Los Angeles Center for Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery v. Aetna Health of California, Inc. et al
Filing
33
AGREED HIPAA-QUALIFIED PROTECTIVE ORDER by Magistrate Judge John E. McDermott re Joint NOTICE OF MOTION AND MOTION for Order for Agreed HIPAA-Qualified Protective Order 31 . See Order for details. (es)
<![CDATA[
(! '&''& &'% '"(%'
!'% &'% '" "%!
"&! &!'%"%
"% + " &(%%,
#9.6;A633
.@2!< ) 0C
#
""$
C
'! !&(%!" #!,
'
232;1.;A@
'56@4?221 #$B.963621#?<A20A6C2"?12?6@2;A2?216;A</F.;1.:<;4#9.6;A633 <@
;4292@2;A2?3<?"?.9 .E699<3.06.9&B?42?F#9.6;A633.;1232;1.;A@2A;. 632 ;@B?.;02
<:=.;F .;1 2A;. 2.9A5 <3 .963<?;6. ;0 232;1.;A@ 0<9920A6C29F A52 #.?A62@ .;1 2.05 .
#.?AF
* %&A52#.?A62@A<A520.=A6<;21.0A6<;A520A6<;:.F2;4.426;16@0<C2?F=?2A?6.9
.;1 A?6.9 =?<02216;4@ D5605 6;09B12 .:<;4 <A52? A56;4@ A.86;4 12=<@6A6<;@ .;1 =?<1B06;4
1<0B:2;A@.;1
* %&A5<@2=?<02216;4@D699;202@@.?69F6;C<9C2A52=?<1B0A6<;<302?A.6;6;3<?:.A6<;
A5.AA52#.?A62@A<A520A6<;/2962C2A</20<;3612;A6.9.;1@2;@6A6C20<::2?06.936;.;06.9<?/B@6;2@@
6;3<?:.A6<;.;1=2?@<;.9=?<A20A2152.9A56;3<?:.A6<;<3#9.6;A633K@K=.A62;A@
* %&B=<;0<;@612?.A6<;<3A52#.?A62@K <6;A <A6<;.;1=B?@B.;AA<%B92 0<3A52
212?.9%B92@<36C69#?<021B?2.;1
%H
2
A52<B?A36;1@4<<10.B@2A<2;A2?
A56@4?221#?<A20A6C2"?12?#?<A20A6C2"?12?<?"?12?
A6@52?2/F A<.;1 A5.A
:7658, (4+ !*56, '56@ "?12? .;1 .;F .:2;1:2;A@ <? :<16360.A6<;@ 52?2A< @5.99
4<C2?;A525.;196;4<31<0B:2;A@12=<@6A6<;A2@A6:<;F12=<@6A6<;2E56/6A@12=<@6A6<;A?.;@0?6=A@
D?6AA2; 16@0<C2?F ?2>B2@A@ 6;A2??<4.A<?F ?2@=<;@2@ ?2@=<;@2@ A< ?2>B2@A@ A< .1:6A ?2@=<;@2@ A<
?2>B2@A@3<?1<0B:2;A@?2@=<;@2@A<@B/=<2;.@52.?6;4.;1<?A?6.9A2@A6:<;F52.?6;4.;1<?A?6.9
2E56/6A@ 2920A?<;60.99F @A<?21 6;3<?:.A6<; .;1 .;F <A52? 6;3<?:.A6<; <? :.A2?6.9 =?<1B021 46C2;
2E05.;421<?16@09<@216;09B16;4.;F6;3<?:.A6<;0<;A.6;21A52?26;<?12?6C21A52?23?<:6@09<@21
.A2?6.9@A5.A:.F0<;A.6;0<;3612;A6.96;3<?:.A6<;6;09B16;40<::2?06.99F@2;@6A6C2<?=?<=?62A.?F
6;3<?:.A6<; 122:21 =?6C.A2 B;12? @A.A2 .;1 3212?.9 9.D 6;09B16;4 /BA ;<A 96:6A21 A< A52 2.9A5
;@B?.;02 #<?A./696AF .;1 00<B;A./696AF 0A <3
.;1 ?24B9.A6<;@ =?<:B94.A21 A52?2B;12?
#.;1<?.963<?;6.9.D&B056;3<?:.A6<;D699/212@64;.A21/F.#.?AF<?;<;=.?AF=?<C616;4
A52 6@09<@21
;3<?:.A6<;JI#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;J<?I<;3612;A6.9AA<?;2FF2@";9F ;3<?:.A6<;J6;
.00<?1.;02D6A5A52A2?:@<3A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?0<9920A6C29F?232??21A<.@#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;
.A2?6.9@ 2.05 . #?<1B06;4 #.?AF .@ 0<;A.6;6;4 <? ?23920A6;4 I<;3612;A6.9
54-0+,490(2 4-573(9054 <? =B?=<@2@ <3 A56@ "?12? I<;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<;J
:2.;@6;3<?:.A6<;0<:=?6@21<30<;3612;A6.9<?=?<=?62A.?FA205;60.9@062;A636036;.;06.9/B@6;2@@
52.9A5 <? :2160.9 6;3<?:.A6<; 6; .00<?1.;02 D6A5 21 % 6C # 0 <? <A52? 6;3<?:.A6<;
?2>B6?21/F9.D<?.4?22:2;AA</282=A0<;3612;A6.9<;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<;1<2@;<A6;09B12.;1
A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?1<2@;<A.==9FA<6;3<?:.A6<;A5.A6@.9?2.1F6;A528;<D92142<?=<@@2@@6<;<3
%H
2
@2A@3<?A5@=206360B@2@.;116@09<@B?2@<352.9A56;3<?:.A6<;.99<D216;
7B1606.9.;1.1:6;6@A?.A6C2=?<02216;4@
A52%2026C6;4#.?AFB;92@@A5.A#.?AF6@.9?2.1F/<B;1/F.4?22:2;A;<AA<16@09<@2@B056;3<?:.A6<;
<? 6;3<?:.A6<; A5.A 5.@ /22; 16@09<@21 A< A52 =B/960 <? A56?1 =2?@<;@ 6; . :.;;2? :.86;4 @B05
6;3<?:.A6<;;<9<;42?0<;3612;A6.9
759,*9,+,(29/4-573(9054'52#.?A62@.;1A526?.AA<?;2F@.?252?2/F.BA5<?6G21
A<?2026C2@B/=<2;..;1A?.;@:6AI#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;J<3#9.6;A633K@=.A62;A@A<A522EA2;A
.;1@B/720AA<A520<;16A6<;@<BA96;216;A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?<?=B?=<@2@<3A56@"?12?I#?<A20A21
2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;J@5.995.C2A52@.:2@0<=2.;11236;6A6<;.@@2A3<?A56;
%HH
.;1
*6A5<BA 96:6A6;4 A52 42;2?.96AF <3 A52 3<?24<6;4 #?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<; 6;09B12@
D6A5<BA 96:6A.A6<; 52.9A5 6;3<?:.A6<; 6;09B16;4 12:<4?.=560 6;3<?:.A6<; ?29.A6;4 A< . A52 =.@A
=?2@2;A<?3BAB?2=5F@60.9<?:2;A.952.9A5<?0<;16A6<;<3.;6;16C61B.9/A52=?<C6@6<;<352.9A5
0.?2A<.;6;16C61B.9<?0A52=.@A=?2@2;A<?3BAB?2=.F:2;A3<?A52=?<C6@6<;<352.9A50.?2A<.;
6;16C61B.9 D5605 612;A6362@ <? ?2.@<;./9F 0<B91 /2 2E=20A21 A< 612;A63F A52 6;16C61B.9 I#?<A20A21
2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;J .9@< 6;09B12@ D6A5<BA 96:6A.A6<; :2160.9 /699@ 09.6:@ 3<?:@ 05.?42@ @522A@
:2160.9 ?20<?1@ :2160.9 05.?A@ A2@A ?2@B9A@ ;<A2@ 160A.A6<; 6;C<602@ 6A2:6G21 /6996;4 @A.A2:2;A@
?2:6AA.;02.1C6023<?:@2E=9.;.A6<;<3/2;236A@05208@;<A602@.;1?2>B2@A@.;16;09B12@.99;<A2@
@B::.?62@0<:=69.A6<;@2EA?.0A@./@A?.0A@<?<?.90<::B;60.A6<;@A5.A.?2/.@21<;<?12?6C213?<:
I#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;J?24.?192@@<33<?:<?3<?:.AI#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;J3B?A52?
6;09B12@6;3<?:.A6<;A5.A0<;A.6;@A523<99<D6;4612;A6362?@<3.=.A62;A6;@B?21:2:/2?<?<3.?29.A6C2
2:=9<F2?<?5<B@25<91:2:/2?<3.=.A62;A6;@B?21:2:/2?
.
;.:2@
/
.9942<4?.=560@B/16C6@6<;@@:.992?A5.;.&A.A26;09B16;4@A?22A.11?2@@06AF0<B;AF
=?206;0A.;1G6=0<12
0
.99292:2;A@<31.A2@2E02=AF2.?3<?1.A2@16?20A9F?29.A21A<.;6;16C61B.96;09B16;4
/6?A51.A2.1:6@@6<;1.A216@05.?421.A2.42.;11.A2<312.A5
1
A292=5<;2;B:/2?@
2
3.E;B:/2?@
3
2920A?<;60:.69.11?2@@2@
4
@<06.9@20B?6AF;B:/2?@
5
:2160.9?20<?1;B:/2?@
6
52.9A5=9.;/2;23606.?F;B:/2?@
7
.00<B;A;B:/2?@
8
02?A6360.A29602;@2 ;B:/2?@ C256092 612;A6362?@ .;1 @2?6.9 ;B:/2?@ 6;09B16;4 9602;@2
=9.A2;B:/2?@
9
12C602612;A6362?@.;1@2?6.9;B:/2?@
:
D2/B;6C2?@.9?2@<B?029<0.A<?@(% @
;
6;A2?;2A=?<A<0<9 #.11?2@@;B:/2?@
<
/6<:2A?60612;A6362?@6;09B16;436;42?.;1C<602=?6;A@
=
3B993.02=5<A<4?.=5606:.42@.;1.;F0<:=.?./926:.42@.;1
>
.;F<A52?B;6>B2612;A63F6;4;B:/2?05.?.0A2?6@A60<?0<122E02=A.@=2?:6AA21/F
%H
0
I#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;J .9@< 6;09B12@ .99 ;<A2@ @B::.?62@ 0<:=69.A6<;@ 2EA?.0A@
./@A?.0A@<?<?.90<::B;60.A6<;@A5.A0<;A.6;.?2/.@21<;<?.?212?6C213?<:I#?<A20A21 2.9A5
;3<?:.A6<;J'52#.?A62@.;1A526?.AA<?;2F@.;1.;F3BAB?2=.?A62@.;1A526?.AA<?;2F@6;A56@0A6<;
.;1.;FA56?1=.?AF<?;<;=.?AF.?252?2/F.BA5<?6G21A<?2026C2@B/=<2;.16@09<@2.;1A?.;@:6A
A52#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;<3#9.6;A633K@=.A62;A@A<A522EA2;A<3.;1@B/720AA<A520<;16A6<;@
<BA96;2152?26;'56@"?12?1<2@;<A0<;A?<9<?96:6AA52B@2/F.#.?AF<3#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;
<A52?D6@2=<@@2@@21/FA52#.?A62@<BA@612A56@0A6<;99#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;=?<C6121A<
.%2026C6;4#.?AF@5.99/2:.6;A.6;21@20B?29FD6A5.12>B.A2@.324B.?1@.@?2>B6?21/F@A.A2.;1
3212?.99.D6;09B16;4 #/F0<B;@29<3?20<?1
54-0+,490(299574,>>,8 42><?=B?=<@2@<3A56@"?12?I<;3612;A6.9AA<?;2F
F2@";9FJ6;3<?:.A6<;:2.;@6;3<?:.A6<;122:212@=206.99F@2;@6A6C2D5605:.F6;09B12/BA6@
;<A96:6A21A<0<;3612;A6.9?2@2.?05.;112C29<=:2;A36;.;06.9A205;60.9:.?82A6;4<?.;F<A52?
@2;@6A6C2 A?.12 @20?2A 6;3<?:.A6<; <;3612;A6.9 AA<?;2F F2@ ";9F ;3<?:.A6<; 1<2@ ;<A 6;09B12
6;3<?:.A6<;A5.A6@.9?2.1F6;A528;<D92142<?=<@@2@@6<;<3A52#.?AFA<D5<:16@09<@B?26@:.12
B;92@@A5.A#.?AF6@.9?2.1F/<B;1/F.4?22:2;A;<AA<16@09<@2@B056;3<?:.A6<;<?6;3<?:.A6<;A5.A
5.@ /22; 16@09<@21 A< A52 =B/960 <? A56?1 =2?@<;@ 6; . :.;;2? :.86;4 @B05 6;3<?:.A6<; ;< 9<;42?
0<;3612;A6.9
,80.4(90545-4-573(9054'5212@64;.A6<;<3#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;3<?=B?=<@2@<3
A56@"?12?@5.99/2:.126;A523<99<D6;4:.;;2?
.
;A520.@2<31<0B:2;A@.;1D?6AA2;16@0<C2?F?2@=<;@2@<?<A52?6@09<@21 .A2?6.9@
/F .336E6;4 A52 9242;1 I"! !' J I"! !' #%"''
' !"% ' "!J<?I"! !' ''"%!,,&"! ,JA<
2.05=.420<;A.6;6;4.;F#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;
/
;A520.@2<32920A?<;60.99F@A<?216;3<?:.A6<;6;.;F3<?:6;09B16;42:/211211.A.
.;1:2A.1.A.0<9920A6C29FI920A?<;60.A.J/F12@64;.A6;4A52920A?<;60.A..@
#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;6;.0<C2?92AA2?.00<:=.;F6;4A52=?<1B0A6<;<3A52920A?<;60
.A.*52?232.@6/920<B;@293<?A52#?<1B06;4#.?AFD699.9@<:.?8A5216@8A.=2<?
<A52?2920A?<;60:216.<;D5605A52920A?<;60.A.6@=?<1B021D6A5A52.==?<=?6.A2
12@64;.A6<; 3.#.?AF?21B021#?<A20A21920A?<;60.A.A<5.?10<=F3<?:6A@5.99
:.?8 A52 5.?1 0<=F D6A5 A52 .==?<=?6.A2 12@64;.A6<; *52;2C2? .;F #?<A20A21
920A?<;60.A.6@0<=621.990<=62@@5.99/2:.?821D6A5A52.==?<=?6.A212@64;.A6<;
0
; A52 0.@2 <3 12=<@6A6<;@ <? <A52? A2@A6:<;F 6 /F . @A.A2:2;A <; A52 ?20<?1 /F
0<B;@29.AA52A6:2<3@B0516@09<@B?2<?66/FD?6AA2;;<A602@2;AA<.990<B;@29<3
?20<?1D6A56;3<B?A22;
/B@6;2@@1.F@.3A2??2026=A<3A52A?.;@0?6=A<3A52A2@A6:<;F
3;<@B0512@64;.A6<;6@:.12.AA52A6:2<3A2@A6:<;F<?D6A56;A56@3<B?A22;
0.92;1.?1.F=2?6<11B?6;4D5605=2?6<1A52A?.;@0?6=A:B@A/2A?2.A21.@<;3612;A6.9
AA<?;2F@ F2@ ";9F .;1 .@ 0<;A.6;6;4 #?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<; A52 2;A6?2
A?.;@0?6=A D699 /2 0<;@612?21 12C<61 <3 <;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<; <? <;3612;A6.9
AA<?;2F@ F2@ ";9F ;3<?:.A6<; '52 A?.;@0?6=A D699 0<;A6;B2 A< /2 A?2.A21 .@
0<;A.6;6;4#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;B;92@@<A52?D6@2.4?221A</FA52#.?A62@'52
#.?A62@ @5<B91 .AA2:=A A< =?2C2;A A52 16@09<@B?2 <3 #?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<; 6;
A?.;@0?6=A@/F?21.0A6;4<?@B/@A6ABA6;4.;F6;16C61B.99F612;A636./926;3<?:.A6<;@B05
.@A52=.A62;A;.:2.11?2@@1.A2<3/6?A5.42=5<;2;B:/2?2A0
1
.05#.?AF.;1A520<B?A?2=<?A2?:B@A.AA.05.0<=F<3.;F36;.9.;1A6:29FD?6AA2;
12@64;.A6<;;<A602A<A52A?.;@0?6=A.;12.050<=F<3A52A?.;@0?6=A6;6A@=<@@2@@6<;
0B@A<1F<?0<;A?<9.;1A52=<?A6<;@12@64;.A216;@B05;<A602:B@AA52?2.3A2?/2A?2.A21
6;.00<?1.;02D6A5A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12? A6@A52?2@=<;@6/696AF<30<B;@293<?2.05
#.?AF A< :.6;A.6; :.A2?6.9@ 0<;A.6;6;4 <;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<; #?<A20A21 2.9A5
;3<?:.A6<;<?<;3612;A6.9AA<?;2FF2@";9F ;3<?:.A6<;6;.@20B?2:.;;2?.;1
.==?<=?6.A29F612;A63621@<.@A<.99<D.002@@A<@B056;3<?:.A6<;<;9FA<@B05=2?@<;@
.;1B;12?@B05A2?:@.@6@=2?:6AA21B;12?A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?
4(+;,79,49(02:7,95,80.4(9,'526;.1C2?A2;A3.69B?2A<12@64;.A2<?D6A55<91
.;F6;3<?:.A6<;.@<;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<;#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;<?<;3612;A6.9AA<?;2F@
F2@";9F ;3<?:.A6<;D699;<A/2122:21A<D.6C2.9.A2?09.6:.@A<6A@0<;3612;A6.9;.AB?226A52?<;
A52@=2063606;3<?:.A6<;16@09<@21<?<;.;F<A52?6;3<?:.A6<;?29.A6;4A52?2A<<?<;A52@.:2<??29.A21
@B/720A<?A<@A<=A52#?<1B06;4#.?AF3?<:12@64;.A6;4@B056;3<?:.A6<;.@#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;.A
.9.A2?1.A26;D?6A6;4.;1D6A5=.?A60B9.?6AF'526;3<?:.A6<;:B@A/2A?2.A21/FA52%2026C6;4#.?AF
.@0<;3612;A6.93?<:A52A6:2A52%2026C6;4#.?AF6@;<A636216;D?6A6;4<3A5205.;426;A5212@64;.A6<;
4(+;,79,4908*258:7, ;A522C2;A<3.;6;.1C2?A2;A16@09<@B?2<3.;<A52?=.?AFK@
<;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<;A<.;<;$B.963621%206=62;AA52=.?AF:.86;4A526;.1C2?A2;A16@09<@B?2
@5.99=?<:=A9FB=<;92.?;6;4<3A5216@09<@B?26;<A63FA52=2?@<;A<D5<:A5216@09<@B?2D.@:.12
A5.A 6A 0<;A.6;@ <;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<; @B/720A A< A56@ "?12? 66 :.82 .99 ?2.@<;./92 233<?A@ A<
=?209B1216@@2:6;.A6<;<?B@2<3A52<;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<;/FA52=2?@<;A<D5<:16@09<@B?2D.@
6;.1C2?A2;A9F:.126;09B16;4/BA;<A96:6A21A<</A.6;6;4.990<=62@<3@B05:.A2?6.9@3?<:A52;<;
$B.963621 %206=62;A .;1 666 ;<A63F A52 =?<1B06;4 =.?AF <3 A52 612;A6AF <3 A52 =2?@<; A< D5<: A52
16@09<@B?2 D.@ :.12 A52 06?0B:@A.;02@ @B??<B;16;4 A52 16@09<@B?2 .;1 A52 @A2=@ A.82; A< 2;@B?2
.4.6;@AA5216@@2:6;.A6<;<?B@2<3A526;3<?:.A6<;
/(22,4.,95,80.4(90548;F#.?AF:.F05.992;42.#?<1B06;4#.?AFK@12@64;.A6<;
<3<;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<;<?<;3612;A6.9AA<?;2FF2@";9F ;3<?:.A6<;.A.;FA6:2/F46C6;4
D?6AA2;;<A602A<A52#?<1B06;4#.?AFA5.A6A</720A@A<A5212@64;.A6<;&B05;<A602@5.99@=206360.99F
612;A63F A52 6@09<@21
.A2?6.9 .A 6@@B2 .;1 @A.A2 A52 ?2.@<;@ 3<? >B2@A6<;6;4 A52 12@64;.A6<; '52
</720A6;4.;1#?<1B06;4#.?AF@5.990<;32?6;4<<13.6A5A<?2@<9C2.;F@B0516@=BA2 3A52#.?A62@.?2
B;./92A<?2@<9C2A5216@=BA2A52</720A6;4=.?AF:.F.==9FA<A52<B?A3<?.?B96;4A5.AA526@09<@21
.A2?6.96@6;.==?<=?6.A29F12@64;.A2146C6;4;<A602A<A52#?<1B06;4#.?AF 3@B05.:<A6<;6@:.12
A52#?<1B06;4#.?AFD6995.C2A52/B?12;A<2@A./96@5A5.AA5212@64;.A6<;6@=?<=2?(;A69A52<B?A
?B92@<;A52:<A6<;A521<0B:2;A@@5.99/2A?2.A21.@<?646;.99F12@64;.A21<?.C<61.;02<31<B/A
A52#.?A62@@5.99;<A05.992;42A5212@64;.A6<;<3#?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<;A5.A?2.@<;./9F3.99@
D6A56;A521236;6A6<;@2A3<?A56;A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?
08*258:7, (4+ #8, 5- ,80.4(9,+ 4-573(9054 6@09<@21
.A2?6.9 12@64;.A21 .@
#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;:.F<;9F/2B@213<?=B?=<@2@<3=?2=.?.A6<;A?6.9.;1.==2.9<3A56@0A6<;
#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;:.F;<A/2B@21<?16@09<@21B;12?.;F06?0B:@A.;02@3<?.;F<A52?=B?=<@2
.
&B/720A A< #.?.4?.=5 /29<D <;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<; .;1 #?<A20A21 2.9A5
;3<?:.A6<;:.F/216@09<@21/FA52%2026C6;4#.?AF<;9FA<A523<99<D6;46;16C61B.9@
=?<C6121A5.A@B056;16C61B.9@.?26;3<?:21<3A52A2?:@<3A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?.
2:=9<F22@<3A52%2026C6;4#.?AFD5<.?2?2>B6?216;4<<13.6A5A<=?<C612.@@6@A.;02
6; A52 0<;1B0A <3 A56@ 96A64.A6<; 6;09B16;4 .;F @2AA92:2;A 16@0B@@6<;@ / 6;5<B@2
0<B;@29 <3 A52 %2026C6;4 #.?AF 0 <BA@612 0<B;@29 3<? A52 %2026C6;4 #.?AF 1
@B==<?A6;4=2?@<;;292:=9<F21/F/.;10@B05.@=.?.924.9@924.9@20?2A.?62@1.A.
2;A?F092?8@924.9092?8@.;1=?6C.A2=5<A<0<=F6;4@2?C602@22E=2?A@<?0<;@B9A.;A@
3.;F=2?@<;@D5<3B?;6@5@2?C602@@B05.@1<0B:2;A0<16;46:.42@0.;;6;4:<08
A?6.97B?F=?<3696;4A?.;@9.A6<;@2?C602@0<B?A?2=<?A6;4@2?C602@12:<;@A?.A6C22E56/6A
=?2=.?.A6<; <? A52 0?2.A6<; <3 .;F 0<:=BA2? 1.A./.@2 3?<: 1<0B:2;A@ .;1 4 A52
<B?A0<B?A?2=<?A2?@C612<4?.=52?@@A2;<4?.=52?@.;10<B?A=2?@<;;29.;15.;F
<A52?=2?@<;<?12?21/FA52<B?A<?.4?221A<6;D?6A6;4/FA52#.?A62@.05=2?@<;
612;A63621 6; #.?.4?.=5 A< D5<: #?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<; 6@ @5<D; <? A< D5<:
6;3<?:.A6<;0<;A.6;216;@B05:.A2?6.9@6@A</2?2C2.921<A52?A5.;A52<B?A.;10<B?A
=2?@<;;296;5<B@20<B;@29.;1<BA@6120<B;@29.;1@B==<?A6;4=2?@<;;292:=9<F21
/F<BA@6120<B;@29@5.9936?@A/2?2>B6?21A<.4?226;D?6A6;4A</2/<B;1/FA52A2?:@
<3A56@"?12?6;A523<?:.AA.0521.@E56/6AA<A56@"?12?.;10<B;@292:=9<F6;4
@B05=2?@<;@<?:.86;4@B0516@09<@B?2A<@B05=2?@<;@@5.99?2A.6;A5.A@64;21D?6AA2;
.4?22:2;A
/
&B/720AA<#.?.4?.=5/29<D<;3612;A6.9AA<?;2FF2@";9F ;3<?:.A6<;:.F/2
16@09<@21/FA52%2026C6;4#.?AF<;9FA<A523<99<D6;46;16C61B.9@=?<C6121A5.A@B05
6;16C61B.9@.?26;3<?:21<3A52A2?:@<3A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?.<BA@6120<B;@293<?
A52%2026C6;4#.?AF/@B==<?A6;4=2?@<;;292:=9<F21/F<BA@6120<B;@29@B05.@
=.?.924.9@ 924.9 @20?2A.?62@ 1.A. 2;A?F 092?8@ 924.9 092?8@ =?6C.A2 =5<A<0<=F6;4
@2?C602@ 0 2E=2?A@ <? 0<;@B9A.;A@ 1 .;F =2?@<;@ D5< 3B?;6@5 @2?C602@ @B05 .@
1<0B:2;A0<16;46:.42@0.;;6;4:<08A?6.97B?F=?<3696;4A?.;@9.A6<;@2?C602@0<B?A
?2=<?A6;4@2?C602@12:<;@A?.A6C22E56/6A=?2=.?.A6<;<?A520?2.A6<;<3.;F0<:=BA2?
1.A./.@23?<:1<0B:2;A@2A52<B?A0<B?A?2=<?A2?@C612<4?.=52?@@A2;<4?.=52?@
.;1 0<B?A =2?@<;;29 .;1 3 .;F <A52? =2?@<; <?12?21 /F A52 <B?A <? .4?221 A< 6;
D?6A6;4/FA52#.?A62@
6620*(9054 5- 9/08 759,*90;, 7+,7 95 ,78548 <09/ **,88 95 759,*9,+
4-573(9054.05=2?@<;46C2;.002@@A<#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;12@64;.A21.@@B05=B?@B.;AA<A56@
"?12?@5.99/2.1C6@21A5.AA52#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;6@/26;416@09<@21=B?@B.;AA<.;1@B/720AA<A52
A2?:@<3A56@"?12?.;1:.F;<A/216@09<@21<?B@21<A52?A5.;.@@2A3<?A56;A56@"?12?
"/07+ (790,856>5- 759,*90;, 7+,7:89,!,7;,+%09/4>!:)65,4( ;
A522C2;AA5.A.#.?AF@228@16@0<C2?F3?<:.;<;=.?AFA<A56@.0A6<;A52;<;=.?AF:.F6;C<82A52
A2?:@<3A56@"?12?6;D?6A6;4A<.99#.?A62@A<A520A6<;D6A5?2@=20AA<.;F6@09<@21 .A2?6.9A</2
=?<C6121A<A52%2>B2@A6;4#.?AF/FA52;<;=.?AF'52A2?:I#?<1B06;4#.?AFJ2;0<:=.@@2@;<A<;9F
A52#.?A62@A<A56@0A6<;/BAA56?1=.?A62@D5<:.F16@09<@2<?=?<1B026;3<?:.A6<;246;?2@=<;@2
A<.@B/=<2;.3A2?A56@"?12?6@2;A2?21/FA52<B?A.0<=F<3A56@"?12?@5.99/26;09B121D6A5
2.05@B/=<2;.@2?C21<;.;F=2?@<;<?2;A6AFA5.A6@;<A.#.?AFA<A56@0A6<;
7,;05:82> )9(04,+(9,70(2!<A56;46;A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?@5.99=?209B12.;F
#.?AF A< A56@ #?<A20A6C2 "?12? <? 6A@ .AA<?;2F 3?<: @5<D6;4 6@09<@21
<;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<; <? <;3612;A6.9 AA<?;2F F2@ ";9F ;3<?:.A6<; A< .; 6;16C61B.9 D5<
=?2=.?21.BA5<?21<??2026C21A526@09<@21 .A2?6.9=?6<?A<A523696;4<3A56@0A6<;
.A2?6.9 12@64;.A21 .@
0204. 759,*9,+ 4-573(9054 <09/ 9/, 5:79 ;F #.?AF D6@56;4 A< @B/:6A .;F
=92.16;4 /?623 :2:<?.;1B: :<A6<; 92AA2? .3361.C6A <? <A52? 1<0B:2;A 36921 D6A5 A52 <B?A A5.A
16@09<@2@ @B::.?6G2@ 12@0?6/2@ 05.?.0A2?6G2@ <? <A52?D6@2 0<::B;60.A2@ #?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;
:B@A3692@B056;3<?:.A6<;B;12?@2.96;.00<?1.;02D6A5A52@2.96;4=?<021B?2@@2A3<?A56;A52 <0.9
%B92@B;92@@.;<A52?=?<021B?26@<A52?D6@2.4?221A<6;D?6A6;4/FA52#.?A62@
4(+;,79,49 75+:*9054 5- 70;02,.,+ (9,70(2 !<A56;4 6; A56@ #?<A20A6C2 "?12?
@5.99?2>B6?2=?<1B0A6<;<31<0B:2;A@6;3<?:.A6<;<?<A52?:.A2?6.9A5.A.#.?AF0<;A2;1@6@=?<A20A21
3?<:16@09<@B?2/FA52.AA<?;2F0962;A=?6C69242A52D<?8=?<1B0A1<0A?6;2<?<A52?=?6C692421<0A?6;2
<?6::B;6AF 31<0B:2;A@6;3<?:.A6<;<?<A52?6@09<@21 .A2?6.9@@B/720AA<.09.6:<3.AA<?;2F
0962;A=?6C69242D<?8=?<1B0A1<0A?6;2<?<A52?=?6C692421<0A?6;2<?6::B;6AF6@6;.1C2?A2;A9F<?
B;6;A2;A6<;.99F=?<1B021@B05=?<1B0A6<;@5.996;;<D.F=?27B1602<?<A52?D6@20<;@A6ABA2.D.6C2?
<3 <? 2@A<==29 .@ A< .;F @B05 =?6C69242 1<0A?6;2 <? 6::B;6AF ;F #.?AF A5.A 6;.1C2?A2;A9F <?
B;6;A2;A6<;.99F=?<1B02@1<0B:2;A@6;3<?:.A6<;<?<A52?6@09<@21 .A2?6.9@6A?2.@<;./9F/2962C2@
.?2=?<A20A21B;12?A52.AA<?;2F0962;A=?6C69242D<?8=?<1B0A1<0A?6;2<?<A52?=?6C692421<0A?6;2
<? 6::B;6AF :.F </A.6; A52 ?2AB?; <3 @B05 1<0B:2;A@ 6;3<?:.A6<; <? <A52? :.A2?6.9 /F =?<:=A9F
;<A63F6;4 A52 ?206=62;A@ .;1 =?<C616;4 . =?6C69242 9<4 3<? A52 6;.1C2?A2;A9F <? B;6;A2;A6<;.99F
=?<1B0211<0B:2;A@6;3<?:.A6<;<?<A52?:.A2?6.9'52?206=62;A@@5.994.A52?.;1?2AB?;.990<=62@
<3 @B05 1<0B:2;A@ 6;3<?:.A6<; <? <A52? :.A2?6.9 A< A52 =?<1B06;4 #.?AF 2E02=A 3<? .;F =.42@
0<;A.6;6;4=?6C692421<?<A52?D6@2=?<A20A21:.?86;4@/FA52?206=62;A@D5605=.42@@5.996;@A2.1
/212@A?<F21.;102?A63621.@@B05A<A52=?<1B06;4#.?AF'52A2?:@<3A56@"?12?@5.99.==9FA<.99
#?6C692421 .A2?6.9=?<1B0211B?6;4A520<B?@2<3A56@0A6<;6;09B16;4:.A2?6.9@=?<1B021=?6<?A<
2;A?F<3A56@"?12?
'52 =?<1B0A6<; <3 1<0B:2;A@ .;1 6;3<?:.A6<; @5.99 ;<A 0<;@A6ABA2 . D.6C2? 6; A56@
0A6<;<?.;F<A52?96A64.A6<;.?/6A?.A6<;=?<02216;4<?:.AA2?<3.;F=?6C692426;09B16;4D6A5<BA
96:6A.A6<; A52 .AA<?;2F0962;A =?6C69242 .;1 A52 .AA<?;2F D<?8 =?<1B0A =?6C69242 .==960./92 A< A52
=?<1B021:.A2?6.9@<?3<?.;F<A52?=?6C692421<?6::B;2:.A2?6.9@0<;A.6;6;4A52@.:2<?@6:69.?
@B/720A :.AA2? '56@ "?12? 2;0<:=.@@2@ .; "?12? B;12? 212?.9 %B92 <3 C612;02 1 A5.A .;F
=?6C69242A5.A:.F5.C2/22;?.6@216;1<0B:2;A@=?<1B0216;A56@0A6<;6@;<AD.6C21.@.?2@B9A<3
16@09<@B?2<3A5<@21<0B:2;A@6;0<;;20A6<;D6A5A56@0A6<;.;1A56@"?12?4<C2?;@.99=2?@<;@<?
2;A6A62@6;.99@A.A2<?3212?.9=?<02216;4@D52A52?<?;<AA52FD2?2=.?A62@A<A56@=?<02216;4'523.0A
<3=?<1B0A6<;<3=?6C6924216;3<?:.A6<;<?1<0B:2;A@/F.;F#?<1B06;4#.?AF6;A56@ 6A64.A6<;@5.99
;<A/2B@21.@./.@6@3<?.?4B6;4A5.A.09.6:<3=?6C69242<?D<?8=?<1B0A5.@/22;D.6C216;.;F
<A52?=?<02216;4*6A5<BA96:6A6;4A523<?24<6;4A56@"?12?@5.99;<A.3320AA52#.?A62@K924.9?645A@A<
.@@2?A=?6C6924209.6:@<C2?1<0B:2;A@6;.;F<A52?=?<02216;4
5:79 ,9(048:708+0*9054'56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?@5.99@B?C6C2A52A2?:6;.A6<;<3A56@
0A6<;'56@<B?A2E=?2@@9F?2A.6;@7B?6@160A6<;<C2?A56@0A6<;3<?2;3<?02:2;A<3A52=?<C6@6<;@<3
A56@ #?<A20A6C2 "?12? 3<99<D6;4 A52 36;.9 ?2@<9BA6<; <3 A56@ 0A6<; .05 =2?@<; <? 2;A6AF A< D5<:
16@09<@B?2<3.;F6@09<@21 .A2?6.9@6@:.12.4?22@A<@B/720A56:@29352?@2936A@293A<A527B?6@160A6<;
<3A52<B?A.;1A<A522EA2;A;202@@.?FA<2;3<?02A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?
,9:7457,897:*90545- 759,*9,+4-573(9054*6A56;@6EAF 0.92;1.?1.F@
.3A2?36;.97B14:2;A6;A56@0A6<;6;09B16;4A522E5.B@A6<;<3.99.==2.9@<?D6A56;@6EAF 0.92;1.?
1.F@.3A2?16@:6@@.9=B?@B.;AA<.@2AA92:2;A.4?22:2;A2.05#.?AF<?<A52?=2?@<;@B/720AA<A52A2?:@
<3A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?6@B;12?.;</964.A6<;A<12@A?<F<??2AB?;A<A52#?<1B06;4#.?AF.99:.A2?6.9@
.;1 1<0B:2;A@ 0<;A.6;6;4 <;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<; #?<A20A21 2.9A5 ;3<?:.A6<; <? <;3612;A6.9
AA<?;2FF2@";9F ;3<?:.A6<;.;1A<02?A63FA<A52#?<1B06;4#.?AFA5.AA56@12@A?B0A6<;<??2AB?;
5.@ /22; 1<;2 <D2C2? <BA@612 0<B;@29 3<? .;F #.?AF 6@ 2;A6A921 A< ?2A.6; .99 0<B?A =.=2?@ A?6.9
A?.;@0?6=A@2E56/6A@.;1.AA<?;2FD<?8=?<C6121A5.A.;F@B05:.A2?6.9@.?2:.6;A.6;21.;1=?<A20A21
6;.00<?1.;02D6A5A52A2?:@<3A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?
5 7,1:+0*,#?<1B06;4<??2026C6;4#?<A20A21 ;3<?:.A6<;<?<A52?D6@20<:=9F6;4
D6A5A52A2?:@<3A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?D699;<A.<=2?.A2.@.;.1:6@@6<;/F.;F#.?AFA5.A.;F
=.?A60B9.? <;3612;A6.9 ;3<?:.A6<; <? <;3612;A6.9 AA<?;2F F2@ ";9F ;3<?:.A6<; 0<;A.6;@ <?
?23920A@A?.12@20?2A@<?.;F<A52?AF=2<30<;3612;A6.9<?=?<=?62A.?F6;3<?:.A6<;/=?27B1602A52
?645A@<3.#.?AFA<</720AA<A52=?<1B0A6<;<36;3<?:.A6<;<?:.A2?6.9A5.AA52#.?AF1<2@;<A0<;@612?
A</2D6A56;A52@0<=2<316@0<C2?F0=?27B1602A52?645A@<3.#.?AFA<@228.12A2?:6;.A6<;/FA52
=?2@616;47B142A5.A=.?A60B9.?:.A2?6.9@/2=?<1B0211=?27B1602A52?645A@<3.#.?AFA<.==9FA<A52
=?2@616;47B1423<?3B?A52?=?<A20A6C2<?12?@<?2=?2C2;AA52#.?A62@3?<:.4?226;46;D?6A6;4A<.9A2?
<? D.6C2 A52 =?<C6@6<;@ <? =?<A20A6<;@ =?<C6121 3<? 6; A56@ #?<A20A6C2 "?12? D6A5 ?2@=20A A< .;F
=.?A60B9.?6;3<?:.A6<;<?:.A2?6.9
9/,7 75*,,+04.8F2;A2?6;4A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?.;196:6A6;4A5216@09<@B?2<3
6;3<?:.A6<;6;A56@0.@2A52=?2@616;47B1421<2@;<A6;A2;1A<=?209B12.;<A52?0<B?A3?<:36;16;4
A5.A6;3<?:.A6<;:.F/2?292C.;A.;1@B/720AA<16@09<@B?26;.;<A52?0.@2;F=2?@<;<?#.?AF@B/720A
A< A56@ #?<A20A6C2 "?12? D5< :.F /2 @B/720A A< . :<A6<; A< 16@09<@2 .;<A52? #.?AFK@ 6;3<?:.A6<;
12@64;.A21<;3612;A6.9=B?@B.;AA<A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?:B@A=?<:=A9F;<A63FA5.A=.?AF<3A52:<A6<;
@<A5.AA52=.?AF:.F5.C2.;<==<?AB;6AFA<.==2.?.;1/252.?1<;D52A52?A5.A6;3<?:.A6<;@5<B91
/216@09<@21
5+0-0*(9054 5- 9/, 759,*90;, 7+,7 '56@ #?<A20A6C2 "?12? :.F /2 :<163621 /F
3B?A52?@A6=B9.A6<;<3A52=.?A62@@B/720AA<<B?A.==?<C.9.;1.#.?AF:.F.==9FA<A52<B?A3<?
?296233?<:A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?.3A2?46C6;4;<A602A<0<B;@29<3?20<?1.;10<;32??6;4D6A5<==<@6;4
0<B;@296;.;233<?AA<?2.05.4?22:2;A<;.;F=?<=<@21:<16360.A6<;
5%(0;,7575+0-0*(9054'56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?@5.99;<A/20<;@A?B21.@.;11<2@
;<A0<;@A6ABA2.;<C.A6<;<3.;F2E6@A6;4</964.A6<;@<30<;3612;A6.96AF.#.?AF:.F<D2.;<A52?#.?AF
<?<A52?D6@2/F<=2?.A6<;<39.D'<A522EA2;AA52F.9?2.1F2E6@A.99@B05</964.A6<;@?2:.6;6;3B99
3<?02.;123320A;<AD6A5@A.;16;4A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?
$052(9054 5- 9/, 759,*90;, 7+,7 '52 <B?A @5.99 5.C2 16@0?2A6<; A< 6:=<@2
@.;0A6<;@6;09B16;4?2.@<;./92:<;2A.?F36;2@3<?C6<9.A6<;@<3A52=?<C6@6<;@<3A56@"?12?99<A52?
?2:2162@.C.69./92A<.;F=2?@<;6;7B?21/F.C6<9.A6<;<3A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?.?23B99F?2@2?C21
!<A56;46;A56@#?<A20A6C2"?12?@5.99?2@A?60A<?<A52?D6@2.3320AA52.1:6@@6/696AF<3
2C612;02B;12?A523212?.9?B92@
9.;!2@/6A
!
(& #
*69@56?29C1&A2
2C2?9F 699@
'29
<;.A5.; 2?:.;
#
*2@A63A5&A?22A
A5.;1 A59<<?@
<@;4292@.963<?;6.
'29
&""%%<; B9F 29
------------------------------
<;John E. McDermott
(;6A21&A.A2@6@A?60A B142
=/0)09
.
++" & ,''&%% /-+" &+!
*"%('&
" !#%!
.+
% "
# #%$
! * 1 "*%,!,
& '*%,"'&4 3*', , $,! & '*%,"'&4 '* 3'& " &,"$
,,'*& 1 1 + &$1
& '*%,"'&4+ "& "&,! *', ,". * * &, * "&,! '. (,"'& ,"'&
*', ,". * *"+ "& (*'." ,'% (-*+-&,,',! , *%+& * +,*" ,"'&+' ,!
*', ,". * *
!. & ". & '(1' & !. * ,! *', ,". * *
% %"$"*/",!,! , *%+' ,! *', ,". * *& * ,' '%($1/",!
& ,' '-& 1",+, *%+
+-%",,',! #-*"+ " ,"'&' ,!"+'-*, '* & '* % &,' ,! *', ,". * *
* &',,'-+ &1'& " &,"$& '*%,"'&*', , $,!& '*%,"'&'*
'& " &,"$
,,'*& 11 +&$1& '*%,"'& "+ $'+ ,'% (-*+-&,,',! *', ,".
& '*%,"'& "& $- "& ' -% &,+ & ,!"& + +" &, + 3'& " &,"$
"! !' ',% !'
#
* * 0 (, '*(-*('+ +' ,! '. (,"'& $"," ,"'&& &',,' "+ $'+ &1'
,!"+"& '*%,"'&,'( *+'&+',! *,!&,!'+ +( " " $$1-,!'*"2 1,! *', ,".
* */",!'-,,! 0(* ++/*",, & '&+ &,' ,! *,1/!' +" &, ,! "& '*%,"'&
+(*', , '*1'* *' ,! (* +" "& #-
$+' * ,'&'," 1&1+, &' *(!" $ *" $'*, !&" $( *+'&& $/!'*
* )-"* ,'++"+,% ' ,! , *%+' ,!"+*', ,". * *& ' ",+"& "& ,'&
,! %& %
-& *+,& ,!, % ,' * ,"& $$ ' -% &,+ '* %, *"$+ +" &, + '*
'&,"&"& '& " &,"$ & '*%,"'& *', , $,! & '*%,"'& '* '& " &,"$
,,'*& 11 +&$1& '*%,"'&"&+ -* %&& *& ,!,$$+- ! ' -% &,+&
%, *"$+ * ,' * %"& "& %1 ( *+'&$ -+,' 1 -&,"$ ,! '%($ ,"'& ' %1 ++" &
-," +"&,!"+%,, */! * -('&$$+- ! ' -% &,+& %, *"$+"& $- "& $$ '(" +
,! * ' & &1 /*","& + (* (* 1 % '&,"&"& &1 '& " &,"$ & '*%,"'&
*', , $,!& '*%,"'&'*'& " &,"$
,,'*& 11 +&$1& '*%,"'&* ,'
* ,-*& ,' '-&+ $/!'(*'." % /",!+- ! ' -% &,+& %, *"$+
" &
*"&, %
,
"! !' ',% !'
#
]]>
Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.
Why Is My Information Online?
