Aaron Marks et al v. City of Hermosa Beach et al

Filing 34

JUDGMENT by Judge Dean D. Pregerson, in favor of Plaintiffs and against City of Hermosa Beach, Hermosa Beach Fire Department. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff AARON MARKS in the sum of 3,990.22. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff MATTHEW HOYT in the sum of 4,107.16. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff THOMAS SURBER in the sum of 11,294.88. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff SCOTT DURKIN in the sum of 4,096.26. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff MIKE SMOTRYS in the sum of 11,965.50.Judgment in favor of Plaintiff JIM BRUCCOLIERI in the sum of 6,904.74. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff BRIAN GREBBIEN in the sum of.3,612.42. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff DAVID SCHWARTING in the sum of 8,986.92. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff STEVE RAMIREZ in the sum of 1,695.16. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff JAMES DE LOS SANTOS in the sum of 8,266.32. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff AARON BUSH in the amount of 500. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff JAMES CRAWFORD in the amount of 500. Judgment in favor of Plaintiff MICHAEL GAROFANO in the amount of 500. Payment to Plaintiffs for reasonable attorneys fees and costs incurred in this litigation in the total amount of $16,500. This $16,500 amount shall be the total fees and costs paid by Defendants to Plaintiffs for this case and Plaintiffs waive their right to recover any additional fees and costs.in the total amount of $82,919.58, Related to: Stipulation for Judgment #32 (MD JS-6, Case Terminated). (shb)

1

JS-6

2
3
4
5
6
7
8

UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT

9

CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA

10
11
12
13
14
15

AARON MARKS, MATTHEW
HOYT, THOMAS SURBER,
SCOTT DURKIN, MIKE
SMOTRYS, JIM BRUCCOLIERI,
BRIAN GREBBIEN, MICHAEL
GAROFANO, AARON BUSH,
JAMES CRAWFORD, DAVID
SCHWARTING, STEVE
RAMIREZ, and JAMES DE LOS
SANTOS,

16
17
18
19
20

Case No.: 2:17-cv-08739-DDP-AFM
Complaint Filed: December 4, 2017
JUDGMENT

Plaintiffs,
v.
CITY OF HERMOSA BEACH, a
Municipal Corporation; HERMOSA
BEACH FIRE DEPARTMENT, a
public safety department; DOES IX, inclusive,

21

Defendants.

22
23
24
25
26
27
28
1
[PROPOSED] JUDGMENT
8595696.1 HE050-081

1

Pursuant to the stipulation of all parties,

2

IT IS HEREBY ORDERED AND ADJUDGED that:

3

Judgment is entered in favor of Plaintiffs and against Defendants, as

4
5

follows:
(a)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff AARON MARKS and against

6

Defendants in the sum of $3,990.22, which shall be apportioned as $1,995.11 in

7

wages owed and $1,995.11 in liquidated damages;

8
9
10
11

(b)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff MATTHEW HOYT and against

Defendants in the sum of $4,107.16, which shall be apportioned as $2,053.58 in
wages owed, and $2,053.58 in liquidated damages.
(c)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff THOMAS SURBER and against

12

Defendants in the sum of $11,294.88, which shall be apportioned as $5,647.44 in

13

wages owed, and $5,647.44 in liquidated damages.

14

(d)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff SCOTT DURKIN and against

15

Defendants in the sum of $4,096.26, which shall be apportioned as $2,048.13 in

16

wages owed, and $2,048.13 in liquidated damages.

17

(e)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff MIKE SMOTRYS and against

18

Defendants in the sum of $11,965.50, which shall be apportioned as $5,982.75 in

19

wages owed, and $5,982.75 in liquidated damages.

20

(f)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff JIM BRUCCOLIERI and against

21

Defendants in the sum of $6,904.74, which shall be apportioned as $3,452.37 in

22

wages owed, and $3,452.37 in liquidated damages.

23

(g)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff BRIAN GREBBIEN and against

24

Defendants in the sum of $3,612.42, which shall be apportioned as $1,806.21 in

25

wages owed, and $1,806.21 in liquidated damages.

26

(h)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff DAVID SCHWARTING and against

27

Defendants in the sum of $8,986.92, which shall be apportioned as $4,493.46 in

28

wages owed, and $4,493.46 in liquidated damages.
2
[PROPOSED] JUDGMENT
8595696.1 HE050-081

1

(i)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff STEVE RAMIREZ and against

2

Defendants in the sum of $1,695.16, which shall be apportioned as $847.58 in

3

wages owed, and $847.58 in liquidated damages.

4

(j)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff JAMES DE LOS SANTOS and against

5

Defendants in the sum of $8,266.32, which shall be apportioned as $4,133.16 in

6

wages owed, and $4,133.16 in liquidated damages.

7

(k)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff AARON BUSH and against Defendants

8

in the amount of $500, which shall be apportioned as $250 in wages owed and $250

9

in liquidated damages.

10

(l)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff JAMES CRAWFORD and against

11

Defendants in the amount of $500, which shall be apportioned as $250 in wages

12

owed and $250 in liquidated damages.

13

(m)

Judgment in favor of Plaintiff MICHAEL GAROFANO and against

14

Defendants in the amount of $500, which shall be apportioned as $250 in wages

15

owed and $250 in liquidated damages.

16

(n)

Payment to Plaintiffs for reasonable attorney’s fees and costs incurred

17

in this litigation in the total amount of $16,500. This $16,500 amount shall be the

18

total fees and costs paid by Defendants to Plaintiffs for this case and Plaintiffs

19

waive their right to recover any additional fees and costs.

20
21

(o)

The judgment shall not be used by Plaintiffs as an admission of

liability against Defendants in any other proceeding.

22
23
24

Dated: July 16, 2018

By:
Honorable Dean D. Pregerson
Judge of the United States District
Court, Central District

25
26
27
28
3

[PROPOSED] JUDGMENT
8595696.1 HE050-081