& (& /+ &C$ $h*(A/3$%& 2@ &C$ $#2%24(# 5$&'(4$%& &2 &C$ 5$@$%5/%&? O& D2*35 +$$4 &C/& &C$'$ (+ %2 2&C$' $#2%24(# 5$&'(4$%& &2 &C$ 5$@$%5/%& @'24 &C(+ (%e*%#&(A$ '$3($@ &C/& 72* +$$=. %2%$ 2' 3(&&3$? F2$+%T& C/A$ &2 6$ %2%$? <$ #/% e*+& +/7 3(&&3$? VXMVXMX\ B2 O D(33 6$%$@(& @'24 72* 322=(%: /& &C$ /*&C2'(&($+ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP WX V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ /%5 /8837(%: &C$4 &2 &C(+ #/+$? 0%5 &C$% /3+2. &C$'$ /'$ 83$%&7 2@ #/+$+ 2*& &C$'$ 5$/3(%: D(&C 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+ /%5 e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%&? +24$ 2@ &C$4 47+$3@? >3$%&7 2@ &C$4? 0%5 O C/A$ /*&C2'$5 0%5 (&T+ %2& $%2*:C &2 +(4837 /+= @2' / d2* C/A$ &2 C/A$ 42'$ &C/% VXMV\MVV 3/':$ /42*%& 2@ 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+? &C/&? 0%5 2%$ A($D @2' DC(#C 72* D(33 @(%5 83$%&7 2@ #/+$ /*&C2'(&7 (+ &C/& 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$+ /'$ (%C$'$%&37 +8$#*3/&(A$. /%5 72* C/A$ &2 C/A$ +24$&C(%: +8$#(@(# /%5 #2%#'$&$ &2 :$& &C/& 52D% &2 / '$/3 %*46$'? e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%&? PC/&T+ 2%$ A($D? PC$'$ /'$ / 32& 42'$ 5(+&'(#& #2*'& 0%5 &C$'$T+ +24$ L&C$'D(+$. (&T+ %2& +*@@(#($%& @2' VXMV\MW` 28(%(2%+ 2% &C(+ &C/% #('#*(& #2*'& 28(%(2%+? 5(A$':$%#$ 2% 5(+&'(#& #2*'& 28(%(2%+? 322= /& &C(+ :$%$'/3 5/4/:$? 0%5 &C$% $+8$#(/337 0%5 DC$% 72* 322= /& (&. &C(%= VXMV\M\W /62*& DC/& (+ 2% 47 4(%5. DC(#C (+ O @$/' &C/& 72*' &C$2'7 2@ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%&. (@ (&T+ A/3(5. D(33 /8837 (% $A$'7 #/+$? 0%5 $A$'7 &(4$ /%76257 +*$+ @2' 5$@/4/&(2% @2' DC(#C 72* #/% :$& :$%$'/3 5/4/:$+. /33 72* C/A$ &2 52 (+ +/7 /%5 O D/%& i_\.YYY. (% $A$'7 +(%:3$ #/+$. (@ &C$'$T+ 5(A$'+(&7 (% #(&(1$%+C(8. D(33 6$ 4$&? O &C(%= &C/&T+ &C$ 32:(#/3 #2%+$h*$%#$ 2@ 72*' &C$2'7. /%5 (& +$$4+ (%&*(&(A$37 D'2%: &2 4$ 6$#/*+$ D$ 52%T& 52 8*%(&(A$ 5/4/:$? <$ 52%T& (%5*3:$ (% / +(4(3/' 5$@$'$%#$? VXMV^MV` PC$'$ C/+ &2 6$ +24$&C(%: 42'$ &C/% +8$#*3/&(A$%$++? B2 &C2+$ /'$ ]] 72* #/% 6'($@ ]] /%5 D$T33 &/3= /62*& VXMV^MXW NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP W\ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ / &(4$ &2 :$& &C(+ 52%$ &C/& O. (% 8/'&(#*3/'. D2*35 3(=$ &2 C/A$ /55'$++$5? PC$ 2&C$' &C(%: (+ &C$ (%e*%#&(2% (&+$3@? ,22=(%: /& &C$ &$482'/'7 '$+&'/(%(%: 2'5$'. %2D O *%5$'+&/%5 DC$% 72* /33 @(3$5 &C(+ /#&(2% 72* D$'$ /#&(%: *%5$' ]] D(&C :'$/& C/+&$ /%5 :'$/& $4$':$%#7 &C/& D/+ $%&('$37 ]] /88$/'+ &2 6$ $%&('$37 e*+&(@($5? H$A$'&C$3$++. &C(+ 3/%:*/:$ (+ /D@*337 6'2/5 (% &C$ VXMV_MW^ '$+&'/(%(%: 2'5$'. +$%5(%: 2' #/*+(%: 72* &2 +$%5 /%7 &C'$/&$%(%: #244*%(#/&(2%+k 8*63(+C(%: 2' #/*+(%: &2 8*63(+C$5 /%7 @/3+$ 2' 4(+3$/5(%: #244*%(#/&(2%+ /62*& 83/(%&(@@+k (%&$'@$'(%: D(&C #2%&'/#&*/3 '$3/&(2%+C(8? O@ 72* 5(: (%&2 &C$ #/+$ 3/D 2% (%e*%#&(2%+. O &C(%= 72* D(33 @(%5 &C/& 4*#C. 4/76$ /33 2@ &C/&. D2*35 %2& 6$ $%@2'#$/63$ D(&C #2%&$48& +/%#&(2%+? P2 C/A$ /% $%@2'#$/63$ VXMV[MY[ VXMV_M\W (%e*%#&(2%. &C$ 3/%:*/:$ 2@ &C$ (%e*%#&(2% C/+ &2 6$ #3$/'. +8$#(@(#. #2%#'$&$. /%5 (%e*%#&(2% 3/%:*/:$ &C/& 6/+(#/337 +/7+ :2 /%5 +(% %2 42'$ (+ %2& :225 $%2*:C &2 C/A$ +24$6257 8*& (% e/(3 @2' #2%&$48& 2' C/A$ 2&C$' #2%&$48& '$4$5($+? B2 ]] /%5 O /4 /3D/7+ '$3*#&/%& &2 $%&$' (%e*%#&(2%+ D(&C &C/& 3$A$3 2@ :$%$'/3(&($+? B2 OT4 :2(%: &2 (%A(&$ 72* VXMV[MUX &2. /++*4(%: D$ :$& 2A$' &C(+ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 /42*%& 8'263$4. &2 +*64(& / '$A(+$5 @2'4 2@ 8'$3(4(%/'7 (%e*%#&(2%? H2D. :'/%&$5. S'? E(#C$+2% C/+ /:'$$5 &2 &C(+. /%5 +2 O 52%T& +$$ &C/& OT4 /+=(%: @2' /%7 5(@@(#*3& '$A(+(2%? I*& VXMV`MYV OT4 /+=(%: 72* &2 &C(%= #2%#'$&$ /%5 $48('(#/337 /62*& &C$ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP W^ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ /#&(2%+ &C/& 72* D/%& '$+&'/(%$5? I$#/*+$ (@ &C$7 /'$ #2%&(%*$5 /%5 D$ C/A$ 8'2#$$5(%:+ &2 $%@2'#$. O 52%T& D/%& &2 6$ (% / 82+(&(2% DC$'$ O /4 &$33(%: 72* 3/&$' DC/& OT4 &$33(%: 72* %2D. DC(#C (+ O 52%T& &C(%= &C(+ (+ #3$/' $%2*:C &2 +*882'& #2%&$48& '$4$5($+? B2 72* #/% :2 &C'2*:C &C$ +8$#(@(# &C(%:+ &C/& C$T+ 52%$? B24$&(4$+ (&T+ 5(@@(#*3&. 6$#/*+$ DC$% 72* :$& +8$#(@(# VXMV`MWU &C$'$ 4/7 6$ D/7+ &2 D$/+$3 /'2*%5 (& /%5 72* 3$:(&(4/&$37 D2''7 /62*& &C/&? I*& O 52%T& D/%& &2 C/A$ ]] S+? B8$&C VXMV`MX[ '$#/33+ O C/A$ 3$%:&C7 $%@2'#$4$%& 8'2#$$5(%:+ 6$@2'$. /%5 O 52%T& D/%& &2 $(&C$' 8*& 47+$3@ 2' &C$ 3(&(:/%&+ &C'2*:C 3$%:&C7 /%5 #2+&37 $%@2'#$4$%& 8'2#$$5(%:+ &2 @(%5 2*& &C$% &C/& &C$ 3/%:*/:$ (+ &22 6'2/5 &2 +*882'& #2%&$48& '$4$5($+? H2D. O *%5$'+&/%5 &C$ &(4$ *':$%#7 2@ &C(+ /%5 O D(33 42A$ /+ h*(#=37 /+ O #/%? <C$% #/% 72* :$& &C$4 52%$f O C/A$ /+=$5 72* &2 52 &D2 &C(%:+? L%$ (+ / 3$:/3 6'($@ /%5 &C$ 2&C$' VXMWYMVW (+ &D$/=(%: &C(+ (%e*%#&(A$ 3/%:*/:$ &2 4/=$ (& 42'$ %/''2D? SE? aNHbM O &C(%= D$ #/% %/''2D &C$ (%e*%#&(2% 3/%:*/:$ D(&C(% &D2 D$$=+ /%5 6'($@ D(&C(% / 42%&C? PcJ -LNEPM L=/7? O 4$/%. (@ 72* C/5 (& 52%$ I*& VXMWYMW` &242''2D. OT5 C/A$ / '*3(%: @2' 72* (% / #2*83$ 2@ 5/7+? (@ 72* D/%& &2 &/=$ / 42%&C. &C/&T+ *8 &2 72*? O D(33 &$33 72* DC/& O D(33 52? B(%#$ &C$ &(4$ *':$%#7 (+ $%&('$37 72*'+. /%5 O /4 #244(&&$5 &2 /#&(%: /+ 8'248&37 /+ 82++(63$ 2%#$ O C/A$ &C(+ (%@2'4/&(2% @'24 72*. OT4 VXMWYMX` NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP W_ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ #2%&$%& %2& &2 +$& / 5$/53(%$ 6$#/*+$ 72* D(33 6$ 42&(A/&$5 @2' 72*' #3($%&T+ (%&$'$+& &2 :$& (& 52%$ +22%$' '/&C$' &C/% 3/&$'? O C28$ 72* D2*35 %2& &/=$ / 42%&C *%3$++. 2@ #2*'+$. (@ 72* C/A$ '$/#C$5 /% /##24425/&(2% D(&C S'? E(#C$+2% &C/& &/=$+ &C$ &(4$ *':$%#7 /D/7. &C$%. 2@ #2*'+$. 72* 52%T& C/A$ &C$ &(4$ 8'$++*'$? D(&C S'? E(#C$+2%f SE? aNHbM <$ C/A$ %2& '$/#C$5 /% /:'$$4$%& D(&C S'? O+ &C/& &C$ +(&*/&(2% 72* /'$ (% '(:C& %2D VXMWVMVV E(#C$+2%. 6*& O D2*35 3(=$ &C$ -2*'& &2 =%2D &C/& (@ S'? E(#C$+2% D2*35 /:'$$ &2 /% /88'28'(/&$ 8$'4/%$%& (%e*%#&(2%. D$ D2*35 5(+4(++ (44$5(/&$37? PcJ -LNEPM PC/& +2*%5+ 3(=$ / 5(+#*++(2% 72* /33 VXMWVMW[ +C2*35 C/A$ (% &C/& '224 '(:C& 2*&+(5$ &C$ 522'+ /@&$' D$ '$#$++? d2* 4/7 6$ /63$ 6$ &2 D2'= /33 2@ &C(+ 2*&? 033 '(:C&? O &C(%= OT4 %2& :2(%: &2 +$& / 5$/53(%$? VXMWVMXV OT4 :2(%: &2 3$/A$ (& &2 72*. S'? a*%1. &2 ]] /#&*/337. O /4 %2& :2(%: &2 +$& / 5$/53(%$. 6*& O 52%T& D/%& &C(+ &2 5'(@& 2@@ (%5$@(%(&$37? O@ 72* &C(%= 72* /'$ :2(%: &2 C/A$ +24$&C(%: '$+23A$5 O D/%& &2 C/A$ (& '$+23A$5 2' #24$ 6/#= /%5 @(3$ &C$+$ 6'($@+? <(&C2*& +$&&(%: / @('4 5$/53(%$. OT5 3(=$ &2 =%2D &C(+ 033 '(:C&f OT4 %2& +$&&(%: / VXMWWMY\ (+ '$+23A$5 D(&C(% / 42%&C? 5$/53(%$. 6*& (@ 72* 52%T& :$& / +$&&3$4$%&. &C$% @(3$ &C(+ 42'$ %/''2D (%e*%#&(2% 3/%:*/:$ /%5 &C$ e*'(+5(#&(2%/3 6'($@(%:? 0%5 O D(33 /#& 2% (& h*(#=37? B2 /33 '(:C&? H2D. S'? E(#C$+2%. C/A$ 72* 8'$&&7 4*#C VXMWWMWW NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP W[ V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ *%5$'+&225 &C$ D/7 &C(+ $%5+ '(:C& %2Df SE? EO-cJBLHM $%5? L5537. O @2332D$5 $A$'7&C(%: &2 &C$ O /#&*/337 *%5$'+&/%5 (& /33? PcJ -LNEPM 033 '(:C&? 033 '(:C&? B2 &C$% (& (+ VXMWWMU[ 2'5$'$5. D(&C &C$ /:'$$4$%& 2@ &C$ 83/(%&(@@. &C/& &C$ /883(#/&(2% @2' 8'$3(4(%/'7 (%e*%#&(2% (+ &/=$% *%5$' /5A(+$4$%& 8$%5(%: &C$ '$#$(8& 2@ @*'&C$' 6'($@(%: /%5 / '$A(+$5 @2'4 2@ 5'/@& 8'$3(4(%/'7 (%e*%#&(2% @'24 &C$ 83/(%&(@@+ /%5 &C$ @*'&C$' 52#*4$%&/&(2% &2 6$ @(3$5 D(&C(% / 42%&C? O& (+ @*'&C$' 2'5$'$5 &C/& D(&C #2%+$%& 2@ &C$ 5$@$%5/%&. &C$ &$482'/'7 '$+&'/(%(%: 2'5$' (+ #2%&(%*$5 (% $@@$#& *%&(3 &C$ -2*'& '*3$+ /@&$' '$#$(8& 2@ &C2+$ @*'&C$' @(3(%:+ @'24 &C$ 83/(%&(@@? O+ &C$'$ /%7&C(%: O C/A$ 3$@& 2*&. S'? a*%1f SE? aNHbM PEL? H2? O /88'$#(/&$ *%5$'+&/%5(%: /62*& &C$ VXMWUMY_ VXMWUMWV PC/%= 72* @2' $3/62'/&(%: &C/&? PcJ -LNEPM 033 '(:C&? O@ &C$'$T+ %2&C(%: $3+$. &C$% D$ D(33 6$ /5e2*'%$5 @2' &C$ 5/7? SE? aNHbM PC/%= 72*? VXMWUMU^ R>'2#$$5(%: '$#$++$5 /& WMWU 8?4?G NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP W` V W U X \ ^ _ [ ` VY VV VW VU VX V\ V^ V_ V[ V` WY WV WW WU WX W\ +j,/*'($ 0? 05/4+ !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! ,/*'($ 0? 05/4+. ESE. -EE WYVY? O. ,0NEOJ 0? 0F0SB. 52 C$'$67 #$'&(@7 &C/& O /4 5*37 /882(%&$5 /%5 h*/3(@($5 &2 /#& /+ L@@(#(/3 -2*'& E$82'&$' @2' &C$ N%(&$5 B&/&$+ F(+&'(#& -2*'& @2' &C$ F(+&'(#& 2@ 0'(12%/? O KNEPcJE -JEPOKd &C/& &C$ @2'$:2(%: 8/:$+ #2%+&(&*&$ / @*33. &'*$. /%5 /##*'/&$ &'/%+#'(8& 2@ /33 2@ &C/& 82'&(2% 2@ &C$ 8'2#$$5(%:+ #2%&/(%$5 C$'$(%. C/5 (% &C$ /62A$]$%&(&3$5 #/*+$ 2% &C$ 5/&$ +8$#(@($5 &C$'$(%. /%5 &C/& +/(5 &'/%+#'(8& D/+ 8'$8/'$5 *%5$' 47 5('$#&(2% /%5 #2%&'23? F0PJF /& >C2$%(Z. 0'(12%/. &C(+ UY&C 5/7 2@ B$8&$46$'. -JEPOKO-0PJ NHOPJF BP0PJB FOBPEO-P -LNEP

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?