Opera Gallery Trading Ltd et al. vs. Golden Trade Fine Art Inc et al.

Filing 117

JUDGMENT RE DEFENDANTS, NATHALIE BIJU-DUVAL AND TUBIN ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, P.C.'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT by Judge Stephen V. Wilson: IT IS ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Plaintiffs, OPERA GALLERY TRADING LTD., a Cyprus limited liabilit y company; and NAJELL INVESTMENTS LTD., a Cyprus limited liability company, as trustee of THE GLOBAL ART PRIVATE TRUST, a Cyprus trust, take nothing as against Defendants, NATHALIE BIJU-DUVAL and RUBIN ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, P.C., and the action be dismissed as against Defendants, NATHALIE BIJU-DUVAL and RUBIN ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, P.C. on the merits, and that Defendants NATHALIE BIJUDUVAL and RUBIN ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL, P.C. recover their costs. (MD JS-6, Case Terminated). (cr)

l

~.ERif U.S. ►~+3~PiLT f'OUR1

2

SEP 2 ? 2016

3

DlSTRlCT tlF CALfF

4

~_
~ ~'

5
Priority ---~-S~nd
E.itter
~—
C losed
argilS-6 .~--

6
7
8

LTNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT
9

JS-~-~s-~ --ScanOnly

—

CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA (WESTERN)
l0
OPERA GALLERY TRADING LTD., a
Cypros limited liability company;and
12 NAJELL INVESTMENTS LTD., a
Cyprus limited liability company, as
13 trustee of THE GLOBAL ART
i PRIVATE TRUST, a Cyprus trust,
11

14

Plaintiffs,
15

vs.
16

GOLDEN TRADE FINE ART INC., a
New York corporation; and GAILORD
BOVRISSE, an individual; NATHALIE
18 A. BIJU-DUVAL; RUBIN
ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL,
19 P.C., a New York professional
corporation, and Does 3 through 10,
17

Case No.: 2:15-CV-00569-SVW (KSx)
SAC Filed: 07-27-2015
TAC 'led: 11-OS-2015
[P~.QS~D] JUDGMENT RE:
DEFENDANTS, NATHALIE
BIJU-DUVAL and RUBIN
ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL,
P.C.'S MOTION FOR SUMMARY
JUDGMENT
Hearing Date: June 27, 2016

2
0
21

This action came on for hearing before the Court on June 27, 2016, the Honorable

22
23

Stephen V. Wilson, District Judge Presiding, on a Motion for Summary Judgment

24

brought by Defendants, NATHALIE BIJU-DUVAL and RUBIN ASSOCIATES

25

I
NTERNATIONAL, P.C. After the evidence presented having been fully considered,

2
6

the issues having been duly heard, and a decision having been duly rendered,

27

///

28

9fi6-5345-(KIUI
1

[PROPOSED] JUDGMENT RE:
DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT

1

IT IS ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that the Plaintiffs, OPERA GALLERY

2

TRADING LTD., a Cyprus limited liability company; and NAJELL INVESTMENTS

3

LTD., a Cyprus limited liability company, as trustee of THE GLOBAL ART PRIVATE

4

TRUST, a Cyprus trust, take nothing as against Defendants, NATHALIE BIJU-DUVAL

5

and RUBIN ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL,P.C., and the action be dismissed as

6

against Defendants, NATHALIE BIJU-DUVAL and RUBIN ASSOCIATES

7

INTERNATIONAL,P.C. on the merits, and that Defendants NATHALIE BIJU-

8

DUVAL and RUBIN ASSOCIATES INTERNATIONAL,P.C. recover their costs.

9
10

11

DATED:

~2/G~
THE
ORABLE,STEPHEN V. WILSON
U.S. District Judge

12
13
14
15
16
17
18
19
2
0
21
22
23
24
25
2
6
27
28

s
~~x~~i

-2-

[PROPOSED]JUDGMENT RE:
DEFENDANTS' MOTION FOR SUMMARY JUDGMENT