Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sherrifs et al v. County of Los Angeles et al

Filing 220

JUDGMENT by Judge Audrey B. Collins, in favor of County of Los Angeles, Leroy Baca against Association for Los Angeles Deputy Sheriffs, DOES, Aaron Edwards, Aaron Maestas, Abel Jimenez, Abner Garcia, Adam Borges, Adam Dorman, Adam Kirste, Adam Roybal, Adam Yancey, Adan Torres, Adolfo Barajas, Adolfo Pastrano, Adrean Fernandez, Adrian Garcia, Adrian Reynoso, Adrian Zuniga, Adrian Ernesto Camera, Adriana Rodriguez, Agostino Brancato, Alan Bash, Alan Chu, Albert Verduzco, Alberto Hernandez, Alejandra Becerra, Alejandra Roman, Alejandro Covian, Alejandro Ramirez, Alejandro Reyes, Alejandro Topete, Alex Chavez, Alex Gamboa, Alex Gilinets, Alex Pino, Alexander Ayala, Alexander Miller, Alexander Tovali, Alexander Toyos, Alexandra Amezcua, Alfonso Aguilera, Alfonso Herrera, Alfonso Rodriguez, Alfred Aguilera, Alfred Guerrero, Alfred Lio, Alfredo De La Cruz, Alfredo Flores, Alfredo Franco, Alfredo Galvan, Alfredo Gomez, Alissa Mills, Allen Asis, Allen Bueltel, Allen Ripley, Allison Holland, Allison Luther, Alma Aguirre, Alva Buller, Amber Smith, Amber Veatch, Amie Oviedo, Amos Cisneros, Amy Smith, Andres Washington, Andres Zunega, Andrew Campbell, Andrew Diaz, Andrew Escalona, Andrew Ferreira, Andrew Gill, Andrew Lynch, Andrew Parrott, Andrew Rodriguez, Andrew Rubalcaba, Andrew Turpen, Andriana Covell, Angel Ramos, Angela Kepley, Angelica Caamal, Anita Limbrick, Anna Zeinun, Annie Ng, Anthony Camargo, Anthony Christian, Anthony Culotta, Anthony Dileva, Anthony Esquivel, Anthony Fernandez, Anthony Paez, Anthony Pitillo, Anthony Ponce, Anthony Regalado, Anthony Santos, Anthony Shapiro, Anthony Smith, Anthony Vu, Anthony Washington, Antoinette Bowen, Antonio Fascio, Antonio Garza, Antonio Quintanilla, Antonio Rebueno, Antonio Ruiz, April Davidson, Ardith Castillo, Arin Davidian, Arlene Renfrow, Armando Arevalo, Armando Barrera, Armando Hidalgo, Armando Loureiro, Armando Macias, Armando Martinez, Armando Morales, Arnulfo Haro, Aron Shintaku, Arthur Bencomo, Arthur Bravo, Arthur Miranda, Arthur Vargas, Artie Mott, Arturo Ayala, Arturo Hernandez, Arturo Soto, Ashly Castro, Audra Alatorre, Aura Sierra, Austreberto Gonzalez, Barbara Connors, Bardo Ortiz, Barnaby Ortega, Baron Howard, Barry Ellsworth, Beau Topar, Benjamin Alvarado, Benjamin Gabrila, Benjamin Verduzco, Bill Brauberger, Billy Lovell, Billy Talamera, Blair Young, Blanca Creta, Brad Breckenridge, Brad Foss, Bradley Reinford, Brandon Love, Brandon Painter, Brandon Patin, Brandon Zeff, Brant Frederickson, Brendan Caslin, Brendan Corbett, Brent Bunch, Brent Parriott, Brett Binder, Brett Durfee, Brewster Thomas, Brian Barre, Brian Beckman, Brian Burchett, Brian Chase, Brian Christy, Brian Corcoran, Brian Cunningham, Brian Jones, Brian Knott, Brian MacDougall, Brian McBride, Brian Mitchell, Brian Mohr, Brian Moreno, Brian Nowell, Brian Oates, Brian Oblander, Brian Reza, Brian Sanford, Brian Sherred, Brian Thibodeaux, Bridgette Simpson, Britta Kjellstrand, Bruce Abbott, Bruce Asada, Bruce Bregger, Bruce Frailich, Bruce Nance, Bruce Waldo, Bruce Yoell, Bryan Riley, Bryan Thompson, Bryan White, Burton Brink, Byron Ward, Calvert Rosborough, Cameron Brazile, Cameron Drake, Cameron Glover, Carl Landrum, Carl Osterthaler, Carl Eugene Adams, Carla Armour, Carlos Alfaro, Carlos Avitia, Carlos Calixto, Carlos Gonzalez, Carlos Jackson, Carlos Lopez, Carlos Moran, Carlos Restrepo, Carlos Santos, Carlos Villafranco, Carol Hall, Caroline Rodriguez, Carolyn Chadwick, Carolyn Gallobruno, Carondelette Grier, Carter Martin, Celina Herrera, Cesar Chavez, Chad Brown, Chad Dowdy, Chad Eitner, Chad Limpanukorn, Chad Sessman, Chadren Hornig, Chandra Trower, Charity Brown, Charlene Fanti, Charles Aguirre, Charles Bass, Charles Braden, Charles Brooks, Charles Harvey, Charles Kunz, Charles McClure, Charles McDaniel, Charles Nuckols, Charles Tilson, Charles Youngstrom, Charlie Upchurch, Cheryl Creason, Chheang Chab, Chris Craft, Christian Chamness, Christian Finger, Christian Selecman, Christian Wahla, Christie Mautier, Christina Alvarez, Christina Banogon, Christine Badaracco, Christine Garcia, Christine Steinbacher, Christopher Armistead, Christopher Barreras, Christopher Courduff, Christopher Gamboa, Christopher Gonzalez, Christopher Jackson, Christopher Johnson, Christopher Jones, Christopher Lee, Christopher Lee, Christopher Lio, Christopher Oakley, Christopher Santos, Christopher Stokes, Christopher Thoreson, Christopher Valente, Christopher Wright, Christopher Young, Chukwueneka Ajufoh, Clarence Gallegos, Clarence Hodge, Clifford Anger, Clifford Slawinski, Clint Duran, Clint Hughes, Clinton Kimball, Cody Signater, Cong Ha, Connie Grant, Corbett Boggs, Cordell Adams, Corina Torrero, Corine Sandfry, Cort Bishop, Cory Johnston, Cory Silverman, Craig Berning, Craig Johnson, Craig McClelland, Craig Summers, Craig Yockey, Cristina Cordoba, Cristobal Torres, Criton McClendon, Curt Starz, Cynthia Cloyd, Cynthia Lombardo, Cynthia Olesinski, Dale Chandler, Dale Eernisse, Dale Hess, Dale Ryken, Dale Thompson, Damita Bowers, Dan Jordan, Dan McPherson, Dana Duncan, Daniel Ament, Daniel Anderson, Daniel Bujer, Daniel Castaneda, Daniel Dail, Daniel Dantice, Daniel Debo, Daniel Duran, Daniel Eifert, Daniel Estrada, Daniel Estrella, Daniel Etter, Daniel Farrell, Daniel Finn, Daniel Leon, Daniel Lobo, Daniel Mageno, Daniel Marckstadt, Daniel Pakizer, Daniel Perez, Daniel Rodriguez, Daniel Throckmorton, Daniel Torres, Daniel Wade, Daniel Zumer, Danielle Damian, Danielle Guagliardo, Danny Amador, Danny Delgadillo, Danny Walls, Daphane Terrell, Daren Nigsarian, Darilyn Mitchell, Darlene Brown, Darlene Olivarez, Darren Blackmer, Darren Williams, Darrin Walker, Darrol Weber, Darryl Beacham, Darryl Cox, Daryl Bonsall, Daryl Peterson, Dave Disbro, David Arredondo, David Bower, David Brakebush, David Busk, David Cameron, David Camps, David Chevez, David Chi, David Cooper, David De La O, David Ehoff, David Elder, David Espinoza, David Faria, David Fuller, David Gaisford, David Gomez, David Goodwin, David Gunner, David Hernandez, David Horner, David Kerr, David Koss, David Lewey, David Magdaleno, David Mertens, David O'Connor, David Porter, David Portesi, David Rasmussen, David Reddish, David Royston, David Salazar, David Smiley, David Takigawa, David Timberlake, David Vasquez, Davie Chang, Davin Emmons, Dawn Rickart, Daymon Felis, Dean Docuyanan, Dean Galarneau, Dean Parker, Deana Austin, Deanna Ballesteros, Deanna Mares, Deanna Santino, Deborah Duda, Deborah Tweedy, Delfino Jauregui, Demetrius Gathright, Dena Dorsey, Denise Beach, Denise Grim, Denise Hernandez, Dennis Barnhoorn, Dennis Bencomo, Dennis Blackstock, Dennis Chavez, Dennis Conway, Dennis Elmore, Dennis O'Brien, Dennis Pogodayen, Dennis Schwartz, Dennis Watters, Denny Tseng, Derek Bumgardner, Derek Kruzner, Derek Newcomb, Derrick McNally, Derrick Thompson, Devery Jones, Diana Gutierrez, Diana Norris, Diana Petty, Diane Dodd, Dianne Moreno, Dick Bunnell, Digna Ramirez, Dirk Behrens, Dirk Blansfield, Disylvio Mitchell, Dominic Delio, Dominic Miller, Don Steck, Don Walker, Donald Knight, Donald Marchand, Donald McNamara, Donald Naslund, Donald Nichiporuk, Donald Stieele, Donovan Gabbedon, Doug Nguyen, Douglas Davis, Douglas Duvall, Douglas Hammer, Douglas Lloyd, Douglas McDaniel, Douglas Runion, Douglas Williams, Duane Decker, Edgar Chavarria, Edgar Payan, Edgar Quintana, Edmund Anderson, Edmund Hood, Edmund Ybarra, Edmundo Perez, Eduardo Arambula, Eduardo Medina, Eduardo Nunez-Bu, Eduardo Salazar, Edward Aguirre, Edward Chow, Edward Cronin, Edward Gilpin, Edward Gonzales, Edward Higashi, Edward Hopper, Edward Huizar, Edward Lopez, Edward Nordskog, Edward Otero, Edward Pacheco, Edward Robles, Edward Westbrook, Edwin Torres, Eileen Martinez, Elaine O'Donnell, Eligio Barajas, Elizabeth Goralsky, Elvis Salas, Enrique Acevedo, Enrique Magdaleno, Enrique Munoz, Enrique Pena, Eric Allen, Eric Brown, Eric Elder, Eric Felis, Eric Hansen, Eric Hoffman, Eric Ley, Eric Metten, Eric Moyer, Eric Salvato, Eric Sanders, Eric Trask, Erica Torres, Erich Doepking, Erik Coker, Erik Delgadillo, Erik Sibrian, Erik Varon, Erika Carlos, Ernest Bille, Ernest Ferreras, Ernest Griffin, Ernest Munoz, Ernesto Castaneda, Ernesto Moran, Ernie King, Ernie Serrano, Estela Alvarez, Eugene Frazier, Eugene Lindsey, Eugene Moreno, Eureka Turner, Ezekiel Salas, Fabian Salazar, Faustino Del Valle, Federico Carlo, Felicia Myers, Fernando Febles, Fernando Garcia, Fidel Parra, Florentino Madrid, Floyd Hayhurst, Francisco Gutierrez, Francisco Montes, Francisco Ramos, Francois Chang, Frank Alvarado, Frank Bravo, Frank Higuera, Frank Huelga, Frank Montoya, Frank Murillo, Frank Parga, Frank Rothe, Franklin Doo, Freddie Cardenas, Frederick Cordova, Frederick McNutt, Frederick Richardson, Fredrick Haemker, Fredrick Noya, Gabriel Akchyan, Gabriel Frias, Gabriel Morales, Gabriel Moran, Gabriel Rendon, Gabriel Rosales, Gabriel Valdez, Gabriela Alvarez, Gabriela Murguia, Garry Dawson, Gary Chan, Gary Hinkue, Gary Sholder, Gary Spencer, Gary Weinmann, Gene Wilson, George Betor, George Contreras, George Guevara, George Hofstetter, George Housos, George Livoti, George Magallanes, George Meeley, George Oriel, George Sauers, George Siensland, George Villalpando, George Walker, Gerald Denson, Gerald Dolen, Gerald Houston, Gerald Neureither, Gerald Newbold, Gerald Warren, Gerard Patterson, Gerardo Magos, Gerardo Servin, Giancarlo Scotti, Gilbert Arakawa, Gilbert Callahan, Gilbert Dominguez, Gina Cali, Gina Martinez, Ginni Alvarez, Gino Reale, Girolamo Renzulli, Glen Marcus, Glen Mayer, Godin Gonzalez, Gonzalo Inzunza, Goro Yoshida, Grace Aranda, Grace Arrighi, Grantland Candiff, Greg Crow, Greg Salcido, Greg Whalen, Greg Zembal, Gregg Brenton, Gregg Plahy, Gregg Plamondon, Gregoria Rodriguez, Gregory Anton, Gregory Boghosian, Gregory Boling, Gregory Carr, Gregory Clark, Gregory Embry, Gregory Evans, Gregory Gabriel, Gregory Herrera, Gregory Hovland, Gregory Hutt, Gregory Keefer, Gregory Martinez, Gregory Maxwell, Gregory Stegner, Guadalupe Lopez, Gualberto Castro, Guillermo Casillas, Guillermo Guerrero, Guillermo Martinez, Guillermo Pacheco, Guy Magnera, Gwen Gardner, Harry Amos, Harry Sahagian, Harvey Crosthwaite, Hector Andujo, Hector Castellanos

Download PDF
1 JS-6 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT 9 CENTRAL DISTRICT OF CALIFORNIA A Professional Law Corporation 6033 W. Century Boulevard, Suite 500 Los Angeles, CA 90045 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 MICHAEL ASCOLESE, ROBERT CONNOR, MARCELLO CURKO, MARK ERBACKER, DEAN GALARNEAU, GEORGE HOFSTETTER, ABEL JIMENEZ, JAMES LARKIN, NEAL LEVANG, FRANK ROTHE, MARK SALLES, and MATT TAYLOR on behalf of themselves individually and all others similarly situated, 19 20 [PROPOSED] JUDGMENT Plaintiffs, 17 18 Case No. ED CV 08-1267ABC (CWx) v. COUNTY OF LOS ANGELES, LEROY BACA, as SHERIFF of LOS ANGELES COUNTY, and DOES 1 through 10, inclusive, 21 Defendants. 22 23 On June 14, 2012, this action came on regularly for hearing on Defendants 24 County of Los Angeles and Leroy Baca’s Motion for Partial Summary Judgment 25 regarding Plaintiffs’ “donning and doffing” claim before the Honorable Audrey B. 26 Collins, Chief District Court Judge of the United States District Court for the 27 Central District of California. Having considered the evidence presented in support 28 of and in opposition to Defendants’ motion, the Court granted Defendants’ Motion 630459.1 LO140-279 [PROPOSED] JUDGMENT 1 for Partial for Summary Judgment in its entirety. (Docket #205.) 2 Subsequently, Plaintiffs filed a Motion to Dismiss the entire case pursuant to “off-the-clock” claims. On August 6, 2012, both motions came on regularly for 5 hearing before the Honorable Audrey B. Collins, Chief District Court Judge. 6 Defendants were represented by Brian P. Walter and Elizabeth T. Arce of Liebert 7 Cassidy Whitmore, and Plaintiffs were represented by Elizabeth Gibbons of Green 8 & Shinee. Having considered the evidence presented in support of and in 9 opposition to Defendants’ motion, and oral argument by the parties, the Court 10 A Professional Law Corporation 6033 W. Century Boulevard, Suite 500 Los Angeles, CA 90045 F.R.Civ.P. 41. Defendants also filed a Motion to Decertify Plaintiffs’ remaining 4 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE 3 denied Plaintiffs’ Motion to Dismiss the entire case, and granted Defendants’ 11 Motion to Decertify which resulted in the dismissal of the Opt-In Plaintiffs’ 12 remaining “off-the-clock” claims without prejudice leaving only the claims of the 13 seven remaining named Plaintiffs at issue. (Docket #212, 213.) As indicated in its 14 Order, the Court tolled the statute of limitations period for all Opt-in Plaintiffs until 15 November 6, 2012. At Plaintiffs’ request, the Court also dismissed the “off-the- 16 clock” claims of named Plaintiffs Michael Ascolese, Marcello Curko, Mark 17 Erbacker, Dean Galarneau, George Hofstetter, James Larkin and Mark Salles 18 without prejudice. 19 Because Plaintiffs’ remaining claims have been disposed of as a result of the 20 Court denying Plaintiffs’ Motion to Dismiss, the Court granting Defendants’ 21 Motion to Decertify, and the Plaintiffs’ request to dismiss the named Plaintiffs 22 without prejudice: 23 /// 24 /// 25 /// 26 /// 27 /// 28 /// 630459.1 LO140-279 -2- [PROPOSED] JUDGMENT 1 IT IS ORDERED, ADJUDGED AND DECREED THAT Plaintiffs take 2 nothing, that the action be dismissed on the merits, and that Defendants County of 3 Los Angeles and Leroy Baca, as the prevailing party, recover its costs from 4 Plaintiffs. 5 6 Dated: November 13, 2012 7 _______________________________________ HONORABLE AUDREY B. COLLINS UNITED STATES DISTRICT COURT JUDGE 8 9 A Professional Law Corporation 6033 W. Century Boulevard, Suite 500 Los Angeles, CA 90045 LIEBERT CASSIDY WHITMORE 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 630459.1 LO140-279 -3- [PROPOSED] JUDGMENT

Disclaimer: Justia Dockets & Filings provides public litigation records from the federal appellate and district courts. These filings and docket sheets should not be considered findings of fact or liability, nor do they necessarily reflect the view of Justia.


Why Is My Information Online?