Brighton Collectibles, LLC v. Publishers Clearing House, LLC

Filing 46

PROTECTIVE ORDER by Magistrate Judge John E. McDermott re Joint NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION for Order for Entry of Stipulated Protective Order 45 . [See Order for details.] (san)

Case

L"7-cv-C12327-TJH-JElN Doc:~ai~~i~f 45-1 F~iiec~ ~C~~ _~~~~_ ~

,=~~c Z of 12 Page ID #:183

1 BROWNE GEORGE,ROSS LLP
Peter W. Ross (State Bar No. 109741)
ross c b rfirm.com
Kept
es ey tate Bar No. ?_29276)
3 ' ~ kwesley(a,bgrfitm.com
1 venue oft e ,tars, Suite 2800
~~ Los Angeles, California 900b7
Telephone:[phone]
Facsimile: (310} 275-5697
6 ' Attorneys for Plaintiff Brighton
'Collectibles, LLC
~
~~
8 ~ '~

UNITED STATES DIS~I:~:~C''~~' COURT

9

CErJ~ R~L Y)1STIZICT C►F rAL~IFOR~~i~, WESTERN DIVISION
,

10 ~ '.
11 BRIGI-~TOtJ (;'OLLECTIF~LES, LLC, a
Delaware limited liability company,
1?
Plaintiff,
1.3

Cap::: :ti~ ~~ . 2:l7-cv-02327 TJH (JEMx)
H~r~~. "T~-zry J. Matter
Magi Utz ate John E. McDermott

1~ ~
`~s.
', PLT~3LISHEkS CLEARING HOUSE,
1` ~ LLC ~ Ne~~~ York lim~t~~ ]i~t~ility
company~,~ A.STRfa II~ITERNATIUNAL.,,
1 ~ ~ II~'C., ~ New Xork co, oration; LF
PROI)tiCTS PTE L`~"'~, a Singapore
~ 7 ' ~;~~rl~~r~_tiot~.,

Ue-~c~ ~.;r°

d~ Stipulated Protective
Ma~~~t,• tte .dudge:
Hoi~, ~c~~~n E. ~~icDermott

Defea~e~ar~ts.

1
l~ ',
2:?
21 ~ ~
`~
7g
7y

'~ C

~~ j

2~
?F
_
~' 955 i ~C

Lase No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH (JEMx)
[Proposed] Stipulated Pro dfive U~•der

Cass ? 17-cv-0`7 ~7-Z.7H-.~~M Do _:4_a~n~nt 45-1 f=~le~! `.~,`;' f' r' f~=~~~ 2 of 12 Page ID #:184
'

1;

The Court, finding that the order reque~t~;~l tiy~ the parties is proper and

2'; desirable in the circumstances of this casE, a7d ~;~c1:~~ cause appearing therefore,
3'pursuant to Rule 26(c) of the Federal Rules o~ C`'vi ~ Procedure, grants the parties'
4 Joint Motion for Entry of Protective Order and ;: apt ;s the fallowing Protective Order
5 for the benefit of all parties and witnesses and t~~ g,:~vem the course ofthe discovery
6 proceedings in this case:
"~ 1

1_ .

! '~

~'l~e fol lc►t~~in~; definiti~ans s~~l( ~;~; ~ ~ y~ ~~~ t~~~s T'r~otective Order:
~.

"E'~r*~~" sl~~all rraean. and reff~r i+;~ ~~~~riz,k~t~n Collectibles, LLC;

~~ ~' Publishers Cl~~ariria ~-Iouse LLC, A~stra Iii~~rn~: ~;~,~ - L, I~ic.; ~~~ LF Products PTE Ltd.
i
10

~.

"rontia~ntial Info~-m~~ri~_~~~" ~~~<~~I ~r,~.~~n =~~~d refer to any

11 ' ~n~e~r_m~i4ion that his r.at been made n~~hlic an+i ~ ~-~a~ +xisc~~~~ure of which may cause
12 harm to the person or entity from which the inf{ ~ :-m ~tion is obtained, including, but
1 ~ ',not limned to, eio~urn~en~s ~n~:~~r d~±a. th~1t - ,~ ; .~~' ~:r;e~ ~r~_ ~~od faith by the
1~ !designating ~~;~.rty to ~o~~titi~~te a. t}•ade s~~~~e~~ {~~

;~1~~Rn~+a' n (_'alifornia Civil Code §

1` ~ ~ 3~~~6.1), con:~~~~~:i,a~ inf~•~i~t:o~; an~'~~c~~~~ ,~7r~p~~~ ~~~E -~ 17a7sine~s or technical
1 ~ infc~-n~~~tion. ThE designs*l~r~ rr~.,~de 1-~~ ~ I'~;ay ~ ~ ~~_~z-, ~:t1-.- shall be a certification
1? ~ :~ the ~C~.~~~zrt c~.~l~d t~~► ~r:~~ ot',~er ;~~rt~~s th.+~ 9~.~~~~~~ :~x~ ~ ~ ~ztii~i~ =s believed in good faith to
~ ~ ~' ~~ cor~fidenti;3i ~vi`hin they meaning ~` this ~'rot~::~~i~~ -Order.
c.

~' I

"~~Tifi~Pn~ ~l fo~ ~~Lt~,r-- e~,~~

=, ~. ;~ ,-~r~Iy Information" shall mean

2~) ~~~~i ref:g~ try a.~^.y Conf~~!e-~iia' ~nf,rn-. =~titj~~ t; _~ ~

_ :~~,~ ~ ~.~f~ in good faith by the

2 c ` • :1e~.>ior~a.tiyz~ ~9tii-t~~ t~ ~e ~a~> }~~~~.3~- sensiti~,~ l~~.t

. ~~a.~~,~~-.~ t ,persons other than

22 ' r..i'.ed aid spvc~fi~;~ incli~-i~ili~1~. :~L'.~~? ~~<:u;E ~a

-i~3~ ,~ substantial and

'.r~~-..r_- ec~iate `.r~j~~ry to the l~~~sira~~s ~yf tl.~~ ~ro~i<i~~' _ ; ~~~. ~''-~e designation made by a
2 j ~ ~~isclr~sir~a p~,~ty ~t• ~~n--nart~~ shy'! b~ ~ :exti~~~ `Er>~ t~~ *.h~ Court and the other
;
2` pasties that s~ich info-rm~~~~c~r~ i~~ believe~:~ t~~ ~: ~ '~ ° ~~(,~E ~ ~~~t ~ bt~ve Confidential
2~I in~r~a:~~ti~~n end slab ~~~:+ trr *hip Fn~~ re3t~is ` ~.~, ' .~ ~~`~ ~+i~~n within the meaning of
2~' ~ ~i~is P~n~~cti~-~ (?r~~e~.
'i
2F'I
~
"~,a~lif~d FPrsor~s" e:~~+;+'e~ ` ° .ie<<.,~ csr• receive Confidential
i~' ''~'` ~'C1

~'
-i_
[Proposed; Stipulated Prom;ti, girder
.:.:

_~~se No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH (JEMx)

Casrg 2~i~7-c~,r-(~~ ;"t-~~[~,;~-i-JE~:~ ~otr~ar7~rnt 4'.~-"~ F=ileci ~Q;~' ~_ . f~ ~~a~~~ 3 of 12 Page ID #:185
i~
'i
i
1 ~ rnfor~mation 1~ot desi~nat~d Confidf,nii~.l fog- :'~~, v,~~~~,.y~s" ~'y~~,s Only Information shall
"~ ;
- ! be limited to:
k

3 ~

i.

Counsel to aT~y ~'a~~y ..:3 ~~ ,. Ii~ig~xion and those employees

4 ~ of the Parties' counsel w}io neeu9 t~ see ~ucf~ C~

~.~~riti~i Information in order to

5 perform their jobs, including the p~~ale~als, cl~; . ~:,t~. ,staff, secretarial staff, and other
~5 support personnel em~lo~~ed by such co~~nse1;
?

ii.

~'l~c~:~e offcer,,, .~i~~.~,~,

;~;n~ ~~~yees ofthe Parties to this

litigatica~n, i¢~~luding their ~~arents, subsidiaries, ~:~l~~a~.x~e~s and insurers, who are
n reasonably neressa~y to asse~fi r_niinsel ?~~ ~ .l~i~ ~i~~ ~,:;s~i~~~~~~;
1~

i~b..

~~y pa~~,;~n~, ~~~ld~~ a,~~~::~.~:;~ ~: _~ ~:;ro~~ ~~'~.ce ofthe Confidential

1 i ~ ~nfonnation as ~ author, ~i~l~iresseE~ ~~r.~,~-i~r ~f,~ o,~, .a_1~ ~~'_~e~re«f;
12 '

iF,.

E~,pert ti,ritn~~sE°~ ~~r c~.~,~s~k`.~a~rts retained or employed by

1; `_'~-~e ~v~rties or t~~ir r~_:spe~vii ~~~ ;~itotn e.~s ~~aif,a;- '~

, ~ ~: ~~~~.~~~c~~~e of assisting counsel in

1 ~~ ~ :'~e r;r~~~cc~:~~t~.~,n, ~;i~fe:~~se c~~ ~,ett~~,zner~t ~,~~~17~~~ li' a ,>~; ~~'~~c~ have complied with
1 5 ' pa~agra~h 2, ~~elar~, and tie em,~~a~~y:~t:~ ~;~~~~~;.t;

, .~~' ~~~ consultants who are

i ~E '' assisting them;
~fhe i `r~;t~cl 5*N~:t,~ , '~°' ri~ ~~'~ a~~~ rt "~+r the Central District of
~ ~' California and its p~rsorir~ ~', ~t~~ t~~nit ~c~ ~~tas~,~s ~" ,.: ~ cif ~pr~eals for the Ninth
1 ~:+ '~ 'ir~c~_~~~t .a~~ ins persc"~rne~~ 4~.~~~ .~.:rt~r ~rk~~r~~r c~;a~r~: ~o ~ ~

~~~~s+s ~~r urisdiction having

~ ) ~ !~_'J(~.~\' '~Z~~?lt lt1 ti~1:S ~lr'~.~tPOt? E~II~ 11~~ q)f~I'S~ 'tlr'_~-~~
2~

vi.

~'ti~ur* ~f:~o~ ~r~ ..~.r~~~ ~._ . '..~ ~~ a~~~~ video

~ -~ rcp~t~e~r,/~~i~rograph~rs who are ~Ptain~~~? ~c~ *,;~:
'~
_y tn~tt~d3~i~ ~~positio~~s, in tl~~s Lt'g~~tir~~x:<<

~w

~;

~t.

2~ !.~d~~p~!~„ire tl~~is litfvt ion; ~~~ ~,n~~ me .', ;'~~~ ~;v}- n ~
n

;,"' -,
^~T',~.-i ~*Cf~ ~?"' fl_;Pe;""l;r~° Cif C~e~ ~9~1'r1E'.~ 1i' ~;i ~~

`e~~ ~v ~~;deotapetestimony,

~~o ~ s~ssigned to hear and
~~~;. ~ ~,n mediate this litigation
' t;'i
"~t

settle this matter, and any

2~ . ~f their r~spe:.ti~~e p~rson~el~
2Y,

viii. ~1~✓~tnesse.5:t ~ r~~~ ~~r '°~ : ~-~ ~,~~- other proceeding in this
C
:;se No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH(JEMx)
(Proposed] SYiPuiaeed Pro~~ .ti ~ Order
:

Cass 2~i1~7-c:v-02321-;JN-i-JAM Uoe~..F~~~~~ilt 4~-1 1~fl~~~l ~ ~~ ~~~=~r`; ~ ~'ti~r~~ 4 of 12 Page ID #:186

1 j ~ act~c~n, during the couirse of their tes~i~~~r.y ~a~~c~ ,`:.: r~~~i~~~1~ss being advised ofthe
2 (need and agreeing to keep the record;; c,c~~;~;l~y;-~ :ai, ;~nci~-'ur
3 ~

ix.

4 ~

e.

Any other ~ers~~n to ~~ Aux ~ t42e ~'arties agree in writing.

"Qualiti~d P~rs~n "~~titl~~ ~~ ie~w car receive Confidential for

5 Attorneys' Eyes ~nl,y Inf€~rmation shell be lirni.,. ~, .,~.
6

i.

Counsel to ;.ny Warty ~~,:~ ~~~~~s litigation and those employees

? c~ftl~~E~ P~~~r~ie;s" c.c~~ns~~l ~~h~~~ i~zF.;cl ~~ s~ ~ <.~, ~~c:}~ ~'<.,~ ~i~ .~:i:~~t~,~l f~~Attorneys'Eyes Only
~ Info~
-nlatic~.:~ :~ order tc ~,~r-F~zr.~ ~r~,~~.~~ ~ ~'~::~, , ~~ ~ ~

~_ ~~; ~~; r~~aralegals, clerical staff,

~;~ secretarial staff, and other ;~u~p~►~rt pF~rs.~~.:z~l c~~.- ,:~° ..,~E.~ ~~; :-;~~ch counsel;
,
1~~ '

ii,

j_l~esi~;.~~tet~ ~rt~~~~~~.~~.sr~a ~;;~y~.~~s,~i ~~~'she Party who receives

11 tiff: docu.me~.t~ ("IT.~~;~ivi~a A~.i~*~") (1~ v~r~~ i~i~ ~: ~ ~;_, t:~~v~lvement in competitive
1 ~ decision-making, (2,)-to w'~om di~,cl~:;rarc is ry~.. , ~z~ :'~~.1~ ~=wcrssary for this litigation,
13

~ric~ 3 j ~~ 1~~r~ !-KGs r~g7ed ?]~c~ "~.r}~,r~ow'~ct~r;~~~-i~

ti~,~ E,.:~b-~~:ant to Be Bound"

y
l`

ii:.

f~,-_-✓ p~,rs~n~ ti~,:'- ,~ 7h~- .~~ t-. L;~. face ofthe Confidential

~ E for Attorneys' Eyes G~nl~~ ~.~,.fc~r; ~°~t~~ :;. ~: ~. ~~. c ~
~?

~~
l~

:"y?r- ~.~~.P or prior recipient

.
'
.~~ '.T~.rj1

~~~.

-~
=~:~,u, ~N-i`r~ .-~ ~~~ . .

~_~~;~ Parke n~~ who <~~a~ r:~t~irtr~~? ~~~- e~ ~~~~,~~,~=,1'~~.~
n

2'~~ ~ ~~t:>~n;~~~ s,l~~~~~ f~~r the ~ury~~s~ c~i~s~~s~~n ~, ~:d~~ ~
;
2 ~ settlem~n~ of this lit~~atiar~ ti~~~~~~ !~~.~~-.° ~ :~l~li~-~1
?r: E:mp1o~~~ es of such Q:Kpe~r~~ r~r ;,~ ,~i-~~.1r t- w '. ~
"
'a

`~u., t~ ~ ~ho are not employees o~
,
7~,

~ ~r their respective

;.r: ~~~t, ,r~rosecution, defense or
: ~ ~~:~~~r~r~~F~~h 2, below, and the
~ , -i~s~ ~-~em,to the e~ctent

?~o ~.c~~r;sr;, of ce-~.orc' in food faith believes s~i~~l~t ;~` ~~ . ~ ~~r~ i~ required to assist in the
?4 ,~rosecutic~n, defertse~ or re,~l~.~t?~~r~ ~f+!~i~'i~itr:~~ :
;
~.~

~'p~ e f:.'~ ~t~d ~t~t~R r':;

?< '~',~,~~.x.~:a ~l~~~ sts pe.~~:;orn~!, +hp 11ni* ,~' ~+qtr. `
,
~
.

~'~~ ~;-+ f,^r the Central District of
~ f ~,ap~als for the Ninth

_ ~rc;ui~ and it., persc~n~~d, ~~n _ ~n~~ , h ,r ~~.e~+ c " , ~~~; ~ ;-t ?°~risdiction having
,

28 ~m~~l~~~m~rt in this 1ltig~~t'c~r and ~r~. rP:.r~.;~- r;~r.
CLse No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH(JEMx)
"'~ ~`'-----~____ —i--------_ _
_ _,..
[
Proposed) Stipulated Pro`: ~;ri1 ~ OGder

~,; ,;

~7.r~,,~~~~-;, 7 T,;~~-J~Pv1 U~~~~~ ,~, ~a~,; ~~~_, l

Case
i
i
i

1

v~.

~°~,~,~ 5 of 12 Page ID #:187

court repo~tc.rs, ster~a~ ~ra~~~7ers, and video

reporters/vic~eographers who are retaii-ie~. t~ trar;~~~;~~~~~~~ car videotape testimony,
3 ~ including depositions, in this litigatic~r~;
vii.

Anv desigr9~tecl arbitr.ktar ~~v~~ ~s assigned to hear and

5 ' adjudicate this litigation, ar any mediatar who ►.~~ assigned to mediate this litigation
~ or consulted by agreement of the ~art~es ire any ~~tt~~E apt t~ settle this matter, and any
of their respective ~erson~iei;
'

'~

~1~1..

r .-,.
y
~~~~~1p~Jl..~J tai ~tl~i '~1~, ,~

}
'py6°

~~

~
. c~t~~,.r proceeding in this

~~ ~lr

';► ' ~~cticn, dut~in~ t~E~ c2tiurse ~~~';.hc~~r t~~,t:rrrony, wrfE+~~ ~~~1~►isel for a Party legitimately
1 ~ I believes may, might or coul~~ h~~ve ki~~-~-,:~~~:e ;~,~> L{~ a~,~~i. ,a-~~lt~rrts of the document
11 designated l~onfidential f:~r _~.tta.rrye;~~:: ~~,~~e;.~' ~)r~ ' ~ ,-,~- ~l~f:~ :,~~cific events,
12 t.ansactic~~~~, disc;~ass~ons, or ~~i;~ i•r"l +.t.~~ i~j `y,~; 1 ;.~~;~~,rit, and upon the witness
l:~ ~ ~eirig ac1~s~;~~~ c~#'the rie~c~ ~~c~ agr~~i~~ ~~~ %eE~.~,° ' ~~~ ~~~ccr~~ cflnfidential; and/or
1z~

i~_

15

?.

."~_rr~~ .~st~:~ ~r

>~a ~ ,, ~;~i=~ ~~~, ~' .~;ies agree in writing.

~'rc~rtc rec~ ~~i:~i~; ~ ~,f«;~~~~_<~tiiot: d::,~ ~: ~~~~~~" ;~s ~'cmfidential Information

1` ~;>r Confden*ial for A:':tor~r. ~~~~' F ti~~:;ti E~`~~~t~ Y,iI"r;~~~ ~ E. ~ ~~~, ;~1 (qualified Persons
1? ~ i~ie~~tifiE~~1 i1.i ?~ar~r~~r~~~Y~ 1(d), ~~1~~;~r~~~,~;~f~'~l ~;.~,~ ~ ~: ~. '_), ~~~ i:~), or Paragraph 1(e)~
~ b ~ ~i~L~~f~__~~~i.r~h~, (~~ , ~'~~)~ {~~~i')> ~c~r (_~.;~, _~ ~°~ " . ~:r ~
~r~,'~~:~r and sl;gill s'~~ _ ~~,v ~,-~_ ~? V~' ~ ~tF.~~ ^►:~:~u

:~ . : ~ ~r~, ~ a~ substantially the form

2t~ . ~ that appears in Exh'~~°t f~. '1~1~~ ~~~ ;~, is ,~ ~ `'~~~~~ ,
~.,
~ re~~iain in the ~~~.~.~se~ ~sz~- _

;~~~:~ a~.~~tl~l ~ copy of this Protective

~~~:~~:1 ~~~it~:en assurance shall

'_~ ~tt~ -i~~y r ~`~_ ., ~ l;~~: .k, ~ .tii~~>closure of the

7~ ~~r~~d~rnti=:~1 1nfo~~~r~~~-~~z, ~5- *I~i~~ ~'~~n~~.~i~.r~t'. ~ `'c

~ ~-,r,,,~~;~' _F,yes Only Information

2;
2'?~ ' !

,~

~`he >>rt~~ltict~,,~n ~` ~~r~~ ~

?.` ! I ~~- ~ ~-; ~~1 `~~r«~1 ~ 17,~' ~J~? ~1~'~~'.t ~:~1

•c.i ~~~ tea ..~

w ~~ ~ I ~~i~' CClilf~F'Ti~l<<~ ~I~(~ i~Tnt7''iE''`=~6v ~']~,'•' ~,

~;~i:.° c~ ~
r_ p ~ ~ il" . ~~
-,r~~3`n'_

~' ^r~~~-tc°}- a~tc~ .~~. P~r±~~ shah ~7~ °~~~;~ ~r '_ ,~~-r~ ~v ~~~i
~F

~ ~7-~ :l~'<-~r~~ during discovery in this
~ ~;' ~ ~ E ~' ~•ivileged as a trade secret
~

nr r~- ~~t.~cterl by the right of

~' ,;_

nrv;~~ileges or right by such
-

A

~rr.~~ti~.':i~n.
`' '`'' ~

~,~_
[Proposed} Sh~la'a~ed Pry

C;ase No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH (JEMx)
_~ . . Ors{er

Il ~~c,» C~~ >,~_-~F -T.~'~ .i ~t D~:;

Case

1

4.

~::~~~ +~a- ~

, _: v of 12 Page ID #:188

~ ~~:t~ .~~~~ _

Whenever dining the course of dig,.; ~t ry ~n this matter a Party or

2 ~ witness is properly requ~st:ed to dis~,I~~se, or v~`~~.~«~a~~~~ily ~.iscloses, materials or
3 information that a Party considers to be Confic~w.:~~i~~~:~~?~ Triformation or Confidential for
~;
4 ~' Attorneys' Eyes Only Informatian, tl,~at Party s' :..r.`1 ~ ~d mate at or before the time of
5 ' disclosure that the infarmati.o~ or m~~t~ria!s a~~~ ~:_ ~~~ iir'c~~tial Information or
6 ,Confidential for Attorneys' Eyes Only InfQrita~i~. ;f:l, ~~y marking the information or
7 materiels as st!ch or }:~~~t*~~~~ ;;s~rr~ : ot~re~• :,i:nils~r ~° . ; ~,r~~ti;~r7 thereon, or by indicating
~ '~ in ~~me ~t~~r ~~~pra~iria*~~ f~~~hinr~ t~~a~ r4~~e ~l~c~~.~ ~aQ~'~.~,r~ ti-~ rr~~~erials produced are
~~ubject t~~ this Pr~ttirtiv~ larder. Ir~~d~~e~~t~ .t `=' ~r- tc, ~~ ::y';~=gate material as
1~ ~ "Confide;ltial" ar ~`C'orifid^r~t~~.P--F~~r ~~~~~~z~~~_~;- ~, ➢; ~,~~~ '~~t~1~y" under this Protective
1 1 Gxd~.r s1~a11 nE,t u~~erate ~s f~-~'v~=r of tree ~'~~~+;~'~~, ~ ~~~~ ~~ ~~. s~,~~~;e~uently designate such
12 '~ matc~~-i.~1 ~~s "Conf+:~~nti~1" ar "~~nf~~I~nti;.~~---F' - ° ~~: .t~~x►1~a~•' Eyes Only."
13

~.

~~1~ter~a.a~s gar i~+fifx~~~~tio~~ ~e~~~,~.~, ~ ~':: . ; ~'~ ~ ~,:~c~~atial Information or

1;~ ; ~'c,nfic-~~~nti~l; fir• ,"~.tt~- :~~~:~ys' I~~~es (~i~';~ r-, f,-,~z;;; .,, ~ ,• ~ ~~i~~"~~~~ any summaries,
l~ ~ '.-o~~ies, ~~b~;tr~,ctt., ur ~,~?~i~x ci~;~ca~nla,r3~~; r~~~:__`,.`ri",- ,' " ~'~~-~~?. ;r~tial Information or
16 ~C~~~r~ ~~~1~~~ti~~:? toy A~r~1~~a~: ,:' F,~es ~h~l~~ I~~f~-~+ ~~; ~:.,

,k;t~1~ k5" treated in accordance

~ -~ ~ ~ ~~,i tz~f~ t~~_,ns ~~'thi~; Pr~:: F - ~;ti~~~f~ L~r~. ~~-~~~:1 ,'i~~`~
._-

;;~~~a }~,,~ the Parties, their

1 &; re~~~~:.~:tir~e a~~ ~~ts, ~ ~rl ~~~;~~ ~~k~er I~eTM_~_~r ~ 1+~ ~~`~~;.
~'
1~► ~ Co:r~fi~intial `'~r 1~',1t~~~~~-ne~. ' ~';~~ ~> ~'~~n'~,~ ~r~ `~ ~v~~~

~ ~.,,~~i ~'~_,:~~idential Information or

?{~ ~, rhi.~ ~`:~~te~r;=~~~. ri:,~r~~~ o~i~ fi~d~ f}•e: }°~r~s~~~~_ii' ,, ~

~ ~.~ ;~~- :,.~tlement of this

;,_;~_~ ~: wlisclosed pursuant to

2 ~ ;' ~~ ]ir.u:,.tac~;~,~ ~~1~~~ ''~r ~o ~L~thFr ~' ~ .,~~ in~1~~~7~7~~~~ ~ ~ ~:~~,~ ',f~~-_~ t~ d to business and other
_
~,;~~~~~~~
P
2~ ~ ?~t~~,~'.~w~~~.~ ~~a:-,~os~:t~. '~,1~t,. :,~~.~,`-:~~ci~~~~, t, ~, f~i er
.
?.~

<•?-<~l~ ~~r

r,
.. ,~ ~`'.i~~~ in this Protective Order

~_►~~ ~ ~~:_. ~ t~i~:~ ~'-~~' ~;g ,+~ ~i~'~~; . ~~~~.~

-t,'

~'orifidentialInformation

2~t ~ ' ~~- ~'t~~~ ~'c~ti.r~tial fir ."'t~rn.~~,~~' ~;..,~~ r~,.~,~- [r~~' n. ~ ~,, ~~; i. ~.,~f~ally obtained by such
,
.`' Party i~-~'ep~~ F'c~~:` ~f ~i,~ _~~✓~r~~ in t'~',, , ~ti<<~~ ~

;r lay r_c~~ such material is also

^~~~ ~ ,~ ~~'~~~.n~~_~1 ~,,..E~, ~~,~~ vl~.,~~~rr~r~y ~~ ~' r.y ~~
,

-~~r ~ ~ ,Y its own Confidential
~~

~Y ~~

- ~ ITif^rr.~ri~~~ .-;r~'~n~i~~1~;-~t ~=' f~~r ~,+t~~~~r,~=~~;' ~'~
,~

`~ ~ta~ ~. ~~~,~,~ation to any person as
,

~~
..,; _
(F'roposed~ ~~ipulated ~'r~.;.?;

~; ~,c No. 2: 7-cv-02327 TJH(JEMx)
]
FJri~F:r

Case

~7-~,~.~-C~~:~r's-~~.?~-~~-J~=Ni Dc~~:'~~n~~n~~l!~~~~

6.

[~~~~~ I of 12 Page ID#:189

~~z~~rJ ~7 ~`f

ii'a Party r~r their c~u~~is l ~s s~,rv~~~ ~~~: ~ ~~ir~~ tt~~s action (including up to

2 '; the deadline to destroy or rett~rri dociam~nts s~~t ~~-1r~~~~ in paragraph 12), with a
,~
3 ~ j subpoena requiring ~rodu~~t~~n cif an a~~p~~s~~~~ ~- ..~ ,~~ 's C'~:~i~~idential Information or
4' Co~~fidential for Attorneys' ~vy~;s Ls~l}~ I~~ri~rrc~~ .:~r, t~~~ ;~a~~poenaed Party will,
5 within three court days, send by ~:.rr~ail a cagy c~ ~,:~ ,; sul~pa~c~na to the attorney for the
6 opposing Party (i.e., the Warty t~-~~t ~r~;~uced t~~~ ;~~~~;i~rial tl~e subpoena seeks). Once
? it receives thf~ n~.;~~, th~~ ~lai:,~:~~i~:~; ~' ~ti~ ~E~.~!' ~ >_~ ~ ~i~t~v ~:~_~~1r~ days to file a motion
_~~~~_ tt~~~ ~,r~c}:er .c~,:.t o}~~ec~`~:~o try thc~ s~. "~~~,, ~~~~zi«. ~
:

~~rt> i~~, c~b~jecting to the subpoena

9 is ~iirnAl~~ f ~~~',,'1~~; s~~?1~c~c°►7~~~~,~ ~~i~tti- ~:~,~?r ~-~;~,~~, ~ ~ ~ti ,~;,~ ~t~:- tliaterial until after a court
1`~9

~U~t,'_; Uii ~~"-P_ C]lOtl~:tl, ~f111.~;:5 ~'E~d~~ s4I'~'~' ~:~) s:iO ~C3 1?.~

. :.l" ( :9~:"1 ~OtlleT ~1a21 t~le

1i s~abpoer:a, i`,~~?f) ur ~3~ t~; Ia~v,
1~

~.

~~111~~ii bri~~f~, _~.i~tric~r~~ns1~. :,,~ c~ ~ my~ ~ :~. .~~:c~~°r~t~; ~r things containing

1~ ' ~'o_~_ific'~:i~i~~' ~rsf~r.~ ~~1~_1 c~E ~:~~~f'.J~~: :~~ `.~c .~ ~ ~ ;~ , `~~F;f;;~~ Only Information are
1- ~IE,~1 ~, ~_,,~ ,:'~t ~'i~~~~tg ~'~c f ~'~~,~ F~~~~~~- : .,,,~ ~,:?_.: . ,~, ~- r~~:'_ ~~~ file these documents
1` ~~r ~~~~inks ~~~,~~~r ;;~:~~1 ~flucl ~'uill ,.~;n1}-s1y ~ ~ ~.:. '~.~

'~ ~ ,;,;_ ~-~ements for doing so. in

:;a~t;c~::~:tr, t~jf: f 1~.1 ~'~. :w ~?'al.' ~~c ;c ~i~ ~~-. :~~,'
,

l~ I_ , ;.al Rules to file the

. "' i;(~ _ ,. r.lc',Clt~> ;~1?1t1:_` yeti?. I,~ -'!` 11:~t:a~1Cc:S '~~+' M d .;[ `.

`r~, ~;;~C"`~' shall be provided an

? ~; c~p~~flrt~~ity, t~~~f~r~~ ~~ mc~ti~~,.:~~ ~'tE~ ~_~ i~~:~r~ ~E;~~ i ~ ~ , :~'.; t~:~ .~",~.ce in that motion the
1E+ e=.~~zn~ 4~~~~~ 1,~~ ~e3e~~~,~n_~.~~~v~ ~'~_t~~ _-,;~~ , ~c~ . '.'~: a . _
~r.~~ ~e filed under seal. If
~~
~ ~-

. `G

~;~~,_:il[';~t~~: ~~iC~~;<~ ~ P ti

"t~ ~~ ~ ' ! t ~ -

~"l ~ _

~JC :~Ct1~~:~1L`_+ :~1~) ~~~,, ~~'r~ ~' ? ' ~;;{• : v'-~', .;]: ~t);:li[ll~

2~ ~ F~~.~ ~•-~,~~~~=r, ~;I~~,~~'~i t~,~ ~`b7., ~ ;t,-~;, t.~ ~ _.~y?~..~ —
"
,

~_~~~"

_.

-. ,

i.`b~i '~'i~;i'1. be f IeC~ UIlC~eT' Se11.

~•~- ~

~ ~, ~~~~;: decline to allow the

_ ~ ~~,►~z_ `c~ f. z, ~:~~~~ ~~ ,.'-~~ s~~~~~°, ri ~~' ~ ~s~. i~~ ~4~ ; ~'ro~ective Order shall

?; ' ~-~: , ::lit tl~.~ f'~r P~'~~~ f ~i~m ~;~~"~:~=its' ~~~,, ~ ~, ~
~~

.~ r "l-,ings to the Court in an

~'

!~ ~ ' ~' ~ ~~
2~ ~~ ~.'~~r e!'~~~~-=,-~~ t~~~~ ~'i?~n~7 ~f,_ ~1~ . .~r~~.- ,~ , ,,t.
.
r

?~

~ ;~ ~ ~ ~ -~ ~~~ Ansel secures a court
~
~

J

~~(;rrp'C'~;".~1; ?li1~F," ~~~.~( ;~~: 1~~' fi PTMO'='~'
`~g
" `' z

,1~ .f'St,dll(~ OTC~eTS t~lclt ~le

-.,r' ~ ~?„

.-4j..
[FroposedJ -lipulate~i Prr~~

~~~ ~~~y°;cation to file a
~ ~.

~

~;T"' ~~.'~ ~~d1C~ 011 t~le peTS011 OT
C4se No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH (JEMx)
h ~ ~: girder

Case 2 Li-cv-O~ 3~i'-~TeIN-J~~~~~ t~c~s~i~~r,r-°rr~ 4~~-:1 1=ilea+ :~:~~°

~ ~'~.~ge ~ of 12 Page ID #:190

t entity that has custody anc~ control c~f t:l-.:: c~c~<;~:~~~~~ :. :~ .. ~f ~~i~f~rent from opposing
~'
cour~s~;l. If o~pe~sin~ ~c~u~s~;l, or the ~ ~ r _:~~~~ ~~r f'. tiy~~ i~:: '~:as custody or control of
3 the dacame~~t, wE>hes to ap~~:~~ the a~~~:-4i~;; ._i~~ ~

~;~ .: 7

L~~;t contact the chambers of

4 I I the ~udg~ ~~vho will rule Qn t~-~~ applic~~ti~m, t~~ ~~ .: ~~, `.!~u jti.~~~e's staffthat an
5 '~ opposition to the applica~~~n will b~ ~ia~,ct.
6

9.

`should any docr~~ne~nt(s~ c~~y~ta~~ir~ , '~:': -7f~:ie~~ia1 Information or

"?i ~~~~~~~cl~_r~i~.l or Att ~~~-ney~' P_yzes ~Jn1~~ Is~~'~.~~~~, ~ ~ ~ . „ , s~?.~~.~rtently filed without
the cles ~;natic~>ri r~ fe.~-red tc i~ ~raa-a~~a~~~~~ ', + :t~ '- ~

~~' r~ ,~'~~ documents)shall,
i
9 ~ ~.r~~~<< ,
:ti~;~~~; ~~rir.~ thG~ ~:t-rnr• a~ til~o~~ d~ tt>~~~; ~ -~~~ ~ , . ~ _~i~ ~'~'~~ error, promptly ask the
1~ ~ ~'c~u~* t~ a~~~~~,~~ it to ~~~ithd~~a~~, t}~r~~ doc~~rrr<;nt~; ~:,~

, ;`.I t~-;E~n ~nllow the procedures

1 1 ~ ~- c~~ir t~ by pEi~-agt•ap1~s ? a,~~ ~, al~r,,~-~°,
12 I

?0.

'~'he ;~~r~c:ss F~~~~ ~,'~~t~~.n~;i~,~ ~~ 1~<ir~

~

~s ~, ~~':~~nn of material as

1 ~ ' ^c~;~ Fick: -1ti ~1 sha11. ~+e as fo~lovw~~:
1 `~ ~!

.,

''e ~,~

t~~y ~~~y ~~,r T1e~~~ '~~::-~ ~, -~_~

designation of

~~

Ti.
}_,~
t~' r ~C1- ~ ~-Z~~'l~'[1~ 1` U */ i,
!.. ~°, r,~ "`Challenging Party»~
'i
1 ~ ~ ,h~l.1 irl~~~~~~t~ t'-e cl.i~~ ~;e ~~~~s~l~atiol~ ~Y ~c~~~s ~y ~ .;~, ~~Pn~ written notice ofeach

1 ~ ' designs:~tion if `;:~ chwt?~n~a .~; ~r.~! ~r~:,~ i~ii~~ ~'~

~ . ~ , `_~~r ~~~~~:1- challenge. To avoid

l ~~ ~ ~nl~. ~: it~~ ~s .n ~:'~~t'i~x ~~ :l_~~)l~ng~ ~-a ~,,~.r~ l-

, `~,: ;~~~~~~en notice must recite

2~ ~ that th. cl~alle~~n~~ t~ ~anfi~a~a~Yti:~li~y i '~~r~~~; ~~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ . ~~ ~~~~~~~?once with this specific
2

l~z,
.~;~,.~.;;.~ c;`G~~^ Pr~~t~c1~~~ ~r~l~r. T'~r= I'~~-~ ~~z z

~~~ ~ha':.l~.i~;e in ~aoc~. f~~.~~h :~r~r? Yn~z~~r r>k=;;r, ~'~~- ,~r~~

~ ~,~ ~ ~,.`~,~ring directly (in voice

a~, >>s ,° i'_~!c~~,~_R.F~, s~~]~cr ~~ •~~;,~ c~~'s~n.~- -~~~a!;i~,a~ti,: ~._
=
r2~ 'i ~-~ + .~ ~~ ~.te o sor~-~~,, ~f :>rl ~ ~~.~~: ~~ ~~r~~~~:~~ ` .

L~

;
';'~ ,~~;' ~~^fit.' ~tJrr (~~5~€.,,,~+~•(~ t~3E' tT`''r

^F ~R:T'

~~~1;~]~?1d71t'y' tO 1'F"1!?~~' t]7 r` +C~E'Sl~fl~lt8(~ I~" <~~~~^T"~~_

~~ if r!~, chan~7<~ 'n ~~~ ~si7a~~~t~~~„ ;S; .r~~. t~, ~.;~1~
,~ff
' ~"
`,

;~~;t ~;izfficient) within 14 days
~~ I'~ ,,n;;~g Party must explain

~l~~':~~~;~~, fir 't~ ?~el~~. =~tha+ ~tl~~ ~~~nf~~~:~~°~<~i;~~~ ~
~ c,

~`~. ~~;t to resolve each

. i
~ C

s,~~~- ~v<~s not proper and must
lf°~ ic`r~"~,ignating Party»~ an
`.~'"i°1:~:~ t~le C1T'CUI11StilIlCeS,d11C1,
'

4' ',,~ , .~r the chosen

.`'
.,._
--f~__ [Proposed] Stinula[ed Prc~ ~t?~

C„se No. 2:17-cv-02327 T]H(JEMx)
Order

Cass ~';~7-c„~0~,~?7-T.7N-JE=i~1 ~G~~uYr7~nt 4~~-1 Fi!{~.,i ~(~~,

~ ,.; 9 of 12 Page ID #:191

~`
,;
;~

1 ~ designation. A Chall~n~in~ ➢~arty~ maj~~ro~c.~z~~ : t~~~~ r+.,;;-x:t stage ofthe challenge
Z 'process only ii' it nas E:ngage~ in this i-n~e~:t aria c:~:,.<~_;::~ ~gucess first or establishes that
3 ~ the Designati;~g Warty is urrwilli~lg, ~~~ ~~~~~ticipai~~ ;~~ ~~~~~e~ ~~Ze~t end confer process in a
4 ~' timely manner.
~

c.

If the Parties can~7i~t re~.~o~-W~. - ~;~~~~a1l~r~ge without court

h intervention, i:he Challenging Warty ~~Z~y fide ai~._z .;~;; ~,~e z~ f~;~tion challenging the
"~ _,~ ,rl_ ~. _: L:~lc~er ~'~~~il. T_,~~~,~il ~.~~l~s

~~ ~.:l ~:~~ ~ ~i~ . lv .,~~ i;~ ~.ompliance with Civil

h L~uca~ I:;.~'_~. 7th-S, if ~~}zlir<~~~~ej. I'ar.:L sa;~~~ ,;-~~' ~ : ~ _~L,;:~ ~~e a~.^,companied by a
9 ' ~.c~ir~~ter~t d~;c~ar~+ion aff~~rt~i;~,~; t~h;~t `a~-: ~r7t~a~~~~ ~~~~~~ ~~c ~~~-f~~l~ed with the meet and
10 ~ ~~oTif~r• ~recluiremettts imposed in the pr~ec,e~iir~g ~~.~t~a-,,~~t~~,~~~~~1~h.
11

~I.

'r~~~_F, b~~r~~I~~ri ~~f};er•s~~~i i.,:; ~~~ ~,rr;- ~:;~~ ~', ~. ~iallenge proceeding shall

l 2 ?~~e cry lire D~signatir~~; P~rt~%. T;rivol,~:~~ ~;~d. ~l~;~n;.~ = .~w:a~ .~t~~~~; made for an improper
r~
l ~ r ~~ a`,;,~;~~ (e.~., t,~ r. ~~ ~5c, c>~ ir~~~~~~,se i;=_~t~:~,~~~~ ~_. ~ ~~ -~~~ ~ ~:i~;~i k~urdens on other
1 ;- ~~r'iE~s; r~~=:_w .:xr~c~e ,:'-',ti ~';~.11~t-~~~~~-~ i' <<~ ~ `i ~:
1~

~ ~ :.1_~ ,~ - ~~rties shall continue to

^'~~O]'~R t~'t4' 1?"'~i~f',I'li~l IC' C UE ~ };.~~~'~ +~?t 1 ~^-vQ',~ i ~ ~,,`~':~ ~
~

adz i~rt ._. ;la It 1S Blltltle(~ U11Clel'tllf'

~~,
~:~ipn~`i~~~'~~.i~:~,,s ci~;si~;P~~.x-ion. tint;p ~~=~~ :~;~~;~ .
? ~~ ~
1€

1 1.

<~ Des~c,~~a?i:-~ ~°~r,'y~ ~~~~ ~

~~~, ~ ~;, ~~hallenge.

i~i~~~ t~a~~ ~

~'~:~En~~~~ lU t:,~r ~;h:ir~~;~~~g ~ a.re°, -►;.~- ~l, :,~~;a , ~:~ii ~_
~~.

~R ~ `,~_~ Parfy that it is
~ ~ ~

~-~~ ~ "Confidential" or

14► ~ ~ "~'=-r~~f~~.'.~ ~ ~t~:ia~ -~ Fa~. .'~ t~~o~~7~~~ t~' ~~y~~: r~?~ ~~~ "

~' ;;the Designating Party

J

L
~l'

.~~~w ~1 lil~l

~~'~~)1'

~~~1~ ~l~2~

W~~.. ~.f~

1, 4~; 4. ~~:.(!1T'.

A,J'_

l

]"~~

~ ',

2i ' d' ~ ~~<<~~~;:~ t;~.~~, ~,~°+~ ~ ~ ,.,~ia~~~~~~,t~, ~~~~ ~ ~. :, ~~.~. ~
' i ~~~ .~~~ ?~e tl~~, r> .,~r -~ers~~. 01 4~-^ clr.~,~~r
~

~

~" ,~~
-

d~.~~' ~±

~LOYL~~C411yW~ly~

~' , ,~', , ~~..~~esignated copy will


;~ ~ ,~~~~f ~~s an exhibit at trial or

?~ ~ , otherwise di~~~l,~y~c( ':~1 fl: ~~~~,~,~~`~ '~:~ -~ ;: ~1~f~,~ ~~.

,r''~~ to the Court ofthe

1~~i`1~~~n ~~t~ <',~.~s ~~t~.r t~~ ~~ ~.~,,~ t~ ,

~~ry.. ~~, -;~:~~n and the expiration

2 ~ .~~~1-_;: 4' ~~~ fi~~ ,~r~e~1 ~r fry-~1 ~~t~~~.r-~ ~,~~~,_,o „t~
`

-_~; ~d~~~'~ ~?~ originals and copies

~~

G~

~ ~.

~~f ~t1"'~~~~ti~~~:~~'1'7f~i`.~ T"?frr~l^I`..'!'~ ~ Ct' ~'~ ,1~¢ ~~~"'~; "
:

.~„~ r,~~, i;~ tl~~: ~~~~~~~~~~i«,~. ~u=~t~~'~ . ;-~~,~~,~
F I„f~ l
a:onGz

.'~''"'''Ti.`'.~;'S' EYeS

171Y

~ ~~-~ ~ .~,~;an or entity (other than
'

~_
[Proposed] Stip~~~ate;1 Prc~ ~~a

'.:~e No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH(JEMx)
C)rd~r

~';1 r ~~~~E- ,,, ~-, t ?`- ~~ ?~ r?,~r;,~~~~~~;~t <;~ ~
{~ ~~

C~~

~ ~

~ ~;1 ~~~ a~~~ 10 of 12 Page ID

1 ' the courts identif~~ed in paragr~~phs lid}(~,) end '~w~~ ~_~j ~t~ove) shall be destroyed or
~ i returned to the Farty who produced such docL-,ro =;:~''~,j o~ information. In the event
I :~
3 I that the ciocurnents are destroyed, rather than r~ ~ ~~:~ :~d, ~. l~~ter to that effect shall be
~ !provided to counsel. Notwitbstandi~~r, t11Ea fore:~~i~-~ -~,, e~c~h party's outside counsel
5 may maintain one copy of all dc~cu~~en~s cc~r~ta;~~.i~~;~: Cc►~~~°idential Information or
6 Confidential For Attor~iey"s Eyes Unpyv n c~rrn~~.~o:~ f~~- the sole purpose of
-n:~irrt~~.ir~ing r~~~?r~i~~sE:t~. a~~c~ ~:~t~~~:i~a~e ~~e ~ ~;f kl~~, ; .~t~ ~r~.
C'~nf~~~ =rte'-i Ir,~<~r~~!~~~~a~i c~~ C~rr~i~c'~:1 ~~i::'. ~~ ~~~ ~t~t+'~n7~.>~a' Eyes Only
~ Inf~~~~~1~=;Q~~ i~~ tl;~~ p_~;,s~;:~~i~.,r~, c«s`~.~~w;~ ~:. ;:,_~,~~~. ~ ~ , ~ '~tl~~ Y=~i;,t:~~pct Court shall be
?
1~1 faispo~~:~ ~w~f x~ f~;~;ic~w5o ~i~';tl~in ?~ ~3a~~s .~~'~~ :~ t"-__ ' . ~~ ~~i~H t~=~~:~ t~~f this Action and the
1 1 ~ r~X~:TT'~ltl~Cl O~ t~"!~~ C1I7~; fCi' c~.iJ~)E's'. ~, C>i' ~ i;:.s Eit'-~c'~"4i - ~lkr '.d.1C~ ~ ~'~: ;~.Ii~% ap[~C'.11~ ltly Pa1't~/ t0
I,G ~ ~~ll;i ~~Ct10fl I~lii~r ~C+~~'k:~i: i;(~ i~7~°~ ~~aS-~C]t'.0 ~_~t1tl~~ c~t ~': 1 `1~~~ u:(l~~t;?1I11I1g t~le II1~1teI'1dIS
Ij

:i~~ ~C:~:•.Tl~/, ~%v'~`j" :i7~lfi~f' n~'.'E` ~~a~ ~, '`:`J .':tll'i ~~I~~., ~_

] ~;~- ; ~on~fi~:~~. ~~,~1 ~=.~r ,~,t.c9~r~;" -' ~,~ ;~~s 5~~~~1 ~
i

~~~,.._

~

~~~'i1.'€:4~~ iTlfOI171at1011 OT

~ r ~ ° -. ,~-~~ ~- ~~rty (hereinafter "Return

lr~ ~ ~.~{;~:~3.~'",Z. ~'~~1~' I'81"~j` cp, ~-'ilk C~.t?1''~1 ':►i 9~1;" ~~._:

~_;~ ~ i."~;~~CCT11t10I1 Ol'~.OI1f1C~8I1t1~11

1 ~; ! ic>r ~~~t;_~_+-r~~:ys' ' .~~~:,:; ~~nl;~ ~:r,~orx~~~ati,,.~ ~3_~s4 ~_~

~~f ~ ~ a~ ~~~~~ties to this action, or its

1 ~ % :o

;~;~~_, ~~t~~r. t.ec~ rir-~7 b~ tx~~ ~:~~:,i~zul c~~~~r-~ l~ :~~t`
`~~ ~ ~~:.ti~i~:~~~ or the party that
1~ I _~c~~a~~:~I~- ~u1,i~~ tt~.: t'~ ~~° ir` ti,~ia~at~~~~ ~r~ ~'~~~ ~'~~,,,~r, ~~~ ~~~~.::-i~ls submitted to the
li.► C~,, _ -r _ ,. !r,~, ?~;e ~ ,,~t _'=,..3 t ~ ~,,'~~ ~" ~~ ~ . ,:A:l~ ,• 4 ~
,
~~.~ ,.~ ~_a-gents to be returned, and
?~l :hi~ .'st .. .. ,~~: '~ -. .kr~ `;~~~,, ;, ~ ~'- , ~>iftF., =, ; ' ,
~

~ :~
~ -,

:~i ~ , ~w~, ,~~~_c prior to the expiration

J

.ri:~~~c' rl'gs~
~._ f!T'.i1C ~. ~aa~

', ..p ~~.

OI' ~ 1~/1 ~~'.' ~' _ ~'t ' ,~'-~° _ r,. " ,r

..~

~

r~

;, . 1 ?::formation or
~ ~,?

.~1~~ .~t jJ't.1rSUallt t0 ~'18

, *~.~?`,,:, ' ;. ': ;. ' , ' ~ i, ~:~:' :strictly in accordance
for'-L~'~":~ ,~~-~f :~<~~~~• ~~~~.~=p 1 .~
~ . . ~;Jz t h ,i ~„ +,~,~., 1~ «f ~ r ~ . P~... ~.:1i~- ~ ~~-~~~: T;, t'~ y
i~, ~ 4 t ~~ ~ parties do not seek the

.
?. ~

~

i

._.~

~~t~, ~~F~ -~ ~ ~~"f,r~ fi~~er~ .~ ~ ; '.' ~.f ~'enk;. ' f~~.. " *`~ .
~ ~' , .,; ~`nly Information as set
~~ . ~~~~l~~~ a~ ~ ~a:, ~~~, ?~a~: uric` ~~c ~ ~~: ~~.~ ,'';~;ra- _ ~ ~ ~' _ ~~_ r~~ ~zial Information or
P
..
~.. r nner it deems proper.
~ :~. ~'Y~is~ ~'r~~~#~-,~a•✓a~ ~"?r:~~r y~~ ~°~ ~_ ~, ~~~ . ,~
2f; % ~
' to the right of the
,-".~;;U
7~

'~ `'""

...~~_
[Pro~~osec7] Sti}~i~'aFed Prc. ~t~•, ~~r,~el•

,: wse No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH(JEMx)

~ -,
.
~~~~ ,, 1 '~t;i-n~ ~_ F T ~~~ ~ ,~~,~~
~_

s,,~. ~, ,,~; ,~~,~, .
± i ~':a
`:

,. ,

-

,~~> 11 of 12 Page ID

1 Parties to present a oration tc~ the Cal1?-~ ~.~~~der ~ . ~;~: ~l Rule of Civil Procedwe 26(c)
2 '. for a separate protective order as to ~r~y partic1.~±;. ~ .. r~ct~me~nt or information,
3 ! including restrictions differing from tllr~se as s~ ;:a~~:~~ti~ herein.
4 ~'

]4.

Third partiE~s who prod~~ti~ c?oc~ams ~. .:~r rr~aterials or provide testimony

5 in connection with this actio~l, w~iet~;~~~r in ~es.~~~_ ~.~~ ~ ~~ ~ subpoena or otherwise, may
6 produce such €documents ar materials and/or to : ~~ ~ursi~ant to the protections
? ~~ff~~,~-tle~~ b~~ ~:I,i~ Ord:. ~~y 5:~~.►~~l~~~in;~ ~nr~~~~~ ~ i_•z~
S

~ ' ~? ;~~~~~~ve.
6

~ 5,

~T'~~e r~~~~isi~~u of 4~;s ~'r~,~~e~+t"_vf~ (~ ~ ~ ~z .~ rc~~~: ~~,~~~ject to further Court

~~.

`n'ith~~t: te~~,~~•~:~ a~r~-C ~ :1- ~,e~;u+~s,~ c' ' y~. . ~, :l,;~r phis Protective Order

~~ ~~~rd~:~.
1 tl

1 ~ ~~~~c;s n~~r_ ~l~arl~~, .~n~~~nc~, c}r ~c~rc~.s~z~•~~:;:~ ~~n~ ' ~.~ € '
1r

d_e a~° i_~~~~al Rule.

~-

1 s -;~~ti:~'~:
1

2C' i ~'
~,. ~~z ~~~ '~ h ~§~~- r~~~Ya~trate 3udge
-

1`
.
~ -~
~ F '~
~~
.~►
?
~;
s;
?. ;

~~
~,
„~
,~
L~
y5G1'r,

::ar;e No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH (JEMx)

-, v-

[Proposed~ `itipuiate~ trt:

: fir ~~ r

~:.

~~ 12 of 12 Page ID

,~ z ;,
__

zp

1

~ XI-~.1~3I'~ACKNOWLE~GIWIE~13' ~~i~► ~(~~ ..~ ~..,
~; .i:~:~1'~ `~'O BE BOUND

3 .
l

'~ '

_.

.~ LrRarr~~; -------. __ _~_._.

LPosition of

5 employment], hereby acknaw~edge tha~~ ~:~y ui : ~r; ~;,;: ti~~ ~,r~vided to me is subject to
~ ' the terms and conditions of the Protec.~ive C_3rdE~ " ~ ;: asF~ ~~~rnber 2:17-cv-02327,
i
pending in the Uniie~~ St<~t~es L~istric' !`~ ~..!;~, f_~:
F '
;

Ha~~:n~ ~~~et: ~ i~~ e.~ ~a ~,cr~~r c f ~ ►;, . ' rr.~ ~~; ~ t _

. : :;:r~trt:l Diistrict of California.
_,: ' _~ci~i ~nc~ slaving read and
.

~ ~ understood its contents, ]hereby agree t~ ?~e lac_ ,.: ~a , ~~ L9r,d to comply with the terms
1 ~~ and provisions thereof. I further ~iL,~~~~ ;,'~~t I 4v~ : ,~_ , ; disul~se documents or
11 inf~rn~ation de~~~^~~fi~d (;E~~~if ~l~~t~~ti.~l ~~~tfa,r,~~ai~id ,~ ~~~ ~~':~~~~~i~~ntial for Attorneys'
1~ ' ~~es Only Inform~tti~r, F;~cept as sr~;; ir~c;a~~~~ }

~ ' it;=: I-~~~ rl~e terms of the

l~ ~ F~•c+.~rtive C~r~E~r~., anr~ t.'~z~t I~~~3ll ~.s<, ~~~ i~ ti ~~~~ G

; ~,r ~ ~~~~~7~~:~~tion solely for

1 ~~ ' purposes ~~f t1~ ~ 1''~~;.:,t'-,~r, ~~ ;s;cars~~~ :. ~~ }~~ ~: ' ~ ~' :~' :E~ ~ ~~~ ~~rder. Ihereby consent
1` ~~o the jurjsdic:tic~r~. ~~f the United St~~te~,, L3',s~ric;~_ '~~' :, ~ f_~s~~ the Ventral District of
.
1 E; ~C~,'if:~:~~i~ fey- p~ir~~a~:~s oaf ~«~~~:~vi~s:; 'r.~ ;~~f~ -e,~~~ ~ ~ ~o~G~ ~~. -~Y~~ order.
~~
8 ~ ~~=)at,~:,:
j t'1

'~lr~' ?.1~ ~ ~i"ai~

—

----

~~'`_ti'"~ 5~~;~i~ r~1 ~I?C~ S~€'?~ '~' _

..

~ ~.

~i
7 /'.
~.—.
,~
~
.
._
n

n7
c .
.

7F

950"~'~

_. ~ j _
::ase No. 2:17-cv-02327 TJH (JEMx)
[Fropused~ 5ti~ulated Pro_:; .:i~; 'Order