Caltex Plastics Inc v. Elkay Plastics Company Inc et al

Filing 16

PROTECTIVE ORDER by Magistrate Judge John E. McDermott, The Court, having reviewed the Stipulation for Protective Order executed by the parties through their respective counsel, and good cause appearing therefor, IT IS ORDERED: 1. Discovery in this a ction is expected to require the production of nonpublic confidential information concerning the business affairs of the parties, including but not limited to pricing information, sales and revenue figures, customer identities, and materials that may constitute trade secrets. There is good cause for the entry of a protective order under Rule 26(c) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure with respect to such materials because the disclosure of the pricing information, sales and revenue data, customer identities, and trade secrets could result in competitive injury. re Stipulation for Protective Order 14 (SEE ORDER FOR FURTHER DETAILS) (lmh)

1

5

FRED A. FENSTER (SBN 50489)
[e-mail]
NANCY C. MORGAN (SBN 205430)
[e-mail]
GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN &
MACHTINGER LLP
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590
Telephone: [phone]/Fax: [phone]

6

Attorneys for Plaintiff Caltex Plastics, Inc.

7

12

GARY M. ANDERSON (State Bar No. 97385)
[e-mail]
DAVID PITMAN (State Bar No. 172944)
[e-mail]
KENYA WILLIAMS (State Bar No. 276875)
[e-mail]
FULWIDER PATTON LLP
Howard Hughes Center
6060 Center Drive, Tenth Floor
Los Angeles, California 90045
Telephone: [phone]/Fax: [phone]

13

Attorneys for Defendant Elkay Plastics Company

2
3
4

8

10
11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

9

14

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

15

CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

16
17
18

CALTEX PLASTICS, INC., a
California corporation,
Plaintiff,

19
20

PROTECTIVE ORDER

v.

21

Case No. 2:12-cv-10033 RSWL(JEMx)

ELKAY PLASTICS COMPANY, a
California corporation, and DOES 110,

22

Defendants.

23
24
25
26

The Court, having reviewed the Stipulation for Protective Order executed by
the parties through their respective counsel, and good cause appearing therefor,

27

IT IS ORDERED:

28
12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

PROTECTIVE ORDER

1

1.

Discovery in this action is expected to require the production of non-

2

public confidential information concerning the business affairs of the parties,

3

including but not limited to pricing information, sales and revenue figures,

4

customer identities, and materials that may constitute trade secrets. There is good

5

cause for the entry of a protective order under Rule 26(c) of the Federal Rules of

6

Civil Procedure with respect to such materials because the disclosure of the pricing

7

information, sales and revenue data, customer identities, and trade secrets could

8

result in competitive injury.
2.

As used herein, “Confidential Material” means: (a) non-public price

10

lists and price quotations; (b) non-public sales, profit and revenue figures; (c) non-

11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

9

public information disclosing the identities of any customer of any party providing

12

discovery, including any party to this action or any third party (a “Producing

13

Party”); and (d) any other non-public information that any Producing Party

14

reasonably believes, in good faith, is likely to cause competitive harm if disclosed

15

or constitutes a trade secret under applicable law.

16

3.

17

“Confidential Material” does not include any information:
(a)

18

that is known to or independently developed by the party

receiving the production (the “Receiving Party”);

19

(b)

that, after the disclosure to the Receiving Party by the Producing

20

Party is revealed to the public or to the Receiving Party by a person having

21

the unrestricted right to do so; or

22

(c)

that is acquired by the Receiving Party from any third party

23

which lawfully possesses the information and owes no contractual duty of

24

non-disclosure to the Producing Party.

25

4.

26

There shall be two categories of Confidential Material under this

Protective Order:

27

(a)

“CONFIDENTIAL,” and

28

(b)

“ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY.”

12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

2

PROTECTIVE ORDER

1

The “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY” category is reserved exclusively for

2

Confidential Material that constitutes trade secrets under applicable law, or

3

Confidential Material regarding pricing, profit or customer information that, if

4

disclosed to the Receiving Party, would cause competitive injury to the Producing

5

Party.

6

5.

All tangible items or subject matter deemed by the Producing Party to

be subject to this Protective Order shall be visibly marked as “CONFIDENTIAL”

8

or “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY” at the time of production or disclosure to be

9

subject to this Protective Order. In order to designate an entire multi-page

10

document as “CONFIDENTIAL” or “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY” each page of

11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

7

the document must be so marked, except in the case of electronic documents

12

produced in native format (e.g., Microsoft Excel files), which may be designated by

13

affixing the appropriate designation on the first page of the document. If not all

14

pages of a document contain Confidential Material, then only those pages deemed

15

in good faith to be subject to each such designation shall be so marked, except in

16

the case of electronic documents produced in native format, which may be

17

designated as described above. With respect to deposition testimony, blanket

18

designations of an entire deposition transcript as “CONFIDENTIAL” or

19

“ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY” should be avoided where possible, although

20

counsel may agree, for the sake of convenience, to temporary treatment of a

21

transcript as “CONFIDENTIAL” or “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY,” pending

22

specific page and line designations made by the Producing Party after the

23

deposition transcript for that deposition session or sitting is transcribed by the

24

reporter. In connection with electronically-produced documents in non-native

25

format, any designation as “CONFIDENTIAL” or “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY”

26

shall be provided in a metadata field and shall also be stamped on the electronic

27

document itself.

28

6.

Except pursuant to a prior written consent of the Producing Party or an

12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

3

PROTECTIVE ORDER

order of the Court allowing broader disclosure, no Confidential Material which has

2

been designated as “CONFIDENTIAL” shall be disclosed by the Receiving Party

3

to anyone other than (a) this Court and its personnel, (b) any person indicated on

4

the face of a document so designated to be its originator or author or a recipient of a

5

copy thereof, or is mentioned in it, (c) counsel of record for the Receiving Party

6

(including attorneys and employees working for such counsel), (d) experts and

7

consultants retained or consulted in this action by the Receiving Party, (e)

8

executives of the Receiving Party who are actively involved in working with the

9

Receiving Party or its legal counsel in the prosecution, defense, or settlement of

10

these proceedings, and (f) any court reporter before whom a deposition is taken in

11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

1

this action.

12

7.

Except pursuant to a prior written consent of the Producing Party or an

13

order of the Court allowing broader disclosure, no Confidential Material which has

14

been designated as “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY” shall be disclosed by the

15

Receiving Party to anyone other than (a) this Court and its personnel, (b) any

16

person indicated on the face of the document to be its originator or author or a

17

recipient of a copy thereof, or is mentioned in it, (c) counsel of record for the

18

Receiving Party (including attorneys and employees working for such counsel), (d)

19

experts or consultants retained or consulted in this action by the Receiving Party,

20

and (e) any court reporter before whom a deposition is taken in this action.

21

8.

All persons to whom disclosure of Confidential Material is made under

22

this Protective Order, other than counsel of record for the parties and the attorneys

23

and employees who work for such counsel, shall be given a copy of the Protective

24

Order prior to such disclosure and, prior to such disclosure, shall sign the form

25

attached hereto as “Exhibit A” indicating that they have read this Protective Order

26

and agree to be bound by its terms.

27
28

9.

Confidential Material shall be handled in the manner set forth herein

and shall be used solely for the purposes of the prosecution or defense of this action
12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

4

PROTECTIVE ORDER

1

unless and until such designation is removed by agreement of counsel for the

2

parties or by order of the Court. This reciprocal contractual obligation shall survive

3

the termination of this action and shall continue even after the Court loses its

4

current jurisdiction over the parties.

5

10.

Where only a portion of a particular document or tangible item

furnished or produced by a Producing Party, or a portion of the transcript of any

7

deposition, is designated as Confidential Material, counsel for the Receiving Party

8

shall delete or redact therefrom the “CONFIDENTIAL” or “ATTORNEYS’ EYES

9

ONLY” portions, before disclosing such information to any person other than those

10

designated herein.

11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

6

11.

Deletions or redactions made from any material or transcript in

12

accordance with the terms of this Protective Order shall not affect the admissibility

13

of any such material or transcript in evidence in this action.

14

12.

Nothing contained herein, including in Paragraph 7 above, shall

15

preclude or impede the ability of the parties’ counsel to communicate with their

16

respective clients to provide advice and counseling with respect to this action, based

17

upon counsel’s review and analysis of Confidential Material designated as

18

“ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY.” Counsel may discuss with employees and officers

19

of their respective clients who are actively involved in the prosecution, defense, or

20

settlement of this action, the general nature of such “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY”

21

materials, without disclosing the specifics of those materials, to the extent necessary

22

to the effective representation of their respective clients.

23

13.

If any Confidential Material is summarized, discussed, or quoted from

24

at any deposition or at any hearing in this action, all persons other than those to

25

whom disclosure is permitted hereunder shall be excluded from such portion of the

26

deposition or hearing.

27
28

14.

The parties shall endeavor to avoid filing Confidential Materials with

the Court to the extent possible. If it becomes necessary to file Confidential
12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

5

PROTECTIVE ORDER

1

Materials with the Court, the party who wishes to file such materials shall (a) seek

2

the consent of the Producing Party to allow such filing, or (b) if such consent is not

3

forthcoming, shall file an application for approval to file the Confidential Materials

4

under seal, pursuant to Local Rule 79-5.

5

15.

Nothing in this Order shall prevent a Receiving Party from contending

Party may at any time request that the Producing Party cancel or modify the

8

designation with respect to any document or information contained therein. The

9

designated status of any Confidential Material and any restriction on the disclosure

10

or use of Confidential Material contained in this Protective Order may be changed

11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

that documents or information have been improperly designated. A Receiving

7

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

6

only by written agreement of the Producing Party or by court order. A party shall

12

not be obligated to challenge the propriety of any designation at the time of

13

production, and a failure to do so shall not preclude a subsequent challenge thereto.

14

Before filing any motion for an order changing the designated status of Confidential

15

Material or any restriction of this Protective Order, the Receiving Party shall make

16

a written request to the Producing Party to agree to the requested change. The

17

parties shall promptly meet and confer to discuss the request. If after meeting and

18

conferring, the parties cannot agree upon the resolution of the Receiving Party’s

19

request, the Receiving Party may move for an order changing the designated status

20

of Confidential Material or otherwise relieving the Receiving Party from the

21

restrictions of this Protective Order. Pending the decision on the motion, the

22

involved item shall be treated in accordance with its designated status. In

23

connection with any such motion, the Producing Party shall have the burden of

24

establishing that the item of protected subject matter contains Confidential Material

25

of such a nature as to justify its designated status or as to justify the restrictions

26

from which the Receiving Party then seeks relief.

27
28

16.

Inadvertent or unintentional production of documents or things

containing Confidential Material, but which are not properly designated as such at
12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

6

PROTECTIVE ORDER

the time of production, shall not be deemed a waiver in whole or in part of a claim

2

for confidential treatment. Any Producing Party who inadvertently produces

3

Confidential Material without designating it as such in accordance with this

4

Protective Order shall immediately notify the Receiving Party after discovery of

5

such inadvertent production. The material so designated shall thereafter be treated

6

as Confidential Material under this Protective Order, unless the designation is

7

changed pursuant to Paragraph 15 of this Protective Order. The Producing Party

8

will also provide replacement pages bearing the appropriate confidentiality legend

9

or legends upon discovery of the error.

10

17.

If information subject to a claim of attorney-client privilege, work

11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

1

product doctrine, or other privilege, doctrine, right, or immunity is nevertheless

12

inadvertently or unintentionally produced, such production shall in no way

13

prejudice or otherwise constitute a waiver or estoppel as to any such privilege,

14

doctrine, right or immunity. Any Producing Party who produces material without

15

intending to waive a claim of privilege or protection of trial preparation materials

16

with respect thereto shall immediately on discovery of the error identify the

17

material or information produced and state the privilege or other protection

18

asserted. After the Producing Party makes that identification, the Receiving Party

19

must promptly return, sequester or destroy the specified material or information and

20

any copies thereof and otherwise follow the procedures set forth in Federal Rule of

21

Civil Procedure 26(b)(5)(B). The Receiving Party may thereafter seek a ruling

22

from the Court as to the merits of the claim of privilege or protection of trial

23

preparation materials; the Producing Party must preserve the information until the

24

claim is resolved.

25

18.

All Confidential Material shall be retained by the Receiving Party or

26

its counsel of record during the pendency of these proceedings, except that experts

27

and consultants retained or consulted by a Receiving Party, and other persons noted

28

herein or permitted by other agreement, may have custody of one copy of any
12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

7

PROTECTIVE ORDER

1

Confidential Material during the pendency of this proceeding.

2

19.

Neither the taking of any action in accordance with the provisions of

this Protective Order, nor the failure to object thereto, shall be construed as a

4

waiver of any claim or defense in this action. Moreover, the failure to designate

5

information in accordance with this Protective Order and the failure to object to a

6

designation at a given time shall not preclude the filing of a motion at a later date

7

seeking to impose such designation or challenging the propriety thereof as of or

8

after any such later date. The entry of this Protective Order shall not be construed

9

as a waiver of any right to object to the disclosure of information in response to

10

discovery and, except as expressly provided, shall not relieve any party of the

11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

3

obligation of producing information in the course of discovery.

12

20.

A nonparty producing information or material voluntarily or pursuant

13

to a subpoena or a court order may designate such material or information as

14

CONFIDENTIAL or ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY, pursuant to the terms of this

15

Protective Order. Any party seeking to challenge the designation of non-party

16

information as CONFIDENTIAL or ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY or who is

17

seeking to use such information in proceedings where it may become a part of the

18

public record, shall follow the procedures set forth above and provide notice to the

19

non-party in sufficient time to allow the non-party to appear and seek continued

20

protection of its information as designated.

21

20.

Upon termination or settlement of these proceedings, including all

22

appeals, each party shall either: (a) return to the Producing Party all

23

“CONFIDENTIAL” and “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY” materials produced in

24

discovery, including all copies, summaries, or abstracts not containing attorney

25

work product or information covered by the attorney-client privilege; or (b) destroy,

26

and certify such destruction in writing to the other party or to third parties, as the

27

case may be, all “CONFIDENTIAL” and “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY” materials

28

produced in discovery, including all copies, summaries, or abstracts not containing
12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

8

PROTECTIVE ORDER

1

attorney work product or information covered by the attorney-client privilege;

2

provided, however, that each party’s counsel may keep one paper archival copy and

3

one electronic archival copy of all pleadings, discovery responses, and produced

4

documents that contain “CONFIDENTIAL” or “ATTORNEYS’ EYES ONLY”

5

materials.

6
7

Dated: February 04, 2013

8

/s/John E. McDermott________________
United States Magistrate Judge

10
11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

9

12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

9

PROTECTIVE ORDER

1

EXHIBIT A

2

ACKNOWLEDGEMENT OF RECEIPT OF PROTECTIVE ORDER AND

3

AGREEMENT TO BE BOUND THEREBY

4
5
I, __________________________, acknowledge that I have received a copy of the

7

Protective Order entered by the United States District Court for the Central District

8

of California in Caltex Plastics, Inc. v. Elkay Plastics Company et al, Case No. CV

9

12-10033 RSWL (JEMx). I agree to be bound by the terms of that Protective Order

10

and submit to the jurisdiction of the United States District Court for the Central

11
1900 Avenue of the Stars, 21st Floor
Los Angeles, California 90067-4590

GREENBERG GLUSKER FIELDS CLAMAN
& MACHTINGER LLP

6

District of California with respect to any proceedings to enforce my obligations

12

thereunder.

13
14
15

Dated: ____________________

_______________________________

16

Signature

17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
12486-00005/1896090.1
640696.1

10

PROTECTIVE ORDER