Illari Chavarra et al v. Benihana National Corp et al
Filing
31
JUDGMENT by Judge Gary A. Feess, in favor of Anabelle Esquerra, Aneta Maksudi, April Lyn Shiroma, Ashley Milton, Cellany Escobar, Chanel Midori Ola, Eugene Contreras Recto, Hatsumi Fukuoka, Ippei Haga, Jessica Quiambo, Juli Okada-Talbert, Julia Konom i Takada, Julie Choe, Julie Vanessa Marquez, Jullia Onouye, Noel Hernandez, Pia Chen, Prapasri Khamcharoen, Princess Aileen Bernardino, Sandy Setsuko Fujimoto, Teresa Pham, Timoth Hanaoka, Yumiko Hagino-Hetherington against Benihana National Corp: I n accordance therewith, the court enters judgment against BENIHANA NATIONAL CORP., and in favor of plaintiffs CELIANY ESCOBAR, SANDY SETSUKO FUJIMOTO, HATSUMI FUKUOKA, JULIE VANESSA MARQUEZ, ASHLEY MILTON, CHANEL MIDORI OTA, TERESA PHAM, JESSICA QUIA MBAO, APRIL LYN SHIROMA, PRINCESS AILEEN BERNARDINO, PIA CHEN, JULIE CHOE, ANABELLE ESQUERRA, IPPEI HAGA, YUMIKO HAGINO-HETHERINGTON, TIMOTHY HANAOKA, NOELL HERNANDEZ, PRAPASRI KHAMCHAROEN, ANETA MAKSUDI, JULI OKADA-TALBERT, JULLIA ONOUYE, EUGENE CON TRERAS RECTO, and JULIA KONOMI TAKADA in the following amounts: Plaintiff CELIANY ESCOBAR $3,700.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff SANDY SETSUKO FUJIMOTO $6,900.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff HATSUMI FUKU OKA $7,000.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff JULIE VANESSA MARQUEZ $6,900.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff ASHLEY MILTON $1,000.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff CHANEL MIDORI OTA $ 1,300.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff TERESA PHAM $1,700.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff JESSICA QUIAMBAO $6,600.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff APRIL LYN SHIROMA $3,700.00 plus at torneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff PRINCESS AILEEN BERNARDINO $1,900.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff PIA CHEN $2,800.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff JULIE CHOE $1,500.00 plus attorneys' fee s and costs; Plaintiff ANABELLE ESQUERRA $4,600.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff IPPEI HAGA $4,400.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff YUMIKO HAGINO-HETHERINGTON $5,500.00 plus attorneys' fees and c osts; Plaintiff TIMOTHY HANAOKA $5,200.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff NOELL HERNANDEZ $1,900.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff PRAPASRI KHAMCHAROEN $4,100.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plain tiff ANETA MAKSUDI $2,200.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff JULI OKADA-TALBERT $6,800.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff JULLIA ONOUYE $1,200.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff EUGENE CONT RERAS RECTO $2,300.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs; Plaintiff JULIA KONOMI TAKADA $1,400.00 plus attorneys' fees and costs. The Court will determine the amounts of Plaintiffs' costs and attorneys' fees pursuant to the terms of the Offers of Judgment, which specifically provide for payment of the above amounts plus all reasonable attorneys' fees and costs associated with Plaintiffs' individual claims as determined by this Court. All other existing dates and deadlines in this matter are hereby vacated. (MD JS-6, Case Terminated). (bm)
1
JS-6
2
3
4
5
6
7
UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
8
9
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
10
11
ILLARI CHAVARRA, an individual;
Et Al,
CASE NO.: 2:13-cv-09326 GAF
(PLAx)
12
Plaintiffs,
13
14
JUDGMENT
vs.
15
16
17
18
BENIHANA NATIONAL CORP., a
Delaware Corporation; and DOES 1
through 100, inclusive,
Defendants.
19
20
21
22
23
The Court has before it plaintiffs CELIANY ESCOBAR, SANDY
SETSUKO FUJIMOTO, HATSUMI FUKUOKA, JULIE VANESSA
MARQUEZ, ASHLEY MILTON, CHANEL MIDORI OTA, TERESA PHAM,
JESSICA QUIAMBAO, APRIL LYN SHIROMA, PRINCESS AILEEN
24
BERNARDINO, PIA CHEN, JULIE CHOE, ANABELLE ESQUERRA, IPPEI
25
HAGA, YUMIKO HAGINO-HETHERINGTON, TIMOTHY HANAOKA,
26
NOELL HERNANDEZ, PRAPASRI KHAMCHAROEN, ANETA MAKSUDI,
27
JULI OKADA-TALBERT, JULLIA ONOUYE, EUGENE CONTRERAS
28
1
2:13-cv-09326 GAF-PLA_______________________________
JUDGMENT
1
RECTO, and JULIA KONOMI TAKADA's acceptance of Rule 68 Offer and
2
Request for Entry of Judgment, and the attached Rule 68 Offers.
3
In accordance therewith, the court enters judgment against BENIHANA
4
NATIONAL CORP., and in favor of plaintiffs CELIANY ESCOBAR, SANDY
5
SETSUKO FUJIMOTO, HATSUMI FUKUOKA, JULIE VANESSA
6
MARQUEZ, ASHLEY MILTON, CHANEL MIDORI OTA, TERESA PHAM,
7
JESSICA QUIAMBAO, APRIL LYN SHIROMA, PRINCESS AILEEN
8
BERNARDINO, PIA CHEN, JULIE CHOE, ANABELLE ESQUERRA, IPPEI
9
HAGA, YUMIKO HAGINO-HETHERINGTON, TIMOTHY HANAOKA,
10
NOELL HERNANDEZ, PRAPASRI KHAMCHAROEN, ANETA MAKSUDI,
11
JULI OKADA-TALBERT, JULLIA ONOUYE, EUGENE CONTRERAS
12
RECTO, and JULIA KONOMI TAKADA in the following amounts:
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Plaintiff CELIANY ESCOBAR
$3,700.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff SANDY SETSUKO FUJIMOTO
$6,900.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff HATSUMI FUKUOKA
$7,000.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff JULIE VANESSA MARQUEZ
$6,900.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff ASHLEY MILTON
$1,000.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff CHANEL MIDORI OTA
$1,300.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff TERESA PHAM
$1,700.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
27
28
2
2:13-cv-09326 GAF-PLA_______________________________
JUDGMENT
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
Plaintiff JESSICA QUIAMBAO
$6,600.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff APRIL LYN SHIROMA
$3,700.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff PRINCESS AILEEN BERNARDINO
$1,900.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff PIA CHEN
$2,800.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff JULIE CHOE
$1,500.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff ANABELLE ESQUERRA
$4,600.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff IPPEI HAGA
$4,400.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff YUMIKO HAGINO-HETHERINGTON
$5,500.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff TIMOTHY HANAOKA
$5,200.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff NOELL HERNANDEZ
$1,900.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff PRAPASRI KHAMCHAROEN
$4,100.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff ANETA MAKSUDI
$2,200.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
Plaintiff JULI OKADA-TALBERT
$6,800.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
27
28
3
2:13-cv-09326 GAF-PLA_______________________________
JUDGMENT
1
2
Plaintiff JULLIA ONOUYE
attorneys' fees and costs;
3
4
Plaintiff EUGENE CONTRERAS RECTO
$2,300.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs;
5
6
$1,200.00 plus
Plaintiff JULIA KONOMI TAKADA
$1,400.00 plus
attorneys' fees and costs.
7
The Court will determine the amounts of Plaintiffs' costs and attorneys' fees
8
pursuant to the terms of the Offers of Judgment, which specifically provide for
9
payment of the above amounts plus all reasonable attorneys' fees and costs
10
associated with Plaintiffs' individual claims as determined by this Court.
11
All other existing dates and deadlines in this matter are hereby vacated.
12
SO ORDERED.
13
14
15
Date: October 14, 2014
16
JS-6
__________________________
Hon, Gary A. Feess
United States District Judge
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
4
2:13-cv-09326 GAF-PLA_______________________________
JUDGMENT