DC Comics et al v. Benjamin Santoyo et al

Filing 18

CONSENT DECREE PURSUANT TO STIPULATION by Judge Christina A. Snyder: Upon Stipulation 17 , Defendant Benjamin Santoyo, an individual and d/b/a El Cora a/k/a El Cora Produce, and his agents, servants, employees and all persons in active concert and p articipation with him who receive actual notice of the injunction are hereby restrained and enjoined re Plaintiffs' copyrights and trademarks in Plaintiffs' Properties, etc. Each side shall bear its own fees and costs of suit. Except as provided herein, all claims alleged in the Complaint are dismissed with prejudice. See document for details. ( MD JS-6. Case Terminated ) (gk)

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13

JS-6

J. Andrew Coombs (SBN 123881)
[e-mail]
Annie S. Wang (SBN 243027)
[e-mail]
J. Andrew Coombs, A Prof. Corp.
517 East Wilson Ave., Suite 202
Glendale, California 91206
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
Attorneys for Plaintiffs DC Comics,
Disney Enterprises, Inc., and Sanrio, Inc.
Oscar E. Toscano (SBN 84736)
[e-mail]
Oscar E. Toscano, Attorney At Law
625 W. Broadway Avenue, Suite B
Glendale, California 91204
Telephone: [phone]
Facsimile: [phone]
Attorney for Defendant Benjamin Santoyo,
an individual and d/b/a El Cora a/k/a El Cora Produce

14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA
DC Comics, Disney Enterprises, Inc.,
and Sanrio, Inc.,

) Case No. CV14-3239 CAS (MANx)
)
)
) [PROPOSED] CONSENT DECREE
Plaintiffs,
) PURSUANT TO STIPULATION
v.
)
)
Benjamin Santoyo, an individual and
d/b/a El Cora a/k/a El Cora Produce, and )
)
Does 2 – 10, inclusive,
)
)
Defendants.
)
The Court, having read and considered the Joint Stipulation for Entry of

25

Consent Decree that has been executed on behalf of Plaintiffs DC Comics, Disney

26

Enterprises, Inc., and Sanrio, Inc. (collectively “Plaintiffs”) on the one hand, and

27

Defendant Benjamin Santoyo, an individual and d/b/a El Cora a/k/a El Cora Produce

28

(“Defendant”), on the other hand, and good cause appearing therefore, hereby:
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-1-

1

ORDERS that this Consent Decree shall be and is hereby entered in the within

2

action as follows:

3

1)

4

matter hereof pursuant to 17 U.S.C. § 101 et seq., 15 U.S.C. § 1051 et seq., 28 U.S.C.

5

§§ 1331 and 1338, and 28 U.S.C. § 1367. Service of process was properly made

6

against Defendant.

7

2)

8

copyright and trademark registrations listed in Exhibits “A” through “F,” attached

9

hereto and incorporated herein by this reference, and the copyrights associated with

This Court has jurisdiction over the parties to this action and over the subject

Plaintiffs are the owners or exclusive licensees of all rights in and to the

10

the same (“Plaintiffs’ Properties”).

11

3)

12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Plaintiffs have expended considerable resources in the creation and commercial

exploitation of Plaintiffs’ Properties on merchandise and in the enforcement of its
intellectual property rights in Plaintiffs’ Properties.
4)

Plaintiffs have alleged that Defendant has made unauthorized uses of Plaintiffs’

Properties or substantially similar likenesses or colorable imitations thereof.
5)

Defendant and his agents, servants, employees and all persons in active concert

and participation with him who receive actual notice of the injunction are hereby
restrained and enjoined from:
a) Infringing Plaintiffs’ copyrights and trademarks in Plaintiffs’ Properties, either
directly or contributorily, in any manner, including generally, but not limited to
manufacturing, importing, distributing, advertising, selling, or offering for sale,
any unauthorized product which features any of Plaintiffs’ Properties
(“Unauthorized Products”), and, specifically:
i) Importing, manufacturing, distributing, advertising, selling, or
offering for sale, the Unauthorized Products or any other unauthorized
products which picture, reproduce, copy or use the likenesses of or
bear a substantial similarity to any of Plaintiffs’ Properties;

28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-2-

1

ii) Importing, manufacturing, distributing, advertising, selling, or

2

offering for sale, in connection thereto any unauthorized promotional

3

materials, labels, packaging or containers which picture, reproduce,

4

copy or use the likenesses of or bear a confusing similarity to any of

5

Plaintiffs’ Properties;

6

iii) Engaging in any conduct that tends falsely to represent that, or is

7

likely to confuse, mislead or deceive purchasers, Defendant’s

8

customers and/or members of the public to believe, the actions of

9

Defendant, the products sold or offered by Defendant, or Defendant

10

himself is connected with Plaintiffs, is sponsored, approved or

11

licensed by Plaintiffs, or is affiliated with Plaintiffs; or

12

iv) Affixing, applying, annexing or using in connection with the

13

importation, manufacture, distribution, advertising, selling, offering

14

for sale, or other use of any goods or services, a false description or

15

representation, including words or other symbols, tending to falsely

16
17
18

describe or represent such goods as being those of Plaintiffs.
6)

Each side shall bear its own fees and costs of suit.

7)

This Consent Decree shall be deemed to have been served upon Defendant at

19
20

the time of its execution by the Court.
8)

21

and, pursuant to Rule 54(a) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure, the Court

22
23

directs immediate entry of this Consent Decree against Defendant.
9)

24

27

The Court shall retain jurisdiction of this action to entertain such further
proceedings and to enter such further orders as may be necessary or appropriate

25
26

The Court finds there is no just reason for delay in entering this Consent Decree

to implement and enforce the provisions of this Consent Decree.
10)

The above-captioned action, shall, upon filing by Plaintiffs of the Settlement
Agreement, Stipulation for Entry of Judgment and Judgment Pursuant to

28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-3-

1

Stipulation, and requesting entry of judgment against Defendant, be reopened

2

should Defendant default under the terms of the Settlement Agreement or this

3

Consent Decree.

4

11)

This Court shall retain jurisdiction over Defendant for the purpose of making

5

further orders necessary or proper for the construction or modification of this

6

consent decree and judgment; the enforcement hereof; the punishment of any

7

violations hereof; and for the possible entry of a further Judgment Pursuant to

8

Stipulation in this action.

9
10

12)

Except as provided herein, all claims alleged in the Complaint are dismissed
with prejudice.

11
12

Dated: October 20, 2014

13

_______________________________
Hon. Christina A. Snyder
United States District Judge

14
15

Presented By:

16

J. Andrew Coombs, A Prof. Corp.

17
18
19
20

By: ______________________________
J. Andrew Coombs
Annie S. Wang
Attorneys for Plaintiffs DC Comics,
Disney Enterprises, Inc. and Sanrio, Inc.

21
22

Oscar E. Toscano, Attorney At Law

23
24
25

By: ______________________________
Oscar E. Toscano
Attorney for Defendant Benjamin Santoyo,
an individual and d/b/a El Cora a/k/a El Cora Produce

26
27
28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-4-

1

EXHIBIT A

2

DC COMICS’ COPYRIGHTED DESIGNS

3
4

Copyright
Registration

5
6

Txu 1-080-661

7
8
9
10

VAu 1-059-478
TX 5-581-762
TX 3-221-758
TXu-532-372

Title of Work
(Character)
DC Comics Anti-Piracy Guide
Batman
Robin
Superman
Wonderwoman
Supergirl
Justice League
DC Comics Anti-Piracy Style
Guide
Superman
Superman
DC Comics style guide.

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-5-

Type of Work

Style Guide

Style Guide
Monthly Publication
Style Guide
visual arts

1

EXHIBIT B

2

DC COMICS’ TRADEMARKS

3
4

Trademark

Trademark Registration Trademark Registration
No.
Date

Bat Emblem

1,581,725

2/6/1990

Bat Emblem

1,581,593

2/6/1990

Bat Emblem

1,581,659

2/6/1990

Bat Emblem
Bat Emblem (BATMAN
BEGINS)
Bat Emblem (BATMAN
BEGINS)
Bat Emblem (BATMAN
BEGINS)
Bat Emblem (BATMAN
BEGINS)

2,119,266

12/9/1997

3,299,017

9/25/2007

3,110,604

6/27/2006

3,326,043

10/30/2007

3,313,612

10/16/2007

Bat Rep II

1,219,120

12/7/1982

BATARANG

3,291,749

9/11/2007

BATCAVE

4,135,575

5/1/2012

BATGIRL

3,070,999

3/21/2006

BATMAN

856,045

9/3/1968

BATMAN

828,412

5/9/1967

18

BATMAN

839,561

11/28/1967

19

BATMAN

858,860

10/22/1968

20

BATMAN

1,221,720

12/28/1982

21

BATMAN

1,652,640

6/30/1991

22

BATMAN

1,622,749

11/13/1990

23

BATMAN

2,457,655

6/5/2001

24

BATMAN & ROBIN

2,171,937

6/7/1998

25

BATMAN & ROBIN

2,404,483

11/14/2000

26

BATMAN & ROBIN

2,245,040

5/11/1999

27

BATMAN BEYOND

2,762,067

9/3/2003

28

BATMAN BEYOND

2,688,935

2/18/2003

5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-6-

1

BATMAN BEYOND

2,649,865

11/12/2002

BATMAN BEYOND

2,643,418

10/29/2002

BATMAN on Bat Rep
BATMAN on Bat Rep II
(Side Face) (3D)

382,770

11/12/1940

804,709

3/1/1966

Batman Rope Rep

1,262,504

12/27/1983

BATMAN THE RIDE

1,861,233

11/1/1994

BATMOBILE
BATMOBILE (By
Assignment)
BATWING & Bat
Emblem (outline)

1,124,961

9/11/1979

1,179,342

11/24/1981

2,858,716

6/29/2004

CATWOMAN

3,181,586

12/5/2006

11

CATWOMAN

1,052,504

11/9/1976

12

CATWOMAN

1,565,883

11/14/1989

13

CATWOMAN

1,883,034

3/7/1995

14

CATWOMAN

1,966,766

4/9/1996

15

DAILY PLANET

3,018,523

11/22/2005

16

DAILY PLANET

3,066,593

3/7/2006

17

DAILY PLANET

3,349,268

12/4/2007

18

DOUBLE W Design

1,332,090

4/23/1985

19

GOTHAM CENTRAL

3,391,794

3/4/2008

20

GOTHAM CITY

3,353,156

12/11/2007

21

GOTHAM GIRLS

2,868,577

8/3/2004

GOTHAM KNIGHTS

3,391,795

3/4/2008

JIMMY OLSEN

1,190,637

2/23/1982

JOKER

1,052,503

11/9/1976

KRYPTO
KRYPTO THE
SUPERDOG
KRYPTO THE
SUPERDOG

1,168,306

9/8/1981

3,061,112

2/21/2006

3,018,682

11/22/2005

KRYPTONITE

1,239,506

5/24/1983

2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

22
23
24
25
26
27
28

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-7-

1

KRYPTONITE

2,656,768

12/3/2002

LEX LUTHOR

1,634,007

2/5/1991

LEX LUTHOR

2,802,600

1/6/2004

LOIS & CLARK

3,355,918

12/18/2007

LOIS LANE

2,781,372

11/11/2003

6

LOIS LANE

1,184,702

1/5/1982

7

MAN OF STEEL

2,226,436

2/23/1999

8

MAN OF STEEL

4,419,423

10/15/2013

9

MAN OF STEEL

4,419,425

10/15/2013

10

MAN OF STEEL

4,522,572

4/29/2014

11

MAN OF STEEL

4,411,861

10/1/2013

12

MR. FREEZE

2,157,292

5/12/1998

13

ROBIN

1,294,617

9/11/1984

14

ROBIN

1,930,901

10/31/1995

15

Robin Rep II

1,279,991

5/29/1984

16

S Logo

1,197,814

6/15/1982

S Logo

1,182,041

12/15/1981

S Logo

1,199,552

6/29/1982

S Logo

1,199,630

6/29/1982

S Logo

1,182,172

12/15/1981

S Logo

1,189,376

2/9/1982

S Logo

1,184,881

1/5/1982

S Logo

1,199,690

6/29/1982

23

S Logo

1,179,537

11/24/1981

24

S Logo

2,226,415

2/23/1999

25

S Logo

2,211,378

12/15/1981

26

S Logo (black)

1,140,418

10/14/1980

27

S Logo (black)

1,173,150

10/13/1981

28

SUPERGIRL

2,023,091

12/6/2005

2
3
4
5

17
18
19
20
21
22

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-8-

1

SUPERGIRL

2,943,882

4/26/2005

SUPERGIRL
SUPERGIRL in
Telescopic

1,238,334

5/17/1983

414,623

6/19/1945

SUPERMAN

3,615,518

5/5/2009

SUPERMAN

1,070,290

7/26/1977

SUPERMAN

648,647

7/16/1957

7

SUPERMAN

1,184,822

1/5/1982

8

SUPERMAN

1,175,907

11/3/1981

9

SUPERMAN

1,180,068

12/1/1981

10

SUPERMAN

1,209,668

9/21/1982

11

SUPERMAN

1,182,947

12/22/1981

12

SUPERMAN

1,186,803

1/19/1982

13

SUPERMAN

1,183,841

12/29/1981

14

SUPERMAN

1,189,393

2/9/1982

15

SUPERMAN

1,248,822

8/23/1983

SUPERMAN

1,216,976

11/16/1982

SUPERMAN

1,181,536

12/8/1981

SUPERMAN

1,221,718

12/28/1982

SUPERMAN

2,204,195

11/17/1998

SUPERMAN
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic

2,419,510

1/9/2001

1,185,526

1/12/1982

1,183,809

12/29/1981

1,185,853

1/12/1982

1,189,355

2/9/1982

1,200,394

7/6/1982

1,220,896

12/21/1982

1,182,226

12/15/1981

1,209,863

9/21/1982

2
3
4
5
6

16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

-9-

18

SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic & Chains Rep
II (Midrift)
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic (By
Assignment)
SUPERMAN in
Telescopic (color)
Superman Rep III
(Running)
Superman Rep III
(Running)
Superman Rep IV (Hands
on Hips)
Superman Rep IX (Flying
Figure)
Superman Rep V
(Running)
Superman Rep VI (Flying
Figure)
Superman Rep VII
(Stepping-Up)
Superman Rep VIII
(Flying Figure)
Superman Rep X
(Standing Clenched Fists
SUPERMAN RIDE OF
STEEL

19

THE DARK KNIGHT

3,680,537

9/8/2009

20

THE DARK KNIGHT

3,690,538

9/8/2009

21

THE DARK KNIGHT

3,680,539

9/8/2009

THE DARK KNIGHT

1,458,274

9/22/1987

The Joker Rep

1,256,974

11/8/1983

THE MAN OF STEEL
The Penguin Rep III
(Jumping)

1,433,864

3/24/1987

1,236,489

5/3/1983

TWO FACE

2,009,805

10/22/1996

WONDER WOMAN

1,221,717

12/28/1982

WONDER WOMAN

1,388,425

4/1/1986

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17

22
23
24
25
26
27

1,218,552

11/30/1982

1,181,537

12/8/1981

2,226,026

2/23/1999

391,821

11/25/1941

371,803

10/10/1939

1,108,577

12/12/1978

1,180,292

12/1/1981

1,178,048

11/17/1981

1,201,149

7/13/1982

1,200,387

7/6/1982

1,209,743

9/21/1982

1,201,167

7/13/1982

1,235,769

4/26/1983

1,229,321

3/8/1983

1,200,233

7/6/1982

2,485,624

9/4/2001

28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 10 -

1
2
3
4
5

WONDER WOMAN
Logo
WONDER WOMAN
Logo II
Wonder Woman Rep III
DOUBLE W DESIGN
(WONDER WOMAN)

820,334

12/13/1966

395,739

6/9/1942

1,236,490

5/3/1983

1,332,090

4/23/1985

6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 11 -

1

EXHIBIT C

2

DEI’S COPYRIGHTED DESIGNS

3

7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21

Gp 81 528

Owl

Gp 85 651

Kanga and Roo
Eeyore
Piglet

Gp 81 528

6

Title of Work
(Character)
Mickey - 1 (Mickey Mouse)
Minnie - 1 (Minnie Mouse)
Donald Duck
Daisy - 1 (Daisy Duck)
Goofy -1 (Goofy)
Pluto
Baby Mickey
Baby Minnie
Baby Donald Duck
Baby Daisy Duck
Baby Goofy
Baby Pluto
Disney's Uncle Scrooge in Only a Poor
Old Man
Walt Disney's Ludwig von Drake
Horace Horsecollar
Chip
Dale
Huey, Dewey & Louie -1
Clarabelle Cow
Winnie the Pooh and the Honey Tree
Winnie the Pooh and the Blustery
Day
Pooh - 1 (Winnie the Pooh)
Rabbit

Gp 81 528

5

Copyright
Registration
VA 58 937
VA 58 938
Gp 80 184
VA 58 933
VA 58 936
Gp 80 192
VAu 64 814
VAu 64 814
VAu 73 216
VAu 73 217
VAu 83 225
VAu 73 219
R 48 971
RE 424 728
Gp 105 126
R 567 615
R 567 614
VA 184 345
Gp 105 128
RE 636 587
RE 718 378
VA 58 940
Gp 81 528

Gp 81 528

4

Gopher

Gp 81 527
R 354 235
R 346 870
R 346 869
R 346 875

Tigger
Snow White and the Seven Dwarfs
Bashful
Doc
Dopey

22
23
24
25
26
27
28

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 12 -

Type of Work
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Comic Strip
Comic Strip
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Publications
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

R 346 876
R 346 871
R 346 874
R 346 873
R 346 872
R 346 868
R 406 910
Gp 80 186
Gp 80 188
R 427 860
R 433 627
R 442 538
R 428 428
R 428 420
R 428 430
R 428 427
R 428 426
R 428 432
R 458 260
R 433 645
R 433 630
R 433 631
R 433 636
R 433 632
R 433 633
R 467 541
R 464 785
R 516 560
R 550 316
R 557 922
R 548 629
R 548 626
R 577 489
R 605 180
R 636 303
R 648 396
R 632 319
R 632 319
R 632 319
R 632 319
R 632 319
R 632 319
R 632 319
R 632 319
R 632 319
RE 27 746

Grumpy
Happy
Sleepy
Sneezy
Snow White
Snow White "Witch"
Pinocchio
Pinocchio

Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Motion Picture
Publications
Model Sheet
Publications
Jiminy Cricket
Model Sheet
Fantasia
Motion Picture
The Reluctant Dragon
Motion Picture
Dumbo
Motion Picture
Dumbo Suggestions for Dumbo
Drawing
Mother Elephant Suggestions for
Drawing
"Dumbo"
Dumbo Ringmaster Suggestions 1348
Drawing
Dumbo - Stork Suggestions
Drawing
Timothy Mouse Suggestions
Drawing
Dumbo "Miscellaneous Crows" - 2006
Drawing
Bambi
Motion Picture
Bambi - Bambi
Drawing
Bambi - Final Thumper Model - 2002
Drawing
Bambi - Skunk Model - 2002
Drawing
Bambi - Owl and Stag Models
Drawing
Faline "Adolescent Age"
Drawing
Bambi's Mother
Drawing
Saludos Amigos
Motion Picture
Joe Carioca
Drawing
The Three Caballeros
Motion Picture
Make Mine Music
Motion Picture
Song of the South
Motion Picture
Brer Rabbit
Drawing
Brer Bear
Drawing
Fun and Fancy Free
Motion Picture
Melody Time
Motion Picture
The Adventures of Ichabod & Mr.
Motion Picture
Toad
Cinderella
Motion Picture
Cinderella
Copyright Booklet
Drizella
Copyright Booklet
Anastasia
Copyright Booklet
Stepmother
Copyright Booklet
Fairy Godmother
Copyright Booklet
Prince
Copyright Booklet
Bruno, the Dog
Copyright Booklet
Lucifer, the Cat
Copyright Booklet
Jaq and Gus
Copyright Booklet
Alice in Wonderland
Motion Picture

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 13 -

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

VA 58 920
VA 58 919
VA 58 921
VA 58 922
VA 58 923
VA 58 924
VA 58 922
VA 58 922
RE 64 027
RE 66 285
RE 66 285
RE 66 285
RE 66 285
RE 66 285
RE 162 852
RE 101 764

Alice - 1 (Alice)
Alice - 2 (The White Rabbit)
Alice – 3 (Queen of Hearts)
Alice - 4 (Cheshire Cat)
Alice - 5 (Caterpillar)
Alice - 6 (Tweedledee and
Tweedledum)
March Hare
Mad Hatter
Peter Pan
Peter Pan
Tinkerbell
Captain Hook
Mr. Smee
Nana
Lady and the Tramp
Lady

RE 101 764
RE 296 296
RE 246 671
RE 246 671
RE 246 671
RE 370 901
RE 546 478
RE 557 357
RE 557 357
RE 557 357
RE 557 357
RE 571 201
RE 705 510
RE 679 798
RE 679 799
RE 679 795
RE 679 805
RE 679 797
RE 679 807
Lp 38 283
Gu 44 754
Gu 44 750
Gu 44 748
Gu 44 745
VA 1-099-033
Lp 39 817
Gu 46 904
Gu 46 908
Gu 46 906
Gu 46 917
LP 42 905

Tramp
Sleeping Beauty
Princess Aurora
Prince Phillip
Maleficent/Dragon
One Hundred and One Dalmatians
The Sword in the Stone
Archimedes
Merlin
Wart/Arthur
Madame Mim
Mary Poppins
The Jungle Book
Mowgli
Baloo
Bagheera
King Louie
Kaa
Shere Khan
The Aristocats
O'Malley
Duchess
Edgar
Roquefort
Marie Valentine Spring 2002
Bedknobs and Broomsticks
Crocky
Sailor Bear
Codfish
Secretary Bird
Robin Hood

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 14 -

Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Coloring Book
Coloring Book
Coloring Book
Coloring Book
Coloring Book
Motion Picture
Previews of
Pictures
Previews of
Pictures
Motion Picture
Book
Book
Book
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Copyright Booklet
Copyright Booklet
Copyright Booklet
Copyright Booklet
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Motion Picture
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Motion Picture

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

Gu 46 582
Gu 46 583
Gu 46 584
Gu 47 230
Gu 47 762
Gu 46 585
Gu 50 764
Gu 50 763
Lp 49 678
Gp 96 289
Gp 96 286
Gp 96 288
Gp 96 287
Gp 103 814
Gu 57 278
Gu 56 625
PA 1 371
Gp 111 695
PA 125 861
VAu 10 933
VAu 10 930
VAu 10 936
VAu 10 928
VAu 12 417
VAu 12 418
VAu 12 415
PA 252 525
VAu 24 517
VAu 29 561
VAu 24 518
VAu 24 070
VAu 24 592
VAu 24 519
VAu 47 075
VAu 47 073
VAu 47 074
PA 290 808
VAu 76 103
VAu 76 102
VAu 81 570
VAu 76 100
VAu 81 572
VAu 81 571
VAu 86 112
VAu 76 104
VAu 85 019
VAu 85 021
VAu 85 022
PA 385 556

Robin Hood
Little John
Sir Hiss
Sheriff of Nottingham
Friar Tuck
Prince John
Maid Marion
Lady Cluck
The Rescuers
Miss Bianca
Orville
Madame Medusa
Bernard
Penny
Rufus
Evinrude
Pete's Dragon
Elliott the Dragon
The Fox and the Hound
Todd (Young)
Copper (Pup)
Vixey
Big Mama
Dinky
Boomer
Squeeks
The Black Cauldron
Eilonwy
Fflewddur
Gurgi
Hen Wen
The Horned King
Taran
Orddu
Orgoch
Orwen
The Great Mouse Detective
Basil 185-126
Dr. Dawson 1284-80
Olivia
Ratigan 285-166
Fidget
Flaversham
Felicia - Clean Up Model 0238
Toby 285-170
Mrs. Judson
Queen Victoria
Bartholomew
Oliver and Company

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 15 -

Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Motion Picture
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Motion Picture
Drawing
Motion Picture
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Motion Picture
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Drawing
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Motion Picture

11

VAu 104 921
VAu 104 920
VAu 104 919
VAu 104 916
VAu 109 377
VAu 109 379
VAu 119 949
PA 431 543
VAu 123 355
VAu 123 351
VAu 123 354
VAu 123 348
VAu 123 352
VAu 123 350
VAu 123 353
VAu 123 349
PAu 1 024 341
VAu 101 067

Dodger Construction Sheets
Einstein Construction Sheets
Frances Construction Sheets
Rita Construction Sheets
Oliver Rough Model
Tito - Ruff Model
How to Draw Georgette
The Little Mermaid
Ariel 9-9-87 Ruff (Ariel)
Scuttle
Ruff Sebastion 9-4-87 (Sebastian)
Ruff Ursula 9-9-87 (Ursula)
Prince Eric
Triton
Flotsam/Jetsam
Flounder
DuckTales
Launchpad McQuack

12

VAu 101 067

Webby

13

VAu 101 067

Doofus

14

VAu 101 067

Mrs. Beakley

VAu 101 067
PA 486 535
VAu 161 749
VAu 155 884
VAu 155 844
VAu 170 264
PA 542 647
VAu 200 866
VAu 210 914
VAu 194 311
VAu 199 855
VAu 200 868
VAu 194 310
VAu 201 337
VAu 194 307
VAu 194 309
VAu 199 856
VAu 200 869
PA 583 905
VAu 215 432
VAu 215 453
VAu 215 793
VAu 218 349
VAu 230 534

Duckworth
The Rescuers Down Under
Cody
Jake (Rough Models)
McLeach (Rough Model)
Marahute (Rough Model)
Beauty and the Beast
Belle (Beauty and the Beast)
Beast
Maurice (Beauty and the Beast)
Mrs. Potts (Beauty and the Beast)
Cogsworth (Beauty and the Beast)
Lumiere (Beauty and the Beast)
Chip (Beauty and the Beast)
Gaston (Beauty and the Beast)
LeFou (Beauty and the Beast)
Phillipe (Beauty and the Beast)
Featherduster (Beauty and the Beast)
Aladdin
Aladdin - Aladdin
Aladdin - Genie
Aladdin - Abu
Aladdin - Iago
Aladdin - Rasoul

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10

15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 16 -

Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Drawings
Motion Picture
Pamphlet of
Drawings
Pamphlet of
Drawings
Pamphlet of
Drawings
Pamphlet of
Drawings
Pamphlet of
Drawings
Motion Picture
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Motion Picture
Artwork
Licensing Kit
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

VAu 218 348
VAu 230 533
VAu 221 841
VAu 221 842
VAu 232 164
PA 659 979
VAu 246 448
VAu 245 946
VAu 246 447
VAu 246 440
VAu 246 438
VAu 246 664
VAu 245 947
VAu 245 945
VAu 246 437
VAu 245 662
VAu 246 446
VA 611 201
PA 720 179
VAu 262 859
VAu 261 970
VAu 261 967
VAu 302 884
VAu 302 886
VAu 302 883
VAu 300 559
VAu 302 885
PA 765 713
VAu 337 565
VAu 337 566
VAu 337 567
VAu 337 568
VAu 337 569
VAu 337 186
VAu 273 627
VAu 348 598
VAu 348 599
PA 795 221
VAu 336 992
VAu 332 434
VAu 336 056
VAu 336 057
VAu 343 663
VAu 336 058
VAu 336 059

Aladdin - The Sultan
Aladdin - Jafar
Aladdin - Jasmine
Aladdin - Jafar as Beggar
Aladdin - Narrator
The Lion King
The Lion King - Mufasa
The Lion King - Sarabi
The Lion King - Simba
The Lion King - Young Simba
The Lion King - Nala
The Lion King - Young Nala
The Lion King - Rafiki
The Lion King - Shenzi, Banzai & Ed
The Lion King - Pumbaa
The Lion King - Timon
The Lion King - Scar
Zazu
Pocahontas
Pocahontas - Pocahontas Standing
Pocahontas - Powhatan
Pocahontas - Percy
Pocahontas - John Smith
Pocahontas - Meeko the Raccoon
Pocahontas - Flit the Hummingbird
Pocahontas - Ratcliffe
Pocahontas - Grandmother Willow
Toy Story
Toy Story - Woody
Toy Story - Buzz Lightyear
Toy Story - Hamm
Toy Story - Rex
Toy Story - Bo Peep Lamp and Sheep
Toy Story - Lenny
Toy Story - Mom
Toy Story - Andy
Toy Story - Hannah
The Hunchback of Notre Dame
The Hunchback of Notre Dame Quasimodo
The Hunchback of Notre Dame Esmeralda
The Hunchback of Notre Dame Phoebus
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Djali
The Hunchback of Notre Dame Gargoyles
The Hunchback of Notre Dame Clopin
The Hunchback of Notre Dame -

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 17 -

Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Licensing Kit
Motion Picture
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Motion Picture
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Artwork
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheets
Model Sheet
Model Sheet

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

VAu 336 878
PA 670 961
VAu 369 603
VAu 369 600
VAu 367 973
VAu 369 605
VAu 369 598
VAu 367 965
VAu 367 964
VAu 367 969
VAu 375 850
VAu 377 944
PA 799 025
VA 849 510
VAu 379 045
VAu 379 027
VAu 379 021
VAu 379 024
VAu 378 480
VAu 381 069
PA 901 890
VA 875 986
VAu 399 357
VAu 399 356
VAu 399 351
VAu 399 349
VAu 399 343
VAu 399 352
VAu 399 350
VAu 399 348
VAu 399 353
VAu 399 342
VAu 399 346
VAu 399 345
VAu 399 344
VAu 399 347
VAu 399 354
VAu 399 355
PA 959 870
VAu 414 563
VAu 405 573
VAu 406 700
VAu 407 195
VAu 405 571
VAu 405 572
VAu 405 197
VAu 405 574
VAu 407 196

Frollo
The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Will
Doll/Sam Doll
Hercules
Hercules - Hercules
Hercules - Baby Hercules
Hercules - Meg
Hercules - Pegasus
Hercules - Baby Pegasus
Hercules - Phil
Hercules - Hades
Hercules - Pain
Hercules - Panic
Hercules - Hydra Head
Mulan
Mulan
The Legend of Mulan - Mulan
The Legend of Mulan - Mulan as Ping
The Legend of Mulan - Mushu
The Legend of Mulan - Shang
The Legend of Mulan - Kahn
The Legend of Mulan - Cricket
A Bug's Life*
A Bug's Life*
Flik*
Hopper*
Atta*
Dot*
Dim*
Tuck & Roll*
Francis*
Heimlich*
Slim*
Rosie*
P.T. Flea*
Manny*
Gypsy*
Thumper*
Molt*
Queen*
Toy Story 2*
Toy Story 2 - Al's Car*
Toy Story 2 - Bullseye*
Toy Story 2 - Coffee Table*
Toy Story 2 - Cushy Chair*
Toy Story 2 - Emporer Zurg*
Toy Story 2 - Jessie*
Toy Story 2 - L'il Yuppie*
Toy Story 2 - Prospector*
Toy Story 2 - Wood Chair*

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 18 -

Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Model Sheets
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

VA960 902
PA 974 011
VAu 486 473
VAu 486 477
VAu 486 476
VAu 486 478
VAu 486 475
VAu 486 474
VAu 486 472
VAu 486 479
VAu 486 471
VA 996 530
VA 992 942
PA 940 885
VA 999 573
VAu 479 682
VAu 479 685
VAu 479 683
VAu 479 684
VAu 479 681
PA 1-250-536
VA 1-242-351
PA 1-322-908
VA 1-326-323
VA 1-403-647
PA 659-601
PA 1-313-530
VA 1-405-082
PA 1-627-575
PA 1-635-067
PA 1-641-991
PA 1-606-305
VA 1-663-815
PA 1-598-561
VA 1-651-813
PA 1-613-593
VA 1-655-713
PA 1-611-956
Pau 2-921-728
VA 515-038
PA 1-623-231
PA 1-588-972
PA 1-595-126
PA 1-332-118
VA 1-358-218
PA 1-122-518

Toy Story 2 - Style Guide*
Dinosaur
Aladar
Baylene
Bruton
Eema
Kron
Neera
Plio
Suri
Yar
Dinosaur - Phase I
Dinosaur - Phase II
The Emperor's New Groove
Emporer's New Groove
Kronk
Kuzco
Kuzco Llama
Pacha
Yzma
The Incredibles
The Incredibles
Cars
Cars – Style Guide
Hannah Montana – Branding Guide
Tim Burton’s The Nightmare Before
Christmas
High School Musical
High School Musical – Branding
Guide
Hannah Montana the Movie
Up
G-Force
Wall-E
Wall-E – Branding and Supplement
Style Guide RSM 2008
High School Musical 2
High School Musical 2 – Summer
2008 Style Guide Supplement
High School Musical 3: Senior Year
Beverly Hills Chihuahua
Beverly Hills Chihuahua
Little Mermaid III: Ariel’s Beginning
Little Mermaid III: Ariel’s Beginning
Bedtime Stories
Underdog
Enchanted
Meet the Robinsons
Meet the Robinsons—Style Guide
Cinderella II : Dreams come true /

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 19 -

Style Guide
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Style Guide
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Motion Picture
One Sheet
Motion Picture
Screenplay
Comic Book
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Motion Picture

1
2
3
4
5
6
7

PA 1-612-331
PA 1-611-943
PA 1-617-950
VA 1-663-828
PA 1-688-323
VA 1-800-737
PA 1-348-114
VAu 959-473

8

VA 1-650-599

9

PA 1-224-960

10
11
12

PA 1-322-906
PA 1-334-112

19

PA 1-737-564
PA 1-742-101
VAu 1-089-554
VA 1-781-144
PA 1-814-870
VAu 1-116-667
VAu 1-116-688
VAu 1-116-686
VAu 1-116-671
PA 1-800-721
VAu 1-093-274

20

VAu 1-089-531

21

VA 1-814-373
PA 1-713-579
VA 1-753-501
VA 1-753-496
VA 1-753-498
PA 1-811-293
VAu 1-082-013
VAu 1-082-015
VAu 1-075-939
PA 1-856-767
PA 1-656-826
PA 1-713-851
PA 1-871-007

13
14
15
16
17
18

22
23
24
25
26
27
28

produced by Walt Disney Television
Animation ; directed by John Kafka
Cinderella III: A Twist in Time
Tinker Bell
Bolt
Bolt – Fall/Winter Style Guide 2008
Toy Story 3
Toy Story 3: GC Product Dev – Style
Guide – Spring/Summer 2010
Handy Manny: no. 1-01
Handy Manny Design Pack –
Characters
Handy Manny Repair Shop –
Spring/Summer 2008 Product
Development Guide
Pirates of the Caribbean: The Curse of
the Black Pearl
Pirates of the Caribbean: Dead Man’s
Chest
Pirates of the Caribbean: At World’s
End
Pirates of the Caribbean: On Stranger
Tides
Cars 2
Cars 2: Professor Z
Cars 2: Tokyo City - Mini
Wreck-It Ralph
Wreck-It Ralph: Adorabeezle
Winterpop
Wreck-It Ralph: Duncan
Wreck-It Ralph: King Candy
Wreck-It Ralph: Gloyd Orangboar
Brave
Brave: Angus
BRAVE: Family – King Fergus, Queen
Elinor, Merida & Royal Triplets
Harris, Hubert & Hamish
Brave: General Art Guide
Tron: Legacy
Tron Legacy: Vertical Banner: Olivia
Tron Legacy: Vertical Banner: Jeff
Tron Legacy: Vertical Banner: Garrett
Frankenweenie
Frankenweenie: Bob
Frankenweenie: Edgar “E” Gore
Frankenweenie: Mr. Frankenstein
Planes
Princess and the Frog, The
Tangled
Frozen

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 20 -

Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Drawings
Style Guide
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Visual Material
Visual Material
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Visual Material
Visual Material
Motion Picture
Visual Material
Visual Material
Visual Material
Motion Picture
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Model Sheet
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

PA 1-038-178
PA 1-848-339
PA 1-146-502
PA 1-354-935
PA 1-703-137
VA 1-800-738
VA 1-831-654
VA 1-770-111
VA 1-802-675
VA 1-850-709
VA 1-766-270
VA 1-864-307

Monsters, Inc.
Disney Pixar Monsters University
Finding Nemo
Ratatouille
Tinker Bell and the Great Fairy
Rescue
Tinker Bell and the Great Fairy
Rescue-Global Creative P Fall 2010
Doc McStuffins-Global Creative PSS13
Disney Handy Manny-Tool Team
Product Design Portfolio-Preschool
Jake and the Neverland Pirates-Global
Creative B Preschool FA12 (Disney Jr)
Disney Sofia the First-Global Creative
P FH13
Phineas and Ferb Branding Guide
Global Creative Boys FA11
Disney The Muppets Character Art &
Photography Guide

12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 21 -

Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Motion Picture
Style Guide
Style Guide
Style Guide
Style Guide
Style Guide
Style Guide
Style Guide

1

EXHIBIT D

2

DEI’S TRADEMARKS

3

Trademark
Trademark
Registration
Registration No.
Date

Trademark

Mark Drawing
Code

5

Mickey Mouse

Typed Drawing

3,115,395

7/11/2006

6

Mickey Mouse

Standard Character
Mark

3,767,849

3/30/2010

Mickey Mouse

Typed Drawing

3,006,349

10/11/2005

Mickey Mouse

Typed Drawing

0,315,056

7/17/1934

10

Mickey Mouse

Standard Character
Mark

3,750,188

2/16/2010

11

Mickey Mouse

Typed Drawing

1,152,389

4/28/1981

12

Mickey Mouse Head
Device

Design Only

2,781,693

11/11/2003

Minnie Mouse

Typed Drawing

3,102,338

6/06/2006

15

Minnie Mouse

3,767,850

3/30/2010

16

Minnie Mouse

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

3,740,338

1/19/2010

Minnie Mouse

Typed Drawing

3,002,502

9/27/2005

Pluto

Typed Drawing

1,152,383

4/28/1981

20

Pluto

Design Only

2,707,323

4/15/2003

21

Goofy

Typed Drawing

1,159,124

6/30/1981

22

Goofy

Design Only

2,721,608

6/3/2003

Donald Duck

Typed Drawing

1,161,868

7/21/1981

Donald Duck

Typed Drawing

3,150,077

9/26/2006

26

Daisy Duck

Design Only

2,704,890

4/8/2003

27

Disney

Typed Drawing

1,162,727

7/28/1981

4

7
8
9

13
14

17
18
19

23
24
25

28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 22 -

1

Disney

Typed Drawing

3,490,082

8/19/2008

Disney Princess

Standard Character
Mark

3,459,442

7/1/2008

Walt Disney

Typed Drawing

1,141,312

11/11/1980

3,584,878

3/3/2009

2
3
4
5
6

Walt Disney Signature Standard Character
Mark
Winnie the Pooh

Typed Drawing

3,024,287

12/6/2005

Pooh

Typed Drawing

3,395,652

3/11/2008

9

Piglet

Standard Character
Mark

4,118,780

3/27/2012

10

Tigger

Design Only

2,860,445

7/6/2004

Eeyore

Design Only

3,591,616

3/17/2009

Eeyore

Typed Drawing

3,464,628

7/8/2008

3,658,573

7/21/2009

3,057,988

2/7/2006

2,891,463

10/5/2004

2,895,966

10/19/2004

3,775,134

4/13/2010

3,745,492

2/2/2010

2,895,967

10/19/2004

3,662,111

7/28/2009

3,648,929

7/20/2006

3,636,910

6/9/2009

3,624,833

5/19/2009

7
8

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27

Standard Character
Mark
Design Plus
Walt Disney’s Cinderella Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Walt Disney’s Snow
Design Plus
White & the Seven
Words, Letters,
Dwarfs
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Walt Disney’s Sleeping Words, Letters,
Beauty
and/or Numbers
Standard Character
Sleeping Beauty
Mark
Standard Character
Peter Pan
Mark
Design Plus
Walt Disney’s Peter Pan Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Standard Character
Peter Pan
Mark
Standard Character
Tinker Bell
Mark
Standard Character
Tinker Bell
Mark
Eeyore

Tinker Bell

Design Only

28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 23 -

1

Tink

Typed Drawing

3,734,512

1/5/2010

Hannah Montana

3,478,026

7/29/2008

3,413,555

4/15/2008

3,473,757

7/22/2008

Hannah Montana

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

3,413,552

4/15/2008

Lilo & Stitch

Typed Drawing

2,811,097

2/3/2004

9

Lilo & Stitch

Typed Drawing

2,845,107

5/25/2004

10

Pinocchio

Serial Number
77618061
Serial Number
77625073

n/a

3,358,115

12/18/2007

3,178,664

11/28/2006

3,370,157

1/15/2008

3,406,600

4/1/2008

3,294,617

9/18/2007

Doc Hudson

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

3,321,900

10/23/2007

Toy Story

Typed Drawing

2,520,404

12/18/2001

22

Toy Story

3,971,114

5/31/2011

23

Ariel

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

3,814,910

7/6/2010

24

Beauty and the Beast

Typed Drawing

2,961,693

6/14/2005

Princess Jasmine

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

3,998,366

7/19/2011

Serial Number
85,182,806

n/a

2
3
4

Hannah Montana

5

Hannah Montana

6
7
8

11

Pinocchio

12
13
14

Cars
Cars

15
16

Lightning McQueen

17

Mater

18

Rust-Eze

19
20

n/a

21

25
26
27

Princess Jasmine

28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 24 -

1

14

Wall-E

15

Handy Manny

16

Handy Manny

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

Minnie Mouse

Design Only

3,580,907

2/24/2009

Mickey Mouse

Design Only

3,580,903

2/24/2009

20

Mickey Mouse Device

Design Only

2,993,058

11/18/2003

21

Princess and the Frog

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers

3,891,449

12/14/2010

3,729,994

12/22/2009

4,106,086

2/28/2012

Serial No.
85928858

Filed:
5/10/2013

Serial No.
85887190

Filed:
3/26/2013

High School Musical

2
3

High School Musical

4

High School Musical

5

High School Musical

6

Meet the Robinsons

7
8

Meet the Robinsons

9

Walt Disney Pictures
Presents The Wild

10

Disney Bolt

11

Disney Bolt

12

Wall-E
13

3,506,572

9/23/2008

3,433,096

5/20/2008

3,420,394

10/24/2006

3,469,823

7/15/2008

3,420,082

4/29/2008

3,354,473

12/11/2007

3,389,689

2/26/2008

3,648,251

6/30/2009

3,604,222

4/7/2009

3,686,824

9/22/2009

3,528,986

11/4/2008

3,276,261

8/7/2007

3,643,979

6/23/2009

17
18
19

22

Princess and the Frog

23
24
25

Tangled
Disney Frozen

26

Doc McStuffins
27
28

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 25 -

1

Sofia the First

2
3
4

Sofia the First
Disney Jake and the
Never Land Pirates

5
6
7

Monsters University
Monsters University

8

Phineas and Ferb
9

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Standard Character
Mark

10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 26 -

4,478,451

2/4/2014

4,310,728

3/26/2013

Serial No.
86070387

Filed:
9/20/2013

4,486,434

2/18/2014

Serial No.
85275549

Filed:
3/24/2011

3,578,149

2/17/2009

1

EXHIBIT E

2

SANRIO CO.’S COPYRIGHTED DESIGNS

3

5

Title of Work (Character)

Type of Work

TX 3-769-888
VAu 684-322

SANRIO 1993 Product and Sales
Promotion Catalog
Sanrio 2005 Character Guide

VA 1-303-874

4

Copyright
Registration

Character Merchandising

VA 1-296-115
VA 811-440
VAu 498-617
VA 130-420
VA 636-579
VA 707-212
VA 246-421
VA 840-495
VA 130-419
VA 130-421
VA 636-582
VA 840-496
VA 636-580
VA 148-625
VA 840-494
VA 636-581
VA 1-352-721
Vau 1-078-385
VA 1-342-775
VA 657-748
VA 1-342-774
Vau 655-028

2004 – 100 Characters
Bad Badtz Maru
Chococat
Hello Kitty
KeroKeroKeroppi
KeroKeroKeroppi
Little Twin Stars
Monkichi
My Melody
Patty & Jimmy
Pekkle
Picke Bicke
Pochaco
Tuxedo Sam
Winkipinki
Zashikibuta
Keroppi / Little Frog…Big Splash
Sanrio 2010 Character Guide
SANRIO 2002 HELLO KITTY
STYLE GUIDE
KOBUTA NO PIPPO
SANRIO 2005 KEROPPI STYLE
GUIDE
THE RUNABOUTS - 2001
TENORIKUMA(BLUE CAFE),
MY MELODY(HEART),
KUROMI(KUROMI5),
CHARMMY KITTY(RABBIT),
HELLO KITTY(LOGO)
EVERYDAY CAT.JUNE 2006
MASYUMARU(INTRO);
CINNAMOROLL(SPORT);
SUGARBUNNIES(DOUGHNUTS);
CHARMMYKITTY(RABBIT);
LITTLE TWIN STARS(STARS);
HELLO KITTY(BEAR);
EVERYDAY CATALOG JULY
2006

Literary Work
Graphic Artwork
Collective work of
artwork, text and
photos
Graphic Artwork
Graphic Artwork
Art original
Graphic Artwork
Sticker Book
Pictorial Cartoon
Drawing
Stickers
Graphic Artwork
Graphic Artwork
Graphic Artwork
Graphic Artwork
Graphic Artwork
Sticker Book
Stickers
Graphic Artwork
Stickers
Visual Material
Visual Material
Visual Material
Visual Material
Visual Material
Visual Material

6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22

VA 1-416-374

23
24
25
26
27
28

VA 1-416-375

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 27 -

Visual Material

Visual Material

1
2

VA 1-370-020

3
4

VA 1-303-873

PANDAPPLE(INTRO),
FROOLIEMEW(FANCY),
CHOCOCAT(DOT)/SANRIO 2005
PRODUCT CATALOG AUG NEW
DOKIDOKI HOTDOG / THE
CHILI PEPPER TRIO / CATALOG
EVERYDAY 5 MAY 2003

5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 28 -

Visual Material
Visual Material

1

EXHIBIT F

2

SANRIO’S TRADEMARKS

3
4
5

Trademark
Chococat

6
7
8

Chococat
Chococat

9
10
11

Chococat
Chococat

12

Mark Drawing
Code
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers

Trademark
Trademark
Registration
Registration No.
Date
2,842,707

5/18/04

2,707,592

4/15/03

2,705,164

4/8/03

2,714,130

5/6/03

2,952,043

5/17/05

2,845,315

5/25/04

13

Chococat

14

Hello Kitty

Design Only

1,200,083

7/6/82

Hello Kitty

Design Only

1,277,721

5/15/84

Hello Kitty

Typed Drawing

1,215,436

11/9/82

18

Hello Kitty

Typed Drawing

1,279,486

5/29/84

19

Hello Kitty

Typed Drawing

1,391,550

4/29/86

Hello Kitty

Design Only

1,370,105

11/12/85

Keroppi

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

3,531,383

11/11/08

3,531,382

11/11/08

3,181,349

12/5/06

3,436,548

5/27/08

3,181,348

12/5/06

3,181,347

12/5/06

15
16
17

20
21
22
23

Keroppi

24

Keroppi

25

Keroppi

26

Keroppi
27
28

Keroppi

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 29 -

1

3,449,938

6/17/08

3,531,381

11/11/08

3,531,380

11/11/08

3,423,288

5/6/08

Keroppi

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

3,181,345

12/5/06

Little Twin Stars

Typed Drawing

1,341,864

6/18/85

9

Little Twin Stars

Typed Drawing

1,192,946

4/6/82

10

Little Twin Stars

3,245,998

5/29/07

3,245,997

5/29/07

3,245,994

5/29/07

3,245,993

5/29/07

3,245,992

5/29/07

3,245,991

5/29/07

Monkichi

Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark
Standard Character
Mark

3,699,381

10/20/09

My Melody

Typed Drawing

1,305,637

11/20/84

20

My Melody

Typed Drawing

1,210,192

9/28/82

21

Pekkle

Typed Drawing

2,053,346

4/15/97

Pochacco

Typed Drawing

2,236,507

4/6/99

Pochacco

Typed Drawing

1,985,358

7/9/96

Sanrio

Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers

2,506,705

11/13/01

Sanrio

Typed Drawing

2,506,577

11/13/01

Sanrio

Design Plus
Words, Letters,

2,721,680

6/3/03

Keroppi

2
3

Keroppi

4

Keroppi

5

Keroppi

6
7
8

11

Little Twin Stars

12

Little Twin Stars
13
14

Little Twin Stars

15

Little Twin Stars

16

Little Twin Stars

17
18
19

22
23
24
25
26
27
28

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 30 -

and/or Numbers

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11

Design Plus
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Sanrio
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Sanrio
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
Design Plus
Sanrio
Words, Letters,
and/or Numbers
KEROKEROKEROPPI Standard Character
Mark
KEROKEROKEROPPI Standard Character
Mark
Sanrio

2,742,381

7/29/03

2,721,679

6/3/03

2,693,639

3/4/03

2,696,063

3/11/03

3,531,378

11/11/2008

3,531,376

11/11/2008

Bow

Design only

3,260,857

7/10/2007

Bow

Design only

3,359,800

12/25/2007

14

Bow

Design only

3,359,801

12/25/2007

15

Bow

Design only

3,272,377

7/31/2007

16

Bow

Design only

3,260,860

7/10/2007

Bow

Design only

3,362,512

1/1/2008

Bow

Design only

3,348,608

12/4/2007

20

Bow

Design only

3,249,704

6/5/2007

21

Bow

Design only

3,362,514

1/1/2008

Bow

Design only

3,359,799

12/25/2007

Bow

Design only

3,260,858

7/10/2007

25

Bow

Design only

3,445,304

6/10/2008

26

Bow

Design only

3,260,859

7/10/2007

Bow

Design only

3,359,802

12/25/2007

12
13

17
18
19

22
23
24

27
28

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 31 -

1

Bow

Design only

3,260,861

7/10/2007

Bow

Design only

3,253,794

6/19/2007

4

Outline of Hello Kitty

Design only

3,666,736

8/11/2009

5

Outline of Hello Kitty

Design only

3,756,724

3/9/2010

Outline of Hello Kitty

Design only

3,751,315

2/23/2010

Outline of Hello Kitty

Design only

3,868,138

10/26/2010

9

Outline of Hello Kitty

Design only

3,756,725

3/9/2010

10

Outline of Hello Kitty

Design only

3,666,736

8/11/2009

Outline of Hello Kitty

Design only

3,679,187

9/8/2009

Outline of Hello Kitty

Design only

3,865,208

10/19/2010

2
3

6
7
8

11
12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28

DC Comics, et al. v. Santoyo: Stipulated Consent Decree

- 32 -