Dina Elkin v. New York Life Insurance Company et al

Filing 20

ORDER PROTECTING CONFIDENTIALITY OF DOCUMENTS AND INFORMATION by Magistrate Judge Alexander F. MacKinnon. Re Stipulation for Protective Order 19 . (ib)

1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

9

CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

10
11
12
13
14
15

Case No. 2:16-cv-8703-DSF-AFM

DINA ELKIN,
Plaintiff,

ORDER PROTECTING
CONFIDENTIALITY OF
DOCUMENTS AND
INFORMATION

vs.
NEW YORK LIFE INSURANCE
COMPANY; and DOES 1 to 50,
Inclusive,

Complaint Filed: October 5, 2016

Defendants.

16
17
18
19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1
300155703v1 0992591

1
2

ORDER OF CONFIDENTIALITY
Good cause having been shown within the parties’ Stipulation of

3

Confidentiality of documents to be produced in this action (the “Stipulation”), the

4

Court hereby orders that the handling of confidential, proprietary and/or trade secret

5

documents or information in this case shall be governed by the terms of the

6

Stipulation as follows:

7

This Court, having reviewed this Stipulation and Proposed Order Protecting

8

Confidentiality of Documents and Information (the “Stipulation and Proposed

9

Order”) through the parties’ respective counsel, being fully advised in the premises,

10

and good cause appearing therefor, hereby orders that the Stipulation and Proposed

11

Order is GRANTED, and enters the following Order Protecting Confidentiality of

12

Documents and Information (“Protective Order”) on the terms set forth below:

13

1.

In this action, the Plaintiff, the Defendants and Long Term Care Group

14

(collectively, the “Parties”) anticipate producing and seeking production of

15

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION (as defined in Paragraph 3 below) during

16

discovery and that there will be questioning concerning CONFIDENTIAL

17

INFORMATION in the course of depositions. The Parties assert the disclosure of

18

such information outside the scope of this litigation could result in significant injury

19

to one or more of the Parties’ business interests and to other individuals’ privacy

20

interests. The Parties request the Court enter the within Protective Order for the

21

purpose of preventing the disclosure and use of CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION

22

except as set forth herein.

23
24

SCOPE:
2.

This Protective Order governs the handling of all documents (within

25

the meaning of Rule 34 of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure), testimony and all

26

other information, including copies, excerpts, and summaries thereof produced in

27

this action.

28
2
300155703v1 0992591

1
2

DEFINITIONS:
3.

For purposes of this Protective Order, “CONFIDENTIAL

3

INFORMATION” means any business, financial, personal and proprietary

4

information that is not generally known to the public and that the “Producing Party”

5

would normally maintain in confidence and not reveal to the general public,

6

including any and all information protected by HIPAA, the HITECH Act, and

7

regulations promulgated thereunder. Any information that is derived from

8

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION also constitutes CONFIDENTIAL

9

INFORMATION to the extent the derived information embodies, contains, or

10

discloses any CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION. The attorneys each agree not to

11

designate material as “CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION” unless he or she is

12

satisfied that they can demonstrate good faith reasons for treating the information in

13

this fashion. Notwithstanding the foregoing, CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION

14

does not include:

15

(a)

16

general public;

17

(b)

18

furnished or produced to the Receiving Party outside the course of any

19

proposed business relationship the Receiving Party may have had with the

20

Producing Party; or

21

(c)

22

from legitimate sources outside of any business relationship the Receiving

23

Party may have had with the Producing Party, (ii) was independently

24

developed by the Receiving Party, or (iii) was received after the time of

25

disclosure hereunder from a third party having the right to make such

26

disclosure and was not required to be held in confidence.

27

Nothing in this Protective Order is intended either (1) to provide a party with

28

any information which at the time of disclosure is available to the

any information which at the time of disclosure had already been

any information which (i) was already known to the Receiving Party

a basis for a claim against an opposing party for disclosing to any non-party, prior to
3
300155703v1 0992591

1

the date of disclosure in this Action, any CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION or (2)

2

to supersede, usurp, or replace any confidentiality obligations owed by one party to

3

the other party or to non-parties which may have existed prior to entry of this Order.

4

4.

For purposes of this Protective Order, “Producing Party” means a party

5

to this action or any non-party on behalf of which information is furnished or

6

produced during the course of this action.

7

5.

For purposes of this Protective Order, “Receiving Party” means a party

8

to this action or any non-party to which information is furnished or produced during

9

the course of this action.

10
11

6.

The term “documents” shall have the same meaning as set forth in Rule

34(a)(1) of the Federal Rules of Civil Procedure.

12

DESIGNATION OF INFORMATION:

13

7.

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION shall be designated as follows:

14

(a)

Any Producing Party may stamp documents “CONFIDENTIAL” prior

15

to production in this action.

16

(b)

17

including exhibits, which contains CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, may

18

be made by a statement to such effect on the record during the course of the

19

deposition. Portions of deposition transcripts may also be designated as

20

CONFIDENTIAL within 14 days after receipt of the transcript by counsel for

21

the person whose CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION was disclosed at the

22

depositions by serving on all other parties to the action a letter designating by

23

page and line number the portion or portions of the deposition transcript

24

containing CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION. Until the 14-day period has

25

expired, the full deposition testimony and transcript shall be treated in its

26

entirety as CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION covered by the Protective

27

Order.

28

When the CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION designation is made with

In the case of depositions, designation of the portion of the transcript,

4
300155703v1 0992591

1

respect to any portion of a deposition, the party making the designation shall direct

2

the reporter attending such deposition to affix the appropriate confidentiality legend

3

to the first page and all portions of the original and all copies of the transcript

4

containing any CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION.

5

8.

If any transcripts of depositions, motions, briefs or other pleadings that

6

are to be filed with this Court (a “Filing”) include CONFIDENTIAL

7

INFORMATION, such pleadings or other papers shall be filed under seal with this

8

Court.

9

trial, and use of confidential information at trial shall be governed by orders of the

10

trial judge. This Protective Order and the designation of material as “confidential”

11

does not entitle the parties to file material under seal. The parties acknowledge the

12

requirements of Civil Local Rule 79-5.2 and acknowledge that good cause to file

13

under seal must be established by submission of competent evidence via declaration

14

establishing that the material sought to be filed under seal qualifies as confidential,

15

privileged or otherwise protectable.

16

This Protective Order does not govern use of confidential information at

9.

Designation of any documents, things, or information as

17

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION renders confidential any originals, copies,

18

excerpts, summaries, quotations or paraphrases of such materials by the Receiving

19

Party.

20

10.

All material which is designated by the Producing Party as containing

21

or comprising CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION shall be maintained in

22

confidence according to the terms of this Protective Order by the Receiving Party

23

and used solely in the preparation, prosecution, defense, or trial of this action.

24

11.

Subject to the provisions of this Protective Order, CONFIDENTIAL

25

INFORMATION shall not, without the consent of the Producing Party or further

26

Order of the Court, be disclosed except that such CONFIDENTIAL

27

INFORMATION may be disclosed to:

28

(a)

attorneys actively working on this case;
5
300155703v1 0992591

1

(b)

persons regularly employed or associated with the attorneys actively

2

working on this case whose assistance is required by said attorneys in

3

the preparation for trial, at trial, or at other proceedings in this case;

4

(c)

the parties, including the parties’ respective officers, directors, and

5

employees whose assistance is required by the parties’ respective

6

attorneys for preparation, trial, or other proceedings in this case;

7

(d)

consultants and expert witnesses retained in connection with this

8

proceeding, to the extent such disclosure is necessary for preparation,

9

trial, or other proceedings in this case;

10

(e)

this Court and its employees (“Court Personnel”);

11

(f)

stenographic reports who are engaged in proceedings necessarily

12

incident to the conduct of this action;

13

(g)

deponents, witnesses, or potential witnesses;

14

(h)

copy or other document service providers hired to assist counsel in this

15
16

litigation;
(i)

17
18

mock jurors, focus group members and the like selected by trial
consultants, jury consultants or by counsel in preparation for trial;

(j)

19

any mediator specifically retained by the parties to mediate the case;
and

20

(k)

other persons by written agreement of the parties.

21

12.

Prior to disclosing any CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION to any

22

person listed in Subparagraphs 11(d), (g), (h), (i), and (j) above, counsel shall

23

provide such person with a copy of this Protective Order and obtain from such

24

person a written acknowledgment in the form attached as Exhibit A to this

25

Protective Order stating that he or she has read this Protective Order and agrees to

26

be bound by its provisions. All acknowledgments shall be retained by such counsel

27

and shall be subject to in camera review by the Court if good cause for review is

28

demonstrated by opposing counsel.
6
300155703v1 0992591

1
2

EXCEPTIONS:
13.

The receipt of any document, thing, pleading, or response to any

3

interrogatory designated as CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION by a party shall not

4

be construed as an agreement by any party that any such document, thing, pleading,

5

or response to an interrogatory is in fact confidential, and shall not operate as a

6

waiver of any party’s right to challenge any such designation as provided herein.

7

14.

If the Receiving Party objects to the designation of certain information

8

as CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, he or she shall inform the Producing Party’s

9

counsel, in writing, of the specific grounds of the objections to the designations. All

10

counsel shall then in good faith and on an informal basis attempt to resolve such

11

disputes. If the parties cannot resolve the dispute, the party disputing the

12

confidentiality designation may file an appropriate motion with the Court at any

13

time to deem the disputed material not confidential. The Producing Party shall have

14

the burden of establishing the propriety of the designation.

15

15.

No party shall be obligated to challenge the propriety or correctness of

16

the designation of information as CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION and a failure

17

to do so shall not preclude a subsequent challenge of a designation.

18

16.

Neither the taking of nor the failure to take any action to challenge any

19

designation of CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION pursuant to this Protective Order

20

or to enforce the provisions of this Protective Order shall constitute a waiver of any

21

right, claim, or defense by any party in this action or any other action.

22
23

INFORMATION INADVERTENTLY DISCLOSED:
17.

If a Producing Party inadvertently discloses to a Receiving Party any

24

document, thing, or information containing information that the Producing Party

25

deems CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION without designating it as

26

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, the Producing Party shall promptly upon

27

discovery of such inadvertent disclosure inform the Receiving Party in writing and

28

the Receiving Party shall thereafter treat the document, thing, or information as
7
300155703v1 0992591

1

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION under this Protective Order. To the extent such

2

document, thing, or information may have been disclosed to persons other than

3

authorized persons described in this Protective Order, the Receiving Party shall

4

make every reasonable effort to retrieve the document, thing, or information

5

promptly from such persons and to prevent any further disclosure to unauthorized

6

persons.

7

18.

If the Producing Party inadvertently discloses to a Receiving Party

8

information that is protected from disclosure because it is privileged or subject to

9

the work product doctrine, the Producing Party shall promptly, upon discovery of

10

such disclosure, so advise the Receiving Party in writing and request that the item or

11

items of information be returned, and no party to this action shall hereafter assert

12

that such disclosure waived any privilege or work product protection. It is further

13

agreed that the Receiving Party will make every reasonable effort to return such

14

inadvertently produced item or items of information, and all copies thereof, within

15

ten (10) days of receiving a written request for the return of such item or items of

16

information.

17

19.

It is understood that no person or party shall incur liability with respect

18

to any disclosure by the Receiving Party of CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION that

19

was inadvertently disclosed without proper designation by the Producing Party,

20

provided the disclosure by the Receiving Party occurred prior to the receipt by the

21

Receiving Party of a written notice of the inadvertent disclosure without proper

22

designation.

23

20.

If CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION is disclosed in violation of this

24

Order, the party who caused, permitted, or was otherwise responsible for the

25

disclosure shall immediately inform the other party to this action of all pertinent facts

26

relating to the disclosure, and shall make every effort to prevent any further

27

disclosure, including any disclosure by any person who received any

28

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION in violation of this Order.
8
300155703v1 0992591

1
2

TERMINATION OF LITIGATION OR SETTLEMENT:
21.

Within 90 days of the conclusion or final settlement of this action and

3

any appeal, all persons subject to the terms hereof shall destroy or assemble and

4

return to the party who produced the CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, all such

5

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, including depositions and deposition exhibits

6

designated as CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, and all copies thereof; and shall

7

destroy any outlines, summaries, abstracts, compilations, memoranda, documents

8

and the like which constitute, embody, contain, or disclose the contents of

9

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION; except that counsel for the parties may retain

10

in their files, subject to their usual document retention and destruction policies, an

11

archival copy of the production documents, deposition transcripts, deposition

12

exhibits, Court filings and attorney work-product containing CONFIDENTIAL

13

INFORMATION, which materials will otherwise remain subject to this Protective

14

Order. The parties shall notify and advise the producing party whether they plan to

15

destroy or assemble and return to the producing party the CONFIDENTIAL

16

INFORMATION. If a party elects to destroy any information that constitutes

17

“protected health information” within the meaning of HIPAA, the HITECH Act, and

18

regulations promulgated thereunder and CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION within

19

the meaning of this Stipulation and Proposed Order (“PHI-CONFIDENTIAL

20

INFORMATION”), then such destruction will be in accordance with HIPAA, the

21

HITECH Act, and regulations promulgated thereunder. If a party elects to retain

22

any PHI-CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION in accordance with that party’s

23

document retention policies, then such retention will be in accordance with HIPAA,

24

the HITECH Act, and regulations promulgated thereunder.

25
26

ADDITIONAL PROTECTION OF CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION:
22.

Nothing in the foregoing provisions of the Protective Order shall be

27

deemed to preclude any party from seeking and obtaining, on an appropriate

28

showing, additional protection with respect to the confidentiality of documents or
9
300155703v1 0992591

1

other discovery material, or relief from this Protective Order with respect to

2

particular material designated hereunder.

3
4

PRODUCTION OF CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION BY NON-PARTIES:
23.

The production of any CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION by non-

5

parties shall be subject to all the terms and conditions of this Protective Order.

6

Pursuant to this Protective Order, a non-party shall be considered to be a Producing

7

Party and shall have the same rights as the parties to designate information as

8

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION and the same rights to object to disclosures of

9

their CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION to individuals or businesses other than

10

those set forth herein.

11
12
13
14

OBLIGATIONS OF PARTIES:
24.

The parties are prohibited from using or disclosing PHI-

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION for any purpose other than this case.
25.

If another court, administrative agency, or any person or entity

15

subpoenas or orders production or disclosure of CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION

16

which a party has obtained under the terms of this Protective Order, such party shall

17

within three (3) business days notify in writing the Producing Party (either directly

18

or through counsel) who produced the CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION of the

19

pending subpoena or order. Nothing in this Protective Order shall be construed as

20

prohibiting production of CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION covered by this

21

Protective Order in response to a lawful subpoena or Court Order.

22

26.

Each of the parties named above and their counsel of record undertake

23

to abide by and be bound by its provisions and to use due care to see that its

24

provisions are known and adhered to by those under their supervision or control.

25

27.

Nothing in this Protective Order shall bar counsel from rendering

26

advice to their client with respect to this litigation and, in the course thereof, relying

27

upon any CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION, provided counsel does not disclose

28

CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION in a manner not specifically authorized under
10
300155703v1 0992591

1
2

this Protective Order.
28.

This Protective Order shall not abrogate or diminish any contractual,

3

statutory, or other legal privilege or protection of any party or person with respect to

4

any CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION. The fact that any materials have been

5

designated CONFIDENTIAL INFORMATION pursuant to this Protective Order

6

shall not affect or operate as a means of objection to the admissibility of any such

7

material; nor shall such designation constitute the authentication of such material or

8

a waiver of any right to challenge the relevance, confidentiality, or admissibility of

9

such material. The fact that materials are designated as CONFIDENTIAL

10

INFORMATION pursuant to the Protective Order shall not affect what a trier of fact

11

in this litigation or any other proceeding may find to be confidential or proprietary.

12
13

EFFECT OF ORDER:
29.

This Protective Order shall remain in full force and effect unless

14

modified by an Order of the Court. Without limiting the generality of the foregoing,

15

this Protective Order shall survive or remain in full force and effect after the

16

termination of this litigation. Nothing in this Protective Order shall limit or preclude

17

any party from applying to the Court for relief from this Protective Order, or for

18

such further or additional protective orders as the Court may deem appropriate.

19

30.

Stipulations may be made, between counsel for the respective parties

20

and Producing Parties, as to the application of this Protective Order to specific

21

situations (e.g., documents which are so voluminous that it would be overly

22

burdensome to mark each page thereof individually) provided that such stipulations

23

are recorded in writing or contained in the record of any oral proceeding.

24
25

This Court shall retain jurisdiction over this Protective Order and the parties
for purposes of enforcing the terms of this Order.

26
27
28

Dated: 7/10/2017

________________________________
ALEXANDER F. MACKINNON
U.S. MAGISTRATE JUDGE
11
300155703v1 0992591

1

EXHIBIT A

2

The undersigned ___________________________________ (print or type

3

name of person) hereby acknowledges that he or she received a copy of the ORDER

4

PROTECTING CONFIDENTIALITY OF DOCUMENTS AND INFORMATION

5

(“PROTECTIVE ORDER”) entered in the case entitled Dina Elkin v. New York Life

6

Insurance Company, Case Number 2:16-cv-8703-DSF-AFM, pending in the United

7

States District Court for Central District of California, has read the PROTECTIVE

8

ORDER, agrees to be bound by all the provisions thereof, and hereby submits to the

9

jurisdiction of the Court for the purpose of enforcement of the terms of the

10

PROTECTIVE ORDER.

11
12
13

Dated:________________

________________________________

14

[Signature]

15

________________________________

16

________________________________

17

________________________________

18

[Address]

19
20
21
22
23
24
25
26
27
28
12
300155703v1 0992591